WorksMathematics
Uniqueness results for the exterior Dirichlet and Neumann problem in two dimensions for the Euler-Lagrange equations of variational integrals with linear growth
Abstract
We consider solutions of the Euler-Lagrange equations associated to the variational integral , where is an exterior domain in e.g., the complement of a disk or a half plane, and the density is of linear growth. Among other things we show that together with the boundedness of yields that on the entire domain.
Introduction and statement of the results
In our note we investigate the exterior Dirichlet problem and in addition the exterior Neumann problem on planar domains associated with the Euler-Lagrange equations corresponding to variational integrals with density being of linear growth providing some uniqueness results. A prominent example is given by the Dirichlet problem
for functions , where is a domain in such that is bounded and denotes a given function. Note that the first line of (1) is the Euler-Lagrange equation for the area integral , but even in the case of problem (1) uniqueness of solutions can not be expected: for instance, if we let and take , then problem (1) admits the three different solutions , , , which means that we have the trivial one together with the upper and lower catenoid. Therefore one can only hope for uniqueness under additional restrictions to be imposed on the solutions as it is stated in Theorem 11.3 of Osserman’s monograph [1]: if denote bounded solutions of (1), then it holds . This means that we have uniqueness for problem (1) in the space , however, as Theorem 11.4 in [1] shows, the existence of solutions to (1) in the space can in general not be guaranteed. The delicate question of existence (and uniqueness) for the exterior Dirichlet problem (1) has been investigated by many authors leading to the result that, roughly speaking, a smallness condition for the oscillation of the boundary data is sufficient for the existence of a solution to (1), whereas prescribed asymptotic growth of at infinity or the existence of a constant asymptotic normal vector for the graph of provides uniqueness. We refer the reader to the contributions of for instance Kuwert [2], Kutev and Tomi [3], do Espírito-Santo and Ripoll [4], Ripoll and Tomi [5] and Aiolfi, Assmann and Ripoll [6], where one will find further references and also a careful analysis of the historical background. We now leave the minimal surface case and want to improve the uniqueness result from Theorem 11.3 in [1] even in a more general framework. Our assumptions are as follows: let denote a bounded Lipschitz domain and consider the exterior region
For we denote by the space of -matrices. Suppose that is of class and in addition of linear growth in the sense that
holds with positive constants . We require further that
and that
is satisfied. Due to (1.5) the density is a strictly convex function, which together with (1.3) yields (compare, e.g., Lemma 2.2, p.156, in [7]). We then look at weak solutions of the equation
which by definition means that we require
for all , “:” denoting the scalar product of matrices. Our first result concerns the exterior Dirichlet problem for equation (1.6) giving an extension of Theorem 11.3 from [1]:
Theorem 1.1. Assume that we have (1.2)–(1.5) and suppose that are weak solutions of (1.6) in the sense of (1.7). Assume further that
Then it follows on , if
or
holds.
We note that in the case of bounded solutions condition (1.9) clearly holds, hence we have uniqueness in the class of bounded solutions of the exterior Dirichlet problem associated to equation (1.6).
From the proof of Theorem 1.1 it follows:
Corollary 1.2 (Uniqueness of entire solutions). Let (1.3)–(1.5) hold for the function and assume that are weak solutions of equation (1.6) on the whole plane, i.e. (1.7) is satisfied for all . Then, in the case that is bounded, is true.
Next we apply Theorem 1.1 to a situation which is closer to the minimal surface setting introduced in problem (1.1): let and consider a density with radial structure, i.e. we let , , with of class such that (compare (1.3)–(1.5))
holds with constants . As domain we take and observe that (1.6) now reads as
In addition to (1.11) we require
and observe that (1.13) is true, if with exponent . We then introduce the -catenoids
(compare formula (2.5) in [8]), which for the choice take the usual form. Note that by [8], Lemma 2, the -catenoids are solutions of (1.12) and in addition satisfy
After these preparations we can deduce from Theorem 1.1:
Corollary 1.3. Let (1.11), (1.13) hold for the function and define as in (1.14). Suppose that is a weak solution of (1.12) with the property (1.15). Then, if either or stays bounded, is equal to in the first case, whereas holds in the second case.
Next we present a result concerning solutions of equation (1.6) whose derivatives in all coordinate directions vanish on in a rather strong sense.
Theorem 1.4. Let (1.2), (1.3) and (1.5) hold, whereas condition (1.4) is replaced by
denoting a positive constant. Let denote a solution of (1.6) with the property
for close to for some other constant (which for instance follows from near together with on , ). Then, if in addition satisfies
the constancy of follows.
In order to proceed we discuss the situation for the case, when the domain from (1.2) is replaced by a half-plane , for instance we may consider
Concerning problem (1.11) with in place of the question of unique solvability has been analyzed by various authors, and without being complete we mention the papers of Hwang [9], [10] and of Collin and Krust [11] for further references. It turns out that two solutions must coincide, if satisfies certain growth restrictions as . Concerning the question of the existence of solutions to (1.1) for the half-plane the interested should consult the paper of Jiang, Wang and Zhu [12].
Let us look at equation (1.6) for the half-plane. It is easy to prove:
Theorem 1.5. The results of Theorem 1.1 and of Theorem 1.4 remain true, if the domain from (1.2) is replaced by the half-plane .
For the half-plane condition (1.17) seems to be somewhat artificial, since the gradient is required to vanish on . We finish the introduction with a more natural result.
Theorem 1.6. Let satisfy (1.3), (1.5), (1.16) and consider as in (1.19). Suppose that is a solution of (1.7) on such that for a positive constant
holds for near (which is true, if on and near ). Then the validity of
implies the existence of points with the property that , .
Our paper is organized as follows: Section 2 contains the proofs of Theorem 1.1 and 1.4. In Section 3 we discuss the half-plane case presenting the proofs of Theorem 1.5 and 1.6.
Proofs of Theorem 1.1 and 1.4
During the proof of Theorem 1.1 we will benefit from:
Lemma 2.1. Let the density satisfy (1.3)–(1.5), let denote a bounded Lipschitz region in and define as in (1.2). Consider a function from the space satisfying equation (1.7). Then it holds for any radius such that
and the Sobolev trace of on coincides with the classical pointwise trace.
Remark 2.2. In the situation of Theorem 1.1 we can apply Lemma 2.1 to the functions and with the result that
holds for arbitrary .
Proof of Lemma 2.1. We assume for notational simplicity that and consider the case . Fix a radius and choose a small number . We let such that and in addition
denoting a positive constant independent of . Noting that belongs to with (recall (2)), we deduce from (1.7) combined with (2.3)
Recalling the boundedness of and using (24) one more time, we get from equation (25)
for a constant and another positive constant both being independent of . Of course we have also used the boundedness of on the set . This yields (recall the bound for in (24))
for all sufficiently small and with some number . Using the convexity of and condition (3) we finally observe that
and therefore (26) implies , which proves (22). That the Sobolev trace on of the function equals the classical trace then is a consequence of (22) combined with Theorem 3.6.2 and Theorem 3.6.3 (a) in the textbook [13] of Morrey.
Remark 2.3. Condition (4) is not needed during the proof of Lemma 2.1. Moreover, Lemma 2.1 is true for the -dimensional case, .
Proof of Theorem 1.1. Let us assume that all the hypotheses hold, where for notational simplicity we let . We consider radii such that and observe that according to Lemma 2.1 it holds and in addition
where satisfies
For (27) we refer to Remark 2.2, in particular (23), with being replaced by . We have equation (7) for and with being replaced by defined in (27), which gives after subtracting the results
and in conclusion
Consider the parameter dependent bilinear form
for and parameters , and rewrite (29) in the form
The Cauchy-Schwarz inequality applied to the positive (recall (5)) bilinear form shows
hence by Young’s inequality we find that
valid for all . Using the latter inequality on the right-hand side of (30), we obtain after appropriate choice of
Next we recall (4), use (28) together with assumption (9) or (10) in order to get for sufficiently large
for some constant . With (31) we go back to (30) and recall that the Cauchy-Schwarz inequality applied to the right-hand side of (30) yields (also using (28))
hence by Hölder’s inequality (and using )
From (31) it follows
hence the first term on the right-hand side of (32) goes to zero as , whereas the second integral stays bounded according to the discussion after (30), which led us to (31). Altogether we conclude from (32) that
hence according to (6), and (8) shows , which finishes the proof of Theorem 1.1.
For proving Corollary 1.2 we just note that in the case of entire solutions the previous calculations remain true, if we drop the set in all formulas.
Proof of Theorem 1.4. For simplicity we let together with . It is easy to see that under the assumptions and with the notation from Theorem 1.4 we can deduce from (27) the validity of (recall the weak form (7))
for all and being fixed. Choosing as in the proof of Lemma 2.1 (see (24)) and letting in equation (33), we obtain from (33), using the Cauchy-Schwarz inequality for the bilinear form followed by an application of Young’s inequality, the estimate
with a uniform constant . Since we assume and according to (24), it follows that we just have to find a bound independent of for the quantity
From assumption (16) we get (noting that here (4) is sufficient)
and (17) implies with independent of . Referring to (5) we find a number such that on it holds
the discussion concerning turns (34) into
for any , and (35) clearly shows that
for any with vanishing Sobolev trace on which follows from (17) (compare the remarks at the end of the proof of Lemma 2.1). In order to prove the constancy of , we again let and choose with (28). The function is admissible in equation (33): by the foregoing discussion (recall (36) together with on ) we have that , thus there is a sequence with the property in the norm of . Equation (33) holds for and by passing to the limit we get the desired result, from which we deduce (compare (29))
where we have used the fact that . Applying the Cauchy-Schwarz inequality to on the right-hand side of (37) and then using Hölder’s inequality we get from (37)
with a constant independent of . We claim
Assuming this for the moment, applying Young’s inequality to the right-hand side of (38) and using (16), we find that (39) implies (passing to )
Now, due to (39) and (40), the right-hand side of (38) actually vanishes as which means
and is a consequence of (5). This yields the constancy of , and from on we get on . Since was arbitrary, must be a constant function. It therefore remains to prove (39): let and choose such that and on , on , . Then is admissible in equation (7) and with the help of the boundedness of we get
where the last inequality is a consequence of (18). Recalling that by the convexity of and assumption (3) it holds
we have shown (39), which completes the proof of Theorem 1.4.
Remark 2.4. If is a bounded domain in , then an inspection of the proof shows, that the result of Theorem 1.4 still holds, if we replace (18) by the stronger condition that is a bounded function.
Proofs of Theorem 1.5 and 1.6
Just for notational simplicity we consider the scalar case and recall definition (19) of the half-plane remarking that the particular choice just enters through condition (20) from Theorem 1.6 and can easily be adjusted to other choices for $H`.
i) Letting in Theorem 1.1, the extension of Theorem 1.1 to the half-plane is based on an appropriate version of Lemma 2.1. We now claim
for any . For proving (41) we define ( sufficiently small)
with functions , , , such that
From (42) we get if , and implies , hence is a compact subset of the open half-plane . Equation (25) is replaced by
and following the lines after (25), we see that it remains to discuss the term
which however due to the bound imposed on (see (42)) stays bounded independent of . Thus we get and in consequence (41) is true.
ii) From (41) it follows as before that the Sobolev trace of on vanishes, if we are in the situation of Theorem 1.1 with and we deduce
where and now is defined as in (28). We have equation (6) for the functions and , which on account of (43) gives
From (44) we obtain the half-plane version of (29), where one just replaces the domain of integration by the set and with obvious changes the proof of Theorem 1.1 can be finished as before.
iii) If we let in the situation of Theorem 1.4, we first note that (36) has to be replaced by ()
For proving (45) we start from equation (33) by letting , but now with the choice with as in (42). The subsequent calculations are easily adjusted. This also concerns the second part of the proof of Theorem 1.4: we have equation (37) with as domain of integration and with exactly as in (28). Proceeding as in Theorem 1.4, we obtain the constancy of .
iv) We finally come to the proof of Theorem 1.6. We first observe that on account of (20) we obtain (45) just for the index . For details we refer to the derivation of (35) (with ) noting that quantity introduced after (34) involves , to which we
can apply (20). Of course, in (34) is defined according to (42). We then proceed as done after (36), letting and applying the adjustments from iii), and get that , hence for some . However, (20) shows and just depends on . From equation (6) it follows directly that we finally arrive at the claim of Theorem 1.6, for details we refer to the discussion after formula (27) of [14].
Michael Bildhauer
Saarland University Department of Mathematics P.O. Box 15 11 50 66041 Saarbrücken, Germany [email protected]
Martin Fuchs
Saarland University Department of Mathematics P.O. Box 15 11 50 66041 Saarbrücken, Germany [email protected]
References
- [1]R. Osserman, A survey of minimal surfaces. Second Edition, Dover Publications, New York 1986.
- [2]E. Kuwert, A bound for minimal graphs with a normal at infinity. Calc. Var. Partial Differential Equations 1 no.4 (1993), 407-416.DOI
- [3]N. Kutev, F. Tomi, Existence and nonexistence for the exterior Dirichlet problem for the minimal surface equation in the plane. Differential Integral Equations 11 no.6 (1998), 917-928.DOI
- [4]N. do Espírito-Santo, J. Ripoll, Some existence results on the exterior Dirichlet problem for the minimal hypersurface equation. Ann. Inst. H. Poincaré C Anal. Non Linéaire 28 no. 3 (2011), 385-393.
- [5]J. Ripoll, F. Tomi, On solutions to the exterior Dirichlet problem for the minimal surface equation with catenoidal ends. Adv. Calc. Var. 7 no. 2 (2014), 205-226.
- [6]A. Aiolfi, C. Assmann, J. Ripoll, The Dirichlet problem for the minimal surface equation on unbounded helicoidal domains of R³. arXiv 2023.
- [7]B. Dacorogna, Direct methods in the calculus of variations. Applied Mathematical Sciences 78, Springer Verlag, Berlin 1989.
- [8]M. Bildhauer, M. Fuchs, An extension of a theorem of Bers and Finn on the removability of isolated singularities to the Euler-Lagrange equations related to general linear growth problems. Calc. Var. Partial Differential Equations 61 no. 3 (2022), No. 99, 8 pp.arxiv.org/abs/2103.16133
- [9]J.-F. Hwang, Comparison principles and Liouville theorems for prescribed mean curvature equations in unbounded domains. Ann. Scuola Norm. Sup. Pisa Cl. Sci 15 no.4 (1988), 341-355.
- [10]J.-F. Hwang, A uniqueness theorem for the minimal surface equation. Pacific J. Math. 176 no.2 (1996), 357-364.DOI
- [11]P. Collin, R. Krust, Le problème de Dirichlet pour l’équation de surfaces minimales sur des domaines non bornés. Bull. Soc. Math. France 119 no.4 (1991), 443-462.
- [12]G. Jiang, Z. Wang, J. Zhu, Stability of Edelen-Wang’s Bernstein type theorem for the minimal surface equation. J. of Functional Analysis 284 (2023), 109821.DOI
- [13]C.B. Morrey, Multiple integrals in the calculus of variations. Springer Verlag, Berlin 2008.
- [14]M. Bildhauer, M. Fuchs, Variants of Bernstein’s theorem for variational integrals with linear and nearly linear growth. Ric. Mat. 73 no.5 (2024), 2911-2923.