betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Coherence/incoherence transition temperature in molecular spin

Abstract

We examine the coherence/incoherence transition temperature of a generic molecular spin. Our results demonstrates that a molecular spin with a high coherence/incoherence transition temperature should possess a low spin number and low axiality, or high spin number and high axiality. Interestingly, the latter is better protected from the magnetic noises than the former and thus be the best candidate for a robust electron-based molecular spin qubit/qudit. The transition temperature can be further optimized if a large non-axial component of the spin Hamiltonian exists.

Introduction

Magnetic materials based on molecules have gained a lot of traction in the last several decades [1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8]. In the area of single-molecule magnets (SMMs) [2, 4, 9, 10], recent observations of the hysteresis at high temperature resulting from creative chemical designs and a deep understanding of the fundamental factors influencing the magnetization relaxation has generated a lot of excitement toward a future where each molecule can be a storage bit [11, 12, 13]. No less important is the rapid development of the area of molecular spin qubit where the paramagnetic molecule is proposed to be used as qubit, the elementary unit for the quantum information processing, or as qudit, a simple molecular quantum processor with more functions/qubits incorporated [3, 4, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18]. Recently, the realization of a Grover search algorithm on a qudit based on a set of addressable nuclear spin states within a single molecule [19] once more demonstrates the potential of this area in particular and the molecular magnetism in general.

In SMM, one of the key characteristics of the material is the relaxation time of the magnetization where the quantum tunneling of magnetization (QTM) plays an important role due to the nanoscale size of the molecule [2, 4, 7, 9, 10]. At high temperature, this QTM process can be treated in an incoherent manner [20, 21]. The magnetization relaxation in this regime can be considered as operating in only one single relaxation mode [22, 23, 24, 25, 26, 27]. Meanwhile, the most important requisite for a robust molecular spin qubit is a long decoherence time of the quantum superposition within the ground doublet, which necessarily requires a large tunneling frequency and a sufficiently low operating temperature so that at least the thermal noise is suppressed [3, 10, 16, 18]. Essentially, a molecular spin qubit needs to operate in the coherence limit of the quantum tunneling of magnetization where at least two relaxation modes with complex conjugate relaxation rates coexist. Assuming effect of nuclear and neighboring electronic spins are negligible, a molecular spin in principle can transit between two mentioned limits, coherent and incoherent quantum tunneling, by lowering the temperature [26, 27]. The remaining question is at which temperature this coherence/incoherence transition occurs and how to calculate it. Practically, this coherence/incoherence transition temperature plays roles as 1) the upper boundary of the temperature domain where a molecular spin qubit shows the coherence; 2) the lower boundary where the incoherent approximation of the quantum tunneling of magnetization is fully invalidated. As far as we are aware, none of the research so far approaches this problem from a theoretical point of view.

In the previous papers, we have proposed and worked out the formula of a quantity named transition decoherence rate γ0\gamma_0 as the boundary between the coherence and incoherence relaxation of the magnetization [26, 27]. As mentioned above, considerable attention has been usually paid to the temperature where the transition between the coherence and incoherence relaxation occurs. In principle, this transition temperature can always be found given the transition decoherence rate γ0\gamma_0. The problem is that besides the temperature, the transition decoherence rate is also a function of other characteristics of the molecular spin system such as the spin number or anisotropy of the spin system. Consequently, the expression for the transition temperature may significantly vary from one spin Hamiltonian to another spin Hamiltonian. This variation raises additional important questions in practice: which molecular spin system will have a high coherence/incoherence transition temperature and/or be insensitive to the magnetic noise? These properties are crucial for a complex candidate to be a molecular spin qubit since they may indicate that the decoherence induced by the thermal and magnetic noise is optimized. They are also of importance for the application of the incoherent quantum tunneling approximation and accordingly the interpretation of the magnetization relaxation in single-molecule magnets. Based on the results presented in the previous works [26, 27], we will seek the answers to all of these questions.

Coherence/incoherence transition temperature

A molecular spin system of spin number SS (transition metal complexes) (or total angular momentum quantum number JJ - lanthanide-based complexes) with the following generic Hamiltonian is considered:

H=∑mth(εm+Wm2)∣m⟩⟨m∣+(εm−Wm2)∣m′⟩⟨m′∣+∑mth(Δm2∣m⟩⟨m′∣+Δm∗2∣m′⟩⟨m∣)+∑nthεn∣n⟩⟨n∣,(1)\mathcal{H} = \sum_{m^{\mathrm{th}}} \left(\varepsilon_m + \frac{W_m}{2}\right) |m\rangle\langle m| + \left(\varepsilon_m - \frac{W_m}{2}\right) |m'\rangle\langle m'| + \sum_{m^{\mathrm{th}}} \left(\frac{\Delta_m}{2}|m\rangle\langle m'| + \frac{\Delta_m^*}{2}|m'\rangle\langle m|\right) + \sum_{n^{\mathrm{th}}} \varepsilon_n |n\rangle\langle n|, \tag*{(1)}

where mm (nn) indicates the doublet mthm^{\mathrm{th}} (or the singlet nthn^{\mathrm{th}}), WmW_m is the energy bias caused by the magnetic field, and Δm\Delta_m is either the intrinsic or field-induced tunneling splitting gap. It is worth noting that the Hamiltonian is formulated in the localized basis [23, 25, 28] and the spin system SS is assumed to be subject to the Redfield equation [22, 23], i.e. weakly interacting with the surrounding thermal bath.

For the mentioned system, we have figured out in the previous works [26, 27] that the transition between coherence and incoherence relaxation occurs at a specific value of the decoherence rate γ\gamma defined as γ≡(γ11′−Γe)/2\gamma\equiv(\gamma_{11'}-\Gamma_e)/2 where γ11′\gamma_{11'} is the escape rate of the ground doublet population and Γe\Gamma_e is the effective relaxation rate as if the tunneling splitting gap of the ground doublet is zero. Generally speaking, γ\gamma is temperature dependent but it is up to a specific spin system that γ\gamma can have different types of dependence on the temperature TT. However, if we restrict our objective only to an estimation of the temperature at which there is a transition in magnetization relaxation from incoherence to coherence, we may consider a common case when the transition rate to the nearest excited doublet/singlet at energy UU contributes the most to the escape rate γ11′\gamma_{11'} and γ11′≫Γe\gamma_{11'} \gg\Gamma_e. In this case, γ\gamma can be roughly approximated by:

γ≈O3kB5πℏ4ρv5U3exp⁡(U/T)−1∣⟨S−1∣∑αβD~αβSαSβ∣S⟩∣2\gamma\overset{\mathcal{O}}{\approx} \frac{3k_B^5}{\pi\hbar^4\rho v^5}\frac{U^3}{\exp(U/T)-1}\left|\left\langle S-1\left|\sum_{\alpha\beta}\widetilde{D}_{\alpha\beta}S_\alpha S_\beta\right|S\right\rangle\right|^2
≈O3kB5πℏ4ρv5S4(2S−1)3D5exp⁡[(2S−1)D/T]−1.(2)\overset{\mathcal{O}}{\approx} \frac{3k_B^5}{\pi\hbar^4\rho v^5}\frac{S^4(2S-1)^3D^5}{\exp\left[(2S-1)D/T\right]-1}. \tag*{(2)}

Here we use the notation LHS ≈O\overset{\mathcal{O}}{\approx} RHS to indicate the left-hand side (LHS) is of the order of magnitude of the right-hand side (RHS). Eq. (2) is taken from Chapter 5 of Ref. [2] where SS is the spin number, DD is the (second-order) axial anisotropy parameter and U≈(2S−1)DU \approx(2S-1)D.

On the other hand, the transition decoherence rate γ0\gamma_0 is closed related to the spin Hamiltonian of the spin system, especially the ground doublet, and given by [26, 27]:

γ0={Δ1,for W1=0,(Δ12−8W12+3Δ1)4W12−Δ1Δ12−8W12+Δ1282W1,for 0<W1<Δ122,322Δ12−2W12,for Δ122<W1<Δ12,0,for W1≥Δ12.(3)\gamma_0 = \begin{cases} \Delta_1, & \text{for } W_1=0,\\ \frac{\left(\sqrt{\Delta_1^2-8W_1^2}+3\Delta_1\right)\sqrt{4W_1^2-\Delta_1\sqrt{\Delta_1^2-8W_1^2}+\Delta_1^2}}{8\sqrt{2}W_1}, & \text{for } 0<W_1<\frac{\Delta_1}{2\sqrt{2}},\\ \frac{3}{2\sqrt{2}}\sqrt{\Delta_1^2-2W_1^2}, & \text{for } \frac{\Delta_1}{2\sqrt{2}}<W_1<\frac{\Delta_1}{\sqrt{2}},\\ 0, & \text{for } W_1\geq\frac{\Delta_1}{\sqrt{2}}. \end{cases} \tag*{(3)}

From Eq. (2) and (3), we can now proceed to a rough estimation of the coherence/incoherence transition temperature T0T_0 corresponding to the transition decoherence rate γ0\gamma_0 in both cases: at resonance (W1=0W_1=0) and out of resonance (W1≠0W_1\ne0).

At resonance

From Eq. (2), it is straightforward that at resonance:

T0≈OUln⁡[1+3kB5πℏ4ρv5S4U5(2S−1)2γ0]≈O(2S−1)Dln⁡[1+3kB5πℏ4ρv5S4(2S−1)3D5Δ1].(4)T_0 \overset{\mathcal{O}}{\approx} \frac{U}{\ln\left[1+\frac{3k_B^5}{\pi\hbar^4\rho v^5}\frac{S^4U^5}{(2S-1)^2\gamma_0}\right]} \overset{\mathcal{O}}{\approx} \frac{(2S-1)D}{\ln\left[1+\frac{3k_B^5}{\pi\hbar^4\rho v^5}\frac{S^4(2S-1)^3D^5}{\Delta_1}\right]}. \tag*{(4)}
Origin of Δ1\Delta_1SSδH\delta HΔ1\Delta_1T0T_0
Rhombic anisotropyIntegerB4(Sz2+S2)\frac{B}{4}(S_z^2+S^2)8DS2(2S)!(S!)2(B16D)S\frac{8DS^2(2S)!}{(S!)^2}\left(\frac{B}{16D}\right)^S(2S−1)Dln⁡[1+3kB58πℏ4ρv5(S!)2S2(2S−1)3(2S)!(B16D)−SD4]\frac{(2S-1)D}{\ln\left[1+\frac{3k_B^5}{8\pi\hbar^4\rho v^5}\frac{(S!)^2S^2(2S-1)^3}{(2S)!}\left(\frac{B}{16D}\right)^{-S}D^4\right]}
Tetragonal anisotropyEvenC(S+4+S−4)C(S_+^4+S_-^4)8DS2(2S)![(S/2)!]2(C16D)S/2\frac{8DS^2(2S)!}{[(S/2)!]^2}\left(\frac{C}{16D}\right)^{S/2}(2S−1)Dln⁡[1+3kB58πℏ4ρv5S2(2S−1)3[(S/2)!]2(2S)!(C16D)−S/2D4]\frac{(2S-1)D}{\ln\left[1+\frac{3k_B^5}{8\pi\hbar^4\rho v^5}\frac{S^2(2S-1)^3[(S/2)!]^2}{(2S)!}\left(\frac{C}{16D}\right)^{-S/2}D^4\right]}
Transverse fieldAnygμBHxSxg\mu_BH_xS_x8DS2(2S)!(gμBHx2D)2S\frac{8DS^2}{(2S)!}\left(\frac{g\mu_BH_x}{2D}\right)^{2S}(2S−1)Dln⁡[1+3kB58πℏ4ρv5S2(2S−1)3(2S)!S2S(gμBHx2SD)−2SD4]\frac{(2S-1)D}{\ln\left[1+\frac{3k_B^5}{8\pi\hbar^4\rho v^5}\frac{S^2(2S-1)^3(2S)!}{S^{2S}}\left(\frac{g\mu_BH_x}{2SD}\right)^{-2S}D^4\right]}

Table 1. Estimations of the coherence/incoherence transition temperature T0T_0 at resonance for some typical origins of the tunneling splitting in molecular spin systems.

For an anisotropic molecular spin with spin number SS (JJ), the ground doublet tunneling splitting Δ1\Delta_1 depends on its spin Hamiltonian Hsp\mathcal{H}_{\mathrm{sp}}. This Hamiltonian has the form Hsp=H0+δH\mathcal{H}_{\mathrm{sp}}=\mathcal{H}_0+\delta H where the axial component H0\mathcal{H}_0 commutes with operator SzS_z and the non-axial component δH\delta H does not. Tunneling splitting of the spin system is caused by the latter and thus may possess various forms. In order to determine the transition temperature dependence on spin number and the anisotropy of the molecular spin system, we thus need to expand Δ1\Delta_1 from the above as a function of the anisotropy and spin number of the system. This is what we show in Table I where some typical forms of δH\delta H [2, 29] and the corresponding estimated T0T_0 derived straightforwardly from Eq. (4) are listed. It is apparent from the table that the transition temperature is proportional to the axial anisotropy parameter DD as well as approximately the spin number SS when these are large since the natural logarithm in the denominator of T0T_0 (the fourth column of Table I) increases slower than the one in the numerator. In the case of a small SS and/or DD, the transition temperature is inversely proportional to some power of DD since the denominator involves the logarithm function where ln⁡(1+x)≈x\ln(1+x)\approx x for x→0x\to0. That is to say, the case of large SS and DD or the case of small SS and DD will maximize the coherence/incoherence transition temperature.

To have a clearer view on the dependence of the transition temperature T0T_0 on the spin number and anisotropy of the spin system as well as giving a clue to designing a molecular spin qubit where coherence can be observed at high temperature, we illustrate this dependence in Figure 1, 2, and 3 for difference types of the anisotropy listed in Table I. As can be seen, regardless of the origin of the tunneling splitting, whether it is from rhombic anisotropic, tetragonal anisotropic, or transverse field, a molecular spin with a high transition temperature either must have a high spin number S(J)S(J) and highly axial (large DD), or low spin number S(J)S(J) and low axiality (small DD). In both cases, a large non-axial Hamiltonian component (BB, CC, HxH_x, ...) is required to maximize the transition temperature. This conclusion is highly likely applicable for any candidate for molecular spin qubit, whether it’s 3d- or 4f-complexes.

Dependence of the coherence/incoherence transition temperature on the spin number and axial anisotropic parameters

Figure 1. Dependence of the coherence/incoherence transition temperature T0T_0 on the spin number SS and the axial anisotropic parameters DD and BB for a rhombic anisotropic molecular spin.

The above conclusion can be explained if we consider physics of the quantum coherence in the ground doublet. In particular, for enhancing quantum coherence in molecular spin, either the ground doublet must be far from other

Figure 2. Dependence of the coherence/incoherence transition temperature T0T_0 on the spin number SS and the anisotropic parameters DD and CC for a tetragonal anisotropic molecular spin.

Figure 3. Dependence of the coherence/incoherence transition temperature T0T_0 on the axial anisotropic parameter DD and the transversal field HxH_x for an axial anisotropic molecular spin where the tunneling splitting results from a transverse magnetic field.

excited states to reduce the decoherence, in particular the thermal dephasing rate, to the latter (hence high SS and highly axial system), or increasing the quantum tunneling splitting to amplify the effect of the quantum tunneling process (hence low SS, low axiality). Of course, for both cases, a large non-axial Hamiltonian component always help to increase the mixing between two tunneling-split states, accordingly increase the tunneling splitting and coherence within the ground doublet.

For the well-known SMM Mn12_{12}ac, we have C≈5×10−5C \approx5 \times10^{-5} K, D≈0.5D \approx0.5 K, and S=10S = 10 (cf. (cf. Ref. 21)). The transition temperature thus is estimated to be around 0.25 K at resonance. It is worth noting that throughout all calculations and figures above and hereinafter, the mass density ρ=1.5×103\rho= 1.5 \times10^{3} kg/m3^{3} and the sound velocity v=1.5×103v = 1.5 \times10^{3} m/s are used.

Out of resonance

From γ0\gamma_0 is given in Eq. (3) and the corresponding transition temperature T0T_0 is approximated in Eq. (4), it is straightforward to obtain the function T0(W1)T_0(W_1),

T0(W1)≃(2S−1)Dln⁡[1+r0rW1](5)T_0(W_1) \simeq\frac{(2S-1)D}{\ln\left[1+\frac{r_0}{r_{W_1}}\right]} \tag*{(5)}

where

r0=3kB5πℏ4ρv5S4(2S−1)3D5Δ1(6)r_0 = \frac{3k_{\mathrm{B}}^5}{\pi\hbar^4 \rho v^5}\frac{S^4(2S-1)^3D^5}{\Delta_1} \tag*{(6)}
rW1={1for W1=0,(1−8W12Δ12+3)4W12Δ121−8W12Δ12+182W1Δ1for 0≤W1Δ1<122,3221−2W12Δ12for 122≤W1Δ1<12,0for W1Δ1≥12.(7)r_{W_1} = \begin{cases} 1 & \text{for } W_1=0,\\ \frac{\left(\sqrt{1-8\frac{W_1^2}{\Delta_1^2}}+3\right)\sqrt{4\frac{W_1^2}{\Delta_1^2}\sqrt{1-8\frac{W_1^2}{\Delta_1^2}}+1}}{\frac{8\sqrt{2}W_1}{\Delta_1}} & \text{for } 0\leq\frac{W_1}{\Delta_1}<\frac{1}{2\sqrt{2}},\\ \frac{3}{2\sqrt{2}}\sqrt{1-2\frac{W_1^2}{\Delta_1^2}} & \text{for } \frac{1}{2\sqrt{2}}\leq\frac{W_1}{\Delta_1}<\frac{1}{\sqrt{2}},\\ 0 & \text{for } \frac{W_1}{\Delta_1}\geq\frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}. \end{cases} \tag*{(7)}

For tunneling splitting Δ1\Delta_1 resulting from rhombic anisotropy, tetragonal anisotropic and transverse field, a table similar to Table I can be easily introduced. However, we do not include it here since it is lengthy and difficult to infer any conclusion from that. Instead, we resort to a visual illustration. In Figure 4, Figure 5, and Figure 6, we examine the dependence of the transition temperature T0T_0 on the energy bias W1W_1 in the ground doublet for two potentially best molecular spin qubit systems concluded from the above section: 1) small spin number SS (JJ) and small axial anisotropy; 2) large spin number SS (JJ) with large axial anisotropy. As can be seen from these figures, the transition temperature T0T_0 in former system generally declines faster and faster w.r.t an increasing in the energy bias W1W_1 and becomes 0 at W1=Δ1/2W_1 = \Delta_1/\sqrt{2}. On the contrary, the transition temperature T0T_0 in the latter system with large SS (JJ) and large axial anisotropy remains approximately constant until W1≈Δ1/2W_1 \approx\Delta_1/\sqrt{2}. Technically, this results from a large r0r_0 due to a large SS and DD in the latter system but small r0r_0 due to a small SS and DD in the former system. This interesting dependence of the transition temperature T0T_0 on the energy bias W1W_1 suggests that those systems with large SS (JJ) and highly axial anisotropy have more potential to be a practical molecular spin qubit than the one with small SS (JJ) since their coherence/incoherence transition temperature, and accordingly the coherence within the ground doublet, are insensitive to the magnetic noise from the environment. This also means in order to secure the coherence, an extreme magnetic dilution can be avoided to a certain extent for this kind of molecular spin system.

Figure 4. Dependence of the transition temperature T0T_0 on the energy bias W1W_1 for a rhombic anisotropic molecular spin.

Figure 5. Dependence of the transition temperature T0T_0 on the energy bias W1W_1 for a tetragonal anisotropic molecular spin.

Figure 6. Dependence of the transition temperature T0T_0 on the energy bias W1W_1 for an axial anisotropic molecular spin where the tunneling splitting results from a transverse magnetic field.

Discussions

Up to now, we haven’t mentioned the role of the ligand on the coherence/incoherence transition temperature. In fact, this has been implicitly included via the anisotropy parameters of the spin Hamiltonian. On the other hand, since our demonstration mainly involves a rough estimation of the transition temperature, the effect of specific properties of the ligand, such as its rigidity, on the thermal vibrations of the molecule entered the demonstration via the selection of Eq. (2) for the transition decoherence rate γ\gamma. Regarding the static effects of other magnetic noises on the molecular spin system from surrounding nuclear or electronic spins, these are obviously covered by the energy bias W1W_1. However, the decoherence sources from the dynamic nature of hyperfine or dipolar interactions have not been taken into account.

It is worth reminding that although in the main text we mainly discussed the spin number SS, which is often a good quantum number for transition metal complexes, the results are applicable to the lanthanide-based molecular spin as well where the total angular momentum number JJ is a good quantum number. In addition, the technique developed in this work can also be applied to other systems with different spin Hamiltonian to roughly estimate their corresponding transition temperature.

The main objective of this paper is to seek the answer for the questions how to calculate the coherence/incoherence transition temperature and what kind of molecular spin system will have a high coherence/incoherence transition temperature and/or insensitive to the magnetic noise. Throughout an examination of the coherence/incoherence transition temperature with some typical spin Hamiltonians, it is possible to conclude that a highly axial anisotropic molecular spin with high spin number SS (JJ) and a large non-axial Hamiltonian component is likely the best candidate. The second best one is a low axial spin system with low spin number SS but still having a large non-axial Hamiltonian component. Both kinds of system are as good at giving a high coherence/incoherence transition temperature but the former is more robust in protection against the magnetic noise. This can be explained by the energy spectrum of these systems which either disfavors the decoherence to higher energy states or amplifies the tunneling splitting gaps by which increasing the coherence within the ground doublet. To our knowledge, this is the first quantitative study to deal with these questions from the theoretical point of view and also of direct practical relevance as well. Indeed, by figuring out the characteristics of those systems with high coherence/incoherence transition temperature, the work sets out a solid guideline on which molecular spin system is the most potential to be a good molecular spin qubit. Furthermore, it also set an upper boundary for the temperature beyond which coherence in molecular spins cannot be observed as well as establishes a lower limit for the temperature below which an application of the incoherent approximation of the quantum tunneling of magnetization is no longer valid.

Acknowledgments

L. T. A. H. and L. U. acknowledge the financial support of the research projects R-143-000-A65-133, A-8000709-00-00 and A-8000017-00-00 of the National University of Singapore. Calculations were done on the ASPIRE-1 cluster (www.nscc.sg) under the projects 11001278 and 51000267. Computational resources of the HPC-NUS are gratefully acknowledged.

References

References

  1. [1]R. Sessoli, D. Gatteschi, a. Caneschi, and M. A. Novak, Nature 365, 141 (1993).
  2. [2]D. Gatteschi, R. Sessoli, and J. Villain, Molecular Nanomagnets (Oxford University Press, 2006) pp. 1–408.
  3. [3]A. Gaita-Ariño, F. Luis, S. Hill, and E. Coronado, Nature Chemistry 11, 301 (2019).
  4. [4]N. F. Chilton, Annual Review of Materials Research 52, 79 (2022).
  5. [5]E. Coronado, Nature Reviews Materials (2019), 10.1038/s41578-019-0146-8.
  6. [6]E. Moreno-Pineda, C. Godfrin, F. Balestra, W. Wernsdorfer, and M. Ruben, Chemical Society Reviews 47, 501 (2018).
  7. [7]E. Moreno-Pineda and W. Wernsdorfer, Nature Reviews Physics 3, 645 (2021).
  8. [8]L. Escalera-Moreno, J. J. Baldoví, A. Gaita-Ariño, and E. Coronado, Chemical Science (2018), 10.1039/C7SC05464E.
  9. [9]J. Bartolomé, F. Luis, and J. F. Fernández, Molecular Magnets, edited by J. Bartolomé, F. Luis, and J. F. Fernández, NanoScience and Technology (Springer Berlin Heidelberg, Berlin, Heidelberg, 2014).
  10. [10]D. Aravena, Journal of Physical Chemistry Letters 9, 5327 (2018).
  11. [11]C. A. P. Goodwin, F. Ortu, D. Reta, N. F. Chilton, and D. P. Mills, Nature 548, 439 (2017).
  12. [12]F. S. Guo, B. M. Day, Y. C. Chen, M. L. Tong, A. Mansikkamäki, and R. A. Layfield, Angewandte Chemie - International Edition 56, 11445 (2017).
  13. [13]F. S. Guo, B. M. Day, Y. C. Chen, M. L. Tong, A. Mansikkamäki, and R. A. Layfield, Science 0652, 1 (2018).
  14. [14]M. N. Leuenberger and D. Loss, Nature 410, 789 (2001).
  15. [15]M. D. Jenkins, Y. Duan, B. Diosdado, J. J. García-Ripoll, A. Gaita-Ariño, C. Giménez-Saiz, P. J. Alonso, E. Coronado, and F. Luis, Physical Review B 95, 1 (2017).
  16. [16]E. Moreno-Pineda, C. Godfrin, F. Balestra, W. Wernsdorfer, and M. Ruben, Chemical Society Reviews 47, 501 (2018).
  17. [17]M. Atzori and R. Sessoli, Journal of the American Chemical Society 141, 11339 (2019).
  18. [18]S. Carretta, D. Zueco, A. Chiesa, Á. Gómez-León, and F. Luis, Applied Physics Letters 118, 240501 (2021), arXiv:2105.00654.DOI
  19. [19]C. Godfrin, A. Ferhat, R. Ballou, S. Klyatskaya, M. Ruben, W. Wernsdorfer, and F. Balestrо, Physical Review Letters 119, 1 (2017), arXiv:1710.11229.DOI
  20. [20]D. A. Garanin and E. M. Chudnovsky, Physical Review B 56, 11102 (1997).
  21. [21]M. N. Leuenberger and D. Loss, Physical Review B 61, 1286 (2000).
  22. [22]K. Blum, Symmetry Matrix Theory and Applications, Springer Series on Atomic, Optical, and Plasma Physics, Vol. 64 (Springer Science & Business Media, Berlin, Heidelberg, 2012) p. 343.
  23. [23]D. A. Garanin, in Advances in Chemical Physics, Vol. 147 (Wiley, 2011) Chap. 4, pp. 213–277, arXiv:0805.0391.DOI
  24. [24]L. T. A. Ho and L. F. Chibotaru, Physical Review B 94, 104422 (2016), arXiv:1607.07576.DOI
  25. [25]L. T. A. Ho and L. F. Chibotaru, , 9 (2017), arXiv:1710.02053.arxiv.org/abs/1710.02053
  26. [26]L. T. A. Ho, L. Ungur, and L. F. Chibotaru, , 10 (2022), arXiv:xxxx.xxxxx.
  27. [27]L. T. A. Ho, L. Ungur, and L. F. Chibotaru, , 10 (2022), arXiv:xxxx.xxxxx.
  28. [28]L. T. A. Ho, L. Ungur, and L. F. Chibotaru, , 10 (2022), arXiv:xxxx.xxxxx.
  29. [29]F. Hartmann-boutron, P. Politi, and J. Villain, International Journal of Modern Physics B 10, 2577 (1996).

Paper details

vlnc:W_q5ec6hse
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 5

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents