betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Tensor cluster expansion as an efficient surrogate for multi-ACE

Abstract

In this work, we generalize an on-lattice tensor cluster expansion (TCE) framework to an arbitrary correlation order. We show that these generalized tensor cluster expansion features span a subspace of MACE features, suggesting that TCE features can sufficiently pre-screen MACE features for chemical diversity in alloyed transition metal dichalcogenide (TMD) monolayers. We show that, using maximum-entropy subset sampling, we can empirically recover chemical diversity from MACE features using a cheaper TCE representation. We then fine-tune a multi-ACE (MACE) potential with both subsets, and use this potential to predict temperature-dependent vibrational properties in alloyed TMD monolayers with varying chemical ordering. In our approach, TCE features can be used as cheap surrogate features for pre-screening chemically rich configurations using MACE features, allowing for the more efficient finetuning of atomic cluster expansion (ACE) potentials, thus achieving a tractable prediction of finite-temperature alloy thermodynamics on modest hardware.

Introduction

Machine learning interatomic potentials (MLIPs) have shown recent successes in large-scale atomistic simulations of various materials systems [1, 2, 3]. In particular, the atomic cluster expansion (ACE) formalism [4] extends the Ising/spin-like cluster expansion techniques to construct a complete basis [5] for describing local chemical environments, while multi-ACE (MACE) [6, 7] extends the ACE potential to efficiently parametrize many-body clusters. Furthermore, recent work has demonstrated that MACE potentials can reproduce vibrational properties and Raman spectra across transition-metal dichalcogenide (TMD) alloys, extending first-principles calculations to larger cells and broader configurational sampling [8].

In general, training an MLIP from the ground up is computationally expensive. An emerging alternative is to fine-tune foundation models, leveraging the extensive datasets used during pretraining while adapting the models to make quantitatively accurate predictions for specialized applications, including heterogeneous catalysis, point-defect migration, dislocation mechanics, solid-state phase transitions, and battery electrolyte dynamics. For example, Batatia et al. demonstrated that fine-tuning the MACE-MP-0 foundation model using relatively small application-specific datasets could substantially improve predictions of catalytic reaction barriers, defect formation and migration energies, and electrolyte transport properties [9].

Primarily, the computational bottleneck is within the generation of first-principles data for such application. Although fine-tuning has significantly reduced

Notice: This manuscript has been coauthored by UT-Battelle, LLC, under contract DE-AC05-00OR22725 with the US Department of Energy (DOE). The US government retains and the publisher, by accepting the article for publication, acknowledges that the US government retains a nonexclusive, paid-up, irrevocable, worldwide license to publish or reproduce the published form of this manuscript, or allow others to do so, for US government purposes. DOE will provide public access to these results of federally sponsored research in accordance with the DOE Public Access Plan (https://www.energy.gov/doe-public-access-plan). the required amount of new first-principles data[10], the generation of each single data point still requires specialized hardware, and is very computationally expensive. This is especially problematic for the study of complex systems, e.g. concentrated alloys, where the prohibitively large design space necessitates the need for a relatively large number of data points.

Strategic selection of a training set is therefore a necessity for efficiently screening new alloy systems. The common strategy is to generate a superset of configurations X\mathcal{X}, then select a subset X∗⊆X\mathcal{X}^{*} \subseteq\mathcal{X} that maximizes some global footprint for chemical diversity. These footprints are usually computed using feature vectors that describe atomic configurations, which, importantly, can be computed independent of ab-initio data, i.e. solely from atomic positions and species[11, 12, 13, 14]. Particularly relevant to this work, Arora et al. used bond counts to stratify configurations of ternary, quaternary, and quinary BCC alloys, using this stratification to pre-screen for chemical complexity prior to performing density functional theory (DFT) calculations[15]. However, as noted by the authors, many-body terms were not included within the descriptor space, meaning that their approach is not suitable for screening for many-body effects. Furthermore, this descriptor is agnostic of lattice relaxation effects, which is potentially problematic for pre-screening configurations with large local lattice distortion.

In the ideal case, the feature vector used to describe the atomic configuration is the same feature vector that is used as input to the MLIP. This ensures that the diversity maximized in the training set is mappable to the diversity of the outputs of the MLIP. Using the MLIP feature vector, in contrast to Arora et al.[15], would furthermore induce expressivity in regard to lattice relaxation effects. In the case where the set used to finetune the MLIP is of modest size, the calculation of the feature vector within the diversity sampling routine described above is tractable. However, for expensive feature vectors, this can become untractable for large training sets. This problem is particularly unavoidable for multicomponent systems, where the number of chemically complex environments increases combinatorially with the number of components in the system of interest.

Therefore, sufficient sampling diversity is of utmost importance for the screening of novel, chemically complex materials, including bulk high-entropy alloys for clean energy applications[16, 17, 18] and, more

recently, concentrated two-dimensional TMDs such as the alloyed monolayer (VNbMoTaW)S2(\mathrm{VNbMoTaW})\mathrm{S}_{2} for CO2\mathrm{CO}_{2} electroruduction[19] and, more generally, tuneable vacancy stability[20]. Beyond electrocatalysis, alloyed TMDs have demonstrated potential for optoelectronic applications, including broadband photodetection and photovoltaic devices, through composition-dependent optical properties and defect engineering[21, 22]. Chalcogen substitution in particular has enabled the tuning of valley polarization and photocurrent generation in Mo(S,Se)\mathrm{Mo(S,Se)} monolayers, while simultaneous metal and chalcogen substitution has been explored for enhancing valley polarization at room temperature[23, 24]. More broadly, alloying provides a route to engineering spin-orbit interactions and accessing competing structural and topological phases, further motivating the exploration of chemically complex TMD monolayers[25, 26].

However, high-entropy alloying as a strategy presents a major challenge, in that compositional complexities combinatorially explode the number of configurations needed to sufficiently sample the chemical diversity of X\mathcal{X}. Consequently, it is advantageous to select a computationally cost-effective, surrogate pre-screener to compute feature vectors, rather than compute the whole MLIP feature vector for a set of atomic configurations.

In this work, we show that the tensor cluster expansion (TCE) framework yields feature vectors that span a subspace of MACE feature vectors. We then show that, using greedy maximum-entropy subset selection, TCE feature vectors act as an efficient pre-screening surrogate for configurational diversity as measured by MACE feature vectors in model concentrated TMD monolayers. Lastly, we show that fine-tuning using this computationally efficient pre-screening method quantitatively predicts vibrational spectra of model TMDs.

Theory

To characterize chemical complexity in the material, we seek a feature vector that serves as a chemical fingerprint. To capture this complexity, we compute mm-point correlation functions corresponding to short-range chemical ordering, i.e. a cluster expansion method. We, thus, generalize the tensor cluster expansion (TCE) method for mm-body terms. TCE computes two- and three-body cluster counts via tensor products between topological tensors and occupation tensors, respectively, defining the nearest-neighbor topology and occupancy within a static lattice:

Nαβ(n)=Aij(n)XiαXjβMαβγ(n)=Bijk(n)XiαXjβXkγ(1)\begin{aligned} N_{\alpha\beta}^{(n)} &= A_{ij}^{(n)}X_{i\alpha}X_{j\beta}\\ M_{\alpha\beta\gamma}^{(n)} &= B_{ijk}^{(n)}X_{i\alpha}X_{j\beta}X_{k\gamma} \tag*{(1)} \end{aligned}

where Latin indices denote points within the lattice, Greek indices denote chemical species within the lattice, nn denotes topological orders for different clusters, X\mathbf{X} denotes occupational tensors within the lattice so that:

Xiα={1site i is occupied by type α0else(2)X_{i\alpha} = \begin{cases} 1 & \text{site }i\text{ is occupied by type }\alpha\\ 0 & \text{else} \end{cases} \tag*{(2)}

Last, A\mathbf{A} and B\mathbf{B} denote topological tensors corresponding to two- and three-body clusters:

Aij(n)={1sites (i,j) are n’th nearest neighbors0elseBijk(n)={1sites (i,j,k) are n’th order triplets0else(3)\begin{aligned} A_{ij}^{(n)} &= \begin{cases} 1 & \text{sites }(i,j)\text{ are }n\text{’th nearest neighbors}\\ 0 & \text{else} \end{cases}\\ B_{ijk}^{(n)} &= \begin{cases} 1 & \text{sites }(i,j,k)\text{ are }n\text{’th order triplets}\\ 0 & \text{else} \end{cases} \tag*{(3)} \end{aligned}

so that N\mathbf{N} and M\mathbf{M} defined in Eq. (1) store the counts of each cluster type, e.g. the number of first nearest neighbor α\alpha-β\beta interactions, or the number of α\alpha-β\beta-γ\gamma equilateral triangles in a highly symmetric structure like a face-centered cubic (FCC) solid. Here, the tensor A\mathbf{A} can be built by a neighbor list, and B\mathbf{B} can be built as a connected tensor product of copies of A\mathbf{A}. For example, in the case of FCC, this tensor product is:

Bijk(1)=Aij(1)Ajk(1)Aki(1)(4)B_{ijk}^{(1)}=A_{ij}^{(1)}A_{jk}^{(1)}A_{ki}^{(1)} \tag*{(4)}

i.e. each pair of lower indices corresponds to a pair of neighbors, and each upper label corresponds to the type of interaction order between those neighbors[27].

In this work, we generalize these expressions to mm-bodies, expanding our previous work where we used only the 2 and 3 body terms [27]. For m=3m=3, the connected tensor product to compute B\mathbf{B} in Eq. (4) is induced by the fully connected graph of size 3, commonly denoted as K3K_3:

K3=complete graph on vertices 1,2,3(5)K_3=\text{complete graph on vertices }1,2,3 \tag*{(5)}

so that each pair of lower indices in connected tensor products like Eq. (4) corresponds to an edge of K3K_3:

Bi1i2i3(ℓ12,ℓ23,ℓ13)=Ai1i2(ℓ12)Ai2i3(ℓ23)Ai1i3(ℓ13)=∏{r,s}∈E(K3)Airis(ℓrs)Bi1i2i3[ℓ]=⋁ℓ′∈[ℓ]Bi1i2i3(ℓ′)(6)\begin{aligned} B_{i_1i_2i_3}^{(\ell_{12},\ell_{23},\ell_{13})} &=A_{i_1i_2}^{(\ell_{12})}A_{i_2i_3}^{(\ell_{23})}A_{i_1i_3}^{(\ell_{13})}\\ &=\prod_{\{r,s\}\in E(K_3)}A_{i_ri_s}^{(\ell_{rs})}\\ B_{i_1i_2i_3}^{[\ell]}&=\bigvee_{\ell'\in[\ell]}B_{i_1i_2i_3}^{(\ell')} \tag*{(6)} \end{aligned}

where [ℓ]=S3⋅ℓ[\ell]=S_3\cdot\ell denotes the orbit of ℓ\ell under the action of S3S_3 (the permutation group on 3 elements) and E(G)E(G) denotes the edge set of a graph GG. We then symmetrize so that the final tensor B[ℓ]\mathbf{B}^{[\ell]} is fully symmetric and remains Boolean, i.e. Bi1i2i3[ℓ]∈{0,1}B_{i_1i_2i_3}^{[\ell]}\in\{0,1\}.

We then generalize the topological tensors to include edges from the graph KmK_m to represent mm-body clusters, rather than just up to K3K_3:

Ai1⋯im[ℓ]=⋁ℓ′∈[ℓ]∏{r,s}∈E(Km)Airis(ℓrs′)(7)A_{i_1\cdots i_m}^{[\ell]}=\bigvee_{\ell'\in[\ell]}\prod_{\{r,s\}\in E(K_m)}A_{i_ri_s}^{(\ell'_{rs})} \tag*{(7)}

where [ℓ]=Sm⋅ℓ[\ell]=S_m\cdot\ell, Km=(Vm,Em)K_m=(V_m,E_m) denotes a labeled, fully connected, undirected graph with vertices VmV_m and edges EmE_m:

Vm={1,⋯ ,m}Em={{u,v}∣(u,v)∈Vm×Vm and u≠v}(8)\begin{aligned} V_m&=\{1,\cdots,m\}\\ E_m&=\{\{u,v\}\mid(u,v)\in V_m\times V_m\text{ and }u\ne v\} \tag*{(8)} \end{aligned}

For example, for m=4m=4 and m=5m=5:

K4=complete graph on vertices 1,2,3,4K5=complete graph on vertices 1,2,3,4,5(9)K_4=\text{complete graph on vertices }1,2,3,4 \qquad K_5=\text{complete graph on vertices }1,2,3,4,5 \tag*{(9)}

Then, using index notation, the tensor A\mathbf{A} can be interpreted as a generalized topological tensor:

Ai[ℓ]={1sites i form a cluster with topology [ℓ]0else(10)A_i^{[\ell]} = \begin{cases} 1 & \text{sites } i \text{ form a cluster with topology } [\ell] \\ 0 & \text{else} \end{cases} \tag*{(10)}

The tensor A[ℓ]\mathbf{A}^{[\ell]} is notably symmetric, i.e. Ai1⋯im[ℓ]=A(i1⋯im)[ℓ]A_{i_1\cdots i_m}^{[\ell]} = A_{(i_1\cdots i_m)}^{[\ell]}, which is provable from Eq. (7) by noting that both KmK_m and [ℓ][\ell] are invariant under the action SmS_m. Furthermore, the number of clusters with occupying types α=(α1,⋯ ,αm)\boldsymbol{\alpha} = (\alpha_1,\cdots,\alpha_m) and geometry [ℓ][\ell] is:

Nα1⋯αm[ℓ]=Ai1⋯im[ℓ]∏k=1mXikαk(11)N_{\alpha_1\cdots\alpha_m}^{[\ell]} = A_{i_1\cdots i_m}^{[\ell]} \prod_{k=1}^{m} X_{i_k\alpha_k} \tag*{(11)}

which is notably also symmetric, i.e. Nα1⋯αm[ℓ]=N(α1⋯αm)[ℓ]N_{\alpha_1\cdots\alpha_m}^{[\ell]} = N_{(\alpha_1\cdots\alpha_m)}^{[\ell]}, yielding an effective Hamiltonian:

Heff=∑[ℓ]∈Λ1m!εα1⋯αm[ℓ]Nα1⋯αm[ℓ](12)\mathcal{H}_{\mathrm{eff}} = \sum_{[\ell]\in\Lambda} \frac{1}{m!} \varepsilon_{\alpha_1\cdots\alpha_m}^{[\ell]} N_{\alpha_1\cdots\alpha_m}^{[\ell]} \tag*{(12)}

and a generalized feature vector:

t=⨁[ℓ]∈Λvec⁡(Nα1⋯αm[ℓ])(13)\mathbf{t} = \bigoplus_{[\ell]\in\Lambda} \operatorname{vec}\left(N_{\alpha_1\cdots\alpha_m}^{[\ell]}\right) \tag*{(13)}

where Λ\Lambda is an a-priori chosen set of topologies, ⊕\oplus denotes a direct sum over cluster subspaces (equivalently concatenation), and mm is the body-order corresponding to the topological label [ℓ][\ell]:

∣ℓ∣=(m2)⟹m=1+1+8∣ℓ∣2(14)|\ell| = \binom{m}{2} \quad\Longrightarrow\quad m = \frac{1+\sqrt{1+8|\ell|}}{2} \tag*{(14)}

The only inputs to computing t\mathbf{t} are then the lattice positions and occupying types to respectively define A\mathbf{A} and X\mathbf{X}, as well as the chosen topologies Λ\Lambda. Each cluster corresponds solely to a topological label ℓ\ell, labeling each edge within the cluster by its neighbor order. For example, a second-nearest-neighbor interaction can be labeled with ℓ=2\ell= 2, and a nearest-neighbor triangle is labeled with ℓ=(1,1,1)\ell= (1,1,1). Then, the tensor contraction in Eq. (11) computes the number of species-decorated clusters with the topological label ℓ\ell, as well as all other topological labels that are symmetrically equivalent to it, namely the set [ℓ]=Sm⋅ℓ[\ell] = S_m \cdot\ell. Furthermore, A\mathbf{A} can be computed once per set of lattice positions, i.e. A\mathbf{A} does not need to be recomputed if atom types are permuted within one lattice.

