betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Utilizing high-p⊥p_\perp theory and data to constrain the initial stages of quark-gluon plasma

Abstract

The scarce knowledge of the initial stages of quark-gluon plasma before the thermalization is mostly inferred through the low-p⊥p_\perp sector. We propose a complementary approach in this report - the use of high-p⊥p_\perp probes' energy loss. We study the effects of four commonly assumed initial stages, whose temperature profiles differ only before the thermalization, on high-p⊥p_\perp RAAR_{AA} and v2v_2 predictions. The predictions are based on our Dynamical Radiative and Elastic ENergy-loss Approach (DREENA) framework. We report insensitivity of v2v_2 to the initial stages, making it unable to distinguish between different cases. RAAR_{AA} displays sensitivity to the presumed initial stages, but current experimental precision does not allow resolution between these cases. We further revise the commonly accepted procedure of fitting the energy loss parameters, for each individual initial stage, to the measured RAAR_{AA}. We show that the sensitivity of v2v_2 to various initial stages obtained through such procedure is mostly a consequence of fitting procedure, which may obscure the physical interpretations. Overall, the simultaneous study of high-p⊥p_\perp observables, with unchanged energy loss parametrization and restrained temperature profiles, is crucial for future constraints on initial stages.

Introduction

In ultrarelativistic heavy-ion collisions (HIC) at the Relativistic Heavy Ion Collider (RHIC) and the Large Hadron Collider (LHC) (commonly termed as mini big bangs), a new form of matter − the quark-gluon plasma (QGP), [1, 2] in which quarks, antiquarks, and gluons are deconfined, is created. The large transverse momentum (high-p⊥p_\perp) particles are formed immediately upon the collision and therefore are affected by all stages of QGP evolution. This makes them excellent probes [3, 4] of this new state of matter, primarily through two main energy loss-based high-p⊥p_\perp observables − angular averaged (RAAR_{AA}) and angular differential (v2v_2) nuclear modification factors.

Traditionally, rare high-p⊥p_\perp probes (p⊥≳5p_\perp\gtrsim5 GeV), which present ∼0.1%\sim0.1\% of all particles produced in HIC, are used for studying the mechanisms of jet-medium interactions, while low-p⊥p_\perp sector [5, 6, 7] (p⊥≲5p_\perp\lesssim5 GeV) is used to infer QGP features, such as e.g. initial stages before the QGP thermalization. However, up-to-date initial-stage properties are poorly known. Therefore, the need for an alternative approach to assessing the initial-stage features emerged. We here propose using high-p⊥p_\perp probes as a complementary tool for this purpose, primarily since high-p⊥p_\perp partons are good probes of QGP properties, where these properties depend on initial QGP stages. Furthermore, the recently acquired extensive set of high-precision experimental data for the two aforementioned high-p⊥p_\perp observables [8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13] facilitates our study. This issue is moreover intriguing, as results of current theoretical studies on this subject are mostly inconclusive. [14, 15, 16]

A more rigorous study on this issue is required, that implies higher control over both the energy loss model and the analyzed temperature profiles. To accomplish this, we apply a full-fledged DREENA-B [17] framework (B stands for one-dimensional (1D) Bjorken [18] expansion), based on our state-of-the-art dynamical energy loss formalism [19] that will be outlined in the next section. It also considers 1D Bjorken [18] medium evolution, which is highly suitable for this study, as it allows the analytical introduction of different evolutions before thermalization, with the same evolution after thermalization, which facilitates the isolation of the effects of different initial stages. Additionally, we checked that the transition from 1D Bjorken to full 3+1D hydrodynamical evolution [20] does not significantly change our high-p⊥p_\perp predictions, implying that for reliable high-p⊥p_\perp predictions, an accurate energy loss model is more important than the medium evolution model. Therefore, DREENA-B [17] provides an optimal framework for the initial-stages study, as it combines a state-of-the-art energy loss model with fully controlled temperature profiles. Note that, in this paper, we provide a part of the more detailed results obtained in Ref. 21, enriched with some complementary predictions.

Numerical and Theoretical Framework

For generating medium modified distribution of high-p⊥p_\perp particles, irrespective of their flavor, we apply the generic pQCD convolution formula:[19, 22]

Efd3σdpf3=Eid3σ(Q)dpi3⊗P(Ei→Ef)⊗D(Q→HQ),(1)\frac{E_f d^3\sigma}{d p_f^3} = \frac{E_i d^3\sigma(Q)}{d p_i^3} \otimes P(E_i \to E_f) \otimes D(Q \to H_Q), \tag*{(1)}

where ii and ff stand for the initial parton (QQ) and final hadron (HQH_Q), respectively. The initial parton momentum distribution Eid3σ(Q)dpi3\frac{E_i d^3\sigma(Q)}{d p_i^3} is calculated in accordance with Ref. 23. The energy loss probability P(Ei→Ef)P(E_i \to E_f) is based on our dynamical energy loss formalism (see paragraph below) and incorporates multigluon[24] and path-length fluctuations.[22, 25, 26] D(Q→HQ)D(Q \to H_Q) denotes fragmentation function, where for the light hadrons, D and B mesons de Florian-Sassot-Stratmann (DSS),[27] Braaten-Cheung-Fleming-Yuan (BCFY)[28] and Kartvelishvili-Likhoded-Petrov (KLP)[29] fragmentation functions are used, respectively.

As a crucial ingredient of the calculations, we employ our state-of-the-art dynamical energy loss formalism,[30, 31, 32] which includes: 1) Dynamical QCD medium of a finite temperature and a finite size, so that the energy exchange with the medium constituents is taken into account as opposed to static scattering centers case. It also considers that the medium created in ultrarelativistic heavy-ion collisions has a finite size, and that initial partons are created inside the medium. 2) The calculations are based on the finite temperature field theory and generalized hard-thermal-loop approach,[33] generically regulating infrared divergences. 3) Both collisional[32] and radiative[30, 31] energy loss mechanisms are included and performed within the same theoretical framework, so that no interference or overlapping occurs between them. 4) The formalism is generalized to the case of finite magnetic mass[34] and running coupling.[19] Chromomagnetic (μM\mu_M) to chromoelectric mass (μE\mu_E) ratio is estimated to be in a range 0.4 − 0.6 by different non-perturbative approaches.[35, 36] Hence, in this paper we assume μM/μE=0.5\mu_M/\mu_E = 0.5. Our most recent advancement within formalism is the relaxation of the widely used soft-gluon approximation.[37] In Ref. 38, we demonstrated that all the above ingredients are necessary to accurately reproduce high-p⊥p_\perp suppression data.

The full-fledged analytical expressions for single gluon radiation spectrum and collisional energy loss per unit length in an expanding medium are given by Eqs. (6) and (2) from Ref. 17, respectively. Thereby, the standard values for heavy and light quark masses are considered (Mc=1.2M_c = 1.2 GeV, Mb=4.75M_b = 4.75 GeV, while for light quarks thermal masses are assumed).

Further, we assume that the medium expansion model is given by the ideal hydrodynamical 1D Bjorken expansion, i.e., T(τ)∼τ0/τ3T(\tau) \sim\sqrt[3]{\tau_0/\tau} (where τ\tau is a proper time), with thermalization time set at τ0=0.6\tau_0 = 0.6 fm/cc.[39] The detailed determination of initial QGP temperature T0T_0 for the considered centrality range is provided in Ref. 17. For brevity, here we focus on 30 − 40% centrality region in sNN=5.02\sqrt{s_{NN}} = 5.02 TeV Pb+PbPb+Pb collisions at the LHC, which corresponds to T0=391T_0 = 391 MeV,[17] although we checked that the same conclusions apply regardless of the considered centrality bin. The QGP transition temperature is assumed to be TC≈160.40T_C \approx160.40

Finally, we provide the expressions for two main high-p⊥p_\perp observables. The angular averaged nuclear modification factor RAAR_{AA} is defined as the ratio of the quenched p⊥p_\perp-spectrum in A+AA+A collisions with respect to p+pp+p collisions, normalized by the number of binary collisions NbinN_{bin}:

RAA(pT)=dNAA/dpTNbindNpp/dpT.(2)R_{AA}(p_T)=\frac{dN_{AA}/dp_T}{N_{bin}dN_{pp}/dp_T}. \tag*{(2)}

However, an alternative form[26]

RAA≈RAAin+RAAout2,(3)R_{AA}\approx\frac{R_{AA}^{in}+R_{AA}^{out}}{2}, \tag*{(3)}

is also used for providing more intuitive insight in the underlying mechanisms. Here[14] RAAin=dNAA/dpTdϕ∣ϕ=0NbindNpp/dpTdϕ∣ϕ=0R_{AA}^{in}=\frac{dN_{AA}/dp_Td\phi\mid_{\phi=0}}{N_{bin}dN_{pp}/dp_Td\phi\mid_{\phi=0}} (RAAout=dNAA/dpTdϕ∣ϕ=π/2NbindNpp/dpTdϕ∣ϕ=π/2R_{AA}^{out}=\frac{dN_{AA}/dp_Td\phi\mid_{\phi=\pi/2}}{N_{bin}dN_{pp}/dp_Td\phi\mid_{\phi=\pi/2}}) stands for in-(out-of-)plane nuclear modification factor. The high-p⊥p_\perp elliptic flow is given by the expression:[26, 41, 42]

v2≈12RAAin−RAAoutRAAin+RAAout.(4)v_2\approx\frac{1}{2}\frac{R_{AA}^{in}-R_{AA}^{out}}{R_{AA}^{in}+R_{AA}^{out}}. \tag*{(4)}

It is worth noting that experimental approach to v2v_2 is different from Eq. (4). However, to our knowledge, and as already discussed in Ref. 21, that approach could lead to different elliptic flow predictions if event-by-event fluctuations are taken into account, which is out of the scope of this study.

Reliability of the Framework

The reliability of DREENA-B framework, outlined in the previous section, is tested against experimentally available data at the LHC in Ref. 17. Note that in generating all predictions we used no fitting parameters, i.e., the parameters take their standard literature values. We obtained a very good agreement between our predictions and the existing data for: i) Both high-p⊥p_\perp RAAR_{AA} and v2v_2, so that long-standing v2v_2 puzzle[43] (inability of various models to jointly explain high-p⊥p_\perp RAAR_{AA} and v2v_2 data, with tendency to underestimate v2v_2 compared to the experimental data) is naturally solved within our framework; ii) Diverse colliding systems, such as Pb + Pb at sNN=2.76\sqrt{s_{NN}}=2.76 TeV and 5.02 TeV, and Xe + Xe at sNN=5.44\sqrt{s_{NN}}=5.44 TeV; iii) Both light and heavy flavor particles, that is, h±h^\pm, DD, BB mesons, and iv) All available centrality ranges.

Results and Discussion

In this section, first, we define the four commonly considered temperature profiles,[14] which differ only at early times. Next, we assess their effects on our full-fledged predictions for high-p⊥p_\perp angular averaged and angular differential nuclear modification factors. Finally, we revise the soundness of the commonly applied multiple fitting procedure. For each result, we provide an intuitive explanation based on RAAR_{AA} asymptotic scaling behavior. For more details, we refer the reader to Ref. 21.

Effect of different initial stages on high-p⊥p_\perp RAAR_{AA} and v2v_2

Now that framework is set and tested, for the study covered by this paper, next we concentrate on four commonly assumed temperature profiles[14] that consider the same 1D Bjorken[18] temperature profile after, but differ before the thermalization (τ<τ0\tau< \tau_0). More particularly, in Figure 1, we distinguish:

Four simplified temperature profiles

Figure 1. Four simplified temperature profiles, with the same 1D Bjorken[18] temperature evolution after thermalization (τ≥τ0\tau\ge\tau_0), and whose differences before thermalization mimics different evolutions at initial stage (τ<τ0\tau< \tau_0). These diverse initial-stage cases are: the free-streaming (full red curve), the linear (dashed blue curve), the constant (dot-dashed orange curve) and divergent case (dotted green curve), as denoted in the legend. Figure adapted from Ref. 21.

  • the free-streaming case (full red curve), which corresponds to omitting the energy loss before the QGP thermalization;

  • the linear case (dashed blue curve), which corresponds to linearly increasing TT with proper time from transition temperature (TC=160T_C = 160 MeV,[40] τC=0.25\tau_C = 0.25 fm) to the initial temperature T0T_0 of equilibrated plasma, otherwise T=0T = 0;

  • the constant case (dot-dashed orange curve), with TT equal to the initial temperature T0T_0; and

  • the divergent case (dotted green curve), corresponding to 1D Bjorken evolution from the beginning τ=0\tau= 0.

First, we assess to what extent high-p⊥p_\perp RAAR_{AA} is affected by the presumed initial stages depicted in Figure 1. From the left column of Figure 2, we infer that high-p⊥p_\perp

Sensitivity of high-$p_{\perp}$ observables to different initial stages

Figure 2. Sensitivity of high-p⊥p_{\perp} observables to different initial stages presented in Figure 1. The left (right) column corresponds to high-p⊥p_{\perp} RAAR_{AA} (v2v_{2}) vs p⊥p_{\perp}. Charged hadron, D meson and B meson predictions are presented in upper, middle and lower row, respectively. Charged hadron RAAR_{AA} predictions are compared with 5.02 TeV Pb + Pb CMS[8] (blue squares), ATLAS[9] (green triangles) and ALICE[10] (red circles) h±h^{\pm} RAAR_{AA} data in the upper left plot, while its v2v_{2} predictions are compared with the corresponding 5.02 TeV Pb + Pb CMS[11] (blue squares), ATLAS[12] (green triangles) and ALICE[13] (red circles) h±h^{\pm} data in the upper right plot. In each plot, full red curve corresponds to the free-streaming case, dashed blue curve to the linear case, dot-dashed orange curve to the constant case, and dotted green curve to the divergent case, as indicated in legend. The results are presented for the centrality range 30−40%30-40\%, and μM/μE=0.5\mu_{M}/\mu_{E}=0.5. Figure adapted from Ref. [21].

RAAR_{AA} is sensitive to the initial stages. Particularly, we see that for both light and heavy flavor particles, suppression is the lowest in the free-streaming case, while progressively increasing toward the divergent case, which is expected due to an increase in energy loss. Unfortunately, the discrepancies between these curves are not very distinguishing, and within the current error bars, one is unable to differentiate between these different scenarios.

Next, we investigate the sensitivity of high-p⊥p_{\perp} elliptic flow to the initial stages. Unexpectedly, from the right column of Figure 2, we observe that v2v_2 is insensitive to the presumed initial stages for all types of particles, contrary to the conclusion derived in Ref. 16. Therefore, from our study, it follows that v2v_2 cannot differentiate between different initial-stage scenarios.

To quantitatively explain the obtained results, we plot heavy flavor momentum dependence of proportionality functions, which are defined in the following manner:

γiin=RAA,iinRAA,fsin,γiout=RAA,ioutRAA,fsout,γi=RAA,iRAA,fs,(5)\gamma_i^{\mathrm{in}} = \frac{R_{AA,i}^{\mathrm{in}}}{R_{AA,fs}^{\mathrm{in}}}, \qquad\gamma_i^{\mathrm{out}} = \frac{R_{AA,i}^{\mathrm{out}}}{R_{AA,fs}^{\mathrm{out}}}, \qquad\gamma_i = \frac{R_{AA,i}}{R_{AA,fs}}, \tag*{(5)}

where i∈{lin,const,div}i \in\{\mathit{lin},\mathit{const},\mathit{div}\}. The results and conclusions for charged hadrons are the same and are shown in Ref. 21. Thus, in Figure 3, we distinguish three sets of curves (corresponding to linear, divergent, and constant cases relative to free-streaming case), each of which contains corresponding three proportionality functions. The most important observation from Figure 3 is that within the same set of curves the proportionality functions are practically identical for the relations involving RAAinR_{AA}^{\mathrm{in}}, RAAoutR_{AA}^{\mathrm{out}} and RAAR_{AA}, that is

Figure 3. RAAinR_{AA}^{in} (dashed curves), RAAoutR_{AA}^{out} (dot-dashed curves) and RAAR_{AA} (full curves) vs p⊥p_{\perp} in linear (blue set of curves), constant (orange set of curves) and divergent case (green set of curves) relative to the free-streaming case. The left (right) plot corresponds to D (B) mesons. The parameters are the same as in Fig. 2.

γiin≈γiout≈γi.(6)\gamma_i^{\mathrm{in}} \approx\gamma_i^{\mathrm{out}} \approx\gamma_i. \tag*{(6)}

It is worth noting that γi<1\gamma_i < 1, and that for i≠j→γi(p⊥)≠γj(p⊥)i \ne j \to\gamma_i(p_{\perp}) \ne\gamma_j(p_{\perp}). If we recall that high-p⊥p_{\perp} RAAR_{AA} and v2v_2 are given by Eqs. (3) and (4), it is straightforward to show that only RAAR_{AA}, and not v2v_2 is affected. More specifically, for any ii we obtain:

RAA,i≈γi(RAA,fsin+RAA,fsout)2=γiRAA,fs,(7)R_{AA,i} \approx\frac{\gamma_i(R_{AA,fs}^{\mathrm{in}} + R_{AA,fs}^{\mathrm{out}})}{2} = \gamma_i R_{AA,fs}, \tag*{(7)}
v2,i≈12γi(RAA,fsin−RAA,fsout)γi(RAA,fsin+RAA,fsout)=v2,fs,(8)v_{2,i} \approx\frac{1}{2}\frac{\gamma_i(R_{AA,fs}^{\mathrm{in}} - R_{AA,fs}^{\mathrm{out}})}{\gamma_i(R_{AA,fs}^{\mathrm{in}} + R_{AA,fs}^{\mathrm{out}})} = v_{2,fs}, \tag*{(8)}

as observed in Figure 2.

As an additional test of v2v_2 equivalence for different initial stages, in Figure 4, we present the ratio of elliptic flow in linear, constant and divergent cases relative to the free-streaming case. From Figure 4, which is a counterpart of Figure 3, we observe that these ratios are consistent with unity for both D and B mesons. The result is the same for charged particles and omitted for consistency. Note that our predictions are valid for p⊥≳10p_{\perp} \gtrsim10 GeV. This, furthermore, confirms the conclusions obtained from Figure 2 (right column) and Figure 3, as well as the validity of our quantitative analysis (given by Eqs. (7) and (8)).

Figure 4. v2v_2 in linear (dashed blue curves), constant (dot-dashed orange curves) and divergent case (dotted green curves) vs p⊥p_{\perp} relative to the free-streaming case. The left (right) plot corresponds to D (B) mesons. The parameters are the same as in Fig. 2.

Additionally, RAAR_{AA} sensitivity to the initial stages is in a qualitative agreement with Refs. 17, 44, 45, where it was shown that high-p⊥p_{\perp} RAAR_{AA} is only sensitive to the averaged properties of the evolving medium, such as average TT (T‾\overline{T}), i.e., the analytical estimate reads:

RAA∼ΔEE∼T‾.(9)R_{AA} \sim\frac{\Delta E}{E} \sim\overline{T}. \tag*{(9)}

The fact that T‾\overline{T}s are different for all four initial-stage cases (see Figure 1) results in observed RAAR_{AA} differences.

Revision of commonly used multiple fitting procedure

Finally, in this subsection, we test an approach commonly used in Refs. 16,41,46–49, in which the energy loss is fitted for the initial-stage cases (see Figure 1), via the change of multiplicative fitting factor in the energy loss to reproduce the high-p⊥p_{\perp} RAAR_{AA} experimental data. More specifically, in our full-fledged calculations we introduce an additional multiplicative fitting factor CifitC_i^{fit}, which is estimated for each initial-state case as the best fit to the free-streaming RAAR_{AA}, since free-streaming is commonly considered scenario in both low- and high-p⊥p_{\perp} sector1. We observe [21] a decreasing trend in multiplicative fitting factors from the free streaming toward the divergent case, as expected, to annul the higher energy losses in corresponding cases compared to the free-streaming one.

Thus obtained (fitted) RAAR_{AA}s are presented in the left plot of Figure 4, and are practically overlapping, as expected. However, the right plot of Figure 4 shows that through this fitting procedure high-p⊥p_{\perp} v2v_2 is significantly affected, that is, the highest value is in the free-streaming case, while the lowest is in the divergent case. This observation could evoke a naive interpretation that initial stages, that is, the only region in which TT profiles differ, are responsible for these discrepancies. However, that would be inconsistent with our results presented in the previous subsection, as well as with intuitive anticipation that the introduction of the energy loss at the initial stage should affect RAAR_{AA}.

To provide a quantitative explanation of the obtained results in Figure 4, we apply asymptotic scaling behavior of RAAR_{AA}[17, 26], which mimics our complex suppression procedure for very high-p⊥p_{\perp} jets and at higher centralities:

RAA=1−ξT‾mL‾n,(10)R_{AA}=1-\xi\overline{T}^{m}\overline{L}^{n}, \tag*{(10)}

where L‾\overline{L} denotes the average path length traversed by the jet. The corresponding T‾\overline{T} and L‾\overline{L} proportionality factors −m≈1.2-m\approx1.2 and n≈1.4n\approx1.4 are estimated in Refs. 50 and 51, respectively. ξ\xi stands for a proportionality factor, which depends on jet’s p⊥p_{\perp} and flavor.

By introducing multiplicative fitting factor in energy loss (see Eq. (9)), and making use of Eq. (10), the fitted RAAR_{AA}s in high-p⊥p_{\perp} limit now read:

RAA,ifit≈1−CiξT‾imL‾in≈1−Ci(1−RAA,i),(11)R_{AA,i}^{fit}\approx1-C_i\xi\overline{T}_i^{m}\overline{L}_i^{n}\approx1-C_i(1-R_{AA,i}), \tag*{(11)}

where i=lin,const,divi=lin, const, div and CiC_is are high-p⊥p_{\perp} limits of corresponding CifitsC_i^{fits}. Note that Eqs. (10) and (11) (in their original form) are applicable to RAAinR_{AA}^{in} and RAAoutR_{AA}^{out} as well (the same multiplicative fitting factor is naturally applied in all three cases). In order for RAA,ifitR_{AA,i}^{fit} to reproduce the free streaming RAAR_{AA}, i.e.,

Sensitivity of charged hadron high-$p_{\perp}$ $R_{AA}$ and $v_2$ to different initial-stage cases

Figure 5. Sensitivity of charged hadron high-p⊥p_{\perp} RAAR_{AA} (left plot) and v2v_2 (right plot) to different initial-stage cases from Figure 1, when a multiplicative factor is included in energy loss to reproduce the free-streaming RAAR_{AA}. In each plot, full red curve corresponds to the free-streaming case, dashed blue curve to the fitted linear case, dot-dashed orange curve to the fitted constant case, and dotted green curve to the fitted divergent case, as indicated in legend. The parameters are the same as in Figure 2. Figure adapted from Ref. 21.

RAA,ifit=RAA,fs,(12)R_{AA,i}^{fit}=R_{AA,fs}, \tag*{(12)}

it is straightforward to obtain:

v2,ifit≈12Ci(RAA,iin−RAA,iout)2RAA,fs=12Ciγi(RAA,fsin−RAA,fsout)RAA,fsin+RAA,fsout=Ciγiv2,fs,(13)v_{2,i}^{fit}\approx\frac{1}{2}\frac{C_i\left(R_{AA,i}^{in}-R_{AA,i}^{out}\right)}{2R_{AA,fs}}=\frac{1}{2}\frac{C_i\gamma_i\left(R_{AA,fs}^{in}-R_{AA,fs}^{out}\right)}{R_{AA,fs}^{in}+R_{AA,fs}^{out}}=C_i\gamma_i v_{2,fs}, \tag*{(13)}

where along with Eq. (12), we applied Eqs. (3)–(6), and Eqs. (10), (11), together with their out- and in-plane counterparts.

From Eq. (13) it follows that the reasons behind v2v_2 decrease in linear, constant and divergent cases compared to the free streaming one are the multiplicative fitting factor CiC_i and proportionality function γi\gamma_i, both of which are smaller than 1. However, note that γi\gamma_i approaches to 1 at high p⊥p_{\perp} (we refer the reader to Figure 3), so that the diminishing of v2v_2 compared to the free streaming case is predominantly a consequence of a decrease in the imposed fitting factor and not the initial stages as obtained in Ref. 16. We thus infer that the common procedure in which the energy loss fitting factor is repeatedly adjusted for each initial stage may lead to misconceptions about the underlying physical mechanisms.

Conclusions and Outlook

We here addressed whether, and to what extent, we can use high-p⊥p_{\perp} observables to explore the initial stages before QGP thermalization. To this end, we studied how four different commonly considered initial stage scenarios, which have the same temperature profile after, but differ in the temperature profiles before thermalization, affect high-p⊥p_{\perp} RAAR_{AA} and v2v_2 predictions, stemming from our DREENA-B[17] framework combined with 1D Bjorken expansion.[18] We surprisingly obtained that high-p⊥p_{\perp} v2v_2 is insensitive to the presumed initial stages, as opposed to high-p⊥p_{\perp} RAAR_{AA}. However, within the current error bars, RAAR_{AA} sensitivity does not allow differentiation between different initial stage cases. Moreover, we inferred that the previously reported sensitivity of high-p⊥p_{\perp} v2v_2 to initial stages is mostly an artifact of the fitting procedure. Consequently, a common procedure, where free parameters in energy loss are separately fitted for each initial stage may obscure the understanding of the underlying physical mechanisms. In general, our results imply that the simultaneous study of high-p⊥p_{\perp} RAAR_{AA} and v2v_2, with restrained temperature profiles (isolating the differences in the initial states) and unchanged energy loss parametrization throughout the study, is needed to set reliable constraints on the initial stages in the future.

Acknowledgements

This work is supported by the European Research Council, grant ERC-2016-COG: 725741, and by the Ministry of Science and Technological Development of the Republic of Serbia, under project No. ON171004 and No. ON173052.

References

  1. [1]J. C. Collins and M. J. Perry, Phys. Rev. Lett. 34 1353 (1975).
  2. [2]S.S. Adler et al., [PHENIX Collaboration], Phys. Rev. Lett. 91 (2003) 072303.
  3. [3]M. Gyulassy and L. McLerran, Nucl. Phys. A 750 (2005) 30.
  4. [4]B. Jacak and P. Steinberg, Phys. Today 63 (2010) 39.
  5. [5]F. Gelis and B. Schenke, Ann. Rev. Nucl. Part. Sci. 66 (2016) 73.
  6. [6]G. Aad et al. [ATLAS Collaboration], JHEP 1311 (2013) 138.
  7. [7]H. Niemi, G. S. Denicol, H. Holopainen and P. Huovinen, Phys. Rev. C 87 (2013) 054901.
  8. [8]V. Khachatryan et al. [CMS Collaboration], JHEP 1704 (2017) 039.
  9. [9]The ATLAS collaboration [ATLAS Collaboration], ATLAS-CONF-2017-012.
  10. [10]S. Acharya et al. [ALICE Collaboration], JHEP 1811, 013 (2018).
  11. [11]A. M. Sirunyan et al. [CMS Collaboration], Phys. Lett. B 776 (2018) 195.
  12. [12]M. Aaboud et al. [ATLAS Collaboration], Eur. Phys. J. C 78 (2018) 997.
  13. [13]S. Acharya et al. [ALICE Collaboration], JHEP 1807 (2018) 103.
  14. [14]J. Xu, A. Buzzatti and M. Gyulassy, JHEP 1408 (2014) 063.
  15. [15]R. Katz, C. A. G. Prado, J. Noronha-Hostler, J. Noronha and A. A. P. Suaide, Phys. Rev. C 102 (2020) 024906.
  16. [16]C. Andres, N. Armesto, H. Niemi, R. Paatelainen and C. A. Salgado, Phys. Lett. B 803 (2020) 135318.
  17. [17]D. Zigic, I. Salom, M. Djordjevic and M. Djordjevic, Phys. Lett. B 791 (2019) 236.
  18. [18]J. D. Bjorken, Phys. Rev. D 27 (1987) 140.
  19. [19]M. Djordjevic and M. Djordjevic, Phys. Lett. B 734 (2014) 286.
  20. [20]E. Molnar, H. Holopainen, P. Huovinen and H. Niemi, Phys. Rev. C 90 (2014) 044904.
  21. [21]D. Zigic, B. Ilic, M. Djordjevic and M. Djordjevic, Phys. Rev. C 101 (2020) 064909.
  22. [22]S. Wicks, W. Horowitz, M. Djordjevic and M. Gyulassy, Nucl. Phys. A 784 (2007) 426.
  23. [24]M. Gyulassy, P. Levai and I. Vitev, Phys. Lett. B 538 (2002) 282.
  24. [25]A. Dainese, Eur. Phys. J. C 33 (2004) 495.
  25. [26]D. Zigic, I. Salom, J. Auvinen, M. Djordjevic and M. Djordjevic, J. Phys. G 46 (2019) 085101.
  26. [27]D. de Florian, R. Sassot and M. Stratmann, Phys. Rev. D 75 (2007) 114010.
  27. [28]M. Cacciari, P. Nason, JHEP 0309 (2003) 006; E. Braaten, K.-M. Cheung, S. Fleming and T. C. Yuan, Phys. Rev. D 51 (1995) 4819.
  28. [29]V. G. Kartvelishvili, A.K. Likhoded, V.A. Petrov, Phys. Lett. B 78 (1978) 615.
  29. [30]M. Djordjevic, Phys. Rev. C 80 (2009) 064909.
  30. [31]M. Djordjevic and U. Heinz, Phys. Rev. Lett. 101 (2008) 022302.
  31. [32]M. Djordjevic, Phys. Rev. C 74 (2006) 064907.
  32. [33]J. J. Kapusta, Finite-Temperature Field Theory (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 1989).DOI
  33. [34]M. Djordjevic, Phys. Lett. B 709 (2012) 229.
  34. [35]Yu. Maezawa et al. [W[HOT-QCD Collaboration], Phys. Rev. D 81 (2010) 091501.
  35. [36]A. Nakamura, T. Saito and S. Sakai, Phys. Rev. D 69 (2004) 014506.
  36. [37]B. Blagojevic, M. Djordjevic and M. Djordjevic, Phys. Rev. C 99 (2019) 024901.
  37. [39]J. E. Bernhard, J. S. Moreland and S. A. Bass, Nucl. Phys. A 967 (2017) 293.
  38. [40]A. Bazavov et al. [HotQCD Collaboration], Phys. Rev. D 90 (2014) 094503.
  39. [41]B. Betz and M. Gyulassy, JHEP 1408 (2014) 090 [Erratum: JHEP 1410 (2014) 043].
  40. [42]P. Christiansen, K. Twoniuk and V. Vislavicius, Phys. Rev. C 89 (2014) 034912.
  41. [43]S. K. Das, F. Scardina, S. Plumari and V. Greco, Phys. Lett. B 747 (2015) 260.

Paper details

vlnc:W_wnmqjyem
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents