betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Note on Jackson's formalism of gauge transformation

Abstract

An outline is given of how Jackson may have obtained the inhomogeneous wave equations for the auxiliary functions ΨΨ and V\bf V in his influential 2002 AJP paper on the transformation from the Lorenz gauge to other electromagnetic gauges. It clarifies the roles of these functions in the calculation of the Coulomb-gauge vector potential AC{\bf A}_C by showing that while AC{\bf A}_C is given directly ∇×V\nabla\times{\bf V}, only the subtraction of ∇Ψ\nablaΨ from the Lorenz-gauge vector potential AL{\bf A}_L yields AC{\bf A}_C.

In his influential 2002 Am. J. Phys. paper on the transformation from the Lorenz gauge to other electromagnetic gauges [1], Jackson does not derive the inhomogeneous wave equations (2.10) satisfied by the auxiliary functions Ψ\Psi and V\mathbf{V} of the formalism he develops for the transformation from the Lorenz gauge to the Coulomb gauge. To clarify the roles of these functions in the calculation of the Coulomb-gauge vector potential, we outline in this note how Jackson may have obtained his Eqs. (2.10). This will show that while the vector potential in the Coulomb gauge is given directly by the curl of the function V\mathbf{V}, only the subtraction of the gradient of the function Ψ\Psi from the vector potential in the Lorenz gauge yields the Coulomb-gauge vector potential.

The well-known inhomogeneous wave equation for the Lorenz-gauge vector potential AL\mathbf{A}_L reads

□AL=−4πcJ,(1)\Box\mathbf{A}_L = -\frac{4\pi}{c}\mathbf{J}, \tag*{(1)}

where J\mathbf{J} is the electric current density, which can be decomposed into its longitudinal and transverse components Jl\mathbf{J}_l and Jt\mathbf{J}_t, respectively. Decomposing similarly also the vector potential AL\mathbf{A}_L, Eq. (1) will read

□(ALl+ALt)=−4πc(Jl+Jt),(2)\Box\left(\mathbf{A}_{L l}+\mathbf{A}_{L t}\right) = -\frac{4\pi}{c}\left(\mathbf{J}_l+\mathbf{J}_t\right), \tag*{(2)}

where ALl\mathbf{A}_{L l} and ALt\mathbf{A}_{L t} are the longitudinal and transverse components of the Lorenz-gauge vector potential AL\mathbf{A}_L, respectively. Since the Coulomb-gauge vector potential AC\mathbf{A}_C, which satisfies the inhomogeneous wave equation

□AC=−4πcJt,(3)\Box\mathbf{A}_C = -\frac{4\pi}{c}\mathbf{J}_t, \tag*{(3)}

is the transverse component of the vector potential in any gauge [2], ALt=AC\mathbf{A}_{L t} = \mathbf{A}_{C} and so Eq. (2) reduces to

□ALl=−(4π/c)Jl.(4)\Box\mathbf{A}_{L l} = -(4\pi/c)\mathbf{J}_{l}. \tag*{(4)}

With ALl\mathbf{A}_{L l} written as ∇Ψ\nabla\Psi, using the fact that a longitudinal vector component can be expressed as the gradient of a scalar, and with Jl\mathbf{J}_{l} given by the expression for the longitudinal component of a current J\mathbf{J} in terms of the pertinent electric charge density ρ\rho, Eq. (4) can be written as

□(∇Ψ)=∇(□Ψ)=−1c∇∫d3x′ ∂ρ(x′,t)R ∂t,(5)\Box(\nabla\Psi) = \nabla(\Box\Psi) = -\frac{1}{c}\nabla\int\frac{d^{3}x'\,\partial\rho(\mathbf{x}',t)}{R\,\partial t}, \tag*{(5)}

where R=∣x−x′∣R = |\mathbf{x} - \mathbf{x}'|. Taking this equation to imply that

□Ψ=−1c∫d3x′ ∂ρ(x′,t)R ∂t(6)\Box\Psi= -\frac{1}{c}\int\frac{d^{3}x'\,\partial\rho(\mathbf{x}',t)}{R\,\partial t} \tag*{(6)}

yields the first of Jackson’s equations (2.10).

Expressing the transverse component Jt\mathbf{J}_{t} of J\mathbf{J} by

Jt=14π∇×(∇×∫d3x′RJ(x′,t)),(7)\mathbf{J}_{t} = \frac{1}{4\pi}\nabla\times\left(\nabla\times\int\frac{d^{3}x'}{R}\mathbf{J}(\mathbf{x}',t)\right), \tag*{(7)}

and writing the transverse vector AC\mathbf{A}_{C} as the curl of a vector, ∇×V\nabla\times\mathbf{V}, the inhomogeneous wave equation (3) for the Coulomb-gauge vector potential will read

□(∇×V)=∇×(□V)=−1c∇×(∇×∫d3x′RJ(x′,t)).(8)\Box(\nabla\times\mathbf{V}) = \nabla\times(\Box\mathbf{V}) = -\frac{1}{c}\nabla\times\left(\nabla\times\int\frac{d^{3}x'}{R}\mathbf{J}(\mathbf{x}',t)\right). \tag*{(8)}

Taking this equation to imply that

□V=−1c∇×∫d3x′RJ(x′,t)(9)\Box\mathbf{V} = -\frac{1}{c}\nabla\times\int\frac{d^{3}x'}{R}\mathbf{J}(\mathbf{x}',t) \tag*{(9)}

yields the second of Jackson’s equations (2.10).

Having decomposed the electric current density into longitudinal and transverse parts in Eq. (2.8), Jackson introduces the auxiliary functions Ψ\Psi and V\mathbf{V} by Al=∇Ψ\mathbf{A}_{l} = \nabla\Psi and At=∇×V\mathbf{A}_{t} = \nabla\times\mathbf{V} in Eq. (2.9), where Al\mathbf{A}_{l} and At\mathbf{A}_{t} are respectively longitudinal and transverse parts into which, he says, “a vector potential can be decomposed in the same way as the current.” He then introduces the inhomogeneous equations (2.10) satisfied by the functions Ψ\Psi and V\mathbf{V} by saying: “For the Coulomb-gauge vector potential [my emphasis], the auxiliary functions Ψ\Psi and V\mathbf{V} satisfy [these equations].” This is a confusing statement since it appears to imply that the Coulomb-gauge vector potential has both the longitudinal and transverse parts, ∇Ψ\nabla\Psi and ∇×V\nabla\times\mathbf{V}. The Coulomb-gauge vector potential AC\mathbf{A}_{C} is by definition a transverse vector, and as such is given fully by the transverse part ∇×V\nabla\times\mathbf{V}, which also equals the transverse part of the Lorenz-gauge vector potential AL\mathbf{A}_{L}. For the Coulomb-gauge vector potential AC\mathbf{A}_{C}, the function Ψ\boldsymbol{\Psi} plays a role only through the Lorenz-gauge vector potential AL\mathbf{A}_{L} by AC=AL−∇Ψ\mathbf{A}_{C}=\mathbf{A}_{L}-\nabla\boldsymbol{\Psi}.

Deservedly, Jackson’s paper has been cited many times since its publication in 2002 – still, to the present author’s knowledge, nobody has pointed out yet the confusing introduction there of the inhomogeneous wave functions (2.10) satisfied by the auxiliary functions Ψ\boldsymbol{\Psi} and V\mathbf{V}. It may have confused some readers, but it should not have those who are well-versed in the subject, since equations (2.10) and the auxiliary functions Ψ\boldsymbol{\Psi} and V\mathbf{V} are used in the paper in accordance with their true meaning.

The auxiliary function Ψ\boldsymbol{\Psi} plays an important role in Jackson’s paper since the inhomogeneous wave equation (6) it satisfies is, except for the different sign of its RHS, the same as his inhomogeneous equation (3.8) for the gauge function χC\chi_{C} of the transformation of the Lorenz-gauge potentials to those in the Coulomb gauge. The retarded solutions of these inhomogeneous equations are thus the same except for their signs.

The function Ψ\boldsymbol{\Psi} can be calculated for a point charge qq moving with constant velocity vv along the zz-axis using its Lorenz-gauge vector potential,

AL(x,t)=βγq[s2+γ2(z−vt)2]1/2z^,β=v/c,γ=(1−β2)−1/2,(10)\mathbf{A}_{L}(\mathbf{x},t)=\frac{\beta\gamma q}{[s^{2}+\gamma^{2}(z-vt)^{2}]^{1/2}}\hat{\mathbf{z}},\quad\beta=v/c,\quad\gamma=(1-\beta^{2})^{-1/2}, \tag*{(10)}

where s=(x2+y2)1/2s=(x^{2}+y^{2})^{1/2}. The longitudinal part of AL\mathbf{A}_{L} is given by

ALl(x,t)=−14π∇∫d3x′R∇′⋅AL(x′,t),(11)\mathbf{A}_{L l}(\mathbf{x},t)=-\frac{1}{4\pi}\nabla\int\frac{d^{3}x'}{R}\nabla'\cdot\mathbf{A}_{L}(\mathbf{x}',t), \tag*{(11)}

where the integral can be evaluated by expanding the inverse distance 1/R1/R in cylindrical coordinates (see [3], p. 140). Carrying out the evaluation of this integral as in a cylindrical-coordinate calculation of the gauge function χC\chi_{C} for this case in [4], we obtain

ALl(x,t)=qβ∇[arsinh⁡γ(z−vt)s−arsinh⁡z−vts].(12)\mathbf{A}_{L l}(\mathbf{x},t)=\frac{q}{\beta}\nabla\left[\operatorname{arsinh}\frac{\gamma(z-vt)}{s}-\operatorname{arsinh}\frac{z-vt}{s}\right]. \tag*{(12)}

Since the function Ψ\boldsymbol{\Psi} is defined by ALl=∇Ψ\mathbf{A}_{L l}=\nabla\boldsymbol{\Psi}, this gives Ψ\boldsymbol{\Psi} as

Ψ(x,t)=qβ[arsinh⁡γ(z−vt)s−arsinh⁡z−vts].(13)\boldsymbol{\Psi}(\mathbf{x},t)=\frac{q}{\beta}\left[\operatorname{arsinh}\frac{\gamma(z-vt)}{s}-\operatorname{arsinh}\frac{z-vt}{s}\right]. \tag*{(13)}

Noting the expression for χC\chi_{C} obtained in [4] and, by different means, in [5], this is in agreement with Jackson’s result Ψ=−χC\boldsymbol{\Psi}=-\chi_{C}.

We note that an alternative approach to the problem of the transformation of electromagnetic potentials in a given gauge to those in a different gauge has been developed in [6].

References

  1. [1]J. D. Jackson, “From Lorenz to Coulomb and other explicit gauge transformations,” Am. J. Phys. 70 917–28 (2002); arXiv:physics/0204034DOI
  2. [2]V. Hnizdo, “Comment on ‘Vector potential in the Coulomb gauge,’” Eur. J. Phys. 25 L21–L22 (2004); arXiv:physics/0309028DOI
  3. [3]J. D. Jackson, Classical Electrodynamics, 3rd ed. (Wiley, 1999)
  4. [4]V. Hnizdo and G. Vaman, “Novel distributional Laplacians and a Coulomb-gauge problem,” arXiv:2509.00282arxiv.org/abs/2509.00282
  5. [5]V. Hnizdo and G. Vaman, “Note on the transformation from the Lorenz gauge to the Coulomb gauge,” arXiv:2405.16530arxiv.org/abs/2405.16530
  6. [6]K-H. Yang and K. T. McDonald, “Formal expressions for the electromagnetic potentials in any gauge” (accessed March 3, 2026), http://kirkmcd.princeton.edu/gauge.pdf

Paper details

vlnc:W_tz8uvtmx
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents