betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Exploring the giant monopole resonance in superheavy nuclei: A theoretical perspective

Abstract

Within the relativistic mean field framework, in an extended Thomas-Fermi approximation, we calculate the binding energy and charge distribution radius for the latest superheavy nuclei, synthesised in various laboratories, with atomic numbers Z=110−118Z = 110-118. The binding energy and radii are compared with the results obtained from relativistic Hartree calculations along with the experimental data, wherever available, to check the reliability of the methods. The calculations are extended to estimate the giant monopole resonances to understand the collective vibration of the nucleons for such superheavy nuclei. The giant monopole resonances obtained from scaling calculations are compared with the constraint computations. Furthermore, the results are compared with other known methods, such as the relativistic Random Phase Approximation (RPA) and time-dependent mean field calculations, along with some known lighter nuclei, specifically Zr isotopes (N = 42-86) and O isotopes (N = 10-36). Finally, the nuclear compressibility of the superheavy nuclei is predicted from the energy obtained in the breathing mode.

Introduction

The superheavy element is one of the most fascinating topics in nuclear physics. So far, up to the atomic number Z=118Z = 118 has been synthesised in the laboratory [1]. The heaviest known element 294Og{}^{294}\mathrm{Og} (Oganesson) has the atomic number Z=118Z = 118 and the mass number A=294A = 294 with the neutron number N=176N = 176. The transuranium elements are not found naturally. They are formed artificially in the laboratory and have very short lifetimes with a high radioactive decay rate. The transuranium elements are useful in many ways, such as nuclear power generation, medical treatment, and scientific research. Because of the short lifetime and difficulties in the synthesis process, the properties of the superheavy elements are not experimentally well known. It is also not clear what the exact atomic weight will be for a particular transuranium element and its position in the Periodic Table. To understand the nature of these superheavy elements in an experimental setup, a proper and thorough theoretical understanding is necessary. From a theoretical point of view, the non-relativistic [2, 3, 4, 5, 6] and relativistic [7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19] formalisms are two successful frameworks from which we get the ground state binding energy, charge radii, quadrupole moments and various types of collective oscillations [20]. Among the collective properties of nuclei, the monopole and quadrupole vibrations are quite common, and these properties of nuclei give a good amount of information that can be used to study further. Being the heaviest side of the mass table, superheavy nuclei have a large number of protons and neutrons (∼300\sim300), possess a perfect collective property.

To deal with these collective properties, one needs a framework, i.e., the relativistic or the non-relativistic formalisms. Furthermore, the semi-classical approach, such as Thomas-Fermi treatment with its higher order correction on ℏ\hbar or direct Hartree-type approach, is more suitable and time-saving in the process of the calculations [21].

One of the fundamental and crucial properties of Nuclear Matter (NM) is the incompressibility at saturation K∞K_{\infty}. Mathematically, K∞K_{\infty} is proportional to the second derivative of energy density [7, 22, 23], i.e.,

K∞∝∂2E∂ρ2∣ρ=ρ0,K_{\infty}\propto\left.\frac{\partial^{2}\mathcal{E}}{\partial\rho^{2}}\right|_{\rho=\rho_{0}},

where E\mathcal{E} = energy density, ρ\rho is the nuclear density and ρ0\rho_{0} is the nuclear density at saturation of the NM. This incompressibility K∞K_{\infty} plays a pivotal role in deciding the nature of the nuclear Equation of State (EoS). For example, with a stiffer EoS, the Tolman-Oppenheimer-Volkoff (TOV) equation predicts a massive Neutron Star (NS) [24]. The EoS also determines the flow rate in the Heavy Ion collision experiment [25]. It is to be noted that the incompressibility is not a directly measurable quantity. One can extract K∞K_{\infty} from the giant monopole vibration at the resonance condition from the experimental data of finite nuclei. The giant monopole resonances (GMR) are high-frequency, small-amplitude and collective excitation of atomic nuclei. This is a property of many-body systems, characterised by the excitation energy of the system. Thus, the study of GMR of superheavy nuclei is a perfect application of collective phenomena in the field of Nuclear Structure physics. The isoscalar giant monopole resonance (ISGMR) has been reported recently for the medium and heavy mass nuclei [26]. Over the past several decades, the incompressibility of nuclear matter has garnered considerable interest, and multiple methods have been utilized to determine the K∞K_{\infty} [6, 27, 28]. Nevertheless, a clear identification of the incompressibility of nuclear matter has proven to be a challenging task because of the lower sensitivity of giant monopole resonance data to incompressibility. The relativistic mean field models, along with the random phase approximation (RPA), predict the nuclear matter incompressibility at saturation within a range of K∞=270±10K_\infty= 270 \pm10 MeV [13, 29]. Similarly, the non-relativistic formalisms with Hartree-Fock (HF) plus RPA give this value of K∞K_\infty to 210–220 MeV, which is less than the relativistic approach; on the other hand, the recent experimental value of K∞=240±20K_\infty= 240 \pm20 MeV [30, 31, 32, 33]. This discrepancy in K∞K_\infty might have come from the diverse behaviour of the density dependence of the symmetry energy in the relativistic and non-relativistic formalism [34]. As mentioned earlier, the K∞K_\infty is not a direct experimental observable; rather, it is an outcome of the experimental measurement of the isoscalar giant monopole resonance (ISGMR). This fact demands a correct measurement of the excitation energy of the ISGMR. A step forward in this direction is the recent ISGMR calculation in the context of the coherent density fluctuation model [35]. Over the last two decades, this fundamental relation of ISGMR and incompressibility has motivated us to study the excitation energy and incompressibility KAK^A of finite nuclei. The excitation energy of the finite nuclei is a collective property that can be studied more accurately in a larger mass system.

In our study, we have taken the heaviest region, which has been synthesised already, of the nuclear landscape for the study of ISGMR and KAK^A. Although so much work has been done on ISGMR calculations for heavier nuclei, the superheavy region is still uncovered. A lot of work can be done by taking the superheavy region to explore the many exciting nuclear phenomena. In the scaling method, one can derive the virial theorem for the RMF model of nuclei treated in the extended Thomas–Fermi approach [15, 16]. The extended Thomas–Fermi solutions satisfy the stability condition against scaling. We apply this semi-classical technique to study collective properties, such as the excitation energy of the breathing mode in superheavy nuclei with the NL3 relativistic parameter set [13]. Since the superheavy region is not explored properly and the results of this region are unknown with the present method, we first compare the results for a few lower mass nuclei, such as O and Zr [36]. Although the well-known NL3 parameter set is quite old and many more parameter sets in the relativistic mean field formalism have been developed, we have chosen the NL3 set in the present calculations due to its merit. The current observation of a higher solar mass neutron star in the multi-messenger experiment [37] suggests a stiffer EoS and the higher side of nuclear matter incompressibility. These properties are well taken in the NL3 force parameters. Further, the NL3 parametrisation gives ground state binding energies, root mean square radii and nuclear densities in very good agreement with the experimental data for known stable and unstable nuclei for both spherical and deformed nuclei.

The celebrity relativistic extended Thomas–Fermi approximation (RETF) [9, 10, 11, 12, 14] [36, 38] with scaling and constraint approaches are used in the frame-work of the non-linear σ−ω\sigma-\omega model [7], which is the ℏ2\hbar^2 correction to the relativistic Thomas–Fermi (RTF) approximation, where variation of density takes care of mostly on the surface of the nucleus [21]. It is to be noted that the RETF formalism is more towards the quantal Hartree approximation. It is also verified that the semi-classical approximation, like the Thomas–Fermi method, is very useful in the calculation of collective properties of nuclei, like the giant monopole resonance (GMR) [39–41].

This paper is organised as follows: In Sec. II, we have summarised the theoretical formalisms, which are relevant for the present analysis. In Sec. III, we discuss the results on binding energy obtained from the RETF formalism. We also compared the results with the Hartree calculations as well as experimental/extrapolated data, wherever available. The charge radius and neutron-skin thickness are compared with Hartree calculations as these experimental values are not available for the superheavy nuclei. After these comparisons, we have elaborated on the giant monopole resonance and compressibility of smaller known nuclei (O and Zr). Then we extended our discussions for the synthesised superheavy nuclei (Z=110Z = 110 to 118). The last Sec. IV is devoted to a summary and the concluding remarks.

The Relativistic Mean Field Formalism

The virial theorem is obtained from the relativistic mean field [8] Hamiltonian in the framework of scaling invariance within the relativistic Thomas–Fermi (RTF) and relativistic extended Thomas–Fermi (RETF) approximations [9, 10, 12, 14, 15, 16] [42, 43]. Although scaling and constrained calculations have been previously established, the method introduced by Patra et al. [15, 16] [42, 44] is a novel approach that differs from other scaling techniques. The detailed formalism of the scaling method can be found in Refs. [15, 16] [42, 44]. For completeness, we have briefly summarised some key expressions, which are essential for the present calculations. We have utilised the non-linear Lagrangian proposed by Boguta and Bodmer [7] to account for many-body correlations that arise from non-linear terms in the σ\sigma-meson self-interaction [45–49] for nuclear many-body systems. The compressibility modulus of nuclear matter, K∞K_\infty, decreases significantly with the inclusion of these terms and comes to the experimental limit. This extension of non-linearity over the linear σ−ω\sigma-\omega model of Walecka improves the finite nuclei results throughout the mass table, along with the nuclear matter properties. Based on this model, a large number of relativistic parameter sets are constructed, such as NL1, NL2, NL-SH, NL3, NL3* and many others. Because of the recent experimental data for finite nuclei as well as for NM and NS, the non-linearity is extended further, and more recent forces like G1, G2, G3, and IOPB-I are designed. Taking into consideration the present problem, we have taken the NL3 force in our calculations.

The Hamiltonian for the relativistic mean field nucleon-meson interacting system is written as [8, 15, 16, 34] [42]:

H=∑iφi†[−iα⋅∇+βm∗+gvV+12gρRτ3+12eA(1+τ3)]φi+12[(∇ϕ)2+ms2ϕ2]+13bϕ3+14cϕ4−12[(∇V)2+mv2V2]−12[(∇R)2+mρ2R2]−12(∇A)2(1)\mathcal{H} = \sum_i \varphi_i^\dagger\left[-i\boldsymbol{\alpha}\cdot\boldsymbol{\nabla}+\beta m^*+g_vV+\frac{1}{2}g_\rho R\tau_3+\frac{1}{2}eA(1+\tau_3)\right]\varphi_i+\frac{1}{2}\left[(\boldsymbol{\nabla}\phi)^2+m_s^2\phi^2\right] +\frac{1}{3}b\phi^3+\frac{1}{4}c\phi^4-\frac{1}{2}\left[(\boldsymbol{\nabla}V)^2+m_v^2V^2\right]-\frac{1}{2}\left[(\boldsymbol{\nabla}R)^2+m_\rho^2R^2\right]-\frac{1}{2}(\boldsymbol{\nabla}A)^2 \tag*{(1)}

The fields for the σ\sigma, ω\omega, ρ\rho-mesons and photon are ϕ\phi, VV and AA, respectively. The τ3\tau_3 is the 3rd3^{rd} component of the iso-spin of the ρ\rho-meson. The actual mass mm of the nucleon appears to be missed due to its oscillations in the mesonic medium and acquires the effective mass m∗=m−gsϕm^*=m-g_s\phi. The msm_s, mvm_v and mρm_\rho are the masses for the σ\sigma-, ω\omega- and ρ\rho-mesons, respectively. The coupling constants gsg_s, gvg_v, gρg_\rho and e2/4π=1/137e^2/4\pi=1/137 are correspond to the σ\sigma, ω\omega, ρ\rho-mesons and photon couplings with the nucleons, respectively. The bb and cc are the self-couplings for the non-linear σ−ω\sigma-\omega model for the σ\sigma-meson field. Using the variational principle, the equations of motion for the nucleons and meson fields can be derived. In the semi-classical approximation, in terms of density, the Hamiltonian is given by:

H=E+gvVρ+gρRρ3+eAρp+Hf,(2)\mathcal{H}=\mathcal{E}+g_vV\rho+g_\rho R\rho_3+eA\rho_p+\mathcal{H}_f, \tag*{(2)}

with

E=∑iφi†[−iα⋅∇+βm∗]φi.(3)\mathcal{E}=\sum_i\varphi_i^\dagger\left[-i\boldsymbol{\alpha}\cdot\boldsymbol{\nabla}+\beta m^*\right]\varphi_i. \tag*{(3)}

Here, Hf\mathcal{H}_f is the free part of the Hamiltonian, the total density ρ\rho is the sum of proton ρp\rho_p and neutron ρn\rho_n density distribution.

The ground state meson fields are obtained from the Euler-Lagrange equations δH/δρq=μq\delta H/\delta\rho_q=\mu_q (q=n,pq=n,p), which are iteratively solved in a self-consistent method. The pairing correlation plays a minor role in the Thomas-Fermi approximation for the giant resonance as well as in the equilibrium property. It is shown by Viñas and group [50, 51] that for open-shell nuclei, the pairing correlation has a marginal effect on ISGMR energy. Thus, we have ignored the pairing contribution in the present semi-classical approach. In the density functional method, the RMF Hamiltonian is written as:

H=E+12gsϕρseff+13bϕ3+14cϕ4+12gvVρ+12gρRρ3+12eAρp(4)\mathcal{H}=\mathcal{E}+\frac{1}{2}g_s\phi\rho_s^{\mathrm{eff}}+\frac{1}{3}b\phi^3+\frac{1}{4}c\phi^4+\frac{1}{2}g_vV\rho+\frac{1}{2}g_\rho R\rho_3+\frac{1}{2}eA\rho_p \tag*{(4)}

with

ρseff=gsρs−bϕ2−cϕ3.(5)\rho_s^{\mathrm{eff}}=g_s\rho_s-b\phi^2-c\phi^3. \tag*{(5)}

Here, we used the scaling technique to calculate the monopole vibration of the nucleus. The baryon density is scaled with a scaling parameter λ\lambda, which is defined in the normalised form [15, 16] [42] as:

ρλ(r)=λ3ρ(λr),(6)\rho_\lambda(\mathbf{r})=\lambda^3\rho(\lambda\mathbf{r}), \tag*{(6)}

where λ\lambda is a collective coordinate associated with the monopole vibration. Since the Fermi momentum KFqK_{Fq} and density are related to each other, the scaled Fermi momentum KFqλK_{Fq\lambda} is given by

KFqλ=[3π2ρqλ(r)]13.(7)K_{Fq\lambda}=\left[3\pi^2\rho_{q\lambda}(\mathbf{r})\right]^{\frac{1}{3}}. \tag*{(7)}

Similarly, the ϕ\phi, VV, RR and Coulomb fields are scaled. Because the transformed ρ\rho field contains the ϕ\phi field itself, it can not be scaled similarly to the density and momentum. In the present approach (semi-classical formalism), the energy and density are scaled as

Eλ(r)=λ4E(λr)=λ4[E0(λr)+E2(λr)],(8)\mathcal{E}_\lambda(\mathbf{r})=\lambda^4\mathcal{E}(\lambda\mathbf{r})=\lambda^4\left[\mathcal{E}_0(\lambda\mathbf{r})+\mathcal{E}_2(\lambda\mathbf{r})\right], \tag*{(8)}
ρsλ(r)=λ3ρ~s(λr).(9)\rho_{s\lambda}(\mathbf{r})=\lambda^3\tilde{\rho}_s(\lambda\mathbf{r}). \tag*{(9)}

The ∼\sim is denoted as an implicit dependence of m~∗\tilde{m}^*. Now, using the scaled variables, the scaled semi-classical Hamiltonian can be written as:

Hλ=λ3E~+12gsϕλρseff+13bλ3ϕλ3+14cλ3ϕλ4+12gvVλρ+12gρRλρ3+12eAλρp(10)\mathcal{H}_\lambda=\lambda^3\tilde{\mathcal{E}}+\frac{1}{2}g_s\phi_\lambda\rho_s^{\mathrm{eff}}+\frac{1}{3}\frac{b}{\lambda^3}\phi_\lambda^3+\frac{1}{4}\frac{c}{\lambda^3}\phi_\lambda^4+\frac{1}{2}g_vV_\lambda\rho+\frac{1}{2}g_\rho R_\lambda\rho_3+\frac{1}{2}eA_\lambda\rho_p \tag*{(10)}

The scaled monopole excitation energy ESE_S is defined as ES=Cm/BmE_S=\sqrt{C_m/B_m}, Cm=C_m=the restoring force and Bm=B_m=the mass parameter. The restoring force is defined as [15, 16] [42] Cm=∂2E∂λ2∣λ=1C_m=\left.\frac{\partial^2\mathcal{E}}{\partial\lambda^2}\right|_{\lambda=1}, which after operation is obtained as:

Cm=∫dr[−m∗∂ρ~s∂λ+3(ms2ϕ2+13bϕ3−mv2V2−mρ2R2)−(2ms2ϕ+bϕ2)∂ϕλ∂λ+2mv2V∂Vλ∂λ+2mρ2R∂Rλ∂λ]λ=1(11)C_m=\int d r\left[-m^*\frac{\partial\tilde{\rho}_s}{\partial\lambda}+3\left(m_s^2\phi^2+\frac{1}{3}b\phi^3-m_v^2V^2-m_\rho^2R^2\right)-\left(2m_s^2\phi+b\phi^2\right)\frac{\partial\phi_\lambda}{\partial\lambda}+2m_v^2V\frac{\partial V_\lambda}{\partial\lambda}+2m_\rho^2R\frac{\partial R_\lambda}{\partial\lambda}\right]_{\lambda=1} \tag*{(11)}

Similarly, the mass parameter of the monopole vibration is expressed as Bm=∂2Eλ∂λ˙2∣λ=1B_m=\left.\frac{\partial^2\mathcal{E}_\lambda}{\partial\dot{\lambda}^2}\right|_{\lambda=1}, (i.e., the double derivative of the scaled energy with the collective velocity λ˙\dot{\lambda}) as:

Bm=∫drU(r)2H.(12)B_m=\int dr U(r)^2\mathcal{H}. \tag*{(12)}

where U(r)U(r) is the displacement field, which is obtained from the relation between collective velocity λ˙\dot{\lambda} and velocity of the moving frame,

U(r)=1ρ(r)r2∫dr′ρT(r′)r′2,(13)U(r)=\frac{1}{\rho(r)r^2}\int dr'\rho_T(r')r'^2, \tag*{(13)}

where, ρT\rho_T is the transition density defined as

ρT(r)=∂ρλ(r)∂λ∣λ=1=3ρ(r)+r∂ρ(r)∂r.(14)\rho_T(r)=\left.\frac{\partial\rho_\lambda(r)}{\partial\lambda}\right|_{\lambda=1}=3\rho(r)+r\frac{\partial\rho(r)}{\partial r}. \tag*{(14)}

On substituting the value of the transition density ρT(r)\rho_T(r) in Eq. (13) and after the simplification of the integral, the displacement field becomes U(r)=rU(r)=r. Ultimately, the mass parameter is written as Bm=∫drr2HB_m=\int dr r^2\mathcal{H}. In non-relativistic limit, Bmnr=∫drr2mρB_m^{nr}=\int dr r^2m\rho. The scaled excitation energy can be expressed by different moments mk=∫0∞EkS(E)dEm_k=\int_0^\infty E^kS(E)dE, where S(E)S(E) is the strength function and kk is an integer. The average excitation energy with the scaling approach is ES=m3m1E_S=\sqrt{\frac{m_3}{m_1}}. The expressions for m3m_3 and m1m_1 can be found in Refs. [6] [52]. Apart from the scaling calculation, the monopole vibration can also be studied with a constrained approach [6, 28] [53, 54, 55]. In this method, one has to solve the constrained functional equation [15, 16]:

∫dr[H−ηr2ρ]=E(η)−η∫drr2ρ.(15)\int dr\left[\mathcal{H}-\eta r^2\rho\right]=E(\eta)-\eta\int dr r^2\rho. \tag*{(15)}

The constrained is ⟨R2⟩0=⟨r2⟩m\langle R^2\rangle_0=\langle r^2\rangle_m. The constrained energy E(η)E(\eta) can be expanded in a harmonic approximation as

E(η)=E(0)+∂E(η)∂η∣η=0+∂2E(η)∂η2∣η=0.(16)E(\eta)=E(0)+\left.\frac{\partial E(\eta)}{\partial\eta}\right|_{\eta=0}+\left.\frac{\partial^2E(\eta)}{\partial\eta^2}\right|_{\eta=0}. \tag*{(16)}

The second-order derivative in the expansion is related to the constrained incompressibility KCAK_C^A for a finite nucleus with mass number AA as

KCA=1AR02∂2Eη∂Rη,(17)K_C^A=\frac{1}{A}R_0^2\frac{\partial^2E_\eta}{\partial R_\eta}, \tag*{(17)}

and the constrained monopole excitation energy ECE_C as

EC=AKCABCm.(18)E_C=\sqrt{\frac{AK_C^A}{B_C^m}}. \tag*{(18)}

Similar to the scaled excitation energy, the average resonance energy for the constraint approach can be written with the sum-rule notation as EC=m1m−1E_C=\sqrt{\frac{m_1}{m_{-1}}}. The scaled and constraint energies are the upper and lower bounds of the resonance, respectively, and the average resonance width Σ\Sigma is their difference, which is defined as [6] [52]

Σ=12ES2−EC2.\Sigma=\frac{1}{2}\sqrt{E_S^2-E_C^2}.

RESULTS AND DISCUSSIONS

In this section, we discuss the obtained results of binding energy, root mean square radius and nucleon density distribution for some selected nuclei. The transition density is also given to understand the change in nucleon distribution inside the superheavy nuclei in the monopole vibrations. The theoretical prediction of the monopole excitation energy in the scaling approach ESE_S along with the constraint calculation ECE_C is discussed in detail in the following subsections through Table 1-Table 2 and Figure 1-Figure 9.

NucleusETF (BE)RHA (BE)Expt. (BE)NucleusETF (BE)RHA (BE)Expt. (BE)
267^{267}Ds1985.31929.41935.2268^{268}Ds1992.71937.01943.5
269^{269}Ds1999.971944.71950.3270^{270}Ds2007.01952.31958.5
271^{271}Ds2014.01959.81965.3272^{272}Ds2020.81967.31973.4
273^{273}Ds2027.51974.81979.0274^{274}Ds2034.21982.21986.2
275^{275}Ds2040.71989.01992.1276^{276}Ds2047.11995.71999.1
277^{277}Ds2053.32002.52004.7278^{278}Ds2059.52009.22011.3
279^{279}Ds2065.52015.92016.6280^{280}Ds2071.52022.52023.4
281^{281}Ds2077.32029.12028.5
272^{272}Rg2016.01961.91965.7273^{273}Rg2023.11969.61974.1
274^{274}Rg2030.01977.31980.2275^{275}Rg2036.81984.91987.4
276^{276}Rg2043.51991.91993.3277^{277}Rg2050.01998.92000.5
278^{278}Rg2056.52005.82006.6279^{279}Rg2062.82012.72013.3
280^{280}Rg2069.12019.52019.4281^{281}Rg2075.22026.32026.0
282^{282}Rg2081.22033.12031.5283^{283}Rg2087.12039.82038.2
276^{276}Cn2039.01987.51989.7277^{277}Cn2045.91994.71995.8
278^{278}Cn2052.62001.82003.3279^{279}Cn2059.32008.92009.4
280^{280}Cn2065.82016.02016.6281^{281}Cn2072.22022.92022.4
282^{282}Cn2078.52029.92029.6283^{283}Cn2084.72036.82035.1
284^{284}Cn2090.72043.72042.0285^{285}Cn2096.72049.52047.4
278^{278}Nh2047.91997.21996.6279^{279}Nh2054.82004.52004.3
280^{280}Nh2061.62011.72010.4281^{281}Nh2068.32018.92017.9
282^{282}Nh2074.92026.12023.9
284^{284}Fl2083.92036.42034.0285^{285}Fl2090.52043.72040.0
286^{286}Fl2096.92051.02047.5287^{287}Fl2103.22057.02053.2
288^{288}Fl2109.42063.02060.4289^{289}Fl2115.52069.02065.8
287^{287}Mc2099.42053.62048.6288^{288}Mc2105.92059.72054.9
289^{289}Mc2112.32065.82062.0290^{290}Mc2118.52071.92067.7
291^{291}Mc2124.72078.02074.8
289^{289}Lv2108.22062.12057.4290^{290}Lv2114.72068.32064.8
291^{291}Lv2121.32074.52070.8292^{292}Lv2127.52080.72078.2
293^{293}Lv2133.72086.82083.5
291^{291}Ts2116.82070.62065.5292^{292}Ts2123.42076.92071.7
293^{293}Ts2129.92083.22078.8294^{294}Ts2136.32089.4322085.0
293^{293}Og2125.32079.12073.6294^{294}Og2132.02085.42081.2
295^{295}Og2138.62091.82087.1

Table 1. The binding energy (BE) obtained from the relativistic Extended Thomas-Fermi (RETF) calculations for some selected nuclei is compared with the relativistic Hartree approximation (RHA) as well as with the experimental data [56], wherever available, for the superheavy nuclei with atomic number Z = 110 − 118. The energy is in MeV, and calculations are done with NL3 parameters set.

NucleusETF (RchR_{\mathrm{ch}})RHA (RchR_{\mathrm{ch}})ETF (Δr\Delta r)RHA (Δr\Delta r)NucleusETF (RchR_{\mathrm{ch}})RHA (RchR_{\mathrm{ch}})ETF (Δr\Delta r)RHA (Δr\Delta r)
267Ds{}^{267}\mathrm{Ds}6.0766.1140.1370.144268Ds{}^{268}\mathrm{Ds}6.0836.1180.1420.150
269Ds{}^{269}\mathrm{Ds}6.0896.1230.1470.155270Ds{}^{270}\mathrm{Ds}6.0966.1280.1520.161
271Ds{}^{271}\mathrm{Ds}6.1026.1320.1560.166272Ds{}^{272}\mathrm{Ds}6.1096.1360.1610.171
273Ds{}^{273}\mathrm{Ds}6.1156.1410.1660.176274Ds{}^{274}\mathrm{Ds}6.1226.1450.1700.181
275Ds{}^{275}\mathrm{Ds}6.1286.1520.1750.188276Ds{}^{276}\mathrm{Ds}6.1356.1590.1800.194
277Ds{}^{277}\mathrm{Ds}6.1426.1660.1840.200278Ds{}^{278}\mathrm{Ds}6.1486.1730.1890.206
279Ds{}^{279}\mathrm{Ds}6.1556.1800.1940.212280Ds{}^{280}\mathrm{Ds}6.1616.1860.1980.217
281Ds{}^{281}\mathrm{Ds}6.1686.1930.2030.222
272Rg{}^{272}\mathrm{Rg}6.1136.1390.1480.160273Rg{}^{273}\mathrm{Rg}6.1196.1430.1530.165
274Rg{}^{274}\mathrm{Rg}6.1266.1480.1580.170275Rg{}^{275}\mathrm{Rg}6.1326.1520.1620.175
276Rg{}^{276}\mathrm{Rg}6.1396.1590.1670.181277Rg{}^{277}\mathrm{Rg}6.1456.1660.1720.187
278Rg{}^{278}\mathrm{Rg}6.1526.1730.1760.193279Rg{}^{279}\mathrm{Rg}6.1586.1800.1810.199
280Rg{}^{280}\mathrm{Rg}6.1656.1870.1860.198281Rg{}^{281}\mathrm{Rg}6.1716.1940.1900.203
282Rg{}^{282}\mathrm{Rg}6.1786.2010.1950.203283Rg{}^{283}\mathrm{Rg}6.1856.2080.2000.208
276Cn{}^{276}\mathrm{Cn}6.1436.1580.1550.169277Cn{}^{277}\mathrm{Cn}6.1496.1660.1590.175
278Cn{}^{278}\mathrm{Cn}6.1566.1730.1640.181279Cn{}^{279}\mathrm{Cn}6.1626.1800.1680.187
280Cn{}^{280}\mathrm{Cn}6.1696.1870.1730.193281Cn{}^{281}\mathrm{Cn}6.1756.1940.1780.199
282Cn{}^{282}\mathrm{Cn}6.1826.2010.1820.202283Cn{}^{283}\mathrm{Cn}6.1886.2080.1870.208
284Cn{}^{284}\mathrm{Cn}6.1956.2150.1910.212285Cn{}^{285}\mathrm{Cn}6.2016.2170.1960.222
278Nh{}^{278}\mathrm{Nh}6.1596.1580.1520.169279Nh{}^{279}\mathrm{Nh}6.1666.1660.1560.175
280Nh{}^{280}\mathrm{Nh}6.1726.1730.1610.180281Nh{}^{281}\mathrm{Nh}6.1796.1800.1650.185
282Nh{}^{282}\mathrm{Nh}6.1856.1870.1700.191
284Fl{}^{284}\mathrm{Fl}6.2026.2150.1670.189285Fl{}^{285}\mathrm{Fl}6.2086.2220.1710.194
286Fl{}^{286}\mathrm{Fl}6.2156.2290.1760.198287Fl{}^{287}\mathrm{Fl}6.2216.2310.1800.207
288Fl{}^{288}\mathrm{Fl}6.2286.2330.1850.216289Fl{}^{289}\mathrm{Fl}6.2346.2360.1890.225
287Mc{}^{287}\mathrm{Mc}6.2256.2380.1680.192288Mc{}^{288}\mathrm{Mc}6.2316.2400.1720.201
289Mc{}^{289}\mathrm{Mc}6.2386.2420.1770.209290Mc{}^{290}\mathrm{Mc}6.2446.2450.1810.218
291Mc{}^{291}\mathrm{Mc}6.2516.2470.1860.226
289Lv{}^{289}\mathrm{Lv}6.2416.2490.1650.194290Lv{}^{290}\mathrm{Lv}6.2486.2510.1690.202
291Lv{}^{291}\mathrm{Lv}6.2546.2540.1740.211292Lv{}^{292}\mathrm{Lv}6.2616.2560.1780.219
293Lv{}^{293}\mathrm{Lv}6.2676.2590.1820.227
291Ts{}^{291}\mathrm{Ts}6.2586.2600.1620.196292Ts{}^{292}\mathrm{Ts}6.2646.2630.1700.204
293Ts{}^{293}\mathrm{Ts}6.2706.2650.1700.212294Ts{}^{294}\mathrm{Ts}6.2776.2680.1750.220
293Og{}^{293}\mathrm{Og}6.2746.2710.1580.197294Og{}^{294}\mathrm{Og}6.2806.2740.1630.205
295Og{}^{295}\mathrm{Og}6.2876.2770.1670.213

Table 2. The charge radius RchR_{\mathrm{ch}} and neutron-skin thickness Δr=Rn−Rp\Delta r = R_{\mathrm{n}} - R_{\mathrm{p}} obtained from the relativistic extended Thomas-Fermi (RETF) and relativistic Hartree approximation for some selected superheavy nuclei with atomic number Z=110−118Z = 110 - 118. The radii are in fm.

Figure 1. The binding energy for superheavy nuclei Z=110−118Z = 110 - 118 isotopes compare with available experimental/extrapolated data [56]

Figure 9. The finite nuclear incompressibility KAK^A for the superheavy nuclei for Z=110−118Z = 110 - 118 as a function of neutron number in scaling and constraint methods.

Binding energy

The binding energy (BE) of finite nuclei is a crucial quantity in the study of nuclear physics. This is the most accurately measured quantity among the known nuclear observables. Thus, knowing the calculated binding energy and how far the method can reproduce is quite instructive. The BE values for some known nuclei in the superheavy region are displayed in Table I. For few representative cases, starting from 267^{267}Ds to 295^{295}Og, with neutron number N=157−177N=157-177. The binding energy in an isotopic chain gives an idea of the energy required to separate a neutron and also acts as a symbol of nuclear stability. Here, we discuss the binding energy results of our calculations for superheavy nuclei Z=110−118Z=110-118 using the NL3 parameter set in the framework of RETF. The semi-classical results are compared with the relativistic Hartree calculations [13] along with the experimental data [56]. The results are depicted in Table I and Figure 1. From the table, one can find that, in general, we get a constant overbinding of ∼50\sim50 MeV for almost all the isotopes considered in the mass region in RETF. In other words, we get about 2% more binding with the RETF formalism than the experimental data. The binding energy difference between the experimental and RETF approach can be bridged out with a scaling factor fS∼1.024f_S\sim1.024, i.e., if we divide the RETF results of binding energy by a factor fSf_S, then we will get the exact experimental binding energy. This discrepancy in bindings between RETF and data may be due to the exclusion of the shell structure of the nucleus in the calculation. However, the quantal RMF binding energy is quite close to the experimental data. The RMF or Hartree calculation under-predicts the RETF results.

The RMF results of binding energy are about 4 MeV, which differs from the data, which is almost equal to the experimental observation. The binding energy calculations towards the neutron dripline in an isotopic chain increase monotonously with neutron number, and it becomes stiffer and stiffer with atomic number. Due to the difficulties in the mass measurement and isotopes synthesis, it is difficult to obtain the binding energy data for a wide range of isotopes, unlike the light or medium mass region of the mass table; hence, for a few cases,

TABLE I. The binding energy (BE) obtained from the relativistic Extended Thomas-Fermi (RETF) calculations for some selected nuclei is compared with the relativistic Hartree approximation (RHA) as well as with the experimental data [56], wherever available, for the superheavy nuclei with atomic number Z=110−118Z = 110 - 118. The energy is in MeV, and calculations are done with NL3 parameters set.

the experimental extrapolated data are used in the comparison. In general, although the RETF calculation is a semi-classical approach, its prediction about the binding energy is quite close to the experimental results, which can be seen from the table and figure (Table 1 and Figure 1) [56].

The charge radius and neutron-skin thickness Rn−Rp=rR_n-R_p=r of superheavy nuclei with Z=110−118Z = 110 - 118

The nuclear charge radius RchR_{ch} is one of the most useful observables that provides information on how effective interactions affect the nuclear structure and clarify the nuclear shell model. In panel (a) of Figure 2, we examine the findings of charge radius RchR_{ch} for superheavy nuclei with atomic numbers Z=110−118Z = 110 - 118. The RchR_{ch} is determined by employing the NL3 parameters within the context of relativistic extended Thomas-Fermi formalism. We have also depicted the relativistic Hartree (RHA) results of RchR_{ch} and neutron-skin thickness (Δr=Rn−Rp\Delta r = R_n - R_p) for comparison in Table II. The charge radius rises linearly with the neutron count in an isotopic series. In panel (b) of Figure 2, we present the neutron skin thickness Δr=Rn−Rp\Delta r = R_n - R_p on femtometers (fm) as a function of the neutron number for the heavy nuclei Z=110−118Z = 110 - 118. The thickness of the skin increases consistently in magnitude with a rise in the neutron count for every isotope of superheavy nuclei across all elements. This slow rise in the Δr\Delta r can be explained by the rearrangement of nucleons due to nuclear interactions when an additional neutron is added while maintaining the atomic number (Z). Since we are analysing the RETF result, which is a semi-classical approximation, the detailed structure of the nucleus is missing. However, the internal structure of the nucleus is visible in the RHA calculations, which can be seen from the RchR_{\mathrm{ch}} and Δr\Delta r in Table II. On average, the RETF and RHA are similar and can be understood as the applicability of the RETF formalism to study the collective properties of the nucleus, including the giant monopole resonances.

Figure 2. The charge radius RchR_{\rm ch} and neutron-skin thickness Δr=Rn−Rp\Delta r = R_n - R_p for superheavy element with atomic number Z=110−118Z = 110 - 118 using NL3 set.

The nuclear and transition density

In this subsection, we analyse the nuclear density and subsequently the transition density for some selected nuclei in the superheavy region. The nuclear density plays a pivotal role not only in the ground state but also in the collective excited state. Thus, it is a crucial quantity for determining the collective oscillations of heavy nuclei. The RETF density and the quantal RHA density are compared in Figure 3. We find that both densities are comparable to each other, except for the disappearance of shell structure in the RETF result. This structure of the density is expected in a semi-classical calculation. On the other hand, the internal shell structure is visible in the RHA density. In general, the RETF density is good enough for our subsequent collective calculations.

Total relativistic extended Thomas-Fermi nuclear densities

Figure 3. The total relativistic extended Thomas-Fermi nuclear densities are compared with the relativistic Hartree approximation (RHA) for a few selected nuclei.

After knowing the applicability of the RETF density for the collective oscillation, we computed the transition density for some nuclei. The transition density is interpreted in the excitation of the collective mode of vibration, i.e. the movement of the nucleus as a whole. In this case, single-particle nucleons change their energy level. In the present case, the rate of change of nuclear density with respect to the scaling parameter λ\lambda at λ=1\lambda= 1 [see eq. (14)]. The RETF results for 293−296Og{}^{293-296}\mathrm{Og} are shown in Figure 4. This figure helps us to understand the structural evolution during a collective transition.

Transition density for oxygen isotopes

Figure 4. The transition density ρT\rho_T for 293,294,295,296Og{}^{293,294,295,296}\mathrm{Og} with RETF method using NL3 force.

Giant monopole energy and finite nuclear incompressibility of light mass region

Before going to investigate the isoscalar giant monopole resonances (ISGMR) for the superheavy nuclei, we reproduced the results of our earlier calculations for the O and Zr isotopes. The calculated results are shown in Figure 5 as a function of neutron numbers. The results for the constraint calculations are also shown in the same figure. The sum rule weighted factor expressed that the monopole scaled energy ESE_S is the ratio of the m3m_3 to the m1m_1, while the monopole constrained energy ECE_C is the ratio of the m3m_3 to m2m_2. Thus, we obtain the higher side of the monopole resonance spectrum in a scaling calculation of the monopole excitation energy. However, the constraint calculation gives the lower side of the spectrum. The difference between the scaling and constraint excitation energy estimates the width of the spectrum, which is defined as Σ=12ES2−EC2\Sigma= \frac{1}{2}\sqrt{E_S^2-E_C^2}. The results for the O isotopes extended from N=10−26N = 10 - 26 and those of the Zr isotopes from N=42−86N = 42 - 86 as shown in Figure 5. The ESE_S is denoted by the solid line and ECE_C is by the dotted line. It is always found that EC≤ESE_C \le E_S and both the excitation energies decrease with an increase in neutron number in an isotopic series, but the Σ\Sigma value increases with neutron number and it is maximum near the dripline. The obtained values of excitation energies for 16O{}^{16}\mathrm{O} from the scaling and constrained calculations are 27.83 MeV and 25.97 MeV, respectively, which are above the range of experimental results 21.13±\pm0.49 MeV [57]. Similarly to the case of 16O{}^{16}\mathrm{O}, the prediction of excitation energy ES=19.53E_S = 19.53 MeV and EC=19.03E_C = 19.03 MeV for 90Zr{}^{90}\mathrm{Zr} with the experimental value of Eexpt=17.89±0.20E_{\rm expt} = 17.89 \pm0.20 MeV [57]. The thetheoretical results on the monopole excitation energy give the impression that the RETF approximation is more suitable for large systems with a large number of nucleons and could be more appropriate for the superheavy region.

Figure 5. (Color online) The giant monopole resonance excitation energy and incompressibility modulus for O and Zr in scaling and constraint method.

The scaling and constraint incompressibility KSAK_S^A and KCAK_C^A for oxygen isotopes starting with N=10N = 10 to N=26N = 26 are given in the lower panel of Figure 5. Similarly, the KAK^A for scaling and constraint values are also shown in the same figure for Zirconium isotopes. The KAK^A results for both the Oxygen and Zirconium isotopes monotonously decrease with the increase in neutron number. The rate of decrease in constraint KCAK_C^A is much faster than that of KSAK_S^A. It is almost zero at N=21N = 21, showing the incompressible nature of Oxygen near the dripline. The general trend in the behaviour of excitation energy and incompressibility is almost the same, with a change in the energy scale. In case of the Zr-isotopes, the difference in scaling and constraint incompressibility ΔK=KS−KC\Delta K = K_S - K_C with the neutron number NN, we find the increasing trend of ΔK\Delta K.

Giant monopole energy and nuclear incompressibility of superheavy nuclei with atomic number Z=110Z = 110-118118

After knowing that the present technique (RETF) is very efficient for the superheavy region, we calculate the GMR in the framework of RETF with the NL3 set for the Z=110Z = 110-118118 nuclei. Both the scaling and constraint calculations are performed to evaluate the monopole excitation energy and the finite nuclear incompressibility. Then we look for any correlation among them, so that it will be useful for further studies. The superheavy nuclei lie on the stability line, but are very unstable due to excessive Coulomb repulsion. To neutralise the repulsive Coulomb effect, a large number of neutral

neutrons are needed and are responsible for making a highly asymmetric finite nuclear system. As a result, the state dependence of the nuclear force plays an important role and makes the situation very complicated and very different from the normal β\beta-stable nuclei. Since the considered nuclei are very asymmetric with a strong Coulomb force, these nuclei are vulnerable to both α\alpha- and β\beta-decays. It is well understood that the nuclear force is highly state-dependent. The singlet–single and triplet–triplet nucleon-nucleon interaction is repulsive, whereas the singlet–triplet is very attractive [58–60]. Due to the presence of a large number of neutrons in superheavy nuclei, the singlet–singlet and triplet–triplet parts of the nuclear force in the superheavy region play the most dominant role, and the stability of the nucleus becomes questionable. In these circumstances, the giant monopole resonance (GMR) is a main source of information on the incompressibility of nuclei and nuclear matter [27]. Since the incompressibility of the finite nuclei has interesting relations with the nuclear matter incompressibility, the study of GMR for the superheavy nuclei is quite intriguing.

In Figure 6, the scaling and constraint monopole excitation energies for Ds, Rg, Cn, Nh, Fl, Mc, Lv, Ts and Og are shown. As usual, in the known cases, here also ESE_S is constantly overestimated by ECE_C. At N=180N = 180, all the nuclei predict a similar scaling monopole excitation energy ES=12.75E_S = 12.75 MeV. The ECE_C is shown in panel (b) of Figure 6. In the constraint excitation energy, we also get the same results for N=190N = 190, i.e., EC=11.75E_C = 11.75 MeV, similar to the ESE_S with a slight shifting in the neutron number. The variation in excitation energy decreases with the higher value of atomic number ZZ for both scaling and constraint calculations. The rate of change of scaling energy (0.028 MeV per nucleon) is less than the rate of change in constraint energy (0.031 MeV per nucleon) with an increase in neutron number. Throughout the superheavy region (Z=110−118Z = 110 - 118), the energy difference between the ESE_S and ECE_C for all the cases (ΔE=ES−EC\Delta E = E_S - E_C) is less than 1 MeV, suggesting a sharp spectrum in the monopole resonances as compared to the O and Zr isotopes. The ΔE\Delta E as a function of neutron number is shown in Figure 7(a). It continues to increase slowly with NN, and most isotopes meet near N=210N = 210. On the other hand, if we analyse the resonance width defined as Σ=12ES2−EC2\Sigma= \frac{1}{2}\sqrt{E_S^2 - E_C^2} goes on decreasing with NN and becomes minimum at about neutron number N=290−220N = 290 - 220 for various isotopic series (see Figure 7(b)). It is extreme left for the lightest Ds series and extreme right for the heavy Og chain. The maximum width Σ\Sigma for the majority case is within 2.3 - 2.44 MeV inferring a sharp resonance peak and indicating a perfect collective monopole resonance.

The giant monopole resonance excitation energy for superheavy nuclei

Figure 6. The giant monopole resonance excitation energy for superheavy nuclei Z=110−118Z = 110 - 118 in scaling and constraint methods as a function of neutron number NN. (a) is for the scaling calculation and (b) is for the constraint case.

Figure 7. (a) The difference in monopole excitation energy between the scaling and constraint calculations (DE=ES−ECDE = E_S - E_C) with NL3 parameter set as a function of neutron number. (b) The resonance width is defined as Σ=12ES2−EC2\Sigma= \frac{1}{2}\sqrt{E_S^2 - E_C^2} for the isotopic series as a function of neutron number.

The relation of giant monopole resonance with the neutron-skin thickness can be seen in Figure 8. The ESE_S is given in Figure 8(a) and ECE_C is in Figure 8(b). For both the ESE_S and ECE_C, we get a negative correlation with the neutron-skin thickness Δr=Rn−Rp\Delta r = R_n - R_p, i.e., both the excitation energies decrease with neutron number and neutron-skin thickness Δr\Delta r increases with NN due to excess in neutron in an isotopic chain. We made a simple linear regression fitting for both the ESE_S and ECE_C separately, and the fitting equations are given as ES=14.044−5.9514×ΔrE_S = 14.044 - 5.9514 \times\Delta r and EC=13.25−6.3282×ΔrE_C = 13.25 - 6.3282 \times\Delta r with a correlation coefficient ζ=99.9999\zeta= 99.9999 for both cases.

Figure 8. The giant monopole resonance excitation energy for superheavy nuclei as a function of neutron-skin thickness Δr=Rn−Rp\Delta r = R_n - R_p.

The incompressibility of superheavy nuclei Z=110-118

Once we know the excitation energy ExE_x, from Eqn. (18), we can evaluate the incompressibility KAK^A for a finite nucleus with mass number AA. The constraint and scaling results of KAK^A are shown in Figure 9 as a function of neutron number. It is clear from the results that when we increase the number of neutrons, the scaling and constraint incompressibility monotonously decrease. The relation of KAK^A and NN looks like a negative correlation as discussed in the earlier sub-section for the excitation energy ExE_x with the neutron-skin thickness Δr\Delta r. That means, the KAK^A decreases with NN with some proportionality relation. The rate of change of scaling incompressibility KSAK_S^A is more than that of KCAK_C^A with neutron number. Similar to the excitation energy, here also we get a common value of KCK_C for all considered isotopes at N=170N = 170, which is shifted to N=157N = 157 in KSK_S calculations. The difference in KAK^A between the scaling and constraint, (ΔK=KSA−KCA\Delta K = K_S^A - K_C^A) is within 19 - 28 MeV.

SUMMARY AND CONCLUSIONS

In the present study, we calculate the giant monopole resonances for the heaviest known region of the finite nuclei mass table within the relativistic extended ThomasFermi formalism using the NL3 parameters set. Before going to compute the collective properties, like ExE^x, and KAK^A, we tested the model and parametrisation for properties of known nuclei in the light and superheavy regions. In this context, the binding energy is compared with the Hartree result and experimental data for a few known cases. We find that the relativistic extended Thomas-Fermi calculations are more suitable with a large number of nucleonic systems. That is why the present method is quite an accurate and time-saving formalism for the calculations of a wide range of isotopes.

Once we established the RETF formalism and the application of scaling and constraint methods to the analysis of collective properties of light and medium mass finite nuclei, we extended the calculations to the superheavy nuclei. We have shown that, unlike the light/medium mass isotopes, the excitation energy and incompressibility for finite nuclei in the Z=110−118Z = 110 - 118 region decrease monotonously in an isotopic chain. Since the scaling and constraint methods predict the higher and lower sides of the monopole spectrum, their difference estimates the width of the resonance. We get a sharper resonance, because both the scaling and constraint calculations are found to be almost similar with a smaller value of DEDE, i.e. DE∼1DE \sim1 MeV.

Although the difference in ESE_S and ECE_C gives an idea about the resonance width, the actual width Σ\Sigma is defined as Σ=12ES2−EC2\Sigma= \frac{1}{2}\sqrt{E_S^2-E_C^2}. In this case, we get the maximum Σ\Sigma within the range 2.3−2.442.3 - 2.44 MeV for the considered band of superheavy nuclei. The maximum Σ\Sigma for a particular element also depends on the neutron number. Since the participation of the Coulomb effect plays an important role in the Σ\Sigma, we get the maximum width for the lower value of NN for lighter ZZ elements (here for Ds) and vice versa (here for Og). That means, in the Ds isotopic series, the maximum Σ\Sigma is at N=190N = 190, and for the Og chain it is at N=220N = 220. The incompressibility for finite nuclei KAK^A is found to be similar for the excitation energy. That means, the rate of change of KAK^A in an isotopic series with neutron number is the same as that of the excitation energy ExE^x in the superheavy region.

Acknowledgments

This work has been supported by the Science and Engineering Research Board (SERB), DST, India, under Ramanujan Fellowship File No. RJF/2022/000140.

References

  1. [1]Yu. Ts. Oganessian et al., Phys. Rev. C 74, 044602 (2006).
  2. [2]Heavy elements and related new phenomena, Edited by W. Greiner and R. K. Gupta (World Scientific, 1999).DOI
  3. [3]E. Chabanat, P. Bonche, P. Haensel, J. Meyer and R. Schaeffer, Nucl. Phys. A 635, 231 (1998).
  4. [4]J. Button et al., Phys. Rev. C 100, 064318 (2019).
  5. [5]J. Kvasil, V. O. Nesterenko, A. Repko, W. Kleinig and P.-G. Reinhard, Phys. Rev. C 94, 064302 (2016).
  6. [6]O. Bohigas, A. Lane and J. Martorell, Phys. Rep. 51, 267 (1979).
  7. [7]J. Boguta and A. R. Bodmer, Nucl. Phys. A 292, 413 (1977).
  8. [8]B. D. Serot and J. D. Walecka, Adv. Nucl. Phys. 16, 1 (1986).
  9. [9]M. Centelles, X. Viñas, M. Barranco, S. Marcos and R. J. Lombard, Nucl. Phys. A 537, 486 (1992).
  10. [10]M. Centelles, X. Viñas, M. Barranco and P. Schuck, Ann. Phys., NY 221, 165 (1993).
  11. [11]C. Spieker, E. Engel and R.M Dreizler, Nucl. Phys. A 562, 569 (1993).
  12. [12]M. Centelles, X. Viñas, M. Barranco, N. Ohtsuka, A. Faessler, Dao T. Khoa and H. Müther, Phys. Rev. C 47, 1091 (1993).
  13. [13]G. A. Lalazissis, J. König and P. Ring, Phys. Rev. C 55, 540 (1997).
  14. [14]M. Centelles, M. Del Estal and X. Viñas, Nucl. Phys. A 635, 193 (1998).
  15. [15]S. K. Patra, M. Centelles, X. Viñas, M. Del Estal Phys. Lett. B 523, 67 (2001).
  16. [16]S. K. Patra, X. Viñas, M. Centelles and M. Del Estal, Nucl. Phys. A 703, 240 (2002).
  17. [17]J. A. Pattnaik, R. N. Panda, M. Bhuyan and S. K. Patra, Phy. Scr. 96, 125319 (2021).
  18. [18]J. A. Pattnaik, K. C. Naik, R. N. Panda, M. Bhuyan and S. K. Patra, Pramana-Jour. of Phys., 97, 136 (2023).
  19. [19]J. A. Pattnaik, K. Dash, R. N. Panda, Phys. of Part. and Nucl. Letts., 22, 448 (2025).
  20. [20]A. Bahini et al, Nucl. Phys. A 1059,123078 (2025).
  21. [21]M. Centelles, X. Viñas, M. Barranco and P. Schuck, Nucl. Phys. A 519, 73c (1990).
  22. [22]A. Kumar, H. C. Das, M. Kaur, M. Bhuyan, and S. K. Patra, Phys. Rev. C 103, 024305 (2021).
  23. [23]J. A. Pattnaik, M. Bhuyan, R. N. Panda and S. K. Patra, Int. Jour. of Mod. Phys. E, 33, 2450040 (2024).
  24. [24]Bharat Kumar, S. K. Biswal and S. K. Patra, Phys. Rev. C 95, 015801 (2017).
  25. [25]P. Danielewicz, R. Lacey and W. G. Lynch Science 298, 1592 (2002).
  26. [26]A. Bahini, J. Carter et al., Phys. Rev. C 109, 014325 (2024).
  27. [27]J. P. Blaizot, Phy Rep. 64, 171 (1980).
  28. [28]T. Maruyama and T. Suzuki, Phys. Lett. B 219, 43 (1989).
  29. [29]D. Vretenar, A. Wandelf and P. Ring, Phys. Lett. B 487, 334 (2002).
  30. [30]S. Shlomo, V. M. Kolomietz, and G. Colò, Eur. Phys. J. A 30, 23 (2006).
  31. [31]G. Colò, Phys. of Part. Nucl. 39, 286 (2008).
  32. [32]U. Garg and G. Colò, Prog. Part. Nucl. Phys. 101, 55 (2018).
  33. [33]J. A. Pattnaik, R. N. Panda, M. Bhuyan, and S. K. Patra, Chin. Phys. C 46, 094103 (2022).
  34. [34]J. Piekarewicz, Phys. Rev. C 66, 034305 (2002).

Paper details

vlnc:W_zj4sbr3n
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 6

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents