betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Phase-separation during sedimentation of dilute bacterial suspensions

Abstract

Numerous natural systems depend on the sedimentation of passive particles in presence of swimming microorganisms. Here, we investigate the dynamics of the sedimentation of spherical colloids at various E. coli concentration within the dilute regime. Results show the appearance of two sedimentation fronts, a spherical particle front and the bacteria front. We find that the bacteria front behave diffusive at short times, whereas at long times decays linearly. The sedimentation speed of passive particles decays at a constant speed and decreases as bacteria concentration (ϕbϕ_b) is increased. As ϕbϕ_b is increased further, the sedimentation speed becomes independent of ϕbϕ_b. The timescales of the bacteria front is associated with the particle settling speeds. Remarkably, all experiments collapse onto a single master line by using the bacteria front timescale. A phenomenological model is proposed that captures the sedimentation of passive particles in active fluids.

Introduction

The settling of particles in the presence of microorganisms is a ubiquitous natural process from small river tributaries to lakes to oceans [5, 6] [1, 2, 3, 4]. Sedimentation of biological matter, for instance, plays an important role on the distribution of plankton in oceans, which is key part of the carbon cycle (i.e. ocean’s biological pump) that transports carbon from the ocean’s surface to depth [7, 8, 9]. From a technological stand point, microbial activity can affect many process such as the production of food, biofuels, and even vaccines [10, 11, 12, 13, 14]. While the settling of passive particles, as a function of suspension volume fraction (ϕ\phi) and interparticle interactions, have been extensively studied [15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23], much less is known about particle sedimentation in the presence of swimming microorganisms.

At infinite dilution, the particle sedimentation speed is set by the balance between the gravitational and viscous drag forces, and the associated velocity called the Stokes’ settling speed is given as,

V0=2a2Δρg9η,V_0 = \frac{2a^2\Delta\rho g}{9\eta},

where aa is the particle radius, Δρ\Delta\rho is the density difference between the particle and the solvent, gg is the acceleration due to gravity, and η\eta is the solvent viscosity [17]. As ϕ\phi increases, the competition between the interparticle forces and thermal motion determines the suspension microstructure, affecting the hydrodynamic interactions between the particles, and in turn the suspension sedimentation speed. These effects are on suspension sedimentation speed are usually described by the hindered settling function, given as H(ϕ)=Vp(ϕ)/V0H(\phi)=V_p(\phi)/V_0, where Vp(ϕ)V_p(\phi) is the mean sedimentation speed due to the upward fluid flow between the settling particles [21].

Obtaining the exact form of H(ϕ)H(\phi) for quiescent particle suspensions is quite challenging and has been the subject of much investigation [18, 24]. One of the first empirical functional form that captures the ϕ\phi-dependence on the hindered settling function was proposed by Richardson and Zaki nearly 70 years ago [16], as H(ϕ)=(1−ϕ)nH(\phi)=(1-\phi)^n where n≈4.65n\approx4.65 for particles Reynolds numbers (ReRe) below 0.2 when wall effects can be neglected. This relationship was found to be valid for both sedimentation and fluidization processes. It is worth emphasizing that there is still a debate on the exact value of the exponent nn. Recently, a comprehensive study has shown that the exponent has in fact two values: n≈5.5n\approx5.5 for Brownian particles and n≈4.5n\approx4.5 for non-Brownian particles. At very dilute particle concentration, the exponents converge to n≈6.5n\approx6.5, a value that is close to Batchelor’s theoretical prediction, H(ϕ)=1−6.55ϕ+O(ϕ2)H(\phi)=1-6.55\phi+O(\phi^2), obtained by including many-body hydrodynamic interactions between monodisperse constituent particles [15].

While there is a rich history (and much still to understand) on the subject of sedimentation of passive suspensions [18, 19, 20, 21, 23, 25], there has been a growing interest in systems that emulate the sedimentation of natural processes, particularly those that include living matter such as swimming microorganisms [26, 27, 28, 29, 30, 31]. Presence of active particles (living or synthetic) inject energy to a suspending solution. Activity can drive the fluid out of equilibrium even in the absence of external forcing and lead to many poorly understood phenomena including low values of reduced viscosity [32, 33], enhancement in particle diffusivity [34, 35, 36, 37, 38], and collective motion (at high densities) [39, 40, 41]. Thus, one expects activity to also affect the sedimentation of passive particles and the associated hindered settling function H(ϕ)H(\phi).

Experiments with synthetic active Janus particles has shown some intriguing results [26, 29, 31]. These investigations show that the particle steady-state density profiles are significantly affected by activity and can be described by an exponential decay [26]. Increasing particle activity leads to a slower exponential decay, which is described by using an effective temperature (and diffusivity) that is much larger than for passive systems [26]. Varying sedimentation speed while maintaining a constant system activity also led to exponential decay in particle diffusivity [31]. These steady-state results agree well with theory and simulations [30, 31, 42, 43, 44].

Sedimentation experiments with live organisms have been far less common but also show unusual phenomena. For example, bacteria has been shown to enhance sedimentation rates in the presence of polymers due to aggregation [45]. In mixtures of swimming algae and particles, the (exponential) steady-state sedimentation profile of passive particle is found to be described by an effective diffusivity (or temperature) that increases linearly with the concentration of swimming microbes [46], similar to results in artificial active particles. Recently it was found that the sedimentation speed of passive particles can be significantly hindered by the presence of swimming microorganisms (E. coliE.\ coli) in the dilute regime [28]; the hindered settling function for these settling active suspensions is captured by a Richardson-Zaki-type equation [16] with an exponent that is much larger than for passive systems and a function of bacteria activity. The time-dependent concentration profiles can be adequately described by an advection-diffusion equation coupled with sink-source terms to describe bacteria population dynamics, and with a dispersivity parameter that increases linearly with bacteria concentration[28]. Nevertheless, the effects of bacterial activity on suspension sedimentation dynamics is still not fully understood.

Here, we experimentally investigate the sedimentation dynamics of dilute active suspensions using mixtures of passive colloidal spheres and swimming E. coli. These initially well-mixed suspensions settle for a period up to three days (depending on bacteria concentration ϕb\phi_b) and image analysis techniques are used to track the height of the particle sedimentation front. We find that the suspension phase separate into a particle- and bacteria-rich fronts. A simple model is presented that can capture the phase separation time based on species dispersivities and settling speeds.

Experimental Methods

In this contribution we experimentally study sedimentation of particles in the presence of bacteria. Active suspensions are prepared by mixing Escherichia coli (wild-type K12 MG1655) and polystyrene spheres (density ρ=1.05 g/cm3\rho= 1.05\ \mathrm{g/cm^3}, Thermo Scientific) of diameter d=2 μmd = 2\ \mu\mathrm{m} in deionized (DI) water. Bacteria are grown to saturation (10910^9 cells/mL) in culture media (LB broth, Sigma-Aldrich). Both spheres and the saturated culture are centrifuged (Centrifuge 5430, eppendorf) and mixed with DI water to reach the desired bacteria volume fraction.

We transfer 1.5 mL of the prepared suspensions into glass vials (9.7 mm in diameter, 35 mm in height), as shown schematically in Figure 1(a); the liquid column is approximately 20 mm tall. The suspensions are homogenized by hand with a pipette so that the bacteria and colloids are uniformly distributed at the start of the experiment. These vials are placed in a water tank to maintain the vials at room temperature T0=22T_0 = 22 °C and to remove optical aberrations during imaging (cylindrical vials are preferred to avoid effects from sharp edges). Images are taken every 10 min for a period of 2-3 days with a Nikon D7100 camera that is equipped with a 105 mm Sigma lens. The light source is a Edge-lit Collimated Backlights (CX,Advanced Illumination).

Experimental setup and sample images

Figure 1. Experimental setup and sample images are shown from left to right: (a) A schematic of the setup and bacteria/particle suspensions. Passive particles are 2 μm\mu\mathrm{m} polystyrene spheres, subject to gravity; volume fraction ϕp=0.04%\phi_p = 0.04\% kept constant for all experiments. Swimming activity is provided by E. coli, a 2 μm\mu\mathrm{m} rod shaped bacterium. Sample snapshots of sedimentation experiments with (b) a mixture of passive particles (ϕp=0.04%\phi_p = 0.04\%) with non-motile bacteria (E. coli) at ϕd,b=0.20%\phi_{d,b} = 0.20\%, (c) mixture of passive particles with motile bacteria (E. coli) at ϕb=0.20%\phi_b = 0.20\% and (d) a mixture of passive particles with motile bacteria (E. coli) at ϕb=0.85%\phi_b = 0.85\%. All vials samples are shown at time t=40t = 40 hr. Note the appearance of two sedimentation fronts, bacteria and particle.

The initial motile bacteria volume fraction ϕb\phi_b in the vials ranges from 0.15% to 1.0%, while the spherical colloids volume fraction is kept constant at ϕp=0.04\phi_p = 0.04%. Both\phi_b$ and ϕp\phi_p concentrations are considered dilute, and no large scale collective behavior are

observed for these bacteria-particle suspensions. The range of ϕb\phi_b used here are below which collective motion is generally observed (≃1010\simeq10^{10} cells/mL)[47]. Under these dilute conditions, E. coli swims at speeds ranging from 10 μm/s\mu\mathrm{m/s} to 20 μm/s\mu\mathrm{m/s} by the actuation of a helical flagellar bundle. This mode of swimming, under steady conditions, can be described in the far field by an extensile dipole flow (i.e., "pusher")[40].

Results and Discussion

Sample snapshots of the sedimentation experiments are shown in Figure 1(b)--(Figure 1d) at t=40t = 40 hr. The control passive case, (mixture of non-motile bacteria at ϕd,b=0.2%\phi_{d,b} = 0.2\% with spherical colloidal particles at ϕp=0.04%\phi_p = 0.04\%) is shown in Figure 1(b), while motile bacteria at ϕb=0.20%\phi_b = 0.20\% and ϕb=0.85%\phi_b = 0.85\% cases are shown in Figure 1(c) and Figure 1(d), respectively. The images show that bacterial activity hinders the settling speed of passive particles, as previously reported[28]. We find that the passive particle sedimentation front sits higher in the ϕb=0.20%\phi_b = 0.20\% case than in the non-motile bacteria case (ϕd,b=0.20%\phi_{d,b} = 0.20\%). This trend continues for the ϕb=0.85%\phi_b = 0.85\% case, which indicates that particle settling speed decreases with increasing ϕb\phi_b (see SM for more information). We also observe the formation of two sedimentation fronts, one that is rich in passive particle and one that is rich in bacteria, as shown in Figure 1(b)--(Figure 1d). These two fronts settle at different speeds. These qualitative results show that (i) bacteria significantly hinders particle sedimentation speed and (ii) the two species phase separate during the sedimentation process. While the appearance of the bacteria front has been previously reported[28], here we will focus on quantifying and understanding the appearance of the two sedimentation fronts and its relationship to particle sedimentation front speed.

Front Sedimentation Heights & Speeds

We begin by measuring the sedimentation height of the passive spheres front as a function of time at different ϕb\phi_b. The particle front sedimentation height, hp(t)h_p(t), is located in the vial by identifying the peak in the vertical gradient of the image intensity. By plotting hp(t)h_p(t) as a function of time, we can extract the sedimentation speed of the particle front VpV_p and define a hindered settling function H(ϕb)H(\phi_b) as a function of bacteria concentration. The hindered settling function is defined as the ratio of the mean sedimentation speed VpV_p of the particle front over the sedimentation speed of a single particle such that H(ϕb)=Vp(ϕb)/V0H(\phi_b) = V_p(\phi_b)/V_0. We note that the Stokes’ sedimentation speed V0V_0 is 0.12 µm/s for the 2 µm polystyrene particles in water. Figure 2(a)–(c) shows sedimentation kymographs (hh vs tt) for the

mixture of particles with non-motile bacteria (ϕd,b=0.20%\phi_{d,b} = 0.20\%) case and two with active suspensions, ϕb=0.20%\phi_b = 0.20\% and ϕb=0.85%\phi_b = 0.85\%, respectively; these kymographs correspond to the data shown in Figure 1(b)–(Figure 1d). These experimental kymographs are obtained by the juxtaposition of a single pixel line at the center of the vial for each image of the time series. As noted before, all samples have a fixed particle volume fraction (ϕp=0.04%\phi_p = 0.04\%). In each case a sedimentation front is formed and moves downward from the top of the container at a speed VpV_p. A first look at the corresponding kymographs reveal that the velocity VpV_p, here visible as the slope of the colloid front (black dashed line), decreases as the concentration of bacteria increases. We again observe the formation of a bacteria front that separates from spherical particles after a time tct_c (red dashed line). The timescale tct_c is defined as the time that the bacteria-rich front diverge from the particle-rich front. Experiments with non-motile bacteria and spherical particles shows that the two phases separate at relatively short time-scales (t<1t < 1 hr), as shown in Figure 2(a). Suspensions of motile bacteria (with particles) on the other hand phase separate at much longer time-scales (t>10t > 10 hr). That is, activity seems to delay phase separation. Moreover, the phase separation time, tct_c, seems to decrease with ϕb\phi_b, that is, tc=tc(ϕb)t_c = t_c(\phi_b). The particle front sedimentation speed VpV_p is found by linear fits to the kymograph plots such that

Kymographs for sedimentation at fixed particle concentration and different bacterial concentrations

Figure 2. Kymographs for sedimentation at fixed particle concentration (ϕp=0.04%\phi_p = 0.04\%) and different bacterial concentrations. (a) With non-motile bacteria at ϕd,b=0.20%\phi_{d,b} = 0.20\%, (b) motile bacteria at ϕb=0.20%\phi_b = 0.20\%, and (c) motile bacteria at ϕb=0.85%\phi_b = 0.85\%. Two fronts are seen when ϕb>0.15%\phi_b > 0.15\%. Note that activity hinders the settling speed of spherical particles.

hp(t)=h0−Vpt,(1)h_p(t) = h_0 - V_p t, \tag*{(1)}

where h0h_0 is the initial front position; in all cases studied here, this linear relationship works relatively well even at long times (t>24t > 24 hr). In absence of bacteria (ϕb=0%\phi_b = 0\%), the front sedimentation speed Vp=0.11V_p = 0.11 µm/s, which is relatively close to the sedimentation speed of a single sphere, V0=0.12V_0 = 0.12 µm/s. This result indicates that hydrodynamic interaction among passive particles are relatively weak in our study. This not surprising since particle volume fraction is quite dilute, ϕp=0.04%\phi_p = 0.04\%.

Figure 3 shows the normalized height of the particle sedimentation front, h(t)/h0h(t)/h_0, for different bacteria volume fractions ϕb\phi_b, where h0h_0 is the front initial height. We find that the settling height of the particle front is linear through all experiments, so it is described by a average speed, VpV_p. A constant sedimentation speed is not a trivial result because the decrease in bacteria activity is commensurable with the time of the experiment. At 48 hr of experiment, approximately 70% of the population has lost motility and behave as a passive colloid [28]. This has been previously characterized by the bacteria motility loss rate kk, which is approximately 6×10−66 \times10^{-6} s−1^{-1} (see Ref. 28). We believe that the decrease in activity promotes a faster sedimentation; concurrently, the increase in passive particles (non-motile bacteria) should decrease the overall sedimentation speed. These two processes are not necessarily of the same magnitude.

The data also show that VpV_p decreases as ϕb\phi_b increases (Figure 3). Surprisingly, this trend weakens and VpV_p becomes independent of ϕb\phi_b for ϕb>0.40%\phi_b > 0.40\% at long times (t>tct > t_c). This transition, however, is not observed at short times (t<tct < t_c). To better illustrate this trend, we plot VpV_p as a function of ϕb\phi_b for all cases (Figure 3, inset); we find that, for t<tct < t_c, VpV_p decreases linearly with ϕb\phi_b. Overall, we find two different functionalities regarding the effects of bacteria activity on VpV_p: (i) for t<tct < t_c, VpV_p decreases linearly with ϕb\phi_b for all cases; (ii) for t>tct > t_c, VpV_p decreases linearly with ϕb\phi_b for ϕb≤0.4%\phi_b \le0.4\% followed by an asymptote for ϕb≥0.45%\phi_b \ge0.45\%.

Height of particle sedimentation front

Figure 3. Height of particle sedimentation front, hp(t)/h0h_p(t)/h_0, where h0h_0 is the initial height tracked on the sedimentation process as a function of time for a range of initial motile bacterial volume fractions ϕb\phi_b. Data shows the decrease in front speed with an increase of bacteria volume fraction ϕb\phi_b. The slope of hp(t)/h0h_p(t)/h_0 does not vary significantly when ϕb>0.40%\phi_b > 0.40\%. Solid lines are obtained by solving Equation 5. Solution to this expression is shown in Equation 7, and it captures relatively well the height of the front of passive particles for a wide range of bacterial concentrations ϕb\phi_b. Inset shows particle front speed (VpV_p) as a function of ϕb\phi_b for short times (t<tct < t_c).

Hindered Settling Function for Active Suspensions

We now compute the suspension hindered settling function HH as a function of bacteria concentration, ϕb\phi_b; note that ϕp\phi_p is kept constant at 0.04% for all cases. This variable is explored as a touchstone to previous literature and as a tool to develop our phenomenological model for the sedimentation of active suspensions. Similar to the VpV_p data (and as expected), we find two regimes for H(ϕb)H(\phi_b). (i) For t<tct < t_c, HH decreases linearly with ϕb\phi_b for all cases [Fig. 4(a), black triangles]; (ii) for t>tct > t_c, HH decreases linearly with ϕb\phi_b for ϕb≤0.4%\phi_b \le0.4\% followed by an asymptote (H≈0.45H \approx0.45) for ϕb≥0.45%\phi_b \ge0.45\% [Figure 4(a), red diamonds]. These data show that bacterial activity can reduce the particle sedimentation speed by a factor of 2, which illustrates the dramatic effect of bacterial activity on sedimentation dynamics. The first regime (t<tct < t_c) can be described by a linearized version of the Richardson-Zaki equation [16] such that H(ϕb)=(1−nϕb)H(\phi_b) = (1 - n\phi_b), with a best fit of n=95n = 95 [Figure 4(a), black line]. This exponent is significantly larger than the expected fitting parameter for Brownian particles (n≈5.5n \approx5.5) [21] and Batchelor’s result (n=6.5n = 6.5) [15], but in line with our own previous results (n≈120n \approx120) [28]. While the mechanisms leading to the linear dependence of HH on ϕb\phi_b was previously investigated in our previous work [28], the transition of HH from a linear dependence to a ϕb\phi_b-independent regime at t>tct > t_c has yet to be reported and/or understood.

Hindered settling function and phase separation timescale

Figure 4. (a) Hindered settling function H(ϕb)H(\phi_b) as a function of bacterial volume fraction ϕb\phi_b. H(ϕb)H(\phi_b) was obtained at short times (black triangles) and at long times (red diamonds). At short times (t<tct < t_c) we observed that sedimentation is hindered linearly in the experiments. However, at long times (t>tct > t_c), HH decreases linearly with ϕb\phi_b for ϕb≤0.4\phi_b \le0.4 followed by an asymptote (H≈0.45H \approx0.45) for ϕb>0.45\phi_b > 0.45 (b) Phase separation timescale tct_c (blue circles) as a function of bacteria volume fraction ϕb\phi_b. Solid line is the timescale prediction obtained by Equation 3 with a time dependent diffusivity that decays with time. Experimental results shows that the timescale tct_c has the same functionality as H(ϕb)H(\phi_b).

The observed ϕb\phi_b-independent regime in HH may be due to the increase in the amount (or volume fraction) of non-motile bacteria within the suspension during the sedimentation process. If we assume a a constant motility loss rate kk [28], it follows that an increase in ϕb\phi_b would result in the production of more non-motile bacteria for the same experimental time Δt\Delta t. This increase in non-motile concentration within the system may overwhelm the effect of activity (ϕb\phi_b), although it is not enough to significantly affect particle sedimentation speed. That is, the dependence of HH on passive (non-motile) particle volume fraction is much weaker than on motile bacterial volume fraction.

Phase Separation During Sedimentation

The images and kymographs shown in Figure 1 and Figure 2, respectively, show that after a certain period of sedimentation time, the active suspension separates into particle-rich and bacteria-rich fronts. Figure 4(b) [blue circles] shows the experimentally measured phase separation time tct_c as a function of ϕb\phi_b for all cases. Similar to H(ϕb)H(\phi_b), the quantity tct_c shows a decreasing trend with ϕb\phi_b, suggesting a deeper underlying relation at play. We now provide a simple argument to understand the origins of tct_c by noting that the behavior of the bacteria front is diffusive and can be captured by an equation of the form:

hb(t)=h0−Vbt−2Dbt.(2)h_b(t) = h_0 - V_b t - 2\sqrt{D_b t}. \tag*{(2)}

Here, DbD_b is a dispersivity related to bacterial activity and VbV_b is the sedimentation speed of the bacteria front. A dispersion length scale can thus be defined as LD(t)=2DbtL_D(t) = 2\sqrt{D_b t}. At earlier times, the bacteria front [or Eq. (2)] settles faster than the particle front [or Eq. (1)], but slower at later times (see SM Figure 3). The phase separation time, tct_c, is the time at which the particle front crosses over the bacteria front, or hb(tc)=hp(tc)h_b(t_c) = h_p(t_c). By equating Eq. (1) and Eq. (2), we obtain the following equation for the phase separation time:

tc=4Db(Vp−Vb)2.(3)t_c = \frac{4D_b}{(V_p - V_b)^2}. \tag*{(3)}

All variables in the above equation can be measured or estimated. For example, VpV_p is experimentally measured as a function of ϕb\phi_b (Figure 3) and Vb=0.02±0.002V_b = 0.02 \pm0.002 µm/s is approximately independent of ϕb\phi_b in the dilute regime investigated here (see SM for more information). The dispersivity DbD_b can be obtained by fitting Eq. (2) to the bacteria front shown in the kymograph. The data shows that DbD_b decays exponentially with time as such that Db(t)=D0exp⁡(−βt)D_b(t) = D_0\exp(-\beta t), where D0D_0 is the initial dispersivity, and β\beta is a dispersivity decay rate; the values of D0D_0 and β\beta can be found in the SM. The decay in dispersivity over time may be due to nutrient and oxygen depletion, or even aerotactic response near the air-liquid interface [48, 49] (see SM for more information). For simplicity, we will proceed with an average dispersivity Db‾\overline{D_b} defined as:

Db‾=1t0∫0t0Db(t) dt,(4)\overline{D_b} = \frac{1}{t_0}\int_0^{t_0} D_b(t)\,\mathrm{d}t, \tag*{(4)}

We plot the calculated phase separation time using Db‾\overline{D_b} in Figure 4(b) [black diamonds]. Results show that this simple argument is able to capture the nonlinear experimental data relatively well, including the decreasing trend of tct_c with ϕb\phi_b. Here, t0t_0 is a long enough time to provide a statistically meaningful average, longer than the experimentally measured phase separation time.

Scaling for Hindering Settling Function

The data show above makes it clear that there is a relationship between the timescale associated with phase separations tct_c and the hindering settling function H(ϕb)H(\phi_b). The other time scale present in the experiments is the bacteria motility loss rate, kk. We can use these two time-scales, tct_c and kk, to non-dimensionalize both hp(t)h_p(t) and tt. The quantity tct_c is used to obtain a ''separation'' length-scale, l0=tcV0l_0 = t_c V_0, to normalize hp(t)h_p(t) such that hp(t)/l0h_p(t)/l_0. This quantity tells us how far or close the front is from separating. Next, we non-dimensionalize time tt with the motility loss rate, kk. The quantity ktkt provides a measure of activity left in the sample. Figure 5(a) shows the normalized particle sedimentation height, hp(t)/l0h_p(t)/l_0, as a function of scaled time, tktk, for a range of ϕb\phi_b. The data shows that hp(t)/l0h_p(t)/l_0 decreases linearly with tktk, suggesting that activity prevents phase separation likely by mixing the two phases during the sedimentation process. Also, we find an average slope of −1.97±0.050-1.97 \pm0.050 through all experiments, indicating that these sample share similar dynamics.

Normalized height plots

Figure 5. (a) Normalized height hp(t)/l0h_p(t)/l_0 as a function of normalized time tktk. Length-scale l0l_0 is defined as l0=V0tcl_0 = V_0t_c. Normalized plot shows a constant slope on all experiments, the slope as a value of 1.97±0.0501.97 \pm0.050. (b) Normalized height as a function of the normalized time. The height was initially normalized by the length-scale l0l_0, and the time by the motility loss rate kk. This normalization gave a constant slope of 1.97±0.0501.97 \pm0.050 as shown in (a). Now, the normalized height is shifted by a constant CC divided by the hindered settling function H(ϕb)H(\phi_b). The shift on the normalized height of the experimental data gives a collapse into a single line at different ϕb\phi_b. The constant has a value of C=1.955±0.045C = 1.955 \pm0.045.

Next, we account for the intercept in Figure 5(a) by noticing that it changes similarly to the inverse of the hindered settling function, H(ϕb)H(\phi_b) (see SM for more information). Therefore, we subtract the re-scaled height (hp(t)/l0h_p(t)/l_0) by a constant divided by the hindered settling function such that C/H(ϕb)C/H(\phi_b). The constant CC is obtained by equating the intercept of hp(t)/l0h_p(t)/l_0 with C/H(ϕb)C/H(\phi_b), giving a value of 1.955±0.0451.955 \pm0.045. Remarkably, all experiments collapse onto a single master curve [Figure 5(b)]. Putting together these results, the sedimentation front of passive particles can be described by the following differential equation:

hp(t)tcV0−CV0dh/dt=−2kt,(5)\frac{h_p(t)}{t_cV_0} - C\frac{V_0}{\mathrm{d}h/\mathrm{d}t} = -2kt, \tag*{(5)}

which can be rearranged to be

dhp(t)dt(hp(t)tcV0+2kt)=CV0.(6)\frac{\mathrm{d}h_p(t)}{\mathrm{d}t}\left(\frac{h_p(t)}{t_cV_0}+2kt\right)=CV_0. \tag*{(6)}

We take the linear solution to this equation to obtain

hp(t)=−2ktcV0t+CV02k.(7)h_p(t) = -2kt_cV_0t + \frac{CV_0}{2k}. \tag*{(7)}

Equation 5 shows that the sedimentation front of the passive particles are described by three main terms. The first term is (sedimentation) height normalized by a diffusion-based length-scale associated with the bacteria-particle settling process. The second term quantifies passive settling under gravity via the hindered settling function. The third term is time normalized by the motility decay rate, and quantifies the level of activity left in the sample. We note that a solution to Equation 5 is a line and is shown in Equation 7. If we solve the equation and revisit front height over time [Fig. 3], we observe that the solution captures all cases of active suspensions.

Our experimental observations show that sedimentation and separation of passive particles and bacteria suspensions are described by using sedimentation and diffusive length scales. The quantity tct_c of active suspensions occurs over very long time-scales compared to mixtures of passive particles that have two different masses and is reminiscent of the effects of centrifuging. This timescale plateau above a critical bacteria concentration (ϕb=0.40%\phi_b = 0.40\%). We find that when tct_c plateau when ϕb>0.40%\phi_b > 0.40\%, and H(ϕb)H(\phi_b) has the same functionality. A possible mechanism that explains our experimental observations is due to an increased presence of

non-motile bacteria which overwhelm the effects of the increased activity. The injection of energy by the bacteria swimming motion plays an important role in the sedimentation process; its decay is quantified by a motility loss rate kk, which is used to describe the settling of spherical particles.

Preparation of new experiments that track spherical particles while they sediment would help to understand these observations. This could be achieved by using a confocal microscope with a smaller vial. The downside of this proposed approach is that controlling the temperature at long times is a challenge. With this approach we would be able to obtain 3-D imaging as a function of time, which would allow to track the spherical particles and explore particle fluctuations.

Conclusions

The sedimentation of passive particles in the presence of swimming bacteria is experimentally investigated. We find that bacterial activity (even in the dilute regime) hinders the sedimentation of passive particles and phase separates at large time-scales, whereas the bacteria front with non-motile bacteria shows at smaller time-scales (t<1t < 1 hr). Particle hindered settling function, H(ϕb)H(\phi_b), as well as tct_c, show two distinct regimes: (i) a monotonic decay by increasing ϕb\phi_b and (ii) a regime in which both H(ϕb)H(\phi_b) and tct_c are no longer dependent of ϕb\phi_b. A simple model based on particle and bacteria length scales is proposed which describes tct_c for a range of ϕb\phi_b. Using non-dimensional analysis, we collapse all sedimentation front data onto a single master line that captures both bacteria concentration regimes. A phenomenological model is proposed to describe the height of the particle sedimentation front. The solution of this model captures relatively well the height of the sedimentation front of the passive particles for all ϕb\phi_b within the dilute regime. In summary, an addition of a diffusive length-scale can captures the short time behavior of the bacteria front, and a sedimentation speed length scales captures the long time behavior of the bacteria front and the particle front. Further study on this field with different colloid concentrations and swimmer actuation modes (pusher vs puller) would presumably shed light on how the hydrodynamic interactions between the passive particles and active bacteria underlay the dynamics of our system and be generalized to others.

Conflicts of interest

There are no conflicts to declare.

Acknowledgements

We thank D. Jerolmack, C. Kammer, and A. Patteson for fruitful discussions. S.P. and P.E.A. acknowledge support from Army Research Office (ARO, Grant W911NF2010113). B.O.T.M., R.R., and P.E.A. acknowledge support by the National Science Foundation grant DMR-1709763.

Notes and references

References

  1. [5]G. J. Herndl and T. Reinthaler, Nature Geoscience, 2013, 6, 718–724.
  2. [6]R. F. Vaccaro, M. P. Briggs, L. Carey and B. H. Ketchum, American Journal of Public Health, 1950, 40, 1257–1266.
  3. [7]P. Tréguer and P. Pondaven, Nature, 2000, 406, 358.
  4. [8]J. Sarmiento and J. Toggweiler, Nature, 1984, 308, 621–624.
  5. [9]T. Kiørboe, A Mechanistic Approach to Plankton Ecology, Princeton University Press, 2008.
  6. [10]S. Giorgi, B. A. H. Reitsma, H. J. F. van Fulpen, R. W. P. Berg and M. Becher, Water Science and Technology, 2018, 78, 1597–1602.
  7. [11]J. T. Boock, A. J. E. Freedman, G. A. Tompsett, S. K. Muse, A. J. Allen, L. A. Jackson, B. Castro-Dominguez, M. T. Timko, K. L. J. Prather and J. R. Thompson, Nature Communications, 2019, 10, 587.
  8. [12]J. A. Vázquez, A. I. Durán, A. Mendiña and M. Nogueira, Biomolecules, 2020, 10,.
  9. [13]J. Hugenholtz and E. J. Smid, Current Opinion in Biotechnology, 2002, 13, 497–507.
  10. [14]L. Boutilier, R. Jamieson, R. Gordon, C. Lake and W. Hart, Water Research, 2009, 43, 4370–4380.
  11. [15]G. Batchelor, Journal of fluid mechanics, 1972, 52, 245–268.
  12. [16]J. Richardson, Transactions of the institution of chemical engineers, 1954, 32, 35–53.
  13. [17]W. B. Russel, W. Russel, D. A. Saville and W. R. Schowalter, Colloidal dispersions, Cambridge university press, 1991.
  14. [18]E. Guazzelli and J. F. Morris, A physical introduction to suspension dynamics, Cambridge University Press, 2011, vol. 45.DOI
  15. [19]E. Guazzelli and J. Hinch, Annual Review of Fluid Mechanics, 2011, 43, 97–116.
  16. [20]R. Piazza, Reports on Progress in Physics, 2014, 77, 056602.
  17. [21]T. A. Brzinski and D. J. Durian, Phys. Rev. Fluids, 2018, 3, 124303.
  18. [22]J. F. Brady, The Physics of fluids, 1988, 31, 717–727.
  19. [23]R. H. Davis and A. Acrivos, Annual Review of Fluid Mechanics, 1985, 17, 91–118.
  20. [24]R. Bürger and W. L. Wendland, Journal of Engineering Mathematics, 2001, 41, 101–116.
  21. [25]R. Piazza, S. Buzzaccaro and E. Secchi, Journal of Physics: Condensed Matter, 2012, 24, 284109.
  22. [26]J. Palacci, C. Cottin-Bizonne, C. Ybert and L. Bocquet, Physical Review Letters, 2010, 105, 088304.
  23. [27]S. Hermann and M. Schmidt, Soft Matter, 2018, 14, 1614–1621.
  24. [28]J. Singh, A. Patteson, B. Torres Maldonado, P. K. Purohit and P. E. Arratia, Soft Matter, 2021, 4151–4160.
  25. [29]F. Ginot, I. Theurkauff, D. Levis, C. Ybert, L. Bocquet, L. Berthier and C. Cottin-Bizonne, Physical Review X, 2015, 5, 011004.
  26. [30]J. Vachier and M. G. Mazza, The European Physical Journal E, 2019, 42, 11.
  27. [31]F. Ginot, A. Solon, Y. Kafri, C. Ybert, J. Tailleur and C. Cottin-Bizonne, New Journal of Physics, 2018, 20, 115001.
  28. [32]H. M. López, J. Gachelin, C. Douarche, H. Auradou and E. Clément, Physical Review Letters, 2015, 115, 028301.
  29. [33]J. Gachelin, G. Miño, H. Berthet, A. Lindner, A. Rousselet and E. Clément, Physical Review Letters, 2013, 110, 268103.
  30. [34]X.-L. Wu and A. Libchaber, Physical Review Letters, 2000, 84, 3017–3020.
  31. [35]D. T. N. Chen, A. W. C. Lau, L. A. Hough, M. F. Islam, M. Goulian, T. C. Lubensky and A. G. Yodh, Physical Review Letters, 2007, 99, 148302.
  32. [36]G. Miño, T. E. Mallouk, T. Darnige, M. Hoyos, J. Dauchet, J. Dunstan, R. Soto, Y. Wang, A. Rousselet and E. Clement, Physical Review Letters, 2011, 106, 048102.
  33. [37]A. Jepson, V. A. Martinez, J. Schwarz-Linek, A. Morozov and W. C. K. Poon, Physical Review E, 2013, 88, 041002.
  34. [38]A. E. Patteson, A. Gopinath, P. K. Purohit and P. E. Arratia, Soft Matter, 2016, 12, 2365–2372.
  35. [39]M. C. Marchetti, J. F. Joanny, S. Ramaswamy, T. B. Liverpool, J. Prost, M. Rao and R. A. Simha, Rev. Mod. Phys., 2013, 85, 1143–1189.
  36. [40]H. C. Berg, E. coli in Motion, Springer Science & Business Media, 2008.
  37. [41]S. Ramaswamy, Annual Review of Condensed Matter Physics, 2010, 1, 323–345.
  38. [42]R. W. Nash, R. Adhikari, J. Tailleur and M. E. Cates, Phys. Rev. Lett., 2010, 104, 258101.
  39. [43]J. Tailleur and M. Cates, Phys. Rev. Lett., 2008, 100, 218103.
  40. [44]Z. Wang, H. Y. Chen, Y. J. Sheng and H. K. Tsao, Soft Matter, 2014, 10, 3209–3217.
  41. [45]J. Schwarz-Linek, C. Valeriani, A. Cacciuto, M. E. Cates, D. Marenduzzo, A. N. Morozov and W. C. K. Poon, Proc. Natl. Acad. Scien., 2012, 109, 4052–4057.
  42. [46]R. Jeanneret, D. O. Pushkin, V. Kantsler and M. Polin, Nature Comm., 2016, 7, 12518.
  43. [47]T. V. Kasyap, D. L. Koch and M. Wu, Physics of Fluids, 2014, 26, 081901.
  44. [48]C. Douarche, A. Buguin, H. Salman and A. Libchaber, Phys. Rev. Lett., 2009, 102, 198101.
  45. [49]J. Schwarz-Linek, J. Arlt, A. Jepson, A. Dawson, T. Vissers, D. Miroli, T. Pilizota, V. A. Martinez and W. C. Poon, Colloids and Surfaces B: Biointerfaces, 2016, 137, 2–16.

Paper details

vlnc:W_n7557xtm
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents