WorksMathematics
Index and nullity of critical spherical catenoids in hyperbolic three-space
Abstract
We prove that every critical spherical catenoid in a geodesic ball of hyperbolic three-space has Morse index four and nullity two. This resolves Medvedev's index conjecture throughout the parameter range of the catenoid family. The kernel consists precisely of the normal components of rotations that preserve the center of the ball and tilt the axis of the catenoid. As consequences, the radius of the supporting ball increases strictly along the family, and each critical spherical catenoid admits a smooth family of free boundary constant mean curvature deformations in its supporting ball. The proof combines a global boundary inequality obtained from a Wronskian, a positive Dirichlet eigenfunction supplied by the time component of the unit normal, and a Riccati comparison for the angular mode . A ground-state identity then yields positivity of every angular mode .
Introduction
The critical catenoid is a basic example in the study of the Morse index of free boundary minimal surfaces. In the Euclidean unit ball in , its index is four, as proved by Devyver [5], Smith and Zhou [14], and Tran [15]; another proof was given by Medvedev [8]. Devyver also proved that every compact orientable free boundary minimal surface in this ball, other than a flat disk, has index at least four [5]. Thus the critical catenoid attains this lower bound. Its nullity is two, and it is equivariantly nondegenerate: its Jacobi fields satisfying the free boundary condition are induced by rotations [1 Lemma 8.1]; see also [1 Remark 8.2]. Moreover, Parise and Zhu have recently shown that every properly embedded free boundary minimal annulus in this ball is congruent to the critical catenoid [11].
The analogous index problem in curved space forms concerns critical spherical catenoids. In , these are rotational minimal annuli obtained by free boundary truncation of the spherical catenoids constructed by Mori [10]. The geometry of rotational hypersurfaces in spaces of constant curvature was developed further by do Carmo and Dajczer [2], and the free boundary truncation was considered by Li and Xiong [6]. Lima [7] proved that an embedded free boundary minimal annulus in a geodesic ball of or that is invariant under the geodesic symmetry about the center of the ball is congruent to a critical rotational annulus; in , these are the critical spherical catenoids. Medvedev [9] proved that the critical spherical catenoid in a geodesic ball of has index four, and that its hyperbolic counterpart has index at least four. He conjectured equality in the hyperbolic case. We prove this equality throughout the parameter range of the critical spherical catenoid family in and determine the nullity.
The analysis in [13] determines the index and nullity contributions of the angular mode for every parameter. The local result in [12] establishes index four and nullity two when the parameter is sufficiently close to its lower endpoint. The theorem below establishes both equalities for every .
2020 Mathematics Subject Classification. Primary 53A10; Secondary 53C42, 58J50, 34B24.
Key words and phrases. Free boundary minimal surfaces, hyperbolic space, critical catenoid, Morse index, nullity, Robin eigenvalue problem, equivariant nondegeneracy, constant mean curvature.
Theorem 1. For each , let be the critical spherical catenoid with angular period , parametrized in Section 2, and let be its supporting geodesic ball. Then
The Robin kernel is generated by the normal components of the two rotations that tilt the axis of the catenoid while fixing the center of .
Here the index and nullity refer to the second variation of area for normal variations whose boundary remains on the supporting sphere. In particular, the ambient ball is fixed when taking variations.
The theorem supplies the global hyperbolic counterpart of the Euclidean index-four results and identifies all infinitesimal degeneracies with rotations of the ambient ball. At fixed ambient curvature , both the geometry of the annulus and its supporting radius vary with . The associated Jacobi operator contains the curvature term , and the Robin coefficient is ; these terms are recorded in Section 3. The proof controls this family of boundary value problems over the entire interval .
The proof has three main ingredients. A Wronskian identity gives a strict boundary inequality valid for every . The time component of the unit normal is a positive Dirichlet eigenfunction with eigenvalue two; a codimension-two min–max argument therefore determines the radial mode . Finally, a comparison of logarithmic derivatives, together with an explicit integral inequality, gives a boundary inequality for the mode ; a ground-state identity turns it into positivity of that mode, and monotonicity in completes the spectral count. The geometric and spectral identities used below are included in the proof.
Three consequences are recorded in Section 8. The radius of the supporting ball is a strictly increasing function of (Corollary 9). Combined with the equivariant implicit function theorem of Bettiol, Piccione and Santoro [1], the theorem shows that each is the member with mean curvature zero of a smooth family of free boundary CMC annuli in its supporting ball (Corollary 11). The restriction to angular period is essential: for , the -fold cover of has index at least , and its nullity exceeds two exactly when is an integer, for a threshold frequency (Remark 13). This agrees with the non-rotational free boundary minimal annuli of Cerezo [3], which bifurcate from multiple covers of critical spherical catenoids.
Geometry of the critical catenoids
We use the hyperboloid model
The center of the balls under consideration is . Fix and define
The positive square roots are understood. The rotational parametrization is
A prime denotes differentiation with respect to throughout the paper. Set . The identities
follow directly from (1). In particular, and are even, whereas and are odd.
For completeness, introduce the Lorentz-orthonormal frame
together with . Then and
Consequently,
A unit normal is
Indeed, (4) and (5) imply that is orthogonal to , , and has Lorentzian norm one. A direct computation using (2)–(5) gives
Thus, with shape operator , the principal curvatures are and . The surface is minimal and
The parametrization is embedded: the quotient is strictly increasing in , and, for each fixed , the pair determines uniquely modulo because .
Free boundary truncation
Write
For the distance from , one has and
It follows that the surface meets a sphere centered at orthogonally precisely when . At a point , this condition reads
As functions of , the left-hand side increases strictly from zero, whereas the right-hand side decreases strictly from to zero. Hence (9) has exactly one solution . The critical catenoid is
It is symmetric with respect to the totally geodesic plane , which contains the neck circle , and its supporting ball is centered at the point where this plane meets the axis . Set
Since for , every interior point of lies strictly inside . At the positive boundary the outward unit conormal is . Orthogonality to the sphere gives
Taking components yields
The quadratic form and separation of variables
We use the convention . For the ambient Ricci tensor, . If is the outward unit normal to the supporting sphere, then for every unit vector tangent to that sphere. Along the free boundary, is such a tangent vector. In the sign convention of [15], the second fundamental form of the boundary is computed with respect to the outward normal, so that its value on is . The general free boundary second variation formula [15], § 2 therefore gives
Its associated self-adjoint operator and boundary condition are
where is the outward unit conormal along . The index is the number of negative eigenvalues, counted with multiplicity; the nullity is the dimension of the kernel. The form domain is and imposes no Robin condition on test functions.
For angular frequency , the radial operator is
in , with boundary conditions
After removing the positive angular integration factor, the radial form is
Each has the two real angular factors and ; the mode has one. The coefficients are even in , so each radial problem splits into even and odd sectors.
For each fixed , one has on the compact interval . All radial problems are therefore regular Sturm–Liouville problems with positive smooth weight. We use the min–max principle, simplicity of radial eigenvalues, and the oscillation theorem: the th eigenfunction, with eigenvalues numbered starting at , has exactly interior zeros. These standard facts are discussed in [16].
A global boundary inequality
For the flat connection of , the Gauss formula reads
Tracing and using minimality gives . The coordinate functions consequently satisfy , so
Lemma 2. For every , the boundary radius in the rotational coordinates satisfies
Proof. By (5),
and substitution in (14) gives . Moreover, and on . Define
The equations for and imply
Using (11), we find
On the other hand, (5) and give
Since , the asserted inequality follows.
The modes zero and one
A Dirichlet eigenfunction
Lemma 3. The first Dirichlet eigenvalue of on is . A corresponding positive eigenfunction is
Proof. The Gauss–Weingarten equations in imply
for a minimal surface in . To see the signs explicitly, let denote the shape operator. In a geodesic orthonormal frame on the surface, tracing the derivative of gives
The Codazzi equation in constant curvature gives , and both trace terms vanish by minimality. This proves (18). Taking its time component gives .
The function is even and . For , the uniqueness of the crossing in (9) gives , so . At , the free boundary condition gives . Thus is a Dirichlet eigenfunction with no interior zero. The oscillation theorem identifies its eigenvalue as the first one.
Proposition 4. The radial Robin problem for has exactly two negative eigenvalues and no zero eigenvalue. One negative eigenfunction is even and the other is odd.
Proof. Integrating (17) by parts in (16), and using (11)–(12), gives
Since is even and is odd, their mixed term in the polarized quadratic form is zero. Hence their span is a two-dimensional negative subspace.
Let be the radial Robin eigenvalues. The preceding subspace gives . The Dirichlet form domain has codimension two in , since its defining conditions are the two endpoint traces. Therefore the span of the first three Robin eigenfunctions contains a nonzero . Lemma 3 and the min–max principle yield
Thus . This proves the exact count and excludes a kernel. The negative tests (19) and (20) supply one negative direction of each parity, so each parity contributes exactly one negative eigenvalue. □
The first angular mode
Proposition 5. The radial Robin problem for has one negative eigenvalue and a one-dimensional kernel generated by . The negative eigenfunction is even and the kernel function is odd.
Proof. The identity
shows, upon differentiating (17), that
Set . The function is odd, positive on , and satisfies . At ,
Parity gives the other boundary condition in (15). Thus is a Robin eigenfunction with eigenvalue zero and exactly one interior zero. By the oscillation theorem, zero is the second radial eigenvalue, and it is simple. There is exactly one negative eigenvalue.
A first eigenfunction can be chosen strictly positive. Reflection preserves the problem, so simplicity makes that eigenfunction even. The kernel generator is odd. □
Positivity of the higher angular modes
Define the conformal coordinate
A dot denotes differentiation with respect to ; primes continue to denote differentiation with respect to . We use the same letters for functions composed with . Equation (5) gives
Indeed, , and the square of this expression is . In this coordinate the zero-eigenvalue equation is
and the full radial form is
The norm in the spectral problem is
In particular, the conformal change preserves the form and the zero equation; the transformed eigenvalue problem has weight .
A boundary logarithmic derivative
Let solve
The coefficient is strictly positive. While is positive, , so increases from 1 and cannot have a first zero. Hence on and on . Define
Lemma 6. For every , one has .
Proof. The Riccati equation for and (22) give
Since , we have the exact identity
If , then for every . An integrating factor in (27) yields .
Suppose now that . By (28), is negative for and positive for . Since is strictly increasing, the function
first decreases and then increases, if the sign change is reached. It follows that
If the sign change is not reached before , the same implication follows from strict decrease throughout the interval.
For a comparison solution, set . From the definitions,
The function is even, and by (21). Consequently, for
we have
and
The strict sign holds because , so . Thus for .
Assume, for contradiction, that . By (29), on . The difference satisfies
Therefore
Here we used ; the strict inequality holds on every integration interval with . At the boundary, (4.1) and give
Since , equation (2.5) yields
We now prove that (6.9) and (6.10) are incompatible. For , define
Let and . Direct differentiation gives
For the last step, the numerator expands as
The denominator in (6.11) is positive for , because . Since , we have , and
Set
Lemma 2 implies . (33) shows that is strictly increasing on . The identity
follows by expanding the square and using . As for , integration of gives
Using (6.12), we conclude that
The final strict inequality follows from
Thus . In contrast, (6.9)–(32) imply
which says . This contradiction proves also when .
A positive quadratic form
Proposition 7. Every radial Robin eigenvalue in angular mode is strictly positive.
Proof. Extend evenly to . The coefficient in (26) is even, so the extension is smooth, positive, and solves the same equation. Its logarithmic derivative is odd. For any , writing and integrating
gives
The identity first follows for smooth functions and extends to by density and continuity of endpoint traces. Lemma 6 makes the boundary coefficient strictly positive. If the right-hand side vanishes, then is constant and , which forces . Therefore for every nonzero .
The minimum of the Rayleigh quotient with the positive weight in (25) is attained for this regular problem. Hence its first eigenvalue is strictly positive. Finally,
proves the assertion for all higher modes, on the full form domain and therefore in both parity sectors.
Proof of the main theorem
Proof of Theorem 1. Propositions 4, 5, and 7 give the following contributions. Angular multiplicities are included in the table.
| Sector | Index contribution | Nullity contribution |
| , even | 1 | 0 |
| , odd | 1 | 0 |
| , even | 2 | 0 |
| , odd | 0 | 2 |
| , both parities | 0 | 0 |
Table 1.
The angular Fourier decomposition is orthogonal for both the inner product and the quadratic form. Its partial sums converge in , and hence their boundary traces converge in . Thus the decomposition also holds on the full form domain. The span of the negative eigenfunctions in the table has dimension four, and its -orthogonal complement is nonnegative for . A function in the Robin kernel has each Fourier coefficient in the corresponding radial kernel. The mode counts therefore give
In particular, .
To identify the kernel geometrically, consider the spatial rotation fields
They preserve the center and the geodesic ball. Equation (7) gives
Indeed, and , while
These rotations tilt the axis of the catenoid. Rotation about the axis itself has zero normal component. The two displayed fields span the entire Robin kernel, as asserted. □
Remark 8. For each fixed , the theorem gives nondegeneracy modulo the rotations preserving the supporting ball. All spectral comparisons above are made for that fixed parameter; no uniform spectral gap as the parameter approaches an endpoint is required. In the terminology of [1], is equivariantly nondegenerate; see Corollary 11.
Consequences
Corollary 9. The supporting radius depends smoothly on and satisfies
In particular, distinct members of the family are free boundary in distinct geodesic balls centered at .
Proof. For , the function has -derivative . By the implicit function theorem, the solution of (9) depends smoothly on , and so does , since .
All quantities of Section 2 depend smoothly on . Let , taken at fixed , and set . This is the parametric Jacobi field of [12 Definition 8.1]; its evenness, the value and the boundary identity (8.1) below are established in [12 Lemmas 8.2 and 8.3], and we include the short derivations for completeness. Each is a minimal immersion of , so the normal component of the variation field is a Jacobi field. Since does not depend on , this gives . The Lorentz reflection satisfies and for every ; hence is even.
At one has and . Since , the vectors and at are
with and . Using and , we obtain
Now let . The boundary relation of Section 2 gives ; in particular . Differentiating , and in , and using , we find
Since at and , differentiating and dividing by gives
Since at , differentiating the free boundary condition , and using the decomposition of together with the identities above, gives
Dividing by and combining the last two identities, we obtain
Suppose that for some . Then (38) and the evenness of show that satisfies both conditions in (15). Since and , zero would be an eigenvalue of the radial Robin problem for , contrary to Proposition 4. Hence never vanishes and has constant sign. By Lemma 2,
and the right-hand side tends to infinity as . Thus is unbounded as , which excludes the negative sign. □
Lemma 10. and as .
Proof. Put . Then and . Fix and suppose that . As is increasing and , (2.9) gives
On one has and, since there, with . Hence
while . Since on , the quotient tends to as , which contradicts the previous display for small. Hence for close to , that is, . Finally, and , so . □
Combined with the limit as (Lemma 10; see also [13]), Corollary 9 shows that is an increasing diffeomorphism of onto . Thus every geodesic ball of is the supporting ball of an isometric image of exactly one . Corollary 9 answers the question of the strict monotonicity of ; see [12 Remark 1.3].
Corollary 11 (Equivariant nondegeneracy and CMC deformations). *For every , the critical spherical catenoid is equivariantly nondegenerate in the sense of [1 Definition 2.4]. Consequently, there exist and a smooth family of embedded free boundary annuli in the fixed ball such that and has constant mean curvature ; here the mean curvature is the trace of the second fundamental form with respect to the unit normal extending . This family is locally unique up to congruence: a free boundary surface in sufficiently close to in , with constant mean curvature with respect to the unit normal close to and with sufficiently small, is congruent to in the sense of [1 Section 2.4].
Proof. Fix , let carry the hyperbolic metric , and orient by . We verify the hypotheses of [1 Theorem 5.1].
The surface. By § 2, ; this is condition (a) of [1 Definition 2.1]. Since is a global unit normal, the normal bundle of is orientable; this is condition (b). Hence is admissible. At the outward unit normal of is , which is tangent to ; thus is normal in the sense of the same definition. Since and is a compact, connected, two-sided surface with , the set has exactly two connected components, and both have compact closure. Each geodesic segment in from to meets exactly once, transversally, on the neck circle , and there points away from . Hence and the circle lie in different components, and, being connected, points everywhere into the component that contains . With this choice of , condition (c) of [1 Definition 2.1] holds, so bounds a finite volume. Moreover, the unit normal used in [1], which points into , is ; hence the mean curvature in [1], the trace of the second fundamental form with respect to this normal, is the one in the statement.
Killing fields. The rotations , and of § 7 fix ; hence they are Killing fields of tangent to , as required in [1 Section 2.4]. Conversely, since is simply connected and has constant curvature, a Killing field defined on a connected open set is the restriction of a global one. If it is tangent to on a nonempty open subset of , then by analyticity it is tangent to the whole sphere , its flow preserves , and therefore it vanishes at ; that is, it lies in . As , the space of Killing–Jacobi fields along is
which is two-dimensional because on .
Equivariant nondegeneracy. In [1] the second fundamental form of is taken with respect to its outer unit normal; for the geodesic sphere of radius this gives along . Hence the linearized free boundary condition [1 (2.3)] is the Robin condition of § 3, and the space of Jacobi fields in is the Robin kernel of Theorem 1. By that theorem, it coincides with the space of Killing–Jacobi fields. Thus is equivariantly nondegenerate.
Deformation. Apply [1 Theorem 5.1] with , the constant family , so that all define the same normal bundle of , an arbitrary , , and the constant frame of Killing–Jacobi field generators , . The theorem gives a smooth family for near , of free boundary hypersurfaces of diffeomorphic to , with constant mean curvature and , which is unique modulo congruence. Setting for proves the existence statement. Since does not depend on , the uniqueness clause of [1 Theorem 5.1] with is the asserted local uniqueness.
Remark 12. For the critical catenoid in the Euclidean unit ball, equivariant nondegeneracy and a two-parameter family of free boundary CMC annuli in the unit balls of the space forms of curvature close to were obtained by Bettiol, Piccione and Santoro [1 Lemma 8.1 and Proposition 8.3]; see also [1 Remark 8.2]. After rescaling, the members with of that family lie in geodesic balls of of small radius. Corollary 11 applies to every and hence, by Corollary 9 and the discussion following it, to the critical spherical catenoid in every geodesic ball of . Embedded, non-rotational free boundary CMC annuli in geodesic balls of , with mean curvature in their normalization, were constructed by Cerezo, Fernández and Mira [4].
Remark 13. The restriction to angular period in Theorem 1 cannot be dropped. The radial form (3.4) is defined for every real , and
Since on , the min–max principle gives, for the radial Robin eigenvalues ,
Hence each is a continuous, strictly increasing function of . Propositions 5 and 7 give , so there is a unique with . For , Propositions 4 and 5 give ; for , one has . On the -fold cover of , of angular period , the angular frequencies are with integer . Each frequency therefore contributes four negative directions, so for the index of the cover is at least . Moreover, the nullity of the cover exceeds two exactly when is an integer, which again requires . This agrees with the construction of Cerezo [3], in which non-rotational free boundary minimal annuli in geodesic balls of bifurcate from -fold covers of critical spherical catenoids (called free boundary hyperbolic catenoids in [3]). The bifurcating annuli are invariant under reflections in planes through the axis, where and are coprime and lies in an interval contained in .
Remark 14 (Scope of the argument). Lemmas 2 and 6 rest on identities specific to the rotational family of Section 2, and the separation of variables uses its rotational symmetry. Three ingredients nevertheless have a wider scope.
(i) The identity (5.1) uses neither the explicit parametrization nor the rotational symmetry: for every two-sided minimal hypersurface , the Gauss–Weingarten and Codazzi equations give , hence for . If is free boundary in a geodesic ball centered at , then on . What is specific to the present family is the sign property of Lemma 3: is positive in the interior, hence it is the first Dirichlet eigenfunction, with eigenvalue ; this is the input of Proposition 4.
(ii) The last step of Proposition 7 is an instance of the ground-state representation for regular Sturm–Liouville problems. Write the Robin conditions as at the endpoints. If a positive solution of the zero-energy equation satisfies at both endpoints, the substitution writes the quadratic form as a nonnegative interior square plus boundary terms whose coefficients are positive multiples of ; the form is therefore positive definite. By symmetry the two conditions reduce here to , which is Lemma 6.
(iii) The proof of Corollary 9 reflects a general transversality principle. Let be a smooth family of free boundary minimal hypersurfaces in the geodesic balls of radius centered at , parametrized over a fixed manifold with boundary, and let . Then is a Jacobi field, and differentiating the two free boundary conditions gives
where is the outward conormal; here one uses that is a principal direction along , the supporting sphere being umbilic. For one has , and this is (8.1). Hence, if vanished, would lie in the Robin kernel. For , is nonzero since , and Proposition 4 excludes a radial Robin kernel, so ; the sign is then fixed by the unboundedness of .
References
- [1]R. G. Bettiol, P. Piccione, and B. Santoro, Deformations of free boundary CMC hypersurfaces, J. Geom. Anal. 27 (2017), no. 4, 3254–3284. https://doi.org/10.1007/s12220-017-9804-5. See also https://arxiv.org/abs/1411.0354.
- [2]M. do Carmo and M. Dajczer, Rotation hypersurfaces in spaces of constant curvature, Trans. Amer. Math. Soc. 277 (1983), no. 2, 685–709. https://doi.org/10.1090/S0002-9947-1983-0694383-X.
- [3]A. Cerezo, Free boundary minimal annuli in geodesic balls of H³, arXiv:2502.20303 (2025). https://arxiv.org/abs/2502.20303.
- [4]A. Cerezo, I. Fernández, and P. Mira, Free boundary CMC annuli in spherical and hyperbolic balls, Calc. Var. Partial Differential Equations 64 (2025), no. 2, Paper No. 37. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00526-024-02883-6.
- [5]B. Devyver, Index of the critical catenoid, Geom. Dedicata 199 (2019), 355–371. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10711-018-0353-2.
- [6]H. Li and C. Xiong, A gap theorem for free boundary minimal surfaces in geodesic balls of hyperbolic space and hemisphere, J. Geom. Anal. 28 (2018), no. 4, 3171–3182. https://doi.org/10.1007/s12220-017-9953-6.
- [7]C. Lima, On uniqueness of free boundary minimal annuli in geodesic balls of S³₊ and H³, arXiv:2503.16763 (2025). https://arxiv.org/abs/2503.16763.
- [8]V. Medvedev, On the index of the critical Möbius band in B⁴, J. Geom. Anal. 33 (2023), no. 3, article no. 93. https://doi.org/10.1007/s12220-022-01069-w.
- [9]V. Medvedev, On free boundary minimal submanifolds in geodesic balls in Hⁿ and Sⁿ₊, Math. Z. 310 (2025), no. 1, article no. 10. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00209-025-03707-9.
- [10]H. Mori, Minimal surfaces of revolution in H³ and their global stability, Indiana Univ. Math. J. 30 (1981), no. 5, 787–794. https://doi.org/10.1512/iumj.1981.30.30057.
- [11]D. Parise and J. J. Zhu, Uniqueness of free boundary minimal annuli, arXiv:2609.17512 (2026). https://arxiv.org/abs/2609.17512.
- [12]A. Pigazzini, Analytic local resolution of Medvedev’s Morse index conjecture for the critical spherical catenoid in H³, arXiv:2605.13562 (2026). https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.13562.
- [13]A. Pigazzini, Robin nullity in mode |k| = 1 and asymptotic radius of the critical spherical catenoid, arXiv:2605.11244 (2026). https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.11244.
- [14]G. Smith and D. Zhou, The Morse index of the critical catenoid, Geom. Dedicata 201 (2019), 13–19. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10711-018-0412-8.
- [15]H. Tran, Index characterization for free boundary minimal surfaces, Commun. Anal. Geom. 28 (2020), no. 1, 189–222. https://doi.org/10.4310/CAG.2020.v28.n1.a6. See also https://arxiv.org/abs/1609.01651v4.
- [16]A. Zettl, Sturm–Liouville Theory, Mathematical Surveys and Monographs, vol. 121, American Mathematical Society, Providence, RI, 2005. https://doi.org/10.1090/surv/121.