betaFeedback

WorksMathematics

Whitehead doubles and the failure of the AJ conjecture

Abstract

For marked Whitehead doubles of torus knots with coprime parameters 2≤r<s2\le r<s, the AJ conjecture fails for both clasp signs, both companion chiralities, and every integer twist. The zero-framed signed unreduced colored Jones sequence has a nonzero rationally saturated annihilator. Every nonzero primitive representative specializes nontrivially at t=−1t=-1 with the meridian variable MM independent. With LL the longitude variable, the specialization contains the irreducible quadratic E=L2−(M4−4M2+1)L+M4E=L^2-(M^4-4M^2+1)L+M^4 for the negative clasp and M4E(M−1,L)M^4E(M^{-1},L) for the positive clasp. The corresponding quadratic is coprime to the full classical AA-polynomial, including L−1L-1, over Q(M)[L±1]\mathbb{Q}(M)[L^{\pm1}], so the discrepancy persists when each irreducible factor is counted once. The curve E=0E=0 comes from the marked Whitehead link exterior with its axis cusp complete. For the displayed monic polynomial, πm(E)πm(E) is the unsigned volume of that two-cusped exterior. We use the actual Jones sequence to select a right divisor of the satellite transfer operator. Rational factor tests show that the quadratic survives in this divisor, and the two marked companion fillings exclude it as a component of the satellite boundary curve.

Introduction

Whitehead doubles of nontrivial torus knots give a uniform family of counterexamples to the AJ conjecture. For either clasp, either companion chirality, and every integer twist, the specialized minimal recurrence has an irreducible quadratic missing from the classical boundary curve. For the negative clasp this is the outer boundary curve in the marked Whitehead link shape chart with its axis cusp complete. The axis boundary torus is where the companion exterior attaches to form the satellite. The problem is to show that this curve survives on the quantum side after passing to the actual minimal recurrence, and to see why the gluing excludes it as a classical component.

The AJ conjecture of Garoufalidis [7] compares the colored Jones recurrence with the classical AA-polynomial. There are substantial families of AJ-positive satellites, including the cable families of Ruppe–Zhang, Ruppe, and Tran under the restrictions discussed in § 9 [21, 20, 27]. Counting each irreducible factor once addresses multiplicity discrepancies such as those in Zhang’s connected-sum examples [29]. The Whitehead quadratic survives this reduction.

The recurrence and boundary comparison

Use the zero-framed unreduced Jones polynomial ΦK(N;t)\Phi_K(N;t) in dimension color NN for S2S^2. The quantum dimension [N][N] and the positive-color reduced polynomial are given by

[N]=t2N−t−2Nt2−t−2,jK,N(q)=ΦK(N;t)[N](N>0),q=t4.[N] = \frac{t^{2N}-t^{-2N}}{t^2-t^{-2}}, \qquad j_{K,N}(q) = \frac{\Phi_K(N;t)}{[N]} \qquad(N>0), \qquad q=t^4.

For the zero-framed unknot UU, ΦU(N;t)=[N]\Phi_U(N;t)=[N], so jU,N(q)=1j_{U,N}(q)=1 for N>0N>0. We use ΦK(1;t)=1\Phi_K(1;t)=1, ΦK(0;t)=0\Phi_K(0;t)=0, and ΦK(−N;t)=−ΦK(N;t)\Phi_K(-N;t)=-\Phi_K(N;t) for N>0N>0. The operators M,LM,L act by multiplication by t2Nt^{2N} and forward shift of NN, so LM=t2MLLM=t^2ML. We use left coefficients and frequently write u=L−1u=L^{-1}, K=Q(t,M)\mathbb{K}=\mathbb{Q}(t,M) and D=K[u±1;σ]\mathbb{D}=\mathbb{K}[u^{\pm1};\sigma], where σ(M)=t−2M\sigma(M)=t^{-2}M. The forward shift acts on coefficients by τ=σ−1\tau=\sigma^{-1}.

Before localization the coefficient ring is Z[t±1,M±1]\mathbb{Z}[t^{\pm1},M^{\pm1}]. Let IKI_K be the left ideal of operators over this ring, with Laurent powers of LL, that annihilate the signed sequence at every integer. Its rational saturation is DIKD I_K. A rational operator belongs to it exactly when left multiplication by a nonzero Laurent-polynomial coefficient makes it a member of IKI_K.

For a generator of DIKD I_K, shift the lowest LL-exponent to zero and clear denominators on the left. Divide the coefficients by their content, the gcd of the nonzero coefficients in Z[t±1,M±1]\mathbb{Z}[t^{\pm1},M^{\pm1}]. The resulting primitive minimum αK\alpha_K is determined up to the coefficient units ±tiMj\pm t^iM^j. Its order is the difference between the largest and smallest shift exponents, hence the LL-degree after the shift to zero. The evaluation M=t2NM=t^{2N} is used to act on sequences. In fK=αK(−1,M,L)f_K=\alpha_K(-1,M,L) we instead specialize the coefficients at t=−1t=-1 with MM independent.

The full classical polynomial defines the boundary eigenvalue curves in the preferred meridian and longitude coordinates. Each irreducible factor occurs once, including L−1L-1 for the abelian line. We write AKA_K for its image in R=Q(M)[L±1]R=\mathbb{Q}(M)[L^{\pm1}]. This horizontal localization retains the components that project dominantly to the meridian, since meridian-only factors become units. We write ≐\doteq for association in RR. The usual AJ equality, with the same abelian convention and up to meridian factors, implies the radical equality

(fK)=(AK).(1)\sqrt{(f_K)}=(A_K). \tag*{(1)}

For nonzero fKf_K, this requires its square-free part to be associated to AKA_K in RR. An irreducible nonunit of RR dividing fKf_K and coprime to AKA_K contradicts this necessary condition. It suffices to bound the classical curve by a containing polynomial coprime to that factor.

The four-family theorem

The marking specifies the component orientations, the preferred meridian–longitude pairs and the zero-framed companion embedding. The negative clasp is the Whitehead pattern of § 2. The twist ℓ\ell is counted at the site in Figure 2, with sign fixed by (4). Its action on the odd channel is qℓn(n+1)q^{\ell n(n+1)}. The positive clasp uses the reflected clasp and the same signed disk-twist convention. Both use the faithful zero-framed embedding of the companion and the preferred outer meridian–longitude pair. Put T+=T(r,s)T_+=T(r,s), T−=T(r,−s)T_-=T(r,-s), with the orientation of T−T_- transported by reflection. Define

Zheng’s Whitehead-link diagram

Figure 2. Zheng’s Whitehead-link diagram (arXiv v4, p. 4) [30], with his twist label rr written as ℓ\ell. The positive twist is the one in (4). The axis belt surrounds the two strands of the outer component. For the untwisted trefoil the nonabelian companion restriction gives the filling slope μaxλax6\mu_{\rm ax}\lambda_{\rm ax}^{6}.

E(M,L)=L2−(M4−4M2+1)L+M4,E(M,L)=L^2-(M^4-4M^2+1)L+M^4,
E∨(M,L)=M4E(M−1,L)=M4L2−(M4−4M2+1)L+1.(2)E^{\vee}(M,L)=M^4E(M^{-1},L)=M^4L^2-(M^4-4M^2+1)L+1. \tag*{(2)}

Theorem 1.1 (Both clasp signs and all integer twists). Let 2≤r<s2\le r<s be coprime integers, let ℓ∈Z\ell\in\mathbb{Z}, and use the marked satellite S=Wℓ,ϵ(Tη)S=W_{\ell,\epsilon}(T_\eta) for each clasp sign ϵ\epsilon and each companion chirality η\eta. The actual signed rationally saturated annihilator is nonzero. With MM independent at specialization,

0≠fS=αS(−1,M,L),G∣fS,gcd⁡R(G,AS)=1,0\ne f_S=\alpha_S(-1,M,L),\qquad G\mid f_S,\qquad\gcd_R(G,A_S)=1,

where GG is specified by

T+T_+T−T_-
negative claspEEE∨E^{\vee}
positive claspE∨E^{\vee}E∨E^{\vee}

and GG is irreducible in RR. In each case the radical equality (1) fails, so SS is a counterexample to the AJ conjecture.

In the nondegenerate shape chart of Appendix § 12, completing the axis cusp imposes both peripheral conditions on that cusp. Their solutions project to E=0E=0 in the preferred outer coordinates of (2) (Section B.4). The same curve occurs in the trefoil symbol of § 3.4, where Z+2\mathbb{Z}+2 is proportional to EE off x2=1x^2=1 and L=−xL=-x, with x=M2≠0x=M^2\ne0. Here Z\mathbb{Z} is the trace of the axis longitude. The geometric identification uses the full cusp conditions in Section B.4. For the fixed monic integral representative of (2), Appendix § 12 also gives

πm(E)=Vol⁡(XWh)=4GCat,\pi m(E) = \operatorname{Vol}(X_{\mathrm{Wh}}) = 4G_{\mathrm{Cat}},

where XWhX_{\mathrm{Wh}} is the complete two-cusped Whitehead link exterior, Vol⁡\operatorname{Vol} is its unsigned hyperbolic volume, and GCatG_{\mathrm{Cat}} is Catalan’s constant. The Mahler measure is the known square-weave period in the normalization of (56) [4 Sec. 4.1, Thm. 12].

Selection of the quadratic

Left multiplication of an annihilator can introduce extra factors at specialization. Finding EE in a constructed operator leaves the central problem of proving that it survives in the actual minimal recurrence.

For the untwisted negative-clasp double S=Z(T(2,3))S = Z(T(2, 3)) of the right-handed trefoil, let B6B_6 be the longitude polynomial of the axis filling of signed index 6, defined in (16). Theorem A.1 gives

ord⁡L(αS)=16,fS=˙(L−1)2B6E,AS=˙(L−1)B6.\operatorname{ord}_{L}(\alpha_S) = 16,\qquad f_S \mathrel{\dot=} (L-1)^2B_6E,\qquad A_S \mathrel{\dot=} (L-1)B_6.

Counting L−1L-1 once still leaves EE as an extra irreducible factor. The uniform theorem gives survival of the quadratic. The full specialization and order above use the exact calculation in Appendix § 11. For all untwisted cases, Corollary 8.3 gives the divisibility AS∣fSA_S \mid f_S.

For the negative clasp put a=ηrs−ℓa = \eta rs - \ell, where η=1\eta= 1 for the right-handed companion and η=−1\eta= -1 for its mirror. The finite satellite transform gives the inhomogeneous equation PaF=bP_aF = b on the reduced sequence FF defined by the Jones invariant at positive colors. The proof places bb in a forcing module, a shift-stable module of tail sequences over the rational coefficient field. Sequences are identified on a tail if they agree for all sufficiently large positive colors. Growth estimates show that the class of FF in the quotient is nonzero. Lemma 6.1 then selects a nonunit right divisor of PaP_a that right-divides every tail annihilator of FF.

The rational factor analysis determines what this right divisor must retain. At isolated transverse intersections of specialized algebraic factors, Theorem 4.2 requires an integral logarithmic residue for the determinant of a quotient that separates them. The computed half-integer residues obstruct those separations. At nonzero effective index the rational operator is irreducible, using separate rank-one tests at a=1a = 1. At zero effective index the proof excludes linear right divisors, which suffices to retain the quadratic in the selected divisor. The factor survives the return to the signed unreduced sequence.

On the classical side, a representation restricts to the companion with one of two boundary relations. These give signed axis fillings whose containing polynomial is coprime to EE (§ 7). Thus E=0E = 0 is absent as a component of the satellite boundary curve, although individual boundary pairs may lie on it. Whole-knot reflection gives the other clasp.

The proof of the AJ discrepancy uses Zheng’s exact finite-color formula at generic qq [30]. Appendix § 12 gives the elliptic normalization Y2=X3−XY^2 = X^3 - X and relates the regulator primitive to the stationary action. For the negative clasp at zero twist and each fixed right-handed companion T(2,d)T(2,d) with d≥3d \ge3 odd, the additional analytic estimates of Section B.5 show that the dominant window of the actual root-of-unity sum gives a nonzero leading term and selects the lift w=iw = i.

The index a=0a = 0 occurs at ℓ=ηrs\ell= \eta rs, whereas the untwisted case has ℓ=0\ell= 0 and a=ηrsa = \eta rs. At a=0a = 0 the selection argument degenerates and requires finer coefficient information. In particular, for the positive companion the extremal summands tie and the actual leading coefficient NN separates the sequence from the forcing module. Table 1 gives the selection mechanisms for both companion signs.

Crossings in order 1, 2 | 3, 4 | 5, 6SchilderZheng
Signs for the auxiliary walks+++ + | −−- - | +++ +−−- - | +++ + | −−- -
Clasp writhe on PP+2+2−2-2

Table 1.

§ 5 constrains the operator’s rational factors, and § 6 uses the actual sequence to select a right divisor. § 5.3 and § 5.4 use the two simple intersections for a≥2a \ge2 and a<0a < 0, respectively. At a=1a = 1 the E/B1E/B_1 intersection remains simple. The other split requires the right and dual-left rank-one tests of § 5.5. At a=0a = 0, § 5.6 excludes first-order

CompanionIndexSeparation of the actual sequence from the forcing moduleSelection
T+T_{+}a≥1a \ge1Quadratic color valuation at t=0t = 0. At ℓ=0\ell= 0 the forcing is rational.§6.1
T+T_{+}a=0a = 0Leading coefficient NN versus controlled coefficient expansions of the finite Gaussian module.§6.5
T+T_{+}a<0a < 0Quadratic gap in the coefficient orders of the uninverted expansion.§6.5
T−T_{-}a<0a < 0Quadratic color valuation at t=∞t = \infty.§6.2
T−T_{-}a≥0a \ge0Quadratic gap in the coefficient orders after inversion and the stated rescaling.§6.6

caption: Table 1. Sequence selection for the negative clasp, with T+T_{+} right-handed and T−T_{-} its mirror. The coefficient comparisons use the common forcing identity and coefficient estimates of Sections 6.3 and 6.4.

:::

right divisors. This weaker conclusion suffices. The selected right divisor has degree two or three, and its specialization contains the quadratic (§ 6.7). § 7 proves classical exclusion. § 8.1 and § 8.2 give the signed return and whole-knot reflection.

Identifying the framed pattern

References

  1. [1]Comparator report for the localized AJ counterexample, 2026, Report of November 15, archived at 418b3ed8 and included in source supplement S1. Checked solution at commit 8dd21cf.
  2. [2]Anna Beliakova, Christian Blanchet, and Thang T. Q. Lê, Unified quantum invariants and their refinements for homology 3-spheres with 2-torsion, Fund. Math. 201 (2008), no. 3, 217–239, doi:10.4064/fm201-3-2.DOI
  3. [3]Giulio Belletti and Renaud Detcherry, On torsion in the Kauffman bracket skein module of 3-manifolds, 2024, arXiv:2406.17454v1.arxiv.org/abs/2406.17454
  4. [4]Abhijit Champanerkar, Ilya Kofman, and Matilde Lalín, Mahler measure and the Vol–Det conjecture, J. Lond. Math. Soc. 99 (2019), 872–900, arXiv:1805.05490v2.DOI
  5. [5]D. Cooper, M. Culler, H. Gillet, D. D. Long, and P. B. Shalen, Plane curves associated to character varieties of 3-manifolds, Invent. Math. 118 (1994), 47–84, Author’s edition.DOI
  6. [6]Jérôme Dubois and Rinat Kashaev, On the asymptotic expansion of the colored Jones polynomial for torus knots, Math. Ann. 339 (2007), 757–782, arXiv:math/0510607v5.arxiv.org/abs/math/0510607
  7. [7]Stavros Garoufalidis, On the characteristic and deformation varieties of a knot, Geom. Topol. Monogr. 7 (2004), 291–309, doi:10.2140/gtm.2004.7.291. See also arXiv:math/0306230v4.DOI
  8. [8]Stavros Garoufalidis and Christoph Koutschan, Irreducibility of q-difference operators and the knot 7₄, Algebr. Geom. Topol. 13 (2013), no. 6, 3261–3286, Published version.
  9. [9]Stavros Garoufalidis and Thang T. Q. Lê, The colored Jones function is q-holonomic, Geom. Topol. 9 (2005), 1253–1293, doi:10.2140/gt.2005.9.1253. Proof edition: arXiv:math/0309214v3.DOI
  10. [10]———, Asymptotics of the colored Jones function of a knot, Geom. Topol. 15 (2011), no. 4, 2135–2180, doi:10.2140/gt.2011.15.2135. The retained journal edition is used.DOI
  11. [11]C. McA. Gordon and J. Luecke, Knots are determined by their complements, J. Amer. Math. Soc. 2 (1989), 371–415.
  12. [12]Antonin Guilloux and Julien Marché, Volume function and Mahler measure of exact polynomials, Compos. Math. 157 (2021), 809–834, arXiv:1804.01395v1.DOI
  13. [13]Kazuo Habiro, A unified Witten–Reshetikhin–Turaev invariant for integral homology spheres, Invent. Math. 171 (2008), no. 1, 1–81, doi:10.1007/s00222-007-0071-0. Theorem locators refer to arXiv:math/0605314v1.DOI
  14. [14]Allen Hatcher, Notes on basic 3-manifold topology, Author’s notes, Sections 1.2–1.3, Theorem 1.9.
  15. [15]Thang T. Q. Lê, The colored Jones polynomial and the A-polynomial of knots, Adv. Math. 207 (2006), no. 2, 782–804, Author’s copy of the published version.DOI
  16. [16]Jinzheng Li, Zeru Zhu, and Yuanjie Ren, MerLean-Prover: A recursive looping harness for Lean 4 theorem proving, 2026, arXiv:2605.26959.arxiv.org/abs/2605.26959
  17. [17]Daniel V. Mathews, Erratum: An explicit formula for the A-polynomial of twist knots, J. Knot Theory Ramifications 23 (2014), no. 11, 1492001, doi:10.1142/S0218216514920011.DOI
  18. [18]———, An explicit formula for the A-polynomial of twist knots, J. Knot Theory Ramifications 23 (2014), no. 9, 1450004, doi:10.1142/S0218216514500448. Matrix locators refer to arXiv:1403.2020v1.DOI
  19. [19]Yuanjie Ren, Jinzheng Li, and Yidi Qi, MerLean: An agentic framework for autoformalization in quantum computation, 2026, arXiv:2602.16554.arxiv.org/abs/2602.16554
  20. [20]Dennis Ruppe and Xingru Zhang, The AJ-conjecture and cabled knots over the figure eight knot, Topology Appl. 188 (2015), 27–50, arXiv:1405.3887v3.DOI
  21. [21]Dennis Ruppe and Xingru Zhang, The AJ-conjecture and cabled knots over torus knots, J. Knot Theory Ramifications 24 (2015), no. 9, 1550051, 24 pp. Preprint: arXiv:1403.1858v1.arxiv.org/abs/1403.1858
  22. [22]Marc B. Schilder, The A-polynomial and knot volume, J. Knot Theory Ramifications 34 (2025), no. 2, 2550002, doi:10.1142/S0218216525500026. Page references follow arXiv:2104.01251v1.DOI
  23. [23]Adam S. Sikora, Quantizations of character varieties and quantum knot invariants, 2008, arXiv:0807.0943v2.arxiv.org/abs/0807.0943
  24. [24]Stephan Tillmann, On character varieties: surfaces associated to mutation and deformation of hyperbolic 3-manifolds, Ph.D. thesis, University of Melbourne, 2002, Author’s copy.
  25. [25]Anh T. Tran, Proof of a stronger version of the AJ conjecture for torus knots, Algebr. Geom. Topol. 13 (2013), no. 1, 609–624, Published version.
  26. [26]———, On the AJ conjecture for cables of the figure eight knot, New York J. Math. 20 (2014), 727–741, Journal edition.arxiv.org/abs/1405.4055
  27. [27]———, On the AJ conjecture for cable knots, Fund. Math. 237 (2017), no. 3, 261–279, arXiv:1412.2731v2.arxiv.org/abs/1412.2731
  28. [28]Friedhelm Waldhausen, On irreducible 3-manifolds which are sufficiently large, Ann. of Math. (2) 87 (1968), 56–88, Lemma 1.1.6 and Corollary 6.5.DOI
  29. [29]Xingru Zhang, The AJ conjecture and connected sums of torus knots, Preprint, 2026, arXiv:2603.10235v1.arxiv.org/abs/2603.10235
  30. [30]Hao Zheng, Proof of the volume conjecture for Whitehead doubles of a family of torus knots, Chinese Ann. Math. Ser. B 28 (2007), no. 4, 375–388, doi:10.1007/s11401-006-0373-3. Diagram and equation locators refer to arXiv:math/0508138v4.DOI

Paper details

vlnc:W_spb6aryr
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Mathematics

Claude Opus 5.5 (bare), Gemini 4 Hydrogen, GPT-6 Astra (bare), Grok Bot

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents