betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

A GRACE Interatomic Potential for W–Ta Systems: Application to Ta Segregation and Pinning of Shear-Coupled Grain-Boundary Migration

Abstract

Tungsten-tantalum alloys are promising plasma-facing materials for fusion reactors, but simulations of their coupled defect, mechanical, and microstructural evolution require an interatomic potential that remains accurate across diverse atomic environments. We develop a transferable W-Ta potential within the GRaph Atomic Cluster Expansion (GRACE) framework. The primary training dataset was generated automatically by maximizing information entropy in an atomically relevant feature space, avoiding manual enumeration of the structures and processes required for specific downstream applications. Extensive validation demonstrates a consistent description of unary and binary phase stability, elasticity, phonons, high-pressure response, surfaces, point defects, dislocation energetics, transformation pathways, alloy thermodynamics, and melting behavior. As a demonstration, the potential is applied to Ta segregation and shear-coupled migration of a Σ5(120)\Sigma5(120) W GB. Simulations reveal strongly site-selective segregation: Ta preferentially occupies a small subset of crystallographically distinct atomic rows. Under shear, segregated Ta impedes disconnection-mediated grain boundary migration. The de-pinning stress initially increases with Ta concentration but plateaus as the dominant pinning environment becomes saturated, while increasing temperature weakens both segregation and pinning. These results establish a broadly validated W-Ta potential and demonstrate how automated entropy-maximized data generation can produce transferable atomistic models capable of resolving mechanisms not explicitly targeted during training.

Introduction

Tungsten (W) and W-based alloys are leading candidate materials for plasma-facing components in fusion reactors because of their high melting temperature, high thermal conductivity, low sputtering yield, and low hydrogen-isotope retention. Despite these advantages, the use of W is limited by low-temperature brittleness, poor workability, recrystallization-induced embrittlement, and neutron-irradiation-induced degradation of mechanical properties [1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7]. These limitations have motivated several alloying and microstructural design strategies, including grain refinement [8], work hardening [9], dispersion strengthening [10], K doping [11], Re alloying [12, 13], and solid-solution alloying [14].

Tantalum (Ta) is a particularly relevant alloying element for W because W and Ta form a high-temperature solid solution and Ta has been considered more favorable than some refractory solutes from the standpoint of fusion-relevant activation and transmutation behavior [15, 16, 17]. Recent experimental studies have shown that small Ta additions, typically in the range of 1–5 wt.%, can improve strength, recrystallization resistance, irradiation tolerance, and high-heat-flux performance relative to pure W [5, 18, 19, 20]. Ta also modifies plasma-induced surface evolution, including D/He retention, blistering, and fuzz formation [21, 22, 23]. On the other hand, studies of W–Ta alloys reported limited or even detrimental effects on ductility and fracture toughness, indicating a strong dependence on processing history, impurity content, grain and subgrain structure, and the spatial distribution of Ta [24, 25]. Therefore, the role of Ta cannot be explained solely by bulk solid-solution strengthening; its interactions with defects, interfaces, and grain boundaries (GBs) must also be considered.

The W–Ta system remains challenging even from the thermodynamic standpoint. Although the experimental phase diagram suggests high-temperature miscibility without stable intermetallic compounds, first-principles and cluster-expansion studies have predicted competing low-temperature ordered phases [17, 26, 27, 28].

This thermodynamic complexity is compounded by the absence of a transferable W–Ta interatomic potential capable of describing the coupled kinetic processes that govern fusion-material performance. In service, W-based alloys simultaneously undergo irradiation damage, defect migration, solute redistribution, recrystallization, plastic flow, high-temperature deformation, and plasma–surface evolution. Modeling these processes requires accuracy far beyond equilibrium bulk properties: the potential must remain reliable across compositions, defects, interfaces, transformation pathways, and extreme thermomechanical conditions.

Existing Embedded Atom Method/Finnis–Sinclair (EAM/FS) potentials for W–Ta [29] are limited in their ability to represent angular bonding, higher-order correlations, body-centered cubic (BCC) defect physics, alloy ordering, interface structures, and migration barriers. More recent Generalized EAM (GEAM) efforts [30] introduced higher-order interactions, but were trained on small datasets and validated over a limited set of properties, with restricted assessment of dislocation energetics, generalized stacking-fault energies, point-defect migration, binary defect interactions, solute clustering, and GB response. These limitations motivate the development of a transferable machine-learning interatomic potential for W–Ta that can be applied to the complex, coupled phenomena expected in extreme fusion environments.

In this work, we develop and validate an ultra-robust GRaph Atomic Cluster Expansion (GRACE) potential for the W–Ta binary system [31, 32, 33]. The potential describes unary and binary energetics, elastic properties, defect structures, transformation pathways, interfacial environments, and high-temperature configurations relevant to W–Ta alloys. The central goal is to provide a robust atomistic model that can be used to study fusion-relevant processes in W–Ta, including irradiation defect evolution, recrystallization, plastic deformation, solute effects, and GB-mediated deformation. As an application, we use this potential to investigate how Ta segregates at high-angle tilt GBs and affects shear-driven GB motion in W, with particular focus on the dependence of GB de-pinning on the segregated Ta atmosphere. By connecting solute content, GB structure, and atomistic de-pinning mechanisms, this study investigates how binary alloying controls GB-mediated deformation in W-based refractory alloys while establishing a transferable potential for broader simulations of W–Ta in extreme environments.

Training Data Generation

The majority of the training data was generated using the feature information entropy maximization approach [33, 34, 35]. At a high level, the method reframes the problem of generating training sets for MLIPs as an optimization under an objective function that quantifies the diversity of the dataset as measured in an atomically-relevant feature space. Using a Gaussian upper bound to the Shannon differential entropy of the feature distribution, the procedure optimizes the information content of the entire dataset by displacing atoms along the gradient of the information entropy. This greedy optimization procedure is completely automated and leads to ultra-diverse dataset, which in turn leads to extremely transferable models across a broad range of properties and conditions [33, 35, 36].

In this work, we follow the data-generation and DFT-evaluation protocol of Ref. [35], restricting the chemical space to W and Ta. Using this procedure, we generated 78,703 configurations containing 788,758 atoms. The dataset was further enriched with 517 intermetallic configurations from the OQMD database [37] and previous DFT studies [26, 38]. The distributions of DFT energies and forces used for model training are shown in Fig. 1.

Density functional theory (DFT) calculations were performed using the Vienna Ab initio Simulation Package (VASP) [39] through the Atomic Simulation Environment (ASE) [40]. The calculations employed the projector-augmented-wave method and the Perdew–Burke–Ernzerhof (PBE) generalized-gradient approximation for the exchange–correlation functional [41].

Single-point calculations were conducted on the supplied atomic configurations without ionic-position or simulation-cell relaxation. Periodic boundary conditions were applied in all three spatial directions. The plane-wave kinetic-energy cutoff was set to (500 eV), and Brillouin-zone sampling was generated automatically using a reciprocal-space spacing of (0.125 Å−1^{-1}). Gaussian smearing was applied with a smearing width of (0.1 eV). All calculations were performed without spin polarization. The electronic self-consistent-field iterations were converged to an energy tolerance of (10−6^{-6} eV), with a maximum of 200 electronic iterations.

Distributions of DFT energies and Cartesian force components in the W–Ta training database

Figure 1. Distributions of DFT energies (a–c) and Cartesian force components (d–f) in the W–Ta training database. The columns correspond to (a,d) W, (b,e) Ta, and (c,f) mixed W–Ta configurations. Counts are plotted on a logarithmic scale, and the annotations report the number of samples NN, mean μ\mu, and standard deviation σ\sigma for each distribution.

GRACE Model Training

The W–Ta interatomic potential was developed using the Graph Atomic Cluster Expansion (GRACE) framework [32]. A one-layer GRACE model was used with a 6.0 Å cutoff, maximum body order of four, angular resolution lmax⁡=4l_{\max}=4, nradmax⁡=32n_{\mathrm{rad}}^{\max}=32 radial channels, nradbase=8n_{\mathrm{rad}}^{\mathrm{base}}=8 radial basis functions, nprodmax⁡=32n_{\mathrm{prod}}^{\max}=32 product functions, and nMLPdens=10n_{\mathrm{MLP}}^{\mathrm{dens}}=10 density-embedding hidden units. A short-range ZBL correction was included with a cutoff of 1.8 Å.

The W–Ta convex hull was used to define an energy-based weighting scheme, where configurations closer to the hull were assigned larger statistical weights to emphasize low-energy crystalline, alloy, and defect structures. Higher-energy configurations were retained with reduced weights to improve transferability to distorted and non-equilibrium environments. The dataset was split into training and test sets using a 5% test fraction. Model parameters were optimized for 1500 epochs using the Adam optimizer with an initial learning rate of 0.008, cosine decay to 6.67×10−46.67 \times10^{-4}, exponential moving averaging with momentum 0.99, and gradient clipping with a maximum norm of 1.0. Huber losses with δ=0.01\delta=0.01 were used for both energies and forces, with relative loss weights of 10 and 5, respectively.

The predictive performance of GRACE on the training and testing datasets is compared with the available EAM/FS [29] and GEAM [30] W–Ta potentials in Figure 2 and Table 1. It is important to note that the EAM/FS and GEAM potentials were not parameterized using the present DFT dataset. Therefore, this comparison is not intended as a direct, like-for-like assessment of fitting accuracy, but rather as an evaluation of how robustly the different potentials reproduce an ultra-diverse set of W–Ta configurations that extensively probes different regions of the energy landscape. GRACE gives the lowest energy errors, with RMSE = 0.0572 eV/atom and MAE = 0.0131 eV/atom, compared with 0.5665 and 0.3359 eV/atom for EAM/FS and 0.6813 and 0.3695 eV/atom for GEAM, respectively. GRACE also provides the most accurate forces, with RMSE = 0.3424 eV/Å, MAE = 0.1617 eV/Å, and R2=0.9831R^2=0.9831.

Parity plots comparing DFT energies and atomic force components with predictions from GRACE, EAM/FS, and GEAM for W, Ta, and W–Ta configurations

Figure 2. Parity plots comparing DFT energies and atomic force components with predictions from GRACE, EAM/FS, and GEAM for W, Ta, and W–Ta configurations. Panels (a)–(c) show shifted energies per atom, and panels (d)–(f) show force components. Dashed lines indicate perfect agreement with DFT.

PotentialE-RMSEE-MAEE-R2R^2F-RMSEF-MAEF-R2R^2
(eV/atom)(eV/atom)(eV/atom)(eV/Å)(eV/Å)
GRACE0.05720.01310.99970.34240.16170.9831
EAM/FS0.56650.33590.96901.32430.79250.7358
GEAM0.68130.36950.94800.64480.34880.9398

Table 1. Comparison of prediction accuracy on the dataset. RMSE, MAE, and R2R^2 are reported for energies and atomic forces relative to DFT reference values.

GRACE Model Validation

The W–Ta GRACE machine-learning interatomic potential was validated against a broad set of unary and binary properties to assess its accuracy and transferability. All GRACE atomistic simulations were performed using the Large-scale Atomic/Molecular Massively Parallel Simulator (LAMMPS) [42].

Unary Properties Validation

Table 2 shows that the GRACE potential reproduces a range of unary properties of BCC W and Ta with good overall agreement relative to the present DFT calculations and available experimental data. For both elements, the predicted equilibrium lattice constants, cohesive energies, bulk moduli, and elastic constants are close to the DFT values, indicating that the model accurately captures the near-equilibrium BCC response. The vacancy formation and migration energies are also well reproduced, while the interstitial formation energies preserve the correct energetic ordering among the different defect configurations. In addition, the surface and twin-boundary energies predicted by GRACE remain close to the DFT references, demonstrating that the potential describes low-coordination and interfacial environments with reasonable accuracy.

PropertyW ExperimentW DFTW GRACETa ExperimentTa DFTTa GRACE
a0a_0 (Å)3.165a^{a}3.1723.1843.3039b^{b}3.3093.322
E0E_0 (eV)-8.9c^{c}-13.018-12.956-8.1d^{d}-11.865-11.815
BB (GPa)308–314e^{e}320.728326.089194.2f^{f}; 198b^{b}196.537191.164
C11C_{11} (GPa)501–521e^{e}551.001561.991266.3f^{f}264.516252.070
C12C_{12} (GPa)199–207e^{e}205.591208.138158.2f^{f}160.565160.711
C44C_{44} (GPa)151–160e^{e}148.866153.27887.4f^{f}74.09769.199
EfvE_\mathrm{f}^{v} (eV)3.1–4.0g^{g}3.2233.4802.2–3.1h^{h}3.0183.011
EmvE_\mathrm{m}^{v} (eV)1.7–2.0i^{i}1.6831.8420.7h^{h}0.6560.640
Efi⟨100⟩E_\mathrm{f}^{i}\langle100\rangle (eV)–11.98511.332–5.6996.586
Efi⟨110⟩E_\mathrm{f}^{i}\langle110\rangle (eV)–10.17610.845–5.2136.041
Efi⟨111⟩E_\mathrm{f}^{i}\langle111\rangle (eV)–9.82410.432–4.5725.174
EfiE_\mathrm{f}^{i} Tet. (eV)–11.39311.406–5.5776.602
EfiE_\mathrm{f}^{i} Oct. (eV)–12.06311.660–5.7766.824
γ100s\gamma_{100}^{s} (J m−2^{-2})–4.0113.827–2.5032.637
γ110s\gamma_{110}^{s} (J m−2^{-2})–3.2523.298–2.3722.409
γ111s\gamma_{111}^{s} (J m−2^{-2})–3.4963.565–2.7202.768
γ211s\gamma_{211}^{s} (J m−2^{-2})–3.9883.808–3.0252.863
γ211TB\gamma_{211}^{\mathrm{TB}} (J m−2^{-2})–0.760j^{j}0.840–0.304j^{j}0.329
TmT_\mathrm{m} (K)3695k^{k}3450.000 ± 105.000l^{l}3555.250 ± 40.2703293c^{c}3085.000 ± 130.000m^{m}3051.140 ± 42.060

Table 2. Unary properties of BCC W and Ta comparing experiment, present DFT, and GRACE predictions.

a^{a} [43]; b^{b} [44]; c^{c} [45]; d^{d} [46]; e^{e} [47]; f^{f} [48]; g^{g} [49]; h^{h} [50]; i^{i} [51]; j^{j} [52]; k^{k} [53]; l^{l} [54]; m^{m} [55].

Values reported without a lettered literature footnote correspond to the present DFT or GRACE calculation.

In the reference DFT calculations, bulk BCC cells were relaxed with respect to both atomic positions and cell dimensions, whereas defect and surface structures were relaxed at fixed cell dimensions. Elastic constants were obtained from energy–strain fits using hydrostatic, orthorhombic, and shear strains ranging from ±0.001 to ±0.003. Vacancy formation and migration energies were evaluated in 6×6×66 \times6 \times6 supercells, with migration barriers determined using a climbing-image nudged elastic band (NEB) [56] calculation with 21 replicas, see subsection 5.1.7. Self-interstitial formation energies were calculated in 6×6×66 \times6 \times6 BCC supercells for the ⟨100⟩\langle100\rangle, ⟨110⟩\langle110\rangle, and ⟨111⟩\langle111\rangle dumbbells and the tetrahedral and octahedral configurations. Surface energies were calculated from relaxed slabs containing two equivalent free surfaces as γ=(Eslab−NEbulk)/(2A)\gamma= (E_\mathrm{slab} - N E_\mathrm{bulk})/(2A).

For the GRACE property calculation, the BCC lattice constants and cohesive energies were obtained from periodic two-atom cells relaxed at zero pressure. Elastic constants were calculated from relaxed 8×8×88 \times8 \times8 BCC supercells using central finite differences, Cij=∂σi/∂εjC_{ij} = \partial\sigma_i/\partial\varepsilon_j, over strains from ±1×10−4\pm1 \times10^{-4} to ±1×10−3\pm1 \times10^{-3}. The tensor was symmetrized and averaged, and the bulk modulus was evaluated as B=(C11+2C12)/3B = (C_{11} + 2C_{12})/3.

Vacancy formation energies were obtained by removing a central atom from periodic 6×6×66 \times6 \times6 supercells and relaxing the remaining atoms at fixed cell dimensions, with Efvac=Evac−(N−1)EBCCE_\mathrm{f}^{\mathrm{vac}} = E_\mathrm{vac} - (N - 1)E_\mathrm{BCC}. Migration barriers were calculated using the NEB method [57, 58] as Emvac=Esaddle−EinitialE_\mathrm{m}^{\mathrm{vac}} = E_\mathrm{saddle} - E_\mathrm{initial}. Self-interstitial formation energies were calculated for the ⟨100⟩\langle100\rangle, ⟨110⟩\langle110\rangle, and ⟨111⟩\langle111\rangle dumbbells and the octahedral and tetrahedral configurations in periodic 6×6×66 \times6 \times6 supercells. After full relaxation, the formation energy was evaluated as Efint=Eint−(N+1)EBCCE_\mathrm{f}^{\mathrm{int}} = E_\mathrm{int} - (N + 1)E_\mathrm{BCC}. For the point-defect calculations, NN denotes the number of atoms in the corresponding perfect supercell, and EBCCE_\mathrm{BCC} is the bulk energy per atom calculated using the same method.

Surface energies were obtained from slabs periodic in-plane and free normal to the surface using γ=(Eslab−NEBCC)/(2A)\gamma= (E_\mathrm{slab} - N E_\mathrm{BCC})/(2A). The 3{112}⟨110⟩\mathrm{3}\{112\}\langle110\rangle coherent twin-boundary energy was calculated from a fully periodic bicrystal containing two equivalent boundaries using the corresponding excess-energy expression.

Melting temperatures were estimated from solid–liquid coexistence simulations in periodic 6×6×506 \times6 \times50 BCC cells. A liquid slab was generated within the equilibrated solid, and the system was evolved under near-zero-pressure NPH conditions until a steady coexistence temperature was reached.

Relative Phase Stability

The stability of pure W and Ta was assessed by comparing several crystal structures relative to the BCC phase. The equation-of-state curves were obtained by uniformly scaling the relaxed cell and evaluating the energy at each volume without further atomic relaxation. Phase energies were reported per atom relative to BCC as ΔEphase=Ephase−EBCC\Delta E_{\mathrm{phase}} = E_{\mathrm{phase}} - E_{\mathrm{BCC}}. As shown in Figure 3 and Table 3, GRACE correctly predicts BCC as the most stable structure for both elements. For W, GRACE closely matches the ab initio relative energies of FCC, SC, and A15, while the higher-energy DC, dimer, and trimer structures remain far above BCC. For Ta, GRACE also captures the main stability trend, including the low energy of A15 and the higher energies of FCC, HCP, HEX, SC, and DC. Some differences remain, especially for A15 and HCP Ta, but the overall ordering of the competing structures is well reproduced.

Equation-of-state curves for competing crystal structures of pure W and Ta

Figure 3. Equation-of-state curves for competing crystal structures of pure (a) W and (b) Ta predicted by the GRACE potential.

StructureAb initio WGRACE WAb initio TaGRACE Ta
ΔE\Delta E (eV/atom)a0a_0 or R0R_0 (Å)ΔE\Delta E (eV/atom)a0a_0 or R0R_0 (Å)ΔE\Delta E (eV/atom)a0a_0 or R0R_0 (Å)ΔE\Delta E (eV/atom)a0a_0 or R0R_0 (Å)
FCC0.470a0.470^{\mathrm{a}}4.000a4.000^{\mathrm{a}}0.4754.0380.304c0.304^{\mathrm{c}}4.1256c4.1256^{\mathrm{c}}0.2394.239
HCP––0.4972.7780.385c0.385^{\mathrm{c}}2.9112c2.9112^{\mathrm{c}}0.2752.922
HEX––1.1372.6620.757c0.757^{\mathrm{c}}2.7715c2.7715^{\mathrm{c}}0.7032.877
SC1.350a1.350^{\mathrm{a}}2.610a2.610^{\mathrm{a}}1.4522.6341.137c1.137^{\mathrm{c}}2.6710c2.6710^{\mathrm{c}}1.0982.746
DC2.330b2.330^{\mathrm{b}}5.870b5.870^{\mathrm{b}}2.6625.7813.128c3.128^{\mathrm{c}}5.9096c5.9096^{\mathrm{c}}2.8856.021
β\beta-W/A150.080a0.080^{\mathrm{a}}5.060a5.060^{\mathrm{a}}0.0975.0690.060c0.060^{\mathrm{c}}5.1805c5.1805^{\mathrm{c}}0.0115.301
Dimer––5.9192.132–6.044c6.044^{\mathrm{c}}5.7112.258
Trimer––4.8492.286–5.944c5.944^{\mathrm{c}}4.5742.417

Table 3. Relative phase stability for unary W and Ta. Energies are reported relative to the corresponding BCC ground state of each element. For dimer and trimer structures, R0R_0 is reported instead of a0a_0.

a^{\mathrm{a}} [59].

b^{\mathrm{b}} [60].

c^{\mathrm{c}} [61].

Thermal Expansion

Thermal expansion was evaluated using periodic 6×6×66 \times6 \times6 BCC supercells heated from 100 to 3500 K in 100 K increments under zero-pressure NPT conditions. The relative expansion, ΔL/L0=[L(T)−L0]/L0\Delta L/L_0 = [L(T) - L_0]/L_0, increased steadily with temperature for both W and Ta, as shown in Figure 4. GRACE closely matches the DFT thermal expansion of W and reproduces the nonlinear DFT trend for Ta, with only minor high-temperature deviations.

Thermal expansion of BCC W and Ta

Figure 4. Thermal expansion of BCC (a) W and (b) Ta, expressed as the relative change in lattice parameter, ΔL/L0\Delta L/L_{0}. GRACE predictions are compared with DFT reference data for W [62] and Ta [63].

High Pressure

High-pressure behavior was evaluated using periodic BCC supercells equilibrated near 300 K and subsequently compressed isotropically in successive 0.5% linear increments under NVT conditions. The pressure was averaged at each volume and plotted against V/V0V/V_{0}. GRACE accurately reproduces the strong nonlinear pressure increase upon compression for both W and Ta up to pressures in the hundreds of GPa.

High-pressure response of BCC W and Ta

Figure 5. High-pressure response of BCC (a) W and (b) Ta as a function of normalized volume, V/V0V/V_{0}. GRACE predictions are compared with DFT results for both elements and experimental data for W from Refs. [64, 65].

Phonon Dispersion

Phonon dispersion calculations were performed for unary BCC W and Ta using DFT and GRACE. Harmonic force constants were obtained using the finite-displacement method implemented in Phonopy [66]. For each method, the equilibrium lattice parameter was determined independently, and 4×4×44 \times4 \times4 primitive-cell supercells were generated with atomic displacements of 0.010.01 Å. Static DFT calculations and zero-step LAMMPS calculations with GRACE were performed for the displaced structures, and the resulting forces were used to construct the force constants. Phonon frequencies were evaluated along the BCC high-symmetry path using 101 wave-vector points per segment. As shown in Figure 6, GRACE closely reproduces the DFT dispersion of W and Ta.

Phonon dispersion relations of unary BCC W and Ta

Figure 6. Phonon dispersion relations of unary BCC (a) W and (b) Ta along the Γ–H–P–Γ–N high-symmetry path. The DFT curves were calculated in this study.

Generalized Stacking Fault Energy

Generalized stacking fault energy (GSFE) curves were computed for the BCC {110}⟨111⟩\{110\}\langle111\rangle, {110}⟨110⟩\{110\}\langle110\rangle, {110}⟨100⟩\{110\}\langle100\rangle, {211}⟨110⟩\{211\}\langle110\rangle, and {211}⟨111⟩\{211\}\langle111\rangle slip systems in W and Ta. For each case, a periodic 6×6×246 \times6 \times24 oriented supercell was divided into two halves, with the upper half displaced over one lattice translation using 21 increments. Atomic relaxation was restricted to the fault-plane normal, and the excess energy was normalized by the area of the two periodic faults. The maximum GSFE values and corresponding normalized displacements are reported in Table 4; all barriers occur near u=0.50u = 0.50. Figure 7 compares the predicted GSFE curves with available DFT data for representative {110}⟨111⟩\{110\}\langle111\rangle and {112}⟨111⟩\{112\}\langle111\rangle slip systems.

Slip plane/directionW, ΦGSFEmax⁡\Phi_{\mathrm{GSFE}}^{\max} J m−2^{-2}Ta, ΦGSFEmax⁡\Phi_{\mathrm{GSFE}}^{\max} J m−2^{-2}
DFTGRACEDFTGRACE
{110}⟨111⟩\{110\}\langle111\rangle1.786a1.786^{\mathrm{a}}1.7260.704b0.704^{\mathrm{b}}; 0.840c0.840^{\mathrm{c}}0.791
{110}⟨110⟩\{110\}\langle110\rangle–3.3881.628b1.628^{\mathrm{b}}1.807
{110}⟨100⟩\{110\}\langle100\rangle–3.3881.628b1.628^{\mathrm{b}}; 1.951c1.951^{\mathrm{c}}1.807
{211}⟨110⟩\{211\}\langle110\rangle–4.6843.330b3.330^{\mathrm{b}}3.566
{211}⟨111⟩\{211\}\langle111\rangle1.813a1.813^{\mathrm{a}}1.8860.844b0.844^{\mathrm{b}}; 1.000c1.000^{\mathrm{c}}0.907

Table 4. Generalized stacking fault energy barriers for representative BCC slip systems in W and Ta.

Generalized stacking fault energy curves for representative BCC slip systems in W and Ta

Figure 7. Generalized stacking fault energy curves for representative BCC slip systems in W and Ta along the (a) {110}⟨111⟩\{110\}\langle111\rangle (b) {112}⟨111⟩\{112\}\langle111\rangle. The DFT data are taken from Ref. [67].

Transformation Paths

Transformation pathways were used to assess whether the GRACE potential reproduces the energetic response of W and Ta as their BCC structures are distorted along trigonal, tetragonal, hexagonal, and orthorhombic paths. Prescribed homogeneous distortions were applied to periodic 6×6×66 \times6 \times6 cells, and the potential energy per atom was evaluated without atomic relaxation. The trigonal path varied the rhombohedral angle from 50∘50^\circ to 112∘112^\circ, while the tetragonal Bain path varied c/ac/a from 0.80.8 to 1.81.8 at constant volume. The hexagonal Burgers-like path transformed BCC toward HCP through coupled lattice distortion and atomic-layer shuffle, parameterized by λ=0\lambda= 0 to 11. The orthorhombic path varied c/ac/a from 1/21/\sqrt{2} to 2\sqrt{2} at constant volume, connecting two symmetry-equivalent BCC variants through a body-centered tetragonal configuration. The resulting GRACE energies were compared with DFT reference calculations performed in this work. As shown in Figure 8, GRACE agrees well with DFT for both W and Ta across all transformation paths.

Relative energy per atom along homogeneous transformation paths for W and Ta

Figure 8. Relative energy per atom, ΔE\Delta E, along homogeneous transformation paths for W and Ta: (a,b) trigonal, (c,d) tetragonal, (e,f) orthorhombic, and (g,h) hexagonal deformation paths. GRACE predictions are compared with DFT calculations performed in this work.

Vacancy Migration Energy

Vacancy migration barriers were calculated using NEB for a nearest-neighbor a0/2⟨111⟩a_0/2\langle111\rangle vacancy hop in periodic 6×6×66 \times6 \times6 BCC supercells. The relaxed endpoints were connected by 21 replicas and optimized using the quick-min algorithm with a spring constant of 1.0 and a force tolerance of 10−8 eV/A˚10^{-8}\,\mathrm{eV}/\mathring{\mathrm{A}}. The barrier was taken as the maximum energy relative to the initial state. As shown in Figure 9, GRACE predicts barriers of approximately 1.8 eV for W and 0.65 eV for Ta, compared with DFT values of about 1.7 eV and 0.65 eV, respectively.

Vacancy migration energy profiles for BCC W and Ta from GRACE and DFT

Figure 9. Vacancy migration energy profiles for BCC W and Ta from GRACE and DFT. W has a higher migration barrier of about 1.7–1.8 eV, while Ta has a lower barrier of about 0.65 eV.

Di-Vacancy Binding Energy

The di-vacancy binding energy was calculated for vacancy pairs in the first through fifth nearest-neighbor shells of BCC W. A periodic 5×5×55 \times5 \times5 conventional BCC supercell was used, and the equilibrium lattice parameter was first obtained by relaxing the bulk cell. Single- and di-vacancy structures were then relaxed using conjugate-gradient minimization with anisotropic zero-pressure box relaxation. All symmetry-equivalent vacancy-pair configurations within each neighbor shell were evaluated, and the binding energy was calculated as Eb=2Evac−Edi−vac−EbulkE_\mathrm{b} = 2E_\mathrm{vac} - E_\mathrm{di-vac} - E_\mathrm{bulk}, where positive values indicate attractive binding. GRACE was compared with DFT data from Ref. [69] and the experimental 1NN value from Ref. [70]. The 4NN and 5NN DFT results should be interpreted cautiously because they were obtained using a relatively small 5×5×55 \times5 \times5 supercell [69]. As shown in Figure 10, GRACE captures the main DFT trend, including the repulsive 2NN interaction, weak long-range binding, and an attractive 1NN interaction, although its magnitude is underestimated relative to experiment. We also note that different DFT studies report significantly varying values [69], potentially indicating subtle electronic effects.

Di-vacancy binding energy in BCC W as a function of vacancy-pair nearest-neighbor separation

Figure 10. Di-vacancy binding energy in BCC W as a function of vacancy-pair nearest-neighbor separation. GRACE predictions are compared with DFT data from Ref. [69] and the experimental 1NN value from Ref. [70].

Atomic String Displacement Curves

The atomic string-displacement model was used to probe the local energy response associated with 1/2⟨111⟩1/2\langle111\rangle screw dislocations in BCC W and Ta, following Gilbert and Dudarev [71, 72]. Periodic 4×4×44 \times4 \times4 cells were oriented with z∥[111]z \parallel[111], and the equilibrium structure was first relaxed to zero pressure using conjugate-gradient minimization. Three displacement modes were considered: a single [111] atomic string, two neighboring strings displaced together, and two neighboring strings displaced in opposite directions to produce shear. For each mode, the selected strings were rigidly displaced along [111]\left[111\right] over one Burgers-vector magnitude, b=a03/2b = a_0\sqrt{3}/2, using 41 equally spaced increments, while all remaining atoms were kept fixed and no relaxation was performed after displacement. The energy at each increment was evaluated relative to the relaxed reference configuration.

As shown in Figure 11, GRACE agrees extremely well with the DFT calculations for both W and Ta. The single-string barriers are approximately 2 eV/bb for W and 1 eV/bb for Ta, while the two-string collective barriers increase to about 3.5–3.7 eV/bb and 1.8–2.0 eV/bb, respectively. The shear mode produces large barriers and asymmetric energy profiles, matching the DFT predictions.

Atomic string-displacement energies for BCC W and Ta

Figure 11. Atomic string-displacement energies for BCC W and Ta from GRACE and DFT calculations from the present study. The panels show (a) single-string, (b) two-string collective, and (c) two-string shear displacements.

Differential Displacement Map

Differential displacement maps were used to characterize the 12⟨111⟩\frac{1}{2}\langle111\rangle screw-dislocation cores in BCC W and Ta using the atomman library [73]. Preconstructed reference and dislocated configurations were relaxed by conjugate-gradient minimization, with periodic boundaries along the dislocation line and shrink-wrapped boundaries in the transverse directions. Differential displacements were evaluated relative to the relaxed defect-free structure. As shown in Figure 12, GRACE predicts compact, localized, non-degenerate cores in both elements, with displacements concentrated near the core and rapidly decaying into the surrounding lattice.

Differential displacement maps of the 1/2⟨111⟩ screw-dislocation core in W and Ta

Figure 12. Differential displacement maps of the 12⟨111⟩\frac{1}{2}\langle111\rangle screw-dislocation core in (a) W and (b) Ta predicted using GRACE. Both elements exhibit compact, localized, non-degenerate screw cores, consistent with the expected BCC transition-metal core structure.

Peierls Energy

The Peierls barrier was calculated for 12⟨111⟩\frac{1}{2}\langle111\rangle screw-dislocation glide in BCC W and Ta using periodic dislocation dipoles generated with the atomman library [73]. Two neighboring easy-core configurations were constructed on the {110}\{110\} slip plane, relaxed to zero pressure, and connected by a 21-replica NEB calculation. The replicas were optimized using the FIRE algorithm. As shown in Figure 13, GRACE captures the overall barrier shape and symmetry for both elements. For W, the predicted barrier follows the lower DFT reference, while for Ta it lies within the range of reported DFT values. Since the double-kink formation energy scales linearly with the square root of the Peierls barrier [72, 74], this agreement is important for describing thermally activated screw-dislocation motion.

Normalized Peierls energy barrier for W and Ta

Figure 13. Normalized Peierls energy barrier, EP/bE_{\mathrm{P}}/b, as a function of reaction coordinate for 12⟨111⟩\frac{1}{2}\langle111\rangle screw-dislocation in (a) W and (b) Ta. GRACE predictions are compared with DFT data for W [72] and Ta [68, 75].

Binary Validation

Lattice Constant

The composition-dependent lattice constant was evaluated for random BCC W–Ta solid solutions using periodic 6×6×66 \times6 \times6 supercells. Fifteen compositions spanning the full range from pure W to pure Ta were generated by randomly assigning Ta atoms to BCC lattice sites using a fixed seed. Each structure was initialized using the Vegard-law lattice constant and relaxed by conjugate-gradient minimization with anisotropic zero-pressure box relaxation. The equilibrium lattice constant was obtained from the relaxed cell length, while the pure W and Ta endpoints were calculated independently using the same procedure.

Figure 14 compares the lattice constant as a function of W concentration, xWx_{\mathrm{W}}, predicted by GRACE, EAM [29], GEAM [30], CPA [27], and experiment [76]. The lattice constant decreases monotonically with increasing W content, consistent with the smaller equilibrium lattice constant of BCC W. GRACE remains close to the CPA and experimental data across the full composition range, whereas EAM underestimates the lattice constant at intermediate compositions.

Composition-dependent lattice constant of BCC W–Ta alloys

Figure 14. Composition-dependent lattice constant of BCC W–Ta alloys. (a) Lattice constant, aa, as a function of W concentration, xWx_{\mathrm{W}}, compared with Vegard’s law. (b) Departure from Vegard’s law, Δa\Delta a. GRACE captures the monotonic decrease in lattice constant with increasing W content and predicts a modest negative deviation from Vegard’s law, in closer agreement with CPA [27] and experiment [76] than EAM [29].

The deviation from Vegard’s law, Δa\Delta a, shown in Figure 14(b), indicates a very weak negative bowing. GRACE reproduces this slight contraction relative to ideal linear mixing, in qualitative agreement with CPA and experiment, although the deviation is somewhat larger near intermediate compositions.

Elastic Constants and Bulk Modulus

Elastic constants and the bulk modulus were evaluated for random BCC W–Ta alloys using periodic 6×6×66 \times6 \times6 supercells at 15 compositions. Each structure was initialized from Vegard’s law, randomly populated, and relaxed to zero pressure. The elastic tensor was obtained from central finite differences of the stress response to axial and shear strains of ±5×10−4\pm5 \times10^{-4} without post-strain atomic relaxation. Cubic projection yielded C11C_{11}, C12C_{12}, and C44C_{44}, with B=(C11+2C12)/3B = (C_{11} + 2C_{12})/3.

Figure 15 compares GRACE, EAM [29], and GEAM [30] predictions with DFT [77] data as a function of W concentration, xWx_{\mathrm{W}}. GRACE captures the main DFT trends: C11C_{11} and C44C_{44} increase with W content, while C12C_{12} varies more weakly. The bulk modulus also increases monotonically with W concentration, and GRACE follows the DFT trend more closely than EAM, which overestimates it over much of the composition range.

Elastic constants and bulk modulus of BCC W–Ta alloys

Figure 15. Elastic constants and bulk modulus of BCC W–Ta alloys as a function of W concentration, xWx_{\mathrm{W}}. (a) Elastic constants C11C_{11}, C12C_{12}, and C44C_{44} predicted by GRACE, EAM [29], and GEAM [30] compared with DFT [77] data. (b) Bulk modulus predicted by the same models and compared with DFT [77].

Point Defect Energetics in W–Ta

The energetics of Ta-related point defects in bcc W were evaluated to assess the ability of GRACE to describe solute–defect interactions relevant to radiation damage and microstructural evolution. The calculated formation and binding energies are summarized in Table 5.

PropertyDFTGRACEEAMGEAM
EsubfE_{\mathrm{sub}}^{\mathrm{f}}(Ta)−0.45a,b-0.45^{a,b}, −0.47c,d,e-0.47^{c,d,e}−0.44-0.44−0.47-0.47−0.48-0.48
E1nnbE_{\mathrm{1nn}}^{\mathrm{b}}(Ta–Ta)−0.09a-0.09^{a}, −0.08b-0.08^{b}−0.08-0.08−0.13-0.13−0.12-0.12
E2nnbE_{\mathrm{2nn}}^{\mathrm{b}}(Ta–Ta)−0.04a-0.04^{a}, −0.02b-0.02^{b}−0.03-0.03−0.02-0.02−0.05-0.05
E1nnbE_{\mathrm{1nn}}^{\mathrm{b}}(Ta–Vac)−0.04a,f-0.04^{a,f}, −0.05b-0.05^{b}−0.01-0.01−0.06-0.060.030.03
E2nnbE_{\mathrm{2nn}}^{\mathrm{b}}(Ta–Vac)−0.21a,b-0.21^{a,b}, −0.20f-0.20^{f}−0.12-0.12−0.03-0.03−0.10-0.10
E⟨111⟩bE_{\langle111\rangle}^{\mathrm{b}}(Ta–SIA)−0.64c,e-0.64^{c,e}, −0.57b-0.57^{b}−0.44-0.44−0.59-0.59−0.05-0.05
E⟨111⟩fE_{\langle111\rangle}^{\mathrm{f}}(W–Ta)10.38c10.38^{c}, 10.01e10.01^{e}10.3910.399.699.699.159.15
E⟨110⟩fE_{\langle110\rangle}^{\mathrm{f}}(W–Ta)10.93c10.93^{c}, 10.45e10.45^{e}11.1411.149.759.7510.1810.18
E⟨100⟩fE_{\langle100\rangle}^{\mathrm{f}}(W–Ta)11.36c11.36^{c}11.5311.5310.5610.5610.7810.78

Table 5. Energetics of Ta point defects in bcc W from DFT calculations compared with GRACE, EAM [29], and GEAM [30]. All energies are in eV.

The formation energy of a substitutional Ta atom in BCC W was calculated as Esubf(Ta)=ETa;sub−EW+μW−μTaE_{\mathrm{sub}}^{\mathrm{f}}(\mathrm{Ta}) = E_{\mathrm{Ta;sub}} - E_{\mathrm{W}} + \mu_{\mathrm{W}} - \mu_{\mathrm{Ta}}, where EWE_{\mathrm{W}} is the energy of the perfect W supercell and μW\mu_{\mathrm{W}} and μTa\mu_{\mathrm{Ta}} are the elemental chemical potentials. GRACE predicts Esubf=−0.44E_{\mathrm{sub}}^{\mathrm{f}} = -0.44 eV, in close agreement with the reported DFT range of approximately −0.45-0.45 to −0.47-0.47 eV. The negative value indicates that substitutional Ta is thermodynamically favored in the W matrix relative to the selected elemental reference states.

With the binding-energy convention used here, positive values indicate attractive interactions, whereas negative values indicate repulsive interactions. Ta–Ta interactions were quantified using ETa−Tab=2Esubf−E2TafE_{\mathrm{Ta-Ta}}^{\mathrm{b}} = 2E_{\mathrm{sub}}^{\mathrm{f}} - E_{\mathrm{2Ta}}^{\mathrm{f}}, where E2TafE_{\mathrm{2Ta}}^{\mathrm{f}} is the formation energy of a supercell containing two substitutional Ta atoms. GRACE predicts binding energies of −0.08-0.08 and −0.03-0.03 eV for first- and second-nearest-neighbor pairs, respectively, consistent with the corresponding DFT ranges of approximately −0.08-0.08 to −0.09-0.09 eV and −0.02-0.02 to −0.04-0.04 eV. GRACE therefore reproduces both the weak interaction strength and its decay with separation.

The Ta–vacancy binding energy was calculated as ETa−Vacb=ETa;sub+EVac−ETa−Vac−EWE^{\mathrm{b}}_{\mathrm{Ta-Vac}} = E_{\mathrm{Ta;sub}} + E_{\mathrm{Vac}} - E_{\mathrm{Ta-Vac}} - E_{\mathrm{W}}. GRACE predicts values of −0.01 and −0.12 eV for the 1NN and 2NN configurations, respectively. The 1NN result is close to the DFT range of approximately −0.04 to −0.05 eV, whereas the 2NN interaction is weaker than the reported DFT range of approximately −0.20 to −0.21 eV. GRACE correctly predicts stronger repulsion at 2NN than at 1NN, but underestimates its values at both separations.

The Ta–self-interstitial interaction was evaluated using ETa−SIAb=ETa;sub+ESIA−ETa−SIA−EWE^{\mathrm{b}}_{\mathrm{Ta-SIA}} = E_{\mathrm{Ta;sub}} + E_{\mathrm{SIA}} - E_{\mathrm{Ta-SIA}} - E_{\mathrm{W}}. For the ⟨111⟩\langle111\rangle configuration, GRACE predicts a binding energy of −0.44 eV, compared with DFT values of approximately −0.57 to −0.64 eV. Thus, GRACE reproduces the repulsive character of the Ta–SIA interaction but underestimates its magnitude.

Mixed W–Ta dumbbell formation energies were calculated as EW−Taf=Edefect−nWμW−nTaμTaE^{\mathrm{f}}_{\mathrm{W-Ta}} = E_{\mathrm{defect}} - n_{\mathrm{W}}\mu_{\mathrm{W}} - n_{\mathrm{Ta}}\mu_{\mathrm{Ta}}, where EdefectE_{\mathrm{defect}} is the relaxed defect energy. GRACE predicts formation energies of 10.39, 11.14, and 11.53 eV for the ⟨111⟩\langle111\rangle, ⟨110⟩\langle110\rangle, and ⟨100⟩\langle100\rangle dumbbells, respectively. These values reproduce the DFT stability sequence ⟨111⟩<⟨110⟩<⟨100⟩\langle111\rangle< \langle110\rangle< \langle100\rangle, identifying the ⟨111⟩\langle111\rangle dumbbell as the most stable mixed-interstitial configuration.

Ta Cluster Binding Energy

The binding energy of Ta clusters was calculated to examine whether GRACE captures the tendency of Ta atoms to cluster in BCC W. For each cluster size, several compact Ta arrangements were relaxed, and the lowest-energy structure was used.

For clusters containing only Ta atoms, the binding energy was calculated as Eb(Tan)=nEsol−E(Tan)−(n−1)EWE_{\mathrm{b}}(\mathrm{Ta}_{n}) = nE_{\mathrm{sol}} - E(\mathrm{Ta}_{n}) - (n - 1)E_{\mathrm{W}}, where EsolE_{\mathrm{sol}} is the energy of a W supercell with one substitutional Ta atom, E(Tan)E(\mathrm{Ta}_{n}) is the energy of the supercell containing a Ta cluster of size nn, and EWE_{\mathrm{W}} is the energy of the pure W supercell. For vacancy-assisted clusters, the binding energy was calculated as Eb(VacTan)=Evac+nEsol−E(VacTan)−nEWE_{\mathrm{b}}(\mathrm{VacTa}_{n}) = E_{\mathrm{vac}} + nE_{\mathrm{sol}} - E(\mathrm{VacTa}_{n}) - nE_{\mathrm{W}}, where EvacE_{\mathrm{vac}} is the energy of a W supercell containing one vacancy.

Figure 16 compares GRACE with EAM [29] and available DFT data [78]. For both pure Ta clusters and vacancy-assisted clusters, the binding energies are negative and become more negative with increasing cluster size. With this sign convention, larger Ta clusters are less favorable. GRACE captures the overall DFT trend, although it predicts less negative binding energies, especially for larger clusters. Thus, GRACE slightly underestimates the strength of Ta–Ta and vacancy–Ta interactions, but correctly shows that Ta clustering in W is not favored. This agrees with previous calculations and irradiation experiments, which reported no clear Ta precipitation or clustering in W–Ta alloys [83].

Binding energies of pure Ta clusters and vacancy-assisted Ta clusters

Figure 16. Binding energies of (a) pure Ta clusters and (b) vacancy-assisted Ta clusters in BCC W for GRACE, EAM [29], and DFT [78].

Enthalpy of Mixing of the W–Ta Binary Alloy

The enthalpy of mixing of the W–Ta binary alloy was evaluated as a function of composition to assess whether the GRACE potential captures the thermodynamic tendency for alloy formation. For each composition, random substitutional BCC W–Ta alloy configurations were generated in a 10×10×1010 \times10 \times10 BCC supercell containing 2000 atoms. Ten independent configurations were generated using different random seeds, and each configuration was minimized with anisotropic box relaxation. The mixing enthalpy was computed as

ΔHmix=EWTa−[xTaETa+(1−xTa)EW]\Delta H_{\mathrm{mix}} = E_{\mathrm{WTa}} - [x_{\mathrm{Ta}}E_{\mathrm{Ta}} + (1 - x_{\mathrm{Ta}})E_{\mathrm{W}}], where EWTaE_{\mathrm{WTa}} is the relaxed alloy energy per atom, and EWE_{\mathrm{W}} and ETaE_{\mathrm{Ta}} are the relaxed energies per atom of pure BCC W and BCC Ta calculated using the same potential. For each composition, the reported value corresponds to the lowest relaxed ΔHmix\Delta H_{\mathrm{mix}} among the ten random configurations.

As shown in Figure 17, the reference data predict negative mixing enthalpies across most of the composition range, indicating that W–Ta alloy formation is energetically favorable relative to the pure BCC elements. The GRACE potential reproduces the composition dependence, including the negative values of the mixing enthalpy, ΔHmix\Delta H_{\mathrm{mix}}, the approach to zero near the pure W and Ta limits, and the minimum near intermediate W concentrations. GRACE agrees closely with the Cluster Expansion (CE) [26] and experimental [38] results over much of the composition range, whereas the EAM potential predicts a substantially deeper minimum.

Enthalpy of mixing of the W–Ta binary alloy as a function of W concentration

Figure 17. Enthalpy of mixing, ΔHmix\Delta H_{\mathrm{mix}}, of the W–Ta binary alloy as a function of W concentration, xWx_{\mathrm{W}}. GRACE predictions are compared with experimental data [38], cluster expansion (CE) [26], GEAM [30], and EAM [29] results.

Stable Ordered Structures from Convex-Hull Analysis

The thermodynamic stability of ordered W–Ta compounds was evaluated using a convex-hull analysis of the mixing enthalpy, as shown in Figure 18. Structures lying on the convex hull represent zero-temperature ground states, whereas structures above the hull are unstable with respect to decomposition into neighboring stable phases.

Convex hull of the W–Ta mixing enthalpy as a function of W concentration

Figure 18. Convex hull of the W–Ta mixing enthalpy, ΔHmix\Delta H_{\mathrm{mix}}, as a function of W concentration, xWx_{\mathrm{W}}. Solid lines indicate the corresponding lower convex hulls. Structures on the hull are stable ground states, whereas the smaller, semi-transparent symbols above the hull represent metastable structures. The dashed line marks ΔHmix=0\Delta H_{\mathrm{mix}} = 0.

Although the experimental W–Ta phase diagram indicates complete high-temperature solid solubility without stable intermetallic compounds, first-principles studies have reported conflicting predictions for the low-temperature ground states. Calculations [27] predicted ordered B2_2 and DO3_3 phases, while cluster-expansion studies identified different stable structures, including C11b [38] and W5_5Ta3_3 [26].

The candidate structures used for the convex-hull construction were taken from the Open Quantum Materials Database (OQMD) [37], previous DFT calculations for the W–Ta system [26], and randomly generated intermetallic compounds. The calculated convex hull exhibits several stable intermediate compositions between the pure Ta and pure W, with the lowest mixing enthalpies occurring near W2_2Ta compositions. In Figure 18, the DFT1 data correspond to the present DFT calculations performed for the same set of structures used in the GRACE convex-hull exploration. The DFT2 data are taken from Ref. [26]. For direct comparison, the same structural set was also evaluated using the EAM and GEAM potentials to construct the corresponding convex hulls.

GRACE reproduces the shape of the DFT convex hull and predicts stable ordered structures across the composition range, consistent with the favorable alloying tendency of the W–Ta system. Notably, GRACE also provides accurate predictions in the W-rich, low-Ta concentration regime. This regime is particularly important for modeling the microstructural evolution of W–Ta alloys considered for plasma-facing component applications, where small Ta additions can influence defect behavior, phase stability, and irradiation response.

Melting Temperature

The W–Ta phase diagram has a lens-shaped form with a narrow solidus–liquidus gap [84], making the individual phase boundaries difficult to resolve directly using atomistic simulations. Therefore, the solid–liquid coexistence temperature at each composition was used as a practical estimate of the melting behavior.

Random BCC W–Ta solid solutions were constructed in 6×6×506 \times6 \times50 supercells with periodic boundary conditions. Each structure was equilibrated near an estimated melting temperature, T0T_0, for 1 ns under zero-pressure NPT conditions. An interior slab was then melted at 5000 K for 100 ps while the surrounding solid was fixed. The full system was subsequently evolved for 10 ns in the NPH ensemble with pressure control applied along the zz direction. The stabilized average temperature was taken as the melting temperature; calculations that fully melted or crystallized were repeated using an updated T0T_0.

As shown in Figure 19, GRACE predicts a monotonic increase in melting temperature with increasing W concentration. Although it underestimates the experimental values [53] by less than 10%, its predictions are closer to the DFT melting temperatures of the pure elements [54, 55] and reproduce the overall composition dependence. GEAM shows closer agreement with experiment [53], whereas EAM substantially overestimates the melting temperature, particularly in the W-rich region.

Melting temperature of the W–Ta binary system as a function of W concentration, $x_{\mathrm{W}}$

Figure 19. Melting temperature of the W–Ta binary system as a function of W concentration, xWx_{\mathrm{W}}.

GRACE Application: Effects of Ta Segregation on Grain-Boundary Pinning in W

Motivation

During high-temperature exposure and mechanical loading, W undergoes recovery, recrystallization, and grain growth, gradually losing the strengthened microstructure produced by deformation. GB chemistry can strongly affect this evolution because GBs control the growth of recrystallized grains. Experiments on nanocrystalline W alloys have shown that solute additions can suppress abnormal grain growth and improve microstructural stability, although the degree of stabilization depends strongly on how the solute is distributed along the GBs [85]. In W–Ta alloys containing approximately 1–5% Ta, Ta additions have been reported to increase the recrystallization temperature, limit grain coarsening, and improve strength retention during high-temperature annealing [5].

GBs also play important roles in intergranular fracture, irradiation-defect absorption, and high-temperature deformation in W-based alloys. Under applied shear or other driving forces, GBs can respond through coupled migration [86], sliding [87], or intermittent stick–slip motion [88]. During stick–slip motion, the boundary remains temporarily pinned while elastic strain builds up, followed by a rapid displacement that releases the stored stress. This displacement may occur through the motion of disconnections, GB dislocations, twinning partials, or coordinated atomic rearrangements. The dominant mechanism depends strongly on the GB structure. For example, stick–slip has been linked to the nucleation of twinning partials in Cu [89], the climb of GB dislocations in SiC [90], and the interruption of ordered atomic rearrangements near coincidence-site-lattice atoms in Ni [91]. GB chemistry can further change whether a boundary migrates, slides, or remains pinned by altering the energy required for each process [92]. Solute segregation has been shown to locally pin Ni–Cu GBs [93] and to hinder migration while promoting sliding in refractory MoNbTa alloys [94]. These findings suggest that alloying can affect not only the overall GB mobility but also where and how strongly a boundary becomes locally pinned.

Despite these observations, the atomic-scale behavior of Ta at W GBs remains poorly understood. First-principles calculations supported by transmission electron microscopy showed that Ta has little tendency to segregate to the investigated low-angle W GBs, but has a modest preference for selected sites within highangle GB cores. This result demonstrates that Ta segregation depends strongly on GB character and local atomic structure [95]. More recent experimental and atomistic studies of sputtered W–10 at.% Ta found that Ta remained primarily distributed as a solid solution rather than forming the solute-rich clusters observed for other alloying elements [96]. The influence of Ta on recrystallization, grain growth, and GB deformation in W therefore cannot be described solely by the nominal alloy concentration. It must also account for GB character, temperature, finite-composition effects, and the occupation of specific GB sites. In particular, it remains unclear how Ta segregation changes local pinning and stick–slip de-pinning in W. The present work therefore investigates finite-temperature Ta segregation at a Σ5(120)\Sigma5(120) symmetric-tilt W GB and determines how the resulting site-specific solute distributions affect GB migration and de-pinning.

Simulation Setup

A Σ5(120)\Sigma5(120) symmetric-tilt GB was generated using the GRand canonical Interface Predictor (GRIP) method [97] with an embedded-atom method (EAM) potential [98]. Multiple microscopic GB configurations were sampled by varying the interfacial atomic density and the relative translation between the adjoining grains. The configuration with the lowest GB energy was selected for all subsequent simulations, as illustrated in Figure 20(a).

Simulation workflow for constructing, equilibrating, and shearing the W–Ta GB

Figure 20. Simulation workflow used to construct, equilibrate, and shear the W–Ta Σ5(120)\Sigma5(120) symmetric-tilt GB. (a) Minimum-energy pure-W GB configuration obtained using the GRIP method. BCC and non-BCC W atoms are shown in gray and white, respectively. (b) Ta atoms are randomly introduced at the prescribed nominal composition, followed by chemical and structural equilibration using hybrid MC/MD simulations. W and Ta atoms are shown in blue and red, respectively. (c) Shear-loading configuration used to drive GB migration. The lower terminal slab is fixed, the upper slab is translated parallel to the GB plane at 1 m/s, and the atoms in the intervening region remain fully mobile and equilibrated at the target temperature.

The minimum-energy GB structure was initially constructed in pure W and subsequently populated with randomly distributed Ta atoms to obtain nominal compositions of 0, 1, 5, 10, 15, 20 at.% Ta. Chemical and structural equilibration was performed over the temperature range 500–3000 K using hybrid Monte Carlo/Molecular Dynamics (MC/MD) simulations [99] with the newly developed W–Ta GRACE potential, see Figure 20(b). The systems were maintained at zero pressure using an anisotropic isothermal–isobaric ensemble and integrated with a timestep of 1 fs under periodic boundary conditions in all directions. Composition-conserving W–Ta identity-swap attempts were performed every 100 MD steps while maintaining the prescribed global Ta concentration. Each system was initially equilibrated for 2,000,000 MD steps, corresponding to 2 ns. The equilibrated structure was then replicated to produce a simulation cell with approximate dimensions of 15×25×10 nm315 \times25 \times10\ \mathrm{nm}^{3} and equilibrated for an additional 2 ns at the same temperature and composition.

Following equilibration, periodic boundary conditions were retained along the two directions parallel to the GB plane, whereas the boundary condition along the GB-normal direction was changed to non-periodic. Two terminal slabs, each approximately 1 nm thick, were defined at the upper and lower ends of the simulation cell. The lower slab was held fixed, while the upper slab was translated rigidly parallel to the GB plane at a constant velocity of 1 m/s, as shown in Figure 20(c). Atoms between the terminal slabs remained fully mobile and were maintained at the target temperature in the canonical ensemble. This loading configuration imposed shear across the bicrystal and drove shear-coupled GB migration.

Quantification Metrics

In this study, the influence of Ta on the initial pinning of the W GB was characterized using both global and atomic row-resolved segregation metrics. Here, an atomic row refers to a line of atoms along the [100] crystallographic direction. The average Ta concentration within the GB region, cTaGBc_{\mathrm{Ta}}^{\mathrm{GB}}, was monitored, and the segregation excess was defined as Γseg=cTaGB−cTabulk\Gamma_{\mathrm{seg}} = c_{\mathrm{Ta}}^{\mathrm{GB}} - c_{\mathrm{Ta}}^{\mathrm{bulk}}, where cTabulkc_{\mathrm{Ta}}^{\mathrm{bulk}} is the Ta concentration in the surrounding bulk solid solution. Concentration profiles normal to the GB were used to determine the spatial extent of Ta enrichment as functions of temperature and nominal composition. Because the GB contains crystallographically distinct atomic rows, the Ta occupancy of each row was also evaluated separately. This row-resolved analysis captures the highly nonuniform segregation state, including the preferential saturation of specific rows, which cannot be represented adequately by the average GB concentration alone.

The imposed grain translation was calculated from the simulation timestep and the prescribed shear velocity as (d=vshearNΔt)(d = v_{\mathrm{shear}}N\Delta t), where NN is the timestep index and Δt\Delta t is the MD timestep. The corresponding shear stress, (σyz)(\sigma_{yz}), was obtained from the global atomic virial stress. The first maximum in (σyz)(\sigma_{yz}) preceding the onset of GB migration was defined as the de-pinning stress. This quantity represents the initial stress required to overcome the resistance produced by the Ta segregation at the boundary and initiate motion of the GB away from its pinned configuration.

Simulation Results

Ta Segregation

Ta segregation to the Σ5(120)\Sigma5(120) tilt GB was examined over temperatures ranging from 500 to 3000 K and nominal Ta concentrations ranging from 1 to 20 at.%. The equilibrium segregation excess was calculated as Γseg=cTaGB−cTabulk\Gamma_{\mathrm{seg}} = c_{\mathrm{Ta}}^{\mathrm{GB}} - c_{\mathrm{Ta}}^{\mathrm{bulk}}, where cTaGBc_{\mathrm{Ta}}^{\mathrm{GB}} and cTabulkc_{\mathrm{Ta}}^{\mathrm{bulk}} are the equilibrium Ta concentrations within the GB region, defined with 1.5 nm width, and the adjoining bulk grains, respectively. A positive value of Γseg\Gamma_{\mathrm{seg}} therefore indicates preferential Ta enrichment at the GB.

Figure 21(a) shows that the segregation excess decreases monotonically with increasing temperature for all nominal Ta concentrations. This behavior is expected and indicates that thermal fluctuations progressively weaken the preferential occupation of GB sites by Ta. The temperature dependence is particularly pronounced at low nominal concentration: for the 1 at.% system, Γseg\Gamma_{\mathrm{seg}} approaches zero at the highest temperatures considered. In contrast, systems with higher nominal Ta concentrations retain a measurable segregation excess over the entire temperature range. At a fixed temperature, Γseg\Gamma_{\mathrm{seg}} increases with nominal Ta concentration, as shown in Figure 21(b). Thus, although elevated temperatures reduce segregation, increasing the available Ta concentration promotes continued enrichment of the GB.

Equilibrium Ta segregation at the $\Sigma 5(120)$ tilt GB

Figure 21. Equilibrium Ta segregation at the Σ5(120)\Sigma5(120) tilt GB. (a) Equilibrium segregation excess, Γseg=cTaGB−cTabulk\Gamma_{\mathrm{seg}} = c_{\mathrm{Ta}}^{\mathrm{GB}} - c_{\mathrm{Ta}}^{\mathrm{bulk}}, as a function of temperature for different nominal Ta concentrations. (b) Equilibrium segregation excess as a function of nominal Ta concentration at temperatures between 500 and 3000 K. The horizontal dashed line denotes the condition of no preferential segregation, Γseg=0\Gamma_{\mathrm{seg}} = 0.

Although Γseg\Gamma_{\mathrm{seg}} quantifies the degree of partitioning between the GB and bulk regions, the present study focuses primarily on the first GB de-pinning event. The onset of de-pinning is governed most directly by the local chemical and structural state of the boundary, particularly the number and spatial distribution of Ta atoms occupying the GB sites. The bulk composition acts as the Ta reservoir, but it has a less direct influence on the initial de-pinning event than the instantaneous Ta concentration within the GB. Consequently, the following analysis emphasizes cTaGBc_{\mathrm{Ta}}^{\mathrm{GB}} rather than the segregation excess alone.

As shown in Figure 22(a), the equilibrium GB concentration increases approximately linearly with nominal Ta concentration at both 500 and 1000 K. In every case, cTaGBc_{\mathrm{Ta}}^{\mathrm{GB}} lies above the no-segregation reference dashed line, confirming that the GB is enriched in Ta relative to the overall alloy composition. The enrichment is slightly greater at 500 K than at 1000 K, consistent with the temperature dependence of Γseg\Gamma_{\mathrm{seg}} in Figure 21. However, the atomistic configurations in Figure 22(b) demonstrate that the segregated Ta atoms are not distributed uniformly throughout the boundary. Instead, Ta preferentially occupies a subset of the available GB sites, producing a spatially heterogeneous solute distribution.

Ta enrichment and spatial distribution within the Σ5(120) GB

Figure 22. Ta enrichment and spatial distribution within the Σ5(120)\Sigma5(120) GB. (a) Equilibrium GB Ta concentration, cTaGBc_{\mathrm{Ta}}^{\mathrm{GB}}, as a function of nominal Ta concentration at 500 and 1000 K. The dashed line represents cTaGB=cTa0c_{\mathrm{Ta}}^{\mathrm{GB}} = c_{\mathrm{Ta}}^{0} and therefore corresponds to the absence of GB enrichment. (b) Representative atomistic configurations illustrating the distribution of Ta atoms within the GB at nominal concentrations of 1, 5, 10, and 15 at.%. BCC atoms, non-BCC GB atoms, and Ta atoms are shown in gray, white, and red, respectively.

To resolve the spatial heterogeneity of Ta segregation, the GB core was decomposed into the seven structurally distinct atomic rows shown in Figure 23(a). For each row, the mean Voronoi volume was calculated by averaging the Voronoi volumes of all atoms assigned to that row using OVITO’s Voronoi analysis modifier [100]. The rows in Figure 23(a) are colored according to their Voronoi volume, with blue and red representing relatively small and large local atomic volumes, respectively. The same color assignment is used for the corresponding row-resolved segregation curves in Figure 23(b)–Figure 23(d).

Figure 23. Row-resolved Ta segregation within the Σ5(120)\Sigma5(120) tilt GB. (a) Atomistic representation of the GB structural unit showing the seven distinct atomic rows. Each row is colored according to its atomic Voronoi volume, with blue and red corresponding to smaller and larger volumes, respectively. The color scale spans approximately 16–18 A˚3\mathring{\mathrm{A}}^3/atom. (b–d) Equilibrium Ta concentration within each row as a function of nominal Ta concentration at (b) 500 K, (c) 1000 K, and (d) 1500 K. The curve colors correspond to the mean Voronoi-volume colors assigned in panel (a), and the dashed line denotes equality between the row and nominal Ta concentrations.

The results reveal a strongly site-selective and sequential segregation process. Row 1, which has the largest Voronoi volume among the identified GB rows, exhibits the strongest Ta enrichment at all temperatures. At 500 K, its Ta concentration is already approximately 60 at.% at a nominal concentration of 1 at.%, and it approaches complete occupation by approximately 5 at.% nominal Ta. Once this high-affinity row approaches saturation, additional Ta is increasingly accommodated by Row 5, which also possesses a relatively large Voronoi volume. Row 5 consequently shows a continuous increase in Ta concentration with increasing nominal alloy composition.

Row 7, which has a smaller mean Voronoi volume, displays substantially weaker enrichment than rows 1 and 5, although its occupation becomes appreciable at higher nominal Ta concentrations. Most other rows exhibit Ta concentrations near or below the nominal alloy concentration, particularly at 500 K. These observations suggest that Ta preferentially occupies GB rows with larger local atomic volumes, where the additional space may accommodate the solute with less local distortion.

The preference for high-volume rows persists at 1000 and 1500 K, but the magnitude of the site-specific enrichment decreases as temperature increases. At 1000 K, row 1 remains the dominant segregation site and approaches saturation at high nominal Ta concentration, while occupation of row 5 increases more gradually. At 1500 K, enrichment of row 1 remains pronounced, but complete saturation is not reached within the investigated composition range. The concentration differences among the lower-affinity rows also become less pronounced with increasing temperature because thermal fluctuations promote a broader distribution of Ta among the available GB sites.

Although Ta preferentially occupies rows with relatively large Voronoi volumes, the correlation is not strictly monotonic. The segregation preference also depends on the local coordination, distortion, and chemical environment. Moreover, complete saturation of one row may redistribute the GB excess volume and modify the local Voronoi volumes, thereby favoring sites that initially exhibited smaller Voronoi volumes in the pure-W GB. Thus, Voronoi volume is an important but composition-dependent descriptor of site-specific segregation.

Ta-Induced Pinning of W GB

The atomistic mechanism associated with the first GB de-pinning event is illustrated in Figure 24 for the system containing 5 at.% Ta at 500 K. The applied shear stress, σyz\sigma_{yz}, initially increases approximately linearly with grain translation and reaches a maximum of approximately 5 GPa. The atomic snapshots corresponding to selected points along the stress–translation curve show that GB migration does not occur through a spatially uniform translation of the entire interface. Instead, a localized disconnection first nucleates along the GB and subsequently propagates along the interface. The resulting motion produces two pronounced stress-release stages. The first stress drop corresponds to initial propagation of the disconnection and migration of the GB by ≈2\approx2 Å, whereas the subsequent drop accompanies further propagation and nearly complete detachment of the boundary from its initial configuration. Thus, the first maximum in σyz\sigma_{yz} is identified as the GB de-pinning stress associated with the nucleation and initial propagation of a disconnection.

Disconnection-mediated de-pinning of the GB containing 5 at.% Ta at 500 K

Figure 24. Disconnection-mediated de-pinning of the GB containing 5 at.% Ta at 500 K. (a) Applied shear stress, σyz\sigma_{yz}, as a function of grain translation. The first stress maximum, approximately 5 GPa, marks the onset of GB de-pinning. (b–g) Bottom-view atomic configurations at the locations indicated in panel (a), with atoms colored by their zz-position. The sequence shows localized disconnection nucleation, propagation along the GB, and the resulting two-stage stress release preceding nearly complete GB detachment.

The influence of Ta concentration and temperature on the de-pinning response is summarized in Figure 25. The configurations in Figure 25(a) and Figure 25(b) show the solute-decorated GB immediately before and after the first de-pinning event for the 1 at.% Ta system at 500 K. The non-BCC atoms identify the migrating GB region, whereas the Ta atoms remain essentially stationary as the GB detaches and migrates away from the segregated solute sites. Their interaction with the GB therefore increases the applied stress required to initiate migration.

Effects of Ta concentration and temperature on GB de-pinning

Figure 25. Effects of Ta concentration and temperature on GB de-pinning. (a,b) Atomic configurations of the 1 at.% Ta system at 500 K immediately before and after the first de-pinning event, respectively. BCC atoms are shown in gray, non-BCC GB atoms in white, and Ta atoms in red. (c–e) Applied shear stress, σyz\sigma_{yz}, as a function of grain translation for different Ta concentrations at 500, 1000, and 1500 K, respectively. (f–h) Stress–translation curves grouped by temperature for systems containing 1, 5, and 10 at.% Ta, respectively.

At 500 K, even the addition of 1 at.% Ta produces a noticeable increase in the first de-pinning stress relative to pure W. The de-pinning stress increases further between 1 and 5 at.% Ta, but changes only weakly between approximately 5 and 15 at.% Ta. This plateau indicates that the dominant segregation configurations controlling the first de-pinning event become nearly saturated. Once these high-impact sites or rows are occupied, additional Ta atoms are distributed among less influential GB sites and produce only a limited additional increase in the de-pinning stress. A similar, although weaker, concentration dependence is observed at 1000 K, whereas the effect of Ta concentration becomes substantially less pronounced at 1500 K.

Figure 25(f–Figure 25h) reorganize the same results by Ta concentration and demonstrate the strong influence of temperature. For each examined composition, the first peak in σyz\sigma_{yz} decreases as the temperature increases from 500 to 1500 K. This reduction is consistent with thermally assisted disconnection nucleation and propagation: increasing temperature enhances atomic fluctuations and reduces the mechanical stress required for the GB to escape from the segregated configuration. Ta segregation consequently produces its strongest pinning effect at 500 K, while thermal activation progressively weakens this effect at higher temperatures.

To distinguish the influence of the total GB composition from that of solute occupation at specific atomic rows, the first de-pinning stress was plotted against both the overall GB Ta concentration, cTaGBc_{\mathrm{Ta}}^{\mathrm{GB}}, and the Ta concentration within row 1, cTarow 1c_{\mathrm{Ta}}^{\mathrm{row\,1}}, as shown in Figure 26. At 500 K, the de-pinning stress initially increases with the overall GB Ta concentration and subsequently approaches a plateau. A corresponding relationship is obtained when the stress is plotted against the concentration of row 1. In particular, the de-pinning stress increases as row 1 becomes progressively occupied and changes only weakly once its Ta concentration approaches saturation. The correlation with the occupation of this individual row indicates that the first de-pinning event is controlled more directly by the local solute configuration than by the average GB concentration alone.

Relationship between Ta segregation, local stress redistribution, and GB de-pinning strength

Figure 26. Relationship between Ta segregation, local stress redistribution, and GB de-pinning strength. The first de-pinning stress is plotted as a function of (a) the overall GB Ta concentration, cTaGBc_{\mathrm{Ta}}^{\mathrm{GB}}, and (b) the Ta concentration within row 1, cTarow 1c_{\mathrm{Ta}}^{\mathrm{row\ 1}}. The increase and subsequent saturation of the peak stress correlate with progressive occupation of row 1. (c) Atomic configurations for nominal Ta concentrations of 1, 5, 10, and 15 at.%, with tracked GB-row atoms colored by the row-averaged normalized difference in σxx\sigma_{xx} relative to the pure-W peak configuration. The color scale ranges from approximately −2-2 to 20. The largest relative stress changes are localized on the segregation-rich row 1.

The local stress redistribution associated with this segregation was quantified by comparing the row-averaged σxx\sigma_{xx} component at the first stress peak of each Ta-containing system with the corresponding row-averaged value at the first peak of the pure-W reference system. For each physical row ss, the normalized difference was calculated as Δσˉxx(s)=(σˉxx,Ta(s)−σˉxx,0(s))/(σˉxx,0(s))\Delta\bar{\sigma}_{xx}^{(s)}=(\bar{\sigma}_{xx,\mathrm{Ta}}^{(s)}-\bar{\sigma}_{xx,0}^{(s)})/(\bar{\sigma}_{xx,0}^{(s)}), where σˉxx,Ta(s)\bar{\sigma}_{xx,\mathrm{Ta}}^{(s)} is the mean value of σxx\sigma_{xx} over all atoms assigned to row ss in the Ta-containing peak configuration, and σˉxx,0(s)\bar{\sigma}_{xx,0}^{(s)} is the corresponding mean for the pure-W peak configuration. The atoms belonging to each row were identified in the initial configuration and used for subsequent tracking, ensuring that the same physical groups of atoms were compared between configurations. Each atom belonging to a given row was assigned the same value of Δσˉxx(s)\Delta\bar{\sigma}_{xx}^{(s)} for visualization. The mapped quantity is normalized and dimensionless. The color range in Figure 26(c) therefore extends from approximately −2 to 20. The σxx\sigma_{xx} component was selected for this visualization because it provides the clearest spatial contrast among the different GB rows. The maps show that the largest relative row-averaged stress changes are concentrated on the segregation-rich row 1. This localization, together with the correlation between cTarow 1c_{\mathrm{Ta}}^{\mathrm{row\,1}} and the first stress peak, supports the conclusion that occupation of this specific GB environment strongly controls the pinning strength and the initiation of disconnection-mediated de-pinning.

The preceding results establish a strong correlation between the occupation of row 1 and the first GB de-pinning stress. To test this relationship more directly and separate the effect of individual GB environments from the complex equilibrium segregation distribution, controlled row-occupation simulations were performed. Starting from the pure-W Σ5(120)\Sigma5(120) GB, all W atoms belonging to one selected GB row were artificially replaced with Ta atoms, while the remaining GB rows and bulk regions were retained as pure W. Each resulting configuration was relaxed at 500 K and zero pressure using the anisotropic NPT ensemble. The relaxed structures were then subjected to the same shear-loading setup used for the equilibrated W–Ta systems.

Figure 27(a) compares the resulting σyz\sigma_{yz}–grain-translation curves for complete Ta occupation of rows 1–4. These configurations are controlled mechanistic tests rather than equilibrium segregation states; therefore, the comparison evaluates the effect of occupying each structural row and does not represent a comparison at identical global Ta concentration. The arrows identify the first pronounced stress drop in each simulation, which is taken as the initial GB de-pinning event. Ta occupation of row 1 produces a markedly different response from occupation of the other rows. The shear stress continues to increase to approximately 5.7 GPa at a grain translation of approximately 0.43 nm before undergoing a sharp decrease. In contrast, occupation of rows 2, 3, and 4 produces substantially earlier de-pinning at first peak stresses of approximately 1.1, 1.4, and 2.2 GPa, respectively.

Controlled row Ta occupation in the $\Sigma 5(120)$ W GB at 500 K

Figure 27. Controlled row Ta occupation in the Σ5(120)\Sigma5(120) W GB at 500 K. Each selected W row was replaced entirely by Ta, relaxed at zero pressure in the NPT ensemble, and subjected to shear loading. (a) σyz\sigma_{yz} as a function of grain translation for Ta occupation of rows 1–4; arrows mark the first de-pinning stress drop. Occupation of row 1 produces the highest peak stress, approximately 5.7 GPa. (b–e) Relaxed configurations (top) and configurations after the first stress drop (bottom) for rows 1–4. Bulk W, GB atoms, and Ta atoms are shown in dark gray, white, and the corresponding row colors, respectively. The results identify row 1 as the dominant site controlling initial GB pinning.

The atomic configurations before loading and immediately after the first stress drop are shown in Figure 27(b)–Figure 27(e). In each case, the stress drop is accompanied by displacement of the GB region relative to its initially relaxed configuration. The smaller and earlier stress drops obtained for rows 2–4 indicate that Ta occupation of these environments provides only limited resistance to the initiation of GB motion. Subsequent increases in stress correspond to continued loading of the newly migrated GB configuration and should therefore be distinguished from the first de-pinning event.

The substantially greater stress and grain translation required to de-pin the GB from Ta-occupied row 1 provide direct evidence that the different GB rows do not contribute equally to solute pinning. Instead, the pinning strength is governed strongly by the crystallographic and local atomic environment occupied by Ta. This controlled comparison supports the interpretation of the equilibrium-segregation simulations: the increase and eventual plateau in the first de-pinning stress arise primarily from the progressive occupation and saturation of row 1, whereas additional Ta distributed among lower-impact rows produces a comparatively small increase in the initial resistance to GB migration.

Conclusion

We developed a transferable GRACE machine-learning interatomic potential for the W–Ta binary system using a large and diverse DFT dataset generated primarily through feature-space information-entropy maximization. Rather than relying on the manual enumeration of anticipated structures, defects, and deformation modes, this approach automatically explores configuration space by maximizing the diversity of atomically relevant features. It therefore enables broad training datasets to be constructed without iterative human selection of configurations or prior knowledge of every downstream application. Supplementing this automatically generated dataset with ordered alloy structures produced a potential that achieves substantially lower energy and force errors than the available empirical W–Ta potentials on the present diverse test set.

Extensive validation demonstrates that the breadth introduced during data generation translates into broad physical transferability. The potential provides a consistent description of equilibrium structures, elastic and vibrational properties, high-pressure response, surfaces, point defects, dislocation energetics, transformation pathways, alloy thermodynamics, and melting behavior. Taken together, these tests show that entropy-maximized sampling can produce a model capable of describing physical phenomena that were not individually targeted during dataset construction. The resulting potential provides a robust foundation for simulations of the coupled mechanical, defect, and microstructural processes relevant to W–Ta alloys in fusion environments.

As a demonstration of these capabilities, the potential was applied to Ta segregation and shear-coupled migration of a Σ5(120)\Sigma5(120) W GB. Ta was found to segregate preferentially to specific atomic rows within the boundary, and occupation of one high-affinity environment strongly increased the stress required for disconnection-mediated de-pinning. The de-pinning stress plateaued as this dominant site became saturated and decreased with increasing temperature. Controlled row-occupation simulations confirmed that pinning depends more strongly on the local atomic environment occupied by Ta than on nominal composition or average GB concentration alone.

References

  1. [1]V Philipps. Tungsten as material for plasma-facing components in fusion devices. Journal of nuclear materials, 415(1):S2–S9, 2011.DOI
  2. [2]R Neu, R Dux, A Kallenbach, T Pütterich, M Balden, JC Fuchs, A Herrmann, CF Maggi, M O’Mullane, R Pugno, et al. Tungsten: an option for divertor and main chamber plasma facing components in future fusion devices. Nuclear fusion, 45(3):209–218, 2005.DOI
  3. [3]Michael Rieth, Sergei L Dudarev, SM Gonzalez De Vicente, Jürgen Aktaa, T Ahlgren, S Antusch, DEJ Armstrong, M Balden, Nadine Baluc, M-F Barthe, et al. Recent progress in research on tungsten materials for nuclear fusion applications. Journal of Nuclear Materials, 432(1–3):482–500, 2013.DOI
  4. [4]JW Coenen, Y Mao, J Almannstötter, A Calvo, S Sistla, H Gietl, B Jasper, J Riesch, M Rieth, G Pintsuk, et al. Advanced materials for a damage resilient divertor concept for demo: Powder-metallurgical tungsten-fibre reinforced tungsten. Fusion Engineering and Design, 124:964–968, 2017.
  5. [5]Shuhei Nogami, Itsuki Ozawa, Daisuke Asami, Naoya Matsuta, Seiji Nakabayashi, Siegfried Baumgärtner, Philipp Lied, Kiyohiro Yabuuchi, Takeshi Miyazawa, Yuta Kikuchi, et al. Tungsten–tantalum alloys for fusion reactor applications. Journal of Nuclear Materials, 566:153740, 2022.DOI
  6. [6]Peter Gumbsch. Brittle fracture and the brittle-to-ductile transition of tungsten. Journal of Nuclear Materials, 323(2-3):304–312, 2003.DOI
  7. [7]Armando Giannattasio and Steve G Roberts. Strain-rate dependence of the brittle-to-ductile transition temperature in tungsten. Philosophical Magazine, 87(17):2589–2598, 2007.DOI
  8. [8]K Farrell, AC Schaffhauser, and JQ Stiegler. Recrystallization, grain growth and the ductile-brittle transition in tungsten sheet. Journal of the Less Common Metals, 13(2):141–155, 1967.DOI
  9. [9]Q Wei and LJ Kecskes. Effect of low-temperature rolling on the tensile behavior of commercially pure tungsten. Materials Science and Engineering: A, 491(1-2):62–69, 2008.DOI
  10. [10]P Schade. 100 years of doped tungsten wire. International Journal of Refractory Metals and Hard Materials, 28(6):648–660, 2010.DOI
  11. [11]Shuhei Nogami, Shotaro Watanabe, Jens Reiser, Michael Rieth, Sven Sickinger, and Akira Hasegawa. Improvement of impact properties of tungsten by potassium doping. Fusion Engineering and Design, 140:48–61, 2019.DOI
  12. [12]GA Geach and JE Hughes. The alloys of rhenium with molybdenum or with tungsten and having good high temperature properties. In Plansee Proceedings, pages 245–253. Pergamon Press London, 1955.
  13. [13]Lorenz Románer, Claudia Ambrosch-Draxl, and Reinhard Pippan. Effect of rhenium on the dislocation core structure in tungsten. Physical review letters, 104(19):195503, 2010.pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/20866976
  14. [14]A Luo, DL Jacobson, and KS Shin. Solution softening mechanism of iridium and rhenium in tungsten at room temperature. International Journal of Refractory Metals and Hard Materials, 10(2):107–114, 1991.DOI
  15. [15]P Makarov and K Povarova. Development of tungsten-based vacuum melted and powder structural alloys. International Journal of Refractory Metals and Hard Materials, 20(4):277–285, 2002.
  16. [16]Tetsuji Noda, Fujio Abe, Hiroshi Araki, and Masatoshi Okada. Materials selection for reduced activation of fusion reactors. Journal of Nuclear Materials, 155:581–584, 1988.DOI
  17. [17]Philip J Maziasz and Ronald L Klueh. Precipitation sensitivity to alloy composition in fe-cr-mn austenitic steels developed for reduced activation for fusion application. Reduced Activation Materials for Fusion Reactors, 1047:56–79, 1990.DOI
  18. [18]S Nogami, M Wirtz, P Lied, and T Chikada. Thermal shock behavior under deuterium plasma exposure of tungsten–tantalum alloys. Physica Scripta, 96(11):114011, 2021.DOI
  19. [19]Takeshi Miyazawa, Yuta Kikuchi, Masami Ando, Ju-Hyeon Yu, Kiyohiro Yabuuchi, Takashi Nozawa, Hiroyasu Tanigawa, Shuhei Nogami, and Akira Hasegawa. Microstructural evolution in tungsten binary alloys under proton and self-ion irradiations at 800° c. Journal of Nuclear Materials, 575:154239, 2023.DOI
  20. [20]Juan Du, Chuan Wu, Tianyu Zhao, Pan Wen, Pinghuai Wang, Jun Tang, Xiang Liu, and Jiming Chen. Properties of potassium doped and tantalum containing tungsten after heavy ion irradiation. Crystals, 13(6):951, 2023.DOI
  21. [21]K Schmid, V Rieger, and A Manhard. Comparison of hydrogen retention in w and w/ta alloys. Journal of Nuclear Materials, 426(1-3):247–253, 2012.DOI
  22. [22]Y Zavaychuk, MHJ ’t Hoen, PA Zeijlmans van Emmichoven, D Terentyev, Inge Uytd­enhouwen, and Guido Van Oost. Surface modification of tungsten and tungsten–tantalum alloys exposed to high-flux deuterium plasma and its impact on deuterium retention. Nuclear Fusion, 53(1):013013, 2013.DOI
  23. [23]K Li, Y Li, W Chen, C Zhao, Y Yuan, L Cheng, TW Morgan, W Liu, and Zhijian Shen. Effect of ta addition on the fuzz formation of additively manufactured w-based materials. Nuclear Fusion, 60(6):064004, 2020.DOI
  24. [24]Stefan Wurster, Bernd Gludovatz, Andreas Hoffmann, and Reinhard Pippan. Fracture behaviour of tungsten–vanadium and tungsten–tantalum alloys and composites. Journal of Nuclear Materials, 413(3):166–176, 2011.DOI
  25. [25]Michael Rieth, Jens Reister, Bernhard Daffner, and Siegfried Baumgärtner. The impact of refractory material properties on the helium cooled divertor design. Fusion Science and Technology, 61(1T):381–384, 2012.DOI
  26. [26]M Muzyk, D Nguyen-Manh, KJ Kurzydłowski, NL Baluc, and SL Dudarev. Phase stability, point defects, and elastic properties of wv and w-ta alloys. Physical Review B—Condensed Matter and Materials Physics, 84(10):104115, 2011.DOI
  27. [27]PEA Turchi, A Gonis, V Drchal, and J Kudrnovský. First-principles study of stability and local order in substitutional ta-w alloys. Physical Review B, 64(8):085112, 2001.DOI
  28. [28]Gus LW Hart, Volker Blum, Michael J Walorski, and Alex Zunger. Evolutionary approach for determining first-principles hamiltonians. Nature materials, 4(5):391–394, 2005.pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/15834412
  29. [29]Yangchun Chen, Jingzhong Fang, Lixia Liu, Wangyu Hu, Ning Gao, Fei Gao, and Huiqiu Deng. Development of the interatomic potentials for w-ta system. Computational Materials Science, 163:91–99, 2019.DOI
  30. [30]Bajrang Sharma, Ying Shi Teh, Babak Sadigh, Sebastien Hamel, Vasily Bulatov, and Amit Samanta. Development of an interatomic potential for the w–ta system. Computational materials science, 230:112486, 2023.DOI
  31. [31]Ralf Drautz. Atomic cluster expansion for accurate and transferable interatomic potentials. Physical Review B, 99(1):014104, 2019.DOI
  32. [32]Anton Bochkarev, Yury Lysogorskiy, and Ralf Drautz. Graph atomic cluster expansion for semilocal interactions beyond equivariant message passing. Physical Review X, 14(2):021036, 2024.arxiv.org/abs/2311.16326
  33. [33]Aparna PA Subramanyam and Danny Perez. Information-entropy-driven generation of material-agnostic datasets for machine-learning interatomic potentials. npj Computational Materials, 11(1):218, 2025.arxiv.org/abs/2407.10361
  34. [34]Mariia Karabin and Danny Perez. An entropy-maximization approach to automated training set generation for interatomic potentials. The Journal of Chemical Physics, 153(9), 2020.arxiv.org/abs/2002.07876
  35. [35]Anton Bochkarev, Yury Lysogorskiy, Aparna Subramanyam, Ralf Drautz, and Danny Perez. Exploring the extremes: atomic basis for multi-elemental materials science under complex thermodynamic conditions. arXiv preprint arXiv:2602.23489, 2026.arxiv.org/abs/2602.23489
  36. [36]David Montes de Oca Zapiain, Mitchell A Wood, Nicholas Lubbers, Carlos Z Pereyra, Aidan P Thompson, and Danny Perez. Training data selection for accuracy and transferability of interatomic potentials. npj Computational Materials, 8(1):189, 2022.arxiv.org/abs/2201.09829
  37. [37]James E Saal, Scott Kirklin, Muratthan Aykol, Bryce Meredig, and Christopher Wolverton. Materials design and discovery with high-throughput density functional theory: the open quantum materials database (oqmd). Jom, 65(11):1501–1509, 2013.DOI
  38. [38]Volker Blum and Alex Zunger. Prediction of ordered structures in the bcc binary systems of mo, nb, ta, and w from first-principles search of approximately 3,000,000 possible configurations. Physical Review B—Condensed Matter and Materials Physics, 72(2):020104, 2005.DOI
  39. [39]Georg Kresse and Jürgen Furthmüller. Efficient iterative schemes for ab initio total-energy calculations using a plane-wave basis set. Physical Review B, 54:11169–11186, 1996.pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/9984901
  40. [40]Ask Hjorth Larsen, Jens Jørgen Mortensen, Jakob Blomqvist, Ivano E Castelli, Rune Christensen, Marcin Dulak, Jesper Friis, Michael N Groves, Björk Hammer, Cory Hargus, et al. The atomic simulation environment—a python library for working with atoms. Journal of Physics: Condensed Matter, 29(27):273002, 2017.DOI
  41. [41]John P Perdew, Kieron Burke, and Matthias Ernzerhof. Generalized gradient approximation made simple. Physical review letters, 77(18):3865, 1996.pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/10062328
  42. [42]A. P. Thompson, H. M. Aktulga, R. Berger, D. S. Bolintineanu, W. M. Brown, P. S. Crozier, P. J. in ’t Veld, A. Kohlmeyer, S. G. Moore, T. D. Nguyen, R. Shan, M. J. Stevens, J. Tranchida, C. Trott, and S. J. Plimpton. LAMMPS - a flexible simulation tool for particle-based materials modeling at the atomic, meso, and continuum scales. Comp. Phys. Comm., 271:108171, 2022.DOI
  43. [43]David R Lide. CRC handbook of chemistry and physics: a ready-reference book of chemical and physical data. CRC Press Boca Raton, 1988.
  44. [44]Agnès Dewaele, Paul Loubeyre, and Mohamed Mezouar. Refinement of the equation of state of tantalum. Physical Review B, 69(9):092106, 2004.DOI
  45. [45]Charles Kittel. Introduction to solid state physics, jhon wiley & sons. Inc., Sixth edition,(New York, 1986), 1996.
  46. [46]Charles Kittel and Paul McEuen. Introduction to solid state physics. John Wiley & Sons, 2018.
  47. [47]D Io Bolef and J De Klerk. Elastic constants of single-crystal mo and w between 77° and 500° k. Journal of applied Physics, 33(7):2311–2314, 1962.DOI
  48. [48]Frank H Featherston and JR Neighbours. Elastic constants of tantalum, tungsten, and molybdenum. Physical Review, 130(4):1324, 1963.DOI
  49. [49]K Maier, M Peo, B Saile, HE Schaefer, and A Seeger. High-temperature positron annihilation and vacancy formation in refractory metals. Philosophical Magazine A, 40(5):701–728, 1979.DOI
  50. [50]P Ehrhart. Atomic defects in metals. Landolt-Bornstein, New Series, 1991.DOI
  51. [51]RW Balluff. Vacancy defect mobilities and binding energies obtained from annealing studies. Journal of nuclear materials, 69:240–263, 1978.
  52. [52]Changle Li, Song Lu, Sergiy Divinski, and Levente Vitos. Theoretical and experimental grain boundary energies in body-centered cubic metals. Acta Materialia, 255:119074, 2023.
  53. [53]Erwin Rudy. Compendium of phase diagram data, volume 65. Air Force Materials Laboratory, Metals and Ceramics Division, 1969.
  54. [54]LG Wang, A Van De Walle, and D Alfe. Melting temperature of tungsten from two ab initio approaches. Physical Review B—Condensed Matter and Materials Physics, 84(9):092102, 2011.
  55. [55]Simone Taioli, C Cazorla, MJ Gillan, and D Alfè. Melting curve of tantalum from first principles. Physical Review B—Condensed Matter and Materials Physics, 75(21):214103, 2007.DOI
  56. [56]Hannes Jónsson, Greg Mills, and Karsten W Jacobsen. Nudged elastic band method for finding minimum energy paths of transitions. In Classical and quantum dynamics in condensed phase simulations, pages 385–404. World Scientific, 1998.DOI
  57. [57]Graeme Henkelman and Hannes Jónsson. Improved tangent estimate in the nudged elastic band method for finding minimum energy paths and saddle points. The Journal of chemical physics, 113(22):9978–9985, 2000.DOI
  58. [58]Graeme Henkelman, Blas P Uberuaga, and Hannes Jónsson. A climbing image nudged elastic band method for finding saddle points and minimum energy paths. The Journal of chemical physics, 113(22):9901–9904, 2000.DOI
  59. [59]Matous Mrovec, Roman Gröger, Aimee Gotway Bailey, Duc Nguyen-Manh, Christian Elsässer, and Vaclav Vitek. Bond-order potential for simulations of extended defects in tungsten. Physical Review B—Condensed Matter and Materials Physics, 75(10):104119, 2007.DOI
  60. [60]Niklas Juslin, P Erhart, Petra Träskelin, Janne Nord, Krister OE Henriksson, Kai Nordlund, Emppu Salonen, and K Albe. Analytical interatomic potential for modeling nonequilibrium processes in the w–c–h system. Journal of applied physics, 98(12), 2005.DOI
  61. [61]Y Mishin and AY Lozovoi. Angular-dependent interatomic potential for tantalum. Acta materialia, 54(19):5013–5026, 2006.DOI
  62. [62]Axel Forslund and Andrei Ruban. Ab initio surface free energies of tungsten with full account of thermal excitations. Physical Review B, 105(4):045403, 2022.DOI
  63. [63]Shigeaki Ono. First-principles molecular dynamics calculations of the equation of state for tantalum. International Journal of Molecular Sciences, 10(10):4342–4351, 2009.DOI
  64. [64]R Kinslow. High-velocity impact phenomena academic press. New York and London, page 547, 1970.
  65. [65]Ramon Ravelo, TC Germann, O Guerrero, Q An, and BL Holian. Shock-induced plasticity in tantalum single crystals: Interatomic potentials and large-scale molecular-dynamics simulations. Physical Review B—Condensed Matter and Materials Physics, 88(13):134101, 2013.DOI
  66. [66]Atsushi Togo and Isao Tanaka. First principles phonon calculations in materials science. Scripta materialia, 108:1–5, 2015.arxiv.org/abs/1506.08498
  67. [67]Xue-Chun Zhang, Shuo Cao, Lian-Ji Zhang, Rui Yang, and Qing-Miao Hu. Unstable stacking fault energy and peierls stress for evaluating slip system competition in body-centered cubic metals. Journal of Materials Research and Technology, 22:3413–3422, 2023.DOI
  68. [68]Yi-Shen Lin, Ganga P Purja Pun, and Yuri Mishin. Development of a physically-informed neural network interatomic potential for tantalum. Computational Materials Science, 205:111180, 2022.
  69. [69]K Heinola, F Djurabekova, and T Ahlgren. On the stability and mobility of di-vacancies in tungsten. Nuclear Fusion, 58(2):026004, 2018.DOI
  70. [70]JY Park, HCW Huang, RW Siegel, and RW Balluffi. A quantitative study of vacancy defects in quenched tungsten by combined field-ion microscopy and electrical resistometry. Philosophical Magazine A, 48(3):397–419, 1983.DOI
  71. [71]Mark R Gilbert and Sergei L Dudarev. Ab initio multi-string frenkel–kontorova model for ab= a/2 [111] screw dislocation in bcc iron. Philosophical Magazine, 90(7-8):1035–1061, 2010.
  72. [72]Mihai-Cosmin Marinica, Lisa Ventelon, Mark R Gilbert, Laurent Prov ille, Sergei L Dudarev, Jaime Marian, Guy Bentceux, and François Willaime. Interatomic potentials for modelling radiation defects and dislocations in tungsten. Journal of Physics: Condensed Matter, 25(39):395502, 2013.DOI
  73. [73]L Hale, Z Trautt, and C Becker. Interatomic potentials repository project, 2018.
  74. [74]TD Swinburne, SL Dudarev, SP Fitzgerald, MR Gilbert, and AP Sutton. Theory and simulation of the diffusion of kinks on dislocations in bcc metals. Physical Review B—Condensed Matter and Materials Physics, 87(6):064108, 2013.
  75. [75]Christopher R Weinberger, Garritt J Tucker, and Stephen M Foiles. Peierls potential of screw dislocations in bcc transition metals: Predictions from density functional theory. Physical Review B—Condensed Matter and Materials Physics, 87(5):054114, 2013.DOI
  76. [76]R Krishnan, SP Garg, and N Krishnamurthy. The tantalum–tungsten system. J. Alloy Phase Diagrams, 3(1):1–3, 1987.
  77. [77]Ning Wei, Ting Jia, Xiaoli Zhang, Ting Liu, Z Zeng, and XiaoYu Yang. First-principles study of the phase stability and the mechanical properties of w-ta and w-re alloys. AIP Advances, 4(5), 2014.DOI
  78. [78]Yu-Wei You, Xiang-Shan Kong, Xuebang Wu, CS Liu, QF Fang, JL Chen, and G-N Luo. Clustering of transmutation elements tantalum, rhenium and osmium in tungsten in a fusion environment. Nuclear Fusion, 57(8):086006, 2017.DOI
  79. [79]Xiang-Shan Kong, Xuebang Wu, Yu-Wei You, CS Liu, QF Fang, Jun-Ling Chen, G-N Luo, and Zhiguang Wang. First-principles calculations of transition metal–solute interactions with point defects in tungsten. Acta Materialia, 66:172–183, 2014.DOI
  80. [80]Wahyu Setyawan, Giridhar Nandipati, and Richard J Kurtz. Ab initio study of interstitial cluster interaction with re, os, and ta in w. Journal of Nuclear Materials, 484:30–41, 2017.DOI
  81. [81]CS Becquart and C Domain. Solute–point defect interactions in bcc systems: Focus on first principles modelling in w and rpv steels. Current Opinion in Solid State and Materials Science, 16(3):115–125, 2012.DOI
  82. [82]Leili Gharaei and Paul Erhart. A first-principles investigation of interstitial defects in dilute tungsten alloys. Journal of Nuclear Materials, 467:448–456, 2015.
  83. [83]Alan Xu, David EJ Armstrong, Christian Beck, Michael P Moody, George DW Smith, Paul AJ Bagot, and Steve G Roberts. Ion-irradiation induced clustering in w-re, w-re and w-ta alloys: An atom probe tomography and nanoindentation study. Acta Materialia, 124:71–78, 2017.
  84. [84]Patrice EA Turchi, Igor A Abrikosov, Benjamin Burton, Suzana G Fries, Göran Grimvall, Larry Kaufman, Pavel Korzhavyi, V Rao Manga, Munekazu Ohno, Alexander Pisch, et al. Interface between quantum-mechanical-based approaches, experiments, and calphad methodology. Calphad, 31(1):4–27, 2007.DOI
  85. [85]Olivia K Donaldson, Khalid Hattar, Tyler Kaub, Gregory B Thompson, and Jason R Trelewicz. Solute stabilization of nanocrystalline tungsten against abnormal grain growth. Journal of Materials Research, 33(1):68–80, 2018.DOI
  86. [86]John W Cahn, Yuri Mishin, and Akira Suzuki. Coupling grain boundary motion to shear deformation. Acta materialia, 54(19):4953–4975, 2006.DOI
  87. [87]VA Ivanov and Yu Mishin. Dynamics of grain boundary motion coupled to shear deformation: An analytical model and its verification by molecular dynamics. Physical Review B—Condensed Matter and Materials Physics, 78(6):064106, 2008.DOI
  88. [88]Y Mishin, A Suzuki, Blas P Uberuaga, and Arthur Ford Voter. Stick-slip behavior of grain boundaries studied by accelerated molecular dynamics. Physical Review B—Condensed Matter and Materials Physics, 75(22):224101, 2007.DOI
  89. [89]Qiyang Hu, Lan Li, and NM Ghonien. Stick–slip dynamics of coherent twin boundaries in copper. Acta materialia, 57(16):4866–4873, 2009.DOI
  90. [90]Stefan Bringuier, Venkateswara Rao Manga, Keith Runge, Pierre Deymier, and Krishna Muralidharan. Grain boundary dynamics of sic bicrystals under shear deformation. Materials Science and Engineering: A, 634:161–166, 2015.DOI
  91. [91]Jacob L Bair and Eric R Homer. Antithermal mobility in σ7 and σ9 grain boundaries caused by stick-slip stagnation of ordered atomic motions about coincidence site lattice atoms. Acta Materialia, 162:10–18, 2019.DOI
  92. [92]Zhe yuan Xing, Haidong Fan, Chuanlong Xu, and Guozheng Kang. Transition from grain boundary migration to grain boundary sliding in magnesium bicrystals. Acta Mechanica Sinica, 40(8):123448, 2024.DOI
  93. [93]Akarsh Verma, Oliver K Johnson, Gregory B Thompson, Shigenobu Ogata, and Eric R Homer. Solute influence in transitions from non-arrhenius to stick-slip arrhenius grain boundary migration. Acta Materialia, 265:119605, 2024.DOI
  94. [94]Fusheng Tan, Tianxu Qiu, Zheng Fang, Lei Yu, Laima Luo, and Yucheng Wu. Competition between grain boundary migration and sliding in refractory high-entropy alloy induced by segregation and temperature. Intermetallics, 193:109240, 2026.DOI
  95. [95]Ahmed Tamer AlMotasem, Teodor Humin iuc, and Tomas Polcar. Factors controlling segregation tendency of solute ti, ag and ta into different symmetrical tilt grain boundaries of tungsten: First-principles and experimental study. Acta Materialia, 211:116868, 2021.DOI
  96. [96]AT AlMotasem, N Daghb ouj, T Humin iuc, J Vesely, M Karlik, M Callisti, X Zhang, and T Polcar. Exploring solute segregation in sputtered w-10 at.% m (m= ti, ag, and ta): Experimental insights and atomistic modeling. Materialia, 39:102346, 2025.DOI
  97. [97]Enze Chen, Tae Wook Heo, Brandon C. Wood, Mark Asta, and Timofey Frolov. Grand canonically optimized grain boundary phases in hexagonal close-packed titanium. Nature Communications, 15(1):7049, 2024.DOI
  98. [98]Xiaowang W Zhou, RA Johnson, and Haydn NG Wadley. Misfit-energy-increasing dislocations in vapor-deposited cofe/nife multilayers. Physical Review B, 69(14):144113, 2004.DOI
  99. [99]Babak Sadigh, Paul Erhart, Alexander Stukowski, Alfredo Caro, Enrique Martinez, and Luis Zepeda-Ruiz. A scalable parallel monte carlo algorithm for atomistic simulations of precipitation in alloys. arXiv preprint arXiv:1012.5082, 2010.DOI
  100. [100]Alexander Stukowski. Visualization and analysis of atomistic simulation data with OVITO-the Open Visualization Tool. MODELLING AND SIMULATION IN MATERIALS SCIENCE AND ENGINEERING, 18(1), JAN 2010.DOI

Paper details

vlnc:W_pk5xar8e
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 1

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents