WorksPhysics and Astronomy
Extraction of the Coulomb Sum Rule, Transverse Enhancement, and Longitudinal Quenching from an Analysis of all Available e-C and e-O Cross Section Data
Abstract
We report on a phenomenological analysis of all available electron scattering data on (about 6600 differential cross section measurements) and on (about 250 measurements) within the framework of the quasielastic (QE) superscaling model (including Pauli blocking). All QE and inelastic cross section measurements are included down to the lowest momentum transfer (including photo-production data). We find that there is enhancement of the transverse QE response function () and quenching of the QE longitudinal response function () at low (in addition to Pauli blocking). We extract parameterizations of a low "Longitudinal Quenching Factor" and an "Transverse Enhancement" contribution. Additionally, we find that the excitation of nuclear states contribute significantly (up to 30%) to the Coulomb Sum Rule . We extract the most accurate determination of to date and find it to be in reasonable agreement with recent theoretical calculations.
We report on a fit to all available electron scattering data on C (about 6600 differential cross section measurements) and O (about 250 measurements) within the framework of the quasielastic (QE) superscaling model (including Pauli blocking). The cross sections measurements include the available data on QE (down to the lowest momentum transfer (), inelastic production, and photoproduction. The fit includes inelastic structure functions and empirical parameters to model both an enhancement of the transverse (T) QE response function and quenching of the longitudinal (L) QE response function at low . As the fit provides an accurate description of the data, it can be used as a proxy to validate modeling of cross sections in Monte Carlo event generators for electron and neutrino () scattering. Careful consideration of nuclear excitations is critical for an accurate extraction of the normalized Coulomb Sum Rule[1] at low as these states can contribute up to 30%. After accounting for the dominant excitations, we extract the most accurate determination of as function of for C and O based on the global fit and compare to theoretical models. In addition, the ”Transverse Enhancement” (TE) of and the ”Quenching Factor” of are also of great interest to scattering experiments[2, 3, 4, 5].
The electron scattering differential cross section can be written[6] in terms of and as:
Here, is the incident electron energy, and are the energy and angle of the final state electron, , is the square of the 4-momentum transfer (defined to be positive), , and . In the analysis we also use the invariant hadronic mass .
The inelastic Coulomb Sum Rule is the integral of , excluding the elastic peak and pion production processes. It has contributions from QE scattering and from electro-excitations of nuclear states:
We define as the reduced longitudinal QE response, which integrates to unity in the absence of any suppression (e.g. Pauli blocking). The charge form factors for the electro-excitation of nuclear states is . In order to account for the small contribution of the neutron and relativistic effects is given by[6]:
where, and are the electric form factors[7] of the proton and neutron respectively and . By dividing (2) by we obtain the normalized inelastic Coulomb Sum Rule :
At high it is expected that because both nuclear excitation form factors and Pauli suppression are small. At small it is expected that because the all form factors for inelastic processes (QE and nuclear excitations) must be zero at .
We begin by parameterizing the measurements of the L and T form factors for the electro-excitation of all nuclear states in with excitation energies () less than 16.0 MeV (the approximate proton removal energy from ). For these states the measurements are straightforward since the QE cross section is zero for MeV.
For MeV the extractions of form factors require corrections for the QE contribution. We perform a reanalysis of all published cross sections with MeV and use our fitted QE model (described below) to extract L and T form factors. For MeV (region of the Giant Dipole resonances) we group the strength from multiple excitations into a few states with a large width and extract effective form factors accounting for all states in this region. The top two panels of Figure 1 show comparisons of our fit (red) to measurements by Yamaguchi (1996) [8] with MeV. An estimated resolution smearing of 600 keV has been applied to the excitations in the fit to match the data. While individual states are well reproduced at low excitation energy, Above 20 MeV the effect of grouping several excitations together into broad effective states in the fit can be seen. While the fit does not capture the structure from individual states, the total strength is seen to be well reproduced. A similar analysis has been done for . The fits to the form factors for and are included in a longer paper (in preparation).

Figure 1. Top two panels: Comparison of extracted from our fit (red) to a sample of experimental data (blue)[8]. For less than 12 MeV the values are multiplied by 1/6. Bottom two panels: The contributions of longitudinal nuclear excitations (between 2 and 55 MeV) to the Coulomb sum rule () in equation 4 for and .
The contribution of nuclear excitation to (factor in eq. (4)) is calculated using the parametrizations of the form factors. The bottom two panels of Figure 1 show the contributions of nuclear excitations to for and . The contribution of all excitations is largest () at GeV. Although the contributions of different regions to is different for and , the total contribution turns out to be similar for the two nuclei. The total contribution of excitations to in can be parameterized as:
where ( GeV), , , , , , , and , , . The uncertainty in the total contribution of excited states was estimated to 15% plus a systematic error to account for the choice of parametrization at very low () added in quadrature.
The universal fit to the data is an update of the 2012 fit by Bosted and Mamyan [9]. The QE contribution is modeled by the superscaling approach[10, 11, 12, 13] with Pauli blocking calculated using the Rosenfelder[13, 14, 15] method. The superscaling function extracted from the fit is similar to the superscaling functions of Amaro 2005[11] and Amaro 2020[12] and yields similar Pauli suppression.
In modeling the QE response we use the same scaling function for both and and fit for empirical corrections to the response functions. For we extract an additive “Transverse Enhancement/MEC” TE() contribution (which includes both single nucleon and two nucleon final states). As shown in ref. [16], TE() increases with the largest fractional contribution around GeV. For we extract a multiplicative dependent ”Longitudinal Quenching Factor”, , which decreases at low .
Since measurements span a large range of and , parametrizations of both and can be extracted. The analysis includes all data for a large range of nuclei. However, in this paper we only include data on and . Briefly, the updated fit includes:
All electron scattering data on , , and in addition to the data in the QE[17] and resonance[18] data archives.
Coulomb corrections[19] using the Effective Momentum Approximation (EMA) in modeling scattering from nuclear targets.
Updated nuclear elastic+excitations form factors.
Superscaling parameters are re-extracted including the Fermi broadening parameter .
Parameterizations of the free nucleon form factors[20] are re-derived from all and data.
Rosenfelder Pauli suppression[13, 14, 15] which reduces and changes the QE distribution at low and .
Updates of fits[20] to inelastic electron scattering data (in the nucleon resonance region and inelastic continuum) for and .
A dependent parameter for the QE process to account for the optical potential[21] of final state nucleons.
Photo-production data in the nucleon resonance region and inelastic continuum[22].
Gaussian Fermi smeared nucleon resonance and inelastic continuum[22]. The parameters for pion production and QE can be different.
Parametrizations of the medium modifications of both the L and T structure functions responsible for the EMC effect (nuclear dependence of inelastic structure functions). These are applied to the free nucleon cross sections prior to application of the Fermi smearing.
Parametrizations of and as described below.
QE data at all values of down to GeV ( GeV) (which were not included in the Bosted-Mamyan fit).
The average (over ) Pauli suppression factor for (, GeV) is described by:
Using the Rosenfeld method with superscaling function used in this analysis, we find , ,
and . The Pauli suppression factor for is 1.0.
Comparisons of the fit to electron scattering measurements[17, 23, 24] at different values of for values close to 0.30, 0.38 and 0.57 GeV (corresponding to extractions of and by Jourdan[25]) are shown in Figure 2. Shown are the total cross section (solid-purple line), the total minus the contribution of nuclear excitations (solid-blue), the QE cross section without TE (dashed-blue), the TE contribution (solid-red), and inelastic pion production (dot-dashed black). An estimated resolution smearing of 3.5 MeV has been applied to the excitations to better match the data.
Figure 2. Comparison of the fit to electron scattering measurements[17, 23, 24] at values close to 0.30, 0.38 and 0.57 GeV (and different scattering angles). Shown are total (solid-purple line), total minus the contribution of the nuclear excitations (solid-blue), the QE cross section without TE (dashed-blue), the TE contribution (solid-red) and inelastic pion production (dot-dashed black line). Additional comparisons are included in supplemental materials[37].
The fit is in good agreement with all electron scattering data for both small and large .
The extracted QE ”Longitudinal Quenching Factor” is unity for , and is zero for . For it is parameterized by:
with , and . The top-left panel of Figure 3 shows the extracted (black-dotted line). The yellow band includes the statistical, parameterization and a normalization error of 2% (all added in quadrature).
Figure 3. Top left panel: QE ”Longitudinal Quenching Factor” (dotted-black line with yellow error band). Top right panel: The various contributions to for (dotted blue with yellow error band) including QE with Pauli suppression only (dotted-purple), QE suppressed by both ”Pauli” and ”Longitudinal Quenching” (solid-green), and the contribution of nuclear excitations (red-dashed with green error band). Bottom left panel: for (dotted-blue with yellow error band) compared to theoretical calculations including Lovato 2016 [26] (solid-purple), Mihaila 2000 [27] (dashed-green), and RPA Cloet 2016[28] (solid-red). Bottom right panel: for (dotted-black with green error band) compared to theoretical calculations of Sobczyk 2020[29] (red-dashed) and Mihaila 2000 (dotted-dashed).
If another formalism is used to model QE scattering (e.g. RFG or spectral functions) then the quenching factor for the model is given by:
The top right panel of Figure 3 shows the various contributions to the measured for (dotted blue line with yellow error band). Shown are the QE contribution with only Pauli suppression (dotted-purple), QE suppressed by both ”Pauli Suppression” and labeled as QE total suppression (solid-green), and the contribution of nuclear excitations (red-dashed line). The green error band is 15% plus 0.01 added in quadrature.
The left panel on the bottom of Figure 3 shows a comparison of the extracted for (dotted-blue curve with yellow error band) to theoretical calculations. These include the Lovato 2016[26] ”First Principle Green’s Function Monte Carlo” (GFMC) calculation (solid-purple line), Mihaila[27] 2000 Coupled-Clusters based calculation (AV18+UIX potential, dashed-green), and Cloet 2016[28] RPA calculation (RPA solid-red). Our measurement for are in disagreement with Cloet 2016 RPA, and in reasonable agreement with Lovato 2016 and Mihaila 2000 except near GeV where the contribution from nuclear excitations is significant.
There is not enough QE data for to perform a complete analysis. We find that the QE fit parameters for also describe all available data on . A difference in between and could be the contribution of nuclear excitations. However as shown in Figure 1 the contributions of nuclear excitations to the for and are consistent with being equal.
The bottom right panel of Figure 3 shows for (dotted-blue with green error band) compared to theoretical calculations. These include the Sobczyk 2020[29] “Coupled-Cluster with Singles-and Doubles (CCSD) NNLOsat” (red-dashed line), and Mihaila 2000[27] Coupled-Cluster calculation with (AV18+UIX potential, dashed green line). The data are in reasonable agreement with Sobczyk 2020 and Mihaila 2000 calculations for except near GeV where the contribution from nuclear excitations is significant.
The contribution to the QE transverse structure function for is parameterized as a distorted Gaussian centered around GeV and a Gaussian at GeV[30] with dependent width and amplitude. for ( MeV). For it is given by:
where is in units of GeV, is the proton mass, is the atomic weight, , , , , and . The parameters of the empirical model of in electron scattering can be used to predict the contribution in neutrino scattering[31].
A comparison between our extraction of and and the extraction (for only three values of ) by Jourdan[25] are shown in Figure 4. At the lowest our is a somewhat lower and our is a somewhat higher (the Jourdan analysis includes data from only two experiments). Also shown are two 1-body+2-body current (1b+2b) calculations: GFMC[26] and ”Energy Dependent-Relativistic Mean Field” (ED-RMF)[32]. In our fit, we show each nuclear excitation with excitation energy at where is the mass of the carbon nucleus. In contrast, the ED-RMF calculations group all excitations in two fixed peaks as shown in Fig.4, and the GFMC calculations do not show any nuclear excitations. Both calculations are in reasonable agreement with our analysis in the QE region. In both models there is enhancement of if only 1b currents are included and additional enhancement if both 1b and 2b currents are included. The curves labeled 2b in Figure 4 show the enhancement in from 2b currents only [i.e. (1b+2b) minus (1b only)], while our empirical extraction of shown in Figure 4 models the enhancement in from all sources.

Figure 4. Comparisons between our extraction of and and the extraction (for only three values of ) by Jourdan[25] (the Jourdan analysis includes data from only two experiments). Also shown are comparisons to 1b+2b GFMC[26] and ED-RMF[32] theoretical predictions. In these two models the curves labeled 2b are the only contribution of 2-body currents to . The transverse enhancement in both 1b and 2b currents is included in the total.
In summary, using all available electron scattering data we extract parameterizations of the quenching of the and the enhancement of over a large range of and , and obtain the best measurement of the Coulomb Sum Rule to date. The measured for are inconsistent with Cloet 2016 RPA, but in reasonable agreement with Lovato 2016 and Mihaila 2000 calculations. The sum rule for is in reasonable agreement with Sobczyk 2020 and Mihaila 2000 calculations,
The contribution of nuclear excitations to is significant (up to 29%). Theoretical studies show that at low nuclear excitations are also significant in scattering[33, 34]. Therefore, nuclear excitations should be included in both electron and MC generators. Decays of excitations with above proton removal threshold can have a proton in the final state (which in experiments cannot be distinguished from QE events).
Additional comparisons of our fit to experimental data are included in the supplemental materials[37]. New precision QE data from both Hall C [35] (at low and forward angles) and Hall A (specifically taken to examine the saturation of the CSR) are expected to be finalized soon and to further improve the separation of longitudinal and transverse cross sections via future fitting efforts. This Research is supported by the U.S. Department of Energy, Office of Science, under University of Rochester grant number DE-SC0008475, and the Office of Science, Office of Nuclear Physics under contract DE-AC05-06OR23177.
References
Supplementary materials
Additional comparisons of the universal fit to some of the measurements of on and .
Figure 5. Radiatively corrected inelastic electron scattering cross sections on for excitation energies less than 50 MeV. The cross sections for excitation energies less than 12 MeV have been multiplied by (1/6). The pink solid line is the predicted from our fit which include nuclear states excitation form factor, quasilelastic scattering (dashed blue line), ”Transverse Enhancement/MEC” (solid red line) and inelastic pion production (at higher excitation energies). Most of the data is from Yamaguchi [8] (Phys. Rev. D3 (1971) 1750). The data for 54 MeV and are from Goldemberg 1964 (Phys. Rev. 134 (1964) B963), and the data for 65 MeV and are from deForest 1965 (Phys. Letters 16 (1965), 311).
Figure 6. Comparisons our fit to a subset of electron scattering differential cross section data with . The total is shown as the solid purple line. The dashed blue line is the QE differential cross section. The TE contribution to the QE differential cross section is shown as the solid red line. Inelastic pion production processes are shown as the dot-dashed black line. The fit is in good agreement with the cross section data for both small and large angles. The values of increase from top bottom from to . Data are from Barreau 1983 (Nucl. Phys. 402A (1983) 515) and Baran 1988 (Phys. Rev. Lett. 61 (1988) 400).
Figure 7. Comparison of our fit (using parameters) to all available measurements on . Data are from O’Connell 1987 (Phys. Rev. C35 (1987) 1063), Anghinolfi 1995 (J. Phy. G: Nucl. Part. Phys. 21 L9, 1995) and Anghinolfi 1996 (Nucl. Phys. A602 (1996) 405.
References
- [1]D. Drechsel and M M Giannini 1989 Rep. Prog. Phys. 52 1083 (eq. 7.9); T. de Forest Jr. and J.D. Walecka, Advances in Physics, 15:57, 1-109 (1966) (eq. 6.8).
- [2]A. A. Aguilar-Arévalo et al., (MiniBooNE) Phys. Rev. Lett. 100, 032301 (2008).
- [3]M. F. Carneiro et al., (MINERvA Collaboration), Phys. Rev. Lett. 124, 181801 (2020).
- [4]P. Abratenko et al., (MicroBooNE), Phys. Rev. Lett. 123, 131801 (2019).
- [5]P. Abratenko et al., (MicroBooNE) Phys. Rev. Lett. 125, 201803 (2020).
- [6]J.A. Caballero, M. C. Martinez, J. L. Herraiz, J.M. Udias Physics Letters B 688, 250 (2010).
- [7]A. Bodek, S. Avvakumov, R. Bradford, H. Budd, Eur. Phys. J C53, 349 (2008).
- [8]Y. Yamaguchi et. al.., Phys. Rev. D3, 1750 (1971).
- [9]P.E. Bosted and V. Mamyan, arXiv:1203.2262 (2012); V. Mamyan, Ph.D. dissertation, Univ. of Virginia, 2010.arxiv.org/abs/1203.2262
- [10]C. Maieron, T.W. Donnelly, I. Sick, Phys.Rev. C65, 025502, (2002).
- [11]J.E. Amaro, M.B. Barbaro, J.A. Caballero, T.W. Donnelly, A. Molinari, and I. Sick, Phys. Rev. C 71, 015501 (2005).
- [12]J.E. Amaro, M.B. Barbaro, J.A. Caballero, R. Gonzalez-Jimenez, G.D. Megias, I. Ruiz Simo, J. Phys. G: Nucl. Part. Phys. 47, 124001 (2020).
- [13]G.D. Megias Vazquez (Tesis Doctoral). Universidad de Sevilla, Sevilla, (2017).
- [14]R. Rosenfelder, Ann. Phys. 128, 188 (1980).
- [15]G. D. Megias, M. V. Ivanov, R. Gonzalez-Jimenez, M. B. Barbaro, J. A. Caballero, T. W. Donnelly, J. M. Udias, Phys. Rev. D 89, 093002 (2014).
- [17]O. Benhar, D. Day and I. Sick, Rev. Mod. Phys. 80, 189 (2008). Quasielastic Electron Nucleus Scattering Archive. http://discovery.phys.virginia.edu/research/groups/qes-archive/
- [18]Resonance-Data-Archive: https://hallweb.jlab.org/resdata/
- [19]P. Gueye, M. Bernheim, J. F. Danel, J. E. Ducret, L.
- [20]P.E. Bosted, Phys. Rev. C 51, 409 (1995).
- [21]Arie Bodek and Tejin Cai, Eur. Phys. J. C. (2019) 79; Arie Bodek and Tejin Cai, Eur. Phys. J. C 80, 655 (2020).
- [22]P.E. Bosted and M.E. Christy, Phys. Rev. C 77, 065206 (2008); M.E. Christy and P.E. Bosted, Phys. Rev. C 81, 055213 (2010).
- [23]P. Barreau et. al., Nucl. Phys. 402A, 515 (1983).
- [24]D. T. Baran et. al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 61, 400 (1988).
- [25]J. Jourdan, Nucl. Phys. A603, 117 (1996); J. Jourdan, Phys. Lett. B353, 189 (1995).
- [26]A. Lovato, S. G. Gandolfi, J. Carlson, S. C. Pieper, R. Schiavilla, Phys. Rev. Lett. 117, 082501 (2016). (GFMC: First Principle Green’s Function Monte Carlo).
- [27]Bogdan Mihaila and Jochen H. Heisenberg, Phys. Rev. Lett. 84, 1403 (2000).
- [28]Ian C. Cloet, Wolfgang Bentz, Anthony W. Thomas, Phys. Rev. Lett. 116, 032701 (2016).
- [29]J. E. Sobczyk, B. Acharya, S. Bacca, and G. Hagen Phys.Rev.C 102, 064312 (2020).
- [30]A. V. Butkevich and S. V. Luchuk, Phys.Rev.C 102, 024602 (2020).
- [31]K. Gallmeister, U. Mosel, and J. Weil, Phys. Rev. C 94, 035502 (2016); S. Dolan, U. Mosel, K. Gallmeister, L. Pickering, and S. Bolognesi Phys. Rev. C 98, 045502 (2018).
- [32]T. Franco-Munoz, R. Gonzalez-Jimenez, and J.M. Udias, arXiv:2203.09996v1 (2022).(ED-RMF: Energy Dependent-Relativistic Mean Field).
- [33]V. Pandey, N. Jachowicz, T. Van Cuyck, J. Ryckebusch, and M. Martini, Phys. Rev. C 92, 024606 (2015).
- [34]M. Martini, N. Jachowicz, M. Ericson, V. Pandey, T. Van Cuyck, and N. Van Dessel, Phys. Rev. C 94, 015501 (2016); V. Pandey, N. Jachowicz, M. Martini, R. Gonzalez-Jimenez, J. Ryckebusch, T. Van Cuyck, and N. VanDessel, Phys. Rev. C 94, 054609 (2016).
- [35]Jlab Hall C E04-001 Spokespersons: A. Bodek, M. E. Christy, C. Keppel; A. Bodek arXiv:hep-ex/0411044; QE data at q values of 0.225, 0.267, 0.337, 0.395, 0.447, 0.571, 0.854 GeV
- [37]Supplemental materials [URL will be inserted by publisher]




