betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Enhancing carrier transfer properties of Na-rich anti-perovskites, Na4OM2 with tetrahedral anion groups: an evaluation through first-principles computational analysis

Abstract

The practical application of Na-based solid-state electrolytes (SSEs) is limited by their low level of conduction. To evaluate the impact of tetrahedral anion groups on carrier migration, we designed a set of anti-perovskite SSEs theoretically based on the previously reported Na4OBr2, including Na4O(BH4)2, Na4O(BF4)2, and Na4O(AlH4)2. It is essential to note that the excessive radius of anionic groups inevitably leads to lattice distortion, resulting in asymmetric migration paths and a limited improvement in carrier migration rate. Na4O(AlH4)2 provides a clear example of where Na migrates in two distinct environments. In addition, due to different spatial charge distributions, the interaction strength between anionic groups and Na is different. Strong interactions can cause carriers to appear on a swing, leading to a decrease in conductivity. The low conductivity of Na4O(BF4)2 is a typical example. This study demonstrates that Na4O(BH4)2 exhibits remarkable mechanical and dynamic stability and shows ionic conductivity, two orders of magnitude higher than that of Na4OBr2. This is attributed to the expansion of the carrier migration channels by the anion groups, the moderate interaction between carriers and anionic groups, and the paddle-wheel effect generated by the anion groups, indicating that the paddle-wheel effect is still effective in low-dimensional anti-perovskite structures, in which atoms are arranged asymmetrically.

Introduction

Over the past three decades, the demand for electrochemical energy storage has accelerated the development of solid-state electrolytes (SSEs). Although significant advancements have been made in lithium-ion batteries (LIBs), including enhanced energy density and safety, the high cost of lithium remains a significant hurdle in reducing LIBs' cost. Consequently, sodium-ion batteries (SIBs) have become a promising alternative owing to their abundance and low cost. Nonetheless, the SIBs suffer from several constraints such as lower energy density, shorter lifespan, higher internal resistance, and lower ionic conductivity, which severely limit the output power of these batteries. As such, it is paramount to search for and design SIBs materials with high ionic conductivity and excellent chemical/electrochemical stability.

Recent reports have highlighted inorganic sodium superionic conductors, which have promoted the exploration of anti-perovskite Li3OCl\mathrm{Li_3OCl} sodium analogs. [1] These studies have shown that anti-perovskite Na3OX\mathrm{Na_3OX} structures exhibit strong sodium ionic conductivity at high temperatures. [2] As two-dimensional materials have exceptional physicochemical properties, recent studies have focused on exploring the rapid ion conduction mechanism of low-dimensional anti-perovskites through theoretical calculations. These investigations have divulged that the phonon softening effect in the low-dimensional structure can cause the rapid migration of cations and increase ionic conductivity (about 10−410^{-4} S cm−1^{-1}). Further experimentation indicates that the primary migration channel of Na+\mathrm{Na^+} in multi-layered Na4OI2\mathrm{Na_4OI_2} occurs between adjacent Na+\mathrm{Na^+} cations residing in the NaO6\mathrm{NaO_6} octahedron. [3] The polarized I−\mathrm{I^-} anions join the Na+\mathrm{Na^+} hopping pathway between the layered anti-perovskites' separated octahedra along the c-axis. [4] These revelations suggest that subsequent structural modifications can enhance Na+\mathrm{Na^+} migration channels and heighten ionic conductivity. It is crucial to note that weak interactions between polarizable anions also impact ionic conductivity.

Research has revealed that by replacing monovalent anions with anionic groups in Na3OX\mathrm{Na_3OX} (X=Cl\mathrm{X=Cl}, Br, and I), it is feasible to elevate the ionic conductivity by an astonishing four orders of magnitude. [5] Cubic anti-perovskite Na3OBH4\mathrm{Na_3OBH_4} possesses an ionic conductivity of 4.4×10−34.4 \times10^{-3} S cm−1^{-1} and 1.1×10−21.1 \times10^{-2} S cm−1^{-1} at ambient temperature and 328 K, respectively, representing an impressive increase.[6] A mixed phase of Li3S(BF4)0.5Cl0.5\mathrm{Li_3S(BF_4)_{0.5}Cl_{0.5}} and the Li3SBF4\mathrm{Li_3SBF_4} proposal exhibits a room temperature conductivity of approximately 0.1 S cm−1^{-1}, which is comparable to organic electrolytes.[7] The remarkable improvement in conductivity is attributed to the cubic anti-perovskite crystal structure, as well as the rotational nature of its anion groups.

In comparison with Na3OX\mathrm{Na_3OX} and other three-dimensional anti-perovskite structures, Na4OBr2\mathrm{Na_4OBr_2} exhibits a distinctive low-dimensional, multi-layer anti-perovskite structure and enjoys a greater carrier concentration, making it a promising candidate to adjust the structure in enhancing ionic conductivity.[8] To substitute Br−\mathrm{Br^-}, anionic groups such as [BH4]−\mathrm{[BH_4]^-}, [BF4]−\mathrm{[BF_4]^-}, and [AlH4]−\mathrm{[AlH_4]^-} were used due to their variations in size, interaction, and chemical properties.

Methods

The Vienna ab initio simulation package (VASP) was utilized to conduct first-principles calculations, employing Perdew-Burke-Ernzerhof (PBE) exchange and correlation functionals and projector-augmented-wave (PAW) pseudopotentials.[9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15] A 10×10×1010 \times10 \times10 k-mesh grid and a cutoff energy of 600 eV have been utilized.[16] The electronic self-consistent field and the forces acting on atoms have a convergence threshold of 1.0×10−71.0 \times10^{-7} eV and 1.0×10−41.0 \times10^{-4} eV Å−1^{-1}, respectively. All geometries were fully relaxed until the residual Hellmann–Feynman forces acting upon each atom were less than 0.01 eV atom−1^{-1}, ensuring consistent and stable results.

In addition, the van der Waals interactions were corrected using the DFT-D3 method proposed by Grimme et al.[17] In analyzing the crystal orbital Hamiltonian population (COHP), an integrated crystal orbital Hamiltonian population (ICOHP) acts as an ab initio measure of the covalent bond strength.[18]

A 2×2×12 \times2 \times1 supercell with a 3×3×23 \times3 \times2 k-point grid to compute the phonon dispersion and 2nd interatomic force constant (2nd IFC) in conjunction with the VASP and PHONOPY packages.[19, 20, 21, 22] One vacancy is created for every 32 sodium atoms, and the sodium: sodium vacancy ratio in the lattice is 1:0.03. For Na4OBr2\mathrm{Na_4OBr_2}, Na4O(BH4)2\mathrm{Na_4O(BH_4)_2}, Na4O(BF4)2\mathrm{Na_4O(BF_4)_2}, and Na4O(AlH4)2\mathrm{Na_4O(AlH_4)_2}, the formation energy of a sodium vacancy is approximately 0.941 eV, 0.348 eV, 0.586 eV, and 0.886 eV in Na4OBr2\mathrm{Na_4OBr_2}, Na4O(BH4)2\mathrm{Na_4O(BH_4)_2}, Na4O(BF4)2\mathrm{Na_4O(BF_4)_2}, and Na4O(AlH4)2\mathrm{Na_4O(AlH_4)_2}, respectively. These values are much lower than the sodium interstitial value in Na4OBr2\mathrm{Na_4OBr_2}, Na4O(BH4)2\mathrm{Na_4O(BH_4)_2}, Na4O(BF4)2\mathrm{Na_4O(BF_4)_2}, and Na4O(AlH4)2\mathrm{Na_4O(AlH_4)_2}, with values of 1.294 eV, 1.711 eV, 1.805 eV and 1.996 eV respectively. To determine migration pathways, we used the climbing image nudged elastic band method (CI-NEB) in conjunction with the dimer method. [23, 24] Supercells have been utilized to minimize carrier interaction with their replicas during migration.

Results and discussions

Structural Properties

Drawing on the previously reported crystal structure of Na4OBr2\mathrm{Na}_{4}\mathrm{OBr}_{2}, we have proposed theoretical structures for two-dimensional anti-perovskites Na4O(BH4)2\mathrm{Na}_{4}\mathrm{O}(\mathrm{BH}_{4})_{2}, Na4O(BF4)2\mathrm{Na}_{4}\mathrm{O}(\mathrm{BF}_{4})_{2}, and Na4O(AlH4)2\mathrm{Na}_{4}\mathrm{O}(\mathrm{AlH}_{4})_{2} by substituting [BH4]−[\mathrm{BH}_{4}]^{-}, [BF4]−[\mathrm{BF}_{4}]^{-}, and [AlH4]−[\mathrm{AlH}_{4}]^{-} anion groups in place of the halogen Br−\mathrm{Br}^{-}, as depicted in Figure 1. In order to alleviate the extensive internal stress imposed by anion substitution, a sequence of lattice parameter optimization and ionic position relaxation steps must be executed. The lattice parameters and a variety of bond distances have been optimized by using the PBE-D3 method and the results are presented in Table 1.

Optimized structures of Na4OBr2, Na4O(BH4)2, Na4O(BF4)2, and Na4O(AlH4)2

Figure 1. The optimized structures of (a) Na4_4OBr2_2 in I4/mmmI4/mmm, (b) Na4_4O(BH4_4)2_2 in PnnmPnnm, (c) Na4_4O(BF4_4)2_2 and (d) Na4_4O(AlH4_4)2_2 in Fmm2Fmm2 in tetragonal and orthorhombic symmetry.

Space groupaa (Å)bb (Å)cc (Å)Atoms pairsAverage distance (Å)
a Na4OBr2Na_{4}OBr_{2}I4/mmmI4/mmm (#139)4.524.5214.91Na-Br3.19
a Na4OBr2Na_{4}OBr_{2}I4/mmmI4/mmm (#139)4.524.5214.91Na-O2.26
b Na4OBr2Na_{4}OBr_{2}I4/mmmI4/mmm (#139)4.504.5014.93Na-Br3.18
b Na4OBr2Na_{4}OBr_{2}I4/mmmI4/mmm (#139)4.504.5014.93Na-O2.25
Na4O(BH4)2Na_{4}O(BH_{4})_{2}PnnmPnnm (#58)4.464.4614.67Na-B2.96
Na4O(BH4)2Na_{4}O(BH_{4})_{2}PnnmPnnm (#58)4.464.4614.67B-H1.22
Na4O(BH4)2Na_{4}O(BH_{4})_{2}PnnmPnnm (#58)4.464.4614.67Na-O2.28
Na4O(BF4)2Na_{4}O(BF_{4})_{2}Fmm2Fmm2 (#42)4.644.5716.23Na-B3.09
Na4O(BF4)2Na_{4}O(BF_{4})_{2}Fmm2Fmm2 (#42)4.644.5716.23B-F1.42
Na4O(BF4)2Na_{4}O(BF_{4})_{2}Fmm2Fmm2 (#42)4.644.5716.23Na-O2.26
Na4O(AlH4)2Na_{4}O(AlH_{4})_{2}Fmm2Fmm2 (#42)4.674.6816.87Na-Al3.13
Na4O(AlH4)2Na_{4}O(AlH_{4})_{2}Fmm2Fmm2 (#42)4.674.6816.87Al-H1.63
Na4O(AlH4)2Na_{4}O(AlH_{4})_{2}Fmm2Fmm2 (#42)4.674.6816.87Na-O2.28

Table 1. Optimized geometries of Na4OM2Na_{4}OM_{2} with the PBE-D3. a: Experimental values from Ref. 25. b: Optimized lattice parameters.

The optimized structural parameters of Na4OBr2\mathrm{Na}_{4}\mathrm{OBr}_{2} exhibit only 4% and 1% errors for the cc-axis and aa-axis, respectively, compared to experimental values, bearing testimony to the credibility of both the method and its accompanying parameters.[25] Due to the anisotropic and rotatable nature of the substituted anionic groups, the symmetry of the space group in these theoretical structures is diminished, as illustrated in Figure 1. As the radius of the anionic group increases, the lattice parameters along the aa and bb axes are no longer equivalent, albeit they remain vertical and display anisotropy on the abab plane. The average distance between Na+\mathrm{Na}^{+} and the center of the anionic group expands, suggesting that the transport channels for carriers must inevitably expand too. Notably, while Na6O\mathrm{Na}_{6}\mathrm{O} tilts in Figure 1, the coordination number remains unaltered, thereby hinting at the preservation of the physicochemical properties of these novel structures.

The Goldschmidt tolerance factor (tt) has been extensively employed to anticipate the formability of prospective anti-perovskite structures, which is defined as:[26]

t=RNa+RM2(RO+RM)(1)t = \frac{R_{\mathrm{Na}} + R_{\mathrm{M}}}{\sqrt{2}(R_{\mathrm{O}} + R_{\mathrm{M}})} \tag*{(1)}

where RNaR_{\mathrm{Na}} is the ionic radius of sodium cations, ROR_{\mathrm{O}} is the radius of oxygen, and RMR_{\mathrm{M}} is the radii of anionic groups, respectively, as per the Shannon and Prewitt (SP) method. [27] [28] The radii significantly differ by the balancing ion that is employed for the anionic groups. An effective radius for the group has been suggested by Kieslich et al. predicated on a collection of effective ionic radii, wherein the radius of a group (XY)n(\mathrm{XY})_n is defined as the summation of the X–Y bond length and the radius of Y.[29, 30] These semi-empirical radii may be utilized to gauge tolerance factors and ascertain the stability of new structures.

The calculated Goldschmidt tolerance factors are presented in Table 2. It suggests that the ideal tolerance factor for cubic perovskite structures should range between 0.8 and 1.0, which is also applicable to anti-perovskite structures. A tolerance factor exceeding 1.0 leads to the formation of a twisted anti-perovskite structure with slanted octahedra. Since the ionic radius of the [BH4]−[\mathrm{BH}_4]^- group closely resembles that of Br−\mathrm{Br}^-, substitutions with [BH4]−[\mathrm{BH}_4]^- are unlikely to affect the structure. The larger radii of [BF4]−[\mathrm{BF}_4]^- and [AlH4]−[\mathrm{AlH}_4]^- increase tt slightly over to 1, altering the crystal structure from a tetragonal lattice to an orthogonal system. The octahedral factor μ\mu is introduced as a supplement to the Goldschmidt tolerance factor,[31] which is defined as:

Ionic radius of M−M^{-} (Å)Tolerance factor ttoctahedral factors μ\mu
Na4_4OBr2_21.960.870.71
Na4_4O(BH4_4)2_22.030.890.69
Na4_4O(BF4_4)2_22.431.010.58
Na4_4O(AlH4_4)2_22.661.070.53

Table 2. Tolerance factor tt and octahedral factors μ\mu of Na4_4OM2_2, respectively.

μ=RORM(2)\mu= \frac{R_{\mathrm{O}}}{R_{\mathrm{M}}} \tag*{(2)}

The calculated results are listed in Table 3. All values of μ\mu are greater than 0.414, indicating that the stability of OM6\mathrm{OM}_6 has not qualitatively changed due to the introduction of anion clusters. Therefore, all of these candidate structures are stable.[32]

Na4_4OBr2_2Na4_4O(BH4_4)2_2Na4_4O(BF4_4)2_2Na4_4O(AlH4_4)2_2
C11C_{11}509.33636.40715.49392.95
C12C_{12}104.52132.00215.34112.44
C13C_{13}136.58151.86200.9168.98
C22C_{22}-660.52712.46398.47
C23C_{23}-146.91197.3272.64
C33C_{33}492.76586.981014.46487.08
C44C_{44}145.68141.67220.02171.60
C55C_{55}-172.44200.43100.67
C66C_{66}111.47179.78189.6098.81
BHillB_{\mathrm{Hill}}25.1830.4877.5519.53
GHillG_{\mathrm{Hill}}14.5119.1331.8013.63
EHillE_{\mathrm{Hill}}36.5247.4682.4939.65

Table 3. The calculated elastic constants (in Kbar) and Bulk moduli BB, Shear moduli GG and Young’s moduli EE (in Gpa) of Na4_4OM2_2.

To further evaluate structural stability and compare the mechanical properties of each candidate, the elastic constants were calculated according to the generalized Hooke's law and are enumerated in Table 3.[33] All eigenvalues of CijC_{ij} were positive, satisfying the critical Cauchy-Born criterion for mechanical stability of the corresponding symmetry. Table 3 also shows the calculated mechanical properties of polycrystalline materials, including bulk modulus and shear modulus. The presence of substituted anionic groups of [BH4]−[\mathrm{BH}_4]^- and [BF4]−[\mathrm{BF}_4]^- improved their respective mechanical properties. However, the introduction of [AlH4]−[\mathrm{AlH}_4]^- caused significant structural distortion, resulting in Na4O(AlH4)2\mathrm{Na}_4\mathrm{O}(\mathrm{AlH}_4)_2 being relatively soft.

Various high-symmetry directions in the Brillouin zone, as well as the total and projected phonon density of states have been plotted in Figure 2. It can be observed that each candidate exhibits dynamic stability, given that there are no imaginary frequencies. Previous reports on Li3OCl\mathrm{Li}_3\mathrm{OCl} and Na3OCl\mathrm{Na}_3\mathrm{OCl} have shown that three-dimensional perovskite structures are thermodynamically and dynamically unstable at low temperatures, and can only exist in metastable state at high temperatures, high pressures or distorted structures. Our results suggest that lower dimensions are more conducive to anti-perovskite structure stability. [34]

Phonon spectra and projected phonon densities of state of Na4OBr2, Na4O(BH4)2, Na4O(BF4)2, and Na4O(AlH4)2

Figure 2. The phonon spectrum and corresponding projection phonon density-of-state of (a)Na4_4OBr2_2, (b)Na4_4O(BH4_4)2_2, (c)Na4_4O(BF4_4)2_2 and (d)Na4_4O(AlH4_4)2_2, respectively.

Two pronounced phonon gaps are discernible in the phonon dispersion spectra of Na4OM2Na_4OM_2, partitioning the whole phonon bands into three frequency regions. The presence of anionic groups enriches the atomic vibration modes, which is similar to the spectral range of the three-dimensional perovskite materials Na3O(BF4)Na_3O(BF_4) and Na3O(AlH4)Na_3O(AlH_4). [30] Additionally, the contributions of Na and O atoms exist in the low-frequency region (0.0~15.0 THz), and are almost unaffected by changes in M anions. Introduction of [BH4]−[BH_4]^{-} and [AlH4]−[AlH_4]^{-} groups, the H atoms in the outer layer of the anion group contribute to the peak of the high-frequency region, which is indicative of the obvious optical branches, as illustrated in Figure 2 (b)(Figure 2d). However, in [BF4]−[BF_4]^{-}, the high-energy vibration is attributed to the B atom located in the center of the anionic group, corresponding to the frequency region (30.0~40.0THz).

Electronic structures

A solid electrolyte material that is suitable for use in batteries should not only exhibit high ionic conductivity but should also maintain electronic insulation. Electronic conductivity is a critical parameter for SSEs, and it is determined by the band structure, especially the energy gap between the valence and conduction bands. Band structures, corresponding density of states (DOS) and partial DOS for each element have been calculated and displayed in Figure 3. As shown in Figure 3, the valance band maximum (VBM) of these structures is mainly contributed by the 2p2p orbitals of O, and the factors affecting the band gap are the energy and contribution of the atomic orbitals corresponding to the conduction band minimum (CBM). The CBM of Na4O(BH4)2Na_4O(BH_4)_2 is narrower than that of the other models, and the PDOS indicates that the corresponding eigenstate of this band is mainly composed of the s orbitals of Na+Na^{+} cations localized on the lattice points, as shown in Figure 3(b). This band has strong electron localization and a relatively large effective mass, so the energy of the CBM is higher, resulting in a larger band gap and the worst electron conductivity. The band gap of Na4OBr2Na_4OBr_2 measures 2.128 eV, but this value increases to 3.382 eV, 2.850 eV, and 3.100 eV when [BH4]−[BH_4]^{-}, [BF4]−[BF_4]^{-}, and [AlH4]−[AlH_4]^{-} anions substituting the Br−Br^{-}, respectively. Thus, it is clear that substituting halogen with anionic groups leads to a decrease in electron conductivity.

Band structures and corresponding density of states of Na₄OBr₂, Na₄O(BH₄)₂, Na₄O(BF₄)₂, and Na₄O(AlH₄)₂

Figure 3. The band structures and the corresponding density of states of (a) Na₄OBr₂, (b) Na₄O(BH₄)₂, (c) Na₄O(BF₄)₂ and (d) Na₄O(AlH₄)₂, respectively.

To verify the chemical bond strength predictions, the COHP sum of states below the Fermi level can be used, as depicted in Figure 4. According to the bonding states’ area in Figure 4, the B-F and Al-H bonds within the anionic group appear relatively weaker than the B-H bonds. It is important to determine the amount of charge transfer in a scientific and quantitative manner. Using Bader charge analysis from Table 4, it is clear that different anionic functional groups yield a similar impact on the charge distribution of ions in the crystal.[35]

Crystal Orbital Hamiltonian Populations analysis for B–H, B–F, and Al–H bonds in the anion groups

Figure 4. The Crystal Orbital Hamiltonian Populations (COHP) analysis for B-H, B-F, and Al–H bonds in the anion groups.

SystemNa (e)O (e)Br (e)B (e)Al (e)H (e)F (e)Anion groups (e)
Na4OBr2Na_4OBr_2+0.82-1.53-0.88-----0.88
Na4O(BH4)2Na_4O(BH_4)_2+0.83-1.53-+1.62--0.63--0.90
Na4O(BF4)2Na_4O(BF_4)_2+0.83-1.54-+2.40---0.83-0.92
Na4O(AlH4)2Na_4O(AlH_4)_2+0.83-1.52--+2.14-0.76--0.91

Table 4. Bader charge analysis and the charge transfer of each ion in Na4OM2Na_4OM_2.

Ionic conductivity

This section discusses the Na+\mathrm{Na}^{+} migration in Na4OM2\mathrm{Na}_{4}\mathrm{OM}_{2}. The activation energy of Na+\mathrm{Na}^{+} diffusion and its pathways are crucial when assessing Na4OM2\mathrm{Na}_{4}\mathrm{OM}_{2} as a plausible material for sodium-ion batteries. Both ab initio Molecular dynamics (AIMD) and NEB methods have been used to calculate Na+\mathrm{Na}^{+} conductivity based on density functional theory. [36, 37, 38] AIMD simulations mainly focus on the dynamic behavior and thermal properties of carriers. While NEB method finds the lowest energy path during the migration, to obtain the migration energy of carriers and calculate the conductivity of the carriers. This method focuses on the interaction between carriers and their coordination environment. In this work, CI-NEB and Dimer methods are utilized to compute the Na+\mathrm{Na}^{+} migration barrier in each model structure, as depicted in Figure 5. For all CI-NEB calculations, three images were inserted between the initial and final states. Subsequently, the Dimer method is implemented to determine the migration states. The corresponding diffusion coefficient and ionic conductivity were determined utilizing the Arrhenius Equation, and these results are set forth in Table 5.

Migration paths and calculated CI-NEB energies

Figure 5. Taking Na4O(BH4)2\mathrm{Na}_4\mathrm{O}(\mathrm{BH}_4)_2 as an example, the migration paths of Na+\mathrm{Na}^{+} in paths A and B are shown in red and blue curves in the structure, respectively. The migration mode of other Na4OM2\mathrm{Na}_4\mathrm{OM}_2 is similar. The lines connecting the points correspond to a spline fitted to the calculated CI-NEB energies.

SystemPathDistance (Å)Energy Barrier (eV)Ionic Conductivity (S·cm−1^{-1})
Na4OBr2Na_4OBr_2A2.9210.431.48×10−61.48 \times10^{-6}
Na4OBr2Na_4OBr_2B2.9200.431.34×10−61.34 \times10^{-6}
Na4O(BH4)2Na_4O(BH_4)_2A2.7310.321.13×10−41.13 \times10^{-4}
Na4O(BH4)2Na_4O(BH_4)_2B2.7270.321.09×10−41.09 \times10^{-4}
Na4O(BF4)2Na_4O(BF_4)_2A3.1150.548.16×10−88.16 \times10^{-8}
Na4O(BF4)2Na_4O(BF_4)_2B3.0070.508.88×10−88.88 \times10^{-8}
Na4O(AlH4)2Na_4O(AlH_4)_2A3.3590.551.93×10−81.93 \times10^{-8}
Na4O(AlH4)2Na_4O(AlH_4)_2B2.9490.352.90×10−52.90 \times10^{-5}

Table 5. Ionic conductivity and related parameters of each candidate.

Ds=D0e−EakbT=ga2ve−EakbT(3)D_{\mathrm{s}} = D_{0}e^{-\frac{E_{\mathrm{a}}}{k_{\mathrm{b}}T}} = ga^{2}v e^{-\frac{E_{\mathrm{a}}}{k_{\mathrm{b}}T}} \tag*{(3)}
σ=ne2Z2kbTDs(4)\sigma= \frac{ne^{2}Z^{2}}{k_{\mathrm{b}}T}D_{\mathrm{s}} \tag*{(4)}

where gg represents the geometrical attribute, aa denotes the migration distance, vv signifies the attempt frequency, EaE_{\mathrm{a}} embodies the sodium defects' migration gate, nn is the defect concentration, equal to 1/32. ZZ characterizes the carrier charge, ee represents the elementary charge, kbk_{\mathrm{b}} is the Boltzmann constant, and TT correlates to the thermodynamic temperature fixed at 298K.

The Na+\mathrm{Na}^{+} migration barrier in Na4OBr2\mathrm{Na}_{4}\mathrm{OBr}_{2} measures 0.43 eV, whereas the integration of [BH4]−[\mathrm{BH}_{4}]^{-} reduces this barrier value to 0.32 eV. Conversely, in Na4OM2\mathrm{Na}_{4}\mathrm{OM}_{2}, the Na6O\mathrm{Na}_{6}\mathrm{O} octahedra shape a migration layer as Na+\mathrm{Na}^{+} cations, connected at equatorial locations to other octahedra, permit migration. In the course of migration, Na+^{+} must follow a bent path, avoiding steeper potential energy curves, by transiting through migration gates (MGs) generated by O2−^{2-} and two anions, as displayed in Figure 6. [39] The MGs in Na4_4OBr2_2 comprises three rigid, spherical anions, whereas Na4_4O(BH4_4)2_2's MGs includes one O2−^{2-} anion and two that rotate and vibrate [BH4_4]−^-. The anionic groups diminish the repulsion that exists between carriers and MGs, due to the mobile H atoms, which reduce the migration barriers adeptly. During carrier migration, the rotation of the [BH4_4]−^- tetrahedra, aligning the surface of the tetrahedra towards the migrating cation as much as possible, acts as the "paddlewheel effect".[30, 40, 41]

Paddle wheel effect of anion groups in four sodium structures

Figure 6. Na+\mathrm{Na}^{+} cations migrate through the MGs and the paddle wheel effect of anion groups in (a) Na4OBr2\mathrm{Na}_4\mathrm{OBr}_2, (b) Na4O(BH4)2\mathrm{Na}_4\mathrm{O}(\mathrm{BH}_4)_2, (c) Na4O(BF4)2\mathrm{Na}_4\mathrm{O}(\mathrm{BF}_4)_2 and (d) Na4O(AlH4)\mathrm{Na}_4\mathrm{O}(\mathrm{AlH}_4) structures.

Figure 5 demonstrates that the insertion of anionic groups [BF4_4]−^- and [AlH4_4]−^- leads to deviations in the initially identical migration channels. Figure 7 provides further clarification on the coordination surroundings of charge carriers during migration. As depicted in Figure 7(a)(Figure 7b), it is evident that the coordination environments for the two selected paths, PATH_A and PATH_B, are equivalent during Na+^{+} migration in the abab plane of both Na4_4OBr2_2 and Na4_4O(BH4_4)2_2. With the introduction of larger-sized [BF4_4]−^- and [AlH4_4]−^- anionic groups, the symmetry disruption progresses from PnnmPnnm to Fmm2Fmm2, resulting in Na+^{+} experience unique coordination surroundings across diverse migration channels, as illustrated in Figure 7(c)(Figure 7d).

Schematic diagrams of the coordination of charge carriers in the initial, transition and final states

Figure 7. Schematic diagrams of the coordination of charge carriers in the initial, transition and final states are shown for (a) Na4OBr2\mathrm{Na}_{4}\mathrm{OBr}_{2} and (b) Na4O(BH4)2\mathrm{Na}_{4}\mathrm{O}(\mathrm{BH}_{4})_{2} structures. (c) and (d) show the coordination of charge carriers in the initial, transition and final states of Na4O(BF4)2\mathrm{Na}_{4}\mathrm{O}(\mathrm{BF}_{4})_{2} and Na4O(AlH4)\mathrm{Na}_{4}\mathrm{O}(\mathrm{AlH}_{4}), respectively. Anionic groups with strong interaction and large volume form different initial, transition, and final state energy environments along different pathways. The substituting of [BF4]−\left[\mathrm{BF}_{4}\right]^{-} and [AlH4]−\left[\mathrm{AlH}_{4}\right]^{-} results in different energy barriers in the migration path of the Na4OM2\mathrm{Na}_{4}\mathrm{OM}_{2} structure.

The disruption of system symmetry caused by large-sized anionic clusters is reflected in changes in the distances between atoms and the strength of their interaction forces. The ICOHP values in Table 6 elucidate the interaction forces between sodium and the outermost atoms of the anionic clusters. Higher ICOHP values for sodium with the outer F−^- atoms of the [BF4_4]−^- anionic cluster and the outer H−^- atoms of the [AlH4_4]−^- anionic cluster (PATH_A) indicate a stronger attraction between these atoms and sodium, which is consistent with the coordination environment of sodium shown in Figure 7(c) and Figure 7(d). Excessively strong interaction forces hinder sodium migration, resulting in low ionic conductivity, as listed in Table 5. However, the disruption of symmetry does not increase the interaction forces between sodium and H in the PATH_B pathway of Na4_4O(AlH4_4)2_2, as shown in Figure 7(d). The substitution of large size [AlH4_4]−^- will not meet the limitations of Goldschmidt tolerance factor and octahedral factor, thus inevitably reducing the symmetry of the structure, and hinder sodium migration. The symmetry disruption leads to irregular atomic arrangements, making it difficult to control the changes in carrier coordination environments within the same system. While the coordination environment of sodium in the PATH_B pathway is similar to that in Na4O(BH4)2\mathrm{Na}_{4}\mathrm{O}(\mathrm{BH}_{4})_{2}. This is attributed to the appropriate size of the BH4−\mathrm{BH}_{4}^{-} anion groups. An excessively large volume would instead hinder sodium migration. Additionally, the outer atoms of the introduced ionic clusters should not have excessively strong interactions with sodium.

Atom pairdNa−H/FAd_{\mathrm{Na-H/F}}{}_AdNa−H/FBd_{\mathrm{Na-H/F}}{}_BICOHPA\mathrm{ICOHP}_AICOHPB\mathrm{ICOHP}_B
Na−H(Na4O(BH4)2)\mathrm{Na-H(Na_4O(BH_4)_2)}2.392.34-0.10-0.13
Na−F(Na4O(BF4)2)\mathrm{Na-F(Na_4O(BF_4)_2)}2.512.38-0.27-0.38
Na−H(Na4O(AlH4)2)\mathrm{Na-H(Na_4O(AlH_4)_2)}2.542.31-0.17-0.09

Table 6. The ICOHP of carriers and their neighbors in the transition states during migration

Conclusions

In this work, to assess the impact of tetrahedral anionic groups on Na+\mathrm{Na}^{+} migration, we designed a set of complex structures of Na4O(BH4)2\mathrm{Na}_{4}\mathrm{O}(\mathrm{BH}_{4})_{2}, Na4O(BF4)2\mathrm{Na}_{4}\mathrm{O}(\mathrm{BF}_{4})_{2}, and Na4O(AlH4)2\mathrm{Na}_{4}\mathrm{O}(\mathrm{AlH}_{4})_{2} founded on the reported Na4OBr2\mathrm{Na}_{4}\mathrm{OBr}_{2}. Elastic constants and phonon calculations confirmed the mechanical and thermodynamic stability of each structure. CI-NEB and DIMER methods were utilized to calculate the migration processes of carriers in each candidate, and the ionic conductivity of carriers was determined by combining migration distances.

Substituting Br−\mathrm{Br}^{-} with [BH4]−[\mathrm{BH}_{4}]^{-} anionic groups, Na4O(BH4)2\mathrm{Na}_{4}\mathrm{O}(\mathrm{BH}_{4})_{2} has significantly increased the ionic conductivity of Na+\mathrm{Na}^{+} cations by about two orders of magnitude. This is largely attributed to the effective paddle-wheel mechanism of [BH4]−[\mathrm{BH}_{4}]^{-} anionic groups, which reduces migration energy barriers by diminishing the repulsion between carriers and MGs during migration. However, the excessive ion volume of [BF4]−[\mathrm{BF}_{4}]^{-} and [AlH4]−[\mathrm{AlH}_{4}]^{-} anionic groups, combined with robust interactions, causes cell distortion when vacancies are present in the system, resulting in significant differences in migration paths within the same plane and unstable conductivity.

Our results demonstrate that Na4O(BH4)2\mathrm{Na}_{4}\mathrm{O}(\mathrm{BH}_{4})_{2}, in the PnnmPnnm space group is both mechanically and thermodynamically stable, the ionic conductivity is two orders of magnitude higher than that of Na4OBr2\mathrm{Na}_{4}\mathrm{OBr}_{2}, indicating that Na4O(BH4)2\mathrm{Na}_{4}\mathrm{O}(\mathrm{BH}_{4})_{2} could be a superior solid-state electrolyte. Additionally, theoretical analyses reveal that excessive interaction and volume can result in negative effects, culminating in decreased ion conductivity. High-throughput calculations and machine learning will enable us to sift through various anionic groups and strive to discover optimal solutions in following researches.

Acknowledgments

This work was supported by the Natural Science Foundation of Shaanxi Province of China (No. 2020JQ-568), the Natural Science Basic Research Plan in Shaanxi Province of China (No. S2020-JC-QN-0623), the National Natural Science Foundation of China (No. 2022GY-375), the Key Laboratory Research and Establish Program of Shaanxi Education Section (No. 17JS130) and the Double First-class University Construction Project of Northwest University.

In each case, the used Shannon effective ionic radii (R) of Na+^{+}, O2−^{2-}, B, Al, H, and F are 1.02, 1.40, 0.41, 0.68, 0.81 and 1.01 Å, respectively. [28, 42] The radius of the XY4−_4^{-} group is defined as the sum of the bond length of X-Y (X = B, Al; Y = H, F) and the ionic radius of Y. The bond length is taken as the optimized average bond length inside the superhalogen, as listed in Table 1.

References

  1. [1]Wang, Y. et al. Antiperovskites with Exceptional Functionalities. Advanced Materials vol. 32 Preprint at https://doi.org/10.1002/adma.201905007 (2020).
  2. [2]Deng, Z. et al. Anti-perovskite materials for energy storage batteries. InfoMat vol. 4 Preprint at https://doi.org/10.1002/inf2.12252 (2022).
  3. [3]Zhang, Y., Zhao, Y. & Chen, C. Ab initio study of the stabilities of and mechanism of superionic transport in lithium-rich antiperovskites. Phys Rev B Condens Matter Mater Phys 87, (2013).DOI
  4. [4]Zhu, J. et al. Sodium Ion Transport Mechanisms in Antiperovskite Electrolytes Na3OBr and Na4OI2: An in Situ Neutron Diffraction Study. Inorg Chem 55, 5993–5998 (2016).DOI
  5. [5]Wang, Y. et al. Structural manipulation approaches towards enhanced sodium ionic conductivity in Na-rich antiperovskites. J Power Sources 293, 735–740 (2015).DOI
  6. [6]Sun, Y. et al. Rotational Cluster Anion Enabling Superionic Conductivity in Sodium-Rich Antiperovskite Na3OBH4. http://pubs.acs.org (2019).DOI
  7. [7]Fang, H. & Jena, P. Li-rich antiperovskite superionic conductors based on cluster ions. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 114, 11046–11051 (2017).DOI
  8. [8]Goldmann, B. A., Clarke, M. J., Dawson, J. A. & Islam, M. S. Atomic-scale investigation of cation doping and defect clustering in the anti-perovskite Na3OCl sodium-ion conductor. J Mater Chem A Mater 10, 2249–2255 (2022).DOI
  9. [9]Kresse, G. & Furthmü, J. Efficient iterative schemes for ab initio total-energy calculations using a plane-wave basis set. (1996).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/9984901
  10. [10]Perdew, J. P., Burke, K. & Ernzerhof, M. Generalized Gradient Approximation Made Simple. (1996).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/10062328
  11. [11]Kohn, W. & Sham, L. J. Self-consistent equations including exchange and correlation effects. Physical review 140, A1133 (1965).DOI
  12. [12]Hohenberg, P. & Kohn, W. Inhomogeneous electron gas. Physical review 136, B864 (1964).
  13. [13]Kresse, G. & Joubert, D. From ultrasoft pseudopotentials to the projector augmented-wave method. Phys Rev B 59, 1758 (1999).DOI
  14. [14]Kresse, G. & Furthmüller, J. Efficiency of ab-initio total energy calculations for metals and semiconductors using a plane-wave basis set. Comput Mater Sci 6, 15–50 (1996).DOI
  15. [15]Kresse, G. & Furthmuller, J. Efficient Iterative Schemes for Ab Initio Total-Energy Calculations Using a Plane-Wave Basis Set. Phys. Rev. B: Condens. Matter Mater. Phys. 54, 11169 (1996).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/9984901
  16. [16]Monkhorst, H. J. & Pack, J. D. Special Points for Brillouin-Zone Integrations. Phys. Rev. B 13, 5188 (1976).DOI
  17. [17]Grimme, S. Semiempirical GGA-Type Density Functional Constructed with a Long-Range Dispersion Correction. J. Comput. Chem. 27, 1787 (2006).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/16955487
  18. [18]Maintz, S., Deringer, V. L., Tchougréeff, A. L. & Dronskowski, R. LOBSTER: A tool to extract chemical bonding from plane-wave based DFT. J Comput Chem 37, 1030–1035 (2016).
  19. [19]R. M. STERNKEIMER. Electronic Polarizabilities of Ions from the Hartree-Fock Wave Functions. (1954).
  20. [20]Togo, A., Oba, F. & Tanaka, I. First-principles calculations of the ferroelastic transition between rutile-type and CaCl2-type SiO2 at high pressures. Phys Rev B Condens Matter Mater Phys 78, (2008).
  21. [21]Togo, A. & Tanaka, I. First principles phonon calculations in materials science. Scr Mater 108, 1–5 (2015).arxiv.org/abs/1506.08498
  22. [22]Gonze, X. & Lee, C. Dynamical matrices, Born effective charges, dielectric permittivity tensors, and interatomic force constants from density-functional perturbation theory. Phys Rev B 55, 10355 (1997).DOI
  23. [23]Mills, G. & 3onsson, H. Quantum and Thermal Effects in H2 Dissociative Adsorption: Evaluation of Free Energy Barriers in Multidimensional Quantum Systems. vol. 72 (1994).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/10056623
  24. [24]Henkelman, G., Uberuaga, B. P. & Jón, H. A climbing image nudged elastic band method for finding saddle points and minimum energy paths. (2000).DOI
  25. [25]Hippier, K., Sitta, S., Vogt, P. & Sabrowsky, H. Crystal Structure of Na4OBr2.
  26. [26]V. M. Goldschmidt, D. gesetze der krystallochemie. N. 14, 477–485 (1926). Die Gesetze der Krystallochemie. (1926).DOI
  27. [27]Xia, W. et al. Antiperovskite Electrolytes for Solid-State Batteries. Chemical Reviews vol. 122 3763–3819 Preprint at https://doi.org/10.1021/acs.chemrev.1c00594 (2022).
  28. [28]Shannon, R. D. Revised Effective Ionic Radii and Systematic Studies of Interatomic Distances in Halides and Chaleogenides. Acta Cryst vol. 32 (1976).DOI
  29. [29]Fang, H. & Jena, P. Li-rich antiperovskite superionic conductors based on cluster ions. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 114, 11046–11051 (2017).DOI
  30. [30]Fang, H. & Jena, P. Sodium Superionic Conductors Based on Clusters. ACS Appl Mater Interfaces 11, 963–972 (2019).DOI
  31. [31]Li, C., Soh, K. C. K. & Wu, P. Formability of ABO3 perovskites. J Alloys Compd 372, 40–48 (2004).DOI
  32. [32]Travis, W., Glover, E. N. K., Bronstein, H., Scanlon, D. O. & Palgrave, R. G. On the application of the tolerance factor to inorganic and hybrid halide perovskites: A revised system. Chem Sci 7, 4548–4556 (2016).DOI
  33. [33]Mouhat, F. & Coudert, F. X. Necessary and sufficient elastic stability conditions in various crystal systems. Phys Rev B Condens Matter Mater Phys 90, 0–3 (2014).DOI
  34. [34]Chen, M. H., Emly, A. & Van Der Ven, A. Anharmonicity and phase stability of antiperovskite Li3 OCl. Phys Rev B Condens Matter Mater Phys 91, (2015).DOI
  35. [35]Yu, M. & Trinkle, D. R. Accurate and efficient algorithm for Bader charge integration. Journal of Chemical Physics 134, (2011).DOI
  36. [36]Peet, J. R. et al. Na+ mobility in sodium strontium silicate fast ion conductors. Chemical Communications 51, 17163–17165 (2015).DOI
  37. [37]Mittal, R. et al. Sodium diffusion and dynamics in Na2Ti3O7: Neutron scattering and ab initio simulations. Mater Adv 3, 2104–2116 (2022).arxiv.org/abs/2107.09905
  38. [38]Gupta, M. K. et al. Diffusion of sodium ions in amorphous Na2Si2O5: Quasielastic neutron scattering and ab initio molecular dynamics simulations. Phys Rev Mater 4, (2020).
  39. [39]Zhao, Q. et al. Design Principles for Rotational Cluster Anion [BH4]-Promote Superionic Conductivity in Sodium-Rich Antiperovskite Na3OBH4. Journal of Physical Chemistry C 126, 16546–16555 (2022).DOI
  40. [40]Udovic, T. J. et al. Sodium superionic conduction in Na2B12H12. Chemical Communications 50, 3750–3752 (2014).
  41. [41]Sadikin, Y., Brighi, M., Schouwink, P. & Černý, R. Superionic Conduction of Sodium and Lithium in Anion-Mixed Hydroborates Na3BH4B12H12 and (Li0.7Na0.3)3BH4B12H12. Adv Energy Mater 5, (2015).
  42. [42]Baloch, A. A. B. et al. Extending Shannon’s ionic radii database using machine learning. Phys Rev Mater 5, 1–10 (2021).DOI

Paper details

vlnc:W_r8dfk624
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents