betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Factors correlating to enhanced surface diffusion in metallic glasses

Abstract

The enhancement of surface diffusion (DS) over the bulk (DV) in metallic glasses (MGs) is well documented and likely to strongly influence the properties of glasses grown by vapor deposition. Here, we use classical molecular dynamics simulations to identify different factors influencing the enhancement of surface diffusion in MGs. MGs have a simple atomic structure and belong to the category of moderately fragile glasses that undergo pronounced slowdown of bulk dynamics with cooling close to the glass transition temperature (Tg). We observe that DS exhibits a much more moderate slowdown compared to DV when approaching Tg, and DS/DV at Tg varies by two orders of magnitude among the MGs investigated. We demonstrate that both the surface energy and the fraction of missing bonds for surface atoms show good correlation to DS/DV, implying that the loss of nearest neighbors at the surface directly translates into higher mobility, unlike the behavior of network- and hydrogen-bonded organic glasses. Fragility, a measure of the slowdown of bulk dynamics close to Tg, also correlates to DS/DV, with more fragile systems having larger surface enhancement of mobility. The deviations observed in the fragility and DS over DV relationship are shown to be correlated to the extent of segregation or depletion of the mobile element at the surface. Finally, we explore the relationship between the diffusion pre-exponential factor (D0) and activation energy (Q) and compare to a ln(D0)-Q correlation previously established for bulk glasses, demonstrating similar correlations from MD as in the experiments and that the surface and bulk have very similar ln(D0)-Q correlations.

Introduction

The enhancement of in-plane surface diffusion coefficient (DSD_S) over the bulk (or volume) diffusion coefficient (DVD_V) in metallic glasses (MGs) is a property of fundamental interest with potential application to engineering so-called ultrastable glasses (UGs) by physical vapor deposition. By carefully optimizing the substrate temperature and deposition rate, Ediger et al. have created organic UGs with exceptional thermodynamic and kinetic stability.[1] Glasses obtained using a traditional melt-quench approach need to be aged for an impractical amount of time to obtain similar stability.[2] The metallic counterpart of UGs was first created by Yu et al. and found to have excellent properties like high elastic modulus.[3] UGs form under deposition due to the additional relaxation enabled by the larger value of DSD_S vs. DVD_V, which allows the as-deposited atoms to have sufficient mobility to quickly find stable, low-energy configurations.[4] Therefore, enhanced surface mobility is necessary to the formation of UGs, and better control of DS/DVD_S/D_V could provide a pathway to the formation of improved UGs.

Early studies on the measurement of DSD_S in glasses employed the surface grating decay method, in which periodic gratings are etched into surfaces and the rate of flattening of the gratings is analyzed. According to the Mullins model,5 different near-surface mass transport mechanisms can be identified based on their unique relation between decay constant and grating periodicity. In these studies, the surface diffusion enhancement factor, DS/DVD_S/D_V, is as high as 10810^8 at the bulk glass transition temperature TgT_g.6–10 Enhanced surface mobility is generally attributed to the smaller number of bonds a surface atom breaks when moving compared to a bulk atom. Network glass-formers like silica, which requires the breaking of network oxide bonds to flow, do not show fast surface diffusion during grating decay.11 Simulations have found that the Si-O bonds are largely intact at the surface as the radial distribution of oxygen atoms around silicon from the bulk to the surface is almost unchanged.12 Organic materials with extensive hydrogen-bonding also have low surface enhanced diffusion, which is attributed to the preservation of hydrogen bonds close to the surface.7 In both these cases, there is no significant change of local environment between the bulk and the surface, and the materials do not show a large decrease of the diffusion barrier for the surface atoms.

In this work, we calculate DS/DVD_{\mathrm{S}}/D_{\mathrm{V}} in metallic glasses (MGs) using classical molecular dynamics simulations. Our main goal is to identify different properties that correlate to DS/DVD_{\mathrm{S}}/D_{\mathrm{V}} across several MGs and to aid in the selection of materials for designing UGs in the future. Compared to network glasses, MGs significantly disrupt their basic nearest-neighbor bonding at the surface, suggesting that a loss of neighbors could directly translate into an increase of mobility. With this in mind, we first explored how the loss of first neighbors and changes in surface energy correlate to surface enhanced diffusion. As a metallic liquid is supercooled, DVD_{\mathrm{V}} deviates from DSD_{\mathrm{S}} and undergoes a marked slowdown while approaching TgT_{\mathrm{g}}, quantified by the fragility index (mm). In contrast, DSD_{\mathrm{S}} undergoes a more moderate slowdown towards TgT_{\mathrm{g}}. Based on this, we correlate DS/DVD_{\mathrm{S}}/D_{\mathrm{V}} to mm, and find generally good trends but that the correlation breaks down when surface diffusion is significantly impacted by surface segregation. Finally, we use extrapolation methods to approximate the surface enhanced diffusion expected for typical experimentally cooled glasses.

Simulation Methods

Classical molecular dynamics (MD) simulations are employed to study various model MGs in this work. The typical MD simulation timescale is usually less than 1 μ\mus and very high cooling rates compared to experiments need to be employed when preparing glasses in MD. As a result, the glasses created by MD simulations are highly under-relaxed relative to real glasses, and the MD glass dynamics are many orders of magnitude faster than in the real glass. The simulations also cover only 4–5 decades of slowdown in dynamics from the high temperature liquid. Our measured DS/DVD_{\mathrm{S}}/D_{\mathrm{V}} values are therefore much smaller than typical experimental observations. Nonetheless, using MD simulations, it is now possible to access long enough timescales that many features associated with glass transition physics can be observed, including VFT behavior in the supercooled liquid and Arrhenius behavior in the glass. Therefore, consistent with many researchers in glass physics,13,14 we will assume that the MD relaxed glass yields mechanisms of bulk and surface diffusion similar to those found in real glasses.

In this work, we study 10 binary MGs that are all modeled by embedded atom method (EAM) potentials to describe the interatomic interactions. The compositions, in terms of mole percent, include Cux_xZr100−x_{100-x} (X = 25, 35, 50, 65, 75, and 90),15 Pd80_{80}Si20_{20},16 Ni80_{80}P20_{20},16 Al90_{90}Sm10_{10},17 and Ni33_{33}Zr67_{67}.18 To generate a glass, the samples were initially equilibrated for 2 ns at 2000 K. The resulting liquids were then cooled to 1000 K in 50 K decrements at the rate of 100 K per 6 ns. During this phase, the systems were sufficiently equilibrated, as the structural relaxation times are of the order of ps or less. Subsequently, the samples were cooled to 500 K in 20 K decrements at the rate of 100 K per 60 ns, corresponding to a cooling rate of ∼109\sim10^9 K/s. All systems undergo the glass transition during this stage, at the temperatures listed in Table 1, as identified from the change in slope observed in the temperature variation of enthalpy or volume. Compared to the experimental TgT_{\mathrm{g}}, also listed in Table 1 for the compositions we have found in the literature, MD glass transition temperatures are usually higher due to orders of magnitude faster cooling during the simulation, although some errors from the EAM potentials are also expected. NPT conditions with zero nominal pressure were employed during the whole procedure. A cubic simulation box with 16384 atoms was used and periodic boundary conditions (PBC) were applied in all three Cartesian directions. The time step applied was 1 fs. Cu10Zr90\mathrm{Cu}_{10}\mathrm{Zr}_{90} was also tried but found to crystallize with the above protocol and is not part of this study.

Composition (AXB100−XA_XB_{100-X})MD TgT_g (K)Expt. TgT_g (K)DS/DVD_S/D_V at TgT_gDecoupling parameter (ζ\zeta)
Cu25_{25}Zr75_{75}720-63.060.29
Cu35_{35}Zr65_{65}7006162437.160.27
Cu50_{50}Zr50_{50}7006662426.090.28
Cu65_{65}Zr35_{35}7607372428.570.36
Cu75_{75}Zr25_{25}780-25.860.40
Cu90_{90}Zr10_{10}740-10.540.41
Pd80_{80}Si20_{20}76065725117.540.33
Ni80_{80}P20_{20}560580251.400.37
Al90_{90}Sm10_{10}6404452614.290.48
Ni33_{33}Zr67_{67}660-11.910.27

Table 1. Calculated glass transition temperature (TgT_g), surface enhanced diffusion (DS/DVD_S/D_V) at TgT_g, and decoupling parameter (ζ\zeta) using MD simulations for all the MGs studied. Experimental TgT_g are shown for the compositions we have found in the literature.

To study the bulk diffusion, the final configuration at the temperature of interest during the quenching process was used as the starting point for production runs in NVT conditions with PBC in all directions. The correct volume for the NVT simulation was obtained by using the volume from the NPT quenching. To measure surface diffusion, with the same configuration obtained from quenching process as before, free surfaces were created by extending the simulation cell boundaries by 10 Å along the ±z\pm z-axis. Again, NVT conditions and PBC (although the atoms cannot interact through the boundaries in the zz-direction) were applied and the system was initially equilibrated for 1 ns to make sure the newly created surfaces at the two edges were relaxed before the production phase begins. Atoms in the outer 2.5 Å (or 12.5 Å of the cell considering the empty space), which is approximately the thickness of a monolayer as determined from radial distribution function of atoms, along the ±z\pm z-axis were used to evaluate the properties associated with the surface. While the outer monolayer at the free boundary has the highest atomic mobility and is chosen as representing the surface in this work, there is an interfacial region of perhaps up to a few nm thickness exhibiting gradients in mobility from surface towards the bulk. The thickness of the interfacial region varies with temperature, and MD simulations in both glass-forming and crystalline materials have investigated this behavior extensively using metrics such as Debye-Waller factor. 19–21 In Cu64Zr36\mathrm{Cu}_{64}\mathrm{Zr}_{36} glass films, a non-monotonic variation of interface thickness with temperature has been observed.19

The diffusion coefficient, DD, is calculated based on Einstein’s equation that relates DD to the mean-squared displacement (MSD) of atoms as

D=lim⁡t→∞1(2d)Nt⟨∑i=1N∣ri(t)−ri(0)∣2⟩(1)D=\lim_{t\to\infty}\frac{1}{(2d)Nt}\left\langle\sum_{i=1}^{N}\left|\mathbf{r}_{i}(t)-\mathbf{r}_{i}(0)\right|^{2}\right\rangle \tag*{(1)}

where dd is the number of dimensions, NN is the number of atoms, ri(t)\mathbf{r}_{i}(t) is the position of atom ii at time tt, and the angular brackets refer to the ensemble average. Figure S1 in the Supplementary Material shows the time evolution of MSD in bulk Cu50Zr50\mathrm{Cu}_{50}\mathrm{Zr}_{50} system at two temperatures in the glassy state. For the bulk diffusion coefficient, d=3d=3. For surface diffusion, only the lateral displacement of atoms in the xy-plane is considered with d=2d=2, and atoms belonging to the surface layer at both t=0t=0 and t=tt=t are considered as contributing to the summation in (1). Unless explicitly noted, the diffusion values in this study are averaged over all the atoms and, hence, are composition-averaged values. Relaxation time, τ\tau, of the bulk is extracted from self-intermediate scattering function, defined as

Time evolution of MSD in Cu50Zr50 at 700 K and 640 K in linear-linear and log-log plots

Figure S1. Time evolution of MSD in Cu50Zr50\mathrm{Cu}_{50}\mathrm{Zr}_{50} at 700 K and 640 K in (left) linear-linear and (right) log-log plots. The dotted lines indicate the best linear fit at longer times. The relaxation times of the system (τ\tau) at the two temperatures are also indicated in the legend.

Fs(q,t)=(1/N)⟨∑n=1Neiq⋅[rn(t)−rn(0)]⟩F_{s}(q,t)=\left(1/N\right)\left\langle\sum_{n=1}^{N}e^{i\mathbf{q}\cdot[\mathbf{r}_{n}(t)-\mathbf{r}_{n}(0)]}\right\rangle

and Fs(q,τ)=1/eF_{s}(q,\tau)=1/e. The magnitude of the chosen wave vector qq coincides with the first maximum of the static structure factor. Figure S2 in the Supplementary Material shows an illustration of the decay of FsF_{s} with time. The lowest temperature studied in the glassy state, where τ\tau grows very fast with cooling, is chosen such that an MSD of at least 5 Å2^{2} per atom is obtained during a simulation time of a few 100s of ns. We also compare the lowest temperature simulation times to bulk relaxation time for all the MGs in Table S1 in the Supplementary Material. For equilibrium liquids, the Stokes-Einstein (SE) equation relates DD to τ\tau by D/T∼(1/τ)D/T\sim(1/\tau), where TT is the temperature. In the supercooled liquid and glassy states, the SE equation breaks down indicating the decoupling of diffusion and relaxation time, and the relation between DD and τ\tau is expressed in terms of the fractional SE equation represented as D/T∼(1/τ)1−ζD/T\sim(1/\tau)^{1-\zeta} where ζ\zeta is the decoupling parameter.22 In Fig. S3 of the Supplementary Material, we show a plot of D/TD/T versus 1/τ1/\tau that is used to estimate ζ\zeta, and, in Table 1, we give the value of ζ\zeta for all the MGs studied in this work. To improve statistics, the method of buffer averaging23 is employed for both diffusion and relaxation time calculations.

Time evolution of the intermediate scattering function

Figure S2. Time evolution of the intermediate scattering function, FSF_S in Cu50Zr50\mathrm{Cu}_{50}\mathrm{Zr}_{50} at 700 K (=Tg= T_{\mathrm{g}}).

Composition (AXB100−XA_XB_{100-X})Lowest temperature studiedSimulation timeRelaxation time (τ\tau)Extrapolated DS/DVD_S/D_VR2R^2 value
Cu25_{25}Zr75_{75}660 K250 ns495 ns4.8e50.995
Cu35_{35}Zr65_{65}640 K200 ns297 ns2.7e50.995
Cu50_{50}Zr50_{50}640 K150 ns195 ns5.0e50.998
Cu65_{65}Zr35_{35}680 K150 ns134 ns8.6e50.996
Cu75_{75}Zr25_{25}680 K180 ns135 ns1.3e60.994
Cu90_{90}Zr10_{10}660 K150 ns45 ns2.5e40.998
Pd80_{80}Si20_{20}680 K400 ns1350 ns5.1e60.989
Ni80_{80}P20_{20}520 K250 ns616 ns-0.976
Al90_{90}Sm10_{10}580 K30 ns13 ns1.0e50.987

Table S1.

Results

Surface enhanced diffusion in different metallic glasses

We begin with describing the typical evolution of dynamics with cooling in MGs. Figure 1(a) shows the temperature variation of surface and bulk diffusion in Cu50_{50}Zr50_{50} in an Arrhenius plot. In the high-temperature liquid state, DSD_S and DVD_V are comparable. As the alloy is supercooled, a significant slowdown in the bulk dynamics is observed when approaching the glass transition temperature TgT_g that can be described by the well-known Vogel-Fulcher-Tammann (VFT) equation.27 In contrast, the surface undergoes only a modest slowdown. Below TgT_g, identified as 700 K from the temperature dependence of volume or enthalpy, both DSD_S and DVD_V can be fitted by the Arrhenius equation, D=D0e−Q/(kBT)D=D_0e^{-Q/(k_BT)}. Here, D0D_0 is the pre-exponential factor and QQ is the activation energy. The bulk dynamics of MGs showing VFT behavior in the supercooled liquid regime and Arrhenius behavior below TgT_g is well known from experiments,28 and we have observed similar behavior for all the MGs studied in this work. Table 2 shows the values of activation energy and pre-exponential factor in the glassy state for all the MGs in this work. Our simulations below TgT_g are likely far from the most stable glassy state and it is not clear a priori that their diffusion should be Arrhenius. However, if we assume that the structure of the glass undergoes minimal changes with temperature and also during the time scales of the MD simulations then it is reasonable to expect that the systems see an almost fixed distribution of activation energies and will show approximately Arrhenius behavior. The assumption that structure is fairly constant during the MD timescales is supported by the fact that we obtain linear MSD with time for all our MD simulations and that timescales for significant structural relaxation in glasses from experiments are typically minutes, hours, or even years. To further support our claim, we reran the DD value for the highest temperature in the glassy state (T=700T = 700K) in Cu50_{50}Zr50_{50} starting from the final atomic configuration obtained after the first determination of DD, which represented 30 ns of ageing. We obtained a value just ~5 % lower from that obtained from our first determination of DD at 700K. Our Arrhenius behavior is also consistent with other MD simulations.29 DS/DVD_{\mathrm{S}}/D_{\mathrm{V}} at TgT_{\mathrm{g}} in the case of Cu50_{50}Zr50_{50} is ~26. Across the 10 different MGs we have studied, DS/DVD_{\mathrm{S}}/D_{\mathrm{V}} varies by almost two orders of magnitude, as listed in Table 1 and shown in Figure 1(b).

Plot of surface and bulk diffusion as a function of temperature for Cu50Zr50 and surface-enhanced diffusion of different metallic glasses

Figure 1. (a) Plot of surface and bulk diffusion as a function of temperature for Cu50_{50}Zr50_{50}. The pronounced slowdown of bulk dynamics in the supercooled regime is well described by the VFT equation. Below TgT_{\mathrm{g}}, both surface and bulk diffusion satisfy the Arrhenius equation. The standard deviations in DD (from 5 independent simulations) are shown in pink and they are smaller than the symbol size at all the temperatures studied. (b) Surface-enhanced diffusion (DS/DVD_{\mathrm{S}}/D_{\mathrm{V}}) of different MGs investigated in this study. The compositions along the x-axis, in the order of decreasing DS/DVD_{\mathrm{S}}/D_{\mathrm{V}}, are Pd80_{80}Si20_{20}, Cu25_{25}Zr75_{75}, Cu35_{35}Zr65_{65}, Cu65_{65}Zr35_{35}, Cu50_{50}Zr50_{50}, Cu75_{75}Zr25_{25}, Al90_{90}Sm10_{10}, Ni33_{33}Zr67_{67}, Cu90_{90}Zr10_{10}, and Ni80_{80}P20_{20}.

Composition (AXB100−XA_XB_{100-X})QVQ_{\mathrm{V}} (eV)QSQ_{\mathrm{S}} (eV)D0,VD_{0,\mathrm{V}} (m2^2/s)D0,SD_{0,\mathrm{S}} (m2^2/s)
Cu25_{25}Zr75_{75} (total)1.470.960.0118.2e-5
component AA:1.420.930.0109.0e-5
component BB:1.531.000.0221.0e-4
Cu35_{35}Zr65_{65}1.531.060.8040.072
1.470.990.3550.022
1.661.126.1890.189
Cu50_{50}Zr50_{50}1.660.931.4862.0e-4
1.610.910.8371.3e-4
1.861.0724.1997.5e-4
Cu65_{65}Zr35_{35}1.360.840.0011.9e-5
1.330.810.0011.4e-5
1.570.990.0216.1e-5
Cu75_{75}Zr25_{25}1.400.760.0055.4e-6
1.380.750.0044.5e-6
1.730.880.3404.3e-6
Cu90_{90}Zr10_{10}1.230.910.0011.4e-4
1.230.900.0011.2e-4
1.611.240.0990.014
Pd80_{80}Si20_{20}1.431.100.0100.001
1.421.090.0080.001
1.741.758.1031.571
Ni80_{80}P20_{20}1.110.700.0522.6e-5
1.100.730.0511.6e-5
1.660.792889.5120.008
Al90_{90}Sm10_{10}0.740.608.1e-61.1e-5
0.740.581.5e-58.5e-6
1.090.857.1e-40.033

Table 2.

TABLE 2. MD calculated bulk glass activation energy (QVQ_{\mathrm{V}}), surface glass activation energy (QSQ_{\mathrm{S}}), bulk pre-exponential factor (D0,VD_{0,\mathrm{V}}), and surface pre-exponential factor (D0,SD_{0,\mathrm{S}}) for diffusion in different binary (AXB100−XA_XB_{100-X}) glasses. For each composition, the three rows of values correspond to total, component AA, and component BB diffusion.

Diffusion activation energies and pre-exponential factors

As both surface and bulk diffusion follow Arrhenius behavior in the glassy state, the surface enhanced diffusion can be written as

DSDV=D0,Se−QS/(kBT)D0,Ve−QV/(kBT)=D0,SD0,Ve(QV−QS)/(kBT).(2)\frac{D_{\mathrm{S}}}{D_{\mathrm{V}}}=\frac{D_{0,\mathrm{S}}e^{-Q_{\mathrm{S}}/(k_{\mathrm{B}}T)}}{D_{0,\mathrm{V}}e^{-Q_{\mathrm{V}}/(k_{\mathrm{B}}T)}}=\frac{D_{0,\mathrm{S}}}{D_{0,\mathrm{V}}}e^{(Q_{\mathrm{V}}-Q_{\mathrm{S}})/(k_{\mathrm{B}}T)} . \tag*{(2)}

From Eq. (2), DS/DVD_{\mathrm{S}}/D_{\mathrm{V}} at TgT_{\mathrm{g}} depends on the difference in activation energies normalized by the glass transition temperature, (QV−QS)/kBTg(Q_{\mathrm{V}}-Q_{\mathrm{S}})/k_{\mathrm{B}}T_{\mathrm{g}}, and the ratio of pre-exponential factors, D0,S/D0,VD_{0,\mathrm{S}}/D_{0,\mathrm{V}}. If either of these factors is invariant across the MGs, the other can be easily identified as having a direct correlation to DS/DVD_{\mathrm{S}}/D_{\mathrm{V}}. Figure 2(a) shows the variation of QVQ_{\mathrm{V}}, QSQ_{\mathrm{S}}, and (QV−QS)/kBTg(Q_{\mathrm{V}}-Q_{\mathrm{S}})/k_{\mathrm{B}}T_{\mathrm{g}}, with the MGs on the abscissa arranged such that DS/DVD_{\mathrm{S}}/D_{\mathrm{V}} decreases from left to right, similar to Figure 1(b). As expected, QVQ_{\mathrm{V}} is always greater than QSQ_{\mathrm{S}}, although in some cases they are comparable to each other. A monotonic trend in (QV−QS)/kBTg(Q_{\mathrm{V}}-Q_{\mathrm{S}})/k_{\mathrm{B}}T_{\mathrm{g}} is not evident in Figure 2(a) along the abscissa, indicating that the difference in activation energies does not correlate directly to the measured surface enhanced diffusion, which can be attributed to the variability observed in the ratio of pre-exponentials. In Figure 2(b), we depict D0,V/D0,SD_{0,\mathrm{V}}/D_{0,\mathrm{S}} for different MGs, which vary by four orders of magnitude. The variation of the ratio of pre-exponentials is also not monotonic from left to right, and, hence, DS/DVD_{\mathrm{S}}/D_{\mathrm{V}} is not directly correlated to the ratio of pre-exponentials.

Figure 2. Correlating surface enhanced diffusion to (a) the normalized difference in activation energies (QV−QS)/kBTg(Q_{\mathrm{V}}-Q_{\mathrm{S}})/k_{\mathrm{B}}T_{\mathrm{g}} (divided by 20), and (b) the ratio of pre-exponential factors D0,V/D0,SD_{0,\mathrm{V}}/D_{0,\mathrm{S}}. The similar variation of (QV−QS)(Q_{\mathrm{V}}-Q_{\mathrm{S}}) and log⁡(D0,V/D0,S)\log(D_{0,\mathrm{V}}/D_{0,\mathrm{S}}) reflects the underlying connection between QQ and D0D_{0} observed earlier.30

(QV−QS)(Q_{\mathrm{V}}-Q_{\mathrm{S}}) (ignoring the normalization factor kBTgk_{\mathrm{B}}T_{\mathrm{g}} as it only has a small impact) in Figure 2(a) and ln⁡(D0,V/D0,S)\ln(D_{0,\mathrm{V}}/D_{0,\mathrm{S}}) in Figure 2(b) have similar variation across the MGs studied, which is consistent with the relation between QQ and D0D_{0} previously established in MGs from experiments. Sharma and Faupel30 have compiled the data of QQ and D0D_{0} from several diffusion studies in MGs and indicated a linear relation between QQ and ln⁡(D0)\ln(D_{0}). Figure 3 replots QQ versus D0D_{0} taken from Sharma and Faupel, together with the linear fit observed in their study30 and adds the results from our simulations. Remarkably, both our MD bulk and surface diffusion data show similar slope as the experimental data. However, for the same QQ, the simulated D0D_{0} is many orders of magnitude higher than the experiments, which reflects the underrelaxed nature of MD glasses compared to real glasses and that the MD diffusion coefficient values are many orders of magnitude higher than the experimental diffusion values. We make an approximate correction to remove this effect in § 13.1 of the Supplementary Material. We note that the here observed linear correlations between the logarithm of pre-factor and QQ were earlier seen in the studies of interfacial regions of crystals31 and biological preservation of materials.32

Plot of activation energy versus pre-exponential factor for metallic glasses

Figure 3. Plot of activation energy (QQ) versus pre-exponential factor (D0D_{0}) for MGs from experiments and simulations. The open circles and the dotted line representing the linear relation between QQ and ln⁡(D0)\ln(D_{0}) are taken from Sharma and Faupel30 compiling several experimental bulk diffusion studies. Open squares correspond to our MD simulations, with Arrhenius fitting of bulk and surface diffusion below TgT_{\mathrm{g}} as shown in Figure 1(a).

Metrics related to missing bonds

Free surfaces lead to missing bonds for many atoms, with a concomitant increase in energy of the system. This energy increase can be quantified by the surface energy, defined as the difference in energy of the system with free surfaces and energy of the bulk system and normalized by the total area of free surfaces. Given the strong connection of missing bonds to both surface energy and surface diffusion, it is reasonable to consider that they might be correlated. Such a correlation could be useful for providing intuitions about surface diffusion and methods to accelerate the measurement or prediction of surface diffusion. Figure 4(a) shows how DS/DVD_{\mathrm{S}}/D_{\mathrm{V}} varies with surface energy for the MGs in our study. As expected, we see that higher surface energy correlates with higher DS/DVD_{\mathrm{S}}/D_{\mathrm{V}}, although there is a significant scatter in the correlation.

Correlation of surface enhanced diffusion with surface energy and weighted loss of first neighbors

Figure 4. Correlation of surface enhanced diffusion with (a) surface energy and (b) weighted loss of first neighbors across several MGs in our study. In this work, the accuracy of the correlations is quantified by using standard metrics like R2R^2, root-mean-squared error (RMSE), and RMSE normalized by the standard deviation (RMSE/σ\sigma).

The idea for the smaller number of bonds (or first-neighbors) leading to enhanced interfacial mobility follows from the fact that hopping rates depend on activation energy (this is a result of the Eyring-Polanyi relation or transition state theory) and that activation energies typically scale with on-lattice stability (known as the Bronsted-Evans-Polanyi relation), and on-lattice energies scale with the number of bonds.33 Here, we attempt to directly measure the missing bonds at the surface and correlate that with DS/DVD_{\mathrm{S}}/D_{\mathrm{V}}. For an alloy it is reasonable to expect that the missing bonds for each species might play a different role, depending on the amount of a species at the surface and its diffusion coefficient. Specifically, one might expect that the importance of a missing bond would scale with the diffusion coefficient of the atom type with the missing bond. For example, if the surface primarily breaks the bonds of the slower species, then it might have a much smaller impact on DS/DVD_{\mathrm{S}}/D_{\mathrm{V}} than if it primarily breaks the bonds of the faster species. With this motivation, we define the loss of first neighbors in the top monolayer as

Weighted loss of first neighbors (W)=∑x=A,B[LxDV,xCS,x∑x=A,BDV,xCS,x](3)\text{Weighted loss of first neighbors }(W)=\sum_{x=A,B}\left[L_x\frac{D_{\mathrm{V},x}C_{\mathrm{S},x}}{\sum_{x=A,B}D_{\mathrm{V},x}C_{\mathrm{S},x}}\right] \tag*{(3)}

Here, xx is the atom type in the binary ABAB-system, LxL_x is the fractional loss of the first neighbors of species xx at the surface and is defined as (CNV−CNS)/CNV(CN_{\mathrm{V}}-CN_{\mathrm{S}})/CN_{\mathrm{V}} with CNCN being the coordination number and the subscript referring to either the bulk or the surface atom of type xx, DVD_{\mathrm{V}} is the bulk diffusion coefficient, and CSC_{\mathrm{S}} is the fraction (or concentration) of atoms of a certain atom type on the surface. We note that DS/DVD_{\mathrm{S}}/D_{\mathrm{V}} is poorly correlated with DVD_{\mathrm{V}} at TgT_{\mathrm{g}} (R2=0.17R^2=0.17) and, hence, DVD_{\mathrm{V}} in Eq. (3) does not lead to any artificial correlation between DS/DVD_{\mathrm{S}}/D_{\mathrm{V}} and WW. For most of the glasses in this study, DV,ACV,A≫DV,BCV,BD_{\mathrm{V},A}C_{\mathrm{V},A}\gg D_{\mathrm{V},B}C_{\mathrm{V},B} (with AA and BB defined as the first and second elements listed in the MG compositions in Table 1) and WW is almost equal to LAL_A. Low values of WW qualitatively indicate that surface atoms have fewer missing bonds and vice versa. Figure 4(b) shows that WW correlates to DS/DVD_{\mathrm{S}}/D_{\mathrm{V}} quite well over the whole range of MGs in this study. This behavior can be contrasted with silica and hydrogen-bonded organic glasses where the surface bonding maintains aspects of the bulk and therefore does not translate into dramatic surface enhanced diffusion.7 For example, as discussed in § 1, for the mobile Si atoms in SiO2_2, the number of Si-O bonds are very similar for surface and bulk atoms, leading to DS/DVD_{\mathrm{S}}/D_{\mathrm{V}} near 1.12 In MGs, with all bonds between atoms being approximately equivalent in determining mobility, the fact that there are significant missing nearest-neighbor bonds at the surface leads to an increase of surface versus bulk mobility. We note that the correlation of WW with DS/DVD_{\mathrm{S}}/D_{\mathrm{V}} may be due to correlation of WW with both D0,S/D0,VD_{0,\mathrm{S}}/D_{0,\mathrm{V}} and QV−QSQ_{\mathrm{V}}-Q_{\mathrm{S}}. It is easy to understand why QV−QSQ_{\mathrm{V}}-Q_{\mathrm{S}} might be correlated with WW as changing bond numbers will change binding strength which is expected to correlate with activation energies. Trends in D0,S/D0,VD_{0,\mathrm{S}}/D_{0,\mathrm{V}} are expected to correlate with anharmonicity of interatomic interactions since D0D_0 is related to anharmonicity,31,34 and anharmonicity may correlate with bonding environment and therefore WW, although this correlation is not immediately obvious. However, in § 14 of the Supplementary Material, we show that QV−QSQ_{\mathrm{V}}-Q_{\mathrm{S}} and D0,S/D0,VD_{0,\mathrm{S}}/D_{0,\mathrm{V}} do not correlate with WW independently, and it is only their combined contributions that correlate. This result is somewhat surprising and suggests that there is significant coupling between D0,S/D0,VD_{0,\mathrm{S}}/D_{0,\mathrm{V}} and QV−QSQ_{\mathrm{V}}-Q_{\mathrm{S}} in ways that require them to be integrated together to see the correlation with WW.

Correlation of fragility to surface enhanced diffusion

Here, we aim to correlate DS/DVD_{\mathrm{S}}/D_{\mathrm{V}} with a glass property called fragility. To understand the fragility, we note that an important classification of glasses is in terms of the amount of slowdown when approaching TgT_g during cooling.35 This slowdown is generally quantified by tracking increasing viscosity (η\eta) or decreasing diffusion coefficient. In experiments, the viscosity of supercooled liquids increases by more than ten orders of magnitude, and η=1012\eta= 10^{12} Pa s at TgT_g by convention. Strong glass-formers like silica have an almost Arrhenius-like increase (or linear behavior in an Angell plot of log⁡(η)\log(\eta) versus Tg/TT_g/T) in viscosity over a wide temperature range. MGs are relatively fragile and exhibit the viscosity rise in a narrow temperature range just below TgT_g. To characterize these differences, the fragility index (mm) is introduced, which is defined as the slope of the Angell plot at TgT_g.35 Strong and fragile glass-formers have low and high values of mm, respectively. Fragility may be expected to be correlated with DS/DVD_{\mathrm{S}}/D_{\mathrm{V}} because from Figure 1, DS≈DVD_{\mathrm{S}} \approx D_{\mathrm{V}} at the beginning of the supercooled state and the surface enhanced diffusion at TgT_g is mostly dominated by the slowdown manifested by the bulk, characterized by the fragility. Another way to rationalize why fragility may underlie enhanced surface diffusion comes from the entropy theory of glasses that relates fragility to the frustration in atomic packing.36–38 According to this theory, fragile systems have frustrated atomic packings. On the other hand, the surface is expected to have reduced packing frustration, thereby behaving like a strong glass. Accordingly, we can expect fragile systems to have large DS/DVD_{\mathrm{S}}/D_{\mathrm{V}} while enhanced surface diffusion in strong systems would be much milder. A strong correlation between fragility and DS/DVD_{\mathrm{S}}/D_{\mathrm{V}} could provide both insights into the surface diffusion physics and approaches to determine DSD_{\mathrm{S}} more efficiently using only bulk properties.

A measure of fragility can also be obtained by using the value of viscosity at 1.25Tg1.25T_g,7 with more fragile liquids having smaller values of η\eta at 1.25Tg1.25T_g. We will adopt this definition of fragility here, with the viscosity replaced by the structural relaxation time (τ\tau) of the system, as the latter is easier to calculate with MD. It has been shown using MD simulations that τ\tau is proportional to η\eta,39 so the correlations obtained using τ\tau should also occur when using η\eta. As the relaxation times of glasses are different at their respective TgT_g in our simulations, we will rescale τ\tau by the value of τ\tau at TgT_g so that the rescaled value at 1.25Tg1.25T_g can be directly used as a measure of fragility. Figure 5(a) shows the variation of scaled relaxation times in an Arrhenius plot for different MGs in this study, and Figure 5(b) shows how DS/DVD_{\mathrm{S}}/D_{\mathrm{V}} correlates to our measure of fragility. A modest correlation can be observed, demonstrating that the surface enhanced diffusion increases with increasing fragility of the system. Ni80_{80}P20_{20} is the main outlier in Figure 5(b), and we expand on this below.

Variation of scaled relaxation time and surface enhanced diffusion with fragility

Figure 5. (a) Variation of scaled relaxation time as a function of inverse temperature normalized to TgT_g for different MGs in this study. The scaling of relaxation time is performed to be commensurate with identical viscosities at TgT_g for glasses in experiments. (b) Plot of surface enhanced diffusion with respect to fragility of the glasses. The dotted line was fit to the original glass compositions, shown as open circles. Modified points that account for surface segregation as described in the text are shown as solid squares for Pd80_{80}Si20_{20} and Ni80_{80}P20_{20}, the two glasses with the greatest surface segregation.

Fragility is a bulk property and does not capture the intricacies of the surface, which is different from the earlier metrics we have used to correlate to DS/DVD_{\mathrm{S}}/D_{\mathrm{V}}. For example, the segregation of an element to the surface, which is a consequence of missing bonds intrinsic to the surface and could impact the overall DSD_{\mathrm{S}}, likely cannot be predicted by fragility. Among the compositions studied in this work, Pd80_{80}Si20_{20} shows the highest value of DS/DVD_{\mathrm{S}}/D_{\mathrm{V}} and the concentration of the mobile element, palladium, increases from 80% in the bulk to ∼89\sim89% at the surface (∼11\sim11% increase). Ni80_{80}P20_{20} has the lowest DS/DVD_{\mathrm{S}}/D_{\mathrm{V}} in our simulations and, in this case, the concentration of the immobile element, phosphorous, increases from 20% to ∼32.5\sim32.5% at the surface (∼63\sim63% increase). These changes are illustrated in the inset of Figure 6(a). Segregation thus might be playing a role in both these cases in either enhancing or diminishing the surface diffusion, an effect that the bulk fragility cannot capture. To quantify the effect of segregation, we recognize that segregation plays no role when either (i) the concentration of elements is identical in the bulk and the surface, or (ii) the mobilities of the two elements are equal at the surface. Based on these 2 criteria, we quantify the effect of segregation on surface diffusion as the product of two terms as

Quantifying the presence of segregation at the surface and correlation between segregation and deviation from fragility

Figure 6. (a) Quantifying the presence of segregation at the surface for the MGs involved in this study. (inset) Comparison of the concentration of immobile components of the bulk and surface in Pd80_{80}Si20_{20} (immobile component Si) and Ni80_{80}P20_{20} (immobile component P). (b) Correlation between SS, defined in Eq. (4), and the deviation in Figure 5(b) between the calculated DS/DVD_S/D_V values and those obtained from a best fit to fragility.

Segregation measure⁡ (S)=∑x=A,B[(CS,x−CV,x)(DS,x−DS,avgDS,avg)].(4)\operatorname{Segregation\ measure}\ (S)=\sum_{x=A,B}\left[\left(C_{\mathrm{S},x}-C_{\mathrm{V},x}\right)\left(\frac{D_{\mathrm{S},x}-D_{\mathrm{S,avg}}}{D_{\mathrm{S,avg}}}\right)\right]. \tag*{(4)}

Here, CVC_{\mathrm{V}} is the fraction (or concentration) of atoms of a certain atom type in the bulk, DS,avgD_{\mathrm{S,avg}} is the average surface diffusion of the two elements. Both terms inside the square brackets for SS in Eq. (4) vary in the range from -1 to 1. A positive value for SS implies that the mobile element is segregated to the surface, thereby enhancing DSD_{\mathrm{S}} and vice versa. Figure 6(a) shows the variation of SS for different MGs studied in this work, with Ni80_{80}P20_{20} exhibiting the most negative values, and therefore likely the largest segregation-induced reduction of DSD_{\mathrm{S}}. To assess the hypothesis that segregation may be impacting the correlation with fragility, we consider the correlation between the residuals of a linear fit of DS/DVD_{\mathrm{S}}/D_{\mathrm{V}} to fragility (deviation from the dotted line shown in Figure 5(b)) and our segregation measure (SS from Eq. (4) and shown in Figure 6(a)). The residuals vs. SS in Figure 6(b) show a modest but definite correlation, suggesting that the deviations of DS/DVD_{\mathrm{S}}/D_{\mathrm{V}} from a linear function of fragility are caused to a significant extent by surface segregation.

The change in composition of the surface could modify DVD_V, the fragility, or both. To assess these changes, we have simulated using periodic boundary conditions bulk glasses with the surface compositions for the glasses with the highest and lowest values of SS in Figure 6(a). For Pd80_{80}Si20_{20}, the surface composition is Pd89_{89}Si11_{11}, and for Ni80_{80}P20_{20} the surface composition is Ni67.5_{67.5}P32.5_{32.5}. DVD_V and fragility are evaluated for the bulk glass with the surface composition, while DSD_S is evaluated from the slab with the original composition. Both the diffusivities are measured at TgT_g of the original composition. DS/DVD_S/D_V vs. fragility evaluated this way, and shown as solid squares in Figure 5(b), is much closer to the trend line for the surface composition of Ni80_{80}P20_{20} while no improvement is observed for Pd80_{80}Si20_{20}. On the other hand, both DSD_S and DVD_V can also be evaluated at TgT_g of the segregated surface composition and in this case, we observed (not shown) the surface composition of Pd80_{80}Si20_{20} agreeing very well with the trend line in Figure 5(b) while Ni80_{80}P20_{20} shows no improvement. We conclude that fragility can be a useful indicator to estimate surface enhanced diffusion, but that surface segregation can lead to a departure from the estimated behavior.

In Sec. S4 of the Supplementary Material, we illustrate a method of estimating experimental-like DS/DVD_S/D_V from MD diffusion values. An important result from the experimental bulk and surface diffusion coefficients shown in Ref.⁷ (Fig. 5 therein) is that there is a linear relation between log DSD_S and log DVD_V. Here, we assume that this linear trend between log DSD_S and log DVD_V also applies to MGs based on the observation that there is an excellent fit observed between these parameters for most of our MGs in the supercooled and glassy state. Also, for the organic glass-formers polystyrene and oo-terphenyl (OTP), it was recently shown that experimental and molecular dynamics (MD) bulk and surface diffusion coefficients show a linear relationship between log DSD_S and log DVD_V.40 We estimate the experimental surface enhanced diffusion DS/DVD_S/D_V by extrapolation from the linear trend between log DSD_S and log DVD_V in Figure S4 of the Supplementary Material.

Plot of MD evaluated $D_S$ against $D_V$ for Cu50Zr50

Figure S4. Plot of MD evaluated DSD_S against DVD_V for Cu50_{50}Zr50_{50}. The dotted line shows the linear fit between log DSD_S and log DVD_V. The dotted line is extended to extrapolate the DSD_S corresponding to a typical experimental DV=10−22D_V = 10^{-22} m2^2/s.

Conclusions

We have simulated multiple binary metallic glasses (MGs) using molecular dynamics with the goal to identify different factors that influence enhanced surface diffusion DS/DVD_S/D_V at TgT_g. While DVD_V exhibits a rapid slowdown of dynamics when approaching TgT_g during cooling, only a moderate slowdown of surface dynamics is observed. DS/DVD_S/D_V at TgT_g varies by two orders of magnitude for the compositions studied. Both the surface energy and the fraction of missing bonds for surface atoms show a significant correlation with the enhanced surface diffusion, implying that the surface bond breaking directly translates into higher mobility, unlike in network- or hydrogen-bonded organic glasses. Furthermore, segregation of elements at the surface is observed in some cases and can significantly impact the surface enhanced diffusion. Fragility, a measure of the slowdown dynamics in the bulk close to TgT_\mathrm{g}, also correlates with DS/DVD_\mathrm{S}/D_\mathrm{V}, although this correlation appears to fail for some cases with high segregation. We applied extrapolation methods to approximate the surface enhanced diffusion expected for typical experimentally cooled glasses and found that the extrapolated ln⁡(D0)\ln(D_0) vs. QQ values for the surface follows the previously established trend for bulk glasses.

Supplementary Material

See the supplementary material for the time evolution of MSD of atoms in the glassy state in Cu50Zr50\mathrm{Cu}_{50}\mathrm{Zr}_{50}; decay of intermediate scattering function to estimate relaxation time (τ\tau); evaluation of the decoupling parameter in the fractional Stokes-Einstein equation; estimating experimental-like surface enhanced diffusion DS/DVD_\mathrm{S}/D_\mathrm{V} from MD simulations; and correlation of activation energy change for diffusion with WW.

Data Availability

The data for all the figures in the Manuscript and Supplementary Information are shared as digital files in the Supplementary Information and on Figshare at 10.6084/m9.figshare.13682542. For any other relevant data, contact AA at [email protected].

Acknowledgments

The authors are grateful to the Extreme Science and Engineering Discovery Environment (XSEDE), which is supported by National Science Foundation grant number OCI-1053575, and the Center for High Throughput Computing at UW-Madison for the computing resources. This work was supported by the University of Wisconsin Materials Research Science and Engineering Center (DMR-1720415).

Supporting Material

Time evolution of mean-squared displacement (MSD) of atoms in bulk Cu50Zr50\mathrm{Cu}_{50}\mathrm{Zr}_{50}

Figure S1 shows the variation of mean-squared displacement (MSD) of atoms with time in bulk Cu50Zr50\mathrm{Cu}_{50}\mathrm{Zr}_{50} at temperatures 700 K (=Tg= T_{\mathrm{g}}) and 640 K (lowest bulk temperature studied in Cu50Zr50\mathrm{Cu}_{50}\mathrm{Zr}_{50}). The relaxation time (τ\tau) of Cu50Zr50\mathrm{Cu}_{50}\mathrm{Zr}_{50} at these temperatures are also indicated in the figure.

Decay of Intermediate Scattering Function FSF_S in bulk Cu50Zr50\mathrm{Cu}_{50}\mathrm{Zr}_{50}

Figure S2 shows the time variation of FSF_S with time in bulk Cu50Zr50\mathrm{Cu}_{50}\mathrm{Zr}_{50} at 700 K. The dotted line represents the well-known Kohlrausch–Williams–Watts (KWW) function, f(t)=Aexp⁡[−(t/τ)γ]f(t) = A \exp[-(t/\tau)^\gamma], with A and γ\gamma as the parameters. For temperatures when the decay of FSF_S is less than 1/e, the KWW fit is used to identify the relaxation time, τ\tau.

Estimation of the decoupling parameter (ζ\zeta) in the fractional Stokes–Einstein equation

Figure S3 shows D/TD/T plotted against 1/τ1/\tau for Cu50Zr50\mathrm{Cu}_{50}\mathrm{Zr}_{50} at 700 K and the slope of the linear fitting shown (red solid line) determines the decoupling parameter, ζ\zeta.

Variation of $D/T$ versus inverse relaxation time for Cu50Zr50

Figure S3. Variation of D/TD/T versus inverse relaxation time in Cu50_{50}Zr50_{50} at 700 K (= TgT_g). The slope of the linear fit gives the decoupling parameter (ζ\zeta) of the fractional Stokes-Einstein equation.

Estimating experimental DS/DVD_S/D_V from MD simulations

An important result from the experimental bulk and surface diffusion coefficients shown in Ref.1 (Figure 5 therein) is that there is a linear relation between log DSD_S and log DVD_V. Here, we assume that this linear trend between log DSD_S and log DVD_V also applies to MGs based on the observation that there is an excellent fit observed between these parameters for most of our MGs in the supercooled and glassy state. The R2R^2 values for the linear fit in different MGs are shown in Table S1. Figure S4 shows log DSD_S against log DVD_V for Cu50_{50}Zr50_{50}.

For the organic glass-formers polystyrene and oo-terphenyl (OTP), it was recently shown that experimental and molecular dynamics (MD) bulk and surface diffusion coefficients show a linear relationship between log DSD_S and log DVD_V. [2] Based on this, we now estimate the experimental surface enhanced diffusion DS/DVD_S/D_V from the linear trend between log DSD_S and log DVD_V in Figure S4 by extrapolation. Note that we do not perform the extrapolation if the linear fit is not good enough, and we have chosen a cutoff of R2>0.98R^2 > 0.98 for when we perform the extrapolation (only Ni80_{80}P20_{20} fails this criterion). We assume a fixed DVD_V value at TgT_g of 10−2210^{-22} m2^2/s, which is consistent with typical experimental values. Figure S4 shows the fit of log DSD_S against log DVD_V for Cu50_{50}Zr50_{50} extrapolated to DV=10−22D_V = 10^{-22} m2^2/s. The surface diffusion is enhanced over the bulk by ∼105\sim10^5 after extrapolation.

The enhanced surface diffusion for all the alloys in this work determined the same way are given in Table S1. The surface enhancement factor at the laboratory TgT_g obtained by extrapolation is in broad agreement with the limited experimental results.[3, 4] The extrapolated experiment bulk and surface diffusion values at experimental TgT_g (Table 1 in the paper gives the values of TgT_g) were used to estimate a more realistic D0D_0 for MD activation energies, which are shown as solid symbols in Figure S5. The new (Q,ln⁡(D0))(Q, \ln(D_0)) pairs more closely follow the experimental observations compared to the earlier estimates derived solely from MD simulations. Especially, the similar ln⁡(D0)\ln(D_0) vs. QQ trends in extrapolated surface MD results, extrapolated bulk MD results, and experimental results suggests that the procedure followed in Figure S4 provides a realistic estimate of DSD_S and that the linear relationship of ln⁡(D0)\ln(D_0) vs. QQ found for bulk diffusion also approximately holds for surface diffusion in metallic glasses.

Plot of pre-exponentials versus activation energy

Figure S5. The pre-exponentials corresponding to the filled squares are obtained by using the experimental TgT_g, a typical experimental DVD_V of 10−2210^{-22} m2^2/s for all glasses, while the surface diffusion-related D0D_0 are obtained from the extrapolation scheme discussed above.

Table S1. Details of the lowest temperature investigated in this work for bulk dynamics, length of the simulation, and the corresponding relaxation time at this temperature for different metallic glass compositions. The fitting scheme illustrated in Figure S4 is used to obtain the extrapolated DS/DVD_S/D_V values (for DV=10−22D_V = 10^{-22} m2^2/s) shown. The R2R^2 value of the fit is also shown.

Correlation of activation energy change for diffusion (QV−QSQ_V - Q_S) with weighted loss of first neighbors WW

To verify if the change of activation energy for surface diffusion (QV−QSQ_V - Q_S) and the ratio of pre-factors D0,S/D0,VD_{0,S}/D_{0,V} are correlated to the weighted loss of first neighbors WW (which is related to coordination number change and given by Eq. (3) in the main manuscript), we plot in Figure S6 the correlation between these quantities. It can be observed that WW does not correlate well with both (QV−QSQ_V - Q_S) and D0,S/D0,VD_{0,S}/D_{0,V}.

Plot of activation energy change and ratio of pre-exponential factors

Figure S6. Plot of (a) activation energy change between bulk and surface diffusion versus WW, and (b) ratio of pre-exponential factors D0,S/D0,VD_{0,S}/D_{0,V} versus WW, across several MGs in our study illustrating almost zero correlation (R2∼0R^2 \sim0) between them.

References

References

  1. [1]Y. Chen, W. Zhang, and L. Yu, J. Phys. Chem. B 120, 8007 (2016).
  2. [2]Y. Li, A. Annamareddy, D. Morgan, C. Cao, J. Perepezko, M.D. Ediger, P. Voyles, and L. Yu, (submitted).
  3. [3]C.R. Cao, Y.M. Lu, H.Y. Bai, and W.H. Wang, Appl. Phys. Lett. 107, 141606 (2015).
  4. [4]C.R. Cao, L. Yu, and J.H. Perepezko, Appl. Phys. Lett. 116, 231601 (2020).

Paper details

vlnc:W_suu2sr68
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents