WorksMathematics
On a finite group in which every non-nilpotent maximal invariant subgroup of order divisible by is normal
Abstract
Let and be finite groups such that acts coprimely on by automorphisms. For any fixed prime divisor of , we prove that if every non-nilpotent maximal -invariant subgroup of of order divisible by is normal then has a Sylow tower and is -nilpotent or -closed for each prime divisor of .
Introduction
In this paper all groups are considered to be finite. In [4 Theorems 1.3 and 3.5] Lu, Pang and Zhong showed that if every non-nilpotent maximal subgroup of a group is normal then is -nilpotent and -closed for some primes and . As a generalization, Shi [6 Theorem 5] proved that a group in which every non-nilpotent maximal subgroup is normal has a Sylow tower. Furthermore, Shi, Li and Shen [7 Theorem 1.7] obtained that such a group is either -nilpotent or -closed for any prime divisor of . For any fixed prime divisor of , they [7 Theorem 1.6] proved that if every non-nilpotent maximal subgroup of of order divisible by is normal then there exists at most one prime divisor of such that is neither -nilpotent nor -closed.
Combining the coprime action of groups, let and be groups such that acts coprimely on by automorphisms. Beltrán and Shao [2 Theorem A] showed if every non-nilpotent maximal -invariant subgroup of is normal then is -nilpotent for some prime dividing . Li et al [3 Theorem 1.5] had that such a group is a Sylow tower group. As an extension, Shi and Liu [8 Theorem 1.5] indicated that if
E-mail addresses: [email protected] (J. Shi), [email protected] (F. Li), [email protected] (N. Li). every non-nilpotent maximal -invariant subgroup of is normal then is -nilpotent or -closed for each prime divisor of . Furthermore, Shi and Xu [10 Theorem 1.9] proved that every non-nilpotent maximal -invariant subgroup of is normal if and only if , where are normal Sylow subgroups of for , are non-normal -invariant Sylow subgroups of for , and there exists an -invariant subgroup of such that is normal in and is a nilpotent maximal -invariant subgroup of . Note that Beltrán and Shao [2 Theorem C] showed that if every non-nilpotent maximal -invariant subgroup of of order divisible by is normal then is solvable, where is a prime divisor of .
In this paper, as a further generalization and extension of above literature, we have the following result, the proof of which is given in Section 3.
Theorem 1.1 Let and be groups such that acts coprimely on by automorphisms. If every non-nilpotent maximal -invariant subgroup of of order divisible by is normal for any fixed prime divisor of . Then has a Sylow tower.
Furthermore, based on Theorem 1.1, we obtain the following result, the proof of which is given in Section 4.
Theorem 1.2 Let and be groups such that acts coprimely on by automorphisms. If every non-nilpotent maximal -invariant subgroup of of order divisible by is normal for any fixed prime divisor of . Then is either -nilpotent or -closed for each prime divisor of .
The following corollary is a direct consequence of Theorem 1.2.
Corollary 1.3 If every non-nilpotent maximal subgroup of a group of order divisible by is normal for any fixed prime divisor of . Then is -nilpotent or -closed for each prime divisor of .
Note that Theorem 1.2 provides a complete generalization and improvement of [7 Theorem 1.6].
Several Necessary Lemmas
Lemma 2.1 [1 Theorem B] Let and be groups of coprime orders and assume that acts on by automorphisms. If has a nilpotent maximal -invariant subgroup of odd order, then is solvable.
Lemma 2.2 [5 Lemma 2.3] Suppose that a group acts coprimely on a group . If every maximal -invariant subgroup of is normal, then is nilpotent.
Lemma 2.3 [11 Lemma 9] Let be a nilpotent Hall-subgroup of a group that is not a Sylow subgroup of . If for each prime divisor of , assume we always have , then there exists a normal subgroup of such that and .
Proof of Theorem 1.1
Proof. Part I. We first provide a new proof to show that is solvable.
Let be a counterexample of the smallest order. For any -invariant normal subgroup of , it is easy to see that the hypothesis of the theorem also holds for the quotient group . It follows that has no non-trivial solvable -invariant normal subgroups.
If every maximal -invariant subgroup of of order divisible by is nilpotent. Then we can easily get that has normal Sylow subgroups arguing as in the proof of [9 Theorem 1.3] in which the solvability of the group is not involved. It implies that has non-trivial solvable -invariant normal subgroups, a contradiction.
If every maximal -invariant subgroup of of order divisible by is non-nilpotent. Then every maximal -invariant subgroup of of order divisible by is normal by the hypothesis. Let be an -invariant Sylow -subgroup of . Since is not normal in , is a proper -invariant subgroup of . Then has a maximal -invariant subgroup such that . Note that . By the assumption, is normal in . Then by Frattini’s argument, a contradiction.
It follows that not only has nilpotent maximal -invariant subgroups of order divisible by but also has non-nilpotent maximal -invariant subgroups of order divisible by .
Let be a non-nilpotent maximal -invariant subgroup of of order divisible by and a minimal -invariant normal subgroup of such that . Let be the largest prime divisor of . Since is non-solvable, . Let be an -invariant Sylow -subgroup of . Then is an -invariant Sylow -subgroup of . Note that is not normal in . It follows that has a maximal -invariant subgroup such that . In the following we discuss in three cases.
Case (1): Assume that is nilpotent.
Since has no non-trivial solvable -invariant normal subgroups and is a nilpotent maximal -invariant subgroup of , must be a nilpotent Hall-subgroup of . Moreover, let be any -invariant Sylow subgroup of , one has . Note that and is odd. Since is non-solvable, cannot be a Sylow subgroup of by Lemma2.1. Therefore, has a normal subgroup such that by Lemma 2.3. Since is not only a maximal -invariant subgroup of but also a Hall-subgroup of , it follows that is not only a minimal normal subgroup of but also a Hall-subgroup of . Thus is characteristic in , which implies that is also an -invariant subgroup of . Then is also a minimal -invariant normal subgroup of . Since , one has . It follows that and are two distinct minimal -invariant normal subgroups of , which implies that . By the minimality of , one has that both and are solvable. Then , which implies that is solvable, a contradiction.
Case (2): Assume that is non-nilpotent and . By the hypothesis, is normal in . It follows that by Frattini’s argument, a contradiction.
Case (3): Assume that is non-nilpotent and . Note that by Frattini’s argument. One has . Let be an -invariant Sylow -subgroup of . Then is an -invariant Sylow -subgroup of . Note that . There exists a maximal -invariant subgroup of such that . If is non-nilpotent. Since , one has by the hypothesis. Then by Frattini’s argument, a contradiction. Thus is nilpotent.
Case (i): When or but is not a Sylow subgroup of , arguing as above Case (1), we can get a contradiction.
Case (ii): When and is an -invariant Sylow 2-subgroup of . By Frattini’s argument, . Note that and . Thus one has . Since , it follows that and then . One has . It follows that . However, and is a maximal -invariant subgroup of , a contradiction.
All above analyses imply that the counterexample of the smallest order does not exist and so is solvable.
Part II. We show that has normal Sylow subgroups.
Let be a counterexample of the smallest order and a minimal -invariant normal subgroup of . Since is a characteristic simple group of and is solvable, is an elementary abelian group of prime-power order. Assume , where is a prime divisor of and . By the minimality of , has a normal Sylow subgroup , where is an -invariant Sylow -subgroup of . Then is normal in . By our assumption, is not normal in . Then . It follows that has a maximal -invariant subgroup such that . By Frattini’s argument, one has .
If . Then we must have and is a normal Sylow -subgroup of , a contradiction.
If . We discuss in two cases.
Case (i): Assume that is non-nilpotent. Then is normal in by the hypothesis. One has by Frattini’s argument, a contradiction.
Case (ii): Assume that is nilpotent. Let be an -invariant Sylow -subgroup of . Then is a normal Sylow -subgroup of , also a contradiction.
Hence the counterexample of the smallest order does not exist and then has normal Sylow subgroups.
Part III. Final conclusion.
Let be a normal Sylow -subgroup of . Considering the quotient group , the hypothesis of the theorem also holds for . Then has a normal Sylow -subgroup , where is an -invariant Sylow -subgroup of . An so on, we can get a normal subgroups series: , where is an -invariant Sylow -subgroup of for each . It follows that has a Sylow tower.
Proof of Theorem 1.2
Proof. Let be an -invariant Sylow -subgroup of . In the following we discuss in two cases.
Case (1): Assume that is normal in . Let , , , be all normal Sylow subgroups of , where is an -invariant Sylow -subgroup of for . Considering the -invariant subgroup . Since is solvable, has an -invariant Hall-subgroup such that . Note that for any -invariant Sylow subgroup of , one has that is not normal in by the choice of above for .
Claim that is nilpotent. Otherwise, assume that is non-nilpotent. By Lemma 2.2, has an non-normal maximal -invariant subgroup . It is obvious that is a maximal -invariant subgroup of .
Case (i): Suppose that is non-nilpotent. Then is normal in by the hypothesis since . It follows that is normal in , a contradiction.
Case (ii): Suppose that is nilpotent. Then . It follows that . For every , one has . It follows that , where is a normal closure of in . Since both and are -invariant subgroups of , one has that is also an -invariant subgroup of . It is easy to see that since is not normal in . By the maximality of , one has . Then . It follows that . For any non-nilpotent maximal -invariant of , is a non-nilpotent maximal -invariant subgroup of of order divisible by , one has that is normal in by the hypothesis. It follows that is normal . Thus every non-nilpotent maximal -invariant subgroup of is normal. By Theorem 1.1, has a normal Sylow subgroup , where is an -invariant Sylow subgroup of . Note that . Then . It follows that . Since and , one has that is normal in , also a contradiction. Therefore, is nilpotent. Hence is -closed when and is -nilpotent when .
Case (2): Assume that is not normal in . Note that has normal Sylow subgroups. Let be all normal Sylow subgroups of , where is an -invariant Sylow -subgroup of for . Let . There exists an -invariant Hall-subgroup of such that . Note that . For any non-nilpotent maximal -invariant subgroup of of order divisible by , is a non-nilpotent maximal -invariant subgroup of of order divisible by . By the hypothesis, is normal in . It follows that is normal in . Then has a normal Sylow subgroup by Theorem 1.1, where is an -invariant Sylow subgroup of . It follows that . Let be a maximal -invariant subgroup of such that . If is non-nilpotent. Since , one has . Then is normal in by the hypothesis. It follows that by Frattini’s argument, a contradiction. Thus is nilpotent, which implies that is nilpotent. Therefore, is -closed when and is -nilpotent when .
References
- [1]A. Beltrán and C. Shao, Restrictions on maximal invariant subgroups implying solvability of finite groups, Annali di Matematica Pura ed Applicata 198(2) (2019) 357-366.DOI
- [2]A. Beltrán and C. Shao, New conditions on maximal invariant subgroups that imply solubility, Results in Mathematics 78(149) (2023) (11 pages).DOI
- [3]M. Li, J. Lu, B. Zhang and W. Meng, Some generalizations of Shao and Beltrán’s theorem, Journal of Algebra and Its Applications 22(3) (2023) 2350067 (6 pages).
- [4]J. Lu, L. Pang and X. Zhong, Finite groups with non-nilpotent maximal subgroups, Monatshefte für Mathematik 171 (2013) 425-431.DOI
- [5]C. Shao and A. Beltrán, Invariant TI-subgroups and structure of finite groups, Journal of Pure and Applied Algebra 225 (2021) 106566 (8 pages).DOI
- [6]J. Shi, A finite group in which all non-nilpotent maximal subgroups are normal has a Sylow tower, Hokkaido Mathematical Journal 48(2) (2019) 309-312.DOI
- [7]J. Shi, N. Li and R. Shen, Finite groups in which every maximal subgroup is nilpotent or normal or has p′-order, International Journal of Algebra and Computation 33(5) (2023) 1055-1063 (arXiv: 2202.02322 [math.GR]).arxiv.org/abs/2202.02322
- [8]J. Shi and Y. Liu, On finite groups in which every non-nilpotent maximal invariant subgroup is normal, Journal of Algebra and Its Applications 24(6) (2025) 2550165 (6 pages).
- [9]J. Shi, M. Shan and F. Xu, Finite groups in which every maximal invariant subgroup of order divisible by p is nilpotent, Georgian Mathematical Journal 33(2) (2026) 319–322.arxiv.org/abs/2502.06408
- [10]J. Shi and F. Xu, Finite groups with some particular maximal invariant subgroups being nilpotent or all non-nilpotent maximal invariant subgroups being normal, arXiv: 2408.01249 [math.GR].arxiv.org/abs/2408.01249
- [11]H. Wielandt, Über produkte von nilpotenten gruppen, Illinois Journal of Mathematics 2 (1958) 611-618.DOI