For a p-torsionfree p-quasisyntomic ring, we construct a fiber sequence relating the p-th Nygaard graded piece of absolute prismatic cohomology to the Frobenius–Witt cotangent complex. The latter is an arithmetic analogue of the cotangent complex in which the differential of p need not vanish. We also clarify the relationship between the regularity criterion proved by Mao using the Frobenius–Witt cotangent complex and the regularity criterion established by Bhatt and Mathew using the Nygaard graded piece. This relationship was anticipated by Bhatt and Mathew.
Introduction
Frobenius–Witt derivations are arithmetic analogues of ordinary derivations in which the differential of p need not vanish. This theory was introduced by T. Saito in [11] and by T. Dupuy, E. Katz, J. Rabinoff and D. Zureick-Brown in [4] (under the name of total p-derivations). Furthermore, relationships between such derivations and the regularity of rings were independently clarified by Saito ([11 Theorem 3.4]) and by Hochster and Jeffries ([5 Corollary 5.10]). As one can define the cotangent complex using the derived version of usual derivations, we can also define the Frobenius–Witt cotangent complex using the derived version of Frobenius–Witt derivations ([Shi26b]). We denote this complex by FLR∈D(R/Lp). Using this complex, Z. Mao proved the following regularity criterion: 1
Theorem 1.1 ([9 Theorem 5.2]). Let R be a noetherian ring such that p belongs to its Jacobson radical rad(R). Then the following assertions are equivalent:
(1) R is regular,
(2) FLR is flat over R/Lp:=R⊗ZLFp.
On the other hand, B. Bhatt and A. Mathew established the regularity criterion using the theory of prismatic cohomology:
Theorem 1.2 ([2 Proposition 4.19]). Let R be a complete intersection local noetherian ring with residue field k of characteristic p. Then the following assertions are equivalent:
(1) R is regular,
(2) Cofib(θR)⊗R/pLk is concentrated in cohomological degree ≥1,
where θR:R/Lp→(grNpΔR)/Lp is a map of D(R/p) defined in [2].
In their paper, Bhatt and Mathew expected this theorem to be related to the works of [11] and [5]. The purpose of this paper is to clarify a relationship between the Frobenius–Witt cotangent complex and the complex Cofib(θR). More precisely, we prove the following theorem, which connects the Nygaard graded piece of prismatic cohomology and the Frobenius–Witt cotangent complex.
Main Theorem 1 (Theorem 3.7). Let R be a p-torsionfree quasisyntomic ring. Then there is a natural fiber sequence:
Fib(α(L(R/p)/Fp)[−p])⟶Cofib(θR)⟶FLR[−1]⟶
in D(R/p).
Here, the map α(L(R/p)/Fp):∧pL(R/p)/Fp→FR/p∗L(R/p)/Fp[p−1] is defined in [10] by linear algebra. This map connects the map cR:∧pL(R/p)/Fp→(R/p)[p] defined by using the Sen operator on the diffracted Hodge complex ΩRΦ and the obstruction map obR,F:FR/p∗L(R/p)/Fp→(R/p)[p] for Frobenius liftings constructed by Illusie [6]; see [10 Theorem 7.1] and Proposition 3.6.
As an application of this theorem, we prove the following.
Main Theorem 2 (Theorem 4.1). Let R be a p-torsionfree quasisyntomic local ring with residue field k. Then the following assertions are equivalent:
(1) FLR⊗R/pLk is concentrated in degree zero,
(2) Cofib(θR:R/p→grNpΔR/Lp)⊗R/pLk is concentrated in cohomological degree ≥1.
By this theorem, we observe that the regularity criterion via the Frobenius–Witt cotangent complex ((2) ⇒ (1) of Theorem 1.1) formally follows from the regularity criterion via prismatic cohomology ((2) ⇒ (1) of Theorem 1.2) under the assumption that R is a p-torsionfree complete intersection local noetherian ring with residue characteristic p.
Notation. Unless otherwise stated, R is assumed to be a p-torsionfree quasisyntomic commutative Zp-algebra, where p is a fixed prime number ([3 Definition 4.10]). We call quasi-categories ∞-categories. For any animated ring A, we denote the derived ∞-category of A by D(A). We denote by D(A) the full subcategory of D(A) consisting of derived p-complete objects. The left adjoint of the inclusion D(A)↪D(A) is denoted by M↦M. We denote the i-th derived wedge product of M∈D(A) by ⋀iM in which we implicitly take the derived p-completion.
Acknowledgments. The authors thank Ryo Suzuki for asking an insightful question about a relationship between [12] and [10].
The first-named author was supported by JSPS KAKENHI Grant number 24KJ1085.
AI disclosure. This work began when the first-named author asked an LLM whether there was a relationship between the Frobenius–Witt cotangent complex and Nygaard filtration of absolute prismatic cohomology. Through discussions with an LLM, the authors could find the fiber sequence connecting them in one of the main theorems (Theorem 3.7). The authors are responsible for verifying the correctness of the statements and proofs in this paper.
Preliminaries
As is mentioned in Notation, we assume that R is a quasisyntomic p-torsionfree ring.
Proposition 2.1 (cf. [1, 10]). We recall basic properties of the diffracted Hodge complex needed in the sequel.
(1) We have a natural equivalence
griconjΩRΦ≃⋀iLR/Zp[−i]
in D(R) for any i≥0. This is[1], Construction 4.7.1.
(2) By construction, the Sen operator ΘR is compatible with the conjugate filtration on ΩRΦ. Under the identification of (1), the pair (griconjΩRΦ,ΘR) is equivalent to the pair (⋀iLR/Zp[−i],−i) as objects in the ∞-category DN(R):=Fun(BN,D(R)). This is[1], Notation 4.7.2.
the latter map is an equivalence. Therefore, the above fiber sequence induces the desired fiber sequence. □
Next, we recall the definition of the map cR defined in [10]. To do this, we first recall some preliminary facts on the ∞-category DN(R) in [10 Section 6.1].
Remark 2.3. In [10], Petrov considers the ∞-category DN(R) defined to be:
DN(R):=Fun(BN,D(R)).
We recall some facts on its mapping animae.
By [8 00JC], there is a canonical map Δ1/∂Δ1⟶BN, which is an inner anodyne map. Thus, the induced functor
DN(R)=Fun(BN,D(R))⟶Fun(Δ1/∂Δ1,D(R))
is an equivalence of ∞-categories. Therefore, as is written in [10 Section 6.1], the mapping anima can be computed as follows:
Although the following two lemmas on the ∞-category DN(R) are not necessary for the construction of the map cR, we recall them here for later use.
Lemma 2.4. Let
(A,0)i(B,f)q(C,0)→
be a fiber sequence in the ∞-category DN(R). Then by the universality of A as a fiber of the map q:B→C, f induces a natural map flow:B→A. Moreover, by the universality of C as a cofiber of the map i:A→B, flow further induces a natural map h:C→A. Then there is a natural equivalence:
flow≃h∘q.
Proof. This follows from the commutativity of the diagram (A,0)i(B,f)q(C,0)→. □
Lemma 2.5. Keep the notation in Lemma 2.4. Let c:C→A[1]⊕A be the map classifying the connecting map of this fiber sequence ((1) of Remark 2.3). Then the composition
CcA[1]⊕AprA
coincides with the map h:C→A.
Proof. This follows from the paragraph between [10 Corollary 6.6] and [10 Lemma 6.7]. □
Construction 2.6. We recall the map
cR:⋀FppL(R/p)/Fp⟶(R/p)[p]
in D(R/p) defined in [10 Notation 6.4]. Consider the following fiber sequence in DN(R):
where in the second equivalence, we used the identification in (1) of Remark 2.3. Therefore, the connecting map of the above fiber sequence defines a map:
cR:⋀pL(R/p)/Fp⟶(R/p)[p],
which is the desired one.
Construction 2.7. To state our first main result, we recall the map θR defined in [2]. Since (3) of Proposition 2.1 implies the equivalence
grNpΔZp≃Fib(ZppZp)≃Fp[−1],
we have the natural map:
Fp⟶Fp⊕Fp[−1]≃grNpΔZp/Lp⟶grNpΔR/Lp,
where the first map is the inclusion into the first factor and the second map is induced by the canonical map Zp→R. We denote by θR the R/p-linearization
R/p⟶grNpΔR/Lp
of the above Fp-linear map.
At the end of this section, we recall the following lemma, which is a stable ∞-categorical version of the octahedral axiom for triangulated categories.
Lemma 2.8. Let D be a stable ∞-category. Let f:A→B and g:B→C be maps in D. Then there is a natural fiber sequence:
Fib(f)⟶Fib(g∘f)⟶Fib(g)⟶
in D.
Proof. This is (TR4) in the proof of [7 Theorem 1.1.2.14]. □
The existence of the fiber sequence
As mentioned in Notation, we assume that R is a quasisyntomic p-torsionfree ring. We first identify the cofiber of the map θR with the fiber of the map cR[−p] (Theorem 3.1). We then factorize cR by the map α(L(R/p)/Fp) defined in [10] in Construction 3.3 and the arithmetic Kodaira–Spencer map κR defined in [12] (Proposition 3.6) and conclude the proof of Theorem 1.1.
in DN(R/p). On the other hand, let cR′ be the map classifying the connecting map of the following fiber sequence (see (1) of Remark 2.3):
(R,0)⟶((FilpconjΩRD)0,ΘR)⟶(⋀pLR/Zp[−p],−p)⟶
in DN(R). By definition, the map cR[−p] in Construction 2.6 is the R/p-linearization of cR′. By (2) of Remark 2.3, the map cR′/Lp classifies the connecting map of the fiber sequence (3.1). Combining them, we see that the map cR[−p] can be written as the following composition:
⋀pL(R/p)/Fp[−p]cR′/LpR/p⊕R/p[1]prR/p.
By Lemma 2.5 and Lemma 2.4, we have the following canonical factorization:
Applying Lemma 2.8 to this factorization, we get the following natural fiber sequence:
Fib(q)⟶Fib((ΘR+p)low/Lp)⟶Fib(cR[−p])⟶.
By Lemma 2.2, this fiber sequence can be naturally identified with the following one
R/p⟶grNpΔR/Lp⟶Fib(cR[−p])⟶.
To complete the proof, it remains to prove that the map R/p⟶grNpΔR/Lp in the above fiber sequence is naturally equivalent to the map θR. By the definition of θR (see Construction 2.7) and the functoriality of the above fiber sequence, we may assume R=Zp. In this case, the factorization (1) can be identified with the following composition:
Fp⟶0⟶Fp.
The first map in the fiber sequence obtained from this composition by applying Lemma 2.8 can be written as follows:
FpcanFp⊕Fp[−1].
By Construction 2.7, this coincides with the map θZp. □
Remark 3.2. In the proof of [2 Proposition 4.19], Bhatt and Mathew also constructed the fiber sequence in the form of Theorem 3.1 by animation. This fiber sequence coincides with the one in Theorem 3.1. More precisely, there exists an automorphism uR on ⋀pL(R/p)/Fp[−p] and a commutative diagram:
in D(R/p), where the upper fiber sequence is the one in Theorem 3.1 and the lower one is the fiber sequence (17) in the proof of [2 Proposition 4.19].
To prove this, we may assume R is a p-completed polynomial Zp-algebra. In this case, the proof of [2 Proposition 4.19] implies that Cofib(θR) is concentrated in cohomological degrees 1 and p with H1≅R/p and Hp≅Ω(R/p)/Fpp. Therefore, we have a natural automorphism
where the upper horizontal map is the one in the fiber sequence of Theorem 3.1 and the lower horizontal map is the one in the fiber sequence (17) in the proof of [2 Proposition 4.19]. This square extends to the desired commutative diagram (2).
Next, we connect the above result with the Frobenius–Witt cotangent complex of R. To do so, we establish the following result (Proposition 3.6) using the result of [10]. For convenience, we recall the construction of the map α(L(R/p)/Fp) defined in [10] and the map κR defined in [12]. The latter map is inspired by the arithmetic Kodaira–Spencer map defined in [4] in the case of smooth algebras.
Construction 3.3. Let E be an object of D(R/p). We define the map α(E) in D(R/p) to be the following composition:
α(E):ΛpE≃Γp(E[−1])[p]ψE[−1][p]FR/p∗E[p−1],
where the first equivalence is Illusie’s décalage equivalence ([6 Proposition I.4.3.2.1]; see also [10 Lemma 2.6]) and ψE[−1] is the map defined in the paragraph between [10 Lemma 2.5] and [10 Lemma 2.6].
Remark 3.4. Precisely, the definition of the map α(E) in [10] is different from the one in Construction 3.3. However, these definitions are the same by the paragraph between [10 Definition 3.4] and [10 Remark 3.5].
Construction 3.5. By [Shi26b, Theorem 5.3], we have the following natural fiber sequence:
R/p⟶FLR⟶FR/p∗L(R/p)/Fp⟶
in D(R/p). The arithmetic Kodaira–Spencer map κR is defined to be the connecting map
where obF,R is the map defined in [10 Convention 5.5 and Lemma 5.6], which comes from the obstruction class defined in [6 III.2.2]. Therefore, it remains to show that there is a natural equivalence κR≃obF,R. Let λR be the map defined in [12 Definition 5.2], which coincides with the map γR0−γR0(1) in [10 Lemma 5.6]. By [12 Theorem 5.3], the map λR is naturally equivalent to the following composition:
By the definition of the arithmetic Kodaira–Spencer map, we have
Fib(κR[−1])≃FLR[−1].
Combining them, we get the desired fiber sequence. □
The comparison of regularity criteria
Using the results in the previous section, we study the relationship between the regularity criterion using the Frobenius–Witt cotangent complex and the one established in [2].
Theorem 4.1. Let R be a p-torsionfree quasisyntomic local ring with residue field k. Then the following assertions are equivalent:
FLR⊗R/pLk is concentrated in degree zero,
(2) Cofib(θR:R/p→grNpΔR/Lp)⊗R/pLk is concentrated in cohomological degree ≥1.
Proof. By definition and Proposition 3.6, we have the following commutative diagram of fiber sequences in D(k):
where the upper fiber sequence is the one in Theorem 3.1 and the lower fiber sequence is obtained by applying (−)⊗R/pLk to the fundamental fiber sequence of Frobenius–Witt cotangent complexes ([Shi26b, Theorem 5.3]). As is mentioned in the proof of [2 Proposition 4.19], the assertion (2) is equivalent to the injectivity of the map
H0(cR[−p]⊗Lk):H0(⋀pL(R/p)/Fp[−p]⊗R/pLk)→k.
Based on this, we first compute H0(⋀pL(R/p)/Fp[−p]⊗R/pLk): Since L(R/p)/Fp⊗R/pLk is concentrated in homological degree [0,1], we have the following fiber sequence:
for 0≤i≤p, where in the second equivalence, we used Illusie’s décalage isomorphism (e.g. [10 Lemma 2.6]). Using this, we see that the natural morphism H1(L(R/p)/Fp⊗R/pLk)[1]→L(R/p)/Fp⊗R/pLk induces a natural equivalence
is an isomorphism by the above identification. This and the injectivity of H0(κR[−1]⊗Lk) imply the injectivity of H0(cR[−p]⊗Lk). As recalled in the first paragraph, this is equivalent to the assertion (2).
(2) ⇒ (1): Conversely, assume (2), which is equivalent to the injectivity of the map H0(cR[−p]⊗Lk). In particular, we have
dimkΓp(H1(L(R/p)/Fp⊗R/pLk))≤1,
which implies
dimkH1(L(R/p)/Fp⊗R/pLk)≤1.
By the commutativity of the above diagram of fiber sequences, this implies that the map H0(κR[−1]⊗Lk) is also injective. This, together with the lower fiber sequence in the above commutative diagram, implies the vanishing of H1(FLR⊗R/pLk). Since the vanishing of homology groups of FLR⊗R/pLk in degree ≥2 always holds by our assumption on R, we get the assertion (1). □
As expected by Bhatt and Mathew in the paragraph right before [2 Lemma 4.18], there is a relationship between the regularity criterion via Cofib(θR) and the regularity criterion via the Frobenius–Witt differentials:
Remark 4.2. Let (R,m,k) be a p-torsionfree complete intersection local noetherian ring with residue characteristic p. If FLR is flat over R/p, then Theorem 4.1 implies that Cofib(θR)⊗R/pLk is concentrated in cohomological degree ≥1. Therefore, [2 Proposition 4.19] implies the regularity of R. Thus, under the assumption that R is a complete intersection, [2 Proposition 4.19] implies the regularity criterion via the Frobenius–Witt cotangent complex (i.e. the former part of [9 Theorem 5.2]).
Department of Mathematics, Institute of Science Tokyo, 2-12-1 Ookayama, Meguro, Tokyo 152-8551
[1][BL22] B. Bhatt and J. Lurie, Absolute Prismatic Cohomology, preprint, (2022). arXiv:2201.06120.arxiv.org/abs/2201.06120
[2]B. Bhatt and A. Mathew, Syntomic Complexes and p-Adic Étale Tate Twists, Forum of Mathematics, Pi, 11 (2023) e1.DOI
[3]B. Bhatt, M. Morrow, and P. Scholze, Topological Hochschild Homology and Integral p-Adic Hodge Theory, Publications mathématiques de l’IHÉS, 129(1) (2019) 199–310.arxiv.org/abs/1802.03261
[4]T. Dupuy, E. Katz, J. Rabinoff, and D. Zureick-Brown, Total p-Differentials on Schemes over ℤ/p², Journal of Algebra, 524 (2019) 110–123.DOI
[5]M. Hochster and J. Jeffries, A Jacobian criterion for nonsingularity in mixed characteristic, Amer. J. Math, 146(6) (2024) 1749–1780.arxiv.org/abs/2106.01996
[6]L. Illusie, Complexe Cotangent et Déformations I, Lecture Notes in Mathematics, 239 (1971) Springer-Verlag, Berlin-New York.
[10]A. Petrov, Non-Decomposability of the de Rham Complex and Non-Semisimplicity of the Sen Operator, preprint, (2025). arXiv:2302.11389, to appear in Annals of Mathematics.arxiv.org/abs/2302.11389
[11]T. Saito, Frobenius–Witt Differentials and Regularity, Algebra & Number Theory, 16(2) (2022) 369–391.DOI
[12]K. Shimada, Arithmetic Kodaira–Spencer Class and Frobenius Liftings via Frobenius–Witt Cotangent Complex, preprint, (2026). arXiv:2608.21772.arxiv.org/abs/2608.21772