WorksPhysics and Astronomy
Thermal Hall effect in a van der Waals ferromagnet CrI3
Abstract
CrI3 is a prototypical van der Waals ferromagnet with a magnetic honeycomb lattice. Previous inelastic neutron scattering studies have suggested topological nature of its magnetic excitations with a magnon gap at the Dirac points, which are anticipated to give rise to magnon thermal Hall effect. Here we report thermal transport properties of CrI3 and show that the long-sought thermal Hall signal anticipated for topological magnons is fairly small. In contrast, we find that CrI3 exhibits an appreciable anomalous thermal Hall signal at lower temperature which may arise from magnon-phonon hybridization or magnon-phonon scattering. These findings are anticipated to stimulate further neutron scattering studies on CrI3 single crystal, which can shed light not only on the intrinsic nature of magnetic excitations but also on the magnon-phonon interaction.
These authors contributed equally to this work.
Introduction
The discovery of exotic electronic properties in monolayer graphene has opened a new research arena of searching for novel quasi-two-dimensional (2D) van der Waals (vdW) materials beyond graphene [1, 2]. One prominent class of such materials are vdW magnets. With magnetism acting as a control knob, 2D vdW magnets provide an exciting playground for the discovery and exploration of novel physical phenomena and perhaps new physics [3, 4, 5, 6]. In addition to various magnetic ground states and unconventional magnetism, vdW magnets also display many other novel phenomena. For instance, ferromagnetism can persist down to the monolayer limit owing to the material’s magnetic anisotropy [7, 8]. Depending on the layer numbers, the magnetic ground state of exfoliated vdW magnets varies [7]. One can also tune the magnetic ground properties using various non-thermal perturbations, such as strain [9, 10], electric gating [11, 12], proximity effect [13, 14, 15, 16], etc. Furthermore, new phenomena – so-called Moiré magnetism – can emerge by stacking layers of vdW magnets on top of each other with certain twisting angles [17, 18, 19].
In addition to the interesting static magnetic properties, another intriguing aspect of vdW magnets is due to the potential topological characteristic of their magnetic excitations. Particularly, vdW ferromagnets with magnetic ions occupying a Kagome lattice or a honeycomb lattice were proposed to host topological magnons [20, 21]. In a ferromagnetic Kagome lattice or honeycomb lattice, there are six symmetry-protected magnon band crossings at K-points, which retain their degeneracy in the presence of symmetric exchange interactions (e.g. Heisenberg interactions). Because of the inversion symmetry breaking relative to the center of the nearest-neighbor bond of Kagome lattice or the second-nearest neighbor bond of honeycomb lattice, the asymmetric Dzyaloshinskii-Moriya interaction (DMI) consequently lifts the degeneracy at these K-points and leads to the opening of magnon gaps. By calculating the Berry curvature of these gapped magnon bands and the associated Chern number, it has been shown that the gapped magnon bands are topological in nature [20, 21]. Such unique magnon modes can give rise to thermal Hall effect (THE), i.e., an induced transverse heat flow in the presence of a longitudinal temperature gradient [22, 23].
The magnon gap opening at -points and the emergence of THE have been reported in Cu(1,3–bdc) which has a Kagome lattice of ions, suggesting that the magnetic excitations of Cu(1,3-bdc) are topological in nature [24, 25]. For a ferromagnetic honeycomb lattice, the most salient system is in which the inelastic neutron scattering (INS) studies have found a gap opening at the -points of magnon bands [26]. However, the underlying mechanism of the observed gap opening remains controversial [26, 27, 28, 29, 30, 31]. For instance, is it driven intrinsically by the DMI [26] or the Kitaev interaction [28], or associated with the interlayer couplings [30], or perhaps driven extrinsically by the mosaic of co-aligned samples for neutron scattering studies [27]? Surprisingly, to date there is no report of THE in literature on , despite the fact that the magnon THE provides smoking-gun evidence of the topological character of low-energy magnetic excitations.
In this work, we report the thermal transport studies of single crystals. we find that the thermal Hall signal associated with the anticipated topological magnetic excitations is fairly small, about an order in magnitude smaller than the predicted value based on the reported DMI values in previous INS studies [26, 27]. In contrast, we show that exhibits an appreciable anomalous thermal Hall signal at low temperature, which is presumably of phononic origin. Potential mechanisms of the THE features observed in are discussed.
EXPERIMETNAL METHODS
CrI has a layered structure with a honeycomb layer of chromium atoms separated by two layers of iodine atoms along the -axis, as shown in Fig. S1 in the Supplemental Material [32]. It undergoes a paramagnetic-to-ferromagnetic phase transition with K and spins aligned along the -axis [33]. In this work, single crystals of CrI were synthesized using chemical vapor transport method [33]. The magnetic susceptibility data were measured using a Superconducting Quantum Interference Device (SQUID, Quantum Design). The thermal transport measurements were conducted using one-heater three-sensor technique on a sample puck adapted to a Physical Property Measurement System (PPMS, Quantum Design). The longitudinal and transverse thermal conductivity were simultaneously measured using a conventional steady-state method. The magnetic field was applied along the magnetic easy axis, i.e., -axis. A schematic of the experimental setup for thermal transport measurements is shown in Fig. S2 [32], and more detailed information can be found in the Supplemental Material of Ref. [34]. To minimize exposing the CrI samples to the air (moisture), the devices were prepared inside a glove bag equipped with an internal microscope and a continuous flow of high purity nitrogen gas.
Results and Discussion
Figure 1(a) shows the temperature dependence of magnetic susceptibility () of CrI measured under zero-field-cooled (ZFC) condition with an applied field of 0.1 T (). sharply increases below the ordering temperature of K and then saturates, indicative of a ferromagnetic phase transition, which is consistent with the literature [33]. In Figure 1(b), we present the thermal conductivity () measured as a function of temperature at 0 T and 5 T magnetic field (). There are a couple of noteworthy features. First, no anomaly in is obviously observed near . Since CrI is an insulator, its total is composed of magnon () and phonon () contributions. Thus, the little effect of magnetic ordering on suggests that dominates over in CrI, a feature distinct from its sister compound CrCl [35]. Second, the change in induced by an applied magnetic field () is very subtle compared to the signal itself. Therefore, to better quantify this change, we plot as a function of temperature in Figure 1(c) together with the scaled temperature derivative of , for reference.

Figure 1. (a) The temperature dependence of magnetic susceptibility () measured at 0.1 T under zero-field-cooling (ZFC) condition. (b) The temperature dependence of of two samples measured at 0 T and high magnetic fields. (c) Temperature vs () (black) and temperature derivative of magnetic susceptibility (red).
We can see that both curves exhibit an upward trend above , which is due to the onset of short-range magnetic correlations prior to the long-range order. The positive value of in the high-temperature regime indicates the existence of magnon-phonon coupling in CrI. While magnons and phonons contribute individually to the thermal conduction, they also scatter each other, which tends to suppress the total thermal conduction. At high temperatures, in the absence of magnetic field magnons (or incoherent magnons right above ) scatters phonons, which reduces the contribution and dominates over the term. An applied magnetic field suppresses magnon population by lifting the magnon bands to higher energy, which subsequently reduces the phonon scattering by magnons and (partially) restores the contribution and thus enhances the total , leading to positive . Similar feature has been observed in another CrI sample as shown in Figure 1 and in Fig. S3 [32] and in other vdW magnets, such as CrCl [35], VI [34], and FeCl [36].
changes the sign below 6 K, implying that in the lower temperature region the field-induced reduction of magnon contributions to is larger than the restoration of phonon contribution due to the suppression of phonon scattering by magnons. Note that while the low-temperature value of CrI is nearly an order in magnitude larger than that of VI (Fig. S4), is comparable which implies a similar strength of magnon-phonon coupling in both compounds.
We move on to discuss the transverse thermal signal of CrI. As will be shown later, it is worth noting that the magnitude of the intrinsic thermal Hall resistivity of CrI (in the order of ) is found to be much smaller than that of the longitudinal thermal resistivity . Therefore, when dealing with signals with such small magnitude, validating the intrinsic nature of the observed signal is pressing [37]. Here, we examine the nature of the THE observed in CrI by studying the hysteresis behavior, the applied heating power dependence, and the sample dependence. We first present the hysteresis behavior of both longitudinal and transverse thermal resistivity and demonstrate that these two measured quantities exhibit distinct behaviors. In Figure 2(a-Figure 2b), we present the raw measurement data of and measured at K. Here the orange and blue curves represent the data measured during field ramping down (1 T to -1 T) and ramping up (-1 T to 1 T) processes, respectively. In contrast to the measured which is nearly symmetric between positive and negative fields [Figure 2(a)], we can see that shows an asymmetry between positive and negative fields that is superimposed with a large symmetric (even) component. Such an even component stems from the contribution introduced due to a small misalignment between the transverse temperature leads, since the intrinsic is much smaller than . Generally, one performs anti-symmetrization to eliminate the longitudinal contribution to the measured . In Figure 2(c-Figure 2d) we present the odd component \[w^{odd} = (w^{H+} - w^{H-})/2\] of both longitudinal and transverse thermal resistivity as and , where () stands for the thermal resistivity measured in the positive (negative) field region. One can see that while the data obtained for these two processes are similar to each other, shows an opposite trend for two field ramping processes, which arises from the hysteresis of . This suggests that a small misalignment between the transverse temperature leads can cause to pick up an extrinsic contribution from which cannot be eliminated by simply anti-symmetrizing the raw data. Instead, this extrinsic contribution can be properly eliminated by averaging the data extracted from both field ramping processes. The resultant asymmetric components for the longitudinal and transverse thermal signal are shown in Figure 2(e-Figure 2f). We can see that shown in Figure 2(e) is nearly zero. In contrast, the thus-extracted , the red symbols shown in Figure 2(f), shows an odd function of magnetic field whose general shape is similar to the magnetization curve (black dash line) measured at the same temperature, representing an intrinsic transverse thermal Hall signal. Similar data processing procedures have been previously applied to extract the intrinsic thermal Hall signal in other systems, such as α-RuCl [37] and FeCl [36].

Figure 2. (a) Thermal resistivity hysteresis between -1 T and 1 T. (b) Thermal hall resistivity hysteresis between -1 T and 1 T. (c-d) The odd component and (), which are from (a-b). (e-f) Asymmetric component and (), which are from (c-d), the dash black line is magnetization curve . Data were measured at K.
We also study the dependence of on the heating power . For an intrinsic THE, the transverse temperature difference scales linearly with , as implied from the definition of () where is thickness of the sample. As shown in Fig. S5, at three different applied heating powers (800 W, 1000 W, 1470 W), the signal is nearly identical, indicating that the thermal Hall signal is indeed independent of . We have also reproduced similar results on another piece of CrI sample [See Fig. S6]. These results affirm the intrinsic nature of the THE observed in CrI.
Figure 3 presents the magnetic field dependence of thermal Hall conductivity (), which is defined as (), measured at various temperatures. The dashed curves are guides to eyes. At low field increases sharply alike the curve seen in Figure 2(f), suggesting that at low field mainly arises from the anomalous THE. Upon increasing the magnetic field, there is an additional component that is linearly proportional to the magnetic field. As shown in Fig. S7, the temperature dependence of the coefficient of this linear THE component displays a broad peak near the same temperature as in the curve. These features are similar to those observed in paramagnetic SrTiO [38] or antiferromagnetic CuTeO [39], implying that this linear THE component is purely driven phonons the mechanism of which is beyond the scope of current study.

Figure 3. The thermal Hall conductivity measured at various temperatures.
We now focus on the anomalous THE component. To better quantify the temperature dependence of the anomalous thermal Hall signal, Figure 4(a) shows the temperature dependence of the extracted anomalous thermal Hall conductivity (). There are two features worth pointing out. First, exhibits a broad peak around 10 K, which is close to the temperature at which the longitudinal thermal conductivity maximizes. Similar behavior is also observed on another sample (Sample 2) shown in Figure 4(a), affirming its reproducibility. This suggests that the observed in this temperature region is related to phonon. However, here could not be purely driven by phonon, as evidenced by the extracted shown in the inset of Figure 4(a) which resembles the curve shown in Figure 2(f). Instead, phonons are responsible for the anomalous THE component via magnon(spin)-phonon coupling due to the magnetoelastic interaction. Similar features have been observed in the VI system [34]. A plausible mechanism is associated with magnon-phonon hybridization. Magnons and phonons hybridize at the band anticrossing points, forming a new type of quasiparticle, the magnon-polaron. Berry curvature hotspots are induced in the region near the anticrossing points between the two hybridized bands, which are anticipated to give rise to a THE [40, 41, 42, 43]. Recent first-principles calculations showed that, without considering the spin-lattice coupling, the low-energy magnon bands and the acoustic phonon bands cross each other at meV and 5.0 meV, at which an observation of the hybridization gap is anticipated when spin-lattice coupling is taken into account [31]. A future INS study to directly probe potential magnon-phonon hybridizations in CrI is desirable. Another plausible mechanism to explain the anomalous THE component is magnon-phonon scattering. As discussed previously, phonons are scattered by magnons, which results in slight suppression of . It was recently predicted that, similar to the extrinsic anomalous Hall effect induced by skew scattering and side-jump scattering of charge carriers, scattering of phonons by collective fluctuations may give rise to the THE [44].

Figure 4. (a) Temperature dependence of anomalous thermal Hall conductivity . The curves are overplotted for reference. Inset shows the extracted as a function of field at 16.6 K. (b) The calculated with various DMI values ().
Second, the value drops quickly to nearly zero in the high temperature region. This finding is a surprise and it is in sharp contrast to the observed in in which a large thermal Hall signal is observed over a wide range of temperature nearly up to [34]. As discussed in the introduction, the sizable magnon gap at K points observed in via INS studies, which was ascribed to the DMI [26, 27], suggests the topological nature of magnetic excitations in that is anticipated to lead to the THE. To support this, we have simulated the magnon bands using a Hamiltonian consisting of exchange parameters extracted from the most recent INS studies [27] and calculated the corresponding thermal Hall conductivity. As shown in Figure 4(b), with a DMI of 0.09 meV that was recently reported [27], an appreciable thermal Hall signal is anticipated in the high temperature region with a maximum value of , which is nearly an order in magnitude larger than the experimental observation presented in Figure 4(a). This raises an intriguing question: Why is the observed thermal Hall signal in so small in the high temperature region compared to the theoretical prediction?
One possible scenario is that the DMI value extracted by fitting the magnetic excitations obtained based on the INS studies using the linear spin wave theory might be overestimated. Indeed, a recent INS study found that the mosaic of co-aligned single crystals artificially contributes to the magnons gap opening at K points, which can lead to an overestimation of the DMI value [26, 27]. This is also strongly supported by recent INS studies on a single, large piece of single crystal of [45] and [46] in which the magnon bands cross each other at K points within the instrumental energy resolution, which is in contrast to the observation of a large magnon gap reported in co-aligned single crystals [47]. These results suggest that the intrinsic DMI is neglectable in both and [45, 46]. Although the spin-orbit coupling of iodine atoms is larger than that of bromine and chlorine atoms, which may lead to a larger DMI in than that of and , it is likely that the previously determined DMI in based on the most recent INS studies is still overestimated due to the 8° sample mosaic of the co-aligned single crystals (compared to 17° reported in an earlier study) [26, 27]. In Figure 4, we plot the calculated thermal Hall conductivity based on a 2D monolayer model with various DMI values. We can see that the calculated thermal Hall conductivity with a DMI of 0.01 meV better agrees with the experimental data.
Another possible mechanism to account for the small thermal Hall signal may be ascribed to the combined effects of the interlayer coupling and the third-neighbor intralayer interaction in . Note that the sign of in is opposite to that found in [34]. Recent theoretical calculations showed that the thermal Hall conductivity in strongly depends on both the interlayer coupling and the 3rd neighbor intralayer coupling and that even the sign of can change [29]. With certain phase parameters, the magnetic excitation becomes gapless Weyl type instead of topological magnon insulator, which gives rise to zero/small thermal Hall signal [29]. INS studies on a large, single piece of single crystal are demanding, which may allow further determination of the exchange interactions and DMI without the need to consider the extrinsic effect stemming from the mosaic of co-aligned samples. This will help to clarify the topological nature of magnetic excitations in and to clarify the mechanisms that account for the thermal Hall signal observed in this study.
Finally, we would like to briefly comment the potential effects of magnon-magnon interactions on . Due to the absence of particle-number conservation law for bosonic excitations, the magnon-magnon interactions can affect the topology of magnetic excitations and thus affect the THE. On the one hand, magnon-magnon interactions can give rise to magnon damping, which is anticipated to suppress [48]. However, magnon damping in CrI was not discernable in the previous INS studies [26, 27]. It is likely that the higher-order magnon-magnon interactions need to be taken into account for the suppression of , as argued in a recent study of SrCu(BO) [49]. On the other hand, a recent theoretical study suggested that, instead of being detrimental to topology, magnon-magnon interactions can serve as a source of topology of magnon bands and lead to the THE [50].
Conclusion
In summary, we report thermal transport properties of the 2D vdW honeycomb ferromagnet CrI, a long-sought topological magnon insulator candidate. We show that the thermal Hall signal in the higher temperature region, which is anticipated for topological magnon insulators, is fairly small. An intrinsically small DMI or the cooperative effect of interlayer coupling and intralayer interaction may account for this observation. In contrast, we find that CrI exhibits THE with an appreciable anomalous thermal Hall signal in the lower temperature region which may arise from magnon-phonon hybridization or magnon-phonon scattering. These findings will stimulate future INS studies on a large, single piece of CrI crystal, which can shed light not only on the magnon-phonon interaction but also on the intrinsic nature of magnetic excitations, which will in turn help elucidate the observed THE phenomena in this study.
Acknowledgements
H.Z. and X.K. acknowledge the financial support by the U.S. Department of Energy, Office of Science, Office of Basic Energy Sciences, Materials Sciences and Engineering Division under DE-SC0019259. X.K. also acknowledges the financial support by the National Science Foundation (DMR-2219046). P.Z. acknowledges the financial support by the National Science Foundation (DMR-2112691). C.C. and D.X. are supported by AFOSR MURI 2D MAGIC (FA9550-19-1-0390). C.X. is partially supported by the Start-up funds at Michigan State University.
References
- [1]G.R. Bhimanapati, Z. Lin, V. Meunier, Y. Jung, J. Cha, S. Das, D. Xiao, Y. Son, M.S. Strano, V.R. Cooper, L. Liang, S.G. Louie, E. Ringe, W. Zhou, S.S. Kim, R.R. Naik, B.G. Sumpter, H. Terrones, F. Xia, Y. Wang, J. Zhu, D. Akinwande, N. Alem, J.A. Schuller, R.E. Schaal, M. Terrones, J.A. Robinson, Recent Advances in Two-Dimensional Materials beyond Graphene, ACS Nano, 9 (2015) 11509-11539.DOI
- [2]A. Gupta, T. Sakthivel, S. Seal, Recent development in 2D materials beyond graphene, Progress in Materials Science, 73 (2015) 44-126.DOI
- [3]J.-G. Park, Opportunities and challenges of 2D magnetic van der Waals materials: magnetic graphene?, Journal of Physics: Condensed Matter, 28 (2016) 301001.DOI
- [4]N. Samarth, Magnetism in flatland, Nature, 546 (2017) 216-217.DOI
- [5]K.S. Burch, D. Mandrus, J.-G. Park, Magnetism in two-dimensional van der Waals materials, Nature, 563 (2018) 47-52.DOI
- [6]M. Blei, J.L. Lado, Q. Song, D. Dey, O. Erten, V. Pardo, R. Comin, S. Tongay, A.S. Botana, Synthesis, engineering, and theory of 2D van der Waals magnets, Applied Physics Reviews, 8 (2021).DOI
- [7]B. Huang, G. Clark, E. Navarro-Moratalla, D.R. Klein, R. Cheng, K.L. Seyler, D. Zhong, E. Schmidgall, M.A. McGuire, D.H. Cobden, W. Yao, D. Xiao, P. Jarillo-Herrero, X. Xu, Layer-dependent ferromagnetism in a van der Waals crystal down to the monolayer limit, Nature, 546 (2017) 270-273.DOI
- [8]C. Gong, L. Li, Z. Li, H. Ji, A. Stern, Y. Xia, T. Cao, W. Bao, C. Wang, Y. Wang, Z.Q. Qiu, R.J. Cava, S.G. Louie, J. Xia, X. Zhang, Discovery of intrinsic ferromagnetism in two-dimensional van der Waals crystals, Nature, 546 (2017) 265-269.
- [9]J. Cenker, S. Sivakumar, K. Xie, A. Miller, P. Thijssen, Z. Liu, A. Dismukes, J. Fonseca, E. Anderson, X. Zhu, X. Roy, D. Xiao, J.-H. Chu, T. Cao, X. Xu, Reversible strain-induced magnetic phase transition in a van der Waals magnet, Nature Nanotechnology, 17 (2022) 256-261.DOI
- [10]Y. Wang, C. Wang, S.-J. Liang, Z. Ma, K. Xu, X. Liu, L. Zhang, A.S. Admasu, S.-W. Cheong, L. Wang, M. Chen, Z. Liu, B. Cheng, W. Ji, F. Miao, Strain-Sensitive Magnetization Reversal of a van der Waals Magnet, Advanced Materials, 32 (2020) 2004533.DOI
- [11]S. Jiang, L. Li, Z. Wang, K.F. Mak, J. Shan, Controlling magnetism in 2D CrI3 by electrostatic doping, Nature Nanotechnology, 13 (2018) 549-553.DOI
- [12]B. Huang, G. Clark, D.R. Klein, D. MacNeill, E. Navarro-Moratalla, K.L. Seyler, N. Wilson, M.A. McGuire, D.H. Cobden, D. Xiao, W. Yao, P. Jarillo-Herrero, X. Xu, Electrical control of 2D magnetism in bilayer CrI3, Nature Nanotechnology, 13 (2018) 544-548.DOI
- [13]D. Zhong, K.L. Seyler, X. Linpeng, N.P. Wilson, T. Taniguchi, K. Watanabe, M.A. McGuire, K.-M.C. Fu, D. Xiao, W. Yao, X. Xu, Layer-resolved magnetic proximity effect in van der Waals heterostructures, Nature Nanotechnology, 15 (2020) 187-191.DOI
- [14]M. Bora, P. Deb, Magnetic proximity effect in two-dimensional van der Waals heterostructure, Journal of Physics: Materials, 4 (2021) 034014.DOI
- [15]C. Gong, X. Zhang, Two-dimensional magnetic crystals and emergent heterostructure devices, Science, 363 (2019) eaav4450.DOI
- [16]M. Gibertini, M. Koperski, A.F. Morpurgo, K.S. Novoselov, Magnetic 2D materials and heterostructures, Nature Nanotechnology, 14 (2019) 408-419.DOI
- [17]K. Hejazi, Z.-X. Luo, L. Balents, Noncollinear phases in moiré magnets, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 117 (2020) 10721-10726.DOI
- [18]A.O. Fumega, J.L. Lado, Moiré-driven multiferroic order in twisted CrI3, CrBr3 and CrI3 bilayers, 2D Materials, 10 (2023) 025026.DOI
- [19]T. Song, Q.-C. Sun, E. Anderson, C. Wang, J. Qian, T. Taniguchi, K. Watanabe, M.A. McGuire, R. Stöhr, D. Xiao, T. Cao, J. Wrachtrup, X. Xu, Direct visualization of magnetic domains and moiré magnetism in twisted 2D magnets, Science, 374 (2021) 1140-1144.DOI
- [20]S.A. Owerre, A first theoretical realization of honeycomb topological magnon insulator, Journal of Physics: Condensed Matter, 28 (2016) 386001.DOI
- [21]L. Zhang, J. Ren, J.-S. Wang, B. Li, Topological magnon insulator in insulating ferromagnet, Physical Review B, 87 (2013) 144101.DOI
- [22]A. Mook, J. Henk, I. Mertig, Magnon Hall effect and topology in kagome lattices: A theoretical investigation, Physical Review B, 89 (2014) 134409.DOI
- [23]S.A. Owerre, Topological honeycomb magnon Hall effect: A calculation of thermal Hall conductivity of magnetic spin excitations, Journal of Applied Physics, 120 (2016).DOI
- [24]R. Chisnell, J.S. Helton, D.E. Freedman, D.K. Singh, R.I. Bewley, D.G. Nocera, Y.S. Lee, Topological Magnon Bands in a Kagome Lattice Ferromagnet, Physical Review Letters, 115 (2015) 147201.DOI
- [25]M. Hirschberger, R. Chisnell, Y.S. Lee, N.P. Ong, Thermal Hall Effect of Spin Excitations in a Kagome Magnet, Physical Review Letters, 115 (2015) 106603.pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/26382691
- [26]L. Chen, J.-H. Chung, B. Gao, T. Chen, M.B. Stone, A.I. Kolesnikov, Q. Huang, P. Dai, Topological Spin Excitations in Honeycomb Ferromagnet ${\mathrm{CrI}}_{3}$, Physical Review X, 8 (2018) 041028.DOI
- [27]L. Chen, J.-H. Chung, M.B. Stone, A.I. Kolesnikov, B. Winn, V.O. Garlea, D.L. Abernathy, B. Gao, M. Augustin, E.J.G. Santos, P. Dai, Magnetic Field Effect on Topological Spin Excitations in ${\mathrm{CrI}}_{3}$, Physical Review X, 11 (2021) 031047.DOI
- [28]I. Lee, F.G. Utermohlen, D. Weber, K. Hwang, C. Zhang, J. van Tol, J.E. Goldberger, N. Trivedi, P.C. Hammel, Fundamental Spin Interactions Underlying the Magnetic Anisotropy in the Kitaev Ferromagnet ${\mathrm{CrI}}_{3}$, Physical Review Letters, 124 (2020) 017201.DOI
- [29]S. Li, A.H. Nevidomskyy, Topological Weyl magnons and thermal Hall effect in layered honeycomb ferromagnets, Physical Review B, 104 (2021) 104419.DOI
- [30]T. Gorni, O. Baseggio, P. Delugas, I. Timrov, S. Baroni, First-principles study of the gap in the spin excitation spectrum of the ${\text{CrI}}_{3}$ honeycomb ferromagnet, Physical Review B, 107 (2023) L220410.DOI
- [31]P. Delugas, O. Baseggio, I. Timrov, S. Baroni, T. Gorni, Magnon-phonon interactions enhance the gap at the Dirac point in the spin-wave spectra of ${\mathrm{CrI}}_{3}$ two-dimensional magnets, Physical Review B, 107 (2023) 214452.DOI
- [32]S.t.S. Material, DOI.
- [33]M.A. McGuire, H. Dixit, V.R. Cooper, B.C. Sales, Coupling of Crystal Structure and Magnetism in the Layered, Ferromagnetic Insulator CrI3, Chemistry of Materials, 27 (2015) 612-620.
- [34]H. Zhang, C. Xu, C. Carnahan, M. Sretenovic, N. Suri, D. Xiao, X. Ke, Anomalous Thermal Hall Effect in an Insulating van der Waals Magnet, Physical Review Letters, 127 (2021) 247202.DOI
- [35]C.A. Pocs, I.A. Leahy, H. Zheng, G. Cao, E.-S. Choi, S.H. Do, K.-Y. Choi, B. Normand, M. Lee, Giant thermal magnetoconductivity in ${\mathrm{CrCl}}_{3}$ and a general model for spin-phonon scattering, Physical Review Research, 2 (2020) 013059.DOI
- [36]C. Xu, C. Carnahan, H. Zhang, M. Sretenovic, P. Zhang, D. Xiao, X. Ke, Thermal Hall effect in a van der Waals triangular magnet ${\mathrm{FeCl}}_{2}$, Physical Review B, 107 (2023) L060404.DOI
- [37]P. Czajka, T. Gao, M. Hirschberger, P. Lampen-Kelley, A. Banerjee, J. Yan, D.G. Mandrus, S.E. Nagler, N.P. Ong, Oscillations of the thermal conductivity in the spin-liquid state of α-RuCl3, Nature Physics, 17 (2021) 915-919.DOI
- [38]X. Li, B. Fauqué, Z. Zhu, K. Behnia, Phonon Thermal Hall Effect in Strontium Titanate, Physical Review Letters, 124 (2020) 105901.DOI
- [39]L. Chen, M.-E. Boulanger, Z.-C. Wang, F. Tafti, L. Taillefer, Large phonon thermal Hall conductivity in the antiferromagnetic insulator Cu<sub>3</sub>TeO<sub>6</sub>, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 119 (2022) e2208016119.DOI
- [40]R. Takahashi, N. Nagaosa, Berry Curvature in Magnon-Phonon Hybrid Systems, Physical Review Letters, 117 (2016) 217205.DOI
- [41]G. Go, S.K. Kim, K.-J. Lee, Topological Magnon-Phonon Hybrid Excitations in Two-Dimensional Ferromagnets with Tunable Chern Numbers, Physical Review Letters, 123 (2019) 237207.DOI
- [42]X. Zhang, Y. Zhang, S. Okamoto, D. Xiao, Thermal Hall Effect Induced by Magnon-Phonon Interactions, Physical Review Letters, 123 (2019) 167202.DOI
- [43]S. Park, B.-J. Yang, Topological magnetoelastic excitations in noncollinear antiferromagnets, Physical Review B, 99 (2019) 174435.DOI
- [44]L. Mangeolle, L. Balents, L. Savary, Phonon Thermal Hall Conductivity from Scattering with Collective Fluctuations, Physical Review X, 12 (2022) 041031.
- [45]S.E. Nikitin, B. Fåk, K.W. Krämer, T. Fennell, B. Normand, A.M. Läuchli, C. Rüegg, Thermal Evolution of Dirac Magnons in the Honeycomb Ferromagnet ${\mathrm{CrBr}}_{3}$, Physical Review Letters, 129 (2022) 127201.DOI
- [46]S.-H. Do, J.A.M. Paddison, G. Sala, T.J. Williams, K. Kaneko, K. Kuwahara, A.F. May, J. Yan, M.A. McGuire, M.B. Stone, M.D. Lumsden, A.D. Christianson, Gaps in topological magnon spectra: Intrinsic versus extrinsic effects, Physical Review B, 106 (2022) L060408.
- [47]Z. Cai, S. Bao, Z.-L. Gu, Y.-P. Gao, Z. Ma, Y. Shangguan, W. Si, Z.-Y. Dong, W. Wang, Y. Wu, D. Lin, J. Wang, K. Ran, S. Li, D. Adroja, X. Xi, S.-L. Yu, X. Wu, J.-X. Li, J. Wen, Topological magnon insulator spin excitations in the two-dimensional ferromagnet ${\mathrm{CrBr}}_{3}$, Physical Review B, 104 (2021) L020402.DOI
- [48]A.L. Chernyshev, P.A. Maksimov, Damped Topological Magnons in the Kagome-Lattice Ferromagnets, Physical Review Letters, 117 (2016) 187203.pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/27835025
- [49]S. Suetsugu, T. Yokoi, K. Totsuka, T. Ono, I. Tanaka, S. Kasahara, Y. Kasahara, Z. Chengchao, H. Kageyama, Y. Matsuda, Intrinsic suppression of the topological thermal Hall effect in an exactly solvable quantum magnet, Physical Review B, 105 (2022) 024415.DOI
- [50]A. Mook, K. Plekhanov, J. Klinovaja, D. Loss, Interaction-Stabilized Topological Magnon Insulator in Ferromagnets, Physical Review X, 11 (2021) 021061.DOI