Furthermore, similar to our work in Ref.[27], this Hamiltonian has the advantage that we can efficiently compute the change in cluster counts from some two-particle swap in Eq. (11) by simply truncating the contraction to only include sites within those swaps, i.e.:

ΔN~α1⋯αm[ℓ]=∑i1∈supp⁡πAi1⋯im[ℓ]Xi1α1′∏k=2mXikαk′−∑i1∈supp⁡πAi1⋯im[ℓ]Xi1α1∏k=2mXikαk(15)\Delta\widetilde{N}_{\alpha_1\cdots\alpha_m}^{[\ell]} = \sum_{i_1\in\operatorname{supp}\pi} A_{i_1\cdots i_m}^{[\ell]} X'_{i_1\alpha_1}\prod_{k=2}^{m}X'_{i_k\alpha_k} - \sum_{i_1\in\operatorname{supp}\pi} A_{i_1\cdots i_m}^{[\ell]} X_{i_1\alpha_1}\prod_{k=2}^{m}X_{i_k\alpha_k} \tag*{(15)}
ΔNα1⋯αm[ℓ]=mΔN~(α1⋯αm)[ℓ]\Delta N_{\alpha_1\cdots\alpha_m}^{[\ell]} = m\Delta\widetilde{N}_{(\alpha_1\cdots\alpha_m)}^{[\ell]}

where π∈SN\pi\in S_N is a 2-cycle acting on NN lattice sites, SNS_N is the permutation group acting on the NN lattice sites in the system, supp⁡π\operatorname{supp}\pi is the support of that permutation, and X′=πX\mathbf{X}' = \pi\mathbf{X} is the permuted state tensor, and parenthesis around indices denote symmetrization with respect to those indices. Then, since any permutation can be decomposed into 2-cycles, Eq. (15) can be then used iteratively for more complex permutations, and more generally any Monte Carlo move that preserves global composition. Then, since the Hamiltonian is linear in N\mathbf{N}, we can efficiently compute the change in energy from the swap:

ΔE(X→πX)=∑[ℓ]∈Λεα1⋯αm[ℓ]ΔNα1⋯αm[ℓ](16)\Delta E(\mathbf{X}\to\pi\mathbf{X}) = \sum_{[\ell]\in\Lambda}\varepsilon_{\alpha_1\cdots\alpha_m}^{[\ell]}\Delta N_{\alpha_1\cdots\alpha_m}^{[\ell]} \tag*{(16)}

i.e., the model explicitly encodes local atomic energies, and linearity of the model allows us to efficiently evaluate energy differences by ignoring bonds far away from where the swap(s) occur, allowing for very efficient canonical Monte Carlo simulations in which any particle swap can be represented by a permutation on lattice sites π∈SN\pi\in S_N, as well as difference training in which we learn the interaction coefficients from difference in cluster counts, rather than raw cluster counts, similar to Ref.[28]. A similar formula can be applied for single-site transmutations by changing the summation domain to include the transmuted lattice sites, also inducing efficient, topology-aware grand canonical Monte Carlo simulations up to arbitrary correlation order.

We furthermore find that the TCE features derived here are contained in a rotationally-invariant feature span of MACE features, of which we outline a proof for in Sec. A.1, with a full proof available in Sec. A.2. The key observation is that, on a fixed lattice, the edges between neighbors can be recovered exactly from a finite set of root-centered angular configurations.

Methods

For the TCE feature vector, we compute a normalized version of Eq. (13) for clusters in the high entropy TMD system (W, Mo, Ta)(S, Se, Te)2_2 with clusters visualized in Figure 1:

Topological feature set $\Lambda$ used for decorating WS$_2$-like structures

Figure 1. Topological feature set Λ\Lambda used for decorating WS2_2-like structures. Each atom type represents a subset of possible atom types occupying that site, i.e. W is a placeholder for a transition metal and S is a placeholder for a chalcogenide, visualized with Open Visualization Tool (OVITO)[29].

t~=⨁[ℓ]∈Λvec⁡(Nα1⋯αm[ℓ]∑i1⋯imAi1⋯im[ℓ])(17)\tilde{\mathbf{t}} = \bigoplus_{[\ell]\in\Lambda} \operatorname{vec}\left(\frac{N_{\alpha_1\cdots\alpha_m}^{[\ell]}}{\sum_{i_1\cdots i_m} A_{i_1\cdots i_m}^{[\ell]}}\right) \tag*{(17)}

which effectively normalizes by both system size as well as the size of a given cluster subspace, in order to stabilize the covariance matrix. For example, for the two-body terms in a single-sublattice system:

∑ijAij(1)=Nz(18)\sum_{ij} A_{ij}^{(1)} = Nz \tag*{(18)}

where zz is the first-nearest coordination number of the solid and NN is the number of atoms in the solid, so that Nαβ(1)/(Nz)N_{\alpha\beta}^{(1)}/(Nz) denotes the proportion of first nearest-neighbor pairs that contain α\alpha and β\beta types. We can also compute the MACE feature t~=ϕMACE(x)\tilde{\mathbf{t}}=\phi_{\mathrm{MACE}}(x) by averaging per-atom descriptors, and compare.

For a given set of configurations indexed by X\mathcal{X}, we can define the total entropy:

S(X)=12log⁡det⁡[∑x∈X(t~x−μ)⊗(t~x−μ)](19)S(\mathcal{X}) = \frac{1}{2}\log\det\left[\sum_{x\in\mathcal{X}}(\tilde{\mathbf{t}}_x-\boldsymbol{\mu})\otimes(\tilde{\mathbf{t}}_x-\boldsymbol{\mu})\right] \tag*{(19)}

where μ\boldsymbol{\mu} is the mean of the dataset:

μ=1∣X∣∑x∈Xt~x(20)\boldsymbol{\mu} = \frac{1}{|\mathcal{X}|}\sum_{x\in\mathcal{X}}\tilde{\mathbf{t}}_x \tag*{(20)}

⊗\otimes denotes an outer product, i.e. (x⊗y)ij=xiyj(\mathbf{x}\otimes\mathbf{y})_{ij}=x_i y_j, ∑x∈X(t~x−μ)⊗(t~x−μ)\sum_{x\in\mathcal{X}}(\tilde{\mathbf{t}}_x-\boldsymbol{\mu})\otimes(\tilde{\mathbf{t}}_x-\boldsymbol{\mu}) is the covariance of the dataset. For brevity, we let wx=t~x−μ\mathbf{w}_x=\tilde{\mathbf{t}}_x-\boldsymbol{\mu}. We then

seek to find the optimal subset of size kk that maximizes this entropy:

X∗=arg⁡max⁡X∗⊂X∣X∗∣=k log⁡det⁡[∑x∈X∗wx⊗wx](21)\mathcal{X}^* = \underset{\substack{\mathcal{X}^*\subset\mathcal{X}\\|\mathcal{X}^*|=k}}{\arg\max}\ \log\det\left[\sum_{x\in\mathcal{X}^*}\mathbf{w}_x\otimes\mathbf{w}_x\right] \tag*{(21)}

We can do this greedily by starting with some initial subset X0\mathcal{X}_0. Then, we can select the next configuration y∈X∖X0y\in\mathcal{X}\setminus\mathcal{X}_0 which maximizes the entropy gain[30, 31]:

S(X0∪{y})−S(X0)=12log⁡det⁡Σ(X0∪{y})det⁡Σ(X0)(22)S(\mathcal{X}_0\cup\{y\})-S(\mathcal{X}_0)=\frac{1}{2}\log\frac{\det\boldsymbol{\Sigma}(\mathcal{X}_0\cup\{y\})}{\det\boldsymbol{\Sigma}(\mathcal{X}_0)} \tag*{(22)}

where Σ(X0)\boldsymbol{\Sigma}(\mathcal{X}_0) is the covariance matrix:

Σ(X0)=∑x∈X0wx⊗wx\boldsymbol{\Sigma}(\mathcal{X}_0)=\sum_{x\in\mathcal{X}_0}\mathbf{w}_x\otimes\mathbf{w}_x
Σ(X0∪{y})=Σ(X0)+wy⊗wy(23)\boldsymbol{\Sigma}(\mathcal{X}_0\cup\{y\})=\boldsymbol{\Sigma}(\mathcal{X}_0)+\mathbf{w}_y\otimes\mathbf{w}_y \tag*{(23)}

Then, by the matrix determinant lemma, the entropy gain from adding sample yy to subset X0\mathcal{X}_0 is proportional to:

log⁡det⁡Σ(X0∪{y})det⁡Σ(X0)=log⁡(1+wyTΣ(X0)−1wy)(24)\log\frac{\det\boldsymbol{\Sigma}(\mathcal{X}_0\cup\{y\})}{\det\boldsymbol{\Sigma}(\mathcal{X}_0)}=\log\left(1+\mathbf{w}_y^{\mathsf{T}}\boldsymbol{\Sigma}(\mathcal{X}_0)^{-1}\mathbf{w}_y\right) \tag*{(24)}

We can then recursively define this procedure with a starting subset X0\mathcal{X}_0 and an initial covariance Σ0\boldsymbol{\Sigma}_0, namely:

yn=arg⁡max⁡y∈X∖Xn log⁡(1+wyTΣn−1wy)y_n=\underset{y\in\mathcal{X}\setminus\mathcal{X}_n}{\arg\max}\ \log\left(1+\mathbf{w}_y^{\mathsf{T}}\boldsymbol{\Sigma}_n^{-1}\mathbf{w}_y\right)
Xn+1=Xn∪{yn}\mathcal{X}_{n+1}=\mathcal{X}_n\cup\{y_n\}
Σn+1=Σn+wyn⊗wyn(25)\boldsymbol{\Sigma}_{n+1}=\boldsymbol{\Sigma}_n+\mathbf{w}_{y_n}\otimes\mathbf{w}_{y_n} \tag*{(25)}

For larger subsets, the inversion of Σn\boldsymbol{\Sigma}_n is very computationally expensive. However, one can avoid recomputing the full inverse via the Woodbury matrix identity[32]. We can iteratively perform this procedure for the TCE feature vector as well as the MACE feature vector, generating the respective subsets XTCE\mathcal{X}_{\mathrm{TCE}} and XMACE\mathcal{X}_{\mathrm{MACE}}. We can measure the overlap between the two subsets as the size of their intersection:

I=∣XTCE∩XMACE∣(26)I=|\mathcal{X}_{\mathrm{TCE}}\cap\mathcal{X}_{\mathrm{MACE}}| \tag*{(26)}

where ∣XTCE∣=∣XMACE∣=k|\mathcal{X}_{\mathrm{TCE}}| = |\mathcal{X}_{\mathrm{MACE}}| = k. In the ideal case, where the two sets are equal, I=kI = k. In the least ideal case, where the two subsets are statistically unrelated (i.e. all overlap is by random chance), I=k2/nI = k^2/n, where n=∣X∣n = |\mathcal{X}|.

Using ASE[33], we generate 100 high entropy, random TMD monolayer solutions with (W1−x−yMoxTay)(S1−z−wSezTew)2(\mathrm{W}_{1-x-y}\mathrm{Mo}_x\mathrm{Ta}_y)(\mathrm{S}_{1-z-w}\mathrm{Se}_z\mathrm{Te}_w)_2. While generating each sample, we randomly select a subset of metals and chalcogens, and then randomly select compositions within those subsets, to ensure that our dataset not only contains the full senary system, but also the relevant chemical subsystems, e.g. W(S1−xSex)2\mathrm{W}(\mathrm{S}_{1-x}\mathrm{Se}_x)_2 and (MoxTa1−x)Te2(\mathrm{Mo}_x\mathrm{Ta}_{1-x})\mathrm{Te}_2. Each monolayer was constructed with mirror-plane symmetry, a lattice parameter of 3.18 Å, and a thickness of 3.19 Å, as per ASE’s convention. To avoid surface-surface interactions across the periodic boundaries, each monolayer was prepared with a 40.0 Å vacuum.

All DFT calculations were performed using the Vienna Ab initio Simulation Package (VASP)[34, 35, 36] with the projector-augmented-wave (PAW)[37] method and the Perdew–Burke–Ernzerhof (PBE) exchange-correlation functional[38] on Clemson University’s Palmetto Cluster[39]. A plane-wave kinetic-energy cutoff of 500 eV was employed. Brillouin-zone integrations were carried out using a Γ\Gamma-centered (3×3×13 \times3 \times1) Monkhorst–Pack kk-point mesh[40]. Structural relaxations were performed using a Gaussian smearing scheme with σ=0.10\sigma= 0.10 eV, with a maximum of 400 ionic steps and up to 100 electronic iterations per ionic step. The lattice parameters were relaxed in-plane while the out-of-plane lattice parameter was constrained, corresponding to fixed and variable lattice degrees of freedom along the relevant directions.

After the relaxation above, also using VASP, we carried out molecular dynamics with a Langevin thermostat and a Parrinello-Rahman barostat[41, 42, 43], with a timestep of 1 fs for 5,000 steps, starting at 50 K and ending at 400 K with a fixed pressure of 0 kbar. Langevin friction coefficients for each species, as well as for the simulation cell, were set to 10 ps−1^{-1} = 10 THz, with a fictitious cell mass of 1000 amu. As done in the structural relaxation, the out-of-plane lattice parameter was fixed. This dataset, involving energies and forces in all snapshots (including relaxation and dynamics), is available on GitHub[44].

We then finetune the MACE-MP-0 large model[9, 45] using rank-4 low rank adaptation (LoRA)[46] and each of the dataset subsets below, creating two different potentials:

  • The TCE-selected subset XTCE\mathcal{X}_{\mathrm{TCE}}

  • The MACE-selected subset XMACE\mathcal{X}_{\mathrm{MACE}}

For validation, we draw 5 random trajectory pairs from the remaining dataset Xr\mathcal{X}_{r}:

Xr=X∖(XTCE∪XMACE)\mathcal{X}_{r} = \mathcal{X} \setminus\left(\mathcal{X}_{\mathrm{TCE}} \cup\mathcal{X}_{\mathrm{MACE}}\right)
Xval⊂Xr(27)\mathcal{X}_{\mathrm{val}} \subset\mathcal{X}_{r} \tag*{(27)}

and benchmark each potential against 10 trajectory pairs from the remaining dataset, i.e. Xr∖Xval\mathcal{X}_{r} \setminus\mathcal{X}_{\mathrm{val}}.

Using the finetuned potentials, we compute the vibrational spectra for the M(X,X′)2M(X,X^{\prime})_{2} monolayers, where M∈{W,Mo,Ta}M \in\{\mathrm{W}, \mathrm{Mo}, \mathrm{Ta}\} and {X,X′}∈{{S,Te},{Se,Te}}\{X,X^{\prime}\} \in\{\{\mathrm{S},\mathrm{Te}\},\{\mathrm{Se},\mathrm{Te}\}\}. We choose these particular M(X,X′)2M(X,X^{\prime})_{2} subsystems so that we can reasonably recover an order-disorder transition from Monte Carlo (MD) simulations without finely resolving low temperatures, as well as additionally focusing on one structural phase, i.e. the HH phase. Namely, for M∈{W,Mo}M \in\{\mathrm{W},\mathrm{Mo}\}, it was predicted using a cluster expansion model that the M(X,X′)2M(X,X^{\prime})_{2} subsystems have HH symmetry and an order-disorder transition temperatures (ODTTs) above 100 K[47], in contrast to subsystems such as W(S, Se)2_2 with an ODTT of 30 K, or (Mo,W)Te2_2 with an ODTT of 10 K.

Importantly, we do not assume that each monolayer system is fully random, i.e. there exists some residual chemical order. In principle, one could use hybrid MC/MD routines with any interatomic potential to sample chemical ordering[48]. However, for systems with significant structural relaxations upon swapping two particles, this routine is intractable, since this necessitates relaxing before accepting or rejecting an MC swap. This is exaggerated even more by MLIP evaluations, which are significantly expensive relative to classical potentials. On-lattice cluster expansion approaches fitted to relaxed configurations are ideal for this problem, in that they can accurately reproduce relaxed DFT energies without explicit structural relaxation[49, 50, 51].

As such, we fit a TCE model (with the same feature set from Figure 1) using the same structural relaxation data X\mathcal{X}, and use that model to run canonical MC simulations at different temperatures to generate partially chemically-ordered samples. We provide more details for these MC simulations in Sec. A.5.

Then, for each sample chemically equilibrated at a temperature TT (with temperatures 100, 200, 300, and 400 K), we compute the vibrational spectrum by running molecular dynamics using Torch-Sim[52, 53], with the following sequence:

  • Structural relaxation at 0 K using FIRE[54], with variable lattice parameters using the Frechet cell filter

  • NVT equilibration at a temperature TT using the Langevin integrator[41, 55] with a timestep 1 fs and a friction coefficient 10 ps−1^{-1} for 100,000 steps

  • NVE run for 100,000 steps

During the NVE run, we compute the mass-weighted velocity autocorrelation function (VACF) and the resulting vibrational density of states (VDOS) via the Fourier transform of the VDOS[56]:

C(t)∝∑imi⟨vi(0)⋅vi(t)⟩C(t) \propto\sum_i m_i \langle\mathbf{v}_i(0) \cdot\mathbf{v}_i(t) \rangle
g(ω)∝∫0∞C(t)exp⁡(iωt) dt(28)g(\omega) \propto\int_0^{\infty} C(t)\exp(i\omega t)\,\mathrm{d}t \tag*{(28)}

Here, we compute the VACF at constant energy rather than constant temperature to avoid known artifacts of a relatively strongly coupled Langevin thermostat on vibrational dampening[57]. Averages above are computed within Torch-Sim by sampling every 10 timesteps and averaged over a moving window of 2,000 samples, corresponding to a spectral resolution of approximately (c×2000×10×1 fs)−1≈1.668 cm−1(c \times2000 \times10 \times1\ \mathrm{fs})^{-1} \approx1.668\ \mathrm{cm}^{-1}, where c=3.0×10−5 cm/fsc = 3.0 \times10^{-5}\ \mathrm{cm/fs} is the speed of light.

Results

In regard to the computational cost, we find that the computation time to compute the data matrix corresponding to TCE features is significantly smaller than that of MACE features. Namely, the computation time of a TCE feature vector is about 3.14 sec/0.18 sec ≈\approx 17x faster than a MACE feature vector on a single CPU (Figure 2). The main reason for this is that the tensor contractions to construct TCE features (Eq. (11)) are simpler mathematical operations than constructing MACE descriptors. Additionally, the TCE features describe a fixed, on-lattice system, so the neighbor list does not need to be recomputed, meaning that the A[ℓ]A^{[\ell]} tensors need to only be computed once if all samples share the same lattice positions. We note that in order to generate a fair comparison in Figure 2, each subset has its own independent cache, i.e. each TCE data point independently computes A\mathbf{A}.

Figure 2. Computation time (with a sample size of 5) to compute TCE features or MACE features of a size-kk subset of 4×44 \times4 TMD monolayers on a single Intel Xeon CPU E5-2660 2.20 GHz CPU.

A standard workflow would typically perform the MACE calculations on a GPU, rather than a single CPU, narrowing the performance gap relative to TCE calculations on a single CPU. However, the tensor contractions performed by tce-lib are well suited to GPU acceleration, especially using libraries that support sparse tensors like PyTorch[52]. We save this implementation for a future work. For now, though, the advantage is clear, in that we can efficiently perform subset selection in a resource-constrained environment.

We find that the overlap between the two chosen subsets significantly exceeds that of a random overlap, meaning that the TCE subset selection is well-selecting the basis used to construct MACE features (Figure 3).

Figure 3. Consistency index I=∣XTCE∩XMACE∣I = \lvert X_{\mathrm{TCE}} \cap X_{\mathrm{MACE}} \rvert vs. subset size k=∣XTCE∣=∣XMACE∣k = \lvert X_{\mathrm{TCE}} \rvert= \lvert X_{\mathrm{MACE}} \rvert bounded by the perfect case I=kI = k and the random case I=k2/nI = k^2/n.

We additionally find that both potentials reasonably predict both the DFT energies and forces in their respective training sets, as well as the shared validation and test sets (Figure 4).

Figure 4. Parity plots of energies (left) and forces (right) for the potentials fine-tuned on the TCE- (top) and MACE-selected (right) subsets. Each panel respectively contains 0.5% and 0.01% of the full energies and forces data for clearer visualization.

Each distribution of residuals is relatively symmetric about 0, with respective widths on the order of 10 meV/atom and 0.5 eV/Å on all dataset splits, indicating further that the potentials are not overfitted (Figure 5).

Distribution of residuals for TCE- and MACE-selected subsets

Figure 5. Distribution of residuals (predicted − DFT) using the TCE and MACE selected subsets (top and bottom respectively) for both energies (left) and forces (right). Here, counts on the vertical axis are log-scaled.

We find that, at low temperatures, the TCE model predicts substantial Te clustering in W(S, Te)2_2, Mo(S, Te)2_2, and Mo(Se, Te)2_2. This chemical ordering, although suppressed relative to 100 K, survives at relatively high temperatures (i.e. 400 K) in these systems. (Figure 6). In the other TMD monolayers, we find more moderate low-temperature chemical ordering.

Extreme M(X, X′)$_2$ configurations at 100 K and 400 K

Figure 6. Extreme M(X,X′)2M(X, X^\prime)_2 configurations visualized with OVITO[29] at 100 K (left subpanels) and at 400 K (right subpanels).

Using the two MACE potentials, we then compute the VDOSs at varying temperatures by Fourier trans-

forming the VACFs. Here, we plot the result as a function of wavenumber ν~=2πω/c\tilde{\nu}=2\pi\omega/c. We additionally show the raw VACF data in Sec. A.6. For both potentials, the VDOSs are qualitatively reasonable. For example, the monolayers containing S rather than Se have higher frequency peaks, with peaks likely corresponding to S’s smaller weight relative to Se. Furthermore, at higher temperatures, we find that some peaks broaden, e.g. the 300 cm−1^{-1} peak in Ta(S, Te)2_2 (Figure 7), which is notably well-mixed even at low temperatures (Figure 6e).

Figure 7. VDOS intensities ∣g(ω)∣2|g(\omega)|^2 from the two MACE potentials finetuned on XMACEX_{\mathrm{MACE}} (left) and XTCEX_{\mathrm{TCE}} (right). Each row represents a different M(X,X′)2M(X, X^\prime)_2 system, with each color representing an MD run at a given temperature.

However, most importantly, both sets of VDOSs are very similar for each M(X,X′)2M(X, X^\prime)_2 system, with differences only at very small spectral resolutions. For example, in Ta(S, Te)2_2, the low-temperature peak around 300 cm−1^{-1} is marginally broader. The important feature of the VDOSs, though, is that the peak locations are invariant with respect to the subset chosen to finetune the potential. This is unsurprising, given that the overlap of XTCE\mathcal{X}_{\mathrm{TCE}} and XMACE\mathcal{X}_{\mathrm{MACE}} is quite large (Figure 3). Thus, this showcases that we can successfully replace a significant portion of compute power, i.e. the computation of atomic descriptors during the selection of a training set, with a significantly more cost-efficient surrogate model. We expect that this result extends to the prediction of a much larger class of dynamical properties in concentrated alloys, e.g. dynamical structure factors[58], phonon lifetimes[59], lattice thermal conductivity[60], etc., but we save this exploration for future work.

Discussion

We show, in this work, that TCE can be used as a cost-effective surrogate for the chemical complexity captured within MACE/ACE descriptors. This is particularly relevant for the high-throughput screening of materials, in which a significant bottleneck is the selection of samples with diverse chemistry to perform ab initio calculations on.

This is particularly relevant in the setting of building autonomous labs for the discovery and development of materials[61]. In this setting, it is advantageous to inject theory-in-the-loop, in the sense that the workflow proposes a class of materials living within some thermodynamic space, generates an MLIP to accurately describe that region of thermodynamic space, and performs the desired computations using the MLIP, often MD. prior to training said MLIP, one needs to choose a sufficiently chemically diverse subspace of configurations within that region of thermodynamic space.

In this work, we show that the popular ACE-class of potentials can be sufficiently pre-screened using computationally cheaper surrogate TCE features. This is principally advantageous for two reasons. More obviously, this pre-screening is, theoretically, more efficient on equivalent hardware, and empirically more efficient on single CPUs.

Furthermore, the TCE cluster counts defined in Eq. (11) are well-suited for basic hardware, including single CPUs. From the numerical experiments in this work, we find that each TCE feature vector takes on the order of 0.1 sec on a single CPU, meaning that it only takes roughly a day to compute feature vectors for 100,000 configurations without parallelization. This matters in a very practical scenario where, for example, an autonomous lab has to wait in an HPC queue for specialized hardware. Then, if the autonomous lab uses TCE surrogates in the pre-screening step, the agent can avoid a potentially long GPU queue.

Similarly, this work potentially opens the route for ab initio accurate MC/MD simulations in hardware-constrained environments. For example, TCE can be used as a surrogate Hamiltonian to resolve configurational energy/entropy and an MLIP like MACE to resolve vibrational energy/entropy, effectively using a hybrid TCE/MACE routine as a more computationally efficient thermodynamic interatomic potential, similar to recent works on on-lattice harmonic potentials[62, 63, 64].

Moreover, there are many potential routes for optimization of the feature vectors. The more obvious route is to implement TCE within PyTorch, as previously described. Moreover, a potentially advantageous route is to build a workflow that does not generate configurations independently, and instead iteratively generates chemically diverse configurations from prior ones. In this scenario, one can compute the truncated ΔN\Delta N from Eq. (15), whose computation time is independent of configuration size.

The primary limitation in this work is creating a dataset that includes defects, which are of particular interest to the TMD community. For point-like defects that sit within the same lattice as the atom types, this is reasonably amenable by adding a vacancy type in the tensor contractions in Eq. (11), i.e. by treating the vacancy as its own alloying type. Representing other types of defects, such as interstitials or ad-atoms, is not as trivial. A potential route is to augment the lattice to include extra lattice sites that can capture these off-lattice defects, similar to prior work done for using the cluster expansion technique to model vacancy diffusion in concentrated alloys, in which the transition state for a vacancy hop is represented by points in a superlattice[65, 66].

A secondary limitation is that TCE restricts its internal representation to rotationally invariant features and therefore does not retain equivariant vector- or tensor-valued information. This restriction is sufficient for predicting scalar quantities such as the total potential energy, and equivariant forces can still be obtained by differentiating the energy with respect to atomic positions. However, it may limit the model’s ability to represent interactions whose natural degrees of freedom are directional or tensorial, particularly when those degrees of freedom must be propagated through multiple layers of the representation. Equivariant architectures such as NequIP and MACE address this issue by maintaining features that transform according to nontrivial representations of the rotation group[6, 67].

This limitation may be important for potentials describing magnetic materials, including ferritic systems. Magnetic moments are vector-like degrees of freedom, and their coupling to atomic structure can involve changes in both moment magnitude and orientation. In iron, magnetic contributions have been associated with phase stability, elastic behavior near the Curie temperature, defect energetics, and structural transformations[68]. A TCE model trained only on invariant structural features may therefore require substantially higher body order or additional scalar contractions to capture such effects accurately, and it cannot directly provide equivariant magnetic observables. Extending TCE to include equivariant channels so that the spanning relation in Eq. (40) has some equivariant expressiveness would be a natural direction for future work.

Conclusions

In this work, we prove that TCE features span an invariant subspace of MACE features. We then show that, in some model alloyed TMD systems, TCE features act as efficient, surrogate pre-screeners for MACE features, by means of performing maximum-entropy subset selection on a high-entropy monolayer TMD dataset. We then compare maximum-entropy subsets selected by both TCE and MACE features to finetune two foundational MACE potentials to calculate VDOSs on some alloyed TMD systems, showing that the two potentials predict nearly identical VDOSs in all of the model systems at all tested temperatures. This approach advances the broader goal of tractable predictions of alloy thermodynamics in concentrated alloys, further opening the path towards the efficient sampling of chemical diversity at-scale. Furthermore, our results establish a direct connection between on-lattice-based descriptions of chemical diversity and representations used in off-lattice MLIPs, providing a foundation for using well-established on-lattice methods to inform the study of chemically complex materials with off-lattice MLIPs.

Data Availability

The full TMD dataset used to train the MLIPs and TCE model in this work, as well as the full scripts to reproduce our results, are available on GitHub[44, 69, 70].

Acknowledgments

We thank Panchapakesan Ganesh for insightful discussion that contributed to this work.

The authors acknowledge support by the U.S. Department of Energy, Office of Science, Office of Workforce Development for Teachers and Scientists, Office of Science Graduate Student Research (SCGSR) program. The SCGSR program is administered by the Oak Ridge Institute for Science and Education for the DOE under contract number DE-SC0014664.

J. Jeffries and E. Martinez acknowledge support from the U.S. Department of Energy, Office of Basic Energy Sciences, Materials Science and Engineering Division under Award No. DE-SC0022980.

E. Zarkadoula was supported by the Center for Nanophase Materials Sciences, (CNMS), which is a US Department of Energy, Office of Science User Facility at Oak Ridge National Laboratory.

Additionally, this material is based on work supported by the National Science Foundation under Grant Nos. MRI# 2024205, MRI# 1725573, and CRI# 2010270 for allotment of compute time on the Clemson University Palmetto Cluster.

Disclaimer

Any opinions, findings, and conclusions or recommendations expressed in this material are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect the views of the National Science Foundation.

Appendix

Outline of proof

The proof begins by choosing one cluster vertex as the root ii and write f=(a,c,α)f=(\mathbf{a},\mathbf{c},\boldsymbol{\alpha}), where aξa_{\xi} labels the root-neighbor shell, cξζc_{\xi\zeta} labels the neighbor-neighbor shell, and σξ=αξ+1\sigma_{\xi}=\alpha_{\xi+1}. The rooted contribution, i.e. the number of clusters of type ff incident to site ii is then:

Φi,f=Xiα1∑j1,…,jν[∏ξ=1νAijξ(aξ)Xjξσξ][∏ξ<ζAjξjζ(cξζ)](29)\Phi_{i,f}=X_{i\alpha_{1}}\sum_{j_{1},\ldots,j_{\nu}}\left[\prod_{\xi=1}^{\nu}A_{ij_{\xi}}^{(a_{\xi})}X_{j_{\xi}\sigma_{\xi}}\right]\left[\prod_{\xi<\zeta}A_{j_{\xi}j_{\zeta}}^{(c_{\xi\zeta})}\right] \tag*{(29)}

with the resulting number of clusters of type ff being the sum of these root contributions:

Nf=Nαℓ=∑iΦi,f(30)N_{f}=N_{\alpha}^{\ell}=\sum_{i}\Phi_{i,f} \tag*{(30)}

where ℓ=a⊕c\ell=\mathbf{a}\oplus\mathbf{c} is the topological label of the cluster and ⊕\oplus denotes concatenation. We note that Eq. (29) decomposes the adjacency tensor product into two distinct products, namely that of the root-neighbor edges (labeled with 1≤ξ≤ν1\leq\xi\leq\nu) and that of neighbor-neighbor edges (labeled with ξ<ζ\xi<\zeta), which is visualized in Figure 8. MACE features natively capture the root-neighbor edges[6, 7], thus, to prove that TCE features are contained within MACE’s feature space, it suffices to recover the second product using root-centered MACE features.

Figure 8. Root-neighbor vs. neighbor-neighbor edges in an arbitrary 4-body cluster (ν=3\nu=3), respectively corresponding to the adjacency tensors Aijξ(aξ)A_{ij_{\xi}}^{(a_{\xi})} and Ajξjζ(cξζ)A_{j_{\xi}j_{\zeta}}^{(c_{\xi\zeta})}, with edge labels aξa_{\xi} and cξζc_{\xi\zeta}.

For each shell pair (a,b)(a,b), let Ωab\Omega_{ab} be its finite set of admissible angle cosines. For some cos⁡θ∈Ωab\cos\theta\in\Omega_{ab}, finite interpolation gives a polynomial qabcq_{ab}^{c} such that:

qabc(cos⁡θ)={1da2+db2−2dadbcos⁡θ=dc20else(31)q_{ab}^{c}(\cos\theta)= \begin{cases} 1 & d_{a}^{2}+d_{b}^{2}-2d_{a}d_{b}\cos\theta=d_{c}^{2}\\ 0 & \text{else} \end{cases} \tag*{(31)}

where aa, bb, and cc denote neighbor shells and dad_{a}, dbd_{b}, and dcd_{c} are respectively the interatomic distance within those shells. Then, let uξ\mathbf{u}_{\xi} be the unit vector pointing from site ii to site jξj_{\xi}. We then have, by the law of cosines, that the neighbor-neighbor part of the adjacency tensor can be represented by the polynomial qabcq_{ab}^{c}, given that jξj_{\xi} and jζj_{\zeta} are both connected to the root atom ii:

qaξaζcξζ(uξ⋅uζ)=Ajξjζ(cξζ)(32)q_{a_{\xi}a_{\zeta}}^{c_{\xi\zeta}}(\mathbf{u}_{\xi}\cdot\mathbf{u}_{\zeta})=A_{j_{\xi}j_{\zeta}}^{(c_{\xi\zeta})} \tag*{(32)}

so that the product

Qac(u1,…,uν)=∏ξ<ζqaξaζcξζ(uξ⋅uζ)(33)Q_{\mathbf{a}}^{\mathbf{c}}(\mathbf{u}_{1},\ldots,\mathbf{u}_{\nu})=\prod_{\xi<\zeta}q_{a_{\xi}a_{\zeta}}^{c_{\xi\zeta}}(\mathbf{u}_{\xi}\cdot\mathbf{u}_{\zeta}) \tag*{(33)}

equals the neighbor-neighbor adjacency product in Eq. (29) whenever the root-shell factors are nonzero. Furthermore, the function QacQ_{\mathbf{a}}^{\mathbf{c}} is a finite-degree polynomial in pairwise dot products. It therefore has a finite expansion in scalar coupled spherical harmonics:

Qac=∑ηΛηa,cKη(34)Q_{\mathbf{a}}^{\mathbf{c}}=\sum_{\boldsymbol{\eta}}\Lambda_{\boldsymbol{\eta}}^{\mathbf{a},\mathbf{c}}\mathcal{K}_{\boldsymbol{\eta}} \tag*{(34)}

where ην\eta_\nu is an angular-coupling multi-index, KηνK_{\eta_\nu} is an invariant angular kernel constructed as a product of spherical harmonics YlmY_l^m and generalized Clebsch-Gordan coefficients CC:

Kην(u^1,…,u^ν)=∑lmCην,lm00∏ξ=1νYlξmξ(u^ξ)(35)K_{\eta_\nu}(\hat{\mathbf{u}}_1,\ldots,\hat{\mathbf{u}}_\nu)=\sum_{lm}C^{00}_{\eta_\nu,lm}\prod_{\xi=1}^{\nu}Y_{l_\xi}^{m_\xi}(\hat{\mathbf{u}}_\xi) \tag*{(35)}

Here, consistent with MACE’s notation, each ην\eta_\nu labels a choice of angular degrees (l1,…,lν)(l_1,\ldots,l_\nu) yielding a total L=0L=0. Then, choose the primitive MACE channels to be

Ai,(a,σ)lm(1)=∑jAij(a)XjσYlm(r^ji)(36)A^{(1)}_{i,(a,\sigma)lm}=\sum_j A^{(a)}_{ij}X_{j\sigma}Y_l^m(\hat{\mathbf{r}}_{ji}) \tag*{(36)}

and let B^i,ην;p,00(1)\hat{B}^{(1)}_{i,\eta_\nu;\mathbf{p},00} denote the scalar coupled product of these primitives, with pξ=(aξ,σξ)p_\xi=(a_\xi,\sigma_\xi):

B^i,ην;p,00(1)=∑lmCην,lm00∏ξ=1νAi,pξlξmξ(1)(37)\hat{B}^{(1)}_{i,\eta_\nu;\mathbf{p},00}=\sum_{lm}C^{00}_{\eta_\nu,lm}\prod_{\xi=1}^{\nu}A^{(1)}_{i,p_\xi l_\xi m_\xi} \tag*{(37)}

Then, expanding the neighbor sums and using Eqs. (33)–(34) gives:

Xiα1∑ηνAηνa,cB^i,ην;p,00(1)=Φi,f(38)X_{i\alpha_1}\sum_{\eta_\nu}A^{a,c}_{\eta_\nu}\hat{B}^{(1)}_{i,\eta_\nu;\mathbf{p},00}=\Phi_{i,f} \tag*{(38)}

By the channel-realization condition, the finite combination in Eq. (38) can be implemented by the chosen MACE products. Receiving-species-dependent weights supply Xiα1X_{i\alpha_1}, and a linear update sums the auxiliary channels, producing hi,f00(2)=Φi,fh^{(2)}_{i,f00}=\Phi_{i,f}, with a final summation layer yielding NfN_f. It follows immediately that a linear invariant readout recovers any Hamiltonian in the corresponding finite TCE span:

H=∑f∈FJf∑ihi,f00(2)=∑f∈FJfNf∝∑α,a,cεαa⊕cNαa⊕c(39)H=\sum_{f\in\mathcal{F}}J_f\sum_i h^{(2)}_{i,f00}=\sum_{f\in\mathcal{F}}J_fN_f \propto\sum_{\alpha,a,c}\varepsilon^{a\oplus c}_{\alpha}N^{a\oplus c}_{\alpha} \tag*{(39)}

Therefore:

{Nαℓ′}⊆span⁡{invariant MACE features}(40)\left\{N^{\ell'}_{\alpha}\right\}\subseteq\operatorname{span}\{\text{invariant MACE features}\} \tag*{(40)}

We note that the exact 1-to-1 equivalence described by the spanning relation above is not very important. Rather, what is important is that the two spaces are at least approximately equivalent in the information theory sense. A practical test for this is to see if, when computing a maximum entropy subset, that we can choose either a TCE or MACE feature vector and achieve the same subset. Then, this means that a TCE feature vector is an effective pre-screening surrogate for chemical complexity, allowing for a more efficient choice of a training set for a MACE potential, as done in this work.

Full proof

We prove below that these generalized TCE features emerge as a subspace of MACE features[6, 7]. More specifically, TCE features span an invariant subspace of MACE features with a particular choice of weights, and some assumptions about the message-passing architecture, which is tuneable by design. We can prove this by first constructing the non-symmetrized TCE feature Nαℓ′N^{\ell'}_\alpha:

Nαℓ′=∑i1,…,im[∏1≤r<s≤mAiris(ℓris′)][∏r=1mXirαr](41)N^{\ell'}_{\alpha}=\sum_{i_1,\ldots,i_m}\left[\prod_{1\leq r<s\leq m}A^{(\ell'_{r_is})}_{i_ri_s}\right]\left[\prod_{r=1}^{m}X_{i_r\alpha_r}\right] \tag*{(41)}

Assume that the shell adjacency matrices are determined by the embedded pair geometry on a fixed lattice, so that:

Aij(n)=χn(rij),(42)A^{(n)}_{ij}=\chi_n(r_{ij}), \tag*{(42)}

or, equivalently, that the shell labels are available to MACE as edge attributes. Then, for sufficiently large but finite angular cutoff and channel dimension, the feature Nαℓ′N^{\ell'}_\alpha can be represented exactly by an invariant MACE feature of correlation order ν=m−1\nu=m-1. Without loss of generality, we can then pick an arbitrary lattice site, labeled the root site, i1i_1. Then, its neighbors can be written as:

i=i1,jξ=iξ+1,i=i_1,\qquad j_\xi=i_{\xi+1},
ξ=1,…,ν,ν=m−1.(43)\xi=1,\ldots,\nu,\qquad\nu=m-1. \tag*{(43)}

Here, ξ\xi iterates through the possible body orders, so that jξj_\xi labels neighboring atoms that are directly connected to the root site. Additionally, define the shell labels, which enumerate the neighbor orders:

aξ:=ℓ1,ξ+1′cξζ:=ℓξ+1,ζ+1′1≤ξ<ζ≤ν(44)a_{\xi} := \ell'_{1,\xi+1} \qquad c_{\xi\zeta} := \ell'_{\xi+1,\zeta+1} \qquad1 \le\xi< \zeta\le\nu \tag*{(44)}

and similarly the neighbor chemical labels, which enumerate the chemical types of i1i_1’s neighbors:

σξ:=αξ+1.(45)\sigma_{\xi} := \alpha_{\xi+1}. \tag*{(45)}

The local contribution rooted at i1i_1 is therefore

Φi,f=Xiα1∑j1,…,jν[∏ξ=1νAijξ(aξ)Xjξσξ][∏1≤ξ<ζ≤νAjξjζ(cξζ)](46)\Phi_{i,f} = X_{i\alpha_1} \sum_{j_1,\ldots,j_\nu} \left[\prod_{\xi=1}^{\nu} A^{(a_\xi)}_{i j_\xi} X_{j_\xi\sigma_\xi}\right] \left[\prod_{1\leq\xi<\zeta\leq\nu} A^{(c_{\xi\zeta})}_{j_\xi j_\zeta}\right] \tag*{(46)}

where f=(a,c,α)f=(\mathbf{a},\mathbf{c},\boldsymbol{\alpha}) is a channel index and the corresponding global TCE feature is Nf=∑iΦi,fN_f=\sum_i\Phi_{i,f}. Φi,f\Phi_{i,f} then counts the number of clusters of type ff incident to site ii.

Note that the adjacency tensors are split into two different products, namely Aijξ(aξ)A^{(a_\xi)}_{i j_\xi} and Ajξjζ(cξζ)A^{(c_{\xi\zeta})}_{j_\xi j_\zeta}. The former represents the edges into site ii, labeled root-neighbor edges, while the latter represents edges between neighbors of site ii, labeled neighbor-neighbor edges. In the generalized formalism above, a cluster of type ff is fully defined by both, which is in contrast to the MACE formalism, whose many-body features are fully defined by the former, visualized in Figure 8.

We can engineer the weights of MACE, however, to include the contributions of the latter adjacency tensor. The standard MACE feature is[6]:

Ai,kl1m1(1)=∑j∈N(i)Rkl1(1)(rji)Yl1m1(r^ji)Wkαj(1)(47)A^{(1)}_{i,kl_1m_1}=\sum_{j\in\mathcal{N}(i)}R^{(1)}_{kl_1}(r_{ji})Y^{m_1}_{l_1}(\hat{\mathbf{r}}_{ji})W^{(1)}_{k\alpha_j} \tag*{(47)}

where N(i)\mathcal{N}(i) is the set of neighbors of atom ii, Rkl1(1)R^{(1)}_{kl_1} is a radial basis function that depends on an implicit channel kk, rjir_{ji} is the distance between atoms ii and jj, Yl1m1Y^{m_1}_{l_1} denotes spherical harmonics, r^ji\hat{\mathbf{r}}_{ji} is the unit vector between atoms ii and jj, αj\alpha_j is the chemical type of atom jj, and Wkαj(1)W^{(1)}_{k\alpha_j} is a species-resolved weight. We note that MACE uses a standard AA to denote this feature, and additionally denotes the chemical species by their atomic number zjz_j. For this work, to simplify the connection to TCE features, we will use the alternative notation above, namely A\mathcal{A} for MACE features and Greek letters for chemical species.

We can design the radial basis functions as well as the species-resolved weight to match TCE descriptors in Eq. (46), namely by choosing the channel k=(n,σ)k=(n,\sigma) to correspond to neighbor order nn and chemical type σ\sigma, and choosing a radial basis function:

χn(dn′)=δnn′\chi_n(d_{n'})=\delta_{nn'}
R(n,α)(1)(r)=χn(r)R^{(1)}_{(n,\alpha)}(r)=\chi_n(r)
W(n,α)β(1)=δαβ(48)W^{(1)}_{(n,\alpha)\beta}=\delta_{\alpha\beta} \tag*{(48)}

where dnd_n denotes the neighbor distance for shell nn so that χn\chi_n is a shell indicator. In general, this should be continuous over rr, i.e. a shell indicator if dnd_n is exactly a neighbor shell, and an interpolant otherwise. These choices yield shell- and species-resolved features that satisfy:

Ai,(n,σ)lm(1)=∑jAij(n)XjσYlm(r^ji).(49)\mathcal{A}^{(1)}_{i,(n,\sigma)lm}=\sum_j A^{(n)}_{ij}X_{j\sigma}Y^m_l(\hat{\mathbf{r}}_{ji}). \tag*{(49)}

where Aij(n)A^{(n)}_{ij} is the adjacency tensor defined in Eq. (3). For the target TCE feature, define the primitive channels:

pξ:=(aξ,σξ)ξ=1,…,ν(50)p_\xi:= (a_\xi,\sigma_\xi) \qquad\xi=1,\ldots,\nu \tag*{(50)}

where aξa_\xi denotes a neighbor order, i.e. the edge type connecting atoms ii and jξj_\xi, and σξ\sigma_\xi is the chemical type of atom jξj_\xi. Eq. (49) then gives:

Ai,pξℓξmξ(1)=∑jξAijξ(aξ)XjξσξYℓξmξ(r^jξi).(51)\mathcal{A}^{(1)}_{i,p_\xi\ell_\xi m_\xi} =\sum_{j_\xi} A^{(a_\xi)}_{i j_\xi}X_{j_\xi\sigma_\xi}Y^{m_\xi}_{\ell_\xi}(\hat{\mathbf{r}}_{j_\xi i}). \tag*{(51)}

Introduce the slot-resolved coupled product

B^i,ν,p,00(1)=∑lmCν,lm00∏ξ=1νAi,pξℓξmξ(1),(52)\widehat{B}^{(1)}_{i,\nu,\mathbf{p},00} =\sum_{lm} C^{00}_{\nu,lm}\prod_{\xi=1}^{\nu}\mathcal{A}^{(1)}_{i,p_\xi\ell_\xi m_\xi}, \tag*{(52)}

where:

p=(p1,…,pν)lm=(ℓ1m1,…,ℓνmν)(53)\mathbf{p}=(p_1,\ldots,p_\nu) \qquad\mathbf{lm}=(\ell_1m_1,\ldots,\ell_\nu m_\nu) \tag*{(53)}

and ν\nu labels a generalized Clebsch–Gordan coupling path to total angular momentum L=M=0L=M=0, and $C denotes the generalized Clebsch-Gordan coefficients. Here, the coupling and the coefficients themselves retain the same meaning as within the standard MACE formalism. Substituting (51) into (52) yields:

B^i,ην;p,00(1)=∑j1,…,jν[∏ξ=1νAijξ(aξ)Xjξσξ]Kην(r^j1i,…,r^jνi)(54)\widehat{B}^{(1)}_{i,\eta_\nu;p,00}=\sum_{j_1,\ldots,j_\nu}\left[\prod_{\xi=1}^{\nu}A^{(a_\xi)}_{ij_\xi}X_{j_\xi\sigma_\xi}\right]\mathcal{K}_{\eta_\nu}\left(\hat{r}_{j_1i},\ldots,\hat{r}_{j_\nu i}\right) \tag*{(54)}

where the invariant angular kernel is:

Kην(u^1,…,u^ν)=∑lmCην,lm00∏ξ=1νYlξmξ(u^ξ)(55)\mathcal{K}_{\eta_\nu}\left(\hat{u}_1,\ldots,\hat{u}_\nu\right)=\sum_{lm}C^{00}_{\eta_\nu,lm}\prod_{\xi=1}^{\nu}Y_{l_\xi}^{m_\xi}\left(\hat{u}_\xi\right) \tag*{(55)}

Thus, the product of the ν\nu primitive A\mathcal{A} features already produces the target factors ∏ξ=1νAijξ(aξ)Xjξσξ\prod_{\xi=1}^{\nu}A^{(a_\xi)}_{ij_\xi}X_{j_\xi\sigma_\xi}, namely the ν\nu root-neighbor adjacency factors and the ν\nu neighbor occupation factors.

What remains is to construct the (ν2)\binom{\nu}{2} adjacency factors among the neighbors, i.e. the neighbor-neighbor edges visualized in Figure 8, which would complete the proof. For fixed root-shell labels aa and bb, define the finite set of the cosine of admissible lattice angles:

Ωab={r^ji⋅r^ki∣Aij(a)Aik(b)=1}(56)\Omega_{ab}=\left\{\hat{r}_{ji}\cdot\hat{r}_{ki}\mid A^{(a)}_{ij}A^{(b)}_{ik}=1\right\} \tag*{(56)}

For every closing shell cc (closing in the sense that the (a,b,c)(a,b,c) edge forms a closed clique), choose a finite interpolation polynomial qabcq^{c}_{ab} satisfying:

qabc(cos⁡θ)={1da2+db2−2dadbcos⁡θ=dc20else(57)q^{c}_{ab}(\cos\theta)= \begin{cases} 1 & d_a^2+d_b^2-2d_ad_b\cos\theta=d_c^2\\ 0 & \text{else} \end{cases} \tag*{(57)}

for all cos⁡θ∈Ωab\cos\theta\in\Omega_{ab}, where dad_a is the distance in shell aa and θ\theta is the angle opposite to {a,b}\{a,b\} side in the triangle defined by the nodes {a,b,c}\{a,b,c\}. Then, define the complete closure-graph projector:

Qac(u^1,…,u^ν)=∏1≤ξ<ζ≤νqaξaζcξζ(u^ξ⋅u^ζ)(58)Q_a^c\left(\hat{u}_1,\ldots,\hat{u}_\nu\right)=\prod_{1\leq\xi<\zeta\leq\nu}q^{c_{\xi\zeta}}_{a_\xi a_\zeta}\left(\hat{u}_\xi\cdot\hat{u}_\zeta\right) \tag*{(58)}

Conditional on the root-shell factors, (57) and the law of cosines imply:

[∏ξ=1νAijξ(aξ)]Qac(r^j1i,…,r^jνi)=[∏ξ=1νAijξ(aξ)][∏ξ<ζAjξjζ(cξζ)](59)\left[\prod_{\xi=1}^{\nu}A^{(a_\xi)}_{ij_\xi}\right]Q_a^c\left(\hat{r}_{j_1i},\ldots,\hat{r}_{j_\nu i}\right)=\left[\prod_{\xi=1}^{\nu}A^{(a_\xi)}_{ij_\xi}\right]\left[\prod_{\xi<\zeta}A^{(c_{\xi\zeta})}_{j_\xi j_\zeta}\right] \tag*{(59)}

Note that, when aξ=aζa_\xi=a_\zeta, repeated-neighbor contributions jξ=jζj_\xi=j_\zeta may be removed by including μ=1\mu=1 in the interpolation set and imposing qaac(1)=0q^c_{aa}(1)=0 for every positive closing shell cc.

The function QacQ_a^c is a finite polynomial in the pairwise dot products u^ξ⋅u^ζ\hat{u}_\xi\cdot\hat{u}_\zeta. It is therefore a finite-degree, rotationally invariant polynomial on (S2)ν(S^2)^\nu. Hence, for sufficiently large but finite angular cutoff, it has an expansion in coupled spherical harmonics with total L=M=0L=M=0:

Qac(u^1,…,u^ν)=∑ηνΛην,caKην(u^1,…,u^ν)(60)Q_a^c\left(\hat{u}_1,\ldots,\hat{u}_\nu\right)=\sum_{\eta_\nu}\Lambda^a_{\eta_\nu,c}\mathcal{K}_{\eta_\nu}\left(\hat{u}_1,\ldots,\hat{u}_\nu\right) \tag*{(60)}

Combining Eqs. (54), (59), and (60) gives:

∑ηνΛην,caB^i,ην;p,00(1)=∑j1,…,jν[∏ξ=1νAijξ(aξ)Xjξσξ][∏ξ<ζAjξjζ(cξζ)](61)\sum_{\eta_\nu}\Lambda^a_{\eta_\nu,c}\widehat{B}^{(1)}_{i,\eta_\nu;p,00}=\sum_{j_1,\ldots,j_\nu}\left[\prod_{\xi=1}^{\nu}A^{(a_\xi)}_{ij_\xi}X_{j_\xi\sigma_\xi}\right]\left[\prod_{\xi<\zeta}A^{(c_{\xi\zeta})}_{j_\xi j_\zeta}\right] \tag*{(61)}

The slot-resolved object B^i,ην;p,00(1)\widehat{B}^{(1)}_{i,\eta_\nu;p,00} defined in (52) is not itself written in the factorized channel notation of the native MACE BB-features:

Bi,ηνk00(1)=∑lmCην,lm00∏ξ=1ν∑k~wkkk~(1)Ai,kξlξmξ(1)(62)B^{(1)}_{i,\eta_\nu k00}=\sum_{lm}C^{00}_{\eta_\nu,lm}\prod_{\xi=1}^{\nu}\sum_{\tilde{k}}w^{(1)}_{kk\tilde{k}}A^{(1)}_{i,k_\xi l_\xi m_\xi} \tag*{(62)}

We could, however, choose the weight wkkk~(1)=δkk~w^{(1)}_{kk\tilde{k}}=\delta_{k\tilde{k}} so that the MACE BB-features exactly match the slot-resolved coupled product. More generally, though, the required permutation-symmetrized channel tensor lies in the finite linear span of the native features Bi,ηνk00(1)B^{(1)}_{i,\eta_\nu k00}. Notably, the neighbor indices are dummy summation variables, so the channel tensor may be symmetrized, and every finite symmetric order-ν\nu tensor is a finite linear combination of rank-one symmetric powers[71]. Consequently, there exist finitely many native MACE channels kqk_q and coefficients Θq,ηνf\Theta^{f}_{q,\eta_\nu} such that:

∑ηνAηνa,cB^i,ην;p,00(1)=∑q∑ηνΘq,ηνfBi,ην,kq00(1)(63)\sum_{\eta_\nu} A^{a,c}_{\eta_\nu}\widehat{B}^{(1)}_{i,\eta_\nu;p,00} = \sum_q\sum_{\eta_\nu}\Theta^{f}_{q,\eta_\nu}B^{(1)}_{i,\eta_\nu,k_q00} \tag*{(63)}

Choose the receiving-species-dependent MACE message weights as

Wαikq0,ην(1)=δαiα1Θq,ηνf=Xiα1Θq,ηνf(64)W^{(1)}_{\alpha_i k_q0,\eta_\nu} = \delta_{\alpha_i\alpha_1}\Theta^{f}_{q,\eta_\nu} = X_{i\alpha_1}\Theta^{f}_{q,\eta_\nu} \tag*{(64)}

Set all message weights at correlation orders different from ν=m−1\nu=m-1 to zero. The resulting messages are

mi,kq00(1)=Xiα1∑ηνΘq,ηνfBi,ην,kq00(1)(65)m^{(1)}_{i,k_q00} = X_{i\alpha_1}\sum_{\eta_\nu}\Theta^{f}_{q,\eta_\nu}B^{(1)}_{i,\eta_\nu,k_q00} \tag*{(65)}

Choose the subsequent MACE update to be linear, set the residual weights to zero, and sum the auxiliary channels:

hi,f00(2)=∑qmi,kq00(1)(66)h^{(2)}_{i,f00} = \sum_q m^{(1)}_{i,k_q00} \tag*{(66)}

Using Eqs. (61) and (63), this gives:

hi,f00(2)=Xiα1∑j1,…,jν[∏ξ=1νAijξ(aξ)Xjξσξ][∏ξ<ζAjξjζ(cξζ)]=Φi,f(67)h^{(2)}_{i,f00} = X_{i\alpha_1} \sum_{j_1,\ldots,j_\nu} \left[ \prod_{\xi=1}^{\nu} A^{(a_\xi)}_{i j_\xi}X_{j_\xi\sigma_\xi} \right] \left[ \prod_{\xi<\zeta} A^{(c_{\xi\zeta})}_{j_\xi j_\zeta} \right] = \Phi_{i,f} \tag*{(67)}

Therefore:

∑ihi,f00(2)=∑iΦi,f=Nf(68)\sum_i h^{(2)}_{i,f00} = \sum_i\Phi_{i,f} = N_f \tag*{(68)}

A linear invariant readout with coefficient JfJ_f then gives:

H=∑fJf∑ihi,f00(2)=∑fJfNf(69)H = \sum_f J_f\sum_i h^{(2)}_{i,f00} = \sum_f J_fN_f \tag*{(69)}

Finally, the number of adjacency factors represented by the correlation-order-ν\nu MACE feature is:

ν+(ν2)=(ν+12)=(m2)(70)\nu+\binom{\nu}{2} = \binom{\nu+1}{2} = \binom{m}{2} \tag*{(70)}

where ν\nu is the number of root-neighbor edges and (ν2)\binom{\nu}{2} is the number of neighbor-neighbor edges. Likewise, the number of occupation factors XX is:

ν+1=m(71)\nu+1=m \tag*{(71)}

where ν\nu is the number of XX factors corresponding to neighbors and 1 is the number of XX factors corresponding to the occupation of the root atom. Hence every mm-body TCE feature is exactly representable by an invariant MACE feature with correlation order ν=m−1\nu=m-1, therefore completing the proof, so:

{Nαℓ′}⊆span⁡{invariant MACE features}(72)\left\{N^{\ell'}_{\alpha}\right\} \subseteq \operatorname{span}\{\text{invariant MACE features}\} \tag*{(72)}

Note that these features are of the non-symmetrized cluster counts ℓ′\ell', rather than the symmetrized counts indexed by the equivalence class [ℓ][\ell]. For a symmetric TCE environment [ℓ][\ell], the corresponding topology tensor is:

Ai1⋯im[ℓ]=⋁ℓ′∈[ℓ]∏1≤r<s≤mAiris(ℓrs′)(73)A^{[\ell]}_{i_1\cdots i_m} = \bigvee_{\ell'\in[\ell]} \prod_{1\le r<s\le m} A^{(\ell'_{r_s})}_{i_r i_s} \tag*{(73)}

Since distinct complete shell assignments are mutually exclusive on a fixed site tuple, the Boolean union is proportional to the ordinary sum:

Ai1⋯im[ℓ]∝∑ℓ′∈[ℓ]∏1≤r<s≤mAiris(ℓrs′)(74)A^{[\ell]}_{i_1\cdots i_m} \propto \sum_{\ell'\in[\ell]} \prod_{1\le r<s\le m} A^{(\ell'_{r_s})}_{i_r i_s} \tag*{(74)}

where the coefficient of proportionality can depend on the stabilizer of ℓ\ell under the action of SmS_m. Thus the feature Nα[ℓ]N^{[\ell]}_{\alpha} is obtained by a final linear sum over the MACE channels constructed for the distinct representatives ℓ′∈[ℓ]\ell'\in[\ell].

In summary, the proof above shows that we can, for any permissible value of ν\nu, engineer the spherical harmonics within the MACE features to index neighbor-neighbor edges. For two-body terms, where there are no neighbor-neighbor edges, the construction is trivial, i.e. fix the spherical harmonics to be constant. For higher-order terms, the construction relies on the fact that Kℓ\mathcal{K}_\ell is SO(3)-invariant over (S2)ν(S^2)^\nu, ensuring the existence of abstract vectors that match the TCE Hamiltonian. For convenience, we have included explicit constructions for two and three-body terms in Sec. A.3.

The construction above does not establish an equivalence between the full TCE and MACE feature spaces. Instead, it shows that every TCE feature belongs to a particular shell-resolved subspace of the MACE feature space. In this subspace, the radial channels act as pair-shell projectors, while the angular couplings retain only the information required to distinguish complete species-decorated shell topologies.

To formalize this statement, let Um\mathcal{U}_m denote the space of possible mm-body environments. The completeness results of Dusson et al. show that the ACE basis systematically spans the relevant space of permutation-and isometry-invariant functions on Em\mathcal{E}_m [5], subject to the usual basis-completeness and regularity assumptions. MACE constructs its higher-order messages from the same type of ACE product basis [4].

Within TCE, two environments u,u′∈Umu,u' \in\mathcal{U}_m are equivalent when they have the same species-decorated pair-shell topology. Namely, if Γm(u)\Gamma_m(u) is defined to be KmK_m with labels for species and edge types, where u=(α,{ℓrs}r<s)u=(\alpha,\{\ell_{rs}\}_{r<s}):

Γm(u)=(Km,α,{ℓrs}r<s)(75)\Gamma_m(u) = (K_m,\alpha,\{\ell_{rs}\}_{r<s}) \tag*{(75)}

then two environments are equivalent within TCE if the two labeled subgraphs are isomorphic:

u∼u′⟺Γm(u)≅Γm(u′)(76)u \sim u' \Longleftrightarrow\Gamma_m(u) \cong\Gamma_m(u') \tag*{(76)}

where we define two labeled graphs G=(V,E)G=(V,E) and G′=(V′,E′)G'=(V',E') as isomorphic if there exists permutations π1\pi_1 and π2\pi_2 such that V′=π1VV'=\pi_1 V and E′=π2EE'=\pi_2 E. Then, the quotient Qm=Um/∼Q_m=\mathcal{U}_m/\sim is the set of distinct mm-body environments that TCE can distinguish. We can then define a basis of indicator functions for one class [q]∈Qm[q]\in Q_m:

τq(u)={1u∼q0else(77)\tau_q(u) = \begin{cases} 1 & u \sim q \\ 0 & \text{else} \end{cases} \tag*{(77)}

These indicators then satisfy the orthogonality relation τq(u)τq′(u)=δqq′τq(u)\tau_q(u)\tau_{q'}(u)=\delta_{qq'}\tau_q(u). Any function on QmQ_m can therefore be written as a linear combination of τq\tau_q, implying that TCE forms a complete basis over QmQ_m.

Two/three-body examples

Below we show specific cases of the described equivalence, namely the case for two-body and three-body features.

Two-body Hamiltonian

Starting from Eq. (49), fixing l=m=0l=m=0 gives us:

Ai,(n,α)00(1)=14π∑jAij(n)Xjα(78)A^{(1)}_{i,(n,\alpha)00} = \frac{1}{\sqrt{4\pi}}\sum_j A^{(n)}_{ij}X_{j\alpha} \tag*{(78)}

This is already quite close to the TCE descriptors. Namely, Ai,(n,α)00(1)A^{(1)}_{i,(n,\alpha)00} is proportional to the number of nn’th nearest neighbors of atom ii that are of type α\alpha. By fixing the weights, we can additionally attach the type of atom ii to the message. First, we can set ν=1\nu=1, fixing the body order ν+1=2\nu+1=2, yielding the feature tensor:

Bi,η1k00(1)=∑k~Wkk~0(1)Aik~00(1)(79)B^{(1)}_{i,\eta_1 k00} = \sum_{\tilde{k}} W^{(1)}_{k\tilde{k}0} A^{(1)}_{i\tilde{k}00} \tag*{(79)}

If here we introduce the channel k=(n,β,α)k=(n,\beta,\alpha), corresponding to neighbor order nn and chemical types α\alpha and β\beta, we can select the weights to be orthogonal:

W(n,β,α),(n′,α′),0(1)=δnn′δαα′(80)W^{(1)}_{(n,\beta,\alpha),(n',\alpha'),0} = \delta_{nn'}\delta_{\alpha\alpha'} \tag*{(80)}

Such that:

Bi,η1,(n,β,α),00(1)=Ai,(n,α)00(1)(81)B^{(1)}_{i,\eta_1,(n,\beta,\alpha),00} = A^{(1)}_{i,(n,\alpha)00} \tag*{(81)}

which is proportional to the number of α\alpha atoms that are nn’th nearest neighbors of atom ii. The message into atom ii is then:

mi,k00(1)=Wαik0,η1(1)Bi,η1k00(1)⟹mi,(n,β,α)00(1)=Wαi,(n,β,α),0,η1(1)Bi,η1,(n,β,α)00(1)(82)\begin{aligned} m^{(1)}_{i,k00} &= W^{(1)}_{\alpha_i k0,\eta_1} B^{(1)}_{i,\eta_1 k00} \\ &\Longrightarrow m^{(1)}_{i,(n,\beta,\alpha)00} = W^{(1)}_{\alpha_i,(n,\beta,\alpha),0,\eta_1} B^{(1)}_{i,\eta_1,(n,\beta,\alpha)00} \tag*{(82)} \end{aligned}

where αi\alpha_i is the chemical type of atom ii. Choose the weight Wγ,(n,β,α)0,η1=δγβW_{\gamma,(n,\beta,\alpha)0,\eta_1}=\delta_{\gamma\beta}. Then, Wαi,(n,β,α)0,η1=δαiβ=XiβW_{\alpha_i,(n,\beta,\alpha)0,\eta_1}=\delta_{\alpha_i\beta}=X_{i\beta}, so:

mi,k00(1)=XiβAi,(n,α)00(1)=14π∑jAij(n)XjαXiβ(83)m^{(1)}_{i,k00} = X_{i\beta}A^{(1)}_{i,(n,\alpha)00} = \frac{1}{\sqrt{4\pi}}\sum_j A^{(n)}_{ij}X_{j\alpha}X_{i\beta} \tag*{(83)}

The atomic energy is then ordinarily computed via its own MLP, namely:

Ei=fi(mi,k00(1))=∑kWikmi,k00(1)(84)E_i=f_i\left(m^{(1)}_{i,k00}\right)=\sum_k W_{ik}m^{(1)}_{i,k00} \tag*{(84)}

where I’ve implicitly set that atom’s MLP to a single linear readout. I will make the assumption here that every atom shares the same network, namely there’s one weight Wik=WkW_{ik}=W_k. So:

H=∑iEi=∑ikWikmi,k00(1)=∑kWk∑imi,k00(1)=14π∑(n,β,α)W(n,β,α)(1)∑ijAij(n)XjαXiβ=14π∑(n,α,β)W(n,α,β)(1)∑ijAij(n)XiαXjβ(85)\begin{aligned} H=\sum_i E_i=\sum_{ik}W_{ik}m^{(1)}_{i,k00}=\sum_k W_k\sum_i m^{(1)}_{i,k00} \\ &=\frac{1}{\sqrt{4\pi}}\sum_{(n,\beta,\alpha)}W^{(1)}_{(n,\beta,\alpha)}\sum_{ij}A^{(n)}_{ij}X_{j\alpha}X_{i\beta} \\ &=\frac{1}{\sqrt{4\pi}}\sum_{(n,\alpha,\beta)}W^{(1)}_{(n,\alpha,\beta)}\sum_{ij}A^{(n)}_{ij}X_{i\alpha}X_{j\beta} \tag*{(85)} \end{aligned}

I.e. the Hamiltonian for this MACE architecture is equivalent to the TCE hamiltonian, with linear read-out weights proportional to the interaction energies εαβ(n)\varepsilon^{(n)}_{\alpha\beta}.

Three-body Hamiltonian

Take ν=2\nu=2 for three body terms. Then, the MACE feature tensor is:

Bi,η2kLM(1)=∑m1,m2,l1,l2Cη2,l1m1,l2m2LM[∑k~wkk~l1(1)Ai,k~l1m1(1)][∑k~wkk~l2(1)Ai,k~l2m2(1)](86)B^{(1)}_{i,\eta_2kLM}=\sum_{m_1,m_2,l_1,l_2}C^{LM}_{\eta_2,l_1m_1,l_2m_2} \left[\sum_{\tilde{k}}w^{(1)}_{k\tilde{k}l_1}A^{(1)}_{i,\tilde{k}l_1m_1}\right] \left[\sum_{\tilde{k}}w^{(1)}_{k\tilde{k}l_2}A^{(1)}_{i,\tilde{k}l_2m_2}\right] \tag*{(86)}

For a scalar feature (scalar in the tensor sense), take L=M=0L=M=0 so that l=l1=l2l=l_1=l_2. Then:

Bi,η2(l)k00(1)=∑m1,m2Cη2(l),lm1,lm200[∑k~wkk~l(1)Ai,k~lm1(1)][∑k~wkk~l(1)Ai,k~lm2(1)](87)B^{(1)}_{i,\eta_2(l)k00}=\sum_{m_1,m_2}C^{00}_{\eta_2(l),lm_1,lm_2} \left[\sum_{\tilde{k}}w^{(1)}_{k\tilde{k}l}A^{(1)}_{i,\tilde{k}lm_1}\right] \left[\sum_{\tilde{k}}w^{(1)}_{k\tilde{k}l}A^{(1)}_{i,\tilde{k}lm_2}\right] \tag*{(87)}

where η2\eta_2 depends on ll. We choose a channel k~=(n,σ)\tilde{k}=(n,\sigma) once again to match the neighbor shell nn and the chemical type σ\sigma. As shown in the two-body features, this lets us construct the AA features:

Ai,(n,σ)lm(1)=∑jAij(n)XjσYlm(r^ji)(88)A^{(1)}_{i,(n,\sigma)lm}=\sum_j A^{(n)}_{ij}X_{j\sigma}Y^m_l(\hat{r}_{ji}) \tag*{(88)}

Then, if p=(a,α)p=(a,\alpha) and q=(b,γ)q=(b,\gamma):

Ai,plm(1)=∑j1Aij1(a)Xj1αYlm(r^j1i)A^{(1)}_{i,plm}=\sum_{j_1}A^{(a)}_{ij_1}X_{j_1\alpha}Y^m_l(\hat{r}_{j_1i})
Ai,qlm(1)=∑j2Aij2(b)Xj2γYlm(r^j2i)(89)A^{(1)}_{i,qlm}=\sum_{j_2}A^{(b)}_{ij_2}X_{j_2\gamma}Y^m_l(\hat{r}_{j_2i}) \tag*{(89)}

Choose the weights wkk~l(1)w^{(1)}_{k\tilde{k}l}, i.e. let k=±1k=\pm1:

wk±,k~,l(1)=δk~,p±δk~,q(90)w^{(1)}_{k_{\pm},\tilde{k},l}=\delta_{\tilde{k},p}\pm\delta_{\tilde{k},q} \tag*{(90)}

Then:

∑k~wk±,k~,l(1)Ai,k~lm(1)=Ai,plm(1)±Ai,qlm(1)(91)\sum_{\tilde{k}}w^{(1)}_{k_{\pm},\tilde{k},l}A^{(1)}_{i,\tilde{k}lm}=A^{(1)}_{i,plm}\pm A^{(1)}_{i,qlm} \tag*{(91)}

Plugging into the BB feature tensor:

Biη2,k±00(1)=∑m1,m2Cη2,lm1,lm2LM[Ai,plm1(1)±Ai,qlm1(1)][Ai,plm2(1)±Ai,qlm2(1)](92)B^{(1)}_{i\eta_2,k_{\pm}00}=\sum_{m_1,m_2}C^{LM}_{\eta_2,lm_1,lm_2} \left[A^{(1)}_{i,plm_1}\pm A^{(1)}_{i,qlm_1}\right] \left[A^{(1)}_{i,plm_2}\pm A^{(1)}_{i,qlm_2}\right] \tag*{(92)}

If we are linearly fitting to the tensors above, we can equivalently linearly fit to any linear combination of the tensors. So, we can take the difference:

Di,lpq=Biη2,k+00(1)−Biη2,k−00(1)4=12∑m1,m2Cη2,lm1,lm200(Ai,qlm1(1)Ai,plm2(1)+Ai,plm1(1)Ai,qlm2(1))(93)\begin{aligned} D^{pq}_{i,l}=\frac{B^{(1)}_{i\eta_2,k_+00}-B^{(1)}_{i\eta_2,k_-00}}{4} \\ &=\frac{1}{2}\sum_{m_1,m_2}C^{00}_{\eta_2,lm_1,lm_2} \left(A^{(1)}_{i,qlm_1}A^{(1)}_{i,plm_2}+A^{(1)}_{i,plm_1}A^{(1)}_{i,qlm_2}\right) \tag*{(93)} \end{aligned}

The generalized Clebsch-Gordan coefficients satisfy the exchange symmetry:

Cη2,lm2,lm1LM=(−1)2l−LCη2,lm1,lm2LM(94)C^{LM}_{\eta_2,lm_2,lm_1}=(-1)^{2l-L}C^{LM}_{\eta_2,lm_1,lm_2} \tag*{(94)}

So:

Di,lpq=Biη2,k+00(1)−Biη2,k−00(1)4=∑m1,m2Cη2,lm1,lm200Ai,plm1(1)Ai,qlm2(1)(95)\begin{aligned} D_{i,l}^{pq}=\frac{B_{i\eta_2,k+00}^{(1)}-B_{i\eta_2,k-00}^{(1)}}{4} \\ &=\sum_{m_1,m_2}C_{\eta_2,lm_1,lm_2}^{00}A_{i,plm_1}^{(1)}A_{i,qlm_2}^{(1)} \tag*{(95)} \end{aligned}

Then, substituting in the two A\mathcal{A} features:

Di,lpq=Biη2,k+00(1)−Biη2,k−00(1)4=∑j1,j2Aij1(a)Aij2(b)Xj1αXj2γ×∑m1,m2Cη2,lm1,lm200Ylm1(r^j1i)Ylm2(r^j2i)(96)\begin{aligned} D_{i,l}^{pq}=\frac{B_{i\eta_2,k+00}^{(1)}-B_{i\eta_2,k-00}^{(1)}}{4} \\ &=\sum_{j_1,j_2}A_{ij_1}^{(a)}A_{ij_2}^{(b)}X_{j_1\alpha}X_{j_2\gamma} \\ &\times\sum_{m_1,m_2}C_{\eta_2,lm_1,lm_2}^{00}Y_l^{m_1}(\hat{r}_{j_1i})Y_l^{m_2}(\hat{r}_{j_2i}) \tag*{(96)} \end{aligned}

Defining the scalar kernel:

Kl(r^,r^′)=∑m1,m2Cη2,lm1,lm200Ylm1(r^)Ylm2(r^′)(97)\mathcal{K}_l(\hat{r},\hat{r}')=\sum_{m_1,m_2}C_{\eta_2,lm_1,lm_2}^{00}Y_l^{m_1}(\hat{r})Y_l^{m_2}(\hat{r}') \tag*{(97)}

which, by the addition theorem, simplifies to:

Kl(r^,r^′)=κlPl(r^⋅r^′)(98)\mathcal{K}_l(\hat{r},\hat{r}')=\kappa_lP_l(\hat{r}\cdot\hat{r}') \tag*{(98)}

for some constant κl\kappa_l and Legendre polynomials PlP_l. We hope here that we can reconstruct the remaining adjacency tensor Aj1j2(c)A_{j_1j_2}^{(c)} from the Legendre polynomials. We can then choose coefficients Λlabc\Lambda_l^{abc} such that, whenever Aij1(a)Aij2(b)=1A_{ij_1}^{(a)}A_{ij_2}^{(b)}=1, we have:

∑lΛlabcKl(r^j1i,r^j2i)=Aj1j2(c)(99)\sum_l\Lambda_l^{abc}\mathcal{K}_l(\hat{r}_{j_1i},\hat{r}_{j_2i})=A_{j_1j_2}^{(c)} \tag*{(99)}

We can construct these coefficients by letting μs=r^j1i⋅r^j2i\mu_s=\hat{r}_{j_1i}\cdot\hat{r}_{j_2i} denote the possible angles indexed by ss, which is finite in a fixed lattice, and define the matrix elements Gslab=Kl(μs)G_{sl}^{ab}=\mathcal{K}_l(\mu_s), as well as the indicator tensor for the third leg:

ysabc={1da2+db2−2dadbμs=dc20else(100)y_s^{abc}= \begin{cases} 1 & d_a^2+d_b^2-2d_ad_b\mu_s=d_c^2\\ 0 & \text{else} \end{cases} \tag*{(100)}
∑lGslabΛlabc=ysabc(101)\sum_lG_{sl}^{ab}\Lambda_l^{abc}=y_s^{abc} \tag*{(101)}

which is, fortunately, invertible, since ll is strictly finite here, i.e. l=0,⋯ ,Sab−1l=0,\cdots,S_{ab}-1 where SabS_{ab} is the number of distinct values of ss. This is alternatively a Green’s function. Then:

Λlabc=(Gab)l−1sysabc(102)\Lambda_l^{abc}=(G^{ab})^{-1}_l{}^{s}y_s^{abc} \tag*{(102)}

The message into atom ii is then, once again:

mi,kLM(1)=∑ν,ηνWαikL,ην(1)Bi,ηνkLM(1)(103)m_{i,kLM}^{(1)}=\sum_{\nu,\eta_\nu}W_{\alpha ikL,\eta_\nu}^{(1)}B_{i,\eta_\nu kLM}^{(1)} \tag*{(103)}

Choose the weights for the two channels we defined earlier, i.e. k=±1k=\pm1, L=0L=0 for even parity, and ν=2\nu=2:

WαikL,η2=δαiβΛlabc=XiβΛlabc(104)W_{\alpha ikL,\eta_2}=\delta_{\alpha i\beta}\Lambda_l^{abc}=X_{i\beta}\Lambda_l^{abc} \tag*{(104)}

Then, the message simplifies to:

mi,k±,00=Xiβ∑lΛlabcBiη2(l)k±00(105)m_{i,k\pm,00}=X_{i\beta}\sum_l\Lambda_l^{abc}B_{i\eta_2(l)k\pm00} \tag*{(105)}

Here, ην\eta_\nu implicitly depends on ll, so we swap the sum to ll. The updated feature from passing the message into a second layer is, with zero residual connections:

hi,kLM(2)=∑k~WkL,k~(1)mi,k~LM(1)(106)h_{i,kLM}^{(2)}=\sum_{\tilde{k}}W_{kL,\tilde{k}}^{(1)}m_{i,\tilde{k}LM}^{(1)} \tag*{(106)}

With our chosen architecture, where k=±1k=\pm1 and L=M=0L=M=0:

hi,f00(2)=∑kWf0,k(1)mi,k00(1)(107)h_{i,f00}^{(2)}=\sum_kW_{f0,k}^{(1)}m_{i,k00}^{(1)} \tag*{(107)}

Choose the weights Wf0,k±=±14W_{f0,k\pm}=\pm\frac{1}{4}. Then:

hi,f00(2)=14mi,k+00(1)−14mi,k−00(1)=Xiβ∑lΛlabcDi,lpq=Xiβ∑j1,j2Aij1(a)Aij2(b)Xj1αXj2γ×∑lΛlabcKl(r^j1i,r^j2i)(108)\begin{aligned} h_{i,f00}^{(2)}=\frac{1}{4}m_{i,k+00}^{(1)}-\frac{1}{4}m_{i,k-00}^{(1)} \\ &=X_{i\beta}\sum_l\Lambda_l^{abc}D_{i,l}^{pq} \\ &=X_{i\beta}\sum_{j_1,j_2}A_{ij_1}^{(a)}A_{ij_2}^{(b)}X_{j_1\alpha}X_{j_2\gamma} \\ &\times\sum_l\Lambda_l^{abc}\mathcal{K}_l(\hat{r}_{j_1i},\hat{r}_{j_2i}) \tag*{(108)} \end{aligned}

By construction, the latter is exactly Aj1j2(c)A_{j_1j_2}^{(c)}. Therefore:

hi,f00(2)=∑j1,j2Aij1(a)Aij2(b)Aj1j2(c)Xj1αXj2γXiβ=∑j,kAij(a)Aik(b)Ajk(c)XjαXkγXiβ(109)h^{(2)}_{i,f00}=\sum_{j_1,j_2}A^{(a)}_{ij_1}A^{(b)}_{ij_2}A^{(c)}_{j_1j_2}X_{j_1\alpha}X_{j_2\gamma}X_{i\beta} =\sum_{j,k}A^{(a)}_{ij}A^{(b)}_{ik}A^{(c)}_{jk}X_{j\alpha}X_{k\gamma}X_{i\beta} \tag*{(109)}

ff represents the flattened index f=(a,b,c;α,β,γ)f=(a,b,c;\alpha,\beta,\gamma). TCE also implicitly uses this indexing flattening when fitting. Then, similar to before, if we have a constant aggregation layer, i.e. a summation layer, into a linear readout layer, the Hamiltonian is:

H=∑ifWif(2)hi,f00(2)=∑fWf(2)∑ihi,f00(2)=∑abcαβγWabcαβγ(2)∑ijkAij(a)Aik(b)Ajk(c)XjαXkγXiβ(110)H=\sum_{if}W^{(2)}_{if}h^{(2)}_{i,f00}=\sum_f W^{(2)}_f\sum_i h^{(2)}_{i,f00} =\sum_{abc\alpha\beta\gamma}W^{(2)}_{abc\alpha\beta\gamma}\sum_{ijk}A^{(a)}_{ij}A^{(b)}_{ik}A^{(c)}_{jk}X_{j\alpha}X_{k\gamma}X_{i\beta} \tag*{(110)}

which, if the weights are symmetric, is the exact TCE Hamiltonian. Namely, if:

Wabcαβγ(2)=W(abc)αβγ(2)=Wabc(αβγ)(2)(111)W^{(2)}_{abc\alpha\beta\gamma}=W^{(2)}_{(abc)\alpha\beta\gamma}=W^{(2)}_{abc(\alpha\beta\gamma)} \tag*{(111)}

then W(2)W^{(2)} corresponds exactly to the ECIs εαβγ[ℓ]\varepsilon^{[\ell]}_{\alpha\beta\gamma}, where ℓ=(a,b,c)\ell=(a,b,c) is the three-body label. This symmetrization could be a separate linear layer, i.e. symmetrization is a linear operation, so this would correspond to another architecture choice.

WS2-like clusters

In Table 1, we describe the TCE features used to decorate the WS2_2-like clusters. Namely, we include up to 4-body interactions. Each body order has a finite set of topological labels ℓ\ell, which index edge types, and each feature is computed for the induced equivalence class ℓ∈Sm⋅ℓ=[ℓ]\ell\in S_m\cdot\ell=[\ell]. We index edge types simply by nearest neighbor distances, accounting for periodic boundary conditions. For example, m=2m=2 and ℓ=1\ell=1 correspond to the pairwise, nearest neighbor interaction. Strictly speaking, ℓ\ell should be a tuple rather than an integer, but we can express singleton ℓ\ell's as integers without loss of generality.

number of bodies mmtopology labels ℓ\ellSpeciesGeometry
m=2m=21WSFirst nearest neighbor, 2.5 Å ±\pm 5%
2W2_2/S2_2Second nearest neighbor, 3.25 Å ±\pm 5%
3WSThird nearest neighbor, 4.0 Å ±\pm 5%
4S2_2Fourth nearest neighbor, 4.5 Å ±\pm 5%
5WSFifth nearest neighbor, 5.0 Å ±\pm 5%
6W2_2/S2_2Sixth nearest neighbor, 5.5 Å ±\pm 5%
m=3m=3(1, 1, 2)WS2_2/W2_2S2x 1nn + 1x 2nn isosceles triangle
(2, 2, 2)W3_3/S3_33x 2nn equilateral triangle
(1, 2, 3)WS2_2/W2_2S1nn + 2nn + 3nn scalene triangle
(2, 3, 3)WS2_21x 2nn + 2x 3nn isosceles triangle
m=4m=4(1, 1, 1, 1, 2, 2)W2_2S2_24x 1nn + 2x 2nn tetrahedron
(1, 1, 1, 2, 2, 2)W3_3S/WS3_33x 1nn + 3x 2nn tetrahedron
(1, 1, 2, 2, 2, 3)W3_3S/WS3_32x 1nn + 3x 2nn + 1x 3nn tetrahedron

Table 1. Description of the cluster set used to compute the feature vector in Eq. (13), visualized in Figure 1.

We note that each (m,ℓ)(m,\ell) pair has a finite set of permissible species within the cluster. This is due to the fact that WS2_2 spans multiple sublattices. As an example, the aforementioned (m,ℓ)=(2,1)(m,\ell)=(2,1) cluster can only describe interactions between the metal and chalcogen sublattices.

Within tce-lib, the only inputs to define such a feature set are the labels ℓ\ell and the nearest neighbor-distances. Many features are identically 0, however, as described above. This is not problematic for using feature vectors as global descriptors, as done in this work, but can be problematic when fitting a TCE model on systems with multiple sublattices. In the example described above, NWW(1)N^{(1)}_{\mathrm{WW}} is identically 0, so that any value of εWW(1)\varepsilon^{(1)}_{\mathrm{WW}} is valid.

TCE fitting and MC runs

Using the feature set Λ\Lambda described in Figure 1, we fit a TCE model using L1L^1 (Lasso) regression using scikit-learn[72, 73], minimizing the loss:

L(ε)=12N∑s=1N(Es−ε:Ns)2+ρ∥ε∥1,φ(112)\mathcal{L}(\varepsilon)=\frac{1}{2N}\sum_{s=1}^{N}(E_s-\varepsilon:\mathbf{N}_s)^2+\rho\lVert\varepsilon\rVert_{1,\varphi} \tag*{(112)}

where ss indexes samples, NN is the number of training samples, EsE_s is the relaxed DFT energy of the ss’th sample, ε\varepsilon are the interaction coefficients (which are learned parameters), Ns\mathbf{N}_s is the number of [ℓ][\ell]- and α\alpha-type clusters in sample ss, :: denotes the tensor dot product, ρ\rho is a regularization parameter, and ∥⋅∥1,φ\lVert\cdot\rVert_{1,\varphi} denotes a generalized L1L^1 tensor norm equipped with a linear transformation φ\varphi:

Xsiα={1site i in sample s has type α0elseNsα1⋯αm[ℓ]=Ai1⋯im[ℓ]∏k=1mXsikαkε:Ns=∑[ℓ]∈Λ∑α1⋯αmεα1⋯αm[ℓ]Nsα1⋯αm[ℓ]∥ε∥1,φ=∑[ℓ]∈Λ∑α1⋯αm∣εα1⋯αm,α1′⋯αm′[ℓ],[ℓ′]∣(113)\begin{aligned} X_{si\alpha} &= \begin{cases} 1 & \text{site }i\text{ in sample }s\text{ has type }\alpha\\ 0 & \text{else} \end{cases} \\ N^{[\ell]}_{s\alpha_1\cdots\alpha_m} &= A^{[\ell]}_{i_1\cdots i_m}\prod_{k=1}^{m}X_{s i_k\alpha_k} \\ \varepsilon:N_s &= \sum_{[\ell]\in\Lambda}\sum_{\alpha_1\cdots\alpha_m}\varepsilon^{[\ell]}_{\alpha_1\cdots\alpha_m}N^{[\ell]}_{s\alpha_1\cdots\alpha_m} \\ \|\varepsilon\|_{1,\varphi} &= \sum_{[\ell]\in\Lambda}\sum_{\alpha_1\cdots\alpha_m}\left|\varepsilon^{[\ell],[\ell']}_{\alpha_1\cdots\alpha_m,\alpha'_1\cdots\alpha'_m}\right| \tag*{(113)} \end{aligned}

The loss above is minimized over a training set. Within this training set, we perform 5-fold cross validation and pick the ρ\rho that minimizes the loss. Furthermore, to promote stability, training features are rescaled to have zero mean and unit standard deviation before fitting. This rescaling defines the linear transformation φ\varphi as the inverse of the rescaling transformation Ns↦N~sN_s \mapsto\widetilde{N}_s, so that the tensor product ε:Ns=(φε):N~s\varepsilon:N_s=(\varphi\varepsilon):\widetilde{N}_s is invariant under the transformation. Here, we choose L1L^1 regularization to promote sparsity in the ε\varepsilon coefficients. The best-fit ε\varepsilon is indeed very sparse, i.e. only about 3% of coefficients are nonzero.

We find that the fit is excellent at predicting the raw DFT energies within both the training and test set (Figure 9).

Figure 9. Parity plot for the fitted TCE model with respect to the relaxed DFT energies.

Then, using the fitted model, we run canonical Monte Carlo on the M(X,X′)2M(X, X')_2 monolayers for 100, 000 steps at varying temperatures with system sizes of 15×1515 \times15, and characterize the chemical ordering via the Warren-Cowley short range order parameters χαβ\chi_{\alpha\beta} [74]:

χαβ=1−pαβ(2−δαβ)xαxβ(114)\chi_{\alpha\beta}=1-\frac{p_{\alpha\beta}}{(2-\delta_{\alpha\beta})x_\alpha x_\beta} \tag*{(114)}

where α\alpha and β\beta denote alloying types, pαβp_{\alpha\beta} is the probability that a bond within the shell is of type α\alpha-β\beta, xαx_\alpha is the concentration of type α\alpha, and δαβ\delta_{\alpha\beta} is the Kronecker delta. Here, χαβ=0\chi_{\alpha\beta}=0 denotes full chemical disorder within the shell, χαβ<0\chi_{\alpha\beta}<0 denotes α\alpha-$\beta clustering, and χαβ>0\chi_{\alpha\beta} > 0 denotes α\alpha-β\beta repulsion. We compute the average SRO parameter only within the chalcogen sublattice, i.e. MM-XX interactions are not counted.

Figure 10. Warren-Cowley short range order parameters equilibrated via Monte Carlo as a function of temperature TT.

As expected, we find that the SRO parameters tend to zero at high temperatures. We find that, for the W(XX, X′X')2_2 and Mo(XX, X′X')2_2 systems, that XX-XX clustering are favorable at low temperatures. Visualizations for each TMD at the two extreme temperatures are included in Figure 6, where the clustering behavior is more obvious. Interestingly, this behavior is not preserved for either Ta(XX, X′X')2_2 system. Namely, Ta(S, Te)2_2 favors XX-X′X' clustering at low temperatures, and Ta(Se, Te)2_2 remains essentially random for the entire tested temperature range.

Raw VACF plots

Below we show the raw VACF data C(t)C(t) defined in Eq. (28).

Figure 11. VACF C(t)C(t) for all M(XX, X′X')2_2 monolayers as a function of temperature for the MACE-selected- (left) and TCE-selected- (right) subset finetuned MLIPs.

The important feature of the above plot is that, in all systems, the correlations vanish over the MD simulation time, meaning that each system is reasonably equilibrated with respect to atomic vibrations.

References

  1. [1]Volker L Deringer, Miguel A Caro, and Gábor Csányi. Machine learning interatomic potentials as emerging tools for materials science. Advanced Materials, 31(46):1902765, 2019.
  2. [2]Tim Mueller, Alberto Hernandez, and Chuhong Wang. Machine learning for interatomic potential models. The Journal of chemical physics, 152(5), 2020.DOI
  3. [3]Yuri Mishin. Machine-learning interatomic potentials for materials science. Acta Materialia, 214:116980, 2021.
  4. [4]Ralf Drautz. Atomic cluster expansion for accurate and transferable interatomic potentials. Physical Review B, 99(1):014104, 2019.
  5. [5]Genevieve Dusson, Markus Bachmayr, Gábor Csányi, Ralf Drautz, Simon Etter, Cas van Der Oord, and Christoph Ortner. Atomic cluster expansion: Completeness, efficiency and stability. Journal of Computational Physics, 454:110946, 2022.
  6. [6]Ilyes Batatia, David P Kovacs, Gregor Simm, Christoph Ortner, and Gábor Csányi. Mace: Higher order equivariant message passing neural networks for fast and accurate force fields. Advances in neural information processing systems, 35:11423–11436, 2022.arxiv.org/abs/2206.07697
  7. [7]Ilyes Batatia, Simon Batzner, Dávid Péter Kovács, Albert Musaelian, Gregor NC Simm, Ralf Drautz, Christoph Ortner, Boris Kozinsky, and Gábor Csányi. The design space of e (3)-equivariant atom-centred interatomic potentials. Nature Machine Intelligence, 7(1):56–67, 2025.DOI
  8. [8]Anas Siddiqui and Nicholas DM Hine. Machine-learned interatomic potentials for transition metal dichalcogenide Mo₁−ₓWₓS₂−₂ᵧSe₂ᵧ alloys. npj Computational Materials, 10(1):169, 2024.DOI
  9. [9]Ilyes Batatia, Philipp Benner, Yuan Chiang, Alin M Elena, Dávid P Kovács, Janosh Riebesell, Xavier R Advincula, Mark Asta, Matthew Avaylon, William J Baldwin, et al. A foundation model for atomistic materials chemistry. The Journal of chemical physics, 163(18), 2025.
  10. [10]Harveen Kaur, Flaviano Della Pia, Ilyes Batatia, Xavier R Advincula, Benjamin X Shi, Jinggang Lan, Gábor Csányi, Angelos Michaelides, and Venkat Kapil. Data-efficient fine-tuning of foundational models for first-principles quality sublimation enthalpies. Faraday Discussions, 256:120–138, 2025.
  11. [11]Mariia Karabin and Danny Perez. An entropy-maximization approach to automated training set generation for interatomic potentials. The Journal of Chemical Physics, 153(9), 2020.
  12. [12]Ji Qi, Tsz Wai Ko, Brandon C Wood, Tuan Anh Pham, and Shyue Ping Ong. Robust training of machine learning interatomic potentials with dimensionality reduction and stratified sampling. npj Computational Materials, 10(1):43, 2024.
  13. [13]Daniel Schwalbe-Koda, Sebastien Hamel, Babak Sadigh, Fei Zhou, and Vincenzo Lordi. Model-free estimation of completeness, uncertainties, and outliers in atomistic machine learning using information theory. Nature Communications, 16(1):4014, 2025.
  14. [14]Marvin Poul, Liam Huber, and Jörg Neugebauer. Automated generation of structure datasets for machine learning potentials and alloys. npj Computational Materials, 11(1):174, 2025.
  15. [15]Gaurav Arora, Alex Tai, Rodrigo Freitas, and David Cereceda. Bond-informed search for ordered configurations in multi-principal element alloys, 2026.arxiv.org/abs/2610.21718
  16. [16]Songqin Xia, Michael C Gao, Tengfei Yang, Peter K Liaw, and Yong Zhang. Phase stability and microstructures of high entropy alloys ion irradiated to high doses. Journal of Nuclear Materials, 480:100–108, 2016.DOI
  17. [17]Fredric Granberg, K Nordlund, Mohammad W Ullah, Ke Jin, Chenyang Lu, Hongbin Bei, LM Wang, F Djurabekova, WJ Weber, and Y Zhang. Mechanism of radiation damage reduction in equiatomic multicomponent single phase alloys. Physical review letters, 116(13):135504, 2016.DOI
  18. [18]Chenyang Lu, Liangliang Niu, Nanjun Chen, Ke Jin, Taini Yang, Pengyuan Xiu, Yanwen Zhang, Fei Gao, Hongbin Bei, Shi Shi, et al. Enhancing radiation tolerance by controlling defect mobility and migration pathways in multicomponent single-phase alloys. Nature communications, 7(1):13564, 2016.DOI
  19. [19]John Cavin, Alireza Ahmadiparidari, Leily Majidi, Arashdeep Singh Thind, Saurabh N Misal, Aditya Prajapati, Zahra Hemmat, Sina Rastegar, Andrew Beukelman, Meenesh R Singh, et al. 2d high-entropy transition metal dichalcogenides for carbon dioxide electrocatalysis. Advanced Materials, 33(31):2100347, 2021.
  20. [20]Wenjiang Gao, Meiyang Yu, Yuli Yan, Cuihuan Geng, and Huabing Yin. Point defects in two-dimensional high-entropy transition metal dichalcogenides: The effect of local chemical environments. Physical Review B, 111(15):155444, 2025.DOI
  21. [21]Kaiqiang Hou, Zongyu Huang, Shengqian Liu, Gengcheng Liao, Hui Qiao, Hongxing Li, and Xiang Qi. A hydrothermally synthesized mos2 (1- x) se2 x alloy with deep-shallow level conversion for enhanced performance of photodetectors. Nanoscale Advances, 2(5):2185–2191, 2020.DOI
  22. [22]Rahul Sharma, Juhi Pandey, Krishna Rani Sahoo, Kewal Singh Rana, Ravi K Biroju, Wolfgang Theis, Ajay Soni, and Tharangattu N Narayanan. Spectroscopic correlation of chalcogen defects in atomically thin mos2 (1- x) se2 x alloys. Journal of Physics: Materials, 3(4):045001, 2020.DOI
  23. [23]Chumki Nayak, Suvadip Masanta, Sukanya Ghosh, Shubhadip Moulick, Atindra Nath Pal, Indrani Bose, and Achintya Singha. Valley polarization and photocurrent generation in transition metal dichalcogenide alloy mos 2 x se 2 (1-x). Physical Review B, 109(11):115304, 2024.arxiv.org/abs/2310.13924
  24. [24]Dipak Maity, Bhuvan Upadhyay, Janmey Jay Panda, Krishna Rani Sahoo, Sreekant A, G Rajalakshmi, Suman Kalyan Pal, and Tharangattu N Narayanan. Tuning the valley depolarization dynamics in selenium and vanadium alloyed monolayer mo s 2. Physical Review Materials, 8(6):064004, 2024.DOI
  25. [25]Gang Wang, Cedric Robert, Aslihan Suslu, Bin Chen, Sijie Yang, Sarah Alamdari, Iann C Gerber, Thierry Amand, Xavier Marie, Sefaatin Tongay, et al. Spin-orbit engineering in transition metal dichalcogenide alloy monolayers. Nature communications, 6(1):10110, 2015.
  26. [26]Sean M Oliver, Ryan Beams, Sergiy Krylyuk, Irina Kalish, Arunima K Singh, Alina Bruma, Francesca Tavazza, Jaydeep Joshi, Iris R Stone, Stephan J Stranick, et al. The structural phases and vibrational properties of mol- xwxte2 alloys. 2D Materials, 4(4):045008, 2017.
  27. [27]Jacob Jeffries, Bochuan Sun, and Enrique Martinez. A generalized and adaptable tensor-contraction-based cluster expansion formalism for multicomponent solids. Computational Materials Science, 262:114338, 2026.arxiv.org/abs/2509.04686
  28. [28]Md Rajib Khan Musa, Yichen Qian, Jie Peng, and David Cereceda. Accelerating the discovery of low-energy structure configurations: A computational approach that integrates first-principles calculations, monte carlo sampling, and machine learning. Scripta Materialia, 259:116535, 2025.DOI
  29. [29]Alexander Stukowski. Visualization and analysis of atomistic simulation data with ovito–the open visualization tool. Modelling and simulation in materials science and engineering, 18(1):015012, 2010.DOI
  30. [30]Andreas Krause, Ajit Singh, and Carlos Guestrin. Near-optimal sensor placements in gaussian processes: Theory, efficient algorithms and empirical studies. Journal of Machine Learning Research, 9(2), 2008.
  31. [31]Dravyansh Sharma, Ashish Kapoor, and Amit Deshpande. On greedy maximization of entropy. In International Conference on Machine Learning, pages 1330–1338. PMLR, 2015.
  32. [32]Nicholas J Higham. Accuracy and stability of numerical algorithms. SIAM, 2002.
  33. [33]Ask Hjorth Larsen, Jens Jørgen Mortensen, Jakob Blomqvist, Ivano E Castelli, Rune Christensen, Marcin Dulak, Jesper Friis, Michael N Groves, Bjørk Hammer, Cory Hargus, et al. The atomic simulation environment—a python library for working with atoms. Journal of Physics: Condensed Matter, 29(27):273002, 2017.
  34. [34]Georg Kresse and Jürgen Hafner. Ab initio molecular dynamics for liquid metals. Physical review B, 47(1):558, 1993.
  35. [35]Georg Kresse and Jürgen Furthmüller. Efficiency of ab-initio total energy calculations for metals and semiconductors using a plane-wave basis set. Computational materials science, 6(1):15–50, 1996.DOI
  36. [36]Georg Kresse and J Furthmüller. Software vasp, vienna (1999). Phys. Rev. B, 54(11):169, 1996.
  37. [37]Georg Kresse and Daniel Joubert. From ultrasoft pseudopotentials to the projector augmented-wave method. Physical review b, 59(3):1758, 1999.DOI
  38. [38]John P Perdew, Kieron Burke, and Matthias Ernzerhof. Generalized gradient approximation made simple. Physical review letters, 77(18):3865, 1996.
  39. [39]Asher Antao, James Daly Burton, Douglas Dawson, Jill Gemmill, Zachary Gerstener, Ben Godfrey, Scott Groel, Zach Jordan, Becky Ligon, Dane Smith, et al. Modernizing clemson university’s palmetto cluster: Lessons learned from 17 years of hpc administration. In Practice and Experience in Advanced Research Computing 2024: Human Powered Computing, pages 1–9. 2024.DOI
  40. [40]Hendrik J Monkhorst and James D Pack. Special points for brillouin-zone integrations. Physical review B, 13(12):5188, 1976.
  41. [41]Michael P Allen and Dominic J Tildesley. Computer simulation of liquids. Oxford university press, 2017.
  42. [42]Michele Parrinello and Aneesur Rahman. Crystal structure and pair potentials: A molecular-dynamics study. Physical review letters, 45(14):1196, 1980.
  43. [43]Michele Parrinello and Aneesur Rahman. Polymorphic transitions in single crystals: A new molecular dynamics method. Journal of Applied physics, 52(12):7182–7190, 1981.
  44. [44]Jacob Jeffries. he-tmd-dataset. https://github.com/jwjeffr/he-tmd-dataset, 2026. Accessed: 2026-08-20.
  45. [45]Tamás Lajos Tompa, Eszter Varga-Umbrich, Ilyes Batatia, Alin M Elena, Noam Bernstein, and Gábor Csányi. Fine-tuning mlip foundation models: strategies for accuracy and transferability. arXiv preprint arXiv:2606.12704, 2026.arxiv.org/abs/2606.12704
  46. [46]Edward J Hu, Yelong Shen, Phillip Wallis, Zeyuan Allen-Zhu, Yuanzhi Li, Shean Wang, Lu Wang, and Weizhu Chen. Lora: Low-rank adaptation of large language models. arXiv preprint arXiv:2106.09685, 2021.arxiv.org/abs/2106.09685
  47. [47]Christopher Linderalv, J Magnus Rahm, and Paul Erhart. High-throughput characterization of transition metal dichalcogenide alloys: thermodynamic stability and electronic band alignment. Chemistry of Materials, 34(21):9364–9372, 2022.
  48. [48]Jacob Jeffries, Fadi Abdeljawad, Suveen Mathaudhu, Emmanuelle Marquis, and Enrique Martinez. Prediction of defect properties in concentrated solid solutions using a langmuir-like model. Physical Review Materials, 9(3):033803, 2025.
  49. [49]Alexander Shapeev. Accurate representation of formation energies of crystalline alloys with many components. Computational Materials Science, 139:26–30, 2017.
  50. [50]Tatiana Kostiuchenko, Fritz Körmann, Jörg Neugebauer, and Alexander Shapeev. Impact of lattice relaxations on phase transitions in a high-entropy alloy studied by machine-learning potentials. npj Computational Materials, 5(1):55, 2019.
  51. [51]Guillermo Vazquez, Daniel Sauceda, and Raymundo Arróyave. Deciphering chemical ordering in high entropy materials: A machine learning-accelerated high-throughput cluster expansion approach. Acta Materialia, 276:120137, 2024.
  52. [52]Adam Paszke, Sam Gross, Francisco Massa, Adam Lerer, James Bradbury, Gregory Chanan, Trevor Killeen, Zeming Lin, Natalia Gimelshein, Luca Antiga, et al. Pytorch: An imperative style, high-performance deep learning library. In Advances in Neural Information Processing Systems, volume 32, 2019.
  53. [53]Orion Cohen, Janosh Riebesell, Rhys Goodall, Adeesh Kolluru, Stefano Falletta, Joseph Krause, Jorge Colindres, Gerbrand Ceder, and Abhijeet S Gangan. Torchsim: An efficient atomistic simulation engine in pytorch. AI for Science, 1(2):025003, 2025.
  54. [54]Erik Bitzek, Pekka Koskinen, Franz Gähler, Michael Moseler, and Peter Gumbsch. Structural relaxation made simple. Physical review letters, 97(17):172001, 2006.
  55. [55]Benedict Leimkuhler and Charles Matthews. Efficient molecular dynamics using geodesic integration and solvent–solute splitting. [56] Daan Frenkel, Berend Smit, and Mark A Ratner. Understanding molecular simulation: from algorithms to applications, 1997.
  56. [57]Frederick Heinz, Sascha Jähnigen, Joana-Lysiane Schäfer, and Bettina G Keller. How thermostats influence dynamics across time scales: a systematic study from fast motions to slow transitions. Molecular Simulation, pages 1–16, 2026.
  57. [58]Xing He, Mayanak K Gupta, Douglas L Abernathy, Garrett E Granroth, Feng Ye, Barry L Winn, Lynn Boatner, and Olivier Delaire. Resolving the dynamic correlated disorder in kta1−x nbx o3. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 122(7):e2419159122, 2025.
  58. [59]Haoyu Dong, Zhiqiang Li, Baole Sun, Yanguang Zhou, Linhua Liu, and Jia-Yue Yang. Thermal transport in disordered wurtzite sc aln alloys using machine learning interatomic potentials. Materials Today Communications, 39:109213, 2024.
  59. [60]Kevin Conley, Colton Gerber, Andrew Novick, Terra Berriodi, Eric S Toborer, and Antti J Karttunen. Heat transport properties of pbt1−xsex alloys using equivariant graph neural network interatomic potential. Materials Horizons, 12(19):8084–8094, 2025.DOI
  60. [61]Eric Stach, Brian DeCost, A Gilad Kusne, Jason Hattrick-Simpers, Keith A Brown, Kristofer G Reyes, Joshua Schrier, Simon Billinge, Tonio Buonassisi, Ian Foster, et al. Autonomous experimentation systems for materials development: A community perspective. Matter, 4(9):2702–2726, 2021.DOI
  61. [62]Huiju Lee and Yi Xia. Machine learning a universal harmonic interatomic potential for predicting phonons in crystalline solids. Applied Physics Letters, 124(10), 2024.arxiv.org/abs/2402.11383
  62. [63]Huiju Lee, Vinay I Hegde, Chris Wolverton, and Yi Xia. Accelerating high-throughput phonon calculations via machine learning universal potentials. Materials Today Physics, 53:101688, 2025.
  63. [64]Kasper Tolborg and Aron Walsh. Low-cost vibrational free energies in solid solutions with ma-chine learning force fields. The Journal of Phys-ical Chemistry Letters, 14(51):11618, 2023.
  64. [65]Jacob Jeffries, Brianna Sebastian-Olazabal, and Enrique Martinez. First-principles transition-state tensorial cluster expansion of vacancy diffusion in ta-w beyond the kinetically-resolved activation approximation. arXiv preprint arXiv:2605.23612, 2026.DOI
  65. [66]Chenyang Li, Thomas Nilson, Liang Cao, and Tim Mueller. Predicting activation energies for vacancy-mediated diffusion in alloys using a transition-state cluster expansion. Physical Review Materials, 5(1):013803, 2021.
  66. [67]Simon Batzner, Albert Musaelian, Lixin Sun, Mario Geiger, Jonathan P Mailoa, Mordechai Kornbluth, Nicola Molinari, Tess E Smidt, and Boris Kozinsky. E (3)-equivariant graph neural networks for data-efficient and accurate interatomic potentials. Nature communications, 13(1):2453, 2022.
  67. [68]Jacob BJ Chapman and Pui-Wai Ma. A machine-learned spin-lattice potential for dynamic simulations of defective magnetic iron. Scientific Reports, 12(1):22451, 2022.
  68. [69]Jacob Jeffries. finetuning. https://github.com/jwjeffr/finetuning, 2026. Accessed: 2026-09-01.
  69. [70]Jacob Jeffries. ordered-tmd-tce. https://github.com/jwjeffr/ordered-tmd-tce, 2026. Accessed: 2026-09-01.
  70. [71]Pierre Comon, Gene Golub, Lek-Heng Lim, and Bernard Mourrain. Symmetric tensors and symmetric tensor rank. SIAM Journal on Matrix Analysis and Applications, 30(3):1254–1279, 2008.arxiv.org/abs/0802.1681
  71. [72]F. Pedregosa, G. Varoquaux, A. Gramfort, V. Michel, B. Thirion, O. Grisel, M. Blondel, P. Prett enhofer, R. Weiss, V. Dubourg, J. Van-derplas, A. Passos, D. Cournapeau, M. Brucher, M. Perrot, and E. Duchesnay. Scikit-learn: Machine learning in Python. Journal of Machine Learning Research, 12:2825–2830, 2011.
  72. [73]Lars Buitinck, Gilles Louppe, Mathieu Blondel, Fabian Pedregosa, Andreas Mueller, Olivier Grisel, Vlad Niculae, Peter Prettenhofer, Alexandre Gramfort, Jaques Grobler, Robert Layton, Jake VanderPlas, Arnaud Joly, Brian Holt, and Gaël Varoquaux. API design for ma- chine learning software: experiences from the scikit-learn project. In ECML PKDD Workshop: Languages for Data Mining and Machine Learn- ing, pages 108–122, 2013.
  73. [74]John M Cowley. An approximate theory of order in alloys. Physical Review, 77(5):669, 1950.

Paper details

vlnc:W_xu9sdtkj
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 5

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents