WorksPhysics and Astronomy
Measurements of isolated photon pair production in association with jets in pp collisions at = 8 TeV with the ATLAS detector
Abstract
Measurements of integrated and differential production cross section of two isolated photons in events with and without associated hadronic jets based on the 2012 dataset of 20.3 fb integrated luminosity of proton-proton collisions at TeV collected by the ATLAS experiment are presented. The measurements consider photons with pseudorapidities of or and transverse energy of GeV. Jets are required to have GeV for and GeV for . Events are classified into categories based on the number of jets and integrated fiducial cross sections of diphoton production in association with inclusive and exclusive number of jets are presented. Fiducial cross sections, differential in sixteen diphoton, jet, dijet and photon-jet observables, are presented and compared with leading-order Sherpa 1.4.1 predictions in all jet categories, fixed-order next-to-leading-order GoSam and BlackHat calculations in selected categories, and NLO-matched predictions from Sherpa 2.2.14 in all categories. Overall, the NLO predictions provide a reasonable description of the data, with significant discrepancies observed for increasing jet multiplicity, particularly for angular variables, attributable to the absence of higher-order terms in the calculations. The Sherpa 2.2.14 NLO-matched predictions provide the best overall description of the data across all jet categories and observables.
© 2026 CERN for the benefit of the ATLAS Collaboration.
Reproduction of this article or parts of it is allowed as specified in the CC-BY-4.0 license.
Introduction
The measurement of the production of two isolated prompt photons1 in association with jets, produced by Standard Model (SM) processes in proton–proton () collisions, is a useful tool to test perturbative QCD (pQCD) predictions. Cross sections for these processes are in fact difficult to compute using pQCD in particular regions of the phase space, such as back-to-back configurations of the two photons, or the diphoton system recoiling against a single jet, for which resummation techniques are necessary [1], and good theoretical knowledge of the photon pair production in association with jets must be established. In particular, fixed-order calculations for this process are available at next-to-leading order (NLO) for multiple jets [2, 3], and this order of the perturbative series might inaccurately predict the overall cross-section normalization and fail to capture the full dynamics of the process, especially in the presence of more than one jet and in particular regions of the phase space. Monte Carlo (MC) generators providing NLO matrix elements matched to parton showers (NLO+PS) [4] can better describe the overall cross-section normalization and the process kinematics simultaneously. This paper aims therefore to provide comparisons of the + jet(s) final state object kinematic and angular properties to various theoretical predictions, to provide insight on and lead toward the improvement of MC simulations of these processes.
In this paper, the measurement of prompt diphoton production in association with jets in collisions at TeV by the ATLAS experiment using an integrated luminosity of 20.3 fb is presented. Diphoton events are categorized according to the number of jets () into exclusive and inclusive categories and fiducial cross sections are measured for each jet category. Fiducial cross sections are also measured differentially in up to sixteen observables, depending on the number of jets present in an event.
Diphoton production at the LHC is dominated by three production processes, as illustrated in Figure 1: the Born process (), which is LO in the strong coupling constant , the NLO bremsstrahlung process () and the box diagram () that appears at NNLO. Additional jets in the event can be produced by emitting a quark or a gluon either in the initial or final state. The full NNLO QCD corrections to inclusive diphoton production have been computed in Ref. [5]; for diphoton production in association with a single jet, NNLO calculations have more recently become available [6], while NLO remains the highest fixed-order accuracy for multiple jets [2, 3].

Figure 1. Diphoton production at the LHC: (a) Born diagram (LO) (b) bremsstrahlung diagram (NLO) and (c) box diagram (NNLO).
The SM production cross section of two isolated photons has been measured at the Tevatron by the DØ and CDF experiments [7, 8, 9] and at the LHC by the ATLAS and CMS experiments [10, 11, 12, 13, 14]. More recently, ATLAS has also observed electroweak diphoton production in association with two jets [15].
The measurement presented in this paper applies less restrictive kinematic selection criteria for the two photons compared with the published ATLAS measurement of inclusive diphoton cross section [16]. This allows for a larger phase space, providing a larger data sample for the measurement that is split into jet categories. The measured cross sections are compared with fixed-order NLO predictions from the GoSam and BlackHat frameworks, to LO predictions from Sherpa 1.4.1 normalized to data, and to Sherpa 2.2.14, which provides NLO-matched matrix elements for diphoton production in association with up to three jets and represents the most advanced theoretical benchmark included in this study.
This paper is organized as follows. § 2 gives a brief overview of the ATLAS detector. § 3 introduces data and MC samples used in this analysis, while § 4 describes the event and object selection. The extraction of the diphoton yield is described in § 5. § 6 describes the unfolding procedure, while the systematic uncertainties affecting the measured yields and cross sections are discussed in § 7. In § 8, various theoretical predictions of the diphoton+jets process are discussed. The measured integrated and differential fiducial cross sections are discussed and compared with the corresponding theoretical predictions in § 9. § 10 summarizes the measurement.
ATLAS detector
The ATLAS detector [17] is a multipurpose detector with a forward–backward symmetric cylindrical geometry2. At small radii, the inner detector (ID) is made up of fine-granularity pixel and microstrip detectors. These silicon-based detectors cover the pseudorapidity range . A gas-filled straw-tube transition radiation tracker (TRT) complements the silicon tracker at larger radii and also provides electron identification capabilities based on transition radiation. Around the TRT, a thin superconducting solenoid produces a 2 T magnetic field.
The electromagnetic (EM) calorimeter is a lead/liquid-argon sampling calorimeter with accordion geometry. The calorimeter is divided into a barrel section covering and two endcap sections covering . For it is divided into three layers in depth, which are finely segmented in and . A thin presampler layer, covering , is used to correct for fluctuations in upstream energy losses. Hadronic calorimetry in the region uses steel absorbers and scintillator tiles as an active medium. Liquid-argon calorimetry with copper absorbers is used in the hadronic endcap calorimeters, which cover the region . A forward calorimeter using copper or tungsten absorbers with liquid argon completes the calorimeter coverage up to .
Surrounding the calorimeters is the muon spectrometer, which measures the deflection of muon tracks. The deflection is provided by a toroidal magnetic field of air-core superconducting magnets.
Events are selected using a first-level trigger implemented in custom electronics, which reduces the event rate to a design value of at most 75 kHz using a subset of detector information [18]. Software algorithms with access to the full detector information are then used in the high-level trigger to yield a recorded event rate of about 400 Hz.
Data and Monte Carlo samples
The analyzed data set consists of collision data at a center-of-mass energy TeV, corresponding to an integrated luminosity of fb, collected by the ATLAS detector at the LHC in 2012. The luminosity was determined following the methodology detailed in Ref. [19].
Three sets of MC samples are used to model diphoton events in association with jets. A Sherpa 1.4.1 sample [4], generated with CT10 parton distribution functions (PDFs) [20] is used as the main MC sample, simulating the production of two photons with up to three partons from the hard process in the final state at LO. These processes with different parton multiplicities are combined with each other and with the parton shower using the ME+PS@LO prescription [21] to remove overlaps and effectively simulate all parton emissions.
The Pythia 8.163 event generator [22] is used to generate and diphoton events at LO. Photon+jet events produced by and processes at LO are also generated. Photons originating from hadronization of colored partons are considered at LO using and dijet diagrams with initial and final-state radiation. The event-generation uses CTEQ6L1 [23] PDFs at LO and its parameters are set according to the ATLAS AU2 tune [24].
Both the Sherpa 1.4.1 and Pythia 8.163 samples are used for event and object selection studies. The Sherpa 1.4.1 sample serves as the primary MC: it is used for background estimation, unfolding of detector effects, and non-perturbative corrections to the fixed-order predictions (see § 8). The Pythia 8.163 sample, which does not include additional jets from the hard matrix element beyond the two photons and therefore has limited applicability for multijet final states, is used exclusively as a cross-check for background estimation and systematic uncertainty evaluation; it is not included in the differential cross section comparisons presented in § 9.
An additional Sherpa 2.2.14 sample is used for theory comparison purposes, as described in § 8. It is not used in event and object selection studies, background subtraction, unfolding, or non-perturbative corrections, as this sample was not available at the time of the analysis.
A Powheg+Pythia 8.170 [22, 25, 26] sample at NLO with final state radiation simulated by Photos [27] and CT10 PDFs, is used to estimate the number of electrons misidentified as photons.
Dedicated Sherpa 1.4.1 samples with two photons and up to two partons were generated with and without underlying event and hadronization mechanisms to compute non-perturbative corrections applied to the fixed-order predictions described in § 8. These are referred to as non-perturbative corrections (NPC).
For all MC samples described in this section, generated events are passed through a full ATLAS detector simulation [28] based on Geant 4 [29]. Pileup from additional collisions in the same and neighboring bunch crossings is simulated by overlaying each MC event with a variable number of simulated inelastic collisions, corresponding to an average of approximately 21 interactions per bunch crossing. The MC events are weighted to reproduce the observed distribution of the average number of interactions per bunch crossing and the size of the luminous region along the beam axis.
NLO fixed-order predictions from GoSam and BlackHat, which are compared with the data in the 1-jet and 2-jet categories, are described in § 8.
Event and object selection
Events were collected in stable beam conditions and with all relevant ATLAS subsystems fully operational. The data were recorded using a diphoton trigger, which requires two electromagnetic clusters with transverse energies above 20 GeV, both fulfilling identification criteria based on the shape of the electromagnetic shower in the EM calorimeter. The efficiency of the diphoton trigger is (98.7 0.5)% for signal events satisfying the analysis selection, which has been evaluated using methods of Refs. [18, 30]. Events with at least one reconstructed primary vertex, which has at least three associated tracks with a transverse momentum above 400 MeV, are selected to reject non-collision backgrounds. Almost twenty million events satisfy these criteria.
Photon reconstruction and selection
Photon and electron candidates are reconstructed from clusters of energy deposited in the calorimeter, combined with tracking information from the inner detector. Clusters matched to a conversion vertex, reconstructed from either two tracks consistent with a vertex originating from a photon conversion, or one track that does not have any hits in the innermost pixel layer and has an electron-like response in the TRT, are reconstructed as converted photon candidates. Clusters without any matching track or conversion vertex are reconstructed as unconverted photon candidates, while clusters with a matching track are reconstructed as electrons [31]. Depending on the detector region, 20–50% of all photons convert into an electron–positron pair in the inner detector material [17].
The photon energy is calibrated using a simulation-based regression, the inputs of which from data are corrected to account for differences between data and MC using information obtained from , and inclusive photon events. An overall energy scale calibration is derived from events [32].
The transverse energy of a photon candidate, , is computed using the pseudorapidity of the EM cluster measured in the second layer of the EM calorimeter, which provides the best photon direction measurement. Photon candidates are first required to satisfy GeV and have , excluding the barrel–endcap transition region of . Photon candidates also have to satisfy loose selection criteria for the shape of the shower in the EM calorimeter [31]. The remaining candidates are then ordered in and the primary vertex of the hard interaction is determined using the photon pointing method [33]. The pseudorapidity and the transverse energy of the photons is recomputed relative to the primary vertex of the hard interaction, referred to as the diphoton vertex in the following.
Both photon candidates must then have GeV and are required to be isolated and satisfy tight identification criteria using nine shower-shape variables related to the energy leakage into the hadronic calorimeter and the lateral and longitudinal shower development in the EM calorimeter [31, 34]. Non-isolated and non-tight photons, satisfying all other selections, are used for the background subtraction, as described in § 5. Photons are considered to be isolated if the calorimeter isolation transverse energy satisfies GeV. The is defined as the sum of the transverse energies of the positive-energy topological clusters [34, 35] within a cone of around the photon candidate, excluding the center of the shower and correcting for leakage of the photon shower into the isolation cone. The contributions of the underlying event and pileup are subtracted based on the jet area/median method described in Ref. [36]. For each photon candidate a track isolation variable is defined as the scalar sum of the transverse momenta of tracks with GeV within a cone of size around the photon candidate. Tracks associated with a photon conversion and those not originating from the diphoton vertex are excluded from the sum. This cone size was optimized to correspond closely to the calorimeter isolation selection of GeV. The track isolation is not directly used as a selection, but to define control regions to measure backgrounds (see § 5.1).
The two photon candidates are required to be separated in the plane by to avoid that they lie within their respective isolation cones, which would affect the isolation selection3. The invariant mass of the two photon candidates is required to be GeV.
After applying these event and photon selection criteria, almost eight hundred thousand events with two tight and isolated photon candidates are retained for further analysis.
Jet reconstruction and selection
Jets are reconstructed using the anti- algorithm [37] with radius parameter of . Jets are then calibrated at the electromagnetic energy scale. The energy deposited in the calorimeters by the EM and hadronic showers is measured and corrected relative to the response of the calorimeters to the true energy corresponding to a jet of stable particles entering the detector in MC simulation. Several corrections related to pileup, the jet origin, jet energy and direction, and an in situ correction accounting for differences between data and MC, are performed [38].
Calibrated jets are further required to have a rapidity of . Jets within of either photon are not considered, to avoid photon–jet double-counting. The transverse momentum of jets is required to be at least GeV for and GeV for . These thresholds are applied as a function of pseudorapidity rather than rapidity, since pileup suppression relies on charged-particle tracks available within the inner detector acceptance (). The higher selection for jets with is to suppress jets originating from pileup interactions, whereas for jets with GeV and , a Jet Vertex Fraction (JVF) requirement is imposed, JVF . The JVF is defined as the sum of the of tracks associated with the jet that are produced at the diphoton vertex, divided by the sum of the of the tracks associated with the jet from all collision vertices [39]. The jet and JVF selection were optimized to reach an at least 90% purity of jets originating from a quark or a gluon from the hard process using SHERPA MC. The residual contribution of pileup jets satisfying the selection is corrected for by the unfolding procedure.
Events are split into categories according to the number of jets satisfying the requirements listed above. Additionally, events in which any selected jet is within of either photon are removed, as such jets would contaminate the photon isolation cone.
For simulated events, the reconstruction-level selection follows the same criteria detailed above. In addition, reconstructed photons are required to be matched to photons originating in the hard process, ensuring that the MC efficiency is computed for signal photons only; in data, the contributions from fake photons and misidentified electrons are estimated and subtracted using the data-driven methods described in § 5.
Fiducial phase space definition
The fiducial phase space in which the cross sections are reported is defined by the kinematic selection of the photons and jets in analogy to the selection described above. Events are required to have at least two photons from a hard interaction. The two highest- photons are required to have GeV and or and have to be separated by in the plane. The isolation criterion is implemented as a particle-level isolation criterion. The sum of transverse momenta of all generated particles in a cone of around a photon, except muons, neutrinos and particles from interactions produced by pileup, is required to be below 9 GeV. This corresponds to the calorimeter isolation selection of GeV at reconstruction-level.
Jets at particle-level are built from all particles, including muons and neutrinos, with a lifetime greater than 10 ps using the anti- algorithm with radius parameter . Jets are required to have the rapidity of and have to fulfill GeV if and GeV otherwise. Jets are not considered if they are separated from any of the two photons by . Events, where a jet satisfying the and requirements is within of either of the two selected photons, are removed.
Measurement strategy
Fiducial cross sections are measured integrated per jet category and also differentially in up to sixteen observables. They are measured as a function of diphoton kinematic and angular properties: the diphoton invariant mass , the transverse momentum of the diphoton system , the opening angle between the photons in the azimuthal plane and defined in the Collins–Soper frame [40]. For events with jets, the cross section is also measured differentially in of up to the first three highest- jets in the event, and the separation of photons and jets in the plane, . Dijet kinematic variables, namely the dijet invariant mass , the transverse momentum of the dijet system , the opening angle between the two highest- jets in the azimuthal plane and their difference in rapidity are measured for events with at least two jets. The azimuthal angle between the diphoton and dijet systems, , is also measured. This observable can be sensitive to the contribution of multiple parton interactions. Table 1 lists all observables that are measured for each category.
Background decomposition and signal yield extraction
The sample of events satisfying the event and object selection still contains a sizable fraction of background. The main background consists of neutral mesons inside jets, where the mesons carry a high fraction of the jet momentum and subsequently decay into two collinear photons. These can be mistaken for a single prompt photon. The selected diphoton candidate spectrum, according to previous measurements [10, 11, 16], contains around 60% prompt diphotons at low (below 100 GeV) and more than 95% at high (above 500 GeV).
A smaller reducible background due to electrons is also present in the selected sample. It amounts to approximately 2–4% of the selected sample, and is spread evenly in all measured distributions, except for the diphoton invariant mass distribution, where a localized peak is visible around the -boson mass ( GeV), since most of the electron background originates from events. The peak in the spectrum helps to identify and quantify the electron background and its disappearance after the subtraction validates the approach.
| Observable / | 0 jets | 1 jet | 2 jets | jets |
| ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | |
| ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | |
| ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | |
| ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | |
| ✓ | ✓ | |||
| ✓ | ✓ | |||
| ✓ | ✓ | |||
| ✓ | ✓ | |||
| ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ||
| ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ||
| ✓ | ✓ | |||
| ✓ | ✓ | |||
| ✓ | ✓ | |||
| ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ||
| ✓ | ✓ | |||
| ✓ |
Table 1. Observables measured in this paper. See text for definitions.
The contribution of the Higgs boson decay is estimated to be negligible in all regions of the phase space, except for the diphoton invariant mass around 125 GeV, where the contribution is predicted to be around 2% of the diphoton yield using simulated events. Since photons from the Higgs boson are genuine prompt photons, this contribution is not subtracted.
Fake-photon background
A well-established matrix method, previously used in ATLAS [10, 16], is used to decompose the photon candidate spectrum into four components: , , and . The labels and distinguish the two configurations in which the subleading or leading photon candidate, respectively, is the fake. The matrix method uses background control regions populated with events with photon candidates that fail the isolation requirement, the tight identification criteria, or both.
Yields of the four final states, , , , , are extracted from a sample of reconstructed photon pairs satisfying the full selection except the isolation criteria, referred to as the TT sample (T for tight) in the following. Events are further classified into four categories based on the photon pair isolation status: II, , and , where I indicates a candidate in the pair passing the isolation criterion, and a candidate failing it. The event counts , , , in these four categories are related to the yields , , , by a matrix equation:
where the indices 1,2 refer to the leading/subleading photon candidate, and the matrix coefficients are: , the isolation efficiencies for prompt photons, assumed equal in diphoton and photon+jet events; , the photon–jet isolation fake rates for the leading/subleading candidate; , the dijet isolation fake rates. Fake rates are defined separately for photon–jet and dijet events due to the different dominant jet origin (quark-initiated vs. gluon-initiated). In dijet events the isolation of the two fake photons is positively correlated because of the color connection between the outgoing partons; this is accounted for by the correction factor .
The matrix method is applied in bins of each measured observable. The various coefficients are obtained as follows: is extracted purely from data; is measured with a tag-and-probe method using data with Sherpa MC input; is derived from MC simulation. Details are given below.
The isolation efficiencies are extracted from the TTII signal region and control regions populated by candidates failing the isolation and tight identification criteria. An assumption is made that isolation and tight identification criteria are uncorrelated for fake photons. A non-tight photon () is required to satisfy modified tight criteria, where four out of the nine shower shape criteria defining the tight selection are removed. Track isolation is used to define an anti-isolated sample, which differs from the non-isolated sample by having a negligible number of prompt photons and a high number of fakes. Candidates in the anti-isolated region are required to have track isolation , which removes prompt photons, and calorimeter isolation , removing fake photons that are misidentified electrons and leaving a pure jet sample. The definition of the anti-isolated sample is optimized on MC and pseudo-data studies, and ensures no overlap with the signal region. The computation of the isolation efficiencies is therefore purely data-driven.
The fake rates for and , the fake rates for dijet events, and the corresponding correlation correction factor are computed using a tag and probe method with input from data and Sherpa MC.
The yields extracted by the matrix method are affected by statistical fluctuations in the signal and control regions. The total statistical uncertainty in the measured yield is estimated using a bootstrap technique [41].
Electron background subtraction
After the subtraction of the fake-photon background, a reducible background of electrons is still present. This component consists of final states with a prompt photon and at least one electron, such as , or ; and Drell–Yan electron pairs or where electrons are misidentified as photons.
The approach taken to subtract the electron background in this analysis is similar to that in Ref. [10]. The electron to photon fake rate is measured in data as a single value, integrated over the photon pseudorapidity and transverse momentum, by counting and events with invariant mass close to the -boson mass. In these control samples, electron candidates are required to satisfy the same kinematic requirements as photons and to satisfy the medium++ identification criterion [42]; electrons within of an identified photon are excluded. The dependency of on the photons’ kinematics is reflected in its effect on events with different number of jets, through the different spectrum of . The value of is therefore computed both from the inclusive data set, which is dominated by events with , and for a subset with GeV, which is characteristic of events with . The electron background is then estimated by applying according to the jet multiplicity to the control samples containing one or two identified electrons.
The electron background depends strongly on , but it is much more evenly distributed for other observables. Therefore, a set of weights is derived based on narrow bins in , which are applied to the data before the fake-photon background subtraction is performed using the matrix method. For this purpose, it is necessary to evaluate the electron contamination also for events not satisfying the isolation requirements. This approach is found to introduce a relative bias of below 1% on the size of the electron background yield, which is already very small (2–4%) and therefore it is neglected.
Diphoton yield extraction
Results of the background subtraction are displayed in Figure 2. The reconstructed yield as a function of features a peak around the -boson mass, which is due to events where both are wrongly identified as photons. The purity varies between the jet categories from 65% for events with just two photons up to 74% for events with two photons and at least three jets. This can be explained by the fact that the cross section is smaller than , and so on. Therefore, if there are already three jets in the event, the two photons are less likely to be misidentified jets than in the case of just two jets or one jet present in the event.
Figure 2. Background decomposition as a function of (a) the number of jets and as a function of the diphoton invariant mass for (b) , (c) 1 and (d) 2, with emphasis on low- region. Uncertainties in data points are statistical only and too small to be visible. Uncertainties in the diphoton distribution after background subtraction obtained from the matrix method are statistical, using a bootstrap method. Uncertainties for other components are not shown.
Figure 3 shows the diphoton yields after background subtraction for selected observables in the and categories compared with Sherpa MC normalized to data, which are used in the unfolding procedure described in the next section.
Figure 3. Comparison of data (points) with statistical uncertainties to Sherpa 1.4.1 MC (line) at reconstruction level for (a) and (b) distribution for ; and (c) and (d) distributions for . Data points are plotted on bin centers. The level of agreement between data and simulation can be assessed by comparing the shapes.
Unfolding
The measured yields of + jet(s) events are unfolded to particle level. Unfolding takes into account the trigger efficiency, signal reconstruction efficiency, selection criteria efficiencies, detector-induced distortions of the measured distributions and the presence of pileup jets. The unfolded spectra are then divided by the luminosity to derive differential cross sections.
Singular Value Decomposition (SVD) unfolding [43] is used in this paper to account for detector effects, relating reconstruction and generation level information from the SHERPA 1.4.1 diphoton samples described in § 3. Originally developed for single differential cross sections, the SVD unfolding is generalized to double differential cross sections. To avoid overestimated uncertainties, SVD unfolding uses a regularization to reduce sudden changes in the MC to unfolded data ratio in adjacent bins. With two-dimensional distributions, there are adjacent bins both in the measured observable and in the number of jets (± 1 jet). A regularization in the latter has been studied. Due to the small number of bins in this dimension (two to four) and the not sufficiently accurate description of the jet multiplicity in the MC
samples used, it does not improve the accuracy of the measurement, but it can lead to a notable bias. Therefore, a regularization is applied only to the adjacent bins in the measured observable, not to adjacent bins in the number of jets.
As a deviation between MC spectrum and the true physical distribution can lead to a bias in the estimated yield, studies are performed to estimate the impact of MC to data differences. For these the MC shape is distorted by reweighting, and unfolding of the original MC shape is carried out with the distorted simulation. This is performed for different shapes of distortions, following MC-to-data shape deviations observed for representative observables in previous ATLAS diphoton measurements. In addition, the observed difference between MC and unfolded data is used as a distortion in a pseudo-data sample and the impact on the unfolded results is evaluated. In each bin, the largest observed bias is taken as a systematic uncertainty in both directions.
SVD unfolding has a free parameter describing the regularization strength , an integer from 1 to the total number of bins, where smaller values lead to a stronger regularization. A regularization that is too strong leads to large biases, while a regularization that is too weak leads to large statistical uncertainties. To choose the regularization strength, a figure of merit is defined combining the statistical uncertainties and the expected biases across all bins using a sub-linear (cube-root) scaling to reduce the influence of outlier bins, with the bias term weighted by a factor of four to favor low-bias solutions. The regularization strength is then chosen to minimize this figure of merit. For observables where the figure of merit did not show a clear minimum, was chosen to be three quarters of the number of bins.
Systematic uncertainties
Table 2 lists the contributions of each systematic uncertainty component for the different categories. The dominant systematic uncertainty in the cross-section measurement, in most regions of the phase space, comes from the definition of the non-tight control region in the fake-photon background subtraction method.
| Uncertainty source [%] | ||||
| Photon energy scale | ||||
| Photon energy resolution | ||||
| Photon identification | ||||
| Jet energy scale | ||||
| Jet energy resolution | ||||
| Jet vertex fraction | ||||
| Fake-photon background | ||||
| Electron background subtraction | ||||
| Unfolding bias | ||||
| MC sample size | ||||
| Trigger efficiency | ||||
| Luminosity | ||||
| Total systematic uncertainty | ||||
| Statistical uncertainty |
Table 2. Summary of relative uncertainties in the integrated cross section for exclusive categories, taken from the observable.
Several systematic effects of the fake-photon background subtraction on the diphoton purity measurement are evaluated by varying the control regions described above. A systematic uncertainty is assigned to the assumption that for fake photons the isolation properties are independent of the identification. As explained previously, the nominal selection corresponds to removing four criteria out of the nine that define the tight region. The systematic uncertainty is computed by calculating the yields using different definitions of the control region, removing not four but two, three and five of the nine criteria defining the tight selection and taking the envelope of the largest difference relative to the nominal definition. This is the dominant systematic uncertainty in the yield.
Anti-isolated control regions are used to calculate the matrix method coefficients, as studies based on MC suggest that the fraction of genuine photons in the -anti-isolated selection is , and even much smaller in the -isolated selection. To assess the effect of this assumption, and of possible mismodeling by the MC of the isolation energy distribution at high value of because of the poor MC modeling of photons issued from parton fragmentation, the fake-photon background subtraction is repeated changing the track isolation requirement of anti-isolated definition to GeV, and the result is taken as a systematic uncertainty in the yield, amounting to about .
SHERPA is used as default MC for the calculation of fake rates and correlations; when an alternative MC generator implementing different parton shower and hadronization models is used to compute those quantities, i.e. Pythia, negligible differences are observed in the measured yields; therefore, no systematic uncertainty is assigned to this specific choice.
Since a single value of the electron-to-photon fake rate is used, integrated over the photon pseudorapidity and transverse momentum, its dependence on the photon kinematics is accounted for by systematic variations. For events with , the dominant uncertainty in the electron background subtraction arises from the difference between the values extracted from the inclusive sample and the high- sample, to account for the non-negligible portion of such events that occur at lower . This uncertainty is almost uniform around for all kinematic distributions, except for , where it increases up to around the -boson mass. A smaller contribution, which is the only one for events with , is evaluated by using different values of for the barrel and endcap parts of the calorimeter, derived from simulation, and by varying to account for its dependence on the transverse momentum of the electron faking a photon.
Figure 4 shows the breakdown of systematic uncertainties in the measured cross section as a function of the diphoton invariant mass in selected categories. In most bins, the jet energy scale and the non-tight control region definition are the dominant systematic uncertainties. In the 0-jet category, the electron background subtraction uncertainty, described in § 5.2, becomes the second largest systematic uncertainty at around GeV. Subdominant background-related uncertainties arise from the photon isolation shape and the photon identification scale factors. These uncertainties are propagated through the unfolding procedure.
Figure 4. Breakdown of the systematic uncertainties for the unfolded distribution for the exclusive jet categories (a) , (b) 1, (c) 2 and (d) the inclusive category. The total systematic uncertainty includes all systematic uncertainties except the luminosity uncertainty.
Two systematic uncertainties are assigned to the unfolding procedure, associated with the statistical uncertainty of the MC sample and the unfolding bias.
Other experimental uncertainties are evaluated by modifying the detector response matrices according to the considered effect, which includes the photon energy scale, photon energy resolution, jet energy scale, jet energy resolution, photon tight identification scale factors, JVF signal efficiency and the definition of pileup jets in the JVF selection. These effects are mostly subdominant, except for jet energy scale becoming more significant when and JVF signal efficiency being the largest systematic uncertainty for low . The jet definition and pileup uncertainty becomes dominant for . The luminosity uncertainty, measured to be 1.9% [19], is also included in the final cross sections. All uncertainty sources are treated as uncorrelated relative to other uncertainty sources, except for the correlation model recommendations on photon and jet energy scale and resolution according to methods in Refs. [31, 32, 38, 39, 44, 45].
Theoretical predictions
The measured fiducial cross sections, both integrated (per category) and differential in up to sixteen kinematic and angular variables, are compared with several theoretical predictions.
One prediction is based on the Sherpa 1.4.1 LO event generator interfaced with a parton shower model, the same generator used for background subtraction and unfolding (see § 3). Particle-level events are selected in the fiducial phase space defined in § 4.3. Since this prediction is only LO, it is not expected to accurately predict the integrated fiducial cross section; accordingly, for differential comparisons, Sherpa 1.4.1 is shown normalized to data. The normalization factors are 1.5, 1.4, and 1.25 for , 1, and 2, respectively; in the category Sherpa 1.4.1 is shown at absolute normalization, since its predicted cross section coincidentally matches the measurement. No theory uncertainties are quoted and MC statistical uncertainties are negligible.
NLO fixed-order pQCD predictions from the GoSam framework [2] are compared with data in the exclusive 1-jet and 2-jet categories. The predictions are computed using CT14 PDFs [46]. Virtual top-quark contributions are neglected and loop-induced processes are not included. The renormalization and factorization scales are set to and varied by factors of 0.5 and 2 to evaluate scale uncertainties. Frixione isolation [5, 47] is applied with , , and . The PDF uncertainty is negligible relative to the scale uncertainty. For the observable, which requires a final state, the GoSam prediction is computed at LO accuracy.
NLO fixed-order pQCD predictions from the BlackHat framework are obtained similarly to Refs. [3, 48]. They use CT10 PDFs [20] and the same central scale definition, , with factor-two up/down scale variations. The PDF uncertainty is also negligible relative to the scale uncertainty. All subprocesses are included except loop-induced ones, and a leading-color approximation is used for finite parts of the one-loop matrix elements, with an expected impact of about 1% on the cross section. Frixione isolation is applied with , , and . The BlackHat predictions were provided for all observables except and .
Non-perturbative corrections (NPC) to the fixed-order predictions are computed from dedicated Sherpa 1.4.1 samples, as described in § 3, with and without hadronization and underlying event using a Rivet routine [49]. The total uncertainty in the fixed-order predictions is obtained as the sum in quadrature of statistical, scale, and NPC uncertainties.
An additional comparison is provided by Sherpa 2.2.14 [50]. Matrix elements are calculated at NLO in QCD for diphoton+0, 1 jet production and at LO for diphoton+2, 3 jet production, merged with the MEPS@NLO prescription. Virtual QCD corrections are provided by OpenLoops; the NNPDF3.0_nnlo PDF set [51] is used, and the loop-induced contribution is included at LO. Given the higher perturbative accuracy, no normalization to data is applied for this prediction. Scale uncertainties are evaluated from a seven-point envelope with consistent parton-shower scale variations; PDF uncertainties are assessed following the PDF4LHC21 prescription [52] and are at the 2–3% level, small compared with the scale uncertainty.
Since the contribution of the Higgs boson decay into two photons is negligible relative to the total diphoton yield, it is not included in the theoretical comparisons.
Results
Integrated cross sections
Background subtraction and unfolding are performed in exclusive jet categories. Due to the limited number of data events, the 3-jet category is inclusive. Results for inclusive 0, 1 and 2-jet categories and for integrated cross sections are derived from the exclusive jet category results, taking correlations between bins of different jet categories into account. Table 3 shows the integrated cross sections after unfolding with their statistical and systematic uncertainties, containing also the luminosity uncertainty, for each jet category.
| [pb] | Stat. unc. [pb] | Syst. unc. [pb] | |
| 0-jet | 28.5 | ||
| 1-jet | 7.4 | ||
| 2-jet | 2.44 | ||
| -jet | 39.2 | ||
| -jet | 10.7 | ||
| -jet | 3.3 | ||
| -jet | 0.82 |
Table 3. Integrated cross sections measured in data for each jet category, with statistical, and total systematic uncertainties. All cross sections are measured in the fiducial region defined in § 4.3.
As expected for a LO generator, Sherpa 1.4.1 greatly underestimates the measured integrated cross sections across all jet categories, with the notable exception of the -jet inclusive category, where the predicted cross section coincidentally matches the data. Table 4 compares the measured cross sections with the NLO-level predictions. GoSam NLO predictions are compatible with the data within uncertainties in both the 1-jet and 2-jet categories, with central values 11% and 9% below the data, respectively. BlackHat is also compatible with the data within uncertainties in the 2-jet category, with a central value 3% below data. Sherpa 2.2.14 predictions are compatible with the data within the scale uncertainties in all categories, with some underestimation in the 0-jet (9%) and 2-jet (15%) exclusive categories and good agreement in the 1-jet category.
| [pb] | [pb] | [pb] | [pb] | |
| 0-jet | ||||
| 1-jet | ||||
| 2-jet | ||||
| -jet | ||||
| -jet | ||||
| -jet | ||||
| -jet |
Table 4. Integrated cross sections per jet category as measured in data, and the corresponding NLO theoretical predictions. The total uncertainty for data values includes the statistical, systematic and luminosity uncertainty. NLO fixed-order predictions are listed with the total statistical, scale and NPC uncertainty. For Sherpa 2.2.14, the scale uncertainty from the seven-point envelope is shown; PDF uncertainties are small in comparison. GoSam and BlackHat predictions are available only for the exclusive 1-jet and 2-jet categories. The small upper uncertainties for GoSam and BlackHat in the 2-jet category reflect the highly asymmetric scale uncertainty envelope in this exclusive jet multiplicity category.
Differential cross sections
Differential cross sections for each jet multiplicity category are shown in Figure 5–Figure 17. Sherpa 1.4.1 is normalized to the measured integrated cross section in each category (except in the -jet category, where it is shown at absolute normalization since its predicted cross section matches the data); the normalization factor is quoted in the plot legends. Sherpa 2.2.14, GoSam, and BlackHat predictions are shown at absolute normalization. The Sherpa 2.2.14 scale and PDF uncertainty band is shown in both the main and the ratio panels. The scale uncertainty bands for GoSam and BlackHat are also shown; in bins where the NLO scale uncertainty exceeds the central NLO prediction, only the central value is displayed as an open marker and the uncertainty band is not drawn. Integrated NLO uncertainty values are listed in Table 4.
Figure 5. Differential cross sections in the category as a function of (a) , (b) , (c) and (d) , compared with theoretical predictions from Sherpa 2.2.14, and to LO Sherpa 1.4.1 predictions normalized to data. Ratios of theory to data are shown in the lower panel. The normalization factor for Sherpa 1.4.1 is quoted in the plot legend.
(a)

(b)
(c) Differential cross sections as a function of the jet transverse momentum for the (a) leading jet, (b) subleading jet and (c) third leading jet in the -jet category, compared with theoretical predictions from Sherpa 2.2.14, and to LO Sherpa 1.4.1 at absolute normalization. Ratios of theory to data are shown in the lower panel. Arrows indicate data points outside the displayed ratio range.
Figure 17.
Figure 5 shows the differential cross sections as a function of the diphoton observables for events with zero jets satisfying the analysis selection, compared with Sherpa 1.4.1 and to the absolute Sherpa 2.2.14 prediction. In the exclusive 0-jet category, the high- and large- regions are kinematically suppressed, as events with large diphoton boost or strong back-to-back asymmetry tend to produce accompanying jets; this is reflected in the increased measurement uncertainties in those bins. Sherpa 2.2.14 describes the spectrum well across the full measured range, with ratios within 10% of data at all values. The distribution is well described at low and moderate values ( GeV), but the prediction overshoots in the high- region where the data uncertainties are large. For , the description is good for , with a progressive undershoot at higher values. For , good agreement is found for rad, while Sherpa 2.2.14 significantly underestimates the data at small separations ( rad). The normalized Sherpa 1.4.1 prediction describes the shape of low and low regions well. The shape of the distribution is well described up to 0.8, where it starts to deviate. The -separation of the two photons is described well by Sherpa 1.4.1, except for the region around .
In Figure 6, measured cross sections for the exclusive category are shown compared with GoSam NLO and Sherpa 2.2.14 predictions for the photon–jet separation and leading jet ; shape comparisons to Sherpa 1.4.1 are also shown. The cross sections are measured differentially in the photon–jet separation , showing a poor description by GoSam for the leading photon at low and high-, but a good
Figure 6. Differential cross sections in the category as a function of (a) , (b) and (c) , compared with GoSam NLO and Sherpa 2.2.14 predictions, and to LO Sherpa 1.4.1 predictions normalized to data. Ratios of theory to data are shown in the lower panel. Arrows indicate data points outside the displayed ratio range. Bins where the GoSam NLO scale uncertainty exceeds the central prediction are indicated by open markers without uncertainty bands. The normalization factor for Sherpa 1.4.1 is quoted in the plot legend.
description of the peak. For the subleading photon, the GoSam description is best for , after that, it starts to deviate by more than 10% and up to 50% at high-. The leading jet transverse momentum is described by GoSam within uncertainties for GeV. Sherpa 2.2.14 provides a good description of both photon–jet separation observables over the bulk of the distribution. For , the prediction matches the measured peak position and falls within approximately 15% of data for . A similar level of agreement is found for up to . At the largest separation values, both observables are slightly underestimated, consistent with the behavior seen in the GoSam NLO prediction. The leading jet is described well across the full measured range. Sherpa 1.4.1 performs well in describing the shape of and , except for the last bin of . The shape of the observable is very well described by Sherpa 1.4.1.
The diphoton observables for the category are shown in Figure 7. The GoSam distribution shows a feature at around 25 GeV, which is not observed in data. This can be explained as follows. The diphoton system needs to recoil against the one jet in the event in the Born contributions, with the starting at 25 GeV. This is no longer true for real contributions, where can start from 0 GeV. Adding up the contributions, the distribution displays a dip at the threshold. A similar feature is observed in Figure 5 of Ref. [53]. Sherpa 2.2.14 provides a good description of the diphoton observables in the category, except at high and small . The distribution is well described across the full range, at a level comparable to the GoSam NLO prediction. The distribution is well reproduced without the low- threshold feature present in the fixed-order calculation. The distribution is well described above about 1.25 rad, including the intermediate-separation region where GoSam shows deviations from data, while at smaller separations the prediction lies 15–20% below the data, within its scale uncertainty. For , the agreement is good for , with a moderate undershoot at higher values that is common to all predictions. Sherpa 1.4.1 fails to describe the shape of , and .
Figure 7. Differential cross sections as a function of (a) , (b) , (c) and (d) for the category, compared with GoSam NLO and Sherpa 2.2.14 predictions, and to LO Sherpa 1.4.1 predictions normalized to data. Ratios of theory to data are shown in the lower panel. Arrows indicate data points outside the displayed ratio range. Bins where the GoSam NLO scale uncertainty exceeds the central prediction are indicated by open markers without uncertainty bands. The normalization factor for Sherpa 1.4.1 is quoted in the plot legend.
For the category, the comparison of the measured data to GoSam and BlackHat predictions for the dijet kinematic observables is shown in Figure 8. GoSam and BlackHat give a similar description of the distribution: both lie slightly below the data at low masses, and the deficit grows rapidly with , from about 30–40% at 300–500 GeV to a factor of several in the highest-mass bins, where both calculations also suffer from large statistical and scale uncertainties. The separation of jets in rapidity is well described up to 2.5, where both GoSam and BlackHat start to deviate. GoSam and BlackHat describe the distribution well below 1.8, above that, they are both below data but mostly within uncertainties. GoSam and BlackHat offer a similar description of , both underestimate data below 90 GeV and describe it well above that, but with data uncertainty rising from 10% up to 200% at high-. Sherpa 2.2.14 provides a good description of the dijet observables, with the exception of . The distribution is described better than by the fixed-order calculations and agrees with the data within uncertainties up to about 250 GeV, but the prediction falls increasingly below the data at higher masses, by about 50% at 600–800 GeV and about 70% above 1 TeV. The distribution is well described across the full range. For , good agreement is found up to , beyond which the prediction falls well below data in a region also poorly described by the fixed-order calculations. The observable is very well described throughout. Sherpa 1.4.1, once normalized to the data, is the only prediction that follows the shape over the full range, within about 20%; it also describes the low- region and well within data uncertainties, and offers the best LO shape description for .
Figure 8. Differential cross sections in the category as a function of (a) , (b) , (c) and (d) , compared with theoretical predictions from GoSam NLO, BlackHat NLO and Sherpa 2.2.14, and to LO Sherpa 1.4.1 predictions normalized to data. Ratios of theory to data are shown in the lower panel. Arrows indicate data points outside the displayed ratio range. Bins where the GoSam or BlackHat NLO scale uncertainty exceeds the central prediction are indicated by open markers without uncertainty bands. The normalization factor for Sherpa 1.4.1 is quoted in the plot legend.
The four diphoton observables in the category are well described by both fixed order calculations, as seen in Figure 9. Sherpa 2.2.14 provides a good description of all diphoton observables in the
Figure 9. Differential cross sections as a function of (a) , (b) , (c) and (d) for the category, compared with GoSam NLO and Sherpa 2.2.14 predictions, and to LO Sherpa 1.4.1 predictions normalized to data. Ratios of theory to data are shown in the lower panel. Arrows indicate data points outside the displayed ratio range. Bins where the GoSam or BlackHat NLO scale uncertainty exceeds the central prediction are indicated by open markers without uncertainty bands. The normalization factor for Sherpa 1.4.1 is quoted in the plot legend.
category, broadly comparable to the fixed-order predictions. The shape is well reproduced from threshold to high masses. For , the prediction agrees well with data for GeV and remains consistent at higher values within the larger uncertainties. The distribution is described well for , with a modest undershoot at higher values that is also present in GoSam. For , a reasonable description is found across the full range, with a slight undershoot at intermediate separations. Sherpa 1.4.1 fails to describe the shape of , and , and provides an adequate description of .
The () distribution is shown compared with a GoSam prediction, a Sherpa 2.2.14 prediction, and Sherpa 1.4.1 in Figure 10. As noted in § 8, the GoSam prediction for this observable is computed at leading-order accuracy. Sherpa 2.2.14 provides a good description of the distribution across the bulk of the measured range (ratio within 15% of data for rad). Sherpa 1.4.1 describes the shape of very well. GoSam gives a good description up to , where it starts to deviate and the last bin is negative. This behavior is caused by a function in the calculation, used to describe the maximum azimuthal separation of the diphoton and dijet systems set at . For a smoother and more accurate prediction, NLO computation of would be necessary [54].
Figure 10. Differential cross section as a function of the observable for the category compared with theoretical predictions from GoSam LO and Sherpa 2.2.14, and to LO Sherpa 1.4.1 predictions normalized to data. Ratios of theory to data are shown in the lower panel. Arrows indicate data points outside the displayed ratio range. Bins where the GoSam scale uncertainty exceeds the central prediction are indicated by open markers without uncertainty bands. The normalization factor for Sherpa 1.4.1 is quoted in the plot legend.
The distribution for the inclusive and categories is shown in Figure 11. The qualitative features seen in the exclusive category are preserved: Sherpa 2.2.14 provides a good description across the bulk of the distribution in both categories, and Sherpa 1.4.1 gives a good shape description throughout. The low- region, where the diphoton and dijet systems are nearly collinear, is sensitive to multiple parton interactions and underlying event; all predictions tend to underestimate data in this region, with the deviation most pronounced in the category, consistent with the expected increase in MPI sensitivity at higher jet multiplicities.
Figure 11. Unfolded differential cross section as a function of the observable for the (a) and (b) categories, compared with Sherpa 2.2.14 predictions and to LO Sherpa 1.4.1 predictions. Ratios of theory to data are shown in the lower panel. For the category, Sherpa 1.4.1 is normalized to data; the normalization factor is quoted in the plot legend. For the category, Sherpa 1.4.1 is shown at absolute normalization since its predicted cross section matches the data. Arrows indicate data points outside the displayed ratio range.
In Figure 12, the photon–jet separation is very well described by both GoSam and BlackHat, except for the region of , where they both underestimate the data. Sherpa 2.2.14 provides a good description of all four photon–jet separation observables in the category, remaining within approximately 15% of data across the bulk of the distribution. In the highest separation bin, the prediction falls slightly below data, consistent with the behavior of the fixed-order calculations. Sherpa 1.4.1 provides a good shape description of the observables in the category.
Figure 12. Differential cross sections as a function of the -separation for the leading jet and (a) the leading photon, (b) subleading photon and for the subleading jet and (c) the leading photon and (d) subleading photon in the category, compared with theoretical predictions from GoSam, BlackHat and Sherpa 2.2.14, and to LO Sherpa 1.4.1 predictions normalized to data. Ratios of theory to data are shown in the lower panel. Arrows indicate data points outside the displayed ratio range. Bins where the GoSam or BlackHat NLO scale uncertainty exceeds the central prediction are indicated by open markers without uncertainty bands. The normalization factor for Sherpa 1.4.1 is quoted in the plot legend.
Both fixed-order NLO calculations provide a good description of the leading and subleading , shown in Figure 13(a) and 13(b), respectively. For the jet transverse momenta, Sherpa 2.2.14 describes the leading-jet reasonably well for GeV, with an increasing undershoot at higher values. For the subleading-jet , good agreement is found for GeV, after which the prediction falls significantly below data, consistent with the behavior of the fixed-order calculations. Sherpa 1.4.1 fails to describe the shapes of both jet transverse momenta.
Figure 13. Differential cross sections as a function of the (a) leading jet transverse momentum and (b) subleading jet transverse momentum for the category, compared with theoretical predictions from GoSam, BlackHat and Sherpa 2.2.14, and to LO Sherpa 1.4.1 predictions normalized to data. Ratios of theory to data are shown in the lower panel. Arrows indicate data points outside the displayed ratio range. Bins where the GoSam or BlackHat NLO scale uncertainty exceeds the central prediction are indicated by open markers without uncertainty bands. The normalization factor for Sherpa 1.4.1 is quoted in the plot legend.
Figure 14–Figure 17 show a comparison of the measured distributions for the inclusive category to Sherpa 1.4.1, shown at absolute normalization since its integrated cross section matches the data in this category, and to the absolute Sherpa 2.2.14 prediction. No fixed-order NLO predictions are available for this jet-multiplicity category.
Figure 14. Differential cross sections as a function of (a) , (b) , (c) and (d) for the category compared with theoretical predictions from Sherpa 2.2.14, and to LO Sherpa 1.4.1 at absolute normalization. Ratios of theory to data are shown in the lower panel. Arrows indicate data points outside the displayed ratio range.
Sherpa 2.2.14 provides the best overall description among the predictions in the category (Figure 14). The spectrum is well reproduced over the full measured range, and the distribution is well described throughout. For , good agreement is found for rad, while a moderate undershoot at small separations is observed, consistent with the behavior seen in lower jet-multiplicity categories. The distribution is reproduced at moderate values, with a progressive overestimate at high similar to that observed in the 0-jet category.
The dijet observables for the category are shown in Figure 15. Sherpa 2.2.14 provides a good description of the dijet system, consistent with the trends observed in the 2-jet category. The distribution is described within uncertainties over the full range, although the prediction lies 20–30% below the data above about 100 GeV. The and distributions are well reproduced across the measured range. For , the agreement deteriorates at large rapidity separations, consistent with the behavior seen in the 2-jet category.
Figure 15. Differential cross sections as a function of (a) , (b) , (c) and (d) for the category compared with theoretical predictions from Sherpa 2.2.14, and to LO Sherpa 1.4.1 at absolute normalization. Ratios of theory to data are shown in the lower panel. Arrows indicate data points outside the displayed ratio range.
The photon–jet separation observables for the category are shown in Figure 16. Sherpa 2.2.14 provides a good description of all four observables, broadly consistent with the level of agreement observed in the 2-jet category, with a slight underestimate at the largest separation values.
Figure 16. Differential cross sections as a function of the -separation for the leading jet and (a) the leading photon, (b) subleading photon, subleading jet and the (c) leading photon (d) subleading photon for the category, compared with theoretical predictions from Sherpa 2.2.14, and to LO Sherpa 1.4.1 at absolute normalization. Ratios of theory to data are shown in the lower panel. Arrows indicate data points outside the displayed ratio range.
The transverse momenta of the three leading jets are shown in Figure 17. Sherpa 2.2.14 provides a reasonable description of the leading and subleading jet distributions, with an increasing undershoot at
higher values consistent with the behavior seen in the 2-jet category. The third-jet distribution is also reasonably reproduced over the measured range.
Overall, Sherpa 1.4.1 describes the shapes well across most observables in the category.
The trends observed in the exclusive and categories persist for all inclusive categories: Sherpa 2.2.14 provides the best overall description, while Sherpa 1.4.1 provides a reasonable shape description across most variables.
Conclusion
A measurement of the production cross section of isolated photon pairs in association with jets in collisions at a center-of-mass energy TeV is presented. This measurement uses an integrated luminosity of 20.3 fb recorded in 2012 by the ATLAS detector at the LHC. Measurements in both inclusive and exclusive categories of the number of jets are presented. Cross sections are also measured differentially in up to sixteen kinematic and angular observables, depending on the jet category. The four main diphoton observables are presented: the diphoton invariant mass, , transverse momentum of the diphoton system , and angular observables and . Transverse momenta of up to the first three leading jets are also measured. The photon–jet separations between the photons and the leading and subleading jets are presented, as are the dijet observables , , and and the azimuthal separation between the diphoton and dijet systems . Relative statistical and systematic uncertainties related to jets become larger with increasing jet multiplicity, ranging from 3% for to 15% for , resulting in a total measurement uncertainty of 10% to 16% across jet categories.
Measured cross sections are compared with the Sherpa 1.4.1 LO MC generator interfaced with a parton shower, fixed-order NLO predictions (GoSam and BlackHat), and NLO-matched predictions from Sherpa 2.2.14. Integrated cross sections are generally underestimated by all generators in all categories (except Sherpa 1.4.1 in the -jet inclusive category, where the predicted cross section matches the measurement), even if the NLO predictions are globally compatible with the measurements within uncertainties. Overall, the NLO predictions provide a reasonable description of the data in most regions of the differential distributions. At the same time, significant discrepancies are observed for increasing jet multiplicity and especially for angular variables, attributable to the absence of higher-order terms in the calculations. Fixed-order NLO predictions from GoSam and BlackHat describe the data with similar accuracy, since the predictions were generated with similar inputs. In the category, the BlackHat prediction is slightly closer to the measured integrated value, but the differences between the two predictions in the differential distributions are small and both provide a good description. Sherpa 2.2.14, which provides NLO matrix elements for diphoton+0, 1 jet production, shows overall compatibility with the data within the scale uncertainties, with some underestimation of the integrated cross sections in the 0-jet (9%) and 2-jet (15%) exclusive categories. Differentially, Sherpa 2.2.14 provides the best overall description of the data across all jet categories and all observables, generally remaining within 15% of the data over the bulk of each distribution. Common limitations include a progressive undershoot at large values across all categories, a slight deficit at the highest jet transverse momenta, an underestimate at large dijet rapidity separations in the two-jet category, and an underestimate at small separations observed consistently across multiple jet-multiplicity categories. The same trends are observed in the inclusive jet categories. These results provide a stringent test of perturbative QCD predictions for diphoton production in association with jets and constitute a benchmark for future improvements to NLO-matched event generators.
Acknowledgements
We thank CERN for the very successful operation of the LHC and its injectors, as well as the support staff at CERN and at our institutions worldwide without whom ATLAS could not be operated efficiently.
The crucial computing support from all WLCG partners is acknowledged gratefully, in particular from CERN, the ATLAS Tier-1 facilities at TRIUMF/SFU (Canada), NDGF (Denmark, Norway, Sweden), CC-IN2P3 (France), KIT/GridKA (Germany), INFN-CNAF (Italy), NL-T1 (Netherlands), PIC (Spain), RAL (UK) and BNL (USA), the Tier-2 facilities worldwide and large non-WLCG resource providers. Major contributors of computing resources are listed in Ref. [55].
We gratefully acknowledge the support of ANPCyT, Argentina; YerPhI, Armenia; ARC, Australia; BMWFW and FWF, Austria; ANAS, Azerbaijan; CNPq and FAPESP, Brazil; NSERC, NRC and CFI, Canada; CERN; CAS, MOST and NSFC, China; MSMT CR, MPO CR and VSC CR, Czech Republic; DNRF and DNSRC, Denmark; IN2P3-CNRS and CEA-DRF/IRFU, France; SRNSFG, Georgia; BMFTR, HGF and MPG, Germany; GSRT, Greece; RGC and Hong Kong SAR, China; ISF and Benoziyo Center, Israel; INFN, Italy; MEXT and JSPS, Japan; CNRST, Morocco; NWO, Netherlands; RCN, Norway; MNiSW and NCN, Poland; FCT, Portugal; MNE/IFA, Romania; MESTD, Serbia; MSSR, Slovakia; ARRS and MIZŠ, Slovenia; MINECO, Spain; SRC and Wallenberg Foundation, Sweden; SERI, SNSF and Cantons of Bern and Geneva, Switzerland; MOST, Taipei; TAEK, Turkey; STFC, United Kingdom; DOE and NSF, United States of America.
Individual groups and members have received support from BCKDF and CANARIE, Canada; UNCE SCI/013, Czech Republic; ERDF, European Union; ANR, France; DFG and AvH Foundation, Germany; BSF-NSF, Israel; CERCA and AGAUR programs from Generalitat de Catalunya, Spain; The Royal Society and Leverhulme Trust, United Kingdom.
In addition, individual members wish to acknowledge support from Chile: Agencia Nacional de Investigación y Desarrollo (Fondecyt 3180653); European Union: European Research Council (ERC - 617185); Spain: Ministry of Science and Innovation (RYC2022-038164-I); Sweden: Swedish Research Council (SRC - 2017-05160), Knut and Alice Wallenberg Foundation (KAW 2013.0149, KAW 2015.0193, KAW 2017.0100).
The ATLAS Collaboration
M. Aaboud, G. Aad, B. Abbott, B. Abeloos, D.K. Abhayasinghe, S.H. Abidi, O.S. AbouZeid, N.L. Abraham, H. Abramowicz, H. Abreu, Y. Abulaiti, B.S. Acharya, S. Adachi, C. Adam Bourdarios, L. Adamczyk, J. Adelman, M. Adersberger, A. Adiguzel, T. Adye, A.A. Affolder, Y. Afik, C. Agheorghiesei, J.A. Aguilar-Saavedra, F. Ahmadov, G. Aielli, S. Akatsuka, T.P.A. Åkesson, E. Akilli, A.V. Akimov, G.L. Alberghi, J. Albert, M.J. Alconada Verzini, S. Alderweireldt, M. Aleksa, I.N. Aleksandrov, C. Alexa, T. Alexopoulos, M. Alhroob, B. Ali, G. Alimonti, J. Alison, S.P. Alkire, C. Allaire, B.M.M. Allbrooke, B.W. Allen, P.P. Allport, A. Aloisio, A. Alonso, F. Alonso, C. Alpigiani, A.A. Alshehri, M.I. Alstaty, B. Alvarez Gonzalez, D. Álvarez Piqueras, M.G. Alviggi, B.T. Amadio, Y. Amaral Coutinho, L. Ambroz, C. Amelung, D. Amidei, S.P. Amor Dos Santos, S. Amoroso, C.S. Amrouche, C. Anastopoulos, L.S. Ancu, N. Andari, T. Andeen, C.F. Anders, J.K. Anders, K.J. Anderson, A. Andreazza, V. Andrei, C.R. Anelli, S. Angelidakis, I. Angelozzi, A. Angerami, A.V. Anisenkov, A. Annovi, C. Antel, M.T. Anthony, M. Antonelli, D.J.A. Antrim, F. Anulli, M. Aoki, L. Aperio Bella, G. Arabidze, Y. Arai, J.P. Araque, V. Araujo Ferraz, R. Araujo Pereira, A.T.H. Arce, R.E. Ardell, F.A. Arduh, J-F. Arguin, S. Argyropoulos, A.J. Armbruster, L.J. Armitage, A. Armstrong, O. Arnaez, H. Arnold, M. Arratia, O. Arslan, A. Artamonov, G. Artoni, S. Artz, S. Asai, N.A. Asbah, A. Ashkenazi, E.M. Asimakopoulou, L. Asquith, K. Assamagan, R. Astalos, R.J. Atkin, M. Atkinson, N.B. Atlay, K. Augsten, G. Avolio, R. Avramidou, B. Axen, M.K. Ayoub, G. Azuelos, A.E. Baas, M.J. Baca, H. Bachacou, K. Bachas, M. Backes, P. Bagnaia, H. Bahrasemani, A.J. Bailey, J.T. Baines, M. Bajic, C. Bakalis, O.K. Baker, P.J. Bakker, D. Bakshi Gupta, E.M. Baldin, P. Balek, F. Balli, W.K. Balunas, J. Balz, E. Banas, A. Bandyopadhyay, Sw. Banerjee, A.A.E. Bannoura, L. Barak, W.M. Barbe, E.L. Barberio, D. Barberis, M. Barbero, A. Barillari, M-S. Barisits, J. Barkeloo, T. Barklow, N. Barlow, R. Barnea, S.L. Barnes, B.M. Barnett, R.M. Barnett, Z. Barnovska-Blenessy, A. Baroncelli, G. Barone, A.J. Barr, L. Barranco Navarro, F. Barreiro, J. Barreiro Guimarães da Costa, R. Bartoldus, A.E. Barton, P. Bartos, A. Basalaev, A. Bassalat, R.L. Bates, S.J. Batista, S. Batlamous, J.R. Batley, M. Battaglia, M. Bauce, F. Bauer, K.T. Bauer, H.S. Bawa, J.B. Beacham, M.D. Beattie, T. Beau, P.H. Beauchemin, P. Bechtle, H.C. Beck, H.P. Beck, K. Becker, M. Becker, C. Becot, A. Beddall, A.J. Beddall, V.A. Bednyakov, M. Bedognetti, P. Bee, T.A. Beermann, M. Begalli, M. Begel, A. Behera, J.K. Behr, A.S. Bell, G. Bella, L. Bellagamba, A. Bellerive, M. Bellomo, P. Bellos, K. Belotskiy, N.L. Belyaev, O. Benary, D. Benchekroun, M. Bender, N. Benekos, Y. Benhammou, E. Benhar Nocchioli, J. Benitez, D.P. Benjamin, M. Benoit, J.R. Bensinger, S. Bentvelsen, L. Beresford, M. Beretta, D. Berge, E. Bergeaas Kuutmann, N. Berger, L.J. Bergsten, J. Beringer, S. Berlendis, N.R. Bernard, G. Bernardi, C. Bernius, F.U. Bernlochner, T. Berry, P. Berta, C. Bertella, G. Bertolli I.A. Bertram{sup}91, G.J. Besjes{sup}43, O. Bessidskaia Bylund{sup}47a,47b, M. Bessner{sup}48, N. Besson{sup}139, A. Bethani{sup}103, S. Bethke{sup}112, A. Betti{sup}25, A.J. Bevan{sup}94, J. Beyer{sup}112, R.M. Bianchi{sup}133, O. Biebel{sup}111, D. Biedermann{sup}20, R. Bielski{sup}103, K. Bierwagen{sup}102, N.V. Biesuz{sup}74a,74b, M. Biglietti{sup}77a, T.R.V. Billoud{sup}110, M. Bindi{sup}55, A. Bingul{sup}12d, C. Bini{sup}75a,75b, S. Biondi{sup}24b,24a, T. Bisanz{sup}55, C. Bittrich{sup}50, D.M. Bjergaard{sup}51, J.E. Black{sup}151, K.M. Black{sup}26, R.E. Blair{sup}6, T. Blazek{sup}29a, I. Bloch{sup}48, C. Blocker{sup}27, A. Blue{sup}59, U. Blumenschein{sup}94, S. Blunier{sup}141a, G.J. Bobbink{sup}118, V.S. Bobrovnikov{sup}38, S.S. Bocchetta{sup}99, A. Bocci{sup}51, D. Bogavac{sup}111, A.G. Bogdanchikov{sup}38, C. Bohm{sup}47a, V. Boisvert{sup}95, P. Bokan{sup}168, T. Bold{sup}85a, A.S. Boldyrev{sup}38, A.E. Bolz{sup}63b, M. Bomben{sup}131, M. Bona{sup}94, J.S. Bonilla{sup}127, M. Boonekamp{sup}139, A. Borisov{sup}38, G. Borissov{sup}91, J. Bortfeldt{sup}37, D. Bortoletto{sup}130, V. Bortolotto{sup}76a,65b,65c,76b, D. Boscherini{sup}24b, M. Bosman{sup}14, J.D. Bossio Sola{sup}31, K. Bouaouda{sup}36a, J. Boudreau{sup}133, E.V. Bouhova-Thacker{sup}91, D. Boumediene{sup}41, S.K. Boutle{sup}59, A. Boveia{sup}122, J. Boyd{sup}37, I.R. Boyko{sup}39, A.J. Bozson{sup}95, J. Bracinik{sup}22, N. Brahimi{sup}104, A. Brandt{sup}8, G. Brandt{sup}178, O. Brandt{sup}63a, F. Braren{sup}48, U. Bratzler{sup}162, B. Brau{sup}105, J.E. Brau{sup}127, K. Brendlinger{sup}48, A.J. Brennan{sup}107, L. Brenner{sup}48, R. Brenner{sup}168, S. Bressler{sup}176, B. Brickwedde{sup}102, D.L. Briglin{sup}22, D. Britton{sup}59, D. Britzger{sup}63b, I. Brock{sup}25, R. Brock{sup}109, G. Brooijmans{sup}42, T. Brooks{sup}95, W.K. Brooks{sup}141b, E. Brost{sup}119, J.H Broughton{sup}22, P.A. Bruckman de Renstrom{sup}86, D. Bruncko{sup}29b,*, A. Bruni{sup}24b, G. Bruni{sup}24b, L.S. Bruni{sup}118, S. Bruno{sup}76a,76b, B.H. Brunt{sup}33, M. Bruschi{sup}24b, N. Bruscino{sup}133, P. Bryant{sup}40, L. Bryngemark{sup}48, T. Buanes{sup}18, Q. Buat{sup}37, P. Buchholz{sup}149, A.G. Buckley{sup}59, I.A. Budagov{sup}39,*, M.K. Bugge{sup}129, F. Bührer{sup}54, O. Bulekov{sup}38, D. Bullock{sup}8, T.J. Burch{sup}119, S. Burdin{sup}92, C.D. Burgard{sup}118, A.M. Burger{sup}5, B. Burghgrave{sup}119, S. Burke{sup}138, I. Burmeister{sup}49, J.T.P. Burr{sup}130, D. Büscher{sup}54, V. Büscher{sup}102, E. Buschmann{sup}55, P.J. Bussey{sup}59, J.M. Butler{sup}26, C.M. Buttar{sup}59, J.M. Butterworth{sup}96, W. Buttinger{sup}37, A. Buzatu{sup}156, A.R. Buzykaev{sup}38, G. Cabras{sup}24b,24a, S. Cabrera Urbán{sup}170, D. Caforio{sup}136, H. Cai{sup}169, V.M.M. Cairo{sup}2, O. Cakir{sup}4a, N. Calace{sup}56, P. Calafiura{sup}19a, A. Calandri{sup}104, G. Calderini{sup}131, P. Calfayan{sup}68, G. Callea{sup}44b,44a, L.P. Caloba{sup}82b, S. Calvente Lopez{sup}101, D. Calvet{sup}41, S. Calvet{sup}41, T.P. Calvet{sup}153, M. Calvetti{sup}74a,74b, R. Camacho Toro{sup}131, S. Camarda{sup}37, P. Camarri{sup}76a,76b, D. Cameron{sup}129, R. Caminal Armadans{sup}105, C. Camincher{sup}37, S. Campana{sup}37, M. Campanelli{sup}96, A. Camplan{sup}43, A. Campoverde{sup}149, V. Canale{sup}72a,72b, M. Cano Bret{sup}146a, J. Cantero{sup}125, T. Cao{sup}159, Y. Cao{sup}169, M.D.M. Capeans Garrido{sup}37, I. Caprini{sup}28b, M. Caprini{sup}28b,*, M. Capua{sup}44b,44a, R.M. Carbone{sup}42, R. Cardarelli{sup}76a, F. Cardillo{sup}54, I. Carli{sup}137, T. Carli{sup}37, G. Carlino{sup}72a, B.T. Carlson{sup}133, L. Carminati{sup}71a,71b, R.M.D. Carney{sup}47a,47b, S. Caron{sup}117, E. Carquin{sup}141b, S. Carrà{sup}71a,71b, G.D. Carrillo-Montoya{sup}37, D. Casadei{sup}34b, M.P. Casado{sup}14,g, A.F. Casha{sup}163, M. Casolino{sup}14, D.W. Casper{sup}167, R. Castelijn{sup}118, F.L. Castillo{sup}170, V. Castillo Gimenez{sup}170, N.F. Castro{sup}134a,134e, A. Catinaccio{sup}37, J.R. Catmore{sup}129, A. Cattai{sup}37, J. Caudron{sup}25, V. Cavaliere{sup}30, E. Cavallaro{sup}14, D. Cavalli{sup}71a, M. Cavalli-Sforza{sup}114, V. Cavassini{sup}14, E. Celebi{sup}12b, F. Ceradini{sup}77a,77b, L. Cerda Alberich{sup}170, A.S. Cerqueira{sup}82a, A. Cerri{sup}154, L. Cerrito{sup}76a,76b, F. Cerutti{sup}19a, A. Cervelli{sup}24b, S.A. Cetin{sup}12b, A. Chafaq{sup}36a, D. Chakraborty{sup}119, S.K. Chan{sup}61, W.S. Chan{sup}118, Y.L. Chan{sup}65a, P. Chang{sup}169, J.D. Chapman{sup}33, D.G. Charlton{sup}22, C.C. Chau{sup}35, C.A. Chavez Barajas{sup}154, S. Che{sup}122, A. Chegwideen{sup}109, S. Chekanov{sup}6, S.V. Chekulaev{sup}164a, G.A. Chelkov{sup}39, M.A. Chelstowska{sup}37, C. Chen{sup}62, C.H. Chen{sup}81, H. Chen{sup}30, J. Chen{sup}62, J. Chen{sup}42, S. Chen{sup}132, S.J. Chen{sup}115a, X. Chen{sup}16,an, Y. Chen{sup}84, Y-H. Chen{sup}48, H.C. Cheng{sup}108, H.J. Cheng{sup}15, A. Cheplakov{sup}39, E. Cheremushkina{sup}38, R. Cherkaoui El Moursli{sup}36d, E. Cheu{sup}7, K. Cheung{sup}66, L. Chevalier{sup}139, V. Chiarelli{sup}53, G. Chiarelli{sup}74a, G. Chiodini{sup}70a, A.S. Chisholm{sup}37, A. Chitan{sup}28b, C. Chiu{sup}161, Y.H. Chiu{sup}172, M.V. Chizhov{sup}39, K. Choi{sup}68, A.R. Chomont{sup}67, S. Chouridou{sup}160, E.Y.S. Chow{sup}118, V. Christodoulou{sup}96, M.C. Chu{sup}65a, J. Chudoba{sup}135, A.J. Chuinard{sup}106, J.J. Chwastowski{sup}86 L. Chytka, D. Cinca , V. Cindro , I.A. Cioară , A. Ciocio , F. Cirotto , Z.H. Citron , M. Citterio , A. Clark , M.R. Clark , P.J. Clark , C. Clement , Y. Coadou , M. Cobal , A. Coccaro , J. Cochran , A.E.C. Coimbra , L. Colasurdo , B. Cole , A.P. Colijn, J. Collot , P. Conde Muiño , E. Coniavitis , S.H. Connell , I.A. Connelly , S. Constantinescu , F. Conventi , A.M. Cooper-Sarkar , F. Cormier , K.J.R. Cormier, M. Corradi , E.E. Corrigan , F. Corriveau , M.J. Costa , D. Costanzo , G. Cottin , G. Cowan , B.E. Cox, J. Crane , K. Cranmer , S.J. Crawley, R.A. Creager , G. Cree, S. Crépé-Renaudin , F. Crescioli , M. Cristinziani , V. Croft , G. Crosetti , A. Cueto , T. Cuhadar Donszelmann , A.R. Cukierman , M. Curatolo , J. Cúth, S. Czekierda , P. Czodrowski , M.J. Da Cunha Sargedas De Sousa , C. Da Via , W. Dabrowski , T. Dado , S. Dahbi , T. Dai , F. Dallaire, C. Dallapiccola , M. Dam , G. D’amen , J. Damp , J.R. Dandoy , M.F. Daneri , N.P. Dang , N.S. Dann , M. Danninger , V. Dao , G. Darbo , O. Dartsi, A. Dattagupta , T. Daubney, S. D’Auria , W. Davey , C. David , T. Davidek , D.R. Davis , E. Dawe , I. Dawson , K. De , R. De Asmundis , A. De Benedetti, S. De Castro , S. De Cecco , N. De Groot , P. de Jong , H. De la Torre , F. De Lorenzi, A. De Maria , D. De Pedis , A. De Salvo , U. De Sanctis , A. De Santo , K. De Vasconcelos Corga, J.B. De Vivie De Regie , C. Debenedetti , D.V. Dedovich, N. Dehghanian, A.M. Deiana , M. Del Gaudio , J. Del Peso , D. Delgove , F. Deliot , C.M. Delitzsch , M. Della Pietra , D. Della Volpe , A. Dell’Acqua , L. Dell’Asta , M. Delmastro , C. Delporte, P.A. Delsart , D.A. DeMarco , S. Demers , M. Demichev , S.P. Denisov , D. Denysiuk , L. D’Eramo , D. Derendarz , J.E. Derkaoui , F. Derue , P. Dervan , K. Desch , C. Deterre , K. Dette , M.R. Devesa, P.O. Deviveiros , A. Dewhurst , S. Dhaliwal, F.A. Di Bello , A. Di Ciaccio , L. Di Ciaccio , W.K. Di Clemente , C. Di Donato , A. Di Girolamo , B. Di Micco , R. Di Nardo , A. Di Simone , R. Di Sipio , D. Di Valentino , C. Diaconu , M. Diamond, F.A. Dias , T. Dias Do Vale , M.A. Diaz , J. Dickinson , E.B. Diehl , J. Dietrich , S. Díez Cornell , A. Dimitrievska , J. Dingfelder , F. Dittus , F. Djama , T. Djobava , J.I. Djvsland , M.A.B. Do Vale , M. Dobre , D. Dodsworth , C. Doglioni , J. Dolejsi , Z. Dolezal , M. Donadelli , J. Donini , A. D’Onofrio , M. D’Onofrio , J. Dopke , A. Doria , M.T. Dova , A.T. Doyle , E. Drechsler , E. Dreyer , T. Dreyer , M. Dris, Y. Du , J. Duarte-Campderros , F. Dubinin , M. Dubovsky , A. Dubreuil , E. Duchovni , G. Duckeck , A. Ducourthial , O.A. Ducu , D. Duda , A. Dudarov , A.C. Dudder , E.M. Duffield , L. Duflot , M. Dührssen , C. Dül̲sen , M. Dumancic , A.E. Dumitriu , A. K. Duncam , M. Dunford , A. Duperrin , H. Duran Yildiz , M. Düren , A. Durgli̲shvili , D. Duschinger, B. Dutta , M. Dyndal , S. Dysch , B.S. Dziedzic , C. Eckardt, K.M. Eckert, R.C. Edgar, T. Eifert , G. Eigen , K. Einsweiler , T. Ekelof , M. El Kacimi, R. El Kosseifi , V. Ellajosyula , M. Ellert , F. Ellinghaus , A.A. Elliot , N. Ellis , J. Elmsheuser , M. Elsing , D. Emeliyanov , Y. Enari , J.S. Ennis , M.B. Epland , J. Erdmann , A. Ereditato , S. Errede , M. Escalier , C. Escobar , B. Esposito , O. Estrada Pastor , A.I. Etienvre , E. Etzion , H. Evans , A. Ezhilov , M. Ezzi , F. Fabbri , L. Fabbri , V. Fabiani , G. Facini , R.M. Faisca Rodrigues Pereira , R.M. Fakhrutdinov , S. Falciano , P.J. Falke , S. Falke , J. Faltova , Y. Fang , M. Fanti , A. Farbin , A. Farilla , E.M. Farina , T. Farooque , S. Farrell , S.M. Farrington 174, P. Farthouat 37, F. Fassi 36d, P. Fassnacht 37, D. Fassouliotis 9 M. Faucci Giannelli 52, A. Favareto 57b,57a, W.J. Fawcett 56, L. Fayard 67, O.L. Fedin 38,a W. Fedorko 171, M. Feickert 45, S. Feigl 129, L. Feligioni 104, C. Feng 145, E.J. Feng 37, M. Feng 51, M.J. Fenton 59, A.B. Fenyuk 38, L. Feremenga 8, J. Ferrando 48, A. Ferrari 168, P. Ferrari 118, R. Ferrari 73a, D.E. Ferreira de Lima 63b, A. Ferrer 170,, D. Ferrere 56, C. Ferretti 108, F. Fiedler 102, A. Filipčič 93, F. Filthaut 117, K.D. Finelli 26, M.C.N. Fiolhais 134a,134c,b, L. Fiorini 170, C. Fischer 14, W.C. Fisher 109, N. Flaschel 48, I. Fleck 149, P. Fleischmann 108, R.R.M. Fletcher 132, T. Flick 178, B.M. Flierl 111, L. Flores 132 L.R. Flores Castillo 65a, N. Fomin 18, G.T. Forcolin 103, A. Formica 139, F.A. Förster 14 A.C. Forti 103, A.G. Foster 22, D. Fournier 67, H. Fox 91, S. Fracchia 147, P. Francavilla 74a,74b, M. Franchini 24b,24a, S. Franchino 63a, D. Francis 37, L. Franconi 129, M. Franklin 61, M. Frate 167, M. Fraternali 73a,73b, D. Freeborn 96, S.M. Fressard-Batraneanu 37, B. Freund 110, W.S. Freund 82b, D. Froidevaux 37, J.A. Frost 130, C. Fukunaga 162, T. Fusayasu 113, J. Fuster 170, O. Gabizon 158, A. Gabrielli 24b,24a, A. Gabrielli 19a, G.P. Gach 85a, S. Gadatsch 56, P. Gadow 112, G. Gagliardi 57b,57a, L.G. Gagnon 110, C. Galea 28b, B. Galhardo 134a,134c, E.J. Gallas 130, B.J. Gallop 138, P. Gallus 136, G. Galster 43, R. Gamboa Goni 94, K.K. Gan 122, S. Ganguly 176, Y. Gao 92, Y.S. Gao 32,o, C. García 170, J.E. García Navarro 170, J.A. García Pascual 15, M. Garcia-Sciveres 19a, R.W. Gardner 40, V. Garonne 129, K. Gasnikova 48, A. Gaudiello 57b,57a, G. Gaudio 73a, I.L. Gavrilenko 38, A. Gavrilyuk 38, C. Gay 171, G. Gaycken 25, E.N. Gazis 10 C.N.P. Gee 138, J. Geisen 55, M. Geisen 102, M.P. Geisler 63a, K. Gellerstedt 47a,47b, C. Gemme 57b, M.H. Genest 60, C. Geng 108, S. Gentile 75a,75b, C. Gentsos 160, S. George 95, D. Gerbaudo 14, G. Gessner 49, S. Ghasemi 149, M. Ghasemi Bostanabad 172, B. Giacobbe 24b, S. Giagu 75a,75b, N. Giangiacomi 24b,24a, P. Giannetti 74a,, S.M. Gibson 95, M. Gignac 140, D. Gillberg 35, G. Gilles 178, D.M. Gingrich 3,ao, M.P. Giordani 69a,69c, F.M. Giorgi 24b, P.F. Giraud 139, P. Giromini 61, G. Giugliarelli 69a,69c, D. Giugni 71a, F. Giuli 130, M. Giulini 63b, S. Gkaitatzis 160, I. Gkialas 9,j, E.L. Gkougkousis 14, P. Gkountoumis 10, L.K. Gladilin 38, C. Glasman 101, J. Glatzer 14, P.C.F. Glaysher 48, A. Glazov 48, M. Goblirsch-Kolb 27, J. Godlewski 86, S. Goldfarb 107, T. Golling 56, D. Golubkov 38, A. Gomez-Cornejo 134a,134b, R. Goncalves Gama 82a, R. Gonçalo 134a, G. Gonella 54, L. Gonella 22, A. Gongadze 39, F. Gonnella 22, J.L. Gonski 61, S. González de la Hoz 170, S. Gonzalez-Sevilla 56, L. Goossens 37, P.A. Gorbounov 38, B. Gorini 37, E. Gorini 70a,70b, A. Gorišek 93, A.T. Goshaw 51, C. Gössling 49, M.I. Gostkin 39, C.A. Gottardo 25, C.R. Goudet 67, D. Goujdamı 36b, A.G. Goussiou 144, N. Govender 34b,c, C. Goy 5, E. Gozani 158, I. Grabowska-Bold 85a, P.O.J. Gradin 168, E.C. Graham 92, J. Gramling 167, E. Gramstad 129, S. Grancagnolo 20, V. Gratchev 38,*, P.M. Gravila 28f, C. Gray 59, H.M. Gray 19a, Z.D. Greenwood 97, C. Grefe 25, K. Gregersen 96, I.M. Greig 48, P. Grenier 151, K. Grevtsov 48, J. Griffiths 8, A.A. Grillo 140, K. Grimm 32,n, S. Grinstein 14,z, Ph. Gris 41, J.-F. Grivaz 67, S. Groh 102, E. Gross 176, J. Grosse-Knetter 55, G.C. Grossi 97, Z.J. Grout 96, C. Grud 108, A. Grummer 116, L. Guan 108, W. Guan 177, J. Guenther 37, A. Guerguichon 67, F. Guescini 164a, R. Gugel 54, B. Gui 122, T. Guillemin 5, S. Guindon 37, U. Gul 59, C. Gumpert 37, J. Guo 146a, W. Guo 108, Y. Guo 62,s, Z. Guo 104, R. Gupta 45, S. Gurbuz 12c, G. Gustavino 124, B.J. Gutelman 158, P. Gutierrez 124, C. Gutschow 96, C. Guyot 139, M.P. Guzik 85a, C. Gwenlan 130, C.B. Gwilliam 92, A. Haas 120, C. Haber 19a, H.K. Hadvavand 8, N. Haddad 5, A. Hadef 62, S. Hageböck 25, M. Hagihara 165, M. Haleem 173, J. Haley 125, G. Halladjian 109, G.D. Hallewell 104, K. Hamacher 178, P. Hamal 126, K. Hamano 172, A. Hamilton 34a, G.N. Hamity 147, K. Han 62,y, L. Han 62, S. Han 15, K. Hanagaki 83, M. Hance 140, D.M. Handl 111, B. Haney 132, R. Hankache 131, P. Hanke 63a, E. Hansen 99, J.B. Hansen 43, J.D. Hansen 43, M.C. Hansen 25, P.H. Hansen 43, E.C. Hanson ¹⁰³, K. Hara ¹⁶⁵, A.S. Hard ¹⁷⁷, T. Harenberg ¹⁷⁸, S. Harkusha ³⁸, P.F. Harrison ¹⁷⁴, N.M. Hartmann ¹¹¹, Y. Hasegawa ¹⁴⁸, A. Hasib ⁵², S. Hassani ¹³⁹, S. Haug ²¹, R. Hauser ¹⁰⁹, L. Hauswald⁵⁰, L.B. Havener ⁴², M. Havranek ¹³⁶, C.M. Hawkes ²², R.J. Hawkings ³⁷, D. Hayden ¹⁰⁹, C. Hayes ¹⁵³, C.P. Hays ¹³⁰, J.M. Hays ⁹⁴, H.S. Hayward ⁹², S.J. Haywood ¹³⁸, M.P. Heath ⁵², V. Hedberg ⁹⁹, L. Heelan ⁸, S. Heer ²⁵, K.K. Heidegger ⁵⁴, J. Heilman ³⁵, S. Heim ⁴⁸, T. Heim ¹⁹a, B. Heinemann ⁴⁸,ak, J.J. Heinrich ¹¹¹, L. Heinrich ¹²⁰, C. Heinz⁵⁸, J. Hejbal ¹³⁵, L. Helary ³⁷, A. Held ¹⁷¹, S. Hellesund ¹²⁹, S. Hellman ⁴⁷a,⁴⁷b, C. Helsens ³⁷, R.C.W. Henderson⁹¹, Y. Heng¹⁷⁷, S. Henkelmann ¹⁷¹, A.M. Henriques Correia³⁷, G.H. Herbert²⁰, H. Herde ²⁷, V. Herget ¹⁷³, Y. Hernández Jiménez ³⁴c, H. Herr¹⁰², G. Herten ⁵⁴, R. Hertenberger ¹¹¹, L. Hervas ³⁷, G.G. Hesketh ⁹⁶, N.P. Hessey ¹⁶⁴a, J.W. Hetherly⁴⁵, S. Higashino ⁸³, E. Higón-Rodriguez ¹⁷⁰, K. Hildebrand⁴⁰, J.C. Hill ³³, K.K. Hill ³⁰, K.H. Hiller⁴⁸, S.J. Hillier ²², M. Hils ⁵⁰, I. Hinchliffe ¹⁹a, M. Hirose ¹²⁸, D. Hirschbuehl ¹⁷⁸, B. Hiti ⁹³, O. Hladik¹³⁵, D.R. Hlaluku ³⁴c, X. Hoad ⁵², J. Hobbs ¹⁵³, N. Hod ¹⁶⁴a, M.C. Hodgkinson ¹⁴⁷, A. Hoecker ³⁷, M.R. Hoeferkamp¹¹⁶, F. Hoenig¹¹¹, D. Hohn ²⁵, D. Hohov⁶⁷, T.R. Holmes ⁴⁰, M. Holzbock ¹¹¹, M. Homann⁴⁹, S. Honda ¹⁶⁵, T. Honda⁸³, T.M. Hong ¹³³, A. Hönle ¹¹², B.H. Hooberman ¹⁶⁹, W.H. Hopkins ¹²⁷, Y. Horii ¹¹⁴, P. Horn ⁵⁰, A.J. Horton ¹⁵⁰, L.A. Horyn ⁴⁰, J-Y. Hostachy⁶⁰, A. Hostiuc¹⁴⁴, S. Hou ¹⁵⁶, A. Hoummada³⁶a, J. Howarth ¹⁰³, J. Hoya ⁹⁰, M. Hrabovsky ¹²⁶, J. Hrdinka³⁷, I. Hristova ²⁰, J. Hrivnac⁶⁷, A. Hrynevich ³⁸, T. Hryn’ova ⁵, P.J. Hsu ⁶⁶, S.-C. Hsu ¹⁴⁴, Q. Hu ³⁰, S. Hu ¹⁴⁶a, Y. Huang ¹⁵, Z. Hubacek ¹³⁶, F. Hubaut ¹⁰⁴, M. Huebner ²⁵, F. Huegging ²⁵, T.B. Huffman ¹³⁰, E.W. Hughes⁴², M. Huhtinen ³⁷, R.F.H. Hunter ³⁵, P. Huo¹⁵³, A.M. Hupe³⁵, N. Huseynov ³⁹,ae, J. Huston ¹⁰⁹, J. Huth ⁶¹, R. Hyneman ¹⁰⁸, G. Iacobucci ⁵⁶, G. Iakovidis ³⁰, I. Ibragimov ¹⁴⁹, L. Iconomidou-Fayard ⁶⁷, Z. Idrissi³⁶d, P. Iengo ³⁷, R. Ignazzi⁴³, O. Igonkina ¹¹⁸,aa,, R. Iguchi ¹⁶¹, T. Iizawa ⁵⁶, Y. Ikegami ⁸³, M. Ikeno ⁸³, N. Ilic ¹⁵¹, F. Iltzsche⁵⁰, G. Introzzi ⁷³a,⁷³b, M. Iodice ⁷⁷a, K. Iordanidou ⁴², V. Ippolito ⁷⁵a,⁷⁵b, M.F. Isacson ¹⁶⁸, N. Ishijima¹²⁸, M. Ishino ¹⁶¹, M. Ishitsuka¹⁴³, C. Issever ¹³⁰, S. Istin ¹²c,ai, F. Ito¹⁶⁵, J.M. Iturbe Ponce ⁶⁵a, R. Iuppa ⁷⁸a,⁷⁸b, A. Ivina ¹⁷⁶, H. Iwasaki ⁸³, J.M. Izen ⁴⁶, V. Izzo ⁷²a, S. Jabbar³, P. Jacka ¹³⁵, P. Jackson ¹, R.M. Jacobs ²⁵, V. Jain ², G. Jäkel ¹⁷⁸, K.B. Jacobs ¹⁰², K. Jakob ⁵⁴, S. Jakobsen ⁷⁹, T. Jakoubek ¹³⁵, D.O. Jamin ¹²⁵, D.K. Jana⁹⁷, R. Jansky ⁵⁶, J. Janssen ²⁵, M. Janus ⁵⁵, P.A. Janus ⁸⁵a, G. Jarlskog ⁹⁹, N. Javadov ³⁹,ae, T. Javůrek ⁵⁴, M. Javurkova ⁵⁴, F. Jeanneau ¹³⁹, L. Jeanty ¹⁹a, J. Jejelava ¹⁵⁷a,af, A. Jelinskas ¹⁷⁴, P. Jenni ⁵⁴,d, J. Jeong ⁴⁸, C. Jeske¹⁷⁴, S. Jézéquel ⁵, H. Ji¹⁷⁷, J. Jia ¹⁵³, H. Jiang⁸¹, Y. Jiang⁶², Z. Jiang¹⁵¹, S. Jiggins ⁵⁴, F.A. Jimenez Morales⁴¹, J. Jimenez Pena ¹⁷⁰, S. Jin ¹¹⁵a, A. Jinaru ²⁸b, O. Jinnouchi ¹⁴³, H. Jivan ³⁴c, P. Johansson ¹⁴⁷, K.A. Johns⁷, C.A. Johnson ⁶⁸, W.J. Johnson ¹⁴⁴, K. Jon-And ⁴⁷a,⁴⁷b, R.W.L. Jones ¹⁵⁴, S.D. Jones ¹⁵⁴, S. Jones ⁷, T.J. Jones ⁹², J. Jongmanns ⁶³a, P.M. Jorge ¹³⁴a,¹³⁴b, J. Jovicevic ¹⁶⁴a, X. Ju ¹⁷⁷, J.J. Jungeburg ¹¹², A. Juste Rozas ¹⁴,z, A. Kaczmarska ⁸⁶, M. Kado ⁶⁷, H. Kagan ¹²², M. Kagan ¹⁵¹, T. Kaji ¹⁷⁵, E. Kakonomiz ¹⁵⁸, C.W. Kalderon ⁹⁹, A. Kaluza¹⁰², S. Kama ⁴⁵, A. Kamenschchikov ³⁸, L. Kanjir ⁹³, Y. Kano ¹⁶¹, V.A. Kantserov ³⁸, J. Kanzaki ⁸³, B. Kaplan ¹²⁰, L.S. Kaplan ¹⁷⁷, D. Kar ³⁴c,, M.J. Kareem ¹⁶⁴b, S.N. Karpov ³⁹, Z.M. Karpova ³⁹, V. Kartvelishvili ⁹¹, A.N. Karyukhin ³⁸, K. Kasahara ¹⁶⁵, L. Kashif ¹⁷⁷, R.D. Kass¹²², A. Kastanas ¹⁵², Y. Kataoka¹⁶¹, C. Kato ¹⁶¹, J. Katzy ⁴⁸, K. Kawade ⁸⁴, K. Kawagoe ⁸⁹, T. Kawamoto ¹⁶¹, G. Kawamura⁵⁵, E.F. Kay ⁹², V.F. Kazanin ³⁸, R. Keeler ¹⁷², R. Kehoe ⁴⁵, J.S. Keller ³⁵, E. Kellermann⁹⁹, J.J. Kempster ²², J. Kendrick ¹, O. Kepka ¹³⁵, S. Kersten ⁹⁵, B.P. Kerševan ⁹³, R.A. Keyes ¹⁰⁶, M. Khader ¹⁶⁹, F. Khalil-Zada ¹³, A. Khanov ¹²⁵, A.G. Kharlamov ³⁸, T. Kharlamova ³⁸, A. Khodinov ³⁸, T. Khoo ⁵⁶, J. Khubua ¹⁵⁷b,, S. Kido ⁸⁴, M. Kiehn ⁵⁶, C.R. Kilby ⁹⁵, S.H. Kim ¹⁶⁵, Y.K. Kim ⁴⁰, N. Kimura ⁶⁹a,⁶⁹c, O.M. Kind ²⁰, B.T. King ⁹²,, D. Kirchmeier ⁵⁰, J. Kirk ¹³⁸, A.E. Kiryunin ¹¹² T. Kishimoto161, D. Kisielewska85a, V. Kitali48, O. Kivernyk5, E. Kladiva29b,*, T. Klapdor-Kleingrothaus54, M.H. Klein108, M. Klein92,*, U. Klein92, K. Kleinknecht102, P. Klimek119, A. Klimentov30, R. Klingenberg49,*, T. Klingl25, T. Klioutchnikova37, F.F. Klitzner111, E.-E. Kluge63a, P. Kluit118, S. Kluth112, E. Kneringer79, E.B.F.G. Knoops104, A. Knue54, A. Kobayashi161, D. Kobayashi89, T. Kobayashi161, M. Kobel50, M. Kocian151, P. Kodyš137, T. Koffas35, E. Koffeman118, N.M. Köhler112, T. Kohriki83, T. Koi151, O. Kolay50, M. Kolb63b, I. Koletsou5, T. Kondo83, N. Kondrashova146a, K. Köneke54, A.C. König117, T. Kono121, R. Konoplich120,ah, V. Konstantinides96, N. Konstantinidis96, B. Konya99, R. Kopeliansky68, S. Koperny85a, K. Korcyl86, K. Kordas160, A. Korn96, I. Korolkov14, E.V. Korolkova147, O. Kortner112, S. Kortner112, T. Kosek137, V.V. Kostyukhin25, A. Kotwal51, A. Koulouris10, A. Kourkoumeli-Charalampidi73a,73b, C. Kourkoumelis9, E. Kourlitis147, V. Kouskoura30, A.B. Kowalewska86, R. Kowalewski172, T.Z. Kowalski85a, C. Kozakai161, W. Kozanecki139, A.S. Kozhin38, V.A. Kramarenko38, G. Kramberger93, D. Krasnopevtsev38, M.W. Krasny131, A. Krasznahorkay37, D. Krauss112, J.A. Kremer85a, J. Kretzschmar92, P. Krieger163, K. Krizka19a, K. Kroeninger49, H. Kroha112, J. Kroll135, J. Kroll132, J. Krstic17, U. Kruchonak39, H. Krüger25, N. Krumnack81, M.C. Kruse51, T. Kubota107, S. Kuday4b, D. Kuechler178, J.T. Kuechler178, S. Kuehn37, A. Kugel63a, F. Kuger173, T. Kuhl48, V. Kukhtin39, R. Kukla104, Y. Kulchitsky38, S. Kuleshov141b, Y.P. Kulinich169, M. Kuna60, T. Kunigo87, A. Kupco135, T. Kupfer49, O. Kuprash159, H. Kurashige84, L.L. Kurchaninov164a, Y.A. Kurochkin38, M.G. Kurth15,115b, E.S. Kuwertz172, M. Kuze143, J. Kvita126, T. Kwan106, A. La Rosa112, J.L. La Rosa Navarro82c, L. La Rotonda44b,44a, F. La Ruffa44b,44a, C. Lacasta170, F. Lacava75a,75b, J. Lacey48, D.P.J. Lack103, H. Lacker20, D. Lacour131, E. Ladygin39, R. Lafaye5, B. Laforge131, T. Lagouri34c, S. Lai55, S. Lammers68, W. Lampl7, E. Lançon30, U. Landgraf54, M.P.J. Landon94, M.C. Lanfermann56, V.S. Lang48, J.C. Lange14, R.J. Langenberg37, A.J. Lankford167, F. Lanni30, K. Lantzsch25, A. Lanza73a, A. Lapertosa57b,57a, S. Laplace131, J.F. Laporte139, T. Lari71a, F. Lasagni Manghi24b, M. Lassnig37, T.S. Lau65a, A. Laudrain67, A.T. Law140, P. Laycock92, M. Lazzaroni71a,71b, B. Le107, J.E. Le Dortz131, E. Le Guirriec104, E.P. Le Quilliec139, M. LeBlanc7, T. LeCompte6,*, F. Ledroit-Guillon60, C.A. Lee30, G.R. Lee141a, L. Lee61, S.C. Lee156, B. Lefebvre106, M. Lefebvre172, F. Legger111, C. Leggett19a, N. Lehmann178, G. Lehmann Miotto37, W.A. Leight48, A. Leisos160,v, M.A.L. Leite82c, R. Leitner137, D. Lellouch176,*, B. Lemmer55, K.J.C. Leney96, T. Lenz25, B. Lenzi37, R. Leone7, S. Leone74a, C. Leonidopoulos52, G. Lerner154, C. Leroy110, R. Les163, A.A.J. Lesage139, C.G. Lester33, M. Levchenko38, J. Levêque5, D. Levin108, L.J. Levinson176, D. Lewis94, B. Li108, C.-Q. Li62,ag, H. Li145, L. Li146a, Q. Li15,115b, Q.Y. Li62, S. Li146b,146a, X. Li146a, Y. Li149, Z. Liang15, B. Libert176a, A. Liblong163, K. Lie65c, S. Liem118, A. Limosani155, C.Y. Lin33, K. Lin109, T.H. Lin102, R.A. Linck68, B.E. Lindquist153, A.L. Lionti56, E. Lipeles132, A. Lipniacka18, M. Lisovyi63b, T.M. Liss169,am, A. Lister171, A.M. Litke140, J.D. Little8, B. Liu81, B.X. Liu6, H.B. Liu30, H. Liu108, J.B. Liu62, J.K.K. Liu130, K. Liu131, M. Liu62, P. Liu19a, Y. Liu15,115b, Y.L. Liu62, Y.W. Liu62, M. Livan73a,73b, A. Lleres60, J. Llorente Merino15, S.L. Lloyd94, C.Y. Lo65b, F. Lo Sterzo45, E.M. Lobodzinska48, P. Loch7, F.K. Loebinger103, K.M. Loew27, T. Lohse20, K. Lohwasser147, M. Lokajicek135,*, B.A. Long26, J.D. Long169, R.E. Long91, L. Longo70a,70b, K.A. Looper122, J.A. Lopez141b, I. Lopez Paz14, A. Lopez Solis131, J. Lorenz111, N. Lorenz Martinez111, P.J. Lösel1, A. Lősle54, X. Lou48, X. Lou15,115b, A. Lounis67, J. Love6, P.A. Love91, J.J. Lozano Bahilo170, H. Lu65a, M. Lu62, N. Lu108, Y.J. Lu66, H.J. Lubatti144,*, C. Luci75a,75b, A. Lucotte60, C. Luedtke54, F. Luehring68, I. Luise131, W. Lukas79 L. Luminari75a, B. Lund-Jensen152,*, M.S. Lutz105, P.M. Luzi131, D. Lynn30, R. Lysak135, E. Lytken99, F. Lyu15, V. Lyubushkin39, H. Ma30, L.L. Ma145, Y. Ma145, G. Maccarrone53, A. Macchiolo112, C.M. Macdonald147, J. Machado Miguens132,134b, D. Madaffari170, R. Madar41, A. Madsen48, N. Madysa50, J. Maeda84, K. Maekawa161, T. Maeno30, A.S. Maevskiy38, V. Magerl54, C. Maidantchik82b, T. Maier111, A. Maio134a,134b,134d, K. Maj86, O. Majersky29a, S. Majewski127, Y. Makida83, N. Makovec67, B. Malaescu131, Pa. Malecki86, V.P. Maleev38, F. Malek60, U. Mallik80,*, D. Malon6, C. Malone33, S. Maltezos10, S. Malyukov37, J. Mamuzic170, G. Mancini53, I. Mandić93, J. Maneira134a, L. Manhaes de Andrade Filho82a, J. Manjarres Ramos50, K.H. Mankinen99, A. Mann111, A. Manousos79, B. Mansoulie139, J.D. Mansour15, M. Mantoani55, S. Manzoni71a,71b, G. Marceca31, L. March56, L. Marchese130, G. Marchiori131, M. Marcisovsky135, C.A. Marin Tobon37, M. Marjanovic41, D.E. Marley108, F. Marroquim82b, Z. Marshall19a, M.U.F. Martensson168, S. Marti-Garcia170, C.B. Martin122, T.A. Martin174, V.J. Martin52, B. Martin dit Latour18, M. Martinez14,z, V.I. Martinez Outschoorn105, S. Martin-Haugh138, V.S. Martoiu28b, A.C. Martyniuk96, A. Marzin37, L. Masetti102, T. Mashimo161, R. Mashinistov38, J. Masik103, A.L. Maslennikov38, L.H. Mason107, L. Massa76a,76b, P. Mastrandrea5, A. Mastroberardino44b,44a, T. Masubuchi161, P. Mättig178, J. Maurer28b, B. Maček93, S.J. Maxfield92,*, D.A. Maximov38, R. Mazini156, I. Maznas160, S.M. Mazza140, N.C. Mc Fadden116, G. Mc Goldrick163, S.P. Mc Kee108, T.G. McCarthy112, L.I. McClymont96, E.F. McDonald107, J.A. Mcfayden37, M.A. McKay45, K.D. McLean172, S.J. McMahon138, P.C. McNamara107, C.J. McNicol174, R.A. McPherson172,ac, J.E. Mdhluli34c, Z.A. Meadows105, S. Meehan144, T. Megy54, S. Mehlhase111, A. Mehta92, T. Meideck60, K. Meier63a,*, B. Meirose46, D. Melini170,h, B.R. Mellado Garcia34c, J.D. Mellenthin55, M. Melo29a, F. Meloni21, A. Melzer25, S.B. Menary103, E.D. Mendes Gouveia134a, L. Meng92, X.T. Meng108, A. Mengarelli24b,24a, S. Menke112, E. Meoni44b,44a, S. Mergelmeyer20, C. Merlassino21, P. Mermod56,*, L. Merola72a,72b, C. Meroni71a,71b, F.S. Merritt40, A. Messina75a,75b, J. Metcalfe6, A.S. Mete167, C. Meyer132, J. Meyer158, J-P. Meyer139, H. Meyer Zu Theenhausen63a, F. Miano154, R.P. Middleton138, L. Mijović52, G. Mikenberg176, M. Mikestikova135, M. Mikuž93, M. Milesi107, A. Milic163, D.A. Millar94, D.W. Miller40, A. Milov176, D.A. Milstead47a,47b, A.A. Minaenko38, M. Miñano Moya170, I.A. Minashvili157b, A.I. Mincer120, B. Mindur85a, M. Mineev39, Y. Minegishi161, Y. Ming177, L.M. Mir14, A. Mirto70a,70b, K.P. Mistry132, T. Mitani175, J. Mitrevski111, V.A. Mitsou170, A. Miucci21, P.S. Miyagawa147, A. Mizukami83, J.U. Mjörnmärk99, T. Mrktchyan180, M. Mlynarikova137, T. Moa47a,47b, K. Mochizuki110, P. Mogg54, S. Mohapatra42, S. Molander47a,47b, R. Moles-Valls25, M.C. Mondragon109, K. Mönig48, S. Monk43, E. Monnier104, A. Montalbano150, J. Montejo Berlingen37, F. Monticelli90, R.W. Moore3, N. Morange67, D. Moreno23, M. Moreno Llácer37, P. Morettini57b, M. Morgenstern118, S. Morgenstern37, D. Mori150, T. Mori161, M. Morii61, M. Morinaga175, V. Morisbak129, A.K. Morley37, G. Mornacchi37, A.P. Morris96, J.D. Morris94, L. Morvaj153, P. Moschovakos10, M. Mosidze157b, H.J. Moss147, J. Moss32,p, K. Motohashi143, R. Mount151, E. Mountricha37, E.J.W. Moyse105, S. Muanza104, F. Mueller112, J. Mueller133, R.S.P. Mueller111, D. Muenstermann91, P. Mullen59, G.A. Mullier21, F.J. Munoz Sanchez103, P. Murin29b, W.J. Murray174,138, A. Murrone71a,71b, M. Muškìnija93, C. Mwewa34a, A.G. Myagkov7, J. Myers136, M. Myska19a, B.P. Nachman19, O. Nackenhorst49, K. Nagai130, K. Nagano83, Y. Nagasaki64, K. Nagata165, M. Nagel54, E. Nagy104, A.M. Nairz37, Y. Nakahama114, K. Nakamura83, T. Nakamura161, I. Nakano123, H. Nanjo128, F. Napolitano63a, R.F. Naranjo Garcia48, R. Narayan11, D.I. Narrias Villar63a, I. Naryshkin , T. Naumann , G. Navarro , R. Nayyar , H.A. Neal , P.Y. Nechaeva , T.J. Neep , A. Negri , M. Negrini , S. Nektarijevic , C. Nellist , M.E. Nelson , S. Nemecek , P. Nemethy , M. Nessi , M.S. Neubauer , M. Neumann , P.R. Newman , T.Y. Ng , Y.S. Ng , H.D.N. Nguyen , T. Nguyen Manh , E. Nibigira , R.B. Nickerson , R. Nicolaidou , J. Nielsen , N. Nikiforou , V. Nikolaenko , I. Nikolic-Audit , K. Nikolopoulos , P. Nilsson , Y. Ninomiya , A. Nisati , N. Nishu , R. Nisius , I. Nitsche , T. Nitta , T. Nobe , Y. Noguchi , M. Nomachi , I. Nomidis , M.A. Nomura , T. Nooney , M. Nordberg , N. Norjoharuddeen , T. Novak , O. Novgorodova , R. Novotny , M. Nozaki , L. Nozka , K. Ntekas , E. Nurse , F. Nuti , F.G. Oakham , H. Oberlack , T. Obermann , J. Ocariz , A. Ochi , I. Ochoa , J.P. Ochoa-Ricoux , K. O’Connor , S. Oda , S. Odaka , A. Oh , S.H. Oh , C.C. Ohm , H. Oide , Y. Okazaki , Y. Okumura , T. Okuyama , A. Olariu , L.F. Oleiro Seabra , D. Oliveira Damazio , J.L. Oliver , M.J.R. Olsson , A. Olszewski , J. Olszowska , D.C. O’Neil , A. Onofre , K. Onogi , P.U.E. Onyisi , H. Oppen , M.J. Oreglia , Y. Oren , D. Orestano , N. Orlando , A.A. O’Rourke , R.S. Orr , B. Osculati , V. O’Shea , R. Ospanov , G. Otero y Garzón , H. Otono , M. Ouchrif , F. Ould-Saada , A. Ouraou , Q. Ouyang , M. Owen , R.E. Owen , V.E. Ozcan , N. Ozturk , J. Pacalt , H.A. Pacey , A. Pacheco Pages , L. Pacheco Rodriguez , C. Padilla Aranda , S. Pagan Griso , M. Paganini , G. Palacino , S. Palazzo , S. Palestini , M. Palka , D. Pallin , I. Panagoulias , C.E. Pandini , J.G. Panduro Vazquez , P. Pani , G. Panizzo , L. Paolozzi , T.D. Papadopoulou , K. Papageorgiou , A. Paramonov , D. Paredes Hernandez , B. Parida , A.J. Parker , K.A. Parker , M.A. Parker , F. Parodi , J.A. Parsons , U. Parzefall , V.R. Pascuzzi , J.M.P. Pasner , E. Pasqualucci , S. Passaggio , F. Pastore , P. Pasuwan , S. Pataraia , J.R. Pater , A. Pathak , T. Pauly , B. Pearson , M. Pedersen , L. Pedraza Diaz , S. Pedraza Lopez , R. Pedro , S.V. Peleganchuk , O. Penc , C. Peng , H. Peng , B.S. Peralva , M.M. Perego , A.P. Pereira Peixoto , D.V. Perepelitsa , F. Peri , L. Perini , H. Pernegger , K. Peters , R.F.Y. Peters , B.A. Petersen , T.C. Petersen , E. Petit , A. Petridis , C. Petridou , E. Petrolo , M. Petrov , F. Petrucci , M. Pettee , N.E. Pettersson , A. Peynaud , R. Pezoa , T. Pham , F.H. Phillips , P.W. Phillips , G. P iaquadio , E. Pianori , A. Picazio , M.A. Pickering , R. Pieg aia , J.E. Pilcher , A.D. Pilkington , M. Pinamonti , J.L. Pinfold , M. Pitt , M.-A. Pleier , V. Pleskot , E. Plotnikova , D. Pluth , P. Podberezko , R. Poettgen , R. Poggi , L. Poggioli , I. Pogrebnyak , D. Pohl , I. Pokharel , G. Polesello , A. Poley , A. Polini , R. Polifka , A. Polini , C.S. Pollard , V. Polonichko , D. Ponomarenko , L. Pontecorvo , G.A. Popeneciu , D.M. Portillo Quintero , S. Pospišil , K. Potamianos , I.N. Potrap , C.J. Potter , H. Potti , T. Poulsen , J. Poveda , T.D. Powell , M.E. Pozo Astigarraga , P. Pralavorio , S. Prell , D. Price , M. Primavera , S. Prince , N. Proklova , K. Prokofiev , S. Protopopescu , J. Proudfoot , M. Przybycien , A. Puri , P. Puzo , J. Qian , Y. Qin , A. Quadt , M. Queitsch-Maitland , A. Qureshi , P. Rados , F. Ragusa , G. Rahal , J.A. Raine , S. Rajagopalan , A. Ramirez Morales , T. Rashid , S. Raspopov , M.G. Ratti , D.M. Rauch , F. Rauscher , S. Rave , B. Ravina , I. Ravinovich , J.H. Rawling , M. Raymond , A.L. Read , N.P. Readioff , M. Reale , D.M. Rebuzzi , A. Redelbach , G. Redlinger , R. Reece , R.G. Reed , K. Reeves , L. Rehnisch , J. Reichert , A. Reiss C. Rembser{sup}37, H. Ren{sup}15, M. Rescigno{sup}75a, S. Resconi{sup}71a, E.D. Resseguie{sup}132, S. Rettie{sup}171, E. Reynolds{sup}22, O.L. Rezanova{sup}38, P. Reznicek{sup}137, R. Richter{sup}112, S. Richter{sup}96, E. Richter-Was{sup}85b, O. Ricken{sup}25, M. Ridel{sup}131, P. Rieck{sup}112, C.J. Riegel{sup}178, O. Rifki{sup}48, M. Rijssenbeek{sup}153, A. Rimoldi{sup}73a,73b, M. Rimoldi{sup}21, L. Rinaldi{sup}24b,24a, G. Ripellino{sup}152, B. Ristić{sup}91, E. Ritsch{sup}37, I. Riu{sup}14, J.C. Rivera Vergara{sup}141a, F. Rizatdinova{sup}125, E. Rizvi{sup}94, C. Rizzi{sup}14, R.T. Roberts{sup}103, S.H. Robertson{sup}106,ac, A. Robichaud-Veronneau{sup}106, D. Robinson{sup}33, J.E.M. Robinson{sup}48, A. Robson{sup}59, E. Rocco{sup}102, C. Roda{sup}74a,74b, Y. Rodina{sup}104, S. Rodriguez Bosca{sup}170, A. Rodriguez Perez{sup}14, D. Rodriguez Rodriguez{sup}170, A.M. Rodríguez Vera{sup}164b, S. Roe{sup}37, C.S. Rogan{sup}61, O. Røhne{sup}129, R. Röhrig{sup}112, C.P.A. Roland{sup}68, J. Roloff{sup}61, A. Romaniouk{sup}38, M. Romano{sup}24b, N. Rompotis{sup}92, M. Ronzani{sup}120, L. Roos{sup}131, E. Ros{sup}170, S. Rosati{sup}75a, K. Rosbach{sup}54, P. Rose{sup}140, N-A. Rosien{sup}55, E. Rossi{sup}72a,72b, L.P. Rossi{sup}57b, L. Rossini{sup}71a,71b, J.H.N. Rosten{sup}33, R. Rosten{sup}14, M. Rotaru{sup}28b, J. Rothberg{sup}144,, D. Rousseau{sup}67, D. Roy{sup}34c, A. Rozanov{sup}104, Y. Rozen{sup}158, X. Ruan{sup}34c, F. Rubbo{sup}151, F. Rühr{sup}54, A. Ruiz-Martinez{sup}35, Z. Rurikova{sup}54, N.A. Rusakovich{sup}39, H.L. Russell{sup}106, J.P. Rutherfoord{sup}7, N. Ruthmann{sup}37, E.M. Rüttinger{sup}48,l, M. Rybar{sup}169, G. Rybkin{sup}67, S. Ryu{sup}6, A. Ryzhov{sup}38, G.F. Rzehorz{sup}55, P. Sabatini{sup}55, G. Sabato{sup}118, S. Sacerdoti{sup}67, H.F-W. Sadrozinski{sup}140, F. Safai Tehrani{sup}75a, P. Saha{sup}119, M. Sahinsoy{sup}63a, A. Sahu{sup}178, M. Saimpert{sup}48, M. Saito{sup}161, T. Saito{sup}161, H. Sakamoto{sup}161, A. Sakharov{sup}120,ah, D. Salamani{sup}56, G. Salamanna{sup}77a,77b, J.E. Salazar Loyola{sup}141b, D. Salek{sup}118, P.H. Sales De Bruin{sup}168, D. Salihagic{sup}112,, A. Salnikov{sup}151, J. Salt{sup}170, D. Salvatore{sup}44b,44a, F. Salvatore{sup}154, A. Salvucci{sup}65a,65b,65c, A. Salzburger{sup}37, D. Sammel{sup}54, D. Sampsonidis{sup}160, D. Sampsonidou{sup}160, J. Sánchez{sup}170, A. Sanchez Pineda{sup}69a,69c, H. Sandaker{sup}129, C.O. Sander{sup}48, M. Sandhoff{sup}178, C. Sandoval{sup}23, D.P.C. Sankey{sup}138, M. Sannino{sup}57b,57a, Y. Sano{sup}114, A. Sansoni{sup}53, C. Santoni{sup}41, H. Santos{sup}134a, I. Santoyo Castillo{sup}154, J.G. Saraiva{sup}134a,134d, O. Sasaki{sup}83, K. Sato{sup}165, E. Sauvan{sup}5, P. Savard{sup}163,ao, N. Savic{sup}112, R. Sawada{sup}161, C. Sawyer{sup}138, L. Sawyer{sup}97, C. Sbarra{sup}24b, A. Sbrizzi{sup}24a, T. Scanlon{sup}96, J. Schaarschmidt{sup}144, P. Schacht{sup}112, B.M. Schachtner{sup}111, D. Schaefer{sup}40, L. Schaefer{sup}132, J. Schaeffer{sup}102, S. Schaepe{sup}37, U. Schäfer{sup}102, A.C. Schaffer{sup}67, D. Schaile{sup}111, R.D. Schamberger{sup}153, N. Scharmberg{sup}103, V.A. Schegelsky{sup}38, D. Scheirich{sup}137, F. Schenck{sup}20, M. Schernau{sup}167, C. Schiavi{sup}57b,57a, S. Schier{sup}140, L.K. Schildgen{sup}25, Z.M. Schillaci{sup}27, E.J. Schioppa{sup}37, M. Schioppa{sup}44b,44a, K.E. Schleicher{sup}54, S. Schlenker{sup}37, K.R. Schmidt-Sommerfeld{sup}112, K. Schmieden{sup}37, C. Schmitt{sup}102, S. Schmitt{sup}48, S. Schmitz{sup}102, U. Schnoor{sup}54, L. Schoeffel{sup}139, A. Schoening{sup}63b, E. Schopf{sup}25, M. Schott{sup}102, J.F.P. Schouwenberg{sup}117, J. Schovancova{sup}37, S. Schramm{sup}56, A. Schulte{sup}102, H.-C. Schultz-Coulon{sup}139, M. Schumacher{sup}54, B.A. Schumm{sup}140, Ph. Schune{sup}139, A. Schwartzmam{sup}151, T.A. Schwarz{sup}108, H. Schweiger{sup}139, Ph. Schwemling{sup}139, R. Schwienhorst{sup}109, A. Sciandra{sup}25, G. Sciolla{sup}27, M. Scornajenghi{sup}44b,44a, F. Scuri{sup}74a, F. Scutti{sup}107, L.M. Scyboz{sup}112, J. Searcy{sup}108, C.D. Sebastiani{sup}75a,75b, P. Seema{sup}25, S.C. Seidel{sup}116, A. Seiden{sup}140, T. Seiss{sup}40, J.M. Seixas{sup}82b,*, G. Sekhniaidze{sup}72a, K. Sekhon{sup}108, S.J. Sekula{sup}45, N. Semprini-Cesari{sup}24b,24a, S. Sen{sup}51, S. Senkin{sup}41, C. Serfon{sup}129, L. Serin{sup}67, L. Serkin{sup}69a,69b, M. Sessa{sup}77a,77b, H. Severini{sup}124, T. Šfiligoj{sup}93, F. Sforza{sup}166, A. Sfyrla{sup}56, E. Shabalina{sup}55, J.D. Shahinian{sup}140, N.W. Shaikh{sup}47a,47b, L.Y. Shan{sup}15, R. Shang{sup}169, J.T. Shank{sup}26, M. Shapiro{sup}19a, A. Sharma{sup}130, A.S. Sharma{sup}1, P.B. Shatalov{sup}38, K. Shaw{sup}154, S.M. Shaw{sup}103, A. Shcherbakova{sup}179, Y. Shen{sup}124, N. Sherafati{sup}35, A.D. Sherman{sup}26, P. Sherwood{sup}96, L. Shi{sup}156,al, C.O. Shimmin{sup}179, M. Shimojima{sup}113, I.P.J. Shipsey{sup}19, S. Shirabe{sup}89, M. Shiyakova{sup}39, J. Shlomi{sup}176, A. Shmeleva{sup}38, D. Shoaleh Saadi{sup}110, M.J. Shochet{sup}40, J. Shochet{sup}107, D.R. Shope{sup}124, S. Shrestha{sup}122, E. Shulga{sup}38, P. Sichо{sup}135, A.M. Sickles{sup}169, P.E. Sidebo{sup}152, E. Sideras Haddad{sup}34c, A. Sidoti{sup}24b, F. Siegert{sup}50, Dj. Sijacki{sup}17, J. Silva{sup}134a, M.Jr. Silva{sup}177`, M.V. Silva Oliveira 82a, S.B. Silverstein 47a, V. Simak 136,, L. Simic 39, S. Simion 67, E. Simioni 102, M. Simon 102, P. Sinervo 163, N.B. Sinev 127, M. Sioli 24b,24a, G. Siragusa 173, I. Siral 108, S.Yu. Sivoklokov 38,, J. Sjölin 47a,47b, M.B. Skinner 91, P. Skubic 124, M. Slater 22, T. Slavicek 136, M. Slawinska 86, K. Sliwa 166, R. Slovak 137, V. Smakhtin 176, B.H. Smart 5, J. Smiesko 29a, N. Smirnov 38, S.Yu. Smirnov 38, Y. Smirnov 38, L.N. Smirnova 38,a, O. Smirnova 99, J.W. Smith 55, M.N.K. Smith 42, R.W. Smith 42, M. Smizanska 91, K. Smolek 136, A.A. Snesarev 38, I.M. Snyder 127, S. Snyder 30, R. Sobie 172,ac, A.M. Soffa 167, A. Soffer 159, A. Søgaard 52, D.A. Soh 156, G. Sokhrannyi 93, C.A. Solans Sanchez 37, M. Solar 136, E.Yu. Soldatov 38, U. Soldevila 170, A.A. Solodkov 38, A. Soloshenko 39, O.V. Solovyanov 38, V. Solovyev 38, P. Sommer 147, H. Son 166, W. Song 138, A. Sopczak 136, F. Sopkova 29b, D. Sosa 63b, C.L. Sotiropoulou 74a,74b, S. Sottocornola 73a,73b, R. Soualah 69a,69c,i, D. South 48, B.C. Sowden 95, S. Spagnolo 70a,70b, M. Spalla 112, M. Spangenberg 174, D. Sperlich 20, F. Spettel 112, T.M. Spieker 63a, R. Spighi 24b, G. Spigo 37, L.A. Spiller 107, D.P. Spiteri 59, M. Spousta 137, A. Stabile 71a,71b, R. Stamen 63a, S. Stamm 20, E. Stanecka 86, R.W. Stanek 6,*, C. Stanescu 77a, B. Stanislaus 130, M.M. Stanitzki 48, B. Stapf 118, S. Stapnes 129, E.A. Starchenko 38, G.H. Stark 40, J. Stark 60, S.H. Stark 43, P. Staroba 135, P. Starovoitov 63a, S. Stärz 37, R. Staszewski 86, M. Stegler 48, P. Steinberg 30, B. Stelzer 150, H.J. Stelzer 37, O. Stelzer 164a, H. Stenzel 58, T.J. Stevenson 94, G.A. Stewart 37, M.C. Stockton 127, G. Stoicea 28b, P. Stolte 55, S. Stonjek 112, A. Straessner 50, J. Strandberg 152, S. Strandberg 47a,47b, M. Strauss 124, P. Strizenec 29b, R. Ströhmer 173, D.M. Strom 127, R. Stroynowski 45, A. Strubig 52, S.A. Stucci 30, B. Stugu 18, J. Stupak 124, N.A. Styles 48, D. Su 151, J. Su 133, S. Suchek 63a, Y. Sugaya 128, M. Suk 136, V.V. Sulin 38, D.M.S. Sultan 56, S. Sultansoy 4c, T. Sumida 87, S. Sun 108, X. Sun 3, K. Suruliz 154, C.J.E. Suster 155, M.R. Sutton 154, S. Suzuki 83, M. Svatos 135, M. Swiatlowski 40, S.P. Swift 2, A. Sydorenko 102, I. Sykora 29a, T. Sykora 137, D. Ta 102, K. Tackmann 48, J. Taenzer 159, A. Taffard 167, R. Tafirout 164a, E. Tahirovic 94, N. Taiblum 159, H. Takai 30, R. Takashima 88, E.H. Takasugi 112, K. Takeda 84, T. Takeshita 148, Y. Takubo 83, M. Talby 104, A.A. Talyshev 38, J. Tanaka 161, M. Tanaka 143, R. Tanaka 67, R. Tanioka 84, B.B. Tannenwald 122, S. Tapia Araya 141b, S. Tapprogge 102, A. Tarek Abouelfadl Mohamed 131, S. Tarem 158, G. Tarna 28b,e, G.F. Tartarelli 71a, P. Tas 137, M. Tasevsky 135, T. Tashiro 87, E. Tassi 44b,44a, A. Tavares Delgado 134a,134b, Y. Tayalati 36d, A.C. Taylor 116, A.J. Taylor 52, G.N. Taylor 107, P.T.E. Taylor 107, W. Taylor 164b, A.S. Tee 91, P. Teixeira-Dias 95, D. Temple 150, H. Ten Kate 37, P.K. Teng 156, J.J. Teoh 128, F. Tepel 178, S. Terada 83, K. Terashi 161, J. Terron 101, S. Terzo 14, M. Testa 53, R.J. Teuscher 163,ac, S.J. Thais 179, T. Theveneaux-Pelzer 48, F. Thiele 43, J.P. Thomas 22, A.S. Thompson 22, P.D. Thompson 179, L.A. Thomsen 179, E. Thomson 132, Y. Tian 42, R.E. Tice Torres 55, V. Tikhomirov 38, Ya.A. Tikhonov 38, S. Timoshenko 38, P. Tipton 179, S. Tisserant 104, K. Todome 143, S. Todorova-Nova 5, S. Todt 50, T. Tojo 89, S. Tokár 29a, K. Tokushuku 83, E. Tolley 122, K.G. Tomiwa 34c, M. Tomoto 114, L. Tompkins 151, B. Tong 61, P. Tornambe 54, E. Torrence 127, H. Torres 50, E. Torró Pastor 144, C. Tosciri 130, J. Toth 104,ab, F. Touchard 104, D.R. Tovey 147, C.J. Treado 120, T. Trefzger 173, F. Tresoldi 154, A. Tricoli 30, I.M. Trigger 164a, S. Trincaz-Duvoid 131, M.F. Tripiana 14, B. Trocme 60, A. Trofymov 67, C. Troncon 71a, M. Trovavelli 172, F. Trovato 154, L. Truong 34b, M. Trzebinski 86, A. Trzupek 86, F. Tsai 48, J.-C.L. Tseng 130, P.V. Tsiareshka 38, N. Tsirintanis 9, V. Tsiskaridze 153, E.G. Tskhadadze 15, I.I. Tsukerman 38, V. Tsulaia 9a, S. Tsuno 83, D. Tsybychev 153, Y. Tu 65b, A. Tudorąche 28b, V. Tudorache 28b, T.T. Türke 28a, A.N. Tuna 61, S. Turchikhin 39, D. Turgeman 176, I. Turk Cakir 64b,u, R. Turra 71a, P.M. Tuts 42, E. Tzovara 102, G. Ucchielli 24b,24a, I. Ueda 83, M. Ughetto 47a,47b, F. Ukegawa 165, G. Unal 37, A. Undrus 30_老司机 G. Unel167, F.C. Ungaro107, Y. Unno83, K. Uno161, J. Urban29b, P. Urquijo107, G. Usai8, J. Usui83, L. Vacavant104, V. Vacek136, B. Vachon106, K.O.H. Vadla129, A. Vaidya96, C. Valderanis111, E. Valdes Santurio47a,47b, M. Valente56, S. Valentinetti24b,24a, A. Valero170, L. Valéry48, R.A. Vallance22, A. Vallier5, J.A. Valls Ferrer170, T.R. Van Daalen14, W. Van Den Wollenberg118, H. Van der Graaf118, P. Van Gemmeren6, J. Van Nieuwkoop150, I. Van Vulpen118, M.C. van Woerden118, M. Vanadia76a,76b, W. Vandelli37, A. Vaniachine38, P. Vankov118, R. Vari75a, E.W. Varnes7, C. Varni57b,57a, T. Varol45, D. Varouchas67, A. Vartapetian8, K.E. Varvell155, G.A. Vasquez141b, J.G. Vasquez179, F. Vazeille41, D. Vazquez Furelos14, T. Vazquez Schroeder106, J. Veatch55, V. Vecchio77a,77b, L.M. Veloce163, F. Veloso134a,134c, S. Veneziano75a, A. Ventura70a,70b, M. Venturi172, N. Venturi37, V. Vercesi73a, M. Verducci77a,77b, C.M. Vergel Infante81, W. Verkerke118, A.T. Vermeulen118, J.C. Vermeulen118, M.C. Vetterli150,ao, N. Viaux Maira141b, O. Viazlo99, I. Vichou169,*, T. Vickey147, O.E. Vickey Boeriu147, G.H.A. Viehhauser130, S. Viel19a, L. Vigani130, M. Villa24b,24a, M. Villaplana Perez71a,71b, E. Vilucchi53, M.G. Vincter35, V.B. Vinogradov39, A. Vishwakarma48, C. Vittori24b,24a, I. Vivarelli154, S. Vlachos10, M. Vogel178, P. Vokac136, G. Volpi14, S.E. von Buddenbrock34c, E. Von Toerne25, V. Vorobel137, K. Vorobev38, M. Vos170, J.H. Vossebeld92, N. Vranjes17, M. Vranjes Milosavljevic17, V. Vrba136,*, M. Vreeswijk118, R. Vuillermet37, I. Vukotic40, P. Wagner25, W. Wagner178, J. Wagner-Kuhr111, H. Wahlberg90, S. Wahrmund50, K. Wakamiya84, V.M. Walbrecht112, J. Walder91, R. Walker111, W. Walkowiak149, V. Wallangen47a,47b, A.M. Wang61, C. Wang145,e, F. Wang177, H. Wang19a, H. Wang3, J. Wang155, J. Wang63b, P. Wang45, Q. Wang124, R.-J. Wang131, R. Wang62, R. Wang6, S.M. Wang156, W.T. Wang62, W.X. Wang62,ad, Y. Wang62,ag, Z. Wang146a, A. Warburton106, C.P. Ward33, D.R. Wardrope96, A. Washbrook52, P.M. Watkins22, A.T. Watson22, M.F. Watson22, G. Watts144, S. Watts103, B.M. Waugh96, A.F. Webb11, S. Webb102, C. Weber179, M.S. Weber21, S.A. Weber35, S.M. Weber63a, J.S. Webster6, A.R. Weidberg130, B. Weinert68, J. Weingarten55, M. Weirich102, C. Weiser54, P.S. Wells37, T. Wenaus30, T. Wengler37, S. Wenig37, N. Wermes25, M.D. Werner81, P. Werner37, M. Wessels63a, T.D. Weston21, K. Whalen127, N.L. Whallon144, A.M. Wharton91, A.S. White108, A. White8, M.J. White1, R. White141b, D. Whiteson167, B.W. Whitmore91, F.J. Wickens138, W. Wiedenmann177, M. Wielers138, C. Wiglesworth43, L.A.M. Wiik-Fuchs54, A. Wildauer112, F. Wilk103, H.G. Wilkens37, L.J. Wilkins95, H.H. Williams132, S. Williams33, C. Willis109, S. Willocq105, J.A. Wilson22, I. Wingerter-Seez5, E. Winkels154, F. Winklmeier127, O.J. Winston154, B.T. Winter25, M. Wittgen151, M. Wobisch97, A. Wolf102, T.M.H. Wolf118, R. Wolff104, M.W. Wolter86, H. Wolters134a,134c, V.W.S. Wong171, N.L. Woods140, S.D. Worm22, B.K. Wosiek86, K.W. Woźniak86, K. Wraight59, M. Wu40, S.L. Wu177, X. Wu62, T.R. Wyatt103, B.M. Wynne52, S. Xella43, Z. Xi108, D. Xu15, H. Xu62,e, L. Xu30, T. Xu139, W. Xu108, B. Yabsley155, S. Yacoob34a, K. Yajima128, D.P. Yallup96, D. Yamaguchi143, Y. Yamaguchi143, A. Yamamoto83, T. Yamanaka161, F. Yamane84, M. Yamatani161, T. Yamazaki161, Y. Yamazaki84, Z. Yan26, H.J. Yang146a,146b, H.T. Yang19a, S. Yang80, Y. Yang161, Z. Yang18, W-M. Yao19a, Y.C. Yap48, Y. Yasu83, E. Yatsenko146a,146b, J. Ye45, S. Ye30, I. Yeletskiikh39, E. Yigitbasi26, E. Yildirim102, K. Yorita175, K. Yoshihara132, C.J.S. Young37, C. Young151, J. Yu81, J. Yu8, X. Yue63a, S.P.Y. Yuen25, I. Yusuff33, B. Zabinski86, G. Zacharias10, E. Zaffaroni36, R. Zaidan1, N. Zakharchuk61, J. Zalieckas18, S. Zambito61, D. Zanzi37, D.R. Zaripovas59, S.V. Zeißner49, C. Zeitnitz178, J. Zemla130, C. Zeng169, Q. Zeng151, O. Zenin38, T. Ženiš29a, D. Zerwas67, M. Zgubić130, D.F. Zhang145, D. Zhang108, F. Zhang177, G. Zhang62,ad, H. Zhang115a, J. Zhang6, L. Zhang54, L. Zhang62 M. Zhang169, P. Zhang115a, R. Zhang62,e, R. Zhang25, X. Zhang145, Y. Zhang15,115b, Z. Zhang67, P. Zhao51, X. Zhao45, Y. Zhao145,67,y, Z. Zhao62, A. Zhemchugov39, B. Zhou108, C. Zhou177, L. Zhou45, M.S. Zhou15,115b, M. Zhou153, N. Zhou146a, Y. Zhou7, C.G. Zhu145, H.L. Zhu62, H. Zhu15, J. Zhu108, Y. Zhu62, X. Zhuang15, K. Zhukov38, V. Zhulanov38, A. Zibell173, D. Zieminska68, N.I. Zimine39, S. Zimmermann54,*, Z. Zinonos112, M. Zinser102, M. Ziolkowski149, L. Živković17, G. Zobernig177, A. Zoccoli24b,24a, K. Zoch55, T.G. Zorbas147, R. Zou40, M. Zur Nedden20, L. Zwalinski37.
1Department of Physics, University of Adelaide, Adelaide; Australia.
2Physics Department, SUNY Albany, Albany NY; United States of America.
3Department of Physics, University of Alberta, Edmonton AB; Canada.
4(a)Department of Physics, Ankara University, Ankara;(b)Istanbul Aydin University, Application and Research Center for Advanced Studies, Istanbul;(c)Division of Physics, TOBB University of Economics and Technology, Ankara; Türkiye.
5LAPP, Université Savoie Mont Blanc, CNRS/IN2P3, Annecy; France.
6High Energy Physics Division, Argonne National Laboratory, Argonne IL; United States of America.
7Department of Physics, University of Arizona, Tucson AZ; United States of America.
8Department of Physics, University of Texas at Arlington, Arlington TX; United States of America.
9Physics Department, National and Kapodistrian University of Athens, Athens; Greece.
10Physics Department, National Technical University of Athens, Zografou; Greece.
11Department of Physics, University of Texas at Austin, Austin TX; United States of America.
12(a)Bahcesehir University, Faculty of Engineering and Natural Sciences, Istanbul;(b)Istanbul Bilgi University, Faculty of Engineering and Natural Sciences, Istanbul;(c)Department of Physics, Bogazici University, Istanbul;(d)Department of Physics Engineering, Gaziantep University, Gaziantep; Türkiye.
13Institute of Physics, Azerbaijan Academy of Sciences, Baku; Azerbaijan.
14Institut de Física d’Altes Energies (IFAE), Barcelona Institute of Science and Technology, Barcelona; Spain.
15Institute of High Energy Physics, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing; China.
16Physics Department, Tsinghua University, Beijing; China.
17Institute of Physics, University of Belgrade, Belgrade; Serbia.
18Department for Physics and Technology, University of Bergen, Bergen; Norway.
19(a)Physics Division, Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, Berkeley CA;(b)University of California, Berkeley CA; United States of America.
20Institut für Physik, Humboldt Universität zu Berlin, Berlin; Germany.
21Albert Einstein Center for Fundamental Physics and Laboratory for High Energy Physics, University of Bern, Bern; Switzerland.
22School of Physics and Astronomy, University of Birmingham, Birmingham; United Kingdom.
23Facultad de Ciencias y Centro de Investigaciones, Universidad Antonio Nariño, Bogotá; Colombia.
24(a)Dipartimento di Fisica e Astronomia A. Righi, Università di Bologna, Bologna;(b)INFN Sezione di Bologna; Italy.
25Physikalisches Institut, Universität Bonn, Bonn; Germany.
26Department of Physics, Boston University, Boston MA; United States of America.
27Department of Physics, Brandeis University, Waltham MA; United States of America.
28(a)Transilvania University of Brasov, Brasov;(b)Horia Hulubei National Institute of Physics and Nuclear Engineering, Bucharest;(c)Department of Physics, Alexandru Ioan Cuza University of Iasi, Iasi;(d)National Institute for Research and Development of Isotopic and Molecular Technologies, Physics Department, Cluj-Napoca;(e)National University of Science and Technology Politechnica, Bucharest;f West University in Timisoara, Timisoara; Romania.
29 a Faculty of Mathematics, Physics and Informatics, Comenius University, Bratislava;b Department of Subnuclear Physics, Institute of Experimental Physics of the Slovak Academy of Sciences, Kosice; Slovak Republic.
30 Physics Department, Brookhaven National Laboratory, Upton NY; United States of America.
31 Universidad de Buenos Aires, Facultad de Ciencias Exactas y Naturales, Departamento de Física, y CONICET, Instituto de Física de Buenos Aires (IFIBA), Buenos Aires; Argentina.
32 California State University, CA; United States of America.
33 Cavendish Laboratory, University of Cambridge, Cambridge; United Kingdom.
34 a Department of Physics, University of Cape Town, Cape Town;b Department of Mechanical Engineering Science, University of Johannesburg, Johannesburg;c School of Physics, University of the Witwatersrand, Johannesburg; South Africa.
35 Department of Physics, Carleton University, Ottawa ON; Canada.
36 a Faculté des Sciences Ain Chock, Université Hassan II de Casablanca;b Faculté des Sciences Semlalia, Université Cadi Ayyad, LPHEA-Marrakech;c LPMR, Faculté des Sciences, Université Mohamed Premier, Oujda;d Faculté des sciences, Université Mohammed V, Rabat; Morocco.
37 CERN, Geneva; Switzerland.
38 Affiliated with an institute covered by a cooperation agreement with CERN.
39 Affiliated with an international laboratory covered by a cooperation agreement with CERN.
40 Enrico Fermi Institute, University of Chicago, Chicago IL; United States of America.
41 LPC, Université Clermont Auvergne, CNRS/IN2P3, Clermont-Ferrand; France.
42 Nevis Laboratory, Columbia University, Irvington NY; United States of America.
43 Niels Bohr Institute, University of Copenhagen, Copenhagen; Denmark.
44 a Dipartimento di Fisica, Università della Calabria, Rende;b INFN Gruppo Collegato di Cosenza, Laboratori Nazionali di Frascati; Italy.
45 Physics Department, Southern Methodist University, Dallas TX; United States of America.
46 Physics Department, University of Texas at Dallas, Richardson TX; United States of America.
47 a Department of Physics, Stockholm University;b Oskar Klein Centre, Stockholm; Sweden.
48 Deutsches Elektronen-Synchrotron DESY, Hamburg and Zeuthen; Germany.
49 Fakultät Physik, Technische Universität Dortmund, Dortmund; Germany.
50 Institut für Kern- und Teilchenphysik, Technische Universität Dresden, Dresden; Germany.
51 Department of Physics, Duke University, Durham NC; United States of America.
52 SUPA - School of Physics and Astronomy, University of Edinburgh, Edinburgh; United Kingdom.
53 INFN e Laboratori Nazionali di Frascati, Frascati; Italy.
54 Physikalisches Institut, Albert-Ludwigs-Universität Freiburg, Freiburg; Germany.
55 II. Physikalisches Institut, Georg-August-Universität Göttingen, Göttingen; Germany.
56 Département de Physique Nucléaire et Corpusculaire, Université de Genève, Genève; Switzerland.
57 a Dipartimento di Fisica, Università di Genova, Genova;b INFN Sezione di Genova; Italy.
58 II. Physikalisches Institut, Justus-Liebig-Universität Giessen, Giessen; Germany.
59 SUPA - School of Physics and Astronomy, University of Glasgow, Glasgow; United Kingdom.
60 LPSC, Université Grenoble Alpes, CNRS/IN2P3, Grenoble INP, Grenoble; France.
61 Laboratory for Particle Physics and Cosmology, Harvard University, Cambridge MA; United States of America.
62 Department of Modern Physics and State Key Laboratory of Particle Detection and Electronics, University of Science and Technology of China, Hefei; China.
63 a Kirchhoff-Institut für Physik, Ruprecht-Karls-Universität Heidelberg, Heidelberg;b Physikalisches Institut, Ruprecht-Karls-Universität Heidelberg, Heidelberg; Germany.
64Faculty of Applied Information Science, Hiroshima Institute of Technology, Hiroshima; Japan.
65 (a)Department of Physics, Chinese University of Hong Kong, Shatin, N.T., Hong Kong;(b)Department of Physics, University of Hong Kong, Hong Kong;(c)Department of Physics and Institute for Advanced Study, Hong Kong University of Science and Technology, Clear Water Bay, Kowloon, Hong Kong; China.
66Department of Physics, National Tsing Hua University, Hsinchu; Taiwan.
67IJCLab, Université Paris-Saclay, CNRS/IN2P3, 91405, Orsay; France.
68Department of Physics, Indiana University, Bloomington IN; United States of America.
69 (a)INFN Gruppo Collegato di Udine, Sezione di Trieste, Udine;(b)ICTP, Trieste;(c)Dipartimento Politecnico di Ingegneria e Architettura, Università di Udine, Udine; Italy.
70 (a)INFN Sezione di Lecce;(b)Dipartimento di Matematica e Fisica, Università del Salento, Lecce; Italy.
71 (a)INFN Sezione di Milano;(b)Dipartimento di Fisica, Università di Milano, Milano; Italy.
72 (a)INFN Sezione di Napoli;(b)Dipartimento di Fisica, Università di Napoli, Napoli; Italy.
73 (a)INFN Sezione di Pavia;(b)Dipartimento di Fisica, Università di Pavia, Pavia; Italy.
74 (a)INFN Sezione di Pisa;(b)Dipartimento di Fisica E. Fermi, Università di Pisa, Pisa; Italy.
75 (a)INFN Sezione di Roma;(b)Dipartimento di Fisica, Sapienza Università di Roma, Roma; Italy.
76 (a)INFN Sezione di Roma Tor Vergata;(b)Dipartimento di Fisica, Università di Roma Tor Vergata, Roma; Italy.
77 (a)INFN Sezione di Roma Tre;(b)Dipartimento di Matematica e Fisica, Università Roma Tre, Roma; Italy.
78 (a)INFN-TIFPA;(b)Università degli Studi di Trento, Trento; Italy.
79Universität Innsbruck, Department of Astro and Particle Physics, Innsbruck; Austria.
80University of Iowa, Iowa City IA; United States of America.
81Department of Physics and Astronomy, Iowa State University, Ames IA; United States of America.
82 (a)Departamento de Engenharia Elétrica, Universidade Federal de Juiz de Fora (UFJF), Juiz de Fora;(b)Universidade Federal do Rio De Janeiro COPPE/EE/IF, Rio de Janeiro;(c)Instituto de Física, Universidade de São Paulo, São Paulo; Brazil.
83KEK, High Energy Accelerator Research Organization, Tsukuba; Japan.
84Graduate School of Science, Kobe University, Kobe; Japan.
85 (a)AGH University of Krakow, Faculty of Physics and Applied Computer Science, Krakow;(b)Marian Smoluchowski Institute of Physics, Jagiellonian University, Krakow; Poland.
86Institute of Nuclear Physics Polish Academy of Sciences, Krakow; Poland.
87Faculty of Science, Kyoto University, Kyoto; Japan.
88Kyoto University of Education, Kyoto; Japan.
89Research Center for Advanced Particle Physics and Department of Physics, Kyushu University, Fukuoka ; Japan.
90Instituto de Física La Plata, Universidad Nacional de La Plata and CONICET, La Plata; Argentina.
91Physics Department, Lancaster University, Lancaster; United Kingdom.
92Oliver Lodge Laboratory, University of Liverpool, Liverpool; United Kingdom.
93Department of Experimental Particle Physics, Jožef Stefan Institute and Department of Physics, University of Ljubljana, Ljubljana; Slovenia.
94Department of Physics and Astronomy, Queen Mary University of London, London; United Kingdom.
95Department of Physics, Royal Holloway University of London, Egham; United Kingdom.
96Department of Physics and Astronomy, University College London, London; United Kingdom.
97Louisiana Tech University, Ruston LA; United States of America.
98Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Louisville, Louisville, KY; United States of America.
99Fysiska institutionen, Lunds universitet, Lund; Sweden.
100Centre de Calcul de l’Institut National de Physique Nucléaire et de Physique des Particules (IN2P3), Villeurbanne; France.
101Departamento de Física Teorica C-15 and CIAFF, Universidad Autónoma de Madrid, Madrid; Spain.
102Institut für Physik, Universität Mainz, Mainz; Germany.
103School of Physics and Astronomy, University of Manchester, Manchester; United Kingdom.
104CPPM, Aix-Marseille Université, CNRS/IN2P3, Marseille; France.
105Department of Physics, University of Massachusetts, Amherst MA; United States of America.
106Department of Physics, McGill University, Montreal QC; Canada.
107School of Physics, University of Melbourne, Victoria; Australia.
108Department of Physics, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor MI; United States of America.
109Department of Physics and Astronomy, Michigan State University, East Lansing MI; United States of America.
110Group of Particle Physics, University of Montreal, Montreal QC; Canada.
111Fakultät für Physik, Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität München, München; Germany.
112Max-Planck-Institut für Physik (Werner-Heisenberg-Institut), Garching; Germany.
113Nagasaki Institute of Applied Science, Nagasaki; Japan.
114Graduate School of Science and Kobayashi-Maskawa Institute, Nagoya University, Nagoya; Japan.
115(a)Department of Physics, Nanjing University, Nanjing;(b)University of Chinese Academy of Science (UCAS), Beijing; China.
116Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of New Mexico, Albuquerque NM; United States of America.
117Institute for Mathematics, Astrophysics and Particle Physics, Radboud University/Nikhef, Nijmegen; Netherlands.
118Nikhef National Institute for Subatomic Physics and University of Amsterdam, Amsterdam; Netherlands.
119Department of Physics, Northern Illinois University, DeKalb IL; United States of America.
120Department of Physics, New York University, New York NY; United States of America.
121Ochanomizu University, Otsuka, Bunkyo-ku, Tokyo; Japan.
122Ohio State University, Columbus OH; United States of America.
123Faculty of Science, Okayama University, Okayama; Japan.
124Homer L. Dodge Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Oklahoma, Norman OK; United States of America.
125Department of Physics, Oklahoma State University, Stillwater OK; United States of America.
126Palacký University, Joint Laboratory of Optics, Olomouc; Czech Republic.
127Institute for Fundamental Science, University of Oregon, Eugene, OR; United States of America.
128Graduate School of Science, University of Osaka, Osaka; Japan.
129Department of Physics, University of Oslo, Oslo; Norway.
130Department of Physics, Oxford University, Oxford; United Kingdom.
131LPNHE, Sorbonne Université, Université Paris Cité, CNRS/IN2P3, Paris; France.
132Department of Physics, University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia PA; United States of America.
133Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Pittsburgh, Pittsburgh PA; United States of America.
134(a)Laboratório de Instrumentação e Física Experimental de Partículas - LIP, Lisboa;(b)Departamento de Física, Faculdade de Ciências, Universidade de Lisboa, Lisboa;(c)Departamento de Física, Universidade de Coimbra, Coimbra;(d)Centro de Física Nuclear da Universidade de Lisboa, Lisboa;(e)Departamento de Física, Escola de Ciências, Universidade do Minho, Braga;(f)Departamento de Física Teórica y del Cosmos, Universidad de Granada, Granada (Spain);(g)Dep Física and CEFITEC of Faculdade de Ciências e Tecnologia, Universidade Nova de Lisboa, Caparica; Portugal.
135Institute of Physics of the Czech Academy of Sciences, Prague; Czech Republic.
136Czech Technical University in Prague, Prague; Czech Republic.
137Charles University, Faculty of Mathematics and Physics, Prague; Czech Republic.
138Particle Physics Department, Rutherford Appleton Laboratory, Didcot; United Kingdom.
139IRFU, CEA, Université Paris-Saclay, Gif-sur-Yvette; France.
140Santa Cruz Institute for Particle Physics, University of California Santa Cruz, Santa Cruz CA; United States of America.
141 (a)Departamento de Física, Pontificia Universidad Católica de Chile, Santiago;(b)Departamento de Física, Universidad Técnica Federico Santa María, Valparaíso; Chile.
142Universidade Federal de São João del Rei (UFSJ), São João del Rei; Brazil.
143Department of Physics, Institute of Science, Tokyo; Japan.
144Department of Physics, University of Washington, Seattle WA; United States of America.
145Institute of Frontier and Interdisciplinary Science and Key Laboratory of Particle Physics and Particle Irradiation (MOE), Shandong University, Qingdao; China.
146 (a)State Key Laboratory of Dark Matter Physics, School of Physics and Astronomy, Shanghai Jiao Tong University, Key Laboratory of Particle Astrophysics and Cosmology (MOE), SKLPPC, Shanghai;(b)State Key Laboratory of Dark Matter Physics, Tsung-Dao Lee Institute, Shanghai Jiao Tong University, Shanghai; China.
147Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Sheffield, Sheffield; United Kingdom.
148Department of Physics, Shinshu University, Nagano; Japan.
149Department Physik, Universität Siegen, Siegen; Germany.
150Department of Physics, Simon Fraser University, Burnaby BC; Canada.
151SLAC National Accelerator Laboratory, Stanford CA; United States of America.
152Department of Physics, Royal Institute of Technology, Stockholm; Sweden.
153Departments of Physics and Astronomy, Stony Brook University, Stony Brook NY; United States of America.
154Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Sussex, Brighton; United Kingdom.
155School of Physics, University of Sydney, Sydney; Australia.
156Institute of Physics, Academia Sinica, Taipei; Taiwan.
157 (a)E. Andronikashvili Institute of Physics, Iv. Javakhishvili Tbilisi State University, Tbilisi;(b)High Energy Physics Institute, Tbilisi State University, Tbilisi; Georgia.
158Department of Physics, Technion, Israel Institute of Technology, Haifa; Israel.
159Raymond and Beverly Sackler School of Physics and Astronomy, Tel Aviv University, Tel Aviv; Israel.
160Department of Physics, Aristotle University of Thessaloniki, Thessaloniki; Greece.
161International Center for Elementary Particle Physics and Department of Physics, University of Tokyo, Tokyo; Japan.
162Graduate School of Science and Technology, Tokyo Metropolitan University, Tokyo; Japan.
163Department of Physics, University of Toronto, Toronto ON; Canada.
164 (a)TRIUMF, Vancouver BC;(b)Department of Physics and Astronomy, York University, Toronto ON; Canada.
165Division of Physics and Tomonaga Center for the History of the Universe, Faculty of Pure and Applied Sciences, University of Tsukuba, Tsukuba; Japan.
166Department of Physics and Astronomy, Tufts University, Medford MA; United States of America.
167Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of California Irvine, Irvine CA; United States of America.
168Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Uppsala, Uppsala; Sweden.
{sup}169`Department of Physics, University of Illinois, Urbana IL; United States of America.
{sup}170`Instituto de Física Corpuscular (IFIC), Centro Mixto Universidad de Valencia - CSIC, Valencia; Spain.
{sup}171`Department of Physics, University of British Columbia, Vancouver BC; Canada.
{sup}172`Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Victoria, Victoria BC; Canada.
{sup}173`Fakultät für Physik und Astronomie, Julius-Maximilians-Universität Würzburg, Würzburg; Germany.
{sup}174`Department of Physics, University of Warwick, Coventry; United Kingdom.
{sup}175`Waseda University, Tokyo; Japan.
{sup}176`Department of Particle Physics and Astrophysics, Weizmann Institute of Science, Rehovot; Israel.
{sup}177`Department of Physics, University of Wisconsin, Madison WI; United States of America.
{sup}178`Fakultät für Mathematik und Naturwissenschaften, Fachgruppe Physik, Bergische Universität Wuppertal, Wuppertal; Germany.
{sup}179`Department of Physics, Yale University, New Haven CT; United States of America.
{sup}180`Yerevan Physics Institute, Yerevan; Armenia.
{sup}a` Also Affiliated with an institute covered by a cooperation agreement with CERN.
{sup}b` Also at Borough of Manhattan Community College, City University of New York, New York NY; United States of America.
{sup}c` Also at Centre for High Performance Computing, CSIR Campus, Rosebank, Cape Town; South Africa.
{sup}d` Also at CERN, Geneva; Switzerland.
{sup}e` Also at CPPM, Aix-Marseille Université, CNRS/IN2P3, Marseille; France.
{sup}f` Also at Département de Physique Nucléaire et Corpusculaire, Université de Genève, Genève; Switzerland.
{sup}g` Also at Departament de Fisica de la Universitat Autonoma de Barcelona, Barcelona; Spain.
{sup}h` Also at Departamento de Física Teórica y del Cosmos, Universidad de Granada, Granada (Spain); Spain.
{sup}i` Also at Department of Applied Physics and Astronomy, University of Sharjah, Sharjah; United Arab Emirates.
{sup}j` Also at Department of Financial and Management Engineering, University of the Aegean, Chios; Greece.
{sup}k` Also at Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Louisville, Louisville, KY; United States of America.
{sup}l` Also at Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Sheffield, Sheffield; United Kingdom.
{sup}m` Also at Department of Physics, Ben Gurion University of the Negev, Beer Sheva; Israel.
{sup}n` Also at Department of Physics, California State University, East Bay; United States of America.
{sup}o` Also at Department of Physics, California State University, Fresno; United States of America.
{sup}p` Also at Department of Physics, California State University, Sacramento; United States of America.
{sup}q` Also at Department of Physics, King’s College London, London; United Kingdom.
{sup}r` Also at Department of Physics, University of Fribourg, Fribourg; Switzerland.
{sup}s` Also at Department of Physics, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor MI; United States of America.
{sup}t` Also at Dipartimento di Fisica E. Fermi, Università di Pisa, Pisa; Italy.
{sup}u` Also at Giresun University, Faculty of Engineering, Giresun; Türkiye.
{sup}v` Also at Hellenic Open University, Patras; Greece.
{sup}w` Also at Horia Hulubei National Institute of Physics and Nuclear Engineering, Bucharest; Romania.
{sup}x` Also at II. Physikalisches Institut, Georg-August-Universität Göttingen, Göttingen; Germany.
{sup}y` Also at IJCLab, Université Paris-Saclay, CNRS/IN2P3, 91405, Orsay; France.
{sup}z` Also at Institucio Catalana de Recerca i Estudis Avançats, ICREA, Barcelona; Spain.
{sup}aa` Also at Institute for Mathematics, Astrophysics and Particle Physics, Radboud University/Nikhef, Nijmegen; Netherlands.
{sup}ab` Also at Institute for Particle and Nuclear Physics, Wigner Research Centre for Physics, Budapest; Hungary. ac Also at Institute of Particle Physics (IPP); Canada.
ad Also at Institute of Physics, Academia Sinica, Taipei; Taiwan.
ae Also at Institute of Physics, Azerbaijan Academy of Sciences, Baku; Azerbaijan.
af Also at Institute of Theoretical Physics, Ilia State University, Tbilisi; Georgia.
ag Also at LPNHE, Sorbonne Université, Université Paris Cité, CNRS/IN2P3, Paris; France.
ah Also at Manhattan College, New York NY; United States of America.
ai Also at Near East University, Nicosia, North Cyprus, Mersin; Türkiye.
aj Also at Physics Department, An-Najah National University, Nablus; Palestine State.
ak Also at Physikalisches Institut, Albert-Ludwigs-Universität Freiburg, Freiburg; Germany.
al Also at School of Physics, Sun Yat-sen University, Guangzhou; China.
am Also at The City College of New York, New York NY; United States of America.
an Also at The Collaborative Innovation Center of Quantum Matter (CICQM), Beijing; China.
ao Also at TRIUMF, Vancouver BC; Canada.
ap Also at Università di Napoli Parthenope, Napoli; Italy.
* Deceased
References
- [1]C. Balázs, E. L. Berger, P. M. Nadolsky, and C.-P. Yuan, All-orders resummation for diphoton production at hadron colliders, Phys. Lett. B 637 (2006) 235, arXiv: hep-ph/0603037.DOI
- [2]G. Cullen, N. Greiner, G. Heinrich, G. Luisoni, P. Mastrolia, et al., Automated One-Loop Calculations with GoSam, Eur. Phys. J. C 72 (2012) 1889, arXiv: 1111.2034 [hep-ph].DOI
- [3]Z. Bern et al., Next-to-leading order γγ + 2-jet production at the LHC, Phys. Rev. D 90 (2014) 054004, arXiv: 1402.4127 [hep-ph].DOI
- [4]T. Gleisberg et al., Event generation with SHERPA 1.1, JHEP 02 (2009) 007, arXiv: 0811.4622 [hep-ph].DOI
- [5]S. Catani, L. Cieri, D. de Florian, G. Ferrera, and M. Grazzini, Diphoton production at the LHC: a QCD study up to NNLO, JHEP 04 (2018) 142, arXiv: 1802.02095 [hep-ph].DOI
- [6]H. A. Chawdhry, M. Czakon, A. Mitov, and R. Poncelet, NNLO QCD corrections to diphoton production with an additional jet at the LHC, JHEP 09 (2021) 093, arXiv: 2105.06940 [hep-ph].DOI
- [7]DØ Collaboration, V. M. Abazov et al., Measurement of direct photon pair production cross sections in p̄p collisions at √s = 1.96 TeV, Phys. Lett. B 690 (2010) 108, arXiv: 1002.4917 [hep-ex].
- [8]DØ Collaboration, V. M. Abazov et al., Measurement of the differential cross sections for isolated direct photon pair production in p̄p collisions at √s = 1.96 TeV, Phys. Lett. B 725 (2013) 6, arXiv: 1301.4536 [hep-ex].DOI
- [9]CDF Collaboration, T. Aaltonen et al., Measurement of the cross section for prompt isolated diphoton production using the full CDF Run II data sample, Phys. Rev. Lett. 110 (2013) 101801, arXiv: 1212.4204 [hep-ex].DOI
- [10]ATLAS Collaboration, Measurement of the isolated diphoton cross section in pp collisions at √s = 7 TeV with the ATLAS detector, Phys. Rev. D 85 (2012) 012003, arXiv: 1107.0581 [hep-ex].DOI
- [11]ATLAS Collaboration, Measurement of isolated-photon pair production in pp collisions at √s = 7 TeV with the ATLAS detector, JHEP 01 (2013) 086, arXiv: 1211.1913 [hep-ex].DOI
- [12]ATLAS Collaboration, Measurement of the production cross section of pairs of isolated photons in pp collisions at 13 TeV with the ATLAS detector, JHEP 11 (2021) 169, arXiv: 2107.09330 [hep-ex].DOI
- [13]CMS Collaboration, Measurement of the production cross section for pairs of isolated photons in pp collisions at √s = 7 TeV, JHEP 01 (2012) 133, arXiv: 1110.6461 [hep-ex].DOI
- [14]CMS Collaboration, Measurement of differential cross sections for the production of a pair of isolated photons in pp collisions at √s = 7 TeV, Eur. Phys. J. C 74 (2014) 3129, arXiv: 1405.7225 [hep-ex].DOI
- [15]ATLAS Collaboration, Observation of the electroweak production of γγjj at √s = 13 TeV in 140 fb⁻¹ of pp collision data with the ATLAS detector, (2026), arXiv: 2607.25869 [hep-ex].arxiv.org/abs/2607.25869
- [16]ATLAS Collaboration, Measurements of integrated and differential cross sections for isolated photon pair production in pp collisions at √s = 8 TeV with the ATLAS detector, Phys. Rev. D 95 (2017) 112005, arXiv: 1704.03839 [hep-ex].DOI
- [17]ATLAS Collaboration, The ATLAS Experiment at the CERN Large Hadron Collider, JINST 3 (2008) S08003.
- [18]ATLAS Collaboration, Performance of the ATLAS Trigger System in 2010, Eur. Phys. J. C 72 (2012) 1849, arXiv: 1110.1530 [hep-ex].DOI
- [19]ATLAS Collaboration, Luminosity determination in pp collisions at √s = 8 TeV using the ATLAS detector at the LHC, Eur. Phys. J. C 76 (2016) 653, arXiv: 1608.03953 [hep-ex].DOI
- [20]H.-L. Lai et al., New parton distributions for collider physics, Phys. Rev. D 82 (2010) 074024, arXiv: 1007.2241 [hep-ph].DOI
- [21]S. Catani, F. Krauss, B. R. Webber, and R. Kuhn, QCD Matrix Elements + Parton Showers, JHEP 11 (2001) 063, arXiv: hep-ph/0109231.DOI
- [22]T. Sjöstrand, S. Mrenna, and P. Z. Skands, A Brief Introduction to PYTHIA 8.1, Comput. Phys. Commun. 178 (2008) 852, arXiv: 0710.3820 [hep-ph].
- [23]J. Pumplin, D. Stump, J. Huston, H. Lai, P. M. Nadolsky, et al., New generation of parton distributions with uncertainties from global QCD analysis, JHEP 07 (2002) 012, arXiv: hep-ph/0201195 [hep-ph].DOI
- [24]ATLAS Collaboration, Summary of ATLAS pythia 8 tunes, ATL-PHYS-PUB-2012-003, 2012, URL: https://cds.cern.ch/record/1474107.
- [25]P. Nason, A New method for combining NLO QCD with shower Monte Carlo algorithms, JHEP 11 (2004) 040, arXiv: hep-ph/0409146.DOI
- [26]S. Frixione, P. Nason, and C. Oleari, Matching NLO QCD computations with Parton Shower simulations: the POWHEG method, JHEP 11 (2007) 070, arXiv: 0709.2092 [hep-ph].DOI
- [27]P. Golonka and Z. Was, PHOTOS Monte Carlo: A Precision tool for QED corrections in Z and W decays, Eur. Phys. J. C 45 (2006) 97, arXiv: hep-ph/0605026.
- [28]ATLAS Collaboration, The ATLAS Simulation Infrastructure, Eur. Phys. J. C 70 (2010) 823, arXiv: 1005.4568 [physics.ins-det].DOI
- [29]S. Agostinelli et al., GEANT4 – a simulation toolkit, Nucl. Instrum. Meth. A 506 (2003) 250.DOI
- [30]ATLAS Collaboration, Performance of the ATLAS Electron and Photon Trigger in pp Collisions at √s = 7 TeV in 2011, ATLAS-CONF-2012-048, 2012, URL: https://cds.cern.ch/record/1450089.
- [31]ATLAS Collaboration, Measurement of the photon identification efficiencies with the ATLAS detector using LHC Run-1 data, Eur. Phys. J. C 76 (2016) 666, arXiv: 1606.01813 [hep-ex].DOI
- [32]ATLAS Collaboration, Electron and photon energy calibration with the ATLAS detector using LHC Run 1 data, Eur. Phys. J. C 74 (2014) 3071, arXiv: 1407.5063 [hep-ex].DOI
- [33]ATLAS Collaboration, Measurement of Higgs boson production in the diphoton decay channel in pp collisions at center-of-mass energies of 7 and 8 TeV with the ATLAS detector, Phys. Rev. D 90 (2014) 112015, arXiv: 1408.7084 [hep-ex].DOI
- [34]ATLAS Collaboration, Measurement of the inclusive isolated prompt photon cross section in pp collisions at √s = 7 TeV with the ATLAS detector, Phys. Rev. D 83 (2011) 052005, arXiv: 1012.4389 [hep-ex].DOI
- [35]ATLAS Collaboration, Topological cell clustering in the ATLAS calorimeters and its performance in LHC Run 1, Eur. Phys. J. C 77 (2017) 490, arXiv: 1603.02934 [hep-ex].DOI
- [36]M. Cacciari, G. P. Salam, and S. Sapeta, On the characterisation of the underlying event, JHEP 04 (2010) 065, arXiv: 0912.4926 [hep-ph].DOI
- [37]M. Cacciari, G. P. Salam, and G. Soyez, The Anti-kt jet clustering algorithm, JHEP 04 (2008) 063, arXiv: 0802.1189 [hep-ph].DOI
- [38]ATLAS Collaboration, Jet energy measurement with the ATLAS detector in proton–proton collisions at √s = 7 TeV, Eur. Phys. J. C 73 (2013) 2304, arXiv: 1112.6426 [hep-ex].DOI
- [39]ATLAS Collaboration, Performance of pile-up mitigation techniques for jets in pp collisions at √s = 8 TeV using the ATLAS detector, Eur. Phys. J. C 76 (2016) 581, arXiv: 1510.03823 [hep-ex].DOI
- [40]J. C. Collins and D. E. Soper, Angular distribution of dileptons in high-energy hadron collisions, Phys. Rev. D 16 (1977) 2219.DOI
- [41]G. Bohm and G. Zech, Introduction to statistics and data analysis for physicists, Hamburg: Verl. Dt. Elektronen-Synchrotron, 2010, ISBN: 978-3-935702-41-6.
- [42]ATLAS Collaboration, Electron efficiency measurements with the ATLAS detector using 2012 LHC proton–proton collision data, Eur. Phys. J. C 77 (2017) 195, arXiv: 1612.01456 [hep-ex].DOI
- [43]A. Höcker and V. Kartvelishvili, SVD approach to data unfolding, Nucl. Instrum. Meth. A 372 (1996) 469, arXiv: hep-ph/9509307 [hep-ph].
- [44]ATLAS Collaboration, Jet energy measurement and its systematic uncertainty in proton–proton collisions at √s = 7 TeV with the ATLAS detector, Eur. Phys. J. C 75 (2015) 17, arXiv: 1406.0076 [hep-ex].DOI
- [45]ATLAS Collaboration, Determination of jet calibration and energy resolution in proton–proton collisions at √s = 8 TeV using the ATLAS detector, Eur. Phys. J. C 80 (2020) 1104, arXiv: 1910.04482 [hep-ex].DOI
- [46]S. Dulat et al., New parton distribution functions from a global analysis of quantum chromodynamics, Phys. Rev. D 93 (2016) 033006, arXiv: 1506.07443 [hep-ph].DOI
- [47]S. Frixione, Isolated photons in perturbative QCD, Phys. Lett. B 429 (1998) 369, arXiv: hep-ph/9801442.DOI
- [48]F. Febres Cordero, Private communication, We thank Fernando Febres Cordero for providing us the BlackHat theoretical predictions and for his advice, 2017.
- [49]A. Buckley et al., Rivet user manual, Comput. Phys. Commun. 184 (2013) 2803, arXiv: 1003.0694 [hep-ph].DOI
- [50]Bothmann, Enrico and others, Event Generation with Sherpa 2.2, SciPost Phys. 7 (2019) 034, arXiv: 1905.09127 [hep-ph].DOI
- [51]NNPDF Collaboration, R. D. Ball, et al., Parton distributions for the LHC run II, JHEP 04 (2015) 040, arXiv: 1410.8849 [hep-ph].
- [52]R. D. Ball et al., The PDF4LHC21 combination of global PDF fits for the LHC Run III, J. Phys. G 49 (2022) 080501, arXiv: 2203.05506 [hep-ph].DOI
- [53]N. Greiner et al., Phenomenological analysis of Higgs boson production through gluon fusion in association with jets, JHEP 01 (2016) 169, arXiv: 1506.01016 [hep-ph].DOI
- [54]N. Greiner, Private communication, We thank Nicolas Greiner for providing us the GoSam theoretical predictions and for his advice, 2017.
- [55]ATLAS Collaboration, ATLAS Computing Acknowledgements, ATL-SOFT-PUB-2026-001, 2026, URL: https://cds.cern.ch/record/2952666.
















