In this paper
AbstractElasticized magnetic energySoft vacuum barrierModel formulationThe potential energy is norm-CoerciveExistence theoryDiscussionReferencesWorksPhysics and Astronomy
Elasticized magnetohydrostatics
Abstract
The modern approach to modeling equilibria in stellarators features two blind spots: lack of foundational agreement between theory and computation, and inability to reliably explore economically-attractive high- concepts. These blind spots originate at a technical level from lack of a useful existence theory for the partial differential equations believed to describe equilibria, and from the encumbrance of crude, inflexible models for the topology of the confining magnetic field. This Article proposes the first stellarator equilibrium model that rigorously guarantees existence of an equilibrium with any chosen magnetic topology. It completely separates determination of the magnetic topology from the equilibrium existence question, and thereby enables importing realistic tearing physics into equilibrium computations. The new model replaces the standard plasma potential energy functional with its ensemble average over rapid kinetic-scale fluctuations. Averaging ``elasticizes" the potential by energetically penalizing separation of field lines. The elasticized potential's super-linear dependence on plasma strain embodies a phenomenological model for profile stiffness, and plays an essential role in the existence theory.
Significance. The design of stellarator fusion reactors requires solving an optimization problem in a very high dimensional space. Analytical theory is meant to serve as a light that guides optimizers through this formidable design space. But it partially fails in this respect due to foundational disagreements between theory and computation and incomplete coverage of high-pressure operation regimes. This work proposes a new framework for modeling steady-state stellarator configurations that repairs the disconnect between theory and computation, and unlocks high-pressure reactor design.
Stellarator fusion is advancing rapidly, driven by the success of Wendelstein 7-X (1) and growing private investment [4, 5] [2, 3]. A central challenge for a stellarator fusion pilot plant is the ability to reliably predict and optimize three-dimensional stellarator equilibria, including the magnetic field and plasma pressure . However, the current approach to equilibrium modeling features two blind spots: lack of foundational agreement between theory and computation, and inability to reliably explore economically-attractive high- concepts. Here denotes the ratio of plasma pressure to magnetic energy density – a number that quantifies how efficiently the magnetic field confines the plasma fuel. These blind spots originate at a technical level from lack of a useful existence theory for the magnetohydrostatics (MHS) equations,
and from the encumbrance of crude, inflexible models for the topology of the confining magnetic field. These blind spots limit the ability of theory to guide design optimization, which is essential for development of a viable fusion pilot plant.
Theory contradicts computation — Notable disagreements between theory and computation touch upon various foundational questions in stellarator confinement. Assuming MHS, Garren-Boozer [6] argued quasisymmetric (QS) stellarator equilibria cannot exist. Using VMEC, Landreman-Paul [8] identified numerical equilibria with precise QS in the entire plasma volume. Assuming MHS, Cary-Shasharina [9, 10] show analytic omnigenity (OM) implies QS. Using VMEC, Goodman et al. [11] find vacuum fields (automatically analytic!) with precise OM and significant deviations from QS. More broadly, the theory of tearing modes predicts smooth current density across rational flux surfaces, while equilibrium computations routinely reveal singular current densities in the same locations [12].
Disagreements between theory and computation of stellarator equilibria plausibly originate from lack of a useful MHS existence theory. In the 1960s Harold Grad recognized severe mathematical difficulties posed by these equations in non-symmetric plasma containers. He conjectured [13, 14, 15] non-existence of smooth solutions with nested flux surfaces. Recent counterexamples [16, 17] show that Grad’s conjecture is false. However, a more practical weakening of Grad’s conjecture still stands. It asserts smooth MHS solutions fail to exist for generic plasma boundary shape and profile functions. A significant body of computational work [12, 18] supports the weakened conjecture. Moreover, the recent counterexamples fall far short of addressing the weakened conjecture because they only include finite-dimensional families of plasma boundary shapes. In spite of the plausible truth of a weakened Grad conjecture, most of stellarator confinement theory continues to assume MHS is actually satisfied in a stellarator. This creates a potential for vacuous theoretical claims and predictions. On the other hand, codes like VMEC do not actually solve the MHS equations. Instead they solve implicitly-defined resolution-dependent regularizations of the MHS model. This sets up ideal conditions for vacuous theoretical predictions manifesting as contradictions between theory and computation.
The mathematical difficulties identified by Grad may not implicate the MHS model per se, but rather the assumption of nested flux surfaces. There is some rigorous mathematical support for this perspective. Bruno-Laurence [19] found nearly-axisymmetric MHS solutions comprising nested toroidal annula in which the magnetic field is Beltrami. Their solutions suffer jump discontinuities across toroidal interfaces, but generally contain magnetic islands and chaos [20]. The equilibrium code SPEC [21] computes this sort of equilibrium in domains far from axisymmetry, where the Bruno-Laurence theory does not apply. More recently, Constantin-Pasqualotto [22] showed that a particular form of magnetic relaxation, similar in spirit to methods implemented in some iterative equilibrium solvers [23, 24, 25], produces non-trivial MHS solutions in any domain. While all of these results are suggestive, they fail to provide a useful MHS existence theory for stellarators. The Bruno-Laurence solutions have only been rigorously established in nearly-axisymmetric domains, and numerical evidence [26] suggests they need not exist in strongly non-axisymmetric domains. While the Constantin-Pasqualotto solutions do exist in stellarator-relevant domains, their suitability for stellarator confinement remains shrouded in mystery. The existence theory does not show these configurations support a sufficient volume of flux surfaces to realistically achieve burning plasma conditions.
Elusive high- designs — Higher field strengths translate to larger magnetic coils, which translates to much higher construction costs. High- stellarator designs therefore generally make more efficient use of their applied magnetic field. But most design optimization studies use fast nested-surface equilibrium solvers like VMEC [7] or DESC [27, 28] inside of the optimization loop. These solvers are doomed to fail sufficiently close to the so-called equilibrium -limit [29, 30], where flux surfaces degrade without triggering an ideal MHD instability. Conditioned on the assumption of piecewise Beltrami fields, the high impact of allowing for non-nested magnetic topology during design optimization with was demonstrated directly [31] through use of the SPEC in place of VMEC or DESC. If the piecewise-Beltrami assumption was known to accurately reproduce the true tearing physics [32, 33, 34, 35] that governs magnetic topology in stellarators, these results would indicate SPEC offers the key to high- design. However, no existing stellarator equilibrium model, including SPEC, faithfully reproduces tearing physics due to pervasive use of crude magnetic topology models. High- designs remain elusive.
The crude nature of current approaches to equilibrium magnetic topology modeling is reflected in the most widespread simulation tools used for stellarator equilibrium modeling. The codes VMEC [7] and DESC [27, 28] assume the plasma-region magnetic field is tangent to concentric toroidal flux surfaces. This assumption is reasonable in low- configurations, but is known to fail at larger [29, 30, 36, 37]. Starting in the late 1980s, the potential for non-nested magnetic topologies in stellarators motivated development of non-nested 3D equilibrium solvers. Iterative solvers, such as PIES [38, 39], SIESTA [40], HINT2 [25], and MRX [41] introduce physically-motivated relaxation effects that numerically generate magnetic islands and chaos, usually starting from a nested initial guess. Other solvers like SPEC [21] and SPECTRE [42] target weak solutions of MHS by extending the rigorous Bruno-Laurence construction [19] to strongly-shaped domains [26]. Iterative schemes do not actually simulate the tearing physics responsible for island formation and saturation. Instead they introduce numerical expedients with questionable physics fidelity. In solvers based on Bruno-Laurence theory, the field in between toroidal interfaces is necessarily Beltrami. This leads to a correct topology model only when all ideal constraints except helicity between interfaces are removed. Potential issues with these crude modeling choices are only compounded by their central, inflexible role in the underlying simulation algorithms. For example, users may not freely specify the embedded topology model in any of these codes, even if a better model is available.
A new approach — This Article proposes the first rigorous energy minimization principle for stellarator equilibria with user-specified magnetic topology. Due to its close connections with the theory of hyperelasticity, this equilibrium modeling framework will be referred to as elasticized magnetohydrostatics.
The Article begins by appealing to physics beyond ideal MHD to address a major technical hurdle in minimizing the standard plasma potential energy due to Newcomb [43]: lack of coercivity. § 1 argues that “elasticizing” Newcomb’s magnetic energy by including the mean energy of kinetic-scale magnetic fluctuations improves the functional’s growth properties. This argument extends those used to formulate a related equilibrium model in Ref. [44]. § 2 then argues further that combining the elasticized magnetic energy with a modified thermodynamic internal energy eliminates all apparent obstacles to coercivity. The modified internal energy differs from the usual ideal gas internal energy by a soft vacuum barrier that energetically penalizes excessive rarefaction. Based on the observations from § 1 and § 2, § 3 presents a precise mathematical formulation of elasticized magnetohydrostatics that defines equilibria as minimizers of a modified potential energy functional. As with Newcomb’s variational principle, this model fixes the underlying magnetic topology by specifying a reference magnetic field. Unlike Newcomb’s model, the potential energy functional is the sum of the modified internal energy from § 2 and the elasticized magnetic energy from § 1. Refining the heuristic arguments from § 1 and § 2, § 4 rigorously proves coercivity of the elasticized potential energy functional. Leveraging the coercivity property and analytical techniques developed in the context of elasticity theory, § 5 applies the direct method in the calculus of variations to prove existence of minimizers for the modified potential in the Sobolev space , comprising back-to-labels maps [45] with gradients that lie in . Here the exponent is set by the nonlinear response of magnetic fluctuations to large-scale plasma deformations. Notably, Theorem 2 provides a minimum potential energy state for any specified magnetic topology whatsoever, including nested, islanded, and chaotic configurations. We are not aware of any comparable results in the literature.
By allowing a user complete freedom to specify equilibrium magnetic topology, as illustrated in Figure 1, elasticized magnetohydrostatics successfully separates magnetic topology modeling from the equilibrium existence problem. It is therefore the first stellarator equilibrium model that provides a direct interface to sophisticated magnetic topology models based on real tearing physics. It also comes equipped with the first useful existence theory for equilibria in the sense that inputs to their existence theorem directly describe essential features of the solution.

Figure 1. Reference (a) and computed (b) field-line Poincaré map using elasticized magnetohydrostatics. Two simulations are compared left-to-right in each figure, differing only by the user-specified magnetic topology. The left simulation features a single integrable island chain, while the right features overlapping and island chains. Euler-Lagrange equation residuals are in each case.
Elasticized magnetic energy
In Newcomb’s variational formulation of ideal MHD [43], the plasma configuration space comprises diffeomorphisms , where denotes the plasma container and denotes a reference plasma container. The diffeomorphism is known as a back-to-labels map because its value , , denotes the location of the fluid parcel currently located at if the entire plasma were moved into its reference configuration. Newcomb’s potential energy is therefore a functional of , whose specific form is given by
where the magnetic field, mass density, and entropy are given in terms of the back-to-labels map according to
Here denotes the matrix whose columns are the partial derivatives of at , denotes the matrix adjugate, and , , denote the magnetic field, the mass density, and the entropy in the plasma’s reference configuration. The fact that , , and are treated as fixed fields in Newcomb’s potential energy functional reflects imposition of frozen-in magnetic flux, mass density, and entropy, respectively. Since the formula indicates the magnetic flux -form in is the pullback of the magnetic flux -form in , all topological features of the magnetic field are encoded in .
Newcomb’s potential energy functional is mathematically problematic because it fails to be coercive, which is a property that many rigorous applications of the calculus of variations rely upon [46]. The functional would be coercive if whenever , where denotes a suitable norm on the function space containing . This function space and its associated norm will be described in detail in § 3. For now it is enough to assume measures both values of and its first derivative .
Lack of coercivity for Newcomb’s functional can be understood heuristically as follows. Consider a -parameter family of back-to-labels maps , with parameter . Suppose that on a subregion of with volume the derivative matrix is given by
while elsewhere . Now choose any . The -norm of the derivative matrix scales with according to
In particular, the -norm of the gradient tends to as . Since the internal energy is bounded as . Coercivity of Newcomb’s functional would therefore require as . To assess whether this actually happens, first note that the adjugate matrix in the region where is large is given by
By the quadratic dependence of on the magnetic energy therefore grows no faster than a constant as . This shows that Newcomb’s potential cannot control any -norm of the derivative matrix with , a particularly dramatic failure of coercivity. The one-parameter family is an escape sequence. (Note that there is no need to consider because then does not define a norm.)
Lack of coercivity is not a necessary condition for existence of minimizers for , as demonstrated by the single-variable function . So it is not fair to infer at this stage that Newcomb’s potential energy functional lacks minimizers in some suitable function space. At the same time, since ideal MHD omits a great deal of important plasma physics [47] it is also not necessary to settle for Newcomb’s potential energy as the only plausible variational description of 3D equilibria. There may be room for improving the coercivity properties of Newcomb’s potential energy by including additional physics effects.
Newcomb’s form of the magnetic energy can be improved by recognizing that real stellarators sustain rapid electromagnetic turbulent fluctuations [48] that contribute to the plasma stress tensor. Here “rapid” refers to a timescale much shorter than the equilibrium evolution timescale. Building on Ref. [44], the argument proceeds as follows. Fluctuations of the true magnetic field generally break the frozen-in flux condition. The reference magnetic field
which would be time-independent in ideal MHD, therefore varies rapidly in time. Suppose averages over the fast time scale can be replaced with ensemble averages defined by some probability measure . Since changes in the equilibrium generally alter the statistics of gyrokinetic turbulence, this probability measure must depend parametrically on the back-to-labels map . The time average of the magnetic energy then simplifies according to
where the one-point mean and variance of the reference magnetic field are given by
These expressions entail functional integration over the space of reference magnetic fields. Replacing with improves on Newcomb’s magnetic energy by incorporating the effects of nonideal electromagnetic fluctuations.
The first term in Eq. (2) represents the magnetic energy stored in the mean magnetic field. The second term gives the excess magnetic energy associated with fluctuations about the mean. Both the energy of the mean field and the excess energy generally exhibit a complicated -dependence due to the presence of expectations over the probability measure . Deducing the precise form of this -dependence from first principles likely lies beyond the reach of analytical methods. However, there is a plausible functional form motivated by simple phenomenological arguments.
In a stellarator the amplitude of turbulent magnetic fluctuations is small compared to the mean field. It is therefore reasonable to expect that the mean magnetic energy reduces to the usual ideal MHD form in the limit of vanishing fluctuations. Thus, to leading order in the fluctuation strength the mean reference field is independent of . Denote this -independent reference field . Higher-order corrections to the mean reference field correspond to fluctuation-driven dynamo effects [49, 50]. This work ignores these effects. These considerations completely determine the functional form of the energy of the mean field.
Next consider the excess energy. The instantaneous magnetic energy is proportional to the plasma strain along the reference magnetic field; components of the strain transverse to the reference field make no energetic contribution. See the left panel in Figure 2. In ideal MHD, where the reference field does not change, the plasma therefore behaves as a directed elastic medium. But as the reference field fluctuates it changes direction, activating other components of the slowly-evolving strain tensor. Therefore, from the perspective of an observer on a timescale much longer than the fluctuation timescale, fluctuations produce an effective undirected (although anisotropic) elastic potential energy. See the right panel in Figure 2. This explains the origin and basic physics interpretation of the excess energy term. Its functional dependence on is determined by considering the one-point magnetic variance , which is discussed next.
Figure 2. (Left) Instantaneously, magnetic energy can be viewed as elastic potential energy stored in field lines, shown as unconnected lines of springs. (Right) Averaging over nonideal turbulent fluctuations produces an effective, undirected elasticity effect, shown schematically as additional springs connecting neighboring field lines.
Stellarators empirically display a phenomenon known as profile stiffness [51, 52, 53], whereby increasing plasma profile gradients beyond a threshold causes the rate of change of turbulent heat flux with profile gradients to sharply increase. Several previous studies [54, 55, 56] indicate that, for large enough profile gradients, steeper heat flux is accompanied by larger amplitude turbulent fluctuations. Assuming critical balance, asymptotic scaling laws for the amplitude of electrostatic turbulence as a function of profile gradients have been obtained [54, 56]. Although similar scaling laws have yet to be derived for electromagnetic fluctuations, these results suggest that the variance of turbulent magnetic fluctuations also grows with profile gradients when those gradients exceed some threshold. These observations suggest a particular form for the excess energy.
The literature on profile stiffness generally assumes the magnetic field has nested flux surfaces and that the “profiles” are constant on those surfaces. Supposing flux surfaces are level sets of some function , the profiles therefore have the form , where is a single-variable function. Since for some reference flux function it follows that gradients of are proportional to according to
This result, in conjunction with assumed validity of the profile stiffness picture above, implies that the should be an increasing function of plasma strain. For suppose that increases. Since is bounded below by the gradient norm must eventually increase as well. Again invoking the assumed rapid fluctuations in the reference magnetic field, increasing causes the RMS profile gradient, , to increase. Profile stiffness then implies that the amplitude of magnetic fluctuations must increase. Thus, the magnetic variance should be an increasing function of . This result applies literally to nested magnetic topologies; in what follows it will be assumed the result remains valid in non-nested topologies. Detailed study of gyrokinetic fluctuation statistics in non-nested topologies remains a largely open area of research.
A simple model that embodies this rough physics picture decomposes the excess energy as the sum of a term linear in and a homogeneous superlinear term. The linear term corresponds to the magnetic variance in the reference configuration. It is reasonable to assume is uniformly positive definite. The homogeneous superlinear term generally depends on a higher-degree reference tensor field. But under the simplifying assumption that the nonlinear term merely renormalizes the linear term, the following phenomenological model for the mean magnetic energy emerges,
Here is an exponent that sets the homogeneous degree of the nonlinearity, is a characteristic magnetic variance above which the nonlinearity becomes important, the fields , , denote the mean reference magnetic field and the reference magnetic variance, and denotes the effective magnetic energy density. The parameters and should be fit to the results of high-fidelity microturbulence simulations in various device configurations. The mean reference magnetic field should be determined by a suitable magnetic topology model. The reference magnetic variance should be determined by requiring the magnetic variance predicted by the equilibrium model agrees with the magnetic variance predicted by a gyrokinetic turbulence model.
When Newcomb’s magnetic energy in Eq. (1) is replaced by in Eq. (3) the one-parameter family introduced earlier ceases to be an escape sequence. The magnetic energy instead scales as as . Thus, including the excess energy of magnetic fluctuations simultaneously improves the physics fidelity of the equilibrium model and improves the potential energy functional’s growth properties.
Soft vacuum barrier
Including excess magnetic energy does not achieve coercivity by itself. The following argument constructs an escape sequence for Newcomb’s potential with excess magnetic energy included. Let and note . Consider a 1-parameter family of back-to-labels maps with parameter . Suppose that on a subregion of with volume the derivative matrix is given by
Elsewhere the derivative matrix is . Now choose any . The -norm of the derivative matrix scales with according to
In particular, the -norm of the gradient tends to as . Coercivity of Newcomb’s functional with excess magnetic energy included would therefore require as . To assess whether this actually happens, first note that the adjugate matrix and the Jacobian determinant in the region where is large are given by
By the superlinear dependence of on the magnetic energy therefore scales according to
Moreover, since and is bounded the internal energy tends to 0 as . This shows that the one-parameter family is an escape sequence for for any .
The origin of this escape sequence is failure of the internal energy or the modified magnetic energy to energetically penalize excessive rarefaction in thin regions. Very small densities are a well-known problem in MHD fluid modeling, especially in the high-energy-density plasma simulation community. When low densities become problematic it has become standard practice to introduce a density floor. A recent take on this idea [57] is described by Farmer et. al.. In addition, in the context of stellarator equilibrium modeling there is little evidence to suggest excessive rarefaction actually happens in reactor-relevant configurations. This all suggests that modifying the internal energy functional so that it sharply penalizes excessive rarefaction is practical, mathematically convenient, and physically harmless.
It is in this spirit that the equilibrium model proposed in this work exchanges the standard ideal gas internal energy with the modified internal energy , where is given by
Here denotes the adiabatic index, denotes a characteristic entropy-dependent pressure, and denotes a (constant, positive) characteristic mass density. The positive constants and control the strength and mass density scale for the vacuum barrier; decreasing mass density below incurs an energy cost proportional to . The barrier abruptness is controlled by the exponent . Eventually there will be a further constraint on , but for now it is sufficient to assume . Note that is manifestly non-negative. Also note that the vacuum barrier term ensures above is no longer an escape sequence.
It will become clear in § 4 that the pair of modifications to Newcomb’s potential, and , together produce a coercive potential energy functional.
Model formulation
Let denote a compact region in with boundary. Denote the volume of as , which gives the interpretation of a characteristic domain length scale. Let denote the (real) linear space of functions such that the -norm of and its first derivative are each finite. Eventually the analysis will select a specific -value. For now it suffices to assume , which ensures in particular that elements of have continuous representatives. If denotes the matrix whose columns equal the partial derivatives of at , is equivalent to and , where denotes the standard Euclidean norm on and denotes the Frobenius norm on matrices. For the allowed range of , it is a well-known fact that is a reflexive Banach space. Of the many possible equivalent norms on this work uses
which has the benefit of being dimensionless. Let denote another region in -diffeomorphic to . Let be the subset of comprising maps that satisfy the three conditions
BL1:
BL2:
BL3:
Note that BL3 is known as the Ciarlet-Nečas [58] condition in the field of nonlinear elasticity. Also note that the upper bound in BL3 exists because is continuous for , which implies is measurable. The set serves as a viable fluid configuration space for the plasma. Note that in the complement of are not valid back-to-labels maps because all fluid parcel labels must be contained in the reference spatial domain .
Elasticized magnetohydrostatics — The potential energy is the elasticized Newcomb potential defined as the sum of the elasticized magnetic energy given in Eq. (3) and the modified internal energy given in Eq. (5). The following provides a detailed specification of the energy functional in terms of a potential energy density .
Let denote the space of symmetric matrices. Let , , , and be fixed fields defined over the reference domain . The reference fields will always satisfy the following assumption.
Assumption 1. Each of the reference fields , , , is . In addition for some vector potential , is uniformly positive definite, and is positive pointwise.
Remark 1. The field need not be tangent to , but Assumption 1 does allow for it. Tangency of to is a common confinement modeling assumption, but it will play no role in the rigorous existence theory.
The elasticized potential energy density is given by
where and are defined in Eq. (5) and Eq. (4). Note that both and depend on the reference fields. The corresponding elasticized potential energy is
Elasticized magnetohydrostatics defines equilibria as follows.
Definition 1. A back-to-labels map is an equilibrium if it is a minimizer for . Equivalently, is an equilibrium if, for every , .
Remark 2. The definition 1 defines equilibria in the model as ground states for the potential energy. The energy functional may therefore have local minima not labeled as equilibria by the definition. As stated, the results proved in this work concerning regularity of equilibria do not apply to local minima that are not global minima. Generically one expects a single global minimizer, and therefore a unique equilibrium. However, there may be special model inputs (domain boundary and reference fields) that produce multiple global minimizers.
The potential energy is norm-Coercive
It is clear from the definition of that for all , as would be expected for a physical energy. In fact satisfies a much stronger positivity property known as coercivity when is appropriately related to the vacuum and variance exponents, .
Theorem 1. Suppose . Then the functional is -norm-coercive. In fact, there are -independent positive constants such that for each
Remark 3. Since is strictly less than either or it follows that the Theorem’s hypothesis requires, in particular, and . The vacuum barrier is artificial, so making it more narrow by increasing is desirable. On the other hand, since the amplitude scaling of electromagnetic fluctuations with supercritical profile gradients remains an open question, it is possible that is unrealistic. This represents a genuine weakness of the rigorous results presented here. However, numerical experiments in § 6 suggest this is a weakness in the analytical methods used to obtain the results, rather than a weakness in the model itself.
Proof. Let and let denote its weak derivative. The coercivity inequality Eq. (7) is trivially satisfied if . So assume that . This implies that the modified internal energy must be finite, which in turn implies that for almost all .
Observe that if is any invertible matrix then its Frobenius norm is bounded from above according to
where denotes the adjugate of . Let be real numbers that satisfy . By Eq. (8) and Hölder’s inequality the -norm of satisfies
Now by the definition Eq. (5) of the modified internal energy density and non-negativity of the modified magnetic energy density,
where denotes the maximum reference mass density. By assumed continuity and point-wise positivity of . This bound suggests choosing in Hölder’s inequality so that , which is permissible because then , by hypothesis. (Notice that .) Proceeding in this manner, the bound in Eq. (9) on ’s -norm becomes
Now let be a uniform lower bound on the eigenvalues of . The integrand relates to according to
Here the first inequality follows from uniform positive definiteness of , while the second inequality follows from Jensen’s inequality applied to the convex function . From Eq. (11) it follows that
Now substituting Eq. (12) into Eq. (10) implies
To finish the proof, note that boundedness of the reference spatial domain and (property BL1) implies that there is some radius such that for all . Therefore . In conjunction with Eq. (13) this implies
which is the desired result. In particular, the positive constants are given by
Existence theory
With coercivity of the elasticized potential established, existence of minimizers now follows from standard arguments from mathematical elasticity. First it is necessary to establish the following Lemmas.
Lemma 1. Assume . The optimization domain is a weakly sequentially closed subset of .
Proof. Let be a weakly-convergent sequence such that for all . Since we always assume and is closed the Rellich-Kondrachov theorem implies that converges uniformly to a continuous map . We must show that the limit map satisfies properties BL1-BL3.
BL1: Let . The sequence is contained in . By uniform convergence of to the sequence converges to . By closedness of the limit of , which is , is contained in . Thus .
BL2: Let . The sequence is contained in . By uniform convergence of to the sequence converges to . By closedness of the limit of , which is , is contained in . Thus .
BL3: We recall an argument due to Ciarlet-Nečas [58] from the proof of their Theorem 5, which we will recount in some detail. We do this to clarify that we need not assume is non-negative almost everywhere, which is not explicitly stated by Ciarlet-Nečas. For let denote the open ball with radius at . Since is continuous and is compact, is compact, and hence measurable. It follows that for every there is an open set with and . In fact there is a such that . Uniform convergence of then implies that for all sufficiently large . Combining this with then gives for all sufficiently large .
Let . The next step is to use the well-known fact that the mapping given by is sequentially weakly continuous when . (This is described for example by Ball[59] in his Corollary 6.2.2.) Thus, by weak-convergence of in , the sequence converges weakly in to . In particular, since the unit constant function is a member of the continuous dual ,
Since this inequality must be satisfied for all we conclude that property BL3 is satisfied by , as claimed.
Lemma 2. Assume . If is a weakly-convergent sequence in with weak limit and for all then
Proof. The proof is a direct application of Theorem 6.4 from Benešová and Kružíк[60].
We begin by extending the reference domain fields , , , to all of while preserving their constraints. By the Whitney extension theorem there is a function that agrees with on . Since is positive is a function on . Again by the Whitney extension theorem there is a extension . Since is positive and agrees with on it provides a extension of that is positive everywhere. Since is uniformly symmetric positive definite we can form its point-wise matrix logarithm . The matrix function is and takes values in symmetric matrices. By the Whitney extension theorem applied to the entries of on the diagonal and above, there is a extension that also takes values in symmetric matrices. Since agrees with on it provides a extension of to all of that is pointwise symmetric positive definite. Finally, by application of the Whitney extension theorem component-wise to there is a vector field that extends . Since agrees with on it provides a divergence-free extension of to all of . Note that the extension need not be uniformly positive definite. Also note that the extension may have nulls, even if does not.
Next we extend the domain of definition of the potential energy density. As highlighted in § 3, the potential energy density is given by a function . We decompose this function as a sum of four terms, , where
By replacing the reference fields with their extensions , we obtain extensions given explicitly by
Notice that each of the extensions is continuous and non-negative when the extended real line is equipped with its usual topology.
Now we establish convexity of in for each fixed . The function is convex in because it is equal to a convex single-variable function of . Note that this observation makes use of positivity of the extension . For fixed , both and have the form , where is symmetric positive semidefinite. Note this uses pointwise positive definiteness of . There is a unique symmetric positive-semidefinite matrix such that . Therefore . This shows the function is given by composing a linear map with a squared norm. Such compositions are known to be convex, which implies is convex in for . Finally convexity of follows from writing
where denotes the Schatten -norm. This implies convexity in because if is any norm on matrices then is convex whenever ; in this case because .
We now apply Theorem 6.4 from Benešova and Kružík [60] as follows. Define
according to
Since is independent of it is clear that is measurable for each . Since each of the is continuous it is clear that is continuous for all . Since each of the is convex in it is also clear that is convex for each . In addition, since each of the is non-negative the function is bounded below by the zero function, which is a member of . It follows that satisfies each of the hypothesis specified in Theorem 6.4 from Benešova and Kružík. Because we know that is contained in and converges uniformly to . By Ball’s Corollary 6.2.2.[59], converges weakly to in and converges weakly to in . In particular converges weakly to in . Setting and in Theorem 6.4, we therefore infer
To complete the proof we note that by hypothesis and by Lemma 1. In light of the fact that extends , the following equalities therefore hold for almost all :
We conclude, by Eq. (16),
as claimed.
The main existence result for elasticized magnetohydrostatics is then.
Theorem 2. Suppose
Then there is a such that, for all , .
Proof. Since for all the lower bound is finite. Choose a bounded decreasing sequence of real numbers , , with . Let denote the sublevel set at energy . For each the set must be non-empty, else would be a lower bound for greater than . Therefore there is an infinite sequence with for each . By Theorem 1 and , the -norm of satisfies
Here are some positive real numbers given in Eqs. (14) and (15). Since the sequence is bounded the inequality Eq. (18) implies that the sequence is bounded in .
It is well-known that is reflexive for . Since by assumption, reflexivity of comes for free. The Banach–Alaoglu theorem and the Eberlein–Šmulian theorem therefore imply that the bounded sequence admits a weakly-convergent subsequence , . Let . Since is a decreasing convergent sequence, . Moreover, by Lemma 2,
But is a lower bound on , which implies . Thus, , and is a global minimizer for , as claimed.
Discussion
The proof presented here for existence of minimizers of the elasticized Newcomb potential largely follows a pattern established in the context of mathematical elasticity [58, 59, 61, 62]. Its most novel mathematical ingredient comprises the method used to establish coercivity, which entails bounding the gradient of the back-to-labels map by its adjugate. The key inequality is given in Eq. (8), which is an elementary result in linear algebra.
The idea of modifying Newcomb’s potential by including the excess magnetic energy associated with turbulent fluctuations originated in earlier work in Ref. [44]. However, this earlier statistical equilibrium model assumed the one-point reference magnetic variance does not depend on the large-scale fluid state . It also fell short of establishing a rigorous existence theory. In contrast, the elasticized magnetohydrostatic model presented here hypothesizes that the reference magnetic variance grows with plasma strain due to profile stiffness. This profile stiffness effect, together with the vacuum barrier, are the crucial new ingredients needed for the existence theory presented here.
It is presently unclear whether solutions of elasticized magnetohydrostatics are always smoother than Bruno-Laurence solutions. While the rigorous existence theory presented here only guarantees minimizers in , a space that allows for jump discontinuities in the magnetic field, we find that well-resolved numerical solutions, such as those shown in Figure 1, do not exhibit jump discontinuities. Like the existence theory, the difficulty in assessing regularity of minimizers for the elasticized Newcomb potential is largely inherited from the theory of mathematical elasticity, where equilibrium regularity is an open problem in general [61]. This obstacle might be sidestepped by allowing for strain gradient dependence in the mean magnetic energy, which is specifically neglected in the present work. A plausible source of strain gradient dependence is large-scale turbulent fluid motions, as discussed in Holm’s formulation of the Lagrangian-averaged -model [63].
The existence theory established here relies on both the vacuum barrier, proportional to , and the nonlinear elastic response, proportional to . If or the elasticized potential loses coercivity and the direct method in the calculus of variations cannot be applied. On the other hand, numerical simulations summarized in Figure 3 indicate that solutions remain well-behaved when either or . This suggests that neither the vacuum barrier nor the nonlinear elastic response is neccessary to obtain well-behaved equilibria using the elasticized model. This conjecture is also supported both by numerics and formal asymptotics from Ref. [44].

Figure 3. Self-convergence of computed solutions as either the nonlinear elastic response (left) or vacuum barrier (right) is removed. The reference magnetic variance is with . Plotted curves show -distance to a reference solution with (left) or (right). Convergence studies with various values of (left) or (right) are indicated with different colors.
If plasma incompressibility is introduced as an additional hypothesis in elasticized magnetohydrostatics, the vacuum barrier is completely unnecessary. It would be interesting to establish existence of incompressible minimizers without the vacuum barrier in future work. It would also be interesting to extend the modeling principles introduced here to other equations of state.
Theorem 2 on existence of minimizers for does not establish that minimizers satisfy the Euler-Lagrange equations. The gap between establishing existence of minimizers and establishing validity of the Euler-Lagrange equations is well-known in the calculus of variations, and in the theory of mathematical elasticity in particular [61, 62]. Part of the subtlety is already clear for minimization of the single-variable function , with , whose solution, , is not a critical point for . The subtleties are more intricate in infinite dimensions. Given the formal similarity of the elasticized Newcomb potential to potentials for hyperelastic solids, methods for establishing variants of the Euler-Lagrange equations developed within elasticity theory likely apply to the elasticized magnetohydrostatic model. This strategy for establishing some form of the Euler-Lagrange equations would be interesting to explore in future work. The strong-form Euler-Lagrange equations for the functional Eq. (6) are given by , where the stress tensor is given by
and the Eulerian fields , , are given in terms of the back-to-labels map by
Here is defined in Eq. (5).
Data, Materials, and Software Availability. All code used to produce the figures in this manuscript is freely available at https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23649878.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS. This research was supported by: (I) the U.S. Department of Energy, Office of Science, Office of Fusion Energy Sciences, under contract DE-FG02-04ER54742; (II) a Google.org AI Impact Challenge: AI for Science award; and (III) the U.S. Department of Energy, Office of Science, Office of Advanced Scientific Computing Research, as a part of the Mathematical Multifaceted Integrated Capability Centers program, under Award Number DE-SC0023164. The authors used Claude Opus 4.8 and 5.5 during manuscript preparation to assist with verification of analytical calculations. All Article prose was prepared by the authors without the assistance of artificial intelligence. The authors takes full responsibility for all final content, analysis, and interpretations.
References
- [4]J. Lion, J.-C. Anglès, L. Bonauer, A. Bañón Navarro, S.A. Cadena Ceron, R. Davies, M. Drevlak, N. Foppiani, J. Geiger, A. Goodman, W. Guo, E. Guiraud, F. Hernández, S. Henneberg, R. Herrero, C. Hintze, H. Höchter, J. Jelonek, F. Jenko, R. Jorge, M. Kaiser, M. Kubie, E. Lascas Neto, H. Laqua, M. Leoni, J.F. Lobsien, V. Maurin, A. Merlo, D. Middleton-Gear, M. Pascu, G.G. Plunk, N. Riva, M. Savchoutkov, F. Sciortino, J. Schilling, J. Shimwell, A. Di Siena, R. Slade, T. Stange, T.N. Todd, L. Wegener, F. Wilms, P. Xanthopoulos, and M. Zheng. Stellaris: A high-field quasi-isodynamic stellarator for a prototypical fusion power plant. Fusion Engineering and Design, 214:114868, May 2025. ISSN 09203796. . URL https://linkinghub.elsevier.com/retrieve/pii/S0920379625000705.
- [5]C. P. S. Swanson, S. T. A. Kumar, D. W. Dudt, E. R. Flom, W. B. Kalb, T. G. Kruger, M. F. Martin, J. R. Olatunji, S. Pasmann, L. Z. Tang, J. von der Linden, J. Wasserman, M. Avida, A. S. Basurto, M. Dickerson, N. de Boer, M. J. Donovan, A. H. Doudna Cate, D. Fort, W. Harris, U. Khera, A. Koen, J. A. Labatte, N. Maitra, A. Ottaviano, R. K. Parmar, E. J. Paul, B. Reydel, A. van Riel, P. K. Romano, M. Savastianov, S. Saxena, S. Seethalla, S. Srinivasan, R. H. Wu, D. Nash, J. Priebe, M. Shepchenkov, S. Walsh, B. Berzin, D. A. Gates, and the Thea Energy team. Overview of the Helios Design: A Practical Planar Coil Stellarator Fusion Power Plant, 2025. URL https://arxiv.org/abs/2512.08027. Version Number: 3.
- [6]D. A. Garren and A. H. Boozer. Existence of quasishelly symmetric stellarators. Physics of Fluids B: Plasma Physics, 3(10):2822–2834, October 1991. ISSN 0889-8221. . URL https://pubs.aip.org/pfb/article/3/10/2822/841899/Existence-of-quasihelically-symmetric-stellarators.DOI
- [7]S. P. Hirshman and J. C. Whitson. Steepest-descent moment method for three-dimensional magnetohydrodynamic equilibria. The Physics of Fluids, 26(12):3553–3568, December 1983. ISSN 0031-9171. . URL https://pubs.aip.org/pfl/article/26/12/3553/809269/Steepest-descent-moment-method-for-three.
- [8]Matt Landreman and Elizabeth Paul. Magnetic Fields with Precise Quasisymmetry for Plasma Confinement. Physical Review Letters, 128(3):035001, January 2022. ISSN 0031-9007, 1079-7114. . URL https://link.aps.org/doi/10.1103/PhysRevLett.128.035001.DOI
- [9]John R. Cary and Svetlana G. Shasharina. Omnigenity and quasisymmetry in helical plasma confinement systems. Physics of Plasmas, 4(9):3323–3333, September 1997. ISSN 1070-664X, 1089-7674. . URL https://pubs.aip.org/pop/article/4/9/3323/457323/Omnigenity-and-quasisymmetry-in-helical-plasma.DOI
- [10]John R. Cary and Svetlana G. Shasharina. Helical Plasma Confinement Devices with Good Confinement Properties. Physical Review Letters, 78(4):674–677, January 1997. ISSN 0031-9007, 1079-7114. . URL https://link.aps.org/doi/10.1103/PhysRevLett.78.674.
- [11]A.G. Goodman, K. Camacho Mata, S.A. Henneberg, R. Jorge, M. Landreman, G.G. Plunk, H.M. Smith, R.J.J. Mackenbach, C.D. Beidler, and P. Helander. Constructing precisely quasi-isodynamic magnetic fields. Journal of Plasma Physics, 89(5):905890504, October 2023. ISSN 0022-3778, 1469-7807. . URL https://www.cambridge.org/core/product/identifier/S002237782300065X/type/journal.article.
- [12]Samuel A. Lazerson, Joaquim Loizu, Steven Hirshman, and Stuart R. Hudson. Verification of the ideal magnetohydrodynamic response at rational surfaces in the VMEC code. Physics of Plasmas, 23(1):012507, January 2016. ISSN 1070-664X, 1089-7674. . URL https://pubs.aip.org/pop/article/23/1/012507/108429/Verification-of-the-ideal-magnetohydrodynamic.DOI
- [13]Harold Grad. Toroidal Containment of a Plasma. The Physics of Fluids, 10(1):137–154, January 1967. ISSN 0031-9171. . URL https://doi.org/10.1063/1.1761965.
- [14]Peter Costorlan, Theodore D. Drivas, and Daniel Ginsberg. Flexibility and Rigidity in Steady Fluid Motion. Communications in Mathematical Physics, 385(1):521–563, July 2021. ISSN 0010-3616, 1432-0916. . URL https://link.springer.com/10.1007/s00220-021-04048-4.
- [15]Robert Cardona, Nathan Duignan, and David Perrella. Asymmetry of MHD Equilibria for Generic Adapted Metrics. Archive for Rational Mechanics and Analysis, 249(1):1, February 2025. ISSN 0003-9527, 1432-0673. . URL https://link.springer.com/10.1007/s00205-024-02075-8.arxiv.org/abs/2312.14368
- [16]Matt Landreman. Analytic toroidal 3D MHD equilibria and steady Euler flows with invariant surfaces, September 2026. URL https://arxiv.org/abs/2609.26742. Version Number: 2.
- [17]Opal Issan, Jonathan Citrin, Matt Landreman, and Brendan Tracey. Analytic non-axisymmetric 3D MHD equilibria without stellarator symmetry, October 2026. URL https://arxiv.org/abs/2610.07304. Version Number: 1.
- [18]M.I. Mikhailov, J. Núhrenberg, and H. Zille. Elimination of current sheets at resonances in three-dimensional toroidal ideal-magnetohydrodynamic equilibria. Nuclear Fusion, 59(6):066002, June 2019. ISSN 0029-5515, 1741-4326. . URL https://iopscience.iop.org/article/10.1088/1741-4326/ab0f50.DOI
- [19]Oscar P. Bruno and Peter Laurence. Existence of three-dimensional toroidal MHD equilibria with nonconstant pressure. Communications on Pure and Applied Mathematics, 49(7):717–764, 1996. ISSN 1097-0312. . URL https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1002/(%29?siC1%291097-0312%28199607%2949%3A7%3C717%3A%3AAID-CPAM3%3E3.0.CO%3B2-C. https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/pdf/10.1002/%28SICI%291097-0312%28199607%2949%3A7%3C717%3A%3AAID-CPAM3%3E3.0.CO%3B2-C.
- [20]John R Cary and Robert G Littlejohn. Noncanonical Hamiltonian mechanics and its application to magnetic field line flow. Annals of Physics, 151(1):1–34, November 1983. ISSN 00034916. . URL https://linkinghub.elsevier.com/retrieve/pii/000349168303135.DOI
- [21]S. R. Hudson, R. L. Dewar, G. Dennis, M. J. Hole, M. McGann, G. von Nessi, and S. Lazerson. Computation of multi-region relaxed magnetohydrodynamic equilibria. Physics of Plasmas, 19(11):112502, November 2012. ISSN 1070-664X. . URL https://doi.org/10.1063/1.4765691.
- [22]Peter Constantin and Federico Pasqualotto. Magnetic Relaxation of a Voigt–MHD System. Communications in Mathematical Physics, 402(2):1931–1952, September 2023. ISSN 1432-0916. . URL https://doi.org/10.1007/s00220-023-04770-1.
- [23]Yi-Min Huang, Justin Kin Jun Hew, Andrew Brown, and Amitava Bhattacharjee. Computation of magnetohydrodynamic equilibria with Voigt regularization. Physics of Plasmas, 32(6):062507, June 2025. ISSN 1070-664X, 1089-7674. . URL https://pubs.aip.org/pop/article/32/6/062507/3350464/Computation-of-magnetohydrodynamic-equilibria-with.
- [24]Andrew Brown, Yi-Min Huang, and Amitava Bhattacharjee. Forced Reconnection in Voigt-Regularized MHD, 2026. URL https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.02432. Version Number: 1.
- [25]Yasuhiro Suzuki, Noriyoshi Nakajima, Kiyomasa Watanabe, Yuji Nakamura, and Takaya Hayashi. Development and application of HINT2 to helical system plasmas. Nuclear Fusion, 46(11):L19–L24, November 2006. ISSN 0029-5515, 1741-4326. . URL https://iopscience.iop.org/article/10.1088/0029-5515/46/11/L01.
- [26]Z. S. Qu, S. R. Hudson, R. L. Dewar, J. J. Hole, A. M. J. Hole. On the non-existence of stepped-pressure equilibria far from symmetry. Plasma Physics and Controlled Fusion, 63(12):125007, October 2021. ISSN 0741-3335. . URL https://dx.doi.org/10.1088/1361-6587/ac2afc.
- [27]D. Panici, R. Conlin, D. W. Dudt, K. Unalmis, and E. Kolemen. The DESC stellarator code suite. Part 1. Quick and accurate equilibria computations. Journal of Plasma Physics, 89(3):955890303, June 2023. ISSN 0022-3778, 1469-7807. . URL https://www.cambridge.org/core/product/identifier/S0022377823000272/type/journal_article.DOI
- [28]D. W. Dudt and E. Kolemen. DESC: A stellarator equilibrium solver. Physics of Plasmas, 27(10):102513, October 2020. ISSN 1070-664X, 1089-7674. . URL https://pubs.aip.org/pop/article/27/10/102513/108268/DESC-A-stellarator-equilibrium-solver.DOI
- [29]J. Loizu, S. R. Hudson, C. Núhrenberg, J. Geiger, and P. Helander. Equilibrium beta-limits in classical stellarators. Journal of Plasma Physics, 83(6):715830601, December 2017. ISSN 0022-3778, 1469-7807. . URL https://www.cambridge.org/core/product/identifier/S0022377817000861/type/journal_article.
- [30]A. Baillod, J. Loizu, Z.S. H. P. Arbez, and J.P. Graves. Equilibrium beta-limits dependence on bootstrap current in classical stellarators. Journal of Plasma Physics, 89(5):905890508, October 2023. ISSN 0022-3778, 1469-7807. . URL https://www.cambridge.org/core/product/identifier/S0022377823000910/type/journal_article.arxiv.org/abs/2211.12948
- [31]C. B. Smiet, J. Loizu, E. Balkovic, and A. Baillod. Efficient single-stage optimization of islands in finite-beta stellarator equilibria. Physics of Plasmas, 32(1):012504, January 2025. ISSN 1070-664X, 1089-7674. . URL https://pubs.aip.org/pop/article/32/1/012504/3331878/Efficient-single-stage-optimization-of-islands-in.arxiv.org/abs/2407.02097
- [32]J. W. Connor, S. C. Cowley, R. J. Hastie, T. C. Hender, A. Hood, and T. J. Martin. Tearing modes in toroidal geometry. The Physics of Fluids, 31(3):577–590, March 1988. ISSN 0031-9171. . URL https://pubs.aip.org/pof/article/31/3/577/903632/Tearing-modes-in-toroidal-geometry.DOI
- [33]C. C. Hegna. The physics of neoclassical magnetohydrodynamic tearing modes. Physics of Plasmas, 5(5):1767–1774, May 1998. ISSN 1070-664X, 1089-7674. . URL https://pubs.aip.org/pop/article/5/5/1767/1069111/The-physics-of-neoclassical-magnetohydrodynamic.DOI
- [34]C. C. Hegna. Physics of magnetic islands in stellarators. Physics of Plasmas, 19(5):056101, May 2012. ISSN 1070-664X, 1089-7674. . URL https://pubs.aip.org/pop/article/19/5/056101/596911/Plasma-flow-healing-of-magnetic-islands-in.
- [35]Richard Fitzpatrick. Tearing mode dynamics in tokamak plasmas. IOP ebooks. IOP Publishing, Bristol, UK, version: 202306 edition, 2023. ISBN 978-0-7503-5367-0 978-0-7503-5366-3. .DOI
- [36]A. Reimann, M. Zarnstorff, D Monticello, A Weller, J. Geiger, and The W7-As Team. Pressure-induced breaking of equilibrium flux surfaces in the W7AS stellarator. Nuclear Fusion, 47(7):572–578, July 2007. ISSN 0029-5515, 1741-4326. . URL https://iopscience.iop.org/article/10.1088/0029-5515/47/7/008.
- [37]Jian Zhang, Ping Zhu, Haifeng Liu, Yasuhiro Suzuki, Chris C. Hegna, and Yuhong Xu. Identification of MHD equilibrium beta limits for CFQS magnetas. June 2026. URL http://arxiv.org/abs/2606.26675. arXiv:2606.26675 [physics.plasm-ph].
- [38]A. Reiman and H. Greenside. Calculation of three-dimensional MHD equilibria with islands and stochastic regions. Computer Physics Communications, 43(1):157–167, December 1986. ISSN 00104655. . URL https://linkinghub.elsevier.com/retrieve/pii/0010465586900597.
- [39]M. Drevlak, D. Monticello, and A Reiman. 3D MHD equilibria with improved initial conditions. Nuclear Fusion, 45(7):731–740, July 2005. ISSN 0029-5515, 1741-4326. . URL https://iopscience.iop.org/article/10.1088/0029-5515/45/7/022.
- [40]C. P. Hirshman, R. Sanchez, and C. R. Cook. SIESTA: A scalable iterative equilibrium solver for toroidal applications. Physics of Plasmas, 18(6):062504, June 2011. ISSN 1070-664X, 1089-7674. . URL https://pubs.aip.org/pop/article/18/6/062504/387811/SIESTA-A-scalable-iterative-equilibrium-solver-for.
- [41]Tobias Bluckhan, Julianne Stratton, and Alan A. Kaptanoglu. MRX: A differentiale 3D MHD equilibrium solver without nested flux surfaces, 2025. URL https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.26986. Version Number: 1.
- [42]E. Balkovic, J. Loizu, E. Lanti, C. Smiet, C. Lazzati, R. Ramassamy, A. Goodman, J. Geiger, and J. P. Graves. SPECTRE: A robust solver for 3D equilibria with arbitrary topology, July 2026. URL https://arxiv.org/abs/2607.27135. Version Number: 1.
- [43]W. A. Newcomb. Reangangian and Hamiltonian methods in magnetohydrodynamics. Technical Report UCRL-6387, California Univ., Livermore (USA). Lawrence Livermore Lab., June 1961. URL https://www.osti.gov/biblio/5034470.
- [44]Maximilian Ruth, Joshua W. Burby, Wrick Sengupta, and Andrew Brown. Statistical equilibrium model for stellarators, 2026. URL https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.08878. Version Number: 1.
- [45]C J Cotter, D. D Holm, and P E Hydon. Multisymplectic formulation of fluid dynamics using the inverse map. Proceedings of the Royal Society A: Mathematical, Physical and Engineering Sciences, 463(2086):2671–2687, October 2007. ISSN 1364-5021, 1471-2946. . URL http://royalsocietypublishing.org/rsfa/article/463/2086/2671/82/.DOI
- [46]Bernard Dacorogna. Direct methods in the calculus of variations. Number v. 78 in Applied mathematical sciences. Springer, New York, 2nd ed edition, 2008. ISBN 978-0-387-55249-1.
- [47]Jeffrey P. Freidberg. Ideal MHD. Cambridge University Press, 1 edition, June 2014. ISBN 978-1-107-00625-6 978-0-511-79504-6. . URL https://www.cambridge.org/core/product/identifier/9780511795046/type/book.
- [48]Alexey Mishchenko, Matthias Borchardt, Roman Hatzky, Ralf Kleiber, Axel Könies, Carolin Nührenberg, Pavlos Xanthopoulos, Gareth Reesberg-Clark, and Gabriel G. Plunk. Global gyrokinetic simulations of electromagnetic turbulence in stellarator plasmas. Journal of Plasma Physics, 89(3):95589034, June 2023. ISSN 0022-3778, 1469-7807. . URL https://www.cambridge.org/core/product/identifier/S0022377823000363/type/journal_article.
- [49]E. J. Spence, M. D. Nornberg, R. A. Bayliss, R. D. Kendrick, and C. B. Forest. Fluctuation-driven magnetic fields in the Madison Dynamo Experiment. Physics of Plasmas, 15(5):055910, May 2008. ISSN 1070-664X, 1089-7674. . URL https://pubs.aip.org/pop/article/15/5/055910/1015740/Fluctuation-driven-magnetic-fields-in-the-Madison.DOI
- [50]W. Z. Maw, W. X. Ding, H. Q. Liu, A. Ti, D. I. Brewer, H. L. Lian, Y. Q. Chu, L. Zeng, H. L. Zhao, J. Zhang, J. Qian, Q. Zang, X. Z. Gong, L. Q. Hu, L. Q. Xu, C. Zhou, T. Lan, A. D. Liu, J. L. Xie, G. Zhuang, Y. T. Song, B. N. Wang, and J. G. Li. Fluctuation-induced dynamo effect in a magnetic confinement plasma. Physical Review Research, 5(2):L022047, June 2023. ISSN 2643-1564. . URL https://link.aps.org/doi/10.1103/PhysRevResearch.5.L022047.
- [51]M.N.A. Beurskens, S.A. Bozhenkov, O. Ford, P. Xanthopoulos, A. Zocco, Y. Turkin, A. Alonso, C. Beidler, I. Calvo, D. Carralero, T. Estrada, G. Fuchert, O. Grulke, M. Hirsch, K. Ida, M. Jakubowski, C. Killer, M. Kryuchowa, S. Kwak, S. Lazercon, A. Langenberg, R. Lunsford, N. Pablant, E. Pasch, A. Pavone, F. Reimold, Th. Romba, A. Von Stechow, H.M. Smith, T. Windisch, M. Yoshimura, D. Zhang, R.C. Wolf, and The W7-X Team. Ion temperature clamping in Wendelstein 7-X electron cyclotron heated plasmas. Nuclear Fusion, 61(11):116072, November 2021. ISSN 0029-5515, 1741-4326. . URL https://iopscience.iop.org/article/10.1088/1741-4326/ac1653.
- [52]Sven Stroteich, Pavlos Xanthopoulos, Gabriel Plunk, and Ralf Schneider. Seeking turbulence optimized configurations for the Wendelstein 7-X stellarator: ion temperature gradient and electron temperature gradient turbulence. Journal of Plasma Physics, 88(5):175880501, October 2022. ISSN 0022-3778, 1469-7807. . URL https://www.cambridge.org/core/product/identifier/S0022377822000757/type/journal_article.DOI
- [53]X Garbet, P Mantica, F Ryter, G Cordey, F Imbeaux, C Sozzi, A Manini, E Asp, V Parail, R Wolf, and The Jet Efda Contributors. Profile stiffness and global confinement. Plasma Physics and Controlled Fusion, 46(9):1351–1373, September 2004. ISSN 0741-3335, 1361-6587. . URL https://iopscience.iop.org/article/10.1088/0741-3335/46/9/002.
- [54]M. Barnes, F. I. Parra, and A. S. Schekochihin. Critically Balanced Ion Temperature Gradient Turbulence in Fusion Plasmas. Physical Review Letters, 107(11):115003, September 2011. ISSN 0031-9007, 1079-7114. . URL https://link.aps.org/doi/10.1103/PhysRevLett.107.115003.DOI
- [55]F. Van Wyk, E. G. Highcock, A. A. Schekochihin, C. M. Roach, A. R. Field, and W. Dorland. Transition to subcritical turbulence in a tokamak plasma. Journal of Plasma Physics, 82(6):905820609, December 2016. ISSN 0022-3778, 1469-7807. . URL https://www.cambridge.org/core/product/identifier/S0022377816001148/type/journal_article.
- [56]T. Adkins, J. G. Abel, M. Barnes, S. Buller, W. D. Narang, F. P. Ivanov, R. F. Parra, A. A. Schekochihin, and J. Squire. Asymptotic scaling theory of electrostatic turbulent transport in magnetised fusion plasmas, 2026. URL https://arxiv.org/abs/2601.15391. Version Number: 1.
- [57]W. A. Farmer, C. L. Ellison, J. H. Hammer, K. R. LeChien, N. B. Meezan, K. S. Raman, V. Svidzinski, and K. Tummel. Numerical Improvements in Magnetohydrodynamic, Pulsed Power Simulations of Near-Target Plasmas. IEEE Transactions on Plasma Science, 52(10):4771–4781, October 2024. ISSN 0093-3813, 1939-9375. . URL https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/document/10413242/.DOI
- [58]Philippe G. Ciarlet and Jindřich Nečas. Injectivity and self-contact in nonlinear elasticity. Archive for Rational Mechanics and Analysis, 97(3):171–188, September 1987. ISSN 0003-9107, 1432-0673. . URL http://link.springer.com/10.1007/BF00250807.
- [59]John M. Ball. Convexity conditions and existence theorems in nonlinear elasticity. Archive for Rational Mechanics and Analysis, 63(4):337–403, December 1976. ISSN 0003-9107, 1432-0673. . URL http://link.springer.com/10.1007/BF00279992.DOI
- [60]Barbora Benešová and Martin Kruží̌k. Weak Lower Semicontinuity of Integral Functionals and Applications. SIAM Review, 59(4):703–766, January 2017. ISSN 0036-1445, 1095-7200. . URL https://epubs.siam.org/doi/10.1137/16M1060947.DOI
- [61]John M. Ball. Some Open Problems in Elasticity. In Paul Newton, Philip Holmes, and Alan Weinstein, editors, Geometry, Mechanics, and Dynamics, pages 3–59. Springer-Verlag, New York, 2002. ISBN 978-0-387-95518-6. . URL http://link.springer.com/10.1007/0-387-21791-6_1.
- [62]J. M. Ball. Minimizers and the euler-lagrange equations. In Philippe G. Ciarlet and Maurice Roseau, editors, Trends and Applications of Pure Mathematics to Mechanics, volume 195, pages 1–4. Springer Berlin Heidelberg, Berlin, Heidelberg, 1984. ISBN 978-3-540-12916-5 978-3-540-38800-5. . URL http://link.springer.com/10.1007/3-540-12916-2_47. Series Title: Lecture Notes in Physics.DOI
- [63]Darryl D. Holm. Lagrangian averages, averaged Lagrangians, and the mean effects of fluctuations in fluid dynamics. Chaos: An Interdisciplinary Journal of Nonlinear Science, 12(2):518–530, June 2002. ISSN 1054-1500, 1089-7682. . URL https://pubs.aip.org/cha/article/12/2/518/134848/Lagrangian-averages-averaged-Lagrangians-and-the-pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/12779582
