betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Resolution of the hyperfine puzzle and its significance for two fermion Dirac atoms

Abstract

The hyperfine interaction in the ground state of a hydrogen atom of assumed radius RR is proportional to −1/R3-1/R^3, raising the question of why the hyperfine interaction does not lead to collapse of hydrogen, or positronium. We approach the problem in terms of a minimax variational calculation based on the exact Gordon solution of the Dirac equation for the hydrogen atom ground state. The full Dirac treatment leads to the result that in an assumed variational state of size RR, when RR minimizes the total energy the magnetic moment of the electron assumes its usual value, eℏ/2mce\hbar/2mc, but when R<ℏ/mcR<\hbar/mc, the effective electron magnetic moment becomes essentially eR/2eR/2, softening the hyperfine interaction and eliminating an energy minumum at small RR. The magnetic moment of the proton is similarly suppressed, and the hyperfine interaction of a small size atom becomes bounded by the kinetic energy, thus assuring stability. We extend the Dirac variational calculation to positronium where we find simple results for the ground state energy and hyperfiine interaction, and then extend this variational calculation to Coulombic atoms of two fermions of arbitrary masses. This paper also lays out a framework for treating diquarks as relativistic Coulombic systems, in the presence of color electric and magnetic interactions.

Introduction

The hyperfine interaction [1, 2] is cental to high-precision atomic spectroscopy [3], as well as in positronium [4] and the color magnetic interactions of quarks in hadrons [5, 6]. In a singlet spin state, the hyperfine interaction is attractive, and as Fermi showed, nominally proportional to the square of the wave function at the origin, giving a contribution to the energy ∝−1/R3\propto-1/R^{3}, where RR is the size of the bound state. Why does this interaction not lead to collapse of the bound state to R→0R \to0, since the kinetic energy rises only as 1/R21/R^{2} non-relativistically (and as 1/R1/R relativistically) in the small RR limit. Why do hydrogen and positronium not collapse?

The simplest picture of non-relativistic hydrogen illustrates the problem. We assume a trial ground state wave function,

φ(r)=e−r/RπR3;(1)\varphi(r) = \frac{e^{-r/R}}{\sqrt{\pi R^{3}}}; \tag*{(1)}

which is the exact solution for the normal hydrogen ground state when the variational parameter RR equals the Bohr radius, a0=ℏ/me2a_0 = \hbar/me^2, with mm the electron mass. In this state the expectation value of the kinetic energy is 1/2mR21/2mR^{2}, and the expectation value of the Coulomb energy is −α/R-\alpha/R, where α=e2/ℏc\alpha= e^2/\hbar c is the QED fine structure constant. (We work in units ℏ=c=1\hbar= c = 1.) In the absence of the hyperfine interaction, the expectation value of the total energy,

E0(R)=12mR2−αR,(2)E_0(R) = \frac{1}{2mR^{2}} - \frac{\alpha}{R}, \tag*{(2)}

has the expected minimum, −α/2R-\alpha/2R, at R=1/mα=a0R = 1/m\alpha= a_0.

The Hamiltonian of the hyperfine interaction between the electron and proton is,

Hhf=μeσ⃗e⋅H⃗(r),(3)H_{hf} = \mu_e \vec{\sigma}_e \cdot\vec{H}(r), \tag*{(3)}

where μe\mu_e is the magnitude of the electron magnetic moment, σ⃗e\vec{\sigma}_e is the electron Pauli spin matrix (twice the electron spin), and

H⃗(r)=−∇⃗×(σ⃗p×∇⃗)μpr(4)\vec{H}(r) = -\vec{\nabla} \times(\vec{\sigma}_p \times\vec{\nabla}) \frac{\mu_p}{r} \tag*{(4)}

is the magnetic field produced by the proton magnetic moment, with σ⃗p\vec{\sigma}_p the proton spin Pauli matrix. Here μp=gpe/4Mp\mu_p = g_p e/4M_p is the magnitude of the proton magnetic moment, with gp/2≈2.79g_p/2 \approx2.79. Then

Hhf=−μeμp(σ⃗e⋅σ⃗p∇2−σ⃗e⋅∇⃗σ⃗p⋅∇⃗)1r(5)H_{hf} = -\mu_e\mu_p \left(\vec{\sigma}_e \cdot\vec{\sigma}_p \nabla^2 - \vec{\sigma}_e \cdot\vec{\nabla}\vec{\sigma}_p \cdot\vec{\nabla}\right) \frac{1}{r} \tag*{(5)}

In an s-state, σ⃗e⋅∇⃗σ⃗p⋅∇⃗(1/r)\vec{\sigma}_e \cdot\vec{\nabla}\vec{\sigma}_p \cdot\vec{\nabla}(1/r) averages to 13σ⃗e⋅σ⃗p∇(1/r)\frac{1}{3}\vec{\sigma}_e \cdot\vec{\sigma}_p \nabla(1/r), so that with ∇2(1/r)=−4πδ(r)\nabla^2(1/r) = -4\pi\delta(r) and the state (1), one recovers the Fermi formula for the expectation value of the hyperfine interaction.

Ehf=8π3μeμp⟨σ⃗e⋅σ⃗p⟩∣ψ(0)∣2=8μeμp3R3⟨σ⃗e⋅σ⃗p⟩.(6)E_{hf} = \frac{8\pi}{3}\mu_e\mu_p\langle\vec{\sigma}_e \cdot\vec{\sigma}_p\rangle|\psi(0)|^2 = \frac{8\mu_e\mu_p}{3R^3}\langle\vec{\sigma}_e \cdot\vec{\sigma}_p\rangle. \tag*{(6)}

In a spin singlet, ⟨σ⃗e⋅σ⃗p⟩=−3\langle\vec{\sigma}_e \cdot\vec{\sigma}_p\rangle= -3, and thus

Ehf,0=−8μeμpR3.(7)E_{hf,0} = -\frac{8\mu_e\mu_p}{R^3}. \tag*{(7)}

For R=a0R = a_0, this result is the usual hyperfine interaction. With the hyperfine interaction added to the usual terms in Eq. (2), the expectation value of the total energy is

E(R)=12mR2−αR−8μeμpR3,(8)E(R) = \frac{1}{2mR^2} - \frac{\alpha}{R} - \frac{8\mu_e\mu_p}{R^3}, \tag*{(8)}

which has a local minimum in RR essentially at the Bohr radius, but diverges to arbitrarily negative values as R→0R \to0.

The puzzle of whether the hyperfine interaction can destabilize the system to sizes far below the Bohr radius is intrinsically relativistic, since in non-relativistic limit c→∞c \to\infty, the electron magnetic moment eℏ/2mce\hbar/2mc itself vanishes. Deriving the properties of bound relativistic Coulomb systems of two fermions, each of finite mass, can in principle be accomplished by solving the relativistic Bethe-Salpeter two body equation [7]. Considerable effort has been devoted to reducing the problem of these systems to a description in terms of an equal time 4×44 \times4 matrix wave function in Dirac and real space. References [8, 9, 10, 11] representative a sample of work in this area. To understand the flaw in the heuristic argument above, we analyze the relativistic atomic Dirac state using a variational wave function of spatial extent RR, based on the Gordon solution [12] of the Dirac equation with an infinitely massive point proton, supplemented by the minimax principle [13].

A central result is that, after the lower Dirac components are extremized at a specified radius, the fermion magnetic moment is proportional to the inverse of the particle mass, e.g, e/2me/2m for the electron, only at the radius that minimizes the energy. On the other hand, for all RR less than 1/m1/m and arbitrary Ze2<1Ze^2 < 1 the Dirac energy has no minimum in RR, and the effective magnetic moments of point fermions in Coulombic atoms, including positronium and muonium (the μ+e−\mu^+e^- atom), become proportional to RR at small RR, vanishing as R→0R \to0. Thus the apparent ∼−Ze2/R3\sim-Ze^2/R^3 divergence in the spin-singlet hyperfine interaction is softened to a ∼−Ze2/R\sim-Ze^2/R divergence, which is dominated by the +1/R+1/R divergence of the kinetic energy.

The magnetic moment of a point proton in hydrogen is also bounded for RR smaller than 1/Mp1/M_p by gpeR/4g_peR/4, leading to a hyperfine energy softened to ∼−gpα/2R\sim-g_p\alpha/2R, smaller in magnitude than the electron kinetic energy. In physical hydrogen though the finite size of the proton by itself removes the apparent divergence of the hyperfine interaction as R→0R \to0, as Miller [14], responding to this paper, has shown in detailed calculations with the usual dipole form of the Sachs magnetic form factor of a finite proton. Finite size effects cannot however resolve the hyperfine puzzle in muonium or positronium, since charged leptons are point particles. The relevant physics remains the Dirac suppression of the effective magnetic moments in trial configurations smaller than the Compton wavelengths of the participating fermions. In neither hydrogen, nor positronium, nor muonium does the hyperfine interaction lead to collapse.

We also look below (§ 2.1) at the hyperfine puzzle from the point of view of the potential felt by the electron at short distances. One might be tempted to interpret the Fermi result, that the hyperfine energy is proportional to the square of the wave function at the origin, as saying that in the hyperfine interaction the electron feels a three dimensional delta function potential at the origin, Vhf,0=−8πμeμfδ(r⃗)V_{\mathrm{hf},0}=-8\pi\mu_e\mu_f\delta(\vec{r}), for a spin-singlet. However, one must treat such a potential, as with general contact interactions in low energy atomic interactions, only as an effective interaction or pseudopotential (see, e.g., Ref. [15]) that cannot be used in higher order calculations, for example, of its bound states.1 The actual attractive potential felt by an electron in a singlet state at short distances that arises from the hyperfine interaction cannot, as we show, produce additional bound states.

In the next Section, II, we show how one can derive the exact energy of the ss-wave ground state Dirac wave function via the minimax variational procedure. In Sec. III, we apply the same variational method to the ground state of positronium. Then in Sec. IV we derive the energy of an electron in an external magnetic field as well as in the magnetic field of a central, positively charged spin-1/2 fermion, and hence find the effective (or “shielded” [17]) electron magnetic moment in terms of the variational wave function. We briefly examine in § 2.1, the actual equivalent potential felt by the electron from the hyperfine interaction. A key takeaway from this section is that the spin-independent contribution to the vector potential from the companion dipole moment is crucial for treating the small rr behavior of the Dirac wave function. We summarize and conclude in Sec. VI. Appendix A reviews the derivation of the exact Coulomb wave function for hydrogen ground state, and in Appendix B we illustrate the minimax principle for a free Dirac particle. Finally in Appendix C we study the ground state energy, and the approximate wave function for two oppositely charged fermions of general masses with a Coulomb interaction.

The framework we develop in this paper is useful for the problem of constructing diquarks in hadrons and in low density quark matter. There the QCD color electric interaction plays the role of the Coulomb potential and the QCD color magnetic interaction the role of the hyperfine interaction, leading to the same problem of the RR dependence of the hyperfine interaction as in hydrogenic atoms. The diquark problem requires understanding the regime in which the strong interaction fine structure constant, αs\alpha_s, can be of order unity; thus the technology we develop to resolve the behavior of the hyperfine interaction in hydrogenic atoms becomes directly applicable in improved analytic treatments of diquarks [18].

Variational approach to the Gordon solution

To uncover the roots of the hyperfine puzzle we work in terms of the relativistic Gordon solution of the Dirac equation for the Coulomb problem [7, 12], and its extension to positronium, employing a simple variational method based on the exact hydrogenic wave function. The Hamiltonian of the relativistic spin-1/2 Coulomb problem is,

HH=γ0γ⃗⋅(p⃗+eA⃗(r))+γ0m−αr(9)H_H = \gamma^0 \vec{\gamma} \cdot(\vec{p} + e\vec{A}(r)) + \gamma^0 m - \frac{\alpha}{r} \tag*{(9)}

(the subscript HH is for hydrogen), where rr is the relative coordinate of the electron and Coulomb center, and A⃗(r)\vec{A}(r) the vector potential for the magnetic field felt by the electron (here e>0e > 0). We include the hyperfine interaction subsequently.

The exact normalized Dirac ground state for an s-wave electron in the absence of a magnetic field is Ψ(r⃗)=(ϕ(r),χ(r⃗))\Psi(\vec{r}) = (\phi(r), \chi(\vec{r})), with

ϕ=11+X2ζϕ~(r),χ=iXσ⃗⋅r^ϕ.(10)\phi= \frac{1}{\sqrt{1+X^2}}\zeta\tilde{\phi}(r), \qquad\chi= iX\vec{\sigma}\cdot\hat{r}\phi. \tag*{(10)}

Here ζ\zeta is the two component spinor in the upper Dirac components, e.g., ζ=(10)\zeta= \begin{pmatrix} 1 \\ 0 \end{pmatrix} for a spin up electron, and

ϕ~(r)=Nrγ−1e−r/a0,(11)\tilde{\phi}(r) = \mathcal{N}r^{\gamma-1}e^{-r/a_0}, \tag*{(11)}

where γ=1−α2\gamma= \sqrt{1-\alpha^2} and N\mathcal{N} is a normalization constant. The derivation of the Dirac ground state energy and parameters is reviewed in Appendix A. The rγ−1r^{\gamma-1} factor leads to a weak divergence at the origin [7], which generates, as Breit has shown [2], higher-order corrections to the hyperfine interaction in the Dirac hydrogen atom. The parameter XX is [7],

X=1α(1−1−α2)>0,(12)X = \frac{1}{\alpha}\left(1-\sqrt{1-\alpha^2}\right)>0, \tag*{(12)}

which is ≈α/2\approx\alpha/2 for α≪1\alpha\ll1.

To discuss the system as a function of it size, we compute its energy in the following using a variational trial wave function of the same form as (10), with

ϕ~(r)=Nrγ−1e−r/R,(13)\tilde{\phi}(r) = \mathcal{N}r^{\gamma-1}e^{-r/R}, \tag*{(13)}

and XX, γ\gamma and RR now parameters to be determined.

Variational approaches to solving the Dirac equation are beset by the “variational catastrophe”: owing to the lack of a lower bound on the Dirac spectrum, simple extremization does not find a minimum energy, since one can always lower the energy indefinitely by mixing in negative energy states. We adopt here the “minimax” procedure [13] for the physical energy, where one first extremizes the ground state energy with respect to XX (the relative normalization parameter of the lower component) and then determines the radius by minimizing the energy with respect to RR.

the energy with respect to RR. Extremization with respect to XX in fact leads to a maximum in the energy, a situation simply illustrated by the free Dirac particle, calculated variationally in Appendix B. Once we have constructed a physical Dirac state, with energy E(R)E(R), we determine the radius by minimizing the energy with respect to RR. The minimax procedure is discussed in detail in Ref. [13] in terms of the positive and negative eigenvalues in the Dirac equation; see also Refs. [19, 20], as well as Ref. [21] and references therein for alternate variational treatments of the Dirac hydrogen atom for general states. Although the minimax method does not in general necessarily provide an exact upper bound to the energy, calculations reported in the literature, e.g., [9, 10, 13], approximate the energy reasonably accurately.

In the minimax procedure, XX, which fixes the relative weight of the lower Dirac components, is first extremized at fixed RR and γ\gamma. The size RR is varied only after this minimax step. To calculate the Coulomb energy in the variational state (13) we use,

⟨1r⟩=∫drr2γ−1e−2r/R∫drr2γe−2r/R=1Rγ.(14)\left\langle\frac{1}{r}\right\rangle= \frac{\int dr r^{2\gamma-1}e^{-2r/R}}{\int dr r^{2\gamma}e^{-2r/R}} = \frac{1}{R\gamma}. \tag*{(14)}

The mass term gives,

⟨γ0m⟩=m1−X21+X2.(15)\left\langle\gamma^0m\right\rangle= m\frac{1-X^2}{1+X^2}. \tag*{(15)}

The expectation value of the kinetic energy — since γ0γ⃗\gamma^0\vec{\gamma} is simply the 4×44\times4 Dirac matrix (0σ⃗σ⃗0)\begin{pmatrix} 0 & \vec{\sigma} \\ \vec{\sigma} & 0 \end{pmatrix}, with σ⃗\vec{\sigma} the Pauli matrices — contributes,

⟨γ0γ⃗⋅p⃗⟩=iX1+X2∫d3rϕ~∗[σ⃗⋅p⃗,σ⃗⋅r^]ϕ~=−2X1+X2∫d3rϕ~∂ϕ~∂r=2X1+X21Rγ,(16)\left\langle\gamma^0\vec{\gamma}\cdot\vec{p}\right\rangle= \frac{iX}{1+X^2}\int d^3r\tilde{\phi}^{*}[\vec{\sigma}\cdot\vec{p},\vec{\sigma}\cdot\hat{r}]\tilde{\phi} = -\frac{2X}{1+X^2}\int d^3r\tilde{\phi}\frac{\partial\tilde{\phi}}{\partial r} = \frac{2X}{1+X^2}\frac{1}{R\gamma}, \tag*{(16)}

where we use

∂∂rϕ~=(−1R+γ−1r)ϕ~.(17)\frac{\partial}{\partial r}\tilde{\phi}=\left(-\frac{1}{R}+\frac{\gamma-1}{r}\right)\tilde{\phi}. \tag*{(17)}

with Eq. (14). Altogether the expectation value of the energy is,

EH=(2X1+X2−α)1Rγ+m1−X21+X2.(18)E_H = \left(\frac{2X}{1+X^2}-\alpha\right)\frac{1}{R\gamma}+m\frac{1-X^2}{1+X^2}. \tag*{(18)}

Minimizing EHE_H with respect to XX and fixed RγR\gamma, the first step in the minimax procedure, gives

X2+2XmRγ−1=0,(19)X^2+2XmR\gamma-1=0, \tag*{(19)}

and thus

X=−mRγ+(mRγ)2+1.(20)X=-mR\gamma+\sqrt{(mR\gamma)^2+1}. \tag*{(20)}

At this extremum in XX, the energy depends only on the product RγR\gamma:

EH(Rγ)=1Rγ((mRγ)2+1−α).(21)E_H(R\gamma)=\frac{1}{R\gamma}\left(\sqrt{(mR\gamma)^2+1}-\alpha\right). \tag*{(21)}

We next minimize EHE_H as a function of RR. Since dEH/dX=0dE_H/dX=0 at the extremum, the implicit RγR\gamma dependence in XX drops out of the minimization. Minimizing with respect to the explicit RγR\gamma implies 1+X2−2X/α=01+X^2-2X/\alpha=0, from which Eq. (12) follows. In addition, comparison of Eqs. (20) and (12) gives

mαRγ=1−α2,(22)m\alpha R\gamma=\sqrt{1-\alpha^2}, \tag*{(22)}

and yields the form for the ground state energy,

EH=m1−α2,(23)E_H=m\sqrt{1-\alpha^2}, \tag*{(23)}

which is, in fact, the exact solution obtained by solving the Dirac equation.

The minmax procedure determines only RγR\gamma and not RR and γ\gamma separately. To obtain those separately we can match coefficients of 1/r1/r in the Dirac equation (see Appendix A) to find

γ=1−α2,(24)\gamma=\sqrt{1-\alpha^2}, \tag*{(24)}

and then R=1/mαR=1/m\alpha, the Bohr radius.2 Note that

EH2=m2−1/R2,(25)E_H^2=m^2-1/R^2, \tag*{(25)}

a result obeyed by the s-wave ground state of the Klein-Gordon hydrogen atom as well.

With the variational wave function (13) we can maximize the energy with respect to XX for given RR. However, the resulting energy at the maximum in XX has a minimum in RR, for general ZαZ\alpha, only if Zα<1Z\alpha<1 and then R>1/mR>1/m. This latter condition is readily apparent from Eq. (25), where the energy becomes imaginary for R<1/mR<1/m. The limiting case R=1/mR=1/m occurs for Zα=1Z\alpha=1 where γ=0\gamma=0. As we see from Eq. (21),

dEHdR=−1γ(1(mRγ)2+1−Zα);(26)\frac{dE_H}{dR}=-\frac{1}{\gamma}\left(\frac{1}{\sqrt{(mR\gamma)^2+1}}-Z\alpha\right); \tag*{(26)}

since the first term in parenthesis is always ≤1\le1, the derivative can vanish only if Zα≤1Z\alpha\le1. For Zα<1Z\alpha<1 and γ=1−(Zα)2\gamma=\sqrt{1-(Z\alpha)^2}, the derivative vanishes when mRZα=1mRZ\alpha=1, as expected. As Zα→1Z\alpha\to1, one has γ→0\gamma\to0, at which point the wave function becomes singular at the origin. For Zα>1Z\alpha>1 there is never a minimum. For Zα<1Z\alpha<1, one has R>1/mR>1/m; the variational state (13) with R<1/mR<1/m cannot minimize the energy.

Positronium

We turn next to the ground state of positronium, whose Hamiltonian in the absence of the hyperfine interaction is,3

Hps=γ10γ1⋅p1+(γ10+γ20)m+γ20γ2⋅p2−α∣r1−r2∣,(27)H_{\mathrm{ps}}=\gamma_1^0\boldsymbol{\gamma}_1\cdot\mathbf{p}_1+(\gamma_1^0+\gamma_2^0)m+\gamma_2^0\boldsymbol{\gamma}_2\cdot\mathbf{p}_2-\frac{\alpha}{\lvert\mathbf{r}_1-\mathbf{r}_2\rvert}, \tag*{(27)}

where 1 denotes the electron and 2 the positron, and mm is again the electron mass. We write the overall ground-state trial wave function as a generalization of Eq. (10) for hydrogen,

Ψps(r)=(11+X12(ζ1,iX1σ⋅r^ζ1)⊗11+X22(ζ2,−iX2σ⋅r^ζ2))ϕ~(r),(28)\Psi_{\mathrm{ps}}(r)=\left(\frac{1}{\sqrt{1+X_1^2}}(\zeta_1,iX_1\boldsymbol{\sigma}\cdot\hat{\mathbf{r}}\zeta_1)\otimes\frac{1}{\sqrt{1+X_2^2}}(\zeta_2,-iX_2\boldsymbol{\sigma}\cdot\hat{\mathbf{r}}\zeta_2)\right)\widetilde{\phi}(r), \tag*{(28)}

where ζ1\zeta_1 and ζ2\zeta_2 are the two component spinors of particles 1 and 2, r=r1−r2\mathbf{r}=\mathbf{r}_1-\mathbf{r}_2, and ϕ~(r)∼r−1e−r/R\widetilde{\phi}(r)\sim r^{-1}e^{-r/R}. While the components of the exact Coulomb wave function do not share a common spatial wave function [10], the trial spatial wave function nonetheless remains a useful starting point.

By symmetry X1=X2≡XX_1=X_2\equiv X. Then the variational ground state energy is

Eps(α)=⟨Ψps∣Hps∣Ψps⟩=2X1+X22Rγ+2m1−X21+X2−αRγ.(29)E_{\mathrm{ps}}(\alpha)=\langle\Psi_{\mathrm{ps}\lvert H_{\mathrm{ps}}\rvert\Psi_{\mathrm{ps}}\rangle =\frac{2X}{1+X^2}\frac{2}{R\gamma}+2m\frac{1-X^2}{1+X^2}-\frac{\alpha}{R\gamma}.} \tag*{(29)}

Comparing with Eq. (18) we see immediately that for this variational wave function,

Eps(α)=2EH(α/2)=2m1−α2/4.(30)E_{\mathrm{ps}}(\alpha)=2E_H(\alpha/2)=2m\sqrt{1-\alpha^2/4}. \tag*{(30)}

Numerical calculations of the ground state energy of the Hamiltonian (27), for 0≤α≤20\le\alpha\le2, give results extremely close to and straddling Eq. (30) for all α\alpha in this range [9, 10].

Extremizing (29) with respect to XX again yields Eq. (19), from which it follows that at the minimum in RR,

X=2α(1−1−α2/4),(31)X=\frac{2}{\alpha}\left(1-\sqrt{1-\alpha^2/4}\right), \tag*{(31)}

the hydrogenic result with α\alpha replaced by α/2\alpha/2. In addition, R=2/mαR=2/m\alpha and γ=1−α2/4\gamma=\sqrt{1-\alpha^2/4}.

In the limit of small α\alpha, in which the system is nonrelativistic, this equation yields the expected result,

Eps(α)→2m(1−18α2)=2m−12mrα2,(32)E_{\mathrm{ps}}(\alpha)\to2m\left(1-\frac{1}{8}\alpha^2\right)=2m-\frac{1}{2}m_r\alpha^2, \tag*{(32)}

where 2m2m is the total and mr=m/2m_r=m/2 is the reduced mass.

Magnetic moment of a particle in a Coulomb potential

We turn now to the effects of a magnetic field on an electron in a Coulombic ground state, evaluating the expectation value of the term γ0γ⃗⋅eA⃗(r)\gamma^0\vec{\gamma}\cdot e\vec{A}(r) in the Hamiltonian (9), and the corresponding term in positronium. Similar to the calculation leading to Eq. (16), we have,

⟨eγ0γ⃗⋅A⃗(r)⟩=2eRe∫d3rϕ†σ⃗⋅A⃗(r)χ=eX1+X2∫d3rϕ†[σ⃗⋅A⃗(r),iσ⃗⋅r^]ϕ=2eX1+X2∫d3r∣ϕ~∣2r^×A⃗(r)⋅⟨σ⃗⟩.(33)\begin{aligned} \langle e\gamma^0\vec{\gamma}\cdot\vec{A}(r)\rangle&= 2e\mathop{\mathrm{Re}}\int d^3r\phi^\dagger\vec{\sigma}\cdot\vec{A}(r)\chi\\ &= \frac{eX}{1+X^2}\int d^3r\phi^\dagger[\vec{\sigma}\cdot\vec{A}(r),i\vec{\sigma}\cdot\hat{r}]\phi\\ &= \frac{2eX}{1+X^2}\int d^3r|\tilde{\phi}|^2\hat{r}\times\vec{A}(r)\cdot\langle\vec{\sigma}\rangle. \tag*{(33)} \end{aligned}

The detailed response of the electron depends on whether A⃗\vec{A} arises from a current source J⃗(r)\vec{J}(r) outside the atom or within the atom. For a uniform external magnetic field, described by the vector potential, A⃗(r)=12(H⃗×r⃗)\vec{A}(r)=\frac{1}{2}(\vec{H}\times\vec{r}),

r^×A⃗(r)=12r^×(H⃗×r⃗)=12(H⃗−(r^⋅H⃗)r^)r.(34)\hat{r}\times\vec{A}(r)=\frac{1}{2}\hat{r}\times(\vec{H}\times\vec{r})=\frac{1}{2}(\vec{H}-(\hat{r}\cdot\vec{H})\hat{r})r. \tag*{(34)}

Averaged over angles in an s-state, the right side becomes H⃗r/3\vec{H}r/3, and with the wave function4 ϕ~(r)\tilde{\phi}(r),

⟨eγ0γ⃗⋅A⃗(r)⟩=eXRBo1+X2⟨σ⃗⟩⋅H⃗,(35)\langle e\gamma^0\vec{\gamma}\cdot\vec{A}(r)\rangle=\frac{eXR\mathcal{B}_o}{1+X^2}\langle\vec{\sigma}\rangle\cdot\vec{H}, \tag*{(35)}

where

Bo=23R∫d3rrϕ~2∫d3rϕ~2=2γ+13≈1−α2/3,(36)\mathcal{B}_o=\frac{2}{3R}\frac{\int d^3r r\tilde{\phi}^2}{\int d^3r\tilde{\phi}^2}=\frac{2\gamma+1}{3}\approx1-\alpha^2/3, \tag*{(36)}

is a Breit correction to the electron gg factor. As Eqs. (35) and (36) show, the energy shift due to a magnetic field depends separately on γ\gamma and RR, unlike in the variational result (21) for the ground state energy.

The crucial takeaway of the above result is that the effective electron magnetic moment in a hydrogenic state, at the extremum in XX, and prior to the minimization in RR, is

μeeff=eXR1+X2Bo.(37)\mu_e^{\mathrm{eff}}=\frac{eXR}{1+X^2}\mathcal{B}_o. \tag*{(37)}

As we discuss below, the explicit factor RR softens the divergence of the hyperfine energy as R→0R\to0. The factor Bo\mathcal{B}_o, which differs from unity because of the higher order corrections to γ=1\gamma=1 appearing in ϕ~\tilde{\phi}, gives higher order corrections in α\alpha; in the following we replace Bo\mathcal{B}_o with unity.5

Magnetic moment of a particle in a Coulomb potential

With the energy EHE_H or EpsE_{ps} extremized with respect to XX, Eq. (19) implies

X1+X2=12(mRγ)2+1.(38)\frac{X}{1+X^2}=\frac{1}{2\sqrt{(mR\gamma)^2+1}}. \tag*{(38)}

Thus for general RR,

μeeff=eR2(mRγ)2+1.(39)\mu_e^{\mathrm{eff}}=\frac{eR}{2\sqrt{(mR\gamma)^2+1}}. \tag*{(39)}

As R→0R\to0, μeeff→eR/2\mu_e^{\mathrm{eff}}\to eR/2, while at the minimum of the energy (21), which exists for R>1/mR>1/m. μeeff=e/2m\mu_e^{\mathrm{eff}}=e/2m, as expected.6

We next consider the response to a magnetic field generated by currents at the center of the atom, as in the hyperfine interaction. The vector potential produced by a point-like positively charged fermion (e.g., f=p,μ+f=p,\mu^+, or e+e^+) is, cf. Eq. (4),

A⃗(r)=μfσ⃗f×r^r2,(40)\vec{A}(r)=\mu_f\vec{\sigma}_f\times\frac{\hat{r}}{r^2}, \tag*{(40)}

where μf\mu_f is the positive fermion magnetic moment, σ⃗f/2\vec{\sigma}_f/2 is the fermion spin, and we neglect corrections arising from the motion of the positively charged fermion which even for positronium are only of order α\alpha. In an s-state r^×A⃗(r)\hat{r}\times\vec{A}(r) averages to 2μfσ⃗f/3r22\mu_f\vec{\sigma}_f/3r^2, so that in the state ϕ~\tilde{\phi} the hyperfine interaction becomes

Ehf=−⟨eγ0γ⃗⋅A⃗(r)⟩=−8eXRBi3(1+X2)R3μf2⟨σ⃗e⋅σ⃗f⟩,(41)E_{hf}=-\langle e\gamma^0\vec{\gamma}\cdot\vec{A}(r)\rangle=-\frac{8eXR\mathcal{B}_i}{3(1+X^2)R^3}\frac{\mu_f}{2}\langle\vec{\sigma}_e\cdot\vec{\sigma}_f\rangle, \tag*{(41)}

where the Breit hyperfine correction here is

Bi=R22∫drϕ~2∫drr2ϕ~2=1γ(2γ−1)≈1+3α2/2.(42)\mathcal{B}_i=\frac{R^2}{2}\frac{\int dr\tilde{\phi}^2}{\int dr r^2\tilde{\phi}^2}=\frac{1}{\gamma(2\gamma-1)}\approx1+3\alpha^2/2. \tag*{(42)}

We see in Eq. (41) the emergence of the explicit 1/R31/R^3 in the hyperfine energy, discussed in the Introduction. Note that the Breit correction converges only if γ>1/2\gamma>1/2, In the following we neglect the Breit factors, and consider at first the hyperfine interaction in positronium. Then μe+=−μe\mu_{e^+}=-\mu_e, and with Eq. (41),

Ehf,ps=8X2α3(1+X2)2R⟨σ⃗e⋅σ⃗e+⟩.(43)E_{hf,ps}=\frac{8X^2\alpha}{3(1+X^2)2R}\langle\vec{\sigma}_e\cdot\vec{\sigma}_{e^+}\rangle. \tag*{(43)}

Since X/(1+X2)X/(1+X^2) is bounded by 1/21/2 in magnitude, the hyperfine energy at small RR is in fact ∼1/R\sim1/R, rather than the naive 1/R31/R^3. With Eq. (38),

Ehf,ps=2α3((mRγ)2+1)R⟨σ⃗e⋅σ⃗e+⟩,(44)E_{hf,ps}=\frac{2\alpha}{3((mR\gamma)^2+1)R}\langle\vec{\sigma}_e\cdot\vec{\sigma}_{e^+}\rangle, \tag*{(44)}

which is bounded in magnitude by the kinetic energy. In the positronium ground state for small α\alpha, R→2/mαR\to2/m\alpha, and

Ehf,ps→mα412⟨σ⃗e+⋅σ⃗e−⟩,(45)E_{hf,ps}\to\frac{m\alpha^4}{12}\langle\vec{\sigma}_{e^+}\cdot\vec{\sigma}_{e^-}\rangle, \tag*{(45)}

in agreement with Refs. [4, 7]; in a singlet state, Ehf,ps→−mα4/4E_{hf,ps}\to-m\alpha^4/4.

In muonium, where the positive particle is pointlike, the trial state (C2) for unequal masses implies that the response of the muon to an external magnetic field is described by the effective magnetic moment (cf. Eq. (37)),

μμeff(R)=−eXμR1+Xμ2.(46)\mu_\mu^{\mathrm{eff}}(R)=-\frac{eX_\mu R}{1+X_\mu^2}. \tag*{(46)}

Here XμX_\mu measures the size of the lower Dirac components of the muon. Since Xμ/(1+Xμ2)≤1/2X_\mu/(1+X_\mu^2)\leq1/2, with Xμ→1X_\mu\to1 as R→0R\to0, the effective muon magnetic moment in the small RR limit becomes, in magnitude, eR/2eR/2. With this shielding of μμeff(R)\mu_\mu^{\mathrm{eff}}(R) in the non-equilibrium state at small RR, the muonium hyperfine interaction scales as ±α/R\pm\alpha/R, and is always well bounded by the electron kinetic energy.

For hydrogen with a point proton, Eq. (41) without the Breit correction implies that in the singlet state of hydrogen – with proton magnetic moment, gpe/4Mpg_pe/4M_p – the hyperfine energy is,

Ehf≈−αgpMpR2(mRγ)2+1.(47)E_{hf}\approx-\frac{\alpha g_p}{M_pR^2\sqrt{(mR\gamma)^2+1}}. \tag*{(47)}

For small RR this remains smaller in magnitude than the electron kinetic energy, ∼1/R\sim1/R, down to R≈αgp/Mp≈0.053 fmR\approx\alpha g_p/M_p\approx0.053\ \mathrm{fm}, well within the proton itself. However, as mentioned in the Introduction, in physical hydrogen the finite size of the proton removes the apparent divergence of the hyperfine interaction as R→0R\to0 [14].

Since the hyperfine interaction, for given RR, scales with α\alpha, we ask – with a view to diquarks held together by color electromagnetic forces – what is the maximum value of α\alpha for which a positronium-like system is stable as R→0R\to0. The total energy of positronium in its spatial ground state, including the hyperfine interaction, behaves there as

E→1Rγ(2−α+2α3⟨σ⃗e+⋅σ⃗e−⟩2γ−1).(48)E\to\frac{1}{R\gamma}\left(2-\alpha+\frac{2\alpha}{3}\frac{\langle\vec{\sigma}_{e^+}\cdot\vec{\sigma}_{e^-}\rangle}{2\gamma-1}\right). \tag*{(48)}

Stability as R→0R\to0 requires,

2>α(1−23(2γ−1)⟨σ⃗e+⋅σ⃗e−⟩).(49)2>\alpha\left(1-\frac{2}{3(2\gamma-1)}\langle\vec{\sigma}_{e^+}\cdot\vec{\sigma}_{e^-}\rangle\right). \tag*{(49)}

The singlet state (where ⟨σ⃗1⋅σ⃗2⟩=−3\langle\vec{\sigma}_1\cdot\vec{\sigma}_2\rangle=-3) has a stronger negative contribution than the triplet state, and so the criterion for absolute stability, in a variational state specified by a γ\gamma, is that α\alpha be bounded above by 2(2γ−1)/(2γ+1)2(2\gamma-1)/(2\gamma+1).

Spatial structure of the hyperfine potential

As mentioned in the Introduction, the hyperfine interaction [6] can be understood as the expectation value of a pseudopotential which is a delta function at the origin. In this Section we examine the conclusions of the previous sections from a related perspective – by constructing the effective potential in the Dirac equation felt by the electron in the presence of the hyperfine interaction, with a Coulomb attraction to a massive central point fermion. We follow Ref. [22] in spirit.

The full Dirac equation for the Coulomb potential with a vector potential, written out for the upper and lower components, is

(E−m+αr)ϕ=σ⃗⋅(−i∇⃗+eA⃗(r))χ,\left(E-m+\frac{\alpha}{r}\right)\phi=\vec{\sigma}\cdot(-i\vec{\nabla}+e\vec{A}(r))\chi,
(E+m+αr)χ=σ⃗⋅(−i∇⃗+eA⃗(r))ϕ.(50)\left(E+m+\frac{\alpha}{r}\right)\chi=\vec{\sigma}\cdot(-i\vec{\nabla}+e\vec{A}(r))\phi. \tag*{(50)}

Eliminating χ\chi we have

(E+m)(E−m+αr)ϕ=σ⃗⋅(−i∇⃗+eA⃗(r))Q(r)σ⃗⋅(−i∇⃗+eA⃗(r))ϕ,(51)(E+m)\left(E-m+\frac{\alpha}{r}\right)\phi =\vec{\sigma}\cdot(-i\vec{\nabla}+e\vec{A}(r))Q(r)\vec{\sigma}\cdot(-i\vec{\nabla}+e\vec{A}(r))\phi, \tag*{(51)}

where

Q(r)≡E+mE+m+α/r.(52)Q(r)\equiv\frac{E+m}{E+m+\alpha/r}. \tag*{(52)}

The terms on the right proportional to the electron spin, with (∇⃗×A⃗(r)+A⃗(r)×∇⃗)ϕ=H⃗(r)ϕ(\vec{\nabla}\times\vec{A}(r)+\vec{A}(r)\times\vec{\nabla})\phi=\vec{H}(r)\phi, where H⃗(r)\vec{H}(r) is the magnetic field, become,

eσ⃗⋅(∇⃗Q(r)×A⃗(r))ϕ+eQ(r)σ⃗⋅H⃗(r)ϕ,(53)e\vec{\sigma}\cdot(\vec{\nabla}Q(r)\times\vec{A}(r))\phi+eQ(r)\vec{\sigma}\cdot\vec{H}(r)\phi, \tag*{(53)}

and with Eq. (40) for the vector potential of the positive central fermion,

eσ⃗⋅∇⃗Q(r)×A⃗(r)=eμfr2dQdrσ⃗⋅(σ⃗p−(σ⃗p⋅r^)r^).(54)e\vec{\sigma}\cdot\vec{\nabla}Q(r)\times\vec{A}(r)=e\frac{\mu_f}{r^2}\frac{dQ}{dr}\vec{\sigma}\cdot(\vec{\sigma}_p-(\vec{\sigma}_p\cdot\hat{r})\hat{r}). \tag*{(54)}

In a singlet state, to which we first confine our attention, σeiσpj→−δij\sigma_{ei}\sigma_{pj}\to-\delta_{ij}, and σ⃗⋅H⃗(r)=−8πμfδ(r⃗)\vec{\sigma}\cdot\vec{H}(r)=-8\pi\mu_f\delta(\vec{r}). Since Q(0)=0Q(0)=0, the second term in (53) vanishes, while

eσ⃗⋅∇⃗Q(r)×A⃗(r)→−2eμfr2dQdr.(55)e\vec{\sigma}\cdot\vec{\nabla}Q(r)\times\vec{A}(r)\to-2e\frac{\mu_f}{r^2}\frac{dQ}{dr}. \tag*{(55)}

Altogether,

(E−m+αr)ϕ=(−i∇⃗+eA⃗(r))QE+m⋅(−i∇⃗+eA⃗(r))ϕ+Vhf,0(r)ϕ,(56)\left(E-m+\frac{\alpha}{r}\right)\phi= \left(-i\vec{\nabla}+e\vec{A}(r)\right)\frac{Q}{E+m}\cdot\left(-i\vec{\nabla}+e\vec{A}(r)\right)\phi+V_{hf,0}(r)\phi, \tag*{(56)}

where

Vhf,0(r)=−2eμfE+m1r2dQdr=−2eμfr2α(E+m)r+α,(57)V_{hf,0}(r)=-\frac{2e\mu_f}{E+m}\frac{1}{r^2}\frac{dQ}{dr}=-\frac{2e\mu_f}{r^2}\frac{\alpha}{(E+m)r+\alpha}, \tag*{(57)}

is the effective potential an electron in a singlet state feels in its hyperfine interaction with the positive fermion. How is this very attractive Vhf,0V_{hf,0} potential for a positive fermion ff, ∼−2μf/er2\sim-2\mu_f/er^2 at small rr, related to the apparent hyperfine puzzle mentioned in the Introduction? In particular, can Vhf,0V_{hf,0} lead to highly localized bound states near the origin, on the scale of the classical radius of the electron, or even an instability in the system? Indeed, while the highly attractive potential might be construed as another manifestation of the hyperfine puzzle, it does not, as we show now, give rise to such localized bound states, thus confirming that the hyperfine puzzle is only a mirage.

As Landau and Lifshitz discuss [23], a r−2r^{-2} potential has no bound states if the coefficient 2μf/e2\mu_f/e is less than 1/8m1/8m, or μf<μe/8\mu_f<\mu_e/8, clearly satisfied in hydrogen and muonium. For positronium, where such a −1/r2-1/r^2 potential by itself would lead to total collapse of the system (independent of electron-positron annihilation), we must take into account the other terms in Eq. (51). Noting that r^⋅A⃗=0\hat{r}\cdot\vec{A}=0, we rewrite Eq. (51) as

((E+αr)2−m2+∇⃗ 2−αA⃗(r)2)ϕ=−α(E+m)r+α(1rdϕdr+2eμfr3ϕ).(58)\left(\left(E+\frac{\alpha}{r}\right)^2-m^2+\vec{\nabla}^{\,2}-\alpha\vec{A}(r)^2\right)\phi =-\frac{\alpha}{(E+m)r+\alpha}\left(\frac{1}{r}\frac{d\phi}{dr}+\frac{2e\mu_f}{r^3}\phi\right). \tag*{(58)}

The repulsive spin-independent αA⃗(r)2=−αμf2/r4\alpha\vec{A}(r)^2=-\alpha\mu_f^2/r^4 term dominates the hyperfine term, −2eμf/r3-2e\mu_f/r^3 on the right at distances ≲α/mf\lesssim\alpha/m_f, preventing the formation of localized bound states. In positronium the A2A^2 term wins at distances smaller than the classical radius of the electron. See Ref. [24] for more detailed analysis. In all two fermion atoms, the hyperfine interaction, although quite attractive at small rr, leads neither to localized bound states nor collapse.

To connect with the analysis of the hyperfine interaction in terms of the Dirac structure of the electron in the previous section, we note that for general spin the expectation value of the hyperfine interaction in an s-state is,

Ehf=8π3⟨σ⃗⋅σ⃗p⟩eμpEH+m∫drdQdr∣ϕ(r)∣2.(59)E_{hf}=\frac{8\pi}{3}\langle\vec{\sigma}\cdot\vec{\sigma}_p\rangle\frac{e\mu_p}{E_H+m}\int dr\frac{dQ}{dr}|\phi(r)|^2. \tag*{(59)}

This form allows ϕ(r)\phi(r) to have a weak divergence at the origin (a difficulty with the Fermi expression [6]; see Ref. [7]) and still give a finite energy. Integrating by parts on the right side of Eq. (59) and using Eq. (12) we find,

1EH+m∫drdQdr∣ϕ(r)∣2=∫dr2EH+m+α/r(mα+1−γr)ϕ(r)2=2X∫drϕ(r)2.(60)\frac{1}{E_H+m}\int dr\frac{dQ}{dr}|\phi(r)|^2 =\int dr\frac{2}{E_H+m+\alpha/r}\left(m\alpha+\frac{1-\gamma}{r}\right)\phi(r)^2 =2X\int dr\phi(r)^2. \tag*{(60)}

Then with the normalization of ϕ\phi, we have

∫drϕ(r)2=∫drϕ(r)2(1+X2)∫4πr2drϕ(r)2=12πa02(1+X2)1γ(2γ−1),(61)\int dr\phi(r)^2=\frac{\int dr\phi(r)^2}{(1+X^2)\int4\pi r^2dr\phi(r)^2} =\frac{1}{2\pi a_0^2(1+X^2)}\frac{1}{\gamma(2\gamma-1)}, \tag*{(61)}

and since eXa0/(1+X2)=μeeXa_0/(1+X^2)=\mu_e, we recover the hyperfine energy in footnote7 Eq. (6).

Summary and conclusion

We have addressed here the puzzle raised by the Fermi result for the hyperfine energy of hydrogen or positronium, that, in an atom of size RR, the hyperfine interaction scales as ±1/R3\pm1/R^3, raising the question of why in a spin singlet state (attractive sign) these systems do not collapse. Studying the Dirac Coulomb problem using the minimax variational approach, we show:

  1. For radii R>1/mR>1/m: The magnetic response of the electron, in a state that minimizes the energy with respect to radius, is governed by μe=e/2m\mu_e=e/2m, with the Breit correction 1/γ(2γ−1)1/\gamma(2\gamma-1) to the hyperfine energy, where the spatial wave function is ∼rγ−1e−r/R\sim r^{\gamma-1}e^{-r/R}. By contrast, in an external magnetic field HH, the electron gg factor receives a Breit correction (2γ+1)/3(2\gamma+1)/3.

  1. At small R<1/mR<1/m: There is no minimum in the variational energy as a function of RR, and the effective electron magnetic moment scales as RR instead of 1/m1/m, softening the naive singular behavior. With the proton magnetic moment treated within the Dirac framework, the hyperfine interaction behaves as ±1/R\pm1/R, for R<1/MpR<1/M_p; the hyperfine interaction is not strong enough at small RR to induce a collapse of hydrogen.

  1. The hyperfine interaction in positronium is similarly softened for configurations smaller than the electron Compton wavelength.

In studying this problem we have introduced a variational approach to calculating the ground state of hydrogen, and extended it to the Coulomb ground state for finite mass fermions, in the text for positronium, and in Appendix C to arbitrary mass fermions.

We have not given here explicit results for the energy and radius of positronium or hydrogen-like bound states that are accurate to higher order in α\alpha, since other physics, e.g., vacuum polarization, contributes beyond that captured by the solution to the Dirac potential problem. However the dependence of the energy and radius on terms higher order in the fine structure constant become important in the framework of relativistic diquarks interacting via color electric and magnetic interactions, a problem we treat in a subsequent paper [18].

Acknowledgments

This research has been supported by the Simons Foundation and NSF Grant No. 013199 to author GRF, and carried out at the Aspen Center for Physics, supported by NSF Grant No. PHY-2210452. Author GB is grateful to the late Geoff Ravenhall for sharing his wisdom about relativistic atoms, and to Christopher Pethick, Tetsuo Hatsuda and Wolfgang Ketterle for insightful discussions.

Derivation of the hydrogen atom ground state solution of the Dirac equation

In this Appendix we very briefly summarize how the Gordon s-wave ground state for a spin-up electron, Eq. (10), with ϕ~(r)=Ne−r/Rrγ−1\tilde{\phi}(r) = N e^{-r/R}r^{\gamma-1}, exactly solves the Dirac equation. The two usual coupled Dirac equations [(50) with A⃗=0\vec{A}=0] for the lower and upper components, ϕ\phi and χ\chi, reduce for the forms in Eq. (10) to,

(EH−m+αr)ϕ~=(−iσ⃗⋅∇⃗)(iσ⃗⋅r^)ϕ~X=X(−1R+γ+1r)ϕ~,(62)\left(E_H-m+\frac{\alpha}{r}\right)\tilde{\phi}=(-i\vec{\sigma}\cdot\vec{\nabla})(i\vec{\sigma}\cdot\hat{r})\tilde{\phi}X=X\left(-\frac{1}{R}+\frac{\gamma+1}{r}\right)\tilde{\phi}, \tag*{(62)}

since ∇⃗⋅r^=2/r\vec{\nabla}\cdot\hat{r}=2/r; and in addition,

(EH+m+αr)X=(1R+1−γr).(63)\left(E_H+m+\frac{\alpha}{r}\right)X=\left(\frac{1}{R}+\frac{1-\gamma}{r}\right). \tag*{(63)}

Matching term by term in rr, we have from Eq. (63),

X=1(EH+m)R=1−γα.(64)X=\frac{1}{(E_H+m)R}=\frac{1-\gamma}{\alpha}. \tag*{(64)}

while Eq. (62) implies that

EH−m=−X/R,(65)E_H-m=-X/R, \tag*{(65)}

and

X=αγ+1.(66)X=\frac{\alpha}{\gamma+1}. \tag*{(66)}

Eliminating XX between Eqs. (64) and (A4), we have

EH2=m2−1/R2,(67)E_H^2=m^2-1/R^2, \tag*{(67)}

and eliminating RR as well,

E=mγ.(68)E=m\gamma. \tag*{(68)}

Then Eqs. (64) and (A4) imply

γ=1−α2,(69)\gamma=\sqrt{1-\alpha^2}, \tag*{(69)}

with EH<mE_H<m implying the positive square root. Finally,

R=1/mα=a0.(70)R=1/m\alpha=a_0. \tag*{(70)}

Free Dirac particle

For a free Dirac particle of momentum pp, with trial wave function Ψ(r)\Psi(r) given in (10), the expectation value of the Hamiltonian H=γ0(γ⃗⋅p⃗+m)H=\gamma^0(\vec{\gamma}\cdot\vec{p}+m) is,

E=2Xp+m(1−X2)1+X2.(71)E=\frac{2Xp+m(1-X^2)}{1+X^2}. \tag*{(71)}

Extremizing with respect to XX we find

pX2+2mX−p=0.(72)pX^2+2mX-p=0. \tag*{(72)}

Thus

X=E−mp=E−mE+m(73)X=\frac{E-m}{p}=\sqrt{\frac{E-m}{E+m}} \tag*{(73)}

where E=p2+m2E=\sqrt{p^2+m^2}, recovering the exact free particle Dirac spinor.

Figure 1, a plot of EE vs. XX, illustrates the maximum at positive XX, corresponding to a positive energy free particle solution, and the minimum at negative XX, corresponding to a negative energy free particle solution.

E/m vs. X for p = 5m

Figure 1. E/mE/m vs. XX for p=5mp=5m. The maximum at positive XX is the positive energy free particle solution, while the minimum at negative XX is the negative energy free particle solution.

Fermions of different masses, with Coulomb attraction

The Dirac Coulomb problem for two fermions with finite masses, m1m_1 and m2m_2, with Hamiltonian,

H=γ10γ⃗1⋅p⃗1+γ10m1+γ20γ⃗2⋅p⃗2+γ20m2−αr,(74)H=\gamma_1^0\vec{\gamma}_1\cdot\vec{p}_1+\gamma_1^0m_1+\gamma_2^0\vec{\gamma}_2\cdot\vec{p}_2+\gamma_2^0m_2-\frac{\alpha}{r}, \tag*{(74)}

where r=∣r⃗1−r⃗2∣r=\lvert\vec{r}_1-\vec{r}_2\rvert, has not been solved analytically. The only exact solution is when one of the masses is infinite.

Nonetheless we can get important information about the energy of the ground state if we assume that for large rr the two particle 4×44\times4 Dirac wave function is a product of individual wave functions of the form (10),

Ψ={11+X12(ζ1,iX1σ⃗⋅r^ζ1)⊗11+X22(ζ2,−iX2σ⃗⋅r^ζ2)}ϕˉ(r),(75)\Psi=\left\{\frac{1}{\sqrt{1+X_1^2}}\left(\zeta_1,iX_1\vec{\sigma}\cdot\hat{r}\zeta_1\right)\otimes\frac{1}{\sqrt{1+X_2^2}}\left(\zeta_2,-iX_2\vec{\sigma}\cdot\hat{r}\zeta_2\right)\right\}\bar{\phi}(r), \tag*{(75)}

where ζ1\zeta_1 and ζ1\zeta_1 are the two component spinors of particles 1 and 2, times a common spatial wave function. We also assume that for rr much larger than the size, RR, of the bound state, that dϕˉ/dr=−ϕˉ/Rd\bar{\phi}/dr=-\bar{\phi}/R plus terms that fall off faster in rr and can thus be neglected asymptotically.

In terms of 2×22\times2 blocks, Ψ\Psi can be written as,

Ψ11=(ζ1⊗ζ2)ZΨ21=(iX1σ⃗⋅r^ζ1⊗ζ2)ZΨ12=(ζ1⊗−iX2σ⃗⋅r^ζ2)ZΨ22=(iX1σ⃗⋅r^ζ1⊗−iX2σ⃗⋅r^ζ2)Z,(76)\begin{aligned} \Psi_{11}&=(\zeta_1\otimes\zeta_2)\mathcal{Z}\\ \Psi_{21}&=(iX_1\vec{\sigma}\cdot\hat{r}\zeta_1\otimes\zeta_2)\mathcal{Z}\\ \Psi_{12}&=(\zeta_1\otimes-iX_2\vec{\sigma}\cdot\hat{r}\zeta_2)\mathcal{Z}\\ \Psi_{22}&=(iX_1\vec{\sigma}\cdot\hat{r}\zeta_1\otimes-iX_2\vec{\sigma}\cdot\hat{r}\zeta_2)\mathcal{Z}, \tag*{(76)} \end{aligned}

where

Z(r)=11+X121+X22ϕˉ(r).(77)\mathcal{Z}(r)=\frac{1}{\sqrt{1+X_1^2}\sqrt{1+X_2^2}}\bar{\phi}(r). \tag*{(77)}

In the two particle Dirac equation for large rr, the Coulomb potential can be neglected, and the equation becomes

(h1⊗1+1⊗h2)Ψ=EΨ,(78)(h_1\otimes1+1\otimes h_2)\Psi=E\Psi, \tag*{(78)}

where in the particle 1 subspace,

h1=γ10γ⃗1⋅p⃗1+γ10m1⟶(m1iσ⃗⋅r^/Riσ⃗⋅r^/R−m1),(79)h_1=\gamma_1^0\vec{\gamma}_1\cdot\vec{p}_1+\gamma_1^0m_1\mathrel{\longrightarrow}\begin{pmatrix}m_1&i\vec{\sigma}\cdot\hat{r}/R\\ i\vec{\sigma}\cdot\hat{r}/R&-m_1\end{pmatrix}, \tag*{(79)}

and similarly in the particle 2 subspace

h2=γ20γ⃗2⋅p⃗2+γ20m2⟶(m2−iσ⃗⋅r^/R−iσ⃗⋅r^/R−m2).(80)h_2=\gamma_2^0\vec{\gamma}_2\cdot\vec{p}_2+\gamma_2^0m_2\mathrel{\longrightarrow}\begin{pmatrix}m_2&-i\vec{\sigma}\cdot\hat{r}/R\\ -i\vec{\sigma}\cdot\hat{r}/R&-m_2\end{pmatrix}. \tag*{(80)}

Component by component, Eq. (78) becomes the algebraic equations,

(−E+m1+m2)−(X1+X2)/R=0,(−E−m1−m2)X1X2+(X1+X2)/R=0,(−E+m1−m2)X2−(X1X2−1)/R=0,(−E−m1+m2)X1−(X1X2−1)/R=0.(81)\begin{aligned} (-E+m_1+m_2)-(X_1+X_2)/R&=0,\\ (-E-m_1-m_2)X_1X_2+(X_1+X_2)/R&=0,\\ (-E+m_1-m_2)X_2-(X_1X_2-1)/R&=0,\\ (-E-m_1+m_2)X_1-(X_1X_2-1)/R&=0. \tag*{(81)} \end{aligned}

The top two equations give

X1X2−1=−2Em1+m2+E,(82)X_1X_2-1=\frac{-2E}{m_1+m_2+E}, \tag*{(82)}

and

(X1+X2)/R=m1+m2−E,(83)(X_1+X_2)/R=m_1+m_2-E, \tag*{(83)}

while the bottom two equations give

X1+X2=−2EE2−(m1−m2)2X1X2−1R.(84)X_1+X_2=\frac{-2E}{E^2-(m_1-m_2)^2}\frac{X_1X_2-1}{R}. \tag*{(84)}

Eliminating the XX's from these three equations we have

E4−2(m12+m22−2/R2)E2+(m12−m22)2,(85)E^4-2(m_1^2+m_2^2-2/R^2)E^2+(m_1^2-m_2^2)^2, \tag*{(85)}

a quartic equation with the remarkably simple physical solution,

E=m12−1/R2+m22−1/R2,(86)E=\sqrt{m_1^2-1/R^2}+\sqrt{m_2^2-1/R^2}, \tag*{(86)}

for arbitrary m1m_1 and m2m_2.

We emphasize that the only assumptions going into this result are that the two particle state at large distances factorizes as (C2), and that the overall spatial wave function has a common exponential behavior ∼e−r/R\sim e^{-r/R} at large rr. The result (C13) can be derived as well from the more complete analysis of Ref. [10].

For positronium, we recover E2=4(m2−1/R2)E^2=4(m^2-1/R^2), and for hydrogen, where m2→∞m_2\to\infty,

E−m2=m12−1/R2,(87)E-m_2=\sqrt{m_1^2-1/R^2}, \tag*{(87)}

as expected.

References

References

  1. [1]E. Fermi, “Über die magnetischen Momente der Atomkerne,” Z. Phys. 60, 320 (1930).DOI
  2. [2]G. Breit, “Possible Effects of Nuclear Spin on X-Ray Terms,” Phys. Rev. 35, 1447 (1930).DOI
  3. [3]M. Horbatsch and E. A. Hessels, “Tabulation of the bound-state energies of atomic hydrogen.” Phys. Rev. A 93, 022513 (2016).DOI
  4. [4]R. Karplus and A. Klein, “Electrodynamic Displacement of Atomic Energy Levels. III. The Hyperfine Structure of Positronium,” Phys. Rev. 87, 848 (1952).DOI
  5. [5]A. De Rujula, H. Georgi, and S. L. Glashow, “Hadron Masses in a Gauge Theory,” Phys. Rev. D 12, 147 (1975).
  6. [6]T. DeGrand, R. L. Jaffe, K. Johnson, and J. Kiskis, “Masses and other Parameters of the Light Hadrons,” Phys. Rev. D 12, 2060 (1975)DOI
  7. [7]H.A. Bethe and E.E. Salpeter, Quantum mechanics of one- and two-electron atoms, Springer-Verlag, Heidelberg, 1957.
  8. [8]H. W. Crater and P. Van Alstine, ”Two-body Dirac equations,” Annals of Physics 148, 57 (1983).DOI
  9. [9]J. W. Darewych and M. Horbatsch, “The relativistic two-body Coulomb system,” J. Phys. B: At. Mol. Opt. Phys. 22, 973 (1989) .DOI
  10. [10]J. W. Darewych and L. Di Leo, “Two-fermion Dirac-like eigenstates of the Coulomb QED Hamiltonian,” J. Phys. A: Math. Gen. 29, 6817 (1996).DOI
  11. [11]M. Malvetti and H. Pilkuhn, “Equal-time relativistic two-body equations,” Phys. Rpts. 248, 1 (1994).DOI
  12. [12]W. Gordon, “Die Energieniveaus des Wasserstoffatoms nach der Diracschen Quantentheorie des Elektrons,” Z, f. Physik, 48, 11 (1928).DOI
  13. [13]J. D. Talman. “Minimax Principle for the Dirac Equation,” Phys. Rev. Letters 57, 1091 (1986).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/10034244
  14. [14]G. A. Miller, “Proton-Size Resolution of the Hyperfine Puzzle in Hydrogen,” arXiv:2602.06929 (2026).arxiv.org/abs/2602.06929
  15. [15]K. Huang and C. N. Yang, “Quantum-Mechanical Many-Body Problem with Hard-Sphere Interaction,” Phys. Rev. 105, 767 (1957).DOI
  16. [16]S. Geltman, “Bound States in Delta Function Potentials,” J. Atomic, Molecular, and Optical Physics, 2011, 573179 (2011).DOI
  17. [17]R. A. Hegstrom, “Relativistic Treatment of the Shielding of the Electron and Proton Magnetic Dipole Moments in Atomic Hydrogen,” Phys. Rev. 184, 17 (1969).
  18. [18]G. Baym and G. R. Farrar, “Relativistic hydrogenic model of diquarks in hadrons,” to be published.
  19. [19]H. Kalf, U.-W. Schmincke, J. Walter, and R. Wüst. ”On the Spectral Theory of Schrödinger and Dirac operators with Strongly Singular Potentials,” in W. N. Everitt (ed), Spectral Theory and Differential Equations, Lecture Notes in Mathematics 448 (Springer, Berlin, Heidelberg, 1975). https://doi.org/10.1007/BFb0067087.
  20. [20]A. Kolakowska, “Application of the minimax principle to the Dirac-Coulomb problem,” J. Phys. B: At. Mol. Opt. Phys. 29, 4515 (1996).DOI
  21. [21]S. Wu, “High-accuracy solution of the Dirac equation for three-dimensional hydrogen atom using a variationally optimized diagonalization method,” Chem. Physics, Chemical Physics 579, 112192 (2024).DOI
  22. [22]S. M. Blinder, “The Hyperfine Interaction Hamiltonian,” J. Molecular Spectroscopy 6, 17 (1960).DOI
  23. [23]L. D. Landau and E.M. Lifshitz, Quantum Mechanics, 3rd ed, 1981; §35.
  24. [24]F. J. Himpsel, “Hyperfine Wave Functions and Force Densities for the Hydrogen Atom,” arXiv:1702.05844 (2017).arxiv.org/abs/1702.05844

Paper details

vlnc:W_j7dbpxe5
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 7

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents