WorksPhysics and Astronomy
The effect of controlled vibrations on the width boundary layers during crystal growth by the Bridgman method
Abstract
By using the finite element code ASTRA, the effect of vibrations on the melt flow in Bridgman crystal growth is investigated for the Earth and Space gravity conditions. It is found that the vibrations significantly decrease the width of interfacial boundary layers in Bridgman crystal growth with submerged vibrator. The influence of the geometrical arrangement of the vibrator, the thermo-gravitational conditions, the frequency of vibration and the rotation effects is investigated. The averaged vibrational flow (AVF) parameters were calculated by means of post-processing the instant thermomechanical fields found in numerical integration of Navier-Stokes problem. The structure of AVF depends on the physical properties of the melt and on the frequency/amplitude values. The frequency of vibrations (vibrational Reynolds number) influences essentially on the AVF structure. Numerical results show that the direction of AVF depends with frequency. It is shown that for normal and low gravity conditions the vibrations can decrease the width of boundary layers and increase the boundary temperature gradients. This can intensify heat and mass transfer near the solid-liquid interface and increase the rate of crystal growth.
Introduction
The dopant distribution in the melt and consequently in the crystal depends on numerous conditions of the crystal growth. The study of the geometrical, thermal and dynamic issues such as forced and thermo-gravitational convection, rotation, magnetic field, vibration etc. is performed in many papers (see, for instance [1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11]). Besides scientific purposes of phenomenological study these investigations are practically targeted on searching the efficient control for the temperature and dopant distribution.1
In real conditions of vertical Bridgman crystal growth, the intensive melt convection always is present due to the horizontal heat fluxes in spite of the thermal scheme provides the stable temperature distribution and the cold melt-crystal interface is situated near the bottom of the crucible.
This convection essentially redistributes the dopant in the melt and does it not always in the desired manner. To decrease this convection the submerged baffles (or heaters) are in use [4, 5]. In these modified crystal growth processes the convection flow is separated into two parts by submerged baffle/heater and has decreased convection intensity near the melt-crystal interface.
In Figure 1 the vibrator is used as a submerged baffle. This case was under study in [4, 5, 6]. The comparison with the isothermal case indicated, that the influence of the convection
Figure 1. Scheme of Bridgman crystal growth with submerged vibrator in the melt
on the temperature field is here negligible (especially under the vibrator). It was shown that weak mixing in the bottom part of crucible (near the solid-liquid interface) can cause the radial inhomogeneuity in the growing crystal even in microgravity environment. To level the dopant distribution in lower part of the crucible the various control tools are usably in use: the horizontal temperature gradient on the baffle surface [5] or on the baffle rotation [4].
The vibrations can be used also as a control handle. In papers [7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 15, 16] the influence of vibrations on heat and mass transfer is studied theoretically and experimentally. In [9, 10] the existence of two types of the averaged vibrational flow (AVF) was found: single vortex and double vortex flows which can be converted one into another depending on the frequency and the geometry of the vibrator.
Present study is devoted to numerical investigation of the influence of vibrations on the melt flow, the structure of AVF and the heat transfer in vertical directional Bridgman crystal growth under terrestrial and microgravity conditions. The calculated results indicate the strong influence of vibrations on the thickness of boundary layers.
The vibrations can decrease the boundary layers at the solid-liquid interface and they can represent the principal effect during the crystal growth process. It is found that by using the vibrations it is possible to vary the value of temperature gradient at the solid-liquid interface, i.e., to vary the kinetics and the rate of the crystal growth. This effect takes place in both terrestrial and microgravity conditions and is dominant for considered configurations. It even prevails on the thermal convection. The effect of Prandtl numbers on the AVF is also studied.
PROBLEM STATEMENT
The modelling conducted on the basis of numerical solution of unsteady 2D Navier-Stokes equations for incompressible axisymmetrical flow. The finite element method and the computer code "ASTRA" [12, 13] used. This code allows to solve 2D and 3D nonstationary Navier-Stokes problems in complex geometry regions.
The AVF was defined by averaging the history of instantaneous unsteady Navier-Stokes solution directly, calculated step-by-step in time. It permits to observe the evolution of the AVF in time and space and its dependence on problem parameters.
The necessity of big CPU time resources was one of the major difficulties of the numerical modelling. For instance the single run can require several tens hours of CPU time on Pentium III 500 MHz.
The principal geometrical scheme of Bridgman crystal growth with submerged vibrator is depicted in Figure 2. In the mathematical model the following assumptions were used: axial symmetry, crystal growth rate and thermal conditions are permanent during the whole process, melt-crystal interface is flat. The small amplitude vibrations are under consideration and therefore the vibrator displacements are negligible while the vibrator velocity is a predefined harmonic function , where and - an amplitude and a frequency of vibrations.
Figure 2. Scheme of calculation region
Unsteady 2D axisymmetrical Navier-Stokes-Boussinesq equations for incompressible fluid read
where and - radial and axial coordinates, - time, and - velocity components in and directions, accordingly, - a temperature, - a pressure, - a density, - a gravity acceleration, - a thermal expansion factor, - a kinematic viscosity, - a heat conduction, - a heat capacity at constant pressure, - in case of axisymmetrical flow and - in case of flat flow. The boundary condition read:
Initial conditions read: : , , .
- crystal growth rate, - temperature scale, n - normal unit vector.
Initial temperature distribution (r, z) was calculated by solving steady temperature equation.
Crystal growth rate reads: sm/h. The problem is characterized by the following similarity numbers:
Reynolds number , vibrational Reynolds number: , Grashof number: , Rayleigh number: , Prandtl number: .
The values of these numbers were: and ; , .
SOLUTION TECHNIQUE
The finite element method is used. The approximations are based on linear triangular elements in space and on implicit finite difference scheme in time. Auxiliary boundary value problems for stream function, vorticity and temperature were solved by using conjugate gradient method with preconditioning without matrix operations [10]. Convective and diffusive terms were approximated symmetrically, for stabilization the additional dissipative diffusion terms were added to each convection-diffusion equation.
The code was tested by solving known benchmark problems [4, 5] and the results of tests for thermal convection in quadratic region [7] indicated good accuracy of the code [14, 15].
The AVF flow characteristics were evaluated by using time averaging formula:
where t is time, F - some of the flow parameters.
The calculations were made using the time step value so that its value was 1/100-1/10 of one period of vibrations (depending on the frequency of vibrations). All presented here results correspond to the time when the averaging vibrational flow (AVF) becomes quasistationary.
Numerical Results
Below the results of the parametric calculations are presented for variety of geometrical configurations of crucibles with submerged vibrators. Considered regions had the following sizes: ; , ; ; ; ; (cm);
where R – a radius of the ampule, H – a height of the ampule, – a distance between the vibrator and the solid-liquid interface, - a vibrator thickness (a distance between its lower and upper surfaces), - a gap (a distance between the vibrator and side wall of the crucible. The following variants with dimensional values of A=50m and 100m, -100 (Hz) are calculated.
Averaged vibrational flow (AVF)
Vibrating baffle forces the melt flow which regarding to time scale can be represented by two flows of different nature with different flow characteristics. First representation is the instantaneous vibrational convective melt flow, which is controlled by the vibrator frequency. This flow can not be detected visually in experiments at rather high vibrator frequencies -100 Hz. Second representation is the AVF, which has significantly decreased velocities and soon becomes quasistationary. This flow can be observed as particle tracks in the experiments with transparent liquids. It is not gravity sensitive and exists as well in case of microgravity and under isothermal conditions. Under non-isothermal conditions when the vibrational flow and thermal convection flow are present simultaneously, the integrated flow is finally observed.
The influence of vibrations (A=100 m and Hz) for microgravity conditions (without thermal convection) is demonstrated in Figure 3 for NaNO melt ([sm/sec], [sm/sec], Pr=9.49). The isolines of stream function are depicted there for instantaneous flow (Figure 3b) and for the AVF (Figure 3c) for the value of time sec. The AVF is present in the areas above and under vibrator so as if it is separated by the vibrator into two parts, which have single-vortex structures. The AVF has the clockwise direction under the vibrator and piecewise direction above. Besides in Figure 3 the graphs of stream function (Figure 3a) and averaged stream function (Figure 3b) versus time are depicted. The results of calculations indicate that the stationary regime of the AVF (for used input parameters) appears after 15-20 seconds (Figure 3c).
Figure 3. Vibrational flow in the melt of NaNO (isothermal case, , μm, Hz, cm, cm)
Influence of vibrations on temperature boundary layer near the solid-liquid interface
Influence of vibrations on temperature distribution is shown in Figure 4-Figure 5. In Figure 4 - for terrestrial environment, and in Figure 5 - for microgravity. In Figure 4 the results without vibrations (, Figure 4a, c, e) and with vibrations ( и , Figure 4b, d, and f) can be seen for the following similarity numbers: , , . Figure 4a and Figure 4b indicate the isolines of stream function, Figure 4c and 4d - isotherms and Figure 4e и 4f - vertical profiles of the temperature (). Under influence of vibrations the large scale AVF is formed. The structure of the AVF in this case has simple arrangement: it is single vortex above the vibrator and double-vortex under (see Figure 4b). Above the vibrator the vortex rotates in counterclockwise direction. Under the vibrator there is the dominant vortex of low intensity rotating in clockwise direction and some secondary vortex of bigger size rotating in counterclockwise direction. Negative values of stream function correspond to the flow rotating in clockwise direction while positive values to the opposite flow.
Figure 4. Influence of vibrations on a temperature boundary layer at front of a crystallization ( , , )
Figure 5. Influence of vibrations on a temperature boundary layer at front of a crystallization in space environment (, , , , , )
The vibrational effect essentially increases the temperature gradient at the solid-liquid interface. This can be seen from comparison of the results in Figure 4c, e and in Figure 4d, f.
It should be told that the fact of narrowing the temperature boundary layer results not only from the AVF itself but from the type of instantaneous flow as well. The type of vibrations plays the principal role. Undoubtedly the instantaneous flow forms the boundary layers. The intensity of instantaneous flow more than 10 times higher than the intensity of the AVF.
The influences of thermal convection on the variation of vertical temperature gradient at the solid-liquid interface (in the area under the vibrator) is practically absent. This can be seen from comparison between the results for terrestrial conditions (Figure 4) and for microgravity conditions (Figure 5). So, in this case the vibrations become a dominant effect forming the temperature distribution and temperature boundary layers at the solid-liquid interface.
The influence of vibrations on the boundary layers depends on the amplitude, the frequency and, also on the Prandtl number of the melt. The calculations indicate, that for small value of Prandtl number , , due to small viscosity and big thermal conductivity the influence of vibrations on the temperature boundary layer thickness is negligible. The influence of vibrations on the temperature boundary layer in melts with small Prandtl numbers can become essential with increase of the amplitude and the frequency is increased (with increase of vibrational Reynolds number ).
The AVF structure under various values of Grashof and Prandtl numbers
The isolines of the AVF stream function under various Grashof and Prandtl numbers for and are presented in Figure 6: a) , ; b) , ; c) , ; d) , ; e) , ; f) , . Under variation of the Prandtl number the AVF structure near the solid-liquid interface can be changed from single vortex to double vortex. The AVF structures under the vibrator for big Prandtl numbers can become layered. The layered structure flows are observed in vertically stratified fluids (under big Prandtl numbers these structures appear when the vertical temperature stratification in homogeneous fluid takes place). It should be mentioned that the results, which were not included into present paper, indicated that the direction of the AVF can be changed by variation of frequency of the vibration [16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21].
Figure 6. Average vibration flow for different Grashoff and Prandtl numbers ( μm, Hz)
Conclusions
For various values of similarity numbers (, , ) by means of the numerical Navier-Stokes modelling the character of the AVF is investigated. The influence of the vibrations on the temperature boundary layer is highlighted for variety of Prandtl numbers.
It is found that the vibrations can decrease the boundary layer thickness at the solid-liquid interface. It can take the principal meaning for improvement of crystal growth technologies due to the possibility to use the vibrations for the control of temperature gradients at solid-liquid interface, i.e. for the control of the kinetics and rate of crystal growth. This effect takes place in both terrestrial and microgravity conditions and for considered configurations the vibrations play the dominant role compared to natural convection.
The results of parametric calculations indicated, that the vibrations could appear a simple, cheap and effective governing factor (in comparison with microgravity, heat transfer and magnetic field), which controls the hydrodynamics, heat and mass transfer, dopant distribution and crystal growth kinetics.
References
- [1]V.I. Polezhaev, (1994) Modeling of hydrodynamics, heat and mass transfer processes on the basis of unsteady Navier-Stokes equations. Applications to the material sciences at earth and under microgravity. Comput. Methods Appl. Mech. Eng. 115, 79-92.
- [2]V.I. Polezhaev et al. , (1991) Mathematical modelling convective heat and mass transfer on the basis of Navier-Stokes equations, Moscow, Nauka.
- [3]S.A. Nikitin, V.I. Polezhaev and A.I. Fedyushkin. (1981) Mathematical simulation in crystals prepared under microgravity conditions. J. Crystal Growth,52, pp.471-477.DOI
- [4]S. Meyer, A.G. Ostrogorsky, (1997) Forced convection in vertical Bridgman configuration with the submerged heater. J. Crystal Growth 171 566-576.DOI
- [5]V.D. Golyshev, M.A. Gonik., (1995) Terrestrial experimental research of new method features of large single crystal growth. In: Proc. Microgravity sci. and applications session, Int. Aerospace Congr., Moscow , August 16-17,1994, Moscow, pp.167-171.
- [6]N.G. Bourago, A.I. Fedyushkin, V.I. Polezhaev, (1997) Modelling of unsteady submerged heating crystal growth in ground-based and microgravity environment. Physical sciences in microgravity. Proceedings of joint Xth European and VIth Russian Symposium on Physical sciences in microgravity. St. Peterburg, Russia, 15-21 June 1997, vol. II, pp.170-173,.
- [7]A.I. Fedyushkin, N.G. Bourago, (1999). Impurity distribution in submerged heater method with and without rotation. Proceedings of the Int.Conf. on Computational Heat and Mass Transfer. April 26-29, 1999, N. Cyprus, Turkey, pp. 207-215.
- [8]I.H. Avetisov, N.G. Bourago, A.I. Fedyushkin, V.I. Polezhaev, A.V. Skorenko, E.V. Zharikov, (1999) The heat and mass transfer during direct crystallization under the vibrational influence. Abstracts of Third Int. Conference “Singe crystal growth, strength problem, and heat mass transfer”. Obninsk, pp.214-215.
- [9]E.V. Zharikov, L.V. Prihod’ko, N.R. Storozhev, (1990) Fluid flow formation resulting from forced vibration of a growing crystal. J. Crystal Growth, 99, pp.910-914.DOI
- [10]D.V. Lyubimov, T.P. Lyubimova, S. Meradji, B. Roux, (1997). Vibrahional control of crystal growth from liquid phase. Journal Crystal Growth 180, pp.648-659.DOI
- [11]A.A. Ivanova, V.G. Kozlov, D.V. Liubimov, T.P. Liubimova, S. Meradgy, B. Ru, (1998). The structure of averaged flow, initiated by vibrating body of big boundary curvature. Izvestia RAS, Mechanics of Fluids, ¹ 5, pp. 30-38.
- [12]G.Z. Gershuni and D.V. Lubimov, (1998). Thermal vibrational convection. John Willey&Sons Ltd., 357p.
- [13]N. G. Bourago and V. N. Kukudzhanov, (1991) Numerical Simulation of Elastic Plastic Media by the Finite Element Method, Pre-print IPMech AS USSR, N.326, 1988, pp. 1-63. Second edition in book "Computer Mechanics", issue 2, Nauka, pp. 78-122.
- [14]N. G. Bourago, (1994) Numerical methods for non-linear processes in elastic plastic media. in “Lectures of FEM-94 Seminar”, Chalmers University of Technology, Gothenburg, pp. 1-15.
- [15]Burago N. G., Fedyushkin A. I. Numerical solution of the Stefan problem // Journal of Physics: Conference Series. 2021. Vol. 1809, No. 1. 012002. DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.1088/1742-6596/1809/1/012002
- [16]A.I. Fedyushkin, N.G. Bourago, (2001) Influence of vibrations on boundary layers in Bridgman crystal growth. Proceedings of 2ⁿᵈ Pan Pacific Basin Workshop on Microgravity Sciences 2001, paper CG-1073.
- [17]Fedyushkin Alexey, Bourago Nicolai, Polezhaev Vadim, Zharikov Evgenii, "The influence of vibration on hydrodynamics and heat-mass transfer during crystal growth", J. of Crystal Growth. 2005. V. 275. N. 1-2. P. e1557 - e1564. DOI: 10.1016/j.jcrysgro.2004.11.220.DOI
- [18]Fedyushkin, A. I.; Bourago, N. G. Vibration for controlling of temperature and dopant distributions in melt. 35th COSPAR Assembly, Paris, France, July 12-19, 2004. DOI: 10.13140/2.1.3568.9763DOI
- [19]Fedyushkin A.I., Burago N.G., Puntus A.A. Convective heat and mass transfer modeling under crystal growth by vertical Bridgman method. Journal of Physics: Conference Series, IOP Publishing ([Bristol, UK], England), V. 1479, 012029, 2020. DOI: 10.1088/1742-6596/1479/1/012029DOI
- [20]Fedyushkin A.I., Burago N.G., Puntus A.A. Effect of rotation on impurity distribution in crystal growth by Bridgman method. Journal of Physics: Conference Series, Institute of Physics (United Kingdom), V. 1359, 012045, 2019. DOI: 10.1088/1742-6596/1359/1/012045DOI
- [21]Fedyushkin A.I. Heat and mass transfer during crystal growing by the Czochralski method with a submerged vibrator. Journal of Physics: Conference Series, Institute of Physics (United Kingdom), V. 1359, 012054, 2019. DOI: 10.1088/1742-6596/1359/1/012054DOI