betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Capillary-gravity wave resistance of a translating, pulsating source

Abstract

A disturbance in steady rectilinear translation along a capillary-gravity interface radiates waves only above a minimum speed cminc_{min}, where it experiences a wave resistance; below this threshold it generates no waves, and the response is merely a localised deformation of the interface around the source, free of wave resistance. Modulating the source amplitude at a frequency ΩΩ shifts the forcing to the sideband pair kV±ΩkV\pmΩ, where kk is the wavenumber and VV is the translation speed, opening resonance conditions absent from the steady problem; radiation then sets in below the steady threshold cminc_{min}. Here we derive the mean wave resistance ⟨R⟩\langle R\rangle of a line source in closed form, and show it to be strictly positive at every nonzero speed VV: the drag-free below-threshold regime disappears for any Ω≠0Ω\neq 0. Crossing the radiation transitions—where the group velocity matches the source speed—produces integrable resonant peaks in ⟨R⟩\langle R\rangle, whose exponents we derive, including at the cusp where two transition branches merge. Below threshold, where a steadily moving source feels no drag, ⟨R⟩\langle R\rangle rises from zero as Ω5Ω^5 (at fixed VV). Throughout, surface tension is essential to ⟨R⟩\langle R\rangle: because it controls the short, dominant capillary-scale waves, discarding it misrepresents ⟨R⟩\langle R\rangle over almost the entire speed-frequency plane.

Introduction

A disturbance moving along a fluid interface can radiate waves and, in doing so, experience a resistive force, the wave resistance. This concept was developed by Havelock [8] for gravity waves on deep water, in the wake of the classical studies of ship waves by Kelvin (1887) and the towing experiments of Froude [7]. This Rapid article concerns the one-dimensional geometry of a line disturbance on a capillary–gravity interface of an inviscid fluid. For a source translating steadily at constant speed VV in this geometry, the wave resistance has been calculated explicitly by Raphael & de Gennes [14] (hereafter RdG):

R={p2γ[1−(cmin⁡V)4]−1/2,V>cmin⁡,0,0≤V<cmin⁡.(1)R = \begin{cases} \frac{p^2}{\gamma}\left[1-\left(\frac{c_{\min}}{V}\right)^4\right]^{-1/2}, & V > c_{\min},\\ 0, & 0 \le V < c_{\min}. \end{cases} \tag*{(1)}

where pp is the magnitude of the localised pressure source and cmin⁡=(4gγ/ρ)1/4c_{\min} = (4g\gamma/\rho)^{1/4} is the minimum phase speed, set by the gravity gg, surface tension γ\gamma and density ρ\rho of the liquid. Below cmin⁡c_{\min} the source radiates no waves, and the response is a deformation of the interface localised around the source.

Many interfacial sources of practical interest are, however, not steady [6, 1]. A floating body that bobs while advancing, or a vertically vibrating probe scanning the surface, imposes a pressure field whose amplitude is modulated at some frequency Ω\Omega. A source that translates uniformly while pulsating is a classical problem of dispersive wave radiation [11]; for pure gravity waves a resonance occurs at ΩV/g=14\Omega V/g = \frac{1}{4} [9, 4], and in the gravity-free limit its capillary counterpart is a critical resonance at Ωγ/(ρV3)=4/27\Omega\gamma/(\rho V^3) = 4/27 (§ 6). When both act together, by contrast, the phase speed has a minimum, cmin⁡c_{\min}, which sets the below-threshold regime of (1.1), where R=0R = 0 for a source translating steadily. The radiated wave field of the corresponding pulsating problem was obtained by Pramanik [13]: the radiating wavenumbers are the roots of two cubics, transitions occur where the group velocity matches the source speed, and the critical curves so defined partition the speed–frequency quadrant into regions of different wave content, surface tension adding two capillary waves upstream. That study did not address the wave resistance, which is our subject here. Unsteady motion is known to lift the below-threshold suppression: an accelerated source—one that changes speed or direction—radiates at V<cmin⁡V < c_{\min} [2, 3], as does a laterally oscillating one. Roccuzzo & Herault [16] recently modelled the wake of a slaloming swimmer as a superposition of translating pulsating sources, and found a wave-drag peak below cmin⁡c_{\min}. Here, by contrast, the trajectory is the uniform rectilinear translation of Raphael & de Gennes [14], with no acceleration of any kind, and the spectral content is supplied by amplitude modulation alone.

In this Rapid article we compute the wave resistance of this line source exactly. An amplitude modulation cos⁡(Ωt)\cos(\Omega t) of a source translating at speed VV displaces the forcing to the two sidebands kV±ΩkV \pm\Omega, opening resonance conditions with no counterpart in the steady problem [13]. We obtain ⟨R⟩\langle R\rangle in closed form, by contour integration, as a finite sum over the radiating modes, and show it to be strictly positive at every speed V>0V > 0 as soon as Ω≠0\Omega\ne0—including the whole below-threshold range where the steady source feels no wave resistance. Across the radiation transitions ⟨R⟩\langle R\rangle develops integrable resonant singularities whose exponents we derive, including at the cusp of one transition curve, where two saddle-node branches merge. The steady RdG result is recovered continuously as Ω→0\Omega\to0. Surface tension, finally, proves essential to ⟨R⟩\langle R\rangle itself and not only to the existence of cmin⁡c_{\min}.

Formulation and stationary response

We consider a vertical pressure source P(x,t)\mathcal{P}(x,t) translating at constant speed VV along the interface of a deep, inviscid, irrotational fluid of density ρ\rho, surface tension γ\gamma and gravity gg. The unperturbed interface lies on the z=0z = 0 plane, and the source moves along the xx-axis, its centre at x=−Vtx = -Vt (with V≥0V \ge0). Its amplitude is modulated harmonically at frequency Ω\Omega,

P(x,t)=pe(x+Vt)cos⁡(Ωt).(2)\mathcal{P}(x,t) = p_e(x + Vt)\cos(\Omega t). \tag*{(2)}

The source is invariant along the transverse yy-direction, so the response is two-dimensional, with surface elevation ζ(x,t)\zeta(x,t). Expanding the xx-dependence in Fourier modes ζ(x,t)=∫−∞∞dk2πeikxζ^(k,t)\zeta(x,t) = \int_{-\infty}^{\infty} \frac{dk}{2\pi} e^{ikx}\hat{\zeta}(k,t), the wavenumber kk ranges over all real values; a free wave of wavenumber kk oscillates at the frequency ω(k)=g∣k∣+(γ/ρ)∣k∣3\omega(k) = \sqrt{g|k| + (\gamma/\rho)|k|^{3}} (which depends only on ∣k∣|k|) [12]. Since ζ\zeta is real, ζ^(−k,t)=ζ^∗(k,t)\hat{\zeta}(-k,t) = \hat{\zeta}^{*}(k,t), and it suffices to take k>0k > 0, for which ω(k)=gk(1+k2/kc2)\omega(k) = \sqrt{gk(1 + k^{2}/k_{c}^{2})} is the capillary–gravity dispersion relation, where kc=ρg/γk_{c} = \sqrt{\rho g/\gamma}. The phase speed c(k)≡ω(k)/kc(k) \equiv\omega(k)/k is minimal at the capillary wavenumber kck_{c}, where it equals cmin⁡c_{\min}, and ωc=cmin⁡kc=2gkc\omega_{c} = c_{\min}k_{c} = \sqrt{2gk_{c}}; the group velocity is cg(k)≡dω/dkc_{g}(k) \equiv\mathrm{d}\omega/\mathrm{d}k. We non-dimensionalise wavenumbers by kck_{c}, speeds by cmin⁡c_{\min} and frequencies by ωc\omega_{c}, writing k~=k/kc\tilde{k} = k/k_{c}, V~=V/cmin⁡\tilde{V} = V/c_{\min} and Ω~=Ω/ωc\tilde{\Omega} = \Omega/\omega_{c}; the dispersion relation then reads ω(k~)/ωc=(k~+k~3)/2\omega(\tilde{k})/\omega_{c} = \sqrt{(\tilde{k} + \tilde{k}^{3})/2}, and the phase speed c/cmin⁡=(1+k~2)/(2k~)c/c_{\min} = \sqrt{(1 + \tilde{k}^{2})/(2\tilde{k})} is minimal at k~=1\tilde{k} = 1. The forcing of each surface mode is set by the spatial Fourier transform of the pressure distribution pep_{e}, p^e(k)=∫−∞∞pe(x)e−ikx dx\hat{p}_{e}(k) = \int_{-\infty}^{\infty} p_{e}(x)e^{-\mathrm{i}kx}\,\mathrm{d}x. For definiteness we take this distribution concentrated along a line, pe(x)=p δ(x)p_{e}(x) = p\,\delta(x). Its Fourier transform is then constant, p^e(k)=p\hat{p}_{e}(k) = p.

Linearising the equation of motion and the boundary condition at the free surface, and eliminating the velocity potential [12], ζ(x,t)\zeta(x,t) obeys, in Fourier space, the forced-oscillator equation

∂ttζ^(k,t)+ω2(k)ζ^(k,t)=−kp2ρ(eiωf1t+eiωf2t),(3)\partial_{tt}\hat{\zeta}(k,t) + \omega^{2}(k)\hat{\zeta}(k,t) = -\frac{kp}{2\rho}\left(e^{\mathrm{i}\omega_{f1}t} + e^{\mathrm{i}\omega_{f2}t}\right), \tag*{(3)}

where the cosine modulation has split the forcing into two sidebands of the Doppler frequency kVkV,

ωf1=kV+Ω,ωf2=kV−Ω.(4)\omega_{f1} = kV + \Omega,\qquad\omega_{f2} = kV - \Omega. \tag*{(4)}

The factor kk on the right-hand side of (3) reflects the non-local, deep-fluid surface dynamics. Note that for a general pressure profile pe(x)p_{e}(x) of finite extent, the constant amplitude pp on the right-hand side of (3) is replaced by the Fourier transform p^e(k)\hat{p}_{e}(k).

The long-time solution of (3) is, for k>0k > 0,

ζ^c(k,t)=kp2ρ[eiωf1tD1−2iωf1ε+eiωf2tD2−2iωf2ε],Dj=ωfj2−ω2,(5)\hat{\zeta}_{c}(k,t) = \frac{kp}{2\rho}\left[\frac{e^{\mathrm{i}\omega_{f1}t}}{D_{1} - 2\mathrm{i}\omega_{f1}\varepsilon} + \frac{e^{\mathrm{i}\omega_{f2}t}}{D_{2} - 2\mathrm{i}\omega_{f2}\varepsilon}\right],\qquad D_{j} = \omega_{fj}^{2} - \omega^{2}, \tag*{(5)}

where the Sommerfeld radiation condition is enforced by adding an infinitesimal friction, 2ε ∂tζ^2\varepsilon\,\partial_{t}\hat{\zeta}, to the left-hand side of (3) [12]. Each radiating mode (k>0k > 0) appears as ei(kx+ωfjt)e^{\mathrm{i}(kx+\omega_{fj}t)}, a wave whose crests travel at the phase velocity −ωfj/k-\omega_{fj}/k. As the source advances in the −x-x direction (x=−Vtx = -Vt), the sign of ωf\omega_{f} sets which way these crests travel: ωf>0\omega_{f} > 0 moves them in the same direction as the source (−x-x; prograde), ωf<0\omega_{f} < 0 in the opposite direction (+x+x; retrograde).

The radiating modes are the real positive roots of DjD_{j}; in dimensionless form Dj∝−Pj(k~)D_{j} \propto-P_{j}(\tilde{k}), introducing the two cubic polynomials that organise the whole analysis,

P1(k~)=k~3−2V~2k~2+(1−4V~Ω~)k~−2Ω~2,(6)P_{1}(\tilde{k}) = \tilde{k}^{3} - 2\tilde{V}^{2}\tilde{k}^{2} + (1 - 4\tilde{V}\tilde{\Omega})\tilde{k} - 2\tilde{\Omega}^{2}, \tag*{(6)}
P2(k~)=k~3−2V~2k~2+(1+4V~Ω~)k~−2Ω~2.(7)P_{2}(\tilde{k}) = \tilde{k}^{3} - 2\tilde{V}^{2}\tilde{k}^{2} + (1 + 4\tilde{V}\tilde{\Omega})\tilde{k} - 2\tilde{\Omega}^{2}. \tag*{(7)}

Three of their roots recur below: k~u\tilde{k}_{u} and k~∗\tilde{k}_{*}, the smallest positive root of P1P_{1} and the retrograde root of P2P_{2} (both long-wavelength modes, ∼Ω~2\sim\tilde{\Omega}^{2}), and k~d\tilde{k}_{d}, a double root, one at each radiation transition. The damping term in (5) is −2iωfjε-2\mathrm{i}\omega_{fj}\varepsilon, so the radiation condition enters with the sign of ωfj\omega_{fj}: negative for the upper sideband ωf1=kV+Ω\omega_{f1} = kV + \Omega, and reversed for the lower one ωf2=kV−Ω\omega_{f2} = kV - \Omega once Ω>kV\Omega> kV. The profile of the fluid interface as a function of the velocity and the modulation frequency was first studied by Pramanik [13]; a representative profile is shown in Figure 1. How many of these roots are real and positive—and hence which waves radiate—depends on (V~,Ω~)(\tilde{V},\tilde{\Omega}); the resulting partition of the plane into four radiation regimes is the phase diagram of Figure 2 (§4).

Figure 1. Interface profile ζ(x′)\zeta(x') in the source frame (x′=x+Vtx'=x+Vt) at t/T=0t/T=0, T=2π/ΩT=2\pi/\Omega, from (5), for V~=1.3\widetilde{V}=1.3, Ω~=0.15\widetilde{\Omega}=0.15: two short capillary ripples (k~≈2.7\widetilde{k}\approx2.7 and 3.33.3) on one side; a longer wave (k~≈0.62\widetilde{k}\approx0.62) with a slowly varying long-wave mode (k~≈0.03\widetilde{k}\approx0.03) on the other. The source is located at x′=0x'=0 (dotted line).

Figure 2. Phase diagram in the (V~,Ω~)(\widetilde{V},\widetilde{\Omega}) plane. Each region is labelled by the numbers (n1,n2)(n_1,n_2) of real positive roots of (P1,P2)(P_1,P_2) and, beneath, by the split of the radiating modes into upstream (↑\uparrow, energy ahead of the source) and downstream (↓\downarrow, behind); the two counts are equal in every region (the narrow (3,1)(3,1) region is labelled by a leader). The green and red curves are the radiation transitions of P1P_1 and P2P_2; both emanate from the bifurcation point (V~,Ω~)=(1,0)(\widetilde{V},\widetilde{\Omega})=(1,0), and the cusp of the P1P_1 curve lies at (V~,Ω~)≈(0.768,0.174)(\widetilde{V},\widetilde{\Omega})\approx(0.768,0.174). The expression for ⟨R⟩\langle R\rangle in each region is given by (10).

Mean wave resistance

The wave resistance is the streamwise force exerted by the fluid on the source [8], reckoned positive when it opposes the motion,

R(t)=−∫−∞+∞P(x,t) ∂xζ(x,t) dx,(8)R(t)=-\int_{-\infty}^{+\infty}\mathcal{P}(x,t)\,\partial_x\zeta(x,t)\,\mathrm{d}x, \tag*{(8)}

where P(x,t)\mathcal{P}(x,t) is given by (2). Using Parseval’s theorem, we substitute (5) and average over a modulation period; only the cos⁡2Ωt\cos^2\Omega t contributions survive, giving

⟨R⟩=∫0∞k2p2ρ[ωf1εD12+4ωf12ε2+ωf2εD22+4ωf22ε2]dk2π.(9)\langle R\rangle=\int_0^\infty\frac{k^2p^2}{\rho}\left[\frac{\omega_{f1}\varepsilon}{D_1^2+4\omega_{f1}^2\varepsilon^2}+\frac{\omega_{f2}\varepsilon}{D_2^2+4\omega_{f2}^2\varepsilon^2}\right]\frac{\mathrm{d}k}{2\pi}. \tag*{(9)}

In the radiation limit ε→0+\varepsilon\to0^+ each Lorentzian collapses onto a signed delta, ωfε/(D2+4ωf2ε2)→(π/2)sgn⁡(ωf)δ(D)\omega_f\varepsilon/(D^2+4\omega_f^2\varepsilon^2)\to(\pi/2)\operatorname{sgn}(\omega_f)\delta(D), and the integral reduces to a sum of residues over the roots of P1P_1 and P2P_2. In terms of the dimensionless wavenumber k~=k/kc\widetilde{k}=k/k_c, this gives

⟨R~⟩≡⟨R⟩p2/γ=14(S~1+S~2≷−S~2<),(10)\langle\widetilde{R}\rangle\equiv\frac{\langle R\rangle}{p^2/\gamma}=\frac{1}{4}\left(\widetilde{S}_1+\widetilde{S}_2^{\gtrless}-\widetilde{S}_2^{<}\right), \tag*{(10)}

where

S~1=∑P1(k~n)=0k~n>0k~n2∣P1′(k~n)∣,S~2≷=∑P2(k~n)=0k~nV~≷Ω~k~n2∣P2′(k~n)∣.(11)\widetilde{S}_1=\sum_{\substack{P_1(\widetilde{k}_n)=0\\ \widetilde{k}_n>0}}\frac{\widetilde{k}_n^2}{\lvert P_1'(\widetilde{k}_n)\rvert},\qquad \widetilde{S}_2^{\gtrless}=\sum_{\substack{P_2(\widetilde{k}_n)=0\\ \widetilde{k}_n\widetilde{V}\gtrless\widetilde{\Omega}}}\frac{\widetilde{k}_n^2}{\lvert P_2'(\widetilde{k}_n)\rvert}. \tag*{(11)}

The three sums in (11) are non-negative; they differ only by the sign with which sgn⁡(ωfj)\operatorname{sgn}(\omega_{fj}) makes them enter (10). The upper sideband has ωf1=kV+Ω>0\omega_{f1}=kV+\Omega>0 at every k>0k>0, so S~1\widetilde{S}_1 always enters with a plus; of the lower-sideband waves, the prograde ones (ωf2>0\omega_{f2}>0) enter with a plus and the retrograde ones (ωf2<0\omega_{f2}<0) with a minus. Writing ω~(k~)=ω/ωc\widetilde{\omega}(\widetilde{k})=\omega/\omega_c, one has Pj=2[ω~ 2−(k~V~±Ω~)2]P_j=2[\widetilde{\omega}^{\,2}-(\widetilde{k}\widetilde{V}\pm\widetilde{\Omega})^2], so the positive roots of P1P_1 solve ω~−k~V~=Ω~\widetilde{\omega}-\widetilde{k}\widetilde{V}=\widetilde{\Omega}, and those of P2P_2 solve ω~−k~V~=−Ω~\widetilde{\omega}-\widetilde{k}\widetilde{V}=-\widetilde{\Omega} (prograde) or ω~+k~V~=Ω~\widetilde{\omega}+\widetilde{k}\widetilde{V}=\widetilde{\Omega} (retrograde). The last equation has exactly one root k~∗\widetilde{k}_*, its left-hand side rising monotonically from 00 to ∞\infty: there is always exactly one retrograde wave.

The three sums combine in (10) with S~2<\widetilde{S}_2^{<} subtracted, so ⟨R⟩\langle R\rangle is not manifestly positive. It is nevertheless strictly positive for every V~>0\widetilde{V}>0 and Ω≠0\Omega\ne0. To prove this, let $\widetilde{k}_u be the smallest positive root of P1P_1, which exists since P1(0)=−2Ω~2<0P_1(0)=-2\tilde{\Omega}^{2}<0. Because ω~+k~V~>ω~−k~V~\tilde{\omega}+\tilde{k}\tilde{V}>\tilde{\omega}-\tilde{k}\tilde{V} for k~>0\tilde{k}>0, the retrograde root k~∗\tilde{k}_* lies below k~u\tilde{k}_u; and the identity ω~cg/cmin⁡=(1+3k~2)/4\tilde{\omega}c_g/c_{\min}=(1+3\tilde{k}^{2})/4 then gives k~u2/P1′(k~u)>k~∗2/P2′(k~∗)\tilde{k}_u^2/P_1'(\tilde{k}_u)>\tilde{k}_*^2/P_2'(\tilde{k}_*).1 The left-hand side is one term of S~1\tilde{S}_1 and the right-hand side is all of S~2<\tilde{S}_2^{<}, so S~1>S~2<\tilde{S}_1>\tilde{S}_2^{<}: the single upper-sideband wave k~u\tilde{k}_u already outweighs the retrograde one k~∗\tilde{k}_*, which therefore cannot reverse the balance. We conclude that the mean wave resistance ⟨R⟩\langle R\rangle is always positive, and vanishes only on the steady below-threshold axis Ω=0\Omega=0, V~<1\tilde{V}<1, where nothing is radiated, and on the axis V~=0\tilde{V}=0, where a source that does not advance radiates symmetrically. Note that the sign of the instantaneous wave resistance R(t)=⟨R⟩(1+cos⁡2Ωt)−Csin⁡2ΩtR(t)=\langle R\rangle(1+\cos2\Omega t)-C\sin2\Omega t (with CC the reactive, non-radiating amplitude) varies in time, dipping to ⟨R⟩−⟨R⟩2+C2<0\langle R\rangle-\sqrt{\langle R\rangle^2+C^2}<0 within each period.

Below-threshold radiation and the phase diagram

The central consequence of (10) is immediate. For any Ω≠0\Omega\ne0 the small root k~∗\tilde{k}_* of P2P_2 exists at any speed V>0V>0: it represents a genuinely propagating mode, radiating power to infinity. It is retrograde (ωf2<0\omega_{f2}<0) and thus enters the residue sum (10) through the subtracted term S~2<\tilde{S}_2^{<}. The upper sideband is never silent either: P1(0)=−2Ω~2<0P_1(0)=-2\tilde{\Omega}^{2}<0 guarantees a positive root k~u\tilde{k}_u of P1P_1 for every Ω≠0\Omega\ne0, and by the inequality of § 3 that single wave already outweighs the retrograde one k~∗\tilde{k}_*, so that ⟨R⟩>0\langle R\rangle>0. The steady threshold V=cmin⁡V=c_{\min} therefore does not carry over to the modulated problem — as soon as the source oscillates, radiation occurs at all speeds, and the below-threshold silent regime of the steady source disappears. Whirligig beetles radiate capillary waves below cmin⁡c_{\min} through their leg strokes {(citep)}(Voise & Casas 2010), an effect ascribed to the unsteadiness of the strokes {(citep)}(Closa et al. 2010); their periodicity, however, is by itself enough.

The number of radiating modes changes across radiation transitions, at which two roots of PjP_j coalesce into a double root k~d\tilde{k}_d. This is the condition cg(k~d)=Vc_g(\tilde{k}_d)=V on the group velocity (i.e. cg/cmin⁡=V~c_g/c_{\min}=\tilde{V}), which traces one curve for each polynomial in the (V~,Ω~)(\tilde{V},\tilde{\Omega}) plane and partitions it into the four regions of the phase diagram, Figure 2. The criterion, and the partition it induces — including the cusp below — were obtained by Pramanik [13], within the general framework of Lighthill [11]. Both transition curves emanate from the steady bifurcation point (V~,Ω~)=(1,0)(\tilde{V},\tilde{\Omega})=(1,0); the P1P_1 curve possesses a cusp at k~f=(23−3)/3≈0.393\tilde{k}_f=\sqrt{(2\sqrt{3}-3)/3}\approx0.393, with coordinates V~f=(3−3)/[2(23−3)1/4]≈0.768\tilde{V}_f=(3-\sqrt{3})/[2(2\sqrt{3}-3)^{1/4}]\approx0.768 and Ω~f=(23−3)1/4(3−3)/6≈0.174\tilde{\Omega}_f=(2\sqrt{3}-3)^{1/4}(3-\sqrt{3})/6\approx0.174.

The same group-velocity criterion fixes where each radiated wave is found relative to the source. A mode sits upstream (ahead) when its energy—carried at the group velocity—outruns the source, and downstream (behind) otherwise. A prograde mode (ωfj>0\omega_{fj}>0) carries its energy forwards, so it sits upstream when cg>Vc_g>V, i.e. when Pj′(k~n)>0P_j'(\tilde{k}_n)>0. A retrograde mode (ωf2<0\omega_{f2}<0) carries its energy backwards and is therefore always downstream. This generalises the steady picture, in which the short capillary wave rides ahead of the source while the long gravity wave trails behind. Each sideband favours one side: the upper sideband (ωf1\omega_{f1}) always supplies one net extra upstream mode — at small Ω~\widetilde{\Omega}, its long prograde wave k~u∼Ω~2\widetilde{k}_u\sim\widetilde{\Omega}^2, with cg≫Vc_g\gg V — whereas the lower sideband (ωf2)(\omega_{f2}) supplies one net extra downstream mode, the retrograde long wave k~∗\widetilde{k}_* (ωf2<0)(\omega_{f2}<0). The radiating modes therefore split into equal numbers upstream and downstream in every region, as annotated in Figure 2. This balance has no counterpart in the pure-gravity problem, where one wave travels upstream and three downstream below the resonance ΩV/g=14\Omega V/g=\frac{1}{4}, only two downstream waves remaining above it [9, 4]. Surface tension adds two capillary waves, both upstream [13].

The transitions leave a clear signature in ⟨R⟩\langle R\rangle. At a double root, Pj′(k~d)=0P_j'(\widetilde{k}_d)=0 and the term k~d2/∣Pj′(k~d)∣\widetilde{k}_d^2/\lvert P_j'(\widetilde{k}_d)\rvert diverges, so that ⟨R⟩\langle R\rangle develops an integrable singularity.

Close to a transition, reached at Ω~=Ω~d\widetilde{\Omega}=\widetilde{\Omega}_d for a given V~\widetilde{V}, the two coalescing roots form a saddle-node, k~±=k~d±α(Ω~−Ω~d)\widetilde{k}_{\pm}=\widetilde{k}_d\pm\sqrt{\alpha(\widetilde{\Omega}-\widetilde{\Omega}_d)}, with the saddle-node coefficient α=−2∂Ω~Pj/Pj′′\alpha=-2\partial_{\widetilde{\Omega}}P_j/P_j'' evaluated at (k~d,Ω~d)(\widetilde{k}_d,\widetilde{\Omega}_d), so that ∣Pj′(k~±)∣∝∣Ω~−Ω~d∣1/2\lvert P_j'(\widetilde{k}_{\pm})\rvert\propto\lvert\widetilde{\Omega}-\widetilde{\Omega}_d\rvert^{1/2} and the resistance diverges as an integrable, one-sided square root, ⟨R~⟩≃A(V~)∣Ω~−Ω~d∣−1/2\langle\widetilde{R}\rangle\simeq A(\widetilde{V})\lvert\widetilde{\Omega}-\widetilde{\Omega}_d\rvert^{-1/2} on the side where the pair is real (for instance A≈0.11A\approx0.11 at V~=0.95\widetilde{V}=0.95). This square-root law degenerates at the bifurcation point (V~,Ω~)=(1,0)(\widetilde{V},\widetilde{\Omega})=(1,0), where the coalescence is pinned at the dispersion minimum k~=1\widetilde{k}=1 and the two transition curves originate. There the steady limit of ⟨R~⟩\langle\widetilde{R}\rangle already diverges as ⟨R~⟩≃14(V~−1)−1/2\langle\widetilde{R}\rangle\simeq\frac{1}{4}(\widetilde{V}-1)^{-1/2} along Ω~=0\widetilde{\Omega}=0, while along the threshold V~=1\widetilde{V}=1 the modulated wave resistance diverges as ⟨R~⟩≃18Ω~−1/2\langle\widetilde{R}\rangle\simeq\frac{1}{8}\widetilde{\Omega}^{-1/2} as Ω~→0\widetilde{\Omega}\to0; the bifurcation point is thus the common origin of the steady and modulated square-root singularities. At the cusp of the P1P_1 curve the two saddle-node branches meet, the radiating root becoming triple, and the one-sided square root is replaced by a stronger, two-sided divergence ⟨R~⟩∝∣Ω~−Ω~f∣−2/3\langle\widetilde{R}\rangle\propto\lvert\widetilde{\Omega}-\widetilde{\Omega}_f\rvert^{-2/3} (Figure 3b). Conversely, for V~\widetilde{V} below the cusp speed a vertical cut meets no P1P_1 transition and ⟨R~⟩\langle\widetilde{R}\rangle rises smoothly as Ω~5\widetilde{\Omega}^5 at small Ω~\widetilde{\Omega} to a broad maximum without resonance, after which it decays as Ω~−1/3\widetilde{\Omega}^{-1/3} (Figure 3a).

Figure 3. Dimensionless mean wave resistance ⟨R~⟩=⟨R⟩/(p2/γ)\langle\widetilde{R}\rangle= \langle R\rangle/(p^{2}/\gamma) (logarithmic scale) versus Ω~=Ω/ωc\widetilde{\Omega} = \Omega/\omega_{c} at four fixed speeds, sweeping VV through the P1P_{1} cusp and the steady threshold. Throughout, ⟨R~⟩\langle\widetilde{R}\rangle diverges integrably at the radiation transitions (dotted asymptotes), where a radiating root of P1P_{1} or P2P_{2} becomes double, and stays finite elsewhere; it decays as Ω~−1/3\widetilde{\Omega}^{-1/3} at high frequency. (a) At V=0.5cmin⁡V = 0.5c_{\min}, below the cusp speed, the vertical cut meets no P1P_{1} transition: ⟨R~⟩\langle\widetilde{R}\rangle rises as Ω~5\widetilde{\Omega}^{5} at small Ω~\widetilde{\Omega} and passes a broad maximum, without any resonance. (b) At the cusp speed V=0.768cmin⁡V = 0.768c_{\min} the two P1P_{1} saddle-node branches meet and the radiating root becomes triple at Ω~f=0.174\widetilde{\Omega}_{f} = 0.174, where ⟨R~⟩\langle\widetilde{R}\rangle diverges on both sides as ∣Ω~−Ω~f∣−2/3\lvert\widetilde{\Omega}-\widetilde{\Omega}_{f}\rvert^{-2/3}. (c) At V=0.95cmin⁡V = 0.95c_{\min}, although V<cmin⁡V < c_{\min}, the source radiates at every Ω≠0\Omega\ne0 (⟨R~⟩\langle\widetilde{R}\rangle vanishes only at Ω=0\Omega= 0 and is too small to be visible before the first transition), crossing two P1P_{1} transitions (Ω~≈0.048,0.134\widetilde{\Omega} \approx0.048, 0.134). (d) Above threshold, V=1.3cmin⁡V = 1.3c_{\min}, the resistance starts from its finite steady value, crosses a low-amplitude P1P_{1} resonance (Ω~≈0.097\widetilde{\Omega} \approx0.097) and a high-amplitude P2P_{2} resonance (Ω~≈0.393\widetilde{\Omega} \approx0.393) — both integrable divergences, of very different prefactor — beyond which a radiating mode disappears and the resistance drops.

For a speed just below the steady threshold, a vertical cut at fixed VV crosses these transition curves and ⟨R~⟩\langle\widetilde{R}\rangle exhibits sharp resonant peaks (Figure 3). At the below-threshold speed V=0.95cmin⁡V = 0.95c_{\min} (Figure 3c) two such peaks appear within Ω~≲0.2\widetilde{\Omega} \lesssim0.2: a first, high-amplitude peak near Ω~≈0.048\widetilde{\Omega} \approx0.048 where two complex-conjugate roots of P1P_{1} coalesce on the real axis, and a second near Ω~≈0.134\widetilde{\Omega} \approx0.134 where the reverse transition takes place. A slow temporal modulation of a marginally below-threshold source is thus sufficient to trigger a pronounced radiative response. Above threshold (V=1.3cmin⁡V = 1.3c_{\min}, Figure 3d) the wave resistance instead starts from its finite steady value, passes a low-amplitude P1P_{1} resonance and a high-amplitude P2P_{2} resonance, and drops as the latter transition removes a radiating mode.

Limiting and asymptotic behaviour

Recovery of the steady limit. As Ω→0+\Omega\to0^{+} the two long sideband roots k~u\widetilde{k}_{u} and k~∗\widetilde{k}_{*} tend to zero and their contributions vanish, while the remaining roots of P1P_{1} and P2P_{2} merge onto those of P0(k~)=k~3−2V~2k~2+k~P_{0}(\widetilde{k}) = \widetilde{k}^{3} - 2\widetilde{V}^{2}\widetilde{k}^{2} + \widetilde{k}. The formula (3.3) then reduces to ⟨R~⟩=12∑P0(k~n)=0, k~n>0k~n2∣P0′(k~n)∣\langle\widetilde{R}\rangle= \frac{1}{2}\sum_{P_{0}(\widetilde{k}_{n})=0,\ \widetilde{k}_{n}>0}\frac{\widetilde{k}_{n}^{2}}{\lvert P_{0}'(\widetilde{k}_{n})\rvert}, which is zero for V~<1\widetilde{V} < 1 (no real positive root of P0P_{0} and positive for V~>1\tilde{V} > 1. This is exactly one half of the steady RdG resistance (1): the factor 12\frac{1}{2} is the time-average ⟨cos⁡2Ωt⟩\langle\cos^2\Omega t\rangle of the modulation, the source amplitude pcos⁡Ωtp\cos\Omega t entering the quadratic resistance through its mean square. Up to this numerical factor, the modulated result therefore connects continuously to the RdG resistance above the threshold and to the wave-free, resistance-free state below it.

Below-threshold asymptotics. In the wave-resistance-free corner of the steady problem (V<cmin⁡V < c_{\min}, small Ω\Omega), the two long roots k~u\tilde{k}_u and k~∗\tilde{k}_* are nearly degenerate and their residues almost cancel; the leading non-zero contribution scales as

⟨R~⟩⟶Ω~→024V~Ω~5.(12)\langle\tilde{R}\rangle\underset{\tilde{\Omega}\to0}{\longrightarrow} 24\tilde{V}\tilde{\Omega}^{5}. \tag*{(12)}

At the opposite end the radiating wavenumbers grow without bound, k~n∼Ω~2/3\tilde{k}_n \sim\tilde{\Omega}^{2/3}; at such large k~\tilde{k} the capillary term k~3\tilde{k}^{3} dominates the dispersion relation over the gravity term k~\tilde{k}, so the radiated waves are short, pure capillary ripples. The order-Ω~0\tilde{\Omega}^{0} terms cancel, and

⟨R~⟩⟶Ω~→∞21/39V~Ω~−1/3,(13)\langle\tilde{R}\rangle\underset{\tilde{\Omega}\to\infty}{\longrightarrow} \frac{2^{1/3}}{9}\tilde{V}\tilde{\Omega}^{-1/3}, \tag*{(13)}

with the universal coefficient 21/3/9≈0.1402^{1/3}/9 \approx0.140. Since cmin⁡c_{\min} enters (13) only through the scales, the high-frequency limit retains no signature of the steady threshold: below- and above-threshold sources alike approach the same capillary decay (13), ⟨R⟩∝Ω~−1/3\langle R\rangle\propto\tilde{\Omega}^{-1/3}, differing only through the prefactor ∝V~\propto\tilde{V}. Below threshold this raises ⟨R⟩\langle R\rangle from zero; above threshold it instead drives ⟨R⟩\langle R\rangle well below the steady RdG value, so that rapid enough modulation suppresses the wave drag of an above-threshold source — the exact opposite of the radiation it induces below threshold. Finally, for V→∞V \to\infty at fixed Ω\Omega the radiation is carried by short capillary ripples (k~n∼2V~2\tilde{k}_n \sim2\tilde{V}^{2}), and the resistance flattens onto a plateau set by surface tension alone, ⟨R~⟩→12+Ω~4V~3+316V~4\langle\tilde{R}\rangle\to\frac{1}{2}+\frac{\tilde{\Omega}}{4\tilde{V}^{3}}+\frac{3}{16\tilde{V}^{4}}. The leading term 12\frac{1}{2} — half the steady RdG value p2/γp^{2}/\gamma — is once more the ⟨cos⁡2Ωt⟩\langle\cos^{2}\Omega t\rangle factor, but that factor does not survive at higher order: the V~−4\tilde{V}^{-4} coefficient is 3/163/16, not the 1/41/4 that factor would give. The expansion is therefore non-analytic at Ω=0\Omega=0, and the limits V→∞V \to\infty and Ω→0\Omega\to0 do not commute.

Because each radiating mode contributes to ⟨R⟩\langle R\rangle in proportion to k~n2\tilde{k}_n^{2} (equation (11)), the resistance is dominated by the short, capillary-scale waves throughout most of the (V~,Ω~)(\tilde{V},\tilde{\Omega}) plane — everywhere, that is, except the below-threshold corner where the radiated waves are long. As a result the two single-physics reductions — approximating the dispersion relation by capillarity alone or by gravity alone — are far from equally accurate. To compare the two, we keep the full physical system (gravity and surface tension), so that cmin⁡c_{\min} and ωc\omega_c remain well defined and set the scales of Figure 4, and merely simplify the dispersion relation used to compute the radiated field. Retaining only the capillary term (ω2=γk3/ρ\omega^2=\gamma k^3/\rho) reproduces ⟨R⟩\langle R\rangle to within a few per cent wherever the radiating waves are short, at high speed (V~≳2\tilde{V}\gtrsim2) or high frequency; but it has no threshold, and below cmin⁡c_{\min} at small Ω~\tilde{\Omega} it misses the near-cancellation of residues, so that by the analysis of (12) it overestimates ⟨R⟩\langle R\rangle by orders of magnitude. Discarding surface tension instead, that is using the pure-gravity dispersion ω2=gk\omega^2=gk, misrepresents ⟨R⟩\langle R\rangle by more than 10% over almost the entire (V~,Ω~)(\tilde{V},\tilde{\Omega}) plane (Figure 4): although γ\gamma is dynamically negligible for the long gravity waves, it controls the short, dominant capillary-scale waves and therefore ⟨R⟩\langle R\rangle itself almost everywhere.

Figure 4. Failure of the pure-gravity approximation for the mean wave resistance ⟨R⟩\langle R\rangle of a line source, obtained by discarding surface tension (dispersion ω2=gk\omega^2 = gk). Contours mark the relative error reaching 10% (solid), 20% (dashed) and 50% (dotted): the approximation is accurate to within 10% only along the thin band where its single gravity branch happens to mimic the exact response, while the error exceeds 50% over most of the (V~,Ω~)(\widetilde{V},\widetilde{\Omega}) plane. Neglecting γ\gamma thus misrepresents ⟨R⟩\langle R\rangle almost everywhere.

Conclusion

We have shown that temporal modulation qualitatively changes the wave resistance of a source moving along a capillary–gravity interface. The cosine modulation shifts the forcing to the sideband pair kV±ΩkV \pm\Omega, and the resulting small roots k~u\tilde{k}_u of P1P_1 and k~∗\tilde{k}_* of P2P_2 guarantee propagating modes — and, by the inequality of § 3, a strictly positive mean wave resistance — at every speed V>0V > 0 once Ω≠0\Omega\ne0. The steady radiation threshold V=cmin⁡V = c_{\min} does not survive modulation: a slow oscillation suffices to make a marginally below-threshold source radiate, with a mean wave resistance that develops integrable resonant peaks where the radiation transitions are crossed.

Physically, the below-threshold radiation takes the form of very long-wavelength modes, k~u∼k~∗∼Ω~2\tilde{k}_u \sim\tilde{k}_* \sim\tilde{\Omega}^{2} as Ω~→0\tilde{\Omega} \to0, superposed on the localised deformation of the interface near the source. This tail leaves a striking signature in the net displaced area. For a steady source the displaced volume is finite, ∫−∞∞ζ dx=−p/(ρg)\int_{-\infty}^{\infty} \zeta\,\mathrm{d}x = -p/(\rho g), a long-wavelength hydrostatic balance [14, 10]. Under modulation this static displacement gives way to a purely oscillatory one, whose displaced area vanishes at every instant: ∫−∞∞ζ dx=0\int_{-\infty}^{\infty} \zeta\,\mathrm{d}x = 0 for every Ω≠0\Omega\ne0, a discontinuous change at Ω=0\Omega= 0. The resistance, by contrast, is recovered continuously as Ω→0\Omega\to0, reducing to the steady RdGR_{\mathrm{dG}} result (1.1) up to the time-average ⟨cos⁡2Ωt⟩=12\langle\cos^2 \Omega t\rangle= \frac{1}{2}. In each of the two opposite single-scale limits the response reduces to a single critical resonance: the surface-tension-free limit reproduces, within linear theory, the critical resonance ΩV/g=14\Omega V/g = \frac{1}{4} of the classical translating–pulsating gravity-wave source [9, 4], while in the gravity-free limit (g→0g \to0) the present theory predicts its capillary counterpart, a single critical condition Ωγ/(ρV3)=4/27\Omega\gamma/(\rho V^3) = 4/27 (equivalently Ω=4ρV3/(27γ)\Omega= 4\rho V^3/(27\gamma), with resonant wavenumber kd=4ρV2/(9γ)k_d = 4\rho V^2/(9\gamma)), the capillary scaling Ω∝V3\Omega\propto V^3 contrasting with the Ω∝V−1\Omega\propto V^{-1} scaling of the gravity resonance.

The results are directly relevant to interfacial objects whose forcing, rather than being steady, is periodically modulated as they translate, and they show how the wave resistance is then to be computed. Two natural extensions suggest themselves. The first replaces the line source by a source of finite width, which enters only through its Fourier transform p^e(k)\hat{p}_{\mathrm{e}}(k) [cf. (3)] and reshapes the radiated spectrum. The second carries the time-dependent analysis over to a localised disturbance on the full two-dimensional interface, generalising the steady result of Raphael & de Gennes [14], Eq. (2.36). The present analysis is linearised throughout (small-amplitude waves): while Dagan & Miloh [4] also addressed the nonlinear regime for pure gravity waves, the nonlinear capillary–gravity [5] problem remains open. Finally, the fluid has been taken inviscid; viscosity is known to keep the steady wave resistance bounded as V→cmin⁡V \to c_{\min} [15], and assessing how it tempers the resonant divergences of the modulated problem is a natural further direction. Experimentally, such a forcing could be realised by a vertically oscillating microprobe or AFM tip in tapping mode—whose lateral force directly measures ⟨R⟩\langle R\rangle—or, contactlessly, by an amplitude-modulated focused acoustic radiation pressure.

Acknowledgements. HD is grateful to the Gulliver laboratory, ESPCI Paris, for its hospitality.

Funding. HD acknowledges support from the Israel Science Foundation (Grant No. 1611/24).

Declaration of interests. The authors report no conflict of interest.

Data availability statement. The scripts supporting this study are available from the corresponding authors on reasonable request.

References

  1. [1]Arutkin, M., Reuveni, S. & Raphael, E. 2026 Wave resistance for stochastic motion at interfaces. Preprint, arXiv:2606.08732.arxiv.org/abs/2606.08732
  2. [2]Chepelianskii, A. D., Chevy, F. & Raphael, E. 2008 Capillary-gravity waves generated by a slow moving object. Phys. Rev. Lett. 100, 074504.pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/18352559
  3. [3]Closa, F., Chepelianskii, A. D. & Raphael, E. 2010 Capillary-gravity waves generated by a sudden object motion. Phys. Fluids 22, 052107.DOI
  4. [4]Dagan, G. & Miloh, T. 1982 Free-surface flow past oscillating singularities at resonant frequency. J. Fluid Mech. 120, 139–154.DOI
  5. [5]Dias, F. & Kharif, C. 1999 Nonlinear gravity and capillary-gravity waves. Annu. Rev. Fluid Mech. 31, 301–346.
  6. [6]Dode, A., Carmigniani, R., Cohen, C., Clanet, C. & Bocquet, L. 2022 Wave drag during an unsteady motion. J. Fluid Mech. 951, A15.DOI
  7. [7]Froude, W. 1874 Experiments with H.M.S. Greyhound. Trans. Inst. Nav. Archit. 15, 36–73.
  8. [8]Havelock, T. H. 1918 Wave resistance: some cases of three-dimensional fluid motion. Proc. R. Soc. Lond. A 95, 354–365.DOI
  9. [9]Kaplan, P. 1957 The waves generated by the forward motion of oscillatory pressure distributions. In Proc. 5th Midwestern Conf. Fluid Mech., pp. 316–329.
  10. [10]Lamb, H. 1932 Hydrodynamics, 6th edn. Cambridge University Press. (Reprinted 1993.)
  11. [11]Lighthill, M. J. 1967 On waves generated in dispersive systems by travelling forcing effects, with applications to the dynamics of rotating fluids. J. Fluid Mech. 27, 725–752.
  12. [12]Lighthill, M. J. 1978 Waves in Fluids. Cambridge University Press.
  13. [13]Pramanik, A. K. 1980 Capillary-gravity waves produced by a moving pressure distribution. Z. Angew. Math. Phys. 31, 174.DOI
  14. [14]Raphael, E. & de Gennes, P.-G. 1996 Capillary gravity waves caused by a moving disturbance: wave resistance. Phys. Rev. E 53, 3448–3455.pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/9964655
  15. [15]Richard, D. & Raphael, E. 1999 Capillary-gravity waves: the effect of viscosity on the wave resistance. Europhys. Lett. 49, 53–58.DOI
  16. [16]Roccuzzo, M. & Herault, J. 2026 Transitions in unsteady capillary-gravity wakes of surface swimmers. Phys. Rev. Fluids 11, 044805.DOI

Paper details

vlnc:W_vcjbxg2p
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents