WorksPhysics and Astronomy
Competing shape evolution, crossing configurations and single particle levels in nuclei
Abstract
The evolution of shape in the even-even zirconium (Zr) isotopes has been the subject of study for many years. However, the odd-mass isotopes have not been investigated as extensively due to limited experimental accessibility and computational challenges. This work, employing the interacting boson-fermion model with configuration mixing, examines the effect of rapid shape evolution and normal-intruder configuration crossing – both identified as quantum phase transitions – alongside evolution in single particle energies, on the positive-parity spectrum of odd-mass Zr isotopes. Calculated energy levels, magnetic moments, values, and quadrupole moments are compared to experimental data, showing good agreement. The special case of Zr, which lies near the critical point of both quantum phase transitions, is also addressed, offering a new interpretation to the isomeric state and the occurrence of the type II shell evolution, in light of recent debates.
In Eq. (1), represents the boson Hamiltonian. Here, describes the normal A configuration with bosons, while describes the intruder B configuration with bosons. Here, a typical Hamiltonian for both configurations is used
with . Interactions in Eq. (2) include the -bosons number operator , the rotational term , and the quadrupole operator
where and are spherical tensors, coupled in a tensor product and . The parameter represents the energy offset between configurations A and B, and the mixing term is given by
where H.c. stands for Hermitian conjugate.
For , the fermion Hamiltonian, is the fermion number operator, with as single particle energies for each orbit and the angular momentum of the orbital.
The Bose-Fermi Hamiltonian consists of monopole, quadrupole, and exchange terms with respective strengths , , and (), and occupation probabilities following the microscopic interpretation of the IBFM [18].
After diagonalization, the resulting wave functions are of the form
Here, is the boson number, the quantum numbers from the boson Hamiltonian, () the boson (fermion) angular momentum, and the total angular momentum. The occupation probabilities for the boson number , the boson number, and the single particle orbitals of the wave function can be determined from
For Eq. (6a), , where , . It provides the occupation probability of , indicating the proportion of normal () and intruder () configurations.
Eq. (6b) represents the occupation probability of the single particle orbitals, . Eq. (6c) represents the occupation probability of , which indicates the degree of deformation. A large suggests dominant U(5) boson symmetry, equivalent to a spherical shape (phase) in the geometrical interpretation of the IBM [20]. If the wave function is distributed among several values, it indicates deformation. Thus, using Eqs. (6a) to (6c) one can analyze the evolution of occupation in the configurational, single particle and deformation content of the wave functions.
To analyze electromagnetic transitions, the operator with multipolarity for transitions of type is define as
with boson and fermion parts. In this work, we concentrate on and transitions
For the transitions, Eq. (8a) defines the boson effective charges for configurations A and B as and , respectively. In Eq. (8b), the fermion part is given by , where is the fermion effective charge.
For the transitions, Eq. (8c) specifies the free value of the neutron spin -factor as , which is quenched by 30%, while the orbital angular momentum -factor is .
The isotopes with mass number – are described by coupling a neutron to their respective even-even cores with –. The parameters of in Eq. (1) and the boson numbers are thus taken from a previous work [16], with the sign one in Eq. (3) modified for –, as recent measurements of spectroscopic quadrupole moments of have shown to be positive [23].
In the odd isotopes, the valence neutrons occupy different orbits within the – shell. Talmi [24] showed that neutrons in – primarily reside in the orbital, with representing a subshell closure. Therefore, for –, an occupation of and , respectively, is assumed, where is the number of valence neutrons. For –, a BCS calculation is performed [18] to evaluate the SqPEs () and their occupations (). As more neutrons are added, the changing
Single quasi-particle occupations, the Fermi energy , and parameters in MeV of the boson-fermion interactions, of Eq. (1), obtained from a fit assuming , and for and B. Beneath each isotope the number of valence neutrons used in the shell model (Zr) and BCS (Zr) evaluations is listed.
| Isotope | Zr | Zr | Zr | Zr | Zr | Zr |
| # particles | 3 | 5 | 1 | 3 | 5 | 7 |
| 3/6 | 5/6 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | |
| 0 | 0 | 0.085 | 0.351 | 0.567 | 0.697 | |
| 0 | 0 | 0.037 | 0.110 | 0.189 | 0.275 | |
| 0 | 0 | 0.033 | 0.091 | 0.152 | 0.219 | |
| 0 | 0 | 0.034 | 0.095 | 0.158 | 0.229 | |
| 0 | 0 | 0.122 | 0.385 | |||
| 0.983 | 0.133 | |||||
| 0.037 | 0.086 | 0.059 | 0.455 | 0.464 | 0.757 | |
| 1.191 | 1.063 | 1.121 | 1.910 | 1.910 | 1.824 |
Table 1. Single quasi-particle occupations, the Fermi energy , and parameters in MeV of the boson-fermion interactions, of Eq. (1), obtained from a fit assuming , and for and B. Beneath each isotope the number of valence neutrons used in the shell model (Zr) and BCS (Zr) evaluations is listed.
Fermi energy affects these evaluations. According to the microscopic interpretation of the IBFM [25], the are required for , and impact of Eq. (1). The neutrons are distributed among the , , , and orbitals, with the considered closed, as done in a previous IBFM calculation [26]. For the BCS calculation, the single particle energies of Zr are used [27], along with a pairing gap of MeV, calculated as the average of [28].
Table I presents the resulting and the strengths () for the positive-parity states. The strengths for the negative-parity states will be addressed in a subsequent publication. The exchange strength increases gradually along the isotopic chain. The quadrupole strength remains relatively constant for Zr and Zr, suggesting an increase in deformation between these regions. The monopole strength decreases from Zr to Zr, with exceptions at Zr and Zr, possibly due to the lack of experimental data. The occupation probabilities increase with the number of valence neutrons, which in turn influences the SqPEs. The evolution in SqPEs, shown in Figure 2(a), depicts a significant lowering of the , and orbitals from Zr to Zr.
Figure 2. Evolution of: (a) Single quasi-particle energies, ; (b) Single quasi-particle occupation probabilities of the lowest positive-parity state, , Eq. (6b). Each color indicates a different orbital: () (blue), () (red), () (green), () (yellow). Note the transition from a singular single quasi-particle occupation for to a distribution of them for ; (c) occupation probability of the lowest positive-parity state, , Eq. (6c), depicting the different possible normal () and intruder () values. Each color represents a different number from (green) to (purple). Note the transition from a single dominant bar (representing a spherical state) for to a distribution of them (representing a deformed state) for . In both (b) and (c), bars from the left (right) of the mass number correspond to normal (intruder) occupations, with intruder bars filled with diagonal lines; (d) the amount of normal occupation in the wave function, Eq. (6a). Note the transition from normal in to intruder in . The values of are indicated in the uppermost panel.
The trends in strengths and SqPEs are reflected in the spectrum of Zr isotopes, shown in Figure 1, illustrating the energies of selected states. The calculated panel, showing good agreement with the experimental data, depicts the normal-intruder mixing, where filled (empty) symbols represent normal (intruder) states, as defined by Eq. (6a). For the lowest positive-parity state, the total angular momentum undergoes an intricate evolution: for Zr, for Zr, and for Zr.
Figure 1. Comparison between experimental (left panel) and calculated (right panel) lowest-energy levels in odd Zr isotopes. On the right panel, the symbols filling indicates the dominance of the normal A configuration (filled) or intruder B configuration (empty) with assignments based on Eq. (6a). For example, the is normal A configuration for –97, mixed for , and intruder B configuration for –103.
This evolution results from a combination of deformation, configuration mixing, and single quasi-particle occupation. For Zr, the state results from the orbital weakly coupled to the respective Zr cores, particularly the spherical normal . A similar situation occurs for Zr, where the state is associated with coupling the orbital to the Zr cores. For Zr, the state results from closely spaced orbitals, ontop of the onset of deformation and configuration crossing, where all the lowest lying states are intruder states.
In Figure 1 the lowest negative-parity level, , and its configuration content is also shown. For Zr it is normal, for Zr it is intruder, for Zr intruder, and for Zr it is intruder (more details will be published elsewhere).
The analysis above is further stressed in Figure 2, depicting the resulting SqPEs from the BCS calculation (panel a), and and the different occupations of the lowest positive-parity state, : the SqP occupation (6b) (panel b), -U(5) boson symmetry occupation (6c) (panel c) and configuration content (6a) (panel d).
For Zr, panel (b) shows a dominant orbit, panel (c) shows a dominant component, and panel (d) shows a dominant normal component. This indicates a weak coupling scenario of a normal wave function with good U(5) boson symmetry coupled to a orbital. A similar pattern is observed for Zr, but with the orbital instead. In contrast, for Zr, panel (b) shows a mixture of , and orbitals within the intruder part of the wave function, panel (c) shows boson U(5)- occupations indicating a deformed intruder state, and panel (d) shows almost no normal occupation in the wave function, indicating an almost pure intruder state.
The increase in -mixture observed in panel (b) corresponds clearly to the lowering of the SqPEs shown in (a) of Figure 2. The evolution observed in panels (c) and (d), from spherical to deformed states and from normal to intruder configurations, indicates the presence of the two quantum phase transitions (IQPTs) similar to those seen in the even-even Zr and odd-mass Nb chains [29].
To further examine the calculated wave functions, it is essential to compare them with electromagnetic transition rates. For transitions in Eq. (8), the boson effective charges , are taken from [16]. The fermion effective charge, , is determined from a fit to the spectroscopic quadrupole moment of Zr, eb.
The fitting procedure yields eb for Zr, compared to the experimental value of eb. The experimental transitions (calculation in parentheses) are: Zr: W.u. (1.1), Zr: W.u. (4.80), Zr: W.u. (1.91), and
: W.u. (82). The calculated values are reasonably close to the experimental ones and indicate the onset of deformation at , as evidenced by the strong increase in transition strength, with a possible need for more deformation.
Magnetic moments, which are strongly influenced by the single particle structure, provide further indicative observables. For transitions operator, Eq. (8), the same values for , , , is used as in [17].
Figure 3 compares the calculated magnetic moments with the experimental ones, as well as the single particle estimations [30]. For , there is a good agreement between the calculation and experimental data for the ground state. Notably, the IBFM-CM result also coincides with the single particle estimations [30], further supporting the single particle character of the ground state. This interpretation extends to the state of , which exhibits an almost pure occupation and spherical normal configuration in its wave function.
Figure 3. Evolution of magnetic moments in units of , along the odd Zr chain. Symbols denote experimental data for the ground state and excited states when available, taken from [32]. Each value has a different color. The solid (dashed) line and black triangles (squares) denote calculated results, based on Eqs. (8c) and (13) (single particle estimation). See text for more details.
However, deviations from the single particle interpretation are observed for the excited states of and the ground state of . For the and states in these isotopes, better agreement is achieved with the IBFM-CM calculation. The reason is that these states become more mixed in their orbitals, losing their single quasi-particle character due to the onset of deformation and configuration mixing. In , the and are strongly mixed in configuration and occupations. For the , there is still some deviation for the IBFM-CM, which might suggest more deformation is needed in the core, as was suggested in [31]. For , the state is pure intruder deformed, with mixed orbitals, which explains the deviation from the single particle value.
A closer examination of is intriguing, as it lies nearest to the critical points of the shape evolution and configuration crossing QPTs between and [16]. Recently, an IBFM calculation with a single configuration was presented in [10, 11] for . In [11], the authors compared the state in to that in , noting that both states are isomers. However, for the state, the magnetic moment for , , deviates from the single particle prediction observed in . This led the authors in [11] to suggest the occurrence of a type II shell evolution, causing the single particle orbital to become lower than the .
While Ref. [11] successfully reproduced this magnetic moment value, the calculated energies did not align well with experimental data. This discrepancy was later questioned in Ref. [33], leading the authors to propose an IBFM configuration mixing model for improvement. In [33], it was argued that there is no need for a change in the single particle energies, as suggested by previous works [7, 26]. Furthermore, as was suggested in [6], only the resulting effective single particle energies are modified, leading to the type II shell evolution between the spin orbit partners and .
This work confirms that lowering the single particle orbital is unnecessary in . Instead, the resulting single quasi-particle energies account for the state as a normal single quasi-particle state of the orbital, while the and are mixed normal-intruder deformed states. Furthermore, the intruder character of the state in mainly results from coupling with the intruder state of core (unlike the less conventional choice of boson core with a hole in [11]). Its isomeric nature is attributed to the dominant single quasi-particle component in the normal-intruder components (total ), while for the state, it is the orbital (), which are weakly connected via in Eq. (8). In , the isomeric nature arises from the single particle character of the state of .
In summary, a comprehensive analysis of the odd isotopes has been conducted using the interacting boson-fermion model with configuration mixing. This approach employed boson, fermion, and Bose-Fermi Hamiltonians with mixed configurations, focusing on positive-parity states. The good agreement with experimental data on energies, transitions, and quadrupole and magnetic moments underscores the manifestation of shape, configuration, and single quasi-particle evolutions that influence the spectrum. The special case of was further examined in light of recent studies [10, 11] suggesting a type II shell evolution in the single-particle orbit. It was demonstrated that while type II shell evolution occurs in the effective single particle orbits, as suggested in [6], it does not occur in the single particle orbits and does not lower the orbit. Instead, the spectrum is shown to result from the interplay of shape, configuration, and single quasi-particle evolutions, offering a resolution to the recent debate [33, 34]. This work may inspire further experimental and theoretical efforts to identify and differentiate shape, configuration, and single particle effects in the structural evolution of atomic nuclei. As demonstrated here, these effects are particularly pronounced in odd-mass nuclei.
Acknowledgments
The author acknowledges support from the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation program under the Marie Skłodowska-Curie grant agreement No. 101107805.
References
References
- [6]T. Togashi, Y. Tsunoda, T. Otsuka, and N. Shimizu, Phys. Rev. Lett. 117, 172502 (2016).
- [7]S. Brant, V. Paar, and A. Wolf, Phys. Rev. C 58, 1349 (1998).
- [10]P. Spagnoletti, G. Simpson, S. Kisyov, D. Bucurescu, J.-M. Régis, N. Saed-Samii, A. Blanc, M. Jentschel, U. Köster, P. Mutti, T. Soldner, G. de France, C. A. Ur, W. Urban, A. M. Bruce, C. Bernards, F. Drouet, L. M. Fraile, L. P. Gaffney, D. G. Ghiță, S. Ilieva, J. Jolie, W. Korten, T. Kröll, S. Lalkovski, C. Larijani, R. Lică, H. Mach, N. Märginean, V. Pazy, Z. Podolyák, P. H. Regan, M. Scheck, J. F. Smith, G. Thiamova, C. Townsley, A. Vanraesenaeyest, V. Vedia, N. Warr, V. Werner, and M. Zielińska, Phys. Rev. C 100, 014311 (2019).
- [11]F. Boulay, G. Simpson, Y. Ichikawa, S. Kisyov, D. Bucurescu, A. Takamine, D. S. Ahn, K. Asahi, H. Baba, D. L. Balabanski, T. Egami, T. Fujita, N. Fukuda, C. Funayama, T. Furukawa, G. Georgiev, A. Gladkov, M. Hass, K. Imamura, N. Inabe, Y. Ishibashi, T. Kawaguchi, T. Kawamura, W. Kim, Y. Kobayashi, S. Kojima, A. Kusoglu, R. Lozeva, S. Momiyama, I. Mukul, M. Niikura, H. Nishibata, T. Nishizaka, A. Odahara, Y. Ohtomo, D. Ralet, T. Sato, Y. Shimizu, T. Sumikama, H. Suzuki, H. Takeda, L. C. Tao, Y. Togano, D. Tominaga, H. Ueno, H. Yamazaki, X. F. Yang, and J. M. Daugas, Phys. Rev. Lett. 124, 112501 (2020).
- [16]N. Gavrielov, A. Leviatan, and F. Iachello, Phys. Rev. C 105, 014305 (2022).
- [17]N. Gavrielov, A. Leviatan, and F. Iachello, Phys. Rev. C 106, L051304 (2022).
- [18]N. Gavrielov, Phys. Rev. C 108, 014320 (2023).
- [20]F. Iachello and A. Arima, The Interacting Boson Model (Cambridge University Press, 1987).
- [23]D. L. Balabanski, T. Egami, T. Fujita, N. Fukuda, C. Funayama, T. Furukawa, G. Georgiev, A. Gladkov, M. Hass, K. Imamura, N. Inabe, Y. Ishibashi, T. Kawaguchi, T. Kawamura, W. Kim, Y. Kobayashi, S. Kojima, A. Kusoglu, R. Lozeva, S. Momiyama, I. Mukul, M. Niikura, H. Nishibata, T. Nishizaka, A. Odahara, Y. Ohtomo, D. Ralet, T. Sato, Y. Shimizu, T. Sumikama, H. Suzuki, H. Takeda, L. C. Tao, Y. Togano, D. Tominaga, H. Ueno, H. Yamazaki, X. F. Yang, and J. M. Daugas, Phys. Rev. Lett. 124, 112501 (2020).
- [24]I. Talmi, Phys. Rev. 126, 2116 (1962).
- [25]O. Scholten, Prog. Part. Nucl. Phys. 14, 189 (1985).
- [26]G. Lhermounneau, B. Pfeifer, K. L. Kratz, H. Ohm, K. S. Sı̄stemich, S. Brant, and V. Paar, Zeitschrift für Phys. A At. Nucl. 337, 149 (1990).
- [27]J. Barea and F. Iachello, Phys. Rev. C 79, 044301 (2009).
- [28]A. Bohr and B. R. Mottelson, Nuclear structure, Vol. 2 (World Scientific, 1998).
- [29]N. Gavrielov, Phys. Scr. 99, 075310 (2024).
- [30]I. Talmi, Simple Models of Complex Nuclei: The Shell Model and Interacting Boson Model (Harwood Academic, 1993).
- [31]V. Karayonchev, J. Jolie, A. Blazhev, A. Dewald, A. Esmaylzadeh, C. Fransen, G. Häfner, L. Knafla, J. Litzinger, C. Müller-Gatermann, J.-M. Régis, K. Schumacher, A. Vogt, N. Warr, A. Leviatan, and N. Gavrielov, Phys. Rev. C 102, 064314 (2020).
- [32]N. J. Stone, At. Data Nucl. Data Tables 90, 75 (2005).
- [33]P. E. Garrett, Phys. Rev. Lett. 127, 169201 (2021).
- [34]F. Boulay, G. S. Simpson, Y. Ichikawa, S. Kisyov, D. Bucurescu, A. Takamine, D. S. Ahn, K. Asahi, H. Baba, D. L. Balabanski, T. Egami, T. Fujita, N. Fukuda, C. Funayama, T. Furukawa, G. Georgiev, A. Gladkov, M. Hass, K. Imamura, N. Inabe, Y. Ishibashi, T. Kawaguchi, T. Kawamura, W. Kim, Y. Kobayashi, S. Kojima, A. Kusoglu, R. Lozeva, S. Momiyama, I. Mukul, M. Niikura, H. Nishibata, T. Nishizaka, A. Odahara, Y. Ohtomo, D. Ralet, T. Sato, Y. Shimizu, T. Sumikama, H. Suzuki, H. Takeda, L. C. Tao, Y. Togano, D. Tominaga, H. Ueno, H. Yamazaki, X. F. Yang, and J. M. Daugas, Phys. Rev. Lett. 127, 169202 (2021).


