betaFeedback

WorksMathematics

Index and nullity of critical spherical catenoids in hyperbolic three-space

Abstract

We prove that every critical spherical catenoid in a geodesic ball of hyperbolic three-space has Morse index four and nullity two. This resolves Medvedev's index conjecture throughout the parameter range of the catenoid family. The kernel consists precisely of the normal components of rotations that preserve the center of the ball and tilt the axis of the catenoid. As consequences, the radius of the supporting ball increases strictly along the family, and each critical spherical catenoid admits a smooth family of free boundary constant mean curvature deformations in its supporting ball. The proof combines a global boundary inequality obtained from a Wronskian, a positive Dirichlet eigenfunction supplied by the time component of the unit normal, and a Riccati comparison for the angular mode k=2k=2. A ground-state identity then yields positivity of every angular mode k≥2k\ge2. We also show that the energy index of every critical spherical catenoid in H3\mathbb{H^3}, that is, the index of the second variation of its energy, equals four; hence the inequality between the energy index and the spectral index conjectured by Medvedev for geodesic balls of Hn\mathbb{H^n} fails.

Introduction

The critical catenoid is a basic example in the study of the Morse index of free boundary minimal surfaces. In the Euclidean unit ball in R3\mathbb{R}^{3}, its index is four, as proved by Devyver [5], Smith and Zhou [16], and Tran [17]; another proof was given by Medvedev [9]. Devyver also proved that every compact orientable free boundary minimal surface in this ball, other than a flat disk, has index at least four [5]. Thus the critical catenoid attains this lower bound. Its nullity is two, and it is equivariantly nondegenerate: its Jacobi fields satisfying the free boundary condition are induced by rotations [1 Lemma 8.1]; see also [1 Remark 8.2]. Moreover, Parise and Zhu have recently shown that every properly embedded free boundary minimal annulus in this ball is congruent to the critical catenoid [12].

The analogous index problem in curved space forms concerns critical spherical catenoids. In H3\mathbb{H}^{3}, these are rotational minimal annuli obtained by free boundary truncation of the spherical catenoids constructed by Mori [11]. The geometry of rotational hypersurfaces in spaces of constant curvature was developed further by do Carmo and Dajczer [2], and the free boundary truncation was considered by Li and Xiong [6]. C. Lima [7] proved that an embedded free boundary minimal annulus in a geodesic ball of S+3\mathbb{S}^{3}_{+} or H3\mathbb{H}^{3} that is invariant under the geodesic symmetry about the center of the ball is congruent to a critical rotational annulus; in H3\mathbb{H}^{3}, these are the critical spherical catenoids. Medvedev [10 Theorem 2] proved that the critical spherical catenoid in a geodesic ball of S+3\mathbb{S}^{3}_{+} has index four, and that its hyperbolic counterpart has index at least four. He conjectured equality in the hyperbolic case [10 Remark 10]. We prove this equality throughout the parameter range of the critical spherical catenoid family in H3\mathbb{H}^{3} and determine the nullity.

The analysis in [15] determines the index and nullity contributions of the angular mode ∣k∣=1|k|=1 for every parameter. The local result in [14] establishes index four and nullity two when the parameter is sufficiently close to its lower endpoint. The theorem below establishes both equalities for every a>12a > \frac{1}{2}.

2020 Mathematics Subject Classification. Primary 53A10; Secondary 53C42, 58J50, 34B24.

Key words and phrases. Free boundary minimal surfaces, hyperbolic space, critical catenoid, Morse index, nullity, Robin eigenvalue problem, equivariant nondegeneracy, constant mean curvature, energy index.

Theorem 1. For each a>12a > \frac{1}{2}, let Σa\Sigma_a be the critical spherical catenoid with angular period 2π2\pi, parametrized in Section 2, and let B(r(a))⊂H3\mathbb{B}(r(a)) \subset\mathbb{H}^3 be its supporting geodesic ball. Then

ind⁡(Σa)=4,nul⁡(Σa)=2.\operatorname{ind}(\Sigma_a)=4,\qquad\operatorname{nul}(\Sigma_a)=2.

The Robin kernel is generated by the normal components of the two rotations that tilt the axis of the catenoid while fixing the center of B(r(a))\mathbb{B}(r(a)).

Here the index and nullity refer to the second variation of area for normal variations whose boundary remains on the supporting sphere. In particular, the ambient ball is fixed when taking variations.

The theorem supplies the global hyperbolic counterpart of the Euclidean index-four results and identifies all infinitesimal degeneracies with rotations of the ambient ball. Together with the Euclidean results and Medvedev’s spherical result, it shows that critical catenoids have index four in the Euclidean unit ball, in geodesic balls of S+3\mathbb{S}^{3}_{+}, and in every geodesic ball of H3\mathbb{H}^3. At fixed ambient curvature −1-1, both the geometry of the annulus and its supporting radius vary with aa. The associated Jacobi operator contains the curvature term +2+2, and the Robin coefficient is coth⁡r(a)\coth r(a); these terms are recorded in Section 3. The proof controls this family of boundary value problems over the entire interval a>12a > \frac{1}{2}.

The proof has three main ingredients. A Wronskian identity gives a strict boundary inequality valid for every a>12a > \frac{1}{2}. The time component of the unit normal is a positive Dirichlet eigenfunction with eigenvalue two; a codimension-two min–max argument therefore determines the radial mode k=0k=0. Finally, a comparison of logarithmic derivatives, together with an explicit integral inequality, gives a boundary inequality for the mode k=2k=2; a ground-state identity turns it into positivity of that mode, and monotonicity in k2k^2 completes the spectral count. The geometric and spectral identities used below are included in the proof.

Three consequences are recorded in Section 8. The radius of the supporting ball is a strictly increasing function of aa (Corollary 10). Together with Lemma 11, this proves that every geodesic ball of H3\mathbb{H}^3 is the supporting ball of an isometric image of exactly one Σa\Sigma_a, as stated without proof by Li and Xiong [6]. Combined with the equivariant implicit function theorem of Bettiol, Piccione and Santoro [1], the theorem shows that each Σa\Sigma_a is the member with mean curvature zero of a smooth family of free boundary CMC annuli in its supporting ball (Corollary 12). The restriction to angular period 2π2\pi is essential: for m≥2m \ge2, the mm-fold cover of Σa\Sigma_a has index at least 4m4m, and its nullity exceeds two exactly when mk∗(a)mk_*(a) is an integer, for a threshold frequency k∗(a)∈(1,2)k_*(a) \in(1,2) (Remark 14). This agrees with the non-rotational free boundary minimal annuli of Cerezo [3], which bifurcate from multiple covers of critical spherical catenoids.

Medvedev also compared the energy index ind⁡E\operatorname{ind}_{E}, the index of the second variation of the energy at fixed conformal structure, with the spectral index ind⁡S\operatorname{ind}_{S} (denoted Ind⁡E\operatorname{Ind}_{E} and Ind⁡S\operatorname{Ind}_{S} in [10]; both are recalled in Section 9). For free boundary minimal submanifolds of geodesic balls in S+n\mathbb{S}^{n}_{+} he proved ind⁡E≤nind⁡S\operatorname{ind}_{E} \le n\operatorname{ind}_{S}, where nn is the dimension of the ambient space, and he conjectured the same inequality in Hn\mathbb{H}^{n} [10 Proposition 11 and Remark 7]. For annuli, V. Lima’s bound ind⁡≤ind⁡E+1\operatorname{ind} \le\operatorname{ind}_{E}+1 [8] then gives ind⁡≤nind⁡S+1\operatorname{ind} \le n\operatorname{ind}_{S}+1; in S+3\mathbb{S}^{3}_{+} this is the upper bound for the index of the critical spherical catenoid [10 Theorem 12 and Corollary 17], since ind⁡S=1\operatorname{ind}_{S}=1 there. In H3\mathbb{H}^{3} one also has ind⁡S(Σa)=1\operatorname{ind}_{S}(\Sigma_a)=1 [10 Theorem 18] (see also Section 9), so the conjectured inequality would give ind⁡(Σa)≤4\operatorname{ind}(\Sigma_a) \le4 in the same way. Our second result shows that the conjectured inequality fails in H3\mathbb{H}^{3}.

Theorem 2. For every a>12a > \frac{1}{2}, the energy index of Σa\Sigma_a equals four. In particular ind⁡E(Σa)>3ind⁡S(Σa)\operatorname{ind}_{E}(\Sigma_a) > 3\operatorname{ind}_{S}(\Sigma_a), and the inequality conjectured in [10 Remark 7] fails for every critical spherical catenoid in H3\mathbb{H}^{3}.

In S+3\mathbb{S}^{3}_{+} the energy index of the critical spherical catenoid is three, by [10 Theorem 2, Proposition 11 and Theorem 18] and V. Lima’s bound; in H3\mathbb{H}^{3} it equals the Morse index.

Consequently, the upper bound in Theorem 1 cannot be obtained as in the spherical case: V. Lima’s bound only gives ind⁡(Σa)≤5\operatorname{ind}(\Sigma_a) \le5. The fourth negative direction is explicit: it comes from the quadric cone with vertex e0e_0 through the two boundary circles (Lemma 18). For the critical catenoid in the Euclidean unit ball the corresponding field is null for the energy, and negative curvature makes it strictly negative (Remark 19). The proof is given in § 9.

Geometry of the critical catenoids

We use the hyperboloid model

H3={X∈R3,1:⟨X,X⟩L=−1, X0>0},⟨X,Y⟩L=−X0Y0+∑j=13XjYj.\mathbb{H}^3 = \{X \in\mathbb{R}^{3,1} : \langle X,X\rangle_L = -1,\ X^0 > 0\}, \qquad\langle X,Y\rangle_L = -X^0Y^0 + \sum_{j=1}^{3} X^jY^j.

The center of the balls under consideration is e0=(1,0,0,0)e_0=(1,0,0,0). Fix a>12a > \frac{1}{2} and define

K=a2−14,A(s)2=acosh⁡(2s)+12,B(s)2=acosh⁡(2s)−12,(1)K = \sqrt{a^2-\frac{1}{4}}, \qquad A(s)^2 = a\cosh(2s)+\frac{1}{2}, \qquad B(s)^2 = a\cosh(2s)-\frac{1}{2}, \tag*{(1)}
φ(s)=∫0sKA(σ)2B(σ) dσ.(2)\varphi(s) = \int_{0}^{s} \frac{K}{A(\sigma)^2B(\sigma)}\,\mathrm{d}\sigma. \tag*{(2)}

The positive square roots are understood. The rotational parametrization is

X(s,θ)=(Acosh⁡φ, Asinh⁡φ, Bcos⁡θ, Bsin⁡θ),(s,θ)∈R×(R/2πZ).(3)X(s,\theta) = (A\cosh\varphi,\ A\sinh\varphi,\ B\cos\theta,\ B\sin\theta), \qquad(s,\theta) \in\mathbb{R} \times(\mathbb{R}/2\pi\mathbb{Z}). \tag*{(3)}

A prime denotes differentiation with respect to ss throughout the paper. Set v=B′v=B'. The identities

A2=1+B2,A′=BvA,v=asinh⁡(2s)B,(4)A^2 = 1+B^2,\qquad A' = \frac{Bv}{A},\qquad v = \frac{a\sinh(2s)}{B}, \tag*{(4)}
v2=1+B2−K2B2,v′=B+K2B3>0(5)v^2 = 1+B^2-\frac{K^2}{B^2},\qquad v' = B+\frac{K^2}{B^3}>0 \tag*{(5)}

follow directly from (2.1). In particular, AA and BB are even, whereas vv and φ\varphi are odd. For completeness, introduce the Lorentz-orthonormal frame

E0=(cosh⁡φ,sinh⁡φ,0,0),E1=(sinh⁡φ,cosh⁡φ,0,0),Er=(0,0,cos⁡θ,sin⁡θ),E_0=(\cosh\varphi,\sinh\varphi,0,0),\quad E_1=(\sinh\varphi,\cosh\varphi,0,0),\quad E_r=(0,0,\cos\theta,\sin\theta),

together with Eθ=(0,0,−sin⁡θ,cos⁡θ)E_\theta=(0,0,-\sin\theta,\cos\theta). Then X=AE0+BErX=AE_0+BE_r and

Xs=A′E0+Aφ′E1+vEr,Xθ=BEθ.X_s=A'E_0+A\varphi'E_1+vE_r,\qquad X_\theta=BE_\theta.

Using (2.2)–(2.5), we obtain

⟨Xs,Xs⟩L=v2+K2/B2A2=1,⟨Xs,Xθ⟩L=0.\langle X_s,X_s\rangle_L=\frac{v^2+K^2/B^2}{A^2}=1,\qquad\langle X_s,X_\theta\rangle_L=0.

Consequently,

g=ds2+B2dθ2.(6)g=ds^2+B^2d\theta^2. \tag*{(6)}

A unit normal is

References

  1. [1]R. G. Bettiol, P. Piccione, and B. Santoro, Deformations of free boundary CMC hypersurfaces, J. Geom. Anal. 27 (2017), no. 4, 3254–3284. https://doi.org/10.1007/s12220-017-9804-5. See also https://arxiv.org/abs/1411.0354.
  2. [2]M. do Carmo and M. Dajczer, Rotation hypersurfaces in spaces of constant curvature, Trans. Amer. Math. Soc. 277 (1983), no. 2, 685–709. https://doi.org/10.1090/S0002-9947-1983-0694383-X.
  3. [3]A. Cerezo, Free boundary minimal annuli in geodesic balls of H³, arXiv:2502.20303 (2025). https://arxiv.org/abs/2502.20303.
  4. [4]A. Cerezo, I. Fernández, and P. Mira, Free boundary CMC annuli in spherical and hyperbolic balls, Calc. Var. Partial Differential Equations 64 (2025), no. 2, Paper No. 37. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00526-024-02883-6.
  5. [5]B. Devyver, Index of the critical catenoid, Geom. Dedicata 199 (2019), 355–371. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10711-018-0353-2.
  6. [6]H. Li and C. Xiong, A gap theorem for free boundary minimal surfaces in geodesic balls of hyperbolic space and hemisphere, J. Geom. Anal. 28 (2018), no. 4, 3171–3182. https://doi.org/10.1007/s12220-017-9953-6.
  7. [7]C. Lima, On uniqueness of free boundary minimal annuli in geodesic balls of S³₊ and H³, arXiv:2503.16763 (2025). https://arxiv.org/abs/2503.16763.
  8. [8]V. Lima, Bounds for the Morse index of free boundary minimal surfaces, Asian J. Math. 26 (2022), no. 2, 227–252.arxiv.org/abs/1710.10971
  9. [9]V. Medvedev, On the index of the critical Möbius band in ℝ⁴, J. Geom. Anal. 33 (2023), no. 3, article no. 93. https://doi.org/10.1007/s12220-022-01069-w.
  10. [10]V. Medvedev, On free boundary minimal submanifolds in geodesic balls in Hⁿ and Sⁿ₊, Math. Z. 310 (2025), no. 1, article no. 10. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00209-025-03707-9.
  11. [11]H. Mori, Minimal surfaces of revolution in H³ and their global stability, Indiana Univ. Math. J. 30 (1981), no. 5, 787–794. https://doi.org/10.1512/iumj.1981.30.30057.
  12. [12]D. Parise and J. J. Zhu, Uniqueness of free boundary minimal annuli, arXiv:2609.17512 (2026). https://arxiv.org/abs/2609.17512.
  13. [13]A. Pigazzini, A degenerate free boundary minimal annulus and non-uniqueness in spherical caps beyond the hemisphere, arXiv:2607.23534 (2026). https://arxiv.org/abs/2607.23534.
  14. [14]A. Pigazzini, Analytic local resolution of Medvedev’s Morse index conjecture for the critical spherical catenoid in H³, arXiv:2605.13562 (2026). https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.13562.
  15. [15]A. Pigazzini, Robin nullity in mode |k| = 1 and asymptotic radius of the critical spherical catenoid, arXiv:2605.11244 (2026). https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.11244.
  16. [16]G. Smith and D. Zhou, The Morse index of the critical catenoid, Geom. Dedicata 201 (2019), 13–19. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10711-018-0412-8.
  17. [17]H. Tran, Index characterization for free boundary minimal surfaces, Commun. Anal. Geom. 28 (2020), no. 1, 189–222. https://doi.org/10.4310/CAG.2020.v28.n1.a6. See also https://arxiv.org/abs/1609.01651v4.
  18. [18]A. Zettl, Sturm–Liouville Theory, Mathematical Surveys and Monographs, vol. 121, American Mathematical Society, Providence, RI, 2005. https://doi.org/10.1090/surv/121.

Paper details

vlnc:W_zwqgjdz5
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Mathematics

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents