betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Geometric Formulation of Covariant Spin Operator

Abstract

In relativistic quantum theory, Lorentz boosts induce momentum-dependent Wigner rotations, complicating the coupling of particle spins in arbitrary frames. We describe particle spin spaces as fibers of an associate bundle over the velocity manifold, and different particle's spins residing at distinct fibers. Analogy to general relativity, we introduce parallel transport to bring spins at different velocities into a common frame, where they can be coupled. Using spinor-helicity variables, we construct the parallel transport operator along geodesics and show how it is uniquely determined by little group covariance. This construction gives explicit form of the covariant spin and orbital operators, and yields a covariant 3-point amplitude basis with definite spin and orbital angular momentum. Higher-point amplitudes can be constructively obtained and applied to the covariant partial wave expansion for amplitudes, form factors, and correlation functions, etc.

Introduction

Introduction. Spin is a fundamental, quantized property of an elementary particle. In quantum mechanics, spin transforms as intrinsic angular momentum under spatial rotations, but its behavior under boosts differs between nonrelativistic and relativistic theories. In nonrelativistic quantum theory, the spin operator, Si=Ji−(x×p)iS_i = J_i - (\mathbf{x} \times\mathbf{p})_i, is invariant under Galilean boosts, which therefore do not mix spin and orbital degrees of freedom. In relativistic quantum theory, by contrast, spin operators such as the Newton–Wigner spin operator [1, 2] generally undergo momentum-dependent Wigner rotations under Lorentz boosts. Consequently, a Lorentz boost generally mixes spin and orbital degrees of freedom.

In multiparticle systems, coupling individual spins to form states of definite total spin is essential for describing scattering, decays, and bound states. In the nonrelativistic setting, Galilean invariance allows spins to be coupled using Clebsch–Gordan coefficients independently of the system’s overall motion. In the relativistic setting, however, spin transformations follow induced representations of the Poincaré group and involve momentum-dependent Wigner rotations. Although spins can be coupled in the center-of-mass (COM) frame, extending the spin coupling to arbitrary frames while keeping its covariant form has remained a longstanding challenge.

We realize the relativistic spin is defined locally in the momentum space, treated as the bundle structure over the velocity manifold. Each velocity carries a spin space, represented by a fiber of an associated bundle. Spins at different velocities must be referred to a common frame before they can be coupled covariantly. Analogy to parallel transport in general relativity, we define the transport to carry spins in different fibers into a common point along the geodesic path. This construction defines an additive covariant spin operator for a multiparticle system and a corresponding orbital operator. It also provides a geometric route from Wigner states to a covariant orbital–spin amplitude basis.

Wigner state, spin operator and fiber bundle

In relativistic quantum theory a massive elementary particle is defined as a unitary irreducible representation of the Poincaré group, and Wigner’s method of induced representations [3, 4] builds it from two ingredients. The first is the little group HH, the Lorentz subgroup that stabilizes a chosen reference velocity u⋆=(1,0)u_\star= (1, 0): its unitary irreducible representations label the rest-frame states ∣mu⋆,σ⟩\lvert m u_\star, \sigma\rangle. The second is the coset space G/H≡SL(2,C)/SU(2)G/H \equiv\mathrm{SL}(2,\mathbb{C})/\mathrm{SU}(2), whose representatives Lu∈GL_u \in G label the velocities u=Luu⋆u = L_u u_\star up to a rest-frame rotation h(u⋆)∈Hh(u_\star) \in H, the momentum-dependent states being obtained by the boost action, ∣p,σ⟩=U^(Lu)∣mu⋆,σ⟩\lvert p, \sigma\rangle= \hat{U}(L_u)\lvert m u_\star, \sigma\rangle with p=mup = m u. The set of all four-velocities uu, that is, the coset space G/HG/H, forms the velocity manifold

M={u:u2=1, u0>0}≃SL(2,C)/SU(2).(1)M = \{u : u^2 = 1,\ u^0 > 0\} \simeq\mathrm{SL}(2,\mathbb{C})/\mathrm{SU}(2). \tag*{(1)}

Its Riemannian metric is ds2=−du⋅duds^2 = -du \cdot du on tangent vectors, and it has constant curvature. A fixed-mass momentum shell is a rescaled copy of MM; particles of different masses are therefore compared on the same normalized manifold, not on one fixed-mass shell. The little group is the stabilizer of a chosen reference point u⋆u_\star of MM. At any other point u=gu⋆u = g u_\star of MM, with g∈Gg \in G, the corresponding stabilizer is the conjugate subgroup gHg−1g H g^{-1}. Every gg admits the coset decomposition g=Luhg = L_u h with h∈Hh \in H, and two choices of the boost representative LuL_u differ by a rest-frame rotation h(u)∈Hh(u) \in H; that rotation is the freedom of choosing the spin axis at the velocity uu, and geometrically it is a gauge transformation [5].

Lifting this coset picture to a bundle, GG forms a principal HH-bundle over the coset base manifold G/HG/H, with each velocity point uu equipped with a little-group HH fiber. A point of the bundle can be written (u,h)(u,h); choosing the standard boosts LuL_u and using the coset decomposition identifies two equivalent bundle structures [6, 7] (u,h)≅(Lu,h)=Luh(u,h) \cong(L_u,h) = L_u h, which is a point g∈Gg \in G. A right multiplication g↦gh(u)g \mapsto g h(u) with h(u)∈Hh(u) \in H defines the right action: it changes the section,

Lu→Luh(u)L_u \to L_u h(u), and the fiber coordinate, h→h(u)−1hh(u)h \to h(u)^{-1}h h(u), since gh(u)=Luhh(u)=(Luh(u))(h(u)−1hh(u))g h(u) = L_u h h(u) = (L_u h(u))(h(u)^{-1}h h(u)); HH is the gauge freedom that rotates the spin axis at fixed velocity and does not move uu. Left action on gg is defined by a Lorentz multiplication from the left, g↦Λg=(ΛLu,h)g \mapsto\Lambda g = (\Lambda L_u,h). Using the coset decomposition ΛLu=LΛuW\Lambda L_u = L_{\Lambda u}W with the Wigner rotation W(Λ,u)≡LΛu−1ΛLuW(\Lambda,u) \equiv L_{\Lambda u}^{-1}\Lambda L_u, one has Λg=(LΛu,Wh)\Lambda g = (L_{\Lambda u},Wh): the left action moves the velocity, u↦Λuu \mapsto\Lambda u, and rotates the fiber by WW as shown in Figure 1.

Coset decomposition on principal bundle

Figure 1. The coset decomposition on principal bundle. The left action of Λ\Lambda carries the frame LuL_u into fiber over Λu\Lambda u, and the Wigner rotation WW is the right multiplication with LΛuL_{\Lambda u}.

The above tells that gg carries a left GG-action and a right HH-action, which act on the two indices of gαIg_{\alpha}^{I} separately; the group element is therefore conveniently labelled by the spinor [8, 9]. In the spinor-helicity formalism [10, 11, 12, 13] it reads

λαI=m gαI,λ~α˙I=(λαI)∗,pαα˙=λαIλ~α˙I,(2)\lambda_{\alpha}^{I}=\sqrt{m}\,g_{\alpha}^{I},\qquad\tilde{\lambda}_{\dot{\alpha}I}=(\lambda_{\alpha}^{I})^{*},\qquad p_{\alpha\dot{\alpha}}=\lambda_{\alpha}^{I}\tilde{\lambda}_{\dot{\alpha}I}, \tag*{(2)}

with II the little-group index and α,α˙\alpha,\dot{\alpha} the Lorentz indices. Once we fix gg to be the standard boost LuL_u, the spinor transforms covariantly under the GG-action as λαI↦ΛλαI(u)=λαJ(Λu)WJI(Λ,u)\lambda_{\alpha}^{I}\mapsto\Lambda\lambda_{\alpha}^{I}(u)=\lambda_{\alpha}^{J}(\Lambda u)W^{I}_{J}(\Lambda,u), and under the HH-action as λαI↦λαJhJI\lambda_{\alpha}^{I}\mapsto\lambda_{\alpha}^{J}h^{I}_{J}.

The spin operator is the infinitesimal generator of the right action of HH, that is, of the transformation that rotates the spin axis at fixed velocity. Using the coordinate λαI\lambda_{\alpha}^{I} on the principal bundle, its differential realization in terms of vector field ∂/∂λαI\partial/\partial\lambda_{\alpha}^{I} is:

SIJ≡λαJ∂∂λαI+c.c.,Sρ≡12(σρ)I JSJI,(3)S_{I}^{J}\equiv\lambda_{\alpha}^{J}\frac{\partial}{\partial\lambda_{\alpha}^{I}}+\mathrm{c.c.},\qquad S_{\rho}\equiv\frac{1}{2}(\sigma_{\rho})_{I}^{\ J}S_{J}^{I}, \tag*{(3)}

where parentheses denote symmetrization in I,JI,J, and c.c. denotes the complex conjugation and ρ=±1,0\rho=\pm1,0 labels the spherical basis of Pauli matrices.

Once a section LuL_u is chosen, the spin operator can also be written in terms of the Poincaré generators. With the Lorentz generators Mαβ≡λαI∂/∂λβIM_{\alpha\beta}\equiv\lambda_{\alpha}^{I}\partial/\partial\lambda^{\beta I}, the Pauli–Lubanski vector is Wαα˙=p α˙βMαβ−pα β˙M˙α˙β˙W_{\alpha\dot{\alpha}}=p^{\beta}_{\ \dot{\alpha}}M_{\alpha\beta}-p_{\alpha}^{\ \dot{\beta}}\dot{M}_{\dot{\alpha}\dot{\beta}}, and the polarization vectors of the section are ϵαα˙IJ(u)≅1mλα(Iλα˙J)\epsilon_{\alpha\dot{\alpha}}^{IJ}(u)\cong\frac{1}{m}\lambda_{\alpha}^{(I}\lambda_{\dot{\alpha}}^{J)}; expanding Eq. (3) in the spinor coordinates then gives

SIJ(u)=12mϵIJαα˙(u)Wαα˙,Sρ(u)=1mϵμ(u)ρWμ.(4)S_{IJ}(u)=\frac{1}{2m}\epsilon_{IJ}^{\alpha\dot{\alpha}}(u)W_{\alpha\dot{\alpha}},\qquad S_{\rho}(u)=\frac{1}{m}\epsilon^{\mu}(u)_{\rho}W_{\mu}. \tag*{(4)}

Taking LuL_u to be the canonical boost Lu=Bc(u)L_u=B_c(u) gives the Newton-Wigner spin operator Si(u)=1m(Wi−W0pip0+m)S_i(u)=\frac{1}{m}\left(W_i-\frac{W^0p_i}{p^0+m}\right).

The principal bundle GG has an associated bundle Es≡G×HVsE_s\equiv G\times_H V_s to describe massive spin-ss particles, with the spin space VsV_s carrying spin-ss irreducible representation ρs\rho_s of H=SU(2)H=\mathrm{SU}(2). The fiber (Es)u(E_s)_u at velocity uu is then the representation space of the spin operator SIJ(u)S_{IJ}(u). A spin-ss particle state is built from Wigner states together with a wave function ψσ(u)\psi_\sigma(u) over EsE_s,

∣Ψ⟩=∑σ=−ss∫Md3uu0 ψσ(u)∣m,u,σ⟩,(5)|\Psi\rangle=\sum_{\sigma=-s}^{s}\int_M\frac{d^3u}{u^0}\,\psi_\sigma(u)|m,u,\sigma\rangle, \tag*{(5)}

with d3u/u0d^3u/u^0 the Lorentz-invariant measure on MM. These states span the Hilbert space Hs≅L2(M,d3u/u0⊗Vs)\mathcal{H}_s\cong L^2(M,d^3u/u^0\otimes V_s), that is, the space of square-integrable functions on EsE_s.

Since EsE_s is associated to GG through ρs\rho_s, the vertical vector fields of Eq. (3) act on the fiber VsV_s through the differential of ρs\rho_s, yielding the fiber-wise operators Sρψσ(u)=(Jρ)σσ′ψσ′(u)S_\rho\psi_\sigma(u)=(\mathcal{J}_\rho)_{\sigma\sigma'}\psi_{\sigma'}(u), where Jρ\mathcal{J}_\rho are the spin-ss angular-momentum matrices in the spherical basis. The unitary isomorphism Eq. (5), which identifies the component ψσ(u)\psi_\sigma(u) of the wave function with the coefficient of ∣m,u,σ⟩|m,u,\sigma\rangle, gives the quantum operator action Sρ∣m,u,σ⟩=∑σ′∣m,u,σ′⟩(Jρ)σ′σS_\rho|m,u,\sigma\rangle=\sum_{\sigma'}|m,u,\sigma'\rangle(\mathcal{J}_\rho)_{\sigma'\sigma}.

From Eq. (3) and Eq. (4), the spin operator is defined relative to the chosen LuL_u, and therefore depends on the choice of spin axes. This is what obstructs a direct coupling of two particle spins. Under Lu→Luh(u)L_u\to L_u h(u), the spin operator rotates according to Sρ↦ρ1(h(u)−1)ρ σSσS_\rho\mapsto\rho_1(h(u)^{-1})_{\rho}^{\ \sigma}S_\sigma, with ρ1\rho_1 the adjoint (spin-one) representation: it is gauge covariant rather than gauge invariant, carrying one adjoint little-group index. A sum of two such operators is therefore not covariant: under a change of frame, Sρ(u)+Sρ(v)S_\rho(u)+S_\rho(v) becomes

ρ1(h(u)−1)ρ σSσ(u)+ρ1(h(v)−1)ρ σSσ(v),(6)\rho_1(h(u)^{-1})_{\rho}^{\ \sigma}S_\sigma(u)+\rho_1(h(v)^{-1})_{\rho}^{\ \sigma}S_\sigma(v), \tag*{(6)}

because the two frames can be redefined independently, by h(u)h(u) and by h(v)h(v); the sum acquires two different rotations and is no longer of the same form. No natural unified choice of the two frames exists that would repair this, so a direct coupling of the two spins is impossible; they can be coupled only after being referred to a common frame.

Spin transport along geodesic. For the spin sum Sρ(u)+Sρ(v)S_\rho(u)+S_\rho(v) to transform covariantly under the gauge transformation, Stot→ρ(h−1)StotS^{\mathrm{tot}}\to\rho(h^{-1})S^{\mathrm{tot}} with h∈Hh\in H, we introduce a transport T(v,u)∈HT(v,u)\in H that refers the spin at uu to the frame at vv. The transported sum Sρtot=ρ1(T(v,u))ρ σSσ(u)+Sρ(v)S^{\mathrm{tot}}_\rho=\rho_1(T(v,u))_{\rho}^{\ \sigma}S_\sigma(u)+S_\rho(v) is a little-group tensor at vv only if the transport compensates the two independent redefinitions of the frames, that is, only if

T(v,u)⟶h(v)−1T(v,u)h(u)(7)T(v,u)\longrightarrow h(v)^{-1}T(v,u)h(u) \tag*{(7)}

under Lu→Luh(u)L_u\to L_u h(u) and $L_v\to L_v h(v): with this gauge law the two little-group factors in the transported sum combine into the single rotation ρ1(h(v)−1)\rho_1(h(v)^{-1}) of an operator at vv, and the sum keeps its form. To construct T(v,u)T(v,u), an element of HH obeying the gauge law of Eq. (7), we need a connection on the principal bundle. There a single element of HH encodes the transport for every representation, the action on EsE_s then following by applying ρs\rho_s fiberwise. The canonical connection is fixed by the Cartan decomposition g=h⊕m\mathfrak{g}=\mathfrak{h}\oplus\mathfrak{m}, with h=su(2)\mathfrak{h}=\mathfrak{su}(2) the little-group algebra: its form is the h\mathfrak{h}-component of the Maurer–Cartan form [7, 14, 15, 16]: λ−1dλ=ωh+ωm\lambda^{-1}d\lambda=\omega_{\mathfrak{h}}+\omega_{\mathfrak{m}}, with the vertical component ωh∈h\omega_{\mathfrak{h}}\in\mathfrak{h}, while the horizontal component ωm∈m\omega_{\mathfrak{m}}\in\mathfrak{m} dropped. To compare the frames at two different velocities one integrates along a curve γ\gamma in MM joining them, and the transport is the path-ordered exponential of ωh\omega_{\mathfrak{h}},

Tγ=Pexp⁡(−∫γωh)∈H,(8)T_\gamma=\mathcal{P}\exp\left(-\int_\gamma\omega_{\mathfrak{h}}\right)\in H, \tag*{(8)}

which belongs to the little group fiber, and thus the gauge law T(v,u)↦h(v)−1T(v,u)h(u)T(v,u)\mapsto h(v)^{-1}T(v,u)h(u) under the right action Lu↦Luh(u)L_u\mapsto L_uh(u) follows.

In addition to their behavior under changes of section, both SρS_\rho and T(v,u)T(v,u) must respect the left action of the Lorentz transformation. For the spin operator, Lorentz transformation induces the Wigner rotation W(Λ,u)W(\Lambda,u) of the frame at uu, and pushing this to HsH_s through the isomorphism Eq. (5) gives

U(Λ)Sρ(u)U(Λ)−1=ρ1(W(Λ,u)−1)ρ σSσ(Λu),(9)U(\Lambda)S_\rho(u)U(\Lambda)^{-1}=\rho_1\left(W(\Lambda,u)^{-1}\right)_\rho^{\ \sigma}S_\sigma(\Lambda u), \tag*{(9)}

where the Wigner rotation W(Λ,u)W(\Lambda,u) depends on uu and the chosen section. Therefore, the same Λ\Lambda gives different Wigner rotations at different velocities,

W(Λ,u)≠W(Λ,v)(u≠v),(10)W(\Lambda,u)\ne W(\Lambda,v)\qquad(u\ne v), \tag*{(10)}

so the direct sum S(u)+S(v)S(u)+S(v) does not generally transform by a common rotation. On the other hand, the transported sum, written schematically as Stot=T(v,u)S(u)+S(v)S^{\mathrm{tot}}=T(v,u)S(u)+S(v), obeys U(Λ)Stot(v)U(Λ)−1=ρ1(W(Λ,v))Stot(Λv)U(\Lambda)S^{\mathrm{tot}}(v)U(\Lambda)^{-1}=\rho_1\left(W(\Lambda,v)\right)S^{\mathrm{tot}}(\Lambda v), only if the transport itself compensates the two rotations,

T(Λv,Λu)=W(Λ,v)T(v,u)W(Λ,u)−1,(11)T(\Lambda v,\Lambda u)=W(\Lambda,v)T(v,u)W(\Lambda,u)^{-1}, \tag*{(11)}

so that the two little-group factors combine into the single rotation of an operator at Λv\Lambda v.

The transport TγT_\gamma itself depends on the curve γ\gamma chosen for it. The transport relation in Eq. (11) would determine the γ\gamma path to be geodesic. Let us start from each side of the Eq. (11), there are two unrelated curves, γ(v,u)\gamma(v,u) from uu to vv and γ(Λv,Λu)\gamma(\Lambda v,\Lambda u) from Λu\Lambda u to Λv\Lambda v, and nothing connects them. To make it hold we must therefore require the curves themselves to be related, point by point (Figure 2)

The principal bundle G over the velocity manifold M

Figure 2. The principal bundle GG over the velocity manifold MM: MM is the shaded patch, the dotted lines are the fibers HH. The path γ\gamma joins the velocities uu and vv, and a Lorentz transformation carries the whole configuration into Λγ\Lambda\gamma, joining Λu\Lambda u and Λv\Lambda v. The lifts of the two paths induce the transports TT (blue), while the frames at uu and Λu\Lambda u, and at vv and Λv\Lambda v, are related by the Wigner rotations WW (red). In both diagrams the arrows commute: the two ways from uu to Λv\Lambda v compose to the same map, Eq. (12) on the base and Eq. (11) on the fibers.

γ(Λv,Λu)=Λγ(v,u).(12)\gamma(\Lambda v,\Lambda u)=\Lambda\gamma(v,u). \tag*{(12)}

This condition fixes the curve uniquely: it is the geodesic path

γ(s)=(1−s)u+sv(1−s)2+s2+2s(1−s) u⋅v,0≤s≤1,(13)\gamma(s)=\frac{(1-s)u+sv}{\sqrt{(1-s)^2+s^2+2s(1-s)\,u\cdot v}},\qquad0\le s\le1, \tag*{(13)}

which is built from the two velocities alone and therefore satisfies Eq. (12) by construction; its parameter ss is in general not affine. The corresponding geodesic boost is B(v,u)=\frac{1+\slashed{v}\slashed{u}}{\sqrt{2(1+u\cdot v)}}, and the transport along the geodesic could be evaluated although quite complicated. In this work, however, we would adapt more elegant way to construct the covariant spinor form of the transport in the principal bundle from symmetry argument, irrelevant of the explicit form of the geodesic and Lorentz boost, provided in supplementary material.

Transport and on-shell amplitudes in spinor formalism. The transport TT is constrained by Eq. (11), which indicates that TT carries one little-group index at uu and one at vv, so that T(v,u)T(v,u) can be written as a function of the spinors λ(u)\lambda(u) and λ(v)\lambda(v). For constituents of spin 12\frac{1}{2} the transport is a 2×22\times2 matrix T KIT^I_{\ K}; like the form of scattering amplitudes below, it is a little-group tensor, carrying one index at uu and one at vv.

Just like the three-point amplitudes are uniquely determined by the Poincare symmetry [8, 17, 18], we note two requirements determine the amplitude form of the transport completely, although only two momenta u,vu,v are involved in TT. (i) Symmetry: a Lorentz-invariant object carrying one index at each leg can only be built from the two spinors λ(u)\lambda(u) and λ(v)\lambda(v), and the only invariant contractions with one index at each leg are ⟨uKvI⟩\langle u_Kv^I\rangle and [uKvI][u_Kv^I], a mixed contraction λλ~\lambda\tilde{\lambda} carries a Lorentz index and is excluded, while every other contraction is a scalar u⋅vu\cdot v that belongs to the coefficient,

T KI(v,u)=a ⟨uKvI⟩+b [uKvI].(14)T^I_{\ K}(v,u)=a\,\langle u_Kv^I\rangle+b\,[u_Kv^I]. \tag*{(14)}

(ii) Kinematics: choosing the canonical section Lu=Bc(u)L_u = B_c(u) and Lv=Bc(v)L_v = B_c(v), we note in the COM frame the spin coupling is trivial, TKI(v,u⋆)=δKIT^I_K(v,u_\star) = \delta^I_K, which fixes b=−ab=-a and the normalization,

τiKI≡[vIuK]−⟨vIuK⟩,τiKI=τiKI2mumv(u⋅v+1).(15)\tau^I_{iK} \equiv[v^Iu_K]-\langle v^Iu_K\rangle,\qquad\tau^I_{iK}=\frac{\tau^I_{iK}}{\sqrt{2m_um_v(u\cdot v+1)}}. \tag*{(15)}

The normalization mumvm_um_v comes from the m\sqrt{m} in Eq. (2): for the physical momenta muum_uu and mvvm_vv, the τ\tau above carries dimension [τ]=[mass][\tau]=[\mathrm{mass}]. Eq. (15) is the unique matrix carrying one index at vv and one at uu and reducing to δKI\delta^I_K in the COM frame, and the horizontal lift along a geodesic has precisely these properties by construction. The symmetric construction above is consistent with the earlier geometric construction using ωh\omega_h as in Eq. (11). For spin sis_i it acts on the symmetric index set {I}=(I1⋯I2si)\{I\}=(I_1\cdots I_{2s_i}) as the symmetrized product

ρs(T){K}{I}=T(K1⋯K2si)(I1⋯I2si),(16)\rho_s(T)^{\{I\}}_{\{K\}}=T^{(I_1\cdots I_{2s_i})}_{(K_1\cdots K_{2s_i})}, \tag*{(16)}

so that a single spin-12\frac{1}{2} object generates every spin.

With TT at hand the spins of several particles can be brought into a single frame. Transporting each little-group index separately gives the transported spin operator,

SK1K2(u)=TK1I1(U,u)TK2I2(U,u)SI1I2(u),(17)S_{K_1K_2}(u)=T_{K_1}^{I_1}(U,u)T_{K_2}^{I_2}(U,u)S_{I_1I_2}(u), \tag*{(17)}

the general case being the symmetric product ρs(T){K}{I}\rho_s(T)^{\{I\}}_{\{K\}} of Eq. (16), the little-group indices at uiu_i being contracted in favour of those at UU, the transported spin operators all carry the same indices and can be added,

SK1K2(U)=SK1K2(u)+SK1K2(v).(18)S_{K_1K_2}(U)=S_{K_1K_2}(u)+S_{K_1K_2}(v). \tag*{(18)}

and coupled by ordinary SU(2) Clebsch–Gordan coefficients.

The amplitude as a linear functional. In the spinor formalism, the basic ingredient is the 3-point on-shell amplitudes, and higher-point amplitudes can be constructed using the recursive relation or the bootstrap method [19, 20].

Let us start with three-point amplitudes in the principal bundle. In the particle-state description the 3-point amplitude is M{I}{J}{K}ψˉ3{K}≡⟨p3σ3∣S∣p1σ1,p2σ2⟩\mathcal{M}_{\{I\}\{J\}}^{\{K\}}\bar{\psi}_{3\{K\}}\equiv\langle p_3\sigma_3|S|p_1\sigma_1,p_2\sigma_2\rangle, with three velocities in the manifold u=p1/m1u=p_1/m_1, v=p2/m2v=p_2/m_2 and U=p3/m3U=p_3/m_3. Using the unitary equivalence Eq. (5) between particle states and sections of EsE_s, and multiplying the (distributional) matrix element by wave functions and integrating, this becomes the probability amplitude, with dΦ3≡∏i=13d3pi/(2Ei)\mathrm{d}\Phi_3\equiv\prod_{i=1}^3\mathrm{d}^3p_i/(2E_i) and δ123≡δ(4)(p1+p2−p3)\delta_{123}\equiv\delta^{(4)}(p_1+p_2-p_3),

∫dΦ3 ψ1{I}ψ2{J}M{I}{J}{K}ψˉ3{K}δ123(4),(19)\int\mathrm{d}\Phi_3\,\psi_1^{\{I\}}\psi_2^{\{J\}}\mathcal{M}_{\{I\}\{J\}}^{\{K\}}\bar{\psi}_{3\{K\}}\delta_{123}^{(4)}, \tag*{(19)}

which is linear in ψ1\psi_1 and ψ2\psi_2, antilinear in ψ3\psi_3.

The amplitude M\mathcal{M} is built in two steps. First, the T1=T1(p3,p1)T_1=T_1(p_3,p_1) and T2=T2(p3,p2)T_2=T_2(p_3,p_2) transport the constituents little group indices of the spin parts in p1p_1 and p2p_2, to the ones in PP, respectively,

M{I1}{I2}{I3}=ρs1(T1){I1}{A}ρs2(T2){I2}{B}M^{A}{B}{I3},(20)\mathcal{M}_{\{I_1\}\{I_2\}}^{\{I_3\}}=\rho_{s_1}(T_1)_{\{I_1\}}^{\{A\}}\rho_{s_2}(T_2)_{\{I_2\}}^{\{B\}}\widehat{\mathcal{M}}_{\{A\}\{B\}}^{\{I_3\}}, \tag*{(20)}

where M^\widehat{\mathcal{M}} is an su(2)\mathfrak{su}(2) tensor at p3/m3p_3/m_3, and it maps the spins s1s_1 and s2s_2 carried by ρs1(T1)\rho_{s_1}(T_1) and ρs2(T2)\rho_{s_2}(T_2) onto the spin s3s_3 through the ordinary Clebsch–Gordan series

Vs1⊗Vs2=⨁S=∣s1−s2∣s1+s2VS,VS⊗VL⟶Vs3.(21)V_{s_1}\otimes V_{s_2}=\bigoplus_{S=|s_1-s_2|}^{s_1+s_2}V_S,\qquad V_S\otimes V_L\longrightarrow V_{s_3}. \tag*{(21)}

The space VLV_L corresponds to the su(2)\mathfrak{su}(2) irreducible component of M^\widehat{\mathcal{M}}. Second, every index carried by M^\widehat{\mathcal{M}} belongs to indices at p3p_3, corresponding to the amplitude 0+0→L0+0\to L, whose unique form is determined to be

YL≡[3∣1∣3⟩L=[P∣p1∣(I1P∣p2∣I2⋯P∣p1∣I2LPI2L∣),(22)Y^L\equiv[3|1|3\rangle^L=[P^{(I_1}_{|p_1|}P^{I_2}_{|p_2|}\cdots P^{I_{2L}}_{|p_1|}P^{I_{2L}}|), \tag*{(22)}

with 2L2L totally symmetric indices; in the COM frame it is the spherical harmonic YLLz(n^)Y_{LL_z}(\hat{\mathbf n}). That it carries orbital angular momentum LL follows from

SK1K2=TK1ITK2J(λ3J∂∂λαI+c.c.),S_{K_1K_2}=T_{K_1}^{I}T_{K_2}^{J}\left(\lambda_{3J}\frac{\partial}{\partial\lambda^I_\alpha}+\mathrm{c.c.}\right),
LK1K2=JK1K2−SK1K2,\mathcal{L}_{K_1K_2}=\mathcal{J}_{K_1K_2}-S_{K_1K_2},
JK1K2=λ3α(K1∂∂λ3K2)α+c.c.(23)\mathcal{J}_{K_1K_2}=\lambda_3^\alpha{}_{(K_1}\frac{\partial}{\partial\lambda_3^{K_2})^\alpha}+\mathrm{c.c.} \tag*{(23)}

Massive spin-spinor amplitudes. Coupling the orbital part to the spin part as in Eq. (21), the master three-point covariant orbital-spin (CLS) amplitude is given by

MLS({1I′},{2J′},{3K})∝ρs1{I}{I′}ρs2{J}{J′}CS{N}s1{I};s2{J}Cs3{K}L{B};S{N}[3∣1∣3⟩{B}L.(24)\mathcal{M}^{LS}(\{1^{I'}\},\{2^{J'}\},\{3_K\})\propto\rho_{s_1\{I\}}^{\{I'\}}\rho_{s_2\{J\}}^{\{J'\}}C^{s_1\{I\};s_2\{J\}}_{S\{N\}}C^{L\{B\};S\{N\}}_{s_3\{K\}}[3|1|3\rangle^L_{\{B\}}. \tag*{(24)}

This expression organizes three-point amplitudes by their orbital-spin content, complementing the spinor structures of Arkani-Hamed, Huang, and Huang (AHH) [8]. In the COM frame, these CLS amplitudes reproduce the orbital-spin couplings used in the Jacob–Wick formalism [21, 22, 23]. This CLS form is completely covariant under the covariant spin and orbital operator action in Eq. (23), without any boost dependence shown in literature [24, 25, 26, 27].

In the AHH formalism, the little group space indices are converted into the Lorentz space ones via the spinors of external particles. While in this work, built in little-group space rather than from Lorentz invariants, the CLS amplitudes carry well-defined spin and orbital quantum numbers and form an independent, complete basis. For example, for basic three massive-gauge-boson amplitudes, one could write down totally eight amplitudes [12][23][31][12][23][31], [12][23∣31⟩[12][23|31\rangle, [12∣23][31][12|23][31], etc. However, CLS amplitudes only contain seven independent elements with $(L,S)=(1,0),(0,1),(1,1),(2,1),(1,2),(2,2),… (3, 2), which are the combination of the above eight amplitudes. Similarly for all other basic three-point amplitudes.

Fermion–antifermion bilinears illustrate the spin–orbital classification. For an equal-mass pair, such as e+e−e^{+}e^{-}, in a charge-conjugation eigenstate, P=(−1)L+1P = (-1)^{L+1} and C=(−1)L+SC = (-1)^{L+S}. The spatial vector current has JPC=1−−J^{PC} = 1^{--} and admits (L,S)=(0,1)(L,S) = (0,1) and (2,1)(2,1), corresponding to the 3S1{}^{3}S_{1} and 3D1{}^{3}D_{1} channels. The pseudoscalar channel has (L,S)=(0,0)(L,S) = (0,0) and JPC=0−+J^{PC} = 0^{-+}. Near threshold, these include the leading ortho- and parapositronium configurations, respectively. In literature [21, 22, 23], the LSLS structure is only hold in the COM frame, however, in this work both JPCJ^{PC} and LSLS hold for any momenta. The supplementary material gives the bilinear decomposition. This can be extended to covariant multipole expansion for general form factors [28].

Given 3-point CLSCLS amplitude basis, higher-point amplitudes can be constructively obtained by recursive relation and bootstrap method [19, 20]. The advantage of this CLSCLS amplitudes is that it is the partial wave eigen-states with covariant orbital and spin eigen-values. Therefore, partial wave analysis can be performed covariantly, without the need of boosting back to the successive COM frames in the decay-chains. This covariant partial-wave analysis has been applied [29] to Λc→Λπ\Lambda_c \to\Lambda\pi, to help identify all the immediate particles: ρ(770)+\rho(770)^{+}, Σ(1385)+\Sigma(1385)^{+}, Σ(1385)0\Sigma(1385)^{0}, Σ(1670)+\Sigma(1670)^{+}, Σ(1670)0\Sigma(1670)^{0}, Σ(1750)+\Sigma(1750)^{+}, and Σ(1750)0\Sigma(1750)^{0} [30, 31].

The above CLSCLS amplitudes can be extended [32] to the ones with massless constituents. When particle 2 becomes massless, both S(p2)S(p_2) and T2T_2 are absent; instead the helicity of particle 2 couples to orbital momentum, YL=[2P]∣2h2∣[P∣1∣P⟩LY^L = [2P]^{|2h_2|}[P|1|P\rangle^L or YL=⟨2P⟩∣2h2∣[P∣1∣P⟩LY^L = \langle2P\rangle^{|2h_2|}[P|1|P\rangle^L depending on the sign of h2h_2. The full amplitude couples this orbital factor to the spin sector of particle 1, described by τ12s1\tau^{2s_1}_{1}. M = C^{\{K\}\{I\}\{J\}}_{\{K\}\{J\}\{I\}}Y^L_L\tau^{2s_{\{I\}}_{\{J\}\{I'\}}}. If both constituents become massless, the amplitude is dictated by the spin of the massive final state: M=[1P]J+h1−h2[2P]J−h1+h2/[12]J−h1−h2M = [1P]^{J+h_1-h_2}[2P]^{J-h_1+h_2}/[12]^{J-h_1-h_2}.

Summary and Outlook

By identifying the spin fiber and parallel transport over the velocity manifold, we have constructed a new covariant spin operator, which couples different particle’s spins in a Lorentz covariant way. The resulting three-point CLSCLS structures organize amplitudes by orbital and spin angular momentum while retaining an explicit prescription for comparing spin frames. Therefore, by introducing the covariant spin and orbital operators in relativistic quantum theory, there is no mixture between the covariant spin and orbital structures under the Lorentz boost. As application, higher-point CLSCLS amplitude, as the partial wave basis, can be constructed from the three-point CLSCLS amplitude basis, which can be applied to high energy scattering, hadronic physics, nucleon structure, and gravitational wave calculation, etc.

Supplementary Materials

The associated bundle, its sections and frames. Let Vs≅C2s+1V_s \cong\mathbb{C}^{2s+1} carry the irreducible unitary representation ρs\rho_s of the little group H=SU(2)H = \mathrm{SU}(2), and let GG be the principal HH-bundle over the velocity manifold MM, with projection π(g)=gu⋆\pi(g) = g u_\star. For g∈Gg \in G and ψ∈Vs\psi\in V_s the associated bundle is the set of pairs (g,ψ)(g,\psi) modulo the identification

Es≡G×HVs=(G×Vs)/∼,(gh,ψ)∼(g,ρs(h)ψ)∀h∈H,(25)\begin{aligned} E_s &\equiv G \times_H V_s = (G \times V_s)/\sim,\\ (gh,\psi) &\sim(g,\rho_s(h)\psi) \qquad\forall h \in H, \tag*{(25)} \end{aligned}

where an element of EsE_s is written (g,ψ)(g,\psi), the pair and its class being identified in the notation; it lies over u=π(g)u = \pi(g) and carries the spin state ψ∈Vs\psi\in V_s. The spin-ss field is a section of this bundle, that is, a smooth map Ψ:M→Es\Psi: M \to E_s with πEs∘Ψ=idM\pi_{E_s} \circ\Psi= \mathrm{id}_M. Once a section LuL_u of GG is chosen, any element over uu reads g=Luhg = L_u h with h∈Hh \in H, so every class over uu has the representative (Lu,ρs(h)ψ)(L_u,\rho_s(h)\psi) and the fiber (Es)u≅Vs(E_s)_u \cong V_s is the spin space at velocity uu; a section is then the same thing as a map ψ:M→Vs\psi: M \to V_s, through Ψ(u)=(Lu,ψ(u))\Psi(u) = (L_u,\psi(u)), and replacing LuL_u by the equally admissible lift Lu′=Luh(u)L'_u = L_u h(u), h:M→Hh : M \to H, changes it according to

ψ(u)⟶ρs(h(u))−1ψ(u),(26)\psi(u) \longrightarrow\rho_s\bigl(h(u)\bigr)^{-1}\psi(u), \tag*{(26)}

since [Luh(u),ψ′(u)]=[Lu,ρs(h(u))ψ′(u)][L_u h(u),\psi'(u)] = [L_u,\rho_s(h(u))\psi'(u)] must equal (Lu,ψ(u))(L_u,\psi(u)); this is (26), the little-group redefinition of the spin axis.

Fixing an orthonormal basis {eσ}σ=−ss\{e_\sigma\}_{\sigma=-s}^{s} of VsV_s (the representation ρs\rho_s being taken in the standard basis with respect to it), the same trivialization provides a global frame of EsE_s,

bσ(u)≡[Lu,eσ],Ψ(u)=ψσ(u)bσ(u),(27)b_\sigma(u) \equiv[L_u,e_\sigma], \qquad\Psi(u) = \psi^\sigma(u)b_\sigma(u), \tag*{(27)}

with bσ(u)b_\sigma(u) corresponding to the Wigner state ∣mu,σ⟩=U(Lu)∣k,σ⟩|mu,\sigma\rangle= U(L_u)|k,\sigma\rangle, k=mu⋆k = m u_\star, which is the distributional section localized at uu; the choice of LuL_u is precisely the choice of its rest-frame axes.

The one-particle Hilbert space is the space of square-integrable sections,

Hs={Ψ∈Γ(Es) | ⟨Ψ,Ψ⟩<∞},⟨Ψ1,Ψ2⟩=∫Md3uu0 (ψ1(u),ψ2(u))Vs,(28)\begin{aligned} \mathcal{H}_s &= \left\{\Psi\in\Gamma(E_s)\,\middle|\,\langle\Psi,\Psi\rangle< \infty\right\},\\ \langle\Psi_1,\Psi_2\rangle&= \int_M \frac{d^3u}{u^0}\,(\psi_1(u),\psi_2(u))_{V_s}, \tag*{(28)} \end{aligned}

where d3u/u0d^3u/u^0 is the Lorentz-invariant measure on MM and ( , )Vs(\ ,\ )_{V_s} the HH-invariant Hermitian form on VsV_s. The integrand is independent of the chosen LuL_u: by (26) both representatives acquire ρs(h)−1\rho_s(h)^{-1}, and

(ρs(h)−1ψ1,ρs(h)−1ψ2)Vs=(ψ1,ψ2)Vs(29)\bigl(\rho_s(h)^{-1}\psi_1,\rho_s(h)^{-1}\psi_2\bigr)_{V_s} = (\psi_1,\psi_2)_{V_s} \tag*{(29)}

by unitarity of ρs\rho_s. In a fixed trivialization, (28) gives the unitary isomorphism of (5). The particle-state description is the more basic of the two: the states ∣mu,σ⟩|mu,\sigma\rangle are distributional, δ\delta-function normalized, and need not be normalizable, whereas Hs\mathcal{H}_s contains only normalizable states; the two are nevertheless physically equivalent, agreeing on all matrix elements of bounded observables, and we pass freely between them.

The left action of GG on itself descends to the associated bundle,

Λ⋅(Lu,ψ)≡(ΛLu,ψ)=(LΛu,ρs(W)ψ),(30)\Lambda\cdot(L_u,\psi)\equiv(\Lambda L_u,\psi)=(L_{\Lambda u},\rho_s(W)\psi), \tag*{(30)}

thus Lorentz transformation Λ\Lambda carries ψ\psi into a new wave function ψ′\psi', whose value at the velocity Λu\Lambda u is ψ′(Λu)=ρs(W(Λ,u))ψ(u)\psi'(\Lambda u)=\rho_s(W(\Lambda,u))\psi(u); its value at uu is therefore obtained with u→Λ−1uu\to\Lambda^{-1}u,

(U(Λ)ψ)(u)=ρs(W(Λ,Λ−1u))ψ(Λ−1u),(31)(U(\Lambda)\psi)(u)=\rho_s(W(\Lambda,\Lambda^{-1}u))\psi(\Lambda^{-1}u), \tag*{(31)}

On the particle states the same operator reads

U(Λ)∣mu,σ⟩=∑σ′∣mΛu,σ′⟩ρs(W(Λ,u))σ′σ,U(\Lambda)|mu,\sigma\rangle=\sum_{\sigma'}|m\Lambda u,\sigma'\rangle\rho_s(W(\Lambda,u))^{\sigma'}{}_{\sigma},

which is the standard Wigner formula; the two forms are identified by the isomorphism of Eq. (5).

Spin as the generator of the right action. For SIJ∈su(2)S_{IJ}\in\mathfrak{su}(2) the derived representation on the fiber is

ρs(SIJ)≡ddt∣0ρs(etSIJ)∈End⁡(Vs).(32)\rho_s(S_{IJ})\equiv\left.\frac{d}{dt}\right|_0\rho_s(e^{tS_{IJ}})\in\operatorname{End}(V_s). \tag*{(32)}

On the principal bundle the same element generates the vertical vector fields of Eq. (3) of the main text, SIJ=λαJ∂/∂λαI+c.c.S_I^J=\lambda_\alpha^J\partial/\partial\lambda_\alpha^I+\mathrm{c.c.} and Sρ=12(σρ)IJSJIS_\rho=\frac{1}{2}(\sigma_\rho)_I{}^J S_J{}^I, which close on su(2)\mathfrak{su}(2) and move gg along its fiber, since etSIJ∈He^{tS_{IJ}}\in H stabilizes u⋆u_\star. Carried to every fiber by the trivialization of Eq. (25), the same element acts through ρs′\rho'_s, yielding the fiber-wise generator

SIJ∈End⁡(Es),SIJ(Lu,ψ)=(Lu,ρs(SIJ)ψ),(33)S_{IJ}\in\operatorname{End}(E_s),\qquad S_{IJ}(L_u,\psi)=(L_u,\rho_s(S_{IJ})\psi), \tag*{(33)}

so that in the same trivialization SIJψ(u)=ρs(SIJ)ψ(u)S_{IJ}\psi(u)=\rho_s(S_{IJ})\psi(u) for every SIJ∈su(2)S_{IJ}\in\mathfrak{su}(2). Its components along the spherical basis SρS_\rho, normalized by ρ1/2(Sρ)=12σρ\rho_{1/2}(S_\rho)=\frac{1}{2}\sigma_\rho, are the fiber-wise operators of the main text. Since the trivialization is built from LuL_u, the operator depends on the choice of standard boosts and is not canonically defined on EsE_s.

The right action on GG does not descend to EsE_s: the prescription (g,ψ)↦(gh,ψ)(g,\psi)\mapsto(gh,\psi) is not well defined, because applied to the equivalent representative (g~h~,ρs(h~)−1ψ)(\tilde g\tilde h,\rho_s(\tilde h)^{-1}\psi) it gives

(g~h~h,ρs(h~)−1ψ)=(g,ρs(h~)ρs(h)ρs(h~)−1ψ),(34)(\tilde g\tilde h h,\rho_s(\tilde h)^{-1}\psi)=(g,\rho_s(\tilde h)\rho_s(h)\rho_s(\tilde h)^{-1}\psi), \tag*{(34)}

which differs from (gh,ψ)=(g,ρs(h)ψ)(gh,\psi)=(g,\rho_s(h)\psi) unless ρs\rho_s is conjugation invariant, i.e. unless HH is Abelian. What the right action induces instead is an action on the trivialization itself, Lu→Luh(u)L_u\to L_uh(u), whose infinitesimal form is Eq. (33). Consequently SIJS_{IJ} is gauge covariant rather than gauge invariant: under Lu→Luh(u)L_u\to L_uh(u) one has Sρ↦ρ1(h)ρσSσS_\rho\mapsto\rho_1(h)_\rho{}^\sigma S_\sigma. The corresponding Hilbert-space operator acts pointwise:

(SρΨ)(u)=Sρ(u)Ψ(u).(35)(S_\rho\Psi)(u)=S_\rho(u)\Psi(u). \tag*{(35)}

As a cross-check that SρS_\rho is indeed the spin operator, note that it has a covariant realization in terms of the Pauli–Lubanski vector. The polarization vectors are those of the section LuL_u,

ϵρμ(u)≡[Lu]μν(0,eρ)ν,ρ=±1,0,(36)\epsilon_\rho^\mu(u)\equiv[L_u]^\mu{}_\nu(0,e_\rho)^\nu,\qquad\rho=\pm1,0, \tag*{(36)}

built on the spherical basis e±1=12(ex±iey)e_{\pm1}=\frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}(e_x\pm i e_y), e0=eze_0=e_z. At the rest velocity u⋆u_\star one has eρ=1e_\rho=1, so Eq. (36) gives ϵρμ(u⋆)=(0,eρ)\epsilon_\rho^\mu(u_\star)=(0,e_\rho), while the Pauli–Lubanski vector there is Wμ=(0,mJ)\mathcal{W}_\mu=(0,m\mathbf{J}) by Eq. (4). The covariant operator Writing the covariant form of the operator as Sρ(u)≡1mϵρμ(u)Wμ(u)S_\rho(u)\equiv\frac{1}{m}\epsilon_\rho^\mu(u)\mathcal{W}_\mu(u), one therefore has

Sρ(u⋆)=eρ⋅J=Jρ,(37)S_\rho(u_\star)=e_\rho\cdot\mathbf{J}=\mathcal{J}_\rho, \tag*{(37)}

the spherical component of the spin: this SρS_\rho is thus indeed the spin operator.

The transport operator, Wigner rotation and holonomy. In above the spin is defined at a single velocity. To compare two such spins one must carry the frame from one velocity to another via transport.

The horizontal lift and the transport. The connection ωh\omega_h specifies which curves in GG are horizontal, lifting a path γ\gamma in MM to a path γ~\tilde\gamma in GG, and the frame that is carried along this lift is what we call the transport TT. Its horizontal lift is the unique curve γ~\tilde\gamma with π∘γ~=γ\pi\circ\tilde\gamma=\gamma whose tangent is horizontal, ωh(γ~˙)=0\omega_h(\dot{\tilde\gamma})=0. Starting at the frame LuL_u, it ends at a lift of vv, that is, at LvL_v times an element of HH; that element is T(v,u)T(v,u).

γ~(1)=LvTγ,Tγ∈H,(38)\tilde\gamma(1)=L_vT_\gamma,\qquad T_\gamma\in H, \tag*{(38)}

and Tγ=Pexp⁡(−∫γωh)T_\gamma=\mathcal{P}\exp\left(-\int_\gamma\omega_h\right) of Eq. (8) is the integrated form of the horizontality condition. The horizontal directions are the left translates of m\mathfrak{m}; the lift is unique once its starting point is fixed, and a different starting point changes TT by the right multiplication that relates the two frames.

The Wilson line and the Wilson loop. For a general path the transport of Eq. (8) is the Wilson line of the connection,

W[γ(Λ,u)]=Pexp⁡(−∫γ(Λ,u)ωh),(39)W[\gamma(\Lambda,u)]=\mathcal{P}\exp\left(-\int_{\gamma(\Lambda,u)}\omega_h\right), \tag*{(39)}

formally identical to the Wilson line of a gauge field, the connection ωh\omega_h playing the role of the gauge potential. Applied to the motion of an accelerated particle it reproduces the Thomas precession [33, 34]. When the open path γ(Λ,u)\gamma(\Lambda,u) is closed into a loop [35] by adjoining the canonical boost paths γu\gamma_u and γΛ−1u\gamma_{\Lambda^{-1}u}, which are the canonical gauge trivializes, the Wilson line becomes the holonomy of a closed loop, i.e. a Wilson loop, and the Wigner rotation is the geometric phase [36, 37] of the triangle u⋆→u→Λu→u⋆u_{\star} \to u \to\Lambda u \to u_{\star}. The construction holds for any section. The transport is therefore a Wigner rotation, the rotation that Λ\Lambda induces at uu and that Eq. (9) of the main text carries: the trivialised form of the transport, not an independent ingredient. An arbitrary path gives a well-defined transport, but it depends on the whole path rather than on its two endpoints.

Why the path is a geodesic. Not every curve is admissible: a path cannot connect two different mass shells, so it is defined on the common velocity manifold MM. The covariance condition Eq. (12) is what singles out the geodesic. Take a Lorentz transformation Λ0\Lambda_0 that leaves both uu and vv invariant; it lies in their common stabiliser, and Eq. (12) then reduces to γ(v,u)=Λ0γ(v,u)\gamma(v,u)=\Lambda_0\gamma(v,u), so every point of the curve is invariant under that stabiliser. In the rest frame of uu the stabiliser of the pair is the SO⁡(2)\operatorname{SO}(2) of rotations about the direction of vv, and a curve from uu to vv left pointwise invariant by it must be the straight line joining them.

Parameterise that line by s∈[0,1]s \in[0,1]. In the rest frame of uu, where u=(1,0)u=(1,0) and v=(γ,v)v=(\gamma,\mathbf{v}), its points are

((1−s)+sγ,  sv)(1−s)2+s2+2s(1−s)γ\frac{\bigl((1-s)+s\gamma,\;s\mathbf{v}\bigr)}{\sqrt{(1-s)^2+s^2+2s(1-s)\gamma}}

the denominator normalising the four-velocity; in a general frame this reads γ(s)=q(s)/q2(s)\gamma(s)=q(s)/\sqrt{q^2(s)} with q(s)=(1−s)u+svq(s)=(1-s)u+sv, which is Eq. (13). Since (1−s)Λu+sΛv=Λq(s)(1-s)\Lambda u+s\Lambda v=\Lambda q(s), the covariance condition Eq. (12) holds automatically, so this is the geodesic of MM.

The transport along a geodesic and the boost. With the connection ωh\omega_h, the horizontal lift of the geodesic Eq. (13) through the frame LuL_u is γ~(t)=Luetξ\widetilde{\gamma}(t)=L_u e^{t\xi}, indeed γ~−1γ~˙=ξ∈m\widetilde{\gamma}^{-1}\dot{\widetilde{\gamma}}=\xi\in\mathfrak{m}, so that

T(v,u)=Lv−1Lueξ,(40)T(v,u)=L_v^{-1}L_u e^{\xi}, \tag*{(40)}

with B(v,u)≡LueξLu−1B(v,u)\equiv L_u e^{\xi}L_u^{-1} the boost along the geodesic. Taking ζ\zeta to be a pure boost, eζ=Bc(v′)e^\zeta=B_c(v') with v′≡Lv−1vv'\equiv L_v^{-1}v, gives B(v,u)=LuBc(v′)Lu−1B(v,u)=L_uB_c(v')L_u^{-1}; B(v,u)B(v,u) therefore satisfies Lorentz covariance, ΛB(v,u)Λ−1=B(Λv,Λu)\Lambda B(v,u)\Lambda^{-1}=B(\Lambda v,\Lambda u), and is fixed as

B(v,u)=δα β+vαα˙uαβ˙2(1+u⋅v).(41)B(v,u)=\frac{\delta_{\alpha}^{\ \beta}+v_{\alpha\dot{\alpha}}u^{\alpha\dot{\beta}}}{\sqrt{2(1+u\cdot v)}}. \tag*{(41)}

Substituting it into Eq. (40) gives the transport in closed form,

T(v,u)=Lv−1B(v,u)Lu,(42)T(v,u)=L_v^{-1}B(v,u)L_u, \tag*{(42)}

which is the spinor expression of Eq. (14) of the main text, written there with one index at each leg. For this boost the Wigner rotation is defined by the standard relation B(v,u)Lu=LvW(B(v,u),u)B(v,u)L_u=L_vW(B(v,u),u), that is W(Λ,u)≡LΛu−1ΛLuW(\Lambda,u)\equiv L_{\Lambda u}^{-1}\Lambda L_u with Λu=v\Lambda u=v; since B(v,u)Lu=LvT(v,u)B(v,u)L_u=L_vT(v,u), the two coincide, T(v,u)=W(B(v,u),u)T(v,u)=W(B(v,u),u), so the transport is the Wigner rotation of the boost and not an independent ingredient.

The properties usually imposed on TT now follow rather than being assumed: T†T=1T^\dagger T=1, det⁡T=1\det T=1 and T(u,u)=1T(u,u)=1 because T∈HT\in H, and also from the spinor form Eq. (14) of the main text; T(v,u)=T(u,v)−1T(v,u)=T(u,v)^{-1} from Eq. (42); the gauge law T(v,u)=h(v)−1T(v,u)h(u)T(v,u)=h(v)^{-1}T(v,u)h(u) under Lu→Luh(u)L_u\to L_uh(u); and T(Λv,Λu)=W(Λ,v)T(v,u)W(Λ,u)−1T(\Lambda v,\Lambda u)=W(\Lambda,v)T(v,u)W(\Lambda,u)^{-1}, which is Eq. (11) of the main text, from the GG-invariance of the connection, the same invariance that makes the transport depend on the endpoints only.

Three-point CLS amplitudes. We consider the processes s3→s1+s2s_3\to s_1+s_2 with each sis_i at most one, writing ϕ\phi, ff and VV for a scalar, a fermion and a vector boson. Their amplitudes are constructed in Ref. [8] and collected in Table I. That construction does not distinguish incoming from outgoing particles, whereas for our CLS amplitudes exchanging the incoming and outgoing pairs gives different amplitudes: for ffVf f V, for instance, the CLS amplitudes can be organised either as V→ffV\to f f or as f→fVf\to fV, because the LS quantum numbers are defined with respect to a chosen pair. We take LS to be the orbital and spin quantum numbers of the outgoing pair.

With Eq. (24) the three-point CLS amplitudes are constructed directly, as follows. For three scalars, s1=s2=s3=0s_1=s_2=s_3=0, there is the single combination (L,S)=(0,0)(L,S)=(0,0),

M(0,0)∝1.(43)\mathcal{M}(0,0)\propto1. \tag*{(43)}

For f→fϕf\to f\phi, that is s3=12s_3=\frac{1}{2} with s1=12s_1=\frac{1}{2} and s2=0s_2=0, the two combinations (0,12)(0,\frac{1}{2}) and (1,12)(1,\frac{1}{2}) give

M(0,12)∝(⟨13⟩−[13]),M(1,12)∝(⟨13⟩+[13]),(44)\begin{aligned} \mathcal{M}(0,\tfrac{1}{2})&\propto(\langle13\rangle-[13]),\\ \mathcal{M}(1,\tfrac{1}{2})&\propto(\langle13\rangle+[13]), \tag*{(44)} \end{aligned}

and for ϕ→ff\phi\to ff, s3=0s_3=0 with s1=s2=12s_1=s_2=\frac{1}{2}, the two combinations (0,0)(0,0) and (1,1)(1,1) give

M(0,0)∝(⟨12⟩−[12]),M(1,1)∝(⟨12⟩+[12]),(45)\begin{aligned} \mathcal{M}(0,0)&\propto(\langle12\rangle-[12]),\\ \mathcal{M}(1,1)&\propto(\langle12\rangle+[12]), \tag*{(45)} \end{aligned}

for f→fVf\to fV, s3=12s_3=\frac{1}{2} with s1=12s_1=\frac{1}{2} and s2=1s_2=1, the four combinations (0,12)(0,\frac{1}{2}), (1,12)(1,\frac{1}{2}), (1,32)(1,\frac{3}{2}) and (2,32)(2,\frac{3}{2}) give

M(0,12)∝⟨12⟩−[12](⟨23⟩−[23]),M(1,12)∝⟨12⟩−[12](⟨23⟩+[23]),M(1,32)∝(m2−m3−m1)(⟨12⟩+[12])(⟨23⟩−[23])+⟨2∣p1∣2⟩(⟨13⟩−[13]),M(2,32)∝(m3+m2−m1)(⟨12⟩+[12])(⟨23⟩+[23])+⟨2∣1∣2⟩(⟨13⟩+[13]),(46)\begin{aligned} \mathcal{M}(0,\tfrac{1}{2})&\propto\langle12\rangle-[12]\left(\langle23\rangle-[23]\right),\\ \mathcal{M}(1,\tfrac{1}{2})&\propto\langle12\rangle-[12]\left(\langle23\rangle+[23]\right),\\ \mathcal{M}(1,\tfrac{3}{2})&\propto(m_2-m_3-m_1)(\langle12\rangle+[12])(\langle23\rangle-[23])\\ &\quad+ \langle2|p_1|2\rangle(\langle13\rangle-[13]),\\ \mathcal{M}(2,\tfrac{3}{2})&\propto(m_3+m_2-m_1)(\langle12\rangle+[12])(\langle23\rangle+[23])\\ &\quad+\langle2|1|2\rangle(\langle13\rangle+[13]), \tag*{(46)} \end{aligned}

for V→ffV\to ff, s3=1s_3=1 with s1=s2=12s_1=s_2=\frac{1}{2}, the four combinations (1,0)(1,0), (0,1)(0,1), (1,1)(1,1) and (2,1)(2,1) give

M(1,0)∝(⟨12⟩−[12])⟨3∣p1∣3],M(0,1)∝(⟨13⟩−[13])(⟨23⟩−[23]),M(1,1)∝(m3+m1−m2)(⟨13⟩+[13])(⟨23⟩−[23])−(m3+m2−m1)(⟨13⟩−[13])(⟨23⟩+[23]),M(2,1)∝(⟨12⟩+[12])⟨3∣p1∣3]+m1+m2+m34(⟨13⟩+[13])(⟨23⟩+[23]),(47)\begin{aligned} \mathcal{M}(1,0)&\propto(\langle12\rangle-[12])\langle3|p_1|3],\\ \mathcal{M}(0,1)&\propto(\langle13\rangle-[13])(\langle23\rangle-[23]),\\ \mathcal{M}(1,1)&\propto(m_3+m_1-m_2)(\langle13\rangle+[13])(\langle23\rangle-[23])\\ &\quad-(m_3+m_2-m_1)(\langle13\rangle-[13])(\langle23\rangle+[23]),\\ \mathcal{M}(2,1)&\propto(\langle12\rangle+[12])\langle3|p_1|3]\\ &\quad+\frac{m_1+m_2+m_3}{4}(\langle13\rangle+[13])(\langle23\rangle+[23]), \tag*{(47)} \end{aligned}

for V→ϕϕV\to\phi\phi, s3=1s_3=1 with s1=s2=0s_1=s_2=0, the single combination (1,0)(1,0),

M(1,0)∝⟨3∣p1∣3],(48)\mathcal{M}(1,0)\propto\langle3|p_1|3], \tag*{(48)}

for ϕ→Vϕ\phi\to V\phi, s3=0s_3=0 with s1=1s_1=1 and s2=0s_2=0, the single combination (1,1)(1,1),

M(1,1)∝⟨1∣p3∣1],(49)\mathcal{M}(1,1)\propto\langle1|p_3|1], \tag*{(49)}

for V→VϕV\to V\phi, s3=1s_3=1 with s1=1s_1=1 and s2=0s_2=0, the three combinations (0,1)(0,1), (1,1)(1,1) and (2,1)(2,1),

M(0,1)∝(⟨13⟩−[13])2,M(1,1)∝⟨13⟩2−[13]2,M(2,1)∝(m1+m2+m3)(m3+m1−m2)4(⟨13⟩+[13])2−⟨1∣p3∣1]⟨3∣p1∣3],(50)\begin{aligned} \mathcal{M}(0,1)&\propto(\langle13\rangle-[13])^2,\\ \mathcal{M}(1,1)&\propto\langle13\rangle^2-[13]^2,\\ \mathcal{M}(2,1)&\propto\frac{(m_1+m_2+m_3)(m_3+m_1-m_2)}{4}(\langle13\rangle+[13])^2\\ &\quad-\langle1|p_3|1]\langle3|p_1|3], \tag*{(50)} \end{aligned}

and for ϕ→VV\phi\to VV, s3=0s_3=0 with s1=s2=1s_1=s_2=1, the three combinations (0,0)(0,0), (1,1)(1,1) and (2,2)(2,2),

M(0,0)∝(⟨12⟩−[12])2,M(1,1)∝⟨12⟩2−[12]2,M(2,2)∝((m1−m2)2−m32)(⟨12⟩+[12])2+⟨1∣p3∣1]⟨2∣p3∣2],(51)\begin{aligned} \mathcal{M}(0,0)&\propto(\langle12\rangle-[12])^2,\\ \mathcal{M}(1,1)&\propto\langle12\rangle^2-[12]^2,\\ \mathcal{M}(2,2)&\propto\left((m_1-m_2)^2-m_3^2\right)(\langle12\rangle+[12])^2\\ &\quad+\langle1|p_3|1]\langle2|p_3|2], \tag*{(51)} \end{aligned}

For V→VVV\to VV there are seven partial waves in total, as follows

M(1,0)∝⟨12⟩−2⟨3∣p1∣3],(52)\mathcal{M}(1,0)\propto\langle12\rangle_-^2\langle3|p_1|3], \tag*{(52)}
M(0,1)∝⟨12⟩−⟨13⟩−⟨23⟩−,(53)\mathcal{M}(0,1)\propto\langle12\rangle_-\langle13\rangle_-\langle23\rangle_-, \tag*{(53)}
M(1,1)∝⟨12⟩−[(m3+m1−m2)⟨13⟩+⟨23⟩−−(m3+m2−m1)⟨13⟩−⟨23⟩+],(54)\begin{aligned} \mathcal{M}(1,1)\propto\langle12\rangle_-\big[&(m_3+m_1-m_2)\langle13\rangle_+\langle23\rangle_-\\ &-(m_3+m_2-m_1)\langle13\rangle_-\langle23\rangle_+\big], \tag*{(54)} \end{aligned}
M(2,1)∝m1+m2+m34⟨12⟩−⟨13⟩+⟨23⟩++⟨12⟩−⟨12⟩+⟨3∣p1∣3],(55)\begin{aligned} \mathcal{M}(2,1)\propto{}&\frac{m_1+m_2+m_3}{4}\langle12\rangle_-\langle13\rangle_+\langle23\rangle_+\\ &+\langle12\rangle_-\langle12\rangle_+\langle3|p_1|3], \tag*{(55)} \end{aligned}
M(1,2)∝((m1−m2)2−m32)⟨13⟩−⟨23⟩−⟨12⟩++(m2−m3−m1)⟨1∣p3∣1]⟨23⟩−+(m3+m2−m1)⟨2∣p3∣2]⟨13⟩−,(56)\begin{aligned} \mathcal{M}(1,2)\propto{}&\left((m_1-m_2)^2-m_3^2\right)\langle13\rangle_-\langle23\rangle_-\langle12\rangle_+\\ &+(m_2-m_3-m_1)\langle1|p_3|1]\langle23\rangle_-\\ &+(m_3+m_2-m_1)\langle2|p_3|2]\langle13\rangle_-, \tag*{(56)} \end{aligned}
M(2,2)∝⟨12⟩+[(m2−m3−m1)⟨13⟩+⟨23⟩−+(m3+m2−m1)⟨13⟩−⟨23⟩++⟨1∣p3∣1]⟨23⟩−+⟨2∣p3∣2]⟨13⟩−],(57)\begin{aligned} \mathcal{M}(2,2)\propto{}&\langle12\rangle_+\big[(m_2-m_3-m_1)\langle13\rangle_+\langle23\rangle_-\\ &+(m_3+m_2-m_1)\langle13\rangle_-\langle23\rangle_+\\ &+\langle1|p_3|1]\langle23\rangle_-+\langle2|p_3|2]\langle13\rangle_-\big], \tag*{(57)} \end{aligned}
M(3,2)∝[m32−(m1−m2)2]⟨12⟩+3−⟨1∣p3∣1]⟨2∣p3∣3]⟨3∣p1∣3]+m1+m2+m34[(m1−m3−m2)⟨23⟩+2⟨1∣p3∣1]+(m3+m1−m2)⟨13⟩+2⟨2∣p3∣2]+(m32−(m1−m2)2)⟨12⟩+⟨13⟩+⟨23⟩+],(58)\begin{aligned} \mathcal{M}(3,2)\propto{}&\left[m_3^2-(m_1-m_2)^2\right]\langle12\rangle_+^3\\ &-\langle1|p_3|1]\langle2|p_3|3]\langle3|p_1|3]\\ &+\frac{m_1+m_2+m_3}{4}\big[(m_1-m_3-m_2)\langle23\rangle_+^2\langle1|p_3|1]\\ &\quad+(m_3+m_1-m_2)\langle13\rangle_+^2\langle2|p_3|2]\\ &\quad+\left(m_3^2-(m_1-m_2)^2\right)\langle12\rangle_+\langle13\rangle_+\langle23\rangle_+\big], \tag*{(58)} \end{aligned}

where (ij)±≡⟨ij⟩±[ij](ij)_\pm\equiv\langle ij\rangle\pm[ij], each line being a polynomial in (ij)±(ij)_\pm and in ⟨i∣pj∣i]\langle i|p_j|i]. These seven structures are equivalent to the seven collected in Table 1.

External particles3-point amplitude structure
(112,212,31)(1\frac{1}{2},2\frac{1}{2},3^{1})[23]\langle31\rangle, ⟨23⟩[31]\langle23\rangle[31], ⟨23⟩⟨31⟩\langle23\rangle\langle31\rangle, [23][31]
(112,21,30)(1\frac{1}{2},2^{1},3^{0})⟨12⟩\langle12\rangle, ⟨12⟩2\langle12\rangle^2, ⟨12⟩[31]\langle12\rangle[31], ⟨12⟩[23]\langle12\rangle[23]
(11,21,31)(1^{1},2^{1},3^{1})⟨12⟩⟨23⟩⟨31⟩\langle12\rangle\langle23\rangle\langle31\rangle, ⟨12⟩[23]⟨31⟩\langle12\rangle[23]\langle31\rangle, ⟨12⟩⟨23⟩[31]\langle12\rangle\langle23\rangle[31], ⟨12⟩[23][31]\langle12\rangle[23][31], ⟨12⟩⟨23⟩⟨31⟩\langle12\rangle\langle23\rangle\langle31\rangle, ⟨12⟩[23]⟨31⟩\langle12\rangle[23]\langle31\rangle
(11,21,30)(1^{1},2^{1},3^{0})⟨12⟩[12]\langle12\rangle[12], ⟨12⟩2\langle12\rangle^2, [12]2[12]^2
(11,20,30)(1^{1},2^{0},3^{0})⟨31⟩[13]\langle31\rangle[13]
(10,20,30)(1^{0},2^{0},3^{0})11

Table 1. Independent three-point amplitude structures for the indicated external particles.

From JPCJ^{PC} to LSLS in bilinear operators. The LSLS analysis above is not only a way of constructing amplitudes: the same structure serves to analyse form factors, since the matrix element of an operator can be resolved in the same basis.

Form factor of fermion bilinear operators. Consider, for instance, the annihilation of two spinning particles,

⟨0∣Oi∣1,2⟩,(59)\langle0|\mathcal{O}_i|1,2\rangle, \tag*{(59)}

where Oi\mathcal{O}_i is a bilinear local operator, in general not a Lorentz scalar. For instance, it may be one of

ψˉψ,iψˉγ5ψ,ψˉγ0ψ,ψˉγiψ,(60)\bar{\psi}\psi,\quad i\bar{\psi}\gamma_5\psi,\quad\bar{\psi}\gamma^0\psi,\quad\bar{\psi}\gamma^i\psi, \tag*{(60)}

which we use as the examples below. This matrix element can be decomposed by LSLS analysis; we use the spinor formalism to assign definite LSLS quantum numbers. For a two-particle state the discrete quantum numbers are

C=(−1)L+S,P=(−1)L+2s,(61)C=(-1)^{L+S},\qquad P=(-1)^{L+2s}, \tag*{(61)}

with CC and PP the charge-conjugation and parity eigenvalues. The quantum numbers of a given operator are collected in the triple (L,S,JPC)(L,S,J^{PC}), with JJ the total angular momentum obtained by coupling LL and SS, and CC, PP the eigenvalues above.

The form factor in Eq. (59) corresponds, in the COM frame, to a three-point amplitude in which the operator insertion plays the role of the third particle, and in the covariant spinor language this amplitude can be written in an arbitrary frame. Writing the operators above in terms of their time and space components corresponds to the decomposition at rest, p=(m,0)p=(m,0): in that frame the zeroth component of a Lorentz tensor is obtained by contracting it with p3/m3p_3/m_3, and its spatial components by contracting it with the polarization vectors ϵi\epsilon_i. The operators ψˉγ0ψ\bar{\psi}\gamma^0\psi and ψˉγiψ\bar{\psi}\gamma^i\psi, the third and fourth in Eq. (54), are components of the bilinear current $j^\mu\equiv\bar{\psi}\gamma^\mu\psi: the former is the contraction p3μjμ/m3p_{3\mu}j^\mu/m_{3} and the latter the contraction ϵijjμ\epsilon_{ij}j^\mu. Placed in the three-point amplitude, the operator insertions therefore read

  • ψˉψ→[12]+⟨12⟩∈(1,1,0++)\bar{\psi}\psi\to[12]+\langle12\rangle\in(1,1,0^{++});

  • iψˉγ5ψ→[12]−⟨12⟩∈(0,0,0−+)i\bar{\psi}\gamma_{5}\psi\to[12]-\langle12\rangle\in(0,0,0^{-+});

  • ψˉγ0ψ→p3μψˉγμψ→[2∣3∣1⟩+⟨2∣3∣1]=0\bar{\psi}\gamma_{0}\psi\to p_{3}^{\mu}\bar{\psi}\gamma_{\mu}\psi\to[2|3|1\rangle+\langle2|3|1]=0;

  • ψˉγiψ→ϵ3μψˉγμψ→[23]⟨31⟩+⟨23⟩[31]\bar{\psi}\gamma_{i}\psi\to\epsilon_{3}^{\mu}\bar{\psi}\gamma_{\mu}\psi\to[23]\langle31\rangle+\langle23\rangle[31]. The first three are matched directly; for the fourth the matching is less obvious. Expanded with Eq. (47), it splits into two LSLS channels: combining the rearrangement

[23]⟨31⟩+⟨23⟩[31]=12((31)−(32)−−(31)+(32)+)(62)[23]\langle31\rangle+\langle23\rangle[31] =\frac{1}{2}\left((31)_{-}(32)_{-}-(31)_{+}(32)_{+}\right) \tag*{(62)}

with the identity

(12)+[3∣p1∣3⟩=m32((13)+(23)++(13)−(23)−)+m1+m22((13)+(23)+−(13)−(23)−),(63)(12)_{+}[3|p_{1}|3\rangle =\frac{m_{3}}{2}\left((13)_{+}(23)_{+}+(13)_{-}(23)_{-}\right) +\frac{m_{1}+m_{2}}{2}\left((13)_{+}(23)_{+}-(13)_{-}(23)_{-}\right), \tag*{(63)}

obtained by using the Schouten identity on the first term of A(2,1)\mathcal{A}(2,1) in Eq. (47), one immediately obtains the two channels ψˉγiψ∈(2,1,1−−)\bar{\psi}\gamma_{i}\psi\in(2,1,1^{--}) and ψˉγiψ∈(0,1,1−−)\bar{\psi}\gamma_{i}\psi\in(0,1,1^{--}).

Each line is obtained in the same steps: the operator is contracted with p3p_{3} or with ϵ3\epsilon_{3}, the fields ψ\psi and ψˉ\bar{\psi} are replaced by the wavefunctions in the spinor-helicity form, and the result is reduced with the spinor techniques. This procedure applies to the remaining fermion bilinears below, where σμν≡i2[γμ,γν]\sigma^{\mu\nu}\equiv\frac{i}{2}[\gamma^{\mu},\gamma^{\nu}].

ψˉγ5γ0ψ→p3μψˉγ5γμψ→[21]−⟨21⟩→(0,0,0−+),(64)\bar{\psi}\gamma_{5}\gamma_{0}\psi\to p_{3}^{\mu}\bar{\psi}\gamma_{5}\gamma_{\mu}\psi\to[21]-\langle21\rangle\to(0,0,0^{-+}), \tag*{(64)}
ψˉγ5γiψ→ϵ3μψˉγ5γμψ→[23]⟨31⟩−⟨23⟩[31]→(1,1,1++),(65)\bar{\psi}\gamma_{5}\gamma_{i}\psi\to\epsilon_{3}^{\mu}\bar{\psi}\gamma_{5}\gamma_{\mu}\psi\to[23]\langle31\rangle-\langle23\rangle[31]\to(1,1,1^{++}), \tag*{(65)}
ψˉσ0iψ→p3μϵ3νψˉσμνψ→[23][31]+⟨23⟩⟨31⟩→(0,1,1−−)+(2,1,1−−),(66)\bar{\psi}\sigma^{0i}\psi\to p_{3}^{\mu}\epsilon_{3}^{\nu}\bar{\psi}\sigma_{\mu\nu}\psi\to[23][31]+\langle23\rangle\langle31\rangle \to(0,1,1^{--})+(2,1,1^{--}), \tag*{(66)}
ψˉσijψ→ϵ3μϵ3νψˉσμνψ→[23][31]−⟨23⟩⟨31⟩→(1,0,1+−),(67)\bar{\psi}\sigma^{ij}\psi\to\epsilon_{3}^{\mu}\epsilon_{3}^{\nu}\bar{\psi}\sigma_{\mu\nu}\psi\to[23][31]-\langle23\rangle\langle31\rangle\to(1,0,1^{+-}), \tag*{(67)}

For the first line the contraction [2∣3∣1⟩−⟨2∣3∣1][2|3|1\rangle-\langle2|3|1] reduces, after integration by parts and use of the equations of motion, to [21]−⟨21⟩[21]-\langle21\rangle. The second line holds for m1=m2m_{1}=m_{2}, the third uses the same technique as for ψˉγiψ\bar{\psi}\gamma_{i}\psi, and the fourth follows from ⟨3I3J⟩=−m3ϵIJ\langle3^{I}3^{J}\rangle=-m_{3}\epsilon^{IJ} and [3I3J]=m3ϵIJ[3^{I}3^{J}]=m_{3}\epsilon^{IJ}.

From spinor-helicity form to non-relativistic multipole expansion

By the same procedure each of these fermion bilinears can be expanded in the CLSCLS amplitudes; in the COM frame the CLSCLS amplitude reads

A(L,S){K}{I}{J}∝CS{N}s1{I};s2{J}Cs3{K}L{B};S{N}[3∣1∣3⟩{B}L,(68)\mathcal{A}(L,S)_{\{K\}}^{\{I\}\{J\}}\propto C^{s_{1}\{I\};s_{2}\{J\}}_{S\{N\}}C^{L\{B\};S\{N\}}_{s_{3}\{K\}}[3|1|3\rangle^{L}_{\{B\}}, \tag*{(68)}

where II, JJ, KK denote the little-group indices. The Clebsch–Gordan coefficients are fixed by the little-group algebra: for s1=s2=12s_{1}=s_{2}=\frac{1}{2} the spin-coupling ones are

C012I1;12I2∝ϵI1I2,C012J1;12J2∝δJ2)(J1,(69)C^{\frac{1}{2}I_{1};\frac{1}{2}I_{2}}_{0}\propto\epsilon^{I_{1}I_{2}},\qquad C^{\frac{1}{2}J_{1};\frac{1}{2}J_{2}}_{0}\propto\delta^{(J_{1}}_{J_{2})}, \tag*{(69)}

and the LSLS ones are

C1J1J20;I1I2=C1J1J2I1I2;0∝δJ1(I1δJ2I2),(70)C^{0;I_{1}I_{2}}_{1J_{1}J_{2}}=C^{I_{1}I_{2};0}_{1J_{1}J_{2}}\propto\delta^{(I_{1}}_{J_{1}}\delta^{I_{2})}_{J_{2}}, \tag*{(70)}
C1J1J21;I1I2;1K1K2∝δJ1I1δJ2I2δJ1(K1δJ2K2),(71)C^{1;I_{1}I_{2};1K_{1}K_{2}}_{1J_{1}J_{2}}\propto\delta^{I_{1}}_{J_{1}}\delta^{I_{2}}_{J_{2}}\delta^{(K_{1}}_{J_{1}}\delta^{K_{2})}_{J_{2}}, \tag*{(71)}
C1J1J22;I1I2I3I4;1K1K2∝δJ1I1δJ2I2δK1I3δK2I4+perm,(72)C^{2;I_{1}I_{2}I_{3}I_{4};1K_{1}K_{2}}_{1J_{1}J_{2}}\propto\delta^{I_{1}}_{J_{1}}\delta^{I_{2}}_{J_{2}}\delta^{I_{3}}_{K_{1}}\delta^{I_{4}}_{K_{2}}+\mathrm{perm}, \tag*{(72)}

with all index sets {I}\{I\}, {J}\{J\}, {K}\{K\} totally symmetric. The orbital part is carried by the harmonic tensors

Y0=1,Y1=[3∣p1∣3⟩,Y2=[3∣p1∣3⟩2,(73)Y_{0}=1,\qquad Y_{1}=[3|p_{1}|3\rangle,\qquad Y_{2}=[3|p_{1}|3\rangle^{2}, \tag*{(73)}

the same objects may also be written with their little-group indices; in the COM frame they read

Y1I1I2=ϵI1K(n^⋅σ)K I2,Y2{I}=Y1(I1I2I3I4).(74)Y_{1}^{I_{1}I_{2}}=\epsilon^{I_{1}K}(\hat{n}\cdot\sigma)_{K}^{\ I_{2}},\qquad Y_{2}^{\{I\}}=Y_{1}^{(I_{1}I_{2}I_{3}I_{4})}. \tag*{(74)}

Here (σi)K J(\sigma_{i})_{K}^{\ J} are the Pauli matrices acting on the little-group indices, to be distinguished from the spin label σ\sigma. For instance, for (L,S,J)=(0,0,0)(L,S,J)=(0,0,0) and (1,1,0)(1,1,0) this gives, respectively,

AI1I2(0,0)∝ϵI1I2,AI1I2(1,1)∝ϵI1K(n^⋅σ)K I2.(75)\mathcal{A}^{I_{1}I_{2}}(0,0)\propto\epsilon^{I_{1}I_{2}},\qquad \mathcal{A}^{I_{1}I_{2}}(1,1)\propto\epsilon^{I_{1}K}(\hat{n}\cdot\sigma)_{K}^{\ I_{2}}. \tag*{(75)}

For the part with J=1J=1 we use a vector index: writing the amplitude as AiI1I2\mathcal{A}^{I_{1}I_{2}}_{i}, we represent it by

AiI1I2∝ϵI1K(σi)K J2AJ1J2I1I2.(76)\mathcal{A}^{I_{1}I_{2}}_{i}\propto\epsilon^{I_{1}K}(\sigma_{i})_{K}^{\ J_{2}}\mathcal{A}^{I_{1}I_{2}}_{J_{1}J_{2}}. \tag*{(76)}

As a check, the (1,0)(1,0) structure reproduces the vector form,

AiI1I2(1,0)=ϵJ1K(σi)K J2AJ1J2I1I2\mathcal{A}^{I_{1}I_{2}}_{i}(1,0)=\epsilon^{J_{1}K}(\sigma_{i})_{K}^{\ J_{2}}\mathcal{A}^{I_{1}I_{2}}_{J_{1}J_{2}}
∝ϵJ1K(σi)K J2ϵI1I2ϵJ1K′(n^⋅σ)K′ J2′ϵJ1′J2′=ϵI1I2ϵJ1K(σi)K J2(n^⋅σ)J1 J2′ϵJ2′J2=2ϵI1I2n^i,(77)\begin{aligned} \propto\epsilon^{J_{1}K}(\sigma_{i})_{K}^{\ J_{2}}\epsilon^{I_{1}I_{2}}\epsilon_{J_{1}K'}(\hat{n}\cdot\sigma)_{K'}^{\ J'_{2}}\epsilon_{J'_{1}J'_{2}} \\ &=\epsilon^{I_{1}I_{2}}\epsilon^{J_{1}K}(\sigma_{i})_{K}^{\ J_{2}}(\hat{n}\cdot\sigma)_{J_{1}}^{\ J'_{2}}\epsilon_{J'_{2}J_{2}} \\ &=2\epsilon^{I_{1}I_{2}}\hat{n}_{i}, \tag*{(77)} \end{aligned}

where the last step uses the Pauli completeness relation in the trace form

Tr⁡(σ2σiTσ2σj)=2δij,(78)\operatorname{Tr}(\sigma_{2}\sigma_{i}^{T}\sigma_{2}\sigma_{j})=2\delta_{ij}, \tag*{(78)}

written with ϵIJ=ϵIJ=(−iσ2)IJ\epsilon^{IJ}=\epsilon_{IJ}=(-i\sigma_{2})^{IJ}, which turns each ϵ\epsilon contracted in the second line into a factor of iσ2i\sigma_{2}. With this notation the four structures read

AiI1I2(1,0)∝ϵI1I2n^i,(79)\mathcal{A}^{I_{1}I_{2}}_{i}(1,0)\propto\epsilon^{I_{1}I_{2}}\hat{n}_{i}, \tag*{(79)}
AiI1I2(0,1)∝ϵI1K(σi)K I2,(80)\mathcal{A}^{I_{1}I_{2}}_{i}(0,1)\propto\epsilon^{I_{1}K}(\sigma_{i})_{K}^{\ I_{2}}, \tag*{(80)}
AiI1I2(1,1)∝ϵI1K(σ⋅n^)K I2,(81)\mathcal{A}^{I_{1}I_{2}}_{i}(1,1)\propto\epsilon^{I_{1}K}(\sigma\cdot\hat{n})_{K}^{\ I_{2}}, \tag*{(81)}
AiI1I2(2,1)∝ϵI1K(3n^in^⋅σ−σi)K I2.(82)\mathcal{A}^{I_{1}I_{2}}_{i}(2,1)\propto\epsilon^{I_{1}K}(3\hat{n}_{i}\hat{n}\cdot\sigma-\sigma_{i})_{K}^{\ I_{2}}. \tag*{(82)}

The arguments label the orbital and spin angular momenta of each structure.

General form factors and correlation functions

The construction of the previous section generalises to a general form factor structure and to a general frame. Form factor construction. For the general form factor

F{α}{α˙}(p)=∫d4x eip⋅x⟨0∣O{α}{α˙}(x)∣p1,σ1,p2,σ2⟩(83)F^{\{\alpha\}\{\dot{\alpha}\}}(p)=\int d^4x\,e^{ip\cdot x}\langle0|O^{\{\alpha\}\{\dot{\alpha}\}}(x)|p_1,\sigma_1,p_2,\sigma_2\rangle \tag*{(83)}

with p=p1+p2p=p_1+p_2, arbitrary external states ∣p1,σ1⟩|p_1,\sigma_1\rangle and ∣p2,σ2⟩|p_2,\sigma_2\rangle of spins s1s_1 and s2s_2, and the operator OO carrying the spinor indices of the Lorentz representation (jL,jR)(j_L,j_R), all independent and complete Lorentz structures can be built from spinors without returning to the COM frame. It suffices to define the object that carries little-group rather than Lorentz indices, the index sets {I}\{I\} and {J}\{J\} being of rank 2jL2j_L and 2jR2j_R,

F~{I}{J}≡F{α}{α˙}λ{α}{I}2jLλ~{α˙}{J}2jR,(84)\widetilde{F}_{\{I\}\{J\}}\equiv F^{\{\alpha\}\{\dot{\alpha}\}}\lambda^{2j_L}_{\{\alpha\}\{I\}}\widetilde{\lambda}^{2j_R}_{\{\dot{\alpha}\}\{J\}}, \tag*{(84)}

Its inverse follows by contracting with the dual tensors,

F{α}{α˙}=1m2jL+2jRF~{I}{J}(λ2jL){α}{I}(λ~2jR){α˙}{J},(85)F^{\{\alpha\}\{\dot{\alpha}\}}=\frac{1}{m^{2j_L+2j_R}}\widetilde{F}_{\{I\}\{J\}}\left(\lambda^{2j_L}\right)^{\{\alpha\}\{I\}}\left(\widetilde{\lambda}^{2j_R}\right)^{\{\dot{\alpha}\}\{J\}}, \tag*{(85)}

the structures of F~\widetilde{F} being in one-to-one correspondence with those of FF. Decomposing F~\widetilde{F} into SU(2)SU(2) irreducible parts,

F~j{K}≡Cj{K}jL{I};jR{J}F~{I}{J},(86)\widetilde{F}_{j\{K\}}\equiv C^{j_L\{I\};j_R\{J\}}_{j\{K\}}\widetilde{F}_{\{I\}\{J\}}, \tag*{(86)}
F~{I}{J}=∑jCjL{I};jR{J}j{K}F~j{K}(87)\widetilde{F}_{\{I\}\{J\}}=\sum_j C^{j\{K\}}_{j_L\{I\};j_R\{J\}}\widetilde{F}_{j\{K\}} \tag*{(87)}

with j=∣jL−jR∣,…,jL+jRj=|j_L-j_R|,\ldots,j_L+j_R, the structures of F~j\widetilde{F}_j are exactly those of the amplitude for j→s1+s2j\to s_1+s_2, given by Eq. (24) and expanded as

F~j=∑L,SgjLSM(L,S,j).(88)\widetilde{F}_j=\sum_{L,S}g_{jLS}\mathcal{M}(L,S,j). \tag*{(88)}

Substituting Eq. (88) into the inverse relations (87) and (85) yields the complete set of Lorentz structures of FF,

F{α}{α˙}=1m2jL+2jR∑j,L,SgjLSM(L,S,j){K}CjL{I};jR{J}j{K}(λ2jL){α}{I}(λ~2jR){α˙}{J}.(89)F^{\{\alpha\}\{\dot{\alpha}\}}=\frac{1}{m^{2j_L+2j_R}}\sum_{j,L,S}g_{jLS}\mathcal{M}(L,S,j)_{\{K\}}C^{j\{K\}}_{j_L\{I\};j_R\{J\}}\left(\lambda^{2j_L}\right)^{\{\alpha\}\{I\}}\left(\widetilde{\lambda}^{2j_R}\right)^{\{\dot{\alpha}\}\{J\}}. \tag*{(89)}

The structures are therefore built from spinor variables, and their number follows from the same spin-coupling technique as that of the amplitudes [28].

Parton correlation functions. These are the special case of a form factor structure in which the two external momenta coincide and the relative momentum qq is carried by the internal operator,

C{α}{α˙}(p,q)=∫dx ρσσ′⟨pσ∣eiq⋅xO{α}{α˙}(x,0)∣pσ′⟩,C^{\{\alpha\}\{\dot{\alpha}\}}(p,q)=\int dx\,\rho_{\sigma\sigma'}\langle p\sigma|e^{iq\cdot x}O^{\{\alpha\}\{\dot{\alpha}\}}(x,0)|p\sigma'\rangle,

with ρ\rho the density matrix. Contracting with the spinors reduces the problem to a little-group tensor, C{α}{α˙}(λ2jL){α}{I}(λ~2jR){α˙}{J}=ρσσ′C~σσ′{I}{J}C^{\{\alpha\}\{\dot{\alpha}\}}(\lambda^{2j_L})_{\{\alpha\}}^{\{I\}}(\widetilde{\lambda}^{2j_R})_{\{\dot{\alpha}\}}^{\{J\}}=\rho_{\sigma\sigma'}\widetilde{C}^{\{I\}\{J\}}_{\sigma\sigma'}, whose independent forms follow from decomposing the direct product of all little-group indices into a scalar structure. The density matrix then serves as a general coefficient, and the approach reproduces the known quark–quark and gluon–gluon correlations.

Covariant partial wave analysis on cascade decay. Traditionally the partial-wave decomposition is performed through the coupling of the orbital and spin parts in the two-body COM frame; when the process involves cascade decay chains the momenta must be boosted and the resulting amplitudes are not covariant, the orbital and spin parts being mixed [38]. With canonical particle states the LSLS decomposition can be performed directly among particles in an arbitrary frame, without boost transformations; this partial-wave analysis [22, 23, 24] has been applied to the process Λc+→Λπ+π0\Lambda_c^+\to\Lambda\pi^+\pi^0 [29].

This cascade decay contains several possible intermediate resonant states, with each resonance corresponding to a distinct decay chain. We consider the intermediate states that Ref. [30] reports above 5σ5\sigma, namely the ρ(770)+\rho(770)^+, Σ(1385)+\Sigma(1385)^+, Σ(1385)0\Sigma(1385)^0, Σ(1670)+\Sigma(1670)^+, Σ(1670)0\Sigma(1670)^0, Σ(1750)+\Sigma(1750)^+ and Σ(1750)0\Sigma(1750)^0 states together with the nonresonant NR1−NR_{1-}. These components fall into three topological classes:

  • Topology I (ρ+\rho^+-type): Λc+→ΛR\Lambda_c^+\to\Lambda R, R→π+π0R\to\pi^+\pi^0, Λ→pπ−\Lambda\to p\pi^-, with meson resonance RR decaying in π+π0\pi^+\pi^0; the two leading terms are the ρ(770)+\rho(770)^+ and the nonresonant JP=1−J^P=1^- one, written NR1−NR_{1-}. The amplitudes corresponding to these channel are defined as:

AΛc+pπ−π+π0(ρ)=AΛc+ΛρAρπ+π0AΛpπ−,(90)\mathcal{A}^{p\pi^-\pi^+\pi^0}_{\Lambda_c^+}(\rho)=\mathcal{A}^{\Lambda\rho}_{\Lambda_c^+}\mathcal{A}^{\pi^+\pi^0}_{\rho}\mathcal{A}^{p\pi^-}_{\Lambda}, \tag*{(90)}
AΛc+pπ−π+π0(NR1−)=AΛc+ΛNR1−ANR1−π+π0AΛpπ−,(91)\mathcal{A}^{p\pi^-\pi^+\pi^0}_{\Lambda_c^+}(NR_{1-})=\mathcal{A}^{\Lambda NR_{1-}}_{\Lambda_c^+}\mathcal{A}^{\pi^+\pi^0}_{NR_{1-}}\mathcal{A}^{p\pi^-}_{\Lambda}, \tag*{(91)}

where each particle symbol stands for the particle together with its little-group indices, pp, Λc+\Lambda_c^+, Λ\Lambda, ρ\rho; the scalars π\pi carry the trivial little-group index, that is none, and appear only as labels.

  • Topology II (Σ∗+\Sigma^{*+}-type): Λc+→Σ∗+π0\Lambda_c^+\to\Sigma^{*+}\pi^0, Σ∗+→Λπ+\Sigma^{*+}\to\Lambda\pi^+, Λ→pπ−\Lambda\to p\pi^-, with Σ∗+\Sigma^{*+} an excited baryon; the candidates are the Σ(1385)+\Sigma(1385)^+, Σ(1670)+\Sigma(1670)^+ and Σ(1750)+\Sigma(1750)^+, and

AΛc+pπ−π+π0(Σ∗+)=AΛc+Λπ0Σ∗+AΣ∗+Λπ+AΛpπ−.(92)\mathcal{A}^{p\pi^-\pi^+\pi^0}_{\Lambda_c^+}(\Sigma^{*+})=\mathcal{A}^{\Lambda\pi^0\Sigma^{*+}}_{\Lambda_c^+}\mathcal{A}^{\Lambda\pi^+}_{\Sigma^{*+}}\mathcal{A}^{p\pi^-}_{\Lambda}. \tag*{(92)}
  • Topology III (Σ∗0\Sigma^{*0}-type): Λc+→Σ∗0π+\Lambda_c^+\to\Sigma^{*0}\pi^+, Σ∗0→Λπ0\Sigma^{*0}\to\Lambda\pi^0, Λ→pπ−\Lambda\to p\pi^-, with Σ∗0\Sigma^{*0} another excited baryon; the candidates are the Σ(1385)0\Sigma(1385)^0, Σ(1670)0\Sigma(1670)^0 and Σ(1750)0\Sigma(1750)^0, and

AΛc+pπ−π+π0(Σ∗0)=AΛc+Λπ+Σ∗0AΣ∗0Λπ0AΛpπ−.(93)\mathcal{A}^{p\pi^-\pi^+\pi^0}_{\Lambda_c^+}(\Sigma^{*0})=\mathcal{A}^{\Lambda\pi^+\Sigma^{*0}}_{\Lambda_c^+}\mathcal{A}^{\Lambda\pi^0}_{\Sigma^{*0}}\mathcal{A}^{p\pi^-}_{\Lambda}. \tag*{(93)}

In each topology every three-point amplitude can be analysed in the LSLS basis; bootstrapping them gives the total amplitude of that topology, and the amplitude of the whole Λc+\Lambda_c^+ decay is the sum of the amplitudes of the topologies. Using this amplitude basis together with the open-source package TF-PWA [31], events are generated and fitted; the comparison with the conventional treatments carried out in Ref. [29] shows that the results agree very well.

References

  1. [1]T. D. Newton and E. P. Wigner, Rev. Mod. Phys. 21, 400 (1949).
  2. [2]W. N. Polyzou, W. Glöckle, and H. Witala, Few Body Syst. 54, 1667 (2013), arXiv:1208.5840 [nucl-th].
  3. [3]E. P. Wigner, Annals Math. 40, 149 (1939).
  4. [4]S. Weinberg, The Quantum theory of fields. Vol. 1: Foundations (Cambridge University Press, 2005).
  5. [5]A Lorentz transformation L ∈ SL(2, C) acts on a four-velocity through its Hermitian matrix representative: with u ≡ uμσμ one has u ↦ L u L†, which is the double cover SL(2, C) → SO+(1, 3). The velocity reached from u* is written u = Lu*, so that u = L u* L†.
  6. [6]B. A. Douvnin, A. T. Fomenko, and S. P. Novikov, Modern Geometry — Methods and Applications: Part II, Graduate Texts in Mathematics, Vol. 104 (Springer, 1985).
  7. [7]S. Kobayashi and K. Nomizu, Foundations of Differential Geometry. Volume II, Interscience Tracts in Pure and Applied Mathematics No. 15 (Interscience Publishers, New York, 1969).
  8. [8]N. Arkani-Hamed, T.-C. Huang, and Y.-t. Huang, JHEP 11, 070 (2021), arXiv:1709.04891 [hep-th].
  9. [9]S. Dittmaier, Phys. Rev. D 59, 016007 (1998), arXiv:hep-ph/9805445.DOI
  10. [10]L. J. Dixon, in TASI in Elementary Particle Physics (2014) pp. 31–67, arXiv:1310.5353 [hep-ph].
  11. [11]H. Elvang and Y.-t. Huang, (2015).
  12. [12]C. Cheung, in TASI in Elementary Particle Physics (2018) pp. 571–623, arXiv:1708.03872 [hep-ph].
  13. [13]S. Badger, J. Henn, J. C. Plefka, and S. Zoia, Lect. Notes Phys. 1021, pp. (2024), arXiv:2306.05976 [hep-th].
  14. [14]S. R. Coleman, J. Wess, and B. Zumino, Phys. Rev. 177, 2239 (1969).
  15. [15]C. G. Callan, Jr., S. R. Coleman, J. Wess, and B. Zumino, Phys. Rev. 177, 2247 (1969).
  16. [16]T. Eguchi, P. B. Gilkey, and A. J. Hanson, Phys. Rept. 66, 213 (1980).
  17. [17]P. Benincasa and F. Cachazo, (2007), arXiv:0705.4305 [hep-th].arxiv.org/abs/0705.4305
  18. [18]E. Witten, Commun. Math. Phys. 252, 189 (2004), arXiv:hep-th/0312171.DOI
  19. [19]R. Britto, F. Cachazo, and B. Feng, Nucl. Phys. B 715, 499 (2005), arXiv:hep-th/0412308.DOI
  20. [20]R. Britto, F. Cachazo, B. Feng, and E. Witten, Phys. Rev. Lett. 94, 181602 (2005), arXiv:hep-th/0501052.DOI
  21. [21]M. Jacob and G. C. Wick, Annals Phys. 7, 404 (1959).
  22. [22]S. U. Chung, Phys. Rev. D 48, 1225 (1993), [Erratum: Phys.Rev.D 56, 4419 (1997)].
  23. [23]S. U. Chung, Phys. Rev. D 57, 431 (1998).
  24. [24]B. S. Zou and D. V. Bugg, Eur. Phys. J. A 16, 537 (2003), arXiv:hep-ph/0211457.DOI
  25. [25]B. S. Zou and F. Hussain, Phys. Rev. C 67, 015204 (2003), arXiv:nucl-th/0210164.
  26. [26]H.-J. Jing, D. Ben, S.-M. Wu, J.-J. Wu, and B.-S. Zou, JHEP 06, 039 (2023), arXiv:2301.01575 [hep-ph].DOI
  27. [27]H.-J. Jing, S.-M. Wu, and J.-J. Wu, Phys. Rev. D 110, 016014 (2024), arXiv:2405.05676 [hep-ph].
  28. [28]H. Huang, T. Tan, Y.-N. Wang, and J.-H. Yu, (2026), arXiv:2605.04030 [hep-ph].arxiv.org/abs/2605.04030
  29. [29]H. Huang, Y.-N. Wang, and J.-H. Yu, (2026), arXiv:2603.04487 [hep-ph].
  30. [30]M. Ablikim et al. (BESIII), JHEP 12, 033 (2022), arXiv:2209.08464 [hep-ex].DOI
  31. [31]Y. Jiang et al., GitHub link: https://github.com/jiangyi15/tf-pwa (2020).
  32. [32]In principle, massless particles have a different momentum orbit and little group, so their bundle construction must be treated separately. However, in the spinor formalism, we find the massive partial wave decomposition can be extended to amplitudes with massless particles.
  33. [33]L. H. Thomas, Nature 117, 514 (1926).
  34. [34]J. Oblak, J. Geom. Phys. 129, 168 (2018), arXiv:1710.06883 [hep-th].DOI
  35. [35]V. Palge and C. Pfeifer, Phys. Rev. A 109, 032206 (2024), arXiv:2310.08121 [quant-ph].DOI
  36. [36]M. V. Berry, Proc. Roy. Soc. Lond. A 392, 45 (1984).
  37. [37]Y. Aharonov and J. Anandan, Phys. Rev. Lett. 58, 1593 (1987).
  38. [38]K. Habermann and M. Mikhasenko, Phys. Rev. D 111, 056015 (2025), arXiv:2409.06913 [hep-ph].DOI

Paper details

vlnc:W_r7b2h6b3
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents