betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Limit theorems for the neutron transport equation

Abstract

Over the last decade, ingenuous developments in Monte Carlo methods have enabled the unbiased estimation of adjoint-weighted reactor parameters expressed as bilinear forms, such as kinetics parameters and sensitivity coefficients. A prominent example is the Iterated Fission Probability method, which relies on the simulation of the fission chains descending from an ancestor neutron: the neutron population at an asymptotic fission generation yields an estimate of the importance function (and hence of the adjoint fundamental eigenmode) at the phase-space coordinates of the ancestor neutron. In this paper we first establish rigorous results concerning the moments of the asymptotic neutron population stemming from a single initial particle, with special focus on the average and the variance. Then, we propose a simple benchmark configuration where exact solutions are derived for these moments, which can be used for the verification of new functionalities of production Monte Carlo codes involving the Iterated Fission Probability method.

Introduction

Monte Carlo simulation is the gold standard method for radiation transport applications, since it involves a minimal number of approximations. In particular, the phase space does not need to be discretized and all the particle-nuclei interaction physics contained in the nuclear data libraries can be used [19]. Thanks to these features, particle-transport codes based on the Monte Carlo method allow one to establish reference solutions against which those produced by faster but approximate deterministic solvers (which rely on the discretization of the phase space) can be benchmarked for accuracy.

The stochastic version of the standard power iteration algorithm is the workhorse of Monte Carlo codes for kk-eigenvalue problems: a collection of neutrons is followed over a sufficiently large number of fission generations, and statistics are recorded on the successive generations once the population has settled into a stationary state. At equilibrium, the ratio between the statistical weights of the neutrons at two consecutive fission generations converges to the fundamental eigenvalue k0k_0, and the neutron flux within a generation correspondingly converges to the fundamental kk-eigenmode, φ0\varphi_0 [19]. Over the last decade, a major breakthrough based on the rediscovery of the Iterated Fission Probability (IFP) method has enabled the use of Monte Carlo to compute adjoint-weighted quantities [13,21]. The key idea is that the adjoint fundamental eigenmode of a kk-eigenvalue calculation is proportional to the neutron importance, which can be estimated by tracking the descendants of an ancestor neutron over a sufficiently large number of power iteration generations and collecting the statistical weights of the surviving neutrons. This technique has been implemented in several production Monte Carlo codes, enabling unbiased estimates for the fundamental adjoint flux [26, 28] or adjoint-weighted parameters (bilinear forms) such as kinetics parameters or perturbations and sensitivities to nuclear data [2] [12, 14, 23, 27, 30].

When developing new algorithms and functionalities in production Monte Carlo codes such as MCNP6® [18], MONK® [24] or TRIPOLI-4® [1], which involve several hundred thousands of lines of code, it is of utmost importance to rely on exact solutions whenever possible for verification purposes. Several such sets of analytical solutions have been established for regular (forward) transport problems, and in particular kk-eigenvalue calculations [7, 17, 25]. For adjoint eigenvalue problems and related adjoint-weighted parameters, comparatively fewer exact solutions have been derived. A prominent example is the two-group, infinite medium model benchmark [15], which has been successfully used to verify recent developments of Monte Carlo codes [2] [13, 30]. In view of these considerations, in this work we set out to establish benchmark solutions for adjoint kk-eigenvalue problems in spatially finite media, which can usefully complement those of the infinite medium model.

Since IFP methods are generally concerned with the asymptotic behaviour of a stochastic neutron population, in this paper we provide general statements about the moments of the neutron population as a function of fission generations. More precisely, we provide exact asymptotics for the moments (of any order) of the fission generation populations for the sub-, super- and critical cases. In particular, this implies that we can obtain precise asymptotics for the average and variance of the neutron population. We further introduce a benchmark configuration where exact results can be derived. For this purpose, we resort to the “rod-model”, a simple transport configuration where neutrons are constrained to move along a line, the only permissible directions being those in the increasing or decreasing spatial coordinate [31]. Within this framework, we establish reference solutions for the asymptotic average number of neutrons stemming from an ancestor particle, as well as for the second moment of this counting process, for sub-critical, critical and super-critical configurations. These findings can be used as an ideal verification test-bed for Monte Carlo code developers interested in IFP-based algorithms.

This paper is organized as follows. In Sec. 2, we introduce the general neutron transport model that we will work with and present a stochastic representation of the model in the form of a branching process. In Sec. 3, we give an informal statement of the main results. In § 4 we consider the specific example of the rod model to illustrate the agreement between our theoretical results and Monte Carlo simulations in some simple cases. Conclusions will finally be drawn in § 6. The precise statements of the main results described in Sec. 3 are provided in the Appendix (Sec. A) with the proofs being given in the supplementary material of Ref. 5.

The stochastic interpretation of the neutron transport equation

Consider a collection of neutrons evolving in the position (r)(\mathbf{r}), direction (Ω)(\boldsymbol{\Omega}) and energy (E)(E) phase space S:=D×S2×(Emin⁡,Emax⁡)\mathcal{S} := D \times S_2 \times(E_{\min}, E_{\max}), where the spatial domain D⊂R3D \subset\mathbb{R}^3 is open and bounded, the direction domain is the unit sphere S2⊂R3S_2 \subset\mathbb{R}^3, and the energy domain is (Emin⁡,Emax⁡)(E_{\min}, E_{\max}), where 0<Emin⁡≤Emax⁡<∞0 < E_{\min} \le E_{\max} < \infty.

It is customarily assumed that neutron trajectories behave stochastically, their randomness being due to the interactions with the surrounding nuclei; furthermore, thanks to the very low density of neutrons in matter, their transport process is inherently linear, in that the probability of neutron-neutron interactions is negligible for all practical purposes. Between collisions, particles move along straight lines whose length obeys a non-homogeneous exponential probability distribution with parameter Σt(r,E)\Sigma_{\mathrm{t}}(\mathbf{r}, E), with units given by inverse length. The total macroscopic cross section Σt(r,E)\Sigma_{\mathrm{t} }(\mathbf{r}, E) defines the probability per unit length that the neutron has a collision in the following infinitesimal displacement about its current position r\mathbf{r}, in the direction Ω\boldsymbol{\Omega} and with energy EE. At the scale of neutron paths, materials are ideally isotropic, so that Σt\Sigma_{\mathrm{t}} does not depend on Ω\boldsymbol{\Omega}. Displacements are formally associated to the backward streaming operator

T†[g](r,Ω,E)=−Ω⋅∇g(r,Ω,E)+Σt(r,E)g(r,Ω,E),(r,Ω,E)∈S,(1)T^\dagger[g](\mathbf{r}, \boldsymbol{\Omega}, E) = -\boldsymbol{\Omega} \cdot\nabla g(\mathbf{r}, \boldsymbol{\Omega}, E) + \Sigma_{\mathrm{t}}(\mathbf{r}, E)g(\mathbf{r}, \boldsymbol{\Omega}, E), \qquad(\mathbf{r}, \boldsymbol{\Omega}, E) \in\mathcal{S}, \tag*{(1)}

with g∈L+∞(S)g \in L^\infty_+(\mathcal{S}) the collection of non-negative, uniformly bounded, measurable functions on S\mathcal{S}.

We assume that the domain DD has leakage boundary conditions, which means that neutrons leaving the domain are lost. At the end of each flight, the neutron undergoes a collision event, provided it is still within the viable domain. We have Σt=Σc+Σs+Σf\Sigma_{\mathrm{t}} = \Sigma_{\mathrm{c}} + \Sigma_{\mathrm{s}} + \Sigma_{\mathrm{f}}, where Σc\Sigma_{\mathrm{c}} (resp. Σs\Sigma_{\mathrm{s}}, Σf\Sigma_{\mathrm{f}}) denotes the capture (resp. scattering, fission) cross section. The ratios Σr/Σt\Sigma_r/\Sigma_{\mathrm{t}}, with r=cr = \mathrm{c} (resp. s,f\mathrm{s}, \mathrm{f}), yield the probability that the collision event is capture (resp. scattering or fission). If the neutron is captured, its history is terminated; if it undergoes scattering, its direction and energy coordinates are randomly distributed according to a (normalized) probability density fs(r,Ω→Ω′,E→E′)f_{\mathrm{s}}(\mathbf{r}, \boldsymbol{\Omega} \to\boldsymbol{\Omega}', E \to E'); if it undergoes fission, it disappears and is replaced by a random number of new neutrons, whose average number is νf(r,E)\nu_{\mathrm{f}}(\mathbf{r}, E) and whose direction and energy coordinates are randomly distributed according to a (normalized) probability density χf(r,Ω→Ω′,E→E′)\chi_{\mathrm{f}}(\mathbf{r}, \boldsymbol{\Omega} \to\boldsymbol{\Omega}', E \to E'). Scattering and fission are formally associated to the backward operators

S†[g](r,Ω,E)=Σs(r,E)∫Emin⁡Emax⁡∫S2g(r,Ω′,E′)fs(r,Ω→Ω′,E→E′) dΩ′dE′,(2)S^\dagger[g](\mathbf{r}, \boldsymbol{\Omega}, E) = \Sigma_{\mathrm{s}}(\mathbf{r}, E) \int_{E_{\min}}^{E_{\max}} \int_{S_2} g(\mathbf{r}, \boldsymbol{\Omega}', E') f_{\mathrm{s}}(\mathbf{r}, \boldsymbol{\Omega} \to\boldsymbol{\Omega}', E \to E') \,\mathrm{d}\boldsymbol{\Omega}'\mathrm{d}E', \tag*{(2)}
F†[g](r,Ω,E)=νf(r,E)Σf(r,E)∫Emin⁡Emax⁡∫S2g(r,Ω′,E′)χf(r,Ω→Ω′,E→E′) dΩ′dE′.(3)F^\dagger[g](\mathbf{r}, \boldsymbol{\Omega}, E) = \nu_{\mathrm{f}}(\mathbf{r}, E)\Sigma_{\mathrm{f}}(\mathbf{r}, E) \int_{E_{\min}}^{E_{\max}} \int_{S_2} g(\mathbf{r}, \boldsymbol{\Omega}', E') \chi_{\mathrm{f}}(\mathbf{r}, \boldsymbol{\Omega} \to\boldsymbol{\Omega}', E \to E') \,\mathrm{d}\boldsymbol{\Omega}'\mathrm{d}E'. \tag*{(3)}

For now, in order to keep the notation simple, we only focus on prompt neutrons however, we refer the reader to Remark 1 for an explanation of how this is easily extended to the case where delayed neutrons are also accounted for.

The backward operators T†T^\dagger, S†S^\dagger and F†F^\dagger are related to each other via the kk-eigenvalue formulation of the adjoint neutron transport equation (NTE) [19], which reads

(T†−S†)[φ†]=1kF†[φ†]⟺(T†−S†)−1F†[φ†]=kφ†.(4)(T^\dagger-S^\dagger)[\varphi^\dagger]=\frac{1}{k}F^\dagger[\varphi^\dagger]\quad\Longleftrightarrow\quad(T^\dagger-S^\dagger)^{-1}F^\dagger[\varphi^\dagger]=k\varphi^\dagger. \tag*{(4)}

Taking the adjoint of all the operators in Eq. (4), we have the customary forward formulation

(T−S)[φ]=1kF[φ]⟺(T−S)−1F[φ]=kφ,(5)(T-S)[\varphi]=\frac{1}{k}F[\varphi]\quad\Longleftrightarrow\quad(T-S)^{-1}F[\varphi]=k\varphi, \tag*{(5)}

where TT, SS and FF are the formal adjoints of the operators T†T^\dagger, S†S^\dagger and F†F^\dagger, respectively. The fundamental eigenmodes φ0†(r,Ω,E)\varphi_0^\dagger(\mathbf{r},\boldsymbol{\Omega},E) and φ0(r,Ω,E)\varphi_0(\mathbf{r},\boldsymbol{\Omega},E) of Eqs. (4) and (5), respectively, can be given a physical meaning: φ0†(r,Ω,E)\varphi_0^\dagger(\mathbf{r},\boldsymbol{\Omega},E) is the importance of a neutron injected into the system with phase-space coordinates (r,Ω,E)(\mathbf{r},\boldsymbol{\Omega},E), and Qf=F[φ0]Q_f=F[\varphi_0] is the stationary post-fission neutron distribution (with φ0\varphi_0 being the pre-fission steady state). We will expand on this further in due course. Since φ0†\varphi_0^\dagger and QfQ_f are unique up to multiplicative constants, we specify their normalisation as

⟨Qf,1⟩=1and⟨Qf,φ0†⟩=1,(6)\langle Q_f,1\rangle=1\quad\text{and}\quad\langle Q_f,\varphi_0^\dagger\rangle=1, \tag*{(6)}

where 11 is the function that takes the value 11 everywhere and the angle brackets denote the scalar product. The physical picture related to Eqs. (4) and (5) is the following: given a population of pre-fission particles distributed according to φ0\varphi_0, FF initiates the next generation of fission particles and (T−S)−1(T-S)^{-1} transports them to the next set of absorption (capture plus fission) sites, resulting in another population of particles distributed according to φ0\varphi_0, albeit multiplied by a factor of k0k_0. In this respect, it is natural to introduce the concept of fission generation, and rewrite Eq. (5) as

F(T−S)−1Qf=k0Qf,(7)F(T-S)^{-1}Q_f=k_0Q_f, \tag*{(7)}

where the fundamental eigenvalue k0k_0 physically represents the ratio between the number of neutrons in two successive fission generations. If k0>1k_0>1 the system is supercritical, corresponding to an exponential growth of the number of particles in system with respect to generations; if k0<1k_0<1 the system is subcritical, corresponding to an exponential decay in the number of particles; and if k0=1k_0=1 there is an equilibrium between neutron loss (absorption and leakage) and gain (fission).

The probabilistic interpretation of Eqs. (4) and (5) is now made explicit. Let NnN_n denote the number of neutrons that stem from the nn-th fission event in their genealogical line of descent, with n≥1n\geq1; furthermore, let {(ri(n),Ωi(n),Ei(n)),i=1,…,Nn}\{(\mathbf{r}_i^{(n)},\boldsymbol{\Omega}_i^{(n)},E_i^{(n)}),i=1,\ldots,N_n\} denote their phase space configurations. Our goal is to characterize the statistical behaviour of the collection of neutrons in the nn-th fission generation, which, in view of the previous remarks, is clearly a discrete-time branching process. Define

Xn(A):=∑i=1Nnδ(ri(n),Ωi(n),Ei(n))(A),A∈B(S), n≥1,(8)\mathcal{X}_n(A):=\sum_{i=1}^{N_n}\delta_{(\mathbf{r}_i^{(n)},\boldsymbol{\Omega}_i^{(n)},E_i^{(n)})}(A),\qquad A\in\mathcal{B}(\mathcal{S}),\ n\geq1, \tag*{(8)}

where B(S)\mathcal{B}(\mathcal{S}) is the set of Borel subsets of S\mathcal{S}. Then Xn(A)\mathcal{X}_n(A) denotes the number of post-fission neutrons in A⊂SA \subset\mathcal{S}. Moreover, X=(Xn)n≥1\mathcal{X}=(\mathcal{X}_n)_{n\geq1} is a branching process with expectation semigroup

References

  1. [1]Alexander M. G. Cox, Emma Horton, Andreas E. Kyprianou, and Denis Villemonais. Stochastic methods for neutron transport equation III: Generational many-to-one and k_eff. SIAM Journal on Applied Mathematics, 81(3):982–1001, 2021.arxiv.org/abs/1909.00581
  2. [2]Eric Dumonteil, Emma Horton, Andreas E. Kyprianou, and Andrea Zoia. Moment asymptotics for the neutron transport equation. Preprint, 2022.
  3. [3]Isaac Gonzalez, Emma Horton, and Andreas E. Kyprianou. Asymptotic moments of spatial branching processes. Probab. Theory Rel. Fields, 184(2):805–858, 2022.
  4. [4]Simon C Harris, Emma Horton, Andreas E Kyprianou, and Minmin Wang. Yaglom limit for critical nonlocal branching markov processes. The Annals of Probability, 50:2373–2408, 2022.DOI

Paper details

vlnc:W_d25cjjfx
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents