betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

New CP-violating sources beyond the reach of EDMs

Abstract

The Standard Model does not contain sufficient amount of CP violation to account for the observed baryon asymmetry of the universe. Beyond Standard Model scenarios that aim to explain this asymmetry introduce new sources of CP violation, but these generically feed into electric dipole moments (EDMs), which are severely constrained by experiment. We indentify a new class of CP-violating sources that cannot generate EDMs directly: EDM operators are C conserving and P violating, whereas CP violation introduced here is, by construction, C violating and P conserving. We give a concrete model realisation accommodating such sources and discuss their relevance for baryogenesis.

Dedicated to the memory of Mark A. Rayner, a brilliant physicist, an exceptional science communicator, and a dear friend.

Introduction

CP violation is one of the necessary ingredients, as shown by Sakharov [1], of any successful baryogenesis mechanism to explain the observed matter-antimatter asymmetry of the Universe. The Standard Model (SM) contains two sources of CP violation, namely the complex phase of the Cabibbo-Kobayashi-Maskawa (CKM) matrix and the QCD θˉ\bar{\theta} term. However, the CP violation present in the SM is insufficient to account for the observed baryon asymmetry [2] [3, 4].

This motivates frameworks beyond the SM proposing new sources of CP violation. Such sources, however, generically induce electric dipole moments (EDMs) that are tightly constrained by present experiments and will be probed even more stringently by the next generation of measurements. However, there is an often-neglected caveat; that is, the observation of EDMs would constitute direct evidence of parity (P) and time-reversal (T) violation and, assuming CPT invariance, of CP violation. Correspondingly, EDMs arise from operators that are P violating and C conserving.

In this paper, we identify a new class of CP-violating sources that arises from C-violating and P-conserving interactions, and hence is structurally distinct from the C-conserving, P-violating interactions probed by EDM searches, despite being CP violating. Such new sources emerge from models featuring an extended dark sector composed entirely of scalar fields.

The key observation is that CP violation originating purely in the scalar sector is necessarily C violating and P conserving: parity is automatically conserved in any renormalisable theory of scalars and (electroweak) gauge bosons in the absence of Yukawa couplings. We demonstrate this general principle in a concrete framework of the Z2\mathbb{Z}_2-symmetric 3-Higgs-doublet model (3HDM) with two inert and one active Higgs doublets, also known as I(2+1)HDM, in which explicit CP violation is confined to the dark (inert) sector, hence referred to as dark CP violation.

This class of CP violation was first introduced in Ref. [5] and subsequently studied in Refs. [6–13].1 It was previously understood that the corresponding contributions to EDMs are severely suppressed, arising only at three-loop order or beyond.

In the present work, we argue that the implications may be considerably stronger: the C-violating, P-conserving nature of this class of CP violation suggests a symmetry-based mechanism for evading EDM constraints, rather than relying on numerical suppression or accidental cancellations between individual diagrams. An essential ingredient is the exact Z2\mathbb{Z}_2 symmetry, which forbids Yukawa couplings of the inert scalars and prevents the direct transmission of dark CP violation to the fermionic sector.2

Although this class of CP violation does not directly generate EDM operators, it offers distinct experimental signatures, particularly through triple-gauge couplings (TGCs). A potential challenge to its EDM invisibility arises when these vertices are embedded into higher-order diagrams involving the parity-violating fermionic interactions of the SM. While the C-odd, P-even TGC structures cannot generate the C-even, P-odd EDM operator through C- and P-conserving interactions, the axial gauge-fermion couplings of the SM may, in principle, be able to circumvent this restriction. We nevertheless conjecture that the absence of EDM contributions from this type of CP violation persists in the full electroweak theory, potentially to all orders in perturbation theory.3

Notwithstanding this, such CP violation can be transmitted to the SM sector through gauge interactions and contribute to baryogenesis, an example of such mechanism is shown in Ref. [12]. This should come as no surprise since Sakharov conditions explicitly require C and CP violation as essential requirements of baryogenesis (as opposed to P and CP violation). A detailed analysis of this CP violation transfer mechanism is under-way and will be presented in an upcoming publication.

It is important to note that when the extended inert sector contains a doublet and a singlet scalar [15], instead of two doublet scalars, the amount of CP-violation is inevitably reduced due to the presence of the singlet, as established in Ref. [7]. This is a consequence of the presence of fewer number of inert states contributing to the relevant processes, along with diluted ZSiSjZ S_i S_j couplings (since the singlet has no direct couplings to the SM gauge bosons). In the analysis that follows, we use the example of the aforementioned 3HDM which is the most minimal model contributing to many signatures we present. We will, however, mention where a model with smaller particle content can contribute.

The remainder of the paper is organised as follows. In § 2 we review the EDM experiments and operators, establishing that all of them are C-even and P-odd. In § 3 we show, at the level of general principles, that CP violation confined to a bosonic sector of scalars and gauge fields must instead be C-odd and P-even, identify the associated C-odd, P-even form factors in triple gauge boson processes, and formulate our conjecture on their embedding into the full electroweak theory. § 4 discusses C-selection-rule tests: transitions of the same state into final states of mutually incompatible C eigenvalue. § 5 places this result in the broader context of static multipole moments, identifies the class of moments that shares the discrete-symmetry quantum numbers of our CP violation, and explains why static moments of fermions cannot provide C-selection-rule tests. § 6 presents the I(2+1)HDM as a concrete realisation of this class of CP violation, and § 7 concludes.

EDM operators: P violating, C conserving

Permanent EDMs are searched for through spin-precession measurements in external electric and magnetic fields. For a spin-12\frac{1}{2} particle, an EDM induces the interaction −dE⃗⋅s⃗-d\vec{E}\cdot\vec{s}, which shifts the magnetic Larmor precession frequency ωL\omega_L according to ℏω↑↓=2(μB±dE)\hbar\omega_{\uparrow\downarrow}=2(\mu B\pm dE), so that the observed total spin-precession frequency is

ωobs=ωL+δωEDM,withωL=2μBℏandδωEDM=±2dEℏ,(1)\omega_{\mathrm{obs}}=\omega_L+\delta\omega_{\mathrm{EDM}}, \qquad\text{with}\qquad\omega_L=\frac{2\mu B}{\hbar}\qquad\text{and}\qquad\delta\omega_{\mathrm{EDM}}=\pm\frac{2dE}{\hbar}, \tag*{(1)}

where the sign depends on the relative orientation of E⃗\vec{E} and B⃗\vec{B} fields. Reversing the electric field isolates the EDM contribution while cancelling the ordinary magnetic precession.

EDM searches employ a range of complementary experimental systems. Neutron EDM, dnd_n, experiments use stored ultracold neutrons in static electric and magnetic fields, with Ramsey spectroscopy and co-magnetometry providing precise measurements of spin precession; the current limit is ∣dn∣<1.8×10−26 e cm|d_n|<1.8\times10^{-26}\,\mathrm{e\,cm} at 90% C.L. [16]. The strongest constraints on the electron EDM, ded_e, arise from paramagnetic polar molecules such as ThO and HfF+^+, where very large internal effective electric fields strongly enhance sensitivity to ded_e [17, 18]. The present bound is ∣de∣<4.1×10−30 e cm|d_e|<4.1\times10^{-30}\,\mathrm{e\,cm} at 90% C.L. [18], with future molecular-ion experiments expected to improve this sensitivity further [19]. Diamagnetic systems such as 199Hg{}^{199}\mathrm{Hg}, 129Xe{}^{129}\mathrm{Xe} and 225Ra{}^{225}\mathrm{Ra} instead probe predominantly hadronic and nuclear sources of CP violation, including nuclear Schiff moments and quark chromo-electric dipole moments [20]. Finally, EDMs of charged particles such as protons, deuterons and muons can be probed in storage rings, where an EDM induces an out-of-plane spin precession and hence a measurable vertical polarisation [21, 22].

Although neutron, atomic, molecular, and storage-ring experiments probe different combinations of effective operators, they all measure the same underlying observable: a flavour-diagonal EDM. For a fermion, the corresponding relativistic interaction is

LEDM=−i2dψψˉσμνγ5ψFμν,(2)\mathcal{L}_{\mathrm{EDM}}=-\frac{i}{2}d_\psi\bar{\psi}\sigma^{\mu\nu}\gamma_5\psi F_{\mu\nu}, \tag*{(2)}

which is C-even, P-odd, and T-odd. Consequently, a non-zero EDM signals P and T violation and, assuming CPT invariance, CP violation. At the energies relevant for EDM searches, the underlying CP-violating interactions are mapped onto hadronic, nuclear, atomic, and molecular matrix elements through an effective field theory expansion [20, 23]. The complete list of flavour-diagonal EDM operators can be found in Ref. [20].4 It is important to note that every operator in this list is C-even and P-odd. Consequently, a source of CP violation that is C-odd and P-even cannot generate any of these operators on its own. In a theory in which C and P are separately conserved apart from such a source, this is an exact consequence of the symmetry structure, rather than a suppression by loops or small couplings. In the SM, C and P are additionally violated by the chiral gauge interactions of the fermions; whether this can convert a C-odd, P-even source into an EDM is the subject of § 3.2.

In the following sections we identify the processes through which this class of CP violation can instead be probed.

Bosonic operators: C violating, P conserving

In a renormalisable theory of scalar fields transforming under a gauge group GG, together with the corresponding gauge fields, with all dimension-four-or-lower terms consistent with the gauge symmetry retained, the gauge-kinetic terms conserve C, P and T, while the scalar potential, through complex mass parameters or self-couplings, can introduce CP-violating terms. Crucially, however, parity remains exactly conserved irrespective of the scalar potential: one can consistently assign P =+1= +1 to all scalar fields and P =−1= -1 to all gauge fields,5 and verify that P is conserved at every vertex once the orbital angular momentum of each transition has been taken into account.6 Any CP violation generated by the scalar potential can therefore be interpreted as a violation of C rather than P [24].7

To illustrate this, consider a generic neutral scalar SS, which need not possess a definite CP quantum number, decaying into a pair of gauge bosons VVVV through a loop of charged scalars. The resulting effective interaction contains the P-conserving operator SFμνFμνSF_{\mu\nu}F^{\mu\nu}, whereas the P-violating operator SFμνF~μνSF_{\mu\nu}\widetilde{F}^{\mu\nu} cannot be generated by purely scalar and gauge interactions at any order in perturbation theory. This follows from the absence of parity-odd tensor structures, in particular the Levi-Civita tensor ϵμναβ\epsilon^{\mu\nu\alpha\beta}, in the underlying interactions. Consequently, even in the presence of CP violation in the scalar sector, the resulting bosonic amplitudes conserve P, implying that any CP violation must originate from C violation. The same reasoning applies to the scalar-loop contributions to the triple-gauge vertices discussed in the following sections.

Triple gauge boson processes

The triple gauge boson processes were first introduced in [25–27] and have been studied extensively ever since, for early studies see [28–35].

For a triple-gauge-boson interaction V1V2V3V_{1}V_{2}V_{3}, with associated momenta q1,q2,q3q_{1},q_{2},q_{3}, the most general Lorentz-invariant vertex, represented schematically in Figure 1, can be decomposed into a basis of independent tensor structures multiplied by the corresponding form factors. This parametrisation is particularly suitable for the analysis here, where the new-physics scale is set by the masses of the additional scalar states and need not be parametrically larger than the characteristic momentum scales of the process. In this regime, a truncated effective-field-theory expansion in local higher-dimensional operators may not provide an accurate description of the full momentum dependence of the vertex [36, 37]. The form-factor approach, by contrast, allows this momentum dependence to be retained explicitly. We therefore formulate our analysis directly in terms of the triple-gauge-boson form factors rather than basing it on a truncated set of gauge-invariant effective operators. For completeness, the corresponding effective-operator description for fully off-shell vector bosons is presented in Appendix § 11.

Figure 1. The general triple gauge boson vertex V1V2V3V_{1}V_{2}V_{3}.

The WWV vertex with V=ZV=Z or γ\gamma

The effective Lagrangian generating the triple gauge vertices involving two WW bosons is

1gWWVLWWV=ig1V(Wρσ†WρVσ−Wρ†VσWρσ)+iκVWρ†WσVρσ+imW2λVWλρ†WσρVσλ−g4VWρ†Wσ(∂ρVσ+∂σVρ)+g5Vϵρσκλ(Wρ†∂κWσ−∂κWρ†Wσ)Vλ+iκ~VWρ†WσV~ρσ+imW2λ~VWλρ†WσρV~σλ,(3)\begin{aligned} \frac{1}{g_{WWV}}\mathcal{L}_{WWV}={}&ig_{1}^{V}\left(W_{\rho\sigma}^{\dagger}W^{\rho}V^{\sigma}-W_{\rho}^{\dagger}V_{\sigma}W^{\rho\sigma}\right)+i\kappa_{V}W_{\rho}^{\dagger}W_{\sigma}V^{\rho\sigma}+\frac{i}{m_{W}^{2}}\lambda_{V}W_{\lambda\rho}^{\dagger}W_{\sigma}^{\rho}V^{\sigma\lambda}\\ &-g_{4}^{V}W_{\rho}^{\dagger}W_{\sigma}\left(\partial^{\rho}V^{\sigma}+\partial^{\sigma}V^{\rho}\right)+g_{5}^{V}\epsilon^{\rho\sigma\kappa\lambda}\left(W_{\rho}^{\dagger}\partial_{\kappa}W_{\sigma}-\partial_{\kappa}W_{\rho}^{\dagger}W_{\sigma}\right)V_{\lambda}\\ &+i\widetilde{\kappa}_{V}W_{\rho}^{\dagger}W_{\sigma}\widetilde{V}^{\rho\sigma}+\frac{i}{m_{W}^{2}}\widetilde{\lambda}_{V}W_{\lambda\rho}^{\dagger}W_{\sigma}^{\rho}\widetilde{V}^{\sigma\lambda}, \tag*{(3)} \end{aligned}

where Vμν=∂μVν−∂νVμV_{\mu\nu}=\partial_{\mu}V_{\nu}-\partial_{\nu}V_{\mu} (and similarly for WμνW_{\mu\nu}), V~μν=12ϵμναβVαβ\widetilde{V}_{\mu\nu}=\frac{1}{2}\epsilon_{\mu\nu\alpha\beta}V^{\alpha\beta}, gWWγ=−eg_{WW\gamma}=-e, gWWZ=−ecot⁡θWg_{WWZ}=-e\cot\theta_{W}, and θW\theta_{W} denotes the weak mixing angle. In the SM at tree level the values of these couplings are κV=g1V=1\kappa_{V}=g_{1}^{V}=1, and λV=λ~V=κ~V=g4V=g5V=0\lambda_{V}=\widetilde{\lambda}_{V}=\widetilde{\kappa}_{V}=g_{4}^{V}=g_{5}^{V}=0. The couplings g4Vg_{4}^{V}, κ~V\widetilde{\kappa}_{V}, and λ~V\widetilde{\lambda}_{V} are CP violating. All other couplings are CP conserving.8

In momentum space, the corresponding effective vertex can be expressed as

ΓWWVαβμ(q1,q2,q3)=f1WWV(q1−q2)μgαβ−1mW2f2WWV(q1−q2)μq3αq3β−f3WWV(q3αgμβ−q3βgμα)−if4WWV(q3αgμβ+q3βgμα)+if5WWVϵμαβρ(q1−q2)ρ+f6WWVϵμαβρq3ρ+1mW2f7WWV(q1−q2)μϵαβρσq3ρ(q1−q2)σ,(4)\Gamma_{WWV}^{\alpha\beta\mu}(q_1,q_2,q_3) = f_1^{WWV}(q_1-q_2)^\mu g^{\alpha\beta} - \frac{1}{m_W^2}f_2^{WWV}(q_1-q_2)^\mu q_3^\alpha q_3^\beta- f_3^{WWV}\left(q_3^\alpha g^{\mu\beta}-q_3^\beta g^{\mu\alpha}\right) - if_4^{WWV}\left(q_3^\alpha g^{\mu\beta}+q_3^\beta g^{\mu\alpha}\right) + if_5^{WWV}\epsilon^{\mu\alpha\beta\rho}(q_1-q_2)_\rho+ f_6^{WWV}\epsilon^{\mu\alpha\beta\rho}q_{3\rho} + \frac{1}{m_W^2}f_7^{WWV}(q_1-q_2)^\mu\epsilon^{\alpha\beta\rho\sigma}q_{3\rho}(q_1-q_2)_\sigma, \tag*{(4)}

where q1q_1, q2q_2, q3q_3 represent the outgoing momenta, as shown in Figure 2.

Figure 2. The diagrams for the WWVWWV vertices (V=γ,ZV = \gamma, Z and i≠j≠k≠ℓi \ne j \ne k \ne\ell) with the effective vertex coefficient igWWVΓWWVαβμ(q1,q2,q3)ig_{WWV}\Gamma_{WWV}^{\alpha\beta\mu}(q_1,q_2,q_3). Note that in the absence of the extra internal loop in WWγWW\gamma diagrams, the opposite CP phase of the W±Si∓SjW^\pm S_i^\mp S_j vertices would cancel each other and demote the process into a CP conserving one.

One can calculate the contribution of the lowest-dimension operators in Eq. (3) to the seven form factors which are9

(P-even, C-even)f1WWV=g1V+q322mW2λV,f2WWV=λV,f3WWV=g1V+κV+λV,(P-even, C-odd)f4WWV=g4V,(P-odd, C-odd)f5WWV=g5V,(P-odd, C-even)f6WWV=κ~V−λ~V,f7WWV=−12λ~V.(5)\begin{aligned} \text{(P-even, C-even)}\quad&f_1^{WWV}=g_1^V+\frac{q_3^2}{2m_W^2}\lambda_V,\qquad f_2^{WWV}=\lambda_V,\qquad f_3^{WWV}=g_1^V+\kappa_V+\lambda_V,\\ \text{(P-even, C-odd)}\quad&f_4^{WWV}=g_4^V,\\ \text{(P-odd, C-odd)}\quad&f_5^{WWV}=g_5^V,\\ \text{(P-odd, C-even)}\quad&f_6^{WWV}=\widetilde{\kappa}_V-\widetilde{\lambda}_V,\qquad f_7^{WWV}=-\frac{1}{2}\widetilde{\lambda}_V. \tag*{(5)} \end{aligned}

For V=γV = \gamma, these coefficients have relation to physical quantities (static moments) as follows:

qW=eg1γ(electric monopole, i.e., charge)μW=e2mW(g1γ+κγ+λγ)(magnetic dipole)dW=e2mW(κ~γ+λ~γ)(electric dipole)QWm=−emW2(κ~γ−λ~γ)(magnetic quadrupole)QWe=−emW2(κγ−λγ)(electric quadrupole)(6)\begin{aligned} q_W &= e g_1^\gamma&& \text{(electric monopole, i.e., charge)}\\ \mu_W &= \frac{e}{2m_W}\left(g_1^\gamma+\kappa_\gamma+\lambda_\gamma\right) && \text{(magnetic dipole)}\\ d_W &= \frac{e}{2m_W}\left(\widetilde{\kappa}_\gamma+\widetilde{\lambda}_\gamma\right) && \text{(electric dipole)}\\ Q_W^m &= -\frac{e}{m_W^2}\left(\widetilde{\kappa}_\gamma-\widetilde{\lambda}_\gamma\right) && \text{(magnetic quadrupole)}\\ Q_W^e &= -\frac{e}{m_W^2}\left(\kappa_\gamma-\lambda_\gamma\right) && \text{(electric quadrupole)} \tag*{(6)} \end{aligned}

Figure 2 shows the diagrams contributing to the C-violating P-conserving WWZWWZ and WWγWW\gamma processes. The WWZWWZ process receives its lowest-order C-violating P-conserving contributions at one loop, requiring at least two non-identical neutral and one charged scalar as shown in diagram ⓐ, and at least two non-identical charged and one neutral scalar as shown in diagram ⓑ. Therefore, beyond the particle content of the SM, a CP-violating Z2\mathbb{Z}_2-symmetric dark sector is needed with at least one scalar doublet and one complex scalar singlet for producing diagram ⓐ, and at least two extra scalar doublets for diagram ⓑ.

The C-violating P-conserving WWγWW\gamma process first appears at two loops. This is due to the unavoidable diagonal couplings of the photon leg, leading to cancellation of the CP phase of the W+Si−SjW^+S_i^-S_j and W−Si+SjW^-S_i^+S_j vertices, and therefore demoting the process into a CP conserving one. The extra internal loop in the WWγWW\gamma diagrams avoids such cancellation, and requires at least two non-identical neutral and two non-identical charged scalars as shown in diagram ⓒ, and at least three non-identical neutral and one charged scalar as shown in diagram ⓓ. Therefore, beyond the particle content of the SM, the WWγWW\gamma process requires a CP-violating Z2\mathbb{Z}_2-symmetric dark sector with at least two extra scalar doublets, i.e., our 3HDM framework discussed in Sec. 6 for generating diagram ⓒ and one doublet plus one singlet for diagram ⓓ.

The ZZV vertex with V = Z or γ\gamma

As a consequence of Bose statistics, the ZZ and γ\gamma self-couplings vanish identically, when all three particles are on-shell. The general form of the vertex function with a pair of on-shell ZZZZ and one off-shell boson V=Z,γV = Z,\gamma which is coupled to a conserved current can be constructed. The effective Lagrangian generating such vertices is

LZZV=emZ2[−f4ZZγ(∂μFμβ)Zα(∂αZβ)−f4ZZZ(∂μZμβ)Zα(∂αZβ)+f5ZZγ(∂σFσμ)Z~μβZβ+f5ZZZ(∂σZσμ)Z~μβZβ].(7)\mathcal{L}_{ZZV}=\frac{e}{m_Z^2}\left[-f_4^{ZZ\gamma}(\partial_\mu F^{\mu\beta})Z_\alpha(\partial^\alpha Z_\beta)-f_4^{ZZZ}(\partial_\mu Z^{\mu\beta})Z_\alpha(\partial^\alpha Z_\beta)+f_5^{ZZ\gamma}(\partial^\sigma F_{\sigma\mu})\widetilde{Z}^{\mu\beta}Z_\beta+f_5^{ZZZ}(\partial^\sigma Z_{\sigma\mu})\widetilde{Z}^{\mu\beta}Z_\beta\right]. \tag*{(7)}

where Z~μ=12ϵμνρσZρσ\widetilde{Z}_{\mu} = \frac{1}{2}\epsilon_{\mu\nu\rho\sigma}Z^{\rho\sigma} with Zμν=∂μZν−∂νZμZ_{\mu\nu} = \partial_{\mu}Z_{\nu} - \partial_{\nu}Z_{\mu} and similarly for the photon tensor FμνF_{\mu\nu}. The most general form of the ZZV∗ZZV^{*} vertex function can be written as

ΓZZVαβμ(q1,q2,q3)=i(q32−mV2)mZ2[−f4ZZV(q3αgμβ+q3βgμα)−f5ZZVϵμαβρ(q1−q2)ρ](8)\Gamma^{\alpha\beta\mu}_{ZZV}(q_{1},q_{2},q_{3}) = \frac{i(q_{3}^{2}-m_{V}^{2})}{m_{Z}^{2}}\left[-f_{4}^{ZZV}\left(q_{3}^{\alpha}g^{\mu\beta}+q_{3}^{\beta}g^{\mu\alpha}\right)-f_{5}^{ZZV}\epsilon^{\mu\alpha\beta\rho}(q_{1}-q_{2})_{\rho}\right] \tag*{(8)}

where q1q_{1}, q2q_{2}, q3q_{3} represent the outgoing momenta, as shown in Figure 3. Note that the coupling f4ZZVf_{4}^{ZZV} is C-odd, P-even while f5ZZVf_{5}^{ZZV} is C-odd, P-odd and hence CP-conserving.

Figure 3. The diagrams for the ZZVZZV vertices (V=γ,ZV = \gamma, Z and i≠j≠ki \ne j \ne k) with the effective vertex coefficient igZZVΓVαβμ(q1,q2,q3)ig_{ZZV}\Gamma_{V}^{\alpha\beta\mu}(q_{1},q_{2},q_{3}). Note that in the absence of the extra internal loop in ZZγZZ\gamma diagrams, the opposite CP phase of the ZSi±Sj∓ZS_{i}^{\pm}S_{j}^{\mp} vertices would cancel each other and demote the process into a CP conserving one.

Figure 3 shows the diagrams contributing to the C-violating P-conserving ZZZZZZ and ZZγZZ\gamma processes. These processes are absent at tree-level in the SM. The ZZZZZZ process receives its lowest-order C-violating P-conserving contributions at one loop, requiring at least three non-identical neutral scalars in diagram ⓐ, and at least three non-identical charged scalars in diagram ⓑ. Therefore, beyond the particle content of the SM, a CP-violating Z2Z_{2}-symmetric dark sector is needed with at least two extra scalar doublets to generate diagram ⓐ, and at least three extra scalar doublets for diagram ⓑ.10

The C-violating P-conserving ZZγZZ\gamma process first appears at two loops. This is due to the fact that in the absence of the extra internal loop the CP phase of the ZSi±Sj∓ZS_{i}^{\pm}S_{j}^{\mp} ZSi−Sj+Z S_i^- S_j^+ vertices would cancel each other and demote the process into a CP conserving one. To avoid such cancellation, one requires at least two non-identical charged and one neutral scalar to generate diagram ⓒ, and at least three non-identical charged scalars for diagram ⓓ. Therefore, beyond the particle content of the SM, the Z2Z_2-symmetric dark sector with at least two extra scalar doublets in diagram ⓒ, and at least three extra scalar doublets in diagram ⓓ.

The ZγVZ\gamma V vertex with V=ZV = Z or γ\gamma

The effective Lagrangian generating the ZγVZ\gamma V vertices (V=γ,ZV = \gamma, Z) is

LZγV=emZ2[−h1Zγ(∂σFσμ)ZβFμβ−h1ZγZ(∂σZσμ)ZβFμβ−1mZ2h2Zγ(∂α∂β□Fρμ)ZαFμβ−1mZ2h2ZγZ(∂α∂β(□+mZ2)Zμ)ZαFμβ−h3Zγ(∂σFσρ)ZαF~ρα−h3ZγZ(∂σZσρ)ZαF~ρα+12mZ2h4Zγ(□∂σFρα)ZσF~ρα+12mZ2h4ZγZ((□+mZ2)∂σZρα)ZσF~ρα].(9)\mathcal{L}_{Z\gamma V} = \frac{e}{m_Z^2}\left[-h_1^{Z\gamma}(\partial^\sigma F_{\sigma\mu})Z_\beta F^{\mu\beta}-h_1^{Z\gamma Z}(\partial^\sigma Z_{\sigma\mu})Z_\beta F^{\mu\beta} -\frac{1}{m_Z^2}h_2^{Z\gamma}(\partial_\alpha\partial_\beta\Box F_{\rho\mu})Z^\alpha F^{\mu\beta}-\frac{1}{m_Z^2}h_2^{Z\gamma Z}\left(\partial_\alpha\partial_\beta(\Box+m_Z^2)Z_\mu\right)Z^\alpha F^{\mu\beta} -h_3^{Z\gamma}(\partial_\sigma F^{\sigma\rho})Z^\alpha\widetilde{F}_{\rho\alpha}-h_3^{Z\gamma Z}(\partial_\sigma Z^{\sigma\rho})Z^\alpha\widetilde{F}_{\rho\alpha} +\frac{1}{2m_Z^2}h_4^{Z\gamma}(\Box\partial^\sigma F^{\rho\alpha})Z_\sigma\widetilde{F}_{\rho\alpha}+\frac{1}{2m_Z^2}h_4^{Z\gamma Z}\left((\Box+m_Z^2)\partial^\sigma Z^{\rho\alpha}\right)Z_\sigma\widetilde{F}_{\rho\alpha}\right]. \tag*{(9)}

Similar to the previous case, the most general form of the ZγVZ\gamma V vertex function with off-shell V=Z,γV = Z,\gamma which is coupled to a conserved current is

ΓZγVαβμ(q1,q2,q3)=i(q32−mV2)mZ2[h1ZγV(q2μgαβ−q2αgμβ)+1mZ2h2ZγVq3α[(q3q2)gμβ−q3μq2β]−h3ZγVϵμαβρq2ρ−1mZ2h4ZγVq3αϵμβρσq3ρq2σ],(10)\Gamma_{Z\gamma V}^{\alpha\beta\mu}(q_1,q_2,q_3)=\frac{i(q_3^2-m_V^2)}{m_Z^2}\left[h_1^{Z\gamma V}(q_2^\mu g^{\alpha\beta}-q_2^\alpha g^{\mu\beta})+\frac{1}{m_Z^2}h_2^{Z\gamma V}q_3^\alpha\left[(q_3q_2)g^{\mu\beta}-q_3^\mu q_2^\beta\right]-h_3^{Z\gamma V}\epsilon^{\mu\alpha\beta\rho}q_{2\rho}-\frac{1}{m_Z^2}h_4^{Z\gamma V}q_3^\alpha\epsilon^{\mu\beta\rho\sigma}q_{3\rho}q_{2\sigma}\right], \tag*{(10)}

where q1,q2,q3q_1,q_2,q_3 represent the outgoing momenta, as also shown in Figure 4. Note again that the couplings h1V,h2Vh_1^V,h_2^V are C-odd P-even, and h3V,h4Vh_3^V,h_4^V are C-odd P-odd and hence CP-even. For V=ZV = Z these coefficients refer to the following transition moments where EγE_\gamma is the photon energy:

Figure 4. The diagrams for the ZγVZ\gamma V vertices (V=γ,ZV=\gamma, Z and i≠j≠ki\ne j\ne k) with the effective vertex coefficient igZγVΓVαβμ(q1,q2,q3)ig_{Z\gamma V}\Gamma^{\alpha\beta\mu}_{V}(q_1,q_2,q_3). Note that both these processes require at least two loops for a non-zero C-violating P-conserving CP violation, and at least two extra Higgs doublets beyond the particle content of the SM.

qZ=0(electric monopole, i.e., charge)q_Z=0 \qquad\text{(electric monopole, i.e., charge)}
μZ=−e2mZEγ2mZ2(h1Z−h2Z)(magnetic dipole)\mu_Z=\frac{-e}{\sqrt{2}m_Z}\frac{E_\gamma^2}{m_Z^2}(h_1^Z-h_2^Z) \qquad\text{(magnetic dipole)}
dZ=−e2mZEγ2mZ2(h3Z−h4Z)(electric dipole)d_Z=\frac{-e}{\sqrt{2}m_Z}\frac{E_\gamma^2}{m_Z^2}(h_3^Z-h_4^Z) \qquad\text{(electric dipole)}
QZm=210emZ2h3Z(magnetic quadrupole)Q_Z^m=\frac{2\sqrt{10}e}{m_Z^2}h_3^Z \qquad\text{(magnetic quadrupole)}
QZe=210emZ2h1Z(electric quadrupole)(11)Q_Z^e=\frac{2\sqrt{10}e}{m_Z^2}h_1^Z \qquad\text{(electric quadrupole)} \tag*{(11)}

Figure 4 shows the diagrams contributing to the C-violating P-conserving ZγZZ\gamma Z and ZγγZ\gamma\gamma processes. These processes are absent at tree-level in the SM, and receive their lowest-order C-violating P-conserving contributions at two loop, requiring at least two non-identical charged and one neutral scalar to generate diagrams ⓐ and ⓑ. Therefore, beyond the particle content of the SM, a CP-violating Z2\mathbb{Z}_2-symmetric dark sector is needed with at least two extra scalar doublets, as in our 3HDM framework.

Embedding the TGC processes into EDM diagrams

The TGC form-factor parametrisations employed in this work are defined for the specific on-shell and off-shell configurations indicated for each vertex. In particular, the off-shell gauge-boson leg is assumed to couple to a conserved current, satisfying qμJμ=0q_\mu J^\mu=0, so that tensor structures proportional to its momentum do not contribute to the amplitude. While this condition follows from electromagnetic current conservation for an off-shell photon, it represents an additional restriction for off-shell ZZ and WW bosons.

Within these kinematic conditions, embedding the C-violating, P-conserving TGC structures into amplitudes involving only C- and P-conserving interactions, such as vectorial gauge–fermion couplings, cannot generate the C-even, P-odd structure required for an EDM. However, the SM also contains axial gauge–fermion interactions, which violate both C and P. Their inclusion renders an EDM contribution compatible with the overall discrete-symmetry quantum numbers, although it does not establish that such a contribution is non-zero.

Importantly, the reduced TGC form factors considered here do not provide a complete description of these higher-order embeddings. In particular, fully off-shell V1∗V2∗V3∗V_1^*V_2^*V_3^* vertices may contain additional longitudinal and momentum-dependent structures that are absent or do not contribute under the restricted kinematic conditions adopted here [38, 39]. Whether these structures contribute to an EDM depends on their coefficients in the underlying theory and on the constraints imposed by gauge invariance, Bose symmetry and the complete fermionic amplitude.11

The same question has been studied for fermionic interactions that are T-odd and P-even, the class to which our CP violation belongs. Refs. [40–42] showed that such interactions do induce EDMs once they are dressed with the parity-violating weak interactions of the SM, and that the resulting EDM bounds are strong. Those results concern fermionic contact operators, whereas the sources considered here are purely bosonic and enter the SM sector only through gauge-boson vertices; they nevertheless show that the separation between C-odd, P-even sources and EDMs is not guaranteed by symmetry alone once the full electroweak theory is included. A sharper version of the question can be formulated in the SMEFT. At dimension six, all CP-odd bosonic operators, QW~Q_{\widetilde{W}}, QG~Q_{\widetilde{G}}, QφW~Q_{\varphi\widetilde{W}}, QφB~Q_{\varphi\widetilde{B}}, QφG~Q_{\varphi\widetilde{G}} and QφW~BQ_{\varphi\widetilde{W}B}, contain the Levi-Civita tensor and are P-odd. They therefore cannot be generated by loops of inert scalars and gauge bosons alone, and first arise at the lowest order at which a chiral SM fermion loop supplies the ϵ\epsilon-tensor. The EDM then requires at least one further loop.

We therefore put forward the following conjecture:

The C-odd, P-even CP violation originating in the inert scalar sector remains inaccessible to EDM observables even after the corresponding interactions are embedded into the complete electroweak theory.

Establishing this conjecture requires demonstrating that potentially relevant contributions involving axial fermionic currents either vanish or cancel in the complete gauge-invariant amplitude, in contrast with the fermionic T-odd, P-even interactions of Refs. [40–42]. Should it fail, the arguments above imply that any EDM contribution arises only beyond the order at which the P-odd bosonic operators are first generated, and carries additional electroweak suppression. Such a demonstration may be obtained through an explicit calculation of the EDM form factor or through a more general analysis of the symmetry and tensor properties of the fully off-shell amplitudes. A systematic investigation of these contributions is in progress and will be presented in subsequent work.

C-selection rules from co-occurrence

So far, we have established that a non-zero f4Vf_4^V, h1Vh_1^V or h2Vh_2^V signals CP violation in a P-even, C-odd structure, without requiring simultaneous observation of any other channel. These form factors can also be induced at higher order by a P-odd CP-violating source combined with the parity-violating weak interactions of the SM; such contributions are, however, bounded by the EDM constraints on that source, so that a value significantly above this bound points to a genuinely P-even origin. These form factors provide quantitative probes of C-violating, P-conserving interactions. In this section, we identify signatures that require simultaneous observation of certain processes to establish the presence of C violation.

Co-occurrence, not a single forbidden channel

As discussed in Ref. [24], simultaneous observation of suitably chosen processes can provide evidence for the violation of discrete symmetries without requiring an independent assignment of the corresponding quantum numbers to the initial state. In the present context, a particularly transparent example is the observation of the same neutral scalar mass eigenstate, hh, in both of the following channels12

h→γγandh→γγγ(12)h \to\gamma\gamma\qquad\text{and} \qquad h \to\gamma\gamma\gamma \tag*{(12)}

Since the two- and three-photon final states have opposite C eigenvalues, C(γγ)=+1C(\gamma\gamma)=+1 and C(γγγ)=−1C(\gamma\gamma\gamma)=-1, these transitions cannot both conserve C for a single initial state. Their co-occurrence therefore constitutes a selection-rule test of charge-conjugation invariance, independently of any prior C assignment to hh.

This observation should, however, be distinguished from the identification of a new source of C-violating CP violation. Since the weak interactions of the SM already violate C, the observation of both channels would not, by itself, establish that the violation originates in the extended scalar sector. Such an interpretation requires identifying contributions beyond the SM expectation and establishing their discrete-symmetry properties.

The same selection-rule argument can be extended to interactions involving neutral electroweak gauge bosons. In a C-conserving theory, a neutral scalar with a definite C eigenvalue cannot simultaneously couple to two- and three-vector final states with opposite C assignments. Candidate comparisons therefore include h→ZZh \to ZZ, h→Zγh \to Z\gamma and h→γγh \to\gamma\gamma, together with the corresponding three-vector processes h→ZZZh \to ZZZ, h→ZZγh \to ZZ\gamma, h→Zγγh \to Z\gamma\gamma and h→γγγh \to\gamma\gamma\gamma. For the SM-like Higgs boson, the ZZ bosons in the three-vector channels are necessarily off shell where required by kinematics. These comparisons illustrate the general C-selection-rule principle; establishing the observability of the dark-sector CP-violating contributions to these processes requires dedicated calculations of the corresponding amplitudes and SM backgrounds.

This strategy has well-established precedents. The decay π0→3γ\pi^0 \to3\gamma provides a classic test of C invariance, since the neutral pion has C=+1C=+1, whereas the three-photon final state has C=−1C=-1 [43]. Similarly, para-positronium (C=+1C=+1) decays predominantly into an even number of photons, while ortho-positronium (C=−1C=-1) decays predominantly into an odd number, and searches for C-forbidden positronium decays continue to test this selection rule [44]. The proposed observables extend the same C-selection-rule principle to the scalar sector.

Static multipole moments and the electron EDM

Since the f4Vf_{4}^{V}, h1Vh_{1}^{V} and h2Vh_{2}^{V} type vertices and the co-occurrence processes discussed so far are loop-level probes, it is natural to ask whether simpler, single-particle observables, namely static multipole moments, could serve the same diagnostic purpose. In this section we classify the static moments by their discrete-symmetry quantum numbers, identify the class that shares those of our CP violation, and explain why static moments cannot provide the C-selection-rule tests of § 4.

Any static charge and current distribution can be expanded in electric and magnetic 2ℓ2\ell-pole moments (ℓ=0,1,2,…\ell= 0, 1, 2, \ldots). A complete description of the source, including its contact interactions with external currents, also requires the toroidal (anapole) family. As classical quantities, all three families are C-odd, since they are linear in the charge density or the current. Electric moments have (P,T)=((−1)ℓ,+)(\mathrm{P}, \mathrm{T}) = ((-1)^{\ell}, +), magnetic moments (P,T)=((−1)ℓ+1,−)(\mathrm{P}, \mathrm{T}) = ((-1)^{\ell+1}, -), and toroidal moments (P,T)=((−1)ℓ,−)(\mathrm{P}, \mathrm{T}) = ((-1)^{\ell}, -). By the Wigner-Eckart theorem, a diagonal static moment of a particle with spin J⃗\vec{J} is proportional to a rank-ℓ\ell tensor built from J⃗\vec{J}, which has P=+1\mathrm{P} = +1 and T=(−1)ℓ\mathrm{T} = (-1)^{\ell}, and exists only for ℓ≤2J\ell\leq2J. Whenever the classical (P,T)(\mathrm{P},\mathrm{T}) properties of a moment differ from those of the spin tensor, the corresponding interaction operator violates that symmetry. The C quantum number of the operator is then inferred assuming CPT-invariance.13 The resulting general rule is given in Table 1, and the explicit assignments up to ℓ=3\ell= 3 are listed in Table 2.

FamilyMoment (P,T)CPTCouples to
Electric 2ℓ2^{\ell}((−1)ℓ,+)((-1)^{\ell}, +)+(−1)ℓ(-1)^{\ell}(−1)ℓ(-1)^{\ell}∇ℓ−1E⃗\nabla^{\ell-1}\vec{E}
Magnetic 2ℓ2^{\ell}((−1)ℓ+1,−)((-1)^{\ell+1}, -)+(−1)ℓ+1(-1)^{\ell+1}(−1)ℓ+1(-1)^{\ell+1}∇ℓ−1B⃗\nabla^{\ell-1}\vec{B}
Toroidal 2ℓ2^{\ell}((−1)ℓ,−)((-1)^{\ell}, -)−(−1)ℓ(-1)^{\ell}(−1)ℓ+1(-1)^{\ell+1}∇ℓ−1j⃗ext\nabla^{\ell-1}\vec{j}_{\mathrm{ext}} (contact)

Table 1. C, P and T assignments of the interaction operators of the electric, magnetic and toroidal 2ℓ2^{\ell}-pole moments of a particle with spin JJ, together with the (P,T) of the corresponding classical moment. The (P,T) of the operator follows from comparing the classical moment with the rank-ℓ\ell spin tensor (P= +1, T= (−1)ℓ(-1)^{\ell}), and the C of the operator then follows assuming CPT-invariance.

ℓ\ellMomentCPTJmin⁡J_{\min}
0Charge (charge radius)+++0
0Magnetic monopole+−−0
1Electric dipole dd (Schiff moment)+−−1/2
1Magnetic dipole μ\mu+++1/2
1Anapole aa (toroidal dipole)−−+1/2
2Electric quadrupole QEQ_E+++1
2Magnetic quadrupole QMQ_M+−−1
2Toroidal quadrupole T2T_2−+−1
3Electric octupole+−−3/2
3Magnetic octupole+++3/2
3Toroidal octupole−−+3/2

Table 2. C, P and T assignments of the interaction operators of the static electromagnetic multipole moments up to ℓ=3\ell= 3. Jmin⁡J_{\min} is the smallest spin supporting the moment, from ℓ≤2J\ell\le2J; a spin-0 particle therefore supports only the rank-0 moments, i.e. the electric charge (and in a P- and T-violating theory, a magnetic charge) independently of any other discrete symmetry.

The pattern alternates with ℓ\ell and produces four classes:

  • ordinary moments, i.e., even-ℓ\ell electric and odd-ℓ\ell magnetic (charge, magnetic dipole, electric quadrupole, . . .), with C = P = T = +1, present in any theory and carrying no information about new physics,

  • EDM-type moments, i.e., odd-ℓ\ell electric and even-ℓ\ell magnetic (electric dipole, magnetic quadrupole, electric octupole, . . .), with C = +1 and P = T = −1, which vanish unless the dynamics violates P and T,

  • anapole-type moments, i.e., odd-ℓ\ell toroidal (anapole, toroidal octupole, . . .), with C = P = −1 and T = +1, which are CP-even and require only the P (and C) violation already present in the weak interactions,

  • toroidal moments with even-ℓ\ell (toroidal quadrupole, . . .), with C = T = −1 and P = +1, which are CP-odd while conserving P.

The EDM belongs to the C-even, P-odd and T-odd class. The CP violation originating in the inert scalar sector is instead C-odd and P-even, i.e., it shares the discrete-symmetry quantum numbers of the last class above, which first appear at rank two and hence require a particle with J≥1J \ge1. In nuclear physics, interactions of this class are known as time-reversal-violating, parity-conserving (TVPC) interactions; their EDM constraints were discussed in § 3.2. For the W boson this class is represented by the g4γg_{4}^{\gamma} coupling of Eq. (5), which is C-odd and P-even, just as the anapole-type and EDM-type classes are represented in Eq. (6) by g5γg_5^\gamma and by κ~γ\tilde{\kappa}_\gamma, λ~γ\tilde{\lambda}_\gamma, respectively.14 In the I(2+1)HDM, this coupling first arises at two loops, as discussed in § 3. The distinction between the EDM-type and the even-ℓ\ell toroidal classes underlies the EDM-protection mechanism proposed in this work. Whether it extends to the complete electroweak theory, including parity-violating fermionic interactions, remains the subject of our conjecture.

For a spin-zero particle, the Wigner–Eckart theorem forbids permanent static electromagnetic multipole moments of rank ℓ≥1\ell\ge1, independently of the discrete symmetries of the underlying theory. In particular, the inert scalars of the I(2+1)HDM cannot possess permanent electric dipole moments, nor any other static electromagnetic moment of rank ℓ≥1\ell\ge1. This does not exclude electromagnetic transition form factors or higher-point interactions, through which CP violation in the scalar sector may manifest itself; the triple-gauge structures of § 3 provide examples of such observables.

Why static moments do not provide C-selection-rule tests

The simultaneous observation of different electromagnetic multipole moments of a single particle does not provide the same type of C-selection-rule test as the co-occurrence of transitions into final states with incompatible C eigenvalues. Such a test requires an initial state of definite C and a transition into final states whose C eigenvalues can be compared with it. Static moments of fermions fail on both counts. Charged fermions are not C eigenstates, whereas neutral self-conjugate (Majorana) fermions are, but their diagonal moments are restricted by the Majorana condition itself. Moreover, a static moment is a property of a single state rather than a transition. We discuss the two cases in turn, using the relation between the bilinears of a fermion field and of its charge conjugate ψc=CψˉT\psi^c = C\bar{\psi}^{T}, which after normal ordering reads

ψˉcΓψc=ηΓψˉΓψ,ηΓ={+1,Γ=1, iγ5, γμγ5,−1,Γ=γμ, σμν, σμνγ5.(13)\bar{\psi}^{c}\Gamma\psi^{c}=\eta_{\Gamma}\bar{\psi}\Gamma\psi,\qquad \eta_{\Gamma}= \begin{cases} +1, & \Gamma=1,\,i\gamma_5,\,\gamma^\mu\gamma_5,\\ -1, & \Gamma=\gamma^\mu,\,\sigma^{\mu\nu},\,\sigma^{\mu\nu}\gamma_5. \end{cases} \tag*{(13)}

For a spin-12\frac{1}{2} particle, the condition ℓ≤2J\ell\le2J restricts the diagonal moments to the charge, magnetic dipole, electric dipole and anapole, i.e. to the four elastic form factors F1F_1, F2F_2, F3F_3 and FAF_A, multiplying γμ\gamma^\mu, σμνqν\sigma^{\mu\nu}q_\nu, σμνγ5qν\sigma^{\mu\nu}\gamma_5q_\nu and (q2γμ−q̸qμ)γ5(q^2\gamma^\mu-\not{q}q^\mu)\gamma_5, respectively [45, 46].

Charged fermions. An electron is not a C eigenstate, since charge conjugation maps it onto a positron, whose moments are fixed by those of the electron through CPT.15 The existence of its magnetic dipole moment therefore imposes no C assignment that could be contradicted by the observation of an EDM. Moreover, the electron EDM is extracted from the electromagnetic form factor of a charged fermion rather than from a transition between states of definite C: an isolated on-shell electron cannot radiate a real photon while remaining on shell, and EDM measurements instead probe the effective dipole interaction through processes involving external electromagnetic fields. The C-selection-rule argument based on incompatible final-state eigenvalues is therefore not applicable to the electron EDM.

Neutral fermions. For a self-conjugate Majorana fermion, χ=χc\chi= \chi^{c}, Eq. (13) gives χˉΓχ=−χˉΓχ=0\bar{\chi} \Gamma\chi= -\bar{\chi} \Gamma\chi= 0 for every structure with ηΓ=−1\eta_{\Gamma} = -1. The vector and tensor bilinears χˉγμχ\bar{\chi}\gamma^{\mu}\chi, χˉσμνχ\bar{\chi}\sigma^{\mu\nu}\chi and χˉσμνγ5χ\bar{\chi}\sigma^{\mu\nu}\gamma_{5}\chi therefore vanish identically, and so do the diagonal charge, magnetic dipole and electric dipole moments [47, 48]. This is an algebraic consequence of the Majorana condition on the field, and holds independently of whether the underlying interactions conserve C, P or CP. The axial-vector bilinear has ηΓ=+1\eta_{\Gamma} = +1 and survives, so the anapole is the only diagonal electromagnetic form factor of a Majorana fermion. Off-diagonal bilinears χˉiΓχj\bar{\chi}_{i}\Gamma\chi_{j} with i≠ji \ne j are not subject to this constraint, so transition magnetic and electric dipole moments between different Majorana mass eigenstates may exist.

Thus, neither the simultaneous observation of different static moments of a charged fermion nor the pattern of diagonal moments of a Majorana fermion provides the co-occurrence test considered here. The distinguishing feature of the proposed selection-rule tests is instead the observation of transitions of the same initial state into final states with incompatible C assignments, as shown in the two- and three-photon decay channels of § 4.

A concrete realisation of dark CP violation

We now present a minimal phenomenological model realising the exact bosonic C-violating P-conserving sources. A Z2\mathbb{Z}_{2}-symmetric 3HDM potential can be written as V3HDM=V0+VZ2V_{\mathrm{3HDM}} = V_{0} + V_{\mathbb{Z}_{2}}, with

V0=−∑i=13μi2(ϕi†ϕi)+∑i,j=13λij(ϕi†ϕi)(ϕj†ϕj)+∑i,j=1i≠j3λij′(ϕi†ϕj)(ϕj†ϕi),VZ2=−μ122(ϕ1†ϕ2)+λ1(ϕ1†ϕ2)2+λ2(ϕ2†ϕ3)2+λ3(ϕ3†ϕ1)2+⋯+h.c.,(14)\begin{aligned} V_{0} &= -\sum_{i=1}^{3}\mu_{i}^{2}(\phi_{i}^{\dagger}\phi_{i})+\sum_{i,j=1}^{3}\lambda_{ij}(\phi_{i}^{\dagger}\phi_{i})(\phi_{j}^{\dagger}\phi_{j})+\sum_{\substack{i,j=1\\i\ne j}}^{3}\lambda'_{ij}(\phi_{i}^{\dagger}\phi_{j})(\phi_{j}^{\dagger}\phi_{i}),\\ V_{\mathbb{Z}_{2}} &= -\mu_{12}^{2}(\phi_{1}^{\dagger}\phi_{2})+\lambda_{1}(\phi_{1}^{\dagger}\phi_{2})^{2}+\lambda_{2}(\phi_{2}^{\dagger}\phi_{3})^{2}+\lambda_{3}(\phi_{3}^{\dagger}\phi_{1})^{2}+\cdots+\mathrm{h.c.}, \tag*{(14)} \end{aligned}

where V0V_{0} is invariant under any phase rotation and VZ2V_{\mathbb{Z}_{2}} is a collection of extra terms which realise the Z2\mathbb{Z}_{2} symmetry group, ensuring the potential respects this symmetry and no larger one [49, 50]. The three doublets ϕ1,2,3\phi_{1,2,3} carry Z2\mathbb{Z}_{2} charges (−,−,+)(-,-,+), respectively, and can be expressed as

ϕ1=(H1+H1+iA12),ϕ2=(H2+H2+iA22),ϕ3=(G+v+h+iG02),(15)\phi_{1}=\begin{pmatrix}H_{1}^{+}\\ \dfrac{H_{1}+iA_{1}}{\sqrt{2}}\end{pmatrix},\qquad \phi_{2}=\begin{pmatrix}H_{2}^{+}\\ \dfrac{H_{2}+iA_{2}}{\sqrt{2}}\end{pmatrix},\qquad \phi_{3}=\begin{pmatrix}G^{+}\\ \dfrac{v+h+iG^{0}}{\sqrt{2}}\end{pmatrix}, \tag*{(15)}

with the Z2\mathbb{Z}_2-odd doublets as inert (⟨ϕ1⟩=⟨ϕ2⟩=0\langle\phi_1\rangle=\langle\phi_2\rangle=0) and the Z2\mathbb{Z}_2-even doublet as active (⟨ϕ3⟩=v2\langle\phi_3\rangle=\frac{v}{\sqrt{2}}) playing the role of the SM Higgs doublet, where hh is the 125 GeV SM-like Higgs and G±G^\pm, G0G^0 the Goldstone bosons. Because the vacuum respects the Z2\mathbb{Z}_2 symmetry, the active and inert sectors do not mix: hh retains exactly the tree-level couplings of the SM Higgs boson, CP violation is confined to the inert sector where it appears explicitly through the complex parameters of VZ2V_{\mathbb{Z}_2}.

Diagonalising the resulting charged and neutral mass matrices yields four CP-mixed neutral eigenstates S1,2,3,4S_{1,2,3,4} and two charged mass eigenstates S1±,S2±S_1^\pm,S_2^\pm,

\begin{pmatrix} S_1 \\ S_2 \\ S_3 \\ S_4 \end{pmatrix} =R^n \begin{pmatrix} H_1 \\ A_1 \\ H_2 \\ A_2 \end{pmatrix}, \qquad \begin{pmatrix} S_1^\pm\\ S_2^\pm\end{pmatrix} =R^c \begin{pmatrix} H_1^\pm\\ H_2^\pm\end{pmatrix}, \tag*{(16)}\end{pmatrix}

where the rotation matrices RnR^n and RcR^c are derived from the potential. For the discussion here, the relevant terms in the Lagrangian are

Lgauge⊃gZSiSjZμ(Si∂μSj−Sj∂μSi)+gZSi±Sj∓Zμ(Si±∂μSj∓−Sj∓∂μSi±)\mathcal{L}_{\mathrm{gauge}}\supset g_{ZS_iS_j}Z_\mu(S_i\partial^\mu S_j-S_j\partial^\mu S_i)+g_{ZS_i^\pm S_j^\mp}Z_\mu(S_i^\pm\partial^\mu S_j^\mp-S_j^\mp\partial^\mu S_i^\pm)
+gW±Si∓SjWμ±(Si∓∂μSj−Sj∂μSi∓).(17){}+g_{W^\pm S_i^\mp S_j}W_\mu^\pm(S_i^\mp\partial^\mu S_j-S_j\partial^\mu S_i^\mp). \tag*{(17)}

This spectrum and coupling structure is what populates the bosonic loops of § 3 with non-identical inert scalars in the loops. For example, the magnitude of the CP-violating component of the ZZZZZZ vertex of diagram (a) in Figure 3 is proportional to the CP-violating weak-basis invariant [51, 52]

JCP∝(mSi2−mSj2)(mSj2−mSk2)(mSk2−mSi2)mSi2mSj2mSk2(gZSiSj)(gZSjSk)(gZSkSi),(18)J_{\mathrm{CP}}\propto\frac{(m_{S_i}^2-m_{S_j}^2)(m_{S_j}^2-m_{S_k}^2)(m_{S_k}^2-m_{S_i}^2)}{m_{S_i}^2m_{S_j}^2m_{S_k}^2}(g_{ZS_iS_j})(g_{ZS_jS_k})(g_{ZS_kS_i}), \tag*{(18)}

which is non-zero only when the scalars SiS_i, SjS_j, SkS_k are non-identical. The C-odd P-even form factor f4f_4 for this process is given by a linear combination of the three-point tensor coefficient functions C002C_{002} (in the notation of the LoopTools package [53]) and calculated to be [54]

f4Z=mZ22π2e(q32−mZ2)(gZS2S3)(gZS1S3)(gZS1S2)∑i,j,k=13ϵijkC002(mZ2,mZ2,q32,mi2,mj2,mk2),(19)f_4^Z=\frac{m_Z^2}{2\pi^2 e\left(q_3^2-m_Z^2\right)}(g_{ZS_2S_3})(g_{ZS_1S_3})(g_{ZS_1S_2})\sum_{i,j,k=1}^{3}\epsilon_{ijk}C_{002}(m_Z^2,m_Z^2,q_3^2,m_i^2,m_j^2,m_k^2), \tag*{(19)}

where mi,j,km_{i,j,k} stand for the mass of the Si,j,kS_{i,j,k} scalars.

Conclusions and outlook

Electric dipole moments (EDMs) are among the most sensitive probes of new sources of CP violation, and their increasingly stringent experimental bounds place severe constraints on many baryogenesis-motivated extensions of the Standard Model (SM). In this work, we have identified a class of CP violation that is separated from these constraints by its discrete-symmetry properties, rather than only by small couplings or loop suppression. The key distinction lies in the discrete-symmetry structure: flavour-diagonal EDM operators are C-even and P-odd, whereas CP violation originating in a renormalisable scalar–gauge sector is C-odd and P-even. Indeed, the scalar and gauge interactions preserve parity, irrespective of the CP-violating scalar self-couplings, since they contain no parity-odd Lorentz structures. Consequently, CP violation confined to this sector cannot, by itself, generate the C-even, P-odd structure required for an EDM.

The I(2+1)HDM provides a concrete realisation of this mechanism. CP violation originates exclusively from the complex parameters of VZ2V_{Z_2} and remains confined to the inert scalar sector. The exact Z2Z_2 symmetry prevents mixing between the inert and active doublets and forbids Yukawa couplings of the inert scalars. As a result, the conventional one-loop and Barr–Zee contributions that dominate the electron EDM in CP-violating scalar extensions, such as the aligned 2HDM discussed in Appendix B, are absent, independently of the inert scalar mass spectrum. The presence of two inert doublets is essential: a single inert doublet cannot accommodate a physical CP-violating phase, while removing the exact Z2Z_2 symmetry in a 2HDM generally allows CP violation to enter the fermionic sector. A dark sector containing one inert doublet and a complex singlet can reproduce part of the phenomenology, notably a reduced one-loop WWZWWZ contribution and the two-loop WWγWW\gamma contribution, whereas the ZZZZZZ, ZZγZZ\gamma and ZγVZ\gamma V vertices require two inert doublets. The I(2+1)HDM therefore represents the minimal realisation of the complete set of signatures investigated in this work.

Rather than manifesting itself through EDMs, this form of CP violation gives rise to a distinct set of observables. In triple gauge couplings, it contributes to the C-odd, P-even form factors f4Vf_4^V and h1,2Vh_{1,2}^V, which vanish in the C-conserving limit. In the I(2+1)HDM, the f4WWZf_4^{WWZ} and f4ZZZf_4^{ZZZ} form factors arise at one loop and are proportional to the CP-odd weak-basis invariants. By contrast, the WWγWW\gamma, ZZγZZ\gamma and ZγVZ\gamma V vertices first receive CP-violating contributions at two loops, as the diagonal nature of the photon couplings prevents the CP-violating phase from entering at one loop. Complementary probes are provided by selection-rule tests involving decays of the same neutral scalar into final states of opposite C parity, such as h→ZVh \to ZV alongside h→ZZZh \to ZZZ or ZZγZZ\gamma, or h→γγh \to\gamma\gamma alongside h→γγγh \to\gamma\gamma\gamma, the latter arising only at three loops in the model. Since the SM already violates C, and generates the C-odd, P-odd structures f5Vf_5^V and h3,4Vh_{3,4}^V, these tests point to the inert sector only once the P-even components are isolated and found to exceed the SM expectation. Static moments, on the other hand, do not provide equivalent tests: spin-zero inert scalars possess no static electromagnetic moments beyond their electric charge, while the C-transformation properties of fermionic moments do not, by themselves, reveal C violation in the underlying interactions.

An important qualification concerns the extent to which this symmetry-based separation protects the theory from EDM constraints. Within the scalar–gauge sector, parity conservation excludes the generation of an EDM operator, while the exact Z2Z_2 symmetry eliminates contributions requiring direct inert-scalar couplings to fermions. However, these properties do not imply that CC and PP are separately conserved in the full theory. The chiral gauge interactions of SM fermions violate both symmetries, and embedding a CC-odd, PP-even bosonic vertex into an amplitude involving non-conserved axial currents can, in principle, produce a CC-even, PP-odd contribution. For fermionic T-odd, P-even interactions such contributions are known to arise [40–42]. For the purely bosonic sources considered here, establishing whether they survive requires an analysis of the fully off-shell gauge-boson vertices and their embedding into complete gauge-invariant amplitudes; this is the content of our conjecture. In any case, since the P-odd bosonic operators of the SMEFT cannot be generated without a chiral fermion loop, any resulting EDM contribution arises only at higher loop order and carries additional electroweak suppression. A systematic investigation of these effects is underway.

Beyond their distinctive collider signatures, CC-odd, PP-even sources of CP violation are particularly interesting in the context of baryogenesis. The Sakharov conditions require both CC and CP violation, making this class of interactions a natural candidate for generating the baryon asymmetry without relying on the conventional sources of CP violation constrained by EDM searches. Gauge interactions can provide a mechanism for communicating a dark-sector asymmetry to the visible sector, as demonstrated in a primordial setting in Ref. [12]. Furthermore, the I(2+1)HDM can accommodate a strong first-order electroweak phase transition, providing another essential ingredient for electroweak baryogenesis [13]. A dedicated investigation of the asymmetry-transfer mechanism and its cosmological implications will be presented separately.

As EDM experiments involving polar molecules, ultracold neutrons, diamagnetic atoms and storage rings continue to improve in sensitivity, the CC-odd, PP-even sources of CP violation identified here remain largely inaccessible to their conventional probes. Their phenomenology must instead be explored through complementary observables, particularly anomalous triple gauge couplings and C-sensitive scalar decays at the HL-LHC and future lepton colliders. The observation of such signatures, especially in the continued absence of an EDM signal, would provide compelling motivation for a qualitatively different origin of CP violation, one rooted in the symmetry structure of an extended scalar sector and potentially relevant to the generation of the baryon asymmetry of the Universe.

Acknowledgments

The author is grateful to David E. Kaplan for numerous discussions and to Raman Sundrum, Michael Ramsey-Musolf and Anne-Katherine Burns for valuable comments. The author acknowledges financial support from Research Ireland grant 21/PATHS/9475 (MOREHIGGS) under the SFI-IRC Pathway Programme.

Calculation of electron EDM contributions

The electron electric dipole moment (eEDM), ded_e, is defined through the effective Lagrangian

Lde=−i2de(eˉσμνγ5e)Fμν,(20)\mathcal{L}_{d_e}=-\frac{i}{2}d_e(\bar{e}\sigma^{\mu\nu}\gamma_5e)F_{\mu\nu}, \tag*{(20)}

where FμνF_{\mu\nu} is the electromagnetic field strength tensor and σμν=i2[γμ,γν]\sigma^{\mu\nu}=\frac{i}{2}[\gamma^\mu,\gamma^\nu]. The relevant part of the Lagrangian mediating these interactions can be written as

L⊃eme8π2[cL(eˉσμνPLe)Fμν+cR(eˉσμνPRe)Fμν+h.c.],(21)\mathcal{L}\supset\frac{em_e}{8\pi^2}\left[c_L(\bar{e}\sigma^{\mu\nu}P_Le)F_{\mu\nu}+c_R(\bar{e}\sigma^{\mu\nu}P_Re)F_{\mu\nu}+\mathrm{h.c.}\right], \tag*{(21)}

where PL,R=12(1∓γ5)P_{L,R}=\frac{1}{2}(1\mp\gamma_5) are the left- and right-handed projection operators. Expanding Eq. (21) explicitly gives

L⊃eme8π2Re⁡(cL+cR∗)(eˉσμνe)Fμν−ieme8π2Im⁡(cL+cR∗)(eˉσμνγ5e)Fμν,(22)\mathcal{L}\supset\frac{em_e}{8\pi^2}\operatorname{Re}(c_L+c_R^*)(\bar{e}\sigma^{\mu\nu}e)F_{\mu\nu}-\frac{iem_e}{8\pi^2}\operatorname{Im}(c_L+c_R^*)(\bar{e}\sigma^{\mu\nu}\gamma_5e)F_{\mu\nu}, \tag*{(22)}

from which one can identify

de=eme4π2Im⁡(cL+cR∗).(23)d_e=\frac{em_e}{4\pi^2}\operatorname{Im}(c_L+c_R^*). \tag*{(23)}

The Wilson coefficients cLc_L and cRc_R are calculated separately for each loop diagram contributing to these observables.

The ordinary CP-violating 2HDM with a softly broken Z2\mathbb{Z}_2 symmetry [55,56] (or similar scalar extensions) possesses scalar-fermion couplings already at tree level, which consequently contribute to EDMs through the usual one- and two-loop Barr-Zee diagrams as shown below.

One-loop contributions of scalars

The one-loop diagram contributing to ded_e is shown in Figure 5, where hih_i are the neutral scalars of the model with couplings to electrons denoted by YeehiY_{ee}^{h_i}. The charged scalar mediated version of this diagram is sub-dominant and is therefore neglected [57]. The one-loop contributions to ded_e are

Figure 5. The 1-loop diagram mediated by neutral scalars hih_i contributing to eEDM.

de1-loop=eme16π2∑i=1nIm⁡[(Yeehi)2]∫01dx∫0xdy(y−1)me2[y(y−x)+(1−y)]+mhi2y,(24)d_e^{\text{1-loop}}=\frac{em_e}{16\pi^2}\sum_{i=1}^{n}\operatorname{Im}\left[(Y_{ee}^{h_i})^2\right]\int_0^1 dx\int_0^x dy\frac{(y-1)}{m_e^2[y(y-x)+(1-y)]+m_{h_i}^2y}, \tag*{(24)}

where nn is the number of neutral scalars mediating the loop in Figure 5.

Two-loop contributions of scalars

The dominant two-loop contributions to ded_e arise from the Barr-Zee diagrams mediated by the scalar states, shown in Figure 6. Diagrams with a ZZ boson in the loop (instead of a photon) are suppressed by a factor of (14−sin⁡2θW)\left(\frac{1}{4}-\sin^{2}\theta_{W}\right), making their contribution almost two orders of magnitude smaller than the photon-mediated diagrams; these are therefore neglected. Similarly, contributions from charged scalars are sub-dominant and are also neglected [58]. For the two-loop calculations, we use the results of Ref. [59].

Figure 6. The Barr–Zee diagrams with largest contributions to eEDM.

The two-loop contributions to ded_e from heavy fermion loops (f=t,b,c,τf=t,b,c,\tau) and WW boson loops are16

de,f2-loop=e3π2(αGFv22πmf)∑i=1n[Im⁡(Yeehi)Re⁡(Yffhi)f(zfhi)+Re⁡(Yeehi)Im⁡(Yffhi)g(zfhi)],(25)d_{e,f}^{2\text{-loop}}=\frac{e}{3\pi^{2}}\left(\frac{\alpha G_{F}v^{2}}{\sqrt{2}\pi m_{f}}\right)\sum_{i=1}^{n}\left[\operatorname{Im}\left(Y_{ee}^{h_i}\right)\operatorname{Re}\left(Y_{ff}^{h_i}\right)f(z_{fh_i})+\operatorname{Re}\left(Y_{ee}^{h_i}\right)\operatorname{Im}\left(Y_{ff}^{h_i}\right)g(z_{fh_i})\right], \tag*{(25)}
de,W2-loop=−e8π2(αGFv2π)∑i=1nYWWhi2mW2/vIm⁡(Yeehi)×[3f(zWhi)+234g(zWhi)+34h(zWhi)+f(zWhi)−g(zWhi)2zWhi].(26)\begin{aligned} d_{e,W}^{2\text{-loop}}={}&-\frac{e}{8\pi^{2}}\left(\frac{\alpha G_{F}v}{\sqrt{2}\pi}\right)\sum_{i=1}^{n}\frac{Y_{WW}^{h_i}}{2m_{W}^{2}/v}\operatorname{Im}\left(Y_{ee}^{h_i}\right)\\ &\times\left[3f(z_{Wh_i})+\frac{23}{4}g(z_{Wh_i})+\frac{3}{4}h(z_{Wh_i})+\frac{f(z_{Wh_i})-g(z_{Wh_i})}{2z_{Wh_i}}\right]. \tag*{(26)} \end{aligned}

where zAB=mA2/mB2z_{AB}=m_{A}^{2}/m_{B}^{2} and YWWhiY_{WW}^{h_i} is the coupling of hih_i to WWWW. For the SM-Higgs coupling to WWWW, we use the notation YWWSM=2mW2/vY_{WW}^{\mathrm{SM}}=2m_{W}^{2}/v. The loop functions f(z)f(z), g(z)g(z) and h(z)h(z) are:

f(z)=12z∫01dx1−2x(1−x)x(1−x)−zlog⁡(x(1−x)z),(27)f(z)=\frac{1}{2}z\int_{0}^{1}dx\frac{1-2x(1-x)}{x(1-x)-z}\log\left(\frac{x(1-x)}{z}\right), \tag*{(27)}
g(z)=12z∫01dx1x(1−x)−zlog⁡(x(1−x)z),(28)g(z)=\frac{1}{2}z\int_{0}^{1}dx\frac{1}{x(1-x)-z}\log\left(\frac{x(1-x)}{z}\right), \tag*{(28)}
h(z)=z2∂∂z(g(z)z)=z2∫01dxz−x(1−x)[1+zz−x(1−x)log⁡(x(1−x)z)].(29)h(z)=z^{2}\frac{\partial}{\partial z}\left(\frac{g(z)}{z}\right)=\frac{z}{2}\int_{0}^{1}\frac{dx}{z-x(1-x)}\left[1+\frac{z}{z-x(1-x)}\log\left(\frac{x(1-x)}{z}\right)\right]. \tag*{(29)}

Therefore, the couplings that are important in EDM contributions for scalar extensions with CP violation are YeehiY_{ee}^{h_i}, YffhiY_{ff}^{h_i} and YWWhiY_{WW}^{h_i}.

Zero EDM contributions from dark CP violation

The eEDM receives contributions only through the Yukawa couplings YeehiY_{ee}^{h_i} of the neutral scalars to the electron, which in turn depend on the mixing between the scalar mass eigenstates and the active doublet ϕ3\phi_{3}. In the I(2+1)HDM, the exact Z2\mathbb{Z}_{2} symmetry forbids any mixing between the inert scalars S1,2,3,4S_{1,2,3,4} and the active sector. Consequently, the inert scalars have no Yukawa couplings to SM fermions,

YeeSi=YffSi=0for all inert scalars Si,(30)Y_{ee}^{S_i}=Y_{ff}^{S_i}=0 \qquad\text{for all inert scalars } S_i, \tag*{(30)}

and the sums in Eqs. (24)–(26) receive contributions only from the SM-like Higgs boson hh, whose couplings are CP-conserving. It therefore follows directly that de=0d_e=0 in all these diagrams. Contributions in which the inert-sector CP violation reaches the electron only through gauge-boson vertices are not of this type, and are the subject of the conjecture in § 3.2.

C-violating CP violation leakage in 2HDM

The EDM contributions of dark CP violation through scalar–fermion couplings vanish exactly, as a direct consequence of the Z2Z_2 symmetry that forbids Yukawa couplings of the inert scalars. This is in sharp contrast to the CP-violating 2HDM where the absence of such protecting symmetry allows CP violation to seep into the fermionic sector, as we show next.

In the case of the flavour-aligned 2HDM, it is possible to have such CP-violating sources due to the absence of the Z2Z_2 symmetry. In terms of the parameters of the potential in the so-called Higgs basis [51, 52, 60–63], this leads to Z7Z_7 being the only complex parameter in the potential, in the exact Higgs-alignment limit [64–69]. As a result, the interactions of h1h_1 remain CP-conserving in the exact Higgs alignment limit, while cubic and quartic scalar interactions involving h2h_2 and h3h_3 violate CP, such as in the h1h2h3h_1h_2h_3 vertex [24].

Such a source of CP violation does contribute to the electron EDM, at three loops through a scalar loop inserted into the Barr–Zee diagrams, and at two loops through a scalar loop inserted into the one-loop scalar-exchange diagram, whose contribution is strongly suppressed by the squared electron Yukawa coupling Ye2Y_e^2, as shown in Figure 7–Figure 8.

Figure 7. The 2-loop extension of the lowest order diagrams contributing to the electron EDM in the CP-violating aligned 2HDM.

Figure 8. The 3-loop extension of the Barr–Zee-type diagrams contributing to the electron EDM in the CP-violating aligned 2HDM.

The effective operators for V1∗V2∗V3∗V_1^{*}V_2^{*}V_3^{*}

The effective operators for the V1∗V2∗V3∗V_1^{*}V_2^{*}V_3^{*} process with all three vector bosons off-shell are given in Ref. [35,39,70–73]. For the reader’s convenience, we show below the CP-violating operators for the Z∗Z∗Z∗Z^{*}Z^{*}Z^{*}, Z∗Z∗γ∗Z^{*}Z^{*}\gamma^{*}, γ∗γ∗Z∗\gamma^{*}\gamma^{*}Z^{*} and W∗W∗V∗W^{*}W^{*}V^{*} processes in Table 3, Table 4, Table 5 and Table 6, respectively.

OperatorExpressionDimension
O~1Z∗Z∗Z∗\widetilde{O}_{1}^{Z^*Z^*Z^*}−Zσ(∂σZν)(∂μZμν)-Z_{\sigma}(\partial^{\sigma}Z_{\nu})(\partial_{\mu}Z^{\mu\nu})dim⁡=6\operatorname{dim}=6
O~2Z∗Z∗Z∗\widetilde{O}_{2}^{Z^*Z^*Z^*}(□Zα)(∂αZμ)(□Zμ)(\square Z_{\alpha})(\partial^{\alpha}Z_{\mu})(\square Z^{\mu})dim⁡=8\operatorname{dim}=8
O~3Z∗Z∗Z∗\widetilde{O}_{3}^{Z^*Z^*Z^*}Zα(∂αZμ)(□2Zμ)Z_{\alpha}(\partial^{\alpha}Z_{\mu})(\square^{2}Z^{\mu})dim⁡=8\operatorname{dim}=8
O~4Z∗Z∗Z∗\widetilde{O}_{4}^{Z^*Z^*Z^*}(□2∂αZβ)(∂μ□Zα)(∂βZμ)(\square^{2}\partial^{\alpha}Z_{\beta})(\partial^{\mu}\square Z_{\alpha})(\partial^{\beta}Z_{\mu})dim⁡=12\operatorname{dim}=12
O~5Z∗Z∗Z∗\widetilde{O}_{5}^{Z^*Z^*Z^*}ZμZμ(∂σZσ)Z^{\mu}Z_{\mu}(\partial^{\sigma}Z_{\sigma})dim⁡=4\operatorname{dim}=4
O~6Z∗Z∗Z∗\widetilde{O}_{6}^{Z^*Z^*Z^*}(□Zμ)Zμ(∂σZσ)(\square Z^{\mu})Z_{\mu}(\partial^{\sigma}Z_{\sigma})dim⁡=6\operatorname{dim}=6
O~7Z∗Z∗Z∗\widetilde{O}_{7}^{Z^*Z^*Z^*}ZμZμ□(∂σZσ)Z^{\mu}Z_{\mu}\square(\partial^{\sigma}Z_{\sigma})dim⁡=6\operatorname{dim}=6
O~8Z∗Z∗Z∗\widetilde{O}_{8}^{Z^*Z^*Z^*}(∂σZσ)(∂μZμ)(∂νZν)(\partial^{\sigma}Z_{\sigma})(\partial^{\mu}Z_{\mu})(\partial^{\nu}Z_{\nu})dim⁡=6\operatorname{dim}=6
O~9Z∗Z∗Z∗\widetilde{O}_{9}^{Z^*Z^*Z^*}(∂σZσ)(□∂αZβ)(∂βZα)(\partial^{\sigma}Z_{\sigma})(\square\partial^{\alpha}Z_{\beta})(\partial^{\beta}Z_{\alpha})dim⁡=8\operatorname{dim}=8
O~10Z∗Z∗Z∗\widetilde{O}_{10}^{Z^*Z^*Z^*}(□∂σZσ)(∂αZβ)(∂βZα)(\square\partial^{\sigma}Z_{\sigma})(\partial^{\alpha}Z_{\beta})(\partial^{\beta}Z_{\alpha})dim⁡=8\operatorname{dim}=8
O~11Z∗Z∗Z∗\widetilde{O}_{11}^{Z^*Z^*Z^*}□∂α(∂σZσ)(∂βZβ)Zα\square\partial^{\alpha}(\partial^{\sigma}Z_{\sigma})(\partial^{\beta}Z_{\beta})Z_{\alpha}dim⁡=8\operatorname{dim}=8
O~12Z∗Z∗Z∗\widetilde{O}_{12}^{Z^*Z^*Z^*}□∂α(∂σZσ)(∂βZβ)(□Zα)\square\partial^{\alpha}(\partial^{\sigma}Z_{\sigma})(\partial^{\beta}Z_{\beta})(\square Z_{\alpha})dim⁡=10\operatorname{dim}=10
O~13Z∗Z∗Z∗\widetilde{O}_{13}^{Z^*Z^*Z^*}□2∂α(∂σZσ)(∂βZβ)Zα\square^{2}\partial^{\alpha}(\partial^{\sigma}Z_{\sigma})(\partial^{\beta}Z_{\beta})Z_{\alpha}dim⁡=10\operatorname{dim}=10
O~14Z∗Z∗Z∗\widetilde{O}_{14}^{Z^*Z^*Z^*}(∂σZσ)(∂μZμ)(∂νZν)(\partial^{\sigma}Z_{\sigma})(\partial^{\mu}Z_{\mu})(\partial^{\nu}Z_{\nu})dim⁡=6\operatorname{dim}=6

Table 3. The CP-violating operators for the Z∗Z∗Z∗Z^*Z^*Z^* vertex

OperatorExpressionDimension
O~1Z∗Z∗γ∗\widetilde{O}_{1}^{Z^*Z^*\gamma^*}−FμβZβ(∂σZσμ)-F^{\mu\beta}Z_{\beta}(\partial^{\sigma}Z_{\sigma\mu})dim⁡=6\operatorname{dim}=6
O~2Z∗Z∗γ∗\widetilde{O}_{2}^{Z^*Z^*\gamma^*}−(∂α∂β□Zμ)ZαFμβ-(\partial_{\alpha}\partial_{\beta}\square Z_{\mu})Z^{\alpha}F^{\mu\beta}dim⁡=8\operatorname{dim}=8
O~3Z∗Z∗γ∗\widetilde{O}_{3}^{Z^*Z^*\gamma^*}−(∂μFμβ)Zα(∂αZβ)-(\partial_{\mu}F^{\mu\beta})Z_{\alpha}(\partial^{\alpha}Z_{\beta})dim⁡=6\operatorname{dim}=6
O~4Z∗Z∗γ∗\widetilde{O}_{4}^{Z^*Z^*\gamma^*}∂μFμν(□∂νZα)Zα\partial^{\mu}F_{\mu\nu}(\square\partial^{\nu}Z_{\alpha})Z^{\alpha}dim⁡=8\operatorname{dim}=8
O~5Z∗Z∗γ∗\widetilde{O}_{5}^{Z^*Z^*\gamma^*}(∂σZσ)Fμν(∂μZν)(\partial^{\sigma}Z_{\sigma})F_{\mu\nu}(\partial^{\mu}Z^{\nu})dim⁡=6\operatorname{dim}=6
O~6Z∗Z∗γ∗\widetilde{O}_{6}^{Z^*Z^*\gamma^*}(∂σZσ)(∂μFμν)Zν(\partial^{\sigma}Z_{\sigma})(\partial^{\mu}F_{\mu\nu})Z^{\nu}dim⁡=6\operatorname{dim}=6
O~7Z∗Z∗γ∗\widetilde{O}_{7}^{Z^*Z^*\gamma^*}□(∂σZσ)Fμν(∂μZν)\square(\partial^{\sigma}Z_{\sigma})F_{\mu\nu}(\partial^{\mu}Z^{\nu})dim⁡=8\operatorname{dim}=8
O~8Z∗Z∗γ∗\widetilde{O}_{8}^{Z^*Z^*\gamma^*}(∂σZσ)Fμν(□∂μZν)(\partial^{\sigma}Z_{\sigma})F_{\mu\nu}(\square\partial^{\mu}Z^{\nu})dim⁡=8\operatorname{dim}=8
O~9Z∗Z∗γ∗\widetilde{O}_{9}^{Z^*Z^*\gamma^*}□∂ν(∂σZσ)(∂βZβ)∂μFμν\square\partial^{\nu}(\partial^{\sigma}Z_{\sigma})(\partial^{\beta}Z_{\beta})\partial^{\mu}F_{\mu\nu}dim⁡=10\operatorname{dim}=10

Table 4. The CP-violating operators for the Z∗Z∗γ∗Z^*Z^*\gamma^* vertex

OperatorExpressionDimension
O~1γ∗γ∗Z∗\widetilde{\mathcal{O}}_{1}^{\gamma^{*}\gamma^{*}Z^{*}}−(∂σFσμ)ZβFμβ-(\partial^{\sigma}F_{\sigma\mu})Z_{\beta}F^{\mu\beta}dim⁡=6\dim=6
O~2γ∗γ∗Z∗\widetilde{\mathcal{O}}_{2}^{\gamma^{*}\gamma^{*}Z^{*}}(□Fμν)Fνα(∂μZα)(\Box F^{\mu\nu})F_{\nu\alpha}(\partial_{\mu}Z^{\alpha})dim⁡=8\dim=8
O~3γ∗γ∗Z∗\widetilde{\mathcal{O}}_{3}^{\gamma^{*}\gamma^{*}Z^{*}}−(∂α∂β∂ρFρμ)ZαFμβ-(\partial_{\alpha}\partial_{\beta}\partial^{\rho}F_{\rho\mu})Z^{\alpha}F^{\mu\beta}dim⁡=8\dim=8
O~4γ∗γ∗Z∗\widetilde{\mathcal{O}}_{4}^{\gamma^{*}\gamma^{*}Z^{*}}(□∂μFμν)(∂σFσα)(∂νZα)(\Box\partial_{\mu}F^{\mu\nu})(\partial^{\sigma}F_{\sigma\alpha})(\partial_{\nu}Z^{\alpha})dim⁡=10\dim=10
O~5γ∗γ∗Z∗\widetilde{\mathcal{O}}_{5}^{\gamma^{*}\gamma^{*}Z^{*}}(∂σZσ)FμνFμν(\partial_{\sigma}Z^{\sigma})F^{\mu\nu}F_{\mu\nu}dim⁡=6\dim=6
O~6γ∗γ∗Z∗\widetilde{\mathcal{O}}_{6}^{\gamma^{*}\gamma^{*}Z^{*}}∂μ(∂σZσ)Fμν(∂βFβν)\partial_{\mu}(\partial_{\sigma}Z^{\sigma})F^{\mu\nu}(\partial^{\beta}F_{\beta\nu})dim⁡=8\dim=8

Table 5. The CP-violating operators for the γ∗γ∗Z∗\gamma^{*}\gamma^{*}Z^{*} vertex

OperatorExpressionDimension
O~1W+∗W−∗V∗\widetilde{\mathcal{O}}_{1}^{W^{+*}W^{-*}V^{*}}Wμ−Wν+(∂μVν+∂νVμ)W^{-}_{\mu}W^{+}_{\nu}(\partial^{\mu}V^{\nu}+\partial^{\nu}V^{\mu})dim⁡=4\dim=4
O~2W+∗W−∗V∗\widetilde{\mathcal{O}}_{2}^{W^{+*}W^{-*}V^{*}}Wμ−Wν+V~μνW^{-}_{\mu}W^{+}_{\nu}\widetilde{V}^{\mu\nu}dim⁡=4\dim=4
O~3W+∗W−∗V∗\widetilde{\mathcal{O}}_{3}^{W^{+*}W^{-*}V^{*}}Wσμ−W  ν+μV~νσW^{-}_{\sigma\mu}W^{+\mu}_{\ \ \nu}\widetilde{V}^{\nu\sigma}dim⁡=6\dim=6
O~4W+∗W−∗V∗\widetilde{\mathcal{O}}_{4}^{W^{+*}W^{-*}V^{*}}[Wν−(∂μW+μ)+Wν+(∂μW−μ)]Vν[W^{-}_{\nu}(\partial_{\mu}W^{+\mu})+W^{+}_{\nu}(\partial_{\mu}W^{-\mu})]V^{\nu}dim⁡=4\dim=4
O~5W+∗W−∗V∗\widetilde{\mathcal{O}}_{5}^{W^{+*}W^{-*}V^{*}}Wμ−W+μ(∂νVν)W^{-}_{\mu}W^{+\mu}(\partial_{\nu}V^{\nu})dim⁡=4\dim=4

Table 6. The CP-violating operators for the fully off-shell W+∗W−∗V∗W^{+*}W^{-*}V^{*} vertex, with V=Z,γV=Z,\gamma. The first three structures correspond to the conventional g4Vg_{4}^{V}, κ~V\widetilde{\kappa}_{V}, and λ~V\widetilde{\lambda}_{V} couplings, respectively, while the last two contain the divergence of a gauge field and contribute only when the corresponding leg is off shell and coupled to a non-conserved current.

Note that in order to generate all independent Lorentz structures of the fully off-shell vertices, we have added the minimal set of higher-dimensional operators.

References

  1. [1]A. D. Sakharov. Violation of CP Invariance, C asymmetry, and baryon asymmetry of the universe. Pisma Zh. Eksp. Teor. Fiz., 5:32–35, 1967.
  2. [2]M. B. Gavela, P. Hernandez, J. Orloff, and O. Pene. Standard model CP violation and baryon asymmetry. Mod. Phys. Lett. A, 9:795–810, 1994.

Paper details

vlnc:W_pnf6vnz4
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents