WorksMathematics
Optimal lengths of commutators of idempotents and similarity of nilpotent operators to their negatives
Abstract
Let \HH be a complex separable infinite-dimensional Hilbert space. We prove that every operator in \BH is a sum of three commutators of idempotents and a product of two such commutators. Both numbers are best possible. The same is true for differences of idempotents, for operators similar to their negatives, and for operators anticommuting with an involution. Each of these four classes therefore has additive length three and multiplicative length two. We also construct nilpotent operators of order three that are similar to their negatives but cannot be conjugated to their negatives by any bounded involution. These results answer Question~7.22(a)–(c), the question in Remark~7.17, and the question about involutions in Section~2.9 of Marcoux, Radjavi and Zhang, J. Funct. Anal. 284 (2023), 109854.
Introduction and main results
Throughout this paper, denotes a complex separable infinite-dimensional Hilbert space, and denotes the algebra of bounded linear operators on . We write for the identity operator and . Following [10], let
For and a positive integer , let and denote the sets of sums and products of elements of . Define
The minima are over positive integers. A length is if no such integer exists. The factors in a product need not be invertible. Each class in Theorem 1.1 below contains , so shorter sums can be extended by zero summands. An involution is an operator with ; it need not be self-adjoint. We write for similarity and for unitary equivalence. The four classes of operators in Theorem 1.1 are invariant under unitary conjugation. We use fixed unitary identifications to regard operators on finite or countable orthogonal sums of copies of as operators on . Write
For , write
For unrestricted bounded factors, Brown and Pearcy [3] proved that an operator in is a commutator if and only if it is not of the form , where and is compact. See also Halmos [8 pp. 128–134] for a discussion of operator commutators. Wu [16] surveys factorizations into prescribed classes, including involutions and partial isometries. Here the two entries of each commutator are required to be idempotents, and we determine the least numbers of summands and factors needed to obtain every operator in .
Marcoux, Radjavi and Zhang proved
see [10 Propositions 7.7 and 7.18, Theorem 7.16]. They also proved that is norm dense in and asked whether it equals [10 Remark 7.17]. Question 7.22 asks for the least number of differences of idempotents needed in a sum, whether every thin operator is a product of two such differences, and the least numbers of summands and factors for operators similar to their negatives. Here a thin operator is a scalar multiple of plus a compact operator.
Theorem 1.1. Let be one of the following four classes: commutators of idempotents, differences of idempotents, operators similar to their negatives, or operators anticommuting with an involution. Then,
This gives in Question 7.22(a), an affirmative answer to Question 7.22(b), and , in Question 7.22(c). The equality answers the question in Remark 7.17.
Note that the equality also follows from earlier results. Pearcy and Topping proved that every operator in is a sum of five idempotents [12]; see also the proof of [13 Theorem 2]. Apply their theorem to , add a zero idempotent, and use to pair the six terms. The lower bound follows from [13 Theorem 1], which excludes from sums of four idempotents.
For every and every real , Theorem 3.3 gives satisfying
Fong and Sourour [7] proved that, if a unitary is not a compact perturbation of a scalar operator, then every unitary is a finite product of operators unitarily equivalent to it. For the bilateral shift of multiplicity one, three factors suffice by [9 Theorem 5.3], and two suffice by [1 Theorem 1.1]. Proposition 3.4 uses the latter theorem to write every unitary as , where and are unitary commutators of idempotents. Both commutators are obtained by unitary conjugation of a fixed pair of idempotents. For this factorization, the identities above hold with . In Proposition 3.5, the right factor is independent of ; both factors anticommute with involutions and are differences of idempotents.
Drnovšek, Radjavi and Rosenthal characterized commutators of idempotents in [6 Theorem 1]. Drnovšek gave an equivalent condition in terms of involutions in [5 Theorem 2.1]. We use this theorem to show that is a commutator of two idempotents over every unital associative algebra whose scalar field has characteristic different from two. Countable direct sums and [4 Lemma 2.6(ii)] give the additive result. For the multiplicative result, we write each strict contraction as , where are pure isometries with infinite-dimensional ker and ker . Proposition 2.1 then shows that the multiples of and used in the factorization belong to .
An operator anticommutes with an involution if and only if it is a scalar multiple of a commutator of idempotents. Indeed, if and , then [5 Corollary 2.4], applied to a sufficiently small positive multiple of relative to the eigenspace decomposition of , gives idempotents and such that . Conversely, is an involution that anticommutes with every scalar multiple of . This equivalence is also recorded in [2 Proposition 2.2].
In [10 Section 2.9], the authors also ask whether a nilpotent operator similar to its negative must be conjugated to its negative by an involution. We give a negative answer for nilpotent operators of order three.
Theorem 1.2. There are and an invertible such that
but no involution satisfies .
Section 4 allows the upper-right entry in the block form of [10 Section 2.6] to vary. Under the hypotheses of Theorem 4.2, a bounded involution exists exactly when the ratios of the block coefficients are bounded. The involution need not preserve the summands. Theorem 4.5 proves Theorem 1.2 with an operator whose singular values are -summable for every . For each , it gives such operators with .
The paper is organized as follows. § 2 determines the additive lengths. Section 3 proves the product representations, including the unitary case and the factorization with a fixed right factor. § 5 constructs the nilpotent examples.
Sums of three commutators
Proposition 2.1. Let be a unital associative algebra over a field of characteristic different from two. For every , is a commutator of two idempotents in .
Proof. Let denote the identity of , and set
Then, and . In put
These elements satisfy
These are the conditions in [5 Theorem 2.1(iii)]. Their equivalence with condition (i) proves that is a commutator of two idempotents. □
We use the alternating direct sums from the proof of [10 Proposition 7.18], together with Proposition 2.1, to obtain the following statements for commutators of idempotents.
Corollary 2.2. For every ,
where the zero summand acts on an infinite-dimensional space. There is also a function
such that for every .
Proof. Apply Proposition 2.1 to and use . Regrouping the copies of and gives the first assertion.
On , define
The first assertion and a permutation of the summands give . Since and
we also have . Their sum is
Finally, fix a unitary and put
Then, . □
We recall the following result of Davidson and Marcoux [4 Lemma 2.6(ii)].
Lemma 2.3. Let be a function, and let be unitarily invariant subsets of . Suppose that
where the zero summand is infinite-dimensional. Then, .
Every commutator of idempotents anticommutes with an involution and is so similar to its negative; see [11 Proposition 2.1]. Every operator anticommuting with an involution is also a difference of idempotents: relative to the topological direct sum of the two eigenspaces, its diagonal blocks vanish, and the calculation in the proof of [11 Proposition 2.2] applies.
Theorem 2.4. One has
Every operator is also a sum of three operators anticommuting with involutions. The identity is not a sum of two operators similar to their negatives. Hence for each of the four classes in Theorem 1.1.
Proof. The classes and are unitarily invariant. Corollary 2.2 gives the hypotheses of Lemma 2.3 with and . Hence
The inclusions stated before the theorem give the remaining three upper bounds.
The spectral argument in the proof of [10 Proposition 7.7] excludes whenever and are similar to their negatives. It therefore also excludes two commutators of idempotents or two operators anticommuting with involutions.
By [13 Theorem 1], is not a sum of four idempotents. If
then
would be such a sum. Thus, .
Products of two commutators
An isometry is called pure if . It has infinite multiplicity when is infinite-dimensional.
Theorem 3.1. For every with , there are pure isometries such that and both and are infinite-dimensional.
Proof. Let . Since
has a bounded inverse. On , define
The equality shows that and are isometries, with . We choose a unitary such that both and are pure.
Fix an orthonormal basis of , and put
@page 4/13 starts_mid=0 ends_mid=1
Lemma 2.3. Let be a function, and let be unitarily invariant subsets of . Suppose that
where the zero summand is infinite-dimensional. Then, .
Every commutator of idempotents anticommutes with an involution and is so similar to its negative; see [11 Proposition 2.1]. Every operator anticommuting with an involution is also a difference of idempotents: relative to the topological direct sum of the two eigenspaces, its diagonal blocks vanish, and the calculation in the proof of [11 Proposition 2.2] applies.
Theorem 2.4. One has
Every operator is also a sum of three operators anticommuting with involutions. The identity is not a sum of two operators similar to their negatives. Hence for each of the four classes in Theorem 1.1.
Proof. The classes and are unitarily invariant. Corollary 2.2 gives the hypotheses of Lemma 2.3 with and . Hence
The inclusions stated before the theorem give the remaining three upper bounds.
The spectral argument in the proof of [10 Proposition 7.7] excludes whenever and are similar to their negatives. It therefore also excludes two commutators of idempotents or two operators anticommuting with involutions.
By [13 Theorem 1], is not a sum of four idempotents. If
then
would be such a sum. Thus, .
Products of two commutators
An isometry is called pure if . It has infinite multiplicity when is infinite-dimensional.
Theorem 3.1. For every with , there are pure isometries such that and both and are infinite-dimensional.
Proof. Let . Since
has a bounded inverse. On , define
The equality shows that and are isometries, with . We choose a unitary such that both and are pure.
Fix an orthonormal basis of , and put
The operator
is boundedly invertible, with
Thus,
In particular, the are closed and decreasing, and
The subspace has codimension two in . Since is invertible, has codimension two in . Therefore,
has dimension two. The orthogonal projections onto decrease strongly to zero. Consequently,
Choose an orthonormal basis of each , and an orthonormal basis of . Define on these basis vectors by
This defines a unitary. Moreover,
Now put and . These are isometries on , and
The inclusions give
Since , it follows by induction that
The intersection of the is zero, so both isometries are pure. Finally, , and so
The subspace is infinite-dimensional, so both kernels are infinite-dimensional. □
Lemma 3.2. Let be a pure isometry with infinite-dimensional . Then, for every . There is also a self-adjoint unitary such that and .
Proof. By the Wold decomposition [15 Chapter I, §1],
On these summands define
Then, and . Taking adjoints gives .
This decomposition identifies with the unilateral shift on , where is separable and infinite-dimensional. Split into four orthogonal infinite-dimensional subspaces. Each gives a reducing subspace on which the shift is unitarily equivalent to . Thus,
Together with , this yields
Proposition 2.1, applied to , proves . Taking adjoints in the two unitary equivalences and applying the same proposition to proves . □
Theorem 2.4 and the following theorem prove Theorem 1.1.
Theorem 3.3. For every and every real , there are such that
Consequently,
Every operator is also a product of two operators anticommuting with involutions. Hence for each of the four classes in Theorem 1.1.
Proof. Apply Theorem 3.1 to , and write . Set
Lemma 3.2 gives , while
Since and are isometries, . Each commutator anticommutes with an involution, is similar to its negative, and is a difference of idempotents. This gives the other three product representations.
By Theorem 2.4, each of the four classes is a proper subset of . Hence one factor does not suffice. □
By [10 Corollary 7.12(a)], every unitary is a product of two commutators of idempotents; those factors need not be unitary. To obtain unitary factors, we use products of bilateral shifts. Marcoux, Omladič, Radjavi and Zhang proved that every unitary is a product of three bilateral shifts of multiplicity one [9 Theorem 5.3]. The author proved that two suffice [1 Theorem 1.1]. We first represent one such shift as a commutator of a fixed pair of idempotents. We use for the unitary group.
Proposition 3.4. There exist an orthogonal projection and an idempotent on such that is a bilateral shift of multiplicity one and every has a representation
for some . In particular,
and of course one factor does not suffice.
Proof. Identify with , where , and let on its standard orthonormal basis. We need an operator commuting with and satisfying
The equation has no nonzero square-summable solution, so and its adjoint are injective. In the polar decomposition
is unitary and commutes with and , since is normal. Moreover,
The range of is dense, hence . The norm-convergent binomial series gives
Set
Apply [5 Theorem 2.2] with both square roots equal to . The identities and verify its hypotheses and give an idempotent with . We keep this pair fixed. The vectors
form an orthonormal basis, and for every integer . Thus, is a bilateral shift of multiplicity one.
By [1 Theorem 1.1], every unitary can be written as
for unitary . Substituting proves the stated representation. Finally, a commutator of idempotents is similar to its negative, whereas is not. Thus, one factor does not suffice. □
Thus, for a unitary , the identities hold with . In this case the factors are unitary, so as well.
For differences of idempotents, one can fix the right factor in advance.
Proposition 3.5. There are a fixed isometry and fixed self-adjoint unitaries such that, for every , the operator
satisfies
The map is bounded and linear. Both and are differences of idempotents.
Proof. Identify with , where is a separable infinite-dimensional Hilbert space. Let
Then, , and . The isometry is pure of infinite multiplicity, so by Lemma 3.2.
Put and . Both spaces are infinite-dimensional and . Choose a unitary and define
This is a self-adjoint unitary interchanging and . Therefore,
For , we obtain
and
The formula defines a bounded linear map . Since and anticommute with involutions, both are differences of idempotents. □
Nilpotent operators similar to their negatives
In [10 Section 2.9], Marcoux, Radjavi and Zhang ask whether a nilpotent operator similar to its negative is conjugate to its negative by an involution. We replace the identity in the upper-right corner of their block form [10 Section 2.6] by an operator . For , put
Throughout this section, is injective. Then, , with in position of . We take and block diagonal on the same orthogonal sum. Theorem 4.2 below determines exactly when an operator in this family is conjugate to its negative by a bounded involution. Choosing compact as well as will give compact counterexamples.
Lemma 4.1. Let be a finite-dimensional complex Hilbert space of odd dimension. For every and every unitary ,
Proof. Put . If , the inequality is immediate. Suppose and write , where and are self-adjoint. Taking real parts gives
and hence . This implies that every eigenvalue of has absolute value at least .
Since is odd, either the positive or the negative spectral subspace of has dimension greater than . Choose the corresponding sign , so that
The spaces and have a nonzero intersection. For a unit vector in that intersection, both and belong to . Thus,
It follows that , which proves (2).
The unitary blocks in the next theorem are arbitrary. The involution need not preserve the summands .
Theorem 4.2. Let , where each has finite odd dimension, and let be unitary on . Let and be bounded sequences of positive numbers. Suppose that, for some ,
Set
A bounded involution satisfying exists if and only if
Moreover, every such involution satisfies, for all sufficiently large ,
Proof. Suppose first that (4.4) holds. The operator
is bounded and satisfies . Direct multiplication gives
Conversely, suppose that is a bounded involution anticommuting with , and put . Since is injective,
Both spaces are invariant under . Hence
Comparing entries gives
In particular,
For , these are the relations in the proof of [10 Proposition 2.8].
Fix a sufficiently large index , and put , and . Use the orthogonal decomposition
Write and . Define the bounded operator
Both sequences and eventually decrease geometrically by (4.3). Choose so large that these inequalities hold from onward and, for each sequence, the term at is no greater than any preceding term. Then,
The operator is invertible on the finite-dimensional space . The second condition in (4.3) makes bounded.
Relative to this decomposition, write
and let be the middle diagonal entry of . Every entry of has norm at most .
Let be the entries of from to . The corresponding entries in (4.7), with the entry of eliminated, give
Multiplication on the left by and (4.8) yield
Next consider . Let be the corresponding entry of , and let be those of . Equations (7) give
Multiply the second equality on the right by . Since , this gives
Multiplication on the left by now gives
The middle diagonal entry of is . Thus,
Taking middle diagonal entries in (7) also gives
Apply Lemma 4.1 on with . It follows that
This proves (5). If were unbounded, the last expression would be less than one for a suitable large index. Hence (4) is necessary. □
The restriction to odd dimensions is needed. On , put
Then, , and the self-adjoint unitary anticommutes with for every . Taking orthogonal sums gives a bounded involution regardless of the sizes of in this even-dimensional example.
For classical similarity, an unbounded ratio can be compensated by the factor . This is the condition used in the following construction.
Proposition 4.3. Let , be bounded sequences of positive numbers. Let be odd integers and choose such that and
There are unitaries on for which
satisfy . If the supremum in (9) is at most , there is an invertible with and
If (3) holds and is unbounded, no bounded involution conjugates to . If and , then is compact.
Proof. On the standard orthonormal basis , set
Since , both operators are unitary and . Put
Then, are unitary, , and commutes with . Define
By (9), is bounded and
Set
The three diagonal blocks are unitary and is bounded, so the upper triangular operator is bounded and invertible. The only possibly nonzero entries of are
Thus, .
For the norm estimate, let and . The operator is unitary, , and . Hence
which proves (10). Theorem 4.2 gives the assertion about involutions. If , the finite-rank truncations of and converge in norm, so every entry of is compact. □
We next take . In this case an involution exists exactly for .
Corollary 4.4. For each , there is a compact normal injective operator such that, for every ,
satisfies .
Here . A bounded involution conjugates to if and only if . Moreover, is compact if and only if .
Proof. Choose odd integers and -th roots of unity with . Such choices are possible because the roots of unity of odd order are dense in the unit circle. Let be as in Proposition 4.3, and set . Then, . For and ,
Proposition 4.3 gives for every .
If , then satisfies (4.3) with the same , whereas is unbounded. Theorem 4.2 excludes an involution. If , the ratio is bounded and (4.6) supplies one. Finally, for both and are compact. For , the upper-right entry is the identity on an infinite-dimensional space, so is not compact. □
For , this gives a compact counterexample. We now impose summability of every positive power of the singular values. For , let denote the Schatten -class of compact operators on whose singular values satisfy
For background on singular values and operator ideals, see [14].
Theorem 4.5. For every , there are and an invertible such that
but no bounded involution satisfies .
Proof. Fix and set
Then,
Thus, (4.3) holds and is unbounded.
We choose odd and -th roots so that
where is independent of .
Now, construct , and by Proposition 4.3. The coefficients tend to zero, so is compact. Since
that proposition gives with the asserted norm bounds. Theorem 4.2 excludes every bounded involution, and follows from the injectivity of .
Regrouping the orthogonal summands writes as a direct sum of matrices on . The range of each is , so its rank is . Also,
Consequently, for every ,
The series converges for every . This completes the proof. □
Declarations
Competing interests. The author declares that he has no competing interests.
Funding. The author received no funding.
Data availability. No datasets were generated during the current study.
Department of Mathematics, Faculty of Sciences of Monastir, University of Monastir, 5019 Monastir, Tunisia
Email address: [email protected]
Email address: [email protected]
References
- [1]M. A. Aouichaoui, All unitary operators are bicycles, Proc. Amer. Math. Soc. 154 (2026), no. 12, 5325–5330.DOI
- [2]M. A. Aouichaoui, The set of commutators of quadratic operators and its norm closure, Proc. Amer. Math. Soc., doi:10.1090/proc/17996.DOI
- [3]A. Brown and C. Pearcy, Structure of commutators of operators, Ann. of Math. (2) 82 (1965), no. 1, 112–127.DOI
- [4]K. R. Davidson and L. W. Marcoux, Linear spans of unitary and similarity orbits of a Hilbert space operator, J. Operator Theory 52 (2004), no. 1, 113–132.
- [5]R. Drnovšek, On commutators of idempotents, Linear Multilinear Algebra 73 (2025), no. 4, 649–654.DOI
- [6]R. Drnovšek, H. Radjavi and P. Rosenthal, A characterization of commutators of idempotents, Linear Algebra Appl. 347 (2002), nos. 1–3, 91–99.DOI
- [7]C. K. Fong and A. R. Sourour, The semigroup generated by a similarity orbit or a unitary orbit of an operator, Proc. Amer. Math. Soc. 131 (2003), no. 10, 3203–3210.DOI
- [8]P. R. Halmos, A Hilbert Space Problem Book, 2nd ed., Grad. Texts in Math., vol. 19, Springer-Verlag, New York, 1982.
- [9]L. W. Marcoux, M. Omladič, H. Radjavi and Y. Zhang, All unitary operators are tricycles, and most are bicycles, Bull. Lond. Math. Soc. 58 (2026), no. 5, e70378.DOI
- [10]L. W. Marcoux, H. Radjavi and Y. Zhang, Around the closure of the set of commutators of idempotents in B(H): Biquasitrangularity and factorisation, J. Funct. Anal. 284 (2023), no. 8, Paper No. 109854, 45 pp.DOI
- [11]L. W. Marcoux, H. Radjavi and Y. Zhang, Around the closures of the set of commutators and the set of differences of idempotent elements of B(H), J. Operator Theory 91 (2024), no. 1, 97–124.
- [12]C. Pearcy and D. Topping, Sums of small numbers of idempotents, Michigan Math. J. 14 (1967), no. 4, 453–465.DOI
- [13]V. I. Rabanovich and Yu. S. Samoilenko, When a sum of idempotents or projections is a multiple of the identity, Funct. Anal. Appl. 34 (2000), no. 4, 311–313.DOI
- [14]B. Simon, Trace Ideals and Their Applications, 2nd ed., Math. Surveys Monogr., vol. 120, American Mathematical Society, Providence, RI, 2005.
- [15]B. Sz.-Nagy, C. Foias, H. Bercovici and L. Kérchy, Harmonic Analysis of Operators on Hilbert Space, 2nd ed., Universitext, Springer, New York, 2010.
- [16]P. Y. Wu, The operator factorization problems, Linear Algebra Appl. 117 (1989), 35–63.DOI