WorksMathematics
Permanence and -periodicity of in the stable stems at the prime three
Abstract
The class lies in stable degree and filtration on the algebraic starting page of the -primary Adams–Novikov spectral sequence of the sphere. We show that it survives and begins a family with period , answering both parts of a question of Carrick and Davies. A comparison with periodic topological modular forms and a bound on the possible differential targets prove permanence. A divisibility calculation for the mod- Moore spectrum supplies a lift to a finite spectrum with a degree- self-map. The resulting iterates have nonzero image in the height-two detector of Carrick and Davies.
Introduction
Write for the sphere spectrum and for its localization at the prime 3, which inverts integers prime to 3. For a spectrum , denotes its -fold suspension (desuspension for negative ) and its th stable homotopy group. Here denotes stable homotopy classes of maps from to , and denotes the graded collection of homotopy groups. An integer indexing is called a stem. We work at the prime 3 throughout.
Chromatic homotopy theory organizes periodic families in the stable stems by height. At height one, the image of the stable -homomorphism, which is induced by one-point compactification of orthogonal transformations, is closely related to the Adams self-map of the mod-3 Moore spectrum. For a positive integer , write for the cofiber of multiplication by on a spectrum , which fits into the sequence . For the last two maps are denoted by and , respectively. The mod-3 Moore spectrum is . The Adams self-map induces multiplication by the degree-4 generator of -homology, where denotes the th Morava -theory [8]. For an integer , write for the generalized Moore spectrum given by the cofiber of . A power of a self-map here uses composition with the appropriate suspensions. The Smith–Toda complex is .
At height two, let denote the degree-16 periodicity generator of the coefficients of . A self-map has degree 144 and induces multiplication by on -homology. Behrens and Pemmaraju constructed such a map on [2]. Belmont printed: 2020 Mathematics Subject Classification. Primary 55Q45. Secondary 55Q51, 55T15, 55P42. printed: Key words and phrases. Adams–Novikov spectral sequence, stable stems, chromatic homotopy. and Shimomura constructed such maps on for and used them to obtain families in the stable stems [4 Corollary 4.7 and §5].
The Adams–Novikov spectral sequence uses Brown–Peterson homology, denoted by for a spectrum . Its initial page is the comodule cohomology group
where is the coefficient ring and is the ring of cooperations [8]. The cohomological degree is the Adams–Novikov filtration and is the internal degree. We write for the group on page in stem and filtration . An omitted spectrum means the sphere. The differential on page sends to . A -cycle is a class killed by , and a -boundary is a class in its image. A permanent cycle survives nontrivially to the limiting page .
Let be the subgroup of Adams–Novikov filtration at least . The limiting page gives the associated graded group of the 3-completed homotopy groups, where AN stands for Adams–Novikov. For the sphere and the finite Moore spectra in the positive stems used below these groups agree with the 3-local groups. A class in that maps to a given class of is called a representative of that class. A hidden extension by three occurs when a class is killed by 3 on but multiplying a representative by 3 gives a nonzero class in higher filtration.
The notation also denotes the usual chromatic generators of , of internal degree for . The Greek-letter class is the algebraic connecting class of modulo 3, in bidegree . The divided class is defined, where the construction applies, by taking the connecting classes of modulo for multiplication by and then by 3. Its bidegree is , and we abbreviate to [4 §5]. Juxtaposition and superscripts on classes denote multiplication and its iterated powers. We use the same symbols for homotopy representatives when the classes are permanent and we are discussing products in homotopy.
Carrick and Davies use the connective height-two image-of- spectrum to detect classes in the stable stems [6]. In high degrees its homotopy groups are calculated from the fiber of on , the connective spectrum of topological modular forms. Here is the stable Adams operation indexed by 2 and 1 is the identity map. The unit map gives the Hurewicz homomorphism on stable homotopy groups, whose image is called the Hurewicz image. A class is detected by when its image under this homomorphism is nonzero. Let denote periodic topological modular forms and the fiber of on , or equivalently the homotopy equalizer of and the identity [7 §3]. We write for the connecting map from this fiber sequence. We use the same symbol for its connective counterpart in the high degrees where agrees with the fiber.
In topological modular forms, and denote the images of and , or their spectral sequence classes when working on a page. The modular discriminant has weight 12 and bidegree . In homotopy, powers of with exponent divisible by three denote powers of the degree-72 class detected by [1 §§5–6]. We use to compare differentials and to detect the periodic family. The modified Adams–Novikov spectral sequence of uses the same stem and filtration convention as the ordinary one.
Carrick and Davies [6 Question 3.15] ask whether the class in stem 153 and Adams–Novikov filtration 3 survives in the 3-primary sphere, and whether it is -periodic. They identify the class on the -page by the relation , where denotes equality up to multiplication by a unit at the prime 3. They report that its counterpart in the -local sphere, obtained by localizing with respect to -homology, is permanent. Naturality then constrains a possible differential on to have target with zero image on the corresponding local page. Permanence in the sphere requires controlling those possible targets there.
For the periodicity question, let be the connecting map of the cofiber sequence defining for . Together with the mod-3 boundary , it gives
To construct a periodic family from a representative of , we need a lift through these two boundaries. Such a lift requires and a choice of with and . Given and a self-map , we write for the class obtained by applying the suspended -fold iterate of to for each integer . The family requires the double boundaries to be nonzero.
Write for the cyclic group of order .
Theorem 1.1. The class is a permanent cycle in the Adams–Novikov spectral sequence for . In particular, , generated by the class detected by . Every representative of has order three and begins a -periodic family of order-three, filtration-three classes. The class in stem is detected by in .
Sections 2 and 3 compute the possible differential targets and rule them out using comparison with , multiplication in the sphere, and a finite-page vanishing line, which bounds the bidegrees that can still be nonzero on a fixed page. Section 4 resolves the hidden extension by three. Section 5 uses -divisibility in the Moore spectrum to choose a lift with . Section 6 then detects every iterate in . These stems are the exceptional degrees in Carrick and Davies’s description of the Hurewicz image [6 Theorem A].
The relevant -groups and products
We use revision f530898 of the data of Belmont and Wang [3], generated with Belmont’s prime-3 adaptation of Wang’s MinimalResolution program [11]. Wang describes the underlying minimal-resolution algorithm in [10]. The data extend through internal degree 185, which contains every algebraic group used in the permanence argument. The program computes the algebraic Novikov spectral sequence and its multiplicative information, which determine the indicated groups and products on the Adams–Novikov -page.
Write for the field of three elements. The notation in Belmont’s generator names labels the basis element with index in homological degree of the chosen resolution. The hyphen separates the two indices. A prefix such as in records the coefficient monomial of the leading term used to name the generator. In these names denotes 3 and for denotes the Brown–Peterson generator of that index.
Lemma 2.1. The groups in the following table have the indicated -bases, with denoting the empty basis of the zero group. Here is the generator in and is the generator in .
| Basis of | |
Table 2.
The product in is nonzero and the map given by multiplication by ,
is surjective.
Proof. The following are the generator names in Belmont’s data [3], in the order of the named elements in the table. Coefficients of the single-generator products are suppressed.
Table 3.
To reproduce the lookups, initialize ANSSData() from beta.py at the root of Belmont’s repository [3]. The method in_deg(n,f) lists the generators in stem and filtration , and three multiplies a class by 3. The -products use the multiplication tables for the mod-3 Moore spectrum and the algebraic boundary, as implemented in beta.py. To compute a product of named classes, start with the unit and compose the corresponding multiplication methods. For the last two claims the alpha1 table gives
The last two images form the basis in . □
Permanence
The BP Hopf algebroid is concentrated in internal degrees divisible by four. Since changes the internal degree by , a nonzero differential can occur only for . Thus none can hit , whose filtration is three. Outgoing differentials have target in stem 152 and filtration . By [5 Proposition 11.6 and Theorem 12.2], the sphere -page vanishes at . For this excludes , and Lemma 2.1 excludes . Figure 1 shows the remaining possibilities .

Figure 1. Possible outgoing differentials from in the sphere Adams–Novikov spectral sequence. The entries come from Belmont’s data [3]. Each filled dot denotes one generator, and the differential labels are beside their targets. Dashed arrows show the three candidates checked below. Crosses mark the zero groups that exclude and on the indicated pages. The shaded band starts above filtration 21, so the vanishing line also excludes every with .
The d5 comparison
Davies’s filtered model of [7 §3] gives the comparison from the sphere and the maps of spectral sequences induced by the equalizer boundary and by the projection . On pages written in stem and filtration coordinates, has degree , meaning it sends to . The modified spectral sequence is also supported in internal degrees divisible by four.
In bidegree the TMF term is zero. The boundary from bidegree of TMF therefore spans the group in , which is generated by . Indeed, is fixed by on , and is the generator of that bidegree. The class is a -cycle. On TMF, [1 Equation (6.1)] and , so by the Leibniz rule and . Hence the image of is a -cycle.
By [7 Propositions 3.10 and 3.11], the classes and project to and , respectively, and maps to , up to units. The boundary is linear over the equalizer via the projection on its TMF term. Consequently the image of the generator of the possible target group is
up to a unit.
Here generates the TMF term in . It has order three, and fixes it, since fixes and and acts on by [7 Remark 3.4]. The equalizer exact sequence therefore shows that its boundary is nonzero. The comparison is injective on , so naturality forces .
The d9 obstruction
Suppose . Its target is represented by a unit multiple of . The group is one-dimensional by [3], so can survive to only if every from is zero. The surjectivity in Lemma 2.1 and the permanence of then imply that every from is zero. This is the entire source group for a hitting . Since is a -cycle, this proves on .
On , by [6 Remark 3.14]. The right-hand side is a nonzero product of permanent cycles, detected by [6 Proposition 3.13]. By the Leibniz rule our hypothetical on would give a nonzero on this permanent product, a contradiction.
The d13 target group
Ravenel’s differential is [5 Lemma 12.10]. We check that is a -cycle. The class is a nonzero -cycle, and its possible source is zero by the data [3]. Hence it is nonzero on . The Leibniz rule then gives
In particular, the generator of survives to , so it cannot be a -boundary. This is the only possible target for . The target for is itself zero by Lemma 2.1, and filtration rules out incoming differentials to through .
Multiplying by and by the permanent cycle kills both generators of that remain on . It follows that . This excludes and proves the permanence assertion of Theorem 1.1.
The hidden extension by three
Let represent . In this section we abbreviate to . Since on , we have . Also because . Sparseness, Belmont’s data [3], and the vanishing line leave possible filtration groups in only at 7, 11, and 19.
In filtration 7, the -kernel on is spanned by , by the multiplication calculation in § 2. The product tables [3] identify it on with up to a unit. Its is nonzero, since maps to in the Adams–Novikov spectral sequence of TMF. The latter is a nonzero -cycle and , so it remains nonzero on . Here we use that maps to [7 Proposition 3.10]. In stem 156 and filtration 8, the only possible incoming differential is from , which is spanned by by the data [3]. This is a permanent cycle because is permanent [2 Corollary 1.2]. Thus multiplication by has zero kernel on the surviving filtration-7 associated graded of stem 153. It follows that lies in .
For filtration 11, Belmont’s data [3] identify the generator as up to a unit, with . The classical differential [4 Table 6] gives a nonzero component of along . Indeed, the products in [3] show that is a unit multiple of . The only possible target for is in , whose product with is a unit multiple of the other generator in . The two components are independent, so the filtration-11 generator supports .
In filtration 19, the data [3] give the sole generator , where lies in . If is nonzero, it is a unit multiple of in , and its product with is the nonzero class . Hence supports in this case. Otherwise is zero on because has no target in and on . This exhausts the possible leading terms of , which proves .
The generalized Moore lift
For , the mod-3 map includes the bottom cell. The sphere element of degree 10 acts on by a map . In the composite we first apply the suspension of by 10 and then this action. Similarly, denotes the image of multiplication by on .
Lemma 5.1. The self-map is nullhomotopic, and
Proof. Write for localization of a spectrum with respect to -homology. The low stem groups [8 Table A3.4], together with the image of , give and from the image of , mapping isomorphically to . Also . The local groups and the comparison on the image of follow from Ravenel’s height-one calculation [9 Theorem 8.10 and Remark 8.12] and the mod-3 cofiber sequence. Applying the stable mapping functors into and to the suspended Moore cofiber sequence therefore shows that is injective. The map localizes to zero because .
For an abelian group , write for its quotient by and for its subgroup killed by 3. The sequence of -comodules for gives the short exact sequence
The maps in this sequence are induced by the bottom-cell inclusion and the mod-3 boundary. They commute with multiplication with the indicated bidegree shift of . In Table 1, the bottom group at is the left term of (1) and the top group is the right term, coming from the top cell of . Each generator is named in Belmont’s notation, and 0 denotes the zero group. We obtain the two end groups from in_deg and three, and use beta1(g,k) for multiplication of a generator by in Belmont’s data [3]. Reading across each pair of columns gives the product up to a unit. In particular the first row is a surjection on the Moore -page, and rows two through six are isomorphisms.
| Action | Source generators Bottom | Source generators Top | Target generators Bottom | Target generators Top | |
Table 1. The bottom and top groups and their products, computed from Belmont’s data [3] using (1). The target of a row with has bidegree .
We first check that the source of the last row has permanent representatives. The bottom-cell generator comes from the permanent product in . For the top-cell generator, let be the sphere class in . Ravenel’s table [8 Table A3.4] gives two independent classes modulo the image of in stem 107, namely and . Here is the height-three Greek-letter element in stem 81 and is the other generator in that stem in Ravenel’s table. The two products in stem 107 are killed by 3. Together with the image of they give the direct sum decomposition . The cyclic order-81 filtration-one group survives by [8 Theorem 5.3.7(a)]. The data [3] leave three other possible filtrations below the vanishing line, namely 5, 13, and 17, each of dimension one. In filtration 17 the generator is up to a unit, for in . Its potential and targets and are zero in the same data. It follows that vanishes on . Comparing with the known group order shows that survives. The kernel of the cyclic order-81 filtration-one quotient has exponent three, since the quotient is an isomorphism on the cyclic order-81 summand. Thus has an order-three representative and lifts to . This lift has filtration four. Indeed the only possible lower filtration is zero, and
| Source | Target | Page check |
| surjective on | ||
| isomorphism on | ||
| injective on | ||
| injective on | ||
| injective on | ||
| The from is zero. |
on is injective onto the order-three subgroup on the filtration-one line, where no differentials occur. Filtration greater than four would place its boundary above filtration five. By the geometric boundary theorem [8 Theorem 2.3.4], the connecting map in (1) therefore sends the filtration-four detector of the lift to . Consequently the from is zero, and any surviving class there is represented by a homotopy product with .
We next check the first two rows on later pages, as shown in Figure 2. For the row with source the map is injective on . All possible -boundaries in the target come from , which on is in the image of by the second row. Thus if a -cycle maps to a -boundary, the Leibniz rule and injectivity on show it was already a boundary.

Figure 2. Moore spectrum bidegrees used in the -divisibility argument. The groups and products are computed from [3] using (1). In (a), each square marks a nonzero -group in one of the two candidate differential patterns. A dashed arrow from filtration to filtration represents a possible . In (b), each arrow adds 10 to the stem and 2 to the filtration. The page checks identify the injectivity needed to compare differentials on the two sides.
The row from to is injective on , since the only possible -sources at the target are in , where we have shown . It remains injective on . A possible -boundary in comes from a class in . By the second row of the table we can choose a preimage in on such that represents this class. Since , injectivity on of the row from gives . Hence the -boundary in question is , and injectivity on shows that any cycle mapping to this boundary was already a -boundary.
A surviving class in now has a surviving antecedent in . The just-proved injections force the antecedent’s and to vanish, and an incoming differential would kill its product with as well. For a survivor in , an antecedent in is a , , and cycle by the corresponding injections from , , and . The strong vanishing line [5 Theorem 12.2] applies to and excludes all remaining outgoing differentials from the antecedents, since their next target filtration is at least 21 in stem 147. In stem 158, filtration 18 is zero on by [3], and filtrations at least 22 are above the line. Thus in every possible filtration at least 6, the surviving associated graded is -divisible by an actual homotopy class. Successively subtracting such products in the finite filtration gives the claimed inclusion.
By § 4, we may choose with . The only possible filtration below 6 of is 2. By (1) and Belmont’s data [3], the group has zero bottom and top generated by in . The identity [6 Lemma 2.6] shows that represents its generator. Subtracting a multiple of from therefore gives a lift still mapping to and satisfying . Lemma 5.1 now implies . Exactness gives a lift with .
Detection of the iterates
Fix the degree-144 self-map from [4 Corollary 4.7] inducing on -homology. For the lift just constructed, set
Here is the identity, so . Put and . For or , the notation means , where is the smash product of spectra. Let denote the unit and its induced maps on homotopy groups, including those on cofibers obtained by smashing with or .
In the degrees of interest agrees with the fiber of on . We have by [6 Proposition 3.13 and Remark 3.14] and the permanence calculation in § 3. In detail the product is detected there. Write for the one-dimensional -span of a generator . The equalizer sequence and give . We also have by and . These groups follow from the prime-three tmf calculation [1 §§5–6].
Write and for the quotient and connecting maps in the mod-27 cofiber sequence. The periodicity element in is the unique class satisfying [6 Proposition 3.17]. Multiplication by uses the module action of on the relevant mod-3 spectra. Lemma 3.22 of [6] identifies this action on with the effect of , up to sign. Let and write for the result of applying this action times. Linearity of the boundary gives .
Choose a lift with . Bauer’s calculation [1 Figure 1] gives , so . Thus is the boundary of a class in . The case of [6 Lemma 3.22] identifies the actions of and up to sign on . By linearity of the boundary this yields in . The map in the degrees of interest is the equalizer boundary with mod-3 coefficients, and it is -linear [6 Lemma 3.23]. Thus the lift of in satisfies
Here the boundary on is linear over .
After rescaling by a unit, exactness gives for a class . The inclusion of the fiber of is -linear [6 §3.3] and satisfies . Also because . Therefore
This proves
for all . The final nonvanishing follows because spans the order-three group in stem of , on which is zero [6 Theorem 2.1]. The boundary is detected in filtration three in the modified spectral sequence for , by the same equalizer computation as in Section 3, with replaced by . The unit comparison therefore puts in filtration at most three, and sphere sparseness gives filtration at least three. The classes have order three because they lie in the image of . This completes the proof of Theorem 1.1.
Acknowledgment
The author is supported by the NSFC Grant No. 12405001. The author thanks AI for its help.
References
References
- [1]T. Bauer, Computation of the homotopy of the spectrum tmf, Geom. Topol. Monogr. 13 (2008), 11–40. DOI 10.2140/gtm.2008.13.11. arXiv:math/0311328.DOI
- [2]M. Behrens and S. Pemmaraju, On the existence of the self map v₂⁹ on the Smith–Toda complex V(1) at the prime 3, Contemp. Math. 346 (2004), 9–49. DOI 10.1090/conm/346/06284. arXiv:math/0303223. Author’s copy.
- [3]E. Belmont and G. Wang, Adams–Novikov charts and data at the prime 3, computational data and code, revision f530898.
- [4]E. Belmont and K. Shimomura, Beta families arising from a v₂⁹ self-map on S/(3, v₁⁸), Algebr. Geom. Topol. 23 (2023), 4349–4378. DOI 10.2140/agt.2023.23.4349. arXiv:2109.01059.DOI
- [5]R. Burklund, J. Hahn, and A. Senger, On the boundaries of highly connected, almost closed manifolds, Acta Math. 231 (2023), 205–344. DOI 10.4310/ACTA.2023.v231.n2.a1. arXiv:1910.14116.DOI
- [6]C. Carrick and J. M. Davies, Nonvanishing of products in v₂-periodic families at the prime 3, Adv. Math. 502 (2026), 111183. DOI 10.1016/j.aim.2026.111183. arXiv:2410.02564v3.DOI
- [7]J. M. Davies, Revisiting the β₁-action on the 3-primary stable homotopy groups of spheres, arXiv:2511.02324v2, 2026.arxiv.org/abs/2511.02324
- [8]D. C. Ravenel, Complex Cobordism and Stable Homotopy Groups of Spheres, 2nd ed., AMS Chelsea Publishing, 2004. DOI 10.1090/chel/347. Author’s copy.DOI
- [9]D. C. Ravenel, Localization with respect to certain periodic homology theories, Amer. J. Math. 106 (1984), 351–414. DOI 10.2307/2374308.DOI
- [10]G. Wang, Computations of the Adams–Novikov E₂-term, Chinese Ann. Math. Ser. B 42 (2021), 551–560. DOI 10.1007/s11401-021-0277-2.DOI
- [11]G. Wang, MinimalResolution, source code. Original repository. Prime-3 version by E. Belmont and G. Wang, revision e8a5482.