WorksPhysics and Astronomy
Isotope Effects and the Negative Thermal Expansion Phenomena in Ice and Water
Abstract
H2O is a unique substance with exceptional thermal properties arising from the subtle interplay between its electronic, phononic, and structural degrees of freedom. Of particular interest in H2O are the negative thermal expansion (NTE) phenomena, observed in its solid phase (ice) at low temperature, and in its liquid phase (water) near the freezing temperature. Furthermore, ice and water exhibit the abnormal volume isotope effect (VIE), where volume expansions occur when replacing H with its heavier isotope, deuterium (D). In order to capture more conceptual and intuitive understanding of intriguing NTE and VIE phenomena in ice and water, we have explored isotope effects in their NTE and melting properties by employing a type of Born-Oppenheimer-approximation approach and the Lindemann criterion. Our findings demonstrate that unusual isotope effects in these phenomena stem from competition between zero-point-energy phonons, thermal phonons, and the hydrogen bonding in H2O. All these components originate from nuclear quantum mechanical (QM) processes, revealing that QM physics plays a crucial role in the seemingly classical ice/water systems.
Introduction
Thermal expansion is a phenomenon of length, area, or volume change of a material with varying temperature (). Most substances exhibit positive thermal expansions (PTEs), implying that they expand upon heating and contract upon cooling. However, HO in its different solid, liquid, and gas phases manifests a fascinating exception to this rule (see the phase diagram in Figure 1(a)) [1]. Namely, contrary to the general rule, upon cooling, liquid water expands below °C exhibiting the volume minimum (density maximum) at °C, and then its volume increases abruptly by about 9% when it freezes to ice at °C ( K), as shown in Figure 1(b). Hence liquid water has the negative thermal expansion (NTE) coefficient between 0 °C and 4 °C (inset of Figure 1(b)), and ice is less dense than liquid water due to its larger volume [2]. In fact, the negative slope () of phase-equilibrium line between ice and water in Figure 1(a) is closely related to the observed NTE at the transition [3, 4, 5, 6]. The density maximum at °C in HO is well known to be essential for ecological systems and various environmental processes [2]. Furthermore, HO exhibits a colossal PTE (volume expands by times), when boiling into its vapor gas phase.
Figure 1. (a) Phase diagram of HO [1]. A, B, C, and D correspond to the triple point, freezing point, boiling point, and critical point, respectively. (b) Thermal expansion data near the freezing point [29]. Note the NTE (abrupt volume jump) at the water to ice transition at °C (273 K), and the NTE of water between 0 °C (273 K) and 4 °C (277 K) shown in the inset. (c) The thermal expansion data of ice-Ih phases of HO and DO. The NTEs are observed below K for both. DO has the larger volume than HO, manifesting the abnormal VIE. (d) Volume variations of supercooled-water isotopes as a function of [2, 30]. (e) Open hexagonal crystal structure of ice-Ih (viewed along the axis). (f) Hydrogen-bonding (H:O-bonding) in tetrahedral building block of ice-Ih. Each oxygen forms two-short H-O covalent bonds, and two-long hydrogen bonds (H:O-bonds) with neighboring H ions.
The most common form of ice at the ambient pressure is the ice-Ih phase [2]. As shown in Figure 1(c), ice-Ih exhibits the normal PTE between K and 273 K (0 °C), albeit at a much lower thermal-expansion rate than liquid water. A notable feature in ice-Ih is another NTE phenomenon below K. The NTE behavior in ice-Ih at low is known to arise from low-energy vibrational modes of ice-Ih phase, which produce the negative Grüneisen parameters [4, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11]. Ice-Ih exhibits an additional abnormal feature in the volume isotope effect (VIE), where the volume of the ice changes distinctly depending on the isotope of hydrogen [12, 13, 14]. In most materials, replacing lighter isotopes with heavier ones leads to a normal VIE, indicating that the material contracts in volume. However, in ice-Ih, replacing H with its heavier isotope, deuterium (D), leads to the volume expansion, as shown in Figure 1(c). This abnormal VIE was reported to arise from the quantum-mechanical (QM) nature of the hydrogen atoms in the ice lattice [9, 10, 15, 16, 17]. Interestingly, the abnormal VIE is also observed in water near the so-called (: the temperature corresponding to the maximum density), as shown in Figure 1(d).
The anomalous thermal expansion properties of ice and water highlight the complex physics and chemistry of the HO system. Through decades of research, their mechanisms are understood to some extent based on numerical computations of the Grüneisen parameters of phonon modes at low [9, 10, 11, 15] and numerical simulations of molecular-dynamics at high [18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23]. Despite extensive studies, however, conceptual understanding of the underlying physics and chemistry of intriguing NTE and VIE phenomena in ice and water is still lacking. So we revisit these issues to capture the comprehensive and intuitive picture from a more fundamental point of view.
In this paper, to identify the physics behind the NTE phenomena in ice and water, we have examined the isotope effects in the NTE properties, such as the volume-minimum temperatures (’s) and the melting temperatures (’s) as well as the VIEs. Specifically, we have addressed the issues on (i) the origin of different ’s for different isotopes as well as the abnormal VIE observed in ice-Ih at low , and (ii) the origin of different ’s and ’s for different isotopes as well as the abnormal VIE observed in ice-Ih and water near the freezing . In the following, the approach we have adopted for the present analysis, including a type of Born-Oppenheimer approximation and the Lindemann criterion, is briefly described (§ 2), and then results and discussions of our findings are presented (§ 3), which is followed by concluding remarks (Section IV).
Methodology
Based on the analysis of existing experimental data for ice and water, we have attempted to provide conceptual interpretation of anomalous NTE/VIE and melting properties observed in ice and water. For this purpose, we have newly employed a type of Born-Oppenheimer approximation [24, 25] to explain the former and the Lindemann criterion [26] to explain the latter.
A type of Born-Oppenheimer approximation we have employed is described in the supplement section (ii) [6]. For a system like HO having the fast-moving high-energy () and the slow-moving low-energy () phonon modes, which are far-separated in energy, it is possible to separate adiabatically the high-energy and low-energy phonon modes [24, 25]. This procedure is just like a conventional Born-Oppenheimer approximation approach applied for a system with the fast-moving electron and slow-moving ion motions [27]. Then the zero-point energy () of high-energy phonon mode plays a role of additional potential energy for the low-energy phonon mode. We have examined the role of this zero-point energy in the anomalous NTE/VIE properties of ice and water.
The application of Lindemann criterion to the melting property of ice is rather rare [28]. Here, to explain the unusual isotope effects observed in the melting of ice, we have adopted a simple Lindemann criterion, which claims that a crystal melts when the average amplitude of thermal vibrations () is larger than some fraction of inter-atomic distance. The derivation of is provided in the supplement section (vi) [6].
Results and Discussions
Hydrogen (H:O)-bonds in ice and water
The anomalous thermal expansion behaviors in ice-Ih and water are known to arise from their characteristic hydrogen-bonding (H:O-bonding) networks [2]. The H:O-bonding arises from an intramolecular attractive interaction, in which a H atom that is covalently bonded to a highly electronegative O atom is attracted to a lone pair of electrons of an O atom in a neighboring molecule. These intermolecular H:O-bonds, albeit much weaker than intramolecular H-O covalent bonds, play a crucial role in determining the arrangement and dynamics of ice and water.
Ice exists in nearly twenty forms of solid phases, each with a unique arrangement of HO molecules held together by H:O-bonds [2]. Among those, Ice-Ih crystallizes in an open hexagonal lattice, in which oxygen ions form an ordered Wurtzite structure having a low packing ratio, as shown in Figure 1(e) [31]. The H:O-bonding network in ice-Ih is composed of tetrahedral building blocks, where each HO molecule forms four H:O-bonds with its neighboring molecules, as depicted in Figure 1(f). In ice-Ih, light H ions are not ordered due to their large zero-point motions.
The NTE observed at low ( K) in ice-Ih is related to its open, tetrahedral-network structure formed by H:O-bonds. It has been found that low-energy transverse phonon modes in ice-Ih, which are associated with bending motions of three hydrogen-bonded molecules, bring about the negative Grüneisen parameter and consequently the NTE phenomenon [4, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 15]. In fact, such NTE phenomena are manifested in other tetrahedrallyarranged solids having a low packing ratio, such as Si and Ge [4, 7, 32]. However, they do not exhibit anomalous VIEs but just normal VIEs, distinct from ice-Ih [33, 34].
Isotope Effects in the NTE of ice-Ih at low : Born-Oppenheimer approximation
In the Born-Oppenheimer approximation, the adiabatic separation of the fast-moving electron wave-function and the slow-moving ion wave-function is possible, and then the obtained volume-dependent eigenvalue of electron () acts as an additional interionic potential energy for the ion motions [27]. In a similar way, for a system with the high-energy () and the low-energy () phonon modes, which are far-separated in energy, one can separate adiabatically the high-energy (described by , variables with mass ) and low-energy (described by , variables with mass ) phonon modes [24, 25]. Then, as described in the supplement [6], the zero-point phonon energy of the fast-moving mode obtained in the quasi-harmonic approximation plays a role of the additional potential energy for the low-energy phonon modes:
where is the wave function of low-energy phonon (slow ) mode, and is the interionic potential energy. Here -dependence of is neglected by using the Einstein-phonon approximation.
In the case of hydrogen-bonded systems, the variable corresponds to the intermolecular O−O bond length, and so it can be considered to be a volume () variable [24, 25]. Accordingly, the effective intermolecular potential energy for the low-energy phonon modes is given by
where is the intermolecular potential energy for the static lattice, and is the QM zero-point energy of the high-energy phonon mode. Consequently, the low-energy vibrational motions become significantly affected by , depending on the volume-dependence of , as provided in Figure 2 below.

Figure 2. (a) Typical volume-dependent behaviors of high-energy phonon modes . The upper one exhibiting the pressure-induced hardening produces the positive Grüneisen parameter and the PTE, while the lower one exhibiting the pressure-induced softening produces the negative Grüneisen parameter and the NTE. (b) Effective intermolecular potential energies ’s () for the PTE-anharmonic (top) and the NTE-anharmonic (bottom) systems, respectively. is assumed to be harmonic (middle). Red dotted lines in the top and bottom illustrate the volume expansion and contraction, respectively, with increasing . (c) The intermolecular potential energy, (red curve), which is intrinsically PTE-anharmonic, can be approximated by the harmonic potential (blue curve) at low . (d) For the NTE case with negative , the heavier-mass system of DO ice has the larger volume (red dot) than the lighter-mass system of HO ice (blue dot) (). Due to the mass-dependent QM zero-point energy , DO ice would have larger binding energy than HO ice by ( value taken from Refs. [17, 39]).
Now consider a system having the high-energy phonon-mode , which decreases or increases with volume, as displayed in Figure 2(a). In fact, for the static lattice is intrinsically anharmonic in nature. But, at low , when the vibrational amplitudes are small, can be assumed to be harmonic, i.e., , as shown in the middle of Figure 2(b) and Figure 2(c). Then, through the contribution of , would have either the anharmonic potential of shallower-flattened-right (top) or that of shallower-flattened-left (bottom) with respect to the harmonic potential in the middle. According to the definition of Grüneisen parameter () [6], the former describes the PTE system with positive , while the latter describes the NTE system with negative . The red arrows in the top and bottom of Figure 2(b) illustrate the positive and negative volume expansions, respectively, with increasing .
In the case of ice-Ih, the high-energy phonon mode corresponds to the intramolecular O-H stretching mode with energy of eV, while the low-energy phonon modes correspond to the intermolecular vibration modes with energy of eV, which are considered to be responsible for the NTE at low [10, 35, 36, 37]. Hence the application of the Born-Oppenheimer approximation would be sufficiently valid in the present case [38].
Note that the high-energy stretching mode in ice-Ih, , was observed to possess a pressure-induced phonon softening [35]. This feature is understood in view of the fact that the O-H bond lengths tend to increase with increasing . In fact, its Grüneisen parameter was calculated to be negative () [9, 39]. Then, as described in the bottom of Figure 2(b), the zero-point energy of yields an NTE-anharmonic . , being an electrostatic interaction, is volume independent of isotopic mass, and so is same for both HO and DO. Hence, considering the mass-dependent (), DO ice would have a higher binding energy than HO ice by ( meV) [17, 39], as displayed schematically in Figure 2(d).
In addition, because of the mass-dependent , of DO becomes less anharmonic than that of HO, that is, of DO is closer to the harmonic potential than that of HO [40]. For simplicity, let us assume that there is just a single low-energy phonon mode, corresponding to an intermolecular vibration in ice-Ih, in the presence of . Then, as shown in Figure 2(d), HO having a stronger contribution from the anharmonic NTE potential would have smaller equilibrium volume (blue dot) than DO (red dot) having a weaker contribution from the anharmonic NTE potential. Thus the asymmetric nature of of an NTE anharmonic type explains why ice-Ih exhibits the abnormal VIE, namely, DO ice has the larger equilibrium volume than HO ice ( at ).
The volume at the minimum of , , can be obtained quantitatively from the volume derivative of . Considering the expansion of up to the first order, . This yields from . Therefore, the isotope volume difference between the DO and HO ice, (), is approximately given by
which is positive because , implying the abnormal VIE.
Indeed, the observed NTE for both HO and DO be low K in Figure 1(c) is explained well by the NTE-anharmonic shown at the bottom of Figure 2(b). But, as increases above K, the PTE is observed for both HO and DO, as if changes from the NTE-anharmonic to the PTE-anharmonic type. This feature can be understood based on the change of from the harmonic to the anharmonic form with increasing , as shown in Figure 2(c). Remember that, in Figure 2(d), the anharmonic was assumed to be harmonic at low [41]. But, with increasing , the intrinsically PTE-anharmonic nature of starts to be more and more effective, and so of ice-Ih eventually becomes PTE-anharmonic, leading to volume expansions for both HO and DO. Namely, with increasing , the phonon modes with positive Grüneisen parameters become populated, and thereby reduce the NTE. Interestingly, even at finite above K, the abnormal VIE will be maintained because of HO is still shallower-fattened-left than that of DO due to a mass-dependent contribution, and thereby the volume of HO is still smaller than that of DO.
As shown in Figure 1(c), there is also an isotope effect on the volume-minimum temperatures (), albeit not so prominent. In fact, in HO ice is only slightly higher ( K) than that in DO ice [12, 14]. would be determined by the crossing point at which changes from an NTE-anharmonic type to a PTE-anharmonic type. As described above, the NTE-anharmonic feature will persist up to higher in HO than in DO, and so in HO is higher than in DO ( K for HO vs. K for DO) [12].
Isotope Effects in the NTE of water near the freezing (melting)
As increases, the thermal vibrational energy of the HO molecules in ice-Ih increases, which weakens the H:O-bonds and causes the molecules to fluctuate around their equilibrium positions. Then H:O-bonds become weaker and weaker so as to be broken, and eventually the volume collapse occurs at the melting temperature . This feature of ice-Ih is different from those of most solids, for which the extra molecular motion in the liquid phase requires more space and therefore melting is accompanied by volume expansion.
As shown in Figure 1(b), HO water has the minimum volume at . This volume minimum is brought about by the balance between two competing effects with increasing : the volume contraction driven by melting vs. the normal volume expansion. As mentioned above, the crystalline H:O-bonding network is to be broken at . In the liquid phase, however, substantial amounts of H:O-bonds are still maintained in cluster forms of hexagonal ice-Ih phase keeping large empty space [42]. Upon heating, the number of these remaining H:O-bonds decreases slowly, resulting in the volume contraction. Meanwhile, due to the increased kinetic vibrational energy of unbonded HO molecules, water expands upon heating like most substances. The crossing of these two effects is supposed to occur at .
As introduced in Figure 1(d), the isotope effects are also manifested in water near . As provided in Table I, DO water has significantly higher () and the higher freezing (melting) temperature () than HO. Heavier TO (T: tritium) water has even higher and [20, 30]. Thus DO and TO waters exhibit wider temperature ranges of the NTE phenomena (7.5 and 8.9 ) than HO water (4 ),
| [K] | [°C] | [K] | [°C] | [K] | |
| HO | 273.15 | 0 | 277.13 | 3.98 | 3.98 |
| DO | 276.83 | 3.68 | 284.34 | 11.19 | 7.51 |
| TO | 277.64 | 4.49 | 286.55 | 13.40 | 8.91 |
Table I. Isotope effects on the freezing (melting) temperature () and the maximum-density temperature () [20]. Here H, D, and T represent hydrogen, deuterium, and tritium, respectively.
Such differences are expected to occur due to the competition between the isotopic mass-dependent H:O-bonding () and the kinetic molecular-vibration () energies of HO and DO. increases upon heating, and melting occurs when overcomes the intermolecular energy holding the crystal structure together that corresponds to the cohesive energy () [43]. When H atoms are replaced with D atoms, the molecules would have stronger intermolecular D:O-bondings due to the reduced zero-point QM fluctuations of heavier D ions. On the other hand, larger intramolecular quantum delocalization of H ions in HO brings about the enhanced dipole moment of the water molecule, producing a stronger H:O-bonding network in HO than in DO. Hence the energy difference in H:O and D:O-bonding energies will be much reduced due to two opposite effects of intermolecular and intramolecular nuclear QM fluctuations [44]. Nevertheless, the D:O-bonding network is expected to be still more robust than the H:O-bonding network [20, 45], and so of DO is larger than that of HO by their difference in (). of HO ice was reported to be meV experimentally [46, 47], and of DO was estimated to be larger than of HO by of meV [39]. Meanwhile, including the zero-point motions in HO ice was reported to be as much as meV at low , whereas in DO is supposed to be smaller than in HO by meV due to its heavier mass [23]. Both ’s increase slowly with increasing .
In Figure 3(a) are plotted ’s and ’s of HO and DO ices as a function of . It is shown that the larger in HO ice will break the weaker H:O-bonds in HO ice at a lower than in DO ice, resulting in the lower
Figure 3. (a) Schematic plot of -dependent variations of the kinetic molecular vibration energies (’s) and the () cohesive energies (’s) of HO (in blue) and DO (in red) ices. The variation of is somewhat exaggerated. Melting occurs when overcomes . It is shown that of DO is higher than that of HO. and values are taken from Ref. [23] and Ref. [39], respectively. (b) Thermal-average amplitudes of ionic displacements of HO (blue) and DO (red) ices. Melting occurs when (a: intermolecular distance, : fractional number ()).
for HO ice than for DO ice (). Also, as a consequence, the lower is naturally expected for HO water than for DO water.
This feature can also be analyzed by using the Lindemann criterion [26]. According to this criterion, a crystal melts when the average amplitude of thermal vibrations of atoms () is larger than some fraction of interatomic distances (), i.e.,
where is the atomic displacement, is some fractional number called the Lindemann parameter ( in general), and is the interatomic distance. As described in the supplement [6], for -th atom is given by (), indicating that all the phonon modes contribute to . Note that has isotopic-mass dependence through and , and, at K, . To examine the isotope effect on , let us consider just one specific phonon mode () for simplicity, . Accordingly, can be obtained from
as schematically plotted in Figure 3(b). Due to a heavier mass of DO than that of HO, of DO is to be smaller than that of HO. On the other hand, since the volume of DO is larger than that of HO, of DO is to be larger than that of HO. is obtained from the crossing of these two graphs, and so of DO is to be higher than of HO.
Let us try to estimate for a specific phonon mode . The intermolecular H:O-bond stretching vibration mode of HO ice is expected to be the most relevant mode to the melting of ice-Ih [10, 11, 17]. So let us select ( meV) for HO, which is close to a center of phonon density of states of H:O-bond stretching vibration modes. For DO, let us select ( meV), which is determined by counting the molecular-mass difference between DO and HO (). Then, in the case of HO, is obtained to be 274.6 K, for , g/mole, and Å [48] in Eq. (5). Here corresponds to the intermolecular O−O distance. Similarly, in the case of DO, is obtained to be 280.4 K, for , g/mole, and Å [48] in Eq. (5). Therefore, the higher of DO than of HO is elucidated well, and the intermolecular bond-stretching vibration modes are suggested to play an important role in the melting of ice-Ih.
As displayed in Figure 1(d), water also exhibits the abnormal VIE, namely, larger volume for DO water than for HO water. As mentioned above, near , substantial amounts of H:O-bonds in water remain in the ice-like clusters, which are embedded in and in equilibrium with the unbonded water molecules [42]. This implies that the nuclear QM effects, the hallmark in ice-Ih phase, are retained even in liquid phases above the melting temperature. Then one can understand the abnormal VIE in water, by employing again the -induced NTE-anharmonic intermolecular potential energy, similarly as discussed in Figure 2(d) for ice-Ih. That is, ’s of water are quite similar in shape to those of ice-Ih, so that HO having a larger contribution from the anharmonic NTE potential would have a smaller equilibrium volume than DO having a smaller contribution from the anharmonic NTE potential.
Further, due to existing nuclear QM effects in liquid phases, DO and HO waters would have different H:O bonding energies, ’s. Figure 4 summarizes the energy configurations and thermal expansion behaviors of DO and HO waters and ice-Ih’s. Figure 4(a), constructed based on the data in the literature, provides the following informations: (i) DO has larger volume than HO for both ice-Ih and water, (ii) waters are located at a higher energy (by meV) [19, 42] and at a smaller volume than those of ice-Ih, (iii) DO and HO have different H:O bonding energies, meV for ice-Ih [39] and meV for water [49].
In Figure 4(b), -dependent thermal expansion behaviors expected from the energy configurations given in Figure 4(a) are provided. It is shown that DO possesses the larger volume for both ice-Ih and water phases and the higher than for HO.

Figure 4. (a) Energy configurations of HO and DO waters and ice-Ih’s. The nuclear QM effects are still retained in the liquid phase near , and so DO water has the larger H:O-bonding energy and the larger volume than HO water, as in ice-Ih phase. The value of is taken from Refs. [19, 42], and that of is taken from Ref. [49]. (b) Thermal expansion behaviors of HO and DO ice-Ih’s and waters expected from the energy configurations of (a).
Concluding Remarks
Prominent isotope effects observed in ice and water indicate that the nuclear QM nature of light H and D ions plays an important role in their thermal physics. Indeed, by employing a type of Born-Oppenheimer approximation for ice-Ih, which has very high-energy phonon modes arising from intramolecular H-O and D-O bond stretching vibrations, we are able to capture a conceptual and intuitive picture of their intriguing NTE and VIE phenomena in the same framework. We demonstrate that the abnormal VIE phenomena in ice and water are attributed to the NTE-anharmonic driven by the QM zero-point energy of the high-energy intramolecular stretching phonon modes with negative . Furthermore, it is found that isotope effects on and of ice, as well as of water, originate from the enhanced nuclear QM fluctuations in HO compared to DO.
These findings reveal that the interplay between zero-point energy phonons, thermal phonons, and the H:O-bondings, all of which are of QM origin, governs the unique NTE, VIE, and melting behaviors of ice and water. A comprehensive and conceptual understanding of these mechanisms would provide valuable insights into not only the NTE but also other hitherto-mysterious thermal properties observed in ice and water, including specific-heat, viscosity, compressibility, and sound velocity.
Acknowledgments
Helpful discussions with Prof. Kwang-Sei Lee and Prof. Byeong June Min are greatly appreciated. JSK acknowledges the support by the National Research Foundation (NRF) of Korea (Grant No. RS-2023-00275779).
Negative Thermal Expansion (NTE) when
The negative slope of phase-equilibrium line at the ice-water transition in Figure 1(a) of the main text suggests the NTE behavior across the ice-water transition upon heating. It is because the thermal-expansion coefficient is given by
where is the bulk-modulus, , which is always positive [27]. Here we used the thermodynamic relation, . Accordingly, can be negative, provided in the pressure-temperature () phase diagram.
Adiabatic separation of the high- and low-energy phonon modes
Let us consider a system having the high-energy and low-energy phonon modes, which are far-separated in energy. Then, as done in the Born-Oppenheimer approximation for the fast electron and slow ion motions [27], one can separate adiabatically the high-energy (fast ) and low-energy (slow ) phonon modes.
Consider the total Hamiltonian for (with mass ) and (with mass ) ion motions:
where
Here corresponds to the static inter-ionic potential obtained by using the Born-Oppenheimer approximation. In the harmonic approximation for ,
Now consider the adiabatic separation of fast () and slow () ionic motions,
Here is the wave function of high-energy phonon (fast ) mode, satisfying
Here is considered just as a given parameter. Substituting Eq. (10) and (S6) into Eq. (7), and using the adiabatic approximation [24, 25], then we have the following equation for the low-energy phonon mode,
In Eq. (12), we considered the ground-state eigenvalue of phonon mode, and so the effective potential for phonons is given by
Therefore, in this adiabatic approximation, the zero-point phonon energy of fast motion of mode () plays a role of additional potential energy for the slow motion of modes. In the case of HO ice and water, the intramolecular O-H stretching mode corresponds to the fast mode, while intermolecular vibrations correspond to the slow mode.
Thermal expansion coefficient of phonon origin
In the quasi-harmonic approximation, pressure exerted by phonons can be obtained from the volume-dependent free energy of phonons, , by using [27 S4, 9]:
The first term corresponds to the energy of the quantum mechanical zero-point vibrations of the normal modes. The second term corresponds to the thermal phonon energy at . Then
where is the boson distribution function [27]. Substituting Eq. (15) into Eq. (6), the thermal-expansion coefficient of phonon origin is given by
Now let us define the -dependent Grüneisen parameter and the -dependent specific heat contributed by a phonon mode with the energy (total specific heat ), as follows:
Let us also define the overall Grüneisen parameter corresponding to the weighted average of ,
Then can be expressed as
Thus, whether a system is the NTE or PTE is determined by the sign of .
Volume change and the Grüneisen parameter
From Eq. (20),
and using Eq. (19),
Note that, for ,
Accordingly, from Eqs. (22), (23), and (24),
Phonon frequency and the Grüneisen parameter
On the other hand, from Eq. (17),
Eq. (27) indicates that, for the NTE with negative , phonon frequency increases with volume (pressure-induced softening), while, for the PTE with positive , phonon frequency decreases with volume (pressure-induced hardening) (see Ref. [9]).
Average amplitude of thermally vibrating atoms:
For a single harmonic oscillator in one dimension, the atomic displacement can be described by the quantized creation and annihilation operators, and , as follows:
Then
where () corresponds to the boson distribution function . At , , and so . At finite , increases with as . In three dimensions, factor 3 needs to be multiplied in the above expressions [S6]. Note that is isotopic-mass dependent through and . But as , becomes , and so it does not have isotopic-mass dependence because of being constant.
For a real solid, the atomic displacement can be described, as follows [S7]:
where and are frequency and polarization vector of phonon, respectively. Then is given by
which is quite similar to Eq. (29) (here, ). Therefore, even in the case of real solid, for a specific phonon mode of Einstein type can be described by a simple form of the single harmonic oscillator . (1968).
[25] Y. Marechal, The Hydrogen Bond and the Water Molecule, Amsterdam, Elsevier (2007).
[S4] D. J. Kim, T. Kizaki, N. Miyai, J. Iwai, N. Hino, S. Fukumoto, J. Korean Phys. Soc. 28, 203 (1995).
[9] B. Pamuk, J. M. Soler, R. Ramirez, C. P. Herrero, P.W. Stephens, P. B. Allen, and M.-V. Fernandez-Serra, Phys. Rev. Lett. 108, 193003 (2012)
[S6] C. Kittel, Introduction to Solid State Physics, seventh edition, John Wiley & Sons, Inc. (1996).
[S7] G. D. Mahan, Many Particle Physics, Plenum, New York (1990).
References
- [1]Introductory Chemistry by LibreTexts project (CK-12), website (see Ch. 13.20), (https://chem.libretexts.org/Bookshelves/Introductory_Chemistry/Introductory_Chemistry_(CK-12)).
- [2]Water Structure and Science, website by M. Chaplin, (https://water.lsbu.ac.uk/water/water-structure-science.html), and references therein.
- [3]Z.-K. Liu, Y. Wang, and S.-L. Shang, Scr. Mater. 65, 664 (2011).
- [4]Z.-K. Liu, Y. Wang, and S.-L. Shang, Sci. Rep. 4, 7043 (2014).
- [5]J. Kim, J.-S. Kang, C.-J. Kang, and B. I. Min, Phys. Rev. B 107, 115157 (2023).
- [6]See the Supplementary Material for the derivations of (i) The NTE for the negative slope of dP/dT < 0, (ii) Adiabatic separation of the high- and low-energy phonon modes, (iii) Thermal expansion coefficient of phonon origin, (iv) The relation between the volume change and the Grüneisen parameter, (v) The relation between the phonon frequency and the Grüneisen parameter, and (vi) Average amplitude of thermally vibrating atoms: ⟨u²⟩¹ᐟ².
- [7]J. S. O. Evans, J. Chem. Soc., Dalton Trans., 3317 (1999).
- [8]Th. Strässle, A. M. Saitta, S. Klotz, and M. Braden, Phys. Rev. Lett. 93, 225901 (2004).
- [9]B. Pamuk, J. M. Soler, R. Ramirez, C. P. Herrero, P.W. Stephens, P. B. Allen, and M.-V. Fernandez-Serra, Phys. Rev. Lett. 108, 193003 (2012).
- [10]K. Umemoto, E. Sugimura, S. de Gironcoli, Y. Nakajima, K. Hirose, Y. Ohishi, and R. M. Wentzcovitch, Phys. Rev. Lett. 115, 173005 (2015).
- [11]M. K. Gupta, R. Mittal, Baltej Singh, S. K. Mishra, D. T. Adroja, A. D. Fortes, and S. L. Chaplot, Phys. Rev. B 98, 104301 (2018)
- [12]K. Röttger, A. Endriss, J. Ihringer, S. Doyle, and W. F. Kuhs, Acta Cryst. 850, 644 (1994).
- [13]A. D. Fortes, Acta Cryst. B 74, 196 (2018).
- [14]D. T. W. Buckingham, J. J. Neumeier, S. H. Masunaga, and Y.-K. Yu, Phys. Rev. Lett. 121, 185505 (2018).
- [15]M. A. Salim, S. Y. Willow, and S. Hirata, J. Chem. Phys. 144, 204503 (2016).
- [16]M. Cherubini, L. Monacelli, and F. Mauri, J. Chem. Phys. 155, 184502 (2021).
- [17]S. Rasti, E. Ö. Jonsson, H. Jonsson, and J. Meyer, J. Phys. Chem. Lett. 13, 11831 (2022).
- [18]J. A. Morrone and R. Car, Phys. Rev. Lett 101, 017801 (2008).
- [19]R. Ramirez and C. P. Herrero, J. Chem. Phys. 133, 144511 (2010).
- [20]C. McBride, J. L. Aragones, E. G. Noya, and C. Vega, Phys. Chem. Chem. Phys. 4, 15199 (2012).
- [21]J. Xu, C. Zhang, L. Zhang, M. Chen, B. Santra, and X. Wu, Phys. Rev. B 102, 214113 (2020).
- [22]A. E. Altereb, G. E. Lopez, and N. Giombattista, Phys. Chem. Chem. Phys. 234, 6914 (2021).
- [23]G. Romanelli, C. Andreani, A. Bocedi, R. Senesi, J. Chem. Phys. 160, 234503 (2024).
- [24]Y. Marechal and A. Witkowski, J. Chem. Phys. 48, 3697 (1968).
- [25]Y. Marechal, The Hydrogen Bond and the Water Molecule, Amsterdam, Elsevier (2007).DOI
- [26]F. A. Lindemann, Phys. Z. 11, 609 (1910).
- [27]N. W. Ashcroft and N. D. Mermin, Solid state physics, New York: Saunders College Publishing (1976).
- [28]G. de With, Chem. Rev. 123, 13713 (2023).
- [29]website The Engineering ToolBox (https://www.engineeringtoolbox.com/).
- [30]The melting temperatures (Tₘ’s) for H₂O, D₂O, and T₂O are 0 °C, 3.68 °C, and 4.49 °C, respectively. The volume-minimum points corresponding to the density maximum points (Tᴹᴰ’s) are 4.0 °C, 11.19 °C, and 13.40 °C for H₂O, D₂O, and T₂O, respectively. Molecular volumes at Tᴹᴰ’s are 29.9 ų, 30.1 ų, and 31.1 ų, respectively.
- [31]E. D. Isaacs, A. Shukla, P. M. Platzman, D. R. Hamann, B. Barbiellini, and C. A. Tulk, Phys. Rev. Lett. 82, 600 (1999).
- [32]T. Soma, J. Phys. Soc. Jpn. 42, 1491 (1977).
- [33]J. C. Noya, C. P. Herrero, and R. Ramírez, Phys. Rev. B 56, 237 (1997).
- [34]C.P. Herrero, Solid State Comm. 110, 243 (1999).
- [35]Y. Yoshimura, S. T. Stewart, M. Somayazulu, H. K. Mao, and R. J. Hemley, J. Phys. Chem. B 115, 3756 (2011).
- [36]C. Q. Sun, X. Zhang, X. Fu, W. Zheng, J.-I. Kuo, Y. Zhou, and J. Zhou, J. Phys. Chem. Lett. 4, 3238 (2013).
- [37]X. Zhang, Y. Huang, P. Sun, X. Liu, Z. Ma, Y. Zhou, J. Zhou, W. Zheng, and C. Q. Sun, Sci. Rep. 5, 13655 (2015).
- [38]The other vibrational modes located inbetween the high and low energy phonon modes, which correspond to the H₂O libration and H-O:H bending modes, are irrelevant to the NTE phenomenon in ice-Ih, and so are ignored in the present Born-Oppenheimer analysis.
- [39]B. Pamuk, P. B. Allen, and M.-V. Fernandez-Serra, Phys. Rev. B 92, 134105 (2015).
- [40]It is because the slope of ωₛ(V) with respect to volume, ∂ωₛ/∂V, is stiffer for H₂O than for D₂O, i.e., (∂ωₛᴴ/∂V − ∂ωₛᴰ/∂V) ≈ ∂ωₛᴴ/∂V (1 − √mᴴ/mᴰ) > 0.
- [41]If the intrinsic PTE-anharmonicity of U₀(V) at low T is dominant over the NTE-anharmonicity of the QM zero-point energy (½ℏωₛ(V)) of high-energy phonon mode, the NTE phenomenon will not emerge. Other ice phases under high pressure are likely to be in this situation, which is why no NTE phenomena are observed at low T.
- [42]G. Nemethy and H. A. Scheraga, J. Chem. Phys. 36, 3382 (1962).
- [43]F.A. Deeney and J.P. O’Leary, Phys. Lett. A 372, 1551 (2008).
- [44]S. Habershon, T. E. Markland, D. E. Manolopoulos, J. Chem. Phys. 131, 024501 (2009).
- [45]M. Ceriotti, W. Fang, P. G. Kusalik, R. H. McKenzie, A. Michaelides, M. A. Morales, and T. E. Markland, Chem. Rev. 116, 7529 (2016).
- [46]E. Whalley, Trans. Faraday Soc. 53, 1578 (1957).
- [47]E. Whalley, J. Chem. Phys. 81, 1 (1984).
- [48]G. Giubertoni, M. Bonn, and S. Woutersen, J. Phys. Chem. B 127, 8086 (2023).
- [49]I. F. Hakem, A. Boussaid, H. Benchouk-Taleb, M. R. Bockstaller, J. Chem. Phys. 127, 224106 (2007).