betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Nuclear effects on longitudinal-transverse structure function ratio in the deuteron

Abstract

Nuclear modifications of the nucleon's structure function F2NF_2^N have been investigated mainly since the discovery of the EMC nuclear effect in 1983, and there were many experimental measurements from the deuteron to a heavy nucleus. Now, the details of the modifications of F2NF_2^N are known from small xx to large xx. On the other hand, it is taken as granted that a nuclear modification does not exist for the longitudinal-transverse structure function ratio RN=FLN/(2xF1N)R_N=F_L^N/(2xF_1^N). However, such a nuclear modification does exist theoretically. A nucleon in a nucleus moves in any space direction, which is not necessary the longitudinal direction along the virtual-photon momentum in charged-lepton scattering. Because of this transverse Fermi motion, the longitudinal and transverse structure functions mix with the mixture probability proportional to the nucleon's transverse-momentum squared p⃗T  2/Q2\vec p_T^{\,\, 2}/Q^2. In this paper, the nuclear modifications are shown numerically for the deuteron by using a standard convolution description. The magnitude of the modifications is of the order of a few percent in the deuteron; however, they should be large in large nuclei. In handling high-energy nuclear data, such nuclear modifications need to be taken into account for a precise determination of physical quantities. Now, the longitudinal-transverse structure-function ratio and tensor-polarized experiments are under preparation for the deuteron at JLab. We hope that such effects will be confirmed experimentally for not only for the deuteron but also for larger nuclei.

The 26th international symposium on spin physics (SPIN2025)

21–26 September, 2025

Qingdao (Tsingtao), Shandong Province, China

Introduction

Until the end of 1970’s, nuclear modifications of structure functions were considered negligible because the average binding energies and Fermi momenta are small in comparison with a typical energy scale of deep inelastic scattering (DIS). Therefore, it was rather surprising that the European Muon Collaboration (EMC) found significant nuclear effects in the structure function F2NF_2^N, where NN indicates the nucleon, in 1983. Such a nuclear modification is now called the nuclear EMC effect. Because it was considered to be a big discovery as the first quark signature in nuclear phenomena, there were a flood of papers on the effect just after the EMC finding. However, a conservative theoretical interpretation in terms of nuclear binding and Fermi motion was proposed a few years later, and they could be considered as the major sources of the nuclear modifications at medium and large xx, where xx is the Bjorken scaling variable. There should be also internal nucleon modification effects within the nuclear medium, but it is not straightforward to separate them from the binding and Fermi-motion effects experimentally. Now, there are many experimental data on F2AF_2^A, where AA indicates a nucleus, from small xx to large xx and from the deuteron to a large nucleus. There are various theoretical works to interpret the nuclear modifications of F2NF_2^N.

The structure function F2N,AF_2^{N,A} contains both longitudinal and transverse components. For the longitudinal-transverse structure-function ratio RN=FLN/(2xF1N)R_N=F_L^N/(2xF_1^N), one usually assumes that there is no nuclear modification even now. In the past, this issue was discussed extensively around the year of 2000. However, there were no nuclear effect in the charged-lepton data in 2003 [1], the neutrino DIS data in 2001 [2], and the JLab (Thomas Jefferson National Accelerator Facility) analysis in 2007 [3]. On the other hand, there was a theoretical proposal that nuclear modifications should exist in 2003 [4] despite the negative experimental results. The reason is the following. The longitudinal and transverse structure functions for the nucleon are defined by taking the virtual-photon momentum direction along the zz axis with the nucleon at rest or in the center-of-momentum frame. For a nuclear target, they are defined in the same way. However, a nucleon in the nucleus moves in any space direction, so that the longitudinal and transverse structure functions mix in the nucleus. Because this mechanism is associated with the transverse motion of the nucleon, such effects are expected to be proportional to p⃗T 2/Q2\vec{p}_T^{\,2}/Q^2.

It is worth to bring this nuclear-modification topic forward now [5]. In analyzing nuclear data, the nucleon’s longitudinal-transverse ratio RNR_N is used even for heavy nuclei by assuming that there is no nuclear modification. However, it is not appropriate for a precise determination of physical quantities from nuclear data because the nuclear modification certainly exists theoretically [4, 5]. Because the ratio will be measured for the deuteron at JLab in the near future [6] and the polarized deuteron experiment is under preparation [7], I show such nuclear modifications numerically for the deuteron in this work. The theoretical formalism is explained in § 2, numerical results are shown in § 3, and they are summarized in § 4.

Formalism

The lepton-hadron DIS cross section is described by the hadron tensor WμνA,N(pA,N,q)W_{\mu\nu}^{A,N}(p_{A,N},q) where pA,Np_{A,N} is the nuclear or nucleon’s momentum and qq is the momentum transfer. The hadron tensor in the charged-lepton DIS is decomposed into two structure functions W1A,NW_1^{A,N} and W2A,NW_2^{A,N} as

WμνA,N(pA,N,q)=−W1A,N(pA,N,q)(gμν−qμqνq2)+W2A,N(pA,N,q)p~A,Nμp~A,NνpA,N2.(1)W_{\mu\nu}^{A,N}(p_{A,N},q)=-W_1^{A,N}(p_{A,N},q)\left(g_{\mu\nu}-\frac{q_\mu q_\nu}{q^2}\right)+W_2^{A,N}(p_{A,N},q)\frac{\widetilde{p}_{A,N\mu}\widetilde{p}_{A,N\nu}}{p_{A,N}^2}. \tag*{(1)}

where p~μ=pμ−(p⋅q)qμ/q2\widetilde{p}_\mu=p_\mu-(p\cdot q)q_\mu/q^2. The hadron tensor with the photon helicity λ\lambda is defined by multiplying the photon polarization vector ελμ\varepsilon_\lambda^\mu as

WλA,N(pA,N,q)=ελμ∗ελνWμνA,N(pA,N,q).(2)W_\lambda^{A,N}(p_{A,N},q)=\varepsilon_\lambda^{\mu*}\varepsilon_\lambda^\nu W_{\mu\nu}^{A,N}(p_{A,N},q). \tag*{(2)}

The transverse and longitudinal structure functions WTA,NW_T^{A,N} and WLA,NW_L^{A,N} are defined by these helicity functions and also by W1A,NW_1^{A,N}, and W2A,NW_2^{A,N} as

WTA,N=Wλ=+1A,N+Wλ=−1A,N2=W1A,N,WLA,N=Wλ=0A,N=(1+νA,N2Q2)W2A,N−W1A,N.(3)W_T^{A,N}=\frac{W_{\lambda=+1}^{A,N}+W_{\lambda=-1}^{A,N}}{2}=W_1^{A,N},\qquad W_L^{A,N}=W_{\lambda=0}^{A,N}=\left(1+\frac{\nu_{A,N}^2}{Q^2}\right)W_2^{A,N}-W_1^{A,N}. \tag*{(3)}

The variables νN\nu_N and νA\nu_A are given by νA=pA⋅q/pA2=ν\nu_A=p_A\cdot q/\sqrt{p_A^2}=\nu and νN=pN⋅q/pN2\nu_N=p_N\cdot q/\sqrt{p_N^2}. In these days, structure functions F1,2,T,LF_{1,2,T,L} are usually used instead of W1,2,T,LW_{1,2,T,L}, and they are related as

F1A,N=FTA,N=pA,N2W1A,N,F2A,N=pA,N⋅qpA,N2W2A,N,F_1^{A,N}=F_T^{A,N}=\sqrt{p_{A,N}^2}W_1^{A,N},\qquad F_2^{A,N}=\frac{p_{A,N}\cdot q}{\sqrt{p_{A,N}^2}}W_2^{A,N},
FLA,N=(1+Q2νA,N2)F2A,N−2xA,NF1A,N.(4)F_L^{A,N}=\left(1+\frac{Q^2}{\nu_{A,N}^2}\right)F_2^{A,N}-2x_{A,N}F_1^{A,N}. \tag*{(4)}

Then, the longitudinal-transverse structure function ratio is calculated as

RA,N(xA,N,Q2)=FLA,N(xA,N,Q2)2xA,NF1A,N(xA,N,Q2).(5)R_{A,N}(x_{A,N},Q^2)=\frac{F_L^{A,N}(x_{A,N},Q^2)}{2x_{A,N}F_1^{A,N}(x_{A,N},Q^2)}. \tag*{(5)}

The used kinematical variables are xAx_A, xNx_N, xx, and yy defined by

xA=Q22pA⋅q,xN=Q22pN⋅q=xy,x=Q22MNν,y=pN⋅qMNν,(6)x_A=\frac{Q^2}{2p_A\cdot q},\qquad x_N=\frac{Q^2}{2p_N\cdot q}=\frac{x}{y},\qquad x=\frac{Q^2}{2M_N\nu},\qquad y=\frac{p_N\cdot q}{M_N\nu}, \tag*{(6)}

where MNM_N and MAM_A are nucleon and nuclear masses, respectively. A standard method for describing the nuclear structure functions is to use the convolution formalism with the spectral function S(pN)S(p_N) as

WμνA(pA,q)=∫d4pN S(pN)WμνN(pN,q).(7)W_{\mu\nu}^{A}(p_A,q)=\int d^4p_N\,S(p_N)W_{\mu\nu}^{N}(p_N,q). \tag*{(7)}

The technical details of this convolution formalism are explained in Refs. [8, 9]. A simple spectral function is given by the momentum-space wave function ϕi\phi_i as

S(pN)=∑i∣ϕi(p⃗N)∣2δ(pN0−MA+MA−i2+p⃗N 2).(8)S(p_N)=\sum_i|\phi_i(\vec{p}_N)|^2\delta\left(p_N^0-M_A+\sqrt{M_{A-i}^2+\vec{p}_N^{\,2}}\right). \tag*{(8)}

The summation is taken over the nucleon ii in the nucleus, and the mass factor MA−iM_{A-i} is given by the separation energy εi\varepsilon_i by εi=(MA−i+MN)−MA\varepsilon_i=(M_{A-i}+M_N)-M_A. In the following numerical analysis, the average separation energy is taken εi→⟨ε⟩\varepsilon_i \to\langle\varepsilon\rangle and the non-relativistic kinematic is assumed for the squared root in Eq. (8). Then, pN0p_N^0 and ⟨ε⟩\langle\varepsilon\rangle are related by pN0=MN−⟨ε⟩−p⃗N 2/(2MA−1)p_N^0 = M_N - \langle\varepsilon\rangle- \vec{p}_N^{\,2}/(2M_{A-1}) with the replacement MA−i→MA−1M_{A-i} \to M_{A-1}. Next, multiplying the projection operators of W1,2AW_{1,2}^{A} and converting them to F1,2,LF_{1,2,L}, we have the nuclear structure functions expressed by the nucleon ones as

\begin{pmatrix} F_2^A(x_A,Q^2) \\ 2x_A F_1^A(x_A,Q^2) \\ F_L^A(x_A,Q^2) \end{pmatrix} = \int_{x}^{A} \mathrm{d}y \begin{pmatrix} f_{22}(y) & 0 & 0 \\ 0 & f_{11}(y) & f_{1L}(y) \\ 0 & f_{L1}(y) & f_{LL}(y) \end{pmatrix} \begin{pmatrix} F_2^N(x/y,Q^2) \\ 2\frac{x}{y}F_1^N(x/y,Q^2) \\ F_L^N(x/y,Q^2) \end{pmatrix}. \tag*{(9)}\end{pmatrix}

The nucleon’s lightcone momentum distributions f22f_{22}, fLLf_{LL}, f11f_{11}, fL1f_{L1}, and f1Lf_{1L} in the nucleus are given

f22(y)=∫0∞dpN⊥ 2πpN⊥yMNν∣q⃗∣∣ϕ(p⃗N)∣2[2(x/y)2pN∥2(1+Q2/ν2)Q2+(1+2(x/y)pN∥Q2+ν2)2],f_{22}(y) = \int_{0}^{\infty} \mathrm{d}p_{N\perp}\,2\pi p_{N\perp}y\frac{M_N\nu}{|\vec{q}|}|\phi(\vec{p}_N)|^2\left[\frac{2(x/y)^2p_{N\parallel}^2}{(1+Q^2/\nu^2)Q^2}+\left(1+\frac{2(x/y)p_{N\parallel}}{\sqrt{Q^2+\nu^2}}\right)^2\right],
fLL(y)=f11(y)=∫0∞dpN⊥ 2πpN⊥yMNν∣q⃗∣∣ϕ(p⃗N)∣2(1+p⃗N⊥ 2p⃗N 2),f_{LL}(y)=f_{11}(y)=\int_{0}^{\infty}\mathrm{d}p_{N\perp}\,2\pi p_{N\perp}y\frac{M_N\nu}{|\vec{q}|}|\phi(\vec{p}_N)|^2\left(1+\frac{\vec{p}_{N\perp}^{\,2}}{\vec{p}_N^{\,2}}\right),
fL1(y)=f1L(y)=∫0∞dpN⊥ 2πpN⊥yMNν∣q⃗∣∣ϕ(p⃗N)∣2p⃗N⊥ 2p⃗N 2.(10)f_{L1}(y)=f_{1L}(y)=\int_{0}^{\infty}\mathrm{d}p_{N\perp}\,2\pi p_{N\perp}y\frac{M_N\nu}{|\vec{q}|}|\phi(\vec{p}_N)|^2\frac{\vec{p}_{N\perp}^{\,2}}{\vec{p}_N^{\,2}}. \tag*{(10)}

The momentum p~μ\widetilde{p}_\mu squared is given by Q2Q^2 as

p~N 2=Q24xN2(1+4xN2pN2Q2)≃Q24xN2(1+4xN2MN2Q2).(11)\widetilde{p}_N^{\,2}=\frac{Q^2}{4x_N^2}\left(1+\frac{4x_N^2p_N^2}{Q^2}\right)\simeq\frac{Q^2}{4x_N^2}\left(1+\frac{4x_N^2M_N^2}{Q^2}\right). \tag*{(11)}

The longitudinal and transverse structure functions mix with each other, and the mixture coefficient is proportional to p⃗N⊥ 2/p⃗N 2∼pN⊥ 2/Q2\vec{p}_{N\perp}^{\,2}/\vec{p}_N^{\,2}\sim p_{N\perp}^{\,2}/Q^2. Therefore, the structure-function mixture between F1NF_1^N and FLNF_L^N in Eq. (9) does not occur in the scaling limit Q2→∞Q^2\to\infty. Now, the theoretical tool is ready to calculate the nuclear structure functions by Eq. (9) and the longitudinal-transverse ratio RAR_A by Eq. (5).

Results

In order to calculate the nuclear modifications for the deuteron, it is necessary to supply the deuteron wave functions ϕi\phi_i and the structure function F1NF_1^N, which is given by F1N(xN,Q2)=(1+Q2/νN2)F2N(xN,Q2)/[2xN{1+RN(xN,Q2)}]F_1^N(x_N,Q^2)=(1+Q^2/\nu_N^2)F_2^N(x_N,Q^2)/[2x_N\{1+R_N(x_N,Q^2)\}]. In the leading order of the QCD running coupling constant αs\alpha_s, F2NF_2^N is calculated by using unpolarized PDFs of MSTW08. As for RNR_N, the SLAC parametrization of 1990 is used. As for the deuteron’s ϕi\phi_i, the Bonn wave function is used. Calculating Eqs. (9) and (10), we obtain the nuclear modifications in Figure 1 at Q2=5 GeV2Q^2=5\ \mathrm{GeV}^2. The nuclear modifications due to the nuclear binding and Fermi motion, which are contained within the spectral function of Eq. (8), are well investigated in F2AF_2^A. The negative modifications at medium xx (∼0.4\sim0.4) come mainly from the nuclear binding, and the steep positive rises at large xx (∼0.7\sim0.7) are caused by the nucleon’s Fermi motion in the nucleus. The structure function F2AF_2^A has both longitudinal and transverse components. The nuclear modifications of the transverse component

Nuclear modifications of $F_1^N$, $F_2^N$, and $F_L^N$ for the deuteron at $Q^2=5\ \mathrm{GeV}^2$

Figure 1. Nuclear modifications of F1NF_1^N, F2NF_2^N, and FLNF_L^N for the deuteron at Q2=5 GeV2Q^2=5\ \mathrm{GeV}^2.

F1NF_1^N are similar to the one of F2NF_2^N in Figure 1. However, the modifications of the longitudinal component FLNF_L^N are very different from the ones of F2NF_2^N.

Next, nuclear modifications of the longitudinal-transverse structure-function ratio RNR_N are calculated by using Eq. (5), and the results are shown in Figure 2 at Q2=1Q^2=1, 10, and 100 GeV2\mathrm{GeV}^2. The dashed curves are obtained by terminating the mixing terms, namely by taking p⃗N⊥ 2/p⃗N 2→0\vec{p}_{N\perp}^{\,2}/\vec{p}_N^{\,2}\to0 in fLL(y)f_{LL}(y), f11(y)f_{11}(y), fL1(y)f_{L1}(y), and f1L(y)f_{1L}(y), and by taking [⋯ ]→1[\cdots]\to1 in f2(y)f_2(y). The differences between the solid and dashed curves become smaller as Q2Q^2 increases because it comes from the longitudinal-transverse admixture proportional to p⃗N⊥ 2/Q2\vec{p}_{N\perp}^{\,2}/Q^2. However, the modifications themselves are not small even at Q2=100 GeV2Q^2=100\ \mathrm{GeV}^2. Although the nucleon momentum distributions are similar in both longitudinal and transverse cases in Eq. (10), the xx-dependent functions are very different between the longitudinal and transverse structure functions, which leads to the modifications even without the mixture as shown by the dashed curves at Q2=100 GeV2Q^2=100\ \mathrm{GeV}^2. From these results, we find that there are two major factors in the nuclear modifications of RNR_N in the convolution formalism:

Nuclear modifications of $R_N$ for the deuteron at $Q^2=1$, 10, and 100 $\mathrm{GeV}^2$

Figure 2. Nuclear modifications of RNR_N for the deuteron at Q2=1Q^2=1, 10, and 100 GeV2\mathrm{GeV}^2.

  1. One is the admixture of the longitudinal and transverse structure functions of the nucleon.

  2. The other is that the xx-dependent functional forms are different between the longitudinal and transverse structure functions, which results in the differences after the convolution integral.

In this work, I did not discuss the small-xx region, where a different physics mechanism contributes, and my studies are focused on the medium- and large-xx regions, where the convolution model works. In general, the nuclear modifications are large at small Q2Q^2 and a typical effect is of the order of a few percent in the deuteron, although it depends much on xx. As xx becomes large, the nuclear effect becomes large. In general, it is not a large effect in the deuteron in Figure 2. However, it should become larger as the nucleus becomes larger. In addition, there are higher-twist effects and target-mass corrections at large xx [5], so that these effects should be considered as well as the nuclear corrections of RNR_N.

Although it has been assumed that the nuclear modification does not exist for the longitudinal-transverse structure-function ratio RNR_N, it certainly exists as shown in this work. In analyzing nuclear cross sections, one needs to be careful to take into account such modifications. The deuteron experiments are under preparation at JLab, one needs to be careful about such nuclear effects. In general, if the target is a heavy nucleus, one should consider them in analyzing cross sections.

Summary

It was shown numerically that the nuclear modifications should exist in the deuteron for the longitudinal-transverse structure-function ratio RNR_N by using the standard convolution model. In particular, the transverse motion of a nucleon in a nucleus gives rise to the mixture of the longitudinal and transverse structure functions with the probability proportional to p⃗N⊥ 2/Q2\vec{p}_{N\perp}^{\,2}/Q^2, which is one of sources of the nuclear modifications of RNR_N. Another source is the difference of the xx-dependent functional forms between the longitudinal and transverse structure functions in the convolution integral. The nuclear modifications are large at small Q2Q^2, of the order of a few GeV2\mathrm{GeV}^2, and at large xx. The modifications are typically a few percent in the deuteron, but they should be larger as the nucleus becomes larger. In analyzing nuclear cross sections, one need to be careful about such nuclear effects for a precise determination of physical quantities. We also hope that the nuclear modification of RNR_N will be found experimentally.

References

  1. [1]K. Ackerstaff et al. (HERMES Collaboration), Phys. Lett. B 475 (2000) 386; A. Airapetian et al., Erratum: Phys. Lett. B 567 (2003) 339.
  2. [2]U. K. Yang et al. (CCFR/NuTeV Collaboration), Phys. Rev. Lett. 87 (2001) 251802.
  3. [3]V. Tvaskis et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 98 (2007) 2003.
  4. [4]M. Ericson and S. Kumano, Phys. Rev. C 67 (2003) 022201.
  5. [5]S. Kumano, Phys. Rev. C 113 (2026) 015206.
  6. [6]R. Ent et al., Update of JLab proposal E12-06-104 (2010).
  7. [7]J. Poudel, A. Bacchetta, J.-P. Chen, and N. Santiesteban, Euro. Phys. J. A 61 (2025) 81.
  8. [8]M. Hirai, S. Kumano, K. Saito, and T. Watanabe, Phys. Rev. C 83 (2011) 035202.
  9. [9]W. Cosyn, Yu-Bing Dong, S. Kumano, and M. Sargsian, Phys. Rev. D 95 (2017) 074036.

Paper details

vlnc:W_zkfn7kd5
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents