betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Gas compression systematically delays the onset of viscous fingering

Abstract

Using gas to drive liquid from a Hele-Shaw cell leads to classical viscous fingering. Strategies for suppressing fingering have received substantial attention. For steady injection of an incompressible gas, the intensity of fingering is controlled by the capillary number Ca. Here, we show that gas compression leads to an unsteady injection rate controlled primarily by a dimensionless compressibility number C. Increasing C systematically delays the onset of fingering at high Ca, highlighting compressibility as an overlooked but fundamental aspect of gas-driven fingering.

When a viscous liquid is displaced from a Hele-Shaw cell or porous medium by the injection of a gas, the gas-liquid interface is hydrodynamically unstable and tends to deform into branched, finger-like structures [1, 2, 3, 4]. This viscous-fingering instability has been extensively studied as an archetype of interfacial pattern formation [5, 6, 7, 8] and for its relevance to a variety of practical applications, including the operation of fuel cells [9, 10], the remediation of groundwater contamination [11, 12], and the subsurface sequestration of CO2_2 [13, 14] or storage of hydrogen [15]. A concern in all applications is understanding the key mechanisms that promote or suppress the development of this instability, which is driven by viscous forces in the defending phase and opposed by capillary forces at the interface. The capillary number Ca compares the magnitudes of these two forces and is thus the key parameter in determining the intensity of fingering. Recent decades have seen an increased focus on exploring the impact of perturbations to the flow or to the flow cell at a given Ca, including active modulation of the injection rate [16, 17] and use of a geometry that varies in space [17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22] and/or in time [17, 23, 24, 25, 26].

One fundamental aspect of this problem that has thus far been ignored is the volumetric compression of the injected gas, which is practically unavoidable under the typical pressures associated with displacing a viscous liquid from a confined geometry. Previous theoretical studies of fingering have taken both fluids to be incompressible and many previous experimental studies have implicitly made the same assumption. Gas compression can lead to unsteady flow or even stick-slip motion, thereby exerting a fundamental influence on displacement processes and pattern formation [27, 28, 29, 30], but the implications of compression on viscous fingering have been overlooked. Here, we use mathematical modelling, simulations, and experiments to study viscous fingering driven by the steady compression of a gas reservoir. We find that steady compression leads to an unsteady injection rate that is dictated by a dimensionless compressibility number CC, which can be interpreted as the rate of viscous depressurisation relative to the rate of compressive pressurisation [30]. We find that increasing CC delays the onset of the instability to a degree that is comparable to that of decreasing Ca by a similar magnitude. Our results suggest that compression can play a fundamental role in viscous fingering, with implications for many previous studies of interfacial instabilities during gas-driven displacement.

We consider a radial Hele-Shaw cell comprising a narrow gap of thickness bb between two rigid, circular plates of radius RcR_c [Fig. 1(a)]. The gap is initially filled with an incompressible liquid of viscosity μ\mu and surface tension γ\gamma. This liquid is displaced by injecting gas through a hole in the centre of one plate. Gas injection is driven by the steady compression of a connected gas reservoir at volumetric rate QQ, such that the volume of the reservoir is Vres(t)=Vres(0)−QtV_{\mathrm{res}}(t)=V_{\mathrm{res}}(0)-Qt. Figure 1(b) shows the time-evolution of the gas-liquid interface in experiments, where silicone oil (1,000 cSt, Sigma) was displaced by air compressed with a syringe pump. These images suggest that increasing the initial reservoir volume Vres(0)V_{\mathrm{res}}(0) (left to right) while holding all other parameters constant systematically delays the onset of fingering, in the sense that the interface remains near-circular up to larger radii. We investigate these observations quantitatively below using full numerical simulations of viscous fingering, complemented by experiments and by a simplified axisymmetric model. We observe strong qualitative and often quantitative agreement between experiments and simulations, as illustrated in Figure 1(c). We compare our experiments and simulations in detail alongside further analysis of the axisymmetric model in a companion study [31]. Here, we focus on the impact of compressibility on the fingering pattern.

Figure 1. (a) A body of gas with initial volume Vg(0)V_g(0) is compressed at a steady volumetric rate QQ in order to displace liquid from the gap bb between two plates, leading to viscous fingering. (b) Experiments performed with Q=2.5Q = 2.5 mL/min for (left to right) Vg(0)=25V_g(0) = 25, 50, 100, and 200 mL. Other parameters are b=420b = 420 μ\mum, Rc=10.5R_c = 10.5 cm, μ=0.97\mu= 0.97 Pa ⋅\cdot s, and γ=2.1×10−2\gamma= 2.1 \times10^{-2} N/m, such that Ca=5.21×103\mathrm{Ca} = 5.21 \times10^3 and α=250\alpha= 250 in all cases. (c) Corresponding fingering simulations [i.e., numerical solutions to Eqs. (3)–(9)]. Column one shows the incompressible case (black box); columns two to six show the compressible case with patm=1.01×105p_{\mathrm{atm}} = 1.01 \times10^5 Pa and Vg(0)=25V_g(0) = 25, 50, 100, 200, and 400 mL. For both experiments and simulations, each snapshot shows interface contours at equal time intervals of t^0.9/10\hat{t}_0.9/10. The arrow indicates increasing compressibility number C\mathcal{C}, which is proportional to Vg(0)V_g(0) and thus increases from left to right.

To simulate viscous fingering, we model flow of the liquid as Stokes flow averaged over the gap bb. We make the problem dimensionless via

x^=xRc,t^=QπRc2bt,p^=πb36μQp,v^=2πRcbQv,V^=VπRc2b,(1)\hat{x}=\frac{x}{R_c},\quad\hat{t}=\frac{Q}{\pi R_c^2 b}t,\quad\hat{p}=\frac{\pi b^3}{6\mu Q}p, \qquad \hat{v}=\frac{2\pi R_c b}{Q}v,\quad\hat{V}=\frac{V}{\pi R_c^2 b}, \tag*{(1)}

leading to the following dimensionless parameters:

Ca=12μQRc2πb3γ,C=12μQVg(0)πRc2patm,V=Vg(0)πRc2b,α=Rcb,R=r0Rc(2)\mathrm{Ca} = \frac{12\mu Q R_c}{2\pi b^3\gamma}, \qquad\mathcal{C} = \frac{12\mu Q V_g(0)}{\pi R_c^2 p_{\mathrm{atm}}}, \qquad\mathcal{V} = \frac{V_g(0)}{\pi R_c^2 b}, \qquad\alpha= \frac{R_c}{b}, \qquad\mathcal{R} = \frac{r_0}{R_c} \tag*{(2)}

where the total volume of gas Vg=Vres+VbV_g = V_{\mathrm{res}} + V_b combines the volume Vres(t)V_{\mathrm{res}}(t) of gas in the reservoir and the volume Vb(t)V_b(t) of gas in the cell. The capillary number Ca\mathrm{Ca}, commonly referred to as the “modified” capillary number, incorporates the role of the aspect ratio α\alpha. The new compressibility number C\mathcal{C} compares viscous and compressive (atmospheric) pressure scales or, equivalently, the rates at which these pressures vary. We fix the geometry of the flow cell and the radius r0r_0 of the initially circular bubble, such that α=250\alpha= 250 and R=0.025\mathcal{R} = 0.025. The nondimensional flow equations are then

∇^2p^=0in x^∈R2∖Ω,(3)\widehat{\nabla}^{2}\hat{p} = 0 \quad\text{in } \hat{x} \in\mathbb{R}^{2}\setminus\Omega, \tag*{(3)}
v^n=−11−f1(∇^p^)⋅non ∂Ω,(4)\hat{v}_n = -\frac{1}{1-f_1}(\widehat{\nabla}\hat{p})\cdot n \quad\text{on } \partial\Omega, \tag*{(4)}
Δp^=Δp^g(t^)−(πκ^4+2αf2)on ∂Ω,(5)\Delta\hat{p} = \Delta\hat{p}_g(\hat{t})-\left(\frac{\pi\hat{\kappa}}{4}+2\alpha f_2\right) \quad\text{on } \partial\Omega, \tag*{(5)}
Δp^=0on ∣x^∣∈1,(6)\Delta\hat{p}=0 \quad\text{on } |\hat{x}|\in1, \tag*{(6)}

where ∂Ω\partial\Omega denotes the gas-liquid interface, v^n\hat{v}_n is the magnitude of the normal velocity of the interface, nn is the unit normal to the interface, and κ^\hat{\kappa} is the signed in-plane curvature of the interface. Gauge pressures of the liquid and gas, Δp\Delta p and Δpg\Delta p_g, respectively, are measured relative to patmp_{\mathrm{atm}}. To capture the effects of thin residual films of the wetting liquid in the gas region [32], the functions f1f_1 and f2f_2 modify the kinematic and dynamic boundary conditions, respectively, to account for volume conservation, and enhanced curvature and viscous stresses at the interface.

and enhanced curvature and viscous stresses at the interface. Following Peng et al. [33], we adopt the empirical expressions

f1=∣μvn/γ∣2/30.76+2.16∣μvn/γ∣2/3(7)f_1 = \frac{|\mu v_n/\gamma|^{2/3}}{0.76+2.16|\mu v_n/\gamma|^{2/3}} \tag*{(7)}
f2=1+1.59∣μvn/γ∣+∣μvn/γ∣2/30.26+1.48∣μvn/γ∣2/3(8)f_2 = 1+1.59|\mu v_n/\gamma|+\frac{|\mu v_n/\gamma|^{2/3}}{0.26+1.48|\mu v_n/\gamma|^{2/3}} \tag*{(8)}

which were derived by fitting to simulations of viscous fingering in a rigid Hele-Shaw channel [34]. We ignore pressure gradients in the gas, taking pg(t)p_g(t) to be spatially uniform. We also assume isothermal compression, such that pg(t)=pg(0)Vg(0)/Vg(t)p_g(t)=p_g(0)V_g(0)/V_g(t), which is justified by our experimental observations (see Appendix A of Ref. [31]). The dimensionless gauge gas pressure may then be written

Δp^g=2C−1(t^+R2−V^b)+Ca−1(π4R+2α)1−V−1(t^+R2−V^b).(9)\Delta\hat{p}_g=\frac{2\mathcal{C}^{-1}\left(\hat{t}+\mathcal{R}^2-\hat{V}_b\right)+\mathrm{Ca}^{-1}\left(\frac{\pi}{4\mathcal{R}}+2\alpha\right)}{1-\mathcal{V}^{-1}\left(\hat{t}+\mathcal{R}^2-\hat{V}_b\right)}. \tag*{(9)}

In addition to the above compressible model, we also consider an analogous incompressible model, in which Eqs. (3)–(8) are unchanged but Δp^g(t^)\Delta\hat{p}_g(\hat{t}) is no longer governed by Eq. (9), instead evolving in time such that Q˙b≡dVb/dt^=1\dot{Q}_b \equiv\mathrm{d}V_b/\mathrm{d}\hat{t}=1 (i.e., Qb≡dV/dt=QQ_b \equiv\mathrm{d}V/\mathrm{d}t=Q).

We solve both compressible and incompressible models numerically using a scheme proposed by Morrow et al. [35], which utilises the level-set method [36]. Our simulations use the perturbed initial condition

R^(θ,0)=R{1+ε∑n=212cos⁡[n(θ−2πrn)]}.(10)\hat{R}(\theta,0)=\mathcal{R}\left\{1+\varepsilon\sum_{n=2}^{12}\cos\left[n(\theta-2\pi r_n)\right]\right\}. \tag*{(10)}

where R^(θ,t^)\hat{R}(\theta,\hat{t}) is the radial position of the interface at azimuthal coordinate θ\theta, and ε≪1\varepsilon\ll1 and 0≤rn≤10 \le r_n \le1 are random numbers sampled from uniform distributions. Simulations are performed on the domain 0≤r^≤10 \le\hat{r} \le1 and 0≤θ<2π0 \le\theta< 2\pi using 1,000 ×\times 1,000 equally-spaced nodes, and are concluded when R^≥0.99\hat{R} \ge0.99 for any value of θ\theta.

To better understand the coupling between gas compression and fluid displacement, we also consider an axisymmetric model in which the interface is taken to be a circle of radius R^0(t^)\hat{R}_0(\hat{t}). By further taking the limits that the air reservoir is much larger than the volume of the Hele-Shaw cell (V≫1\mathcal{V} \gg1) and that the capillary pressure is negligible relative to atmospheric pressure (2C−1≫Ca−1[π/(4R)+2α]2C^{-1} \gg\mathrm{Ca}^{-1}[\pi/(4R) + 2\alpha]), and ignoring thin-film effects (f1=0f_1 = 0, f2=1f_2 = 1), Eqs. (3)–(9) reduce to

dR^0dt^=Δp^g2R^0ln⁡(1/R^0),Δp^g=2(t^+R2−R^02)C.(11)\frac{\mathrm{d}\hat{R}_0}{\mathrm{d}\hat{t}} = \frac{\Delta\hat{p}_g}{2\hat{R}_0\ln(1/\hat{R}_0)}, \qquad\Delta\hat{p}_g = \frac{2(\hat{t}+\mathcal{R}^2-\hat{R}_0^2)}{C}. \tag*{(11)}

The dynamics of this axisymmetric model [Eq. (11)] are then determined solely by the compressibility number. For the incompressible case (C=0C = 0), the solution to the axisymmetric model is R^0=R2+t^\hat{R}_0 = \sqrt{\mathcal{R}^2+\hat{t}} and Δp^g=ln⁡(1/R^0)\Delta\hat{p}_g = \ln(1/\hat{R}_0).

We solve Eq. (11) numerically to plot the actual, time-varying injection rate Q^b(t^)=dV^b/dt^=2R^0(dR^0/dt^)\hat{Q}_b(\hat{t}) = \mathrm{d}\hat{V}_b/\mathrm{d}\hat{t} = 2\hat{R}_0(\mathrm{d}\hat{R}_0/\mathrm{d}\hat{t}) and the gauge gas pressure in Figure 2(a,Figure 2b), respectively, for a range of CC. Both quantities are initially zero for all C>0C > 0. Both then increase toward and then beyond the incompressible solution, corresponding to an initial period of increasing injection rate due to gas pressurisation. The pressure evolves non-monotonically in time for all CC, increasing at early times when the compression rate exceeds the injection rate (Q^b<1\hat{Q}_b < 1) and then decreasing at late times, once the injection rate exceeds the compression rate (Q^b>1\hat{Q}_b > 1). The injection rate Q^b\hat{Q}_b is determined by a balance between the gauge gas pressure and the viscous resistance in the draining liquid. This observation can be used to demonstrate the existence of two dynamical regimes in the axisymmetric model [see [31]]. For C≲1C \lesssim1 (blue curves), the breakout time t^f≡t^(R^0=1)\hat{t}_f \equiv\hat{t}(\hat{R}_0 = 1) is unity and the breakout pressure Δp^g(R^0=1)\Delta\hat{p}_g(\hat{R}_0 = 1) is zero, corresponding to a nonmonotonic evolution of Q^b\hat{Q}_b, which tends to a finite value at breakout. For C≳1C \gtrsim1 (red curves), breakout is delayed (t^f>1\hat{t}_f > 1) and the breakout pressure is significantly greater than zero. This overpressure leads to a monotonically increasing and ultimately divergent injection rate as the viscous resistance vanishes at breakout. These regimes arise in the axisymmetric model due to the coupling of time-evolving compressive and viscous forces, independent of viscous fingering. The same features were recently identified and analysed in detail in the context of a capillary tube [30].

Image not extracted

Figure 2. Nondimensional (left) injection rate Q^b\hat{Q}_b and (right) gauge gas pressure Δp^g\Delta\hat{p}_g for C=0.018C = 0.018, 0.0360.036, 0.0710.071, 0.140.14, 0.280.28, 0.570.57, 1.131.13, 2.272.27, and 4.544.54 (dark blue to dark red; arrows). Blue and red curves are for C<1C < 1 and C>1C > 1, respectively. The incompressible case is also shown (dashed black). Panels (a) and (b) are from the axisymmetric model [Eq. (11)]. Panels (c) and (d) are from fingering simulations (solid curves) and experiments (symbols), both for Ca=2.08×104\mathrm{Ca} = 2.08 \times10^{4} with V=0.215\mathcal{V} = 0.215, 0.4300.430, 0.8590.859, 1.721.72, 3.443.44, 6.876.87, 13.713.7, 27.527.5, and 5555 (experimental values in bold).

Figures 2(c, d) show Q^b\hat{Q}_b and Δp^g\Delta\hat{p}_g, respectively, from fingering simulations at the same values of CC as in Figure 2(a,Figure 2b) and for Ca=2.08×104\mathrm{Ca} = 2.08 \times10^{4}, demonstrating that the qualitative dynamics of the axisymmetric model and the fingering simulations are strikingly similar. The presence of viscous fingering, and to a lesser extent residual films, leads to a few key differences. Notably, the fingering simulations achieve breakout much earlier (typically around t^f≈0.5\hat{t}_f \approx0.5 for low C≲1C \lesssim1) because the irregular, branched interface bypasses a substantial fraction of the defending liquid. In addition, the transition to monotonically increasing Q^b\hat{Q}_b occurs significantly below the threshold C≈1C \approx1 from the axisymmetric model. (Note that the threshold CC is approximate in the Hele-Shaw geometry because of a secondary dependence on R\mathcal{R} [31].) Unlike in the axisymmetric model, the values of Q^b\hat{Q}_b and Δp^g\Delta\hat{p}_g from the fingering simulations do also depend on the value of Ca\mathrm{Ca}, but we find that this dependence is comparatively weak, as discussed below. Nonetheless, this comparison suggests that the basic physics of compression-driven displacement underpin the dynamics of this system, even in the presence of viscous fingering. For comparison, we also plot experimental measurements at four values of CC in Figure 2(c, Figure 2d), which show excellent qualitative agreement with the fingering simulations (see Ref. [31] for a detailed comparison).

The importance of CC is further illustrated by considering fingering simulations at fixed CC and varying Ca\mathrm{Ca} as plotted in Figure 3(a, Figure 3b). In practice, this can be achieved by varying QQ while holding QVg(0)Q\mathcal{V}_g(0) and all other parameters constant. The results of the axisymmetric model are included for reference (dashed black). The injection rate Q^b\hat{Q}_b [Figure 3(a)] is particularly insensitive to variations in Ca\mathrm{Ca} and, hence, to the evolution of the fingering pattern. The gauge gas pressure Δp^g\Delta\hat{p}_g [Figure 3(b)] appears to be somewhat more sensitive to the pattern, featuring a more pronounced Ca\mathrm{Ca}-dependent deviation from the axisymmetric solution after the peak pressure is reached. However, variations in Ca\mathrm{Ca} clearly have much less of an impact on Q^b\hat{Q}_b and Δp^g\Delta\hat{p}_g than variations in CC of a similar magnitude [Figure 2(c, Figure 2d)]. This insensitivity to Ca\mathrm{Ca} is surprising, given the strong impact of Ca\mathrm{Ca} on the fingering pattern, as illustrated in Figure 3(c, Figure 3d) for the corresponding experiments and simulations, respectively. The severity of the fingering pattern increases with Ca\mathrm{Ca}, with the instability beginning at smaller radii, generating narrower and more-branched fingers, and leading to earlier breakout—see the values of the near-breakout time t^0.9\hat{t}_{0.9} at which the interface first crosses R^=0.9\hat{R} = 0.9, in Figure 3(c, Figure 3d). However, the evolving balance between compressive and viscous forces is a bulk feature that is relatively insensitive to the shape of the interface.

Image not extracted

Figure 3. Nondimensional (a) injection rate Q^b\hat{Q}_b and (b) gauge gas pressure Δp^g\Delta\hat{p}_g from fingering simulations for C=0.14C = 0.14 and Ca=2.61×103\mathrm{Ca} = 2.61 \times10^{3}, 5.21×1035.21 \times10^{3}, 1.04×1041.04 \times10^{4}, and 2.08×1042.08 \times10^{4} (solid blue curves; arrows show increasing Ca\mathrm{Ca}). The solution to the axisymmetric model Eq. (11) is shown for comparison (dashed black). Panels (c) and (d) show the evolution of the fingering pattern from corresponding experiments and simulations, respectively, plotted at equal time intervals of t^0.9/10\hat{t}_{0.9}/10.

To further examine the influence of CC and Ca\mathrm{Ca} on viscous fingering, we perform a linear stability analysis of the full model [Eqs. (3)–(9)] by considering the growth of perturbations to a near-circular interface R^(θ,t^)=\hat{R}(\theta,\hat{t}) =

R^0(t^)+εγn(t^)cos⁡(nθ)+O(ε2)\hat{R}_0(\hat{t}) + \varepsilon\gamma_n(\hat{t})\cos(n\theta) + \mathcal{O}(\varepsilon^2), where ε≪1\varepsilon\ll1, and γn\gamma_n is the amplitude of mode nn. This analysis adopts the same assumptions as the axisymmetric model: V≫1V \gg1, capillary pressure is negligible compared with atmospheric pressure (but not negligible overall), and we ignore thin films. As such, the base state R^0(t^)\hat{R}_0(\hat{t}) is determined by Eq. (11), but we retain terms with Ca\mathrm{Ca} in the stability analysis. Following the methodology of Paterson [5], it can be shown that the growth rate of each mode is given by

λn=γ˙nγn=n−12R^02[Q^b−n(n+1)CaR^0],(12)\lambda_n = \frac{\dot{\gamma}_n}{\gamma_n} = \frac{n-1}{2\hat{R}_0^2}\left[\hat{Q}_b - \frac{n(n+1)}{\mathrm{Ca}\hat{R}_0}\right], \tag*{(12)}

where Q^b=2R^0(dR^0/dt^)\hat{Q}_b = 2\hat{R}_0(\mathrm{d}\hat{R}_0/\mathrm{d}\hat{t}) for a circular interface and dR^0/dt^\mathrm{d}\hat{R}_0/\mathrm{d}\hat{t} is determined by Eq. (11). The most unstable mode is then

nmax⁡=1+CaR^0Q^b3,(13)n_{\max} = \sqrt{\frac{1+\mathrm{Ca}\hat{R}_0\hat{Q}_b}{3}}, \tag*{(13)}

which comes about by solving ∂λn/∂n=0\partial\lambda_n/\partial n = 0 for nn. Increasing Ca\mathrm{Ca}, R^0\hat{R}_0, and Q^b\hat{Q}_b all increase λn\lambda_n and nmax⁡n_{\max}, thus promoting the instability (i.e., perturbations grow faster and generate more fingers). In the incompressible system, for which Eqs. (12) and (13) were originally derived and where Q^b=1\hat{Q}_b = 1 and R^0=(R2+t^)1/2\hat{R}_0 = (R^2 + \hat{t})^{1/2}, Ca\mathrm{Ca} is the key parameter in determining the onset of viscous fingering. For the compressible case, however, both Q^b(t^)\hat{Q}_b(\hat{t}) and R^0(t^)\hat{R}_0(\hat{t}) depend primarily on CC. The very low initial injection rates Q^b≪1\hat{Q}_b \ll1 observed in the axisymmetric model, the fingering simulations, and the experiments [Figure 2(a, Figure 2c)] tend to reduce λn\lambda_n and nmax⁡n_{\max} considerably at early times relative to an incompressible flow, suggesting that fingering is delayed by compressibility [see [31]].

To compare the predictions of this linear stability analysis with the nonlinear evolution of the instability in the fingering simulations, we quantify the severity of the fingering pattern using the isoperimetric ratio

I(t^)=L^2(t^)4πA^(t^),(14)\mathcal{I}(\hat{t}) = \frac{\hat{L}^{2}(\hat{t})}{4\pi\hat{A}(\hat{t})}, \tag*{(14)}

where L^\hat{L} and A^\hat{A} denote the perimeter and area of the gas region, respectively. For a circular interface, I=1\mathcal{I}=1; any deformation away from a circle results in I>1\mathcal{I}>1. Hence, the initial deviation of I\mathcal{I} away from 1 is an indicator of the onset of instability. Figure 4(a) shows the onset radius R^∗\hat{R}^{*} at which fingers begin to develop (defined here as max⁡(R^)\max(\hat{R}) when I=1.1\mathcal{I}=1.1) as a function of CC for different Ca\mathrm{Ca}. As C→0C \to0, R^∗\hat{R}^{*} asymptotes to the incompressible case. Increasing CC or decreasing Ca\mathrm{Ca} systematically delays the onset of fingering relative to the incompressible case. Varying either Ca\mathrm{Ca} or CC by a similar magnitude has a comparable effect, highlighting the power of CC as a control parameter. While compressibility delays onset primarily by reducing the initial injection rates at higher CC, the overshoot in Q^b\hat{Q}_{b} at later times could drive anomalously fast growth and exacerbate the final severity of fingering. As shown in Figure 4(b), however, the delayed onset with increasing CC also correlates with lower I(t^0.9)\mathcal{I}(\hat{t}_{0.9}), meaning a less severe fingering pattern near breakout. Hence, CC not only delays the onset of the instability, but also hinders the nonlinear growth of the fingering pattern. We observe the same qualitative behaviour in experiments over a comparable range of C∼10−2−100C \sim10^{-2} - 10^{0} [31] [see 31, for a discussion of the distinct patterns formed in experiments and simulations].

Image not extracted

Figure 4. (a) The onset radius R^∗\hat{R}^{*} at which fingers begin to develop, defined as the maximum radius of the interface when I=1.1\mathcal{I} = 1.1, from fingering simulations at varying CC with V=0.215V = 0.215, 0.4300.430, 0.8590.859, 1.721.72, 3.443.44, 6.876.87, 13.713.7, 27.527.5, 5555, and 110110. (b) The subsequent values of I\mathcal{I} at the near-breakout time t^0.9\hat{t}_{0.9}. Dashed lines denote the corresponding incompressible cases. Arrows indicate the direction of increasing Ca=2.61×103\mathrm{Ca} = 2.61 \times10^{3}, 5.21×1035.21 \times10^{3}, 1.04×1041.04 \times10^{4}, and 2.08×1042.08 \times10^{4}.

Thus, compressibility naturally and passively leads to an unsteady injection rate that can significantly delay the onset of fingering and reduce the severity of the fingering pattern, with the compressibility number CC having a comparable effect to that of Ca\mathrm{Ca}, the traditional control parameter. Even for relatively small CC, which would be unavoidable even in systems that are nominally incompressible, the onset radius is consistently larger and the final isoperimetric ratio is consistently smaller than for the incompressible case [Fig. 4], suggesting that compressibility is rarely truly negligible. Our study is of particular relevance to flows in porous media where the presence of compressibility is already widely appreciated in subsurface fluid injection [37], although its full implications for fluid displacement and fingering were previously not. There is broad scope for taking advantage of compressibility in gas-driven flows in porous media and our study provides a strong foundation for doing so. Further, our results imply that features in other physical systems that play a role analogous to compressibility, such as elasticity, heat capacity, or electrical capacitance, can play an important and even controlling role in the evolution of those systems.

Data availability — The supporting data for this study are openly available on Zenodo [38].

Published version — This article is published as L. C. Morrow, C. Cuttle, and C. W. MacMinn. Gas compression systematically delays the onset of viscous fingering. Physical Review Letters, 131:224002, 2023.

Acknowledgments

We are grateful to Mr. Clive Baker for technical support. This work was supported by the European Research Council (ERC) under the European Union’s Horizon 2020 Programme (Grant No. 805469), by the UK Engineering and Physical Sciences Research Council (EPSRC) [Grant No. EP/S034587/1], and by the John Fell Oxford University Press Research Fund [Grant No. 132/012].

References

  1. [1]S. Hill, Channeling in packed columns, Chem. Eng. Sci. 1, 247 (1952).DOI
  2. [2]P. G. Saffman and G. I. Taylor, The penetration of a fluid into a porous medium or Hele-Shaw cell containing a more viscous liquid, Proc. Math. Phys. Eng. Sci. 245, 312 (1958).
  3. [3]R. L. Chukhue, P. Van Meurs, and C. van der Poel, The instability of slow, immiscible, viscous liquid-liquid displacements in permeable media, Trans. 216, 188 (1959).DOI
  4. [4]G. M. Homsy, Viscous fingering in porous media, Ann. Rev. Fluid Mech. 19, 271 (1987).
  5. [5]L. Paterson, Radial fingering in a Hele Shaw cell, J. Fluid Mech. 113, 513 (1981).
  6. [6]K. V. McCloud and J. V. Maher, Experimental perturbations to Saffman-Taylor flow, Physics Reports 260, 139 (1995).DOI
  7. [7]Y. Couder, Viscous fingering as an archetype for growth patterns, in Perspectives in Fluid Dynamics, edited by G. K. Batchelor, H. K. Moffatt, and M. G. Worster (Cambridge University Press, 2000) pp. 53–104.
  8. [8]J. Casademunt, Viscous fingering as a paradigm of interfacial pattern formation: Recent results and new challenges, Chaos 14, 809 (2004).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/15446992
  9. [9]C. Lee, B. Zhao, R. Abouatallah, R. Wang, and A. Bazylak, Compressible-gas invasion into liquid-saturated porous media: Application to polymer-electrolyte-membrane electrolyzers, Phys. Rev. Applied 11, 054029 (2019).DOI
  10. [10]M. Mortazavi, A. D. Santamaria, V. Chauhan, J. Z. Benner, M. Heidari, and E. F. Médici, Effect of PEM fuel cell porous media compression on in-plane transport phenomena, J. Power Sources Advances 1, 100001 (2020).DOI
  11. [11]W. S. Clayton, A field and laboratory investigation of air fingering during air sparging, Ground Water Monit. Remediat. 18, 134 (1998).DOI
  12. [12]L. Hu, X. Wu, Y. Liu, J. N. Meegoda, and S. Gao, Physical modeling of air flow during air sparging remediation, Environ. Sci. Technol. 44, 3883 (2010).DOI
  13. [13]Y. Wang, C. Zhang, N. Wei, M. Oostrom, T. W. Wietsma, X. Li, and A. Bonneville, Experimental study of crossover from capillary to viscous fingering for supercritical CO₂–water displacement in a homogeneous pore network, Environ. Sci. Technol. 47, 212 (2013).DOI
  14. [14]Y.-F. Chen, S. Fang, D.-S. Wu, and R. Hu, Visualizing and quantifying the crossover from capillary fingering to viscous fingering in a rough fracture, Water Resour. Res. 53, 7756 (2017).
  15. [15]L. Paterson, The implications of fingering in underground hydrogen storage, Int. J. Hydrog. Energy 8, 53 (1983).DOI
  16. [16]E. O. Dias, E. Alvarado-Lassalle, M. S. Carvalho, and J. A. Miranda, Minimization of viscous fluid fingering: A variational scheme for optimal flow rates, Phys. Rev. Lett. 109, 144502 (2012).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/23083248
  17. [17]L. C. Morrow, T. J. Moroney, and S. W. McCue, Numerical investigation of controlling interfacial instabilities in non-standard Hele-Shaw configurations, J. Fluid Mech. 877, 1063 (2019).DOI
  18. [18]H. Zhao, J. Casademunt, C. Yeung, and J. V. Maher, Perturbing Hele-Shaw flow with a small gap gradient, Physical Review A 45, 2455 (1992).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/9907268
  19. [19]E. O. Dias and J. A. Miranda, Finger tip behavior in small gap gradient Hele-Shaw flows, Physical Review E 82, 056319 (2010).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/21230588
  20. [20]T. T. Al-Housseiny, P. A. Tsai, and H. A. Stone, Control of interfacial instabilities using flow geometry, Nature Phys. 8, 747 (2012).DOI
  21. [21]E. O. Dias and J. A. Miranda, Taper-induced control of viscous fingering in variable-gap Hele-Shaw flows, Physical Review E 87, 053015 (2013).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/23767628
  22. [22]H. S. Rabbani, D. Or, Y. Liu, C.-Y. Lai, N. B. Lu, S. S. Datta, H. A. Stone, and N. Shokri, Suppressing viscous fingering in structured porous media, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 115, 4833 (2018).DOI
  23. [23]D. Pihler-Puzović, P. Illien, M. Heil, and A. Juel, Suppression of complex fingerlike patterns at the interface between air and a viscous fluid by elastic membranes, Phys. Rev. Lett. 108, 074502 (2012).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/22401208
  24. [24]T. T. Al-Housseiny, I. C. Christov, and H. A. Stone, Two-phase displacement and interfacial instabilities under elastic membranes, Physical Review Letters 111, 034502 (2013).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/23909329
  25. [25]Z. Zheng, H. Kim, and H. A. Stone, Controlling viscous fingering using time-dependent strategies, Phys. Rev. Lett. 115, 174501 (2015).DOI
  26. [26]P. H. A. Anjos, M. Zhao, J. Lowengrub, W. Bao, and S. Li, Controlling fingering instabilities in Hele-Shaw flows in the presence of wetting film effects, Physical Review E 103, 063105 (2021).DOI
  27. [27]B. Sandnes, E. G. Flekkøy, H. A. Knudsen, K. J. Måløy, and H. See, Patterns and flow in frictional fluid dynamics, Nat. Commun. 2, 288 (2011).DOI
  28. [28]B. Sandnes, E. G. Flekkøy, and K. J. Måløy, Stick slip displacement of confined granular mixtures: Bubble expansion, Eur. Phys. J. Spec. Top. 204, 19 (2012).DOI
  29. [29]B. Lai, C.-Y. and Rallabandi, A. Perazzo, Z. Zheng, S. E. Smiddy, and H. A. Stone, Foam-driven fracture, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. 115, 8082 (2018).DOI
  30. [30]C. Cuttle and C. W. MacMinn, Dynamics of compression-driven gas–liquid displacement in a capillary tube, Physical Review Letters 130, 114001 (2023).DOI
  31. [31]C. Cuttle, L. C. Morrow, and C. W. MacMinn, Compression-driven viscous fingering in a radial Hele-Shaw cell, Physical Review Fluids 8, 113904 (2023).DOI
  32. [32]C.-W. Park and G. M. Homsy, Two-phase displacement in Hele Shaw cells: theory, J. Fluid Mech. 139, 291 (1984).DOI
  33. [33]G. G. Peng, D. Pihler-Puzović, A. Juel, M. Heil, and J. R. Lister, Displacement flows under elastic membranes. part 2. analysis of interfacial effects, J. Fluid Mech. 784, 512 (2015).DOI
  34. [34]D. A. Reinelt and P. G. Saffman, The penetration of a finger into a viscous fluid in a channel and tube, SIAM J. Sci. Stat. Comput. 6, 542 (1985).DOI
  35. [35]L. C. Morrow, T. J. Moroney, M. C. Dallaston, and S. W. McCue, A review of one-phase Hele-Shaw flows and a level-set method for non-standard configurations, ANZIAM J. 63, 269 (2021).DOI
  36. [36]S. Osher and J. A. Sethian, Fronts propagating with curvature-dependent speed: Algorithms based on Hamilton-Jacobi formulations, J. Comput. Phys. 79, 12 (1988).DOI
  37. [37]H. Wang, Theory of linear poroelasticity with applications to geomechanics and hydrogeology, Vol. 2 (Princeton university press, 2000).
  38. [38]C. Cuttle, L. Morrow, and C. W. MacMinn, Compression-driven viscous fingering: Experimental and numerical data, Zenodo (2023) (Available at: https://dx.doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.10075655).

Paper details

vlnc:W_z9y8sby8
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents