WorksMathematics
Deligne pairing isomorphisms for projective duals and higher-rank associated hypersurfaces
Abstract
Given a family π:X\to S of complex projective varieties, polarised by a (sufficiently) relatively very ample L, we give an isomorphism between a Deligne pairing involving higher relative cotangent Chern classes, and the relative projective dual line X^\vee(L). As a consequence, we obtain explicit Deligne pairing isomorphisms for all of the higher associated hypersurfaces of Gelfand–Kapranov–Zelevinsky, including mixed polarisations, as well as higher-rank versions of such hypersurfaces involving sufficiently positive vector bundles.
Introduction.
This note aims at showing a simple way to generalise a class of results yielding isomorphisms between resultant lines and Deligne pairings. The first notable result of this type is due to Zhang [Zha96] (see also similar previous results in Arakelov geometry: [12, 13, 14, 18 BGS94]), who constructed an isomorphism between the Chow line and the top-Deligne pairing of a very ample line bundle on a family . Yhis result saw a slight generalisation in [19], with the full mixed case treated in [Reb25] (see also [CM21] in the Arakelov setting).
Work of Kapadia [9, 10] then extended Zhang’s result to a modification of the Chow line, the hyperdiscriminant (or Hurwitz line, which may be constructed using the first associated hypersurface described in [8]). This, in view of Paul’s [11 ?] and Phong–Sturm’s [15] results, was motivated by the study of K-stability. Analogous ideas were used in [DR24] and [Reb25].
We show in this note that one can describe arbitrary higher associated hypersurfaces in the sense of [8], as well as vector bundle resultants [?], and many other constructions, in terms of Deligne pairings. All of those results may be unified simply by realising the (relative) projective dual of the embedding of by a single relatively very ample line bundle, as a Deligne pairing. Namely, we prove the following.
Theorem A. Let be a family satisfying hypotheses as below, and let be a (sufficiently) relatively very ample line bundle on . Let be the line defining the relative projective dual . Then, there is a canonical isomorphism
The proof follows the ideas of [Zha96, Reb25] and [9], adequately modified to fit the construction: we evaluate an auxiliary pairing along two different sections, which define birational hypersurfaces, and use standard properties of the Deligne pairing. Applying Theorem A to the hyperplane bundles of projectivised vector bundles of the form , with positive vector bundles on , then yields a wealth of applications, described at the end of the article. We obtain, in particular, an expression for the higher associated hypersurfaces of [8]
as well as a higher-rank version of the main result of [Reb25]: given very positive vector bundles on , with degrees summing to :
We refer the reader to the last section for more precise statements.
Acknowledgements. The author thanks Ruadhaí Dervan for discussions related to the main results of this article.
AI usage statement. The entirety of this article was written by the author. It is based on an old idea of using Kapadia’s arguments to prove the general isomorphism, and was considered in [Reb25] (see Section 3.6 therein), but ultimately left for a later article. LLMs were used in verifying and clarifying calculations in the present article, as well as to clarify results in [9], and auditing the article for correctness.
Preliminaries.
Deligne pairings for Chern polynomials.
1.1. Deligne pairings were constructed by Elkik [7] (building on [3]); we give their construction using generators and relations as in [7 II.2.4] and [Zha96]. For the entirety of this section, we refer the reader to the aforementioned [7 Zha96], as well as [5]. We recall afterwards how to construct Deligne pairings for more general Chern polynomials, as will be needed for us.
Our standing assumption on families throughout the article will be the following:
Definition 1.1. We say a morphism satisfies if it is smooth, flat, projective, finitely presented, and of relative (pure) dimension .
We now fix satisfying as above. We begin with the datum of line bundles on . We then define the Deligne pairing
to be the line bundle on which has, as sections, formal expressions of the form
with each and each collection satisfying that , subject to all relations
where is such that the divisor is flat over , and is a rational function on . This turns out to quotient to a line bundle on the base . We warn the reader that the notation for Chern classes may be confusing in case of repeated indices: denotes the genuine Chern class of , whereas will denote the -th product of , a degree Chern polynomial expression.
Let now be a collection of vector bundles with , and let , with projections , and set . Let be nonnegative integers summing to . One then defines Deligne pairings for Segre classes by
We may have for some , in which case will simply denote omission in the Deligne pairing. It is then clear that we recover the usual construction for line bundles. We note, as observed in a more general setting in [7 Remarque V.1.2(e)], that in particular if ,
We now turn to Chern classes of the , following Eriksson–Freixas [5 Section 7.1.1] which coincides with Elkik’s (by [5 Corollary 7.11]). First set , and recall the identities
This allows us to define pairings for Chern classes inductively. Assuming the ’s to sum adequately, we set
It is then clear that, if all the ,
which is further computed by determinants as above. The Deligne pairing is then extended, by linearity, to general Chern–Segre polynomials.
Finally, we note that we will use additive notation for the Deligne pairings themselves, as line bundles.
Properties of Deligne pairings.
We collect here a list of properties which will be used in the proof of the main theorem. Throughout, unless otherwise stated, will be used to denote line bundles, vector bundles, homogeneous Chern polynomials, sometimes understood to have suitable degrees. The equal sign will always denote ”there exists an isomorphism, compatible with the previous operations, which is natural in the sense of [EFiM24]”. All of the following properties may be found in [5] and {citep}[7]`, to which we refer the reader.
We first have the following normalisations:
For integers , ,
For , , ,
We note the following twisting formula:
Suppose satisfies , and satisfies with satisfying . Let be a homogeneous Chern polynomial on , on , such that . Then,
where
Suppose is exact and is homogeneous of degree , then
In particular, for adequately chosen,
and if ,
Suppose is a regular section of , , with vanishing locus flat over of relative dimension . Then
In particular, for a flat relative effective Cartier , applying (1.19) to the canonical section yields:
Suppose both satisfy over . Let be an isomorphism over a quasi-compact open of , dense in every fibre (we will call such maps relative birational maps, and say and are *relatively birational over ). If is a Chern polynomial of degree on ,
Finally, we note a useful comparison for Segre classes, which is a particular case of the definitions in the previous section, is the following: let be a vector bundle of rank , and . Write . Let be a Chern polynomial of adequate degree on . Then,
Deligne pairing isomorphism for the projective dual.
Relative dual line and incidence constructions.
Let satisfy . Let be a relatively very ample line bundle on , such that is locally free of rank . Let . We denote by the relative projective dual of by the relative embedding given by . In other words, given the incidence
then is the image of by the projection to , with its reduced scheme structure. We will denote by its fibre, which is just the projective dual of . We first note the following:
Lemma 2.1. For all large enough, uniformly in , is a hypersurface.
Proof. By [8 Chapter 1, Corollary 1.2], it suffices to show that the image of each by , , does not contain a projective line. Suppose it is the case, and let be the preimage of such a line in , then . But since is ample, we have , hence . Thus the result holds for any . □
In the case that is a hypersurface in each fibre, it is automatically a relative effective Cartier divisor on . There then exists such that
We then define
We will call the relative dual line. By the projection formula, one then has
We now give a different incidence construction closely related to . Consider the jet bundle , and note that one has a canonical section given by jet evaluation,
with . By very ampleness, the evaluation morphism at each is surjective, and the vanishing locus then has as fibre over its projectivised kernel . We also will use the following:
Proposition 2.2. The projection is relatively birational over .
Proof. Let be the smooth locus of , which is dense in every fibre of by [8 Chapter 1, 1]. Then by [8 Chapter 1, Proposition 3.2(b)], is a fibrewise isomorphism, hence an isomorphism, concluding the proof.
By [8 Chapter 3, Example 3.12], one then has that
Proof of the main result.
We now prove the following.
Theorem 2.3. Suppose are as in the previous subsection, and that is a relative effective Cartier divisor. We then have that
Proof. Consider the auxiliary pairing
We will first evaluate it along the relative birational morphism defined above, then along . Using thus (1.21) (and Proposition 2.2), then (1.20), we obtain
By (2.2), linearity, and finally (1.12) together with , we find
By (1.7) this is finally
Using now (1.19) applied to , and (1.10),
By (1.13), only the terms with are nonvanishing; the projection formula (1.12) applied to the two remaining terms then yields
Using (2.3), comparing (2.9) and (2.12) yields
To conclude, we finally apply (1.15) to the exact sequence
where only the term with is nonvanishing. This concludes the proof. □
Important special cases.
We prove the following as a consequence of Theorem 2.3. As we will see, its corollaries will recover more familiar objects.
Theorem 3.1. Let satisfy . Let be a vector bundle of rank on . Write , , and assume is relative effective. Let be the relative dual line . Then,
Proof. By Theorem 2.3, we have
Applying (1.15) to the (twisted) cotangent sequence
and using that only the term with is nonvanishing, yields
while (1.15) now applied to the relative Euler sequence
with only the case nonvanishing, yields
Expanding via (1.10),
and the result follows from (1.22). □
Example 3.2. Let with the sufficiently very ample on and with ranks summing to . Using the Whitney formula (1.15) applied to the direct sum, one obtains from Theorem 3.1 the higher-rank case of the results of [Reb25], alluded to in the last section thereof:
In particular, for sufficiently very ample line bundles, one recovers the isomorphism part of [Reb25, Theorem B], itself generalising [Zha96]. In the case where , the vector bundle formula recovers the pairing of [3], [6 Definition 3.4]. The vector bundle resultant, i.e. the left-hand side above, also appears in [8 Chapter 3, Example 3.9].
Example 3.3. For sufficiently very ample and with , is the (relative) -th associated hypersurface of in the sense of [GKZ08, Chapter 3, 2.E], that is, the set of codimension linear subspaces of such that, for some ,
Applying Theorem 3.1 using and (1.10), we have the following simple Deligne pairing interpretation of associated hypersurfaces:
For , this recovers the isomorphism part of the main result of [9]. Note that we also obtain an explicit expression for the degrees
Example 3.4. One also obtains a mixed version of the higher associated hypersurfaces, generalising the mixed Hurwitz forms of [PSS26], which give for example
Likewise, one can mix the previous two examples, involving multiple vector bundles in higher associated hypersurfaces. The statement of Theorem 2.3 more generally applies to any situation involving projective duality, and is thus
References
Rémi Reboulet, CNRS, Institut Camille Jordan, 21 Av. Claude Bernard, 69100 Villeurbanne, France
Email address: [email protected]
References
- [3]P. Deligne. Le déterminant de la cohomologie. In Current trends in arithmetical algebraic geometry, volume 67 of Contemp. Math., pages 93–177. American Mathematical Society, Providence, RI, 1987.DOI
- [5]Dennis Eriksson and Gerard Freixas i Montplet. Deligne-Riemann-Roch and intersection bundles. J. Éc. Polytech., Math., 11:247–361, 2024.arxiv.org/abs/2305.13129
- [6]Dennis Eriksson, Gerard Freixas i Montplet, and Richard A. Wentworth. Complex Chern–Simons bundles in the relative setting. Preprint, arXiv:2109.02033 [math.AG] (2021), 2021.arxiv.org/abs/2109.02033
- [7]R. Elkik. Fibrés d’intersections et intégrales de classes de Chern. (Intersection bundles and integrals of Chern classes). Ann. Sci. Éc. Norm. Supér. (4), 22(2):195–226, 1989.DOI
- [8]I. M. Gelfand, M. M. Kapranov, and A. V. Zelevinsky. Discriminants, resultants, and multidimensional determinants. Mod. Birkhäuser Class. Boston, MA: Birkhäuser, reprint of the 1994 edition edition, 2008.
- [9]H Manilal Kapadia. Deligne Pairings and Discriminants of Algebraic Varieties. Preprint, arXiv:1312.7870 [math.DG] (2013), 2013.arxiv.org/abs/1312.7870
- [10]Hetal Manilal Kapadia. Deligne pairings and discriminants of algebraic varieties. PhD thesis, Rutgers University, 2014.
- [11]Sean Timothy Paul. Geometric analysis of Chow Mumford stability. Adv. Math., 182(2):333–356, 2004.DOI
- [12]Patrice Philippon. Sur des hauteurs alternatives. I. (On alternative heights. I). Math. Ann., 289(2):255–283, 1991.DOI
- [13]Patrice Philippon. Sur des hauteurs alternatives. II. (On alternative heights. II). Ann. Inst. Fourier, 44(4):1043–1065, 1994.DOI
- [14]Patrice Philippon. Sur des hauteurs alternatives. III. J. Math. Pures Appl. (9), 74(4):345–365, 1995.
- [15]D. H. Phong and Jacob Sturm. Stability, energy functionals, and Kähler–Einstein metrics. Commun. Anal. Geom., 11(3):565–597, 2003.DOI
- [18]C. Soulé. Géométrie d’Arakelov et théorie des nombres transcendants. (Arakelov geometry and transcendental number theory). In Gilles Lachaud, editor, Journées arithmétiques. Exposés présentés aux seizièmes congrès en Luminy, France, 17-21 Juillet, 1989, volume 198-200 of Astérisque, pages 355–371. Paris: Société Mathématique de France, 1991.
- [19]Qingchun Tian. Generalized Chow forms and reduction of semi-stable varieties. Acta Math. Sin., Engl. Ser., 16(2):219–228, 2000.DOI