betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Self-similar Worthington jets

Abstract

When a micron-sized bubble bursts, capillary waves deform the cavity into a cone that ejects a Worthington jet. The jet is born by inertial focusing, and the local collapse follows self-similar Euler solutions set by the semiangle ββ. Writing rjr_j and vjv_j for the dimensionless jet-base radius and velocity, the local Weber number Wej=rjvj2We_j=r_j v^2_j measures inertia relative to capillarity. The theory, supported by accurate numerical simulations gives rj∝τα(β)r_j\proptoτ^{α(β)} with α≃0.63α\simeq0.63 and, hence Wej≫1We_j\gg1, with Wej→∞We_j\to\infty as rj→0r_j\to0, so inertia increasingly overwhelms capillarity. In simulations, the interface collapses onto a universal shape for more than two decades in dimensionless time when lengths are scaled using our prediction for rjr_j. For water, this gives incipient radii of O(1)\mathcal{O}(1) nm, predicting nanometric sea-spray aerosols.

Bubble bursting ejects Worthington jets whose breakup transfers material across liquid–gas interfaces, from sea spray [1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6] and rain-induced aerosols [7] to sparkling wines [8] and electrochemical sprays [9]. The jet dynamics and minimum drop sizes are set by capillary-wave focusing [10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16]. The radii RR of the bubbles for which submicrometric droplets can be produced via bubble bursting jets at a surfactant-free or negligibly contaminated interface of a liquid of density ρ\rho, dynamic viscosity μ\mu and interfacial tension coefficient σ\sigma, are characterized by a value of the Ohnesorge number Oh=μ/ρRσ≈0.03Oh=\mu/\sqrt{\rho R\sigma}\approx0.03 [12, 14]; for water, this means micron-sized bubbles with Bo=ρgR2/σ≪1Bo=\rho gR^2/\sigma\ll1, with gg indicating gravity [17]. In this regime, capillary waves deform the bubble into a conical cavity of semiangle β\beta and entrap a tiny bubble beneath the cavity before the fastest, thinnest jet is emitted [18] (Figure 1 and Figure 2(a)(Figure 2i)–(iv)). The local question is what similarity law governs the focusing flow after this conical cavity has formed.

Figure 1. The gas cavity approaches a cone of semiangle β\beta, described using the polar distance rr and angle θ\theta measured from the apparent apex, or equivalently the axial and radial coordinates zz and rpr_p. The jet radius rjr_j and velocity vjv_j define the local observables used to test the self-similar scaling.

Figure 2. Inertial focusing at Bo=0Bo = 0 and Oh=0.03Oh = 0.03. (a) Interface (orange), streamlines (grey), and velocity magnitude near jet inception. Snapshots (i)–(iv): τ′−τ0=−1.9×10−3\tau' - \tau_0 = -1.9 \times10^{-3}, −1.3×10−4-1.3 \times10^{-4}, +1.0×10−4+1.0 \times10^{-4}, and +5.4×10−3+5.4 \times10^{-3}. (b) Local Weber number WejWe_j versus jet radius rjr_j. Symbols identify the refinement levels (ℓpre,ℓpost)(\ell_{\mathrm{pre}},\ell_{\mathrm{post}}) before and after inception (see End Matter). Shading marks the conical-inertial window 0.002≤rj≤0.0240.002 \le r_j \le0.024. Solid, dashed, and dotted lines show our theory (α=0.629\alpha= 0.629), inertio-capillary scaling (α=2/3\alpha= 2/3), and the constant-flux scaling of Ref. [33], respectively. Inset: radius at Rej=20Re_j = 20 versus OhOh, with slope guides α/(2α−1)\alpha/(2\alpha- 1) for the same two exponents; the horizontal line marks the low-OhOh plateau. Grey shading in the inset marks the conical regime 0.027<Oh<0.040.027 < Oh < 0.04. (c) Maximum jet velocities measured in Ref. [22] (circles), compared with Eq. (5) (solid) and their inertio-capillary prediction (Eq. (6) in Ref. [22], dashed).

We denote raw dimensionless simulation time by τ′=tVc/R\tau'=tV_c/R and time relative to the singularity by τ=τ′−τ0\tau=\tau'-\tau_0, where the singularity time τ0\tau_0 depends on OhOh. In the classical inertio-capillary interpretation, dynamic and capillary pressures balance during collapse, giving rj∝∣τ∣2/3r_j\propto|\tau|^{2/3} and a constant local Weber number Wej=vj2rj=O(1)We_j=v_j^2r_j=\mathcal{O}(1) [11, 19, 20, 21, 22]. Interface collapse alone does not probe this balance as both 2/32/3 and a nearby exponent can collapse the evolving shapes [19, 21, 22]. Our direct numerical simulations instead give Wej=O(102)We_j=\mathcal{O}(10^2), diverging as rjr_j decreases (Figure 2(b)). These results establish a physical inconsistency in applying inertio-capillary similarity to the singular Worthington jets considered here [14, 15, 21, 22, 23, 24, 25, 26, 27, 28, 29]: the assumed constant, order-unity Weber number contradicts the large, diverging value at the jet base. The underlying similarity solutions [19, 20] remain applicable to inertial ligament pinch-off but the force balance of the singular Worthington jet is different.

We resolve this inconsistency by deriving self-similar Euler solutions of the second kind, with the cone semi-

angle β\beta selecting the value of the exponent α(β)≲2/3\alpha(\beta)\lesssim2/3 in rj∝ταr_j\propto\tau^\alpha for the measured bubble-bursting cone angles, finding that capillary effects are negligible. Indeed, for Oh=0.03Oh=0.03, the measured β=38.4∘\beta=38.4^\circ gives α=0.629\alpha=0.629 and, hence, our theory predicts, in agreement with the numerical results, the value of the exponent γ<0\gamma<0 in Wej∝rjγWe_j\propto r_j^\gamma, which implies Wej→∞We_j\to\infty as rj→0r_j\to0 (Figure 2(b)). Moreover, the rescaled numerical interfaces collapse onto a universal shape before and after jet inception (Figure 3). Our geometry-selected theory also gives remarkably better agreement with the experimental jet velocities in an acoustically driven conical cavity than the inertio-capillary expression (Figure 2(c)) [22]. The jet dynamics determine the sizes and velocities of bubble-bursting drops that feed sea-spray aerosols [3] and the thicknesses and velocities of jets produced by the acoustic forcing of microbubbles, with applications in targeted drug delivery and biofilm removal [22, 30]. The geometry-selected theory describes local inertial collapse with an approximately equipotential conical boundary, independently of how the cavity forms.

Figure 3. Self-similar interface evolution at Bo=0Bo = 0, Oh=0.03Oh = 0.03. The upper and lower rows show cavity collapse before inception and the emitted jet, respectively. Panels (a,c) show unscaled interfaces, shifted by the instantaneous axial reference zjz_j; (b,d) show the same profiles scaled with ∣τ∣α|\tau|^{\alpha}, where α=0.629\alpha= 0.629. The colour scale uses ∣τ′−τ0∣|\tau' - \tau_0| with τ0=0.494430\tau_0 = 0.494430. The complete comparison with α=2/3\alpha= 2/3 appears in Supplemental Fig. S3.

Next, we solve the conical collapse of the cavity as a local inertial-focusing problem. Capillarity and viscosity, through OhOh, select whether the system enters the singular regime — when the tiny bubble is entrapped — and set the cone angle β(Oh)\beta(Oh) and jet inception time in the small-BoBo regime. More generally, the cavity evolution before inception sets β(Oh,Bo)\beta(Oh,Bo) [31]. Once the similarity window rj≪r≪1r_j\ll r\ll1 exists with rr the polar distance, see Figure 1, the dominant balance must be inertial owing to the very large values of the local Weber number. The exponent in rj∝τα(β)r_j\propto\tau^{\alpha(\beta)} is therefore not universal but fixed by the far-field cone geometry through α(β)=1/(2−ν(β))\alpha(\beta)=1/(2-\nu(\beta)), with ν(β)\nu(\beta) fixed by the condition Pν(−cos⁡β)=0P_\nu(-\cos\beta)=0, where PνP_\nu indicates the Legendre function of degree ν\nu. Measuring the incoming angle fixes the exponent independently of a fit to the jet dynamics. Dependence on the initial or far-field cavity geometry, also observed in recent shallow-layer bubble-bursting jets [32], is a signature of a second-kind similarity rather than a secondary correction.

The experimental measurements in [22] test the velocity prediction; the measured growth of WejW_{ej} as rj→0r_j \to0 tests the force balance, and the trend α[β(Oh)]<2/3\alpha[\beta(Oh)] < 2/3 tests the exponent (see End Matter). For water bubbles of radius R∼10 μmR \sim10\,\mu\mathrm{m}, the predicted viscous cutoff lies at nanometric scales, where additional physics must enter before viscosity can regularize the continuum-incompressible singularity.

Conical similarity. — When the production of vorticity at the interface can be neglected, the velocity field v\mathbf{v} can be expressed as the gradient of a velocity potential ϕ\phi, v=∇ϕ\mathbf{v} = \nabla\phi. In the incompressible limit, ϕ\phi verifies the Laplace equation ∇2ϕ=0\nabla^2\phi= 0, which must be solved subject to dynamic and kinematic boundary conditions at the interface F=rp−rs(z,τ)=0F = r_p - r_s(z,\tau) = 0, with rsr_s the radial interface position in cylindrical coordinates (z,rp)(z,r_p). The spherical coordinates (r,θ)(r,\theta) are centred at the apparent apex of the cone (see Figure 1). In the limit in which capillary and viscous stresses are negligible, the dynamic boundary condition is the Euler–Bernoulli equation particularized at F=0F = 0, ∂ϕ/∂τ+∣∇ϕ∣2/2=0\partial\phi/\partial\tau+ |\nabla\phi|^2/2 = 0, whereas the kinematic boundary condition reads ∂F/∂τ+∇ϕ⋅∇F=0\partial F/\partial\tau+ \nabla\phi\cdot\nabla F = 0.

Far from the jet base in the local similarity limit, r/rj→∞r/r_j \to\infty with r≪1r \ll1, the interface converges to a cone of semiangle θ=β\theta= \beta, so the local problem lacks a spatial scale. Thus, it is natural to seek for a local, self-similar solution. To investigate the structure of the solution, we make use of the scaled variables proposed in Ref. [19],

ϕ=τδh[z′−ℓ0(Oh)τε,rpτε]\phi= \tau^\delta h\left[\frac{z' - \ell_0(Oh)}{\tau^\varepsilon},\frac{r_p}{\tau^\varepsilon}\right]

and

rs(z,τ)=τεg[z′−ℓ0(Oh)τε](1)r_s(z,\tau) = \tau^\varepsilon g\left[\frac{z' - \ell_0(Oh)}{\tau^\varepsilon}\right] \tag*{(1)}

with τ>0\tau> 0 for the post-inception solution, and z=z′−ℓ0(Oh)z = z' - \ell_0(Oh) and rpr_p the axial and radial cylindrical coordinates (see Figure 1). Before inception, τ<0\tau< 0 and interface lengths are rescaled with ∣τ∣ε|\tau|^\varepsilon. The system composed of the Laplace equation, the Euler–Bernoulli equation, and the kinematic boundary condition can be written in terms of the variables in Eq. (1) if δ=2ε−1\delta= 2\varepsilon- 1 [19], with this condition arising from the balance between the temporal and the convective derivatives in the dynamic and kinematic boundary conditions. So far, equation δ=2ε−1\delta= 2\varepsilon- 1 constitutes the only restriction for self-similar solutions to exist. However, an additional condition that the exponents δ\delta and ε\varepsilon must fulfill is deduced by imposing the behaviour of the velocity potential ϕ\phi in the far field. The constant-flux condition in [33] describes conical collapse, including slender cones (β≪1\beta\ll1), and bubble-bursting jets emitted from truncated cones at Oh≲0.02Oh \lesssim0.02. Truncation removes the apex without fixing the conical sidewall angle β\beta. The far-field velocity potential then satisfies

rp∂ϕ∂rp→−q∞forrp/rj→∞,(2)r_p\frac{\partial\phi}{\partial r_p} \to-q_\infty\quad\text{for}\quad r_p/r_j \to\infty, \tag*{(2)}

with q∞q_\infty the value of the time-independent far-field flow rate per unit length along the axis of the cone, fixed at the instant when the jet starts to be issued. Notice that Eqs. (1) and (2) imply that δ=0\delta= 0 and, hence, ε=1/2\varepsilon= 1/2 and rj(τ)∝τ1/2r_j(\tau) \propto\tau^{1/2}, with rj∝τ−1r_j \propto\tau^{-1} in agreement with numerical results [33] — see also Figure 2(b).

However, for 0.027≲Oh≲0.040.027 \lesssim Oh \lesssim0.04, jets are issued right after a tiny bubble is entrapped at the bottom of the cavity as a consequence of the collapse of a conical cavity of semiangle β=O(1)\beta= O(1), for which the far-field boundary condition in Eq. (2) is no longer valid. In this case, which corresponds to the thinnest and fastest jets, the early dynamics admit an intermediate spatial region rj(τ)≪r≪1r_j(\tau) \ll r \ll1 for τ≪1\tau\ll1 (see Figure 1). The velocity decays in the local similarity far field, where the quadratic velocity term is negligible to leading order [34]. The Euler–Bernoulli condition on F=0F = 0 then gives ∂ϕ/∂τ=−∣∇ϕ∣2/2≃0\partial\phi/\partial\tau= -|\nabla\phi|^2/2 \simeq0. The material derivative satisfies Dϕ/Dτ=−∣∇ϕ∣2/2≃0D\phi/D\tau= -|\nabla\phi|^2/2 \simeq0 under the same approximation. Thus an initially equipotential interface, with its potential set to ϕ(τ=0)=0\phi(\tau= 0) = 0, remains approximately equipotential in this short-time limit, giving ϕ(θ=β)≃0\phi(\theta= \beta) \simeq0 in the intermediate region. The results in Figure 1(b) and 6 of [26] and the literature results support this condition; the velocity field in Figure 2(a)(ii,iii) is normal to the conical surface, showing that this surface is approximately equipotential in the intermediate region. Hence, for 0.027≲Oh≲0.040.027 \lesssim Oh \lesssim0.04, the far field boundary condition driving the ejection of the jet must be a solution of the Laplace equation satisfying the condition ϕ(θ=β)=0\phi(\theta= \beta) = 0, which implies that

ϕ∼ArνPν(−cos⁡θ)=Aτεν(r/τε)νPν(−cos⁡θ)(3)\phi\sim Ar^\nu P_\nu(-\cos\theta) = A\tau^{\varepsilon\nu}(r/\tau^\varepsilon)^\nu P_\nu(-\cos\theta) \tag*{(3)}

in the similarity far field rj≪r≪1r_j \ll r \ll1, with the time-independent constant AA fixed by the velocity in the far field at the instant when the jet starts to be issued. (3), together with the far-field condition ϕ(θ=β)=0\phi(\theta=\beta)=0, imposes that the degree of the Legendre function ν\nu must satisfy the condition

Pν(−cos⁡β)=0.(4)P_\nu(-\cos\beta)=0. \tag*{(4)}

Figure 4 in the End Matter shows the solution of Eq. (4) and, thus, the value of the degree ν\nu for different values of the cone semiangle β\beta. Matching the potential in Eq. (1) to Eq. (3) implies that self-similar solutions will exist if δ=νε\delta=\nu\varepsilon and δ=2ε−1\delta=2\varepsilon-1, namely, if ε=1/(2−ν(β))\varepsilon=1/(2-\nu(\beta)). Hence, for the present family of self-similar solutions, rj(τ)∝τ1/(2−ν(β))r_j(\tau)\propto\tau^{1/(2-\nu(\beta))}, vj(τ)∝τ(ν(β)−1)/(2−ν(β))v_j(\tau)\propto\tau^{(\nu(\beta)-1)/(2-\nu(\beta))} and Wej(τ)∝τ(2ν(β)−1)/(2−ν(β))We_j(\tau)\propto\tau^{(2\nu(\beta)-1)/(2-\nu(\beta))}. In view of the values of ν(β)\nu(\beta) given in Figure 4 and for the measured bubble-entrapment range 35∘≲β≲41∘35^\circ\lesssim\beta\lesssim41^\circ (β=38.4∘\beta=38.4^\circ at Oh=0.03Oh=0.03; Figure 4), 1/(2−ν(β))≲2/31/(2-\nu(\beta))\lesssim2/3 and Wej≫1We_j\gg1 for τ≪1\tau\ll1, which is a necessary condition for fast and slender Worthington jets to be issued after the collapse of a cavity [18].

Figure 4. (a) Values of ν\nu solving Eq. (4) as a function of the cone angle β\beta; the grey symbols are the cone angles measured in the DNS. The red dot marks Taylor’s cone, β=49.3∘\beta= 49.3^\circ, ν=0.5\nu= 0.5. (b) Exponent α=1/(2−ν)\alpha= 1/(2-\nu) as a function of OhOh for Bo=0Bo = 0 (levels 13–15) and Bo=10−3Bo = 10^{-3} (level 13), using the same cone fits; marker shapes distinguish refinement levels. The dashed line marks α=2/3\alpha= 2/3.

The values of ν(β)\nu(\beta) in Figure 4 (End Matter) show that ν(β)→0\nu(\beta)\to0 and α(β)→1/2\alpha(\beta)\to1/2 as β→0\beta\to0, consistent with the far-field condition in Eq. (2), used in [33] to predict, up to prefactors, the ejection of Worthington jets following the collapse of cones with β≪1\beta\ll1 or slender axisymmetric cavities of arbitrary shape, like parabolas. These theoretical predictions are in excellent agreement with experiments and numerical simulations [35]. Also, rj(τ)∝τ2/3r_j(\tau)\propto\tau^{2/3} when the semiangle β\beta coincides with the one characterizing Taylor’s cone in electrosprays, β=49.3∘\beta=49.3^\circ [36]. Here ν=1/2\nu=1/2, so α=2/3\alpha=2/3 is a special case of the present inertial family. Its WejWe_j is constant, without requiring its magnitude to be of order unity. The exponent 2/32/3 alone therefore cannot establish an inertio-capillary balance. Here, we stress that one of the main advances over [33] is that our theory predicts the near-inception jet dynamics observed in simulations and experiments for conical cavities with β=O(1)\beta=O(1), with the equipotential condition ϕ(θ=β)=0\phi(\theta=\beta)=0 selecting ν(β)\nu(\beta) and hence α(β)=1/(2−ν(β))\alpha(\beta)=1/(2-\nu(\beta)), whereas constant-flux forcing gives rj∝τ1/2r_j\propto\tau^{1/2} with β\beta-dependent prefactors. In fact, it is shown below that our present theory describes the conical-collapse regime relevant to sea spray [4] and to acoustically driven jets used in drug delivery and biofilm removal [22, 30].

DNS and experimental validation. — We express three local quantities as functions of the jet radius rj(τ)r_j(\tau), namely the flow rate per unit length along the axis of the cone qj=vjrjq_j=v_jr_j, the flow rate feeding the jet Qj=πrjqjQ_j=\pi r_jq_j, and the local Weber number Wej=vj2rj=qj2/rjWe_j=v_j^2r_j=q_j^2/r_j. After some algebra, we find qj(τ)∝rj(2α(β)−1)/α(β)q_j(\tau)\propto r_j^{(2\alpha(\beta)-1)/\alpha(\beta)}, Qj∝rj(3α(β)−1)/α(β)Q_j\propto r_j^{(3\alpha(\beta)-1)/\alpha(\beta)}, Wej∝rj(3α(β)−2)/α(β)We_j\propto r_j^{(3\alpha(\beta)-2)/\alpha(\beta)}, with α(β)=1/(2−ν(β))\alpha(\beta)=1/(2-\nu(\beta)) and ν(β)\nu(\beta) fixed by the condition Pν(−cos⁡β)=0P_\nu(-\cos\beta)=0. The results depicted in Figure 2(b) and Figure 5(a) in the End Matter compare our theoretical results above with the numerical values of Wej(rj)We_j(r_j) and Qj(rj)Q_j(r_j) calculated using Basilisk C [37, 38, 39] for Oh=0.03Oh=0.03, with β\beta determined from the numerical simulations, showing that inertia governs the jet-base dynamics, as predicted by our theory. The plot corresponding to Wej(rj)=qj2/rjWe_j(r_j)=q_j^2/r_j in Figure 2(b) (see also Figure 5(b) in the End Matter) reveals that our theory clearly departs from the inertio-capillary balance Wej=const=O(1)We_j=\mathrm{const}=O(1) and captures the observed growth of WejWe_j toward the singularity (Wej=O(102)We_j=O(10^2) over 0.002≤rj≤0.0240.002\le r_j\le0.024); notice also that Wej∝rj−1We_j\propto r_j^{-1} for larger times after jet inception [40]. Moreover, Figure 3 (see also Supplementary Fig. S3 and Supplementary Videos 1 and 2) shows the collapse of the rescaled shapes before and after inception, strongly supporting the predicted self-similar structure. The same profiles also collapse with α=2/3\alpha=2/3 (Supplementary Fig. S3). The distinction between the two theories is therefore the physical balance revealed by WejWe_j. Notice also that the reason why it has been long thought [19, 21, 22] that the collapse of clean capillary cavities is driven by a balance between dynamic and capillary pressures relies on the small differences between the inertio-capillary exponent α=2/3\alpha=2/3 and the correct result α(β≈40∘)≈0.63\alpha(\beta\approx40^\circ)\approx0.63.

Figure 5. Dependence on OhOh and refinement. (a) Jet-feeding flux QjQ_j versus rjr_j for Oh=0.028Oh = 0.028, 0.030.03 and 0.040.04. (b) Corresponding Weber-number trajectories, with Wej=Qj2/(πrj3)We_j = Q_j^2/(\pi r_j^3). In (a,b), colour denotes OhOh, darker shades indicate higher focusing levels ℓpre\ell_{\mathrm{pre}}, and symbols identify the pre- and post-inception refinement pairs. Shading marks the conical-inertial regime. The guides in (b) are those of Figure 2(b), with the dashed line marking Wej=1We_j = 1. (c) Radius at fixed Rej=20Re_j = 20, showing the full dataset and the same slope guides as in the inset of Figure 2(b). Grey points denote the additional OhOh values. In (c), grey shading marks the conical regime 0.027<Oh<0.040.027 < Oh < 0.04.

Next, we compare in Figure 2(c) our theory with the experimental values of the maximum jet velocity reported in Figure 5(a) of [22], corresponding to a collapsing conical cavity formed by converging, acoustically driven surface waves. To carry out the comparison, we need to define a length scale in their flow equivalent to our initial bubble radius, RR, which we choose to be their critical surface wave amplitude hc≈20 μmh_c\approx20\,\mu\mathrm{m}. Using our previous result qj=vjrj∝rj(2α(β)−1)/α(β)q_j=v_jr_j\propto r_j^{(2\alpha(\beta)-1)/\alpha(\beta)} and defining the dimensionless smallest length scale of the jet as rm=∣h−hc∣/hcr_m=|h-h_c|/h_c, where hh is their wave amplitude, we can write

Vj=CMσμOhc2(α−1)/αrm(α−1)/α,(5)V_j=C_M\frac{\sigma}{\mu}Oh_c^{2(\alpha-1)/\alpha}r_m^{(\alpha-1)/\alpha}, \tag*{(5)}

where Ohc=μ/ρσhc≈0.0264Oh_c=\mu/\sqrt{\rho\sigma h_c}\approx0.0264 and CMC_M is a numerical prefactor of order unity. The experimental jet velocity of Figure 5(a) of [22] is compared in Figure 2(c) with the prediction of our equation (5), using CM=4.6C_M=4.6 and α=0.654\alpha=0.654, corresponding to β=46∘\beta=46^\circ (as measured from Figure 3(a) in [22]). We can see that the agreement with the experiments is visibly better than the one obtained using the inertio-capillary theory (Eq. (6) in [22]), proving that our theory can be used to achieve better quantitative predictions of existing experimental data.

Viscous cutoff. — Viscosity becomes comparable to inertia when Rej=vjrj/Oh∼1Re_j=v_jr_j/Oh\sim1 [18]. Combining this condition with vjrj∝rj(2α−1)/αv_jr_j\propto r_j^{(2\alpha-1)/\alpha} gives $r_m\propto Oh^{\alpha/(2\alpha-1)` and Rm=Rrm∝[μ2/(ρσ)]Oh(2−3α)/(2α−1)R_m = R r_m \propto[\mu^2/(\rho\sigma)]Oh^{(2-3\alpha)/(2\alpha-1)}. In the simulations, RejRe_j remains above unity. We choose Rej=20Re_j = 20 and measure the corresponding radius, for which the two finest grids agree (inset of Figure 2(b) and Figure 5(c) in the End Matter). This gives a grid-independent diagnostic of the regularization of the resolved branch [41]. The measured radius is an upper-bound proxy for rmr_m as the Rej=1Re_j = 1 crossing remains at the mesh floor. Due to the fact that α(β)<2/3\alpha(\beta) < 2/3 [42], the minimum jet radius and the corresponding maximum achievable velocity are respectively smaller (radius) and larger (velocity) than the ones deduced using α=2/3\alpha= 2/3, which gives Rm∼100 nmR_m \sim100\ \mathrm{nm} [4, 25, 43]. Indeed, for Oh=0.03Oh = 0.03, the cone fit [44] gives β=38.4∘\beta= 38.4^\circ, α≃0.63\alpha\simeq0.63, Rm∼0.2μ2/(ρσ)R_m \sim0.2\mu^2/(\rho\sigma), and the maximum velocity deduced using the definition of RejRe_j is VM≈4σ/μV_M \approx4\sigma/\mu; using water properties, Rm∼3 nmR_m \sim3\ \mathrm{nm} and VM∼320 m s−1V_M \sim320\ \mathrm{m\,s^{-1}}: these values indicate that viscosity is unable to regularize the singularity within the range of validity of the continuum description, and also suggest that, thanks to their purely inertial nature, if continuum axisymmetry was preserved down to the instant of jet inception [45], bubble bursting jets in clean liquids could produce a flux of aerosol particles with sizes ranging from nanometres — not hundreds of nanometres, as it was previously thought [4, 25, 43] — to microns.

Conclusion

We have derived a family of self-similar solutions of the incompressible Euler equations for the collapse of a conical gas cavity of semiangle β\beta. The jet radius and velocity scale as rj(τ)∝τ1/(2−ν(β))r_j(\tau) \propto\tau^{1/(2-\nu(\beta))} and vj(τ)∝τ(ν(β)−1)/(2−ν(β))v_j(\tau) \propto\tau^{(\nu(\beta)-1)/(2-\nu(\beta))}, with ν(β)\nu(\beta) the degree of the Legendre function satisfying Pν(−cos⁡β)=0P_{\nu}(-\cos\beta) = 0. For the measured bubble-entrapment range 35∘≲β≲41∘35^\circ\lesssim\beta\lesssim41^\circ, this gives 0.62≲1/(2−ν)≲0.640.62 \lesssim1/(2-\nu) \lesssim0.64, close enough to 2/32/3 to explain why inertio-capillary scalings appeared plausible. The evidence for the validity of our result comes directly from WejWe_j, not only from the fitted exponent. For the measured bubble-bursting cone angles, Wej(τ)∝τ(2ν−1)/(2−ν)We_j(\tau) \propto\tau^{(2\nu-1)/(2-\nu)} diverges as τ→0\tau\to0, and the DNS gives both Wej≫1We_j \gg1 and collapse of the free surface near the jet base over the pre- and post-inception windows in Figure 3 when lengths are scaled with ∣τ∣1/(2−ν[β(Oh)])|\tau|^{1/(2-\nu[\beta(Oh)])}. For these small-BoBo cases, OhOh controls access to the singularity by selecting β\beta, the inception time, and the regularization scale; once the similarity window exists, the local collapse is governed by inertia. For water, we find that viscosity is unable to regularize the divergent self-similar solution within the continuum approach. The predicted nanometric viscous cutoff calls for a description of how inertial focusing is regularized in a real liquid. Future work could match the present similarity solution to a moleculelar description of jet inception, while three-dimensional simulations would be needed to test whether azimuthal perturbations interrupt focusing at larger scales. Following the resulting jet through breakup, including thermal fluctuations [46, 47], would establish whether nanometric jet radii lead to nanometric droplets, and how the geometry-selected collapse shapes the smallest sea-spray aerosols. The range of validity of this inertial description could also be tested across other routes to singular jet formation, including Faraday-wave collapse [19], air-cavity collapse during drop recoil on superhydrophobic solids [48], and the singular-jet regime after drop impact on a deep liquid pool [49, 50, 51, 52]. Comparisons from finite cone angles to the slender limit could identify where the approximately equipotential conical boundary or inertial balance fails.

Acknowledgments

This research work has been partially supported by the Grants PID2024-156545NB-I00 and PID2023-146809OB-I00, financed by the Spanish MI-CIU/AEI/10.13039/501100011033 and by ERDF/EU. V.S. acknowledges start-up funding from Durham University. This work made use of the Hamilton HPC Service of Durham University. The simulation work was also carried out on the national e-infrastructure of SURFsara, a subsidiary of SURF cooperation, the collaborative ICT organisation for Dutch education and research; this simulation work was sponsored by NWO — Domain Science for the use of supercomputer facilities.

Code availability. The solver, case files, and post-processing scripts required to reproduce the figures in this Letter are available at the public CoMPhy Lab repository [44].

End Matter

Numerical methods and data availability

We solve the axisymmetric two-phase incompressible Navier–Stokes equations with the opensource freesoftware language Basilisk C [37, 38, 39]. The interface is represented using a geometric volume-of-fluid field cc, with density and viscosity interpolated in the one-fluid formulation. At Bo=0Bo = 0, the dimensional governing equations are

∇⋅u=0,(6)\nabla\cdot\mathbf{u} = 0, \tag*{(6)}
ρ(c)(∂tu+u⋅∇u)=−∇p+∇⋅[2μ(c)D]+σκδsn,(7)\rho(c) \left(\partial_t\mathbf{u}+\mathbf{u}\cdot\nabla\mathbf{u}\right)=-\nabla p+\nabla\cdot\left[2\mu(c)\mathbf{D}\right]+\sigma\kappa\delta_{s}\mathbf{n}, \tag*{(7)}

where D=[∇u+(∇u)T]/2\mathbf{D}=[\nabla\mathbf{u}+(\nabla\mathbf{u})^{T}]/2. Lengths, velocities, time, and pressure are scaled with RR, Vc=σ/(ρlR)V_c=\sqrt{\sigma/(\rho_lR)}, R/VcR/V_c, and σ/R\sigma/R, respectively. We fix ρg/ρl=10−3\rho_g/\rho_l=10^{-3} and μg/μl=2×10−2\mu_g/\mu_l=2\times10^{-2}; all results reported in the Letter use Bo=0Bo=0 and Oh≃0.03Oh\simeq0.03, unless stated otherwise. The additional Oh=0.028Oh=0.028 and 0.040.04 series are shown in Figure 5.

For Bo=0Bo=0, the initial condition is a spherical bubble of radius RR intersecting a flat free surface. The point contact is regularized by a capillary bridge of size δb=0.01R\delta_b=0.01R, leaving an initial opening of radius ≃2δb\simeq2\delta_b. The computational domain spans −6≤z′≤4-6\leq z'\leq4 and 0≤rp≤100\leq r_p\leq10 for the production cases; the lower axial boundary is a no-slip, no-penetration wall, the upper axial boundary is an outflow, and rp=0r_p=0 is the axis of symmetry.

Adaptive mesh refinement is applied to the volume fraction, velocity, and curvature fields. To resolve the focusing singularity at jet inception, we developed a feature-tracking refinement criterion that follows the largest incoming curvature wave before inception and the newly formed jet thereafter. The interface shapes in Figure 3 use MAXlevel=15MAXlevel=15, corresponding to a finest cell size Δ/R=10/215≃3.1×10−4\Delta/R=10/2^{15}\simeq3.1\times10^{-4}, while the flux comparison in Figure 2 spans post-inception levels 13–16.

Grid sensitivity is assessed in Figure 2 using pairs (ℓpre,ℓpost)(\ell_{\mathrm{pre}},\ell_{\mathrm{post}}). Here ℓpre\ell_{\mathrm{pre}} is the temporary ceiling while the focusing curvature wave is tracked before inception; once the jet forms, the mesh is released to the post-inception ceiling ℓpost\ell_{\mathrm{post}}.

Solution to the equation Pν(−cos⁡β)=0P_\nu(-\cos\beta)=0

For each β\beta, Eq. (4) is solved as a scalar root-finding problem for the real degree ν\nu of Pν(−cos⁡β)P_\nu(-\cos\beta), choosing the branch continuous with Taylor’s cone, β=49.3∘\beta=49.3^\circ and ν=1/2\nu=1/2. Figure 4(a) shows this mapping; panel (b) converts the DNS-measured cone angles into α=1/(2−ν)\alpha=1/(2-\nu) as a function of OhOh. The exponents are systematically below 2/32/3 and vary with OhOh, providing additional evidence against a fixed inertio-capillary exponent and in favour of the inertial conical-collapse similarity.

Supplemental Material for “Self-similar Worthington jets”

José M. Gordillo; Javier Rodríguez–Rodríguez; Vatsal Sanjay

supplemental.pdf

Cone-angle extraction and sensitivity

At the snapshot nearest to jet inception, we fit the cavity flank to rp=mz′+cr_p = mz^\prime+ c by unweighted least squares on the interface-facet endpoints within −1.30≤z′≤−0.25-1.30 \le z^\prime\le-0.25 and 0.20≤rp≤1.100.20 \le r_p \le1.10 (Figure S1). The fitted line gives the semiangle from the axis, β=arctan⁡m\beta= \arctan m, and the apparent apex, ℓ0=−c/m\ell_0 = -c/m. This full-window fit gives β=38.356∘\beta= 38.356^\circ. Solving Pν(−cos⁡β)=0P_\nu(-\cos\beta) = 0 then determines α=1/(2−ν)\alpha= 1/(2-\nu) independently of the jet-flux fit.

Cone-angle extraction and sensitivity plots

Figure S1. Cone-angle extraction and sensitivity. (a) Cavity interface at Oh=0.03Oh = 0.03, with the full fitting window in light grey and its cropped part in darker grey. The full-window fit (dashed line) gives β=38.4∘\beta= 38.4^\circ; dotted extensions reach the apparent apex ℓ0\ell_0, and the arc measures β\beta from the axis. (b) Evolution of β\beta before reconnection, using the cropped window at the available snapshot times. (c) Angles at the last pre-reconnection snapshot of each simulation, labelled by pre/post refinement levels, with ranges from nine fitting windows. The right axis gives the corresponding α(β)\alpha(\beta). Filled and open stars mark the full and cropped fits to the same interface in (a).

To compare with the other interface sequences, which extend only to rp<0.6r_p < 0.6, we crop the radial fitting window to 0.20≤rp≤0.600.20 \le r_p \le0.60 and retain the same axial limits. For the same interface in Figure S1, cropping alone increases β\beta to 39.151∘39.151^\circ, a shift of 0.795∘0.795^\circ. Within the cropped window, β\beta rises by 0.890.89–0.99∘0.99^\circ during the last τ≈2×10−3\tau\approx2 \times10^{-3} before reconnection (Figure S1). Across the nine windows defined by rp,min⁡∈{0.15,0.20,0.25}r_{p,\min} \in\{0.15, 0.20, 0.25\} and rp,max⁡∈{0.50,0.55,0.60}r_{p,\max} \in\{0.50, 0.55, 0.60\}, the fitted angle varies by 1.481.48–1.57∘1.57^\circ at the last pre-reconnection snapshot of each simulation (panel c).

The solver, cone-fitting routine and paper-processing scripts are available in the public CoMPhy Lab repository.

Flux exponents and refinement

At Oh=0.03Oh = 0.03, the jet has Wej≃80We_j \simeq80–142142 and Rej≃23Re_j \simeq23–5151 over the reference interval 0.005≤rj≤0.0239520.005 \le r_j \le0.023952. The Weber number is large and increases as rjr_j decreases; together with Rej>20Re_j > 20, this supports the inertial balance within this window. We take the theoretical exponent 0.629 from the cone geometry and compare it with the numerical flux slopes measured independently over finite radius intervals.

For a flux law Qj∝rjsQ_j \propto r_j^s, the corresponding Weber-number law is Wej∝rj2s−3We_j \propto r_j^{2s-3} and the effective exponent is αeff=1/(3−s)\alpha_{\mathrm{eff}} = 1/(3-s). The two slopes are therefore algebraically equivalent diagnostics. We fit the plotted jet-base flux QjQ_j separately for each refinement history (ℓpre,ℓpost)(\ell_{\mathrm{pre}},\ell_{\mathrm{post}}), keeping histories with the same final level distinct. For each trajectory, the fit uses geometric means from 24 equal logarithmic radius bins, with equal weight assigned to every occupied bin.

We compare fixed exponents by refitting their amplitudes on the same observations, with equal total weight per occupied radius bin. The smaller residuals for 0.629 than for 2/3 in all nine tested windows for each of the nine available histories favour 0.629 over these intervals.

(ℓpre,ℓpost)(\ell_{\mathrm{pre}},\ell_{\mathrm{post}})ssαeff\alpha_{\mathrm{eff}}RMS (0.629)RMS (2/3)
(12,13)1.4472±0.00261.4472 \pm0.00260.6440±0.00110.6440 \pm0.00110.017720.02501
(12,14)1.4254±0.00381.4254 \pm0.00380.6351±0.00150.6351 \pm0.00150.008520.03381
(13,14)1.4320±0.00251.4320 \pm0.00250.6378±0.00100.6378 \pm0.00100.010830.03205
(13,15)1.4231±0.00211.4231 \pm0.00210.6342±0.00090.6342 \pm0.00090.006750.03615
(14,15)1.4063±0.00391.4063 \pm0.00390.6275±0.00150.6275 \pm0.00150.007490.04240
(14,16)1.4102±0.00361.4102 \pm0.00360.6290±0.00140.6290 \pm0.00140.004850.04049
(15,15)1.4031±0.00361.4031 \pm0.00360.6262±0.00140.6262 \pm0.00140.008350.04454
(15,16)1.4025±0.00521.4025 \pm0.00520.6260±0.00210.6260 \pm0.00210.009140.04957
(16,16)1.3998±0.00391.3998 \pm0.00390.6249±0.00150.6249 \pm0.00150.008970.04544

Table 1. Finite-window flux fits at Oh=0.03Oh = 0.03, reconstructed from the plotted observations. The reference window contains 11–25 observations and 11–24 occupied bins per trajectory. The quoted uncertainties are formal least-squares residual standard errors, calculated with m−2m - 2 degrees of freedom for mm occupied bins. The last two columns give the RMS residual in ln⁡Qj\ln Q_j for the fixed exponents α=0.629\alpha= 0.629 and α=2/3\alpha= 2/3. For each fixed exponent, the amplitude is refitted to the same extracted observations, with equal total weight assigned to each occupied radius bin.

Leaving the slope free gives 0.6249≤αeff≤0.62900.6249 \le\alpha_{\mathrm{eff}} \le0.6290 for the five histories with ℓpre≥14\ell_{\mathrm{pre}} \ge14 in the reference window, close to the value selected by the cone geometry. For (ℓpre,ℓpost)=(16,16)(\ell_{\mathrm{pre}},\ell_{\mathrm{post}}) = (16,16), however, varying the fitting window gives 0.6118≤αeff≤0.63040.6118 \le\alpha_{\mathrm{eff}} \le0.6304 (Table 2). The small formal errors are derived from residual scatter within individual fits and account for neither window dependence nor correlations along a trajectory.

rj,min⁡r_{j,\min}rj,max⁡r_{j,\max}(12,13)(12, 13)(12,14)(12, 14)(13,14)(13, 14)(13,15)(13, 15)
0.00500.0180000.64650.63890.64030.6362
0.00500.0239520.64400.63510.63780.6342
0.00500.0300000.64010.62980.63330.6301
0.00650.0180000.64580.63560.63990.6365
0.00650.0239520.64240.63060.63640.6333
0.00650.0300000.63760.62410.63080.6280
0.00800.0180000.64360.63360.63800.6356
0.00800.0239520.63960.62850.63360.6312
0.00800.0300000.63400.62170.62690.6246
rj,min⁡r_{j,\min}rj,max⁡r_{j,\max}(14,15)(14, 15)(14,16)(14, 16)(15,15)(15, 15)(15,16)(15, 16)(16,16)(16, 16)
0.00500.0180000.63190.63270.63130.63100.6304
0.00500.0239520.62750.62900.62620.62600.6249
0.00500.0300000.62290.62350.62170.62180.6197
0.00650.0180000.62870.63050.62770.62770.6275
0.00650.0239520.62410.62520.62150.62110.6209
0.00650.0300000.61910.61800.61770.61730.6148
0.00800.0180000.62500.62900.62480.62560.6254
0.00800.0239520.62000.62320.61910.61850.6183
0.00800.0300000.61480.61550.61400.61440.6118

Table 2. Effective exponents αeff\alpha_{\mathrm{eff}} obtained by varying the radius window, using the same 24-bin fitting procedure for each refinement history. Column headings give (ℓpre,ℓpost)(\ell_{\mathrm{pre}},\ell_{\mathrm{post}}). Together, the two blocks contain the nine histories for which flux observations at Oh=0.03Oh = 0.03 are available in the figure.

Radius at a fixed Reynolds number

For the singular Worthington jet, a natural continuum cutoff may come from viscous stresses. However, the simulations do not resolve that cutoff length scale rj=rmr_j = r_m, such that Rej≡vjrj/Oh∼1Re_j \equiv v_jr_j/Oh \sim1. We compare the resolved jet across OhOh using its radius rj(Re∗)r_j(Re_*) when the jet-base Reynolds number RejRe_j reaches Re∗=20Re_* = 20, 25 or 30. For a fixed cone angle, vjrj∝rj(2α−1)/αv_jr_j \propto r_j^{(2\alpha-1)/\alpha} gives rj(Re∗)∝(Re∗Oh)α/(2α−1)r_j(Re_*) \propto(Re_*Oh)^{\alpha/(2\alpha-1)}, so these choices alter the prefactor without changing the predicted power of OhOh.

We first take the median RejRe_j within logarithmically spaced radius bins to suppress isolated transient spikes. We then interpolate in logarithmic coordinates between the two bin medians bracketing Re∗Re_* to obtain rj(Re∗)r_j(Re_*), using the same procedure for every OhOh and refinement history. For Re∗=20Re_* = 20, the (15, 15) and (16, 16) histories give almost identical radii at Oh=0.03Oh = 0.03 and differ by about six percent at $Oh = 0.04 (Figure S2). The corresponding radii at Re∗=25Re_* = 25 and 30 also increase with OhOh, while the differences between these two histories remain small. Neither the increase above the low-OhOh plateau nor the agreement between these histories therefore depends on choosing Re∗=20Re_* = 20.

Figure S2. Jet radius rj(Re∗)r_j(Re_\ast) versus OhOh at Re∗=20Re_\ast= 20 (blue), 25 (green) and 30 (purple), with symbols identifying the refinement pairs (ℓpre,ℓpost)(\ell_{\mathrm{pre}},\ell_{\mathrm{post}}). Solid black lines show the conical scaling at Re∗=20Re_\ast= 20 (lower) and 30 (upper), and the grey dashed line shows the inertio-capillary scaling. The horizontal grey line indicates the low-OhOh plateau, and the shaded band covers the conical regime 0.027<Oh<0.040.027 < Oh < 0.04. The Re∗=20Re_\ast= 20 points and guides are the same as in the inset of Figure 2(b) and Figure 5(c) of the Letter.

Interface collapse

Figure S3 compares the profiles shown in Fig. 3 of the Letter after rescaling with α=2/3\alpha= 2/3 and α=0.629\alpha= 0.629. Both exponents collapse the interfaces over the displayed pre- and post-inception windows, so the collapse of the shapes alone does not distinguish the underlying force balance.

Figure S3. Comparison of the two similarity exponents on the same interfaces. The upper row shows pre-inception cavity collapse; the lower row shows the post-inception jet. Columns show unscaled profiles, α=2/3\alpha= 2/3, and α=0.629\alpha= 0.629. In each rescaled panel, τ=τ′−τ0\tau= \tau' - \tau_0, with τ0=0.494430\tau_0 = 0.494430. Supplementary Videos 1 and 2 show the pre- and post-inception sequences.

Supplementary videos

Video 1 shows the pre-inception cavity.

Video 2 shows the post-inception jet.

Video 3 provides a visual summary of the work.

Files: SM1-pre-collapse.mp4, SM2-post-collapse.mp4, and SM3-summary.mp4.

References

  1. [1]F. MacIntyre, Flow patterns in breaking bubbles, J. Geophys. Res. 77, 5211 (1972).DOI
  2. [2]K. Bigg and C. Leck, The composition of fragments of bubbles bursting at the ocean surface, J. Geophys. Res. 113, D11209 (2008).DOI
  3. [3]X. Wang, G. B. Deane, K. A. Moore, O. S. Ryder, M. D. Stokes, C. M. Beall, D. B. Collins, M. V. Santander, S. M. Burrows, C. M. Sultana, and K. A. Prather, The role of jet and film drops in controlling the mixing state of submicron sea spray aerosol particles, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 114, 6978 (2017).DOI
  4. [4]L. Deike, Mass transfer at the ocean–atmosphere interface: The role of wave breaking, droplets, and bubbles, Annu. Rev. Fluid Mech. 54, 191 (2022).DOI
  5. [5]X. Jiang, L. Rotily, E. Villermeaux, and X. Wang, Submicron drops from flapping bursting bubbles, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 119, e2112924119 (2022).DOI
  6. [6]X. Jiang, L. Rotily, E. Villermeaux, and X. Wang, Abyss aerosols: Drop production from underwater bubble collisions, Phys. Rev. Lett. 133, 024001 (2024).DOI
  7. [7]Y. Joung and C. B. Buie, Aerosol generation by raindrop impact on soil, Nature Commun. 6, 6083 (2015).DOI
  8. [8]T. Séon and G. Liger-Belair, Effervescence in champagne and sparkling wines: From bubble bursting to droplet evaporation, Eur. Phys. J. Spec. Top. 226, 117 (2017).DOI
  9. [9]A. Bashkatov, F. Bürk le, Ç. Demirkır, W. Ding, V. Sanjay, A. Babich, X. Yang, G. Mutschke, J. Czarske, D. Lohse, D. Krug, L. Büttner, and K. Eckert, Electrolyte droplet spraying in H2 bubbles during water electrolysis under normal and microgravity conditions, Nature Commun. 16, 4580 (2025).
  10. [10]J. M. Boulton-Stone and J. R. Blake, Gas bubbles bursting at a free surface, Journal of Fluid Mechanics 254, 437–466 (1993).
  11. [11]L. Duchemin, S. Popinet, C. Josserand, and S. Zaleski, Jet formation in bubbles bursting at a free surface, Phys. Fluids 14, 3000 (2002).
  12. [12]P. L. L. Walls, L. Hénaux, and J. C. Bird, Jet drops from bursting bubbles: How gravity and viscosity couple to inhibit droplet production, Phys. Rev. E 92, 021002(R) (2015).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/26382335
  13. [13]S. Krishnan, E. J. Hopfinger, and B. A. Puthenveettil, On the scaling of jetting from bubble collapse at a liquid surface, J. Fluid Mech. 822, 791 (2017).DOI
  14. [14]C. Bras, C. Bartlett, P. Walls, E. Flynn, Y. Yu, and J. Bird, Minimum size for the top jet drop from a bursting bubble, Phys. Rev. Fluids 3, 074001 (2018).
  15. [15]L. Deike, E. Ghabache, G. Liger-Belair, A. Das, S. Zaleski, S. Popinet, and T. Seon, Dynamics of jets produced by bursting bubbles, Phys. Rev. Fluids 3, 013603 (2018).DOI
  16. [16]A. Berny, L. Deike, T. Séon, and S. Popinet, Role of all jet drops in mass transfer from bursting bubbles, Phys. Rev. Fluids 5, 033605 (2020).DOI
  17. [17]In the following, lower-case letters indicate dimensionless variables defined using R, the capillary velocity Vc = √(σ/(ρR)), and ρVc² as the characteristic values of length, velocity and pressure. In the limit Bo → 0, the pre-inception bubble-bursting dynamics are controlled by Oh, or equivalently La = Oh−2; gas properties become relevant after ejection through the drag exerted on the jet tip and emitted droplets [25, 51].
  18. [18]J. M. Gordillo and J. Rodríguez-Rodríguez, Capillary waves control the ejection of bubble bursting jets, J. Fluid Mech. 867, 557 (2019).DOI
  19. [19]B. Zeff, B. Kleber, J. Fineberg, and D. Lathrop, Singularity dynamics in curvature collapse and jet eruption on a fluid surface, Nature 403, 401 (2000).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/10667786
  20. [20]A. Sierou and J. Lister, Self-similar recoil of inviscid drops, Phys. Fluids 16, 1379 (2004).
  21. [21]C.-Y. Lai, J. Eggers, and L. Deike, Bubble bursting: Universal cavity and jet profiles, Phys. Rev. Lett. 121, 144501 (2018).DOI
  22. [22]M. Cattaneo, L. Presser, and O. Supponen, Faraday wave singularities trigger microbubble jetting, Phys. Rev. Lett. 135, 204002 (2025).DOI
  23. [23]E. Ghabache, A. Antkowiak, C. Josserand, and T. Séon, On the physics of fizziness: How bubble bursting controls droplets ejection, Physics of Fluids 26, 121701 (2014).
  24. [24]A. Gañán Calvo, Revision of bubble bursting: Universal scaling laws of top jet drop size and speed, Phys. Rev. Lett. 119, 204502 (2017).
  25. [25]F. J. Blanco-Rodríguez and J. M. Gordillo, On the sea spray aerosol originated from bubble bursting jets, J. Fluid Mech. 886, R2 (2020).
  26. [26]A. M. Gañán-Calvo and J. M. López-Herrera, On the physics of transient ejection from bubble bursting, J. Fluid Mech. 929, A12 (2021).
  27. [27]A. M. Gañán-Calvo, The ocean fine spray, Phys. Fluids 35, 023317 (2023).
  28. [28]J. Eshima, T. Aurégan, P. K. Farsoiya, S. Popinet, H. A. Stone, and L. Deike, Size amplification of jet drops due to insoluble surfactants, Phys. Rev. Fluids 10, 123604 (2025).DOI
  29. [29]S. Rodriguez-Aparicio, A. Cebrián-García, E. J. Vega, J. M. Montanero, and M. G. Cabezas, Effect of surface-active contaminants on bubble bursting yielding the smallest first-emitted droplet, J. Fluid Mech. 1032, A49 (2026).
  30. [30]M. Cattaneo, G. Guerriero, G. Shakya, L. A. Krattiger, L. G. Paganella, M. L. Narciso, and O. Supponen, Cyclic jetting enables microbubble-mediated drug delivery, Nat. Phys. 21, 590 (2025).DOI
  31. [31]The Bond number changes the initial cavity shape, while Oh controls capillary-wave damping.
  32. [32]Z. Yang, V. Sanjay, C. R. Constante-Amores, and J. Feng, Confinement-induced suppression of jet drop size by bubble bursting in shallow liquids (2026), arXiv:2606.28609 [physics.flu-dyn].arxiv.org/abs/2606.28609
  33. [33]J. M. Gordillo and F. J. Blanco-Rodríguez, Theory of the jets ejected after the inertial collapse of cavities with applications to bubble bursting jets, Phys. Rev. Fluids 8, 073606 (2023).
  34. [34]H. Wagner, Über stoß-und gleitvorgänge an der oberfläche von flüssigkeiten, Z. Angew. Math. Mech. 12, 193 (1932).DOI
  35. [35]Y. Fan, A. Bußmann, F. Reuter, H. Bao, S. Adami, J. M. Gordillo, N. Adams, and C.-D. Ohl, Amplification of supersonic microjets by resonant inertial cavitation-bubble pair, Phys. Rev. Lett. 132, 104004 (2024).DOI
  36. [36]G. I. Taylor, Disintegration of water drops in an electric field, Proc. R. Soc. Lond. A 280, 383 (1964).DOI
  37. [37]S. Popinet, An accurate adaptive solver for surface-tension-driven interfacial flows, J. Comput. Phys. 228, 5838 (2009).DOI
  38. [38]S. Popinet, A quadtree-adaptive multigrid solver for the Serre–Green–Naghdi equations, J. Comput. Phys. 302, 336 (2015).DOI
  39. [39]V. Sanjay, D. Lohse, and M. Jalaal, Bursting bubble in a viscoplastic medium, J. Fluid Mech. 922, A2 (2021).DOI
  40. [40]The spatial region in which streamlines are horizontal in Fig. 4(b) of Ref. [33] corresponds to the far-field boundary condition in Eq. (2): when, at later times after jet inception the vertical position of the base of the jet reaches this region, rj ∝ τ1/2, Wej ∝ τ−1/2 ∝ rj−1 for all values of Oh, no matter the value of β [33].
  41. [41]Supplemental Fig. S2 tests the sensitivity of the radii in the Fig. 2(b) inset and Fig. 5(c) to the chosen Reynolds-number threshold. The increase with Oh and the agreement across different grid resolutions persist at Rej = 25 and 30.
  42. [42]See [49–51], where experimental exponents α < 2/3 are also reported.
  43. [43]E. Villermaux, X. Wang, and L. Deike, Bubbles spray aerosols: Certitudes and mysteries, PNAS Nexus 1, pgac261 (2022).DOI
  44. [44]V. Sanjay, Code repository: bursting bubble simulations, https://github.com/comphy-lab/Bursting-Bubble (2026), last accessed: 7 July 2026.
  45. [45]S. Gekle and J. M. Gordillo, Generation and breakup of worthington jets after cavity collapse. part 1. jet formation, J. Fluid Mech. 663, 293 (2010).DOI
  46. [46]M. Moseler and U. Landman, Formation, stability, and breakup of nanojets, Science 289, 1165 (2000).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/10947978
  47. [47]J. Eggers, Dynamics of liquid nanojets, Phys. Rev. Lett. 89, 084502 (2002).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/12190472
  48. [48]B. Zhang, V. Sanjay, S. Shi, Y. Zhao, C. Lv, X.-Q. Feng, and D. Lohse, Impact forces of water drops falling on superhydrophobic surfaces, Phys. Rev. Lett. 129, 104501 (2022).DOI
  49. [49]S. T. Thoroddsen, K. Takehara, H. D. Nguyen, and T. G. Etoh, Singular jets during the collapse of drop-impact craters, J. Fluid Mech. 848, R3 (2018).DOI
  50. [50]Z. Q. Yang, Y. S. Tian, and S. T. Thoroddsen, Multitude of dimple shapes can produce singular jets during the collapse of immiscible drop-impact craters, J. Fluid Mech. 904, A19 (2020).DOI
  51. [51]Y. Tian, Z. Yang, and S. Thoroddsen, Conical focusing: mechanism for singular jetting from collapsing drop-impact craters, J. Fluid Mech. 958, R1 (2023).DOI
  52. [52]G.-J. Michon, C. Josserand, and T. Séon, Jet dynamics post drop impact on a deep pool, Phys. Rev. Fluids 2, 023601 (2017).DOI

Paper details

vlnc:W_mqm4fuuu
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 1

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents