betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

A Bound Helium Dianion Does Not Exist

Abstract

For a non-relativistic atom with ZZ protons and NN bound electrons, Lieb proved in 1984 that N<2Z+1N<2Z+1. Several improved bounds have been developed, but they all leave open the question of whether a bound helium dianion can exist. We prove that the answer is no. The ground-state energies of the four- and three-electron helium Hamiltonians coincide, E4(Z=2)=E3(Z=2)E_4(Z{=}2)=E_3(Z{=}2), so a helium nucleus binds at most three electrons. A weighted form of Lieb's identity reduces the problem to the nonnegativity of an explicit two-electron Schrodinger operator mm, and Barta's inequality further reduces it to the pointwise nonnegativity of an explicit function of three variables. We prove the nonnegativity of this function by a combination of analytic estimates and a computer-assisted certification in interval arithmetic, and we publish the certificate with the paper.

Introduction and main result

Let HN(Z)H_N(Z) be the nonrelativistic Hamiltonian of NN electrons and a fixed nucleus of charge ZZ, acting on antisymmetric functions of NN position–spin variables with two spin states, in atomic units:

HN(Z)=∑i=1N(−12Δi−Zri)+∑1≤i<j≤N1rij,ri=∣xi∣, rij=∣xi−xj∣.(1)H_N(Z) = \sum_{i=1}^{N} \left(-\frac{1}{2}\Delta_i-\frac{Z}{r_i}\right) + \sum_{1\le i<j\le N}\frac{1}{r_{ij}}, \qquad r_i = |x_i|,\ r_{ij} = |x_i-x_j|. \tag*{(1)}

Let EN(Z)=inf⁡σHN(Z)E_N(Z) = \inf\sigma H_N(Z). By the HVZ theorem [1] EN≤EN−1E_N \le E_{N-1}, and HNH_N has a bound state (an eigenvalue below its essential spectrum) if and only if EN<EN−1E_N < E_{N-1}. The ionization problem asks for the critical number Nc(Z)N_c(Z), the largest NN with EN<EN−1E_N < E_{N-1}. Physically, no atom binds more than one extra electron [8, 9]. Mathematically, a classic result of Lieb [2] shows that a bound state requires N<2Z+1N < 2Z + 1, so Nc(Z)≤2ZN_c(Z) \le2Z; for hydrogen this gives Nc(1)≤2N_c(1) \le2, which is sharp. Lieb’s bound has since been improved to Nc(Z)≤1.22Z+3Z1/3N_c(Z) \le1.22Z + 3Z^{1/3} by Nam [3], to Nc(Z)≤1.5211Z+1+0.294Z1/3N_c(Z) \le1.5211Z + 1 + 0.294Z^{1/3} for Z≥6Z \ge6 by Benguria, González-Brantes and Tubino [4], and, for Z≥4Z \ge4, to Nc(Z)≤1.1185Z+4Z1/3N_c(Z) \le1.1185Z + 4Z^{1/3} by Hundertmark, Pattakos and Schulz [5]. Recently an unrefereed, AI-generated manuscript released by OpenAI [6] has claimed a proof of the ionization conjecture, that is that there exists a universal constant CC so that Nc(Z)≤Z+CN_c(Z) \le Z + C, however their constant is not explicit. None of these results improves the Z=2Z=2 case, where it has been open for forty years whether or not bound dianionic helium exists. We prove that it does not:

Theorem 1.1. E4(2)=E3(2)E_4(2) = E_3(2). Consequently Nc(2)≤3N_c(2) \le3: a helium nucleus binds at most three electrons.

Our proof is computer-assisted. Its mathematical part (§ 2–§ 6) reduces the theorem to the nonnegativity of one explicit elementary function qq of three real variables on an explicit closed region, and establishes analytically the regularity needed to certify that nonnegativity by Taylor bounds. In § 7 we prove that q≥0q \ge0 on that region in interval arithmetic with outward rounding. We follow the standards of computer-assisted proofs in analysis [14, 15]. Rigorous computer-assisted lower bounds for atomic and ionic ground-state energies have recently been obtained by Hofacker [7]; the question here is of a different kind, since no energy bound decides whether an eigenvalue exists. All floating-point operations that enter the proof are enclosed rigorously, the certificate is published, and the parts that cannot be certified by a computer are proved by hand.

Strategy. Three ideas carry the proof.

(i) A reduction to a two-electron operator. Lieb’s argument multiplies the eigenvalue equation by rkr_k and sums over kk; the resulting identity has a pair term ∑i<j(ri+rj)/rij\mathop{\sum}_{i<j}(r_i+r_j)/r_{ij} that is bounded below by N−1N-1 pointwise, and Z≥N−1Z \ge N-1 follows. With a one-body weight w(r)w(r) growing linearly at infinity in place of rr, the same identity acquires a kinetic term, and the pointwise bound on the pair term fails (a regular tetrahedron gives 1.837<21.837 < 2, § 2); but combined with the energy constraint through a Lagrange multiplier β\beta, the identity becomes the statement that an explicit four-electron operator M\mathcal{M} is nonnegative. M\mathcal{M} contains one- and two-body terms only, so M=∑i<jmij\mathcal{M} = \mathop{\sum}_{i<j}m_{ij} for a two-electron operator mm, and m≥0m \ge0 suffices. The choice of ww matters: with w=r2w=r^2 or with weights flat in the core, mm has a negative “core-pair” eigenvalue, because on L2(R6)L^2(\mathbb{R}^6) nothing prevents both electrons of a pair from occupying the 1s shell. With w(r)=r4/(r3+8)w(r)=r^4/(r^3+8) and β=0.9\beta=0.9 the operator mm has a single bound state at +0.0355+0.0355, below its thresholds 0.04680.0468 and 0.10220.1022.

(ii) A supersolution. Barta’s inequality (the ground-state transform) gives m≥inf⁡qm \ge\inf q for the local energy q=mφ/φq=m\varphi/\varphi of any positive φ\varphi. The exact ground state has q≡0.0355q \equiv0.0355; an explicit φ\varphi with exact nuclear and electron–electron cusps, r\sqrt{r} tails, three exponential terms and 400 coefficients has q≥0.0102q \ge0.0102 on 1.3×1061.3 \times10^6 test points. Nonnegativity of qq, a function of (r1,r2,r12)(r_1,r_2,r_{12}), is then the whole problem; no spectral computation is involved.

(iii) Certification. The cusps cancel the Coulomb singularities of qq exactly, and we remove them analytically before evaluation. Barta’s inequality is used only on the bounded region max⁡(r1,r2)≤240\max(r_1,r_2) \le240: outside it, mm is bounded below by elementary operator inequalities (one electron far from the nucleus sees the one-body ground-state energy plus the asymptotic pair term), and an IMS localization glues the two regions at the price of an explicit error 0.01450.0145, which the certification absorbs by proving q≥0.0145q \ge0.0145 on 120≤max⁡(r1,r2)≤240120 \le\max(r_1,r_2) \le240. On the bounded region, in three coordinate charts (interior, scaled coalescence, and a cone chart at the triple coalescence point) qq is smooth up to the boundary, and second-order Taylor bounds with interval-evaluated Hessians certify the required lower bound on boxes; branch-and-bound covers each chart.

Theorem 1.1 excludes eigenvalues of H4(2)H_4(2) below the bottom E3(2)E_3(2) of its essential spectrum. It does not exclude eigenvalues embedded in the continuum and protected by symmetry (the four-electron analogues of the He−^- 1s2s2p 4Po1s2s2p\,{}^4Po state), since the reduction of Theorem 2.2 uses E<E3E < E_3; we return to this and to the other atoms in § 9.

Organization. § 2 proves the reduction theorem. § 3 studies the two-electron operator mm and fixes the parameters. § 4 proves Barta’s inequality in the form we need, with cusps. Section 5 defines φ\varphi and derives the singularity-free form of its local energy. Section 6 proves the far-field theorem, which confines the pointwise problem to a bounded region, then defines the charts on that region and proves the regularity of qq in each. Section 7 describes the certified evaluation and states its result; Section 8 assembles the proof; Section 9 discusses extensions. Appendix A lists the basis and the coefficients of φ\varphi; Appendix B records the non-rigorous numerical computations that guided the choices (they are not part of the proof).

Lieb's identity with a one-body weight, and the reduction

Throughout, Ef=⟨Ψ,fΨ⟩\mathbb{E}f=\langle\Psi,f\Psi\rangle for a normalized Ψ\Psi. Let w:[0,∞)→[0,∞)w:[0,\infty)\to[0,\infty) be C2C^2 with w(r)≤C(1+r)w(r)\le C(1+r), w′w' and Δw:=w′′+2w′/r\Delta w:=w''+2w'/r bounded, and write wk=w(rk)w_k=w(r_k).

Lemma 2.1 (Weighted Lieb inequality). Let Ψ\Psi be a normalized eigenfunction of HN(Z)H_N(Z) with eigenvalue E<EN−1(Z)E<E_{N-1}(Z). Then

ZE∑kwkrk≥E∑i<jwi+wjrij+∑k[12∫wk∣∇kΨ∣2−14∫(Δw)k∣Ψ∣2]+(EN−1−E)E∑kwk.Z\mathbb{E}\sum_k\frac{w_k}{r_k}\ge\mathbb{E}\sum_{i<j}\frac{w_i+w_j}{r_{ij}}+\sum_k\left[\frac{1}{2}\int w_k|\nabla_k\Psi|^2-\frac{1}{4}\int(\Delta w)_k|\Psi|^2\right]+(E_{N-1}-E)\mathbb{E}\sum_k w_k.

References

  1. [1]M. Reed, B. Simon, Methods of Modern Mathematical Physics IV: Analysis of Operators, Academic Press (1978), Theorem XIII.17.
  2. [2]E. H. Lieb, Bound on the maximum negative ionization of atoms and molecules, Phys. Rev. A 29, 3018–3028 (1984).
  3. [3]P. T. Nam, New bounds on the maximum ionization of atoms, Commun. Math. Phys. 312, 427–445 (2012).arxiv.org/abs/1009.2367
  4. [4]R. D. Benguria, J. M. González-Brantes, T. Tubino, New bounds on the excess charge for atomic systems, arXiv:2207.08328.arxiv.org/abs/2207.08328
  5. [5]D. Hundertmark, N. Pattakos, M. R. Schulz, On the excess charge problem of atoms, arXiv:2504.18487.arxiv.org/abs/2504.18487
  6. [6]OpenAI, Uniform excess charge for Coulomb molecules and the outer radius of neutral atoms, OpenAI Math Release preprint, September 24, 2026, https://github.com/openai/math (AI-generated, unrefereed).hub.valency.io/works/W_6vk6sck8
  7. [7]M. Hofacker, Rigorous lower bounds for atomic and ionic ground-state energies, arXiv:2610.34480.arxiv.org/abs/2610.34480
  8. [8]A. I. Boldyrev, M. Gutowski, J. Simons, Small multiply charged anions as building blocks in chemistry, Acc. Chem. Res. 29, 497–502 (1996).DOI
  9. [9]T. Andersen, Atomic negative ions: structure, dynamics and collisions, Phys. Rep. 394, 157–313 (2004).DOI
  10. [10]S. Agmon, Lectures on Exponential Decay of Solutions of Second-Order Elliptic Equations, Princeton University Press (1982).
  11. [11]H. Nakashima, H. Nakatsuji, Solving the Schrödinger equation for helium atom and its isoelectronic ions with the free iterative complement interaction (ICI) method, J. Chem. Phys. 127, 224104 (2007).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/18081387
  12. [12]C. L. Pekeris, Ground state of two-electron atoms, Phys. Rev. 112, 1649–1658 (1958).DOI
  13. [13]C. N. Yang, Concept of off-diagonal long-range order and the quantum phases of liquid He and of superconductors, Rev. Mod. Phys. 34, 694–704 (1962).DOI
  14. [14]T. Hales et al., A formal proof of the Kepler conjecture, Forum Math. Pi 5, e2 (2017).
  15. [15]W. Tucker, Validated Numerics: A Short Introduction to Rigorous Computations, Princeton University Press (2011).
  16. [16]R. E. Moore, R. B. Kearfott, M. J. Cloud, Introduction to Interval Analysis, SIAM (2009).DOI

Paper details

vlnc:W_n5297k2y
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — published within the last 30 days
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 1

downloads · 2

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Anthropic Claude Fable

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents