WorksMathematics
Uniform restriction lower bounds and nongeodesic common nodal curves in integrable systems
Abstract
We construct a family of real analytic metrics on the two-torus, for which a fixed embedded nongeodesic circle is a nodal component of infinitely many real Laplace eigenfunctions. The examples address a question asked by Bourgain-Rudnick \cite{BR11}, and give a negative answer to the question asked by Toth-Zelditch \cite{TZ21} and Han \cite{Han}: whether a curve shared by infinitely many nodal sets must be geodesic. To explain the restriction obstruction, we prove uniform lower bounds for joint eigenfunctions of quantum completely integrable (QCI) systems under transverse crossing and isolation of a tangential characteristic branch, then extend to multi-branch setting. The results are used to characterize the possible joint nodal curves in the Liouville tori, narrowing down the choices. Finally, the counterexample realizes one possibility for which cancellation happens exactly on a nongeodesic curve.
Introduction and main results
A fixed curve can occur in the nodal sets of eigenfunctions at arbitrarily large eigenvalues. On a flat two-torus, a theorem of Bourgain–Rudnick says that a real analytic curve has this property precisely when it is a segment of a closed geodesic [5 Theorem 1.1]. Does the same geometric rigidity hold on a general analytic surface? Toth–Zelditch raise this question in their discussion of nodal curves [16 §1.3 of the arXiv version]; it is also formulated in Han’s problem notes [10 Problem 4.9].
We give an explicit negative answer. One fixed analytic metric, with no nonzero Killing field, admits a fixed embedded nongeodesic circle which is a regular nodal component of an infinite sequence of real joint eigenfunctions. The construction persists within an explicit family converging to a flat metric. Thus analyticity or the absence of continuous symmetries do not guarantee that the common nodal curves is a geodesic segment.
The nongeodesic counterexample
A fixed curve can occur in the nodal sets of eigenfunctions at arbitrarily large eigenvalues. A fixed curve can occur in the nodal sets of eigenfunctions at arbitrarily large eigenvalues. Fix a metric and a curve. Call a fixed curve persistent if it is contained in the nodal sets of eigenfunctions with eigenvalues tending to infinity.
Theorem 1.1 (A nongeodesic common nodal circle). On , let and set
There are distinct eigenvalues and real -normalized eigenfunctions such that
is a regular connected component of every nodal set . If
then and . The metric has no nonzero Killing vector field, and the signed geodesic curvature of the oriented circle (2)
In particular, the common nodal circle is not a geodesic. Moreover, in as .
The analytic part of the paper identifies the relevant obstruction. Restriction records the tangential component of a characteristic covector. If a branch with positive joint Liouville mass is isolated by this tangential projection and crosses the hypersurface transversely, a microlocal Cauchy estimate gives a uniform restriction lower bound. Distinct branches with the same tangential covector can instead cancel. Our example realizes this cancellation exactly on a nongeodesic curve. The general restriction theorem, its extension to disconnected fibers, and the explicit construction therefore give complementary information about persistent nodal sets.
The winding numbers of are . Formula (3) distinguishes a coordinate straight line from a geodesic of the metric. Its curvature is nonzero on open arcs, so even such arcs can be shared by infinitely many nodal sets.
The proof in Section 7 uses nonreal Floquet multipliers for a one-dimensional weighted eigenvalue problem. The same scalar solutions, inserted at two different coordinate scales, give exact joint eigenfunctions with a common phase front. The restriction theorem below supplies necessary geometric conditions for persistence, while the construction shows that the nongeodesic alternative can occur.
Restriction on a regular joint torus
Let be a compact smooth manifold without boundary, of dimension , equipped with a smooth positive density. Let
be commuting self-adjoint operators whose full symbols have the form , with real and the lower-order symbols uniformly bounded in the appropriate symbol classes. Assume that is uniformly semiclassically elliptic of order two. Write
We assume that is a regular value, so on the compact joint fiber. Each connected component is a Lagrangian torus by the Liouville–Arnold theorem. Consider normalized exact joint eigenfunctions
The customary assumption is included. Allowing convergence without a specified rate is justified by the parameter-dependent local construction in Section 2.
Let be a compact smooth embedded hypersurface, possibly with boundary; all patches below lie in its interior. For a local defining function , set
An isolated transverse point means the following. There is an index with , a sufficiently small neighborhood of , and an open set containing such that
Here is chosen so that, in coordinates , and is a single graph in . Thus (5) excludes competing points of the entire joint fiber over the selected tangential window. This definition is independent of the choice of defining function and coordinates.
Theorem 1.2 (Restriction on a connected regular joint fiber). Assume that is connected and that has an isolated transverse point on . Then the joint eigenfunctions (4) satisfy
for all sufficiently small .
In particular, the hypotheses hold if is injective on and some Hamiltonian flow crosses transversely there. The local formulation (5) is sufficient because a single open flow box has positive normalized Liouville measure on a connected joint torus.
Finite fibers and the geometry of persistence
The rotating joint fiber of a Liouville torus has four connected components. To apply the restriction argument to this model, each component must have an observable patch.
Theorem 1.3 (Restriction on finitely many joint tori). Suppose that is a compact regular joint fiber. Assume that every component contains an isolated transverse point over , with isolation always understood relative to the full fiber as in (5). Then (6) holds for every normalized sequence (4).
The components may carry unknown and sequence-dependent proportions of the mass. The proof in Section 6 uses the decomposition of a defect measure into normalized Liouville measures on the finitely many components.
For a Liouville metric and a rotating joint energy , write and . The four tangential momenta at a nonzero curve tangent are
They are distinct precisely when
Theorem 1.3 therefore gives a restriction lower bound near any such point. Its contrapositive forces every connected persistent joint nodal curve to follow one of the four line fields
Section 6 proves this rigidity statement and its consequences: a fixed contractible closed curve cannot persist in a compact rotating window, a closed noncoordinate persistent curve requires an action resonance, and restriction on a curve with a separating point determines an exact joint eigenfunction stably.
The circle of Theorem 1.1 follows one of the permitted phase fronts. Its action resonance is . Along the circle, two distinct transverse characteristic branches have the same tangential covector and their traces cancel. This realizes the obstruction to Theorem 1.3. The same local Cauchy estimate determines the quantum limit of the constructed real sequence: it is the equal mixture of Liouville measures on the two cancelling components (Proposition 7.3). Because its full joint fiber has four components, we retain a separate spherical example in Section 5 which demonstrates the necessity of branch isolation within the connected-fiber setting of Theorem 1.2.
Related results and organization
Upper restriction bounds for Laplace eigenfunctions were established by Burq–Gérard–Tzvetkov [3]; for a hypersurface the general bound is . In the quantum integrable surface setting, Toth obtained logarithmic bounds for suitable curves [13]. Bourgain–Rudnick proved uniform toral restriction estimates [4, 5]. Quantum ergodic restriction provides lower bounds along suitable subsequences under dynamical and asymmetry assumptions [15, 6], and Galkowski–Zélditch studied lower bounds for Cauchy data on negatively curved surfaces [9]. Here the joint equations provide invariance under all commuting Hamiltonian flows, and isolation of a tangential branch prevents cancellation.
The construction in Theorem 1.1 concerns a single fixed curve at infinitely many eigenvalues of a single metric. Prescribed-nodal-set results for individual eigenfunctions, such as [7], address an interesting yet different question. Common curved hypersurfaces in higher-dimensional flat tori already arise from products [5 §1.2]; our result concerns a closed surface. The underlying Liouville framework is standard [8], and the exact construction uses elementary Floquet theory. The geometric conclusion is the failure of geodesic rigidity even for analytic metrics without Killing fields arbitrarily close to a flat metric.
Sections 2 and 3 prove the local Cauchy estimate and Theorem 1.2. Sections 4 and 5 retain the nodal-intersection application and spherical examples. Sections 6 and 7 contain the finite-component extension and rigidity consequences, and the exact nongeodesic counterexample and its interpretation.
Disclaimer on AI usage
This paper uses generative AI models. Precisely, we used ChatGPT 6 Astra, Deepseek V4.1-Flash for the mathematical part and the writing, checking and graphing. Some other AI models are used in a nonessential way during the writing. Of course, the authors are responsible for the correctness of the whole content of this paper.
Acknowledgements
The first author is supported by the research project funded by Wuhan University of Technology (Grant No. 202601hx0314).
Both authors would like to thank Prof. John Toth and Prof. Long Jin for helpful discussions relating to this work.
A microlocal Cauchy estimate
We first prove a local estimate which does not require the joint fiber to be connected. Its constants are uniform for the joint energy in a sufficiently small fixed neighborhood of . In particular, convergence is sufficient; no estimate on its rate is needed.
We use two consequences of joint ellipticity. For joint eigenfunctions with energy in a fixed bounded neighborhood of , elliptic regularity gives uniform bounds in every semiclassical Sobolev space and a fixed compact microlocalization:
Moreover, a compact microlocal cutoff supported where annihilates to , uniformly when the separation constant is uniform. These assertions follow by applying an elliptic parametrix to ; see, for example, [19]. Here and below an remainder has all the Sobolev bounds required for restriction. For a compactly microlocalized operator we will use
In local coordinates this follows from Cauchy–Schwarz in the bounded semiclassical normal-frequency variable.
Choose an isolated transverse point as in the hypothesis of Theorem 1.2. Write , with , and choose so that near . Shrinking the tangential window and the selected neighborhood if necessary, we may arrange that their relevant closures are compact. The isolation hypothesis then persists for all sufficiently close to : every point of
lies in the selected noncharacteristic neighborhood. Indeed, a contrary sequence has a convergent subsequence by joint ellipticity and would produce a competing point of the full fiber at . This argument uses the isolation of the entire joint fiber, not just one of its connected components.
All coordinate calculations below are made in Lebesgue measure. If the ambient density is , conjugate locally by . The conjugated operators have the same principal symbols and uniformly bounded subprincipal symbols. The restriction of differs from the natural density realization of by a smooth positive multiplication operator. Thus the coordinate estimates give the stated estimates in the original norms. Spatial cutoffs are taken equal to one on a larger neighborhood of the chosen flow box; their errors are microlocally negligible in the smaller neighborhoods used below.
Factorization at the actual energy
The following noncharacteristic reduction is the usual first-order evolution factorization; compare [2, 12, 19]. We include its subprincipal construction because it is important for the size of the evolution error.
Lemma 2.1 (Uniform parameter-dependent factorization). For in a sufficiently small neighborhood of , there exist , elliptic in the selected neighborhood, and a tangential family such that
microlocally there. Here and, after the compact microlocal cutoffs, is uniformly bounded on ; it may be taken in . The tangential symbol is
and
uniformly in and .
Proof. The implicit function theorem, applied with the parameter , gives
All symbols and their derivatives are uniform on fixed smaller neighborhoods. Write the full Weyl symbol of as and set . With the convention , the first Weyl correction is
Define
The function vanishes on , so smooth division gives
Taking , the Weyl product satisfies
This proves (11). Extend as a real tangential symbol, using fixed cutoffs outside the working neighborhood. The real principal symbol and the bounded subprincipal term give (12). In particular, the construction factors itself: the quantity never occurs. □
Propagation and comparison with Dirichlet data
Proposition 2.2 (Local Cauchy estimate). At an isolated transverse point there are a fixed , a uniformly bounded tangential operator , a neighborhood of , and constants such that
for every exact joint eigenfunction , , and . The principal symbol of is supported in and equals one near . The symbol equals one on a nonempty relatively open flow box in through .
Proof. Write and in this proof, and initially take . Choose , equal to one near . On the transversal choose a compact cutoff
in the selected neighborhood, where near the graph over for all . Extend along the flow. Multiplying by a longitudinal cutoff outside a larger fixed slab produces such that
All supports lie inside the factorization neighborhood in this slab. The number is fixed independently of and .
Set and . The commutator formula and (14) give
This is a localized statement: the principal commutator vanishes in the slab, whereas the derivatives of the longitudinal cutoff are outside it. Insert nested cutoffs in the normal variable
before applying Lemma 2.1. Pseudolocality makes the separated cutoff errors in the inner slab, and hence
The real tangential principal symbol and (12) give the energy estimate
One may obtain this directly by differentiating ; the skew-adjoint part contributes at most . Consequently,
We next compare the localized trace with the original Dirichlet data. Define the tangential symbol
and let . Smooth division in the selected neighborhood gives
Choose a compact microlocal cutoff supported in that neighborhood and equal to the identity near the relevant support of at and near every point of (10) over . Joint ellipticity and the absence of competing branches give
For the second equality, only the tangentially localized restriction is being discarded outside the selected neighborhood. To justify it, first use (8); the restriction relation then retains precisely the ambient covectors over . Those on the joint fiber lie where is the identity, and the remaining compact set is uniformly joint elliptic. This also proves the asserted after taking the trace.
Quantizing (17), with nested compact microlocal cutoffs, gives
where and are uniformly bounded and compactly microlocalized. Importantly, the cutoff state need not solve the homogeneous equation to order . Instead,
on the support needed in (19). The commutator is , which is sufficient. Applying (9) to (19) and then (18) yields
After undoing the density conjugation this is the same assertion with a uniformly bounded tangential operator of principal symbol .
Finally choose equal to one near zero and set . Then
Equations (16) and (20) prove (13). This last cutoff makes the estimate global on . The construction makes on a small flow box through . Homogeneity restores the factor in the error term.
The connected-fiber restriction theorem
We recall explicitly the invariant-measure argument, so that its use of connectedness and its lack of a nonresonance assumption are clear.
Lemma 3.1 (The joint semiclassical measure). Suppose is compact, connected, and regular. Every semiclassical measure of normalized joint eigenfunctions with is the normalized Liouville measure on . In particular, for each fixed compactly supported symbol ,
Proof. Compact microlocalization (8) ensures that every subsequence has a further subsequence with a semiclassical measure of total mass one. The joint equations and put its support in . Self-adjointness and the commutator identity give
Thus is invariant under all commuting Hamiltonian flows. At a regular point their vector fields are independent and span . In Liouville–Arnold angle coordinates they generate all translations of the connected torus. Their only invariant probability measure is normalized Haar measure, namely . This is the connected-fiber form of the standard joint-measure description in [14]. Every convergent subsequence has this same limit, proving (21) for the original family. □
Proof of Theorem 1.2. Apply Proposition 2.2 at the isolated transverse point. Transversality implies that a small relatively open patch through that point has a flow tube
which is open in . The cutoff in the proposition can be chosen equal to one on a smaller such tube. Consequently,
Lemma 3.1 gives for sufficiently small . On the other hand, (13) bounds this norm by . Absorbing the last term proves the asserted positive lower bound. □
Corollary 3.2 (Conditional restriction bounds). In the setting of Theorem 1.2, assume in addition that is compact and an independent estimate gives for the normalized family. Then, for every ,
Proof. The upper bounds follow from the assumed sup-norm estimate. For use
For , Hölder’s inequality and the lower bound give the result. □
Remark 3.3 (Connectedness and nonresonance). No arithmetic nonresonance assumption is used: invariance under all flows already forces Haar measure on a connected regular fiber. For a disconnected regular fiber, invariant probability measures can distribute their mass among its torus components. The local estimate above remains valid on an isolated sheet; the additional issue is whether every possible component carrying mass is detected by the restriction.
Remark 3.4 (Turning boundaries). The transverse hypothesis cannot hold at a smooth one-sided boundary of the projected torus. Indeed, suppose locally , with and . At , every flow stays on . The function has a local minimum at zero, and hence for every . Thus a lower-bound problem at such a turning hypersurface requires an argument other than the noncharacteristic Cauchy estimate used here.
Sign changes from restriction lower bounds
The restriction estimate has a nodal consequence when combined with decay of period integrals. For a complex-valued eigenfunction, it is preferable to count sign changes of its real and imaginary parts separately: the union of their zero sets is the entire curve if either part vanishes identically.
For a continuous real-valued function on a parametrized compact arc , let be the supremum of the integers for which there are parameters in satisfying for . We set and allow the value . For functions with isolated zeros this is the usual number of sign changes.
Whenever a square root of the Laplacian is used below, its symbol is understood near the positive joint energy. A smooth spectral modification at low energy puts it in the global semiclassical calculus without changing the eigenfunctions under consideration.
Proposition 4.1 (A sign-change criterion). Let be a fixed compact smooth arc, and let be continuous complex-valued functions on . Suppose that
and that every nontrivial compact subarc in the interior of satisfies
Then
In particular, if the functions are real-valued, their number of sign changes tends to infinity.
Proof. Fix an integer and choose pairwise disjoint nontrivial compact subarcs in the interior of . The first condition in (4.2) and (4.1) imply, for each , that
for all sufficiently small . If neither real nor imaginary part takes both positive and negative values on , then each has a constant weak sign there. Consequently,
contradicting (4.4). Thus each contributes a sign transition of at least one of the two parts. Since the arcs are disjoint, the sum in (4.3) is at least for all sufficiently small . The integer was arbitrary. □
We next give hypotheses under which the three estimates in the proposition follow from results on joint eigenfunctions. In this paragraph is a surface, , and the limiting first energy is . For a geodesic segment parametrized by arclength , set
The admissibility condition of Wang–Wu [17 Definition 1], applied to the moment map , is
for some . Here differentiates at fixed cotangent components in Fermi coordinates along , with the arclength coordinate. This condition is a separate assumption; it does not follow from the noncharacteristic crossing condition of Theorem 1.2.
Corollary 4.2 (Nodal intersections on admissible geodesic segments). Assume the connected regular joint-fiber and joint-eigenvalue hypotheses of Theorem 1.2, with a surface, , , and . Let be a compact embedded geodesic segment. Suppose that
every point of belongs to ;
on ;
is injective;
satisfies (26).
Then every normalized joint eigenfunction family in that theorem satisfies
For real-valued joint eigenfunctions this is a conclusion about the sign changes of itself.
Proof. At any point , the two vectors and span by the fiber-rank assumption. Therefore at least one of the two Hamiltonian vector fields crosses at this point. The first and third hypotheses allow us to apply Theorem 1.2 to every nontrivial compact subarc . We obtain
The fiber-rank hypothesis also gives
Indeed, after joint elliptic localization to a neighborhood of the joint fiber, the rank-one pointwise estimate on the energy circle gives this bound on a neighborhood of each point of ; see [18 Theorem 1 and the second assertion of Theorem 2]. Compactness of makes the constant uniform. The rank condition here is imposed on all characteristic lifts over , rather than merely on one of its branches.
Every fixed subsegment inherits (26). Since and , [17 Theorem 2] applies and yields
Proposition 4.1 now applies to . □
Remark 4.3. This proof uses unweighted periods over finitely many fixed subsegments, as stated in [17]; it does not require a weighted extension of that theorem. The constants in (28) are allowed to depend on . Consequently the argument gives qualitative divergence and does not, by itself, give a uniform power-law lower bound for the number of sign changes. This is the same comparison between absolute mass and signed periods that underlies nodal arguments such as [11].
Spherical harmonics and the necessity of branch isolation
The sphere illustrates the connected-fiber restriction theorem and shows why crossing alone is insufficient, even when the full joint fiber is connected. Equip with the round metric
and consider
These operators commute, and their principal symbols are
The normalized complex spherical harmonics are joint eigenfunctions, where is a real multiple of .
Fix , put , and choose an integer nearest to . Then, for all sufficiently large , and
Thus the joint eigenvalues obey the energy-window condition. The limiting joint fiber is
It is a compact connected regular Lagrangian torus: the two signs of join at the two turning latitudes. Its projection is
Meridian restriction
Let be a nontrivial compact interval strictly inside , and let . For the local defining function , one has
The latter map is injective on the joint fiber. Therefore Theorem 1.2 gives
for all sufficiently large . The fiber-rank condition also holds over , so the local pointwise bound is uniform there. These are nonturning-region estimates; the different behavior at the turning latitudes is described, for example, in [1].
For completeness, the real meridian restriction has order sign changes on . Set . The associated Legendre equation gives the exact equation
The coefficient in parentheses is bounded above and below by positive constants on for all large . Sturm comparison with constant positive coefficients therefore bounds the number of zeros in above and below by constant multiples of , up to additive constants. Every such zero is simple, by uniqueness for the second-order equation, and is consequently a sign change. This conclusion follows directly from the separated equation and does not require admissibility in the sense of (26).
Cancellation on the equator
Consider instead and . On the same connected regular joint torus,
Thus a commuting Hamiltonian already crosses the equator at every characteristic lift. If crossing by the second operator is desired, one can equally use
This replacement preserves the joint fiber, with limiting energy .
Now choose to be an integer nearest to among the integers satisfying odd. The distance to that parity class is at most one, so (29) remains valid. The identity
implies
The failure of branch isolation is explicit:
Both normal branches have the same tangential covector, and their restrictions cancel exactly. Hence a noncharacteristic crossing cannot replace branch isolation in Theorem 1.2. This obstruction occurs on a single connected regular torus, independently of the additional issue of distributing mass among several components of a joint fiber.
Finite joint fibers and rigidity of persistent nodal curves
The local Cauchy estimate also applies when the full regular joint fiber has several connected components. This extension is useful for Liouville metrics, whose rotating joint fibers consist of four tori. We first prove the extension stated in Theorem 1.3, and then use it to classify the curves on which exact joint eigenfunctions can vanish persistently. The lower bounds in this section follow from the microlocal argument of the paper; separation of variables will be used only for a uniform upper bound.
Detecting every component of a regular fiber
Proof of Theorem 1.3. Write the compact regular fiber as
Each component is a compact Liouville torus. Let be its normalized Liouville measure. Joint ellipticity and the normalization of imply that every semiclassical defect measure is a probability measure supported on . Invariance under all the commuting Hamiltonian flows, which span the tangent space of each component, gives
The weights need not be known and may depend on the subsequence.
For each , choose the transverse point and tangential window supplied by the theorem. Shrink the window and the transverse patch so that their closures lie in the original neighborhoods. The isolation hypothesis concerns preimages in the entire fiber: no other sheet, whether in or in another component, has a tangential covector in this smaller window. Applying Proposition 2.2, with the transverse Hamiltonian chosen for this component, gives a cutoff in a small flow tube such that
We choose the support disjoint from the other components and the cutoff nonzero on an open subset of . Consequently,
All cutoffs and constants can be chosen for nearby joint energies, as in the local estimate. In particular, convergence suffices here.
If the asserted restriction lower bound failed, a sequence with and would have a subsequence with defect measure (6.1). Equation (35) would then imply, for every ,
Since , every would vanish, contradicting their sum being one. This proves the theorem without a condition selecting a component or prescribing its mass.
Corollary 6.1 (Uniformity in the joint energy). Suppose that the geometric hypotheses of Theorem 1.3 hold at . There are a neighborhood of and constants such that every exact joint eigenfunction satisfying
obeys
The same conclusion holds with replaced by a fixed small patch containing the transverse points used in the hypothesis.
Proof. Otherwise, choosing successively smaller energy neighborhoods and smaller upper bounds on , one could find normalized exact joint eigenfunctions with
The proof just given applies to this sequence and yields a contradiction. For a patch, choose all the local Cauchy cutoffs over that patch. Uniformity of their estimates follows by factoring at the actual nearby energy: the transverse derivative remains bounded away from zero, and the tangential windows continue to exclude the other sheets after shrinking. No estimate of by is required. □
Remark 6.2. A transverse isolated patch on only one component does not suffice for a lower bound on arbitrary normalized joint eigenfunctions: that component can have weight zero in (34). Requiring such a patch on every component is what removes the need to determine the weights. The example in Theorem 1.1 will fail precisely at this point: the two components carrying the cancelling waves have the same tangential covectors along the common nodal curve.
The four branches of a Liouville metric
Let and let
where are real smooth periodic functions. The commuting operators
are self-adjoint on their natural domains in . Their semiclassical principal symbols are
For and , define the exact joint eigenspace
We work in the rotating interval
which is nonempty because . For , put
The full joint fiber is the disjoint union of the four graph tori
They are regular, since
For completeness, these second-order differential operators fit the first-order framework of the main theorem by setting
They commute and are self-adjoint, with real principal symbols
The symbol map has invertible differential. The space (39) is therefore exactly the joint eigenspace at energy for (43), and its classical fiber is (42).
Let be a smooth regular curve. A point of with nonzero tangent is called separating at energy if
This is independent of the regular parametrization. Indeed, the four tangential covectors in (42) are represented by
and they are pairwise distinct exactly when (44) holds.
Lemma 6.3 (Restriction near a separating point). Suppose that (44) holds at a point of at energy . There are a fixed compact subarc , an open interval containing , and constants such that
Curve norms are taken with respect to metric arclength.
Proof. At the specified point, choose four disjoint neighborhoods of the tangential covectors (45). Shrinking the base arc makes each neighborhood isolate its sheet from the entire four-component fiber. On each branch, the vectors span the base tangent space. If is a local defining function for the curve, at least one of is therefore nonzero. The transverse Hamiltonian may depend on the branch, which is permitted in Theorem 1.3. Thus every component has a transverse isolated patch over the same short arc. Apply Corollary 6.1 to the system (43). This proves the estimate for all nearby . □
We will also use the following elementary upper bound. Its proof is included to keep the subsequent stability assertion independent of additional pointwise estimates.
Lemma 6.4 (Uniform upper bound in a rotating window). For every compact , there are such that
Proof. The identities and give
On a fixed coordinate period, each scalar equation has exact independent solutions with uniform expansions
where , , and the errors are in , uniformly for . To verify this elementary WKB estimate, the substitution , gives
The solution with initial data , satisfies
Boundedness of and Gronwall’s inequality give the asserted expansion; the equation is identical in form.
Every solution of both equations in (48) has an exact representation
Indeed, expand first in the basis; its two coefficient functions must solve the equation. The scalar basis functions themselves need not be periodic. Their Gram matrices on a full coordinate period have positive diagonal entries bounded away from zero and off-diagonal entries : integration by parts applies to the leading off-diagonal phases because are bounded away
from zero. Hence the tensor-product Gram matrix, together with the positive bounds on , gives
The basis functions are uniformly bounded, so this coefficient estimate proves (47). □
Persistent curves and stable restriction
Define the closed nowhere-zero one-forms
A phase front is a leaf of or . Locally, it is a level curve of ; these primitives need not be single-valued on the torus. All curves below are fixed independently of .
Proposition 6.5 (Rigidity of persistent nodal curves). Let be a connected smooth embedded regular curve. Suppose that normalized exact joint eigenfunctions satisfy
Then is contained in a leaf of exactly one of the four foliations
In particular, it is a coordinate curve or a phase front of the limiting joint energy. If is closed, it is a closed leaf.
Proof. A separating point at the limiting energy would, by Lemma 6.3, give a fixed subarc on which the restriction norms of are bounded below for all large . This contradicts their vanishing. Thus, at every point of a regular parametrization ,
These are precisely the four tangent lines in (50). Since , the four lines are distinct at every point. The continuous tangent line of therefore selects a locally constant label, which is constant because is connected. Uniqueness for integral curves of the resulting smooth line field places in one leaf. A closed embedded curve tangent to that field is itself a closed leaf. □
Corollary 6.6 (A contractible closed curve cannot persist). Let be a fixed smooth embedded contractible closed curve and let be compact. There are such that
In particular, cannot be a persistent nodal component in this rotating window.
Proof. Fix . If had no separating point, the line-field argument in the preceding proof would make it a closed leaf of one of (50). Coordinate leaves are noncontractible. On a phase-front leaf,
Regularity implies that neither nor vanishes; both have constant sign. For a parametrization by and a lift , its winding numbers therefore satisfy
Such a leaf is also noncontractible, a contradiction. Hence a separating point exists at every . Apply Lemma 6.3 at these points and take a finite subcover of their energy neighborhoods. The minimum of the finitely many lower-bound constants and frequency thresholds gives (51). □
Corollary 6.7 (Action resonance for closed noncoordinate curves). Under the hypotheses of Proposition 6.5, suppose that is closed and noncoordinate. Define the positive actions
The winding numbers of satisfy and, for one fixed sign,
Consequently . If this action ratio is irrational, every smooth embedded closed persistent nodal curve is a coordinate circle.
Proof. By Proposition 6.5, the curve is a leaf of for one sign. The preceding proof shows that . Integrating its annihilating one-form and using periodicity gives
which proves the assertions. □
Remark 6.8. The phase coordinates
identify the torus with a rectangular torus of side lengths and . Its phase fronts become . Thus the resonance is exactly the condition for these leaves to close. It is necessary for persistence of a closed noncoordinate curve, but does not itself construct an exact eigenfunction vanishing on a chosen leaf.
Proposition 6.9 (Stable uniqueness from restriction). Let be a fixed compact smooth embedded regular curve, possibly with boundary, and let . Suppose that has a separating point for every . There are such that
Restriction is therefore injective on each such joint eigenspace, with a uniformly bounded inverse on its range. In particular, for in the same ,
Proof. The finite-cover argument using Lemma 6.3 proves the lower estimate uniformly on . Lemma 6.4 gives the upper estimate because
Finally, belongs to the same exact joint eigenspace, so the lower estimate applied to this difference gives (55). □
These statements allow every vector in a joint eigenspace, including linear combinations when the joint eigenvalue has multiplicity. They concern exact joint eigenfunctions in a regular rotating window; no assertion is made for arbitrary Laplace eigenfunctions, or for differences of functions with different joint eigenvalues. The construction in the next section realizes one of the noncoordinate phase fronts permitted by Proposition 6.5, and shows that this exceptional foliation need not consist of geodesics.
A nongeodesic common nodal circle
We now construct the exceptional noncoordinate phase front allowed by § 6. The existence argument is exact and independent of the restriction lower bound. The final calculation identifies the transverse branches whose traces cannot be separated.
The Floquet construction
Let be a nonconstant smooth function with period , where is an integer. Let be relatively prime positive integers with . On , set
and define
The operators commute and are formally self-adjoint for .
Proposition 7.1 (Matching separated equations). For the metric (56), there exist real normalized joint eigenfunctions with
at distinct eigenvalues, for which
is a regular connected nodal component. This embedded circle has winding and signed geodesic curvature
It is not a geodesic, and has no nonzero Killing field. If is real analytic, so are the metric and the eigenfunctions.
Proof. The twisted one-dimensional problem. Put and consider the operator
on . It is associated with the closed quadratic form on the twisted domain. Since , the boundary terms cancel; the operator is self-adjoint. Compactness of the form-domain embedding gives compact resolvent. The only constant function obeying the boundary condition is zero, so is strictly positive. Choose eigenpairs at distinct eigenvalues
Extend by . The matching values and derivatives, together with the differential equation, give a smooth global solution. It is -periodic because .
The multiplier is nonreal, so and are independent solutions: otherwise they would have the same multiplier, whereas . Their nonzero Wronskian gives a constant nonzero current
In particular, never vanishes.
Exact joint eigenfunctions and the common component. Define the real, doubly periodic function
Equation (60) yields
Consequently,
Along (58), both arguments in (62) equal , and hence
Coprimality of makes (58) embedded. The implicit function theorem and compactness give a tubular neighborhood in which its nodal set is exactly this circle. Thus it is a regular connected component of the full nodal set. Normalize in to obtain . Distinct eigenvalues make the normalized functions orthogonal. Analyticity follows from the analytic differential equation when is analytic.
Geodesic curvature. Write and orient the curve by increasing . Its Euclidean unit tangent and left normal are
For a conformal metric , the signed geodesic curvature is
Here , while on the curve
Substitution proves (59). Since and is nonconstant, this curvature is not identically zero.
Absence of Killing fields. If is a Killing field, the trace-free parts of give
Thus are harmonic periodic functions and hence constants. The remaining equation becomes
Integrating first in and then in , and using that is not identically zero, gives . □
Proof of Theorem 1.1. Apply Proposition 7.1 with , , , and . Positivity follows from . Formula (59) becomes (3). □
Why the choices matter. The small period makes a nonreal Floquet multiplier into a periodic solution on the original circle. The factors exactly compensate for differentiating and . Matching their arguments along produces cancellation for every , while removes geodesicity. Finite translation symmetries remain, but there is no nonzero Killing field; the persistence mechanism is the matching of scalar equations. Since the common curve is not geodesic, it cannot be a curve fixed pointwise by a nontrivial isometric reflection.
Remark 7.2 (A simpler example with a Killing field). The broad existence phenomenon also has a one-variable version. For and any with , rephase each of the same Floquet solutions so that is real. Then satisfies , and is a regular nodal circle because . Its geodesic curvature has magnitude . This direct comparison explains why the additional features of Proposition 7.1 matter: it removes the Killing field, makes the curve noncoordinate, and places the joint sequence in a rotating energy window.
Action resonance and transverse branch cancellation
For (56), the energy lies in the rotating interval . With , the constructed sequence lies in . Its full joint fiber has the four graph components (42), so the finite-component formulation of Section 6 is the appropriate one.
Along , the one-form
annihilates the tangent. Thus the common nodal circle is a phase front of the kind allowed by Proposition 6.5. If
periodicity and change of variables give
The winding therefore satisfies the resonance of Corollary 6.7. Resonance closes the phase front; the Floquet construction supplies exact eigenfunctions vanishing on it.
The failure of the restriction hypothesis is particularly transparent in Theorem 1.1. On , put , so . The four covectors restricted to the tangent give
The mixed branches are distinct in , but both have zero tangential covector. They cannot be separated by a pseudodifferential cutoff on the curve. For the local defining function and the Laplace symbol , these same branches satisfy
Both flows cross the curve transversely. The obstruction is therefore the coincidence of tangential covectors, despite nonzero geodesic curvature and transverse Hamiltonian crossing. The two same-sign branches remain individually observable; the next proposition uses the Cauchy estimate to show that they carry no limiting mass in this sequence.
The distinction from § 5 should be kept explicit. The spherical example violates branch isolation on one connected torus. Here the cancellation occurs between two components of a four-component regular fiber. It exhibits failure of the hypothesis that every component be detectable in Theorem 1.3.
The quantum limit selected by the common nodal curve
The local Cauchy estimate determines the semiclassical distribution of the constructed eigenfunctions, although the full joint fiber is disconnected. This gives a direct application of the restriction method to the example, without requiring asymptotic information about its Floquet eigenfunctions.
Proposition 7.3 (A unique limit on two components). Let be the real normalized eigenfunctions of Proposition 7.1, and put . Denote by the normalized Liouville measure on the graph torus in (6.9). Then the full sequence has the unique semiclassical measure
In particular, for every ,
The same conclusion holds for any sequence of real normalized functions in , with , that vanishes identically on .
Proof. Write for the principal symbol of . The joint equations and ellipticity imply that any subsequential defect measure is supported on . Invariance under both commuting Hamiltonian flows gives
as in (6.1). We show that the common zero curve determines these weights.
Along one has
The four tangential momenta are therefore
The and branches each have a unique, nonzero tangential covector, whereas the two mixed branches both restrict to zero. Thus a short arc has tangential windows isolating the and sheets from the entire fiber. In a coordinate neighborhood of this arc, use the defining function , up to an additive constant. On the two isolated branches,
Both are nonzero because . The first-order symbol has the same transversality. Proposition 2.2 therefore supplies cutoffs and in flow tubes on the corresponding components such that
Choose each cutoff nonzero on an open part of its torus and supported away from the other components. Passing to the defect measure gives
The integrals are positive, hence .
Since the functions are real, their defect measure is invariant under time reversal . This follows by conjugating a pseudodifferential observable; its principal symbol is changed from to . The map exchanges and and sends their normalized Liouville measures to one another. Thus . Their sum is one, proving (67). Every subsequential defect measure has been identified with the same probability measure, so the entire sequence converges. The proof uses only reality, the joint equations, and the zero trace, which also proves the final assertion. □
Remark 7.4 (The spatial limit). The limit has positive spatial density everywhere, despite exact vanishing on the fixed circle. Set
On each graph torus the absolute Jacobian is
Thus the unnormalized joint Liouville density is , and the projection of its normalization is
Consequently,
This positive spatial limit is compatible with exact nodality because the two remaining branches have indistinguishable tangential covectors and their traces cancel.
Geometry of the explicit example
For , the conformal factor ranges from 5 to 15. The curvature in (3) vanishes only at and is nonzero on the intervening arcs. Figure 1 and Figure 2 display the geometry and one eigenfunction. The three-dimensional drawing records the topology; the metric and curvature are specified by their formulas, not by an embedding in Euclidean space.
Figure 1. The analytic metric and its common nodal circle . Top left: a coordinate fundamental square; the two red segments join to one circle. Top right: the winding on a topological torus. Bottom: the signed geodesic curvature.
Figure 2. A numerical member of the exact family for , rescaled for display. The scalar eigenfunction is computed in the twisted Fourier basis , with eigenvalue approximately .
References
School of Mathematics and Statistics, Wuhan University of Technology, Wuhan, Hubei, China
Email address: [email protected]
Department of Mathematics and Statistics, McGill University, Montréal, Quebec, Canada
Email address: [email protected]
References
- [1][BDWZ12] N. Burq, S. Dyatlov, R. Ward, and M. Zworski, Weighted eigenfunction estimates with applications to compressed sensing, SIAM J. Math. Anal. 44 (2012), no. 5, 3481–3501.
- [2][BGT04] N. Burq, P. Gérard, and N. Tzvetkov, The Cauchy problem for the nonlinear Schrödinger equation on compact manifolds, in Phase space analysis of partial differential equations, Vol. I, Publ. Cent. Ric. Mat. Ennio Giorgi, Scuola Norm. Sup., Pisa, 2004, 21–52.DOI
- [3][BGT07] N. Burq, P. Gérard, and N. Tzvetkov, Restrictions of the Laplace–Beltrami eigenfunctions to submanifolds, Duke Math. J. 138 (2007), no. 3, 445–486.
- [4][BR09] J. Bourgain and Z. Rudnick, Restriction of toral eigenfunctions to hypersurfaces, C. R. Math. Acad. Sci. Paris 347 (2009), no. 21–22, 1249–1253.arxiv.org/abs/0907.4824
- [5][BR11] J. Bourgain and Z. Rudnick, On the nodal sets of toral eigenfunctions, Invent. Math. 185 (2011), no. 1, 199–237. doi:10.1007/s00222-010-0307-2; arXiv:1003.1743.DOI
- [6][DZ13] S. Dyatlov and M. Zworski, Quantum ergodicity for restrictions to hypersurfaces, Nonlinearity 26 (2013), no. 1, 35–52.DOI
- [7][EPS15] A. Enciso and D. Peralta-Salas, Eigenfunctions with prescribed nodal sets, J. Differential Geom. 101 (2015), no. 2, 197–211. arXiv:1404.1039.arxiv.org/abs/1404.1039
- [8][GT20] J. Galkowski and J. A. Toth, Pointwise bounds for joint eigenfunctions of quantum completely integrable systems, Comm. Math. Phys. 375 (2020), 915–947. doi:10.1007/s00222-020-03730-3.DOI
- [9][GZ21] J. Galkowski and S. Zelditch, Lower bounds for Cauchy data on curves in a negatively curved surface, Israel J. Math. 244 (2021), no. 2, 971–1000.arxiv.org/abs/2002.09456
- [10][Han] X. Han, Problems, online seminar notes, §4.1.5, Problem 4.9, p. 61, undated. https://www.csun.edu/~xiaolong/Han_Pblm.pdf (accessed 16 October 2026).
- [11][JZ16] J. Jung and S. Zelditch, Number of nodal domains and singular points of eigenfunctions of negatively curved surfaces with an isometric involution, J. Differential Geom. 102 (2016), no. 1, 37–66.arxiv.org/abs/1310.2919
- [12][KTZ07] H. Koch, D. Tataru, and M. Zworski, Semiclassical Lᵖ estimates, Ann. Henri Poincaré 8 (2007), no. 5, 885–916.
- [13][Tot09] J. A. Toth, L²-restriction bounds for eigenfunctions along curves in the quantum completely integrable case, Comm. Math. Phys. 288 (2009), no. 1, 379–401.
- [14][TZ03] J. A. Toth and S. Zelditch, Norms of modes and quasi-modes revisited, in Harmonic analysis at Mount Holyoke (South Hadley, MA, 2001), Contemp. Math., vol. 320, Amer. Math. Soc., Providence, RI, 2003, 435–458.
- [15][TZ13] J. A. Toth and S. Zelditch, Quantum ergodic restriction theorems: manifolds without boundary, Geom. Funct. Anal. 23 (2013), no. 2, 715–775.DOI
- [16][TZ21] J. A. Toth and S. Zelditch, Nodal intersections and geometric control, J. Differential Geom. 117 (2021), no. 2, 345–393. doi:10.4310/jdg/1612975018. The geodesicity question cited here is in §1.3, p. 12, of arXiv:1708.05754v1 (2017).DOI
- [17][WW] W. Wang and X. Wu, Average estimate for eigenfunctions along geodesics in the quantum completely integrable case, arXiv:2506.15992v2 (2026).arxiv.org/abs/2506.15992
- [18][WXb] X. Wu and X. Xiao, Trace estimates and improved pointwise bounds for joint eigenfunctions, arXiv:2604.22197 (2026).arxiv.org/abs/2604.22197
- [19][Zwo12] M. Zworski, Semiclassical analysis, Graduate Studies in Mathematics, vol. 138, Amer. Math. Soc., Providence, RI, 2012.

