betaFeedback

WorksMathematics

Hyperbolic string vertices as geometric chains

Abstract

For 0<L<=2arcsinh(1), the hyperbolic string vertices of Costello and Zwiebach consist of the bordered hyperbolic surfaces with geodesic boundary of length L whose interior simple closed geodesics have length at least L. We show that the corresponding regions in moduli space are compact oriented orbifolds with corners whose boundaries are, including orientations and automorphism groups, the spaces of twisted sewings. Hence their generating chain satisfies the master equation without the bracket term exactly in a complex of geometric chains. The usual connected form cannot hold exactly for geometric chains; we determine its exact form, show that it holds modulo gluing and covering relations in a complex computing the homology of the moduli spaces, and that the vertex currents are the unique top-dimensional solution. Finally we compare with Costello's homotopical framework. In a strict model given by hyperbolic surfaces with marked boundary points, every solution of his master equation with his initial condition integrates exactly to the vertex currents, up to the sign (-1)^(3g-3+n); such solutions exist, are unique up to homotopy, and correspond to the hyperbolic vertices. Under a continuity assumption on the comparison map and granting the inputs of Costello's homology computation, the hyperbolic vertices represent his homotopy class of solutions, for a completed notion of homotopy.

Introduction

Fix L>0L > 0. For a compact oriented surface XX with a hyperbolic metric for which every boundary component is a geodesic of length LL, Costello and Zwiebach [10] consider the condition

ℓγ(X)≥Lfor every simple closed geodesic γ in the interior of X.(1)\ell_\gamma(X) \ge L \quad\text{for every simple closed geodesic } \gamma\text{ in the interior of } X. \tag*{(1)}

For L≤L∗:=2arcsinh⁡1L \le L_* := 2\operatorname{arcsinh} 1 they show that the sets Vg,n(L)\mathcal{V}_{g,n}(L) of such surfaces satisfy the geometric Batalin–Vilkovisky master equation of closed string field theory [39]: the boundary of Vg,n(L)V_{g,n}(L) is the union of the surfaces obtained by sewing two boundary components of a vertex of lower complexity, or one boundary component of each of two vertices, with an arbitrary twist. The same statement for LL below arcsinh⁡1\operatorname{arcsinh} 1, with a different proof, is due to Andersen, Borot and Orantin [1 Theorem on the quantum master equation in the section on string field theory], who attribute the idea that systolic sets satisfy the master equation to Costello. Both proofs compare sets of surfaces: they show that each boundary point arises by sewing and that sewing lands in the boundary. Orientations, multiplicities and the factors coming from automorphisms are not discussed, and the statement at the level of chains is asserted but not proved [1].

This paper gives the chain level statement in the geometric chains of [38]. These chains are generated by maps from compact oriented orbifolds with corners, so a compact region of a moduli space with a description of its boundary as an oriented orbifold defines a chain whose boundary can be computed exactly, without choosing a fundamental chain. The work consists in establishing the orbifold structure and in matching the boundary with the sewing spaces, including orientations and automorphism groups.

The model. We work in the finite dimensional moduli spaces of hyperbolic surfaces with geodesic boundary of length LL, as in Mirzakhani [27], not in the infinite dimensional spaces of surfaces with local coordinates of [10]. Sewing two boundary components requires the choice of an orientation reversing isometry between them; these choices form a circle, which plays the role of the twist. The boundary components are unlabelled and the surfaces may be disconnected, with unordered components; the reason is explained below.

Results. Let Nχ,n\mathcal{N}_{\chi,n} be the moduli space of possibly disconnected hyperbolic surfaces XX with nn unlabelled boundary components of length LL, all components of negative Euler characteristic and χ(X)=χ\chi(X)=\chi, regarded as an orbifold in the wide sense (the generic surface may have non-trivial automorphisms). Let Vχ,n⊆Nχ,n\mathcal{V}_{\chi,n}\subseteq\mathcal{N}_{\chi,n} be the region defined by (1) for all components.

Theorem A (Theorem 4.3). For 0<L≤L∗0<L\leq L_\ast, Vχ,n\mathcal{V}_{\chi,n} is a compact suborbifold with corners of Nχ,n\mathcal{N}_{\chi,n} of full dimension −3χ−n-3\chi-n. A point has depth kk if exactly kk interior simple closed geodesics have length LL; these are pairwise disjoint, and near the point Vχ,n\mathcal{V}_{\chi,n} is given in Fenchel–Nielsen coordinates by ℓγ1,…,ℓγk≥L\ell_{\gamma_1},\ldots,\ell_{\gamma_k}\geq L.

For punctured surfaces and small thresholds this is [23 Proposition 1.1], where it is called well known; we include the proof for bordered surfaces and the explicit range L≤L∗L\leq L_\ast, including the endpoint.

Theorem B (Theorem 5.3). For 0<L≤L∗0 < L \le L_*, there is an orientation reversing isomorphism Θ\Theta of compact orbifolds with corners in the wide sense from the space of sewings of Vχ,n+2V_{\chi,n+2} along an unordered pair of boundary components onto the boundary ∂Vχ,n\partial V_{\chi,n} in the sense of Joyce [21], through which the gluing morphism factors. Here Nχ,n\mathcal{N}_{\chi,n} is oriented by ∏idℓi∧dτi\prod_i d\ell_i \wedge d\tau_i in Fenchel–Nielsen coordinates with left twists, and the space of sewings is oriented by the base followed by the circle of gluing isometries, oriented by rotation.

In particular ∂Vχ,n=−Sχ,n\partial V_{\chi,n}=-S_{\chi,n} for the weighted fundamental chain Vχ,nV_{\chi,n} of Vχ,nV_{\chi,n} and the weighted chain Sχ,nS_{\chi,n} of the sewing space (Corollary 5.4). In Section 6 we define the sewing operator Δ\Delta on chains over orbifolds in the wide sense, show Δ2=0\Delta^2=0 and ∂Δ+Δ∂=0\partial\Delta+\Delta\partial=0, and deduce:

Theorem C (Theorem 6.8). The sum V\mathbb{V} of the fundamental chains of all Vχ,nV_{\chi,n} satisfies (∂+Δ)V=0(\partial+\Delta)\mathbb{V}=0 exactly, before passing to the quotient by degenerate chains, in the complex C\mathcal{C} of chains over the orbifolds Nχ,n\mathcal{N}_{\chi,n} in the wide sense. This auxiliary complex does not compute homology; in the complex of [38] the content of Theorem C is Corollary 5.4.

This is the exponential form (d+ℏΔ)eS/ℏ=0(d+\hbar\Delta)e^{S/\hbar}=0 of the master equation, the power of ℏ\hbar of a surface being −(χ+n)/2=∑i(gi−1)-(\chi+n)/2=\sum_i(g_i-1). Its connected part (Corollary 6.9) contains, whenever a separating curve cuts a surface into two pieces of the same type tt, the term Δ×[Sq⁡(Vt)]\Delta_\times[\operatorname{Sq}(V_t)], the sewing of an unordered pair of vertices of type tt. Integration turns this term into 12{Tt,Tt}\frac{1}{2}\{T_t,T_t\}, and the integration currents satisfy the usual form of the master equation (Corollary 6.13).

Rigidity (Theorem 7.2). Among compactly supported top dimensional currents on the moduli spaces of connected surfaces, the integration currents of the hyperbolic vertices are the only solution of the master equation with the given term on the pair of pants. This is an analogue, in a complex without room for homotopies, of Costello’s uniqueness up to homotopy [8].

Why disconnected surfaces. If a separating geodesic cuts a vertex into two pieces of the same topological type tt, the corresponding boundary face is the quotient of the space of sewings of Vt×VtV_t \times V_t by the involution exchanging the two pieces. In the usual connected form ∂V+ΔV+12{V,V}=0\partial V+\Delta V+\frac{1}{2}\{V,V\}=0 this face is represented by 12{Vt,Vt}\frac{1}{2}\{V_t,V_t\}, whose source is the space of sewings itself, with coefficient 12\frac{1}{2}. Geometric chains distinguish a chain [S,f∘q][S,f\circ q] from 2[S/Z2,f]2[S/\mathbb{Z}_2,f] when q:S→S/Z2q:S\to S/\mathbb{Z}_2 is a non-trivial double covering, so the connected form cannot hold exactly as soon as dim⁡Vt>0\dim V_t>0; this happens for instance for (g,n)=(2,0)(g,n)=(2,0), cut into two one-holed tori, and for (0,6)(0,6), cut into two fourholed spheres. With unordered components the two sides of the identity contain the same quotient, and the identity is exact (Corollary 6.9); the failure of the connected form with 12{Vt,Vt}\frac{1}{2}\{V_t,V_t\} is Proposition 6.10. With the gluing relation of [37] in place of DD, a covering of degree dd is equivalent to dd times its base, and after reduction the connected form holds in the quotient by gluing relations, a complex which still computes the homology of the moduli spaces (Theorem 6.11). With covering relations also in the direction of the kernels, the relations can be put on the auxiliary complex itself; then Δ\Delta descends, the quotient computes homology, V~≡eV−1\widetilde{V} \equiv eV^{-1}, and the connected vertices form a Maurer–Cartan element of a differential graded Lie algebra computing the homology of the moduli spaces (Theorem 8.4, Corollary 8.5).

Comparison with Costello (§ 9). Costello [8] defines string vertices homotopically, as the solution, unique up to homotopy, of the master equation in an algebra built from homotopy coinvariants of the circle actions on moduli spaces of surfaces with parametrized boundary; on the strict quotients, where our chains live, his sewing operator is not defined on singular chains [8 footnote 6]. As a model of his framework we use the moduli spaces N~\widetilde{\mathcal{N}} of hyperbolic surfaces with a marked point on each labelled boundary component, on which gluing is strictly associative, and we construct a residue map Φ\Phi, which takes the coefficient of t1−1⋯tn−1t_1^{-1}\cdots t_n^{-1} and projects to the moduli orbifolds, from Costello’s algebra for N~\widetilde{\mathcal{N}} to the complex of Theorem 8.4; multiplied by (−1)3g−3+n(-1)^{3g-3+n} on the moduli space of type (g,n)(g,n), it intertwines the BV operators and the brackets.

Theorem E (Theorem 9.15). Every solution of Costello’s master equation for N~\widetilde{\mathcal{N}} with his initial condition integrates exactly, up to the sign (−1)3g−3+n(-1)^{3g-3+n}, which depends on the orientation of Costello’s circle operator (Remark 9.12(2)), to the currents Tg,nT_{g,n} of the hyperbolic vertices. Such solutions exist and are unique up to homotopy, and, if the comparison map hh from N~\widetilde{\mathcal{N}} to Costello’s moduli spaces is continuous, they represent Costello’s class. Here and below homotopies and Costello’s class refer to the completed notion of homotopy of § 9.1, which may be coarser than Costello’s own if one does not use his sketched [8 Lemma 8.1.1]. The integration statement concerns Maurer–Cartan elements in the model N~\widetilde{\mathcal{N}}; for Costello’s solutions on his own moduli spaces there is no direct integration statement, since there is no map from them to NL\mathcal{N}_L compatible with gluing.

Theorem F (Theorem 9.17). The residue map induces a bijection of homotopy classes of Maurer–Cartan elements from Costello’s algebra for N~\widetilde{\mathcal{N}} to the algebra of Theorem 8.4. If hh is continuous, the comparison map to Costello’s moduli spaces also induces a bijection, under which Costello’s

class corresponds to the class of the hyperbolic vertices VhV_{\mathfrak{h}}.

The first statement of Theorem E uses only the rigidity theorem. The existence and uniqueness statement and Theorem F(1) use in addition a computation of the equivariant homology of N~\widetilde{N} by a Koszul resolution, the standard extension of the theorem of Jones and Hood–Jones [22, 18] to tori (Proposition 9.8), Theorem 8.4, Harer’s bound on the homology of mapping class groups [24] (Lemma 9.3), and an order-by-order argument (Lemma 9.2) in place of the lemma of Goldman–Millson type which Costello sketches. The transfer to Costello’s own model is conditional: it assumes that hh is continuous, Costello not having specified the topology of his moduli spaces, and it uses his computation of the homology of his algebra, which rests on [8 Proposition 5.1.1], whose proof is sketched, and on the rational homotopy equivalence of Mg(n)/(S1)nM_g(n)/(S^1)^n with Mg,nM_{g,n}. Neither result needs Φ\Phi to be a quasi-isomorphism: only the associated graded homology in degrees −1-1 and −2-2 matters, and it vanishes except for the class of the pair of pants (§ 9.5). To our knowledge no explicit geometric string vertex, of minimal area or hyperbolic, had been shown to represent Costello’s class before; the combinatorial string vertices of [6] represent it by construction, via the homotopy invariance of Maurer–Cartan moduli spaces (they use the framed version of the differential graded Lie algebra of [9]; § 9.6).

Relation to other work. Moosavian and Pius [28] use hyperbolic metrics with constant curvature to construct string vertices satisfying the master equation to first order. Fırat and Valdes-Meller [15] derive a Mirzakhani type recursion for the volumes of the hyperbolic vertices. Çaldăraru, Costello and Tu [6] describe the string vertices of [8] homologically and combinatorially, via ribbon graphs and singular chains, and Tu [32] expresses the fundamental classes of the Deligne–Mumford spaces through these vertices. Fırat constructs the local coordinates of the hyperbolic three-string vertex [Fi21]. The open-closed version is [7], see also [19 Fi24]; we treat only closed surfaces here.

Weighted geometric chains

We use the geometric chain complexes C∗g,morC_*^{g,\mathrm{mor}} and GC∗morGC_*^{\mathrm{mor}} of [38 Definition on liftable maps and orbifold morphisms], with rational coefficients. A class [Q,f^][Q,\hat{f}] consists of a compact oriented effective orbifold with corners QQ and an orbifold morphism f^:Q→X\hat{f}: Q \to X to an orbifold with corners XX, up to isomorphism; [−Q,f^]=−[Q,f^][-Q,\hat{f}]=-[Q,\hat{f}], a disconnected QQ is the sum of its components, and ∂[Q,f^]=∑F[F,f^∘iQ∣F]\partial[Q,\hat{f}]=\sum_F[F,\hat{f}\circ i_{Q|F}] over the components FF of the boundary ∂Q\partial Q. in the sense of Joyce, with the outward normal first. Orbifolds with corners in the wide sense are proper étale Lie groupoids with corners up to Morita equivalence, not necessarily effective [38]. For such an orbifold QQ the kernels of the local actions form a locally constant family of finite groups; on a connected component QaQ_a we write KaK_a for it, and QredQ_{\mathrm{red}} for the effective orbifold obtained by dividing the local groups by their kernels [38].

References

  1. [1][ABO] J. E. Andersen, G. Borot and N. Orantin. Geometric recursion. Preprint, arXiv:1711.04729.arxiv.org/abs/1711.04729
  2. [2][AP] C. Allday and V. Puppe. Cohomological Methods in Transformation Groups. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 1993.DOI
  3. [3][Br97] G. E. Bredon. Sheaf Theory. 2nd ed., Graduate Texts in Mathematics 170, Springer, New York, 1997.
  4. [4][Bro] K. S. Brown. Cohomology of Groups. Graduate Texts in Mathematics 87, Springer, New York, 1982.
  5. [5][Bu] P. Buser. Geometry and Spectra of Compact Riemann Surfaces. Progress in Mathematics 106, Birkhäuser, Boston, 1992.
  6. [6][CCT] A. Căldăraru, K. Costello and J. Tu. Categorical enumerative invariants, I: string vertices. Preprint, arXiv:2009.06673.
  7. [7][Cho] M. Cho. Open-closed hyperbolic string vertices. J. High Energy Phys. 2020, no. 5, Paper No. 046. arXiv:1912.00030.DOI
  8. [8][Cos05] K. Costello. The Gromov–Witten potential associated to a TCFT. Preprint, arXiv:math/0509264, 2005.DOI
  9. [9][Cos07] K. Costello. Topological conformal field theories and Calabi–Yau categories. Adv. Math. 210 (2007), 165–214. arXiv:math/0412149.DOI
  10. [10][CZ] K. Costello and B. Zwiebach. Hyperbolic string vertices. J. High Energy Phys. 2022, no. 2, Paper No. 002. arXiv:1909.00033.arxiv.org/abs/1909.00033
  11. [11][ES] C. J. Earle and A. Schatz. Teichmüller theory for surfaces with boundary. J. Differential Geom. 4 (1970), 169–185.DOI
  12. [12][FM] B. Farb and D. Margalit. A Primer on Mapping Class Groups. Princeton Mathematical Series 49, Princeton University Press, 2012.DOI
  13. [15][FVM] A. H. Fırat and N. Valdes-Meller. Topological recursion for hyperbolic string field theory. J. High Energy Phys. 2024, no. 11, Paper No. 005. arXiv:2409.02982.
  14. [16][GKM] M. Goresky, R. Kottwitz and R. MacPherson. Equivariant cohomology, Koszul duality, and the localization theorem. Invent. Math. 131 (1998), 25–83.DOI
  15. [17][Gr] A. Gramain. Le type d’homotopie du groupe des difféomorphismes d’une surface compacte. Ann. Sci. École Norm. Sup. (4) 6 (1973), 53–66.DOI
  16. [18]C. E. Hood and J. D. S. Jones. Some algebraic properties of cyclic homology groups. K-Theory 1 (1987), 361–384.DOI
  17. [19]E. Harrelson, A. A. Voronov and J. J. Zúñiga. Open-closed moduli spaces and related algebraic structures. Lett. Math. Phys. 94 (2010), 1–26. arXiv:0709.3874.arxiv.org/abs/0709.3874
  18. [20]W.-Y. Hsiang. Cohomology Theory of Topological Transformation Groups. Springer, Berlin, 1975.DOI
  19. [21]D. Joyce. On manifolds with corners. In: Advances in Geometric Analysis, Adv. Lect. Math. 21, International Press, 2012, pp. 225–258. arXiv:0910.3518.arxiv.org/abs/0910.3518
  20. [22]J. D. S. Jones. Cyclic homology and equivariant homology. Invent. Math. 87 (1987), 403–423.DOI
  21. [23]L. Ji and S. A. Wolpert. A cofinite universal space for proper actions for mapping class groups. In: In the Tradition of Ahlfors–Bers V, Contemp. Math. 510, Amer. Math. Soc., 2010, pp. 151–163. arXiv:0811.3871.arxiv.org/abs/0811.3871
  22. [24]J. L. Harer. The virtual cohomological dimension of the mapping class group of an orientable surface. Invent. Math. 84 (1986), 157–176.DOI
  23. [25]J.-L. Koszul. Crochet de Schouten–Nijenhuis et cohomologie. In: Élie Cartan et les mathématiques d’aujourd’hui, Astérisque, numéro hors série (1985), 257–271.
  24. [26]J.-L. Loday. Cyclic Homology. Grundlehren der mathematischen Wissenschaften 301, Springer, Berlin, 1992.
  25. [27]M. Mirzakhani. Simple geodesics and Weil–Petersson volumes of moduli spaces of bordered Riemann surfaces. Invent. Math. 167 (2007), 179–222.DOI
  26. [28]S. F. Moosavian and R. Pius. Hyperbolic geometry and closed bosonic string field theory. Part I. The string vertices via hyperbolic Riemann surfaces. J. High Energy Phys. 2019, no. 8, Paper No. 157. arXiv:1706.07366.arxiv.org/abs/1706.07366
  27. [29]M. Rothenberg and N. E. Steenrod. The cohomology of classifying spaces of H-spaces. Bull. Amer. Math. Soc. 71 (1965), 872–875.
  28. [30]I. Satake. On a generalization of the notion of manifold. Proc. Nat. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 42 (1956), 359–363.pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/16578464
  29. [31]A. Sen and B. Zwie­bach. String field theory: a review. In: Handbook of Quantum Gravity, Springer, Singapore, 2024, pp. 2385–2600. arXiv:2405.19421.arxiv.org/abs/2405.19421
  30. [32]J. Tu. Categorical enumerative invariants of the ground field. Selecta Math. (N.S.) 32 (2026), no. 4, Paper No. 73. arXiv:2103.01383.
  31. [33]S. Wolpert. The length spectra as moduli for compact Riemann surfaces. Ann. of Math. (2) 109 (1979), 323–351.DOI
  32. [34]S. Wolpert. The Fenchel–Nielsen deformation. Ann. of Math. (2) 115 (1982), 501–528.DOI
  33. [35]S. Wolpert. On the symplectic geometry of deformations of a hyperbolic surface. Ann. of Math. (2) 117 (1983), 207–234.DOI
  34. [37]H. Yu. Gluing geometric chains of manifolds and orbifolds with corners. Preprint, arXiv:2611.15551.arxiv.org/abs/2611.15551
  35. [38]H. Yu. Geometric chains of orbifolds with corners and singular homology. Preprint, arXiv:2610.28446v2.arxiv.org/abs/2610.28446
  36. [39]B. Zwiebach. Closed string field theory: quantum action and the Batalin–Vilkovisky master equation. Nucl. Phys. B 390 (1993), 33–152.DOI

Paper details

vlnc:W_vtvf9zuf
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Mathematics

AI

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents