Introduction
Nuclear beta transitions play a central role in our quest for understanding fundamental interactions. First of all, they give us a unique insight into strongly coupled Quantum Chromodynamics (QCD) phenomena. In addition, superallowed 0 + → 0 + 0^{+} \to0^{+} 0 + → 0 + transitions provide the best probe of the V u d V_{ud} V u d entry of the Cabibbo-Kobayashi-Maskawa (CKM) matrix of the Standard Model (SM), with additional information offered also by neutron and mirror decays [1 , 2 , 3 ] . Beta decays also allow for phenomenological determinations of the axial nucleon charge g A g_{\mathrm{A}} g A [3 , 4 , 5 ] . Beyond the SM (BSM), they probe dimension-6 operators representing leading deformations of the SM [1 , 3 , 6 ] . The current sensitivity is to operators suppressed by a scale of order 10 TeV [1 ] , above the direct reach of the Large Hadron Collider and comparable to its indirect reach via Drell-Yan production [7 , 8 , 9 , 10 ] .
The theoretical description of beta transitions has a long history starting almost a century ago [11 ] , with the main ingredients worked out by the end of the 1950s [12 , 13 , 14 ] . Quite naturally, the commonly used formalism and nomenclature contain elements that may seem opaque from today’s perspective. It may be advantageous to develop a language that more readily connects to recent advances in quantum field theory. This is the main purpose of this paper.
In this paper we propose a Lorentz-covariant on-shell framework for nuclear beta transitions. An important ingredient is the spinor-helicity variables for massive particles developed in Ref. [15 ] , which allow one to write down nuclear amplitudes that are manifestly covariant under the little group transformations. Our approach naturally accommodates frame independence, arbitrary nuclear spins, and a systematic recoil expansion, while treating standard and exotic currents on the same footing. Elements of this formalism have already been used in Refs. [16 , 17 ] , but this paper provides the first complete covariant treatment at subleading recoil order.
Applied to allowed beta decay, the covariant framework nicely combines with a systematic effective field theory (EFT) expansion of the nuclear currents in the recoil momentum. At leading and first recoil order, the amplitudes can be parametrized in terms of a finite set of transition-dependent Wilson coefficients multiplying Lorentz- and little-group-covariant structures. The standard (vector and axial) currents are incorporated together with exotic (scalar, pseudoscalar, and tensor) ones. Our approach bears some resemblance to that of Holstein in Ref. [18 ] , however the main difference is that not only momenta but also polarizations are treated fully covariantly. Namely, the dependence on the nuclear polarizations is encoded via spin vectors and higher-rank spin tensors, which are Lorentz- and little-group covariant functions of the massive spinors associated with the parent nucleus. This makes it possible to derive differential distributions without committing to the rest frame of the parent nucleus, and to recover the standard correlation coefficients only at the final stage.
For the standard currents, our Wilson coefficients can be simply mapped onto the traditional parametrization in the nuclear beta-decay literature [18 ] . A complete treatment of exotic currents through first recoil order is a relevant addition to the literature. Standard and exotic Wilson coefficients can also be related to the nucleon-level non-relativistic EFT (NR-EFT) approach of Ref. [16 ] . This connection provides a simple path to relate the Wilson coefficients to quark-level EFT parameters. More generally, the proposed organization in terms of on-shell covariant structures provides a natural starting point for incorporating higher recoil orders, radiative corrections, and forbidden transitions.
This paper is organized as follows. In § 2 we introduce the spinor-helicity formalism for massive and massless particles and explain how it can be employed to construct beta decay amplitudes. In § 3 we specialize to allowed beta transitions. We derive the most general form of the vector, axial, scalar, pseudoscalar, and tensor currents through first recoil order in our framework. In § 4 we use these amplitudes to obtain the fully differential decay distribution encoded in a set of form factors. Specializing to the rest frame of the parent nucleus, the latter are related to the familiar beta-decay correlation coefficients. § 5 is devoted to discussing the relation of our results to previous literature. In particular, we match our Wilson coefficients to parameters of traditional nuclear-, nucleon- and quark-level EFT descriptions of beta decay, before we conclude in § 6 . Some technical details are postponed to the appendices. In Section A we collect spinor identities used in the main text. In Section B we review the quark- and nucleon-level EFT descriptions. In Section C we collect the recoil-order contributions to form factors involving exotic currents. Finally, in Section D we detail how the formalism is adapted to pure Gamow-Teller transitions, where the parent and daughter spins differ by one unit.
Formalism
In this section we briefly review how to associate spinor variables to momenta of massless and massive particles. The spinor formalism is then used to construct tree-level beta decay amplitudes that are Lorentz invariant and transform appropriately under the little group. Spinor notation and conventions reviewed in this section largely follow Ref. [19 ] . Throughout we use the mostly minus metric signature, and the ϵ 0123 = 1 \epsilon_{0123}=1 ϵ 0123 = 1 sign convention for the Levi-Civita tensor.
First of all, one defines the Lorentz vectors of sigma matrices: σ μ = ( 1 , σ ) \sigma^\mu=(1,\boldsymbol{\sigma}) σ μ = ( 1 , σ ) , σ ˉ μ = ( 1 , − σ ) \bar{\sigma}^\mu=(1,-\boldsymbol{\sigma}) σ ˉ μ = ( 1 , − σ ) , with σ ≡ ( σ 1 , σ 2 , σ 3 ) \boldsymbol{\sigma}\equiv(\sigma^1,\sigma^2,\sigma^3) σ ≡ ( σ 1 , σ 2 , σ 3 ) denoting the usual triplet of Pauli matrices. A massless momentum p μ p^\mu p μ , p 2 = 0 p^2=0 p 2 = 0 , can be associated with a pair of two-component commuting spinors λ α \lambda_\alpha λ α , λ ~ α ˙ \tilde{\lambda}_{\dot{\alpha}} λ ~ α ˙ , α = 1 , 2 \alpha=1,2 α = 1 , 2 , via the relation p σ ≡ p μ [ σ μ ] α β ˙ = λ α λ ~ β ˙ p\sigma\equiv p^\mu[\sigma_\mu]_{\alpha\dot{\beta}}=\lambda_\alpha\tilde{\lambda}_{\dot{\beta}} p σ ≡ p μ [ σ μ ] α β ˙ = λ α λ ~ β ˙ .1 The spinor indices can be raised by an antisymmetric ϵ \epsilon ϵ tensor: λ α = ϵ α β λ β \lambda^\alpha=\epsilon^{\alpha\beta}\lambda_\beta λ α = ϵ α β λ β , λ ~ α ˙ = ϵ α ˙ β ˙ λ ~ β ˙ \tilde{\lambda}^{\dot{\alpha}}=\epsilon^{\dot{\alpha}\dot{\beta}}\tilde{\lambda}_{\dot{\beta}} λ ~ α ˙ = ϵ α ˙ β ˙ λ ~ β ˙ , where summation over repeated spinor indices is implicit. One can then show that [ p σ ˉ ] α ˙ β = λ ~ α ˙ λ β [p\bar{\sigma}]^{\dot{\alpha}\beta}=\tilde{\lambda}^{\dot{\alpha}}\lambda^\beta [ p σ ˉ ] α ˙ β = λ ~ α ˙ λ β , and ( λ λ ) ≡ λ α λ α = 0 (\lambda\lambda)\equiv\lambda^\alpha\lambda_\alpha=0 ( λλ ) ≡ λ α λ α = 0 , ( λ ~ λ ~ ) ≡ λ ~ α ˙ λ ~ α ˙ = 0 (\tilde{\lambda}\tilde{\lambda})\equiv\tilde{\lambda}_{\dot{\alpha}}\tilde{\lambda}^{\dot{\alpha}}=0 ( λ ~ λ ~ ) ≡ λ ~ α ˙ λ ~ α ˙ = 0 . The latter implies that the spinors satisfy the Weyl equations: 0 = p σ λ ~ ≡ [ p σ ] α β ˙ λ ~ β ˙ 0=p\sigma\tilde{\lambda}\equiv[p\sigma]_{\alpha\dot{\beta}}\tilde{\lambda}^{\dot{\beta}} 0 = p σ λ ~ ≡ [ p σ ] α β ˙ λ ~ β ˙ , and 0 = p σ ˉ λ ≡ [ p σ ˉ ] α ˙ β λ β 0=p\bar{\sigma}\lambda\equiv[p\bar{\sigma}]^{\dot{\alpha}\beta}\lambda_\beta 0 = p σ ˉ λ ≡ [ p σ ˉ ] α ˙ β λ β . The U ( 1 ) U(1) U ( 1 ) subgroup of the little group associated with p μ p^\mu p μ acts on the spinors as λ → t − 1 λ \lambda\to t^{-1}\lambda λ → t − 1 λ , λ ~ → t λ ~ \tilde{\lambda}\to t\tilde{\lambda} λ ~ → t λ ~ , as this transformation does not change the momentum p μ p^\mu p μ . We also define the antisymmetric combinations of sigma matrices: σ μ ν ≡ i 2 [ σ μ σ ˉ ν − σ ν σ ˉ μ ] \sigma^{\mu\nu}\equiv\frac{i}{2}[\sigma^\mu\bar{\sigma}^\nu-\sigma^\nu\bar{\sigma}^\mu] σ μν ≡ 2 i [ σ μ σ ˉ ν − σ ν σ ˉ μ ] , and σ ˉ μ ν ≡ i 2 [ σ ˉ μ σ ν − σ ˉ ν σ μ ] \bar{\sigma}^{\mu\nu}\equiv\frac{i}{2}[\bar{\sigma}^\mu\sigma^\nu-\bar{\sigma}^\nu\sigma^\mu] σ ˉ μν ≡ 2 i [ σ ˉ μ σ ν − σ ˉ ν σ μ ] .
On the other hand, a massive momentum, p 2 = m 2 p^2=m^2 p 2 = m 2 , can be associated with two pairs of two-component spinors χ α K \chi_\alpha^K χ α K and χ ~ α ˙ K \tilde{\chi}_{\dot{\alpha}}^K χ ~ α ˙ K , K = 1 , 2 K=1,2 K = 1 , 2 [15 ] . In addition to the spinor index α \alpha α , the spinors now have the S U ( 2 ) SU(2) S U ( 2 ) little group index K K K , so that little group acts as χ K → χ L Ω L K \chi^K\to\chi^L\Omega_L{}^K χ K → χ L Ω L K , χ ~ K → Ω K L χ ~ L \tilde{\chi}_K\to\Omega_K{}^L\tilde{\chi}_L χ ~ K → Ω K L χ ~ L . The little group indices can be raised and lowered in the analogous way as the spinor ones: χ K = ϵ K L χ L \chi_K=\epsilon_{KL}\chi^L χ K = ϵ K L χ L , χ ~ K = ϵ K L χ ~ L \tilde{\chi}^K=\epsilon^{KL}\tilde{\chi}_L χ ~ K = ϵ K L χ ~ L (spinor indices are implicit from now on). The defining relations connecting the massive spinors and momentum are p σ = χ K χ ~ K p\sigma=\chi^K\tilde{\chi}_K p σ = χ K χ ~ K , χ K χ L = χ ~ L χ ~ K = m δ L K \chi^K\chi_L=\tilde{\chi}_L\tilde{\chi}^K=m\delta^K_L χ K χ L = χ ~ L χ ~ K = m δ L K . From these, it follows that the massive spinors satisfy the Dirac equation, p σ ˉ χ K = m χ ~ K p\bar{\sigma}\chi^K=m\tilde{\chi}^K p σ ˉ χ K = m χ ~ K , p σ χ ~ K = m χ K p\sigma\tilde{\chi}_K=m\chi_K p σ χ ~ K = m χ K .
With the spinor formalism at hand, scattering amplitudes can be written in the form that makes transparent their little group covariance properties. Consider an amplitude M [ 1 X h 2 Y ( J , J 3 ) … ] \mathcal{M}[1_X^h2_Y^{(J,J_3)}\ldots] M [ 1 X h 2 Y ( J , J 3 ) … ] containing an incoming massless particle X X X with momentum p 1 μ p_1^\mu p 1 μ and helicity h h h , and an incoming massive particle Y Y Y with momentum p 2 μ p_2^\mu p 2 μ , spin J J J , and polarization J 3 J_3 J 3 along some chosen quantization axis. The amplitude can be constructed out of momenta p 1 p_1 p 1 , p 2 p_2 p 2 , … \ldots … and the corresponding spinors λ 1 \lambda_1 λ 1 , λ ~ 1 \tilde{\lambda}_1 λ ~ 1 , χ 2 K i \chi_2^{K_i} χ 2 K i or χ ~ 2 K i \tilde{\chi}_2^{K_i} χ ~ 2 K i , … \ldots … . The general rules of quantum field theory imply little group covariance of scattering amplitudes. That is to say, under the massless little group transformation λ 1 → t − 1 λ 1 \lambda_1\to t^{-1}\lambda_1 λ 1 → t − 1 λ 1 and λ ~ 1 → t λ ~ 1 \tilde{\lambda}_1\to t\tilde{\lambda}_1 λ ~ 1 → t λ ~ 1 , our amplitude must scale as M [ 1 X h 2 Y ( J , J 3 ) … ] → t 2 h M [ 1 X h 2 Y ( J , J 3 ) … ] \mathcal{M}[1_X^h2_Y^{(J,J_3)}\ldots]\to t^{2h}\mathcal{M}[1_X^h2_Y^{(J,J_3)}\ldots] M [ 1 X h 2 Y ( J , J 3 ) … ] → t 2 h M [ 1 X h 2 Y ( J , J 3 ) … ] . For massive particles, on the other hand, little group covariance can be realized if the amplitude is constructed out of exactly 2 J 2J 2 J spinors χ 2 K i \chi_2^{K_i} χ 2 K i or χ ~ 2 K i \widetilde{\chi}_2^{K_i} χ 2 K i , such that it is a fully symmetric tensor in the K 1 … K 2 J K_1 \ldots K_{2J} K 1 … K 2 J indices. Each independent configuration of these indices represents a possible value of polarization: J 3 = J J_3=J J 3 = J corresponds to ( K 1 , K 2 , … , K 2 J ) = ( 1 , 1 , … , 1 ) (K_1,K_2,\ldots,K_{2J})=(1,1,\ldots,1) ( K 1 , K 2 , … , K 2 J ) = ( 1 , 1 , … , 1 ) , J 3 = J − 1 J_3=J-1 J 3 = J − 1 corresponds up to normalization to ( 1 , 1 , … , 1 , 2 ) (1,1,\ldots,1,2) ( 1 , 1 , … , 1 , 2 ) or any permutation thereof, J 3 = J − 2 J_3=J-2 J 3 = J − 2 corresponds to ( 1 , 1 , … , 1 , 2 , 2 ) (1,1,\ldots,1,2,2) ( 1 , 1 , … , 1 , 2 , 2 ) , and so on. In other words, the amplitude can be represented as a symmetric tensor in the little group space: M [ 1 X h 2 2 Y h 2 K 1 … K 2 J … ] \mathcal{M}[1_X^{h_2}2_Y^{h_2}{}_{K_1\ldots K_{2J}}\ldots] M [ 1 X h 2 2 Y h 2 K 1 … K 2 J … ] . We will work with all-incoming amplitudes where the momentum conservation imposes ∑ i p i = 0 \sum_i p_i=0 ∑ i p i = 0 . Outgoing particles can be handled using crossing symmetry. For massless particles the crossing rule in our conventions is M [ A → ( − n ) X h B ] = s h M [ A X − h → B ] \mathcal{M}[A\to(-n)_X^h B]=s_h\mathcal{M}[A_X^{-h}\to B] M [ A → ( − n ) X h B ] = s h M [ A X − h → B ] , where X ˉ \bar{X} X ˉ denotes the antiparticle of X X X , while s h = 1 s_h=1 s h = 1 for bosons and s h = sgn ( h ) s_h=\operatorname{sgn}(h) s h = sgn ( h ) for fermions. For massive particles crossing rule is M [ A → ( − n ) Y O 1 … O 2 J B ] = ( − ) 2 J M [ A Y O 1 … O 2 J → B ] \mathcal{M}[A\to(-n)_Y^{O_1\ldots O_{2J}}B]=(-)^{2J}\mathcal{M}[A_Y^{O_1\ldots O_{2J}}\to B] M [ A → ( − n ) Y O 1 … O 2 J B ] = ( − ) 2 J M [ A Y O 1 … O 2 J → B ] . The lower position of the little group indices encodes polarization flips (together with possible additional minus signs) due to crossing.
We can now apply the formalism discussed above to beta decay. We consider the decay amplitudes
M β − = M [ 1 N 1 → ( − 2 ) N 2 ( − 3 ) e − ( − 4 ) ν ˉ ] , \mathcal{M}_{\beta^-}=\mathcal{M}[1_{\mathcal{N}_1}\to(-2)_{\mathcal{N}_2}(-3)_{e^-}(-4)_{\bar{\nu}}], M β − = M [ 1 N 1 → ( − 2 ) N 2 ( − 3 ) e − ( − 4 ) ν ˉ ] ,
M β + = M [ 1 N 1 → ( − 2 ) N 2 ( − 3 ) e + ( − 4 ) ν ] , (1) \mathcal{M}_{\beta^+}=\mathcal{M}[1_{\mathcal{N}_1}\to(-2)_{\mathcal{N}_2}(-3)_{e^+}(-4)_{\nu}], \tag*{(1)} M β + = M [ 1 N 1 → ( − 2 ) N 2 ( − 3 ) e + ( − 4 ) ν ] , (1)
for a parent nucleus N 1 \mathcal{N}_1 N 1 with spin J 1 J_1 J 1 undergoing β − \beta^- β − (β + \beta^+ β + ) decay into a daughter nucleus N 2 \mathcal{N}_2 N 2 with spin J 2 J_2 J 2 , an electron e − e^- e − (positron e + e^+ e + ), and an anti-neutrino ν ˉ \bar{\nu} ν ˉ (neutrino ν \nu ν ). In the all-incoming convention, all these particles are described by momentum labels p 1 p_1 p 1 , p 2 p_2 p 2 , p 3 p_3 p 3 , and p 4 p_4 p 4 , respectively, satisfying p 1 0 > 0 p_1^0>0 p 1 0 > 0 , p 2 , 3 , 4 0 < 0 p_{2,3,4}^0<0 p 2 , 3 , 4 0 < 0 (for outgoing particles, the momentum labels are the negatives of their physical momenta). Momentum conservation implies p 1 + p 2 + p 3 + p 4 = 0 p_1+p_2+p_3+p_4=0 p 1 + p 2 + p 3 + p 4 = 0 . We also define the momentum transfer q ≡ p 1 + p 2 q\equiv p_1+p_2 q ≡ p 1 + p 2 . We will consider M β ∓ \mathcal{M}_{\beta^\mp} M β ∓ in the limit of unbroken isospin, in which case p 1 2 = p 2 2 = m N 2 p_1^2=p_2^2=m_{\mathcal{N}}^2 p 1 2 = p 2 2 = m N 2 . Note that this implies 2 p 1 q = 2 p 2 q = q 2 2p_1q=2p_2q=q^2 2 p 1 q = 2 p 2 q = q 2 . Moreover, p 3 2 = m e 2 p_3^2=m_e^2 p 3 2 = m e 2 , while neutrinos are treated as massless, p 4 2 = 0 p_4^2=0 p 4 2 = 0 . The corresponding spinor variables are χ 1 I 1 \chi_1^{I_1} χ 1 I 1 , χ 2 O 2 \chi_2^{O_2} χ 2 O 2 , χ 3 K \chi_3^K χ 3 K , λ 4 \lambda_4 λ 4 , together with their twiddle counterparts. The spinors are related to the incoming momenta as
p 1 σ = χ 1 I χ ~ 1 I , p 2 σ = χ 2 O χ ~ 2 O , p 3 σ = χ 3 K χ ~ 3 K , p 4 σ = λ 4 λ ~ 4 , (2) p_1\sigma=\chi_1^{I}\widetilde{\chi}_{1I},\qquad p_2\sigma=\chi_2^{O}\widetilde{\chi}_{2O},\qquad p_3\sigma=\chi_3^K\widetilde{\chi}_{3K},\qquad p_4\sigma=\lambda_4\widetilde{\lambda}_4, \tag*{(2)} p 1 σ = χ 1 I χ 1 I , p 2 σ = χ 2 O χ 2 O , p 3 σ = χ 3 K χ 3 K , p 4 σ = λ 4 λ 4 , (2)
with an implicit sum over the little group indices of the massive spinors. In our conventions, the little group indices of the parent nucleus are up, and those of the daughter nucleus and the beta particle are down. Little group covariance dictates that M β ∓ \mathcal{M}_{\beta^\mp} M β ∓ must be a tensor with 2 J 1 + 2 J 2 + 1 2J_1+2J_2+1 2 J 1 + 2 J 2 + 1 massive little group indices, M β + = [ M β + ] I 1 … I 2 J 1 O 1 … O 2 J 2 K \mathcal{M}_{\beta^+}=[\mathcal{M}_{\beta^+}]^{I_1\ldots I_{2J_1}}{}_{O_1\ldots O_{2J_2}K} M β + = [ M β + ] I 1 … I 2 J 1 O 1 … O 2 J 2 K , which is fully symmetric separately in the I j I_j I j and O j O_j O j indices. Moreover, it must transform as M β − → t − 1 M β − \mathcal{M}_{\beta^-}\to t^{-1}\mathcal{M}_{\beta^-} M β − → t − 1 M β − , M β + → t M β + \mathcal{M}_{\beta^+}\to t\mathcal{M}_{\beta^+} M β + → t M β + , under the little group transformations associated with the massless momentum p 4 μ p_4^\mu p 4 μ .
At tree level, beta decay amplitudes can be factorized into a product of nuclear and leptonic currents.2
M β − = − { [ j V μ + j A μ ] ( χ 3 K σ μ ν λ 4 ) + [ j S + j P ] ( χ 3 K λ 4 ) + [ j T μ ν ] ( χ 3 K σ μ ν λ 4 ) } , \mathcal{M}_{\beta^-}=-\left\{\left[j_V^\mu+j_A^\mu\right](\chi_3^K\sigma_{\mu\nu}\lambda_4)+\left[j_S+j_P\right](\chi_3^K\lambda_4)+\left[j_T^{\mu\nu}\right](\chi_3^K\sigma_{\mu\nu}\lambda_4)\right\}, M β − = − { [ j V μ + j A μ ] ( χ 3 K σ μν λ 4 ) + [ j S + j P ] ( χ 3 K λ 4 ) + [ j T μν ] ( χ 3 K σ μν λ 4 ) } ,
M β + = [ j V + μ + j A + μ ] ( χ ~ 3 κ σ ˉ μ λ 4 ) ∗ + [ j S + + j P + ] ( χ 3 κ λ 4 ) ∗ + [ j T + μ ν ] ( χ 3 κ σ μ ν λ 4 ) ∗ (3) \mathcal{M}_{\beta+} = [j_{V+}^{\mu}+j_{A+}^{\mu}](\tilde{\chi}_3\kappa\bar{\sigma}_{\mu}\lambda_4)^*+[j_{S+}+j_{P+}](\chi_3\kappa\lambda_4)^*+[j_{T+}^{\mu\nu}](\chi_3\kappa\sigma_{\mu\nu}\lambda_4)^* \tag*{(3)} M β + = [ j V + μ + j A + μ ] ( χ ~ 3 κ σ ˉ μ λ 4 ) ∗ + [ j S + + j P + ] ( χ 3 κ λ 4 ) ∗ + [ j T + μν ] ( χ 3 κ σ μν λ 4 ) ∗ (3)
where j X ± j_{X\pm} j X ± represent the matrix elements of the vector, axial, scalar, pseudoscalar, and tensor current operators j ^ X ± ( x ) \hat{j}_{X\pm}(x) j ^ X ± ( x ) between the nuclear states:
j X ± = ⟨ N 2 ( − p 2 ) O 1 … O 2 J 2 ∣ j ^ X ± ( 0 ) ∣ N 1 ( p 1 ) I 1 … I 2 J 1 ⟩ . (4) j_{X\pm}=\langle\mathcal{N}_2(-p_2)_{O_1\ldots O_{2J_2}}|\hat{j}_{X\pm}(0)|\mathcal{N}_1(p_1)^{I_1\ldots I_{2J_1}}\rangle. \tag*{(4)} j X ± = ⟨ N 2 ( − p 2 ) O 1 … O 2 J 2 ∣ j ^ X ± ( 0 ) ∣ N 1 ( p 1 ) I 1 … I 2 J 1 ⟩ . (4)
The definition of the current operators in terms of the quark fields is given in Eq. (B.2). Implicitly, j X ± ≡ [ j X ± ] O 1 … O 2 J 2 I 1 … I 2 J 1 j_{X\pm}\equiv[j_{X\pm}]^{I_1\ldots I_{2J_1}}_{O_1\ldots O_{2J_2}} j X ± ≡ [ j X ± ] O 1 … O 2 J 2 I 1 … I 2 J 1 is a tensor with 2 J 1 + 2 J 2 2J_1+2J_2 2 J 1 + 2 J 2 little group indices, where I i ( O i ) I_i(O_i) I i ( O i ) encode the polarization J 3 J_3 J 3 of the parent (daughter) nucleus. In practice, these indices appear because j X ± j_{X\pm} j X ± are functions of the massive spinors. Implicitly, all 2 J 1 2J_1 2 J 1 spinors associated with the parent nucleus carry the upper little group index, χ 1 I i \chi_1^{I_i} χ 1 I i , while those associated with the daughter nucleus carry the lower index, χ 2 O i \chi_{2O_i} χ 2 O i . Both upper and lower indices are implicitly fully symmetrized, such that j X j_X j X is fully symmetric in both the upper and lower indices.3
The discrete parity symmetry P \mathcal{P} P acts on momenta as p i → p ~ i ≡ ( p i 0 , − p i ) p_i\to\tilde{p}_i\equiv(p_i^0,-\mathbf{p}_i) p i → p ~ i ≡ ( p i 0 , − p i ) . Parity invariance of QCD implies that currents should transform under P \mathcal{P} P as
j X ± μ 1 … μ n ( p 1 , p 2 ) = η 1 η 2 ( − ) X ( − ) μ 1 … ( − ) μ n j X ± μ 1 … μ n ( p ~ 1 , p ~ 2 ) , (5) j_{X\pm}^{\mu_1\ldots\mu_n}(p_1,p_2)=\eta_1\eta_2(-)^{X}(-)^{\mu_1}\ldots(-)^{\mu_n}j_{X\pm}^{\mu_1\ldots\mu_n}(\tilde{p}_1,\tilde{p}_2), \tag*{(5)} j X ± μ 1 … μ n ( p 1 , p 2 ) = η 1 η 2 ( − ) X ( − ) μ 1 … ( − ) μ n j X ± μ 1 … μ n ( p ~ 1 , p ~ 2 ) , (5)
where η i \eta_i η i are intrinsic parities of the nuclei, ( − ) μ (-)^\mu ( − ) μ is defined as ( − ) 0 ≡ 1 (-)^0\equiv1 ( − ) 0 ≡ 1 , ( − ) k ≡ − 1 (-)^k\equiv-1 ( − ) k ≡ − 1 , and moreover we define ( − ) V = ( − ) S = ( − ) T = 1 (-)^V=(-)^S=(-)^T=1 ( − ) V = ( − ) S = ( − ) T = 1 , ( − ) A = ( − ) P = − 1 (-)^A=(-)^P=-1 ( − ) A = ( − ) P = − 1 . In the next section we will build currents out of massive spinors, ensuring that the parity constraint in Eq. (5) is satisfied. The parity properties of spinor bilinears are collected in Table 1 .
Table 1. Transformations of spinor bilinears under parity P \mathcal{P} P acting as p i → p ~ i ≡ ( p i 0 , − p i ) p_i \to\tilde{p}_i \equiv(p_i^0,-p_i) p i → p ~ i ≡ ( p i 0 , − p i ) , and under P T \mathcal{PT} P T acting as P T F ( p 1 , p 2 ) ≡ F ( − p 1 , − p 2 ) ∗ \mathcal{PT}F(p_1,p_2) \equiv F(-p_1,-p_2)^* P T F ( p 1 , p 2 ) ≡ F ( − p 1 , − p 2 ) ∗ .
Furthermore, if time reversal symmetry T \mathcal{T} T is unbroken, the currents should transform under it (more precisely, under the product of P T \mathcal{P}\mathcal{T} P T ) as4
[ j X ± μ 1 … μ n ( p 1 , p 2 ) ] O 1 … O 2 J 2 I 1 … I 2 J 1 = − ( − ) X ( − ) 2 J 1 { [ j X ± μ 1 … μ n ( − p 1 , − p 2 ) ] I 1 … I 2 J 1 O 1 … O 2 J 2 } ∗ . (6) \left[j_{X\pm}^{\mu_1\ldots\mu_n}(p_1,p_2)\right]^{I_1\ldots I_{2J_1}}_{O_1\ldots O_{2J_2}}=-(-)^X(-)^{2J_1}\left\{\left[j_{X\pm}^{\mu_1\ldots\mu_n}(-p_1,-p_2)\right]^{O_1\ldots O_{2J_2}}_{I_1\ldots I_{2J_1}}\right\}^*. \tag*{(6)} [ j X ± μ 1 … μ n ( p 1 , p 2 ) ] O 1 … O 2 J 2 I 1 … I 2 J 1 = − ( − ) X ( − ) 2 J 1 { [ j X ± μ 1 … μ n ( − p 1 , − p 2 ) ] I 1 … I 2 J 1 O 1 … O 2 J 2 } ∗ . (6)
The P T \mathcal{P}\mathcal{T} P T transformation properties of spinor bilinears are collected in Table 1 .
Finally, strong dynamics in the isospin limit respects G G G -parity [20 ] , which is a combination of charge conjugation with an isospin rotation. For J 1 = J 2 J_1=J_2 J 1 = J 2 and transitions within an isospin multiplet, we can classify the currents into first- and second-class currents according to their G G G -parity transformation properties, with the latter expected to be suppressed [14 ] . In our notation, currents with the first-class G G G -parity assignment satisfy the constraint
j X ± μ 1 … μ n ( p 1 , p 2 ) = − ( − ) X ( − ) 2 J 1 j X ± μ 1 … μ n ( p 2 , p 1 ) , X = V , A , T , j_{X\pm}^{\mu_1\ldots\mu_n}(p_1,p_2)=-(-)^X(-)^{2J_1}j_{X\pm}^{\mu_1\ldots\mu_n}(p_2,p_1),\qquad X=V,A,T, j X ± μ 1 … μ n ( p 1 , p 2 ) = − ( − ) X ( − ) 2 J 1 j X ± μ 1 … μ n ( p 2 , p 1 ) , X = V , A , T ,
j X ± ( p 1 , p 2 ) = ( − ) X ( − ) 2 J 1 j X ± ( p 2 , p 1 ) , X = S , P . (7) j_{X\pm}(p_1,p_2)=(-)^X(-)^{2J_1}j_{X\pm}(p_2,p_1),\qquad X=S,P. \tag*{(7)} j X ± ( p 1 , p 2 ) = ( − ) X ( − ) 2 J 1 j X ± ( p 2 , p 1 ) , X = S , P . (7)
So far, the discussion has been valid for arbitrary spins of the parent and daughter nuclei. In the remainder of this paper we restrict our discussion to allowed beta decay [21 ] . The following section covers the case of mixed Fermi-Gamow-Teller (J 1 = J 2 > 0 J_1=J_2>0 J 1 = J 2 > 0 , η 1 = η 2 \eta_1=\eta_2 η 1 = η 2 ). The case of pure Fermi transitions (J 1 = J 2 = 0 J_1=J_2=0 J 1 = J 2 = 0 , η 1 = η 2 \eta_1=\eta_2 η 1 = η 2 ) can be trivially obtained from the mixed case, while pure Gamow-Teller transitions (J 1 = J 2 ± 1 J_1=J_2\pm1 J 1 = J 2 ± 1 , η 1 = η 2 \eta_1=\eta_2 η 1 = η 2 ) will be discussed in Section D.
Covariant approach to allowed beta decay
In this section we study the mixed Fermi-Gamow-Teller allowed transitions in the on-shell formalism laid out in the previous section. That is to say, we restrict the discussion to the specific case of equal nuclear spins and parities: J 1 = J 2 ≡ J J_1=J_2\equiv J J 1 = J 2 ≡ J , η 1 = η 2 \eta_1=\eta_2 η 1 = η 2 . We expand the currents in powers of the recoil momentum q = p 1 + p 2 q=p_1+p_2 q = p 1 + p 2 . In this power counting we also take into account that χ 2 χ 1 − χ ~ 2 χ ~ 1 ∼ q \chi_2\chi_1-\tilde{\chi}_2\tilde{\chi}_1\sim q χ 2 χ 1 − χ ~ 2 χ ~ 1 ∼ q , see Eq. (A.11). In this paper we truncate the expansion at linear order in q q q (subleading order in recoil), but it is straightforward to continue to higher orders if needed. Our immediate goal is to write down the most general form allowed by symmetries of the currents j X ± j_{X\pm} j X ± up to subleading order in recoil. These currents are then inserted in Eq. (3) to construct the beta decay amplitude.
For the standard (vector and axial) currents contributing to β − \beta^- β − decay the most general form up to subleading order in recoil and consistent with parity is the following.5
j V − μ = M F − { ( C V i [ χ 2 σ μ χ ~ 1 + χ ~ 2 σ ˉ μ χ 1 ] − i C M i − C V i 2 m N [ χ 2 σ μ ν χ 1 + χ ~ 2 σ ˉ μ ν χ ~ 1 ] q ν ) [ χ 2 χ 1 + χ ~ 2 χ ~ 1 ] 2 J − 1 ( 2 m N ) 2 J − 1 + ( C I S i + J − 1 2 3 J C Q i ) q μ [ χ 2 χ 1 + χ ~ 2 χ ~ 1 ] 2 J ( 2 m N ) 2 J + J − 1 2 J C Q i [ χ 2 σ μ χ ~ 1 − χ ~ 2 σ ˉ μ χ 1 ] [ χ 2 σ ν χ ~ 1 − χ ~ 2 σ ˉ ν χ 1 ] q ν [ χ 2 χ 1 + χ ~ 2 χ ~ 1 ] 2 J − 2 ( 2 m N ) 2 J } + O ( q 2 ) , j A − μ = M F − { ( C A i [ χ 2 σ μ χ ~ 1 − χ ~ 2 σ ˉ μ χ 1 ] + i C I T i 2 m N [ χ 2 σ μ ν χ 1 − χ ~ 2 σ ˉ μ ν χ ~ 1 ] q ν ) [ χ 2 χ 1 + χ ~ 2 χ ~ 1 ] 2 J − 1 ( 2 m N ) 2 J − 1 } + O ( q 2 ) . (8) \begin{aligned}
j^\mu_{V-}={}&M_F^- \Biggl\{\left(C_V^i\left[\chi_2\sigma^{\mu}\tilde{\chi}_1+\tilde{\chi}_2\bar{\sigma}^{\mu}\chi_1\right]-i\frac{C_M^i-C_V^i}{2m_N}\left[\chi_2\sigma^{\mu\nu}\chi_1+\tilde{\chi}_2\bar{\sigma}^{\mu\nu}\tilde{\chi}_1\right]q_\nu\right)\frac{\left[\chi_2\chi_1+\tilde{\chi}_2\tilde{\chi}_1\right]^{2J-1}}{(2m_N)^{2J-1}}\\
&+\left(C_{IS}^i+\frac{J-\frac{1}{2}}{3J}C_Q^i\right)q^\mu\frac{\left[\chi_2\chi_1+\tilde{\chi}_2\tilde{\chi}_1\right]^{2J}}{(2m_N)^{2J}}\\
&+\frac{J-\frac{1}{2}}{J}C_Q^i\left[\chi_2\sigma^\mu\tilde{\chi}_1-\tilde{\chi}_2\bar{\sigma}^\mu\chi_1\right]\left[\chi_2\sigma^\nu\tilde{\chi}_1-\tilde{\chi}_2\bar{\sigma}^\nu\chi_1\right]q_\nu\frac{\left[\chi_2\chi_1+\tilde{\chi}_2\tilde{\chi}_1\right]^{2J-2}}{(2m_N)^{2J}}\Biggr\}+O(q^2),\\
j^\mu_{A-}={}&M_F^- \Biggl\{\left(C_A^i\left[\chi_2\sigma^\mu\tilde{\chi}_1-\tilde{\chi}_2\bar{\sigma}^\mu\chi_1\right]+i\frac{C_{IT}^i}{2m_N}\left[\chi_2\sigma^{\mu\nu}\chi_1-\tilde{\chi}_2\bar{\sigma}^{\mu\nu}\tilde{\chi}_1\right]q_\nu\right)\frac{\left[\chi_2\chi_1+\tilde{\chi}_2\tilde{\chi}_1\right]^{2J-1}}{(2m_N)^{2J-1}}\Biggr\}+O(q^2). \tag*{(8)}
\end{aligned} j V − μ = j A − μ = M F − { ( C V i [ χ 2 σ μ χ ~ 1 + χ ~ 2 σ ˉ μ χ 1 ] − i 2 m N C M i − C V i [ χ 2 σ μν χ 1 + χ ~ 2 σ ˉ μν χ ~ 1 ] q ν ) ( 2 m N ) 2 J − 1 [ χ 2 χ 1 + χ ~ 2 χ ~ 1 ] 2 J − 1 + ( C I S i + 3 J J − 2 1 C Q i ) q μ ( 2 m N ) 2 J [ χ 2 χ 1 + χ ~ 2 χ ~ 1 ] 2 J + J J − 2 1 C Q i [ χ 2 σ μ χ ~ 1 − χ ~ 2 σ ˉ μ χ 1 ] [ χ 2 σ ν χ ~ 1 − χ ~ 2 σ ˉ ν χ 1 ] q ν ( 2 m N ) 2 J [ χ 2 χ 1 + χ ~ 2 χ ~ 1 ] 2 J − 2 } + O ( q 2 ) , M F − { ( C A i [ χ 2 σ μ χ ~ 1 − χ ~ 2 σ ˉ μ χ 1 ] + i 2 m N C I T i [ χ 2 σ μν χ 1 − χ ~ 2 σ ˉ μν χ ~ 1 ] q ν ) ( 2 m N ) 2 J − 1 [ χ 2 χ 1 + χ ~ 2 χ ~ 1 ] 2 J − 1 } + O ( q 2 ) . (8)
In writing the above, we assumed J ≥ 1 / 2 J\ge1/2 J ≥ 1/2 ; we comment on the J = 0 J=0 J = 0 case below Eq. (10) . Here, M F ∓ M_F^\mp M F ∓ is the Fermi matrix element which, for β ∓ \beta^\mp β ∓ transitions within the same isospin multiplet, is given by M F ∓ = δ T T ′ δ T 3 ′ ± 1 T 3 T ( T + 1 ) − T 3 ( T 3 ± 1 ) M_F^\mp=\delta^{T T'}\delta^{T_3}_{T'_3\pm1}\sqrt{T(T+1)-T_3(T_3\pm1)} M F ∓ = δ T T ′ δ T 3 ′ ± 1 T 3 T ( T + 1 ) − T 3 ( T 3 ± 1 ) , where ( T , T 3 ) (T,T_3) ( T , T 3 ) and ( T ′ , T 3 ′ ) (T',T'_3) ( T ′ , T 3 ′ ) are the isospin quantum numbers of the parent and daughter nuclei. At leading order in recoil only two Wilson coefficients arise: C V i C_V^i C V i (vector) and C A i C_A^i C A i (axial), while at subleading order we have in addition C M i C_M^i C M i (weak magnetism), C I S i C_{IS}^i C I S i (induced scalar), C I T i C_{IT}^i C I T i (induced tensor), and C Q i C_Q^i C Q i (quadrupole, which exists for J ≥ 1 J \ge1 J ≥ 1 only). The Wilson coefficients C X i C_X^i C X i are a priori transition-dependent, which we stress by including the label i i i . However, one can show that, in the limit of unbroken isospin, C V i C_V^i C V i is universal for all allowed transitions. Furthermore, for the so-called mirror transitions [22 , 23 , 24 ] , isospin conservation relates C M i C_M^i C M i to the magnetic moments μ N 1 \mu_{N_1} μ N 1 and μ N 2 \mu_{N_2} μ N 2 of the parent and daughter nuclei [25 , 26 ] : C M i C V i = A μ + − μ − μ N \frac{C_M^i}{C_V^i} = A\frac{\mu_+ - \mu_-}{\mu_N} C V i C M i = A μ N μ + − μ − , where A A A is the mass number for the transition, the nuclear magneton is defined as μ N = e 2 m p \mu_N = \frac{e}{2m_p} μ N = 2 m p e , and μ + \mu_+ μ + and μ − \mu_- μ − denote the magnetic moments of the nuclei with larger and smaller isospin quantum number T 3 T_3 T 3 , respectively. Furthermore, one can verify that the terms multiplied by C I S i C_{IS}^i C I S i , C Q i C_Q^i C Q i , and C I T i C_{IT}^i C I T i do not satisfy the constraint in Eq. (7) . These are the second-class currents in Weinberg’s classification [14 ] , which only arise due to isospin breaking and are therefore expected to be suppressed. The induced scalar and quadrupole interactions also violate vector current conservation. On the other hand, C A i C_A^i C A i is not fixed by symmetries. While dimensional analysis suggests ∣ C A i ∣ = O ( 1 ) v 2 |C_A^i| = \frac{O(1)}{v^2} ∣ C A i ∣ = v 2 O ( 1 ) , its precise value currently cannot be determined with enough accuracy from first principles, with the exception of the neutron decay.6 In practice, C A i C_A^i C A i is determined phenomenologically from the lifetime and/or correlation measurements. See Figure 1 for example values of C A i C_A^i C A i for a selection of mirror transitions.
Figure 1. Phenomenological values of C A i C_A^i C A i for mirror transitions up to mass number A = 45 A = 45 A = 45 . To determine C A i C_A^i C A i we use values of the mixing parameters collected in Ref. [24 ] .
For the exotic currents contributing to β − \beta^- β − decay, for J ≥ 1 / 2 J \ge1/2 J ≥ 1/2 the most general forms up to subleading order in recoil and consistent with parity are the following
j S − = M F C S i [ χ 2 χ 1 + χ ~ 2 χ ~ 1 ] 2 J ( 2 m N ) 2 J − 1 + O ( q 2 ) j_S^- = M_F C_S^i \frac{[\chi_2\chi_1 + \widetilde{\chi}_2\widetilde{\chi}_1]^{2J}}{(2m_N)^{2J-1}} + O(q^2) j S − = M F C S i ( 2 m N ) 2 J − 1 [ χ 2 χ 1 + χ 2 χ 1 ] 2 J + O ( q 2 )
j P − = M F C P i [ χ 2 χ 1 − χ ~ 2 χ ~ 1 ] [ χ 2 χ 1 + χ ~ 2 χ ~ 1 ] 2 J − 1 ( 2 m N ) 2 J − 1 + O ( q 2 ) j_P^- = M_F C_P^i [\chi_2\chi_1 - \widetilde{\chi}_2\widetilde{\chi}_1] \frac{[\chi_2\chi_1 + \widetilde{\chi}_2\widetilde{\chi}_1]^{2J-1}}{(2m_N)^{2J-1}} + O(q^2) j P − = M F C P i [ χ 2 χ 1 − χ 2 χ 1 ] ( 2 m N ) 2 J − 1 [ χ 2 χ 1 + χ 2 χ 1 ] 2 J − 1 + O ( q 2 )
j T − i μ ν = M F − 2 { C T i [ χ 2 σ μ ν χ 1 + χ ~ 2 σ ‾ μ ν χ ~ 1 ] + i C T ( 1 ) i − C T i + ( J − 1 / 2 ) C T Q i 3 J m N [ χ 2 σ [ μ χ ~ 1 + χ ~ 2 σ ‾ [ μ χ 1 ] q ν ] + C T ( 2 ) i 2 m N ϵ μ ν α β q α [ χ 2 σ β χ ~ 1 − χ ~ 2 σ ‾ β χ 1 ] ] [ χ 2 χ 1 + χ ~ 2 χ ~ 1 ] 2 J − 1 ( 2 m N ) 2 J − 1 − i ( J − 1 / 2 ) C T Q i J m N 2 [ χ 2 χ 1 − χ ~ 2 χ ~ 1 ] [ χ 2 σ [ μ χ ~ 1 − χ ~ 2 σ ‾ [ μ χ 1 ] p 1 ν ] [ χ 2 χ 1 + χ ~ 2 χ ~ 1 ] 2 J − 2 ( 2 m N ) 2 J − 2 } + O ( q 2 ) , (9) j_{T-}^{i\mu\nu}=\frac{M_F^-}{2}\{C_{T}^{i}[\chi_2\sigma^{\mu\nu}\chi_1+\widetilde{\chi}_2\overline{\sigma}^{\mu\nu}\widetilde{\chi}_1]+i\frac{C_{T(1)}^{i}-C_T^{i}+\frac{(J-1/2)C_{TQ}^{i}}{3J}}{m_N}[\chi_2\sigma^{[\mu}\widetilde{\chi}_1+\widetilde{\chi}_2\overline{\sigma}^{[\mu}\chi_1]q^{\nu]}+\frac{C_{T(2)}^{i}}{2m_N}\epsilon^{\mu\nu\alpha\beta}q_\alpha[\chi_2\sigma_\beta\widetilde{\chi}_1-\widetilde{\chi}_2\overline{\sigma}_\beta\chi_1]]\frac{[\chi_2\chi_1+\widetilde{\chi}_2\widetilde{\chi}_1]^{2J-1}}{(2m_N)^{2J-1}}-i\frac{(J-1/2)C_{TQ}^{i}}{Jm_N^2}[\chi_2\chi_1-\widetilde{\chi}_2\widetilde{\chi}_1][\chi_2\sigma^{[\mu}\widetilde{\chi}_1-\widetilde{\chi}_2\overline{\sigma}^{[\mu}\chi_1]p_1^{\nu]}\frac{[\chi_2\chi_1+\widetilde{\chi}_2\widetilde{\chi}_1]^{2J-2}}{(2m_N)^{2J-2}}\}+O(q^2), \tag*{(9)} j T − i μν = 2 M F − { C T i [ χ 2 σ μν χ 1 + χ 2 σ μν χ 1 ] + i m N C T ( 1 ) i − C T i + 3 J ( J − 1/2 ) C T Q i [ χ 2 σ [ μ χ 1 + χ 2 σ [ μ χ 1 ] q ν ] + 2 m N C T ( 2 ) i ϵ μν α β q α [ χ 2 σ β χ 1 − χ 2 σ β χ 1 ]] ( 2 m N ) 2 J − 1 [ χ 2 χ 1 + χ 2 χ 1 ] 2 J − 1 − i J m N 2 ( J − 1/2 ) C T Q i [ χ 2 χ 1 − χ 2 χ 1 ] [ χ 2 σ [ μ χ 1 − χ 2 σ [ μ χ 1 ] p 1 ν ] ( 2 m N ) 2 J − 2 [ χ 2 χ 1 + χ 2 χ 1 ] 2 J − 2 } + O ( q 2 ) , (9)
where X [ μ Y ν ] ≡ ( X μ Y ν − X ν Y μ ) / 2 X^{[\mu}Y^{\nu]} \equiv(X^\mu Y^\nu-X^\nu Y^\mu)/2 X [ μ Y ν ] ≡ ( X μ Y ν − X ν Y μ ) /2 . At leading order in recoil two more Wilson coefficients arise, C S i C_S^i C S i (scalar) and C T i C_T^i C T i (tensor). At subleading order we also have C P i C_P^i C P i (pseudoscalar), C T ( n ) i C_{T(n)}^i C T ( n ) i with n = 1 , 2 n=1,2 n = 1 , 2 (subleading tensor), and C T Q i C_{TQ}^i C T Q i (quadrupole tensor). One can show that C P i C_P^i C P i and C T ( 2 ) i C_{T(2)}^i C T ( 2 ) i do not satisfy the constraint in Eq. (7) .
For the standard and exotic currents in Eqs. (8) and (9) , the parity symmetry constraint in Eq. (5) is satisfied, given the action of P \mathcal{P} P on spinor bilinears collected in Table 1. Furthermore, the time reversal constraint in Eq. (6) is satisfied provided the Wilson coefficients C X i C_X^i C X i are real.
Using the recoil expansion of the spinor bilinears in Eq. (A.11), we can rewrite the currents up to O ( q 2 ) O(q^2) O ( q 2 ) corrections as
j V − i μ = M F − { 2 C V i p 1 μ − [ C V i − C S i ] q μ + i C M i J m N ϵ μ ν α β q ν p 1 α S β + C Q i J 2 q ν S μ ν } , j_{V-}^{i\mu}=M_F^-\left\{2C_V^i p_1^\mu-\left[C_V^i-C_S^i\right]q^\mu+i\frac{C_M^i}{Jm_N}\epsilon^{\mu\nu\alpha\beta}q_\nu p_{1\alpha}S_\beta+\frac{C_Q^i}{J^2}q_\nu S^{\mu\nu}\right\}, j V − i μ = M F − { 2 C V i p 1 μ − [ C V i − C S i ] q μ + i J m N C M i ϵ μν α β q ν p 1 α S β + J 2 C Q i q ν S μν } ,
j A − i μ = M F − { 2 m N C A i J S μ + C A i + C I T i J m N ( q S ) p 1 μ } , j_{A-}^{i\mu}=M_F^-\left\{\frac{2m_NC_A^i}{J}S^\mu+\frac{C_A^i+C_{IT}^i}{Jm_N}(qS)p_1^\mu\right\}, j A − i μ = M F − { J 2 m N C A i S μ + J m N C A i + C I T i ( q S ) p 1 μ } ,
j S − i = M F − { 2 m N C S i } , j_{S-}^{i}=M_F^-\left\{2m_NC_S^i\right\}, j S − i = M F − { 2 m N C S i } ,
j P − i = M F − { C P i J ( q S ) } , j_{P-}^{i}=M_F^-\left\{\frac{C_P^i}{J}(qS)\right\}, j P − i = M F − { J C P i ( q S ) } ,
j T − i μ ν = i M F − { − C T i J [ p 1 μ S ν − p 1 ν S μ ] + C T ( 1 ) i 2 m N [ p 1 μ q ν − p 1 ν q μ ] + C T i + C T ( 2 ) i 2 J [ q μ S ν − q ν S μ ] + C T Q i 2 m N J 2 [ p 1 μ S ν α − p 1 ν S μ α ] q α } . (10) j_{T-}^{i\mu\nu}=iM_F^-\left\{-\frac{C_T^i}{J}\left[p_1^\mu S^\nu-p_1^\nu S^\mu\right]+\frac{C_{T(1)}^i}{2m_N}\left[p_1^\mu q^\nu-p_1^\nu q^\mu\right]+\frac{C_T^i+C_{T(2)}^i}{2J}\left[q^\mu S^\nu-q^\nu S^\mu\right]+\frac{C_{TQ}^i}{2m_NJ^2}\left[p_1^\mu S^{\nu\alpha}-p_1^\nu S^{\mu\alpha}\right]q_\alpha\right\}. \tag*{(10)} j T − i μν = i M F − { − J C T i [ p 1 μ S ν − p 1 ν S μ ] + 2 m N C T ( 1 ) i [ p 1 μ q ν − p 1 ν q μ ] + 2 J C T i + C T ( 2 ) i [ q μ S ν − q ν S μ ] + 2 m N J 2 C T Q i [ p 1 μ S ν α − p 1 ν S μα ] q α } . (10)
Above, 1 ≡ δ O 1 I 1 ⋯ δ O 2 J I 2 J \mathbb{1}\equiv\delta_{O_1}^{I_1}\cdots\delta_{O_{2J}}^{I_{2J}} 1 ≡ δ O 1 I 1 ⋯ δ O 2 J I 2 J , with implicit full symmetrization of, independently, upper and lower indices. We also introduced the spin (pseudo)vector S μ S^\mu S μ [29 ] and the symmetric two-index spin tensor S μ ν S^{\mu\nu} S μν defined in Eqs. (A.1) and (A.2). The spin vector encodes the information about polarization of the parent nucleus. It is transverse, that is to say p 1 μ S μ = 0 p_1^\mu S_\mu=0 p 1 μ S μ = 0 . The spin tensor is symmetric in the Lorentz indices, S μ ν = S ν μ S^{\mu\nu}=S^{\nu\mu} S μν = S ν μ , transverse, p 1 μ S μ ν = 0 p_1^\mu S_{\mu\nu}=0 p 1 μ S μν = 0 , and traceless, S μ μ = 0 S^\mu{}_\mu=0 S μ μ = 0 . For J = 0 J=0 J = 0 (pure Fermi decays), the spin-dependent structures S μ S^\mu S μ and S μ ν S^{\mu\nu} S μν are absent and only the J J J -independent terms are retained. For J = 1 / 2 J=1/2 J = 1/2 , one should set C Q i = C T Q i = 0 C_Q^i=C_{TQ}^i=0 C Q i = C T Q i = 0 . Eq. (10) is an elegant and compact covariant expression for the currents, where the massive spinors are concealed within S μ S^\mu S μ and S μ ν S^{\mu\nu} S μν . This form is particularly convenient for calculating differential distributions in the next section.
We can formally relate β − \beta^{-} β − and β + \beta^{+} β + decay amplitudes by exploiting crossing symmetry and real analyticity of the amplitudes:
M β + = M β − ∗ ∣ p 1 ↔ − p 2 , p 3 → − p 3 , p 4 → − p 4 . (11) \mathcal{M}_{\beta^{+}}=\mathcal{M}_{\beta^{-}}^{*}\big|_{p_{1}\leftrightarrow-p_{2},p_{3}\to-p_{3},p_{4}\to-p_{4}}. \tag*{(11)} M β + = M β − ∗ p 1 ↔ − p 2 , p 3 → − p 3 , p 4 → − p 4 . (11)
Using this, we can derive the β + \beta^{+} β + currents from the Eq. (10) ones:
j V + μ = M F + { 2 C ˉ V i p 1 μ − [ C ˉ V i + C ˉ S i ] q μ + i C ˉ M i J m N ϵ μ ν α β q ν p 1 α S β − C ˉ Q i J 2 q ν S μ ν } , j A + μ = M F + { 2 m N C ˉ A i J S μ + C ˉ A i − C ˉ I T i J m N ( q S ) p 1 μ } , j S + = M F + { − 2 m N C ˉ S i 1 } , j P + = M F + { C ˉ P i J ( q S ) } , j T + μ ν = i M F + { − C ˉ T i J [ p 1 μ S ν − p 1 ν S μ ] − C ˉ T ( 1 ) i 2 m N J [ p 1 μ q ν − p 1 ν q μ ] + C ˉ T i − C ˉ T ( 2 ) i 2 J [ q μ S ν − q ν S μ ] − C ˉ T Q i 2 m N J 2 [ p 1 μ S ν α − p 1 ν S μ α ] q α } . (12) \begin{aligned}
j^{\mu}_{V+}&=M_{F}^{+}\left\{2\bar{C}^{i}_{V}p_{1}^{\mu}-\left[\bar{C}^{i}_{V}+\bar{C}^{i}_{S}\right]q^{\mu}+i\frac{\bar{C}^{i}_{M}}{Jm_{N}}\epsilon^{\mu\nu\alpha\beta}q_{\nu}p_{1\alpha}S_{\beta}-\frac{\bar{C}^{i}_{Q}}{J^{2}}q_{\nu}S^{\mu\nu}\right\},\\
j^{\mu}_{A+}&=M_{F}^{+}\left\{\frac{2m_{N}\bar{C}^{i}_{A}}{J}S^{\mu}+\frac{\bar{C}^{i}_{A}-\bar{C}^{i}_{IT}}{Jm_{N}}(qS)p_{1}^{\mu}\right\},\\
j_{S+}&=M_{F}^{+}\left\{-2m_{N}\bar{C}^{i}_{S}\mathbb{1}\right\},\\
j_{P+}&=M_{F}^{+}\left\{\frac{\bar{C}^{i}_{P}}{J}(qS)\right\},\\
j^{\mu\nu}_{T+}&=iM_{F}^{+}\left\{-\frac{\bar{C}^{i}_{T}}{J}\left[p_{1}^{\mu}S^{\nu}-p_{1}^{\nu}S^{\mu}\right]-\frac{\bar{C}^{i}_{T(1)}}{2m_{N}J}\left[p_{1}^{\mu}q^{\nu}-p_{1}^{\nu}q^{\mu}\right]+\frac{\bar{C}^{i}_{T}-\bar{C}^{i}_{T(2)}}{2J}\left[q^{\mu}S^{\nu}-q^{\nu}S^{\mu}\right]\right.\\
&\qquad\left.-\frac{\bar{C}^{i}_{TQ}}{2m_{N}J^{2}}\left[p_{1}^{\mu}S^{\nu\alpha}-p_{1}^{\nu}S^{\mu\alpha}\right]q_{\alpha}\right\}. \tag*{(12)}
\end{aligned} j V + μ j A + μ j S + j P + j T + μν = M F + { 2 C ˉ V i p 1 μ − [ C ˉ V i + C ˉ S i ] q μ + i J m N C ˉ M i ϵ μν α β q ν p 1 α S β − J 2 C ˉ Q i q ν S μν } , = M F + { J 2 m N C ˉ A i S μ + J m N C ˉ A i − C ˉ I T i ( q S ) p 1 μ } , = M F + { − 2 m N C ˉ S i 1 } , = M F + { J C ˉ P i ( q S ) } , = i M F + { − J C ˉ T i [ p 1 μ S ν − p 1 ν S μ ] − 2 m N J C ˉ T ( 1 ) i [ p 1 μ q ν − p 1 ν q μ ] + 2 J C ˉ T i − C ˉ T ( 2 ) i [ q μ S ν − q ν S μ ] − 2 m N J 2 C ˉ T Q i [ p 1 μ S ν α − p 1 ν S μα ] q α } . (12)
where C ˉ X i = ( C X i ) ∗ \bar{C}^{i}_{X}=(C^{i}_{X})^{*} C ˉ X i = ( C X i ) ∗ .
The parametrization of the currents in Eqs. (10) and (12) is the starting point for obtaining differential distributions for beta decay in the next section. Before we move on, however, let us comment on one important technicality. As mentioned earlier, the derivation of the currents in Eq. (10) from the spinorial currents in Eqs. (8) and (9) assumes equal masses of the parent and daughter nuclei. Nevertheless, from now on we will consider that Eqs. (10) and (12) remain valid as they stand when Δ ≡ m N − m N 2 > 0 \Delta\equiv m_{N}-m_{N_{2}}>0 Δ ≡ m N − m N 2 > 0 (m N ≡ m N 1 m_{N}\equiv m_{N_{1}} m N ≡ m N 1 ). This in fact defines our Wilson coefficients outside the isospin-symmetric mass limit. Concretely, we could go back to Eqs. (8) and (9) , redefining C X i → C ^ X i C^{i}_{X}\to\hat{C}^{i}_{X} C X i → C ^ X i , and repeating all the derivations for Δ > 0 \Delta>0 Δ > 0 . Doing that we would still arrive at Eq. (10) , with C X i = C ^ X i + Δ ∑ Y M X Y C ^ Y i C^{i}_{X}=\hat{C}^{i}_{X}+\Delta\sum_{Y}M_{XY}\hat{C}^{i}_{Y} C X i = C ^ X i + Δ ∑ Y M X Y C ^ Y i , with some coefficients M X Y M_{XY} M X Y . Restoring Δ > 0 \Delta>0 Δ > 0 is of course necessary for the sake of calculating differential distributions in § 4 , as the final-state phase space vanishes in the Δ → 0 \Delta\to0 Δ → 0 limit. In our power counting we will treat the nuclear mass difference Δ \Delta Δ as being of the same order as the recoil momentum, Δ ∼ O ( q ) \Delta\sim\mathcal{O}(q) Δ ∼ O ( q ) .
Differential distributions
Having provided in the previous section a Lorentz-covariant description of beta decay amplitudes, we move to discussing a Lorentz-invariant description of the differential decay width. We are interested in observables involving summation over polarizations of the beta particle and the daughter nucleus. We define the spin-summed amplitude squared: ∣ M β ∣ 2 ≡ ∑ O 1 … O 2 J 2 , K ∣ M β + ∣ 2 |\mathcal{M}_{\beta}|^{2}\equiv\sum_{O_{1}\ldots O_{2J_{2}},K}|\mathcal{M}_{\beta+}|^{2} ∣ M β ∣ 2 ≡ ∑ O 1 … O 2 J 2 , K ∣ M β + ∣ 2 , where O i O_{i} O i and K K K are the little group indices of the daughter nucleus and beta particle. For allowed decay, that amplitude squared can be parametrized as
∣ M ‾ β ∣ 2 = 8 κ { ( p 1 p 3 ) ( p 1 p 4 ) N + [ ( p 1 p 3 ) ( p 1 p 4 ) − m N 2 ( p 3 p 4 ) ] K − m N ( S p 3 ) J [ ( p 1 p 4 ) A + ( p 3 p 4 ) A ′ ] − m N ( S p 4 ) J [ B ( p 1 p 3 ) + ( p 3 p 4 ) B ′ ] + S μ ν J 2 [ 2 m N 2 p 3 μ p 3 ν C + p 3 μ p 3 ν ( p 1 p 4 ) C 3 ′ + p 4 μ p 4 ν ( p 1 p 3 ) C 4 ′ ] − m N ϵ μ ν α β p 1 μ S ν p 3 α p 4 β J D + ϵ μ ν α β p 1 μ S ν ρ p 3 α p 4 β J 2 [ p 3 ρ D 3 ′ + p 4 ρ D 4 ′ ] + 2 m N S μ ν ρ p 3 μ p 4 ν J 3 [ E 3 ′ p 3 ρ + E 4 ′ p 4 ρ ] } + O ( m N − 2 ) , (13) \left|\overline{\mathcal{M}}_{\beta}\right|^{2}=8\kappa\left\{(p_{1}p_{3})(p_{1}p_{4})\mathcal{N}+\left[(p_{1}p_{3})(p_{1}p_{4})-m_{\mathcal{N}}^{2}(p_{3}p_{4})\right]\mathcal{K}
-\frac{m_{\mathcal{N}}(S_{p_{3}})}{J}\left[(p_{1}p_{4})\mathcal{A}+(p_{3}p_{4})\mathcal{A}'\right]-\frac{m_{\mathcal{N}}(S_{p_{4}})}{J}\left[\mathcal{B}(p_{1}p_{3})+(p_{3}p_{4})\mathcal{B}'\right]
+\frac{S^{\mu\nu}}{J^{2}}\left[2m_{\mathcal{N}}^{2}p_{3}^{\mu}p_{3}^{\nu}\mathcal{C}+p_{3}^{\mu}p_{3}^{\nu}(p_{1}p_{4})\mathcal{C}_{3}'+p_{4}^{\mu}p_{4}^{\nu}(p_{1}p_{3})\mathcal{C}_{4}'\right]
-\frac{m_{\mathcal{N}}\epsilon_{\mu\nu\alpha\beta}p_{1}^{\mu}S^{\nu}p_{3}^{\alpha}p_{4}^{\beta}}{J}\mathcal{D}+\frac{\epsilon_{\mu\nu\alpha\beta}p_{1}^{\mu}S^{\nu\rho}p_{3}^{\alpha}p_{4}^{\beta}}{J^{2}}\left[p_{3}^{\rho}\mathcal{D}_{3}'+p_{4}^{\rho}\mathcal{D}_{4}'\right]
+\frac{2m_{\mathcal{N}}S^{\mu\nu\rho}p_{3}^{\mu}p_{4}^{\nu}}{J^{3}}\left[\mathcal{E}_{3}'p_{3}^{\rho}+\mathcal{E}_{4}'p_{4}^{\rho}\right]\right\}+O(m_{\mathcal{N}}^{-2}), \tag*{(13)} M β 2 = 8 κ { ( p 1 p 3 ) ( p 1 p 4 ) N + [ ( p 1 p 3 ) ( p 1 p 4 ) − m N 2 ( p 3 p 4 ) ] K − J m N ( S p 3 ) [ ( p 1 p 4 ) A + ( p 3 p 4 ) A ′ ] − J m N ( S p 4 ) [ B ( p 1 p 3 ) + ( p 3 p 4 ) B ′ ] + J 2 S μν [ 2 m N 2 p 3 μ p 3 ν C + p 3 μ p 3 ν ( p 1 p 4 ) C 3 ′ + p 4 μ p 4 ν ( p 1 p 3 ) C 4 ′ ] − J m N ϵ μν α β p 1 μ S ν p 3 α p 4 β D + J 2 ϵ μν α β p 1 μ S ν ρ p 3 α p 4 β [ p 3 ρ D 3 ′ + p 4 ρ D 4 ′ ] + J 3 2 m N S μν ρ p 3 μ p 4 ν [ E 3 ′ p 3 ρ + E 4 ′ p 4 ρ ] } + O ( m N − 2 ) , (13)
where κ \kappa κ is a numerical factor fixed to be κ = ( M F ∓ ) 2 \kappa=(M_{F}^{\mp})^{2} κ = ( M F ∓ ) 2 for allowed decays with J ≡ J 1 = J 2 J\equiv J_{1}=J_{2} J ≡ J 1 = J 2 , κ = 2 \kappa=2 κ = 2 for pure Gamow–Teller decays with J = J 2 + 1 J=J_{2}+1 J = J 2 + 1 , and κ = 2 ( 2 J + 3 ) 2 J + 1 \kappa=\frac{2(2J+3)}{2J+1} κ = 2 J + 1 2 ( 2 J + 3 ) for pure Gamow–Teller decays with J = J 2 − 1 J=J_{2}-1 J = J 2 − 1 . Eq. (13) defines the form factors N \mathcal{N} N , K \mathcal{K} K , A \mathcal{A} A , A ′ \mathcal{A}' A ′ , B \mathcal{B} B , B ′ \mathcal{B}' B ′ , C \mathcal{C} C , C i ′ \mathcal{C}_{i}' C i ′ , D \mathcal{D} D , D i ′ \mathcal{D}_{i}' D i ′ , E i ′ \mathcal{E}_{i}' E i ′ , which are bilinear in the Wilson coefficients C X i C_{X}^{i} C X i and have dimensions [ m a s s ] − 4 [\mathrm{mass}]^{-4} [ mass ] − 4 . They are in general functions of the invariant ( p 1 p 3 ) (p_{1}p_{3}) ( p 1 p 3 ) (or equivalently, of E e ≡ − ( p 1 p 3 ) / m N E_{e}\equiv-(p_{1}p_{3})/m_{\mathcal{N}} E e ≡ − ( p 1 p 3 ) / m N ) as well as parameters such as the electron mass m e m_{e} m e , the parent nucleus mass m N m_{\mathcal{N}} m N , and the nuclear mass difference Δ \Delta Δ (or equivalently, the maximum relativistic energy of the beta particle in the rest frame defined as E 0 = Δ + m e 2 − Δ 2 2 m N E_{0}=\Delta+\frac{m_{e}^{2}-\Delta^{2}}{2m_{\mathcal{N}}} E 0 = Δ + 2 m N m e 2 − Δ 2 ). We assume their eventual dependence on ( p 1 p 4 ) (p_{1}p_{4}) ( p 1 p 4 ) has been eliminated using the identity ( p 1 p 4 ) = m N ( E e − E 0 ) − ( p 3 p 4 ) (p_{1}p_{4})=m_{\mathcal{N}}(E_{e}-E_{0})-(p_{3}p_{4}) ( p 1 p 4 ) = m N ( E e − E 0 ) − ( p 3 p 4 ) , which follows from momentum conservation and on-shell conditions. By definition, the form factors do not depend on ( p 3 p 4 ) (p_{3}p_{4}) ( p 3 p 4 ) . The form factors N \mathcal{N} N , K \mathcal{K} K , A \mathcal{A} A , B \mathcal{B} B , C \mathcal{C} C , D \mathcal{D} D , arise at leading order in recoil, and they are closely related to the usual correlation coefficients a a a , A A A , B B B , c c c and D D D and the Fierz term b b b defined in Ref. [13 ] , see below in Eq. (16) . These form factors in general receive also recoil-order corrections, while the primed ones: A ′ \mathcal{A}' A ′ , B ′ \mathcal{B}' B ′ , C i ′ \mathcal{C}_{i}' C i ′ , D i ′ \mathcal{D}_{i}' D i ′ , E i ′ \mathcal{E}_{i}' E i ′ , arise only at the recoil order. The form factors D \mathcal{D} D and D ′ \mathcal{D}' D ′ are T T T -odd, while the remaining ones are T T T -even. Beyond subleading order in recoil (that is at O ( m N − 2 ) O(m_{\mathcal{N}}^{-2}) O ( m N − 2 ) ) additional tensor structures are possible, but we will not discuss them in this paper. The last line of Eq. (13) features the 3-index spin tensors defined in Eq. (A.2). Implicitly, S μ S^{\mu} S μ is kept only for J ≥ 1 / 2 J\geq1/2 J ≥ 1/2 , S μ ν S^{\mu\nu} S μν is kept for J ≥ 1 J\geq1 J ≥ 1 , and S μ ν ρ S^{\mu\nu\rho} S μν ρ is kept for J ≥ 3 / 2 J\geq3/2 J ≥ 3/2 .
A straightforward if tedious calculation allows one to determine the dependence of the form factors on the Wilson coefficients C X i C_{X}^{i} C X i . Below we present the complete leading order result, while at the first recoil order we only give the dependence on the Wilson coefficients entering the standard currents:
N = Re { ∣ C V i ∣ 2 + ∣ C S i ∣ 2 ± 2 m e E e C V i C ‾ S i + λ 0 [ ∣ C A i ∣ 2 + ∣ C T i ∣ 2 ± 2 m e E e C A i C ‾ T i ] − m e 2 m N E e C V i ( C ‾ V i ∓ C ‾ S i ) + λ 0 3 [ ± 2 E e − E 0 − m e 2 / E e m N C A i C ‾ M i ± E 0 − m e 2 / E e m N C A i ( C ‾ I T i ± α A C ‾ A i ) ] } , \mathcal{N}=\operatorname{Re}\left\{|C_{V}^{i}|^{2}+|C_{S}^{i}|^{2}\pm2\frac{m_{e}}{E_{e}}C_{V}^{i}\overline{C}_{S}^{i}+\lambda_{0}\left[|C_{A}^{i}|^{2}+|C_{T}^{i}|^{2}\pm2\frac{m_{e}}{E_{e}}C_{A}^{i}\overline{C}_{T}^{i}\right]-\frac{m_{e}^{2}}{m_{\mathcal{N}}E_{e}}C_{V}^{i}\left(\overline{C}_{V}^{i}\mp\overline{C}_{S}^{i}\right)+\frac{\lambda_{0}}{3}\left[\pm\frac{2E_{e}-E_{0}-m_{e}^{2}/E_{e}}{m_{\mathcal{N}}}C_{A}^{i}\overline{C}_{M}^{i}\pm\frac{E_{0}-m_{e}^{2}/E_{e}}{m_{\mathcal{N}}}C_{A}^{i}\left(\overline{C}_{IT}^{i}\pm\alpha_{A}\overline{C}_{A}^{i}\right)\right]\right\}, N = Re { ∣ C V i ∣ 2 + ∣ C S i ∣ 2 ± 2 E e m e C V i C S i + λ 0 [ ∣ C A i ∣ 2 + ∣ C T i ∣ 2 ± 2 E e m e C A i C T i ] − m N E e m e 2 C V i ( C V i ∓ C S i ) + 3 λ 0 [ ± m N 2 E e − E 0 − m e 2 / E e C A i C M i ± m N E 0 − m e 2 / E e C A i ( C I T i ± α A C A i ) ] } ,
K = Re { ∣ C V i ∣ 2 − ∣ C S i ∣ 2 + λ 0 3 [ − ∣ C A i ∣ 2 + ∣ C T i ∣ 2 ± 2 ( 2 E e − E 0 ) m N C A i C ‾ M i ± E 0 m N C A i ( C ‾ I T i ± α A C ‾ A i ) ] } , \mathcal{K}=\operatorname{Re}\left\{|C_{V}^{i}|^{2}-|C_{S}^{i}|^{2}+\frac{\lambda_{0}}{3}\left[-|C_{A}^{i}|^{2}+|C_{T}^{i}|^{2}\pm\frac{2(2E_{e}-E_{0})}{m_{\mathcal{N}}}C_{A}^{i}\overline{C}_{M}^{i}\pm\frac{E_{0}}{m_{\mathcal{N}}}C_{A}^{i}\left(\overline{C}_{IT}^{i}\pm\alpha_{A}\overline{C}_{A}^{i}\right)\right]\right\}, K = Re { ∣ C V i ∣ 2 − ∣ C S i ∣ 2 + 3 λ 0 [ − ∣ C A i ∣ 2 + ∣ C T i ∣ 2 ± m N 2 ( 2 E e − E 0 ) C A i C M i ± m N E 0 C A i ( C I T i ± α A C A i ) ] } ,
A = Re { ∓ λ 1 [ ∣ C A i ∣ 2 − ∣ C T i ∣ 2 ] − 2 C V i C ‾ V i + 2 C S i C ‾ T i ∓ E 0 m N C V i C ‾ M i − 2 E e m N C V i ( C ‾ A i ± C ‾ I T i ) + λ 1 2 [ 2 E e − E 0 m N C A i C ˉ M i − E 0 m N C A i ( C ˉ I T i ± α A C ˉ A i ) ] ± λ 3 6 E e + E 0 10 m N C A i C ˉ Q i } , (14) \begin{aligned}
\mathcal{A}=\operatorname{Re}\{\mp\lambda_{1}[|C_{A}^{i}|^{2}-|C_{T}^{i}|^{2}]-2C_{V}^{i}\overline{C}_{V}^{i}+2C_{S}^{i}\overline{C}_{T}^{i}\mp\frac{E_{0}}{m_{\mathcal{N}}}C_{V}^{i}\overline{C}_{M}^{i}-\frac{2E_{e}}{m_{\mathcal{N}}}C_{V}^{i}(\overline{C}_{A}^{i}\pm\overline{C}_{IT}^{i}) \\
&+\frac{\lambda_1}{2}[\frac{2E_e-E_0}{m_N}C_A^i\bar C_M^i-\frac{E_0}{m_N}C_A^i(\bar C_{IT}^i\pm\alpha_A\bar C_A^i)]\pm\lambda_3\frac{6E_e+E_0}{10m_N}C_A^i\bar C_Q^i\}, \tag*{(14)}
\end{aligned} A = Re { ∓ λ 1 [ ∣ C A i ∣ 2 − ∣ C T i ∣ 2 ] − 2 C V i C V i + 2 C S i C T i ∓ m N E 0 C V i C M i − m N 2 E e C V i ( C A i ± C I T i ) + 2 λ 1 [ m N 2 E e − E 0 C A i C ˉ M i − m N E 0 C A i ( C ˉ I T i ± α A C ˉ A i )] ± λ 3 10 m N 6 E e + E 0 C A i C ˉ Q i } , (14)
B = Re { ± λ 1 [ ∣ C A i ∣ 2 + ∣ C T i ∣ 2 ± 2 m e E e C A i C ˉ T i ] − 2 C V i C ˉ A i − 2 C S i C ˉ T i + 2 m e E e C V i C ˉ T i + 2 m e E e C A i C ˉ S i \mathcal{B}=\operatorname{Re}\left\{\pm\lambda_1\left[|C_A^i|^2+|C_T^i|^2\pm2\frac{m_e}{E_e}C_A^i\bar C_T^i\right]-2C_V^i\bar C_A^i-2C_S^i\bar C_T^i+2\frac{m_e}{E_e}C_V^i\bar C_T^i+2\frac{m_e}{E_e}C_A^i\bar C_S^i
\right. B = Re { ± λ 1 [ ∣ C A i ∣ 2 + ∣ C T i ∣ 2 ± 2 E e m e C A i C ˉ T i ] − 2 C V i C ˉ A i − 2 C S i C ˉ T i + 2 E e m e C V i C ˉ T i + 2 E e m e C A i C ˉ S i
± E 0 − m e 2 E e m N C V i C ˉ M i + 2 ( E e − E 0 ) m N C V i ( C ˉ A i ± C ˉ I T i ) + m e 2 m N E e C A i ( C ˉ V i + C ˉ I S i ) \left.
\pm\frac{E_0-\frac{m_e^2}{E_e}}{m_N}C_V^i\bar C_M^i+\frac{2(E_e-E_0)}{m_N}C_V^i\left(\bar C_A^i\pm\bar C_{IT}^i\right)+\frac{m_e^2}{m_NE_e}C_A^i\left(\bar C_V^i+\bar C_{IS}^i\right)
\right. ± m N E 0 − E e m e 2 C V i C ˉ M i + m N 2 ( E e − E 0 ) C V i ( C ˉ A i ± C ˉ I T i ) + m N E e m e 2 C A i ( C ˉ V i + C ˉ I S i )
+ λ 1 [ − 2 E e − E 0 − m e 2 E e 2 m N C A i C ˉ M i + E 0 − m e 2 E e 2 m N C A i ( C ˉ I T i + α A C ˉ A i ) ] ± λ 3 10 7 E 0 − 6 E e − m e 2 E e m N C A i C ˉ Q i } , \left.
+\lambda_1\left[-\frac{2E_e-E_0-\frac{m_e^2}{E_e}}{2m_N}C_A^i\bar C_M^i+\frac{E_0-\frac{m_e^2}{E_e}}{2m_N}C_A^i\left(\bar C_{IT}^i+\alpha_A\bar C_A^i\right)\right]\pm\frac{\lambda_3}{10}\frac{7E_0-6E_e-\frac{m_e^2}{E_e}}{m_N}C_A^i\bar C_Q^i\right\}, + λ 1 − 2 m N 2 E e − E 0 − E e m e 2 C A i C ˉ M i + 2 m N E 0 − E e m e 2 C A i ( C ˉ I T i + α A C ˉ A i ) ± 10 λ 3 m N 7 E 0 − 6 E e − E e m e 2 C A i C ˉ Q i ⎭ ⎬ ⎫ ,
C = Re { λ 2 [ ∣ C A i ∣ 2 − ∣ C T i ∣ 2 ] ± E 0 2 m N C V i C ˉ Q i + λ 2 [ ∓ 2 E e − E 0 2 m N C A i C ˉ M i ± E 0 2 m N C A i ( C ˉ I T i ± α A C ˉ A i ) ] \mathcal{C}=\operatorname{Re}\left\{\lambda_2\left[|C_A^i|^2-|C_T^i|^2\right]\pm\frac{E_0}{2m_N}C_V^i\bar C_Q^i+\lambda_2\left[\mp\frac{2E_e-E_0}{2m_N}C_A^i\bar C_M^i\pm\frac{E_0}{2m_N}C_A^i\left(\bar C_{IT}^i\pm\alpha_A\bar C_A^i\right)\right]
\right. C = Re { λ 2 [ ∣ C A i ∣ 2 − ∣ C T i ∣ 2 ] ± 2 m N E 0 C V i C ˉ Q i + λ 2 [ ∓ 2 m N 2 E e − E 0 C A i C ˉ M i ± 2 m N E 0 C A i ( C ˉ I T i ± α A C ˉ A i ) ]
+ 3 λ 4 ( 2 E e − E 0 ) 2 m N C A i C ˉ Q i } , \left.
+\frac{3\lambda_4(2E_e-E_0)}{2m_N}C_A^i\bar C_Q^i\right\}, + 2 m N 3 λ 4 ( 2 E e − E 0 ) C A i C ˉ Q i } ,
\mathcal{D}=\operatorname{Im}\left\{-2C_V^i\bar C_A^i+2C_S^i\bar C_T^i
\pm\frac{2E_e-E_0}{m_N}C_V^i\bar C_M^i-\lambda_1\left[\frac{E_0}{2m_N}C_A^i\bar C_M^i+\frac{2E_e-E_0}{2m_N}C_A^i\bar C_{IT}^i\right]\pm\lambda_3\frac{E_0}{2m_N}C_A^i\bar C_Q^i\right\}. {#eq:4.2}
A ′ = Re { ∓ C V i C ˉ M i − C V i ( C ˉ A i ± C ˉ I T i ) − λ 1 2 [ C A i C ˉ M i + C A i ( C ˉ I T i ± α A C ˉ A i ) ] ∓ 3 λ 3 10 C A i C ˉ Q i } , \mathcal{A}'=\operatorname{Re}\left\{\mp C_V^i\bar C_M^i-C_V^i\left(\bar C_A^i\pm\bar C_{IT}^i\right)-\frac{\lambda_1}{2}\left[C_A^i\bar C_M^i+C_A^i\left(\bar C_{IT}^i\pm\alpha_A\bar C_A^i\right)\right]\mp\frac{3\lambda_3}{10}C_A^i\bar C_Q^i\right\}, A ′ = Re { ∓ C V i C ˉ M i − C V i ( C ˉ A i ± C ˉ I T i ) − 2 λ 1 [ C A i C ˉ M i + C A i ( C ˉ I T i ± α A C ˉ A i ) ] ∓ 10 3 λ 3 C A i C ˉ Q i } ,
B ′ = Re { ± C V i C ˉ M i − C V i ( C ˉ A i ± C ˉ I T i ) − λ 1 2 [ C A i C ˉ M i − C A i ( C ˉ I T i ± α A C ˉ A i ) ] ∓ 3 λ 3 10 C A i C ˉ Q i } , \mathcal{B}'=\operatorname{Re}\left\{\pm C_V^i\bar C_M^i-C_V^i\left(\bar C_A^i\pm\bar C_{IT}^i\right)-\frac{\lambda_1}{2}\left[C_A^i\bar C_M^i-C_A^i\left(\bar C_{IT}^i\pm\alpha_A\bar C_A^i\right)\right]\mp\frac{3\lambda_3}{10}C_A^i\bar C_Q^i\right\}, B ′ = Re { ± C V i C ˉ M i − C V i ( C ˉ A i ± C ˉ I T i ) − 2 λ 1 [ C A i C ˉ M i − C A i ( C ˉ I T i ± α A C ˉ A i ) ] ∓ 10 3 λ 3 C A i C ˉ Q i } ,
C 3 ′ = Re { ∓ C V i C ˉ Q i ∓ λ 2 [ C A i C ˉ M i + C A i ( C ˉ I T i ± α A C ˉ A i ) ] + 3 λ 4 C A i C ˉ Q i } , \mathcal{C}'_3=\operatorname{Re}\left\{\mp C_V^i\bar C_Q^i\mp\lambda_2\left[C_A^i\bar C_M^i+C_A^i\left(\bar C_{IT}^i\pm\alpha_A\bar C_A^i\right)\right]+3\lambda_4C_A^i\bar C_Q^i\right\}, C 3 ′ = Re { ∓ C V i C ˉ Q i ∓ λ 2 [ C A i C ˉ M i + C A i ( C ˉ I T i ± α A C ˉ A i ) ] + 3 λ 4 C A i C ˉ Q i } ,
C 4 ′ = Re { ∓ C V i C ˉ Q i ± λ 2 [ C A i C ˉ M i − C A i ( C ˉ I T i ± α A C ˉ A i ) ] − 3 λ 4 C A i C ˉ Q i } , \mathcal{C}'_4=\operatorname{Re}\left\{\mp C_V^i\bar C_Q^i\pm\lambda_2\left[C_A^i\bar C_M^i-C_A^i\left(\bar C_{IT}^i\pm\alpha_A\bar C_A^i\right)\right]-3\lambda_4C_A^i\bar C_Q^i\right\}, C 4 ′ = Re { ∓ C V i C ˉ Q i ± λ 2 [ C A i C ˉ M i − C A i ( C ˉ I T i ± α A C ˉ A i ) ] − 3 λ 4 C A i C ˉ Q i } ,
D 3 ′ = Im { ∓ C V i C ˉ Q i ± λ 2 [ C A i C ˉ M i + C A i C ˉ I T i ] + λ 4 C A i C ˉ Q i } , \mathcal{D}'_3=\operatorname{Im}\left\{\mp C_V^i\bar C_Q^i\pm\lambda_2\left[C_A^i\bar C_M^i+C_A^i\bar C_{IT}^i\right]+\lambda_4C_A^i\bar C_Q^i\right\}, D 3 ′ = Im { ∓ C V i C ˉ Q i ± λ 2 [ C A i C ˉ M i + C A i C ˉ I T i ] + λ 4 C A i C ˉ Q i } ,
D 4 ′ = Im { ∓ C V i C ˉ Q i ∓ λ 2 [ C A i C ˉ M i − C A i C ˉ I T i ] − λ 4 C A i C ˉ Q i } , \mathcal{D}'_4=\operatorname{Im}\left\{\mp C_V^i\bar C_Q^i\mp\lambda_2\left[C_A^i\bar C_M^i-C_A^i\bar C_{IT}^i\right]-\lambda_4C_A^i\bar C_Q^i\right\}, D 4 ′ = Im { ∓ C V i C ˉ Q i ∓ λ 2 [ C A i C ˉ M i − C A i C ˉ I T i ] − λ 4 C A i C ˉ Q i } ,
\mathcal{E}'_3=\mathcal{E}'_4=\operatorname{Re}\left\{\mp\lambda_5C_A^i\bar C_Q^i\right\}. {#eq:4.3}
Here, the upper (lower) signs refer to β − \beta^- β − (β + \beta^+ β + ) decay. The spin-dependent group-theoretical coefficients λ i \lambda_i λ i are collected in the second column of Table 2 . In this form, the results can also be used for pure Gamow-Teller decays, after setting C V i = C S i = C I S i = C T ( 1 ) i = 0 C_V^i=C_S^i=C_{IS}^i=C_{T(1)}^i=0 C V i = C S i = C I S i = C T ( 1 ) i = 0 and with corresponding λ i \lambda_i λ i and α X \alpha_X α X coefficients given in the third and fourth columns of Table 2 .7 See Section D for the conventions for currents and Wilson coefficients in the pure Gamow-Teller case. For pure Fermi decays (J = J 2 = 0 J=J_2=0 J = J 2 = 0 ) one should set instead C A i = C T i = C M i = C I T i = C P i = C T ( 2 ) i = C Q i = C T Q i = 0 C_A^i=C_T^i=C_M^i=C_{IT}^i=C_P^i=C_{T(2)}^i=C_Q^i=C_{TQ}^i=0 C A i = C T i = C M i = C I T i = C P i = C T ( 2 ) i = C Q i = C T Q i = 0 . The subleading recoil dependence of the form factors on the exotic Wilson coefficients is given in Section C.
Table 2. Group-theoretical factors appearing in the form factors and correlation coefficients for allowed beta decays. The columns refer to mixed Fermi-Gamow-Teller decays (J ≡ J 1 = J 2 J\equiv J_1=J_2 J ≡ J 1 = J 2 ), pure Gamow-Teller decays with J = J 2 + 1 J=J_2+1 J = J 2 + 1 , and those with J = J 2 − 1 J=J_2-1 J = J 2 − 1 .
Given the amplitude squared, the differential decay width is given by d Γ = ∣ M ‾ β ∣ 2 2 m N d Π 3 d\Gamma=\frac{|\overline{\mathcal{M}}_\beta|^2}{2m_N}d\Pi_3 d Γ = 2 m N ∣ M β ∣ 2 d Π 3 , where the 3-body phase space element is d Π 3 = ( 2 π ) 4 δ 4 ( p 1 + p 2 + p 3 + p 4 ) ∏ i = 2 4 d 4 p i ( 2 π ) 3 δ ( p i 2 − m i 2 ) θ ( − p i 0 ) d\Pi_3=(2\pi)^4\delta^4(p_1+p_2+p_3+p_4)\prod_{i=2}^4\frac{d^4p_i}{(2\pi)^3}\delta(p_i^2-m_i^2)\theta(-p_i^0) d Π 3 = ( 2 π ) 4 δ 4 ( p 1 + p 2 + p 3 + p 4 ) ∏ i = 2 4 ( 2 π ) 3 d 4 p i δ ( p i 2 − m i 2 ) θ ( − p i 0 ) . In our formalism we can calculate the differential decay width in any reference frame. Traditionally, however, it is presented in the rest frame of the parent nucleus. In order to link to known results, we parametrize the rest frame momenta as p 1 = ( m N , 0 ) p_1=(m_N,0) p 1 = ( m N , 0 ) , p 3 = − ( E e , k e ) p_3=-(E_e,\mathbf{k}_e) p 3 = − ( E e , k e ) , p 4 = − ( E ν , k ν ) p_4=-(E_\nu,\mathbf{k}_\nu) p 4 = − ( E ν , k ν ) , where E e E_e E e is the energy of the beta particle, k i \mathbf{k}_i k i are 3-vectors describing spatial momenta of the beta particle and the neutrino whose magnitudes are fixed by on-shell conditions as ∣ k e ∣ = E e 2 − m e 2 |\mathbf{k}_e|=\sqrt{E_e^2-m_e^2} ∣ k e ∣ = E e 2 − m e 2 , ∣ k ν ∣ = E ν |\mathbf{k}_\nu|=E_\nu ∣ k ν ∣ = E ν , while the neutrino energy is fixed by the kinematics as8 {}^{8} 8 E ν = E 0 − E e 1 − E e E ν − k e k ν m N E ν E_\nu=\frac{E_0-E_e}{1-\frac{E_eE_\nu-\mathbf{k}_e\mathbf{k}_\nu}{m_NE_\nu}} E ν = 1 − m N E ν E e E ν − k e k ν E 0 − E e . We also assume the parent nucleus state is prepared with a definite spin projection J 3 ∈ [ − J , J ] J_3\in[-J,J] J 3 ∈ [ − J , J ] along the spin quantization axis characterized by the unit vector j \mathbf{j} j . In that frame and for such a state, the spin vector is S = ( 0 , J ) S=(0,\mathbf{J}) S = ( 0 , J ) , where the 3-vector J = J 3 j \mathbf{J}=J_3\mathbf{j} J = J 3 j . Furthermore, the components of the spin tensors take the values S 00 = S 0 k = 0 S^{00}=S^{0k}=0 S 00 = S 0 k = 0 , S k l = [ δ k l − 3 j k j l ] J ( J + 1 ) − 3 ( J j ) 2 2 S^{kl}=\left[\delta^{kl}-3j^kj^l\right]\frac{J(J+1)-3(\mathbf{J}\mathbf{j})^2}{2} S k l = [ δ k l − 3 j k j l ] 2 J ( J + 1 ) − 3 ( Jj ) 2 , and S 000 = S 0 k l = S 00 k = 0 S^{000}=S^{0kl}=S^{00k}=0 S 000 = S 0 k l = S 00 k = 0 , S k l r = − ( J j ) [ 5 ( J j ) 2 + 1 − 3 J ( J + 1 ) ] 10 { δ k l j r + δ l r j k + δ r k j l − 5 j k j l j r } S^{klr}=-\frac{(\mathbf{J}\mathbf{j})[5(\mathbf{J}\mathbf{j})^2+1-3J(J+1)]}{10}\left\{\delta^{kl}j^r+\delta^{lr}j^k+\delta^{rk}j^l-5j^kj^lj^r\right\} S k l r = − 10 ( Jj ) [ 5 ( Jj ) 2 + 1 − 3 J ( J + 1 )] { δ k l j r + δ l r j k + δ r k j l − 5 j k j l j r } . The phase space element in the rest frame can be written as d Π 3 = d E e d Ω e d Ω ν 8 m N ( 2 π ) 5 ∣ k e ∣ ( E 0 − E e ) ( 1 − E e E ν − k e k ν m N E ν ) − 2 d\Pi_3=\frac{dE_ed\Omega_ed\Omega_\nu}{8m_N(2\pi)^5}|\mathbf{k}_e|(E_0-E_e)\left(1-\frac{E_eE_\nu-\mathbf{k}_e\mathbf{k}_\nu}{m_NE_\nu}\right)^{-2} d Π 3 = 8 m N ( 2 π ) 5 d E e d Ω e d Ω ν ∣ k e ∣ ( E 0 − E e ) ( 1 − m N E ν E e E ν − k e k ν ) − 2 , where d Ω i = d cos θ i d ϕ i d\Omega_i=d\cos\theta_i d\phi_i d Ω i = d cos θ i d ϕ i are the angular variables of the beta particle and neutrino momenta. Putting it all together, the differential distribution in the rest frame of the parent nucleus takes the form9 {}^{9} 9
d Γ d E e d Ω e d Ω ν = κ E e ∣ k e ∣ ( E 0 − E e ) 2 64 π 5 { ( 1 + 3 E e m N ) N − 3 ( k e k ν ) 2 m N E e E ν 2 N + k e k ν E e E ν [ N + 3 E e m N ( N − N ) ] } \frac{d\Gamma}{dE_e d\Omega_e d\Omega_\nu}=\frac{\kappa E_e|\mathbf{k}_e|(E_0-E_e)^2}{64\pi^5}\left\{\left(1+\frac{3E_e}{m_N}\right)\mathcal{N}-\frac{3(\mathbf{k}_e\mathbf{k}_\nu)^2}{m_NE_eE_\nu^2}\mathcal{N}+\frac{\mathbf{k}_e\mathbf{k}_\nu}{E_eE_\nu}\left[\mathcal{N}+\frac{3E_e}{m_N}\left(\mathcal{N}-\mathcal{N}\right)\right]\right\} d E e d Ω e d Ω ν d Γ = 64 π 5 κ E e ∣ k e ∣ ( E 0 − E e ) 2 { ( 1 + m N 3 E e ) N − m N E e E ν 2 3 ( k e k ν ) 2 N + E e E ν k e k ν [ N + m N 3 E e ( N − N ) ] }
+ J ⋅ k e J E e [ A + 3 E e m N A − E e m N A ′ + k e k ν m N E ν ( A ′ − 3 A ) ] + J ⋅ k ν J E ν [ B + 3 E e m N B − E ν m N B ′ + k e k ν m N E ν ( B ′ E e − 3 B E ν ) ] + J ( J + 1 ) − 3 ( J j ) 2 6 J 2 [ δ k l − 3 j k j l ] [ 2 k e k k ν l E e E ν ( 1 + 3 E e m N − 3 ( k e k ν ) m N E e ) C − k e k k e l m N E e C 3 ′ − k ν k k ν l m N E ν C 4 ′ ] + J ⋅ ( k e × k ν ) J E e E ν ( 1 + 3 E e m N − 3 ( k e k ν ) m N E e ) D + J ( J + 1 ) − 3 ( J j ) 2 2 J 2 ( k e × k ν ) ⋅ j m N E e E ν [ ( j k e ) D 3 ′ + ( j k ν ) D 4 ′ ] − ( J j ) [ 5 ( J j ) 2 + 1 − 3 J ( J + 1 ) ] 5 J 3 k e k k ν l m N E e E ν [ E 3 ′ k e r + E 4 ′ k ν r ] [ δ k l j r + δ k r j l + δ l r j k − 5 j k j l j r ] + O ( m N − 2 ) . (15) + \frac{\mathbf{J}\cdot\mathbf{k}_e}{J E_e}\left[\mathcal{A}+\frac{3E_e}{m_N}\mathcal{A}-\frac{E_e}{m_N}\mathcal{A}'+\frac{\mathbf{k}_e\mathbf{k}_\nu}{m_N E_\nu}\left(\mathcal{A}'-3\mathcal{A}\right)\right]
+ \frac{\mathbf{J}\cdot\mathbf{k}_\nu}{J E_\nu}\left[\mathcal{B}+\frac{3E_e}{m_N}\mathcal{B}-\frac{E_\nu}{m_N}\mathcal{B}'+\frac{\mathbf{k}_e\mathbf{k}_\nu}{m_N E_\nu}\left(\frac{\mathcal{B}'}{E_e}-\frac{3\mathcal{B}}{E_\nu}\right)\right]
+ \frac{J(J+1)-3(\mathbf{J}\mathbf{j})^2}{6J^2}\left[\delta^{kl}-3j^k j^l\right]\left[\frac{2k_e^k k_\nu^l}{E_e E_\nu}\left(1+\frac{3E_e}{m_N}-\frac{3(\mathbf{k}_e\mathbf{k}_\nu)}{m_N E_e}\right)\mathcal{C}-\frac{k_e^k k_e^l}{m_N E_e}\mathcal{C}'_3-\frac{k_\nu^k k_\nu^l}{m_N E_\nu}\mathcal{C}'_4\right]
+ \frac{\mathbf{J}\cdot(\mathbf{k}_e\times\mathbf{k}_\nu)}{J E_e E_\nu}\left(1+\frac{3E_e}{m_N}-\frac{3(\mathbf{k}_e\mathbf{k}_\nu)}{m_N E_e}\right)\mathcal{D}+\frac{J(J+1)-3(\mathbf{J}\mathbf{j})^2}{2J^2}\frac{(\mathbf{k}_e\times\mathbf{k}_\nu)\cdot\mathbf{j}}{m_N E_e E_\nu}\left[(j k_e) \mathcal{D}'_3+(j k_\nu)\mathcal{D}'_4\right]
-\frac{(\mathbf{J}\mathbf{j})[5(\mathbf{J}\mathbf{j})^2+1-3J(J+1)]}{5J^3}\frac{k_e^k k_\nu^l}{m_N E_e E_\nu}\left[\mathcal{E}'_3 k_e^r+\mathcal{E}'_4 k_\nu^r\right]\left[\delta^{kl}j^r+\delta^{kr}j^l+\delta^{lr}j^k-5j^k j^l j^r\right]
+O(m_N^{-2}). \tag*{(15)} + J E e J ⋅ k e [ A + m N 3 E e A − m N E e A ′ + m N E ν k e k ν ( A ′ − 3 A ) ] + J E ν J ⋅ k ν [ B + m N 3 E e B − m N E ν B ′ + m N E ν k e k ν ( E e B ′ − E ν 3 B ) ] + 6 J 2 J ( J + 1 ) − 3 ( Jj ) 2 [ δ k l − 3 j k j l ] [ E e E ν 2 k e k k ν l ( 1 + m N 3 E e − m N E e 3 ( k e k ν ) ) C − m N E e k e k k e l C 3 ′ − m N E ν k ν k k ν l C 4 ′ ] + J E e E ν J ⋅ ( k e × k ν ) ( 1 + m N 3 E e − m N E e 3 ( k e k ν ) ) D + 2 J 2 J ( J + 1 ) − 3 ( Jj ) 2 m N E e E ν ( k e × k ν ) ⋅ j [ ( j k e ) D 3 ′ + ( j k ν ) D 4 ′ ] − 5 J 3 ( Jj ) [ 5 ( Jj ) 2 + 1 − 3 J ( J + 1 )] m N E e E ν k e k k ν l [ E 3 ′ k e r + E 4 ′ k ν r ] [ δ k l j r + δ k r j l + δ l r j k − 5 j k j l j r ] + O ( m N − 2 ) . (15)
Given this, one can identify how the familiar correlation coefficients are related to the form factors:
ξ a = N + 3 E e ( N − N ′ ) m N , \xi_a=\mathcal{N}+\frac{3E_e(\mathcal{N}-\mathcal{N}')}{m_N}, ξ a = N + m N 3 E e ( N − N ′ ) ,
ξ A = A + 3 E e A − E e ( B + A ′ ) + 1 3 ( E 0 − E e ) B ′ m N , \xi_A=\mathcal{A}+\frac{3E_e\mathcal{A}-E_e(\mathcal{B}+\mathcal{A}')+\frac{1}{3}(E_0-E_e)\mathcal{B}'}{m_N}, ξ A = A + m N 3 E e A − E e ( B + A ′ ) + 3 1 ( E 0 − E e ) B ′ ,
ξ B = B + E e 2 − m e 2 E e A − ( E 0 − E e ) B ′ + E e 2 − m e 2 3 E e A ′ m N , \xi_B=\mathcal{B}+\frac{\frac{E_e^2-m_e^2}{E_e}\mathcal{A}-(E_0-E_e)\mathcal{B}'+\frac{E_e^2-m_e^2}{3E_e}\mathcal{A}'}{m_N}, ξ B = B + m N E e E e 2 − m e 2 A − ( E 0 − E e ) B ′ + 3 E e E e 2 − m e 2 A ′ ,
ξ c = 2 J − 1 J ( 1 + 3 E e m N ) C , \xi_c=\frac{2J-1}{J}\left(1+\frac{3E_e}{m_N}\right)\mathcal{C}, ξ c = J 2 J − 1 ( 1 + m N 3 E e ) C ,
ξ D = ( 1 + 3 E e m N ) D . (16) \xi_D=\left(1+\frac{3E_e}{m_N}\right)\mathcal{D}. \tag*{(16)} ξ D = ( 1 + m N 3 E e ) D . (16)
Above, ξ \xi ξ is an arbitrary normalization factor, whose role is to render the correlation coefficients dimensionless. Conventionally, one takes ξ ≡ ∣ C V ∣ 2 + ∣ C S ′ ∣ 2 + J + 1 J ( ∣ C A ∣ 2 + ∣ C T ′ ∣ 2 ) \xi\equiv|C_V|^2+|C_S'|^2+\frac{J+1}{J}\left(|C_A|^2+|C_T'|^2\right) ξ ≡ ∣ C V ∣ 2 + ∣ C S ′ ∣ 2 + J J + 1 ( ∣ C A ∣ 2 + ∣ C T ′ ∣ 2 ) . The beta–neutrino angular correlation coefficient (little a a a ) is defined as the coefficient multiplying the k e k ν E e E ν \frac{\mathbf{k}_e\mathbf{k}_\nu}{E_eE_\nu} E e E ν k e k ν structure in the curly bracket in Eq. (15) . Similarly, the c c c and D D D correlations are defined, respectively, as the coefficients of the J ( J + 1 ) − 3 ( J j ) 2 3 J ( 2 J − 1 ) E e E ν [ ( k e k ν ) − 3 ( k e j ) ( k ν j ) ] \frac{J(J+1)-3(\mathbf{J}\mathbf{j})^2}{3J(2J-1)E_eE_\nu}\left[(\mathbf{k}_e\mathbf{k}_\nu)-3(\mathbf{k}_e\mathbf{j})(\mathbf{k}_\nu\mathbf{j})\right] 3 J ( 2 J − 1 ) E e E ν J ( J + 1 ) − 3 ( Jj ) 2 [ ( k e k ν ) − 3 ( k e j ) ( k ν j ) ] and J ( k e × k ν ) J E e E ν \frac{\mathbf{J}(\mathbf{k}_e\times\mathbf{k}_\nu)}{J E_eE_\nu} J E e E ν J ( k e × k ν ) structures. The beta asymmetry (capital A A A ) is defined by d Γ d E e d Ω e ⊃ κ E e ∣ k e ∣ ( E 0 − E e ) 2 16 π 4 J k e J E e ξ A \frac{d\Gamma}{dE_e d\Omega_e}\supset\frac{\kappa E_e|\mathbf{k}_e|(E_0-E_e)^2}{16\pi^4}\frac{\mathbf{J}\mathbf{k}_e}{J E_e}\xi_A d E e d Ω e d Γ ⊃ 16 π 4 κ E e ∣ k e ∣ ( E 0 − E e ) 2 J E e J k e ξ A in the differential distribution obtained after integrating Eq. (15) over the neutrino angles. Similarly, the neutrino asymmetry (capital B B B ) is defined by d Γ d E e d Ω ν ⊃ κ E e ∣ k e ∣ ( E 0 − E e ) 2 16 π 4 J k ν J E ν ξ B \frac{d\Gamma}{dE_e d\Omega_\nu}\supset\frac{\kappa E_e|\mathbf{k}_e|(E_0-E_e)^2}{16\pi^4}\frac{\mathbf{J}\mathbf{k}_\nu}{J E_\nu}\xi_B d E e d Ω ν d Γ ⊃ 16 π 4 κ E e ∣ k e ∣ ( E 0 − E e ) 2 J E ν J k ν ξ B in the differential distribution obtained after integrating Eq. (15) over the beta particle angles. In general, all these correlation coefficients are functions of the beta energy E e E_e E e , however, given the expression for the form factors in Eq. (14) , at leading order in recoil they are constant. For unpolarized decays, only the first line in Eq. (15) is relevant. Note that, at recoil order, the full distribution in Eq. (15) contains more information than that summarized in the correlation coefficients in Eq. (16) .
Finally, integrating Eq. (15) over all angular variables one obtains the beta spectrum:
d Γ d E e = κ E e ∣ k e ∣ ( E 0 − E e ) 2 4 π 3 { ( 1 + 3 E e m N ) N − E e − m e 2 E e m N N ′ } + O ( m N − 2 ) . (17) \frac{d\Gamma}{dE_e}=\frac{\kappa E_e|\mathbf{k}_e|(E_0-E_e)^2}{4\pi^3}\left\{\left(1+\frac{3E_e}{m_N}\right)\mathcal{N}-\frac{E_e-\frac{m_e^2}{E_e}}{m_N}\mathcal{N}'\right\}+O(m_N^{-2}). \tag*{(17)} d E e d Γ = 4 π 3 κ E e ∣ k e ∣ ( E 0 − E e ) 2 ⎩ ⎨ ⎧ ( 1 + m N 3 E e ) N − m N E e − E e m e 2 N ′ ⎭ ⎬ ⎫ + O ( m N − 2 ) . (17)
This depends only on two form factors: N \mathcal{N} N and ℵ \aleph ℵ . At leading order, the curly bracket in Eq. (17) contains only constant pieces, or, in the presence of exotic currents, terms proportional to m e E e \frac{m_e}{E_e} E e m e (the Fierz term). At first recoil order (that is O ( m N − 1 ) O(m_N^{-1}) O ( m N − 1 ) ), also terms linear in E e E_e E e appear.
Discussion
In this paper we have developed a new, convenient, fully Lorentz-covariant formalism to deal with allowed beta decay amplitudes. We have followed the EFT approach, consistently expanding the amplitudes in powers of the recoil momentum q q q . As a simple application, we derived the fully differential decay rate (after summing over beta and daughter polarizations) to leading order (O ( q 0 ) O(q^0) O ( q 0 ) ) and including the complete first-order (O ( q 1 ) O(q^1) O ( q 1 ) ) recoil corrections. Of course, not all the results regarding the differential distribution are new. The leading-order result was derived by Jackson, Treiman, and Wyld in Ref. [13 ] . Their parameters C X C_X C X and C X ′ C'_X C X ′ are related to our Wilson coefficients by C V , S i = C V , S + C V , S ′ C^i_{V,S}=C_{V,S}+C'_{V,S} C V , S i = C V , S + C V , S ′ , C A , T i = J J + 1 ( C A , T + C A , T ′ ) C^i_{A,T}=\sqrt{\frac{J}{J+1}}(C_{A,T}+C'_{A,T}) C A , T i = J + 1 J ( C A , T + C A , T ′ ) (the combinations C X − C X ′ C_X-C'_X C X − C X ′ have no counterparts in our paper because we do not consider right-handed neutrinos).
Furthermore, effects due to complete recoil corrections to standard currents were calculated by Holstein in the seminal Ref. [18 ] . For mixed Fermi-Gamow-Teller transitions, the results displayed in Eq. (14) (in the limit where exotic currents are neglected) are equivalent up to O ( q 2 ) O(q^2) O ( q 2 ) to the ones in Ref. [18 ] upon the following mapping of the parameters:
Table 5.1.
where the common normalization factor is x N ≡ V u d v 2 M F 2 x_N\equiv\frac{V_{ud}}{v^2M_F^2} x N ≡ v 2 M F 2 V u d . 10
It is also instructive to compare our formalism to that of Ref. [16 ] . That reference derives beta decay amplitudes from a nucleon-level NR-EFT Lagrangian organized as an expansion in ∇ / m N \nabla/m_N ∇/ m N , where ∇ \nabla ∇ is the spatial derivative, and m N ≡ m n + m p 2 m_N\equiv\frac{m_n+m_p}{2} m N ≡ 2 m n + m p is the nucleon mass. This is qualitatively distinct from the nucleus-level EFT employed in this work, with a different set of strengths and limitations. The starting point in [16 ] is the nucleon-level pionless NR-EFT Lagrangian with zero- and one-derivative interactions contributing to β \beta β decay.11
L N R − E F T = − ( ψ p † ψ n ) [ C V + ( e ˉ σ ˉ 0 ν ) + C S + ( e c ν ) ] + ( ψ p † σ k ψ n ) [ C A + ( e ˉ σ ˉ k ν ) + C T + ( e c σ 0 σ ˉ k ν ) ] + 1 2 m N { i C T 1 + ( ψ p † σ k ψ n ) ∇ k ( e c ν ) − C M + ϵ i j k ( ψ p † σ j ψ n ) ∇ i ( e ˉ σ ˉ k ν ) − i C E + ( ψ p † σ k ψ n ) ∇ k ( e ˉ σ ˉ 0 ν ) − i C T 1 + ( ψ p † ψ n ) ∇ k ( e c σ 0 σ ˉ k ν ) + i C T 2 + ( ψ p † ψ n ) ( e c ∂ ↔ t ν ) + 2 i C T 3 + ( ψ p † σ k ψ n ) ( e c ∇ ↔ k ν ) − i C F V + ( ψ p † ∇ ↔ k ψ n ) ( e ˉ σ ˉ k ν ) + i C F A + ( ψ p † σ k ∇ ↔ k ψ n ) ( e ˉ σ ˉ 0 ν ) + C F T + ϵ i j k ( ψ p † σ i ∇ ↔ j ψ n ) ( e c σ 0 σ ˉ k ν ) } + O ( ∇ 2 ) + h . c . , (18) \begin{aligned}
\mathcal{L}_{\mathrm{NR-EFT}}={}&-(\psi_p^\dagger\psi_n)\left[C_V^+(\bar e\bar\sigma^0\nu)+C_S^+(e^c\nu)\right]+(\psi_p^\dagger\sigma^k\psi_n)\left[C_A^+(\bar e\bar\sigma^k\nu)+C_T^+(e^c\sigma^0\bar\sigma^k\nu)\right]\\
&+\frac{1}{2m_N}\left\{iC_{T_1}^+(\psi_p^\dagger\sigma^k\psi_n)\nabla_k(e^c\nu)-C_M^+\epsilon^{ijk}(\psi_p^\dagger\sigma^j\psi_n)\nabla_i(\bar e\bar\sigma^k\nu)-iC_E^+(\psi_p^\dagger\sigma^k\psi_n)\nabla_k(\bar e\bar\sigma^0\nu)\right.\\
&\left.-iC_{T_1}^+(\psi_p^\dagger\psi_n)\nabla_k(e^c\sigma^0\bar\sigma^k\nu)+iC_{T_2}^+(\psi_p^\dagger\psi_n)(e^c\overleftrightarrow{\partial}_t\nu)+2iC_{T_3}^+(\psi_p^\dagger\sigma^k\psi_n)(e^c\overleftrightarrow{\nabla}_k\nu)\right.\\
&\left.-iC_{FV}^+(\psi_p^\dagger\overleftrightarrow{\nabla}_k\psi_n)(\bar e\bar\sigma^k\nu)+iC_{FA}^+(\psi_p^\dagger\sigma^k\overleftrightarrow{\nabla}_k\psi_n)(\bar e\bar\sigma^0\nu)+C_{FT}^+\epsilon^{ijk}(\psi_p^\dagger\sigma^i\overleftrightarrow{\nabla}_j\psi_n)(e^c\sigma^0\bar\sigma^k\nu)\right\}\\
&+\mathcal{O}(\nabla^2)+\mathrm{h.c.}, \tag*{(18)}
\end{aligned} L NR − EFT = − ( ψ p † ψ n ) [ C V + ( e ˉ σ ˉ 0 ν ) + C S + ( e c ν ) ] + ( ψ p † σ k ψ n ) [ C A + ( e ˉ σ ˉ k ν ) + C T + ( e c σ 0 σ ˉ k ν ) ] + 2 m N 1 { i C T 1 + ( ψ p † σ k ψ n ) ∇ k ( e c ν ) − C M + ϵ ij k ( ψ p † σ j ψ n ) ∇ i ( e ˉ σ ˉ k ν ) − i C E + ( ψ p † σ k ψ n ) ∇ k ( e ˉ σ ˉ 0 ν ) − i C T 1 + ( ψ p † ψ n ) ∇ k ( e c σ 0 σ ˉ k ν ) + i C T 2 + ( ψ p † ψ n ) ( e c ∂ t ν ) + 2 i C T 3 + ( ψ p † σ k ψ n ) ( e c ∇ k ν ) − i C F V + ( ψ p † ∇ k ψ n ) ( e ˉ σ ˉ k ν ) + i C F A + ( ψ p † σ k ∇ k ψ n ) ( e ˉ σ ˉ 0 ν ) + C F T + ϵ ij k ( ψ p † σ i ∇ j ψ n ) ( e c σ 0 σ ˉ k ν ) } + O ( ∇ 2 ) + h.c. , (18)
where f 1 Γ ∇ ↔ f 2 ≡ f 1 Γ ∇ f 2 − ∇ f 1 Γ f 2 f_1\Gamma\overleftrightarrow{\nabla}f_2\equiv f_1\Gamma\nabla f_2-\nabla f_1\Gamma f_2 f 1 Γ ∇ f 2 ≡ f 1 Γ∇ f 2 − ∇ f 1 Γ f 2 , the nucleon degrees of freedom are described by non-relativistic quantum fields ψ N \psi_N ψ N , N = p , n N=p,n N = p , n , while leptons are described by the relativistic fields ν \nu ν and e e e , e c e^c e c . Unlike C X i C_X^i C X i in the covariant formalism, the Wilson coefficients C X + C_X^+ C X + in Eq. (18) do not carry the nuclear-transition-dependent label i i i , as they are specifically related to neutron interactions. They can be matched to the parameters of the quark-level EFT in Eq. (B.1), with the non-perturbative information about matrix elements of quark currents between nucleon states summarized in the charges g X g_X g X [16 ] , many of which are known from lattice QCD or constrained by symmetries. In the NR-EFT approach the transition dependence enters via the matrix elements of nucleon bilinears between the nuclear states.
We can match our transition-dependent Wilson coefficients C X i C_X^i C X i to the nucleon-level parameters by equating beta decay amplitudes calculated in the two theories. The resulting map is given in Eq. (B.5). Then we can use the map in Ref. [16 ] between C X + C_X^+ C X + and the quark-level parameters to connect C X i C_X^i C X i to the more fundamental parameters in Eq. (B.1). The result is
C V i ≃ V u d v 2 g V ( 1 + ϵ L + ϵ R ) ( 1 + Δ 2 m N ) 1 + Δ R V , C_V^i \simeq\frac{V_{ud}}{v^2}g_V(1+\epsilon_L+\epsilon_R)\left(1+\frac{\Delta}{2m_N}\right)\sqrt{1+\Delta_R^V}, C V i ≃ v 2 V u d g V ( 1 + ϵ L + ϵ R ) ( 1 + 2 m N Δ ) 1 + Δ R V ,
C A i ≃ − V u d v 2 J J + 1 r i ( g A − Δ 2 m N g I T ) ( 1 + ϵ L − ϵ R ) 1 + Δ R A , C_A^i \simeq-\frac{V_{ud}}{v^2}\sqrt{\frac{J}{J+1}}r_i\left(g_A-\frac{\Delta}{2m_N}g_{IT}\right)(1+\epsilon_L-\epsilon_R)\sqrt{1+\Delta_R^A}, C A i ≃ − v 2 V u d J + 1 J r i ( g A − 2 m N Δ g I T ) ( 1 + ϵ L − ϵ R ) 1 + Δ R A ,
C S i ≃ V u d v 2 g S ϵ S , C_S^i \simeq\frac{V_{ud}}{v^2}g_S\epsilon_S, C S i ≃ v 2 V u d g S ϵ S ,
C T i ≃ V u d v 2 J J + 1 r i g T ϵ T ( 1 + Δ 2 m N ) , C_T^i \simeq\frac{V_{ud}}{v^2}\sqrt{\frac{J}{J+1}}r_i g_T\epsilon_T\left(1+\frac{\Delta}{2m_N}\right), C T i ≃ v 2 V u d J + 1 J r i g T ϵ T ( 1 + 2 m N Δ ) ,
C M i ≃ V u d v 2 J J + 1 r i A ( g M + β i g V ) ( 1 + ϵ L + ϵ R ) , C_M^i \simeq\frac{V_{ud}}{v^2}\sqrt{\frac{J}{J+1}}r_i A(g_M+\beta_i g_V)(1+\epsilon_L+\epsilon_R), C M i ≃ v 2 V u d J + 1 J r i A ( g M + β i g V ) ( 1 + ϵ L + ϵ R ) ,
C P i ≃ V u d v 2 J J + 1 r i A g P ϵ P , C_P^i \simeq\frac{V_{ud}}{v^2}\sqrt{\frac{J}{J+1}}r_i A g_P\epsilon_P, C P i ≃ v 2 V u d J + 1 J r i A g P ϵ P ,
C T ( 1 ) i ≃ V u d v 2 A ( g T − 2 g T ( 1 ) − α i g T ) ϵ T , C_{T(1)}^i \simeq\frac{V_{ud}}{v^2}A\left(g_T-2g_T^{(1)}-\alpha_i g_T\right)\epsilon_T, C T ( 1 ) i ≃ v 2 V u d A ( g T − 2 g T ( 1 ) − α i g T ) ϵ T ,
C I S i ≃ V u d v 2 A g I S ( 1 + ϵ L + ϵ R ) . C_{IS}^i \simeq\frac{V_{ud}}{v^2}A g_{IS}(1+\epsilon_L+\epsilon_R). C I S i ≃ v 2 V u d A g I S ( 1 + ϵ L + ϵ R ) .
C I T i ≃ − V u d v 2 J J + 1 r i A g I T ( 1 + ϵ L − ϵ R ) , C T ( 2 ) i ≃ 4 V u d v 2 J J + 1 r i A g T ( 3 ) ϵ T . (19) C^{i}_{IT} \simeq-\frac{V_{ud}}{v^2}\sqrt{\frac{J}{J+1}}r_i A g_{IT}(1+\epsilon_L-\epsilon_R), \\
C^{i}_{T(2)} \simeq4\frac{V_{ud}}{v^2}\sqrt{\frac{J}{J+1}}r_i A g^{(3)}_{T}\epsilon_T. \tag*{(19)} C I T i ≃ − v 2 V u d J + 1 J r i A g I T ( 1 + ϵ L − ϵ R ) , C T ( 2 ) i ≃ 4 v 2 V u d J + 1 J r i A g T ( 3 ) ϵ T . (19)
Above, the transition-dependent parameters r i r_i r i , α i \alpha_i α i , and β i \beta_i β i parametrize matrix elements of nucleon operators, which are defined in Eq. (B.4). r i r_i r i is often called the ratio of the Gamow–Teller to Fermi matrix elements , while the other two appear in subleading matrix elements. The nucleon charges g X g_X g X are defined by the matrix elements of quark bilinears between nucleon states, see Eq. (B.3). For the subleading Wilson coefficients we only retain the leading recoil order matching, while for the leading ones we also track first recoil corrections. For C V i C^{i}_{V} C V i and C A i C^{i}_{A} C A i we display for completeness the radiative corrections to the matching parametrized by Δ R V \Delta^{V}_{R} Δ R V [32 ] and Δ R A \Delta^{A}_{R} Δ R A [28 ] , while such effects are ignored for the remaining Wilson coefficients. The ≃ \simeq ≃ sign signals that these matching equations hold up to isospin-breaking corrections to the nuclear matrix elements of nucleon bilinears, which are not included in Ref. [16 ] . They also do not take into account two-body current effects [16 ] . Nevertheless, they give an approximate picture of the expected transition dependence of the nuclear-level Wilson coefficients C X i C^{i}_{X} C X i . In particular, C V i C^{i}_{V} C V i and C S i C^{i}_{S} C S i are approximately the same for all Fermi or mixed Fermi-Gamow-Teller transitions, while the same parameter r i r_i r i controls the leading order axial and tensor coefficients, so that their ratio is approximately fixed for all beta decays: C T i / C A i ≈ − g T ϵ T g A ( 1 + ϵ L − ϵ R ) C^{i}_{T}/C^{i}_{A} \approx-\frac{g_T\epsilon_T}{g_A(1+\epsilon_L-\epsilon_R)} C T i / C A i ≈ − g A ( 1 + ϵ L − ϵ R ) g T ϵ T . On the other hand, the ratio of pseudoscalar to axial coefficients in this approximation is proportional to the mass number A A A : C P i / C A i ≈ − A g P ϵ P g A ( 1 + ϵ L − ϵ R ) C^{i}_{P}/C^{i}_{A} \approx-A\frac{g_P\epsilon_P}{g_A(1+\epsilon_L-\epsilon_R)} C P i / C A i ≈ − A g A ( 1 + ϵ L − ϵ R ) g P ϵ P . Similar scaling is present for the coefficient responsible for weak magnetism [23 ] : C M i / C A i ≈ − A g M + β i g V g A C^{i}_{M}/C^{i}_{A} \approx-A\frac{g_M+\beta_i g_V}{g_A} C M i / C A i ≈ − A g A g M + β i g V in the SM limit ϵ X = 0 \epsilon_X=0 ϵ X = 0 . For mirror decays we can use the isospin symmetry prediction for C M i C^{i}_{M} C M i together with phenomenological determinations of C A i C^{i}_{A} C A i to extract β i \beta_i β i , confirming it is an O ( 1 ) O(1) O ( 1 ) parameter for a wide range of transitions, so that it does not affect the overall scaling. The overall scale of the Wilson coefficients is set by 1 v 2 \frac{1}{v^2} v 2 1 at leading order, and A v 2 = m N m N v 2 \frac{A}{v^2}=\frac{m_N}{m_Nv^2} v 2 A = m N v 2 m N at subleading order, demonstrating that the dimensionless expansion parameter of the EFT is really the recoil momentum over the nucleon (rather than nuclear) mass m N m_N m N .
Conclusions and outlook
In this paper we have proposed a novel treatment of nuclear beta decay. It makes use of the on-shell spinor-helicity formalism for massive and massless particles to conveniently handle arbitrary spins of the parent and daughter nuclei. The formalism allows one to write down beta decay amplitudes in a manifestly Lorentz-invariant and little-group-covariant fashion. From these, the usual observables such as the half-life, beta spectrum, and angular correlations can be readily obtained. By construction, the observables can be calculated in any reference frame, not only in the rest frame of the parent nucleus.
Applied to allowed beta decay, we have employed an EFT approach, systematically expanding the amplitudes through linear order in the recoil momentum q q q (where the dimensionless expansion parameters are q / m N q/m_N q / m N and q / m N q/m_N q / m N , with m N m_N m N and m N m_N m N being the parent nucleus and nucleon mass). The most general form of the hadronic currents (which fully determine the amplitudes via Eq. (3) to that order is given in Eqs. (10) and (12) . In this formulation, the complete spin dependence of the currents relevant at this order is covariantly encoded in rank-1 and rank-2 tensors S μ S^\mu S μ and S μ ν S^{\mu\nu} S μν , which are built from the massive spinors characterizing the parent nucleus. In the rest frame these reduce to more familiar spin matrices which can be built from Clebsch-Gordan coefficients following the usual rules of spin algebra. In that frame, the Wilson coefficients of the standard currents are in one-to-one correspondence with the a … f a\ldots f a … f parameters of Ref. [18 ] , cf. Eq. (5.1). The complete characterization of exotic (scalar, pseudoscalar, tensor) currents at the first recoil order is new.
Using our formalism, we calculated the fully differential distribution for allowed beta decay after summing over the polarizations of the daughter nucleus and the beta particle. That distribution can be characterized in a Lorentz-invariant way by a set of scalar form factors defined in Eq. (13) , which are functions of the kinematic invariants. In the rest frame one recovers the known spectral functions of Ref. [18 ] in the limit where exotic currents are set to zero. We also connect our covariant formalism to the NR-EFT approach of Ref. [16 ] . This in particular makes transparent the leading transition dependence of the Wilson coefficients, cf. Eq. (19) .
There are several directions to go from here. It would be interesting to link our Wilson coefficients to nuclear-structure calculations, enabling systematic predictions for the coefficients. Furthermore, the on-shell spinor-helicity formalism is very convenient for higher-order calculations. Our approach can be readily extended to the second order in recoil. Moreover, we can tap into the toolbox of (generalized) unitarity to calculate loop corrections to the differential distributions (see Ref. [17 ] for an application to the calculation of the Coulomb corrections to the D D D parameter). Finally, working along similar lines, the covariant formalism leads to a particularly transparent and convenient formulation of forbidden beta decays [33 ] , where fewer results are currently known in the literature.
Acknowledgements
We are grateful to Martín González-Alonso and Ajdin Palavrić for useful discussions and comments on the manuscript. SCA is supported by the Generalitat Valenciana (Spain) through the plan GenT program (CIDEGENT/2021/037) and by MCIU/AEI/10.13039/501100011033 (grants CEX2023-001292-S and PID2023-146220NB100). AF has received funding from the IN2P3 (CNRS) Master Project On-shell techniques for forbidden nuclear decay .
Useful spinor identities
Spin vector and tensors
In our conventions the spin pseudovector S μ S^\mu S μ is a matrix in the little group space. For J ≥ 1 / 2 J \ge1/2 J ≥ 1/2 it is defined as
[ S μ ] O 1 … O 2 J I 1 … I 2 J ≡ − J 2 m N [ χ 1 O 1 σ μ χ ~ 1 I 1 + χ ~ 1 O 1 σ ˉ μ χ 1 I 1 ] δ O 2 I 2 … δ O 2 J I 2 J . (20) \left[S^\mu\right]^{I_1\ldots I_{2J}}_{O_1\ldots O_{2J}} \equiv-\frac{J}{2m_N}\left[\chi_1 O_1 \sigma^\mu\widetilde{\chi}^{I_1}_1+\widetilde{\chi}_1 O_1 \bar{\sigma}^\mu\chi^{I_1}_1\right]\delta^{I_2}_{O_2}\ldots\delta^{I_{2J}}_{O_{2J}}. \tag*{(20)} [ S μ ] O 1 … O 2 J I 1 … I 2 J ≡ − 2 m N J [ χ 1 O 1 σ μ χ 1 I 1 + χ 1 O 1 σ ˉ μ χ 1 I 1 ] δ O 2 I 2 … δ O 2 J I 2 J . (20)
Here and everywhere below, the upper and lower little group indices are, independently, implicitly fully symmetrized. The spin vector is transverse: p 1 μ S μ = 0 p_1^\mu S_\mu= 0 p 1 μ S μ = 0 , and satisfies S μ S μ = − J ( J + 1 ) 1 S^\mu S_\mu= -J(J+1)\mathbf{1} S μ S μ = − J ( J + 1 ) 1 . This object encodes information about the polarization of the parent nucleus.
For J ≥ n / 2 J \ge n/2 J ≥ n /2 we can also define a family of rank-n n n Lorentz tensors transforming covariantly under the little group. For our purpose we explicitly need the rank-two and rank-three tensors:
[ S μ ν ] O 1 … O 2 J I 1 … I 2 J = J ( J − 1 2 ) ( 2 m N ) 2 [ χ 1 O 1 σ μ χ ~ 1 I 1 + χ ~ 1 O 1 σ ˉ μ χ 1 I 1 ] [ χ 1 O 2 σ ν χ ~ 1 I 2 + χ ~ 1 O 2 σ ˉ ν χ 1 I 2 ] δ O 3 I 3 ⋯ δ O 2 J I 2 J + J ( J − 1 2 ) 3 Π μ ν δ O 1 I 1 ⋯ δ O 2 J I 2 J , \left[S^{\mu\nu}\right]^{I_1\ldots I_{2J}}_{O_1\ldots O_{2J}} = \frac{J\left(J-\frac{1}{2}\right)}{(2m_N)^2}\left[\chi_{1O_1}\sigma^\mu\tilde{\chi}_1^{I_1}+\tilde{\chi}_{1O_1}\bar{\sigma}^\mu\chi_1^{I_1}\right]\left[\chi_{1O_2}\sigma^\nu\tilde{\chi}_1^{I_2}+\tilde{\chi}_{1O_2}\bar{\sigma}^\nu\chi_1^{I_2}\right]\delta^{I_3}_{O_3}\cdots\delta^{I_{2J}}_{O_{2J}}+\frac{J\left(J-\frac{1}{2}\right)}{3}\Pi^{\mu\nu}\delta^{I_1}_{O_1}\cdots\delta^{I_{2J}}_{O_{2J}}, [ S μν ] O 1 … O 2 J I 1 … I 2 J = ( 2 m N ) 2 J ( J − 2 1 ) [ χ 1 O 1 σ μ χ ~ 1 I 1 + χ ~ 1 O 1 σ ˉ μ χ 1 I 1 ] [ χ 1 O 2 σ ν χ ~ 1 I 2 + χ ~ 1 O 2 σ ˉ ν χ 1 I 2 ] δ O 3 I 3 ⋯ δ O 2 J I 2 J + 3 J ( J − 2 1 ) Π μν δ O 1 I 1 ⋯ δ O 2 J I 2 J ,
{#eq:A.2}
\left[S^{\mu\nu\rho}\right]^{I_1\ldots I_{2J}}_{O_1\ldots O_{2J}} = -\frac{J\left(J-\frac{1}{2}\right)(J-1)}{(2m_N)^3}\left[\chi_{1O_1}\sigma^\mu\tilde{\chi}_1^{I_1}+\tilde{\chi}_{1O_1}\bar{\sigma}^\mu\chi_1^{I_1}\right]\left[\chi_{1O_2}\sigma^\nu\tilde{\chi}_1^{I_2}+\tilde{\chi}_{1O_2}\bar{\sigma}^\nu\chi_1^{I_2}\right]\left[\chi_{1O_3}\sigma^\rho\tilde{\chi}_1^{I_3}+\tilde{\chi}_{1O_3}\bar{\sigma}^\rho\chi_1^{I_3}\right]\delta^{I_4}_{O_4}\cdots\delta^{I_{2J}}_{O_{2J}}+\frac{(J-1)(J-\frac{1}{2})}{5}\left[\Pi^{\mu\nu}S^\rho+\Pi^{\mu\rho}S^\nu+\Pi^{\nu\rho}S^\mu\right]^{I_1\ldots I_{2J}}_{O_1\ldots O_{2J}},
where Π μ ν ≡ η μ ν − p 1 μ p 1 ν m N 2 \Pi^{\mu\nu}\equiv\eta^{\mu\nu}-\frac{p_1^\mu p_1^\nu}{m_N^2} Π μν ≡ η μν − m N 2 p 1 μ p 1 ν . These are symmetric in all Lorentz indices. Much as the spin vector, the spin tensors are transverse: p 1 μ i S μ 1 … μ i … μ n = 0 p_1^{\mu_i}S_{\mu_1\ldots\mu_i\ldots\mu_n}=0 p 1 μ i S μ 1 … μ i … μ n = 0 . Furthermore, they are traceless: η μ i μ j S μ 1 … μ i … μ j … μ n = 0 \eta^{\mu_i\mu_j}S_{\mu_1\ldots\mu_i\ldots\mu_j\ldots\mu_n}=0 η μ i μ j S μ 1 … μ i … μ j … μ n = 0 .
For the sake of calculating differential distributions, we use the following rules for multiplying spin vectors and tensors:
S μ S ν = − J ( J + 1 ) 3 Π μ ν + i 2 m N ϵ μ ν α β p 1 α S β + S μ ν S^\mu S^\nu=-\frac{J(J+1)}{3}\Pi^{\mu\nu}+\frac{i}{2m_N}\epsilon^{\mu\nu\alpha\beta}p_{1\alpha}S_\beta+S^{\mu\nu} S μ S ν = − 3 J ( J + 1 ) Π μν + 2 m N i ϵ μν α β p 1 α S β + S μν
S μ S ν ρ = − ( 2 J − 1 ) ( 2 J + 3 ) 20 ( Π μ ν S ρ + Π μ ρ S ν − 2 3 Π ν ρ S μ ) − i 2 m N ϵ μ ν α β p 1 α S β ρ − i 2 m N ϵ μ ρ α β p 1 α S β ν + S μ ν ρ , (21) S^\mu S^{\nu\rho}=-\frac{(2J-1)(2J+3)}{20}\left(\Pi^{\mu\nu}S^\rho+\Pi^{\mu\rho}S^\nu-\frac{2}{3}\Pi^{\nu\rho}S^\mu\right)-\frac{i}{2m_N}\epsilon^{\mu\nu\alpha\beta}p_{1\alpha}S_\beta{}^\rho-\frac{i}{2m_N}\epsilon^{\mu\rho\alpha\beta}p_{1\alpha}S_\beta{}^\nu+S^{\mu\nu\rho}, \tag*{(21)} S μ S ν ρ = − 20 ( 2 J − 1 ) ( 2 J + 3 ) ( Π μν S ρ + Π μ ρ S ν − 3 2 Π ν ρ S μ ) − 2 m N i ϵ μν α β p 1 α S β ρ − 2 m N i ϵ μ ρ α β p 1 α S β ν + S μν ρ , (21)
where
[ S μ 1 … μ s ν 1 … ν s ] O 1 … O 2 J I 1 … I 2 J ≡ ∑ K 1 … K 2 J = 1 2 [ S μ 1 … μ s ] K 1 … K 2 J I 1 … I 2 J [ S ν 1 … ν s ] O 1 … O 2 J K 1 … K 2 J . \left[S^{\mu_1\ldots\mu_s\nu_1\ldots\nu_s}\right]^{I_1\ldots I_{2J}}_{O_1\ldots O_{2J}}\equiv\sum_{K_1\ldots K_{2J}=1}^{2}\left[S^{\mu_1\ldots\mu_s}\right]^{I_1\ldots I_{2J}}_{K_1\ldots K_{2J}}\left[S^{\nu_1\ldots\nu_s}\right]^{K_1\ldots K_{2J}}_{O_1\ldots O_{2J}}. [ S μ 1 … μ s ν 1 … ν s ] O 1 … O 2 J I 1 … I 2 J ≡ K 1 … K 2 J = 1 ∑ 2 [ S μ 1 … μ s ] K 1 … K 2 J I 1 … I 2 J [ S ν 1 … ν s ] O 1 … O 2 J K 1 … K 2 J .
Leptonic sum rules
Here we present the leptonic sum rules used for calculating differential distributions. Summation ∑ K = 1 2 \sum_{K=1}^{2} ∑ K = 1 2 of the little group index K K K is implicit on the left-hand side of all equations, which corresponds to summing over two polarizations of the beta particle.
( χ ~ 3 K σ ˉ μ λ 4 ) ( χ ~ 3 K σ ˉ ν λ 4 ) ∗ = 2 [ p 3 μ p 4 ν + p 3 ν p 4 μ − η μ ν ( p 3 p 4 ) − i ϵ μ ν α β p 3 α p 4 β ] , (\tilde{\chi}_{3K}\bar{\sigma}^{\mu}\lambda_4)(\tilde{\chi}_{3K}\bar{\sigma}^{\nu}\lambda_4)^*=2\left[p_3^\mu p_4^\nu+p_3^\nu p_4^\mu-\eta^{\mu\nu}(p_3p_4)-i\epsilon^{\mu\nu\alpha\beta}p_{3\alpha}p_{4\beta}\right], ( χ ~ 3 K σ ˉ μ λ 4 ) ( χ ~ 3 K σ ˉ ν λ 4 ) ∗ = 2 [ p 3 μ p 4 ν + p 3 ν p 4 μ − η μν ( p 3 p 4 ) − i ϵ μν α β p 3 α p 4 β ] ,
( χ ~ 3 K σ ˉ μ λ 4 ) ∗ ( χ ~ 3 K σ ˉ ν λ 4 ) = 2 [ p 3 μ p 4 ν + p 3 ν p 4 μ − η μ ν ( p 3 p 4 ) + i ϵ μ ν α β p 3 α p 4 β ] . (22) (\tilde{\chi}_3^K\bar{\sigma}^{\mu}\lambda_4)^*(\tilde{\chi}_3^K\bar{\sigma}^{\nu}\lambda_4)=2\left[p_3^\mu p_4^\nu+p_3^\nu p_4^\mu-\eta^{\mu\nu}(p_3p_4)+i\epsilon^{\mu\nu\alpha\beta}p_{3\alpha}p_{4\beta}\right]. \tag*{(22)} ( χ ~ 3 K σ ˉ μ λ 4 ) ∗ ( χ ~ 3 K σ ˉ ν λ 4 ) = 2 [ p 3 μ p 4 ν + p 3 ν p 4 μ − η μν ( p 3 p 4 ) + i ϵ μν α β p 3 α p 4 β ] . (22)
( χ ~ 3 K σ ˉ μ λ 4 ) ( χ 3 K λ 4 ) ∗ = − 2 m e p 4 μ , (\tilde{\chi}_{3K}\bar{\sigma}^{\mu}\lambda_4)(\chi_3^K\lambda_4)^*=-2m_e p_4^\mu, ( χ ~ 3 K σ ˉ μ λ 4 ) ( χ 3 K λ 4 ) ∗ = − 2 m e p 4 μ ,
( χ ~ 3 K σ ˉ μ λ 4 ) ∗ ( χ 3 K λ 4 ) = − 2 m e p 4 μ . (23) (\tilde{\chi}_3^K\bar{\sigma}^{\mu}\lambda_4)^*(\chi_3^K\lambda_4)=-2m_e p_4^\mu. \tag*{(23)} ( χ ~ 3 K σ ˉ μ λ 4 ) ∗ ( χ 3 K λ 4 ) = − 2 m e p 4 μ . (23)
( χ ~ 3 κ σ μ λ 4 ) ( χ 3 κ σ α β λ 4 ) ∗ = 2 i m e [ η μ α η β ρ − η μ β η α ρ + i ϵ μ α β ρ ] p 4 ρ , ( χ ~ 3 κ σ μ λ 4 ) ∗ ( χ 3 κ σ α β λ 4 ) = 2 i m e [ − η μ α η β ρ + η μ β η α ρ + i ϵ μ α β ρ ] p 4 ρ , (24) \begin{aligned}
(\widetilde{\chi}_3\kappa\sigma^\mu\lambda_4)(\chi_3\kappa\sigma^{\alpha\beta}\lambda_4)^*&=2im_e\left[\eta^{\mu\alpha}\eta^{\beta\rho}-\eta^{\mu\beta}\eta^{\alpha\rho}+i\epsilon^{\mu\alpha\beta\rho}\right]p_{4\rho},\\
(\widetilde{\chi}_3\kappa\sigma^\mu\lambda_4)^*(\chi_3\kappa\sigma^{\alpha\beta}\lambda_4)&=2im_e\left[-\eta^{\mu\alpha}\eta^{\beta\rho}+\eta^{\mu\beta}\eta^{\alpha\rho}+i\epsilon^{\mu\alpha\beta\rho}\right]p_{4\rho}, \tag*{(24)}
\end{aligned} ( χ 3 κ σ μ λ 4 ) ( χ 3 κ σ α β λ 4 ) ∗ ( χ 3 κ σ μ λ 4 ) ∗ ( χ 3 κ σ α β λ 4 ) = 2 i m e [ η μα η β ρ − η μ β η α ρ + i ϵ μα β ρ ] p 4 ρ , = 2 i m e [ − η μα η β ρ + η μ β η α ρ + i ϵ μα β ρ ] p 4 ρ , (24)
( χ 3 κ λ 4 ) ( χ 3 κ λ 4 ) ∗ = ( 2 p 3 p 4 ) , ( χ 3 K λ 4 ) ∗ ( χ 3 K λ 4 ) = ( 2 p 3 p 4 ) . (25) \begin{aligned}
(\chi_3\kappa\lambda_4)(\chi_3\kappa\lambda_4)^*&=(2p_3p_4),\\
(\chi_3^K\lambda_4)^*(\chi_3^K\lambda_4)&=(2p_3p_4). \tag*{(25)}
\end{aligned} ( χ 3 κ λ 4 ) ( χ 3 κ λ 4 ) ∗ ( χ 3 K λ 4 ) ∗ ( χ 3 K λ 4 ) = ( 2 p 3 p 4 ) , = ( 2 p 3 p 4 ) . (25)
( χ 3 κ σ μ ν λ 4 ) ( χ 3 κ λ 4 ) ∗ = 2 i [ p 3 μ p 4 ν − p 3 ν p 4 μ − i ϵ μ ν α β p 3 α p 4 β ] , ( χ 3 K σ μ ν λ 4 ) ∗ ( χ 3 K λ 4 ) = 2 i [ − p 3 μ p 4 ν + p 3 ν p 4 μ − i ϵ μ ν α β p 3 α p 4 β ] . (26) \begin{aligned}
(\chi_3\kappa\sigma^{\mu\nu}\lambda_4)(\chi_3\kappa\lambda_4)^*&=2i\left[p_3^\mu p_4^\nu-p_3^\nu p_4^\mu-i\epsilon^{\mu\nu\alpha\beta}p_{3\alpha}p_{4\beta}\right],\\
(\chi_3^K\sigma^{\mu\nu}\lambda_4)^*(\chi_3^K\lambda_4)&=2i\left[-p_3^\mu p_4^\nu+p_3^\nu p_4^\mu-i\epsilon^{\mu\nu\alpha\beta}p_{3\alpha}p_{4\beta}\right]. \tag*{(26)}
\end{aligned} ( χ 3 κ σ μν λ 4 ) ( χ 3 κ λ 4 ) ∗ ( χ 3 K σ μν λ 4 ) ∗ ( χ 3 K λ 4 ) = 2 i [ p 3 μ p 4 ν − p 3 ν p 4 μ − i ϵ μν α β p 3 α p 4 β ] , = 2 i [ − p 3 μ p 4 ν + p 3 ν p 4 μ − i ϵ μν α β p 3 α p 4 β ] . (26)
( χ 3 κ σ μ ν λ 4 ) ( χ 3 κ σ α β λ 4 ) ∗ = 2 { η μ β p 3 α p 4 ν + η ν α p 3 β p 4 μ − η ν β p 3 α p 4 μ − η μ α p 3 β p 4 ν + η μ β p 3 ν p 4 α + η ν α p 3 μ p 4 β − η ν β p 3 μ p 4 α − η μ α p 3 ν p 4 β + ( p 3 p 4 ) [ η μ α η ν β − η μ β η ν α ] + i ϵ μ ν α β p 4 A p 3 α − i ϵ μ ν α α p 4 A p 3 β + i ϵ ν α β A p 3 A p 4 μ − i ϵ μ α β A p 3 A p 4 ν } , \begin{aligned}
(\chi_3\kappa\sigma^{\mu\nu}\lambda_4)(\chi_3\kappa\sigma^{\alpha\beta}\lambda_4)^*
=2\Big\{&
\eta^{\mu\beta}p_3^\alpha p_4^\nu+\eta^{\nu\alpha}p_3^\beta p_4^\mu-\eta^{\nu\beta}p_3^\alpha p_4^\mu-\eta^{\mu\alpha}p_3^\beta p_4^\nu\\
&+\eta^{\mu\beta}p_3^\nu p_4^\alpha+\eta^{\nu\alpha}p_3^\mu p_4^\beta-\eta^{\nu\beta}p_3^\mu p_4^\alpha-\eta^{\mu\alpha}p_3^\nu p_4^\beta\\
&+(p_3p_4)\left[\eta^{\mu\alpha}\eta^{\nu\beta}-\eta^{\mu\beta}\eta^{\nu\alpha}\right]\\
&+i\epsilon^{\mu\nu\alpha\beta}p_{4A}p_3^\alpha-i\epsilon^{\mu\nu\alpha\alpha}p_{4A}p_3^\beta+i\epsilon^{\nu\alpha\beta A}p_{3A}p_4^\mu-i\epsilon^{\mu\alpha\beta A}p_{3A}p_4^\nu
\Big\},
\end{aligned} ( χ 3 κ σ μν λ 4 ) ( χ 3 κ σ α β λ 4 ) ∗ = 2 { η μ β p 3 α p 4 ν + η ν α p 3 β p 4 μ − η ν β p 3 α p 4 μ − η μα p 3 β p 4 ν + η μ β p 3 ν p 4 α + η ν α p 3 μ p 4 β − η ν β p 3 μ p 4 α − η μα p 3 ν p 4 β + ( p 3 p 4 ) [ η μα η ν β − η μ β η ν α ] + i ϵ μν α β p 4 A p 3 α − i ϵ μν α α p 4 A p 3 β + i ϵ ν α β A p 3 A p 4 μ − i ϵ μα β A p 3 A p 4 ν } ,
( χ 3 K σ μ ν λ 4 ) ∗ ( χ 3 K σ α β λ 4 ) = − 2 { η ν β p 3 α p 4 μ − η μ β p 3 α p 4 ν − η ν α p 3 β p 4 μ + η μ α p 3 β p 4 ν + η ν β p 3 μ p 4 α − η μ β p 3 ν p 4 α − η ν α p 3 μ p 4 β + η μ α p 3 ν p 4 β + ( p 3 p 4 ) [ η μ β η ν α − η μ α η ν β ] − i ϵ μ ν α α p 4 A p 3 β + i ϵ μ ν α β p 4 A p 3 α − i ϵ μ α β A p 3 A p 4 ν + i ϵ ν α β A p 3 A p 4 μ } . (27) \begin{aligned}
(\chi_3^K\sigma^{\mu\nu}\lambda_4)^*(\chi_3^K\sigma^{\alpha\beta}\lambda_4)
=-2\Big\{&
\eta^{\nu\beta}p_3^\alpha p_4^\mu-\eta^{\mu\beta}p_3^\alpha p_4^\nu-\eta^{\nu\alpha}p_3^\beta p_4^\mu+\eta^{\mu\alpha}p_3^\beta p_4^\nu\\
&+\eta^{\nu\beta}p_3^\mu p_4^\alpha-\eta^{\mu\beta}p_3^\nu p_4^\alpha-\eta^{\nu\alpha}p_3^\mu p_4^\beta+\eta^{\mu\alpha}p_3^\nu p_4^\beta\\
&+(p_3p_4)\left[\eta^{\mu\beta}\eta^{\nu\alpha}-\eta^{\mu\alpha}\eta^{\nu\beta}\right]\\
&-i\epsilon^{\mu\nu\alpha\alpha}p_{4A}p_3^\beta+i\epsilon^{\mu\nu\alpha\beta}p_{4A}p_3^\alpha-i\epsilon^{\mu\alpha\beta A}p_{3A}p_4^\nu+i\epsilon^{\nu\alpha\beta A}p_{3A}p_4^\mu
\Big\}. \tag*{(27)}
\end{aligned} ( χ 3 K σ μν λ 4 ) ∗ ( χ 3 K σ α β λ 4 ) = − 2 { η ν β p 3 α p 4 μ − η μ β p 3 α p 4 ν − η ν α p 3 β p 4 μ + η μα p 3 β p 4 ν + η ν β p 3 μ p 4 α − η μ β p 3 ν p 4 α − η ν α p 3 μ p 4 β + η μα p 3 ν p 4 β + ( p 3 p 4 ) [ η μ β η ν α − η μα η ν β ] − i ϵ μν α α p 4 A p 3 β + i ϵ μν α β p 4 A p 3 α − i ϵ μα β A p 3 A p 4 ν + i ϵ ν α β A p 3 A p 4 μ } . (27)
Recoil expansion of spinor bilinears
For q 2 < 4 m N 2 q^2<4m_N^2 q 2 < 4 m N 2 , the massive spinors describing the two nuclei can be related as [34 , 35 ]
χ 2 = − 1 1 − q 2 4 m N 2 [ χ 1 − q σ 2 m N χ ~ 1 ] , χ ~ 2 = 1 1 − q 2 4 m N 2 [ χ ~ 1 − q σ ‾ 2 m N χ 1 ] . (28) \begin{aligned}
\chi_2&=-\frac{1}{\sqrt{1-\frac{q^2}{4m_N^2}}}\left[\chi_1-\frac{q\sigma}{2m_N}\widetilde{\chi}_1\right],\\
\widetilde{\chi}_2&=\frac{1}{\sqrt{1-\frac{q^2}{4m_N^2}}}\left[\widetilde{\chi}_1-\frac{q\overline{\sigma}}{2m_N}\chi_1\right]. \tag*{(28)}
\end{aligned} χ 2 χ 2 = − 1 − 4 m N 2 q 2 1 [ χ 1 − 2 m N q σ χ 1 ] , = 1 − 4 m N 2 q 2 1 [ χ 1 − 2 m N q σ χ 1 ] . (28)
This relation implies identification of the little group frames of the two particles. It allows one to expand spinor bilinears in powers of q q q :
χ 2 χ 1 + χ ~ 2 χ ~ 1 = 2 m N 1 + O ( q 2 ) , \chi_2\chi_1+\widetilde{\chi}_2\widetilde{\chi}_1=2m_N1+O(q^2), χ 2 χ 1 + χ 2 χ 1 = 2 m N 1 + O ( q 2 ) ,
χ 2 χ 1 − χ ~ 2 χ ~ 1 = − 1 2 m N [ χ 1 q σ χ ~ 1 + χ ~ 1 q σ ‾ χ 1 ] + O ( q 2 ) , \chi_2\chi_1-\widetilde{\chi}_2\widetilde{\chi}_1=-\frac{1}{2m_N}\left[\chi_1q\sigma\widetilde{\chi}_1+\widetilde{\chi}_1q\overline{\sigma}\chi_1\right]+O(q^2), χ 2 χ 1 − χ 2 χ 1 = − 2 m N 1 [ χ 1 q σ χ 1 + χ 1 q σ χ 1 ] + O ( q 2 ) ,
χ 2 σ μ χ ~ 1 + χ ~ 2 σ ‾ μ χ 1 = ( p 1 − p 2 ) μ 1 − i 2 m N 2 ϵ μ ν α β q β p 1 α [ χ 1 σ ρ χ ~ 1 + χ ~ 1 σ ‾ ρ χ 1 ] + O ( q 2 ) , \chi_2\sigma^\mu\widetilde{\chi}_1+\widetilde{\chi}_2\overline{\sigma}^\mu\chi_1=(p_1-p_2)^\mu1-\frac{i}{2m_N^2}\epsilon^{\mu\nu\alpha\beta}q_\beta p_{1\alpha}\left[\chi_1\sigma^\rho\widetilde{\chi}_1+\widetilde{\chi}_1\overline{\sigma}^\rho\chi_1\right]+O(q^2), χ 2 σ μ χ 1 + χ 2 σ μ χ 1 = ( p 1 − p 2 ) μ 1 − 2 m N 2 i ϵ μν α β q β p 1 α [ χ 1 σ ρ χ 1 + χ 1 σ ρ χ 1 ] + O ( q 2 ) ,
χ 2 σ μ χ ~ 1 − χ ~ 2 σ ˉ μ χ 1 = − [ χ 1 σ μ χ ~ 1 + χ ~ 1 σ ˉ μ χ 1 ] − p 1 μ 2 m N 2 [ χ 1 q σ χ ~ 1 + χ ~ 1 q σ ˉ χ 1 ] + O ( q 2 ) , \chi_{2}\sigma^{\mu}\widetilde{\chi}_{1}-\widetilde{\chi}_{2}\bar{\sigma}^{\mu}\chi_{1}=-\left[\chi_{1}\sigma^{\mu}\widetilde{\chi}_{1}+\widetilde{\chi}_{1}\bar{\sigma}^{\mu}\chi_{1}\right]-\frac{p_{1}^{\mu}}{2m_{N}^{2}}\left[\chi_{1}q\sigma\widetilde{\chi}_{1}+\widetilde{\chi}_{1}q\bar{\sigma}\chi_{1}\right]+\mathcal{O}(q^{2}), χ 2 σ μ χ 1 − χ 2 σ ˉ μ χ 1 = − [ χ 1 σ μ χ 1 + χ 1 σ ˉ μ χ 1 ] − 2 m N 2 p 1 μ [ χ 1 q σ χ 1 + χ 1 q σ ˉ χ 1 ] + O ( q 2 ) ,
χ 2 σ μ ν χ 1 + χ ~ 2 σ ˉ μ ν χ ~ 1 = 1 m N ϵ μ ν α β p 1 α [ χ 1 σ β χ ~ 1 + χ ~ 1 σ ˉ β χ 1 ] + i m N ( p 1 μ q ν − p 1 ν q μ ) 1 \chi_{2}\sigma^{\mu\nu}\chi_{1}+\widetilde{\chi}_{2}\bar{\sigma}^{\mu\nu}\widetilde{\chi}_{1}=\frac{1}{m_{N}}\epsilon^{\mu\nu\alpha\beta}p_{1\alpha}\left[\chi_{1}\sigma_{\beta}\widetilde{\chi}_{1}+\widetilde{\chi}_{1}\bar{\sigma}_{\beta}\chi_{1}\right]+\frac{i}{m_{N}}\left(p_{1}^{\mu}q^{\nu}-p_{1}^{\nu}q^{\mu}\right)\mathbf{1} χ 2 σ μν χ 1 + χ 2 σ ˉ μν χ 1 = m N 1 ϵ μν α β p 1 α [ χ 1 σ β χ 1 + χ 1 σ ˉ β χ 1 ] + m N i ( p 1 μ q ν − p 1 ν q μ ) 1
− 1 2 m N ϵ μ ν α β q α [ χ 1 σ β χ ~ 1 + χ ~ 1 σ ˉ β χ 1 ] + O ( q 2 ) , -\frac{1}{2m_{N}}\epsilon^{\mu\nu\alpha\beta}q_{\alpha}\left[\chi_{1}\sigma_{\beta}\widetilde{\chi}_{1}+\widetilde{\chi}_{1}\bar{\sigma}_{\beta}\chi_{1}\right]+\mathcal{O}(q^{2}), − 2 m N 1 ϵ μν α β q α [ χ 1 σ β χ 1 + χ 1 σ ˉ β χ 1 ] + O ( q 2 ) ,
χ 2 σ μ ν χ 1 − χ ~ 2 σ ˉ μ ν χ ~ 1 = i m N { p 1 μ [ χ 1 σ ν χ ~ 1 + χ ~ 1 σ ˉ ν χ 1 ] − p 1 ν [ χ 1 σ μ χ ~ 1 + χ ~ 1 σ ˉ μ χ 1 ] } + 1 m N ϵ μ ν α β p 1 α q β 1 \chi_{2}\sigma^{\mu\nu}\chi_{1}-\widetilde{\chi}_{2}\bar{\sigma}^{\mu\nu}\widetilde{\chi}_{1}=\frac{i}{m_{N}}\left\{p_{1}^{\mu}\left[\chi_{1}\sigma^{\nu}\widetilde{\chi}_{1}+\widetilde{\chi}_{1}\bar{\sigma}^{\nu}\chi_{1}\right]-p_{1}^{\nu}\left[\chi_{1}\sigma^{\mu}\widetilde{\chi}_{1}+\widetilde{\chi}_{1}\bar{\sigma}^{\mu}\chi_{1}\right]\right\}+\frac{1}{m_{N}}\epsilon^{\mu\nu\alpha\beta}p_{1\alpha}q_{\beta}\mathbf{1} χ 2 σ μν χ 1 − χ 2 σ ˉ μν χ 1 = m N i { p 1 μ [ χ 1 σ ν χ 1 + χ 1 σ ˉ ν χ 1 ] − p 1 ν [ χ 1 σ μ χ 1 + χ 1 σ ˉ μ χ 1 ] } + m N 1 ϵ μν α β p 1 α q β 1
− i 2 m N { q μ [ χ 1 σ ν χ ~ 1 + χ ~ 1 σ ˉ ν χ 1 ] − q ν [ χ 1 σ μ χ ~ 1 + χ ~ 1 σ ˉ μ χ 1 ] } + O ( q 2 ) , -\frac{i}{2m_{N}}\left\{q^{\mu}\left[\chi_{1}\sigma^{\nu}\widetilde{\chi}_{1}+\widetilde{\chi}_{1}\bar{\sigma}^{\nu}\chi_{1}\right]-q^{\nu}\left[\chi_{1}\sigma^{\mu}\widetilde{\chi}_{1}+\widetilde{\chi}_{1}\bar{\sigma}^{\mu}\chi_{1}\right]\right\}+\mathcal{O}(q^{2}), − 2 m N i { q μ [ χ 1 σ ν χ 1 + χ 1 σ ˉ ν χ 1 ] − q ν [ χ 1 σ μ χ 1 + χ 1 σ ˉ μ χ 1 ] } + O ( q 2 ) ,
[ χ 2 σ μ ν χ 1 + χ ~ 2 σ ˉ μ ν χ ~ 1 ] q ν = 1 m N ϵ μ ν α β q ν p 1 α [ χ 1 σ β χ ~ 1 + χ ~ 1 σ ˉ β χ 1 ] + O ( q 2 ) , \left[\chi_{2}\sigma^{\mu\nu}\chi_{1}+\widetilde{\chi}_{2}\bar{\sigma}^{\mu\nu}\widetilde{\chi}_{1}\right]q_{\nu}=\frac{1}{m_{N}}\epsilon^{\mu\nu\alpha\beta}q_{\nu}p_{1\alpha}\left[\chi_{1}\sigma_{\beta}\widetilde{\chi}_{1}+\widetilde{\chi}_{1}\bar{\sigma}_{\beta}\chi_{1}\right]+\mathcal{O}(q^{2}), [ χ 2 σ μν χ 1 + χ 2 σ ˉ μν χ 1 ] q ν = m N 1 ϵ μν α β q ν p 1 α [ χ 1 σ β χ 1 + χ 1 σ ˉ β χ 1 ] + O ( q 2 ) ,
[ χ 2 σ μ ν χ 1 − χ ~ 2 σ ˉ μ ν χ ~ 1 ] q ν = i m N p 1 μ [ χ 1 q σ χ ~ 1 + χ ~ 1 q σ ˉ χ 1 ] + O ( q 2 ) , (29) \left[\chi_{2}\sigma^{\mu\nu}\chi_{1}-\widetilde{\chi}_{2}\bar{\sigma}^{\mu\nu}\widetilde{\chi}_{1}\right]q_{\nu}=\frac{i}{m_{N}}p_{1}^{\mu}\left[\chi_{1}q\sigma\widetilde{\chi}_{1}+\widetilde{\chi}_{1}q\bar{\sigma}\chi_{1}\right]+\mathcal{O}(q^{2}), \tag*{(29)} [ χ 2 σ μν χ 1 − χ 2 σ ˉ μν χ 1 ] q ν = m N i p 1 μ [ χ 1 q σ χ 1 + χ 1 q σ ˉ χ 1 ] + O ( q 2 ) , (29)
where 1 = δ O I \mathbf{1}=\delta^{I}_{O} 1 = δ O I , and spinors appearing to the left (right) in spinor contractions implicitly carry lower O O O (upper I I I ) little group indices.
More fundamental EFTs
In this work we employ a general Lorentz-covariant parametrization of nuclear beta amplitudes in a systematic EFT expansion in the recoil momentum q q q . The Wilson coefficients C X i C^{i}_{X} C X i of this nuclear-level EFT can be connected to more fundamental parameters of quark- and nucleon-level EFTs. Below we briefly summarize these more fundamental EFTs.
Quark-level EFT
At scales above μ ≃ 2 G e V \mu\simeq2\ \mathrm{GeV} μ ≃ 2 GeV , quarks and gluons become perturbative degrees of freedom. The effective theory at that scale relevant for β \beta β transitions, the so-called weak EFT (WEFT), describes charged-current effective interactions between quark and lepton currents, organized in an expansion in ∂ / m W \partial/m_{W} ∂ / m W , where m W m_{W} m W is the W W W boson mass. The leading operators can be parametrized as [36 ]
L W E F T ⊃ − V u d v 2 { 2 ( 1 + ϵ L ) ( e ˉ σ ˉ μ ν ) ( u ˉ σ ˉ μ d ) + 2 ϵ R ( e ˉ σ ˉ ν ) ( u c σ μ d ˉ c ) + 1 2 ϵ T ( e c σ μ ν ν ) [ u ˉ σ ˉ μ ν d ˉ c + u c σ μ ν d ] + ϵ S ( e c ν ) [ u ˉ d ˉ c + u c d ] − ϵ P ( e c ν ) [ u ˉ d ˉ c − u c d ] } + h . c . , (30) \begin{aligned}
\mathcal{L}_{\mathrm{WEFT}}\supset-\frac{V_{ud}}{v^{2}}\left\{2(1+\epsilon_{L})(\bar{e}\bar{\sigma}_{\mu\nu})(\bar{u}\bar{\sigma}^{\mu}d)+2\epsilon_{R}(\bar{e}\bar{\sigma}_{\nu})(u^{c}\sigma^{\mu}\bar{d}^{c})+\frac{1}{2}\epsilon_{T}(e^{c}\sigma_{\mu\nu}\nu)\left[\bar{u}\bar{\sigma}^{\mu\nu}\bar{d}^{c}+u^{c}\sigma^{\mu\nu}d\right]+\epsilon_{S}(e^{c}\nu)\left[\bar{u}\bar{d}^{c}+u^{c}d\right]-\epsilon_{P}(e^{c}\nu)\left[\bar{u}\bar{d}^{c}-u^{c}d\right]\right\} \\
&+\mathrm{h.c.}, \tag*{(30)}
\end{aligned} L WEFT ⊃ − v 2 V u d { 2 ( 1 + ϵ L ) ( e ˉ σ ˉ μν ) ( u ˉ σ ˉ μ d ) + 2 ϵ R ( e ˉ σ ˉ ν ) ( u c σ μ d ˉ c ) + 2 1 ϵ T ( e c σ μν ν ) [ u ˉ σ ˉ μν d ˉ c + u c σ μν d ] + ϵ S ( e c ν ) [ u ˉ d ˉ c + u c d ] − ϵ P ( e c ν ) [ u ˉ d ˉ c − u c d ] } + h.c. , (30)
where e e e and e ˉ c \bar{e}^{c} e ˉ c describe left- and right-handed electrons, u u u , u ˉ c \bar{u}^{c} u ˉ c , d d d , d ˉ c \bar{d}^{c} d ˉ c describe left- and right-handed up and down quarks, and ν \nu ν describes the left-handed electron neutrino. All these are fermionic quantum fields in the 2-component spinor notation [19 ] . Furthermore, V u d V_{ud} V u d is the CKM matrix element (with conventions fixed such that it is real), and the dimensionful scale is v = ( 2 G F ) − 1 / 2 ≈ 246.22 G e V v=(\sqrt{2}G_{F})^{-1/2}\approx246.22\ \mathrm{GeV} v = ( 2 G F ) − 1/2 ≈ 246.22 GeV . The Wilson coefficients ϵ X \epsilon_{X} ϵ X , X = L , R , S , P , T X=L,R,S,P,T X = L , R , S , P , T , parametrize possible effects of non-SM particles heavier than 2 G e V 2\ \mathrm{GeV} 2 GeV . In the SM limit, ϵ X = 0 \epsilon_X = 0 ϵ X = 0 for all X X X . Given this Lagrangian, we can identify the quark-level hadronic currents appearing in Eq. (4) :
j ^ V − μ ( x ) = V u d ( 1 + ϵ L + ϵ R ) v 2 [ u c σ μ d ˉ c + u ˉ σ ˉ μ d ] , j ^ V + μ ( x ) = V u d ( 1 + ϵ ˉ L + ϵ ˉ R ) v 2 [ d c σ μ u ˉ c + d ˉ σ ˉ μ u ] , j ^ A − μ ( x ) = V u d ( 1 + ϵ L − ϵ R ) v 2 [ u c σ μ d ˉ c − u ˉ σ ˉ μ d ] , j ^ A + μ ( x ) = V u d ( 1 + ϵ ˉ L − ϵ ˉ R ) v 2 [ d c σ μ u ˉ c − d ˉ σ ˉ μ u ] , j ^ S − ( x ) = V u d ϵ S v 2 [ u ˉ d ˉ c + u c d ] , j ^ S + ( x ) = V u d ϵ ˉ S v 2 [ d ˉ u ˉ c + d c u ] , j ^ P − ( x ) = − V u d ϵ P v 2 [ u ˉ d ˉ c − u c d ] , j ^ P + ( x ) = V u d ϵ ˉ P v 2 [ d ˉ u ˉ c − d c u ] , j ^ T − μ ν ( x ) = V u d ϵ T v 2 [ u ˉ σ ˉ μ ν d ˉ c + u c σ μ ν d ] , j ^ T + μ ν ( x ) = V u d ϵ ˉ T v 2 [ d ˉ σ ˉ μ ν u ˉ c + d c σ μ ν u ] . (31) \begin{aligned}
\hat{j}^{\mu}_{V-}(x) &= \frac{V_{ud}(1+\epsilon_L+\epsilon_R)}{v^2}\left[u^c\sigma^\mu\bar{d}^c+\bar{u}\bar{\sigma}^\mu d\right], \qquad
\hat{j}^{\mu}_{V+}(x) = \frac{V_{ud}(1+\bar{\epsilon}_L+\bar{\epsilon}_R)}{v^2}\left[d^c\sigma^\mu\bar{u}^c+\bar{d}\bar{\sigma}^\mu u\right],\\
\hat{j}^{\mu}_{A-}(x) &= \frac{V_{ud}(1+\epsilon_L-\epsilon_R)}{v^2}\left[u^c\sigma^\mu\bar{d}^c-\bar{u}\bar{\sigma}^\mu d\right], \qquad
\hat{j}^{\mu}_{A+}(x) = \frac{V_{ud}(1+\bar{\epsilon}_L-\bar{\epsilon}_R)}{v^2}\left[d^c\sigma^\mu\bar{u}^c-\bar{d}\bar{\sigma}^\mu u\right],\\
\hat{j}_{S-}(x) &= \frac{V_{ud}\epsilon_S}{v^2}\left[\bar{u}\bar{d}^c+u^cd\right], \qquad
\hat{j}_{S+}(x) = \frac{V_{ud}\bar{\epsilon}_S}{v^2}\left[\bar{d}\bar{u}^c+d^cu\right],\\
\hat{j}_{P-}(x) &= -\frac{V_{ud}\epsilon_P}{v^2}\left[\bar{u}\bar{d}^c-u^cd\right], \qquad
\hat{j}_{P+}(x) = \frac{V_{ud}\bar{\epsilon}_P}{v^2}\left[\bar{d}\bar{u}^c-d^cu\right],\\
\hat{j}^{\mu\nu}_{T-}(x) &= \frac{V_{ud}\epsilon_T}{v^2}\left[\bar{u}\bar{\sigma}^{\mu\nu}\bar{d}^c+u^c\sigma^{\mu\nu}d\right], \qquad
\hat{j}^{\mu\nu}_{T+}(x) = \frac{V_{ud}\bar{\epsilon}_T}{v^2}\left[\bar{d}\bar{\sigma}^{\mu\nu}\bar{u}^c+d^c\sigma^{\mu\nu}u\right]. \tag*{(31)}
\end{aligned} j ^ V − μ ( x ) j ^ A − μ ( x ) j ^ S − ( x ) j ^ P − ( x ) j ^ T − μν ( x ) = v 2 V u d ( 1 + ϵ L + ϵ R ) [ u c σ μ d ˉ c + u ˉ σ ˉ μ d ] , j ^ V + μ ( x ) = v 2 V u d ( 1 + ϵ ˉ L + ϵ ˉ R ) [ d c σ μ u ˉ c + d ˉ σ ˉ μ u ] , = v 2 V u d ( 1 + ϵ L − ϵ R ) [ u c σ μ d ˉ c − u ˉ σ ˉ μ d ] , j ^ A + μ ( x ) = v 2 V u d ( 1 + ϵ ˉ L − ϵ ˉ R ) [ d c σ μ u ˉ c − d ˉ σ ˉ μ u ] , = v 2 V u d ϵ S [ u ˉ d ˉ c + u c d ] , j ^ S + ( x ) = v 2 V u d ϵ ˉ S [ d ˉ u ˉ c + d c u ] , = − v 2 V u d ϵ P [ u ˉ d ˉ c − u c d ] , j ^ P + ( x ) = v 2 V u d ϵ ˉ P [ d ˉ u ˉ c − d c u ] , = v 2 V u d ϵ T [ u ˉ σ ˉ μν d ˉ c + u c σ μν d ] , j ^ T + μν ( x ) = v 2 V u d ϵ ˉ T [ d ˉ σ ˉ μν u ˉ c + d c σ μν u ] . (31)
To calculate the neutron beta decay amplitude from the Lagrangian in Eq. (B.1), we need matrix elements of the quark currents between nucleon (neutron and proton) states. Their most general form allowed by the Lorentz symmetry and the discrete P P P symmetry of QCD can be parametrized as [14 , 18 , 36 ]
⟨ p ∣ u ˉ γ μ d ∣ n ⟩ = u ˉ p [ g V γ μ + g I S 2 m N q μ − i g M − g V 2 m N σ μ ν q ν ] u n + O ( q 2 ) , ⟨ p ∣ u ˉ γ μ γ 5 d ∣ n ⟩ = u ˉ p [ g A γ μ γ 5 + g I P 2 m N γ 5 q μ − i g I T 2 m N σ μ ν γ 5 q ν ] u n + O ( q 2 ) , ⟨ p ∣ u ˉ d ∣ n ⟩ = g S u ˉ p u n + O ( q 2 ) , ⟨ p ∣ u ˉ γ 5 d ∣ n ⟩ = g P u ˉ p γ 5 u n + O ( q 2 ) , ⟨ p ∣ u ˉ σ μ ν d ∣ n ⟩ = u ˉ p [ g T σ μ ν + i g T ( 1 ) m N ( q μ γ ν − q ν γ μ ) + i g T ( 3 ) m N ( γ μ γ ρ γ ν − γ ν γ ρ γ μ ) q ρ ] u n + O ( q 2 ) . (32) \begin{aligned}
\langle p|\bar{u}\gamma_\mu d|n\rangle&= \bar{u}_p\left[g_V\gamma_\mu+\frac{g_{IS}}{2m_N}q_\mu-i\frac{g_M-g_V}{2m_N}\sigma_{\mu\nu}q^\nu\right]u_n+O(q^2),\\
\langle p|\bar{u}\gamma_\mu\gamma_5d|n\rangle&= \bar{u}_p\left[g_A\gamma_\mu\gamma_5+\frac{g_{IP}}{2m_N}\gamma_5q_\mu-i\frac{g_{IT}}{2m_N}\sigma_{\mu\nu}\gamma_5q^\nu\right]u_n+O(q^2),\\
\langle p|\bar{u}d|n\rangle&= g_S\bar{u}_pu_n+O(q^2),\\
\langle p|\bar{u}\gamma_5d|n\rangle&= g_P\bar{u}_p\gamma_5u_n+O(q^2),\\
\langle p|\bar{u}\sigma_{\mu\nu}d|n\rangle&= \bar{u}_p\left[g_T\sigma_{\mu\nu}+\frac{ig_T^{(1)}}{m_N}(q_\mu\gamma_\nu-q_\nu\gamma_\mu)\right.\\
&\qquad\left.+\frac{ig_T^{(3)}}{m_N}(\gamma_\mu\gamma_\rho\gamma_\nu-\gamma_\nu\gamma_\rho\gamma_\mu)q^\rho\right]u_n+O(q^2). \tag*{(32)}
\end{aligned} ⟨ p ∣ u ˉ γ μ d ∣ n ⟩ ⟨ p ∣ u ˉ γ μ γ 5 d ∣ n ⟩ ⟨ p ∣ u ˉ d ∣ n ⟩ ⟨ p ∣ u ˉ γ 5 d ∣ n ⟩ ⟨ p ∣ u ˉ σ μν d ∣ n ⟩ = u ˉ p [ g V γ μ + 2 m N g I S q μ − i 2 m N g M − g V σ μν q ν ] u n + O ( q 2 ) , = u ˉ p [ g A γ μ γ 5 + 2 m N g I P γ 5 q μ − i 2 m N g I T σ μν γ 5 q ν ] u n + O ( q 2 ) , = g S u ˉ p u n + O ( q 2 ) , = g P u ˉ p γ 5 u n + O ( q 2 ) , = u ˉ p [ g T σ μν + m N i g T ( 1 ) ( q μ γ ν − q ν γ μ ) + m N i g T ( 3 ) ( γ μ γ ρ γ ν − γ ν γ ρ γ μ ) q ρ ] u n + O ( q 2 ) . (32)
Above, u N u_N u N is the Dirac spinor wave function of the neutron or proton. Different Lorentz structures are weighted by nucleon charges g X g_X g X , most of which are known with sufficient precision. Isospin symmetry fixes g V = 1 g_V=1 g V = 1 (up to corrections quadratic in isospin breaking [37 , 38 ] ), and relates g M g_M g M to the difference of the proton and neutron magnetic moments [18 , 28 , 39 ] , g M g V = μ p − μ n μ N ≃ 4.706 \frac{g_M}{g_V}=\frac{\mu_p-\mu_n}{\mu_N}\simeq4.706 g V g M = μ N μ p − μ n ≃ 4.706 , where μ N = e 2 m p \mu_N=\frac{e}{2m_p} μ N = 2 m p e is the nuclear magneton. It also implies vanishing of the induced scalar g I S g_{IS} g I S , induced tensor g I T g_{IT} g I T , and the subleading tensor g T ( 3 ) g_T^{(3)} g T ( 3 ) charges, which are then expected to be O ( 10 − 2 ) O(10^{-2}) O ( 1 0 − 2 ) due to isospin breaking effects, see in particular Refs. [40 , 41 ] . The axial, scalar, and tensor charges can be calculated on the lattice, with the Flavor Lattice Averaging Group (FLAG) 2024 average g A = 1.263 ( 10 ) g_A=1.263(10) g A = 1.263 ( 10 ) , g S = 1.085 ( 114 ) g_S=1.085(114) g S = 1.085 ( 114 ) , g T = 0.981 ( 21 ) g_T=0.981(21) g T = 0.981 ( 21 ) [27 ] . Using partial conservation of the axial current one finds g P = m N m ˉ q g A = 346 ( 9 ) g_P=\frac{m_N}{\bar{m}_q}g_A=346(9) g P = m ˉ q m N g A = 346 ( 9 ) , and g I P = − 4 m N 2 m π 2 g A ≈ − 226 ( 5 ) g_{IP}=-\frac{4m_N^2}{m_\pi^2}g_A\approx-226(5) g I P = − m π 2 4 m N 2 g A ≈ − 226 ( 5 ) [42 ] , where m ˉ q \bar{m}_q m ˉ q is the average of the light quark masses, and m π m_\pi m π is the pion mass. We are not aware of a precise determination for g T ( 1 ) g_T^{(1)} g T ( 1 ) , but by naturalness considerations it is expected to be O ( 1 ) O(1) O ( 1 ) .
Nucleon-level EFT
The nucleon-level NR-EFT approach in Ref. [16] is based on the effective Lagrangian in Eq. (18) . To calculate beta decay amplitudes from it, one needs matrix elements of nucleon bilinears between nuclear states. For β − \beta^- β − transitions, the parametrization given in Ref. [16] in the rest frame of the parent nucleus and in the isospin-symmetric limit reduces to12 ^{12} 12
⟨ N 2 ∣ ψ p † ψ n ∣ N 1 ⟩ = 2 m N M F − 1 , ⟨ N 2 ∣ ψ p † σ k ψ n ∣ N 1 ⟩ = 2 m N M F − r i J ( J + 1 ) S k , ⟨ N 2 ∣ ψ p † ∇ ↔ k ψ n ∣ N 1 ⟩ = 2 m N M F − { − i 1 A q k 1 − β i r i J ( J + 1 ) ϵ k l m q l S m } , ⟨ N 2 ∣ ψ p † σ l ∇ ↔ l ψ n ∣ N 1 ⟩ = 2 m N M F − { − i r i A J ( J + 1 ) q l s l } , ϵ k l m ⟨ N 2 ∣ ψ p † σ l ∇ ↔ m ψ n ∣ N 1 ⟩ = 2 m N M F − { i r i A J ( J + 1 ) ϵ k l m q l S m + α i q k 1 } . (33) \begin{aligned}
\langle N_2|\psi_p^\dagger\psi_n|N_1\rangle&=2m_NM_F^-\mathbb{1},\\
\langle N_2|\psi_p^\dagger\sigma^k\psi_n|N_1\rangle&=2m_NM_F^-\frac{r_i}{\sqrt{J(J+1)}}S^k,\\
\langle N_2|\psi_p^\dagger\overleftrightarrow{\nabla}^k\psi_n|N_1\rangle&=2m_NM_F^-\left\{-i\frac{1}{A}q^k\mathbb{1}-\beta_i\frac{r_i}{\sqrt{J(J+1)}}\epsilon^{klm}q^lS^m\right\},\\
\langle N_2|\psi_p^\dagger\sigma^l\overleftrightarrow{\nabla}^l\psi_n|N_1\rangle&=2m_NM_F^-\left\{-i\frac{r_i}{A\sqrt{J(J+1)}}q^ls^l\right\},\\
\epsilon^{klm}\langle N_2|\psi_p^\dagger\sigma^l\overleftrightarrow{\nabla}^m\psi_n|N_1\rangle&=2m_NM_F^-\left\{i\frac{r_i}{A\sqrt{J(J+1)}}\epsilon^{klm}q^lS^m+\alpha_iq^k\mathbb{1}\right\}. \tag*{(33)}
\end{aligned} ⟨ N 2 ∣ ψ p † ψ n ∣ N 1 ⟩ ⟨ N 2 ∣ ψ p † σ k ψ n ∣ N 1 ⟩ ⟨ N 2 ∣ ψ p † ∇ k ψ n ∣ N 1 ⟩ ⟨ N 2 ∣ ψ p † σ l ∇ l ψ n ∣ N 1 ⟩ ϵ k l m ⟨ N 2 ∣ ψ p † σ l ∇ m ψ n ∣ N 1 ⟩ = 2 m N M F − 1 , = 2 m N M F − J ( J + 1 ) r i S k , = 2 m N M F − { − i A 1 q k 1 − β i J ( J + 1 ) r i ϵ k l m q l S m } , = 2 m N M F − { − i A J ( J + 1 ) r i q l s l } , = 2 m N M F − { i A J ( J + 1 ) r i ϵ k l m q l S m + α i q k 1 } . (33)
Given these matrix elements and the Lagrangian in Eq. (18) , we can calculate β − \beta^- β − decay amplitudes in the rest frame of the parent nucleus. These can be compared with the amplitudes in Eq. (3) in the covariant formalism evaluated in the rest frame, with the currents parametrized in Eq. (10) . The two are equal upon the following identification of the Wilson coefficients:
C V i = C V + + Δ 2 m N C F V + − m e 2 m N C T 2 + , C A i = J J + 1 r i ( C A + − m e m N C T 3 + ) , C M i = J J + 1 r i A ( C M + + β i C F V + ) , C I T i = J J + 1 r i ( C F A + − C A + − A C E + ) , C S i + m e 2 m N C I S i = C S + + m e 2 m N ( C V + − C F V + ) , C P i = J J + 1 r i A C P + , C T i = J J + 1 r i ( C T + + Δ 2 m N C F T + ) , C T ( 1 ) i = A ( C T 1 + + C T 2 + − α i C F T + ) , C T ( 2 ) i = J J + 1 r i ( C F T + − C T + − 2 A C T 3 + ) . (34) \begin{aligned}
C_V^i&=C_V^++\frac{\Delta}{2m_N}C_{FV}^+-\frac{m_e}{2m_N}C_{T2}^+,\\
C_A^i&=\sqrt{\frac{J}{J+1}}r_i\left(C_A^+-\frac{m_e}{m_N}C_{T3}^+\right),\\
C_M^i&=\sqrt{\frac{J}{J+1}}r_iA\left(C_M^++\beta_iC_{FV}^+\right),\\
C_{IT}^i&=\sqrt{\frac{J}{J+1}}r_i\left(C_{FA}^+-C_A^+-AC_E^+\right),\\
C_S^i+\frac{m_e}{2m_N}C_{IS}^i&=C_S^++\frac{m_e}{2m_N}\left(C_V^+-C_{FV}^+\right),\\
C_P^i&=\sqrt{\frac{J}{J+1}}r_iAC_P^+,\\
C_T^i&=\sqrt{\frac{J}{J+1}}r_i\left(C_T^++\frac{\Delta}{2m_N}C_{FT}^+\right),\\
C_{T(1)}^i&=A\left(C_{T_1}^++C_{T_2}^+-\alpha_iC_{FT}^+\right),\\
C_{T(2)}^i&=\sqrt{\frac{J}{J+1}}r_i\left(C_{FT}^+-C_T^+-2AC_{T_3}^+\right). \tag*{(34)}
\end{aligned} C V i C A i C M i C I T i C S i + 2 m N m e C I S i C P i C T i C T ( 1 ) i C T ( 2 ) i = C V + + 2 m N Δ C F V + − 2 m N m e C T 2 + , = J + 1 J r i ( C A + − m N m e C T 3 + ) , = J + 1 J r i A ( C M + + β i C F V + ) , = J + 1 J r i ( C F A + − C A + − A C E + ) , = C S + + 2 m N m e ( C V + − C F V + ) , = J + 1 J r i A C P + , = J + 1 J r i ( C T + + 2 m N Δ C F T + ) , = A ( C T 1 + + C T 2 + − α i C F T + ) , = J + 1 J r i ( C F T + − C T + − 2 A C T 3 + ) . (34)
while C Q i = C T Q i = 0 C^{i}_{Q}=C^{i}_{TQ}=0 C Q i = C T Q i = 0 in the isospin-symmetric parametrization above. These last two Wilson coefficients are generated only when the matrix elements in Eq. (B.4) are generalized to include isospin-breaking corrections. In particular, if we include ⟨ N 2 ∣ ψ ˉ p ∇ ↔ k ψ n ∣ N 1 ⟩ ⊃ 2 i m N M F − δ ˉ j 2 ? q l S k l \langle N_{2}|\bar{\psi}_{p}\overleftrightarrow{\nabla}_{k}\psi_{n}|N_{1}\rangle\supset2im_{N}M_{F}^{-}\frac{\bar{\delta}_{j2}}{?}q^{l}S^{kl} ⟨ N 2 ∣ ψ ˉ p ∇ k ψ n ∣ N 1 ⟩ ⊃ 2 i m N M F − ? δ ˉ j 2 q l S k l , and ϵ k l m ⟨ N 2 ∣ ψ ˉ p σ l ∇ ↔ m ψ n ∣ N 1 ⟩ = 2 m N M F − δ ˉ j 2 q l S k l \epsilon^{klm}\langle N_{2}|\bar{\psi}_{p}\sigma^{l}\overleftrightarrow{\nabla}_{m}\psi_{n}|N_{1}\rangle=2m_{N}M_{F}^{-}\bar{\delta}_{j2}q^{l}S^{kl} ϵ k l m ⟨ N 2 ∣ ψ ˉ p σ l ∇ m ψ n ∣ N 1 ⟩ = 2 m N M F − δ ˉ j 2 q l S k l then the quadrupole Wilson coefficients are generated as
C Q i = − A δ i C F V + , C T Q i = A γ i C F T + . (35) C^{i}_{Q}=-A\delta_{i}C^{+}_{FV},\qquad C^{i}_{TQ}=A\gamma_{i}C^{+}_{FT}. \tag*{(35)} C Q i = − A δ i C F V + , C T Q i = A γ i C F T + . (35)
Exotic recoil-order contributions
For allowed decays, the first-recoil-order contributions (O ( q ) O(q) O ( q ) ) to the form factors from interference between standard and exotic currents take the form
\begin{aligned}
\delta_{1}\mathcal{V}={}&\frac{m_{e}}{m_{N}}\operatorname{Re}\Biggl\{\left(\frac{E_{0}}{E_{e}}-1\right)C^{i}_{V}\bar{C}^{i}_{T(1)}+C^{i}_{S}\left(\bar{C}^{i}_{V}+\bar{C}^{i}_{IS}\right)+\frac{\lambda_{0}}{3}\left[\left(\frac{E_{0}}{E_{e}}-1\right)C^{i}_{A}\bar{C}^{i}_{P}\\
&-\left(\frac{E_{0}}{E_{e}}+2\right)C^{i}_{A}\left(\bar{C}^{i}_{T(2)}\pm\alpha_{T}\bar{C}^{i}_{T}\right)+2\left(\frac{E_{0}}{E_{e}}-1\right)C^{i}_{T}\bar{C}^{i}_{M}+\left(\frac{E_{0}}{E_{e}}-1\right)C^{i}_{T}\left(\bar{C}^{i}_{IT}\pm\alpha_{A}\bar{C}^{i}_{A}\right)\right]\Biggr\},\\
\delta_{1}\mathcal{N}={}&\frac{m_{e}}{m_{N}}\operatorname{Re}\Biggl\{C^{i}_{V}\bar{C}^{i}_{T(1)}\pm C^{i}_{S}\left(\bar{C}^{i}_{V}+\bar{C}^{i}_{IS}\right)\\
&+\frac{\lambda_{0}}{3}\left[C^{i}_{A}\bar{C}^{i}_{P}+2C^{i}_{A}\left(\bar{C}^{i}_{T(2)}\pm\alpha_{T}\bar{C}^{i}_{T}\right)+2C^{i}_{T}\bar{C}^{i}_{M}+C^{i}_{T}\left(\bar{C}^{i}_{IT}\pm\alpha_{A}\bar{C}^{i}_{A}\right)\right]\Biggr\},\\
\delta_{1}A={}&\frac{m_{e}}{m_{N}}\operatorname{Re}\Biggl\{-C^{i}_{V}\bar{C}^{i}_{P}-C^{i}_{A}\bar{C}^{i}_{T(1)}+C^{i}_{S}\left(\bar{C}^{i}_{A}\pm\bar{C}^{i}_{IT}\right)+C^{i}_{T}\left(\bar{C}^{i}_{V}+\bar{C}^{i}_{IS}\right)\\
&\pm\lambda_{1}\left[C^{i}_{A}\left(\bar{C}^{i}_{T(2)}\pm\alpha_{T}\bar{C}^{i}_{T}\right)+C^{i}_{T}\bar{C}^{i}_{M}\right]+\lambda_{3}\left[-C^{i}_{A}\bar{C}^{i}_{TQ}+C^{i}_{T}\bar{C}^{i}_{Q}\right]\Biggr\},\\
\delta_{1}B={}&\frac{m_{e}}{m_{N}}\operatorname{Re}\Biggl\{-\left(\frac{E_{0}}{E_{e}}-1\right)C^{i}_{V}\bar{C}^{i}_{P}\pm\frac{E_{0}}{E_{e}}C^{i}_{V}\left(\bar{C}^{i}_{T}\pm\bar{C}^{i}_{T(2)}\right)-\left(\frac{E_{0}}{E_{e}}-1\right)C^{i}_{A}\bar{C}^{i}_{T(1)}\\
&\pm\left(\frac{E_{0}}{E_{e}}-1\right)C^{i}_{S}\left(\bar{C}^{i}_{A}\pm\bar{C}^{i}_{IT}\right)\pm C^{i}_{T}\left(\bar{C}^{i}_{V}+\bar{C}^{i}_{IS}\right)\pm\lambda_{1}\left[C^{i}_{A}\left(\bar{C}^{i}_{T(2)}\pm\alpha_{T}\bar{C}^{i}_{T}\right)-\left(\frac{E_{0}}{E_{e}}-1\right)C^{i}_{T}\bar{C}^{i}_{M}\right]\\
&+\lambda_{3}\left(\frac{E_{0}}{E_{e}}-1\right)\left[-C^{i}_{A}\bar{C}^{i}_{TQ}+C^{i}_{T}\bar{C}^{i}_{Q}\right]\Biggr\},\\
\delta_{1}C={}&\frac{m_{e}}{2m_{N}}\operatorname{Re}\Biggl\{C^{i}_{S}\bar{C}^{i}_{Q}+\lambda_{2}\left[C^{i}_{A}\bar{C}^{i}_{P}-C^{i}_{A}\left(\bar{C}^{i}_{T(2)}\pm\alpha_{T}\bar{C}^{i}_{T}\right)-C^{i}_{T}\bar{C}^{i}_{M}+C^{i}_{T}\left(\bar{C}^{i}_{IT}\pm\alpha_{A}\bar{C}^{i}_{A}\right)\right]\\
&\pm3\lambda_{4}\left[-C^{i}_{A}\bar{C}^{i}_{TQ}+C^{i}_{T}\bar{C}^{i}_{Q}\right]\Biggr\},\\
\delta_{1}D={}&\frac{m_{e}}{m_{N}}\operatorname{Im}\Biggl\{\pm C^{i}_{V}\left(\bar{C}^{i}_{T}\pm\bar{C}^{i}_{T(2)}\right)+C^{i}_{A}\bar{C}^{i}_{T(1)}+C^{i}_{S}\bar{C}^{i}_{M}\pm C^{i}_{T}\left(\bar{C}^{i}_{V}\mp\bar{C}^{i}_{IS}\right)\\
&\pm\frac{\lambda_{1}}{2}\left[C^{i}_{A}\bar{C}^{i}_{P}+C^{i}_{A}\left(\bar{C}^{i}_{T(2)}\pm\alpha_{T}\bar{C}^{i}_{T}\right)+C^{i}_{T}\bar{C}^{i}_{M}+C^{i}_{T}\left(\bar{C}^{i}_{IT}\pm\alpha_{A}\bar{C}^{i}_{A}\right)\right]+\frac{\lambda_{3}}{2}\left[-C^{i}_{A}\bar{C}^{i}_{TQ}+C^{i}_{T}\bar{C}^{i}_{Q}\right]\Biggr\},\\
\delta_{1}C'_{4}={}&\frac{m_{e}}{E_{e}}\operatorname{Re}\Biggl\{-C^{i}_{S}\bar{C}^{i}_{Q}+\lambda_{2}\left[-C^{i}_{A}\bar{C}^{i}_{P}+C^{i}_{A}\left(\bar{C}^{i}_{T(2)}\pm\alpha_{T}\bar{C}^{i}_{T}\right)+C^{i}_{T}\bar{C}^{i}_{M}-C^{i}_{T}\left(\bar{C}^{i}_{IT}\pm\alpha_{A}\bar{C}^{i}_{A}\right)\right]\\
&\pm3\lambda_{4}\left[C^{i}_{A}\bar{C}^{i}_{TQ}-C^{i}_{T}\bar{C}^{i}_{Q}\right]\Biggr\}. \tag*{(36)}
\end{aligned}
while the standard–exotic interference contributions to A ′ A' A ′ , B ′ B' B ′ , C 3 ′ C'_3 C 3 ′ , D 3 ′ D'_3 D 3 ′ , D 4 ′ D'_4 D 4 ′ , E 3 ′ \mathcal{E}'_3 E 3 ′ , and E 4 ′ \mathcal{E}'_4 E 4 ′ vanish. We remind that the upper (lower) sign refers to β − \beta^- β − (β + \beta^+ β + ) decay, while λ i \lambda_i λ i and α A , T \alpha_{A,T} α A , T are defined in Table 2 .
The first-recoil-order contributions to the form factors from interference between leading and recoil-suppressed pieces of the exotic currents take the form
δ 2 N = Re { ± E 0 − 2 E e + m e 2 E e m N C S i C ˉ T ( 1 ) i ± λ 0 3 [ E 0 − 2 E e + m e 2 E e m N C T i C ˉ P i − E 0 + 2 m e 2 E e m N C T i ( C ˉ T ( 2 ) i ± α T C ˉ T i ) ] } , δ 2 N = Re { ± 2 E e − E 0 m N C S i C ˉ T ( 1 ) i ± λ 0 3 [ 2 E e − E 0 m N C T i C ˉ P i + E 0 m N C T i ( C ˉ T ( 2 ) i ± α T C ˉ T i ) ] } , δ 2 A = Re { ± E 0 − 2 E e m N C T i C ˉ T ( 1 ) i + λ 1 2 [ E 0 m N C T i C ˉ P i + 2 E e − E 0 m N C T i ( C ˉ T ( 2 ) i ± α T C ˉ T i ) ] + λ 3 14 E e − E 0 10 m N C T i C ˉ T Q i } , δ 2 B = Re { m e 2 E e m N C S i ( C ˉ T i ± C ˉ T ( 2 ) i ) ∓ E 0 − 2 E e + m e 2 E e m N C T i C ˉ T ( 1 ) i + λ 1 2 [ − E 0 − m e 2 E e m N C T i C ˉ P i + E 0 − 2 E e − m e 2 E e m N C T i ( C ˉ T ( 2 ) i ± α T C ˉ T i ) ] ± λ 3 14 E e − 13 E 0 − m e 2 E e 10 m N C T i C ˉ T Q i } , δ 2 C = Re { ± E 0 − 2 E e 2 m N C S i C ˉ T Q i + λ 2 [ ± 2 E e − E 0 2 m N C T i C ˉ P i ± E 0 2 m N C T i ( C ˉ T ( 2 ) i ± α T C ˉ T i ) ] − λ 4 3 E 0 2 m N C T i C ˉ T Q i } , δ 2 D = Im { ± 2 E e − E 0 m N C T i C ˉ T ( 1 ) i − λ 1 2 [ E 0 m N C T i C ˉ P i + 2 E e − E 0 m N C T i C ˉ T ( 2 ) i ] ± λ 3 E 0 − 2 E e 2 m N C T i C ˉ T Q i } , δ 2 A ′ = Re { C S i C ˉ P i + C S i ( C ˉ T i ± C ˉ T ( 2 ) i ) + λ 1 2 [ C T i C ˉ P i + C T i ( C ˉ T ( 2 ) i ± α T C ˉ T i ) ] ∓ 3 λ 3 10 C T i C ˉ T Q i } , δ 2 B ′ = Re { C S i C ˉ P i − C S i ( C ˉ T i ± C ˉ T ( 2 ) i ) + λ 1 2 [ − C T i C ˉ P i + C T i ( C ˉ T ( 2 ) i ± α T C ˉ T i ) ] ∓ 3 λ 3 10 C T i C ˉ T Q i } , δ 2 C 3 ′ = Re { ∓ C S i C ˉ T Q i + λ 2 [ ± C T i C ˉ P i ± C T i ( C ˉ T ( 2 ) i ± α T C ˉ T i ) ] + 3 λ 4 C T i C ˉ T Q i } , δ 2 C 4 ′ = Re { ∓ C S i C ˉ T Q i + λ 2 [ ∓ C T i C ˉ P i ± C T i ( C ˉ T ( 2 ) i ± α T C ˉ T i ) ] + 3 λ 4 C T i C ˉ T Q i } , δ 2 D 3 ′ = Im { ∓ C S i C ˉ T Q i + λ 2 [ ∓ C T i C ˉ P i ± C T i C ˉ T ( 2 ) i ] + λ 4 C T i C ˉ T Q i } , δ 2 D 4 ′ = Im { ∓ C S i C ˉ T Q i + λ 2 [ ∓ C T i C ˉ P i ± C T i C ˉ T ( 2 ) i ] − λ 4 C T i C ˉ T Q i } , δ 2 E 3 ′ = Re { ∓ λ 5 C T i C ˉ T Q i } , δ 2 E 4 ′ = Re { ∓ λ 5 C T i C ˉ T Q i } . (37) \begin{aligned}
\delta_2\mathcal{N}={}&\operatorname{Re}\left\{\pm\frac{E_0-2E_e+\frac{m_e^2}{E_e}}{m_N}C_S^i\bar C_{T(1)}^i\pm\frac{\lambda_0}{3}\left[\frac{E_0-2E_e+\frac{m_e^2}{E_e}}{m_N}C_T^i\bar C_P^i-\frac{E_0+\frac{2m_e^2}{E_e}}{m_N}C_T^i\left(\bar C_{T(2)}^i\pm\alpha_T\bar C_T^i\right)\right]\right\},\\
\delta_2\mathfrak{N}={}&\operatorname{Re}\left\{\pm\frac{2E_e-E_0}{m_N}C_S^i\bar C_{T(1)}^i\pm\frac{\lambda_0}{3}\left[\frac{2E_e-E_0}{m_N}C_T^i\bar C_P^i+\frac{E_0}{m_N}C_T^i\left(\bar C_{T(2)}^i\pm\alpha_T\bar C_T^i\right)\right]\right\},\\
\delta_2 A={}&\operatorname{Re}\left\{\pm\frac{E_0-2E_e}{m_N}C_T^i\bar C_{T(1)}^i+\frac{\lambda_1}{2}\left[\frac{E_0}{m_N}C_T^i\bar C_P^i+\frac{2E_e-E_0}{m_N}C_T^i\left(\bar C_{T(2)}^i\pm\alpha_T\bar C_T^i\right)\right]+\lambda_3\frac{14E_e-E_0}{10m_N}C_T^i\bar C_{TQ}^i\right\},\\
\delta_2 B={}&\operatorname{Re}\left\{\frac{m_e^2}{E_em_N}C_S^i\left(\bar C_T^i\pm\bar C_{T(2)}^i\right)\mp\frac{E_0-2E_e+\frac{m_e^2}{E_e}}{m_N}C_T^i\bar C_{T(1)}^i\right.\\
&\left.\qquad+\frac{\lambda_1}{2}\left[-\frac{E_0-\frac{m_e^2}{E_e}}{m_N}C_T^i\bar C_P^i+\frac{E_0-2E_e-\frac{m_e^2}{E_e}}{m_N}C_T^i\left(\bar C_{T(2)}^i\pm\alpha_T\bar C_T^i\right)\right]\pm\lambda_3\frac{14E_e-13E_0-\frac{m_e^2}{E_e}}{10m_N}C_T^i\bar C_{TQ}^i\right\},\\
\delta_2 C={}&\operatorname{Re}\left\{\pm\frac{E_0-2E_e}{2m_N}C_S^i\bar C_{TQ}^i+\lambda_2\left[\pm\frac{2E_e-E_0}{2m_N}C_T^i\bar C_P^i\pm\frac{E_0}{2m_N}C_T^i\left(\bar C_{T(2)}^i\pm\alpha_T\bar C_T^i\right)\right]-\lambda_4\frac{3E_0}{2m_N}C_T^i\bar C_{TQ}^i\right\},\\
\delta_2 D={}&\operatorname{Im}\left\{\pm\frac{2E_e-E_0}{m_N}C_T^i\bar C_{T(1)}^i-\frac{\lambda_1}{2}\left[\frac{E_0}{m_N}C_T^i\bar C_P^i+\frac{2E_e-E_0}{m_N}C_T^i\bar C_{T(2)}^i\right]\pm\lambda_3\frac{E_0-2E_e}{2m_N}C_T^i\bar C_{TQ}^i\right\},\\
\delta_2 A'={}&\operatorname{Re}\left\{C_S^i\bar C_P^i+C_S^i\left(\bar C_T^i\pm\bar C_{T(2)}^i\right)+\frac{\lambda_1}{2}\left[C_T^i\bar C_P^i+C_T^i\left(\bar C_{T(2)}^i\pm\alpha_T\bar C_T^i\right)\right]\mp\frac{3\lambda_3}{10}C_T^i\bar C_{TQ}^i\right\},\\
\delta_2 B'={}&\operatorname{Re}\left\{C_S^i\bar C_P^i-C_S^i\left(\bar C_T^i\pm\bar C_{T(2)}^i\right)+\frac{\lambda_1}{2}\left[-C_T^i\bar C_P^i+C_T^i\left(\bar C_{T(2)}^i\pm\alpha_T\bar C_T^i\right)\right]\mp\frac{3\lambda_3}{10}C_T^i\bar C_{TQ}^i\right\},\\
\delta_2 C'_3={}&\operatorname{Re}\left\{\mp C_S^i\bar C_{TQ}^i+\lambda_2\left[\pm C_T^i\bar C_P^i\pm C_T^i\left(\bar C_{T(2)}^i\pm\alpha_T\bar C_T^i\right)\right]+3\lambda_4C_T^i\bar C_{TQ}^i\right\},\\
\delta_2 C'_4={}&\operatorname{Re}\left\{\mp C_S^i\bar C_{TQ}^i+\lambda_2\left[\mp C_T^i\bar C_P^i\pm C_T^i\left(\bar C_{T(2)}^i\pm\alpha_T\bar C_T^i\right)\right]+3\lambda_4C_T^i\bar C_{TQ}^i\right\},\\
\delta_2 D'_3={}&\operatorname{Im}\left\{\mp C_S^i\bar C_{TQ}^i+\lambda_2\left[\mp C_T^i\bar C_P^i\pm C_T^i\bar C_{T(2)}^i\right]+\lambda_4C_T^i\bar C_{TQ}^i\right\},\\
\delta_2 D'_4={}&\operatorname{Im}\left\{\mp C_S^i\bar C_{TQ}^i+\lambda_2\left[\mp C_T^i\bar C_P^i\pm C_T^i\bar C_{T(2)}^i\right]-\lambda_4C_T^i\bar C_{TQ}^i\right\},\\
\delta_2\mathcal{E}'_3={}&\operatorname{Re}\left\{\mp\lambda_5 C_T^i\bar C_{TQ}^i\right\},\\
\delta_2\mathcal{E}'_4={}&\operatorname{Re}\left\{\mp\lambda_5 C_T^i\bar C_{TQ}^i\right\}. \tag*{(37)}
\end{aligned} δ 2 N = δ 2 N = δ 2 A = δ 2 B = δ 2 C = δ 2 D = δ 2 A ′ = δ 2 B ′ = δ 2 C 3 ′ = δ 2 C 4 ′ = δ 2 D 3 ′ = δ 2 D 4 ′ = δ 2 E 3 ′ = δ 2 E 4 ′ = Re ⎩ ⎨ ⎧ ± m N E 0 − 2 E e + E e m e 2 C S i C ˉ T ( 1 ) i ± 3 λ 0 m N E 0 − 2 E e + E e m e 2 C T i C ˉ P i − m N E 0 + E e 2 m e 2 C T i ( C ˉ T ( 2 ) i ± α T C ˉ T i ) ⎭ ⎬ ⎫ , Re { ± m N 2 E e − E 0 C S i C ˉ T ( 1 ) i ± 3 λ 0 [ m N 2 E e − E 0 C T i C ˉ P i + m N E 0 C T i ( C ˉ T ( 2 ) i ± α T C ˉ T i ) ] } , Re { ± m N E 0 − 2 E e C T i C ˉ T ( 1 ) i + 2 λ 1 [ m N E 0 C T i C ˉ P i + m N 2 E e − E 0 C T i ( C ˉ T ( 2 ) i ± α T C ˉ T i ) ] + λ 3 10 m N 14 E e − E 0 C T i C ˉ T Q i } , Re ⎩ ⎨ ⎧ E e m N m e 2 C S i ( C ˉ T i ± C ˉ T ( 2 ) i ) ∓ m N E 0 − 2 E e + E e m e 2 C T i C ˉ T ( 1 ) i + 2 λ 1 − m N E 0 − E e m e 2 C T i C ˉ P i + m N E 0 − 2 E e − E e m e 2 C T i ( C ˉ T ( 2 ) i ± α T C ˉ T i ) ± λ 3 10 m N 14 E e − 13 E 0 − E e m e 2 C T i C ˉ T Q i ⎭ ⎬ ⎫ , Re { ± 2 m N E 0 − 2 E e C S i C ˉ T Q i + λ 2 [ ± 2 m N 2 E e − E 0 C T i C ˉ P i ± 2 m N E 0 C T i ( C ˉ T ( 2 ) i ± α T C ˉ T i ) ] − λ 4 2 m N 3 E 0 C T i C ˉ T Q i } , Im { ± m N 2 E e − E 0 C T i C ˉ T ( 1 ) i − 2 λ 1 [ m N E 0 C T i C ˉ P i + m N 2 E e − E 0 C T i C ˉ T ( 2 ) i ] ± λ 3 2 m N E 0 − 2 E e C T i C ˉ T Q i } , Re { C S i C ˉ P i + C S i ( C ˉ T i ± C ˉ T ( 2 ) i ) + 2 λ 1 [ C T i C ˉ P i + C T i ( C ˉ T ( 2 ) i ± α T C ˉ T i ) ] ∓ 10 3 λ 3 C T i C ˉ T Q i } , Re { C S i C ˉ P i − C S i ( C ˉ T i ± C ˉ T ( 2 ) i ) + 2 λ 1 [ − C T i C ˉ P i + C T i ( C ˉ T ( 2 ) i ± α T C ˉ T i ) ] ∓ 10 3 λ 3 C T i C ˉ T Q i } , Re { ∓ C S i C ˉ T Q i + λ 2 [ ± C T i C ˉ P i ± C T i ( C ˉ T ( 2 ) i ± α T C ˉ T i ) ] + 3 λ 4 C T i C ˉ T Q i } , Re { ∓ C S i C ˉ T Q i + λ 2 [ ∓ C T i C ˉ P i ± C T i ( C ˉ T ( 2 ) i ± α T C ˉ T i ) ] + 3 λ 4 C T i C ˉ T Q i } , Im { ∓ C S i C ˉ T Q i + λ 2 [ ∓ C T i C ˉ P i ± C T i C ˉ T ( 2 ) i ] + λ 4 C T i C ˉ T Q i } , Im { ∓ C S i C ˉ T Q i + λ 2 [ ∓ C T i C ˉ P i ± C T i C ˉ T ( 2 ) i ] − λ 4 C T i C ˉ T Q i } , Re { ∓ λ 5 C T i C ˉ T Q i } , Re { ∓ λ 5 C T i C ˉ T Q i } . (37)
The contributions in Eqs. (C.1) and (C.2) should be added to those in Eqs. (14) and (4.3) to obtain the complete characterization of the differential distribution in allowed beta decay at first recoil order.
Gamow-Teller transitions
In this appendix we briefly review how the formalism spelled out in § 3 can be modified to describe allowed spin-changing transitions with J 1 ≡ J = J 2 ± 1 J_{1} \equiv J = J_{2} \pm1 J 1 ≡ J = J 2 ± 1 and the same parity of the parent and daughter nuclei. These are referred to as (pure) Gamow-Teller transitions. As in the mixed Fermi-Gamow-Teller case, the β \beta β decay amplitude is split into the leptonic and hadronic current parts, cf. Eq. (3) . For β − \beta^{-} β − decays with J = J 2 + 1 J = J_{2} + 1 J = J 2 + 1 , the most general hadronic currents to subleading order in recoil with the correct little group transformation properties and consistent with the parity constraint in Eq. (5) can be written in the spinorial form as
j V − μ = i C M i m N 2 ϵ μ ν α β q ν p 1 α ( χ 1 σ β χ ~ 1 ) [ χ 2 χ 1 + χ ~ 2 χ ~ 1 ] 2 J 2 ( 2 m N ) 2 J 2 − C Q i m N 2 ( χ 1 σ { ν χ ~ 1 ) q ν [ χ 2 σ μ } χ ~ 1 − χ ~ 2 σ ‾ μ } χ 1 ] [ χ 2 χ 1 + χ ~ 2 χ ~ 1 ] 2 J 2 − 1 ( 2 m N ) 2 J 2 − 1 + O ( q 2 ) , j A − μ = { 2 C A i ( χ 1 σ μ χ ~ 1 ) + C I T i m N 2 p 1 μ ( χ 1 q σ χ ~ 1 ) } [ χ 2 χ 1 + χ ~ 2 χ ~ 1 ] 2 J 2 ( 2 m N ) 2 J 2 + O ( q 2 ) , j S − = O ( q 2 ) , j P − = C P i m N ( χ 1 q σ χ ~ 1 ) [ χ 2 χ 1 + χ ~ 2 χ ~ 1 ] 2 J 2 ( 2 m N ) 2 J 2 + O ( q 2 ) , j T − μ ν = − i { 2 C T i m N p 1 μ ( χ 1 σ ν ρ χ ~ 1 ) + C T ( 2 ) i m N ( χ 1 σ [ μ χ ~ 1 ) q ν ] } [ χ 2 χ 1 + χ ~ 2 χ ~ 1 ] 2 J 2 ( 2 m N ) 2 J 2 + i C T Q i 2 m N 2 q α ( χ 1 σ { α χ ~ 1 ) ( [ χ 2 σ μ } χ ~ 1 − χ ~ 2 σ ‾ μ } χ 1 ] p 1 ν − ( μ ↔ ν ) ) [ χ 2 χ 1 + χ ~ 2 χ ~ 1 ] 2 J 2 − 1 ( 2 m N ) 2 J 2 − 1 + O ( q 2 ) . (38) \begin{aligned}
j_{V-}^{\mu} ={}& i\frac{C_{M}^{i}}{m_{N}^{2}}\epsilon^{\mu\nu\alpha\beta}q_{\nu}p_{1\alpha}(\chi_{1}\sigma_{\beta}\widetilde{\chi}_{1})\frac{[\chi_{2}\chi_{1}+\widetilde{\chi}_{2}\widetilde{\chi}_{1}]^{2J_{2}}}{(2m_{N})^{2J_{2}}} \\
&-\frac{C_{Q}^{i}}{m_{N}^{2}}(\chi_{1}\sigma^{\{\nu}\widetilde{\chi}_{1})q_{\nu}[\chi_{2}\sigma^{\mu\}}\widetilde{\chi}_{1}-\widetilde{\chi}_{2}\overline{\sigma}^{\mu\}}\chi_{1}]\frac{[\chi_{2}\chi_{1}+\widetilde{\chi}_{2}\widetilde{\chi}_{1}]^{2J_{2}-1}}{(2m_{N})^{2J_{2}-1}}+O(q^{2}), \\
j_{A-}^{\mu} ={}& \left\{2C_{A}^{i}(\chi_{1}\sigma^{\mu}\widetilde{\chi}_{1})+\frac{C_{IT}^{i}}{m_{N}^{2}}p_{1}^{\mu}(\chi_{1}q\sigma\widetilde{\chi}_{1})\right\}\frac{[\chi_{2}\chi_{1}+\widetilde{\chi}_{2}\widetilde{\chi}_{1}]^{2J_{2}}}{(2m_{N})^{2J_{2}}}+O(q^{2}), \\
j_{S-} ={}& O(q^{2}), \\
j_{P-} ={}& \frac{C_{P}^{i}}{m_{N}}(\chi_{1}q\sigma\widetilde{\chi}_{1})\frac{[\chi_{2}\chi_{1}+\widetilde{\chi}_{2}\widetilde{\chi}_{1}]^{2J_{2}}}{(2m_{N})^{2J_{2}}}+O(q^{2}), \\
j_{T-}^{\mu\nu} ={}& -i\left\{\frac{2C_{T}^{i}}{m_{N}}p_{1}^{\mu}(\chi_{1}\sigma^{\nu\rho}\widetilde{\chi}_{1})+\frac{C_{T(2)}^{i}}{m_{N}}(\chi_{1}\sigma^{[\mu}\widetilde{\chi}_{1})q^{\nu]}\right\}\frac{[\chi_{2}\chi_{1}+\widetilde{\chi}_{2}\widetilde{\chi}_{1}]^{2J_{2}}}{(2m_{N})^{2J_{2}}} \\
&+i\frac{C_{TQ}^{i}}{2m_{N}^{2}}q_{\alpha}(\chi_{1}\sigma^{\{\alpha}\widetilde{\chi}_{1})\left([\chi_{2}\sigma^{\mu\}}\widetilde{\chi}_{1}-\widetilde{\chi}_{2}\overline{\sigma}^{\mu\}}\chi_{1}]p_{1}^{\nu}-(\mu\leftrightarrow\nu)\right)\frac{[\chi_{2}\chi_{1}+\widetilde{\chi}_{2}\widetilde{\chi}_{1}]^{2J_{2}-1}}{(2m_{N})^{2J_{2}-1}}+O(q^{2}). \tag*{(38)}
\end{aligned} j V − μ = j A − μ = j S − = j P − = j T − μν = i m N 2 C M i ϵ μν α β q ν p 1 α ( χ 1 σ β χ 1 ) ( 2 m N ) 2 J 2 [ χ 2 χ 1 + χ 2 χ 1 ] 2 J 2 − m N 2 C Q i ( χ 1 σ { ν χ 1 ) q ν [ χ 2 σ μ } χ 1 − χ 2 σ μ } χ 1 ] ( 2 m N ) 2 J 2 − 1 [ χ 2 χ 1 + χ 2 χ 1 ] 2 J 2 − 1 + O ( q 2 ) , { 2 C A i ( χ 1 σ μ χ 1 ) + m N 2 C I T i p 1 μ ( χ 1 q σ χ 1 ) } ( 2 m N ) 2 J 2 [ χ 2 χ 1 + χ 2 χ 1 ] 2 J 2 + O ( q 2 ) , O ( q 2 ) , m N C P i ( χ 1 q σ χ 1 ) ( 2 m N ) 2 J 2 [ χ 2 χ 1 + χ 2 χ 1 ] 2 J 2 + O ( q 2 ) , − i { m N 2 C T i p 1 μ ( χ 1 σ ν ρ χ 1 ) + m N C T ( 2 ) i ( χ 1 σ [ μ χ 1 ) q ν ] } ( 2 m N ) 2 J 2 [ χ 2 χ 1 + χ 2 χ 1 ] 2 J 2 + i 2 m N 2 C T Q i q α ( χ 1 σ { α χ 1 ) ( [ χ 2 σ μ } χ 1 − χ 2 σ μ } χ 1 ] p 1 ν − ( μ ↔ ν ) ) ( 2 m N ) 2 J 2 − 1 [ χ 2 χ 1 + χ 2 χ 1 ] 2 J 2 − 1 + O ( q 2 ) . (38)
with the understanding that the C Q i C_{Q}^{i} C Q i and C T Q i C_{TQ}^{i} C T Q i structures are absent for J = 1 J = 1 J = 1 . For J = J 2 − 1 J = J_{2} - 1 J = J 2 − 1 , on the other hand, the currents with correct little group and parity transformation properties can be obtained from Eq. (D.1) by 1 ↔ 2 1 \leftrightarrow2 1 ↔ 2 . Adjusting the signs for future convenience, we obtain the currents
j V − μ = − i C M i m N 2 ϵ μ ν α β q ν p 1 α ( χ 2 σ β χ ~ 2 ) [ χ 2 χ 1 + χ ~ 2 χ ~ 1 ] 2 J ( 2 m N ) 2 J + C Q i m N 2 ( χ 2 σ { ν χ ~ 2 ) q ν [ χ 2 σ μ } χ ~ 1 − χ ~ 2 σ ‾ μ } χ 1 ] [ χ 2 χ 1 + χ ~ 2 χ ~ 1 ] 2 J − 1 ( 2 m N ) 2 J − 1 + O ( q 2 ) , j A − μ = − 2 C A i ( χ 2 σ μ χ ~ 2 ) [ χ 2 χ 1 + χ ~ 2 χ ~ 1 ] 2 J ( 2 m N ) 2 J − C I T i m N 2 ( χ 2 q σ χ ~ 2 ) p 1 μ [ χ 2 χ 1 + χ ~ 2 χ ~ 1 ] 2 J ( 2 m N ) 2 J + O ( q 2 ) , j S − = O ( q 2 ) , \begin{aligned}
j_{V-}^{\mu} ={}& -i\frac{C_{M}^{i}}{m_{N}^{2}}\epsilon^{\mu\nu\alpha\beta}q_{\nu}p_{1\alpha}(\chi_{2}\sigma_{\beta}\widetilde{\chi}_{2})\frac{[\chi_{2}\chi_{1}+\widetilde{\chi}_{2}\widetilde{\chi}_{1}]^{2J}}{(2m_{N})^{2J}} \\
&+\frac{C_{Q}^{i}}{m_{N}^{2}}(\chi_{2}\sigma^{\{\nu}\widetilde{\chi}_{2})q_{\nu}[\chi_{2}\sigma^{\mu\}}\widetilde{\chi}_{1}-\widetilde{\chi}_{2}\overline{\sigma}^{\mu\}}\chi_{1}]\frac{[\chi_{2}\chi_{1}+\widetilde{\chi}_{2}\widetilde{\chi}_{1}]^{2J-1}}{(2m_{N})^{2J-1}}+O(q^{2}), \\
j_{A-}^{\mu} ={}& -2C_{A}^{i}(\chi_{2}\sigma^{\mu}\widetilde{\chi}_{2})\frac{[\chi_{2}\chi_{1}+\widetilde{\chi}_{2}\widetilde{\chi}_{1}]^{2J}}{(2m_{N})^{2J}}-\frac{C_{IT}^{i}}{m_{N}^{2}}(\chi_{2}q\sigma\widetilde{\chi}_{2})p_{1}^{\mu}\frac{[\chi_{2}\chi_{1}+\widetilde{\chi}_{2}\widetilde{\chi}_{1}]^{2J}}{(2m_{N})^{2J}}+O(q^{2}), \\
j_{S-} ={}& O(q^{2}),
\end{aligned} j V − μ = j A − μ = j S − = − i m N 2 C M i ϵ μν α β q ν p 1 α ( χ 2 σ β χ 2 ) ( 2 m N ) 2 J [ χ 2 χ 1 + χ 2 χ 1 ] 2 J + m N 2 C Q i ( χ 2 σ { ν χ 2 ) q ν [ χ 2 σ μ } χ 1 − χ 2 σ μ } χ 1 ] ( 2 m N ) 2 J − 1 [ χ 2 χ 1 + χ 2 χ 1 ] 2 J − 1 + O ( q 2 ) , − 2 C A i ( χ 2 σ μ χ 2 ) ( 2 m N ) 2 J [ χ 2 χ 1 + χ 2 χ 1 ] 2 J − m N 2 C I T i ( χ 2 q σ χ 2 ) p 1 μ ( 2 m N ) 2 J [ χ 2 χ 1 + χ 2 χ 1 ] 2 J + O ( q 2 ) , O ( q 2 ) ,
j P − = − C P i m N ( χ 2 q σ χ ~ 2 ) [ χ 2 χ 1 + χ ~ 2 χ ~ 1 ] 2 J ( 2 m N ) 2 J + O ( q 2 ) , j_{P-}=-\frac{C_P^i}{m_N}(\chi_2 q \sigma\tilde{\chi}_2)\frac{[\chi_2\chi_1+\tilde{\chi}_2\tilde{\chi}_1]^{2J}}{(2m_N)^{2J}}+O(q^2), j P − = − m N C P i ( χ 2 q σ χ ~ 2 ) ( 2 m N ) 2 J [ χ 2 χ 1 + χ ~ 2 χ ~ 1 ] 2 J + O ( q 2 ) ,
j T − μ ν = i { 2 C T i m N p 1 [ μ ( χ 2 σ ν ] χ ~ 2 ) + C T ( 2 ) i m N ( χ 2 σ [ μ χ ~ 2 ) q ν ] } [ χ 2 χ 1 + χ ~ 2 χ ~ 1 ] 2 J ( 2 m N ) 2 J − i C T Q i 2 m N 3 q α ( χ 2 σ { α χ ~ 2 ) ( [ χ 2 σ μ } χ ~ 1 − χ ~ 2 σ ˉ μ } χ 1 ] p 1 ν − ( μ ↔ ν ) ) [ χ 2 χ 1 + χ ~ 2 χ ~ 1 ] 2 J − 1 ( 2 m N ) 2 J − 1 + O ( q 2 ) , (39) \begin{aligned}
j_{T-}^{\mu\nu}={}&i\left\{\frac{2C_T^i}{m_N}p_1^{[\mu}(\chi_2\sigma^{\nu]}\tilde{\chi}_2)+\frac{C_{T(2)}^i}{m_N}(\chi_2\sigma^{[\mu}\tilde{\chi}_2)q^{\nu]}\right\}\frac{[\chi_2\chi_1+\tilde{\chi}_2\tilde{\chi}_1]^{2J}}{(2m_N)^{2J}}\\
&-i\frac{C_{TQ}^i}{2m_N^3}q_\alpha(\chi_2\sigma^{\{\alpha}\tilde{\chi}_2)\left([\chi_2\sigma^{\mu\}}\tilde{\chi}_1-\tilde{\chi}_2\bar{\sigma}^{\mu\}}\chi_1]p_1^\nu-(\mu\leftrightarrow\nu)\right)\frac{[\chi_2\chi_1+\tilde{\chi}_2\tilde{\chi}_1]^{2J-1}}{(2m_N)^{2J-1}}+O(q^2), \tag*{(39)}
\end{aligned} j T − μν = i { m N 2 C T i p 1 [ μ ( χ 2 σ ν ] χ ~ 2 ) + m N C T ( 2 ) i ( χ 2 σ [ μ χ ~ 2 ) q ν ] } ( 2 m N ) 2 J [ χ 2 χ 1 + χ ~ 2 χ ~ 1 ] 2 J − i 2 m N 3 C T Q i q α ( χ 2 σ { α χ ~ 2 ) ( [ χ 2 σ μ } χ ~ 1 − χ ~ 2 σ ˉ μ } χ 1 ] p 1 ν − ( μ ↔ ν ) ) ( 2 m N ) 2 J − 1 [ χ 2 χ 1 + χ ~ 2 χ ~ 1 ] 2 J − 1 + O ( q 2 ) , (39)
with the understanding that the C Q i C_Q^i C Q i and C T Q i C_{TQ}^i C T Q i structures are absent for J = 0 J=0 J = 0 .
Expanding the spinor bilinears in the recoil momentum up to O ( q 2 ) O(q^2) O ( q 2 ) corrections, both Eqs. (D.1) and (D.2) lead to
j V − μ = − i C M i m N ϵ μ ν α β q ν p 1 α Σ β + C Q i q ν Σ μ ν , j_{V-}^{\mu}=-i\frac{C_M^i}{m_N}\epsilon^{\mu\nu\alpha\beta}q_\nu p_{1\alpha}\Sigma_\beta+C_Q^i q_\nu\Sigma^{\mu\nu}, j V − μ = − i m N C M i ϵ μν α β q ν p 1 α Σ β + C Q i q ν Σ μν ,
j A − μ = 2 m N C A i Σ μ + C T i + α A C A i m N p 1 μ q ν Σ ν , j_{A-}^{\mu}=2m_N C_A^i\Sigma^\mu+\frac{C_{T}^i+\alpha_A C_A^i}{m_N}p_1^\mu q_\nu\Sigma^\nu, j A − μ = 2 m N C A i Σ μ + m N C T i + α A C A i p 1 μ q ν Σ ν ,
j P − = C P i q ν Σ ν , j_{P-}=C_P^i q_\nu\Sigma^\nu, j P − = C P i q ν Σ ν ,
j T − μ ν = − i C T i [ p 1 μ Σ ν − p 1 ν Σ μ ] + i C T ( 2 ) i 2 [ q μ Σ ν − q ν Σ μ ] + i C T Q i 2 m N [ p 1 μ Σ ν α − p 1 ν Σ μ α ] q α , (40) j_{T-}^{\mu\nu}=-iC_T^i[p_1^\mu\Sigma^\nu-p_1^\nu\Sigma^\mu]+i\frac{C_{T(2)}^i}{2}[q^\mu\Sigma^\nu-q^\nu\Sigma^\mu]+i\frac{C_{TQ}^i}{2m_N}[p_1^\mu\Sigma^{\nu\alpha}-p_1^\nu\Sigma^{\mu\alpha}]q_\alpha, \tag*{(40)} j T − μν = − i C T i [ p 1 μ Σ ν − p 1 ν Σ μ ] + i 2 C T ( 2 ) i [ q μ Σ ν − q ν Σ μ ] + i 2 m N C T Q i [ p 1 μ Σ ν α − p 1 ν Σ μα ] q α , (40)
where α A \alpha_A α A is defined in Table 2 , and
[ Σ μ ] O 3 … O 2 J I 1 … I 2 J ≡ ( χ 1 I 1 σ μ χ ~ 1 I 2 ) m N δ O 3 I 3 … δ O 2 J I 2 J , [\Sigma^\mu]^{I_1\ldots I_{2J}}_{O_3\ldots O_{2J}}\equiv\frac{(\chi_1^{I_1}\sigma^\mu\tilde{\chi}_1^{I_2})}{m_N}\delta_{O_3}^{I_3}\ldots\delta_{O_{2J}}^{I_{2J}}, [ Σ μ ] O 3 … O 2 J I 1 … I 2 J ≡ m N ( χ 1 I 1 σ μ χ ~ 1 I 2 ) δ O 3 I 3 … δ O 2 J I 2 J ,
[ Σ μ ν ] O 3 … O 2 J I 1 … I 2 J ≡ ( χ 1 I 1 σ { μ χ ~ 1 I 2 ) ( χ 1 O 3 σ ν } χ ~ 1 I 3 + χ ~ 1 O 3 σ ˉ ν } χ 1 I 3 ) m N 2 δ O 4 I 4 … δ O 2 J I 2 J , (41) [\Sigma^{\mu\nu}]^{I_1\ldots I_{2J}}_{O_3\ldots O_{2J}}\equiv\frac{(\chi_1^{I_1}\sigma^{\{\mu}\tilde{\chi}_1^{I_2})(\chi_{1O_3}\sigma^{\nu\}}\tilde{\chi}_1^{I_3}+\tilde{\chi}_{1O_3}\bar{\sigma}^{\nu\}}\chi_1^{I_3})}{m_N^2}\delta_{O_4}^{I_4}\ldots\delta_{O_{2J}}^{I_{2J}}, \tag*{(41)} [ Σ μν ] O 3 … O 2 J I 1 … I 2 J ≡ m N 2 ( χ 1 I 1 σ { μ χ ~ 1 I 2 ) ( χ 1 O 3 σ ν } χ ~ 1 I 3 + χ ~ 1 O 3 σ ˉ ν } χ 1 I 3 ) δ O 4 I 4 … δ O 2 J I 2 J , (41)
[ Σ μ ] O 1 … O 2 J + 2 I 1 … I 2 J ≡ 1 m N ( χ 1 O 2 J + 1 σ μ χ ~ 1 O 2 J + 2 ) δ O 1 I 1 … δ O 2 J I 2 J , [\Sigma^\mu]^{I_1\ldots I_{2J}}_{O_1\ldots O_{2J+2}}\equiv\frac{1}{m_N}(\chi_{1O_{2J+1}}\sigma^\mu\tilde{\chi}_{1O_{2J+2}})\delta_{O_1}^{I_1}\ldots\delta_{O_{2J}}^{I_{2J}}, [ Σ μ ] O 1 … O 2 J + 2 I 1 … I 2 J ≡ m N 1 ( χ 1 O 2 J + 1 σ μ χ ~ 1 O 2 J + 2 ) δ O 1 I 1 … δ O 2 J I 2 J ,
[ Σ μ ν ] O 1 … O 2 J + 2 I 1 … I 2 J ≡ 1 m N 2 ( χ 1 O 2 J + 1 σ { μ χ ~ 1 O 2 J + 2 ) ( χ 1 O 1 σ ν } χ ~ 1 I 1 + χ ~ 1 O 1 σ ˉ ν } χ 1 I 1 ) δ O 2 I 2 … δ O 2 J I 2 J . (42) [\Sigma^{\mu\nu}]^{I_1\ldots I_{2J}}_{O_1\ldots O_{2J+2}}\equiv\frac{1}{m_N^2}(\chi_{1O_{2J+1}}\sigma^{\{\mu}\tilde{\chi}_{1O_{2J+2}})(\chi_{1O_1}\sigma^{\nu\}}\tilde{\chi}_1^{I_1}+\tilde{\chi}_{1O_1}\bar{\sigma}^{\nu\}}\chi_1^{I_1})\delta_{O_2}^{I_2}\ldots\delta_{O_{2J}}^{I_{2J}}. \tag*{(42)} [ Σ μν ] O 1 … O 2 J + 2 I 1 … I 2 J ≡ m N 2 1 ( χ 1 O 2 J + 1 σ { μ χ ~ 1 O 2 J + 2 ) ( χ 1 O 1 σ ν } χ ~ 1 I 1 + χ ~ 1 O 1 σ ˉ ν } χ 1 I 1 ) δ O 2 I 2 … δ O 2 J I 2 J . (42)
Σ μ \Sigma^\mu Σ μ and Σ μ ν \Sigma^{\mu\nu} Σ μν are analogous to the spin vector and tensor defined in Eqs. (A.1) and (A.2), but with the little-group index structure appropriate for spin changing by one unit. We also define [ Σ ˉ μ ] I 1 … I 2 J O 3 … O 2 J ≡ ( [ Σ μ ] O 3 … O 2 J I 1 … I 2 J ) ∗ [\bar{\Sigma}^\mu]^{O_3\ldots O_{2J}}_{I_1\ldots I_{2J}}\equiv([\Sigma^\mu]^{I_1\ldots I_{2J}}_{O_3\ldots O_{2J}})^* [ Σ ˉ μ ] I 1 … I 2 J O 3 … O 2 J ≡ ([ Σ μ ] O 3 … O 2 J I 1 … I 2 J ) ∗ for J = J 2 + 1 J=J_2+1 J = J 2 + 1 , [ Σ ˉ μ ] I 1 … I 2 J O 1 … O 2 J + 2 ≡ ( [ Σ μ ] O 1 … O 2 J + 2 I 1 … I 2 J ) ∗ [\bar{\Sigma}^\mu]^{O_1\ldots O_{2J+2}}_{I_1\ldots I_{2J}}\equiv([\Sigma^\mu]^{I_1\ldots I_{2J}}_{O_1\ldots O_{2J+2}})^* [ Σ ˉ μ ] I 1 … I 2 J O 1 … O 2 J + 2 ≡ ([ Σ μ ] O 1 … O 2 J + 2 I 1 … I 2 J ) ∗ for J = J 2 − 1 J=J_2-1 J = J 2 − 1 , and likewise for Σ ˉ μ ν \bar{\Sigma}^{\mu\nu} Σ ˉ μν . We have the identities
Σ μ Σ ˉ ν = − 2 3 Π μ ν 1 + i J m N ϵ μ ν α β p 1 α S β − 1 J ( J − 1 2 ) S μ ν , J ≥ 1 , \Sigma^\mu\bar{\Sigma}^\nu=-\frac{2}{3}\Pi^{\mu\nu}\mathbf{1}+\frac{i}{Jm_N}\epsilon^{\mu\nu\alpha\beta}p_{1\alpha}S_\beta-\frac{1}{J(J-\frac{1}{2})}S^{\mu\nu},\qquad J\geq1, Σ μ Σ ˉ ν = − 3 2 Π μν 1 + J m N i ϵ μν α β p 1 α S β − J ( J − 2 1 ) 1 S μν , J ≥ 1 ,
Σ μ Σ ˉ ν ρ = 1 5 J [ 3 Π μ ν S ρ + 3 Π μ ρ S ν − 2 Π ν ρ S μ ] − i J ( J − 1 2 ) m N [ ϵ μ ν α β p 1 α S β ρ + ϵ μ ρ α β p 1 α S β ν ] + 2 J ( J − 1 2 ) ( J − 1 ) S μ ν ρ , J ≥ 3 2 , (43) \Sigma^\mu\bar{\Sigma}^\nu\rho= \frac{1}{5J}\left[3\Pi^{\mu\nu}S^\rho+3\Pi^{\mu\rho}S^\nu-2\Pi^{\nu\rho}S^\mu\right]-\frac{i}{J(J-\frac{1}{2})m_N}\left[\epsilon^{\mu\nu\alpha\beta}p_{1\alpha}S_\beta{}^\rho+\epsilon^{\mu\rho\alpha\beta}p_{1\alpha}S_\beta{}^\nu\right]+\frac{2}{J(J-\frac{1}{2})(J-1)}S^{\mu\nu\rho},\qquad J\geq\frac{3}{2}, \tag*{(43)} Σ μ Σ ˉ ν ρ = 5 J 1 [ 3 Π μν S ρ + 3 Π μ ρ S ν − 2 Π ν ρ S μ ] − J ( J − 2 1 ) m N i [ ϵ μν α β p 1 α S β ρ + ϵ μ ρ α β p 1 α S β ν ] + J ( J − 2 1 ) ( J − 1 ) 2 S μν ρ , J ≥ 2 3 , (43)
Σ μ Σ ˉ ν = − 2 J + 3 2 J + 1 { 2 3 Π μ ν 1 + i ( J + 1 ) m N ϵ μ ν α β p 1 α S β + 2 ( J + 1 ) ( 2 J + 3 ) S μ ν } , \Sigma^\mu\bar{\Sigma}^\nu=-\frac{2J+3}{2J+1}\left\{\frac{2}{3}\Pi^{\mu\nu}\mathbf{1}+\frac{i}{(J+1)m_N}\epsilon^{\mu\nu\alpha\beta}p_{1\alpha}S_\beta+\frac{2}{(J+1)(2J+3)}S^{\mu\nu}\right\}, Σ μ Σ ˉ ν = − 2 J + 1 2 J + 3 { 3 2 Π μν 1 + ( J + 1 ) m N i ϵ μν α β p 1 α S β + ( J + 1 ) ( 2 J + 3 ) 2 S μν } ,
Σ μ Σ ˉ ν ρ = 1 J ( J + 1 2 ) ( J + 1 ) { ( J + 3 2 ) ( J + 2 ) 5 [ 3 Π μ ν S ρ + 3 Π μ ρ S ν − 2 Π ν ρ S μ ] + i ( J + 2 ) m N [ ϵ μ ν α β p 1 α S β ρ + ϵ μ ρ α β p 1 α S β ν ] + 2 S μ ν ρ } , J ≥ 1 2 , (44) \Sigma^\mu\bar{\Sigma}^\nu\rho=\frac{1}{J(J+\frac{1}{2})(J+1)}\left\{\frac{(J+\frac{3}{2})(J+2)}{5}\left[3\Pi^{\mu\nu}S^\rho+3\Pi^{\mu\rho}S^\nu-2\Pi^{\nu\rho}S^\mu\right]+\frac{i(J+2)}{m_N}\left[\epsilon^{\mu\nu\alpha\beta}p_{1\alpha}S_\beta{}^\rho+\epsilon^{\mu\rho\alpha\beta}p_{1\alpha}S_\beta{}^\nu\right]+2S^{\mu\nu\rho}\right\},\qquad J\geq\frac{1}{2}, \tag*{(44)} Σ μ Σ ˉ ν ρ = J ( J + 2 1 ) ( J + 1 ) 1 { 5 ( J + 2 3 ) ( J + 2 ) [ 3 Π μν S ρ + 3 Π μ ρ S ν − 2 Π ν ρ S μ ] + m N i ( J + 2 ) [ ϵ μν α β p 1 α S β ρ + ϵ μ ρ α β p 1 α S β ν ] + 2 S μν ρ } , J ≥ 2 1 , (44)
where Π μ ν ≡ η μ ν − p 1 μ p 1 ν m N 2 \Pi^{\mu\nu}\equiv\eta^{\mu\nu}-\frac{p_1^\mu p_1^\nu}{m_N^2} Π μν ≡ η μν − m N 2 p 1 μ p 1 ν , and S μ ν ρ S^{\mu\nu\rho} S μν ρ is defined in Eq. (A.2).
In these formulas, the left-hand sides implicitly involve summing over the little group indices of the daughter nucleus. In Eq. (D.7) it is implicit that S μ S^\mu S μ should be omitted for J = 0 J=0 J = 0 , S μ ν S^{\mu\nu} S μν should be omitted for J ≤ 1 / 2 J\leq1/2 J ≤ 1/2 , and S μ ν ρ S^{\mu\nu\rho} S μν ρ should be omitted for J ≤ 1 J\leq1 J ≤ 1 .
For β + \beta^+ β + decay our convention is that we replace in Eqs. (D.1) to (D.3) C A , T , M , P i → C ˉ A , T , M , P i C^i_{A,T,M,P}\to\bar{C}^i_{A,T,M,P} C A , T , M , P i → C ˉ A , T , M , P i , and C Q , I T , T ( 2 ) , T Q i → − C ˉ Q , I T , T ( 2 ) , T Q i C^i_{Q,IT,T(2),TQ}\to-\bar{C}^i_{Q,IT,T(2),TQ} C Q , I T , T ( 2 ) , T Q i → − C ˉ Q , I T , T ( 2 ) , T Q i .