WorksPhysics and Astronomy
Impact of structural distortions on the correlated electronic structure of orbital-selective Mott insulating NaCoSbO under strains
Abstract
NaCoSbO is a promising candidate to realize the Kitaev spin liquid phase since the large Kitaev spin exchange interaction is tunable via the change in electronic structure, such as the trigonal crystal field splitting (). Here, we show that the uncorrelated electronic structure of NaCoSbO is rather insensitive to the strain effect due to the low crystal symmetry accompanied by oxygen displacements and the presence of Sb orbitals. This suggests that the Kitaev spin-exchange interaction obtained from perturbation theory also does not depend much on the strain effect. Using density functional theory plus dynamical mean field theory, we find that the correlated electronic structure of NaCoSbO is an orbital selective Mott insulating state where the trigonal orbital is insulating due to correlation-assisted hybridization, while other orbitals behave as typical Mott insulators, resulting in tunability of under the strain effect effectively. Our results show that the local Co-site symmetry and dynamical correlation effects will play an important role in engineering the novel magnetic phase in this and related materials.
Bond-dependent spin exchange interaction in a honeycomb structure plays a crucial role in materials for stabilizing the Kitaev quantum spin liquid (QSL) phase¹. In particular, or orbitals in a honeycomb structure have been attracting much interest in realizing anisotropic spin interactions due to their large spin-orbit coupling (SOC)². However, the spatially extended or orbitals typically generate longer-range spin interaction terms, making the magnetic phase diagram much more complex. Moreover, it is rather difficult to tune the SOC effect via structural changes such as strain or pressure. Recently, orbitals have been suggested to stabilize the Kitaev QSL phase due to the anisotropic hopping mechanism despite their small SOC³,⁴. In this regard, Na₃Co₂SbO₆ (NCSO) has drawn much attention as a possible material candidate due to its tunability close to the QSL phase⁵.
NCSO has monoclinic structure with space group and undergoes a magnetic phase transition from a paramagnetic (PM) insulating state to an antiferromagnetic (AFM) insulating state at K⁶–⁹. The Co²⁺ () ion is in the high spin (HS) state with the electronic configuration of (, ), forming a spin-orbit-entangled pseudospin state, from which the Kitaev interaction arises via the second or higher order perturbation³–⁵,¹⁰,¹¹. It is shown that the - hopping channel in NCSO enhances the Kitaev interaction while the non-Kitaev terms (Heisenberg , off-diagonal , and trigonal ) are much weakened⁵. Also, the stability of the QSL phase depends sensitively on the size of the trigonal crystal field splitting () since a large can weaken the Kitaev interaction. Therefore, tuning the or related material parameters via strain or pressure is a priority of driving the system into Kitaev QSL phase.
The experimental estimates of electronic structure in NCSO, such as the sign and magnitude of the , have been relied on fitting the crystal field multiplet calculations to the spectroscopic measurements including X-ray absorption spectroscopy (XAS), inelastic neutron scattering (INS), X-ray linear dichroism (XLD), and X-ray magnetic circular dichroism (XMCD). Kim et al found that the magnitude of the is 25.1 meV by fitting to the XAS/XLD data, and the orbital is located below the orbitals¹². However, Veenendaal et al reported that the orbital is located above the orbitals with of 35-60 meV by fitting configuration interaction analysis to the XLD and XMCD data¹³. This sign of has been attributed to the hybridization of orbitals with the positive ion located in the honeycomb Co layers, and it is also consistent with the analysis using the INS data¹⁴.
Although most theoretical works of studying the QSL phase in NCSO have focused on computing the anisotropic spin exchange parameters of the localized spin Hamiltonian based on perturbation theory assuming the pure trigonal distortion, more realistic treatment of structural changes in the monoclinic NCSO under strain or pressure and its impact on the correlated electronic structure and the spin-exchange interactions have not been explored yet. Moreover, a Jahn-Teller (JT) distortion is typically allowed in the monoclinic phase such as the NCSO case, while other QSL candidate materials such as BaCo₂(AsO₄)₂ (BCAO)¹⁰,¹⁵,¹⁶, -BaCo₂(PO₄)₂¹⁷,¹⁸, or -RuCl₃¹⁹, have a pure trigonal distortion associated with . A JT distortion can further split degenerate orbitals into different energy levels, which could result in some novel physical phenomena²⁰. In addition, the properties of material parameters such as depend on the orbital-dependent correlation effect of the Co²⁺ ion due to the strong on-site and its hybridization effect with the ligand fields of O²⁻ and Sb⁵⁺ orbitals, which can be treated accurately using first principles.
Here, we study the impact of structural distortions of NCSO under strain on its correlated electronic structure and spin-exchange interactions using first-principles. We first perform structural relaxations of strained structures using density functional theory (DFT)+[21] based on the projected-augmented wave (PAW) method[22] as implemented in the Vienna ab initio simulation package (VASP)[23, 24]. All atomic positions of NCSO are relaxed to obtain the strained structures, while the volume is fixed to 270.84 Å, which is the zero-strain relaxed volume. The exchange-correlation energy functional was treated using the generalized gradient approximation (GGA) adopting the Perdew-Burke-Ernzerhof (PBE) functional[25]. The cutoff energy for the plane-wave basis was used as 600 eV with the Gamma-centered $8 \times 4 \times 8 -point mesh. The Hellmann-Feynman force on each atom was set to be smaller than 0.01 eV/Å for convergence. We imposed the Hubbard and Hund coupling on the Co orbitals with eV and eV for DFT+ calculations. We also impose the Néel AFM order for the relaxation since this is the ground-state spin configuration (see Appendix § 0.3).
We then performed DFT+dynamical mean field theory (DMFT) calculation[26] for each relaxed structure to study the dynamical correlation effects on NCSO. For DMFT calculations, we construct the Wannier Hamiltonian using the Wannier90 code[27] for the Co , O , and Sb orbitals. The Wannier Hamiltonian of this -model and its comparison to the DFT band is given in Appendix § 0.4 and Appendix C. Due to the low point group symmetry () of CoO octahedra, the off-diagonal elements in Wannier Hamiltonian are non-negligible. To minimize the effect of the off-diagonal elements, we diagonalize the Co block in the full -Hamiltonian by applying unitary rotation matrix[28], and use the diagonalized Hamiltonian for DFT+DMFT loop. Then, we solve the DMFT impurity problem using the continuous time quantum Monte Carlo method[29] with the Hubbard eV and the Hund’s coupling eV to treat correlations of Co $3d$ orbitals. Once the DMFT calculations converge, all final results including the spectral function, the occupancy matrix, and the self-energy are obtained as the original trigonal basis using the unitary transform. Here, we adopt single-site DMFT to treat the local dynamical correlation effect since this approximation has been successfully applied to the transition-metal compounds in a similar honeycomb structure$[30, 31]. The details of DFT+DMFT calculation are given in Appendix D.
Experimental studies of neutron and X-ray diffractions show that NCSO forms a\u0020centrosymmetric monoclinic cell with the space group ([No. 12])[6, 7, 8, 9]. The DFT+U$ relaxed structure with the AFM Néel configuration exhibits a slightly larger volume along with the elongated in-plane -axis compared to the experimental one (see Table I). While Co ions in NCSO form a layered honeycomb structure, the local Co-O octahedra follow the trigonal symmetry (Figure 1 (a,b)), similarly to those in transition-metal dihalides such as CoI with the space group ([No. 164]). This trigonal distortion splits the triplet of the Co manifold into an singlet and a degenerate doublet, where the trigonal crystal field splitting is defined as (see Figure 1c)$[20, 32, 33, 34]. However, the point group symmetry of the local CoO-site in NCSO is , which is lower than that of CoI (). This lower local-site symmetry can play an important role in tuning the correlation effects in NCSO and related low-symmetry compounds.
Figure 1. The (a) side and (b) top views of the crystal structure, NaCoSbO. due to structural distortions. (c) A schematic diagram of orbital energy level changes due to the trigonal compression and oxygen displacements. (The -axis corresponds to the [111] direction along the local Co–O axis).
The trigonal distortion of the Co–O octahedra can be parametrized by the and ratios where is the in-plane O–O bond lengths and and are the out-of-plane O–O bond lengths as shown in Figure 1(a,b). Here, is the edge that intersects the nearest-neighbor Co–Co bonding, while is not. The values of , , and computed for the fully relaxed NCSO structure without any strains are given and compared to known experimental structures in Table I. Under zero strain (), the fully relaxed NCSO structure shows the trigonal compression along the -axis, yielding the average and , both of which are less than one. Additionally, the monoclinic distortion in NCSO results in unequal Co–O bond lengths within the Co–O octahedra, akin to the JT distortion observed in
| NaCoSbO | [Å] | [Å] | [Å] | [Å] | [] | [Å] | [Å] | [Å] | Co-O [Å] |
| DFT+ Néel | 270.84 | 5.40 | 9.33 | 5.66 | 108.5 | 3.212/3.207/3.199 | 2.828/2.809/2.809 | 3.019/2.999/2.999 | 2.161/2.166 |
| Viciu et al.⁶ | 267.22 | 5.37 | 9.28 | 5.65 | 108.5 | 3.172/3.168/3.157 | 2.757/2.785/2.785 | 2.915/2.927/2.927 | 2.136/2.125 |
| Wong et al.⁷ | 266.81 | 5.36 | 9.29 | 5.65 | 108.4 | 3.169/3.167/3.152 | 2.758/2.784/2.784 | 2.915/2.926/2.926 | 2.132/2.127 |
Table 1. Lattice and structural parameters of NaCoSbO without any strains ().
various perovskite transition-metal oxides. This is due to the anisotropic elongation of the oxygen positions, which alters the ratio between the Co–O bond lengths along the -axis and those in the -plane, i.e., . Although the JT distortion can be small in the unstrained state, its effects become more pronounced under applied strain, and a significant JT distortion is also evident in the experimental structure⁶,⁷.
Without the JT distortion, the trigonal and orbitals are the appropriate basis functions for diagonalizing the local Co Hamiltonian under trigonal distortion (see Appendix § 0.4). In general, even in the absence of JT distortions, unequal values of and () are allowed under trigonal symmetry. For example, BCAO with the space group ([No. 148]) shows with the local-site symmetry of , but there are no JT distortions and Co-O bonds are still equivalent. In contrast, all out-of-plane O-O bond lengths are equivalent with in CoI. In NCSO, however, the local-site symmetry is further reduced by the JT distortion, which induces and an energy splitting between the orbitals (). This results in the non-zero off-diagonal terms in the local Co Hamiltonian represented using the trigonal basis.
To understand the response of and due to structural changes, we compute the local Co-site -Hamiltonian by projecting the DFT band structure to trigonal basis functions. In the case of both CoI and BCAO, the off-diagonal terms of the local Hamiltonian in the manifold represented using trigonal basis functions are zeros, and can be defined as . The term is zero, thus the two orbitals are degenerate. For NCSO, the low Co-site symmetry lifts the degenerate orbital energy levels and results in non-negligible off-diagonal terms in the trigonal Hamiltonian. We define both terms as and .
Fig. 2a shows that the trigonal distortions of NCSO and CoI occur even at zero strain, resulting in a Co–O octahedron compressed along the -axis with and . The corresponding structural values agree well with the experimental data (see Table I) and these distortions are further enhanced under tensile strains (). In Figure 2c, we plot as a function of strain for each relaxed structure by extracting the on-site orbital energies from trigonal Wannier orbitals projected onto the uncorrelated DFT band structure. In both compounds, the is positive ( meV for CoI and meV for NCSO) at zero strain. This of NCSO is consistent with the experimental esti-
Figure 2. The strain effect on structural parameters of NaCoSbO and CoI: (a) the ratio (solid line) and (dashed line), (b) the Co-Co interlayer distance, (c) the trigonal crystal field , and (d) the energy splitting within the orbitals ().
mate obtained using INS¹⁴. Under the compression along the trigonal -axis, the negative is conventionally expected due to the stronger hybridization of orbitals with the O ions when $L_2/L_1 < 1{sup}34 as the geometric lobes of the $e_g^\pi$ ($a_{1g}$) orbitals point to the octahedral faces parallel (perpendicular) to the $c$-axis{citep}³²,³³,³⁵. However, it is important to note that the Wannier orbitals are maximally localized, and the hybridization effect on the crystal field splitting is minimized. Moreover, the Sb $s$-orbitals also hybridize with O $p$ orbitals and weaken the Co-O hybridization effect. We find that the Co-Co interlayer distance does not have much effect on the crystal field splitting as it is large and does not depend much on strains ({xref}Fig. 2b`).
Although the structural changes ( and ) due to strains are similar for both NCSO and CoI (Figure 2a), the response of the material parameters including and of NCSO are much less sensitive to strains. The of CoI increases under tensile strains and changes sensitively about 27 meV per 1% of strain (Figure 2c). This trend of the positive is consistent with that of TiCl (the same point group as CoI) when as discussed in Georgescu et al.[32]. For NCSO, the change of structural parameters does not directly impact the energy levels of localized orbitals due to the low Co-site symmetry. At zero strain, the JT distortion further splits the orbitals of NCSO with the crystal splitting of meV and changes about 6 meV per 1% of strain (Figure 2d).
We now study the effect of dynamical correlations on the electronic structure of strained NCSO in the paramagnetic phase. Since the five Co orbitals in NCSO are not equivalent, we treat the correlation effect of them separately with distinct DMFT self-energies. Without the effects of the Hubbard and the Hund’s coupling (DFT calculation), the ground state of NCSO is the metallic state with a low-spin electronic configuration . The DFT DOS shows that the low-energy bands of and orbitals are fully filled, leaving a single electron on the doublet state (Figure 3a).
Figure 3. (a) DFT DOS of NCSO at zero strain. (b) DFT+DMFT DOS of NCSO with eV and eV within paramagnetic phase. The imaginary part of the DMFT self-energy obtained for (c) , , and (d) orbitals.
The paramagnetic DFT+DMFT calculation using eV and eV shows that NCSO at the zero strain becomes an orbital-selective Mott insulator with an energy gap of 1 eV. The bands under the effect of strong correlations become almost half-filled (Figure 3b) with the occupancy . Figure 3d shows that the imaginary part of self-energy () of the orbitals has a strong pole (divergent) at eV with the broad upper Hubbard bands near 3.5 eV above the Fermi energy, indicating that the orbitals exhibit the typical strongly-correlated Mott insulating behavior. We find that this Mott state is robust against the strain effect.
Unlike the half-filled orbitals, the and orbitals are partially filled with one shared hole in the manifold (), implying that the correlation effect can arise due to the multi-orbital physics in a non-trivial way. The partially filled occupancies among the and orbitals are due to the large Hund’s coupling acting on the manifold with a small . This shared hole is mostly located on the orbitals where the broad upper Hubbard band is formed near 2 eV above the Fermi energy. The pole of the orbital is located near 1.5 eV above the Fermi energy and the pole strength is weaker than the orbital one (Figure 3c). This means that the Mott insulating state of the orbital shows moderate correlations, which could be tunable by strains. The self-energies for and orbitals are similar despite the small JT splitting between two orbitals.
The for the orbital shows much broader peaks with an almost filled occupancy (). The peak position is located near 2.0 eV above the Fermi energy, which corresponds to the Sb orbital energy level due to their hybridization (Figure 3c). This shows that the orbital is close to a hybridization-induced insulating state rather than a Mott insulating state. Our result also suggests that the one-particle energy level of the orbital can be effectively shifted lower due to the nearly full occupation, resulting in the negative trigonal crystal field splitting (), while the orbital energy is higher than the orbital ones at the DFT level (). We want to emphasize that the orbital-dependent correlation effect plays an important role in tuning the effective Co 3 orbital levels and the resulting splitting under strains. This is also in sharp contrast to the CoI case where the DMFT occupancy of the orbital is smaller than the one () due to the absence of the Sb orbital.
Now, we study the strain effect on the change of correlations in NCSO and CoI. Figure 4a shows that the DMFT occupancy in NCSO are rather insensitive to compressive strains as the occupancy is close to the full occupation (). Under tensile strain, gradually decreases, and the and occupancies are almost degenerate at . We expect that the sign change of could occur near the tensile strain and possibly realize the spin liquid phase due to the strongly suppressed . The change of the DMFT occupancy under tensile strain is closely related to the orbital-dependent correlation effect since the occupancy increases (decreases) gradually as the decreases (increases) (Figure 4b). For the CoI case, the trend of the occupancy change is more rapid (Figure 4c) but still consistent with the change of as the and occupancies are almost degenerate at where becomes nearly zero. Overall, the tensile (compressive) strain favors the stronger correlation effect of () orbital as it is less hybridized with O orbitals. The difference between two compounds originates from the low Co-site symmetry and the presence of Sb orbitals in NCSO.
Figure 4. DFT+DMFT results of (a) the occupancy and (b) the pole strength of the , , and orbitals in NCSO as a function of strain. (c) The occupancy and (d) the pole strength of the , , and orbitals in CoI for comparison.
In summary, we studied the strain and structural distortion effects on electronic and magnetic properties of NCSO using first-principles calculations. We found that the orbital-dependent correlation effect of Co ions will play an important role in tuning the material parameters under strains. While the orbitals are insulating due to the nearly full occupation, other Co orbitals are more strongly correlated as a Mott insulating state. The electronic structure dependence on strains is much weaker for NCSO compared to the CoI case due to its low Co-site symmetry originated from the O distortion and the presence of the Sb orbitals. The study of spin-exchange interactions incorporating such realistic and correlated electronic structures[36] will be important for the future study of this and related Kitaev spin-liquid candidate materials.
Acknowledgement
This work was supported by the Materials Sciences and Engineering Division, Basic Energy Sciences, Office of Science, US Department of Energy. We gratefully acknowledge the computing resources provided on Bebop and Improv, high-performance computing clusters operated by the Laboratory Computing Resource Center at Argonne National Laboratory.
References
Magnetic Ground State of NaCoSbO
Here, we briefly discuss about magnetic ground states of NaCoSbO using DFT+ while varying and fixing eV. The energy differences between magnetic structures, including FM, zigzag AFM, stripe AFM, and the Néel AFM show that the Néel AFM structure is more stable than the other magnetic structures in a strongly correlated regime ( eV), while the FM is the most stable structure in a weakly correlated regime (Figure 5).
Figure 5. Relative energy per formula unit of FM, zigzag AFM, stripe AFM structure to Néel AFM structure of NCSO as a function of the Hubbard while fixing eV within DFT+ calculation.
Wannier Hamiltonian
Here, we construct the tight-binding Hamiltonian using the maximally localized Wannier functions (MLWFs)[37]. The correlated subspace of Co orbitals can be solved using the DMFT equations. Trigonal and Jahn-Teller distortions in NaCoSbO can also be studied using the on-site orbital energies of Co orbitals. To construct Wannier functions, we first solve the non-spin-polarized Kohn-Sham equation within DFT using VASP code. Once the Kohn-Sham equation is solved, all eigenfunctions and the energy bands are obtained: , where is the Kohn-Sham Hamiltonian. We then constructed a manifold of bands with maximally localized Wannier functions (MLWFs)[37]
using VASP and WANNIER90[38] codes. In this work, the local , , and axes for constructing Co orbitals are chosen be aligned close to the local bondings of the perfect octahedron such that the local axis will point toward the -axis. After the Wannier procedure, the real-space Wannier Hamiltonian is obtained.
The local Wannier Hamiltonians () of the Co orbitals of NCSO (within the -model), BaCo(AsO) with the space group [No. 148] (within the -model), and the CoI with the space group [No. 164] (within the -model) respectively at zero strain are represented using the cubic harmonic basis ():
By using a unitary matrix
that rotates the cubic harmonic basis to the trigonal basis , the matrices (B2), (B3), and (B4) become
in the trigonal basis . The blocks of the matrices (B7) and (B8) have the off-diagonal terms of zeros, implying the trigonal basis is more suitable than the cubic one for BCAO and CoI. This is consistent since both of the space groups of BaCo(AsO) and of CoI represent for trigonal systems although the has a lower symmetry than the . On the other hand, the block of the matrix (B6) has a small non-zero off-diagonal terms, originated from the small JT compression at zero strain due to the monoclinic space group of NCSO.
To see the effects of both trigonal and JT distortions within the space group , we consider a Hamiltonian
in the cubic basis where and . The parameters , , represent the energy splitting between and orbitals, the one between and orbitals, and the distortion between and away from respectively, due to the JT effect from the monoclinic-cell type. The parameter represents the trigonal distortion.
By using the unitary matrix (B5), one can obtain the matrix representation of in the trigonal basis such that
Then the trigonal crystal field , defined as the energy splitting between the singlet and the doublet in the trigonal basis, is given by
Basically, the sum of all the upper (lower) off-diagonal terms in the block from the cubic Hamiltonian (Eq. (9)) represents the trigonal crystal field in the trigonal basis. Also, the effect of JT distortion is given by the energy splitting between and such that
From Wannier calculations, we also obtained the hopping matrix between the nearest Co neighbors (-bond) of the zero strain structure within the -model
By comparing the matrix (B17) to the hopping matrix of the Co nearest-neighbors (-bond) for an ideal edge-sharing bond with metal–ligand–metal bond angles
in the cubic basis of [10, 34], one can find the hopping integrals for each exchange channel - (, , ), - (, ), and - () at zero strain as shown in Table II. These hopping integrals are comparable with previous ab initio calculations[34, 39].
The onsite Hamiltonian for O orbitals (within the -model) is
By using the matrices (B2) and (B15), one can find the charge transfer gap at zero strain
Finally, the numerical hopping between orbitals within the -model is given by
Table 2. Hopping integrals and charge transfer gap of NCSO at zero strain.
By comparing to the - hopping matrix for an ideal octahedron[10]
one can obtain eV and eV. Figure 6 shows that only the direct hopping integral favoring Heisenberg interaction is sensitive to the strain effect.
Figure 6. Strain effect on (a) the hopping integral between orbitals and (b) the hopping integral and the charge transfer gap .
Energy Band of the Ambient NCSO Structure
Here, we compare the non-spin-polarized DFT and Wannier energy bands obtained from the fully relaxed NCSO structure. Figure 7(a,Figure 7b) show that the DFT and Wannier bands fit well for both - and -models, indicating that the eigenvalues of the Kohn-Sham equation are exactly the same with those obtained from the -model Wannier functions. Using the obtained Wannier functions, the Co Hamiltonians can be extracted and analyzed.
Figure 7. (a,b) Energy bands of NCSO calculated with DFT and Wannier functions. (c) Molecular-like orbital in the trigonal basis under the effects of ligand fields within -model Wannier functions. (d) Atomic-like orbital in trigonal basis within -model Wannier functions
DMFT method
DMFT maps the lattice many-body problem with the on-site interaction into a single-site problem with the same interaction and coupled to self-consistently determined bath [40]. In the limit of the large lattice coordination, the self-energy , then the local self-energy can be treated as the single-site impurity problem coupled to electron-bath as in the Anderson impurity model (AIM)[41, 42]. The hybridization function describing the ability of an electron to hop in and hop out of an atom is due to the spatial overlap between the correlated orbitals and the conduction band states.
The DFT+DMFT calculation procedure can be described as follows. First, we diagonalize the -model Wannier Hamiltonian, such as the matrix (B2), in order to obtain the Hamiltonian where the Co submatrix can be diagonal with a corresponding unitary matrix of column eigenvectors. Since the matrix representations of the local Co Wannier Hamiltonians in cubic and trigonal bases contain non-zero off-diagonal terms which can lead to the fermion-sign problem in Monte Carlo simulation[43, 44], these diagonalized Hamiltonians without off-diagonal terms can be beneficial. All of the final results, including density of states (DOS) (or spectral function), occupancy matrix, and the imaginary part of self-energy will be rotated from the diagonal basis to the trigonal basis with the unitary matrix .
Next, the Hamiltonian is then used to construct the local lattice Green’s function within the DMFT self-consistent loop. Within the DMFT self-consistent loop, starting from the local impurity self-energy , one can obtain the matrix of :
where is the chemical potential, is the identity matrix, is the double-counting potential, and is the volume of the Brillouin zone. We use the fully-localized-limit double-counting potential given by
where is the occupancy.
Once the lattice Green’s function is computed from the Eq. (18), then the effective non-interacting Green’s function of the Anderson model can be found by
This non-interacting Green’s function is then used to solve the Anderson impurity model and calculate the interacting impurity Green’s function using continuous time quantum Monte Carlo (CTQMC) impurity solver[29, 45, 46, 47]. Then, the new self-energy is given by
Then, we substitute the mixed new self-energy into the (Eq. (18)) so that the algorithm iterates until the convergence criterion is satisfied, e.g.
One then can obtain the analytically continued Green’s function using the maximum entropy method[48]. Then, the spectral function in the trigonal basis, which can be compared to photoemission in experiment, is given by
Also, the occupancy matrix in the trigonal basis is given by
where is the Fermi distribution function.
Effect of the different choice of Wannier orbitals
To study the effect of different choices of Wannier orbitals on and , we plot the and the energy splitting of NCSO obtained using different choices of Co , Sb , and O orbitals as a function of strain (Figure 8(a,Figure 8b)). We obtained -, -, -, and -model Wannier Hamiltonians with energy windows of eV, eV, eV, and eV respectively. Within these models, the slopes of the as a function of strain are the same to each other but shifted between the models (see Figure 8a). This implies the hybridization of Wannier orbitals and their environments can play a key role in determining the magnitude of . At zero strain, the within the -model is negative with meV, consistent with the one measured by Kim et al. using XAS[12]. Also, since the geometric lobes of the orbitals () are similar to each other, the energy splitting between them does not change much across all models.
Figure 8. (a,b) and of NCSO as a function of strain within -, -, -, and -model Wannier Hamiltonians. (c) Crystal field splitting between and orbitals of NCSO within and models.
The choice of Wannier orbitals also has a similar effect on the crystal field splitting between and orbitals (Figure 8(c)). At zero strain the -model is only about 0.32 eV, while the -model is about 0.96 eV, consistent with the common crystal field of Co in literature[13, 16, 49]. Within the -model, the orbitals whose lobes directly point to the surrounding O are more strongly repulsed by the ligand fields of these O than the orbitals whose lobes points between these O. Thus, the energy levels of the orbitals are much higher than those of the orbitals. Within the -model, the orbitals are much localized and is decreased.
Comparison of Trigonal Distortions between NaCoSbO, BaCo(AsO), and CoI
In the main text, we compared the trigonal distortions and the of NCSO and CoI. Here, we also show the trigonal distortion and the of BaCo(AsO) (BCAO). Figure 9(a) shows the slopes of trigonal distortions ( and ) as a function of strain in BCAO is similar to the ones of NCSO and CoI. Figure 9(b) shows that the of BCAO, whose symmetry is higher (lower) than NCSO (CoI), is more (less) sensitive to the strain than the one of NCSO (CoI). These indicates the symmetry (space group) of a compound determines how sensitive the of the compound is under the effect of strain. Importantly, the positive slopes of the as a function of strain in NCSO, CoI, and BCAO yield a unique and crucial effect of strain, in which the energy level of the orbital increases (decreases) relative to the ones of the orbitals as these compounds are more tensile (compressive).
Figure 9. (a) Trigonal distortions and (b) trigonal crystal field versus strain of NCSO (-model), BCAO (-model), and CoI (-model)
DMFT Calculations for NCSO at a/a0=pm1%
Here, we show DMFT calculations for NCSO at . Under the compressive strain , the orbital occupancy is almost fully filled () consistently with the DMFT DOS (Figure 10a). On the other hand, a noticeable unoccupied states of the orbital is located at eV for the tensile strain (Figure 10b), accompanied by a larger peaks of the imaginary self-energy of this orbital at eV (Figure 10d), indicating this orbital becomes more correlated in the tensile region. However, the electron correlation of the orbital is still slightly smaller than the ones of the orbitals since the peak of the imaginary self-energy is smaller than the ones of the imaginary self-energy at eV. Also, a slightly smaller (larger) peak of the imaginary self-energy of the orbital than the one of the orbital indicates a JT compression (elongation), consistent with the JT ratio at .
Figure 10. DFT+DMFT DOS of NCSO with eV and eV for (a) compressive strain and (b) tensile strain . The corresponding DMFT self-energy of , , and orbitals for (c) compressive () and (d) tensile () strains.
DMFT Calculation for CoI2
Here, we show some DMFT results for CoI2 at . Figure 11(a,b,c) show that the unoccupied states of orbital increases as the strain effect becomes more tensile, indicating the orbital becomes more correlated as the occupancy gets closer to the half filling. For the compressive strain , the imaginary self-energy of the orbitals has a stronger peak than the one of the orbital at eV, implying the orbitals are more correlated than the one.
Figure 11. (a,b,c) DFT+DMFT DOS of CoI2 with eV and eV for . (d,e) The corresponding self-energy for , , and orbitals of CoI2 for and
Spin Exchange Interactions
Here, we show the spin exchange interactions obtained via the fourth-order strong coupling perturbation theory developed by Liu and Kee analysis[10]. The pseudospin- interactions of the Kitaev Hamiltonian on -type nearest-neighbor (NN) bond have a general form[5, 50]
where and are Kitaev and Heisenberg interactions respectively. The off-diagonal term arises from combined hoppings and where , , and are – hoppings via the – exchange channel[10, 34]. The arises due to the trigonal crystal field that modifies the pseudospin wave functions (Kramer doublet).
Although a finite under the strain effect can affect , , , and in general[5], for simplicity we consider the ideal octahedron limit (no trigonal and JT distortions). The total Heisenberg and Kitaev interactions can be investigated via each anisotropic hopping channel:
Within the intersite , two-hole , and cyclic processes, each exchange interaction from the Eqs. (26) and (I3) is given by
Following the analysis of Liu and Kee[10], the analytic expressions of these terms are given by
Also, the off-diagonal term is given by
Using the above equations, the magnetic exchange interactions , , and under strain effect can be obtained with our material parameters obtained from DFT. For eV and eV, we found that the Kitaev term is the largest while the Heisenberg and the off-diagonal terms are still finite at zero strain. Within the limit of perfect octahedron, and are not sensitive to strain, but is reduced under the tensile strain (Figure 12a) due to the reducing of hopping (Figure 6a). Our and results at zero strain are consistent with those obtained from the DFT spin-exchange calculation[14] and the trends of these values under strains are also similar to those in CuCoSbO[12].
Figure 12. (a) Heisenberg , Kitaev , and off-diagonal interactions versus strain with eV and eV, and (b) Heisenberg (solid) and Kitaev (dashed) interactions versus strain with eV and various values of . The exchange interactions are calculated using Liu and Kee analysis[10] with [3] and [51].
We also found that the Hubbard and Hund’s coupling values can also affect the exchange interactions. While fixing eV and varying , we found that the system is pushed closest to the QSL () at eV, but the dependence is not much sensitive to the strain, compared to the one at eV (Figure 12b). On the other hand, while fixing eV and varying , we found that the overall Heisenberg interaction is very sensitive to (Figure 13).
Figure 13. Heisenberg and Kitaev interactions from each exchange channel and their total versus strain calculated using Liu and Kee analysis[10] with eV, [3], and [51] while varying the Hund’s coupling .
For eV ( eV) the overall Heisenberg interaction is small, while the FM Kitaev one is large due to the dominant contribution from the - channel, consistent with Liu et al analysis for Co compounds[5]. We found that the generated from the - channel is not very sensitive to the strain and also remains unchanged as varies, consistent with Liu and Khaliullin analysis[3]. However, the AFM Heisenberg interaction from the - channel weakens the combined - and - FM Heisenberg interactions, thus reducing the overall Heisenberg interaction . As the Hund’s coupling gets larger ( eV), the contribution from the - channel gets larger, therefore, the total is enhanced while the total is weakened.
References
- [3]H. Liu and G. Khaliullin, Phys. Rev. B 97, 014407 (2018).
- [5]H. Liu, J. c. v. Chaloupka, and G. Khaliullin, Phys. Rev. Lett. 125, 024701 (2020).
- [6]L. Viciu, Q. Huang, E. Morosan, H. Zandbergen, N. Greenbaum, T. McQueen, and R. Cava, Journal of Solid State Chemistry 180, 1060 (2007).
- [7]C. Wong, M. Avdeev, and C. D. Ling, Journal of Solid State Chemistry 243, 18 (2016).
- [8]V. Politaev, V. Nalbandyan, A. Petrenko, I. Shukaev, V. Volotchaev, and B. Medvedev, Journal of Solid State Chemistry 183, 684 (2010).
- [9]J.-Q. Qin, S. Okamoto, Y. Wu, Q. Zheng, H. D. Zhou, H. B. Cao, and M. A. McGuire, Phys. Rev. Mater. 3, 074405 (2019).
- [10]X. Liu and H.-Y. Kee, Phys. Rev. B 107, 054420 (2023).
- [12]G.-H. Kim, M. Park, S. Samanta, U. Choi, B. Kang, U. Seo, G. Ji, S. Noh, D.-Y. Cho, J.-W. Yoo, J. M. Ok, H.-S. Kim, and C. Sohn, Science Advances 10, eadn8694 (2024).
- [13]M. van Veenendaal, E. H. T. Poldi, L. S. I. Veiga, P. Ben-cok, G. Fabbris, R. Tartaglia, J. L. McChesney, J. W. Free-land, R. J. Hemley, H. Zheng, J. F. Mitchell, J.-Q. Yan, and D. Haskel, Phys. Rev. B 107, 214443 (2023).
- [14]C. Kim, J. Jeong, G. Lin, P. Park, T. Masuda, S. Asai, S. Itoh, H.-S. Kim, H. Zhou, J. Ma, and J.-G. Park, Journal of Physics: Condensed Matter 34, 045802 (2021).
- [16]B. S. Mou, X. Zhang, L. Xiang, Y. Xu, R. Zhong, R. J. Cava, H. Zhou, Z. Jiang, D. Simony, N. Drichko, and S. M. Winter, Phys. Rev. Mater. 8, 084408 (2024).
- [20]K. Mitsumoto, C. Hotta, and H. Yoshino, Phys. Rev. Res. 4, 033157 (2022).
- [21]A. I. Lichtenstein, V. I. Anisimov, and J. Zaanen, Phys. Rev. B 52, R5467 (1995).
- [22]P. E. Blöchl, Phys. Rev. B 50, 17953 (1994).
- [23]G. Kresse and J. Furthmüller, Phys. Rev. B 54, 11169 (1996).
- [24]G. Kresse and D. Joubert, Phys. Rev. B 59, 1758 (1999).
- [25]J. P. Perdew, K. Burke, and M. Ernzerhof, Phys. Rev. Lett. 78, 1396 (1997).
- [26]V. Singh, U. Herath, B. Wah, X. Liao, A. H. Romero, and H. Park, Computer Physics Communications 261, 107778 (2021).
- [27]A. A. Mostofi, J. R. Yates, Y.-S. Lee, I. Souza, D. Vanderbilt, and N. Marzari, Computer Physics Communications 178, 685–699 (2008).
- [28]A. T. Lee, H. Park, and A. T. Ngo, Phys. Rev. B 108, 205146 (2023).
- [29]K. Haule, Phys. Rev. B 75, 155113 (2007).
- [30]H.-S. Kim, K. Haule, and D. Vanderbilt, Phys. Rev. Lett. 123, 236401 (2019).
- [31]S. Samanta, F. Cossu, and H.-S. Kim, Npj Quantum Matter 9 (2024).
- [32]A. B. Georges, A. J. Millis, and J. M. Rondinelli, Phys. Rev. B 105, 245153 (2022).
- [33]F. Rodolakis, J.-P. Rueff, M. Sikora, I. Alliot, J.-P. Itié, F. Baudelet, S. Ravy, P. Wzietek, P. Hansmann, A. Toschi, M. W. Haverkort, G. Sangiovanni, K. Held, P. Metcalf, and M. Marsi, Phys. Rev. B 84, 245113 (2011).
- [34]S. M. Winter, Journal of Physics: Materials 5, 045003 (2022).
- [36]M. I. Katsnelson and A. I. Lichtenstein, Phys. Rev. B 61, 8906 (2000).
- [37]N. Marzari, A. A. Mostofi, J. R. Yates, I. Souza, and D. Vanderbilt, Reviews of Modern Physics 84, 1419–1475 (2012).
- [38]A. A. Mostofi, J. R. Yates, G. Pizzi, Y.-S. Lee, I. Souza, D. Vanderbilt, and N. Marzari, Computer Physics Communications 185, 2309 (2014).
- [39]C. Kim, H.-S. Kim, and J.-G. Park, Journal of Physics: Condensed Matter 34, 023001 (2021).
- [40]K. Held, Advances in Physics 56, 829 (2007).
- [41]P. W. Anderson, Phys. Rev. 124, 41 (1961).
- [42]G. Kotliar and D. Vollhardt, Physics Today 57, 53 (2004).
- [43]F. i. c. v. IV and M. Ferrero, Phys. Rev. B 105, 125104 (2022).
- [44]X.-Z. Li and H. Yao, Ann. Rev. Condensed Matter Phys. 10, 337 (2019), arXiv:1805.08219 [cond-mat.str-el].
- [45]E. Sheridan, C. Weber, E. Plekhanov, and C. Rhodes, Phys. Rev. B 99, 205156 (2019).
- [46]E. Gull, A. J. Millis, A. I. Lichtenstein, A. N. Rubtsov, M. Troyer, and P. Werner, Rev. Mod. Phys. 83, 349 (2011).
- [47]P. Werner and A. J. Millis, Phys. Rev. B 74, 155107 (2006).
- [48]M. Jarrell and J. Gubernatis, Physics Reports 269, 133 (1996).
- [49]B. Kang, M. Park, S. Song, S. Noh, D. Choe, M. Kong, M. Kim, C. Seo, E. K. Ko, G. Yi, J.-W. Yoo, S. Park, J. M. Ok, and C. Sohn, Phys. Rev. B 107, 075103 (2023).
- [50]T. Takayama, J. Chaloupka, A. Smerald, G. Khaliullin, and H. Takagi, Journal of the Physical Society of Japan 90, 062001 (2021), https://doi.org/10.7566/JPSJ.90.062001.
- [51]K. F. Foyevtsova, H. O. Jeschke, I. I. Mazin, D. J. Khomskii, and R. Valentí, Phys. Rev. B 88, 035107 (2013).