In this paper, First, we prove that for every topological MV-algebra the topology is induced by a uniformity. As a application, we obtain that every topological MV-algebra is completely regular and every T0 first countable topological MV-algebra is metrizable. Second, we study the completion of the canonical difference uniformity in topological MV-algebra. Finally, we construct some examples show that not all topological MV-algebras are canonically completable and the property of canonically completable topological MV-algebra does not imply local order convexity.
Introduction
MV-algebras were introduced by Chang [3] as an algebraic framework for infinite-valued Łukasiewicz logic. They extend Boolean algebras by allowing truth values to vary beyond the classical two-valued setting. The development of the subject revealed a close connection between many-valued logic and ordered algebra. In particular, Mundici’s representation theorem [10] establishes a categorical equivalence between MV-algebras and abelian lattice-ordered groups with a strong unit. Under this equivalence, an MV-algebra is represented as an interval Γ(G,u)=[0,u] in such a group, with x⊕y=(x+y)∧u and ¬x=u−x. This correspondence provides a structural foundation for the subject; a systematic account of MV-algebras and their logical and order-theoretic aspects can be found in [4].
A natural question is how this algebraic structure constrains a topology for which the MV-operations are continuous. More generally, topological MV-algebras bring together algebraic operations, lattice order, and convergence, and make it possible to study the extent to which familiar principles of topological algebra persist in a setting governed by truncated addition. Hoo initiated the systematic study of topological MV-algebras in [6]. His work investigated topologies constructed from ideals, including I-adic topologies and their completions, and established basic interactions between algebraic and topological properties. An important separation result from this early theory is that the axioms T0, T1, and T2 are equivalent for topological MV-algebras. Subsequent work developed the relationships among neighborhood systems, order, and uniform structures. Weber [13] proved that the topology of a topological MV-algebra is determined by its neighborhoods of 0, and studied the relation between local convexity and uniform MV-algebras.
The study of filter topologies further clarified the role of algebraic compatibility. Luan, Weber, and Yang [8] characterized when a filter topology turns an MV-algebra into a topological MV-algebra and, under those conditions, related it to a uniform MV-algebra. Their results also show why continuity requirements must be stated carefully: a filter topology need not make the binary MV-operation jointly continuous. These investigations provide substantial information about particular constructions and about topologies with additional order properties. They also lead to a broader question concerning an arbitrary topology already known to make the MV-operations continuous: must the underlying topological space admit a compatible uniformity?
There is a strong precedent for a positive answer in the theory of topological groups. The group operations canonically generate left and right uniformities, and the resulting uniform structures explain the complete regularity of topological groups. Moreover, the Birkhoff–Kakutani metrization theorem asserts that a Hausdorff topological group is metrizable precisely when it is first countable [1]. For MV-algebras, however, these conclusions cannot simply be transferred through the algebraic interval representation. The operation ⊕ is truncated addition, and its translations are generally not invertible. In addition, Mundici’s algebraic equivalence does not by itself supply a compatible topological group structure for a given topology on the interval. Uniformizability and metrization therefore require a topological argument that takes account of the MV-structure.
Recent results have brought the separation problem into sharper focus. Gan, Luan, Deng, and Yang [5] proved that every topological MV-algebra is regular. Together with the earlier separation theorem, this yields the equivalence of T0, T1, T2, and T3 in this class. Regularity, however, does not in general imply complete regularity, so the existence of enough continuous real-valued functions to separate points from closed sets requires a further argument. Li and Yang [7] subsequently proved that every locally convex topological MV-algebra is uniformizable and hence completely regular. Their theorem establishes the desired conclusion under an additional order-theoretic hypothesis and makes it natural to ask whether that hypothesis is needed for the underlying space to be uniformizable.
The purpose of this paper is to establish uniformizability on every topological MV-algebra and to obtain the corresponding separation and metrization theorems. The paper organize as follows: In Section 2, we establish some basic facts. Section 3 prove that for every topological MV-algebra the topology is induced by a uniformity. As a application, we obtain that every topological MV-algebra is completely regular and every T0 first countable topological MV-algebra is metrizable. In Section 4, we study the completion of the canonical difference uniformity in topological MV-algebra. We mainly prove that a Hausdorff topological MV-algebra A is canonically completable if and only if the operation ⊕:(A,UA)2→(A,UA) is Cauchy continuous, where the domain carries the product uniformity; when this holds, the topological MV-algebra structure on A extending that of A is unique; its canonical difference uniformity equals the completion uniformity UA, so A is canonically complete (see Theorem 4.5). § 6 constructs some examples show that not all topological MV-algebras are canonically completable and the property of canonically completable topological MV-algebra does not imply local order convexity.
Preliminaries
Definition 2.1.[3, 4] An MV-algebra is an algebra (A,⊕,∗,0), where (A,⊕,0) is an abelian monoid and ∗ is a unary operation on A such that for all x,y∈A,
(MV1) x∗∗=x;
(MV2) x⊕0∗=0∗;
(MV3) (x∗⊕y)∗⊕y=(y∗⊕x)∗⊕x.
Given an MV-algebra (A,⊕,∗,0), for each x,y∈A we define:
1:=0∗,x⊙y:=(x∗⊕y∗)∗,x⊖y:=x⊙y∗.(1)
For any x,y∈A, we define x≤y if and only if x⊖y=0. We call this order a natural order on A.
Proposition 2.2.[4 Proposition 1.1.5] On each MV-algebra A the natural order determines a lattice structure. Specifically, the join x∨y and the meet x∧y of the elements x and y are given by
(a) x∨y=(x⊙y∗)⊕y=(x⊖y)⊕y;
(b) x∧y=(x∗∨y∗)∗=x⊙(x∗⊕y).
Example 2.3. Let [0,1]={x∈R∣0≤x≤1} and for each x,y∈[0,1] define by:
x⊕y:=min{1,x+y},x∗:=1−x.
Then ([0,1],⊕,∗,0) is an MV-algebra, known as the standard MV-algebra.
Lemma 2.4. Let A be an MV-algebra. For any x,y,z∈A, the following statements hold:
This proves the first coordinate of (5). Interchanging x and z, and using commutativity of ⊕, proves the second coordinate. The assertion about Φ((0,0),(0,0))=(0,0) follows immediately from (4).
Compatible uniformity on every topological MV-algebra
We begin by introducing some notations. Let X be a set and let A and B be subsets of X×X, i.e. relations on the set X. The inverse relation of A will be denoted by −A, i.e., −A={(x,y):(y,x)∈A}. The composition of A and B will be denoted by A+B, i.e., A+B={(x,z):there is a y∈X such that (x,y)∈A and (y,z)∈B}. 2A means that A+A.
The diagonal of the Cartesian product X×X is the set ΔX={(x,x):x∈X}. Every set V⊆X×X that contains ΔX and satisfies the condition V=−V is called an entourage of diagonal. The family of all entourages of diagonal will be denoted by DX. Let x0 be a point in X and let V∈DX. The set V[x0]={x∈X:(x0,x)∈V} is called the ball with centerx0 and radiusV.
A uniformity [2] on a set X is a subfamily U⊆DX which satisfies the following conditions:
(U1) If V∈U and V⊆W∈DX, then W∈U.
(U2) If V1,V2∈U, then V1∩V2∈U.
(U3) For every V∈U, there exists a W∈U such that 2W⊆V.
A uniformity U on a set X is called a separated uniformity if U satisfies the condition: (U4)⋂U=ΔX.
A subfamily B⊆U is called a base for the uniformity U if for every V∈U there exists a W∈B such that W⊆V.
The following result is well known.
Theorem 3.1.[2 Theorem 8.1.1] For every uniformity U on a set X the family O={U⊆X:for every x∈U there is a V∈U such that V[x]⊆U} is a topology on the set.
The topology O is called the topology induced by the uniformityU. A topological space X with a topology T is (pseudo)metrizable if the topology T is induced by a (pseudo)metric d on the set X.
Definition 3.2.[6] A topological MV-algebra is an MV-algebra A equipped with a topology such that
⊕:A×A⟶A,∗:A⟶A
are continuous. Then the term operations ⊙,⊖,∨,∧ are also continuous.
Let N0 denote the collection of open neighborhoods of zero in a topological MV-algebra A.
Theorem 3.3. Let A be a topological MV-algebra. For U∈N0, put
EU={(x,y)∈A2:δ(x,y)∈U×U}, where δ is defined by (3).(6)
Then {EU:U∈N0} is a base for the uniformity UA={D∈DA:EU⊆D for some U∈N0 such that EU⊆D} inducing the given topology of A. If A is T0, then UA is a separated uniformity.
Proof. Firstly, we show that UA is a uniformity on A.
For (U1). It is trivial.
For (U2). This follows from the fact EU∩EV=EU∩V holds for each U,V∈N0.
For (U3). Let Φ:A2×A2→A2 be defined by (4), that is,
Φ((a,b),(c,d))=((a⊖d)⊕(c⊖b),(b⊖c)⊕(d⊖a))
for each ((a,b),(c,d))∈A2×A2. Since A is a topological MV-algebra, Φ is continuous on A2×A2, which is endowed the the product topology. Take any D∈UA. Then there is U∈N0 such that EU⊆D. By Lemma 2.6, there is an open neighborhood V of 0 such that
Φ((V×V)×(V×V))⊆U×U,
because Φ((0,0),(0,0))=(0,0). If (x,y),(y,z)∈EV, identity (5) now gives δ(x,z)∈U×U. Hence 2EV⊆EU, as required. Clearly, {EU:U∈N0} is a base for the uniformity UA.
Secondly, we shall prove that UA induce the given topology of A. In fact, since A is a topological MV-algebra, for each fix a∈A, the left translation ρa:A→A defined by ρa(x)=a⊖x for each x∈A is continuous. Similarly, the right translation ρa:A→A defined by λa(x)=x⊖a for each x∈A is continuous. Thus,
EU[a]={b∈A:a⊖b∈U,b⊖a∈U}=ρa−1(U)∩λa−1(U).
is an open neighborhood of a in the original topology for each U∈N0. This implies that the original topology on A is finer than the topology induced by UA.
Conversely, let O be an original open neighborhood of a. Define
ϑa:A2→A
by ϑa(x,y)=(a⊖x)⊕y for each (x,y)∈A2. Clearly, ϑa is continuous and ϑa(0,0)=a. Choose U∈N0 with ϑa(U×U)⊆O. For x∈EU[a], Lemma 2.5(e) yields
x=(a⊖(a⊖x))⊕(x⊖a)=ϑa(a⊖x,x⊖a)∈O.
Thus EU[a]⊆O. The sets EU[a] are consequently a neighborhood base for the original topology at every a. This implies that the topology induced by UA is finer than the original topology on A. Thus we have proved that UA induces the given topology of A.
If A is T0, then A is Hausdorff by [5 Corollary 3.10]. Hence, ⋂U∈N0U={0}, so membership in every EU forces both directional differences to be zero and hence x=y. This implies that the condition: (U4)⋂UA=ΔA holds. □
Definition 3.4
A topological space X is called
(a) a T0 space if for every pair of distinct points x,y∈X, there exists an open set U∈τ such that exactly one of x and y belongs to U;
(b) a T1-space if for any distinct points x,y∈X the point x has a neighborhood Ux⊆X such that y∈/Ux;
(c) a T2-space if for any distinct points x,y∈X the point x has a neighborhood Ux⊆X such that y∈/Ux;
(d) regular if for any point x∈X and a neighborhood Ox⊆X of x there is a neighborhood Ux⊆X of x such that Ux⊆Ox;
(e) a T3-space if X is a regular T1-space;
(f) completely regular if for every closed set F⊆X and every point x∈X\F, there exists a continuous function f:X→[0,1] such that f(x)=0 and f(y)=1 for all y∈F;
(g) a Tychonoff space is a completely regular T1 space.
Corollary 3.5.Every topological MV-algebra is completely regular.
Proof. Since every topological space the topology of which is induced by a uniformity is completely regular [2], the statement follows from Theorem 3.3.
Corollary 3.6.Let A be a topological MV-algebra. Then the following statements are equivalent:
(a) A is a T0 space;
(b) A is a T1 space;
(c) A is a T2 space;
(d) A is a T3 space;
(e) A is a Tychonoff space.
Proof. The equivalences of (a)-(d) follows from [5 Corollary 3.10]. Since every T3 topological space the topology of which is induced by a uniformity is Tychonoff space[2 Corollary 8.1.13], the statement follows from Theorem 3.3.
Lemma 3.7.[2 Theorem 8.1.21]A uniformity U on a set X is induced by a metric on X if and only if U is separated with a countable base.
Corollary 3.8.Every T0, first countable topological MV-algebra is metrizable.
The completion of the canonical difference uniformity in topological MV-algebra
In this section, we assume that every topological MV-algebra is Hausdorff. In this section, we study the Hausdorff completion of the compatible uniformity on a topological MV-algebra defined in Theorem 3.3. We call this uniformity the canonical difference uniformity on a topological MV-algebra. Denote the canonical difference uniformity on a topological MV-algebra A by UA.
Let (X,U) be a uniform space. A family F of subsets in X is Cauchy if, for every entourage E∈U, some F∈F satisfies F×F⊆E. A filter (resp. a filter basis) F is called a Cauchy filter (resp. a Cauchy filter basis) if F is Cauchy [11 0.34 Definition]. A uniform space (X,U) is called complete if every U-Cauchy filter on (X,U) converges to some x in (X,U). Let both (X,UX) and (Y,UY) be uniform spaces. A map f:(X,UX)→(Y,UY) is called uniformly continuous if for every M∈UY there exists N∈UX such that (f(x),f(y))∈M for each (x,y)∈N, where f is called a uniform equivalence if f is bijective and both f:(X,UX)→(Y,UY) and its inverse f−1:(Y,UY)→(X,UX) are uniformly continuous [11, 0.14 Definition]. A map f:(X,UX)→(Y,UY) is called a uniform embedding if the induced map (X,UX)→(f(X),UY∣f(X)), x↦f(x) is a uniform equivalence [11 0.43 Definition]. A map f:(X,UX)→(Y,UY) is Cauchy continuous if it sends Cauchy filters to Cauchy filter basises. A completion of a uniform space (X,UX) is a pair ((Y,UY),i) consisting of a complete uniform space (Y,UY) and a uniform embedding i:(X,UX)→(Y,UY) such that i(X) is dense in Y[11 0.44 Definition]. For each Hausdorff uniform space (X,UX) there is a unique Hausdorff completion ((X,UX),i) of (X,UX) in the sense of uniform equivalence [11 0.48 Theorem, 0.51 Proposition]. In this section, the term “completion of (X,UX)” will then also be applied to the space (X,UX) and, still more abusively, to the set X.
Lemma 4.1. Let X be dense in a Hausdorff uniform space Z, let Y be a complete Hausdorff uniform space, and let f:X→Y be continuous. Then f has a unique continuous extension f:Z→Y if f is Cauchy continuous.
Proof. Assume f is Cauchy continuous. For p∈Z, the traces on X of neighborhoods of p generate a Cauchy filter Fp in X. The image f(Fp) is a Cauchy filter basis, and therefore has a unique limit in Y, because Y is a complete Hausdorff uniform space. Define
f(p)=limf(Fp).
For p∈X, continuity of f shows that this is f(p).
To check the continuity of f, let W be an open neighborhood of f(p). Choose a closed neighborhood C of f(p) contained in W, using the regularity of Y. There is an open neighborhood O of p in Z with f(O∩X)⊆C. For every q∈O, the filter basis f(Fq) is eventually in C, so its limit belongs to C. Hence f(O)⊆C⊆W. Uniqueness follows because X is dense and Y is Hausdorff. □
Proposition 4.2. A continuous MV-homomorphism f:A→B is uniformly continuous from (A,UA) to (B,UB). If A is an MV-subalgebra of B with the subspace topology, then UA=UB∣A×A.
Proof. Given a zero-neighborhood U in B, choose a zero-neighborhood V in A with f(V)⊆U. Since f preserves directional differences, (f×f)(EV)⊆EU. For a subalgebra, the identities EUB∩A2=EU∩AA and the description of subspace zero-neighborhoods prove the second assertion. □
Lemma 4.3. Suppose two uniformities on a set Y induce the same topology and have the same restriction to a dense subset X. Then the two uniformities are equal.
Proof. Let E be a closed entourage for the first uniformity. Equality of the restrictions gives an entourage F of the second uniformity with F∩X2⊆E∩X2. Choose a product-topologically open entourage G⊆F for the second uniformity. Such entourages form a base, and the product topology is the same for both uniformities. Density of X2 gives
G⊆G∩X2⊆E.
Thus E is also an entourage of the second uniformity. Closed entourages form a base for every uniformity, so the first uniformity is contained in the second. Interchanging them proves the reverse containment. □
Definition 4.4. A Hausdorff topological MV-algebra A is canonically complete if its canonical difference uniformity is complete. It is canonically completable if the completion A of the uniform space (A,UA) is a topological MV-algebra containing A as an MV-subalgebra.
Here A carries its uniform completion topology, and the containment is understood through the canonical uniform embedding jA:A→A: the operations on A must restrict to those of A.
From now on a topological MV-algebra A is Hausdorff and A means the completion of (A,UA), with completion uniformity UA.
Theorem 4.5. A Hausdorff topological MV-algebra A is canonically completable if and only if the operation ⊕:(A,UA)2→(A,UA) is Cauchy continuous, where the domain carries the product uniformity. When this holds, the topological MV-algebra structure on A extending that of A is unique. Its canonical difference uniformity equals the completion uniformity UA, so A is canonically complete.
Proof. Identify A with its image under jA, and write UA for the uniformity of its Hausdorff completion. Thus A is a dense uniform subspace of A.
Necessity. Suppose that A is canonically completable, and denote the continuous addition on its completion by ⊕. Let F be a Cauchy filter on (A,UA)2. The product (A,UA)2 is complete. The image of F under the uniform embedding
jA×jA:A×A↪A×A
therefore converges to some (p,q)∈A×A. Joint continuity gives
⊕(F)⟶p⊕qin A.
Since every convergent family on a uniform space is Cauchy [11 Proposition 0.35], ⊕(F) is a Cauchy filter basis in A. Because ⊕ restricts to ⊕ and UA∣A×A=UA, it follows that ⊕(F)=⊕(F) is a Cauchy filter basis in (A,UA). This proves Cauchy continuity.
Sufficiency. Assume that ⊕ is Cauchy continuous. The identities
x∗⊕y∗=y⊕x,y∗⊕x∗=x⊕y
give, for every zero-neighborhood U,
(x,y)∈EU⟺(x∗,y∗)∈EU.
Thus the involution is a uniform isomorphism of (A,UA) onto itself. The extension theorem for uniformly continuous maps into complete Hausdorff uniform spaces gives a unique uniformly continuous map ∗:A→A with ∗∣A=∗. Both ∗∘∗ and the identity map are continuous and agree on the dense subset A; hence ∗∘∗=idA.
Assume ⊕:(A,UA)2→(A,UA) is Cauchy continuous. Then so is ⊕:(A,UA)2→(A,UA), because UA∣A×A=UA. Since A×A is dense in the uniform space A×A and A is a complete Hausdorff uniform space, applying Lemma 4.1 to ⊕:A×A→A there is a unique continuous extension ⊕:A×A→A of ⊕.
Put 0=jA(0). Every term formed from ⊕, ∗, 0 defines a continuous map on the appropriate finite power of A. For an MV-identity in n variables, its two term maps
agree on An, because the operations restrict to those of A. The set on which two continuous maps into a Hausdorff space agree is closed. Since An is dense in An, the identity holds throughout An. In particular, for p,q,r∈A, we obtain
These are all the defining MV-axioms. Consequently (A,⊕,∗,0) is a Hausdorff topological MV-algebra, and jA is an MV-embedding. Definition 4.4 now shows that A is canonically completable.
Two continuous extensions of addition agree on the dense set A2, and two continuous extensions of the involution agree on the dense set A. Since A is Hausdorff, the respective extensions agree everywhere; the zero is forced to be jA(0). This proves uniqueness.
Let V be the canonical difference uniformity of the resulting topological MV-algebra A. By Theorem 3.3, it induces the completion topology. Since A is a topological MV-subalgebra, Proposition 4.2 gives
V∣A2=UA=UA∣A2.
The two uniformities therefore induce the same topology and have the same restriction to the dense subset A. Lemma 4.3 yields V=UA. As the latter is complete, A is canonically complete.
Corollary 4.6. Let A be a canonically completable topological MV-algebra. Every continuous MV-homomorphism f:A⟶B into a canonically complete Hausdorff topological MV-algebra extends uniquely to a continuous MV-homomorphism f:A⟶B. Moreover, A is canonically completable if and only if it admits a topological MV-embedding into some canonically complete Hausdorff topological MV-algebra.
Proof. By Theorem 4.5, A is a canonically complete topological MV-algebra extending A. By Proposition 4.2, f is uniformly continuous, so it extends uniquely to a uniformly continuous map f:A⟶B by [2 Theorem 8.3.10]. Preservation of the operations follows by continuity and density.
One direction of the embedding assertion follows by taking A. Conversely, identify A with a topological MV-subalgebra of a canonically complete algebra B. Its closure C in B is a subalgebra [6 Theorem 3.5]. It is a closed uniform subspace of a complete space [11 Proposition 0.39], hence complete. By Proposition 4.2, its canonical uniformity is the subspace uniformity from B, and A is uniformly dense in C. Thus C realizes the uniform completion of A and supplies the required continuous operations.
According to [9], a subset V of a partially ordered set is order convex if a,b∈V and a≤x≤b imply x∈V. A topology is locally order convex if every point has a neighborhood base consisting of order convex sets. Let A be a MV-algebra and $V is a subset of A. V is called a downward closed set if z≤v for some v∈V, then z∈V.
Theorem 4.7. For a Hausdorff topological MV-algebra A, the following are equivalent:
(a) A is locally order convex;
(b) zero has a neighborhood base of downward closed sets;
(c) ⊕:(A,UA)2⟶(A,UA) is uniformly continuous, where the domain carries the product uniformity;
(d) the MV-operations extend to uniformly continuous operations on (A,UA).
When this holds, A is canonically completable and its completion A is again locally order convex.
Proof. An order convex set containing zero is downward closed, so (a) implies (b). Assume (b). For each a∈A given a neighborhood O of a, choose an open zero-neighborhood U with EU[a]⊆O, using Theorem 3.3. Choose a downward closed zero-neighborhood V⊆U. Then EV[a] is a neighborhood of a and EV[a]⊆EU[a]⊆O. If b,c∈EV[a] and b≤z≤c, using commutativity of ⊙, the definition of ⊖ by (1) and Lemma 2.4(c) gives
a⊖z≤a⊖b∈V,z⊖a≤c⊖a∈V.
Thus z∈EV[a] and EV[a] is order convex neighborhood, proving (a).
(b) ⇒ (c). Take any a,b,c,d∈A. First note the MV-inequality
(a⊕c)⊖(b⊕d)≤(a⊖b)⊕(c⊖d).(7)
Indeed, a≤b⊕(a⊖b) and c≤d⊕(c⊖d). Adding and applying Lemma 2.4(a) proves the inequality.
Given a zero-neighborhood U, choose a downward closed zero-neighborhood W⊆U. Continuity at (0,0) provides an open zero-neighborhood V with V⊕V⊆W. If (a,b),(c,d)∈EV, then a⊖b,b⊖a∈V and c⊖d,d⊖c∈V. Hence,
(a⊖b)⊕(c⊖d)∈V⊕V⊆W
Thus, by (7) and W being downward closed,
(a⊕c)⊖(b⊕d)∈W⊆U
Similarly, we have (b⊕d)⊖(a⊕c)∈U. This implies that ((a⊕c),(b⊕d))∈EU. This is uniform continuity.
(c) ⇒ (b). The identities
x∗⊖y∗=y⊖x,y∗⊖x∗=x⊖y
give, for every zero-neighborhood U,
(x,y)∈EU⟺(x∗,y∗)∈EU.
Thus, the involution is always uniformly continuous, so every MV-term, in particular ∧, is uniformly continuous. Given a zero-neighborhood U, choose an open zero-neighborhood V such that
(x,x′),(z,z′)∈EV⟹(x∧z,x′∧z′)∈EU.
For x∈V, the pair (x,0) lies in EV; and (z,z)∈EV for every z. Therefore x∧z∈U, which implies that ↓V⊆U, where ↓V={y∈A:y≤x for some x∈V}. Clearly, V⊆↓V. Consequently, the downward closed set ↓V is a zero-neighborhood. This proves (b).
Condition (c), together with uniform continuity of the involution, gives uniformly continuous extensions of the basic operations to the completions by [2 Theorem 8.3.10]. The MV-identities pass to the completion as in Theorem 4.5; hence (d). Conversely, restricting a uniformly continuous extension gives (c). Finally, Theorem 4.5 identifies the completion uniformity with the completed algebra’s canonical uniformity. Applying (c) implies (a) to that algebra proves the last assertion.
The relationship in Theorem 4.7 is consistent with the established theory of lattice and MV-uniformities [7, 12, 13]. It is stronger than the continuous-extension criterion of Theorem 4.5. § 6 demonstrates that the two criteria are genuinely different even for a countable Boolean algebra.
Let (X,U) be a uniform space. (X,U) is called totally bounded if for each U∈U, there is a finite set F⊆X such that X=⋃x∈FU[x].
Corollary 4.8. Let A be a Hausdorff topological MV-algebra such that the uniform space (A,UA) is totally bounded. Then A is canonically completable if and only if A is locally order convex. In this case its canonical completion is a compact Hausdorff topological MV-algebra.
Proof. Assume that A is locally order convex. Then it follows that A is canonically completable from Theorem 4.7.
Conversely, Since the completion of a totally bounded Hausdorff uniform space is compact [2 Corollary 8.3.17], A is compact topological MV-algebra. Hence, the continuous extension ⊕:(A,UA)×(A,UA)⟶(A,UA) of ⊕ is uniformly continuous by [11 Corollary 0.54], because its domain A×A is compact. Its restriction ⊕ to (A,UA)×(A,UA) is therefore uniformly continuous, and Theorem 4.7 gives local order convexity.
:::
Some examples
In this section, we give two examples which show that not all topological MV-algebras are canonically completable and the property of canonically completable topological MV-algebra does not imply local order convexity.
The following construction shows that first countability, second countability, and linearity of the MV-order do not suffice for continuous extendability.
Example 5.1. There exists a countable Hausdorff second-countable topological MV-chain A with canonical completion
A=[0,1]×Zdiscrete,
such that even one fixed truncated translation x↦a⊕x has no continuous extension to A. In particular, A is not canonically completable.
Proof. Fix an irrational real number α, and put
G=Q+Zα,A=G∩[0,1].
Every x∈G has a unique expression x=q+nα, where q∈Q and n∈Z. Define the additive map κ:G→Z by κ(q+nα)=n. The interval A is an MV-subalgebra of the standard algebra, with
x⊕y=min{x+y,1},x∗=1−x.
Its natural order is the usual order, so it is an MV-chain. Define a metric on A by, for each x,y∈A
d(x,y)={∣x−y∣,∣x−y∣+1,κ(x)=κ(y)κ(x)=κ(y).(8)
It is a metric because it is the sum of the usual metric and the pullback of the discrete metric on Z. For each n∈Z, the set
An=(nα+Q)∩[0,1]
is an open and closed subspace with its usual real subspace topology. Since A is countable and metrizable, it is Hausdorff and second countable. We verify continuity of the MV-operations. Because 1∈Q, κ(1−x)=−κ(x). One can easily show that the involution ∗ is an isometry for (8), that is, d(x,y)=d(x∗,y∗). Hence, ∗ is continuous. Next, we shall show that ⊕ is continuous. Fix a,b∈A and ϵ>0.
Case 1: a+b<1. Put δ=min{31−(a+b),2ϵ}. We shall prove that d(x⊕y,a⊕b)<ϵ whenever d(x,a)<δ and d(y,b)<δ. Since δ<1, we have κ(x)=κ(a) and κ(y)=κ(b). Hence, x+y≤a+b+∣x−a∣+∣y−b∣≤a+b+2δ<1. Furthermore,
If x+y>1, then x⊕y=1. Hence, κ(x⊕y)=κ(1)=κ(a⊕b). Thus,
d(x⊕y,a⊕b)=d(1,1)=0<ϵ.
This proves continuity of ⊕. Therefore A with the topology induced by d defined in (8) is a topological MV-algebra.
A zero-neighborhood base is {Uϵ:0<ϵ<1}, where
Uϵ={x∈A:d(0,x)<ϵ}={x∈A0:d(0,x)<ϵ}=Q∩[0,ϵ).
Put
EUϵ={(x,y)∈A×A:x⊖y∈Uϵ and y⊖x∈Uϵ}
and
Edϵ={(x,y)∈A×A:d(x,y)<ϵ}.
If (x,y)∈Edϵ, then d(x,y)<ϵ<1. Thus, we have κ(x)=κ(y). This implies that x−y∈Q and ∣x−y∣=d(x,y)<ϵ. Since the standard-algebra difference is x⊖y=max{x−y,0}, we have x⊖y∈Uϵ and y⊖x∈Uϵ, proving Edϵ⊆EUϵ.
If (x,y)∈EUϵ, then x⊖y∈Uϵ and y⊖x∈Uϵ. Hence κ(x⊖y)=κ(y⊖x)=0 and ∣x−y∣<ϵ. Therefore we have κ(x)=κ(y). Then d(x,y)=∣x−y∣<ϵ, which implies that (x,y)∈Edϵ, proving Edϵ⊇EUϵ. Thus the canonical difference uniformity UA on A is induced by the metric (8).
Give [0,1]×Z the complete metric
ρ((s,n),(t,m))={∣s−t∣,∣s−t∣+1,n=mn=m.(9)
Completeness follows because a Cauchy sequence eventually is contained in [0,1]×{n} for some n∈Z and [0,1]×{n} is complete. The map j:A→[0,1]×Z defined by
j(x)=(x,κ(x))(10)
is isometric. Since each nα+Q is dense in R, An=(nα+Q)∩[0,1] is dense in [0,1] for each n∈Z. Hence j(An) is dense in the branch [0,1]×{n} for each n∈Z. This implies that j(A) is dense in [0,1]×Z. This proves that the uniform space [0,1]×Z with the uniformity induced by the metric ρ defined by (9) is the canonical completion of the uniform space (A,UA).
Now take a=1/2∈A0. We shall show that the left translation λa:A→A defined by λa(x)=a⊕x for each x∈A has no continuous extension to A.
Since A1=(α+Q)∩[0,1] is dense in [0,1] with the Euclidean topology, we can choose a sequence {bn:n∈N}⊆A1 such that {bn:n∈N} converges to 1/2 in [0,1] and
b2n<1/2,b2n+1>1/2
for each n∈N. Hence, the sequence {bn:n∈N} is d-Cauchy in A and {j(bn):n∈N} converges to (1/2,1) in [0,1]×Z=A.
If λa has a continuous extension to A, then λa(j(bn))→λa((1/2,1)). This is impossible. Since
a⊕b2n=1/2+b2n,κ(a⊕b2n)=1
and
a⊕b2n+1=1,κ(a⊕b2n+1)=0,
by j∘λa=λa∘j, we have
λa(j(b2n))=j(λa(b2n))=j(a⊕b2n)⟶(1,1)
and
λa(j(b2n+1))=j(λa(b2n+1))j(a⊕b2n+1)⟶(1,0).
This is contradiction. Thus the fixed translation has no continuous extension, and neither does the binary operation.
Example 5.2. There is a second countable and metrizable topological MV-algebra but not locally order convex, and hence, its MV-operation ⊕ is not uniformly continuous for the canonical difference uniformity.
Proof. This example comes from [12 Example 1.1.11(a)]. For the sake of completeness, we give the construction.
Let A be the finite and cofinite subsets of N, that is,
A={X⊆N:X is finite or cofinite}.
Then A with the symmetric difference △ is a Boolean group. Indeed, ∅ is the identity in (A,△), the inverse element of each X∈A is itself and X△Y=(X∪Y)∖(X∩Y) is in A for each X,Y∈A. One can easily show that the operator △ is associative on A. Put
Bk={2k−1,2k}
for each k∈N∖{0} and
Un={k∈F⋃Bk:F⊆{n,n+1,…} is finite}.(11)
for each n∈N. Then each Un is a subgroup of the Boolean group (A,△) such that ⋂n∈NUn={∅} and Un⊇Um when m≥n, because (⋃k∈F1Bk)△(⋃k∈F2Bk)=⋃k∈F1△F2Bk. Put
τ={O⊆A: each X∈O there some n∈N such that X△Un⊆O}.(12)
Then the Boolean group (A,△) with the topology τ is a Hausdorff first countable topological group. Hence, it is second countable and metrizable, because A is countable.
Define ⊕ and ∗ on A by
X⊕Y=X∪Y and X∗=N∖X
for each X,Y∈A, respectively. Then (A,⊕,∗,0) is an MV-algebra, where 0=∅. We claim that the MV-algebra (A,⊕,∗,0) with the topology τ defined by (12) is a topological MV-algebra.
Next we shall prove that ⊕:A×A→A is continuous. Take any X,Y∈A and any neighbourhood V of X⊕Y. Then there some n∈N such that (X⊕Y)△Un⊆V. Since X,Y are either finite or cofinite sets, there is m≥n such that either Bk⊆Z or Bk∩Z=∅ for each k≥m, where Z=X,Y. We claim that
Since either Bk⊆Z or Bk∩Z=∅ for each k≥m (where Z∈{X,Y,E,F}), we have either
(((X△E)∪(Y△F))△(X∪Y))∩Bk=∅
or
Bk⊆(((X△E)∪(Y△F))△(X∪Y))
for each k≥m. Note that E∪F is finite. Hence,
((X△E)∪(Y△F))△(X∪Y)∈Um⊆Un.
This implies that
(X△E)⊕(Y△F)=(X△E)∪(Y△F)∈(X∪Y)△Un=(X⊕Y)△Un.
Thus, we have proved
(X△Um)⊕(Y△Um)⊆(X⊕Y)△Un⊆V.
Finally, we shall show that the topological MV-algebra A is not locally order convex. If an order convex zero-neighborhood W⊆U1 existed, it would contain some Un. For k≥n, both ∅ and Bk would be in W, forcing {2k−1}∈W, contrary to {2k−1}∈/U1. Thus local order convexity fails.
Hence, form Theorem 4.7 it follows that the MV-operation ⊕ is not uniformly continuous for the canonical difference uniformity.
Let A be the topological MV-algebra constructed in Example 5.2. We retain the notation Bk and Un from the proof of Example 5.2. Take a point ∞∈/N, and put Ω=N∪{∞}. For X⊆Ω, define the set P(X) by
P(X)={k≥1:∣X∩Bk∣=1}.
Put
B={X⊆Ω:P(X) is finite}.(13)
Define ⊕ and ∗ on B by
X⊕Y=X∪YandX∗=Ω∖X
for each X,Y∈B, respectively. Then (B,⊕,∗,0B) is an MV-algebra, where 0B=∅. Indeed, for all X,Y∈B,
P(Ω∖X)=P(X),P(X∪Y)⊆P(X)∪P(Y).
It follows that B is closed under complementation and finite unions. Since ∅,Ω∈B, it is a Boolean algebra.
Example 5.3. Let topological MV-algebra A be from Example 5.2 and MV-algebra B defined by (13). Define a map
j:A⟶B,j(X)={X,X∪{∞},X is finite,X is cofinite.(14)
Then there is a topology on MV-algebra B such that B is a canonically complete metrizable topological Boolean MV-algebra but not locally order convex and j is a uniform MV-embedding with dense image, for the canonical difference uniformities. Consequently, (B,j) realizes the canonical uniform completion of A.
Proof. For each n≥1, set
Vn={k∈S⋃Bk:S⊆{n,n+1,…}}.(15)
Then each Vn is a subgroup of the Boolean group (B,△). Indeed, if E=⋃k∈SBk and F=⋃k∈TBk belong to Vn, then
E△F=k∈S△T⋃Bk∈Vn.
Moreover,
Vn+1⊆Vn,n≥1⋂Vn={∅}.
Put
τB={O⊆B: each X∈O there some n∈N such that X△Vn⊆O}.(16)
Then the Boolean group (B,△) with the topology τB is a Hausdorff first countable topological group. Hence, it is metrizeble. We claim that the MV-algebra (B,⊕,∗,0B) with the topology τB defined by (16) is a topological MV-algebra.
Complementation is continuous because, for every E∈Vn,
Ω∖(X△E)=(Ω∖X)△E.
Thus it maps X△Vn onto X∗△Vn.
To prove joint continuity of union at a fixed pair (X,Y)∈B2, let n≥1. Choose
m=max{n,1+max(P(X)∪P(Y)∪{0})}.
Then neither ∣X∩Bk∣=1 nor ∣Y∩Bk∣=1 with k≥m. For arbitrary E,F∈Vm, put
D=((X△E)∪(Y△F))△(X∪Y).
If k<m, then E∩Bk=F∩Bk=∅, so D∩Bk=∅. If k≥m, each of X,Y,E,F meets Bk in either ∅ or Bk. Consequently, D∩Bk is also either ∅ or Bk. Finally, ∞∈/D, because E and F do not change membership of ∞. Hence D∈Vm⊆Vn. This proves
{X′∪Y′:X′∈X△Vm,Y′∈Y△Vm}⊆(X∪Y)△Vn.
Thus union is jointly continuous, and B is a topological Boolean MV-algebra.
Next, we shall prove that the topological MV-algebra B is canonically complete. Define
where EVn={(X,Y)∈B×B:X∖Y∈Vn,Y∖X∈Vn} for each n∈N.
Suppose first that (X,Y)∈EVn. Both directional differences avoid ∞ and Hn−1, so X and Y agree there. On any block Bk with k≥n, both directional differences must be either empty or the whole block. If X∩Bk is a singleton, this forces Y∩Bk=X∩Bk: any other choice would make at least one directional difference a singleton on that block. The same argument with X and Y interchanged shows that they have identical patterns.
Conversely, suppose the right-hand side of (17) holds. On each split block, X and Y agree. On every other block, each is either empty or the whole block. Agreement on Hn−1 and at ∞ then shows that both directional differences are unions of whole blocks with indices at least n. They belong to Vn, proving the claim.
Let F be any Cauchy filter on (B,UB). For every n≥1, choose
Qn∈F,Qn×Qn⊆EVn,
and put
Gn=i=1⋂nQi.
Then
Gn∈F,Gn=∅,Gn+1⊆Gn,Gn×Gn⊆EVn.(18)
By (17) with n=1, all members of G1 have the same pattern. Fix Y0∈G1, and write
ε=εY0,F=P(Y0).
The set F is finite, and every member of every Gn has pattern σ(Y0).
For each k≥1, the inclusion Gk+1×Gk+1⊆EVk+1 implies that all members of Gk+1 agree on Bk. Hence the following definition is independent of the choice of Y:
Tk=Y∩Bk(Y∈Gk+1).
If k∈F, then Tk is the singleton prescribed by σ(Y0). If k∈/F, then Tk is either ∅ or Bk. Set
Iε={∅,{∞},ε=0,ε=1,X=(k≥1⋃Tk)∪Iε.
Then P(X)=F, so X∈B, and σ(X)=σ(Y0).
We show that F converges to X. Fix n≥1 and take any Y∈Gn. If k<n, then Gn⊆Gk+1, whence Y∩Bk=Tk=X∩Bk. Also, X and Y have the same pattern. Equation (17) therefore gives (X,Y)∈EVn. Thus
Gn⊆EVn[X].
Since Gn∈F, it follows that EVnB[X]∈F for every n. The sets EVnB[X] form a neighborhood base for the canonical uniform topology, so F→X. Every Cauchy filter therefore converges in B, proving canonical completeness.
The map j in (14) is injective because j(X)∩N=X. Complementation interchanges the finite and cofinite cases, so
j(N∖X)=Ω∖j(X).
Moreover, the union of two members of A is cofinite if and only if at least one of them is cofinite. Consequently,
j(X∪Y)=j(X)∪j(Y),j(∅)=∅.
Thus j is a Boolean MV-homomorphism.
We have the exact identity
Vn∩j(A)=j(Un)(n≥1).(19)
Indeed, the image of a cofinite set contains ∞ and hence cannot belong to Vn. The elements on the left are therefore precisely the finite unions of whole blocks with indices at least n, which are the elements on the right. Preservation of symmetric difference now gives
(j(X)△Vn)∩j(A)=j(X△Un).
Hence j is a topological embedding.
The canonical basic entourages of A are
EUnA={(X,Y)∈A2:X∖Y∈Un,Y∖X∈Un}.
Since j preserves directional differences, (19) yields
(j(X),j(Y))∈EVnB⟺(X,Y)∈EUnA.
The canonical uniformity of A is therefore exactly the pullback of the restricted canonical uniformity of B. This proves that j is a uniform embedding.
Finally, we shall show that j(A) is dense in B. Fix X∈B, and put r0=max(P(X)∪{1}). For every integer r≥r0, define
ar={X∩Hr,(X∩Hr)∪(N∖Hr),∞∈/X,∞∈X.
In the first case ar is finite, and in the second it is cofinite; thus ar∈A. The sets j(ar) and X agree on Hr and at ∞. All split blocks of X lie in Hr, while neither set has split blocks beyond r. Thus σ(j(ar))=σ(X), and (17) gives
(j(ar),X)∈EVr+1B.
For any fixed n, this pair belongs to EVnB whenever r≥max{r0,n−1}. Hence j(ar)→X, proving that j(A) is dense in B.
We have shown that B is a complete separated uniform space and j is a uniform embedding with dense image.
The natural order in these Boolean MV-algebras is inclusion. Given an order-convex zero-neighborhood W satisfying
∅∈W⊆V1.
There would then exist n with Vn⊆W. For any k≥n, both ∅ and Bk belong to W, and
∅⊆{2k−1}⊆Bk.
Order convexity would force {2k−1}∈W⊆V1, which is impossible because every member of V1 is a union of whole blocks. Thus B is not locally order convex.
References
[1]A.V. Arhangel’skii, M.G. Tkachenko, Topological Groups and Related Structures, Atlantis Studies in Mathematics, vol. 1, Atlantis Press, Paris; World Scientific Publishing Co. Pte. Ltd., Hackensack, NJ, 2008.DOI
[2]R. Engelking, General Topology, Sigma Series in Pure Mathematics, Heldermann, Berlin, 1989.
[4]R. L. O. Cignoli, I. M. L. D’Ottaviano, and D. Mundici, Algebraic Foundations of Many-Valued Reasoning, Trends in Logic, vol. 7, Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht, 2000.DOI
[5]A. P. Gan, W. Luan, F. A. Deng, and Y. C. Yang, On regularity of topological MV-algebras, Fuzzy Sets and Systems 475 (2024), 108747.DOI
[6]C. S. Hoo, Topological MV-algebras, Topology Appl. 81 (1997), 103–121.DOI
[7]Q. Li and Y. Yang, Locally convex topological MV-algebras and uniformization of MV-algebras, Topology and its Applications 382 (2026), 109771.DOI
[8]W. Luan, H. Weber, and Y. Yang, Filter topologies and topological MV-algebras, Fuzzy Sets and Systems 406 (2021), 11–21.DOI
[9]L. Nachbin, Topology and order, D. Van Nostrand Company, New York, 1965.
[10]D. Mundici, Interpretation of AF C*-algebras in Łukasiewicz sentential calculus, Journal of Functional Analysis 65 (1986), 15–63.DOI
[11]W. Roelcke, S. Dierolf, Uniform structures on topological groups and their quotients, McGraw-Hill International Book Co., New York 1981.
[12]H. Weber, Uniform lattices. I: A generalization of topological Riesz spaces and topological Boolean rings, Annali di Matematica Pura ed Applicata (4) 160 (1991), 347–370.DOI
[13]H. Weber, On topological MV-algebras and topological ℓ-groups, Topology and its Applications 159 (2012), 3392–3395.