betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Detection of proton tracks with LiF Fluorescent Nuclear Track Detectors

Abstract

Fluorescent nuclear track detectors based on LiF crystals were successfully applied for detection of proton induced tracks. Irradiations were performed with protons with energy ranging from 1 MeV up to about 56 MeV and for all proton energies the fluorescent tracks were observed. The tracks are not continuous, but consist of a series of bright spots. The gaps between spots tend to narrow with decreasing proton energy (increasing ionization density). For the highest of the studied energies, the spots are scattered so sparsely, that it is not possible to link spots belonging to one track. The intensity (brightness) of the fluorescent tracks increases with the increasing LET and agrees well with the trend established earlier for various heavier ions.

Introduction

Fluorescent detection of nuclear tracks is a radiation measuring method originally developed by Akselrod and co-workers using Al2O3\mathrm{Al}_2\mathrm{O}_3:C,Mg single crystals [1, 5] and successfully introduced into dosimetric practice in the various fields of application [2, 3, 4, 12, 14, 15]. In the last few years another material was found to be suitable for application as a fluorescent nuclear track detector (FNTD): undoped lithium fluoride crystals [8, 10]. The physical mechanism enabling fluorescent imaging of particle tracks in LiF is based on the creation by ionizing particles F2\mathrm{F}_2 color centers in the crystal lattice. These centers, when excited with the blue light (wavelength around 445 nm), emit photoluminescence in the red spectral range (peaked at 670 nm). With the fluorescent microscope, using high magnification and a sensitive digital camera, it is possible to image the radiation tracks with a resolution below 1 micrometer. Track intensity, which is the intensity of the fluorescent light emitted from a track, depends on the ionization density, i.e., on the amount of the locally deposited energy. LiF crystals have been successfully used to image tracks of various ions, ranging from helium to iron [9]. However, in the case of protons, for high-energy beams, like those used in radiotherapy, it has been so far difficult to observe the single tracks of primary protons due to the low ionization density of these particles. Preliminary analysis of proton-irradiated LiF crystals revealed the presence of some fluorescent tracks but only in the form of very scarcely distributed spots. The number of these spots was by more than an order of magnitude lower than the number of protons impinging on the crystal. Their fluorescence intensity was very low – at a similar level as the intensity of the tracks produced by gamma radiation. It was therefore difficult to decide whether the observed tracks were produced by primary protons, by protons with degraded energy, or by some secondary particles. On the other hand, it was known that low-energy protons may produce quite distinct tracks, as it happens in the LiF crystals irradiated with thermal neutrons, where the tracks produced by 2.73 MeV 3H{}^{3}\mathrm{H} nuclei (products of the nuclear reaction of neutrons with 6Li{}^{6}\mathrm{Li} nuclei) are well visible [11]. Therefore, the goal of the present work was to study more closely the capability of LiF FNTDs for detecting protons of both low and high energy. The subject is relevant not only to measurements of radiotherapy proton beams, but also to dosimetry of cosmic radiation, where protons are abundant. LiF FNTDs were recently flown to the lunar orbit in the frame of the Artemis mission (MARE experiment) [6] and are currently also employed in the ongoing DOSIS-3D project on board the International Space Station [7].

Experimental details

Samples

Lithium fluoride single crystals were grown with the Czochralski method at the IFJ PAN. The grown bulk crystals were then cut with diamond saws into square plate samples of a typical size of about 4×4×14 \times4 \times1 mm and polished. Next, the crystal samples were heated at a temperature close to LiF melting point (820-830 °C) for 10 minutes, which improved the quality of the crystal surface by removing small scratches caused by polishing.

Proton irradiations

The main proton irradiations were performed at the IFJ PAN in Kraków, exploiting the proton beam from AIC-144 cyclotron, with the initial energy of 60 MeV [17]. To obtain proton beams with lower energy, a PMMA range-shifter was applied. The dose was kept constant at the level of 20 mGy (in terms of absorbed dose in water, as measured with an ionization chamber), which corresponds to a proton fluence ranging from about 1.9×1061.9 \times10^{6} cm−2^{-2} to 1.1×1071.1 \times10^{7} cm−2^{-2}, depending on proton energy. Positions of the detectors along the proton Bragg curve are illustrated in Figure 1.

Illustration of positions of LiF FNTDs during irradiations at different depths along the proton Bragg curve

Figure 1. Illustration of positions of LiF FNTDs during irradiations at different depths along the proton Bragg curve (proton dose rate measured with an ionisation chamber).

Additionally, the experiments were supplemented by irradiations with monoenergetic low-energy protons at the Laboratory of Ion Beam Interactions of Ruđer Bošković Institute in Zagreb using a 6 MV Tandem Van de Graaff (VdG) accelerator. Irradiations were performed at the nuclear microbeam end-station, where ion beam size and current can be precisely controlled [13]. The energy of protons ranged between 1 MeV and 6 MeV (±0.2%) and the fluence was kept below 10510^{5} cm−2^{-2}. The details of the used proton beams are given in Table 1. The main experiments consisted of exposures with proton beams directed perpendicularly to the crystal surface. Additionally, some crystals were irradiated with proton beams directed in parallel to the surface. In the case of the Van de Graaff irradiations, for technical reasons the smallest achievable angle to the surface was 20°.

Depth in water [mm]Energy [MeV]Fluence [cm−2^{-2}]LET (LiF) [keV/μm]
AIC-144 cyclotron1.4756.31.06×1071.06 \times10^{7}2.42
AIC-144 cyclotron3.3754.11.02×1071.02 \times10^{7}2.50
AIC-144 cyclotron14.8238.71.09×1071.09 \times10^{7}3.26
AIC-144 cyclotron24.3620.51.09×1071.09 \times10^{7}5.44
AIC-144 cyclotron25.5217.21.11×1071.11 \times10^{7}6.26
AIC-144 cyclotron26.2814.71.09×1071.09 \times10^{7}7.11
AIC-144 cyclotron26.6513.41.06×1071.06 \times10^{7}7.68
AIC-144 cyclotron27.4210.11.04×1071.04 \times10^{7}9.62
AIC-144 cyclotron27.887.91.06×1071.06 \times10^{7}11.64
AIC-144 cyclotron28.186.41.07×1071.07 \times10^{7}13.73
Van de Graaff-66.67×1046.67 \times10^{4}14.49
Van de Graaff-56.25×1046.25 \times10^{4}16.70
Van de Graaff-36.25×1046.25 \times10^{4}25.52
Van de Graaff-27.14×1047.14 \times10^{4}34.40
Van de Graaff-17.14×1047.14 \times10^{4}53.65

Table 1. The details of the proton beams exploited for irradiation of FNTDs. In the case of AIC-144 the given energy values represent mean energy calculated with the SRIM program [18] for a given depth in water. The depth in water was calculated from the thickness of the PMMA using an experimentally determined water equivalent ratio (WER) of 1.165. LET in LiF was calculated with the SRIM for the mean proton energies.

Microscopic observations

Microscopic fluorescent images of LiF crystals were acquired using a Nikon Eclipse fluorescence widefield microscope with a DS-Qi2 camera. For excitation, the pE-100 illumination system with 440 nm LEDs was used. A band-pass filter ET445/30 was used for excitation light, while a long-pass ET570lp for emission. The observations were conducted with a 100× TU Plan ELWD (NA 0.80) objective lens. One pixel of the obtained images corresponded to about 0.07 µm. Each measurement consisted of registering a stack of image frames (slices) acquired in 1 µm steps at different depths into a crystal, starting just below the crystal surface. The 1 µm distance approximately corresponds to the vertical resolution of the used optical setup. The acquisition time of a single frame varied between 20 and 40 seconds.

Image analysis

Image processing and analysis were performed with the ImageJ/Fiji software [16]. The background was numerically subtracted using the self-developed Fiji plugin. The tracks were then analyzed using the “Analyze Particles” command of Fiji, which provided data on the number of tracks (spots) and the intensity of each of them. The track intensity was defined as the maximum intensity within a bright spot divided by the time of the image acquisition. In these analyses, only tracks from the first slice were included (to avoid multiple counting tracks of the same particle), and the tracks with an area lower than 6 pixels were disregarded (to avoid counting artifacts). For qualitative analysis, the maximum intensity projections (MIP) were generated, which are a kind of two-dimensional representation of three-dimensional images that enable a fast interpretation of the track geometry. In a MIP for each pixel position in a stack of images, the brightest pixel among all layers of the stack is taken. The MIP images are schematically illustrated in Figure 2. A circular shape of a track in the MIP means that a particle was directed perpendicularly to the crystal surface, while an elongated shape corresponds to a particle directed under an angle. Curved shapes of tracks may be also observed, indicating changes of a particle trajectory due to interactions with nuclei.

Schematic illustration of maximum intensity projections of fluorescent tracks

Figure 2. Schematic illustration of the maximum intensity projections (MIP) of fluorescent tracks. a) – a particle directed under an angle to the crystal surface, b) – a particle directed perpendicularly to the crystal surface.

Results and discussion

Figure 3 illustrates examples of fluorescent tracks produced by the protons directed nearly parallel to the crystal surface. It should be noticed that tracks are not continuous, but consist of a series of bright spots. The gaps between spots tend to narrow with decreasing proton energy (increasing ionization density). This is a result of fluctuation of fluorescence intensity along a track, which is a typical feature of fluorescent tracks and was earlier observed for ion tracks. Figure 4 illustrates this effect for a track of an iron ion (the result of the earlier experiments at the HIMAC accelerator, Chiba, Japan ([9]). Since the ionization density for this particle is high (LETLiF>400 keV/μm\mathrm{LET}_{\mathrm{LiF}}>400\ \mathrm{keV}/\mu\mathrm{m}), track intensity much exceeds the background and as a result the track is continuous. However, if the signal-to-noise ratio was significantly lower (e.g. background intensity near 3000 units), only parts of the track with the peak intensity would exceed the background, which would produce a series of bright spots, exactly as occurs in the case of proton tracks. The physical mechanism of this effect seems to be related to the microscopic pattern of energy loss by a particle, but it is yet not fully understood and this subject is currently under study.

Examples of track images of low-energy protons, panels a) and b), with 20 µm scale bars

Figure 3. Examples of track images of low-energy protons (VdG irradiations) directed nearly parallel to the crystal surface: a) 2 MeV, b) 5 MeV (energy of protons entering the crystals). Images represent maximum intensity projections of stacks of 9 frames taken in 1 µm steps. The color scale arbitrary.

Fe ion track and graph of image intensity versus distance

Figure 4. Illustration of fluctuations of track intensity along a track of an iron ion (irradiations at HIMAC, Chiba) compared to the intensity of the background around the track. Inset: actual image of the track (background not subtracted).

In the case of higher energy protons (Figure 5), the distance between spots exceeds 10 μ\mum and it is hard to decide which spot belongs to which track.

Examples of tracks produced by the cyclotron proton beam directed nearly parallel to the crystal surface

Figure 5. Examples of tracks produced by the cyclotron proton beam directed nearly parallel to the crystal surface. Proton energy at entering crystal 56.3 MeV. The image was registered about 0.2-0.3 mm from the crystal edge (proton beam directed from the left side of the image).

Figure 6 shows examples of tracks measured for proton beams directed perpendicularly to the crystal surface, for the highest and the lowest of the studied energies. The left column of the figure (panels a and c) presents images registered in the first 1 µm slice, while the right column (panels b and d) presents the maximum intensity projections (MIP). The number of tracks visible in the MIP images is much higher than for a single slice. The reason for this effect lies in the observed distance between bright spots along a track. For protons with high energy, these gaps between spots may extend over several micrometers. Since the thickness of a single image layer is only 1 micrometer, it is obvious that in such a layer only part of the tracks may be visible.

Examples of track images after irradiation with the proton beam from the cyclotron

Figure 6. Examples of track images after irradiation with the proton beam from the cyclotron: a) 56.3 MeV, the first 1 µm slice of LiF, b) 56.3 MeV, maximum intensity projection (MIP) of 20 µm layer, c) 7.9 MeV, the first 1 µm slice of LiF, d) 7.9 MeV, maximum intensity projection of 20 µm layer. The scale is the same for all images. The color scale is arbitrary.

In the case of 56.3 MeV protons, the tracks visible in the MIP image remain nearly circular, as mostly they correspond to single spots. Oppositely, in the case of 7.9 MeV protons many tracks of elongated shape are visible, which are produced by the scattered protons or some secondary particles. In general, the brightness and the number of visible tracks increase with decreasing proton energy. The latter is mainly the effect of the mentioned decreasing length of the gaps between bright spots.

Figure 7 presents examples of tracks registered in the first 1 µm slice after irradiations with the proton beams from the Van de Graaff accelerator. Similarly, as for higher energies, the brightness and the number of tracks increase with decreasing energy.

Examples of track images registered in the first 1 µm slice of LiF after irradiations with the proton beams from the Van de Graaff accelerator

Figure 7. Examples of track images registered in the first 1 µm slice of LiF after irradiations with the proton beams from the Van de Graaff accelerator: a) 6 MeV, b) 1 MeV. The scale is the same for both images. The color scale is arbitrary.

The measured intensities of tracks for a given proton energy are not uniform but present quite a wide distribution of values. This is partly a result of the track properties (presence of gaps and possible nonuniformity of crystal properties) and partly by the actual distribution of proton energies in a beam. Figure 8 compares track intensity distributions for three chosen energies. With decreasing energy, the distribution broadens in the high-intensity directions, which is a result of energy straggling of protons during passage through a layer of PMMA absorber. In general, the intensity of tracks increases with decreasing proton energy, in accordance with the so far observed trend for various ionizing particles.

Distribution of track intensity for three proton energies

Figure 8. Distribution of track intensity for three proton energies.

This is presented quantitatively in Figure 9 and Figure 10. The agreement between intensities of the fluorescent tracks induced by protons and by heavier ions is quite good.

Figure 9. Track intensity for protons vs. LET in LiF. In the case of the cyclotron irradiations, the median values of the track intensity distributions were taken.

Figure 10. Dependence of track intensity on LET for protons and various ions. In the case of the cyclotron irradiations, the median values of the track intensity distributions were taken.

It was mentioned, when discussing images presented in Figure 6, that the number of registered tracks increases with decreasing energy of the proton beam. Quantitatively this effect is illustrated in Figure 11 and Figure 12, which show the ratio between the number of the observed tracks and the expected number of protons impinging on the same area. This ratio strongly increases with the decreasing energy (increasing LET). For the highest studied energy only about 5% of the expected number of protons is registered in a single fluorescent image. This number increases up to 40% near the Bragg peak. The growth of the counting efficiency is caused by the shortening of the gaps between bright spots along a track and possibly also by the general brightening of the tracks, which makes weaker spots visible.

Ratio between the number of the registered tracks in a single slice and the proton fluence versus proton energy

Figure 11. Ratio between the number of the registered tracks in a single slice and the proton fluence vs. proton energy.

Ratio between the number of the registered tracks in a single slice and the proton fluence versus LET in LiF

Figure 12. Ratio between the number of the registered tracks in a single slice and the proton fluence vs. LET in LiF.

Concluding remarks

In this work, we studied the performance of LiF FNTDs after irradiations with protons with energy ranging from 1 MeV up to about 56 MeV. For all proton energies, the fluorescent tracks in the form of bright spots were observed. The distance between these spots depends on the particle energy (ionization density). For the highest of the studied energies, the spots are scattered so sparsely, that it is not possible to link spots belonging to one track. With the decreasing proton energy, the distance between spots and in consequence the number of registered spots increases. However, even for the lowest energy the number of the registered tracks is lower than the estimated number of protons per the same area. The physical mechanism causing the tracks to be not continuous seems to be related to the microscopic pattern of energy loss by a particle, but it is still not clear and this subject is currently under study.

The intensity (brightness) of the fluorescent tracks increases with the increasing LET and fits well with the trend established earlier for various ions ranging from helium to iron.

Acknowledgments

This work was funded by the National Science Centre, Poland (grant No 2020/39/B/ST9/00459).

Irradiations with proton beams at Ruder Boskovic Institute were performed in the frame of the RADIATE Transnational Access project (22002881-ST-1.1-RADIATE).

References

  1. [1]Akselrod, G.M., Akselrod, M.S., Benton, E.R., Yasuda, N., 2006a. A novel Al₂O₃ fluorescent nuclear track detector for heavy charged particles and neutrons. Nucl. Instr. and Meth. B 247, 295-306.
  2. [2]Akselrod, M., Fomenko, V., Harrison, J., 2020. Latest advances in FNTD technology and instrumentation. Radiat. Meas. 133, 106302.DOI
  3. [3]Akselrod, M., Kouwenberg, J., 2018. Fluorescent nuclear track detectors – Review of past, present and future of the technology. Radiat. Meas. 117, 35-51.DOI
  4. [4]Akselrod, M.S., Sykora, G.J., 2011. Fluorescent nuclear track detector technology - A new way to do passive solid state dosimetry. Radiat. Measur. 46, 1671-1679.DOI
  5. [5]Akselrod, M.S., Yoder, R.C., Akselrod, G.M., 2006b. Confocal fluorescent imaging of tracks from heavy charged particles utilising new Al₂O₃:C,Mg crystals. Rad. Prot. Dosim. 119, 357-362.pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/16644943
  6. [6]Berger, T., 2023. NASA Artemis I mission and the MARE experiment, 26ᵗʰ Workshop on Radiation Monitoring for International Space Station (WRMISS), Rome, Italy. https://wrmiss.org/workshops/workshop/twenty­sixth/
  7. [7]Berger, T., Przybyla, B., Matthia, D., Reitz, G., Burmeister, S., Labrenz, J., Bilski, P., Horwacik, T., Twardak, A., Hajek, M., Fugger, M., Hofstätter, C., Sihver, L., Palfalvi, J.K., Szabo, J., Stradi, A., Ambrozova, I., Kubancak, J., Brabcova, K.P., Vanhavere, F., Cauwels, V., Van Hoey, O., Schoonjans, W., Parisi, A., Gaza, R., Semones, E., Yukihara, E.G., Benton, E.R., Doull, B.A., Uchihori, Y., Kodaira, S., Kitamura, H., Boehme, M., 2016. DOSIS & DOSIS 3D: long-term dose monitoring onboard the Columbus Laboratory of the International Space Station (ISS). J. Space Weather Space Clim. 6, A39.DOI
  8. [8]Bilski, P., Marczewska, B., 2017. Fluorescent detection of single tracks of alpha particles using lithium fluoride crystals. Nucl. Instr. and Meth. B 392, 41-45.DOI
  9. [9]Bilski, P., Marczewska, B., Gieszczyk, W., Kłosowski, M., Naruszewicz, M., Sankowska, M., Kodaira, S., 2019a. Fluorescent imaging of heavy charged particle tracks with LiF single crystals. Journal of Luminescence 213, 82-87.DOI
  10. [10]Bilski, P., Marczewska, B., Gieszczyk, W., Kłosowski, M., Naruszewicz, M., Zhydachevskyy, Y., Kodaira, S., 2019b. Luminescent properties of LiF crystals for fluorescent imaging of nuclear particles tracks. Optical Materials 90, 1-6.DOI
  11. [11]Bilski, P., Marczewska, B., Kłosowski, M., Gieszczyk, W., Naruszewicz, M., 2018. Detection of neutrons with LiF fluorescent nuclear track detectors. Radiat. Meas. 116, 35-39.DOI
  12. [12]Greilich, S., Osinga, J.M., Niklas, M., Lauer, F.M., Klimpki, G., Bestvater, F., Bartz, J.A., Akselrod, M.S., Jakel, O., 2013. Fluorescent nuclear track detectors as a tool for ion-beam therapy research. Radiat. Meas. 56, 267-272.
  13. [13]Jakšić, M., Bogdanović R., Bogovac, M., Desnica, V., Fazinić, S., Karlušić, M., Međunić, Z., Muto, H., Pastuović, Ž., Siketć, Z., Skukan, N., Tadić, T., 2007. New capabilities of the Zagreb ion microbeam system. Nucl. Instr. Meth. B 260, 114-118.DOI
  14. [14]Muñoz, I.D., Burigo, L.N., Gehrke, T., Brons, S., Greilich, S., Jäkel, O., 2023. Sensitivity correction of fluorescent nuclear track detectors using alpha particles: Determining LET spectra of light ions with enhanced accuracy. Medical Physics 50, 2385-2401.DOI
  15. [15]Sawakuchi, G.O., Ferreira, F.A., McFauden, C.H., Hallacy, T.M., Granville, D.A., Sahoo, N., Akselrod, M.S., 2016. Nanoscale measurements of proton tracks using fluorescent nuclear track detectors. Med. Phys. 43, 2485-2490.DOI
  16. [16]Schindelin, J., Arganda-Carreras, I., Frise, E., Kaynig, V., Longair, M., Pietzsch, T., Preibisch, S., Rueden, C., Saalfeld, S., Schmid, B., Tinevez, J.-Y., White, D.J., Hartenstein, V., Eliceiri, K., Tomancak, P., Cardona, A., 2012. Fiji: an open-source platform for biological-image analysis. Nature Methods 9, 676.DOI
  17. [17]Swakon, J., Olko, P., Adamczyk, D., Cywicka-Jakiel, T., Dabrowska, J., Dulny, B., Grzanka, L., Horwacik, T., Kajdrowicz, T., Michalec, B., Nowak, T., Ptaszkiewicz, M., Sowa, U., Stolarczyk, L., Waligorski, M.P.R., 2010. Facility for proton radiotherapy of eye cancer at IFJ PAN in Krakow. Radiat. Meas. 45, 1469-1471.DOI
  18. [18]Ziegler, J.F., Ziegler, M.D., Biersack, J.P., 2010. SRIM - The stopping and range of ions in matter. Nucl. Instr. and Meth. B 268, 1818-1823.

Paper details

vlnc:W_vmgk8x2q
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents