betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Optimal damping of vibrating systems: dependence on initial conditions

Abstract

Common criteria used for measuring performance of vibrating systems have one thing in common: they do not depend on initial conditions of the system. In some cases it is assumed that the system has zero initial conditions, or some kind of averaging is used to get rid of initial conditions. The aim of this paper is to initiate rigorous study of the dependence of vibrating systems on initial conditions in the setting of optimal damping problems. We show that, based on the type of initial conditions, especially on the ratio of potential and kinetic energy of the initial conditions, the vibrating system will have quite different behavior and correspondingly the optimal damping coefficients will be quite different. More precisely, for single degree of freedom systems and the initial conditions with mostly potential energy, the optimal damping coefficient will be in the under-damped regime, while in the case of the predominant kinetic energy the optimal damping coefficient will be in the over-damped regime. In fact, in the case of pure kinetic initial energy, the optimal damping coefficient is +∞+\infty! Qualitatively, we found the same behavior in multi degree of freedom systems with mass proportional damping. We also introduce a new method for determining the optimal damping of vibrating systems, which takes into account the peculiarities of initial conditions and the fact that, although in theory these systems asymptotically approach equilibrium and never reach it exactly, in nature and in experiments they effectively reach equilibrium in some finite time.

Introduction

If we have an multi-degree of freedom (MDOF) linear vibrating system, i.e. a system of coupled damped oscillators, how to determine damping coefficients that ensure optimal evanescence of free vibrations? In the literature one finds several different criteria, typically based on frequency domain analysis of the system, although there are also approaches based on time domain analysis [1]. The tools used for designing the criteria include modal analysis [2], transfer functions [3], H2H_2 and H∞H_\infty norms coming from systems theory [4, 5] and spectral techniques [6]. A general overview of the optimization tools for structures analysis can be found in e.g. [7]. Another optimization criterion used is to take as optimal the damping coefficients that minimize the (zero to infinity) time integral of the energy of the system, averaged over all possible initial conditions corresponding to the same initial energy [8]. This criterion was investigated widely, mostly by mathematicians in the last two decades, more details can be found, e.g., in references [8, 9, 10, 11, 12].

However, what is common to all these criteria is that they implicitly or explicitly ignore the dependence of the dynamics of the system on the initial conditions. Sometimes this is suitable, e.g. for systems with continuous excitation, but in some cases it make sense to study the free vibrations of the system with non-zero initial conditions. A prominent example where this is the case is the vibration control of buildings subjected to earthquake excitation [13, 14]. Indeed, depending on the initial conditions, MDOF systems can exhibit oscillatory or non-oscillatory response [15], so it is clear that initial conditions can play an important role in the overall dynamics of the system.

Implicitly, dependence of the behavior of system on initial conditions has been investigated in the context of time-optimal vibrations reduction [16] and transient response [17] in terms of computationally efficient methods for the calculation of the system response. Our aim with this paper is to start more systematic investigation of the role of initial conditions in the study of linear vibrating systems. Specifically, the dependence of the energy integral on the initial conditions has not been investigated, as far as we are aware, and therefore it is not clear how much information about the behavior of vibrating systems is lost by taking the average over all initial conditions or by assuming zero initial conditions and it is not clear how well the optimal damping obtained in this way works for a specific choice of initial conditions, e.g. for an experiment with initial conditions such that the initial energy consists only of potential energy, etc. We have chosen to study the particular criterion of minimizing time integral of the energy as in this case it is straightforward to modify it to take into account the initial conditions: instead of averaging over all possible initial conditions, we study the dependence of the time integral of the energy of the system on initial conditions. Specifically, for criteria based on frequency domain approach, which are designed for forced vibrations, it is not clear how to take into account the non-zero initial conditions in a systematic way.

We will explore this dependence by considering free vibrations of single degree of freedom (SDOF), two-degree of freedom (2-DOF) and MDOF vibrating systems with mass proportional damping (MPD). In particular, for a SDOF, averaging over all initial conditions gives the critical damping as optimal [8, 10], and we show, by considering the minimization of the energy integral without averaging over initial conditions, that damping coefficients approximately 30% less than critical to infinite are obtained as optimal, depending on the initial conditions. We systematize all our results with respect to the relationship between initial potential and initial kinetic energy, e.g., for initial conditions with initial potential energy grater than initial kinetic energy the optimal damping coefficient is in the under-damped regime, while for initial conditions with initial kinetic energy grater than initial potential energy we find the optimal damping deep in the over-damped regime. We also consider the minimization of the energy integral averaged over a subset of initial conditions and obtain a significant dependence of the optimal damping coefficient on the selected subset. Qualitatively, we find the same behavior in 2-DOF and MDOF systems as well.

Furthermore, we show that the minimization of the energy integral for certain types of initial conditions does not give a satisfactory optimal damping coefficient. Specifically, for SDOF systems, the obtained optimal damping coefficient does not distinguish between two initial states with the same magnitude of initial displacement and initial velocity, but which differ in the relative sign of initial displacement and initial velocity. These initial conditions differ significantly in the rate of energy dissipation as a function of the damping coefficient, i.e. it is not realistic for one damping coefficient to be optimal for both of these initial conditions. The same is true for each individual mode of MDOF systems with respect to the signs of initial displacements and velocities, expressed via modal coordinates. Another disadvantage of this criterion is that, for initial conditions with purely kinetic initial energy, it gives an infinite optimal damping coefficient, which is not practical for experiments. Also, the energy integral is calculated over the entire time, due to the fact that these systems asymptotically approach equilibrium and never reach it exactly, but in nature and experiments they effectively reach equilibrium in some finite time.

We introduce a new method for determining the optimal damping of MDOF systems, which practically solves the aforementioned problems and gives optimal damping coefficients that take into account the peculiarities of each initial condition and the fact that these systems effectively reach equilibrium in some finite time. We take that the system has effectively reached equilibrium when its energy drops to some small fraction of the initial energy, e.g., to the energy resolution of the measuring device with which we observe the system. Our method is based on the determination of the damping coefficient for which the energy of the system drops to that desired energy level the fastest.

In this paper we focus on mass proportional damping so that we could analytically perform a modal analysis and present ideas in the simplest possible way, but, as we briefly comment at the end of the paper, everything we have done can be done in a similar fashion analytically for the case of Rayleigh damping [18] as well as for tuned mass damper [19, 20]. Also, it is possible to carry out this kind of analysis numerically for systems with damping that does not allow analytical treatment. This will be the subject of our further research.

The rest of the paper is organized as follows: Section 2 is devoted to SDOF systems, in particular minimization of the energy integral and optimal damping is studied for the chosen set of initial conditions. In Section 3 we analyze 2-DOF systems with MPD. MDOF systems with MPD are the subject of Section 4. In Section 5 we propose a new optimization criterion and analyze its properties. Section 6 summarizes important findings of the paper.

SDOF systems

Free vibrations of a SDOF linear vibrating system can be described by the equation

x¨(t)+2γx˙(t)+ω02x(t)=0,x(0)=x0,x˙(0)=v0,(1)\ddot{x}(t) + 2\gamma\dot{x}(t) + \omega_0^2x(t) = 0,\quad x(0) = x_0,\quad\dot{x}(0) = v_0, \tag*{(1)}

where x(t)x(t) denotes the displacement from the equilibrium position (set to x=0x = 0) as a function of time, the dots denote time derivatives, γ>0\gamma> 0 is the damping coefficient, ω0\omega_0 stands for the undamped oscillator angular frequency (sometimes called the natural frequency of the oscillator) and (x0,v0)(x_0, v_0) encode the initial conditions [21, 22]. The physical units of the displacement x(t)x(t) depend on the system being considered. For example, for a mass on a spring (or a pendulum) in viscous fluid, when it is usually called elongation, it is measured in [m][m], while for an RLC circuit it could either be voltage, or current, or charge. In contrast, the units of γ\gamma and ω0\omega_0 are [s−1][\mathrm{s}^{-1}] for all systems described with the SDOF model. The form of the solution to the equation (1) depends on the relationship between γ\gamma and ω0\omega_0, producing three possible regimes [21, 22]: under-damped (γ<ω0\gamma< \omega_0), critically damped (γ=ω0\gamma= \omega_0) and over-damped (γ>ω0\gamma> \omega_0) regime.

Here we would like to point out that, although it is natural to classify the solution of SDOF into three regimes depending on the value of γ\gamma, we can actually take one form of the solution as a unique solution valid for all values of γ>0\gamma> 0, γ≠ω0\gamma\ne\omega_0,

x(t)=e−γt(x0cos⁡(ωt)+v0+γx0ωsin⁡(ωt)),(2)x(t) = e^{-\gamma t}\left(x_0\cos(\omega t) + \frac{v_0 + \gamma x_0}{\omega}\sin(\omega t)\right), \tag*{(2)}

where ω=ω02−γ2\omega= \sqrt{\omega_0^2 - \gamma^2} is the (complex valued) damped angular frequency. In order to describe the critically damped regime, one can take the limit γ→ω0\gamma\to\omega_0 of the solution (2) to obtain the general solution of the critically damped regime

xc(t)=e−ω0t(x0+(v0+ω0x0)t).(3)x_c(t) = e^{-\omega_0t}\left(x_0 + (v_0 + \omega_0x_0)t\right). \tag*{(3)}

Therefore, in order to calculate the energy and the time integral of the energy, we do not need to perform separate calculations for all three regimes, but a single calculation using the displacement given by (2) and the velocity given by

x˙(t)=e−γt(v0cos⁡(ωt)−γv0+ω02x0ωsin⁡(ωt)).(4)\dot{x}(t) = e^{-\gamma t}\left(v_0\cos(\omega t) - \frac{\gamma v_0 + \omega_0^2x_0}{\omega}\sin(\omega t)\right). \tag*{(4)}

For simplicity, in this section we will refer to the quantity

E(t)=x˙(t)2+ω02x(t)2(5)E(t) = \dot{x}(t)^2 + \omega_0^2x(t)^2 \tag*{(5)}

as the energy of the system, and to the quantities EK(t)=x˙(t)2E_K(t) = \dot{x}(t)^2 and EP(t)=ω02x(t)2E_P(t) = \omega_0^2x(t)^2 as the kinetic energy and potential energy of the system respectively. The connection of the quantity (5) to the usual expressions for the energy is straightforward, e.g., for a mass mm on a spring in viscous fluid

E(t)=m2E(t),(6)\mathcal{E}(t) = \frac{m}{2}E(t), \tag*{(6)}

and similarly for other systems described with the SDOF model. Using (2) and (4) in (5), we obtain

E(t)=e−2γt(E0cos⁡2(ωt)+γ(ω02x02−v02)sin⁡(2ωt)ω+(E0(ω02+γ2)+4ω02γx0v0)sin⁡2(ωt)ω2)(7)E(t) = e^{-2\gamma t}\left(E_0\cos^2(\omega t) + \gamma\left(\omega_0^2x_0^2 - v_0^2\right)\frac{\sin(2\omega t)}{\omega} + \left(E_0(\omega_0^2 + \gamma^2) + 4\omega_0^2\gamma x_0v_0\right)\frac{\sin^2(\omega t)}{\omega^2}\right) \tag*{(7)}

for the energy of the system, where E0=v02+ω02x02E_0 = v_0^2 + \omega_0^2 x_0^2 is the initial energy given to the system at t=0t = 0. Accordingly, E0K=v02E_{0K} = v_0^2 is the initial kinetic energy and E0P=ω02x02E_{0P} = \omega_0^2 x_0^2 is the initial potential energy. Expression (7) is valid for both under-damped and over-damped regimes, and to obtain the energy of the critically damped regime we take the γ→ω0\gamma\to\omega_0 limit of the energy (7), and obtain

Ec(t)=e−2ω0t(E0+2ω0(ω02x02−v02)t+2ω02(E0+2ω0x0v0)t2).(8)E_c(t) = e^{-2\omega_0 t}\left(E_0 + 2\omega_0\left(\omega_0^2 x_0^2 - v_0^2\right)t + 2\omega_0^2\left(E_0 + 2\omega_0 x_0 v_0\right)t^2\right). \tag*{(8)}

Minimization of the energy integral and optimal damping in dependence of initial conditions

We consider the SDOF system with initially energy E0E_0. All possible initial conditions that give this energy can be expressed in polar coordinates with constant radius r=E0r = \sqrt{E_0} and angle θ=arctan⁡(v0ω0x0)\theta= \arctan\left(\frac{v_0}{\omega_0 x_0}\right), i.e. we have

ω0x0=rcos⁡θ\omega_0 x_0 = r\cos\theta
v0=rsin⁡θ.(9)v_0 = r\sin\theta. \tag*{(9)}

In Figure 1 we sketch the circle given by (9), i.e. given by all possible initial conditions with the same energy E0E_0. For clarity of the exposition, here we comment on a few characteristic points of the circle presented in Figure 1:

Figure 1. Sketch of all possible initial conditions with the same initial energy E0E_0 in the (ω0x0,v0)(\omega_0 x_0,v_0) coordinate system. Square of the coordinates corresponds to initial potential energy E0P=ω02x02E_{0P} = \omega_0^2 x_0^2 and initial kinetic energy E0K=v02E_{0K} = v_0^2 respectively. This representation gives us a useful visualization, e.g.: all initial conditions with E0P>E0KE_{0P} > E_{0K} are represented by two arcs, i.e. points with θ∈(−π/4,π/4)∪(3π/4,5π/4)\theta\in(-\pi/4,\pi/4) \cup(3\pi/4,5\pi/4) (blue dotted arcs); initial conditions with E0K=E0E_{0K} = E_0 and E0P=0E_{0P} = 0 are represented by two points on a circle with θ={π/2,3π/2}\theta= \{\pi/2,3\pi/2\} (two red filled circles); etc.

References

  1. [1]R. A. Rojas, E. Wehrle, R. Vidoni, Optimal design for the passive control of vibration based on limit cycles, Shock and Vibration 2019 (2019).DOI
  2. [2]Z.-F. Fu, J. He, Modal analysis, Elsevier, 2001.
  3. [3]I. Takewaki, Optimal damper placement for minimum transfer functions, Earthquake Engineering & Structural Dynamics 26 (11) (1997) 1113–1124.doi.org/10.1002/(sici)1096-9845(199711)26:11<1113::aid-eqe696>3.0.co;2-x
  4. [4]Y. Cheung, W. Wong, H∞ and H2 optimizations of a dynamic vibration absorber for suppressing vibrations in plates, Journal of Sound and Vibration 320 (1) (2009) 29–42.
  5. [5]N. Alujević, G. Zhao, B. Depraetere, P. Sas, B. Pluymers, W. Desmet, H2 optimal vibration control using inertial actuators and a comparison with tuned mass dampers, Journal of Sound and Vibration 333 (18) (2014) 4073–4083.DOI
  6. [6]P. Lancaster, U. Prells, Inverse problems for damped vibrating systems, Journal of Sound and Vibration 283 (3) (2005) 891–914.DOI
  7. [7]R. T. Haftka, Z. Gürdal, Elements of structural optimization, Vol. 11, Springer Science & Business Media, 2012.
  8. [8]K. Veselić, On linear vibrational systems with one dimensional damping II, Integral Equations and Operator Theory 13 (1990) 883–897.
  9. [9]S. J. Cox, I. Nakić, A. Rittmann, K. Veselić, Lyapunov optimization of a damped system, Systems & control letters 53 (3-4) (2004) 187–194.DOI
  10. [10]I. Nakić, Optimal damping of vibrational systems, PhD thesis, Fernuniversität Hagen (2003).
  11. [11]N. Truhar, K. Veselić, An efficient method for estimating the optimal dampers’ viscosity for linear vibrating systems using Lyapunov equation, SIAM journal on matrix analysis and applications 31 (1) (2009) 18–39.DOI
  12. [12]K. Veselić, Damped oscillations of linear systems: a mathematical introduction, Vol. 2023, Springer Science & Business Media, 2011.DOI
  13. [13]C. Ventura, R. Blázquez, Influence of system initial conditions on elastic and inelastic response spectra, in: Proceedings of the Tenth World Conference on Earthquake Engineering, Madrid, Spain, Vol. 1, 1992, pp. 195–200.
  14. [14]A.-P. Wang, Y.-H. Lin, Vibration control of a tall building subjected to earthquake excitation, Journal of Sound and Vibration 299 (4-5) (2007) 757–773.DOI
  15. [15]M. Morzfeld, D. T. Kawano, F. Ma, Characterization of damped linear dynamical systems in free motion, Numerical Algebra, Control and Optimization 3 (1) (2013) 49–62.DOI
  16. [16]A. Dhanda, J. Vaughan, W. S. Jinghose, Vibration reduction using near time-optimal commands for systems with nonzero initial conditions, Journal of Dynamic Systems, Measurement, and Control 138 (4) (2016) 041006.DOI
  17. [17]P. S. Meirelles, J. Arruda, Transient response with arbitrary initial conditions using the dft, Journal of sound and vibration 287 (3) (2005) 525–543.DOI
  18. [18]J. T. Katsikadelis, Dynamic analysis of structures, Academic press, 2020.
  19. [19]M. Gutierrez Soto, H. Adeli, Tuned mass dampers, Archives of Computational Methods in Engineering 20 (2013) 419–431.DOI
  20. [20]L. Zuo, S. Nayfeh, Minimax optimization of multi-degree-of-freedom tuned-mass dampers, Journal of Sound and Vibration 272 (3) (2004) 893–908.DOI
  21. [21]M. D. Grigoriu, Linear Dynamical Systems, Springer, 2021.DOI
  22. [22]F. S. Crawford, Waves : Berkeley physics course / volume 3, McGraw-Hill, New York, USA, 1968.
  23. [23]A. Muravyov, S. G. Hutton, A geometrical interpretation of damping for discrete classically damped systems, International journal of mechanical sciences 40 (1) (1998) 83–86.DOI
  24. [24]K. Lelas, N. Poljak, D. Jukić, Damped harmonic oscillator revisited: the fastest route to equilibrium, American Journal of Physics 91 (10) (2023) 767–775.
  25. [25]I. Nakić, Z. Tomljanović, N. Truhar, Mixed control of vibrational systems, ZAMM-Journal of Applied Mathematics and Mechanics/Zeitschrift für Angewandte Mathematik und Mechanik 99 (9) (2019) e201800328.arxiv.org/abs/1906.00503

Paper details

vlnc:W_yc2bztar
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 10

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents